Home News Sport Reel Worklife Travel Future M

Article 370: What happened with Kashmir and why it matters

6 August 2019

Kashmir tensions

GETTY IMAGES

India's BJP-led government is hailing its decision to strip the state of Jammu and
Kashmir of autonomy after seven decades, characterising it as the correction of a
"historical blunder". The BBC's Geeta Pandey in Delhi explains why this has happened
and why it's important.

Why is Kashmir controversial?

Kashmir is a Himalayan region that both India and Pakistan say is fully theirs.

The area was once a princely state called Jammu and Kashmir, but it joined India in 1947
when the sub-continent was divided up at the end of British rule.

India and Pakistan subsequently went to war over it and each came to control different parts
of the territory with a ceasefire line agreed.

There has been violence in the Indian-administered side - the state of Jammu and Kashmir -
for 30 years due to a separatist insurgency against Indian rule.
What's happened now?
In the first few days of August, there were signs of something afoot in Kashmir.

Tens of thousands of additional Indian troops were deployed, a major Hindu pilgrimage was
cancelled, schools and colleges were shut, tourists were ordered to leave, telephone and
internet services were suspended and regional political leaders were placed under house
arrest.

But most of the speculation was that Article 35A of the Indian constitution, which gave some
special privileges to the people of the state, would be scrapped.

The government then stunned everyone by saying it was revoking nearly all of Article 370,
which 35A is part of and which has been the basis of Kashmir's complex relationship with
India for some 70 years.

How significant is Article 370?

The article allowed the state a certain amount of autonomy - its own constitution, a separate
flag and freedom to make laws. Foreign affairs, defence and communications remained the
preserve of the central government.

As a result, Jammu and Kashmir could make its own rules relating to permanent residency,
ownership of property and fundamental rights. It could also bar Indians from outside the state
from purchasing property or settling there.
 Modi's Kashmir move will fuel resentment

Former chief minister says India has betrayed Kashmir

Why a special law on Kashmir is controversial

The constitutional provision has underpinned India's often fraught relationship with Kashmir,
the only Muslim-majority region to join India at partition.

Why did the government do it?

Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party had long
opposed Article 370 and revoking it was in the party's 2019 election manifesto.

They argued it needed to be scrapped to integrate Kashmir and put it on the same footing as
the rest of India. After returning to power with a massive mandate in the April-May general
elections, the government lost no time in acting on its pledge.

Critics of Monday's move are linking it to the economic slowdown that India is currently facing
- they say it provides a much-needed diversion for the government.

GETTY IMAGES

Many Kashmiris believe that the BJP ultimately wants to change the demographic character
of the Muslim-majority region by allowing non-Kashmiris to buy land there.

Although Home Minister Amit Shah's announcement in parliament on Monday came as a

surprise to most Indians, it would have taken the government some preparation to arrive at
the decision.

The move also fits in with Mr Modi's desire to show that the BJP is tough on Kashmir, and
Pakistan.
What's changed on the ground?
Kashmir will no longer have a separate constitution but will have to abide by the Indian
constitution much like any other state.

All Indian laws will be automatically applicable to Kashmiris, and people from outside the state
will be able to buy property there.

The government says this will bring development to the region.

GETTY IMAGES

"I want to tell the people of Jammu and Kashmir what damage Articles 370 and 35A did to the
state," Mr Shah told parliament. "It's because of these sections that democracy was never
fully implemented, corruption increased in the state, that no development could take place."

The government is also moving to break up the state into two smaller, federally administered
territories. One region will combine Muslim-majority Kashmir and Hindu-majority Jammu. The
other is Buddhist-majority Ladakh, which is culturally and historically close to Tibet.

P Chidambaram, a senior leader in the opposition Congress Party described the decision as a
"catastrophic step" and warned in parliament that it could have serious consequences.

"You may think you have scored a victory, but you are wrong and history will prove you to be
wrong. Future generations will realise what a grave mistake this house is making today," he
said.

Is this all legal?

According to the constitution, Article 370 could only be modified with the agreement of the
"state government". But there hasn't been much of a state government in Jammu and
Kashmir for over a year now.

In June last year, India imposed federal rule after the government of the then chief minister,
Mehbooba Mufti, was reduced to a minority. This meant the federal government only had to
seek the consent of the governor who imposes its rule.
The government says it is well within its rights to bring in the changes and that similar
decisions have been taken by federal governments in the past.

