Fundamentals of Electrical Power Measurement
Fundamentals of Electrical Power Measurement
Fundamentals of Electrical Power Measurement
of
Electrical Power Measurement
Barry Bolling
Application Engineer
Yokogawa Corporation of America
Credits: Bill Gatheridge
Presentation: IEEE / UTC Aerospace
2 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Fundamentals
of
Electrical Power Measurements
3 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview – Part I of III
Part I: Electrical Power Measurements
Review Some Basics
Power Measurements Using a Precision
Power Analyzer
Single-Phase Power Measurements
Current Sensors
Three-Phase Power Measurements
2 & 3 Wattmeter Method
4 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview – Part II of III
5 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview – Part III of III
Part III: Power Measurements using a
Digital Oscilloscope
How to properly use a Digital Oscilloscope to
make Electrical Power Measurements
Some “Do’s” and “Don’ts”
Measurement Examples
Comparison of a DSO and a Power Analyzer
6 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa Corporate History
1930 Vintage
Standard AC Voltmeter • Founded in 1915.
0.2% Accuracy Class • First to produce and sell electric
meters in Japan.
• North American operation
established in 1957
• World wide sales in excess of $4.3
Billion
• 84 companies world wide
• Over 19,000 employees worldwide
• Operations in 33 Countries
WT3000
Precision Power Analyzer
7 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa Corporation of America
8 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Part I – Electrical Power Measurements
PART I
ELECTRICAL POWER MEASUREMENTS
9 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
First, Some Basics: OHM’S LAW
10 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Average and RMS Values
11 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Average and RMS Values
12 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
What’s A Watt ?
A unit of Power equal to one
Joule of Energy per Second
DC Source: W = V x A
AC Source: W = V x A x PF
13 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
AC Power Measurement
Active Power:
Watts P = Vrms x Arms x PF
Also sometimes referred to as True Power or Real Power
Apparent Power:
Volt-Amps S = Vrms x Arms
14 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of AC Power
15 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
16 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
T
Pavg = 1/T 0 v(t) * I (t) dt
17 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
True RMS Measurements
T
Ptotal = 1/T 0 v(t) * I (t) dt
URMS = 1/T T
0 v(t)2 dt
IRMS = 1/T T
0 i(t)2 dt
18 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Single Phase Power Measurement
Wattmeter
AC A +
W
Source I(t) One - phase
V two - wire
V(t)
Load
. +
Single Wattmeter
Method
19 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
20 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Single-Phase Two-Wire System
21 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current Sensors
AEMC
Yokogawa
Scope
Probes Yokogawa
CT’s
Yokogawa/GMW-
LEM/Danfysik CT System
Pearson
Electronics Ram Meter
Shunts
22 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current Sensors
SELECTION CONSIDERATIONS
23 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current Sensors
SELECTION CONSIDERATIONS
• Instrument Compatibility
• Output: Millivolts/Amp, Milliamps/Amp; or Amps
• Impedance and Load, Burden
• Scope Probes - - CAUTION! Use on Scopes, NOT
Power Analyzers
• Physical Requirements
• Size
• Connections: Clamp-On or Donut type
• Distance from Load to Instrument
24 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current Sensors
A WORD OF CAUTION
25 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Single-Phase Three-Wire Power Measurement
Wattmeter 1
L1 A W
+
AC I(t)
Source V
V(t) One - phase
three - wire
N . +
Load
V(t)
I(t)
V
L2 W
A +
Wattmeter 2
PT = W1 + W2
Two Wattmeter
Method
26 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Single-Phase Three-Wire System
(Split Phase)
27 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Single-Phase Three-Wire System
28 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Single-Phase Three-Wire System
29 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Single-Phase Three-Wire System
30 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Blondel Theorem
31 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Andre Blondel
Blondel was born in France. He was employed as an engineer by the
Lighthouses and Beacons Service until he retired in 1927 as its general first
class inspector.He became a professor of electrotechnology at the School of
Bridges and Highways and the School of Mines. Very early in his career he
suffered immobility due to a paralysis of his legs, which confined him to his room
for 27 years, but he never stopped working.
