Supply Chain Management
Supply Chain Management
Supply Chain Management
What is Supply Chain Management (SCM)? Supply chain management (SCM) is the active management of supply
chain activities to maximize customer value and achieve a sustainable competitive advantage. It represents a
conscious effort by the supply chain firms to develop and run supply chains in the most effective & efficient ways
possible. Supply chain activities cover everything from product development, sourcing, production, and logistics, as
well as the information systems needed to coordinate these activities. The concept of Supply Chain Management
(SCM) is based on two core ideas: The first is that practically every product that reaches an end
SCM involves a series of key activities and processes that must be completed in an efficient
(fuel-conserving, cost-reducing, etc.) and timely manner. Otherwise, product will not be available
when needed by consumers like you.
If you think about it, every order needs to be executed according to these seven goals. You must
attempt to deliver a “perfect order” to every customer every time. Doing it right the first time
makes the customer happy, saves the cost of fixing errors, and doesn't require extra use of
assets. Thus, every part of the organization has a vested interest in pursuing perfection.
A “perfect order” delivery is only attained when all Seven Rights of Fulfillment are achieved. To
accomplish a perfect order fulfillment, the seller has to have your preferred product available for
order, process your order correctly, ship the entire order via the means that you request, provide
you with an advanced shipping notification and tracking number, deliver the complete order on
time and without damage, and bill you correctly. A seller’s ultimate goal is to make the customer
happy by doing the job right, which gives them a good reason to use the seller’s services again in
the future.
SCM Flows
If the goal of SCM is to provide high product availability through efficient and timely fulfillment of
customer demand, then how is the goal accomplished?
Obviously, you need effective flows of products from the point of origin to the point of
consumption. But there’s more to it. Consider the diagram of the fresh food supply chain. A two-
way flow of information and data between the supply chain participants creates visibility of
demand and fast detection of problems. Both are needed by supply chain managers to make
good decisions regarding what to buy, make, and move.
Other flows are also important. In their roles as suppliers, companies have a vested interest in
financial flows; suppliers want to get paid for their products and services as soon as possible and
with minimal hassle. Sometimes, it is also necessary to move products back through the supply
chain for returns, repairs, recycling, or disposal.
Because of all the processes that have to take place at different types of participating companies,
each company needs supply chain managers to help improve their flows of product, information,
and money. This opens the door of opportunity to you to to a wide variety of SCM career options
for you!
SCM Processes
Supply chain activities aren't the responsibility of one person or one company. Multiple people
need to be actively involved in a number of different processes to make it work.
It's kind of like baseball. While all the participants are called baseball players, they don't do
whatever they want. Each person has a role – pitcher, catcher, shortstop, etc. – and must
perform well at their assigned duties – fielding, throwing, and/or hitting – for the team to be
successful.
Of course, these players need to work well together. A hit-and-run play will only be successful if
the base runner gets the signal and takes off running, while the batter makes solid contact with
the ball. The team also needs a manager to develop a game plan, put people in the right
positions, and monitor success.
Winning the SCM “game” requires supply chain professionals to play similar roles. Each supply
chain player must understand his or her role, develop winning strategies, and collaborate with
their supply chain teammates. By doing so, the SCM team can flawlessly execute the following
processes:
Planning – the plan process seeks to create effective long- and short-range supply chain
strategies. From the design of the supply chain network to the prediction of customer demand, supply
chain leaders need to develop integrated supply chain strategies.
Procurement – the buy process focuses on the purchase of required raw materials, components,
and goods. As a consumer, you're pretty familiar with buying stuff!
Production – the make process involves the manufacture, conversion, or assembly of materials
into finished goods or parts for other products. Supply chain managers provide production support and
ensure that key materials are available when needed.
Distribution – the move process manages the logistical flow of goods across the supply chain.
Transportation companies, third party logistics firms, and others ensure that goods are flowing quickly and
safely toward the point of demand.
Customer Interface – the demand process revolves around all the issues that are related to
planning customer interactions, satisfying their needs, and fulfilling orders perfectly.
One of the supply chain management features that you want to look for is excellent inventory management.
The software should be able to maintain stability with tracking of inventory as well as the finished goods.
This function should also include the ability to track materials needed for production and eliminate any
excess waste that may be costing your company extra money. This will not only help with the reducing of
cost spent on materials, but also on the issue of storage.
Managing of Orders
Another of the key supply chain management features is the ability to manage orders through your
company. Your new software should be able to manage an order from the time it is placed until the time it
is delivered as a finished product. This helps make everyone accountable for the work they do as well as
keeping everyone working efficiently. This will improve your customer service abilities when your
customer sees that they are still getting the same quality product but at a quicker rate.
Procurement
One key supply chain management feature is the ability to create lasting relationships with your clients. In
doing this you want to make sure that all tasks associated with a particular order are being tracked properly.
This will help you not only in your customer service area but also in the area of negotiating for sales. If you
are able to give a more definite finish date for a product then you are more likely to earn their trust and win
the sale.
Logistics
As your company expands, you want to make sure your software will expand with you. You want to make
sure you have a supply chain management feature that will allow your company room to grow; whether
locally or globally. This will help to save you money in the long run because no further software will need
to be purchased to keep your company running. Downtime can be the biggest cost to a company and by
choosing the right software you will not have that worry on your shoulders.
Planning and Forecasting
If your company produces a product that is popular around holiday times then you want to be able to
predict the demand you may have at a certain time of year. The right supply chain management features
will help you in this battle by looking at years past data and seeing where you will be at that same time in
the year. This is a great asset to have so that your planning and scheduling can be right on target.
Managing of Returns
Finally, the last supply chain management feature to mention is the return management. If your product is
defective or broken when it arrives at your customers’ location then chances are you are going to have a
very unhappy customer. Let your supply chain management feature handle this for you. The automatic
processing of claims is one way that the software will help eliminate this headache.
1. Value Flow:-
Flow of the goods and services from vendor (suppliers) to customers (occasionally there would
be reserve logistics). Flow to vendor side is referred to as upstream and customers side as
downstream.
2. Information Flow:-
Both upstream and downstream – Upstream (against the direction of major value flow)
Includes inputs for forecasts, marketing plans, dispatch plans, production plans, procurement
qualities and timing, orders from customers/ dealers, quality feedback, warranties invoked etc.
Downstream refers to stocks available, dispatch advices, stock transfer notes, quality assurance
reports, warranties, etc.
3. Cash Flow:-
Cash Flow determines how a given value flow is financed by various players in the supply chain.
The optimal cash flow structure will be determined by the “power balances” between the vendor,
converter and customer and the relative cost of finance and other fiscal benefits between these
players.
Lesson Transcript
A marketing, communications, and supply chain professional who has a masters degree in IT Mangement.
Has been working with young professionals to develop their leadership styles.
In this lesson, we'll be looking at physical distribution and the movement of finished goods from production
to consumer. We will explore the functions of physical distribution and its importance.
Definition
Physical distribution is the group of activities associated with the supply of finished product from the
production line to the consumers. The physical distribution considers many sales distribution channels,
such as wholesale and retail, and includes critical decision areas like customer service, inventory,
materials, packaging, order processing, and transportation and logistics. You often will hear these
processes be referred to as distribution, which is used to describe the marketing and movement of
products.
Accounting for nearly half of the entire marketing budget of products, the physical distribution process
typically garnishes a lot of attention from business managers and owners. As a result, these activities are
often the focus of process improvement and cost-saving initiatives in many companies.
Customer service
Order processing
Inventory control
Transportation and logistics
Packaging and materials
The customer service function is a strategically designed standard for consumer satisfaction that the
business intends to provide to its customers. As an example, a customer satisfaction approach for the
handbag business mentioned above may be that 75% of all custom handbags are delivered to the
customer within 72 hours of ordering. An additional approach might include that 95% of custom handbags
be delivered to the customer within 96 hours of purchase. Once these customer service standards are set,
the physical distribution system is then designed to attain these goals.
Order processing is designed to take the customer orders and execute the specifics the customer has
purchased. The business is concerned with this function because it directly relates to how the customer is
serviced and attaining the customer service goals. If the order processing system is efficient, then the
business can avoid other costs in other functions, such as transportation or inventory control. For
example, if the handbag business has an error in the processing of a customer order, the business has to
turn to premium transportation modes, such as next day air or overnight, to meet the customer service
standard set out, which will increase the transportation cost.
Inventory control is a major role player in the distribution system of a business. Costs include investment
into current inventory, loss of demand for products, and depreciation. There are different types of
inventory control systems that can be implemented, such as first in-first out (or FIFO) and flow through,
which are methods for businesses to handle products.
Agents/Brokers
Agents or brokers are individuals or companies that act as an extension of the manufacturing
company. Their main job is to represent the producer to the final user in selling a product.
Thus, while they do not own the product directly, they take possession of the product in the
distribution process. They make their profits through fees or commissions.
Wholesalers
Unlike agents, wholesalers take title to the goods and services that they are intermediaries
for. They are independently owned, and they own the products that they sell. Wholesalers do
not work with small numbers of product: they buy in bulk, and store the products in their own
warehouses and storage places until it is time to resell them. Wholesalers rarely sell to the
final user; rather, they sell the products to other intermediaries such as retailers, for a higher
price than they paid. Thus, they do not operate on a commission system, as agents do.
Distributors
Distributors function similarly to wholesalers in that they take ownership of the product, store
it, and sell it off at a profit to retailers or other intermediaries. However, the key difference is
that distributors ally themselves to complementary products. For example, distributors of
Coca Cola will not distribute Pepsi products, and vice versa. In this way, they can maintain a
closer relationship with their suppliers than wholesalers do.
Retailers
Retailers come in a variety of shapes and sizes: from the corner grocery store, to large
chains like Wal-Mart and Target. Whatever their size, retailers purchase products from
market intermediaries and sell them directly to the end user for a profit.
Objectives Of Distribution
The main objectives of distribution in marketing are as follows:
1. Movement of goods
The main objective of distribution is to make flow of goods from production place
toconsumption place. For this, the role of the distribution channel system and its members
becomes very important.
2. Availability of goods
The objective of distribution function is to make or supply necessary goods to the large masses of
customers living indifferent geographical areas.
3. Protection of goods
The objective of distribution is also to properly storing, handling and protecting the goods and
supplying them to the consumers in good condition.
4. Cost reduction
The objective of distribution is also to reduce cost of product by bringing effectiveness in distribution
process.
5. Customer satisfaction
The other objective of distribution function is to help consumers feel satisfied through effective
distribution.
1. Product Availability:
The first objective is to make available the product to the consumer who wants to buy it. The
availability has two aspects – the desired level of coverage in terms of appropriate retail outlets
and secondly, the positioning of the product within the store. Product availability is important for
consumer convenience goods, where customer does not wait to buy a particular brand. However,
for unique and important products immediate availability is less critical.
4. Market Information:
Since intermediaries are in the marketplace and near to consumers they are the best and first
hand source of getting feedback with regard to sales trends, inventory levels, competitors’ moves
and customers’ reactions.
5. Cost-Effectiveness:
Costs to be incurred to attain the firm’s channel objectives should not be too much in relation to
gains. There is often a trade off between channel costs, associated with physical distribution
activities such as transportation and inventory storage, and achieving high levels of performance
on many other objectives.
6. Flexibility:
A flexible channel is one where it is relatively easy to switch channel structures or add new types
of middlemen without generating costly economic or legal conflicts with existing channel
members.
