Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No.

3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Asia Pacific Journal of
Factors Affecting the Reading Comprehension Education, Arts and Sciences
of Grade Six Pupils in the City Division of Vol. 5 No.3, 72-78
July 2018
Sorsogon, Philippines as Basis for the P-ISSN 2362-8022
Development of Instructional Material E-ISSN 2362-8030
www.apjeas.apjmr.com
Michael L. Estremera (MAED)1, Geraldine L. Estremera2
1
Marinas 1 Elementary School, Sorsogon East, Sorsogon City, Philippines;
2
Balogo Elementary School, Sorsogon East, Sorsogon City, Philippines.
1
[email protected], [email protected],
2
[email protected]

Date Received: November 13, 2017; Date Revised: July 11, 2018

Abstract - This study probed on the factors Keywords: Factors, Silent Reading, Oral Reading,
affecting the reading comprehension of Grade Six PHILIRI, Reading Comprehension
pupils, comprehension level based on pre-test PHILIRI
for S.Y. 2013-2014 and training needs of teachers. INTRODUCTION
Results of the study served as basis in the development Reading is a complex process that involves
of instructional material to improve the reading level sensation, perception, comprehension, application and
of the pupils. The researchers distributed the integration. It is the process of making and getting
questionnaires in the four districts comprising the City meaning from printed words and symbols. Reading as
Division. The researchers aptly considered the a whole, is a means of communication and of
descriptive-developmental method of research. It information and ideas. As a matter of fact Aracelo (
described the reading level of the Grad Six pupils and 1994) as cited by Panerio [1] reported that “85% of the
training needs of teachers to efficiently and effectively things that people do involve reading”. Individuals read
handle their pupils. A reading module was street signs, advertisements, menus in restaurants and
collaboratively developed by the researches to improve recipes from cook books, dosage of medicine and
the reading level of the pupils. Findings reveal that in others.
Silent Reading, 5% or 1444 out of 2503 pupils were on Moreover, reading is the foundation of academic
frustration level of comprehension, 30% were on success and life learning. One article from Philippine
instructional and only 302 or 12% were classified as Star [2] states that:
independent readers. In oral reading, 71% or 1789 out “The undeniable fact remains that majority of
of 2503 fell on frustration level, 594 turned out Filipino students do not possess the ability and
instructional readers while the remaining percentages motivation to read. In 2007, the Department of
were categorized as independent readers. This is only Education reported that 70 percent or our
5% or 120 of the pupils tested. Further, it revealed that learners are incapable of reading within the
there were factors affecting the reading comprehension expected level. This is the situation of reading
of the pupils. These factors are pupil, language, achievement intensifies in the Philippines as
teacher, school head, school, home and community evaluated by Scholastic Inc., the world’s largest
factors. The researchers recommend the ff. (i) the publisher and distributor of children’s book”.
module that was developed may be utilized to develop
not just the level of comprehension but the linguistic Due to the fast evolving world and changing
competence as well, infusing other interrelated skills technology it cannot be denied that sometimes reading
such speaking, writing, listening and viewing. (ii)There is taken for granted. Former DepEd Sec. Abad deplored
should be close monitoring of pupil’s progress by the the poor performance of the pupils’ assessment test and
parents and school administrators; and (iii) A reading said that, the low scores in English, Mathematics and
program like peer-pair and remedial reading may be Science can be attributed to pupils’ lack of ability in
provided. basic reading and comprehension. In addition, he said

