Robinson P. Paul et al, / (IJCSIT) International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, Vol.

5 (2) , 2014, 2107-2111

Performance Comparision of Single &

3-Ø Controlled and Uncontrolled Rectifier Using
Matlab-Simulink
Robinson P. Paul#1, Ghansyam B. Rathod#2, Milan Bareja#3, Pratyaksh Maru#4
#1,#2
Asst.Prof, Electronics and Telecommunication,
BVM Engg College, Gujarat, India.
#3
Asst.Prof, Electronics and Communication,
GEC, Bhuj, Gujarat, India.
#4
Asst.Prof, EC, Dr. Jivraj Mehta Institute of Technology,
Gujarat, India.

Abstract-This paper presents simulations & performance 1.1 Matlab-Simulink for Power Electronics
result of single and 3-Ø rectifier circuits (controlled and
uncontrolled) using MATLAB-SIMULINK which is one of the In this section will study about the modeling and simulation
most used power electronics cicuit. This paper also describes method for the power electronics circuits.
method & concepts used to simulate power electronic circuits SimPowerSystems provides component libraries and
using the SIMULINK toolbox within MATLAB software. The analysis tools for modeling and simulating electrical power
use of tool like MATLAB-SIMULINK has always been a systems. The libraries offer models of electrical power
useful for researcher and the designer for analyzing and components, including three-phase machines, electric
designing different circuits. The paper demonstrate the
performance comparison of single and 3-Ø rectifier circuits in
drives, and components for applications such as flexible
term of its output voltage , current and possible maximum AC transmission systems (FACTS) and renewable energy
and minimum firing angle. systems. Harmonic analysis, calculation of total harmonic
Index Terms: Power Electronics, SimPowerSystems, Rectifier, distortion (THD), load flow, and other key electrical power
Firing angle, powergui, Average and RMS DC voltage etc… system analyses are automated. SimPowerSystems models
can be used to develop control systems and test system-
1. INTRODUCTION level performance. You can parameterize your models
Power Electronics includes the use of different electronics using MATLAB variables and expressions, and design
components & its structure, characteristic and application control systems for your electrical power system in
circuit, which can withstand large voltage and current. Due Simulink. You can add mechanical, hydraulic, pneumatic,
to the withstand capability at high voltage and current, this and other components to the model using Simscape and test
devices are used in industry for control application. The them together in a single simulation environment. To
single and 3-Ø uncontrolled and controlled rectifiers with deploy models to other simulation environments, including
R, RL load (with and without freewheeling diode); hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) systems, SimPowerSystems
choppers; inverters; AC voltage regulator are one of supports C-code generation. [4] SimPowerSystems contains
them.[1] application libraries, Electrical Sources (Contains blocks
The Rectifier is the power electronic circuit which is highly that generate electric signals), Elements (Contains linear
used in all power supply units. All the modern power and nonlinear circuit elements.), Extra Library (Contains
controlled circuits like simple fan regulator to DC motor three-phase blocks and specialized measurement and
drive use the concept of phase control through which power control blocks. You can also open this library by entering
to the output is controlled. This type of rectifier is called powerlib_extras at the command line.) , Machines
controlled rectifier. [2] In uncontrolled rectifier due to the (Contains power machinery models.), Measurements
use of simple power diode we can’t control the voltage & (Contains blocks for the current and voltage
current. For controlled rectifier modern devices like SCR measurements.), Power Electronics (Contains power
and TRIAC are used, which can control the output voltage electronics devices.) and powergui (used to decide supply;
and current by providing the necessary pulse at appropriate i.e. continues or discrete) libraries to design and stimulate
angle which is called firing angle. [3] different power electronics circuits. THYRISTOR,
In the section 1.1 will looks at how the modeling and MOSFET, GTO, AC/DC VOLTAGE supply are one of the
simulation of a power electronic converter can be carried examples of various libraries blocks. Figure 1 contains
out using MATLAB/SIMULINK software and in section some of the blocks of the SimPowerSystem.
1.2 will define important parameters to understand the
performance of single and 3-Ø rectifiers.

www.ijcsit.com 2107
 Robinson P. Paul et al, / (IJCSIT) International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, Vol. 5 (2) , 2014, 2107-2111

VL
IL = (6)
RL
The rectification ratio (η ), also known as rectification
efficiency, is expressed by

PDC
η= (7)
PL + PD
PDC = VDC .I DC (8)
PL = VL .I L (9)
PD = RD .I 2 L (10)
Where,
PD=the losses in the rectifier
RD=the equivalent resistance of the rectifier