When a customer is considering buying a product he tries to access its value by looking at
various factors which surround it. Factors like its delivery, availability etc which are directly
influenced by channel members. Similarly, a marketer too while choosing his distribution
members must access what value is this member adding to the product. He must compare the
benefits received to the amount paid for using the services of this intermediary. These benefits
can be the following:
Cost Saving
The members of distribution channel are specialized in what they do and perform at much lower
costs than companies trying to run the entire distribution channel all by itself.
Time Saving
Along with costs, time of delivery is also reduced due to efficiency and experience of the channel
members. For example if a grocery store were to receive direct delivery of goods from every
manufacturer the result would have been a chaos. Everyday hundreds of trucks would line up
outside the store to deliver products. The store may not have enough space for storing all their
products and this would add to the chaos. If a grocery wholesaler is included in the distribution
chain then the problem is almost solved. This wholesaler will have a warehouse where he can
store bulk shipments. The grocery store now receives deliveries from the wholesaler in amounts
required and at a suitable time and often in a single truck. In this way cost as well as time is
saved.
Customer Convenience
Including members in the distribution chain provides customer with a lot of convenience in their
shopping. If every manufacturer owned its own grocery store then customers would have to visit
multiple grocery stores to complete their shopping list. This would be extremely time-consuming
as well as taxing for the customer. Thus channel distribution provides accumulating and assorting
services, which means they purchase from many suppliers the various goods that a customer
may demand. Secondly, channel distribution is time saving as the customers can find all that
they need in one retail store and the retailer
Retailers buy in bulk quantities from the manufacturer or wholesaler. This is more cost effective
than buying in small quantities. However they resell in smaller quantities to their customers. This
phenomenon of breaking bulk quantities and selling them in smaller quantities is known as bulk
breaking. The customers therefore have the benefit of buying in smaller quantities and they also
get a share of the profit the retailer makes when he buys in bulk from the supplier.
Resellers often use persuasive techniques to persuade customers into buying a product thereby
increasing sales for that product. They often make use of various promotional offers and special
product displays to entice customers into buying certain products.
Resellers offer financial programs to their customers which makes payment easier for the
customer. Customers can buy on credit, buy using a payment plan etc.
Manufacturers who include resellers for selling their products rely on them to provide information
which will help in improving the product or in increasing its sale. High-level channel members
often provide sales data. On all other occasions the manufacturer can always rely on the reseller
to provide him with customer feedback.
Revenue loss
The manufacturer sells his product to the intermediaries at costs lower than the price at which
these middlemen sell to the final customers. Therefore the manufacturer goes for a loss in
revenue. The intermediaries would never offer their services to the manufacturer unless they
made a profit out of selling his products. They are either made a direct payment by the
manufacturer, for instance shipping costs or as in the case of retailers by selling the product at
costs higher than the price at which the product was bought from the manufacturer (also known
as markup). The manufacturer could have sold at this final price and made a greater profit if he
had been managing the distribution all by himself.
Along with loss over the revenue the manufacturer also loses control over what message is being
conveyed to the final customers. The reseller may engage in personal selling in order to increase
the product sale and communicate about the product to his customers. He might exaggerate
about the benefits of the product this may lead to miscommunication problems with end users.
The marketer may provide training to the salespersons of retail outlets but on the whole he has
no control on the final message conveyed.
The importance given to a manufacturer�s product by the members of the distribution channel
is not under the manufacturer�s control. In various cases like transportation delays the product
loses its importance in the channel and the sales suffer. Similarly a competitor�s product may
enjoy greater importance as the channel members might be getting a higher promotional
incentive.
Some of the factors to consider while selecting channels of distribution are as follows: (i) Product
(ii) Market (iii) Middlemen (iv) Company (v) Marketing Environment (vi) Competitors (vii)
distribution:
(i) Product:
Perishable goods need speedy movement and shorter route of distribution. For durable and
standardized goods, longer and diversified channel may be necessary. Whereas, for custom made
channel. Products of high unit value are sold directly by travelling sales force and not through
middlemen.
(ii) Market:
(a) For consumer market, retailer is essential whereas in business market we can eliminate
retailing.
(b) For large market size, we have many channels, whereas, for small market size direct selling
may be profitable.
(c) For highly concentrated market, direct selling is preferred whereas for widely scattered and
(d) Size and average frequency of customer’s orders also influence the channel decision. In the
Customer and dealer analysis will provide information on the number, type, location, buying
habits of consumers and dealers in this case can also influence the choice of channels. For
example, desire for credit, demand for personal service, amount and time and efforts a customer
(iii) Middlemen:
(a) Middlemen who can provide wanted marketing services will be given first preference.
(b) The middlemen who can offer maximum co-operation in promotional services are also
preferred.
(c) The channel generating the largest sales volume at lower unit cost is given top priority.
(iv) Company:
(a) The company’s size determines the size of the market, the size of its larger accounts and its
ability to set middlemen’s co-operation. A large company may have shorter channel.
(b) The company’s product-mix influences the pattern of channels. The broader the product- line,
dealership.
(c) A company with substantial financial resources may not rely on middlemen and can afford to
reduce the levels of distribution. A financially weak company has to depend on middlemen.
(e) A company desiring to exercise greater control over channel will prefer a shorter channel as it
(f) Heavy advertising and sale promotion can motivate middlemen in the promotional campaign.
Thus, quantity and quality of marketing services provided by the company can influence the
During recession or depression, shorter and cheaper channel is preferred. During prosperity, we
have a wider choice of channel alternatives. The distribution of perishable goods even in distant
markets becomes a reality due to cold storage facilities in transport and warehousing. Hence, this
(vi) Competitors:
Marketers closely watch the channels used by rivals. Many a time, similar channels may be
deliberately avoid channels used by competitors. For example, company may by-pass retail store
channel (used by rivals) and adopt door-to-door sales (where there is no competition).
This refers to geographical distribution, frequency of purchase, average quantity of purchase and
This involves cost-benefit analysis. Major elements of distribution cost apart from channel
Distribution Cost Analysis is a fast growing and perhaps the most rewarding area in marketing
Every year companies lose billions of dollars in their distribution channel operations through a
combination of lost revenue opportunities and leakage, channel inefficiencies and lack of tight
compliance disciplines.
Sales Forecasting
Channel Marketing Management
Inventory Management
Incentive Program Management
Revenue Recognition
Financial Compliance and Risk Management
Data Integrity
Most companies are constantly struggling to address all this ever-growing complexity with
inefficient, piecemeal approaches and an overworked staff who is always a couple steps behind
the curve. Current systems are incomplete in data reconciliation, automation, analytics and
integration with other enterprise applications. They often succumb to believing whatever their
partners say and paying claims without question in order not to rock the boat.
Worse yet, some companies have simply adopted a culture of acceptance that the
complexity, inefficiency and profit leakage in their go-to-market channels are just “necessary
evils” that can’t be resolved. So they’ve settled into a pattern of ignoring the issues and accepting
the losses.
Definition: Distribution Channel Management
As the name implies, it is the whole process of delivering a product/service from the manufacturer to the end customer. It
is also known as marketing channel.
2. Indirect Channel: A specialized intermediary is added in this type of channel as they have the required contacts,
experience and scale of operations. He might be a consultant, Original Equipment manufacturer (OEMs), etc. The reason
for this includes the efficiency of distribution costs.
For eg:
A Toyota dealer will depend on a lot of factors to persuade customers, such as other dealers and the motor company itself.
He needs to ensure its sales are on a rise and the service which they provide is worthy of customer’s trust. So basically, the
whole trust of Toyota depends upon the distribution channel.
Hence, this concludes the definition of Distribution Channel Management along with its overview.
Browse the definition and meaning of more terms similar to Distribution Channel Management. The Management
Dictionary covers over 7000 business concepts from 6 categories.
These international grocery retailers follow a multi brand and multi product business format which includes all products
like food encompassing all types of fresh vegetables, fruits, juices, chocolates etc, fashion and clothing including bed linen
etc, grocery, all types of branded consumables, as well as liquor and many more household goods under one roof. They
generally follow a format that allows for selling to whole sellers, retailers as well as general public at the mega stores.
Traditionally these International Grocery Retailers have operated mainly in US and in Europe. Specifically in Europe the
largest markets have been in Germany, France and UK. With globalisation and with several countries opening their
markets to FDI in retail, these Organisations are moving into other parts of the world and into emerging markets.
There is yet another group of International retailers like IKEA, Lego, Toys ‘R’Us etc who have chosen to focus and
specialise in a particular segment like furniture etc.
In the earlier times, the nova rich and the business class were the main customers who sourced these branded products
from abroad. However in the recent times we see the educated and economically empowered youth demanding fashion and
going in for branded items. International brands have thus established a niche for themselves in domestic markets aided by
the increasing demand for branded fashion products. International grocery retailers have expanded their business in
emerging markets by virtue of their investments and procurement strategies.
To compound this, what is considered supply chain management in the United States is more
commonly known as logistics management in Europe, according to the blog for PLS Logistics
Services, a logistics management firm in Pennsylvania.
When the question was posed in an Inbound Logistics article, the answers varied based on the
functions a supply chain (or logistics) professional handled. Some thoughts from their readers:
Purchasing, materials handling, logistics, transportation, inventory control and supply chain
management have continued to evolve, causing many of these functional areas to intersect with
one another. This intersection has resulted in blurred definitions for some of these terms such as
logistics and supply chain management.
While these two terms do have some similarities they are, in fact, different concepts with different
meanings. Supply chain management is an overarching concept that links together multiple
processes to achieve competitive advantage, while logistics refers to the movement, storage and
flow of goods, services and information within the overall supply chain.
It is the efforts of a number of organizations working together as a supply chain that help manage the flow of raw materials
and ensure the finished goods provide value. Supply chain managers work across multiple functions and companies to
ensure that a finished product not only gets to the end consumer, but meets all requirements as well. Logistics is just one
small part of the larger, all-encompassing supply chain network.
What is Logistics?
The Council of Supply Chain Management Professionals defines logistics as “part of the supply chain process that plans,
implements and controls the efficient, effective forward and reverse flow and storage of goods, services and related
information between the point of origin and the point of consumption in order to meet customer’s requirements.”
Bowersox, Closs and Cooper define logistics as activities – transportation, warehousing, packaging and more – that move
and position inventory and acknowledge its role in terms of synchronizing the supply chain.
The objective behind logistics is to make sure the customer receives the desired product at the right time and place with
the right quality and price. This process can be divided into two subcategories: inbound logistics and outbound logistics.
Inbound logistics covers the activities concerned with obtaining materials and then handling, storing and transporting them.
Outbound logistics covers the activities concerned with collection, maintenance and distribution to the customer. Other
activities, such as packing and fulfilling orders, warehousing, managing stock and maintaining the equilibrium between
supply and demand also factor into logistics.
Logistics Costs
Logistics costs are defined differently by different companies. Some companies do not account interest and depreciation
on inventories as logistic costs. Others include the distribution costs of their suppliers or the purchasing costs. In some
cases, even the purchase value of the procured goods is included in the logistic costs. So, there is no generic definition of
this term but every company needs to define the logistics costs for itself and the KPI’s it will be tracking to lower the
costs.