This led him to invent the bifilar and soft iron oscillographs. These instruments
won the grand prize at the St. Louis Exposition in 1904. They remained the best
way to record high-speed electrical phenomena for more than 40 years when
they were replaced by the cathode ray oscilloscope.
32 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three - Phase Systems
vcn
vca
120o
vab
vbn
33 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three - Phase Systems
Phase
Voltages
Measured
Line to
Neutral
34 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three - Phase Systems
vab
b
vca Four - Wire
van vbc Three - Phase
c System
vbn
vcn
n
35 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
a A W +
a
AC V
Source b A +
Wb
V Four - Wire
van c A W +
Three - Phase
c Load
vbn V
vcn
+
n
Three Wattmeter
PT = Wa + Wb + Wc
Method
36 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Three-Phase Four-Wire System
37 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Three-Phase Four-Wire System
+ Phase
Phase Power
Power Factor
+
Phase
Current
&
Voltage
38 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Results Three-Phase Four-Wire System
Phase
Voltages
Measured
Line to
Neutral
Phase
Currents
39 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three-Phase Four–Wire Vector Diagram
U1
Phase
Voltages
Measured
Line to
Neutral
U2
U3
40 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three-Phase Three-Wire Systems
vab
vca Three - Wire
Three - Phase
b System
vcb
c
41 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Remember
Blondel’s Theory
42 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power 3P-3W System
a A +
Wa
V V
AC
Source vac
vab
Three - Wire
+ A + Three - Phase
b Wb Load
+
vcb
c V +
Wc
A +
Two Wattmeter
Method PT = Wa + Wb
43 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
44 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three-Phase Three-Wire System
45 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Electrical Power Measurements
46 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Three-Phase Three-Wire System With Three Meters
47 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Delta Measurements
3P3W (3V3A) Connection P3P3W = P3P4W
L-L
Voltage L-N
Voltage
+
Phase
+ Power
Neutral
Curren
t
Phase Power Measurement Solution on 3P3W (3V3A) Connection
48 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 48
3P-3W and 3P-4W Power Measurements
P3P3W = P3P4W
3P-3W 3P-4W
PART II
POWER FACTOR MEASUREMENTS
50 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor Measurement
51 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
R - L - C Circuit
Itot IL IC IR
R
S
Vmax*sin(w*t) C
52 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current LAGS Voltage in an Inductor
53 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Current LEADS Voltage in a Capacitor
54 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Real World Examples
Inductive Load
AC Motor
Current LAGS
Voltage in an
Inductor
Capacitive Load
Compact Florescent
Lamp
Current LEADS
Voltage in a
Capacitor
55 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor Measurement
• PF = COS Ø
• Where is the Zero
Crossing for the
Current
Waveform?
• How do we
accurately
measure Ø
between these two
waveforms?
56 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor Measurement
57 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Phasor Form of Power
S Q
“POWER TRIANGLE”
VOLT-AMPS VAR
WATTS P
58 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor Measurement
True Power Factor
PF = W / VA
PF = 87.193/113.753
PF = 0.76651
59 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor Measurement
Displacement
Power Factor
PF = Cos Ø
Between
Fundamental
Waveforms
PF = Cos 21.06
PF = 0.9332
PF = P1 / S1
PF = 48.16 / 51.61
PF = 0.9332
60 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor on 3-Phase System
PFTotal = W / VA
61 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor on 3-Phase 3-Wire System
PFTotal = W / VA
PFTotal = ( W1 + W2 ) / ( 3/2)( VA1 + VA2 )
62 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Factor on 3-Phase 3-Wire System
PFTotal = W / VA
PFTotal = ( W1 + W2 ) / ( 3/3)( VA1 + VA2 + VA3 )
• This method will give correct Power Factor calculation on
either Balanced or Unbalanced 3-Wire system. Note that
all three VA measurements are used in the calculation.
