(BS en 14236-2007) - Ultrasonic Domestic Gas Meters.
(BS en 14236-2007) - Ultrasonic Domestic Gas Meters.
(BS en 14236-2007) - Ultrasonic Domestic Gas Meters.
14236:2007
ICS 91.140.40
12&23<,1*:,7+287%6,3(50,66,21(;&(37$63(50,77('%<&23<5,*+7/$:
BS EN 14236:2007
National foreword
© BSI 2007
English Version
CEN members are bound to comply with the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations which stipulate the conditions for giving this European
Standard the status of a national standard without any alteration. Up-to-date lists and bibliographical references concerning such national
standards may be obtained on application to the CEN Management Centre or to any CEN member.
This European Standard exists in three official versions (English, French, German). A version in any other language made by translation
under the responsibility of a CEN member into its own language and notified to the CEN Management Centre has the same status as the
official versions.
CEN members are the national standards bodies of Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland,
France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal,
Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and United Kingdom.
© 2007 CEN All rights of exploitation in any form and by any means reserved Ref. No. EN 14236:2007: E
worldwide for CEN national Members.
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Contents Page
Foreword ................................................................................................................................................7
1 Scope.........................................................................................................................................8
2 Normative references ..............................................................................................................8
3 Terms, definitions and symbols ...........................................................................................10
3.1 Terms and definitions............................................................................................................10
3.2 Symbols ..................................................................................................................................13
4 Normal operating conditions ................................................................................................14
4.1 Flow range ..............................................................................................................................14
4.2 Maximum working pressure .................................................................................................15
4.3 Temperature range.................................................................................................................15
4.4 Range of gases.......................................................................................................................16
4.4.1 Test gases...............................................................................................................................16
4.5 Orientation ..............................................................................................................................16
5 Metrological performance .....................................................................................................16
5.1 General ....................................................................................................................................16
5.2 Mode comparison ..................................................................................................................17
5.2.1 General ....................................................................................................................................17
5.2.2 Requirements .........................................................................................................................17
5.2.3 Test ..........................................................................................................................................17
5.3 Permissible errors..................................................................................................................17
5.3.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................17
5.3.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................17
5.4 Gas — air relationship ...........................................................................................................18
5.4.1 General ....................................................................................................................................18
5.4.2 Requirements .........................................................................................................................18
5.4.3 Test ..........................................................................................................................................19
5.5 Pressure absorption ..............................................................................................................19
5.5.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................19
5.5.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................19
5.6 Metrological stability .............................................................................................................20
5.6.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................20
5.6.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................20
5.7 Immunity to contaminants in gas stream ............................................................................20
5.7.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................20
5.7.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................20
5.7.3 Specification of contamination dust ....................................................................................22
5.8 Installation effects..................................................................................................................22
5.8.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................22
5.8.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................22
5.9 Zero flow .................................................................................................................................22
5.9.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................22
5.9.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................22
5.10 Reverse flow ...........................................................................................................................23
5.10.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................23
5.10.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................23
5.11 Low flow registration .............................................................................................................23
5.11.1 Requirement ...........................................................................................................................23
5.11.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................23
5.12 High flow registration ............................................................................................................23
2
EN 14236:2007 (E)
3
EN 14236:2007 (E)
7 Optional features....................................................................................................................49
7.1 Pressure measuring point.....................................................................................................49
7.1.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................49
7.1.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................49
7.2 Resistance to high ambient temperature ............................................................................49
7.2.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................49
7.2.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................50
7.2.3 Meter fitted with a thermal shut-off valve ............................................................................51
7.3 Meters with temperature conversion ...................................................................................51
7.4 Ancillary devices (if fitted) ....................................................................................................51
7.4.1 Requirement ...........................................................................................................................51
7.4.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................52
7.5 Use in hazardous zones ........................................................................................................52
8 Index ........................................................................................................................................52
8.1 Recording and storage ..........................................................................................................52
8.1.1 Requirement ...........................................................................................................................52
8.1.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................52
8.2 Display.....................................................................................................................................52
8.2.1 Requirement ...........................................................................................................................52
8.2.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................52
8.3 Segmental display..................................................................................................................53
8.3.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................53
8.3.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................53
8.4 Non-volatile memory..............................................................................................................53
8.4.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................53
8.4.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................53
8.5 Display reset ...........................................................................................................................54
8.5.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................54
8.5.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................54
9 Marking ...................................................................................................................................54
9.1 All meters ................................................................................................................................54
9.2 Two-pipe meters.....................................................................................................................55
9.2.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................55
9.2.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................55
9.3 Durability and legibility of marking ......................................................................................55
9.3.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................55
9.3.2 Weathering..............................................................................................................................55
9.3.3 Indelibility test ........................................................................................................................56
9.4 Accompanying information ..................................................................................................56
10 Software ..................................................................................................................................57
10.1 Requirements .........................................................................................................................57
10.2 Test ..........................................................................................................................................57
11 Communications ....................................................................................................................57
11.1 General ....................................................................................................................................57
11.2 Character transmission .........................................................................................................58
11.3 Communications protocol.....................................................................................................58
11.3.1 General ....................................................................................................................................58
11.3.2 Wakeup ...................................................................................................................................58
11.3.3 Sign-off....................................................................................................................................58
11.3.4 Security ...................................................................................................................................58
11.3.5 Time-outs ................................................................................................................................58
11.4 Data..........................................................................................................................................58
11.4.1 General ....................................................................................................................................58
11.4.2 Data read-out mode ...............................................................................................................59
11.5 Test-mode ...............................................................................................................................59
11.5.1 General ....................................................................................................................................59
11.5.2 Test-mode commands ...........................................................................................................59
4
EN 14236:2007 (E)
5
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Foreword
This document (EN 14236:2007) has been prepared by Technical Committee CEN/TC 237 “Gas
meters”, the secretariat of which is held by BSI.
This European Standard shall be given the status of a national standard, either by publication of an
identical text or by endorsement, at the latest by July 2007, and conflicting national standards shall be
withdrawn at the latest by July 2007
This document has been prepared under a mandate given to CEN by the European Commission and
the European Free Trade Association, and supports essential requirements of EU Directive
2004/22/EC.
For relationship with EU Directive 2004/22/EC, see informative Annex ZA, which is an integral part of
this document.
According to the CEN/CENELEC Internal Regulations, the national standards organizations of the
following countries are bound to implement this European Standard: Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria,
Cyprus, Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland,
Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania,
Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland and United Kingdom.
7
EN 14236:2007 (E)
1 Scope
This European Standard specifies requirements and tests for the construction, performance and
safety of class 1,0 and class 1,5 battery powered ultrasonic gas meters (hereinafter referred to as
meters), having co-axial single pipe, or two pipe connections, used to measure volumes of distributed
fuel gases of the second and/or third family, as given in EN 437, at maximum working pressures not
3
exceeding 0,5 bar 1 ) and maximum actual flow rates of up to 10 m /h over a minimum ambient
temperature range of -10 °C to +40 °C, and minimum gas temperature span of 40 K, for domestic
applications. This European Standard applies to meters where the measuring element and the
register(s) are enclosed in the same case.
This European Standard applies to meters with and without built-in temperature conversion, that are
installed in locations with vibration and shocks of low significance and in
closed locations (indoor or outdoor with protection as specified by the manufacturer) with
condensing or with non-condensing humidity
open locations (outdoor without any covering) with condensing humidity or with non-condensing
humidity
Unless otherwise stated, all pressures given in this European Standard are gauge pressures.
When more than one meter type is submitted for testing, then each meter type is required to be tested
against this European Standard.
Clauses 1 to 15 and Annex C are for design and type testing only.
2 Normative references
The following referenced documents are indispensable for the application of this document. For dated
references, only the edition cited applies. For undated references, the latest edition of the referenced
document (including any amendments) applies.
EN 60068-2-5, Environmental testing — Part 2: Tests — Test Sa: Simulated solar radiation at ground
level (IEC 60068-2-5:1975)
EN 60068-2-30, Environmental testing — Part 2-30: Tests — Test Db: Damp heat, cyclic (12 + 12 h
cycle) (IEC 60068-2-30:2005)
1) 5
1 bar = 1 000 mbar = 10 Pa.