Generally, logistics costs include:
1) Transportation costs
2) Inventory carrying costs
3) Labour Costs
4) Customer service costs
5) Rent for storage costs
6) Administration costs
7) Other costs
2. What is Logistics?
"Logistics is about getting the right product, to the right customer, in the right quantity, in the right
condition, at the right place, at the right time, and at the right cost (the 7 Rs)" - John J. Coyle et al
In the past, various tasks were under different departments, but now they are under the same
department and report to the same head as below,
As you can see, purchasing and warehouse function communicates with suppliers and sometimes
called "supplier facing function". Production planning and inventory control function is the center
point of this chart. Customer service and transport function communicates with customers and
sometimes called "customer-facing functions.
7. What is 3PL?
The concept of 3PL appeared on the scene in the 1980s as the way to reduce costs and improve
services which can be defined as below,
"3PL refers to the outsourcing of activities, ranging from a specific task, such as trucking or marine
cargo transport to broader activities serving the whole supply chain such as inventory management,
order processing and consulting."
In the past, many 3PL providers didn't have adequate expertise to operate in complex supply chain
structure and process. The result was the inception of another concept.
8. What is 4PL?
The 4PL is the concept proposed by Accenture Ltd in 1996 and it was defined as below,
"4PL refers to a party who works on behalf of the client to do contract negotiations and management of
performance of 3PL providers, including the design of the whole supply chain network and control of
day-to-day operations"
You may wonder if a 4PL provider is really needed. According to the research by Nezar Al-Mugren
from the University of Wisconsin-Stout, top 3 reasons why customers would like to use 4PL providers
are as below,
- It's a Network: Many companies have the department that controls various activities within the
supply chain. So the people are led to believe that SCM is a "function" which it's not. It is actually a
"network" consists of many players as below,
A generic supply chain structure is as simple as Supplier, Manufacturer, Wholesaler and Retailer (it's
more complex in the real world but a simple illustration serves the purpose).
The word "management" can be explained briefly as "planning, implementing, controlling". Supply
Chain Management is then the planning, implementing and controlling of the networks.
- Information Must Flow: Another important attribute of supply chain management is the flow of
material, information and finance (money). Even though there are 3 types of flow, the most important
one is information flow aka information sharing. Let's see the example of this through the simplified
version of bullwhip effect as below,
When demand data is not shared, each player in the same supply chain must make some sort of
speculation. According to the above graphic, the retailer has a demand for 100 units, but each player
tends to keep stock more and more at every step of the way. This results in higher costs for everyone in
the same supply chain.
When information is shared from retailer down to supplier, everyone doesn't have to keep stock that
much. The result is lower cost for everyone.
- Coordination is Essential: Information sharing requires a certain degree of "coordination" (it's also
referred to as collaboration or integration in scholarly articles). Do you wonder when people started
working together as a network? In 1984, companies in the apparel business worked together to reduce
overall lead-time. In 1995, companies in automotive industry used Electronic Data Interchange to
share information. So, working as a "chain" is the real world practice.
- Avoid Conflicting Objectives: Working as a network requires the same objective, but this is often
not the case (even with someone in the same company). "Conflicting Objectives" is the term used to
describe the situation when each function wants something that won't go well together. For example,
purchasing people always place the orders to the cheapest vendors (with a very long lead-time) but
production people need material more quickly.
To avoid conflicting objectives, you need to decide if you want to adopt a time-based strategy, low-
cost strategy or differentiation strategy. A clear direction is needed so people can make the decisions
accordingly.
- Balance Cost/Service: The concept of Cost/Service Trade-off appeared as early as in 1985 but it
seems that people really don't get it.
When you want to improve service, the cost goes up. When you want to cut cost, service suffers. It's
like a "seesaw", the best way you can do is to try to balance both sides.
Real world example is that a "new boss" ask you to cut costs by 10%, improve service level by 15%,
double inventory turns and so on. If you really understand cost/service trade-off concept, you will
agree that you can't win them all. The most appropriate way to handle this is to prioritize your KPIs.
- Foster Long-term Relationship: To work as the same team, long-term relationship is a key.
Otherwise, you're just a separate company with a different strategy/agenda. So academia keeps
preaching about the importance of relationship building, but is not for everyone.
Since there are too many suppliers to deal with, portfolio matrix is often used to prioritize the
relationship building. Focus your time and energy to create the long-term relationship with suppliers of
key products and items with limited sources of supply because these are people who can make or break
your supply chain.
All the activities, associated with the sourcing, procurement, conversion and logistics
management, comes under the supply chain management. Above all, it encompasses the
coordination and collaboration with the parties like suppliers, intermediaries, distributors and
customers. Logistics Management is a small portion of Supply Chain Management that deals
with the management of goods in an efficient way.
Supply Chain Management, it is a broader term which refers to the connection, right from the
suppliers to the ultimate consumer.
It has been noticed that there is a drastic change in the manner in which business was conducted
many years ago and now. Due to the improvement in the technology, which leads to the
development of all key areas of business. Supply Chain Management also evolved as an
improvement over Logistics Management, from past years. Check out this article to understand
the difference between Logistics Management and Supply Chain Management.
Comparison Chart
BASIS FOR
LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
COMPARISON
Meaning The process of integrating the movement The coordination and management of the
and maintenance of goods in and out the supply chain activities are known as Supply
BASIS FOR
LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
COMPARISON
Evolution The concept of Logistics has been evolved Supply Chain Management is a modern
earlier. concept.
One in another Logistics Management is a fraction of Supply Chain Management is the new
Supply Chain Management. version of Logistics Management.
There are many factors said to cause or contribute to the bullwhip effect in
supply chains; the following list names a few:
Order batching; companies may not immediately place an order with their
supplier; often accumulating the demand first. Companies may order weekly or
even monthly. This creates variability in the demand as there may for instance
be a surge in demand at some stage followed by no demand after.
Price variations – special discounts and other cost changes can upset
regular buying patterns; buyers want to take advantage on discounts offered
during a short time period, this can cause uneven production and distorted
demand information.
Demand information – relying on past demand information to estimate
current demand information of a product does not take into account any
fluctuations that may occur in demand over a period of time.
Let’s look at an example; the actual demand for a product and its materials start
at the customer, however often the actual demand for a product gets distorted
going down the supply chain. Let’s say that an actual demand from a customer
is 8 units, the retailer may then order 10 units from the distributor; an extra 2
units are to ensure they don’t run out of floor stock.
Every day, new warehousing and wholesale supplier businesses are opening their doors, and
plenty more are on their way out because they can’t keep up in a competitive economy. In order
to maintain a successful distribution center in this business environment, you have to run
an efficient operation in which you are constantly moving product and satisfying your
customers. To keep afloat, it is important to maintain stable business relationships by providing
reliable logistics and product delivery while keeping your costs down. In this article we’ll go over 5
ways to successfully manage your supplier business so you can fulfill all of these requirements.
Many logistics experts assert that warehouses and distribution centers are virtually the same
operation, but experts like Cliff Holste at Supply Chain Digest insist that they are not. Though
both warehouse and distribution center management operations typically take place in large
warehouse environments, the term “warehouse” refers to a traditional product storage model, and
“distribution center” refers to the more contemporary and high-velocity order fulfillment model.
Whatever model you choose, it pays to streamline your operations with the latest organizational
and technical upgrades. If you’re looking to improve operations and overall, successfully manage
your warehouse or distribution center, consider these 5 tips.
1. Take Advantage of Technological Innovation
There are some excellent technologies out there that can make your job much easier. For
example, a warehouse management system (WMS) is crucial to a modern distribution center
management. There are many different types of WMS software packages available on the
market, depending on your needs. Common functions include an advanced shipping notification
(ASN) system, which can be used to keep track of all of the inbound orders you are receiving,
which is crucial to properly coordinating shipments with crossdocking and replenishments. You
can combine this with a vendor compliance program to make incoming shipments integrate
smoothly with your operations.
Dynamic slotting modules and workflow organization systems are also important tools for
streamlining your warehouse operations. A good WMS system has a number of other useful tools
for managing orders, inventory, and shipments.
Also consider your automation options to make everything run smoother. Conveyor systems are
excellent for closing the distances that pickers have to cover. Other operations can be
successfully automated with picking towers, stretch wrap systems, robotic palletizers, and AS/RS
systems.
2. Organize Your Warehouse
Warehouses feature complex organizational schemes that can be tinkered with in a dizzying
amount of ways to increase efficiency and effectiveness. One way to think about this
organization has to do with mapping out the flow of material in the facility. From the point at which
you receive your merchandise to the point at which it leaves the warehouse to be shipped to your
customers, you should be thinking about the most efficient way to direct the flow.
The product you are offloading last should be the first to go into your truck. This is just a crude
example, but logistical questions like these will determine things like your pick path and the way
items move through your warehouse. How will your products be stored and how will they move?
What are the picking methods that achieve the most efficient results?
3. Manage Inventory
Inventory is a vital component to your operation. Are you going to specialize in a specific type of
products, or will you carry a wide variety? How much inventory are you going to have on hand at
a given time?
It is a good idea to shoot for a low inventory and high velocity of materials in this business.
Otherwise you will have to manage product shelf life and tackle other similar issues on top of
everything else.
You may carry certain stocks at different seasonal periods, or your inventory may be constantly
changing due to market trends. Your WMS can help you with dynamic slotting so you can keep
on top of your inventory.
4. Analyze Everything
This secret ties in with the first point about utilizing technology, specifically, information
technology. There are robust means of data collection and analytics available to modern supply
businesses, and you should take advantage of high data resolutions to maximize the efficiency of
every aspect of your operation.
Most of the data collection can be done automatically with features like barcode and radio
frequency identification, which can be integrated into your WMS for greater control. Other ways to
pick up data include voice-activated technology and RFID methods. You can also manually
gather data if required.
Gather as much data as you can from your picking operations. This way you can decide whether
a batch picking, zone picking, single-order, or multi-order picking methodology is going to work
best with your particular business. If you treat every product movement as a transaction, you’ll
have a greater wealth of data to determine how everything moves in your factory, which allows
for maximum efficiency.
5. Stay On Board with Your Staff
A good amount of automation and data tracking will allow you to develop effective logistics, but
your warehouse is only as efficient as your staff is effective at their jobs. It is a good idea to
implement a robust training program that provides a standard operating procedure, which
provides appropriate guidelines for working within your particular warehouse.
Training should include maintenance and operation of machinery, warehouse organization,
reporting, processes, customer service, and other essential components of your business. Labor
management software may help to keep track of your staff performance as well.
Employee feedback is always valuable, as on-the-ground information can be the best kind of
data. Keeping your employees happy with a positive work environment improves communication
and staff cohesion, which needless to say, will keep your warehouse running smooth.
In organizations having many production centers which are situated at distant places, it may be an important issue to decide
whether for the purpose of purchasing for all the production centers, there should be only one purchase department or for each
production centre, there should be one purchase department. Upon the following factors the decision shall primarily depend:-
a. the distance between the production centers & the central godown,
b. the nature of the materials used i.e. whether the material is bulky, heavy, fragile etc. ,
d. the firm’s policy in this respect; & secondarily upon the comparative advantage & disadvantage of the two systems.
Where for the purpose of purchasing for all, there is one purchase department; in that case it is referred to as centralized purchase.