This calculation is performed in the Yokogawa Power
Analyzers when using the 3V-3A wiring method.
63 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
3-Phase 3-Wire Power Factor Measurement
3V 3A
Measurement Method
• P = P1 + P2
• PF = P / VA
• PF = 49.466 / 93.060
• PF = 0.53155
• How is VA calculated?
64 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Measurement Applications
POWER MEASUREMENT
APPLICATIONS
65 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Standby Power & Energy Star
Standby Power
®
Energy Star
&
IEC62301 Testing
(Household Applicances)
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 66
Overview
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 67
Scope of IEC62301
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 68
Terms and Definitions
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 69
Appliance Type
Pulse Power Mode
Example: Laser Printer or Copy Machine with Heaters
70 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Terms and Definitions
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 71
Other Applications
OTHER APPLICATIONS
72 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Measurement Application
3-P 3-W PWM Motor Drive Power Measurement
3V 3A
Measurement
Method
Drive voltage is
typically
measured using
the Mean value
scaled to rms.
• DC Bus
Voltage is
measured as
U+pk
73 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Device Efficiency Measurement
Device Efficiency is Calculated as Output Power
Divided by Input Power
Usually expressed as a percentage
Use Two Power Meters to Measure the Input and
Output Power
Calculate the Efficiency from the readings of the
two Power Meters
Problem – Input and Output Readings may not be
made Simultaneously. Possible error due to Time
Skew
Use a Multi-Element Power Analyzer to Measure
Input and Output Power
Calculate the Efficiency in a Single Power Analyzer
Eliminates any Error due to Time Skew of
Measurements
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 74
Device Efficiency Measurements
Device
Efficiency:
Output P
Input P
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 75
Device Efficiency & Power Loss
Input Power
Device Efficiency
Output
Power Device Loss
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com 76
Power Measurement Application
Device Start Up
Analysis
Device Voltage
Device Current
Cycle-by-Cycle
Start Up Power
77 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview – Part III of III
PART III
BASIC POWER MEASUREMENTS
using a
DIGITAL OSCILLOSCOPE
78 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Analysis with a DSO
79 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Special Note:
80 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
Remember - AC Power Measurement
Active Power:
Watts P = Vrms x Arms x PF
Also sometimes referred to as True Power or Real Power
Apparent Power:
Volt-Amps S = Vrms x Arms
81 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement of Power
T
Pavg = 1/T 0 v(t) * I (t) dt
82 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Analyzer vs. DSO
Function Power Analyzer DSO
Bandwidth DC – 2MHz DC – 500 MHz
Power DC –50 MHz
83 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Measurement Challenge: SKEW
Current clamp
e.g. 30 A, 100 MHz
model 701932
Differential probe
e.g. 1400 V, 100 MHz
model 700924
Skew = Propagation Delay Difference
Current Voltage
Auto Deskew function Successful de-skew!
84 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Deskew Calibration
• Signal source used for adjusting the skew between a voltage
probe and a current probe.
- Many different kinds of probes can be used for power
measurements. Each probe has a different signal path
length.
- Signal source generates time-coincident voltage and
current signals. This allows you to adjust for skew
between voltage and current probes.
85 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
BEFORE DE-SKEW
86 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
AFTER DE-SKEW
87 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa Solution: Auto De-skew
To correctly measure the analysis parameters such as power, impedance, power factor, watt hour,
and ampere hour from the voltage and current under analysis, the voltage and current signals
must be applied to the Vertical Input channels of the Oscilloscope while preserving the phase
relationship which exists between U & I in the DUT.