8
EN 14236:2007 (E)
EN 60079-10, Electrical apparatus for explosive gas atmospheres — Part 10: Classification of
hazardous areas (IEC 60079-10:1995)
prEN 60079-11, IEC 60079-11, Ed. 5.0: Explosive atmospheres — Part 11: Equipment protection by
intrinsic safety “i”
EN 60079-15, Electrical apparatus for explosive gas atmospheres — Part 15: Construction, test and
marking of type of protection "n" electrical apparatus (IEC 60079-15:2005)
EN 60086-4, Primary batteries — Part 4: Safety standard for lithium batteries (IEC 60086-4:2000)
EN 60695-11-5, Fire hazard testing — Part 11-5: Test flames — Needle-flame test method —
Apparatus, confirmatory test arrangement and guidance (IEC 60695-11-5:2004)
EN 60707, Flammability of solid non-metallic materials when exposed to flame sources — List of test
methods (IEC 60707:1999)
EN 60730-1:2000, Automatic electrical controls for household and similar use — Part 1: General
requirements (IEC 60730-1:1999, modified)
EN 61000-6-1, Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) — Part 6-1: Generic standards — Immunity for
residential, commercial and light-industrial environments
EN 61000-6-2, Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) — Part 6-2: Generic standards – Immunity for
industrial environments (IEC 61006-2-2:2005)
EN 62056-21:2002, Electricity metering — Data exchange for meter reading, tariff and load control —
Part 21: Direct local data exchange (IEC 62056-21:2002)
9
EN 14236:2007 (E)
EN ISO 4892-3, Plastics — Methods of exposure to laboratory light sources — Part 3: Fluorescent UV
lamps (ISO 4892-3-2006)
EN ISO 6270-1, Paints and varnishes — Determination of resistance to humidity — Part 1: Continuous
condensation (ISO 6270-1:1998)
EN ISO 9227, Corrosion tests in artificial atmospheres – Salt spray tests (ISO 9227:2006)
ISO 834-1, Fire resistance tests — Elements of building construction — Part 1: General requirements
ISO 7724-3, Paints and varnishes — Colorimetry — Part 3: Calculation of colour differences
ASTM D471, Standard Test Method for Rubber Property — Effect of Liquids
ASTM D1003, Standard Test Method for Haze and Luminous Transmittance of Transparent Plastics
For the purposes of this European Standard, the following terms and definitions apply.
3.1.1
actual flow rate
flow rate at the gas pressure and gas temperature conditions prevailing in the gas distribution line in
which the meter is fitted, at the meter inlet
3.1.2
base conditions
fixed conditions to which a volume of gas is converted (i.e. base gas temperature 15 °C, base gas
pressure 1 013,25 mbar)
3.1.3
contaminants
gas borne dust, vapour and other substances that could affect the operation of the meter
3.1.4
communications port
galvanic or optical serial data port
3.1.5
display
device (e.g. liquid crystal display) which shows the contents of a memory (e.g. registered volume or
flags)
10
EN 14236:2007 (E)
3.1.6
distributed gas
gas locally available
3.1.7
error of indication (∈ )
value which shows the relationship in percentage terms of the difference between the volume
indicated by the meter and the volume which has actually flowed through the meter, to the latter
volume:
Vi − Vc
∈= ⋅ 100
Vc
where
3
Vi is the indicated volume in cubic metres (m );
3
Vc is the volume in cubic metres (m ) that has actually flowed through the meter
3.1.8
external leak tightness
leak tightness of the gas carrying components of the gas meter with respect to the atmosphere
3.1.9
flag
single alphabetic character on the index giving a visual signal of significant events and/or change(s) in
the operation of the meter
3.1.10
galvanic connection/interface
hard wired serial connection or pulse output from the meter
3.1.11
index
all that which is viewed through the index window, including the display
3.1.12
index window(s)
area(s) of transparent material through which the index can be read
3.1.13
maximum error shift
maximum mean error shift at any of the tested flow rates
3.1.14
maximum working pressure
upper limit of the working pressure for which the meter has been designed, as declared by the
manufacturer and marked on the index or the data plate
3.1.15
mean error
arithmetic mean of consecutive errors of indication at a flow rate
3.1.16
measuring element
part of the meter which produces an electrical signal proportional to the gas flow rate
11
EN 14236:2007 (E)
3.1.17
memory
element which stores digital information
3.1.18
meter case
complete meter, not casing only
3.1.19
meter class
class to which a meter belongs, according to the metrological requirements of this European Standard,
i.e. class 1,5 or class 1,0.
3.1.20
meter cover
rigid enclosure on the front of the meter made either wholly of transparent material, or of opaque
material provided with index window(s)
3.1.21
normal conditions of operation
conditions referring to the meter operating:
3.1.22
operating mode
method (sample frequency and timing) of obtaining volume flow measurements
3.1.23
optical port
serial data port using an infra-red transmitter and receiver
3.1.24
pressure absorption
difference between the pressure measured at the inlet and outlet connections of the meter whilst the
meter is operating
3.1.25
pressure measuring point
permanent fitting on the meter outlet enabling a direct measurement of the outlet pressure to be
obtained
3.1.26
range of mean errors
difference between the minimum and maximum mean errors over a specified flow range
3.1.27
regression line
straight line, generated using a statistical method, to give a graphical representation of a set of results
12
EN 14236:2007 (E)
3.1.28
register
electronic device comprising both memory and display, which stores and displays information
3.1.29
segment
individual part of a display which is able to show a portion of a character
3.1.30
starting flow rate
lowest flow rate at which the meter is able to indicate a volume of gas passed
3.1.31
temperature conversion device
device which converts the measured volume to a corresponding volume at base gas temperature
3.1.32
test house
organisation used to perform prescribed tests on meters, in accordance with this standard
3.1.33
thermal cut-off valve
heat sensitive valve used to cut off the flow of gas to the meter if the ambient temperature rises above
a predetermined level for a specified time
3.1.34
ultrasonic gas meter
gas meter that uses ultrasound and that is designed to measure, memorise and display the fuel gas
volume that has passed through it
3.1.35
ultrasonic transducer
device used to generate and detect the ultrasound signals within the meter
3.1.36
working pressure
pressure of the gas at the inlet of the meter
3.2 Symbols
3.2.1
D
outside diameter of the pipe in millimetres (mm)
3.2.2
g
-2
acceleration due to gravity, in metres per square second (m ⋅ s )
3.2.3
MPE
maximum permissible error, in percent (%)
3.2.4
pmax
maximum working pressure
13
EN 14236:2007 (E)
3.2.5
Qmax
3
maximum flow rate, specified in cubic metres per hour (m /h) for which the meter has been designed
3.2.6
Qmin
3
minimum flow rate, specified in cubic metres per hour (m /h) for which the meter has been designed
3.2.7
Qr
overload flow rate, the highest flow rate at which the meter operates for a short period of time without
deteriorating
3.2.8
Qstart
lowest flow rate at which the meter is capable of registering the passage of gas, as declared by the
manufacturer
3.2.9
Qt
transitional flow rate, occurring between the maximum and minimum flow rates at which the flow rate
range is divided into two zones, the ‘upper zone’ and the ‘lower zone’
3.2.10
tb
base gas temperature
3.2.11
tb,i
base gas temperature for meters declared suitable for differential temperature and intermittent
operation
3.2.12
Ti
temperature at meter inlet
3.2.13
tm
ambient temperature of the meter
3.2.14
tg
gas temperature range of the meter
3.2.15
tsp
specified centre temperature for a temperature converted meter
The values of maximum flow rates and those corresponding values of the upper limits of the minimum
flow rates shall be those given in Table 1.
14
EN 14236:2007 (E)
The definitions of the meter classifications applicable in this European Standard are given in Table 2.
The manufacturer shall declare the maximum working pressure of the meter and this pressure shall
be marked on the index or data plate of the meter. This pressure shall not exceed 0,5 bar.
Unless otherwise stated, all temperatures given in this document shall be measured to within ± 1 °C.
All meters shall be capable of meeting the requirements for a minimum ambient temperature range of
-10 °C to +40 °C (see 5.14), a minimum gas temperature span of 40 K and a storage temperature of
≤ -20 °C to ≥ +60 °C. The gas temperature range shall be within the ambient temperature range.
The manufacturer shall declare the gas temperature range and the ambient temperature range.
The manufacturer can declare a wider ambient temperature range using a minimum temperature of
-10 °C, -25 °C or -40 °C and a maximum temperature of 40 °C, 55 °C or 70 °C and/or a wider storage
temperature range. The meter shall be capable of meeting the requirements over this declared wider
range.
If the manufacturer declares that the meter is resistant to high ambient temperatures, the meter shall
also be capable of meeting the requirements of the heat resistance test and shall be marked
accordingly (see 7.2.1 and 9.1).