When, on the other hand, when for each production center, there is a purchase department, it is referred as decentralized purchase. The
comparative advantage & the disadvantages of the two systems are as below:
2. For production of standard products, one basic raw material is used by the plant or plants.
The above cannot be the firm conclusion, because centralized purchase may benefit plants which are distinctly situated but use very
costly but light materials, the reason behind this is that, negligible cost of transport is there & better control on material cost can be
achieved.
The purchasing function is usually performed most economically and efficiently by a specialised,
centralised purchasing department, directed by a skilled purchasing manager.
However, the purchasing function does not have to be performed in such a manner. In theory, it
can be performed, and in practice, it sometimes is performed by any number of different
company officers or departments.
The functions of purchasing department are varied and wide which are based upon different
approaches. The purchasing activities may be divided into those that are always assigned to the
purchasing department and those that are sometimes assigned to some other department. The
followings are some of the important functions which are necessary to be performed.
1. Receiving indents
4. Receiving of quotation
5. Placing order
ADVERTISEMENTS:
7. Verification of invoices
1. Receiving indents:
The first and foremost function of purchasing is receiving demand/requisition of material from
different departments of the organisation, such as from production, stores, maintenance,
administrative, drawing office, planning, tool room, packing, painting, heat treatment etc.
After receiving the indent from users’ departments it examines in details and takes action
according to the need and urgency of any item. This is called ‘recognition of need’. Sometimes,
needs can be met by transfer of a stock of one department to another department. In other
cases, the reserve stock or the stocks kept in bank can be utilized i.e., pledged stock with bank.
The real problem arises when the order is placed for want of preciseness in the description of
goods needed, the items are received and these are not acceptable to the user department and it
also becomes difficult to convince the suppliers to return the goods in case of faulty supplies.
Therefore, purchasing department must have adequate knowledge of items being purchased to
be able to secure full description.
The purchasing department should not have such alternative purchases of commodities, which
are not available easily, on their own responsibility or at a lower cost unless and until it gets the
consent from the user department.
In a nutshell, it is recommended that the description of items for purchase on the part of indenter,
purchaser and seller should be quite clear and without ambiguity to promote harmony in an
organisation.
For majority of items, selection of one of the vendors should be made. While selecting the item,
the purchase officer has to see whether the item to be purchased is on a regular basis i.e., it is
being purchased time and again or it is a seldom purchase on non-recurring basis.
Whenever the items are to be bought from single manufacturer, such as branded or patented
item, there is no difficulty in the selection of the sources of supply; the order can be placed with
the party according to terms and conditions of their sale.
Selection of source of supply requires the services of shrewd purchasing officer who can keep
pace with policies of the organisation and market from where the materials have to be purchased.
4. Receiving of quotation:
As soon as the purchase requisition is received in the purchase division, sources of supply will be
located; a decision is then taken in respect of the method of tendering/limitation of quotations
from prospective suppliers.
Prices are also ascertained by preparing a comparative statement with the help of either of the
following documents supplied either by the supplier or taken from the previous records of
advertisements, like:
(f) Negotiation between suppliers and the purchase department like catalogue, price lists etc.
It is in the interest of purchasing department to keep this information up to date. Even for the
items which are being purchased on a regular basis, the purchasing section should invite tenders
and know full well the market price. It will ensure that prices being paid to the existing vendor are
competitive.
5. Placing order:
Placing a purchase order is the next function of purchasing officer. Since purchase order is a
legal binding between the two parties, it should always be accurate, clear and acceptable to both.
The purchase order should contain the following particulars:
Every purchasing department has the responsibility for follow-up of the orders it places on
different suppliers. All items do not require extensive follow-up. For some less important and low
value items follow-up would be costly and wastage of money and time only.
7. Verification of invoices:
In normal course, it is also the responsibility of purchase department to check the invoices and
accordingly advise the accounts department for clearing the payment to the parties concerned.
Contradictory statements have been given as to who should be assigned this function.
Some are of the view that invoices should be checked by the purchase department placed by it
whereas other suggests that it should go to the accounting department. In support of this, the
experts add that it is part of the responsibility of purchase department that orders are accurately
executed and properly filled as per terms and conditions of the contract.
If there is any error in the bills, the purchase department can get the correction done or
adjustment effected. If the invoices are checked by the stores or accounts departments, there
may be some delay in attending to the errors.
8. Inspection of incoming materials:
The purchasing department should have a close contact with inspection department. On receipt
of the materials from different suppliers, they are to be inspected as per specifications indicated
in the purchase order to verify their quality and quantity.
Uninspected materials are a burden on the economy of the organisation. If inspection is delayed,
the payments of the suppliers also are likely to be delayed, resulting in bad relations between
suppliers and purchasers.
In this regard, the purchase department should have a thorough knowledge of the means of
transportation. It should make a correct choice of carriers or routes because otherwise it may
entail delay and additional transportation costs.
This department has to refer to previous correspondence on purchase orders, notes, catalogues,
blue prints, price lists etc. very frequently which makes it imperative to maintain records in
appropriate manner. These records are essential for making the day to day purchase.
To a considerable extent, the attitude and reactions of other departments towards purchasing
department extends to these other departments. Mutual trust and cooperation is essential
between the purchasing department and other departments to secure high degree of efficiency.
13. Creating goodwill of the organisation in the eyes of the suppliers:
Good vendor relationship has to be maintained and developed to reflect enterprise’s image and
goodwill. Maintaining such relations requires mutual trust and confidence which grows out of
dealings between the two parties over a period of time. Worth of a purchasing department can be
measured by the amount of goodwill it has with its vendors.
1.Best-of-breed
The name is pretty explanatory, but just in case: A best-of-breed product is acknowledged (by
the genuinely knowledgeable) as the best product of its type. Importantly, this more often than
not refers to a specific module or product that focuses on one specific feature. The simple fact of
the matter is, it’s hard to be the best at everything. An integrated solution might be fantastic
overall, but not every component module is going to be best-of-breed. That’s why many
businesses cobble together solutions that take individual components from separate vendors.
With particular regard to vendor types:
Single vendor – it’s very unlikely to get best-of-breed functionality for every feature with a
single vendor. With careful selection, you should be able to find a single vendor will likely be the
best in one-to-several areas. Make sure you do your homework if you take this option!
Multi-vendor – this is basically the key advantage of choosing a multi-vendor solution.
2.Complexity
Here, I’m referring to the complexity inherent in integrating and implementing solutions for your
business. Although there’s definitely a trend toward making everything compatible, there are still
a great many legacy systems out there that weren’t built using common underlying software
architectures or principles.
Single vendor – should have the advantage – the single vendor only has to worry about
integrating its own product with your pre-existing systems. That can be challenging, but it’s at
least a closed set of details to fuss over.
Multi-vendor – the onus here is on you to integrate everything. With multiple systems and
a wide tranche of details, very few outside vendors will be able to integrate everything into a
single cohesive whole – at least, not without great cost. And speaking of which…
3.Cost
There’s no getting around it – pricing is going to be different across the two categories.
Single vendor – typically, this will be lower in price, thanks to better volume discounts.
Multi-vendor – price will be higher because you’ll be forced to buy separate individual
modules to constitute your solution.
4.Implementation difficulty
This is reference to the challenges that you’ll likely encounter for installing and setting up
whichever system you ultimately purchase.
5.Procurement effort
Systems don’t just purchase themselves, right? The question is, how hard will it be to get them?
The answers are pretty straightforward, however!
Single vendor – (relatively) simple – you’re only dealing with one vendor, after all!
Multi-vendor – more effortful – you have a lot of different vendors with whom to negotiate
contracts, and not every contract is going to run the same length and/or will be renewed at the
same time, if at all!
6.Product upgrades
We live in an age of ultra-rapid product updates and upgrades. What can we expect from our
vendor packages?
Single vendor – you’ll probably see major updates to single vendor solutions much more
infrequently. The updates/upgrades will likely be much more comprehensive!
Multi-vendor – because you’re using and seeing smaller packages from each vendor, you
should be getting upgrades more often. That could cause some problems with integration,
however.
7.Staff training
The thing with software (and business IT in general, really), is that you do need training to take
maximum advantage of your solution. That is true of most things, of course, but with technology,
it seems especially true! The question here then, is just how much support you’re going to get in
this domain (and how much you’re likely to get).
Single vendor – you and your staff will likely need less training overall, but you’ll likely get
more training sessions from the vendor
Multi-vendor – you and your staff will likely need more training overall, but you’ll likely get
less training since your purchase will represent a smaller order for the vendor.
8.Vendor survival
Well, this is pretty important. You want your vendor to supply you with product(s), upgrades, and
service/support for years to come, right?
Single vendor – if it’s a big single vendor (especially if it’s an established one), it’ll likely
stay in business for the long-haul.
Multi-vendor – here’s where things can get tricky. On the one hand, smaller companies
might be best-in-breed in particular areas, but because of their size, they might not get volumes
of business necessary to stay afloat. Alternately, they may just reach a level of success where
the bigger players will buy them out. After which, there’s no guarantee that the product will stick
around…
STORES MANAGEMENT
Stores Management
Store is an important component of material management since it is a place that keeps the
materials in a way by which the materials are well accounted for, are maintained safe, and are
available at the time of requirement. Storage is an essential and most vital part of the economic
cycle and store management is a specialized function, which can contribute significantly to the
overall efficiency and effectiveness of the materials function. Literally store refers to the place
where materials are kept under custody.
Typically a store has a few processes and a space for storage. The main processes (Fig 1) of
store are (i) to receive the incoming materials (receiving), (ii) to keep the materials as long as
they are required for use (keeping in custody), and (iii) to move them out of store for use
(issuing). The auxiliary process of store is the stock control also known as inventory control. In a
manufacturing organization, this process of receiving, keeping in custody, and issuing forms a
cyclic process which runs on a continuous basis. The organizational set up of the store depends
upon the requirements of the organization and is to be tailor made to meet the specific needs of
the organization.
Introduction
The term material simply includes raw material, components, tools spare parts and consumable
stators. Material which forms a part of a finished product is the firs
t and most important element of cost. Materials constitute such a significant part of product cost
and since this cost is controllable, proper planning, purchasing, purchasing, handling and
accounting are of great importance. In other words, proper control of materials is necessary form
time order for purchase of materials are placed with suppliers units they have been consumed.
Concept and meaning of materials
The term 'materials' is generally, used in manufacturing concerns. Materials are the commodities
or articles used for processing in the factory to manufacture goods or rendering serves. It
includes physical commodities used to manufacture the final product. It is the first and most
important element of cost.
Materials form a high portion of the total cost of reduction. In certain cases, like sugar, matters
may form as high as 60 percent of total cost. The production is rarely less than 25 to 30 percent
is case of most products. This means that efficiency as regards materials is a vital factor in total
cost of production and products earned. Any saving in materials will be directly reflected in profit.
Therefore, it is necessary that minimum care should be devoted to the purchase, storing and use
of materials. Raw materials, diesel, tools etc. are the example of materials.
Types of materials
Normally, there are two types of materials in manufacturing concern. They are as follows:
Direct materials
Direct materials: means the materials which form part of finished output and can be identified
with the finished product easily. For example; wood, plywood, adhesive, wood polish, nails etc.
in case of manufacturing furniture, cost of cotton in case of manufacturing cotton yarn, cost of
yarn in case of manufacturing cloth, cost of iron in case of manufacturing machinery etc. the
main feature of direct materials is that these enter into and form part of the finished product.