72
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
that one of the major problems in reading is the poor between the lines, combining information and making
reading comprehension, which leads to poor inferences and comprehending them. In this level, the
understanding of printed symbols. reader will answer the how and why questions. The
The Department of Education (DepEd) intensifies third level is the applied or reading beyond the lines,
reading literacy in schools by forcing the program using information to express opinion and form ideas
called” Every Child A Reader Program” (ECARP) [3]. and involves application. The fourth level is the critical
The undersecretary said that the new program aims to level where the reader will answer an open-ended
make every Filipino a reader at the end of Grade III. question regarding the behavior of the minor or major
The undersecretary is expecting that no pupil will be character and the style of presentation.
promoted to higher grades unless he/she manifests In the same vein, Gray [8] affirms that there are
mastery and basic literacy skills in particular grade [4]. other factors that influence the reading activity. These
Reading and reading comprehension are interrelated are comprehension, concentration, memory and
skills. In order for students to be able to comprehend personality. The teacher factor must be considered also
what they are reading, they have to develop in the reading process. The teacher chooses her subject
comprehension skills in reading. By itself, the concept and the instructional materials to be used for the
of reading comprehension is vast in breadth and depth. students. The foregoing authors stress that the students
Comprehension is the ultimate outcome of having read. may do better in reading with proper concentration,
It is the most important ongoing activity of reading. quick memory and optimistic personality. This was
These statements show bearing to the study insofar as connected to the outcome of the study that there had
the ultimate objective of the developed reading primer been factors related to the reading comprehension of
is towards the development of reading comprehension the pupils which include absenteeism, economic status
by integrating the other reading skills to ensure and so forth.
permanency in learning. Background knowledge plays an essential role in
Jonhston [5] considers reading comprehension as reading comprehension. In an effort to comprehend a
building bridges between the “new and the unknown” text, students rely on their background knowledge to
and the importance of prior knowledge are vital in the link what they already know to the text they are
reading instruction. Comprehension simply cannot reading. Background knowledge includes both a
occur when nothing is already “known” because then reader’s real-world experiences and literary
there is nothing to which reader could link the knowledge. Drawing parallels between background
“unknown”. Indeed, prior knowledge is so necessary knowledge and texts helps students become active
for comprehension to freely flow from easiest to the readers, improving their reading comprehension [9]. As
most complicated. In support to the foregoing view, the for Atienza [10] whether or not students have mastered
researcher primarily ignited the schema of the pupils by vocabulary skills affects their reading comprehension.
infusing related portraits in each skill to be developed Students must be able to comprehend a familiar word
in the reading primer. and its relationship with other words within a text.
Understanding the meaning of text and knowing the Mastering vocabulary includes recognizing a word’s
author’s intentions among others are part of part of speech, definition, useful context clues, and how
comprehension. Russel [6] claims that comprehension it functions in a sentence. These vocabulary strategies
requires knowledge not only of words but their can help improve comprehension. These milieus were
relationships in sentences, paragraphs and longer considered by the researcher in the development of the
passages. It involves understanding of the intent of the reading primer by integrating local events and
author and may go beyond literal and recorded facts to celebrations in order to establish connection and
hidden meaning or implications. Hence, it entails deep consider the background knowledge of the readers.
thinking and requires skills to infer and read critically. In the long run, this piece of work was confined at
This finding was confirmed in this study since majority determining the factors affecting the reading
of the pupils were categorized under frustration level of comprehension of Grade VI pupils and level of
reading comprehension. comprehension. Included also are some
Likewise, according to Villamin [7] there are four recommendations to improve the reading level of the
levels of comprehension. The first level is the literal subject of the study. Other Grade levels such as Grade
which means reading lines, getting the information I to V pupils with English subject were excluded in this
drift, answering questions on: who, what, where and study. It is thus limited at providing results on factors
when. The second level is the interpretive or reading and reading comprehension level. Other issues which
73
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
may be deemed researchable are left to future questionnaires to the respondents. Classmates and
researchers. friends of the researchers were also instrumental in the
retrieval of some accomplished questionnaires. An
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY unstructured interview was also done upon retrieval to
This basic research envisioned to determine the supplement the necessary data. Furthermore, pertinent
factors affecting the reading comprehension and level data and information which could enhance this
of comprehension of Grade VI pupils. The findings endeavor were gathered from other sources such as
served as a basis to come-up reading module and school heads, teachers, former professors, colleagues
recommended training needs of teachers. Specifically, and co – teachers.
this academic pursuit aimed to determine the factors
affecting the reading comprehension of the Grade VI Data Analysis
pupils as perceived by their teachers; establish how The quantitative method of analyzing data was
many pupils fall under frustration, instructional and utilized in this research. This involves frequency counts
independent level based on pretest PHILIRI of Grade and percentage to determine the most common answers
VI pupils; find-out the training needs of English to the foregoing questions. Ranking was likewise
Teachers; and develop instructional material may be employed to determine the measure that will be
developed as an output of the study. proposed as an output of the study to address the
prevailing problems. Tabular and graphical
METHODS presentations helped to accurately show the outcome of
The descriptive-developmental method of research this piece of work. Moreover, related literatures and
was used in this quest for solution. It described the studies could be used to support the findings of the
factors and level of comprehension skills of the pupils. research. The previously cited literature could anchor
The training needs of teachers were also delineated. the findings of the endeavor.
These led to the development of an instructional
material as an output of the study. The reading module Ethical Issues
is named as “Read To Learn, Save the World”. It made This research was undertaken in response to
use of local events and sceneries as reading passages DepEd’s call for research intensification and also
and portraits to establish connection with the pupils. systematically finding answers to the challenges
encountered by teachers relative to the implementation
The Sampling of K to 12 curricula and is not categorically divulging
The primary sources of data were the Grade VI the incompetence of the respondents or the low
teachers representing at least 95% of the schools per academic performance of pupils featured in this
district to ensure high reliability and validity of the masterpiece. As a matter of fact, Schools Division
research work. This surpassed the ideal 20% population Superintendent approved the pursuance of this
when using random sampling. These schools could be research; hence, respective school heads, teachers, and
central, big and small schools chosen randomly thru a parents of the minor pupils concerned were also
fish bowl technique. The remaining percentages of notified. In the process of research, the data and
non-respondent schools are situated along coastal areas information that were taken from the respondents had
which deterred the researchers to distribute the been held with utmost confidentiality and anonymity.
questionnaires. Ensuing research ethics and rules had also been aptly
observed by the researcher to circumvent future
Table A. The Respondents
problems relative to plagiarism, intellectual dishonesty
SCHOOL No. of Teacher Respondents and the like. Cited references were accordingly
Sorsogon East District 13 affirmed.
Sorsogon West District 21
The Table 2 indicates that Grade VI pupils have
Bacon West District 16
Bacon East District 14
poor study habit, not motivated to read, commits
∑= 64 absences and are nutritionally-challenged. In fact,
according to research conducted by the U.S. National
Institutes for Child Health and Development, [11] there
Data Collection
is one overriding reason above all others that is the root
Approval of the Schools Division Superintendent
cause of the unacceptably high percentage of
was sought prior to the distribution of questionnaires.
individuals who struggle as readers. These individuals
Thereafter, the researcher personally distributed the
74
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
have not been taught scientifically-based reading out that reading is one of the components of reading
instruction with a comprehensive and systematic skills that should be taught and developed among the
phonics component. According to their pupils. He further claims that spelling, grammar and
findings, struggling readers have difficulty identifying, immersion play a key role in the academic performance
discriminating, and isolating sounds—foundational of the clienteles.
skills for fluent reading. The mean percent of 74.48 for teacher factors and
54.69 for school head factors would imply that teachers
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION are doing their part in order to teach their pupils.
As for the language factors, it turned out that pupils Respondents are faced with multifarious extra
have limited vocabulary, poor grammar and spelling functions which steal the supposedly in contact time
and are low in finding the main ideas of what is being with pupils. For the school head factors, the
read. Added factor is language immersion which is respondents considered these factors as merely trivial
necessary to expose the pupils to the target language. due to the many-sided functions too of their principals.
This findings is supported by Benton [12] who points-