15
EN 14236:2007 (E)
The manufacturer shall specify the range of gases for which the meter is suitable, from Table 3.
second family gases shall be tested with air and 99,5 % CH4.
third family gases shall be tested with air and 99,5 % Propane and/or 99,5 % Butane, as
appropriate.
By agreement with the Test House any other test gas can be included. The additional gases shall be
marked on the meter as defined in 9.1.
4.5 Orientation
Where meters can be installed in orientations other than with the connection ports vertical, meters
shall be tested in those other orientations, for durability and as agreed with the Test House.
5 Metrological performance
5.1 General
Provision shall be made for synchronizing the start and finish of test periods with test equipment,
either via a galvanic connection or optical port.
The test equipment shall generate an event that starts the test. The measured response (volume
reading) from the meter shall be synchronous with its sampling instant. To achieve this, the meter
shall delay its measured response until the next sample period after it has received a start command.
The sampling instant shall be synchronous with the start of the data transmission string.
NOTE This is used to start/stop an independent timer of sufficient resolution to accurately time the period
between successive measure periods.
If it is intended to use the meter in two directions (forward and reverse flow) then all tests shall be
performed in both directions.
16
EN 14236:2007 (E)
5.2.1 General
If the meter has a normal operating (sampling) mode and one or more test (fast sampling) modes then,
provided that the requirement in 5.2.2 is met, all subsequent tests in this European Standard shall be
carried out in the test-mode. If the requirement is not satisfied then all subsequent tests shall be
performed in the normal operating mode.
5.2.2 Requirements
The accuracy of the measurements shall not be influenced by different sampling modes.
The difference of the mean errors of the standard mode and the test-mode shall not exceed 0,3 % for
Qt ≤ Q ≤ Qmax and 0,6 % for Qmin ≤ Q < Qt.
If this requirement is not satisfied, subsequent tests shall be undertaken in the normal operating mode.
5.2.3 Test
Test the meter in the standard mode and in the test-mode in accordance with 5.3.2 a).
5.3.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 5.3.2 a) the mean error shall be within the maximum permissible
errors specified in Table 4 and the range of mean errors shall be within the limits specified in Table 5.
When the errors between Qt and Qmax all have the same sign, they shall not exceed 1 % for class 1,5
and 0,5 % for class 1,0.
When tested in accordance with 5.3.2 b) the mean error shall be within the maximum permissible
errors specified in Table 4 and the range of mean errors shall be within the limits specified in Table 5
for each individual test gas at each test temperature.
If the manufacturer has declared a wider ambient and gas temperature range, then the extreme
temperatures declared shall be substituted for -10 °C and +40 °C, as appropriate.
After the meter has been subjected to other influences, given by the individual clauses of this
European Standard, the mean errors shall be within the error limits specified within those clauses
when tested by the methods given in 5.3.2 a) or 5.3.2 b).
5.3.2 Test
a) Error on air
Thermally stabilize the meter to be tested to the temperature of the test laboratory.
Pass a volume of air at 20 °C, the actual volume of which is measured by a reference standard,
through the meter and note the volume indicated by the meter. This indicated volume can be
obtained via the communication port. The minimum volume of air to be passed through the meter
is specified by the manufacturer and agreed with the Test House.
17
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Carry out six consecutive tests at each of the following flow rates in ascending or descending
order Qmin, 3 Qmin, 5 Qmin, 10 Qmin, 0,1 Qmax, 0,2 Qmax, 0,4 Qmax, 0,7 Qmax, Qmax.
Calculate the six errors of indication (see 3.1.7) at each of the flow rates, the mean of the six
errors and note it as a point on the error curve. Then, calculate the difference of the arithmetic
mean of the errors of indication at each of the flow rates.
Carry out the test as described in 5.3.2 a) and additionally at –10 °C and +40 °C (or that wider
temperature range declared by the manufacturer) using the test gases in turn specified in 4.4.1
and any other test gas by agreement with the Test House, which shall be marked on the meter
(see 9.1).
5.4.1 General
Where meters satisfy the requirements in 5.4.2, air shall be used for subsequent tests as the test
medium.
5.4.2 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 5.4.3 the range of mean errors on all test gases combined (including
air) shall be within the limits specified in Table 5 (see X in Figure 1).
The difference between the mean error on the test gases and that on air at each flow rate shall satisfy
the limits specified in Table 6 (see Y in Figure 1).
NOTE Figure 1 represents a graphical explanation of the requirements given in 5.3 and 5.4.
18
EN 14236:2007 (E)
1.5
2
1
Y
X
Q min Qt Q max
-1.5
-3
Key
1 error %
2 flow rate Q
error on gas
error on air
5.4.3 Test
Apply the requirements of 5.4.2 to the results from testing the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) and
5.3.2 b).
5.5.1 Requirements
3
The pressure absorption of the meter with a flow of air of density 1,2 kg/m , at a flow rate equal to
Qmax, shall not exceed 2,0 mbar.
5.5.2 Test
3
Pass air through the meter with a flow of air of density 1,2 kg/m , at a flow rate equal to Qmax, and
measure the differential pressure across the meter with a suitable measuring instrument.
19
EN 14236:2007 (E)
5.6.1 Requirements
The difference between any two of the six errors of indication at each flow rate greater than or equal
to Qt shall not exceed 0,6 % and at each flow rate less than Qt the difference shall not exceed 1,0 %.
5.6.2 Test
Apply the requirements of 5.6.1 to the results from testing the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a).
5.7.1 Requirements
When meters are tested in accordance with 5.7.2, the errors of these meters shall not exceed the
following:
Class 1,0 Mean error: MPE; Error shift: one third of the MPE in Table 4.
After the test in 5.7.2, the pressure absorption tested in accordance with 5.3.2 a) shall not exceed
2,2 mbar.
5.7.2 Test
Test a minimum of 6 meters. Where more than one installation orientation is specified by the
manufacturer, test a minimum of 3 m in each orientation.
The test equipment used for this test need not have absolute traceability provided that each meter is
calibrated on equipment that does have such traceability prior to commencing the test.
Attach the meter to a dust rig that has 10 D of vertical pipe before the meter and pass air through the
meter for 5 min at Qmax. Stop the air supply and add 5 g of 300 to 400 grade dust to the rig inlet. Start
the air supply and maintain a flow of Qmax for a further 5 min.
Repeat this procedure with 5 g of each dust grade in the order 200 to 300, 100 to 200 and 0 to 100.
20
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Dimensions in millimetres
Key
1 meter connection
2 dust inlet (screwed plug)
3 air supply (fan)
4 fast acting full bore valve
d) a length of straight pipe 30 D to 45 D in length, to ensure that all dust is airborne before entering
the meter;
e) copper pipework with soldered or compression fittings is preferred. Steel pipe fittings are not
recommended as the dust will adhere to the screw threads.
Other designs of test rig can be used, at the discretion of the Test House. Check the effectiveness of
a test rig design on a regular basis, using a test box. This is to ensure that when 20 g of dust is added
using the procedure mentioned above at least 18 g is deposited inside the test box fitted to the rig
outlet. Ensure that the test box has a similar volume and shape to the meter to be tested and fitted
with a filter on the outlet to minimize the dust passing through the outlet.
21
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Four separate batches of dust shall be used with 95 % of the particles in each batch in the
appropriate size range given below:
5.8.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 5.8.2, the mean errors at all flow rates shall remain within the MPE
and the mean error difference at each flow rate shall not exceed one third of the MPE specified in
Table 4. The meter shall recover from the flow disturbance to be within the MPE, specified in Table 4.
5.8.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) with a straight pipe of length no less than 10 D connected
to the meter inlet.
Repeat the test, with a pipe of the same diameter as the nominal connection diameter of the meter,
but with two 90° elbows with their planes at right angles and not more than 2 D apart. Connect this to
the meter inlet with the first bend not more than 2 D from the inlet.
Repeat the test in accordance with 5.3.2 a) with a straight pipe of length not less than 10 D connected
to the meter inlet.
5.9.1 Requirements
Neither the meter display nor the internal register shall change in value (increase or decrease) when
the meter is tested by the method given in 5.9.2.
5.9.2 Test
This test is carried out at -10 °C, +20 °C and +40 °C. If the manufacturer has declared a wider ambient
and gas temperature range, then the extreme temperatures declared are substituted for -10 °C and
+40 °C above as appropriate.