Output
signals with
no delay
Current
Voltage
88 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Analysis with a DSO
Typical Measurements
89 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Supply Input with Power Analyzer
90 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Supply Input with DSO
91 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Power Supply Input Summary
Measurement Comparison
Measurement Power Power
Item Analyzer DSO
Voltage RMS 118.28 V 117.27 V
Current RMS 1.3323 A 1.3321 A
Watts 97.54 W 96.49 W
Power Factor 0.619 0.617
92 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Switching Loss
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
PWM Inverter Output with Power Analyzer
94 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
PWM Inverter Output with Power DSO
95 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
PWM Inverter Output Summary
Measurement Comparison
Measurement Power Power
Item Analyzer DSO
Voltage RMS 176.18 V 178.56 V
Current RMS 0.3830 A 0.3950 A
Watts 44.75 W 46.37 W
Power Factor 0.6632 0.6602
96 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
DSO Power Calculation
97 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
DSO Power Calculation
Line Measurements:
•49.5 VA
•42.1 W
•25.9 VAR
•PF = 0.85
PF
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Harmonic
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Harmonics
www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
ScopeCorder (Hybrid Instrument) with DSP
101 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
What You Will Need
• Power Measurements with a DSO
– Oscilloscope
– Options – power analysis, probe power
– Probes
• Differential Voltage Probe
• Current probe
• High Voltage Probe
– Other
• Isolation line-transformer for non-isolated designs
(safety).
• Deskew Device
102 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
103 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Precision Power
Analyzers
104 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Digital Scopes & ScopeCorders
with Power Analysis
105 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Portable Power Test
Instruments
106 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
107 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Power Transducers
108 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Multi Function
Digital Meters
109 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Yokogawa’s Power Measuring Solutions
Portable Instruments
110 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview - What We Hope You Learned
Helped You With a Better Understanding
of Electrical Power Measurements
Review of Some of the Basics
Power Measurements Using a Precision
Power Analyzer and Digital Oscilloscope
Single-Phase Power Measurements
Current Sensors
Three-Phase Power Measurements
2 & 3 Wattmeter Method
111 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview - What We Hope You Learned
112 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Overview - What We Hope You Learned
Part III: Power Measurements using a
Digital Oscilloscope
How to properly use a Digital Oscilloscope to
make Electrical Power Measurements
De Skew Operation
Measurement Examples on a Power Supply
Input and a PWM Inverter Output
Measurement Comparison between the DSO
and a Power Analyzer
Answer your questions concerning
Electrical Power Measurements
113 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Invitation to Power Measurement Webinars
Power Analysis: Precision AC Power Measurements This one hour seminar will cover Precision Power
Measurements and Power Factor Measurements.
Power Measurement & Harmonic Analysis This 1-hour seminar is packed with tips and techniques for
making accurate power measurements on distorted waveforms like from a Power Supply, Electronic
Ballast and Variable Speed PWM Motor Drive. We will also cover methods for making and analyzing the
harmonic content of various power waveforms.
Advances in Precision Electrical Power Measurement This informative Webinar covers new measurement
techniques and solutions for making precision power measurements to improve product performance
and efficiency designs.
Back to the Basics of Electrical Power Measurement Target audience is Engineers and Technicians that need
to make Power Measurements but may not be experts in the field or may need a refresher course.
Power Analysis: Precision AC Power Measurements This webinar will cover Precision Power Measurements
and Power Factor Measurements.
Digital Oscilloscope Power Analysis In this 1-hour seminar you will be introduced to the many specialized
power measurements necessary to evaluate switched-mode power supplies.
Requirements and Easy Solutions for Standby Power Measurements This 30-minute Webinar discusses the
area of Standby Power Measurements.
Power Measurement and Analysis Power measurement requires much more than a simple measurement of
voltage and current, requiring phase angle as well as harmonic distortion. Government regulations exist
for both. (not yet online)
Fundamentals of Electrical Power Measurements This one hour webinar will provide attendees with
Solutions and Education for making Electrical Power Measurements.
114 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Webinars & Webinars On Demand
http://tmi.yokogawa.com/us/technical-library/seminars-webcasts/
115 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com
Thank You & Contact Info
Yokogawa Corp of America
Test & Measurement Div.
2 Dart Rd.
Newnan, GA 30265
tmi.yokogawa.com
Tel: 1-800-888-6400
Barry Bolling
Application Engineer
Ext 2538
116 www.EngineeringBooksLibrary.com