Indirect materials
Indirect material: refers to the materials costs, which cannot be allocated but can be apportioned
to or absorbed by cost centers or cost units. These are the materials, which cannot be traced as
part of the product, and their cost is distributed among the various cost centers or cost units on
some equitable basis.
Examples of indirect materials are coal and fuel for generating power, cotton waste, lubricating
oil and grease used in maintaining the machinery, materials consumed for repair and
maintenance work, dusters and brooms used for cleaning the factory, etc.
UNIT-3
Inventory Management
In any business or organization, all functions are interlinked and connected to each other and are often overlapping. Some
key aspects like supply chain management, logistics and inventory form the backbone of the business delivery function.
Therefore these functions are extremely important to marketing managers as well as finance controllers.
Inventory management is a very important function that determines the health of the supply chain as well as the
impacts the financial health of the balance sheet. Every organization constantly strives to maintain optimum inventory
to be able to meet its requirements and avoid over or under inventory that can impact the financial figures.
Inventory is always dynamic. Inventory management requires constant and careful evaluation of external and internal
factors and control through planning and review. Most of the organizations have a separate department or job function
called inventory planners who continuously monitor, control and review inventory and interface with production,
procurement and finance departments.
Defining Inventory
Inventory is an idle stock of physical goods that contain economic value, and are held in various forms by an organization
in its custody awaiting packing, processing, transformation, use or sale in a future point of time.
Any organization which is into production, trading, sale and service of a product will necessarily hold stock of various
physical resources to aid in future consumption and sale. While inventory is a necessary evil of any such business, it may
be noted that the organizations hold inventories for various reasons, which include speculative purposes, functional
purposes, physical necessities etc.
From the above definition the following points stand out with reference to inventory:
All organizations engaged in production or sale of products hold inventory in one form or other.
Inventory can be in complete state or incomplete state.
Inventory is held to facilitate future consumption, sale or further processing/value addition.
All inventoried resources have economic value and can be considered as assets of the organization.
Besides Raw materials and finished goods, organizations also hold inventories of spare parts to service the products.
Defective products, defective parts and scrap also forms a part of inventory as long as these items are inventoried in the
books of the company and have economic value.
There are three types of costs that must be considered in setting inventory levels:
1. Holding\Carrying cost:
They are expenses such as storage, handling, insurance, taxes, obsolescence, theft, and interest
on funds financing the goods. These charges increase as inventory levels rise. To minimize
carrying costs, management makes frequent orders of small quantities. Holding costs are
commonly assessed as a percentage of unit value, rather than attempting to derive monetary
value for each of these costs individually. This practice is a reflection of the difficulty inherent in
deriving a specific per unit cost, for example, obsolescence or theft.
2. Ordering costs:
Ordering costs are those fees associated with placing an order, including expenses related to
personnel in purchasing department, communications, and the handling of related paper work.
Lowering these costs would be accomplished by placing small number of orders, each for a large
quantity. Unlike carrying costs, ordering expenses are generally expressed as a monetary value
per order.
3. Stock-out costs:
They include sales that are lost, both short and long term, when a desired item is not available;
the costs associated with back ordering the missing item; or expenses related to stopping the
production line because a component part has not arrived. These charges are probably the most
difficult to compute, but arguably the most important because they represent the costs incurred
by customers when an inventory policy falters. Failing to understand these expenses can lead
management to maintain higher inventory levels than customer requirements may justify
THE SCOOP ON LEAN INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
TECHNIQUES
.What is Lean Inventory Management?
“Lean” refers to a systematic approach to enhancing value in a company’s inventory by identifying and eliminating waste
of materials, effort and time through continuous improvement in pursuit of perfection.
Lean management movement is credited to Henry Ford, who in the 1920s applied the concept of “continuous flow” in the
assembly-line process. Over the years, the concept has been modified and applied to nearly all industries.
Lean inventory management techniques are built upon five principles:
i) Value: Define the value that your company will get from lean inventory management.
ii) Flow: Understand how inventory flows in your warehouse and clear any obstacles that do not add up.
iii) Pull: Move inventory only when requested by customer.
iv) Responsiveness: Being able to adapt to change.
v) Perfection: Continuously refine your inventory management processes to improve quality, cycle time, efficiency and
cost.
In the 1980s, the concepts of Total Quality Managements (TQM) and Six Sigma that were advocated for by W. E. Deming
and Bill Smith respectively were reintroduced to US businesses.
Lean inventory management uses the concepts of TQM and Six Sigma to eliminate. The result is usually reduction
of costs and improvement in quality. When used together with a customer first policy, the result is usually a satisfied
customer.
Lean management is a combination of a set of tools, philosophy and a system.
As a tool, companies can use the principles to select the right technique or methods to improve what needs improving.
As a philosophy, lean management emphasizes minimization or elimination of excesses on all resources used in various
operations of the enterprise.
As a system, companies can use lean management to lower their costs, and improve customer satisfaction.
The success on any lean inventory management depends on how a company best implements the principles to achieve its
needs. The greatest benefit of the principles comes in identify its key attributes and applying them across functional
boundaries.
JIT is generally accepted as being a concept invented by Taiichi Ohno of Toyota; after World
War2 resources were very scarce in Japan so using them to create something that the
customer did not actually want right now was not a good idea.
On a visit to the US the management team of Toyota were inspired by, of all things, how they
saw a supermarket (Piggly Wiggly) handle their inventory. Only what was removed from the
shelves by the customers was actually replenished and ordered from suppliers. In this way
shelves never became empty, nor did they end up overflowing with excessive inventory.
Taiichi Ohno was tasked by Eiji Toyoda to make production more efficient through
implementing these ideas and pull production with just in time concepts was developed. It
took more than 15 years for Toyota to perfect their ideas and it was not introduced into
western manufacturing until the end of the 1970’s.
With a JIT system each process pulls from the preceding process’ “supermarket” and that
process will then work to replenish those shelves.
1. Reduction in the order to payment timeline; cash, as they say is king in business.
Many businesses will suffer with cash flow problems as they will often have to purchase large
amounts of raw materials prior to manufacturing and subsequent payment by the customer.
Often this gap is many months. Through implementing JIT you are able to considerably
reduce that time period.
2. Reduction in Inventory costs; one of the main aims with any JIT implementation is to
improve stock turns and the amount of stock being held. Personal experience has seen
reductions of more than 90% stock in some industries. Along with the reduction in the stock
come many other associated benefits.
3. Reduction in space required; by removing large amounts of stock from the system
and moving processes closer together we will often see a significant reduction in the amount
of floor space being used. Results from 100’s of projects run within companies in the UK
through the Manufacturing Advisory Service saw average reductions of 33% for simple 5 day
implementation projects.
4. Reduction in handling equipment and other costs; if you don’t have to move large
batches there is less need for complex machinery to move them and all of the associated
labor and training.
5. Lead time reductions; one of the most significantly impacted areas is that of the time
it takes for products to flow through the process. Instead of weeks or months most JIT
implementations result in lead times of hours or a few days.
6. Reduced planning complexity; the use of simple pull systems such as Kanban, even
with your suppliers, can significantly reduce the need for any form of complex planning. With
many implementations the only planning is the final shipping process.
7. Improved Quality; the removal of large batch manufacturing and reduction in handling
often results in significant quality improvements; often in the region of 25% or more.
8. Productivity increases; to achieve JIT there are many hurdles that must be overcome
with regards to how the process will flow. These will often result in productivity improvements
of 25% upwards.
9. Problems are highlighted quicker; often this is cited as being a negative aspect of
JIT in that any problems will often have an immediate impact on your whole production
process. However this is the perfect way to ensure that problems are highlighted and solved
immediately when they occur.
10. Employee empowerment; one requirement of JIT as with most other aspects of Lean
manufacturing is that employees are heavily involved in the design and application of your
system.
Reliable Equipment and Machines; if your machinery is always breaking down or giving
you quality problems then it will frequently manifest in big issues with any JIT flow. The
implementation of Total Productive Maintenance is required to ensure that you can rely on your
equipment and to minimize the impact that any failures have on your processes.
Well designed work cells; poor layout, unclear flow, and a host of other issues can all be
cleared up by the implementation of 5S within your production. This simple and very easy to
implement lean tool will make a significant improvement in your efficiencies all by itself.
Quality Improvements; an empowered workforce that is tasked with tackling their own
quality problems with all of the support that they need is another vital part of any lean and JIT
implementation. Setting up kaizen or quality improvement teams and using quality tools to
identify and solve problems is vital.
Standardized Operations; only if you know how each operation is going to be performed
can you be sure what the reliable outcome will be. Defining standard ways of working for all
operations will help to ensure that your processes are reliable and predictable.
Pull Production; Just in time does not push raw materials in at the front end to create
inventory (push production), it seeks to pull production through the process according to
customer demand. It achieves this by setting up “supermarkets” between different processes
from which products are taken or by the use of Kanbans which are signals (flags) to tell the
previous process what needs to be made.
Single piece Flow; the ideal situation is one in which you will produce a single product as
ordered by the customer. This for some industries is not immediately possible but should always
be your end goal. To achieve this you will need to work on reducing batch sizes significantly
through the use of Single Minute Exchange of Die (SMED) which seeks to significantly reduce
the time taken for any setup. It will also often require the use of smaller dedicated machines and
processes rather than all singing all dancing mega machines.
Flow at the beat of the customer; the demand of your customer is often referred to as
your Takt time. You need to ensure that your cells and processes are organized, balanced and
planned to achieve the pull of the customer. This is achieved through Heijunker and Yamazumi
charts.
Ensure that each production department has exactly the right materials at the right
time. the principles of Supply Chain Scheduling mentioned that there are always
enough raw materials for production processes, Capacity Requirements Planning
ensures that there is never too much raw materials inventory on hand, and reduces
costs associated with the misallocation of resources.
Customer Satisfaction:
PRODUCTION SCHEDULING
The production schedule is derived from the production plan; it is a plan that
authorized the operations function to produce a certain quantity of an item within a
specified time frame. The production schedule is drawn in the production planning
department
1. The first involves due dates and avoiding late completion of jobs;
2. The second goal involves throughput times;
3. The third goal concerns the utilization of work centers.
Production scheduling involves due dates and avoiding late completion of jobs. The
firm wants to minimize the time a job spends in the system, from the opening of a shop
order until it is closed or completed. It Concerns the utilization of work centers. Firms
usually want to fully utilize costly equipment and personnel.
Inventory Control
Inventories are a vital part of business. Not only are they necessary for operations, but
also they contribute to customer satisfaction. A typical manufacturing firms carries
different kinds of inventories, including the following:
1. Raw materials;
2. Partially finish goods (work in progress);
3. Finish goods;
4. Replacement parts;
5. Goods in transit to ware house or customers;
To decouple operation:
Delayed deliveries and unexpected demand increase the risk of shortages. Delays can
occur because of weather conditions, supplier’s stockouts, delivery of wrong materials,
quality problem and so on. The risk of shortage can be reduced by holding safety
stocks.
Occasionally, firms suspect that substantial price increase and purchase large
quantities. It depends on the ability of storage.
To permit operations:
The fact that production operations take a certain amount of time means that there will
generally be some work in progress or any other factors may lead to pipe line
inventories.
Inadequate control of inventories can result in both under and overstocking of items.
Understocking results lost sales and dissatisfied customers. Overstocking can be
increased holding cost as a result increase product price.