22
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Record the meter display and the internal register of the meter. Fill the meter with dry pure methane at
atmospheric pressure and seal the inlet and outlet ports of the meter with gas tight fittings. Allow the
meter to stabilize at the test temperature and then store for 24 h at the test temperature. Record the
meter display and internal register and subtract the respective first readings from the second readings
to indicate any registration change. Repeat the test at each test temperature.
5.10.1 Requirements
If the meter has been designed to only be used in one direction, then when tested in accordance
with 5.10.2 the register shall neither increase nor decrease. Where an additional reverse flow register
is fitted, this shall indicate the passage of the test volume during the test described in 5.10.2.
5.10.2 Test
A test volume of 0,2 Qmax is passed through the meter in the reverse direction at a nominal flow rate
of Qmax. The index reading is recorded before and after the test.
5.11.1 Requirement
When tested by the method given in 5.11.2, the starting flow rate shall not be greater than 0,25 Qmin.
5.11.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), except that the test shall be carried out at 1,2 Qstart with a
3
test volume of 0,01 m .
5.12.1 Requirement
When tested in accordance with 5.12.2 the mean error shall not exceed the MPE, specified in Table 4.
5.12.2 Test
5.13.1 General
The normal operating mode of the meter shall have a sample period (T) that does not exceed 2 s,
randomised to ± 2 s, unless the manufacturer can demonstrate that a proposed longer sampling rate
will not cause the metrological characteristics of the meter to be significantly impaired by pulsed or
unsteady flow. Where the mean sample period is longer than 2 s, the tests of 5.13.3 shall still be
applied.
23
EN 14236:2007 (E)
5.13.2 Requirements
The difference between the cumulative volume at the ends of test runs 2 and 6, (see Table 7), and the
cumulative volume at runs 1 and 5 respectively, shall not exceed two thirds of the total MPE range
specified in Table 4.
The difference between the cumulative volume at the ends of test runs 3, 4, 7 and 8, (see Table 7),
and the cumulative volume at runs 1 and 5 respectively shall not exceed one third of the total MPE
range specified in Table 4.
The observed standard deviation of the error with stepping flow shall be within a range of 0,75 to 1,25
times the calculated standard deviation of the error.
Test 5.13.3 shall be performed with the meter in its normal operating mode.
5.13.3 Test
Subject the meter to flow conditions specified in Table 7 with either continuous or square wave airflow at
the on/off timings and flow rates, for a duration of 24 h, recording the start and end index volumes of
each test.
The following formula is used to calculate the standard deviation (sd) as a percentage of the total
volume of gas passed during a test:
50 ⋅T
sd =
S ⋅ N½
where
24
EN 14236:2007 (E)
5.14.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 5.14.2 the meter shall meet the following requirements:
that no error of indication shall differ from its regression line by more than 1 % for class 1,5 and
2
/3 % for class 1,0.
5.14.2 Test
Install the meter on an appropriate test rig, see Figure C.1, and stabilize the meter at the starting
temperature of the test for a period of 3 h prior to commencing the change of temperature at the rate
specified below.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 b) at a flow rate of 0,05 Qmax using test gas as specified in
4.4.1, according to meter type. Repeat this test at a frequency of three or four tests per hour while
changing the ambient temperature from –10 °C to +40 °C at a rate of 2 °C/h with the relative humidity
not exceeding 50 %.
6.1 General
The gas meter shall be constructed in such a way that any mechanical interference capable of
affecting the measuring accuracy results in permanently visible damage to the gas meter or the
verification or protection marks.
Any means of adjusting the performance characteristics of the meter shall be effectively secured and
protected against unauthorized interference.
access shall only be obtained by using a password or a code that can be updated, or by using a
specific device;
the last intervention, at least, shall be registered in the memory, including date and time of
intervention and a specific element to identify the intervention;
it shall be possible to have access to the intervention(s) registered in the memory for a minimum
period of two years.
The meter connections shall be fitted with suitable non-sealing caps or covers to protect any threads
and to prevent the entry of foreign matter during transit and storage.
A sealing drawing shall be part of the documentation for type approval. It shall include the
metrological sealing as well as all other tamper evident seals.
25
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.2.1 General
Parts of the meter case in direct contact with the ambient air on the outside and with the gas on the
inside shall be of sufficient thickness to meet the requirements of 6.2.
The meter case shall be constructed and arranged so that any non-permanent deformation cannot
prevent the satisfactory operation of the meter.
The meter shall have a meter case that can be sealed in such a way that the internal parts of the
meter are accessible only after breaking the metrological seal(s) or causing clear evidence of
interference.
6.2.2.1 Requirements
The meter shall be designed in such a way that it gives protection against the ingress of dust and
water so that it conforms, as a minimum, to the IP 54 degree of protection, in accordance with
EN 60529.
6.2.2.2 Test
Test the meter (including the battery compartment) in accordance with EN 60529.
6.2.3.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.2.3.2, the meter shall not leak and there shall be no permanent
deformation of the meter.
6.2.3.2 Test
Subject the meter to 2 000 cycles at 30 cycles per hour, at internal pressures varying from 0 mbar to
1,5 times the maximum working pressure or 350 mbar whichever is the greater. The rate of change of
-1
pressure shall not exceed 20 mbar ⋅ s .
6.2.4.1 Requirements
The meter shall be leak tight under normal conditions of use. When tested in accordance with 6.2.4.2,
the meter shall not leak.
6.2.4.2 Test
Pressurize the meter, at normal laboratory temperature, with air to 1,5 times the declared maximum
working pressure and check for leaks.
a) immersing the meter in water and observing for leakage for 30 s after any external trapped air
has been dispersed, or
26
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.2.5.1 Requirement
Following the test specified in 6.2.5.2, the meter shall satisfy the requirements of 6.2.4.1.
6.2.5.2 Test
Suspend the meter in an ambient temperature of (120 ± 2) °C for 15 min. For safety reasons, any
battery fitted to the meter shall be removed during the heating period.
6.2.6 Connections
6.2.6.1 Orientation
6.2.6.1.1 Requirements
The connections of meters having top mounted two pipe connections shall have the centrelines of
these connections within 2° of the vertical, with respect to the horizontal plane of the meter.
The distance between the centrelines of the connections, measured at the free end of the connections,
shall be within ± 0,5 mm of the nominal distance between the centrelines, or within ± 0,25 % of the
nominal distance between centrelines, whichever is the greater, and the centrelines shall be within 2°
of being parallel.
The free ends of the connections shall be level within 2 mm, or within 1 % of the nominal distance
between the centrelines of the connections, whichever is the greater, with respect to the horizontal
plane of the meter.
6.2.6.1.2 Test
6.2.6.2 Nominal connection diameters for single and two pipe meters
6.2.6.2.1 Requirements
The connections of meters having a co-axial single pipe connection shall be in accordance with
Figure 3.
6.2.6.2.2 Test
27
EN 14236:2007 (E)
d1
d2
d3
d4
d5
h
AF
Dimensions in millimetres
3
QMAX(m /h) d1 d2 d3 d4 d5 h SW
≤ 10 G2 54 46 32 26 +3 65
9 0
Key
1 sealing hole
AF across flats
28
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.2.6.3 Torque
6.2.6.3.1 Requirements
The meter connection shall be subjected to the appropriate torque specified in Table 8, in accordance
with 6.2.6.3.2 and shall then comply with the following:
any residual rotational deformation of the meter connection shall not exceed 2°.
6.2.6.3.2 Test
Firmly support the case of the meter and apply the appropriate torque value to each connection in
turn using a torque wrench.
6.2.6.4.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 6.2.6.4.2, the meter shall remain leak tight after this test in
accordance with 6.2.4.1.
The mean errors of the meter shall remain within the MPE specified in Table 4, before and after being
subjected to the test described in 6.2.6.4.2.
After the test, the residual deformation of the connections shall not exceed 5°.
6.2.6.4.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Rigidly support the meter by one of its connections and subject it to the appropriate bending moment,
see Table 8, for a period of 2 min. Different meters are used for the lateral test(s) and the fore and aft
test (see Figure 4).
In the case of the meter being of two pipe construction, repeat the lateral bending moment test on the
other meter connection, but for the fore and aft test support the meter by both connections.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
29
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
M Bending moment
6.2.7.1 Requirements
The meter shall remain leak tight and its mean errors shall be within the MPE specified in Table 4
before and after being subjected to the vibration test described in 6.2.7.2.
