The 2015 Nepal Gorkha Earthquake: An Overview of The Damage, Lessons Learned and Challenges
The 2015 Nepal Gorkha Earthquake: An Overview of The Damage, Lessons Learned and Challenges
Research Paper
1
Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, JAPAN, [email protected]
2
Associate Professor, Graduate School of Science and Engineering, Ehime University, Matsuyama, JAPAN, [email protected]
3
Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, JAPAN, [email protected]
4
Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, JAPAN, [email protected]
5
Professor, Department of Urban and Environmental Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, JAPAN, [email protected]
6
Professor, Graduate School of Information Science and Electrical Engineering, Kyushu University, Fukuoka, JAPAN,
[email protected]
Note: Discussion on this paper is open until March 2017
106
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
to China and India (JICA, 2007). A part of the road was huge settlement of the access road in the Kathmandu
damaged due to the earthquake. This section side was observed (Fig. 8a). An apartment building close
summarizes the damage of the road and the surrounding to this sinking road was found to be settled and tilted as
infrastructures during the earthquake as well as the seen in Fig. 8(b).
geological and geotechnical information available close In location 4, two types of retaining walls exist: One is
to the area. the reinforced retaining wall and the other is the gravity
retaining wall. As seen from Fig. 9(a), in the joint
3.1 Damages to the road and surrounding infrastructures between the two walls, damage was observed. Also, in
some parts of the gravity retaining wall, cracks were
Our survey focused only on the damage of the road observed along the same line in which ground fissuring of
located near the Lokanthali area (Fig. 3), covering a the access road was observed Fig. 9(b). Ground
length of about 400 m. The state of the road before and fissuring extended up to the residential areas along the
after the earthquake (Fig. 4) is shown in NPC (2015a) road. Two residential buildings located along this fissure
Post disaster needs assessment, A: Key findings. were found to be heavily damaged (Fig. 10). According
Kathmandu, Nepal: Government of Nepal, National to the owner the building with exposed brick structure,
Planning Commission. whom the authors happened to meet, the building settled
The various locations of the surveyed area were are by about more than 1 m towards the road and tilted.
shown in Fig. 5. In the Kathmandu side, heaving and Many ground fissuring were also observed in the
subsidence of the road, slope failures in the main road surrounding of the two buildings.
and in the access road, ground fissuring, retaining wall
damage and damage to the residential buildings close to
the access road were observed. Similarly, in the
Bhaktapur side, heaving and subsidence of the main
road, slope failures in the access road and ground
fissuring were observed.
Slope failure in location 3 is shown in Fig. 6. As seen
in the figure the traffic police box was tilted by about 12
degree due to slope failures and settlement of the road.
In the Bhaktapur side (location no. 7) subsidence of the
main road was observed (Fig. 7a). Also, slope failure
Fig. 3. Kathmandu-Bhaktapur road (URL Source:
took place in the access road (Fig. 7b). In location 5, http://www.earth.google.com).
108
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
109
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
N
BH1 BH3
BH2
Ground fissuring was also observed in many locations honeymoon couples. Fig. 14 shows the states of the
around the residential area surrounding the access roads. tower before and after the earthquake.
Fig. 11(a) shows one of those having a maximum width
of 20 cm. Ground fissuring in 30° azimuth towards the 4.2 Damage at Patan durbar square
east was observed. Such ground cracking was observed
not only in the road embankment but also continued Patan, famous as the oldest city in Kathmandu valley,
within a wide area both towards the left and right side of is also known as the city of fine arts. Another name of
the road embankment. The angle of ground fissuring is Patan, is Lalitpur. The exquisite artworks and
almost the same in both sides of road embankment and architectural buildings, scattered in and around Patan
of was 400 m in length towards the south west (Fig. 11b). Durbar square, are from 16th century and onwards. In
1979 they were listed in the world heritage monument. It
3.2 Damage to the road and surrounding infrastructures is probably one of the oldest Buddhist Cities in the world.
The city is situated on a plateau across Bagmati River. In
No detailed geotechnical information about the soil Patan, the Char Narayan Mandir, the statue of Yog
characteristics in the Lokanthali area is available. The Narendra Malla, a pati inside Patan Durbar Square, the
closest information available is from the three borehole Taleju Temple, the Hari Shankar, Uma Maheshwar
locations near 84m long Manahara bridge (Fig. 12) which Temple and the Machhindranath Temple in Bungamati
is located less than 1 km from Lokanthali (JICA, 2007). were destroyed during the earthquake.