Table 2. Factors Affecting the Poor Reading Comprehension of Grade VI pupils S.Y. 2013-2014
Factors Affecting The Reading Comprehension Frequency Percent Mean Percent
1. Pupil Factors
a. Nutritional Status 53 82.81
b. Pupils are not motivated to read 57 89.06 83.75
c. Pupils read stories, selections and essays selectively 49 76.56
d. Pupils’ poor study habit 64 100
e. Absenteeism 45 70.31
2. Language Factors
a. Pupils’ poor/limited vocabulary 61 95.31
b. Pupils poor grammar and spelling 42 65.63 84.06
c. Low comprehension level 64 100
d. Selection contain unfamiliar words 40 62.5
e. Pupils are not immersed to English 62 96.88
3. Teacher Factors
a. Lack of appropriate strategies and approaches to 35 54.69 74.48
foster love for reading
b. Lack of skills in preparing reading materials 45 70.31
c. Overlapping teaching loads and extra functions 63 98.44
4. School Head Factors 54.69
a. Lack of seminar in teaching reading 45 70.31
b. Poor supervisory scheme 25 39.06
5. School Factors
a. Class size 60 93.75
b. Lack of catchy reading materials 55 85.94 78.91
c. Substandard classroom for learning with inadequate
facilities 48 75
d. Absence of functional library 39 60.94
5. Home Factors
a. No follow-ups at home 62 96.88
b. Less motivation by siblings to study 60 93.75 83.75
c. Low educational background of parents 45 70.31
d. Pupils are forced to work for an extra income 42 65.63
e. Absence of reading materials at home 59 92.19
6. Community Factors
a. Lack of support from the Brgy. Council 45 70.31 64.06
b. Lack of support from external stakeholders 43 67.19
c. Non-functional learning resource center (LRC) 35 54.69