6.2.7.2 Test
Carry out the test specified in 5.3.2 a) at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Secure the meter to the vibration test rig, a diagrammatic layout of which is shown in Figure 5, by
means of a horizontal clamp across the top of the meter.
In Figure 5, the meter (2) is shown mounted to the spindle of an electrodynamic shaker (1), which is
driven by an amplified sine wave from a voltage generator. The head of the shaker can be rotated
through 90° for the fore-aft and lateral planes.
The acceleration level is sensed using an accelerometer (3) (piezoelectric transducer) whose output is
conditioned using a charge amplifier (4).
An automatic vibration exciter control (5), which is inserted between the conditioned accelerometer
signal and the power amplifier (6), is used in a sweeping mode in which the frequency is cycled
between a pair of selected frequencies, alternatively increasing and decreasing.
30
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
31
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Subject the meter to a swept frequency of between (10 ± 0,5) Hz and (150 ± 7,5) Hz at a sweep rate
of 1 octave per minute with a peak acceleration of (2 ± 0,1) g, for 20 sweeps in the vertical plane,
20 sweeps in the fore-aft plane and 20 sweeps in the lateral plane.
Recheck the mean errors of the meter, by carrying out the test specified in 5.3.2 a) at Qmin, 0,1 Qmax
and Qmax and confirm the leak tightness by carrying out the test described in 6.2.3.2.
NOTE 1 The clamping force should be sufficient to restrain the meter without causing damage or distortion to
the meter case.
NOTE 2 An octave is a band of frequency where the upper frequency limit of the band is exactly twice the
lower limit, e.g. 10 Hz to 20 Hz, 20 Hz to 40 Hz, 40 Hz to 80 Hz and 80 Hz to 160 Hz.
The time to sweep from 10 Hz to 100 Hz at a sweep rate of 1 octave per minute is 3 min 15 s.
6.2.8.1 Requirement
The meter shall remain leak tight, in accordance with 6.2.4.1, after being subjected to an impact load
using the method described in 6.2.8.2.
6.2.8.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 6.2.4.2 and perform the impact load test as follows.
The test apparatus consists of a hardened steel hemispherical tipped striker and a rigid smooth-bore
tube in which the striker is capable of sliding freely (see Figure 6).
The total mass of the striker is 3 kg. There are two sizes of striker tip, one having a radius of 1 mm,
the other having a radius of 4 mm (see Figure 7).
Use both sizes of striker tip during the test, but do not subject any test area on any one meter sample
to more than one impact for each size of striker. In the case of the same area being selected for test
with each size of striker tip, use two meter samples.
For each strike, rigidly support the meter on a firm base with the intended area of impact, which can
be any area of the meter case, horizontal. Place the end of the guide tube on the chosen impact area
of the meter. Allow the striker to fall freely and vertically through the tube onto the test area. The
striker tip falls from a height of h mm above the test area, where:
E=m·g·h
where
32
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Dimensions in millimetres
Key
1 meter level
2 vent hole
3 smooth bore rigid tube
4 hardened hemispherically tipped striker of mass 3 kg
5 radial clearance (0,5 ± 0,25)
33
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Dimensions in millimetres
Key
6.2.9.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 6.2.9.2, the meter shall remain leak tight in accordance with 6.2.4.1
and the mean errors shall remain within 2 MPE specified in Table 4.
6.2.9.2 Test
Hold the meter, with no packaging, in the upright position (in its horizontal plane), and drop vertically,
from rest, on to a flat, hard, horizontal surface from a height of 0,5 m. This height refers to the
distance from the base of the meter to the surface onto which it will fall.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
34
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.3.1 General
All parts of the meter shall be able to resist any corrosive substances contained in the internal and
external atmospheres with which they can be in contact during normal conditions of use.
Tests shall be performed on the gas containing components themselves or on sample plaques.
Sample plaques shall only be used in place of a component if no forming operations are carried out
on the component after any protective or decorative finish has been applied.
Sample plaques, if used, shall be approximately 100 mm square in size, their thickness being that of
the component they are replacing, unless otherwise specified by the meter manufacturer.
Any finishes on items supplied for test shall have been fully dried and cured.
Attack at the edges or up to 2 mm from the edge of sample plaques shall be ignored if the component
it replaces has no exposed edges when fully installed in the finished meter.
For resistance to external corrosion, gas-containing components shall comply with 6.3.2.1 to 6.3.2.6
unless the manufacturer declares that these are manufactured from base materials that are corrosion
resistant. In this case, the base materials shall comply with 6.3.3.1 to 6.3.3.3, in accordance with the
appropriate subclauses dependant on whether the material is metallic or non-metallic and the tests
shall be carried out with no additional protection.
For resistance to internal corrosion, gas-containing components shall comply with 6.3.4.1 to 6.3.4.4
unless the manufacturer declares that these are manufactured from base materials that are corrosion
resistant. In this case, the base materials shall comply with 6.3.5.1 to 6.3.5.2, in accordance with the
appropriate subclauses dependant on whether the material is metallic or non-metallic and the tests
shall be carried out with no additional protection.
6.3.2 Protection against external corrosion for material which is not corrosion resistant
6.3.2.1.1 Requirements
After testing as described in 6.3.2.1.2, corrodible base material shall not be exposed.
6.3.2.1.2 Test
Where a metallic protective coating is applied directly onto a metal surface, the indicator lamp will light
without any penetration of the surface. In this case the surface is to be visually inspected for
penetration.
6.3.2.2.1 Requirement
After testing as described in 6.3.2.2.2, the result shall be less than classification 2 given in
EN ISO 2409.
35
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.3.2.2.2 Test
6.3.2.3.1 Requirements
There shall be no cracking or loss of adhesion of the protective coating when tested for impact
resistance in accordance with 6.3.2.3.2.
6.3.2.3.2 Test
During the test, place the surface of the test piece that would normally be the outside surface of the
meter, so that it faces upwards.
6.3.2.4.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.3.2.4.2, any blistering of the protective coating shall be less than
that given as the degree of blistering 2/(S2) in Figure 1 a) of EN ISO 4628-2:2003, and the degree of
corrosion shall be not greater than that given as Ri 1 in Table 1 of EN ISO 4628-3:2003.
6.3.2.4.2 Test
Test in accordance with 7.4 of EN ISO 2812-1:1994, procedure A, using a test period of 168 h.
During the tests, immerse at least 30 % of the sample in the liquid, including the area at which the
meter case joins the meter connection, a separate sample being used for each of the following test
liquids:
a) mineral oil — ASTM oil Nr.2 according to ASTM D 471 [Aniline point (93 ± 3) °C/Viscosity
2 2
19,2 mm /s to 21,5 mm /s at 99 °C];
b) Ethanol (C2H5OH);
c) 5 % aqueous solution of sodium salts of sulphated broadcut primary alcohol, chain length C9 to
C13 pH values 6,5 to 8,5 (e.g. Shell Teepol HB72) ) (N2SO4(CH2)xOH).
2)
This information is given for the convenience of users of this European Standard and does not constitute an
endorsement by CEN of the product named. Equivalent products can be used if they can be shown to lead to the
same results.
36
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.3.2.5.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.3.2.5.2, the degree of corrosion shall not be greater than that given
as Ri 1 in Table 1 of EN ISO 4628-3:2003.
6.3.2.5.2 Test
6.3.2.6.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.3.2.6.2, any blistering of the coating shall be less than that given as
the degree of blistering 2/(2) in Figure 1 a) of EN ISO 4628-2:2003 and the degree of corrosion shall
be not greater than that given as Ri 1 in Table 1 of EN ISO 4628-3:2003.
6.3.2.6.2 Test
When tested in accordance with 6.3.3.1.2, there shall be no signs of pitting, or of corrosion deposits.
After being tested in accordance with 6.3.3.1.4, the sample plaques or meters shall withstand the
impact test given in 6.2.8.2.
Test the sample plaques or meters, after they have been subjected to the tests given in 6.3.3.1.2, in
accordance with 6.2.8.2.
When tested in accordance with 6.3.3.2.2, there shall be no signs of pitting or corrosion deposits.
37
EN 14236:2007 (E)
After being tested in accordance with 6.3.2.5.2, the sample plaques or meters shall withstand the
impact test given in 6.2.8.2.
Test the sample plaques or meters, after being subjected to the tests given in 6.3.2.5.2, in accordance
with 6.2.8.2.
When tested in accordance with 6.3.3.3.2, there shall be no signs of pitting or corrosion deposits.