Figure 13 shows the geological profile of the borehole no. Figure 15 is a 2010 photo of the intact temples.
3 (location close to Lokanthali). Several of the tiered temples appear to have collapsed.
From Fig. 13 it is clear that the area is mostly Fig. 16 shows the Harishankar temple, built in 1706 and
dominated by very thick layer of compressive clay. one of the most outstanding temples in Patan before and
Settlement of this clay deposits and possible amplification after the earthquake.
of motion may have resulted in such localized damage in
this part of the Kathmandu-Bhaktapur road. However, 4.3 Damage at Bhaktapur durbar square
detailed borehole information adjacent to the site and
other geotechnical survey results are necessary to arrive In Bhaktapur durbar square, several monuments,
at a definite conclusion. including the Fasi Deva temple, the Chardham temple
and the 17th century Vatsala Durga Temple, were fully or
partially destroyed. Figure 17 shows the famous Hindu
4. Damage to historical sites temple (Vatsala Durga temple) before the earthquake.
Built in 1672, this beautiful stone building was a favorite
Nepal is nonetheless home to eight UNESCO World for many people to sit out on and watch the sunset in
Heritage cultural sites. That includes three royal cities Bhaktapur durbar square. It is no more than rubble now
and several Hindu and Buddhist sites within the (Fig. 18). Few other temples (Fig. 19) in the square were
Kathmandu Valley, as well as Lumbini, the legendary also seriously damaged including a school building which
birthplace of the Buddha, all of which are in the area completely collapsed (Fig. 20).
affected by the earthquake. Many of those centuries-old
buildings and monuments were destroyed in the 4.4 Damage to Changu Narayan temple
Kathmandu Valley, including some at the Kathmandu
Durbar Square, the Patan Durbar Square, the Bhaktapur One of the oldest Hindu temples in Nepal, Changu
Durbar Square, the Changu Narayan temple and the Narayan is believed to have been built in the 5th century
Swayambhunath temple. In the following subsections few A.D. Located on a hilltop east of Kathmandu, the two-
examples of damage inflicted on those historical buildings tiered pagoda (Fig. 21) is considered one of Nepal’s most
and monuments, word heritage sites and historic town unique architectural monuments. Constructed on a single
are discussed. slab of stone, the Changu Narayan temple had withstood
the large earthquake of 1934 Bihar-Nepal Earthquake.
4.1 Damage at Kathmandu durbar square This time earthquake inflicted some damage to this main
temple as seen from the scaffolding of the temple after
Several pagodas on Kathmandu Durbar Square, a the earthquake (Fig. 22). Two of the four temples on the
UNESCO World Heritage Site, collapsed. The Dharahara premises of Changu Narayan square have been reduced
tower in that square, built in 1832, completely collapsed to rubble by the earthquake (Fig. 23 shows one of them).
leading to death of at least 180 people including
111
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
CONTENT
GRAPHIC
DENSITY
FIELD AND LABOTARY
SPT/CPT
RUN (m)
E
WATER
(G/cm3)
DEPTH
DATA AND TEST
GROUND ELEVATION: M
DRY
REPORTED ELSEWHERE
SYS
(%)
(m)
‘N’
DESCRIPTION OF STRATA
0 Moist and damp area of compressive soil.
1 Very compressive soil.
Boulders and gravels
9 2
45.12 1.26
3
43.44 C=10.43kN/m2
Lead gray, stiff to very stiff
4 compressive silty clay
27
5
40.89 30
6
14
7
1.03 15
8
58.33 C=15.64kN/m2 13 Grey to dark gray, stiff
9 compressive silty clay
10
60.58 13
11
0.79 13
12
86.37 C=41.40kN/m2 27
13
27
14
86.37 30
15
16
Grey to dark gray, very stiff compressive
0.79
17 clay with very les amount of silt
84.75 C=60.77kN/m2 30
18
29
19
28
20
30
21
Ground Observation: 1.00m
Project: Basic design study on the project for improvement of
SUMMARY BORING LOG
Kathmandu-Bhaktapur Road in Nepal
CLINT/OWNER: Nippon Koei-(JICA) Starting date: 13/12/2006 Completed date: 16/12/2006
Consulting Engineers: ITECO Nepal in association with ICGS Job No. 3351 Sheet No. 1
Fig. 13. Soil profile at borehole no. 3 (JICA, 2007).