But expert opinion is sharply divided.

One constitutional expert, Subhash Kashyap, told news agency ANI that the order was
"constitutionally sound" and that "no legal and constitutional fault can be found in it".

However another constitutional expert, AG Noorani, told BBC Hindi it was "an illegal decision,
akin to committing fraud" that could be challenged in the Supreme Court.

Opposition political parties could launch a legal challenge but Kashmir is an emotive issue
with many Indians, and most parties would be wary of opposing the move lest they be
branded anti-India.

That could leave any challenge up to individuals or activists.

Read more about Kashmir

Kashmir: Why India and Pakistan fight over it

Tracing the path that led to Pulwama

The funerals driving Indian Kashmir youth to militancy

Finding God in the anguish of violence

Related Topics

Article 370 of the Constitution of India Narendra Modi Kashmir India

India-Pakistan relations Kashmir tensions Asia Pakistan

Share this story About sharing

More on this story

Article 370: Former chief minister says India has betrayed Kashmir
5 August 2019

Article 370: India's move on Kashmir will fuel resentment

5 August 2019

The funerals driving Indian Kashmir youth to militancy

14 May 2018

Finding God in the anguish of violence

26 December 2018

Kashmir attack: Tracing the path that led to Pulwama

1 May 2019

Kashmir: Why India and Pakistan fight over it

27 February 2019

India

India's popular former foreign minister dies

7 August 2019 India
Pakistan vows to fight 'illegal' Kashmir decision
6 August 2019 Asia

Global report warns of Indian water crisis

6 August 2019 India

More Videos from the BBC

Recommended by Outbrain
No-deal Brexit: How Man jailed for 'ferocious' Arsenal star confronts
might it affect the EU? pub attacks carjackers in London

Neil tests Johnson's Classic police car was 'I was deaf from birth but
knowledge of GATT 24 family's 'place of refuge' now I'm going blind'

Elsewhere on BBC
Recommended by Outbrain

BBC News BBC Travel

Marines used brute force, says tanker The massive mosque built once a year
captain

BBC News BBC Travel

'I was forced to marry my cousin' Why the French love to say no
BBC.com BBC Future
The Secrets of Singapore’s Gardens by The strange science inside your
the Bay sourdough

From Around the Web

Promoted content by Outbrain

Top Stories
Festival shooting 'domestic terror' probe launched
The FBI opens a terrorism inquiry into an attack just prior to the deadly events in El Paso and
Dayton.
3 hours ago

Celebrated author Toni Morrison dies

7 hours ago

Pakistan vows to fight 'illegal' Kashmir decision

4 hours ago

Features
What happened in Kashmir and why it matters

Pol Pot's unrepentant right-hand man

Lives lived and lost along Manila's Pasig river

No-deal Brexit: How might it affect the EU?

'She was the greatest living American writer'

Russia’s ‘Tiananmen teen’ protester

Should US police be able to seize guns?

What happens to a body donated to science?

How sanctions affect Iran... in five objects

Elsewhere on the BBC

Lyrics quiz
Have you been getting these songs wrong?
 Feeling hot
What happens to your body in extreme heat?

Most Read
Madagascar plane fall: Cambridge student Alana Cutland's 1
body found

Texas police apologise for horseback officers leading black man 2

by rope

Trump sues California over candidates' tax return law 3

Garlic festival shooting: FBI opens 'domestic terrorism' 4

investigation

Brazil prisoner who dressed up as daughter to escape found 5

dead

North Korea 'stole $2bn for weapons via cyber-attacks' 6

Brexit: EU 'refusing to negotiate', says Gove 7

Pakistan vows to fight India's 'illegal' Kashmir move 8

Disney disappoints despite a string of movie hits 9

Ministers act to end NHS pensions row amid waiting list rise 10
 Why you can trust BBC News

BBC News Services

On your mobile

On your connected tv

Get news alerts

Contact BBC News

Explore the BBC

Home News

Sport Reel

Worklife Travel

Future Culture

Music TV

Weather Sounds

Terms of Use About the BBC

Privacy Policy Cookies

Accessibility Help Parental Guidance

Contact the BBC Get Personalised Newsletters

Advertise with us Ad choices

Copyright © 2019 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our
approach to external linking.