75
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________

FREQUENCY
1789
1800
1444
1600
1400
1200
1000 757
800 594
600 302
400 120
200
0
Oral Reading Silent Reading

Frustration Instructional Independent

Graph 1. No. of Pupils Classified under Frustration, Instruction and Independent Level

Highlighted also in the above table are the school Pupils’ score 90 to 96% in word recognition and 59%
factors which have to do with class size, lack of to 79 in comprehension. Fortunately, there are 120
instructional materials and absence of functional pupils who made it to the independent level as revealed
library. These, according to the respondents, affect the in the previous graph. They are those pupils with
reading comprehension of the pupils. Furthermore, highest level of reading who could independently read
home factors earned a mean of 83.75. This would mean with ease without the help or guidance of the teacher.
that when pupils go back their respective home after The pupils in this level are free from tension, finger
class, they are seldom monitored by their parents; pointing or lip movement. The pupils read with rhythm
hence are less motivated to study. The low educational and with conversational tone and interpret punctuation
background also poses a challenge to the pupils. correctly. Scores range from 97% to 100% in word
Surprisingly, some pupils are made to work in order to recognition and 80% to 100% in comprehension.
help family’s finances. On the other hand, shown also in the above graph is
Delineated in graph 1 found in the next page are the the turn-out for the silent reading assessment. This
no. pupils who were classified under the three levels of reading assessment used a standard reading selection to
reading comprehension according to PHILIRI. These be read by the Grade VI pupils silently. Thereafter,
are frustration, instructional and independent level series of questions were given to gauge whether they
determined by respondents during the reading have understood the selection given or the other way
assessment. around. As seen in the foregoing graph, there are 1444
It is noticeable that in oral reading test 1789 or or 58% who fell under frustration level, 30% out of
nearly 71% of the Grade VI pupils are under the 2503 were on instructional level, and only 302 or 12%
frustration level of reading comprehension while 24% survived to the independent level of reading
or exactly 594 of the pupils are classified as comprehension. These pupils were able to answer the
instructional readers. Pupils show withdrawal from questions perfectly based on the selection given by the
reading situations crying or refusing to read. They PHILIRI.
commit errors in reading such as reversal, repetition, The aforementioned findings seem to link with
substitution, insertion, mispronunciation and inability Russel [6] who claims that comprehension requires
to interpret punctuation marks. knowledge not only of words but their relationships in
Pupils’ score range are 89% and below in word sentences, paragraphs and longer passages. It involves
recognition and 59 to 79% in comprehension. The understanding of the intent of the author and may go
instructional readers are those who could do simple beyond literal and recorded facts to hidden meaning or
recall of the content of the selections they have read.