By developing Equation (7), using Equations (5), (8), (9)

and (10), we get:
VDC .I DC V 2 DC 1
η= 2
= . (11)
VL .I L + RD .I L VL 1 + ( RD )
Fig 1: Simulation Blocks
RL
1.2 Performance parameters for Rectifiers The ripple factor is an important parameter for the rectifier
Before starting to examine various single-phase or multi- which used to describe the quality of the rectification. The
phase rectifiers’ circuits, we should define some RF is defined as the ratio of the effective AC component of
parameters. These parameters are needed to compare the the load voltage versus the DC voltage.
performances among the various structures. For the
performance comparison we will assume ideal switches
(diodes or thyristors) with zero commutation time
V 2 L − V 2 DC
RF = = FF 2 − 1 (12)
(instantaneous turn on and off) and zero on-resistance VDC
(when conducting they present neither voltage drop nor One of the parameters used to define the characteristics of
losses).The DC voltage on the load is the average output the transformer is the Transformer Utilization Factor
voltage over the period T. [5] (TUF).
T
1
T 0
PDC
VDC = VL (t).d(t) TUF = (13)
V . AP + V . AS
( )
(1) 2
Similarly, it is possible to define the R.M.S. voltage on the Where,
load is given by: VAP and VAS are the power ratings at the primary
T and secondary of the transformer
1 2
T 0
VL = v L (t).d(t) (2)
For the comparison of the different topologies, it is also
useful to take into consideration the Peak Inverse
The ratio of the two voltages is the Form Factor (FF). Voltage(PIV) during the blocking state of the device or the
Vdc maximum current in the load. [10][11]
FF = (3)
VL
2. SINGLE AND 3-Ø PHASE UNCONTROLLED RECTIFIER
This parameter is very important because it is an index of The particle physics point of view, the ideal rectifier is the
the efficiency of the rectification process. one that provides the best direct current to the load. This
If the load to be purely resistive, the currents can be define means the ideal rectifier have very low ripple, very high
as Stability. As we shall see later, this goal is achieved by
vL (t) using three-phase systems and full-wave rectifiers. Single-
iL (t) = (4)
RL phase rectifiers are still in low-power stand-alone
converters and as output stage in Switched Mode Power
Supplies. Still Single Phase rectifier is in use for low power
VDC .I DC stand alone converter and in SMPS (Switched Mode Power
η= (5)
VL .I L + RD .I L Supply). Table 1 represent all the performance parameter of
the single phase topology.

www.ijcsit.com 2108
 Robinson P. Paul et al, / (IJCSIT) International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, Vol. 5 (2) , 2014, 2107-2111

Table 1: Performance Parameter of the Single Phase

topologies
Half Center-
Bridge
wave Tap
Peak repetitive reverse voltage
πVdc πVdc π/2Vdc
VRRM
r.m.s. input voltage per
2.22VDC 1.11VDC 1.11VDC
transformer leg VSrms
Diode average current IF(AV) IDC 0.5IDC 0.5IDC
Diode peak repetitive forward
π.IF(AV) π/2.IF(AV) π/2.IF(AV)
current IFRM
Diode r.m.s. current IF(rms) π/2.IDC π/4.IDC π/4.IDC
Form factor of diode current π/2 π/2 π/2
Form factor – FF 1.57 1.11 1.11
Rectification ratio – η 0.405 0.81 0.81
Ripple factor – RF 1.21 0.482 0.482
Transformer rating primary VA 2.69PDC 1.23PDC 1.23PDC
Transformer rating secondary 3.49
1.75 PDC 1.23 PDC
VA PDC Chart -2: Matlab Simulation result for the Single phase
Transformer utilization factor 0.324 0.671 0.813 Full wave uncontrolled rectifier
Output ripple frequency fR fmains 2fmains 2fmains

Fig -2: Matlab Simulation Model for Single phase half

wave uncontrolled rectifier

Fig -4: Matlab Simulation Model for 3-Ø Half wave

uncontrolled rectifier

As shown in figure 2, figure 3 and figure 4 represent the

Matlab simulation model for the single and 3-Ø
Uncontrolled rectifier. Same as Chart 1, Chart 2 and Chart
3 represent output simulation result for the same.

Chart -1: Matlab Simulation result for the Single phase

half wave uncontrolled rectifier

Fig -3: Matlab Simulation Model for Single phase Full Chart -3: Matlab Simulation result for the 3-Ø Full wave
wave uncontrolled rectifier uncontrolled rectifier

www.ijcsit.com 2109
 Robinson P. Paul et al, / (IJCSIT) International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, Vol. 5 (2) , 2014, 2107-2111