112
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
Comprising temples, shrines and the iconic stup Not only the historical monuments and old brick
which bears the painted on eyes of the Buddha the 150 masonry buildings, but many recently built and
year old Swayambhunath (also known a monkey temple) comparatively well-engineered buildings including
is not only a revered location for locals, but also one of multistory business complexes and apartment buildings
the most-visited tourist destinations in the capital (Fig. were also heavily damage. In recent years, especially
24). Swayambhunath temple complex in the Kathmandu during the last one decade, Kathmandu valley has had a
Valley suffered heavy damage due to the earthquake. sharp rise in the number of multistory business
Few structures within the temple complex suffered complexes and apartment buildings, mainly constructed
damage (Fig. 25). of reinforced concrete framed structure with brick
masonry infill. Most modern residential and commercial
4.6 Damage to historic town of Sankhu buildings also follow the similar construction practice, but
a large number of these buildings have been constructed
Sankhu is the ancient town, with predominant Newari without adequately incorporating the seismic design
culture, located in the north-eastern corner of Kathmandu criteria. Even within the Kathmandu valley, which is the
Valley in about 17 km from the capital city Kathmandu. most densely populated urban settlement of the nation,
Sankhu is probably the worst affected historical town, most peripheral areas enjoyed waiver of the
where 80 to 90 % of the buildings were completely col- administrative process of construction permit up until a
lapsed. couple of years ago. Moreover, in many occasions,
Figure 26 shows the view of the buildings in the town manipulation of the design data and use of substandard
before the earthquake. Figure 27 shows the state of the material quality have also added to poor seismic capacity
same buildings after the earthquake. Total collapse of of the buildings.
many structures in the city were observed here and there The trend of damage to reinforced concrete buildings
(Fig. 28). during this earthquake can be categorized into two main
patterns: 1) column breakage and severe structural tilting
113
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
or complete collapse in comparatively short buildings (i.e. the other hand, out of more than 50 tall buildings in
3-6 story), as in Fig. 29 and 2) massive shaking and Kathmandu and Patan, more than 40 were found to have
heavy damage to non-structural elements, such as brick sustained medium to heavy damage, mainly in non-
masonry partition walls, in comparatively tall buildings structural parts (Fig. 30).
(i.e., >10 story), as in Fig. 30. Leaving aside a few cases Kathmandu valley is filled with soft sediment deposit
of complete collapse in other locations, damage to short composed primarily of lacustrine material that goes as
buildings was concentrated in some pocket areas, such deep as 500 meters in the center. Borehole logs of
as Gongbu, Swayambhu, Sitapaila, and Kapan (Fig. 31). different times are also evident that a larger part of the
However, most such buildings in central core were not sediment deposit is composed of organic clayey material.
affected much except for a few cracks in the walls. On Despite the fact that the bearing capacity of this clayey
114
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
al., 2016). It reveals that the rupture process extended to to hospital buildings and life-line infrastructures
the east side of Kathmandu City. including power line, water pipes, communication
network, and roads. The only international airport in
Nepal was reported to be totally undamaged.
8. Conclusions and recommendations d. Immediate geotechnical and geological
investigations of the soils in the vicinity of historical
The following conclusions and recommendations monuments are required.
could be made based on this preliminary survey of the e. Reconstruction and retrofitting measures to be
earthquake damage of the structures. adopted considering acceleration amplification in
a. The damage to newly built building structures was future earthquakes.
concentrated at particular pocket areas and more f. It is very important to take into the account the effect
specifically in newly developed sub-urban areas of of soil stratum (surface and lower layers) and the
the Kathmandu city core. velocity distribution profiles based on geotechnical
b. Most old brick masonry buildings were heavily data base.
damaged throughout the valley, and the destruction g. New approaches in the geotechnical design and
was particularly found to be concentrated in retrofitting of foundations, which are cost-effective
Bhaktapur city core and Sankhu area of Kathmandu. and locally available, require immediate attention.
c. One typical characteristic of the damage pattern h. Use of information technology and local participation
found this time was that, comparatively little damage towards disaster mitigation also need attention.