Operation management
1. Process: Physical process or facility used to produce the product like equipment,
technology and workforces. (main is capital)
2. Quality: Standard must be set, people trained and the product or service must be
inspected.
3. Capacity: size of the physical facilities.
4. Inventory (stock): What to order, how much to order, when to order, Inventory
control systems are used to materials from purchasing through raw materials, work in
process, and finish goods inventory.
When: When resources needed, when work should be done, when ordered for raw
materials supply and corrective actions needed.
Aggregate Planning
The goal of aggregate planning is to achieve a production plan that will effectively
utilize the organization’s resource to satisfy expected demand. Planner must make
decisions on output rates, employment levels and changes inventory levels and
changes, back order, and subcontracting in or out. Aggregate planners are concerned
with the quantity and the timing of expected demand.
Intermediate planning
Intermediate plans consider the function of intermediate decisions, General level of
employment, output, finished goods, inventories, subcontracting and back order.
Supply chain is a sequence of the organizations their facilities, functions and activities
that are involved in producing and delivering a product or service.
The need to improve operations: The opportunity lies largely with the procurement,
distribution and logistics.
1. Lower inventories
2. Lower cost
3. Higher productivity
4. Grater agility (quickness)
5. shorter lead time
6. Higher profit
7. Grater customer loyalty.
Operation Strategy
Operation strategy is a strategy for the operations function that is linked to the
business strategy and other functional strategy leading to a competitive advantage to
the firm.
Operation strategy is concern with policies and plans for using the resources of a firm
to support its long term competitiveness. An operation strategy is involved with
decisions process to select appropriate technology, physical facilities and the
inventory.
Competitiveness:
Companies must be competitive to sell their goods and services in the market place.
Business organization competes through some techniques. Marketing influences
competitiveness in several ways including identifying customer’s wants and needs,
pricing, advertising and promotion.
Operations influences competitiveness through product services, design, cost,
location, quality, response time, flexibility, inventory and supply chain management
and service many of this are interrelated.
The basic decision in an economic order quantity (EOQ) procedure is to determine the amount of
stock to be ordered, at a particular time so that the total of ordering and carrying costs may be
reduced to a minimum point. A firm should place optimum orders and neither too large nor to
small. The EOQ is the level of inventory order that minimizes the total cost associated with
inventory. The EOQ model is based on following four assumptions:
(i) A firm has a steady and known demand of D units each period for a particular input.
(iii) The costs of carrying stocks are a constant amount C per unit per period.
(iv) The costs of ordering more inputs are a fixed amount O per order. Orders are delivered
instantly.
EOQ = √2DO/ C
To show how we might use the formula consider exhibit III in which a firm has an annual
inventory requirement of 10,000 units. The accounting costs associated with placing an order
with the supplier come to Rs. 200 per order and the carrying costs of holding stocks are expected
to be Rs. 4 per unit.
0=Rs. 200
C=Rs. 4
= √10,00.000
= 1,000 units
Hence, this concludes the definition of Buffer Stock along with its overview.
Stock outs
The situation when a firm runs out of stock which results in shutdown
of slow down of production / sales.
This approach is designed to minimize the risk of stock outs at all costs. Particularly in
manufacturing
environment stocks-outs can have a disastrous effect on the production process.
There are two concepts associated with stock out cost. First one is maximum stock levels, which i
s defined
as the sum of reorder
level and reorder quantity and from this (minimum usage x minimum lead time) is
subtracted.
This stock level is a signal to the management that there should not be additional investment
in stocks
because that is not needed and will be
a useless. In other words, any investment over and above this level is
loss incurring.
The second is the minimum level of stock or also known as buffer stock. This level refers to a
warning to
the management that stock level is approaching to such a low level that could result in
a stock cost. We
compute this stock level as under:
Buffer stock = reorder level (average usage x average lead time)
In order to avoid stock out situation, a safety stock level should be procured and maintained.
Safety stock is the minimum inventory amount needed for an item, based on
anticipated usage and expected
delivery time of materials.
This cushion guards against unpredicted surge in demand or delivery time
January 8 Days
February 11 Days
March 9 Days
April 6 Days
May 7 Days
June 5 Days
Reorder levels
Companies must identify how much inventory to re-order, and when to re-order. To do this the
company needs to identify a level of inventory which can be reached before an order needs to be
placed. This is known as the reorder level.
When demand and lead time (the time to receive inventory from the time it is ordered) are known
with certainty the ROL may be calculated exactly, i.e. ROL = demand in the lead time.
Where there is uncertainty, an optimum level of buffer (or safety) inventory must be carried. This
depends on:
variability of demand
cost of holding inventory
cost of stockouts.
In reality, demand will vary from period to period, and the reorder level (ROL) must allow some
buffer (or safety) inventory, the size of which is a function of maintaining the buffer (which
increases as the levels increase), running out of inventory (which decreases as the buffer
increases) and the probability of the varying demand levels.
Fixation of inventory levels b.) Maximum level
a. Fixation of inventory levels : Fixation of inventory levels facilitates easy maintenance and contro
various materials in a proper way. However, following points should be remembered: Only fixation of
levels does not facilitate inventory control. A constant watch on the actual stock level of materials sho
kept so that proper action can be taken in time The levels which are fixed are not for permanent basi
subject to regular revision.
b. Maximum level : This is the top level which indicates that level of material stock should not excee
level. If it does, it may involve blocking of funds in inventory which may be used for some other usefu
purposes. This level is fixed after considering following factors:
- Maximum Usage
- Lead Time
- Storage facilities available
- Prices of material
- Other various costs involved like insurance, storage cost etc.
- Availability of funds for procurement of materials
- Nature of material
- EOQ
c. Minimum level: This level is fixed below the re-order level but above the danger level. The level o
should not be reduced below this level. If it does, then it involves the risk of non availability of materia
whenever required. This level is fixed after considering two factors: Rate of Consumption and Lead T
d. Re-order level: This level is fixed between maximum and minimum level in such a way that the re
of materials for the production can be met properly till the fresh supply of material is received. This le
material stock indicates that steps should be taken for procurement of further lots of material.
e. Danger level: This level is fixed below minimum level. If the stock reaches this level an immediate
must be taken by the company in respect of getting supply. This level indicates a panic situation for t
company as it has to make purchases in a rush which may involve higher costs.
Popularly known as the "80/20" rule ABC concept is applied to inventory management as a
rule-of-thumb. It says that about 80% of the Rupee value, consumption wise, of an inventory
remains in about 20% of the items.
This rule , in general , applies well and is frequently used by inventory managers to put their
efforts where greatest benefits , in terms of cost reduction as well as maintaining a smooth
availability of stock, are attained.
The ABC concept is derived from the Pareto's 80/20 rule curve. It is also known as the 80-20
concept. Here, Rupee / Dollar value of each individual inventory item is calculated on annual
consumption basis.
Thus, applied in the context of inventory, it's a determination of the relative ratios between the
number of items and the currency value of the items purchased / consumed on a repetitive basis
:
10-20% of the items ('A' class) account for 70-80% of the consumption
the next 15-25% ('B' class) account for 10-20% of the consumption and
the balance 65-75% ('C' class) account for 5-10% of the consumption
'A' class items are closely monitored because of the value involved (70-80% !).
20% of the items account for 80% of total inventory consumption value (Qty consumed X
unit rate)
Specific items on which efforts can be concentrated profitably
Provides a sound basis on which to allocate funds and time
A,B & C , all have a purchasing / storage policy - "A", most critically reviewed , "B" little
less while "C" still less with greater results.
ABC Analysis is the basis for material management processes and helps define how stock is
managed. It can form the basis of various activity including leading plans on alternative stocking
arrangements (consignment stock), reorder calculations and can help determine at what intervals
inventory checks are carried out (for example A class items may be required to be checked more
frequently than c class stores
In addition to other management procedures, ABC classifications can be used to design cycle
counting schemes. For example, A items may be counted 3 times per year, B items 1 to 2 times,
and C items only once, or not at all.
A items (High cons. Val) B items (Moderate cons.Val) C item (Low cons. Val)
VED ANALYSIS
VED stands for Vital essential and desirable. Organizations mainly use this technique for controlling spare
parts of inventory. Like, high level of inventory is required for vital parts that are very costly and essential
for production. Others are essential spare parts, whose absence may slow down the production process,
hence it is necessary to maintain such inventory. Similarly, an organization can maintain a low level of
inventory for desirable parts, which are not often required for production.
In VED Analysis, the items are classified into three categories which are:
SDE Analysis
This analysis classifies inventory based on how freely available an item or scarce an item is, or the length of its lead
time. This is how the inventory is classified:
Scarce (S) = Items which are imported and require longer lead time.
Difficult (D) = Items which require more than a fortnight to be available, but less than 6 months’ lead time.
Easily available (E) = Items which are easily available
If you have time you may test out all of these methods of Inventory Analysis to determine which one you are most
comfortable with. There are certain businesses that work better with one type of method than the other. Once you
find out which of these methods is perfect for you and your company, a positive R.O.I. is just within reach.
kanban
Kanban is a visual signal that’s used to trigger an action. The word kanban is Japanese and
roughly translated means “card you can see.”
Toyota introduced and refined the use of kanban in a relay system to standardize the flow of
parts in their just-in-time (JIT) production lines in the 1950s. The approach was inspired by a
management team's visit to a Piggly Wiggly supermarket in the United States, where Engineer
Taiichi Ohno observed that store shelves were stocked with just enough product to meet
consumer demand and inventory would only be restocked when there was a visual signal -- in
this case, an empty space on the shelf.
In manufacturing, Kanban starts with the customer’s order and follows production downstream. At
its simplest, kanban is a card with an inventory number that’s attached to a part. Right before the
part is installed, the kanban card is detached and sent up the supply chain as a request for
another part. In a lean production environment, a part is only manufactured (or ordered) if there is
a kanban card for it. Because all requests for parts are pulled from the order, kanban is
sometimes referred to as a "pull system."
The concept of providing visual clues to reduce unnecessary inventory has also been applied
to agile software development. In this context, the inventory is development work-in-progress
(WIP) and new work can only be added when there is an "empty space" on the team's task
visualization board.
UNIT-4
When we talk about information access for the supply chain, retailers have an
essential designation. They emerge to the position of prominence with the help of
technologies. The advancement of inter organizational information system for the
supply chain has three distinct benefits. These are −
Here we will be discussing the role of some critical hardware and software devices in
SCM. These are briefed below −
Electronic Commerce
Electronic commerce involves the broad range of tools and techniques used to
conduct business in a paperless environment. Hence it comprises electronic data
interchange, e-mail, electronic fund transfers, electronic publishing, image
processing, electronic bulletin boards, shared databases and magnetic/optical data
capture.
High productivity
Cost efficiency
Competitive benefit
Advanced billing
The application of EDI supply chain partners can overcome the deformity and
falsehood in supply and demand information by remodeling technologies to support
real time sharing of actual demand and supply information.
Barcode Scanning
We can see the application of barcode scanners in the checkout counters of super
market. This code states the name of product along with its manufacturer. Some
other practical applications of barcode scanners are tracking the moving items like
elements in PC assembly operations and automobiles in assembly plants.
Data Warehouse
Data warehouse can be defined as a store comprising all the databases. It is a
centralized database that is prolonged independently from the production system
database of a company.