3. SINGLE AND 3-Ø PHASE CONTROLLED RECTIFIER

As per the above simulation we have seen that it is
necessary to vary the output voltage of the rectifier. The
structures as given in Figure 2, 3 and 4 provide output
voltages that are in a fixed ratio with the input AC voltages.
The diodes alone cannot satisfy controlling requirements.
The diodes are substituted with thyristors. The thyristor is a
device whose transition from the blocking to the
conducting state depends not only on the polarity of the
anode–cathode voltage but is also controlled via the
application of an adequate current pulse. Thyristors have
three terminals: the trigger pulse is applied to the gate while Fig-6: Matlab Simulation result for Single phase Full wave
the anode–cathode voltage is positive. The name thyristor phase controlled rectifier.
derives from the Greek word thy-, meaning ‘switch’, and
the suffix -istor, which derives from transistor (trans-fer
res-istor) to indicate that the device belongs to the
semiconductor family [6][9]. Sometimes it is called Silicon
Controlled Rectifier (SCR) to distinguish it from similar
devices like the Gate Turn-Off thyristor (GTO) or the
TRIode to control AC (Triac) or others, much less capable
of handling high power, that are often used in the circuitry
generating the trigger pulses for the SCR. In the rest of this
paper, thyristor means SCR. In this section we still assume
that we have ideal switches and purely resistive loads. Here
pages we shall only consider three-phase systems and those
topologies that are more commonly used to supply the load
with variable voltage and, consequently, variable current.
[7][8] Chart -5: Matlab Simulation result for the Single phase
As shown in figure 5, figure 6 and figure 7 represent the Full wave controlled rectifier
Matlab simulation model for the single and 3-Ø controlled
rectifier, where Chart 4, Chart 5 and Chart 6 represent +
v

output simulation result for the same.

- Supply Voltage 230V, 50Hz
V1
+
v
-
V2
+
v
- i
+
- Output current
V3
D1 D3 D5 I

230V 50Hz
Scope
+
R Load v In Mean
- Output v oltage Av erage Output v oltage
V
230V 50Hz1 Mean Value

Display
230V 50Hz2 D4 D6
D2

Continuous

powergui

Fig-7: Matlab Simulation result for 3-Ø Full wave phase

controlled rectifier.
Fig-5: Matlab Simulation result for Single phase half wave
phase controlled rectifier.

Chart -4: Matlab Simulation result for the Single phase Chart -6: Matlab Simulation result for the 3-Ø Full wave
half wave controlled rectifier phase controlled rectifier.

www.ijcsit.com 2110
 Robinson P. Paul et al, / (IJCSIT) International Journal of Computer Science and Information Technologies, Vol. 5 (2) , 2014, 2107-2111

CONCLUSIONS [3] Lander, Cyril W. (1993). "2. Rectifying Circuits". Power

electronics (3rd ed. ed.). London: McGraw
As Power Electronics is one of the important branches in
Hill. ISBN: 9780077077143.
recent industry revolution and power electronic systems are [4] The MathWorks, Inc
getting more complex today, the simulation is one of the [5] R. Visintini , “Elettra Synchrotron Light Laboratory, Trieste,
easiest and effective sources for research and design Italy”.
[6] R.S. Ramshaw, Power Electronics Semiconductor Switches
development. The use of this Simulation toolbox must be a (Chapman & Hall, London, 1993).
part of the modern syllabus for the students to enhance their [7] P.C. Sen, Power Electronics (Tata McGraw-Hill, 1988).
knowledge. Even with the help of present model students [8] J. Schaefer, Rectifier Circuits: Theory and Design (Wiley, 1965).
can simulate the power electronics circuit with various load
[9] G.J. Wakileh, Power Systems Harmonics (Springer, 2001).
& conditions to understand and to explore in the design [10] M.H. Rashid (ed.), Power Electronics Handbook (Academic Press,
field. Most studies either deal with devices like diodes or 2001)
thyristors — simultaneously handling high currents and [11] A.W. Kelley and W.F. Yadusky, Phase-controlled rectifier line-
high voltages (up to some kA/kV, see for example, Refs. current harmonics and power factor as a function of firing angle and
output filter inductance, Proc. APEC’90.
[12], [13], [14]) or with their control, for example the use [12] Eupec, Rectifier diode D 2601N, BIP AC / SM PB, 2002-05-31,
of microcontrollers in a new design for firing pulse Eupec Data Sheet.
generation (see Ref. [15]) [13] Eupec, Phase control thyristor T 2871N, BIP AM / SM PB, 2002-04-
07, Eupec Data Sheet.
[14] Powerex Inc., FT1500AU-240 Ultra high voltage thyristor, Powerex
REFERENCES Data Sheet.
[1] A. Hemant Mehar, “MATLAB Simulation Techniques in Power
[15] R.W. Wall and H.L. Hess, Design and microcontroller
Electronics”, IEEE Technology and Engineering Education
implementation of a three-phase SCR power converter, Idaho
(ITEE),VOL. 7, NO.4 December, 2012.
University, Department of Electrical Engineering
[2] Singh-Khanchandani, “Power Electronics (Book)”, ISBN:
9780070583894, Publication Year: 2006.

www.ijcsit.com 2111