After being tested in accordance with 6.3.3.3.4, the sample plaques or meters shall withstand the
impact test given in 6.2.8.2.
Test the sample plaques or meters in accordance with 6.3.3.3.2 and then in accordance with 6.2.8.2.
6.3.4 Protection against internal corrosion for material which is not corrosion resistant
6.3.4.1.1 Requirement
After being tested in accordance with 6.3.4.1.2, the result shall be less than classification 2 given in
EN ISO 2409.
6.3.4.1.2 Test
6.3.4.2.1 Requirement
There shall be no cracking or loss of adhesion of the protective coating when tested for impact
resistance in accordance with 6.3.4.2.2.
38
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.3.4.2.2 Test
During the test, the surface of the test piece that would normally be the inside surface of the meter is
placed facing downwards and it is this surface which is to be examined.
6.3.4.3.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.3.4.3.2, any blistering of the protective coating shall be less than
that given as the degree of blistering 2/(2) in Figure 1 a) of EN ISO 4628-2:2003 and the degree of
corrosion shall be not greater than that given as Ri 1 in Table 1 of EN ISO 4628-3:2003.
The sample used for these tests shall be representative parts of the meter, which include at least one
of the connections.
6.3.4.3.2 Test
Test in accordance with 7.4 of EN ISO 2812-1:1994, procedure A, using a test period of 168 h.
During the tests, immerse at least 30 % of the sample in the liquid, including the area at which the
meter case joins the meter connection, a separate sample being used for each of the following test
liquids:
6.3.4.4.1 Requirements
After testing in accordance with 6.3.4.4.2, any blistering of the coating shall be less than that given as
the degree of blistering 2/(2) in Figure 1 a) of EN ISO 4628-2:2003 and the degree of corrosion shall
be not greater than that given as Ri 1 in Table 1 of EN ISO 4628-3:2003.
6.3.4.4.2 Test
39
EN 14236:2007 (E)
When tested in accordance with 6.3.5.1.2, there shall be no signs of pitting or corrosion deposits.
After testing in accordance with 6.3.5.1.4, the sample plaques or meters shall withstand the impact
test given in 6.2.8.2.
Test the sample plaques or meters in accordance with 6.3.5.1.2 and then in accordance with 6.2.8.2.
When tested in accordance with 6.3.5.2.2, there shall be no signs of pitting or corrosion deposits.
After testing in accordance with 6.3.5.2.4, the sample plaques or meters shall withstand the impact
test given in 6.2.8.2.
Test the sample plaques or meters in accordance with 6.3.4.4.2 and then in accordance with 6.2.8.2.
6.4.1.1 Requirements
After testing the decorative finish (i.e. finish without corrosion protection) or a sample plaque in
accordance with 6.4.1.2, the finish shall not be fully penetrated neither shall any jagged edges extend
by more than 1 mm from any scratch mark.
6.4.1.2 Test
40
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.4.2 Humidity
6.4.2.1 Requirements
After testing the decorative finish or a sample plaque in accordance with 6.4.2.2, there shall be no
lifting of the coat.
Any blistering shall be less than that given as a degree of blistering 2/(2) in Figure 1 a) of
EN ISO 4628-2:2003.
6.4.2.2 Test
6.5.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 6.5.2, the meters shall satisfy the requirements of 6.2.4.1.
6.5.2 Test
a) Expose a complete meter to ultraviolet exposure for five periods, each of 8 h duration, using a
suspended sun lamp that has been in use for a total of not less than 50 h and not more than
400 h.
Ensure that the light source of the sun lamp is a combination tungsten filament mercury arc,
enclosed in glass that has a low transmission below 280 nm, the glass envelope is conical and
silvered internally to form a reflector and that the lamp is rated between 275 W and 300 W.
Position the sample with its normally exposed surface facing the lamp, 400 mm below the bottom
of the lamp and on the axis of the lamp. Ensure that the surrounding air is not confined and is
free to circulate.
After each exposure except the last, immerse the sample completely in de-ionized water for 16 h.
Clean and carefully dry it with cotton wool after each immersion period.
6.6 Ageing of external surfaces of the meter, including index windows and adhesion
of the index window
6.6.1 Requirements
After testing separate meters in accordance with 6.6.2, the following requirements apply:
a) the external surfaces of the meter shall not sustain damage that will affect the function of the
meter;
41
EN 14236:2007 (E)
b) the index window shall not become detached, crazed or blistered and the index shall remain
clearly visible through the window from a minimum of 15° from the normal to the window;
6.6.2 Test
c) Drop a solid steel ball of 25 mm diameter three times from a height of 350 mm normal to the
surface of the meter while in the operating condition and maintained at a temperature of
(–5 ± 1) °C. Repeat the test for each external surface of the meter including the index window.
6.7.1 Requirements
After the test specified in 6.7.2, the visual appearance of the meter shall not alter and the meter index
shall still be legible.
6.7.2 Test
Carry out the procedure according to EN 60068-2-5 under the following conditions:
a) with the meter in the non-operating condition, i.e. not connected to gas lines;
6.8.1 Requirements
After the completion of the test specified in 6.8.2, the meter shall satisfy the following requirements:
c) there shall be no visual evidence of corrosion of the internal electronic circuits likely to affect the
functional properties of the meter, nor shall there be any apparent degradation of protective
coatings (e.g. lacquer);
Class 1,0 Mean error: MPE; Error shift: one third of the MPE in Table 4.
42
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.8.2 Test
Test the meter in each orientation, where more than one installation orientation is specified by the
manufacturer.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Carry out the procedure for the effects of humidity in accordance with EN 60068-2-30, under the
following conditions:
c) upper temperature of (40 °C if the upper rated temperature does not exceed 40 °C, or 55 °C if the
upper rated temperature is greater than 40 °C);
24 h after these tests, test the meter again in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
6.9.1 Requirements
All external surfaces of the meter (including the index window) and gas containing casework material
shall not support combustion. The material shall have a flammability rating of V-0 in accordance with
EN 60707.
6.9.2 Test
Subject the external surfaces of the meter to the flame test as specified in EN 60695-11-5. Apply the
flame to the edges, corners and surfaces of the casing, each for a period of 30 s.
6.10.1 Requirement
When tested in accordance with 6.10.2, the mean errors shall stay within the MPE specified in Table 4.
6.10.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Maintain the meter, with no gas flowing through it, under the following conditions:
At the end of each period, return the meter to normal laboratory ambient temperature and test in
accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
43
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.11.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 6.11.2, the mean errors after any stage of the test shall remain within
the MPE specified in Table 4.
6.11.2 Test
6.11.2.1 General
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Pass nitrogen, to which has been added approximately 3 % by gaseous volume of 30 % toluene/70 %
iso-octane mixture (see 6.11.2.2) through the meter, for a minimum of 42 days (1 008 h) at (20 ± 2) °C,
(65 ± 10) % relative humidity and a flow rate of not less than 0,25 Qmax.
Check the mean errors of the meter every 7 days (168 h) in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at
0,1 Qmax and Qmax until a steady state of mean errors is attained (see NOTES 1, 2).
It is permissible, as an alternative method, to exercise the meter with air having a relative humidity of
(85 ± 5) % for the complete period of 42 days (1 008 h) at (20 ± 2) °C and a flow rate of not less than
0,25 Qmax and then test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
NOTE 1 A steady state is considered to be attained if the movement in registration between two consecutive
tests is less than the uncertainty of measurement as calculated using ISO/TR 5168, or if there is a reverse in the
movement over a period of 14 days (336 h).
NOTE 2 It is important that, when removing the meter from the exercise rig in order to check the error of
indication at the 7 day intervals, the meter ports be sealed, to prevent the ingress of air, until the error of
indication is about to be checked.
Exercise the meter with air for a further period of 7 days (168 h) at (20 ± 2) °C, (65 ± 10) % relative
humidity and a flow rate of not less than 0,25 Qmax.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
a) a meter exercise rig (A), open to atmosphere, fitted with a suitable circulating pump or blower;
b) a nitrogen supply with a flow rate measurement capability (B) (rotameter, meter or both);
c) relative humidity control (C), comprising a water reservoir and valves capable of giving a relative
humidity of (65 ± 10) %. The relative humidity is measured by a hair or paper hygrometer or by a
moisture meter;
d) solvent addition (D). The toluene/iso-octane mixture is added to the top of the vaporization tower
by means of a micro-metering pump. The tower has a bottom diffuser plate and is filled with
alternative layers of small glass beads and cotton fabric (or other similar material) to give a large
surface area. The tower is surrounded with a heating blanket that produces a high temperature at
the blanket/tower interface to speed up vaporization.