ERP system holds a high level of integration that is achieved through the proper
application of a single data model, improving mutual understanding of what the
shared data represents and constructing a set of rules for accessing data.
With the advancement of technology, we can say that world is shrinking day by day.
Similarly, customers' expectations are increasing. Also companies are being
more prone to uncertain environment. In this running market, a company can only
sustain if it accepts the fact that their conventional supply chain integration needs to
be expanded beyond their peripheries.
The strategic and technological interventions in supply chain have a huge effect in
predicting the buy and sell features of a company. A company should try to use the
potential of the internet to the maximum level through clear vision, strong planning
and technical insight. This is essential for better supply chain management and also
for improved competitiveness.
We can see how Internet technology, World Wide Web, electronic commerce etc. has
changed the way in which a company does business. These companies must
acknowledge the power of technology to work together with their business partners.
We can in fact say that IT has launched a new breed of SCM application. The
Internet and other networking links learn from the performance in the past and
observe the historical trends in order to identify how much product should be made
along with the best and cost effective methods for warehousing it or shipping it to
retailer.
Benchmarking Defined
Before more recent technology was invented, surveyors would chisel a horizontal mark in a permanent
structure, where a tool could be placed in the indention to help create a benchmark with a level rod, helping
them and future craftsmen to have a point of reference for building.
In the business world, companies use benchmarking as a point of reference as well. But instead of having
physical benchmarks carved in stone, they use benchmark reports as a way to compare themselves to others
in the industry. Benchmarking is the practice of a business comparing key metrics of their operations to
other similar companies.
You can also think of a benchmark report as a dashboard on a car. It is a way you can quickly determine
the health of the business. Much like a dashboard, where you can check your speed, gas level, and
temperature, a benchmark report can examine things like revenue, expenses, production amounts,
employee productivity, etc.
Benchmarking occurs across all types of companies, including private, public, nonprofit, and for-profit, as
well as industries e.g., technology, education, and manufacturing. Many companies have positions or
offices in the company that are in charge of benchmarking. Some of the positions include:
Institutional researcher
Information officer
Data analyst
Consultant
Business analyst
Market researcher
Companies use benchmarking as a way to help become more competitive. By looking at how other
companies are doing, they can identify areas where they are underperforming. Companies are also able to
identify ways they can improve their own operations without having to recreate the wheel. They are able to
accelerate the process of change because they have models from other companies in their industry to help
guide their changes.
1. Assemble the right group of people for the job before you start the project:Every part
of the business that will be affected by the change must be involved at some level. This includes
bringing on board employees in planning, procurement and information technology.
2. Evaluate existing systems: It’s crucial to examine your operations and to identify goals.
After you understand your goals, the next step is to consider the business requirements that support
those goals. The requirements can be broken up into two areas: key requirements and nice-to-
haves.
Key requirements must be included with the system, or else it’s not a candidate for
implementation. The nice-to-haves are requirements that you could work around if the system
didn’t offer them. Outlining and prioritizing requirements is critical to mapping out your
organization’s desired outcome.
3. See where there are gaps in time, data and collaboration within your operations: You
can find these by asking the right questions. While every business is different, there are some
general questions to explore. For example, what will the benefits be with more closely aligned
planning and procurement? Can the business work with suppliers in its existing procurement
system “using real-time demand and forecast data?”
4. Review all existing and prospective systems: You need to know in which areas your
existing system is falling short, as well as what the potential solution brings to the table. Some
systems may align well with the new technology, while others may not.
5. Choose the solution that works best for your organization: “Now that the leg work is
completed and a clear picture of the organization’s needs is established, choosing the right
technology is a matter of aligning priorities with capabilities and price,” the article says.
6. Bring suppliers on board: Identify and prioritize steps for integrating with suppliers. It
may be best to start out with a handful of suppliers, especially if you use the same systems.
7. Take it “one step at a time:” Complete the project in increments to ensure you’re putting
the right system in place for your organization and evaluate your progress along the way.
Economic Dualism theory suggests that large companies create dual economy by subcontracting, in which
they can expand their resources in times of fortune and reduce capacity in times of recession, thus using
sub-contracting as a cushion against economic cycles. However this theory fails in present conditions
where subcontractors are seen as partners sharing risks, rewards and revenues (Paul D Cousins, 2003). This
outsourcing can be entire function like Nike outsourced its manufacturing function or it can be a part of the
function like many companies outsource the management of their payroll/pension systems while keeping
the HRM activities within the system. A survey estimates that some 56% of global product manufacturing
is exported to manufacturing specialists (Hill & Jones, 2008).
Evolution of Outsourcing Subcontracting model has changes drastically over last two decades. One of the
most common strategies was "Multiple Sourcing", which arises from the principle "Not to keep all your
eggs in one basket" which was adequate when competition is local or national. With companies becoming
global, competition has intensified, time to market cycles has to be kept low, increased innovations as
customers demanding high quality products, at competitive prices became difficult with multiple sourcing
strategy. This shifted the focus of companies towards "Parallel Sourcing" strategy where companies use
single source within model groups and multiple sources for different products. This provides buyer benefits
of sole sourcing like closer working relationships, information sharing etc and benefits of multiple sourcing
like security of supply and market pricing (Paul D Cousins, 2003).
This approach is followed by what is called "Network approach" which is complemented by concepts of
Supplier tiers. In this approach suppliers are organized into Tier I (Major assemblers) followed by Tier II
(Sub-assemblers). This kind of supply structure has become popular with in automotive and aerospace
industry where in it allowed buyers to work with fewer, sophisticated suppliers. As a result buyers rely on
fewer, powerful suppliers for supply of sub-assemblies (Paul D Cousins, 2003).
What to Outsource?
With customer being the key focus in these present dynamic environments, companies’ keeps on trying to
increase the total value generated to the customers by increasing the gap between customer willingness to
pay and costs associated with the product. To achieve this companies outsource activities that they think
the specialized company will generate more value by performing that activity. In the environment of
growing customer demand for supply chain efficiency and effectiveness it is recommended for the
company to perform the supply chain activities that it has distinctive competence and outsource the rest of
activities. Yet, not all processes are outsourced. Outsourcing the wrong process could be
counterproductive, expensive, or even fatal to a company (Andrea and Dana Meyer, 2002).
Core vs. Non-Core (Andrea and Dana Meyer, 2002)
The most crucial aspect of outsourcing is in making the distinction between the core competencies, which
should be kept in-house, and the non-core activities, which are candidates for outsourcing. Becoming
excessively dependent on partners reduces the strategic options available to a company. Processes that
nurture the core, protect the core, or help the company exploit its core competencies are also held
internally. Companies need to think carefully about what they wish to sow, nurture, and reap in-house in
order to harvest long-term profits.
Five-Stage Model (Andrea and Dana Meyer, 2002)
Prof. Fine enumerated five variables that predict the wisdom of in-sourcing vs. outsourcing.
Specialist provider achieves scale economies by aggregating volumes of activities from multiple companies
through standardization and decreases the unit costs across the supply network. Value from high levels of
expertise occurs when the provider can accumulate large quantities of knowledge that would be hard for
each client company to replicate.
Value Equation: Transaction Costs (Andrea and Dana Meyer, 2002)
Transaction costs are inevitable in the outsourcing. Costs of internal transactions which are in general
informal are very low and hidden where as the transaction costs with the outsourced company are visible
and substantial. Extra transaction costs arise from having to formally specify what the partner is to do,
managing that external activity. Companies decompose transaction costs into 3 categories:
Oversight costs: Cost of managing the relationship, performance, information exchange etc.
Switching costs: Cost of changing from in-sourcing to outsourcing
Risk: The potential costs of problems associated with the outsourcing arrangement
Benefits of Out-Sourcing
Cost reduction and cost savings Out-sourcing reduces the costs if the price you are paying for the
company is less than the costs that you incur if the same activities are performed in-house. Specialist
companies are able to perform activities at a lower cost as they can realize economies of scale by
performing the same kind of activity for various companies. These specialized companies invest more in
efficient-scale manufacturing facilities/processes to spread the costs against large volumes and bring down
unit costs.
Specialists also save costs through learning effects more rapidly than the clients. These companies learn
fast how to operate the processes more efficiently compared to its clients. Since most of the out-sourced
companies are based at low-cost global locations, costs can easily drive down (Hill & Jones, 2008).
Enhanced Differentiation Companies should be able to differentiate its final products by out-sourcing
certain noncore activities. These companies can provide more reliable products by strongly focusing and
achieving competence in that activity thus decreasing the defect rate. Most of these specialized companies
have adopted Six Sigma methodologies and bring down error rates, thereby increasing the reliability of
product.
For example carmakers outsource specific kinds of vehicle component design activities such as microchips
and headlights to the specialists who have earned reputation for design excellence (Hill & Jones, 2008).
Focus on core business Strategic out-sourcing makes the managers to focus their energies and companies
resources in performing the core activities that can create sustainable have more potential to create value
and competitive advantage. By this companies enhance their competence and push out the value creation
frontier and create more value for their customers (Hill & Jones, 2008).
Flexibility Companies gain access to new technologies and use supplier’s technology to accelerate new
product development. Companies can also adapt to changing business environments by changing suppliers
if the existing suppliers using technologies that are obsolete. Thus companies mitigate the risk of investing
in resources/technologies that have short life cycles (Yijie Dou and Joseph Sarkis, 2010).
Access to knowledge pool Out-sourcing activities across the borders enables companies to access to
knowledge pool connected with products, processes and management strategies that prove to be effective
and efficient. It also makes the organization use new advanced technologies in product and process
development. By out-sourcing some of the value creating activities to Japan, many US companies exploited
the benefits of lean manufacturing that they cannot realize in the home country (Thomos L. Sporleder,
2006).
Additional Capacity Out-sourcing helps the companies to adapt to seasonal fluctuations in demand by
out-sourcing the need for extra products beyond the capacity of the organization rather that going for
Green-field expansions. In periods of low demand companies uses its resources in satisfying customer
needs and out-source the extra demand to out-sourced company in periods of high demand (Sunil Chopra,
2010).
Demand Uncertainty (Risk Pooling) In periods of demand uncertainty organizations finds it difficult to
manage additional costs associated with high inventory, lack of material in case of peak demands etc. By
out-sourcing, uncertainty in the demand can be reduced because of aggregating uncertainties across many
companies, supplier decreases the total uncertainty thus save these costs for the companies (Sunil Chopra,
2010).
Other than these, companies reluctant to make high capital investments, companies operating in product
categories with short product life cycles, companies planning to be quicker to the market in already
established industries out-source so as to decrease risks. Sometimes overhead costs of performing some
back office functions are more considering out-sourcing these functions thus controlling the costs.
Risks of Out-sourcing
Lacking control of operations Once the processes are out-sourced, the companies won’t have a complete
control mechanism to deliver the value as the out-sourced activities are out of company bounds. The
vendor for some reasons may fail to deliver leading to disturbance in the flow of activities that fulfill
customer order. So companies should have a contingency plan for these uncertainties. (Yijie Dou and
Joseph Sarkis, 2010).
Loss of Competitive Knowledge Organizations by out-sourcing activities lose the knowledgeable
resources they possess. They also lose their hold and competence on activity that they out-source. IBM by
outsourcing most of its activities in PC industry became the market leader at a faster pace. Later its strategy
was followed by other competitors like Compaq which out-sourced activities to the same suppliers and this
resulted in decrease in IBM market share from 40% to 8% in span of 10 years (Thomos L. Sporleder, 2006)
Companies must preserve and nurture some form of competitive advantage in the form of core
competencies. Most of the presenters stressed the importance of identifying a company's strategic core
competencies before outsourcing or partnering. A company that outsources its future has no future (Andrea
and Dana Meyer, 2002).