116
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
Fig. 37. Acceleration, velocity and displacement profiles of the earthquake (Source: USGS).
i. Rebuilding the historical sites this time around, retrofitting of the historical monuments in the
especially the older ones, will be no easy task. In the Kathmandu valley, it is very important to collect infor-
117
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
Sundarijal Itaiti
Gokarna airport Harisiddhi Chapagaun
1500
1340~1386 m
G 1320~1340 m Manahara Khola 1340 m
1400
T 1305~1310 m 1300~1310 m T
P P
1300
Fig. 39. Schematic geological cross section of Kathmandu valley along N-S (Sakai, 2001).
Fig. 40. Map projection of the final-slip distribution (Kubo et al., 2016).
mation regarding the foundations of those structures. Kumar Dahal, Tribhuvan University for his tremendous
That is definitely going to be a challenging task for help and cooperation during their survey.
geotechnical engineers and researchers in the years
to come.
References
Acknowledgements
Bilham, R., Bodin, P. and Jackson, M., 1995. Entertaining
The financial support provided by Kyushu University a great earthquake in western Nepal: Historic
under the special grant of the president, Kyushu inactivity and geodetic tests for the present state of
University towards the survey is greatly appreciated. The strain. Journal of Nepal Geological Society, 11 (1):
authors also gratefully acknowledge Assoc. Prof. Ranjan 73-78.
118
H. Hazarika et al. / Lowland Technology International 2016; 18 (2): 105-118
Special Issue on: Nepal Earthquake & Disaster
Bilham, R., Larson, K., Freymuller, R. and Members, P.I., NASA. http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/NaturalHaz-
1997. GPS measurements of present-day ards/view.php?id=84406, retrieved on September 15,
convergence across the Nepal Himalaya. Nature, 2016.
386: 61-64. NSET and GHI, 1999. Earthquake scenario, product of
Chamlagain, D. and Gautam, D., 2015. Seismic hazard in the Kathmandu valley earthquake risk. management
the Himalayan intermontane basins: An example from project, National Society for Earthquake Technology-
Kathmandu Valley Nepal. Mountain Hazards and Nepal (NSET-Nepal) and GeoHazards International
Disaster Risk Reduction: 73-103. (GHI).
JICA (Japan International cooperation Agency), 2002. Paudyal, Y.R., Yatabe, R., Bhandary, N.P. and Dahal,
The study of earthquake disaster mitigation in R.K., 2012. A study of local amplification effect of soil
Kathmandu valley, Kingdom of Nepal. Final Report, I, layers on ground motion in the Kathmandu valley
II, III, IV. using micro tremor analysis. Earthquake Engineering
JICA (Japan International cooperation Agency), 2007. and Engineering Vibration, 11 (2): 257-268.
Planning for improvement of Kathmandu-Bhaktapur Piya, B.K., 2004. Generation of a geological database for
road in the Kingdom of Nepal, Report on the the liquefaction hazard assessment in Kathmandu
preliminary design and investigation. valley. MSc Thesis, International Institute for Geo-
Kubo, H., Dhakal, Y.P., Suzuki, W., Kunugi, T., Aoi, S. Information Science and Earth Observation,
and Fujiwara, H., 2016. Estimation of the source Enschede, the Netherlands.
process of the 2015 Gorkha, Nepal, earthquake and Sakai, H., 2001. Stratigraphic division sedimentary facies
simulation of long-period ground motions in the of the Kathmandu basin group, Central Nepal. J. of
Kathmandu basin using a one-dimensional basin Nepal Geol. Soc., Special Issue, 25: 19-22.
structure model. http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s40623- Sakai, H., Sakai, H., Yahagi, W., Fuji, R., Hayashi, T. and
016-0393-5. Upreti, B.N., 2006. Pleistocene rapid uplift of the
Mukhopadhyay, B., 2011. Clusters of moderate size Himalayan frontal ranges recorded in the Kathmandu
earthquakes along main central thrust (MCT) in and Siwalik basins. Palaeogeography,
Himalaya. Intl. J. Geosciences, 2011, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 241 (1): 16-27.
doi:10.4236/ijg.2011.23034 Published online August
2011, 2: 318-325.