76
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
implications. Hence, it entails deep thinking and upshots, the researcher concluded that there were
requires skills to infer and read critically. factors which affected the reading comprehension of
In the same vein, according to Villamin [7], there Grade Six pupils in the City Division of Sorsogon.
are four levels of comprehension. The first level is the Majority fell under frustration level both in Oral and
literal which means reading lines, getting the Silent Reading.
information drift, answering questions on: who, what, Eventually, it is recommended that commended that
where and when. The second level is the interpretive or effective teaching strategies and other activities may be
reading between the lines, combining information and devised by teachers to improve the level of reading
making inferences and comprehending them. In this comprehension. The developed reading primer that was
level, the reader will answer the how and why developed may be utilized to develop not just the level
questions. The third level is the applied or reading of comprehension but the linguistic competence as
beyond the lines, using information to express opinion well, infusing other interrelated skills such speaking,
and form ideas and involves application. The fourth writing, listening and viewing. There shall be close
level is the critical level where the reader will answer monitoring of pupil’s progress by the parents and
an open-ended question regarding the behavior of the school administrators. A reading program like peer-pair
minor or major character and the style of presentation. and remedial reading may be provided. If necessary,
the module can be mass -produced to partially solve the
inadequacy of instructional materials. A training of
Grade VI teachers on Instructional Materials
Preparation, Seminar in Teaching Reading and
Training in Teaching Bilingual Learners should be
conducted.

REFERENCES
[1] Panerio, Reane O.(2008). Reading Comprehension
Skills of Gubat South Central School. Unpublished
Graph 2. Training Needs of Teachers Undergraduate Thesis: Bicol University Campus
[2] http://www.philstar.com.article.aspx?articled.639604&
publicationsubcategyld=442,2010
Reflected in the graph 2 are the training needs of
[3] DepEd Order No.47, s. 2017 amendment to DepEd
teachers. Out of the five (5) identified trainings, the Order No. 18, s. 2017 re: Guidelines on the Utilization
training in teaching English as a 2nd language ranked of the Every a Reader Program (ECARP).
the first which is 93.75% of the respondents. Training [4] Mendoza, M. (2012). Proficiency Level of Grade
on instructional materials preparation earned a V and VI Multigrade Pupils in Reading, Barcelona
frequency of 58. Conversely, training in teaching Sorsogon: Unpublished Undergraduate Thesis.
reading obtained a frequency of 45 or 70.31% of the Sorsogon State College
total no. of teacher respondents. The least chosen [5] Johnston, P. (1991). Implications of Basic Research for
training according to the respondents is the training in the Assessment of Reading Comprehension Tech.
teaching bilingual learners which garnered a frequency Report No. 206. Urbana and Champaign: Center for the
Study of Reading, University of Illinois
of only 40 which is 62.5%.
[6] Russel, D. R., (1995). Children Learn to Read. New
York: Glinn and Company
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION [7] Villamin, A. (1987). Developmental Reading in Quezon
This undertaking has been conceptualized in order City Philippines: Phoenix Publishing House Inc. pp. 11-
to give light to the intervening factors affecting the 12.
pupils. English teachers and school administrators, [8] Gray, William S., (1949). Chapter II in Reading ( High
therefore, may consider the results of this study in the School and College), Part I of the 47th Year Book of the
teaching-learning process in order for their clienteles to National Society for the Study of Education. Chicago
be linguistically inclined. School heads and faculty University
members, on the other hand, shall clasp their hands [9] Al Khateeb, O. (2010). The Impact of Using KWL
Strategy on Grade Ten Female Students' Reading
together in crafting school intervention programs and
Comprehension of Religious Concepts in Ma'an City.
projects that will cater to the needs of their end Retrieved August 10, 2010 from World Wide Web
recipients such as Reading Remediation Programs, http://www.eurojournals.com/ejss_12_3_14.pdf.
Literary measures and the like. Considering the
77
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com
 Asia Pacific Journal of Education, Arts and Sciences, Vol. 5 No. 3, July 2018
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________
[10] Atienza, L. (2002). Basic Communication and Thinking
Skills.Bulacan: Trinitas Publishing Inc.
[11] US Department of Education’s report The Nation’s
Report Card: Reading (2005.)
[12] Benton, W. (1972). Encyclopedia Britanica Vol. 19,
University of Chicago

78
P-ISSN 2362-8022 | E-ISSN 2362-8030 | www.apjeas.apjmr.com