Risk of Holdup It is the risk associated with the dependence of the out-sourcing company for the
specialized value added activities. Increase in dependence tends to decrease the bargaining power of the
parent company. So a better alternative to mitigate this risk is to adapt a parallel sourcing policy, having
different specialist providers. Daimler Chrysler adopted this policy of parallel sourcing (Hill & Jones,
2008).
Loss of Vital Information Organizations out-sourcing important functions which get them in direct touch
with customers may lose important competitive information from the customer feedback. A good flow of
communication between the out-sourced and out-sourcing company can prevent this loss of information
(Hill & Jones, 2008).
It sometimes becomes mandatory for the company to share vital confidential information with the out-
sourced company. It can lead to leakage of valuable information the company shares in order to achieve
efficiency in supply chain operations.
Conceptual Foundations of Demand Chain, Value Chain, and
Supply Chain
of all supply chain members across the supply chain. Although supply chain management has
been hailed as an innovative way to compete in today’s business world, its concept created a lot
of confusion, as evidenced by the presence of more than 2,000 different definitions of supply
chain management (see Gibson et al., 2005). Adding to the confusion, the term supply chain was
often interchangeably used with demand chain and value chain. Therefore, it is important for us
to synthesize these terms and differentiate among them when appropriate.
Because the ultimate goal of supply chain management is to serve the customer better, supply
chain management begins with the understanding of customer values and requirements. Indeed,
Poirier (1999) argued that the primary objective of supply chain improvements was to serve
ultimate customers more effectively and therefore an analysis of the supply chain should focus on
the “finish line” (demand), not the “starting point” (supply). To enhance the customer values and
meet customer requirement, careful planning of demand-creation and -fulfillment activities is
critical to the success of the whole organization. This planning cannot be articulated without
understanding the dynamics of interrelated business activities and jointly developing ideas for
business process improvement among the intra- and inter-organizational units. Therefore, any
efforts geared toward the customer-centric and “pull” approach throughout the entire business
processes are considered part of the demand chain.
In a context similar to the demand chain, a value chain is referred to as a series of interrelated
business processes that create and add value for customers. Its intent is to disaggregate all of a
firm’s business processes into discrete activities to evaluate their level of contributions to the
firm’s value and then discern value-adding activities from non-value-adding activities. Herein,
“value is the amount buyers are willing to pay for what a firm provides them and thus is measured
by total revenue, a reflection of the price a firm’s product commands and the units it can sell”
(Porter, 1985, p.38). Thus, the extent of value created and added by the firm often dictates its
level of business success, because the higher the value, the greater the profit margin and
competitive advantages.
As shown in Figure 1.3, the value chain focuses on the customer’s value by connecting the
customer’s needs to every aspect of the value-adding business activities encompassing sourcing,
manufacturing, logistics, and marketing across the organizational boundary. The value chain is
often driven by four key imperatives (Bovet, 1999):
Reduced uncertainty, which minimizes asset intensity through the reduction and
elimination of inventory
Increased speed, which minimizes the risk of obsolescence
Increased revenue resultant from the maximization of customization and the subsequent
customer loyalty
Increased productivity through multiple asset productivity
Although Table 1.2 shows that the strategic focus and perspectives of the demand chain, the
value chain, and the supply chain are somewhat different from one another as described by
Sherman (1998, p 2), their fundamental concepts and ultimate goals are not distinctively different
in that all these concepts are customer-centric and stress the importance of coordinated linkage
between business activities to the firm’s competitiveness. Therefore, these three terms can be
regarded as synonyms. To put it simply, the supply chain originates at the sources of supply and
flows toward the customer, whereas the demand chain flows backward from the customer and
ends up with the enterprise. The value chain is created when the supply chain is in sync with the
demand chain. Regardless of the semantic differences, the supply chain benefit may be
maximized by following the seven principles outlined by Copacino (1997):
Understand the customer values and requirements so that the firm can identify how to
align its operations to meet its customers’ requirements and needs.
Manage logistics assets such as warehouses, terminals, transportation equipment, and
pipeline inventory across the supply chain with the help of both the downstream and upstream
supply chain partners.
Organize the customer management in such a way that the firm can provide a single point
of contact to the customer for information and post-sales follow-ups.
Formulate joint sales and operations plans as the basis for a more responsive supply
chain by sharing real-time demand and forecast information within and across the supply chain.
Leverage manufacturing and sourcing flexibility by utilizing postponement strategies.
Focus on the synergies of strategic alliances and relationship management by building the
sense of mutual trust and the spirit of gain sharing.
Develop customer-driven performance measures to drive the behavior
Table 1.2. The Comparison of Demand Chain, Value Chain, and Supply Chain
Primary Activities New product development Cost accounting Pricing Revenue Procurement
Market research Sales and management Capital investment Manufacturing
promotion Forecasting Value-added services Logistics Payment
Objectives
On completion, participants will be capable of:
Specifying the role and goal of the Logistics function within a company.
Using the basic tools and techniques to plan and improve all aspects of the supply chain.
Describing the control systems that can be used for operations management in a wide variety
of environments.
Contents
Relationship of Logistics and Operations Management strategy with:
o Overall business strategy
o Manufacturing strategy
o Make/buy policy
o Manufacturing environment (make to order/ make to stock, job/batch/line/flow
production)
Theory & principles of supply chain management
Basic planning & control techniques:
o Forecasting demand
o Essentials of Industrial Engineering
o Capacity management
o Scheduling and sequencing
o Inventory management
o Planning & control systems and methodologies (Material Requirements
Planning, Manufacturing Resource Planning, Optimised Production Technology, Just In Time)
Measuring performance in Logistics and Operations Management
3PL
Third party logistics providers usually specialise in
Integrating operations
Warehousing
Transportation services
Cross-docking
Inventory management
Packaging
Freight forwarding
These services are scaled and customised to the customer’s specific needs based on their market
conditions and the different demands and delivery service requirements for their products or
materials.
There are thousands of 3PLs in the market that offer different models and perform different
tasks. For example, certain 3PLs may only specialise in certain industries.
The 3PL have a large footprint throughout the country. This makes it viable for companies to
service clients in remote regions at a much lower cost than doing it themselves.
Types of 3PL Providers
1. Standard
Basic activities: Pick and pack, warehousing and distribution.
2. Service Developer
Value-added services such as tracking and tracing, cross-docking and specific packaging
3. Customer Adapter
This comes in at the request of a customer. It is when the 3PL takes over complete logistics of
the firm.
4. Customer Developer
This is the highest level of 3PL. This is when the 3PL integrates itself with the company, and ends
up taking over the entire logistics operation.
4PL:
Procurement
Storage
Distribution
Processes
A 4PL company takes over the logistics section of a business. This could be the entire process, or
a side business that’s imperative to have as part of the main business.
An example here would be a bicycle importer. The main function is to import bicycles however,
they need to have spare parts for these unique bikes. A 4PL would manage the total logistic
operations for the spare parts business.
Imagine a person having a long whip in his hand, and if he gives a little nudge to the whip at the handle, it
creates little movements in the parts closest to the handle, but parts further away would move more in an
increasing fashion.
Similarly, in the supply chain world, the end customers have the whip handle and they create a little
movement in the demand which travels up the supply chain in increasing fashion. As we move away from
the customer, we can see bigger movements. On average, there are six to seven inventory points between
the end customer and raw material supplier (as shown below in figure 1). Everyone tries to protect
themselves from stock-out situations and missed customer orders, by keeping extra inventory to hedge
against variability in the supply chain. Hence, huge buffers of inventories up to six months can exist
between the end customer and raw material supplier. This bullwhip effect ultimately causes the upstream
manufacturers to have increased uncertainty which results in lower forecast accuracies leading to higher
inventories.
Every industry has its own unique supply chain, inventory placements, and complexities. However, after
analyzing the bullwhip effect and implementing improvement steps, inventories in the range of 10 to 30
percent can be reduced and 15 to 35 percent reduction in instances of stock out situations and missed
customer orders can be achieved. Below are some of the methods to minimize the bullwhip effect.
1.
1. Accept and understand the bullwhip effect
The first and the most important step towards improvement is the recognition of the presence of the
bullwhip effect. Many companies fail to acknowledge that high buffer inventories exist throughout their
supply chain. A detailed stock analysis of the inventory points from stores to raw material suppliers will
help uncover idle excess inventories. Supply chain managers can further analyze the reasons for excess
inventories, take corrective action and set norms.
2.
2. Improve the inventory planning process
Inventory planning is a careful mix of historical trends for seasonal demand, forward-looking demand, new
product launches and discontinuation of older products. Safety stock settings and min-max stock range of
each inventory point need to be reviewed and periodically adjusted. Inventories lying in the entire network
need to be balanced based on regional demands. Regular reporting and early warning system need to be
implemented for major deviations from the set inventory norms.
3.
3. Improve the raw material planning process
Purchase managers generally tend to order in advance and keep high buffers of raw material to avoid
disruption in production. Raw material planning needs to be directly linked to the production plan.
Production plan needs to be released sufficiently in advance to respect the general purchasing lead times.
Consolidation to a smaller vendor base from a larger vendor base, for similar raw material, will improve the
flexibility and reliability of the supplies. This, in turn, will result in lower raw material inventories.
4.
4. Collaboration and information sharing between managers
There might be some inter-conflicting targets between purchasing managers, production managers,
logistics managers and sales managers. Giving more weight to common company objectives in
performance evaluation will improve collaboration between different departments. Also providing regular
and structured inter-departmental meetings will improve information sharing and decision-making
process.
5.
5. Optimize the minimum order quantity and offer stable pricing
Certain products have high minimum order quantity for end customers resulting in overall high gaps
between subsequent orders. Lowering the minimum order quantity to an optimal level will help provide
create smoother order patterns. Stable pricing throughout the year instead of frequent promotional offers
and discounts may also create stable and predictable demand.
What is Warehousing?
Warehousing is the act of storing goods that will be sold or distributed later. While a small, home-
based business might be warehousing products in a spare room, basement, or garage, larger
businesses typically own or rent space in a building that is specifically designed for storage.
Logistics expertise
Network analysis
Mode and load network optimization
Cost containment strategization
Managing vendor compliance
Systems support
Customized Services
The expertise in supply chain management, warehousing, and other operations that a third party logistics firm can
offer is of substantial value to companies. Third party logistics can also be of benefit to shipping and carrying
companies. A third party logistics firm will help a company to maximize efficiency, eliminate weak points that result
in lost profits or revenue, and otherwise ensure maximal success and profitability.
For many companies, the most efficient and cost-effective choice for supply chain management, warehousing, and
other logistics operations, is to outsource those functions to a third party logistics company. By hiring specialists who
will use their industry expertise to continuously optimize the supply chain for maximal efficiency and cost-
effectiveness, companies can divert resources to core areas of their business instead.
Decentralized Purchasing, Its Advantages And Disadvantages
Based on the basic philosophies of jidoka and Just-in-Time, the TPS can efficiently and
quickly produce vehicles of sound quality, one at a time, that fully satisfy customer
requirements.