44
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.11.2.3 Procedure
Allow the toluene/iso-octane mixture (see 6.11.2.4) to percolate down the tower and vaporize.
Introduce the carrier gas, at a controlled flow rate, through the diffuser at the bottom of the tower
where it picks up the vaporized solvent. Pass the gaseous mixture into the exercise rig where it is
circulated through the meter. A fresh supply of solvent is continuously added to give a stable
concentration.
It is estimated that under conditions of normal temperature and pressure 1 mole of an ideal gas would
occupy 22,4 l. Whilst the vapours of toluene and iso-octane cannot be considered ideal, this principle
has been used to calculate the (approximate) concentration of 3 % by volume of a 30 % toluene/70 %
iso-octane mixture in nitrogen.
6.11.2.5 Calculation
92,13 g = 106 ml toluene will occupy 22,4 l at normal temperature and pressure (NTP).
114,23 g = 165 ml iso-octane will occupy 22,4 l at normal temperature and pressure (NTP).
The total volume of solvent mixture to be added to 2 240 l of carrier gas to give a 3 % concentration
by volume of 30 % toluene/70 % iso-octane is 441,9 ml. This is equivalent to 0,197 ml per litre of
carrier gas.
NOTE The actual amount of solvent to be added to the system will be dependent on the carrier gas flow rate
and the conditions inside the tower.
45
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
46
EN 14236:2007 (E)
6.12.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 6.12.2, the mean errors shall remain within the MPE specified in
Table 4.
6.12.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Connect the meter to the water vapour test rig (see Figure 9).
In Figure 9, the meter (3) is shown connected to a test rig which consists of a closed circuit containing
a suitable circulating pump or blower (4), a chamber containing either a saturated solution of
potassium acetate (CH3COOK) to give a relative humidity of 20 % at 20 °C or a saturated solution of
potassium hydrogen sulphate (KHSO4) to give a relative humidity of 86 % at 20 °C (1), and a hair or
paper hygrometer with a range of 0 % to 100 % relative humidity (2).
Exercise the meter with air having a relative humidity of less than 20 % for 7 days (168 h) at
(20 ± 2) °C and a flow rate of not less than 0,25 Qmax. At the end of this period test the meter in
accordance with 5.3.2 a) but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
On completion of this low humidity performance test, exercise the meter with air having a relative
humidity of (85 ± 5) % for a minimum of 42 days (1 008 h) at (20 ± 2) °C and a flow rate of not less
than 0,25 Qmax. Check the error of indication every 7 days (168 h) in accordance with 5.3.2a), until a
steady state of error of indication is attained. (See NOTE below.)
It is permissible as an alternative method to exercise the meter with air having a relative humidity of
(85 ± 5) % for the complete period of 42 days (1 008 h) at (20 ± 2) °C and a flow rate of not less than
0,25 Qmax and then test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Exercise the meter with air having a relative humidity of less than 20 % for at least 7 days (168 h) at
(20 ± 2) °C and at a flow rate of not less than 0,25 Qmax.
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
NOTE A steady state is considered to be attained if the movement in registration between two consecutive
tests is less than the uncertainty of measurement as calculated using ISO/TR 5168, or if there is a reverse in the
movement over a period of 14 days (336 h).
47
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
6.13 Ageing
6.13.1 Requirements
Where more than one installation orientation is specified by the manufacturer, a meter shall be tested
in each orientation.
When meters are tested in accordance with 6.13.2, the errors of these meters shall not exceed the
following:
48
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Class 1,0 Mean error: MPE; Error shift: one third of the MPE in Table 4.
6.13.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
Open the meter to atmosphere and hold it at any one of the temperatures given in Table 9, for the
appropriate time period given in Table 9. The manufacturer declares the temperature at which the test
is to be carried out.
At the end of this period, the meter is slowly returned to a temperature of 20 °C ± 2 °C, at a rate of not
more than 2 °C/h, and again tested in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but only at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
7 Optional features
7.1.1 Requirements
a) the maximum diameter of the hole through the pressure measuring point shall be 1 mm;
b) the meter shall remain leak tight after carrying out tests specified in 7.1.2 b).
7.1.2 Test
a) Measure the diameter of the hole through the pressure measuring point.
b) Initially check the meter for leak tightness in accordance with 6.2.4.2.
Apply a torque of 4 N ⋅ m to the pressure measuring point in a clockwise and then anti-clockwise
direction and then release. Drop a mass of 0,5 kg from a height of 250 mm, through a vertical tube,
onto the outer extremity of the body of the pressure measuring point.
7.2.1 Requirements
Where the manufacturer declares that the meter is resistant to high ambient temperatures, the meter
shall conform to the following requirements:
49
EN 14236:2007 (E)
a) the leakage rate of the meter case, when tested in accordance with 7.2.2, shall not exceed
3
150 dm / h;
7.2.2 Test
7.2.2.1 Apparatus
The furnace (see Figure 10) shall allow an ambient temperature rise according to the curve defined in
ISO 834-1.
The dimensions of the furnace shall allow the installation of the meter and its connections to be in
identical positions to those used in practice.
Make arrangements to maintain a constant pressure equal to 100 mbar during the complete test.
Connect the meter to the inlet and outlet connections and install the whole in the centre of the furnace
using supports if necessary.
With the bleed valve closed, pressurize the meter to 100 mbar with nitrogen and verify its tightness.
With the meter under the nitrogen test pressure, increase the temperature of the furnace according to
the temperature rise curve of ISO 834-1.
When the temperature at the coldest point of the meter reaches 650 °C, control the furnace
temperature to maintain at that point a constant temperature of 650 °C for a period of 30 min.
During the complete test, maintain the pressure in the meter at the test pressure by means of the
bleed valve. The leakage rate is registered by successive metering, the metering periods not
exceeding 5 min.
The leakage is the quotient of the metered nitrogen volume by the measuring time.
NOTE 1 Air can be used in place of nitrogen in this test, but be aware that it can support the combustion of
volatile emissions.
NOTE 2 To avoid blocking of the outlet connections by condensation of materials distilled from the internal
components of the meter, it is preferable to carry out the test on an empty meter case, supplied as such by the
manufacturer. If this is not possible, the outlet pipe of the apparatus should be inclined downwards and a safety
tap for the removal of condensation products installed upstream of the bleed valve.
50
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
1 furnace 5 inlet
2 meter at centre of furnace 6 pressure gauge
3 check meter 7 bleed valve
4 pressure regulator 8 air purge valve
7.2.3.1 Requirements
The thermal shut-off valve shall not close when tested in accordance with 7.2.3.2.
7.2.3.2 Test
7.4.1 Requirement
If ancillary devices are fitted, for example prepayment or remote reading devices, they shall not affect
the metrological characteristics of the meter, nor obscure the markings specified in 9.1.
Ancillary devices approved by the meter manufacturer shall not compromise the battery life specified
in 12.4.
51
EN 14236:2007 (E)
7.4.2 Test
With the ancillary device fitted, the meter shall be tested in accordance with 5.3.2 a).
Where the manufacturer declares that the meter is suitable for use in hazardous zones as defined in
EN 60079-10, the design, construction and marking of the meter shall then comply with EN 60079-0
and prEN 60079-11, or EN 60079-0 and EN 60079-15, as appropriate.
8 Index
8.1.1 Requirement
The recorded cumulative volume shall be shown by the display and stored in a non-volatile storage
device for a minimum of 36 months. The manufacturer shall declare the memory retention time.
8.1.2 Test
Confirm by visual inspection. The memory retention time can be based on calculations from data for
the relevant components, or from the results of manufacturer’s own relevant tests.
8.2 Display
8.2.1 Requirement
In addition to an alphabetical flag character, the display shall have a minimum of 8 numerical
characters and the last 3 numerical characters shall be decimal places indicating thousandths of a
cubic metre, e.g. 02 903,420 b. Any alphabetical flag character chosen shall not be able to be
confused as a digit by the user. There shall be a sufficient number of numerals to ensure that after the
volume passed during 8 000 h of flow at Qmax, the index cannot pass its original value.
The index shall be easily readable without the use of tools and the characters in the display shall have
3
a minimum height of 4,95 mm. The unit of measurement (m ) shall be unambiguously and boldly
displayed, within the index.
The numerals indicating the sub-multiples of the cubic metre shall be clearly distinguishable from the
other numerals and they shall be separated from the other numerals by a clearly marked decimal sign.
8.2.2 Test
Confirm by visual inspection and measurement. Where the indicated values, used in the accuracy
tests, are obtained exclusively via the communications port, ensure that the inspection confirms that
the reading from the communications port(s) is the same as the value registered in the display.
52
EN 14236:2007 (E)
8.3.1 Requirements
The index shall have a facility to display all its segments (i.e. display registers all ‘8’s) and then display
no segments (i.e. blank display). This shall either occur periodically, the period not to exceed one
minute, for a maximum duration of 5 s, or through the use of an injected test signal.
When the above display is discontinued, the display shall automatically revert to reading its updated
volume measurement and the memory register shall not have been disturbed.
If test signal injection is used, the means of initiating this test signal injection shall be capable of being
sealed such that unauthorized interference is detectable, and such that the metrological seal need not
be broken to operate this facility.
8.3.2 Test
Confirm by visual inspection and, by using suitable measuring equipment where appropriate, time the
various states of the display. If appropriate to the test, inject the test signal in accordance with the
method agreed between the manufacturer and the Test House.
8.4.1 Requirements
be maintained without any power source across the maximum and minimum storage
temperatures,
When tested in accordance with 8.4.2 a) the non-volatile memory shall remain accessible and
constant at the extremes of the temperature range.
When tested in accordance with 8.4.2 b) there shall be no difference between the index readings
recorded in 3) and 6).
8.4.2 Test
1) Determine a method for accessing the volume index in the non-volatile memory. Ensure that
there is no difference between the two readings. The manufacturer shall declare how this
can be performed;
3) note the meter index on the display and in the non-volatile memory;
4) subject the meter to the extremes of ambient temperature, as specified by the manufacturer,
for a minimum of 3 h at each temperature;
5) at each of the temperature extremes, at the end of the dwell time, read the volume index
from the non-volatile memory.
53
EN 14236:2007 (E)
2) immediately apply a flow rate equal to Qmax to the meter for a period of 5 min;
3) confirm that the meter has registered the gas flow, then cap the meter to prevent further
registration and immediately note the new meter index and time;
4) leave the meter at room temperature for a minimum of 6 h 5 min after the time noted in 3);
5) remove the battery and subject the meter to the minimum and maximum storage
temperatures, as specified by the manufacturer, for a minimum of 3 h at each temperature;
6) reconnect the battery and compare the current index reading with the reading noted in 3).
8.5.1 Requirements
The display, which indicates the total quantity of gas supplied (index), shall not be able to be reset
during use.
8.5.2 Test
Confirm by visual inspection the value of the volume index. Using suitable equipment and commands,
supplied by the manufacturer, attempt to reset the volume index.
9 Marking
g) ambient temperature range, if greater than -10 °C to +40 °C, e.g. tm = -20 °C...+55 °C (see 4.3);
h) gas temperature range, if different to -5 °C to +35 °C, e.g. tg = -10 °C...+40 °C (see 4.3);
Groups H, L, E, P/B;
54
EN 14236:2007 (E)
If the meter is resistant to high temperatures (see 7.2) it shall be marked additionally with a ‘T’.
If the meter is temperature converted it shall be marked additionally with “tb=” and the base
temperature (e.g. tb = 15 °C).
If the meter has a thermal shut-off valve fitted it shall be marked additionally with an ‘F’.
If the meter is declared suitable for use in an open environment (see Clause 1) it shall be marked
additionally with ‘H3’.
The markings shall be in a clearly visible position and shall be durable under the normal conditions of
the meter.
If all applicable information cannot be displayed on the meter, this shall be provided on the packaging
or with the meter literature.
9.2.1 Requirements
Meters with two-pipe connections shall be clearly and permanently marked with the direction(s) of flow
by means of (an) arrow(s).
9.2.2 Test
9.3.1 Requirements
All required labels shall remain securely fixed, in that their edges shall not lift from the backing
surfaces, and the markings on the meter, on the index and on the index plate when viewed through
the index window and any separate data plate if fitted, shall remain legible after being subjected to the
tests given in 9.3.2 and 9.3.3.
9.3.2 Weathering
Expose the assembled index, index plate, index window and samples of the meter labels to ultraviolet
exposure for five periods, each of 8 h duration, using a suspended sun lamp that has been in use for
not less than 50 h and not more than 400 h.
Ensure that the light source of the sun lamp is a combination tungsten filament mercury arc, enclosed
in glass that has a low transmission below 280 nm, that the glass envelope is conical and silvered
internally to form a reflector and that the lamp is rated between 275 W and 300 W.
Position the sample with its normally exposed surface facing the lamp, 400 mm below the bottom of
the lamp and on the axis of the lamp. Ensure that the surrounding air is not confined and is free to
circulate.
After each exposure except the last, immerse the sample completely in de-ionised water for 16 h.
Clean and carefully dry it with cotton wool after each immersion.
55
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Meters suitable for use in open locations shall be marked in accordance with 9.1.
9.3.2.2.1 Requirement
All markings on the meter, the index and index plate when viewed through the index window and any
separate data plate, if fitted, shall remain easily legible after being subjected to the test given in
9.3.2.2.2.
Total colour difference measured in accordance with ISO 7724-3 shall be inside the following limits:
DL* ≤ 12
Da* ≤ 6
Db* ≤ 6
Light transmission in accordance with ASTM D1003 shall have Haze in % ≤ 15.
9.3.2.2.2 Test
One meter shall be exposed for 66 days to artificial weathering and exposure to artificial radiation in
accordance with EN ISO 4892-3 and the parameters in Table 10. Prior to exposure measurements
will be made to enable the test criteria to be assessed.
Following exposure the meter shall be visually inspected for legibility. Appropriate tests shall be
carried out to check the requirements for colour difference and transmission of light are met.
All markings on the external surface of the meter, which can be touched when the meter is in normal
use, shall satisfy the indelibility tests as specified in Annex A of EN 60730-1:2000.
Operating instructions shall be available in written form or as a database and shall identify the name
and address of the manufacturer.
Each meter (or a utility responsible for groups of identical meters) shall be delivered with installation,
operation and maintenance manuals, in a language acceptable by the user and easily understandable,
giving appropriate instructions.
56
EN 14236:2007 (E)
position(s) of seals;
10 Software
10.1 Requirements
Software shall be designed to an established structured design method, allowing the requirements
and functional operation of the software to be defined in a precise manner. The software version
reference number shall be accessible for each meter. This shall be available through the serial
number string.
10.2 Test
11 Communications
11.1 General
The meter shall provide access to information stored in the meter’s memory via a serial data link. Data
shall be provided through a suitable interface.
The information shall, as a minimum, provide for the transmission of the index reading (volatile and
non-volatile memory), the meter serial number and the status flag and provision for error detection.
Meter reading devices shall not affect the metrology of the meter.
A facility shall be provided to clear the battery change flag once the battery has been changed. A
procedure shall be defined by the manufacturer.
a test-mode message structure, to enable common test procedures for gas meters.
57
EN 14236:2007 (E)
NOTE These provisions augment the EN 62056-21 protocol and do not conflict with the provisions or
operation of the existing protocol.
All requirements specified within 11.2 to 11.8.2 inclusive, shall be verified by visual inspection.
11.3.1 General
The data transmission protocol used by any available interface shall be to Mode C of EN 62056-21.
11.3.2 Wakeup
The meter shall respond to a preliminary wakeup message in accordance with Annex B of
EN 62056-21:2002.
11.3.3 Sign-off
NOTE This provides feedback to the communicating equipment that the meter has accepted and will
execute the sign-off command. The B0 command does not give an ACK response, forcing communicating
equipment to wait up to 1,5 s to infer successful sign-off.
11.3.4 Security
System security shall be provided as defined in EN 62056-21, details of these systems shall be
provided by the manufacturer.
11.3.5 Time-outs
11.3.5.1 General
NOTE This alternative to EN 62056-21:2002 allows a shorter time-out at the discretion of meter
manufacturers, to minimize power drain.
11.4 Data
11.4.1 General
The minimum information to be provided via the optical port shall be:
58
EN 14236:2007 (E)
meter flag(s).
11.5 Test-mode
11.5.1 General
If the meter has a test-mode, it shall meet the requirements of this clause.
The command structure shall be capable of setting the meter into and out of test-mode, demanding a
test measurement, and entering any manufacturer specific test-mode option. To minimize flow
metrology errors, the meter shall transmit the STX (defined in 11.5.2) of its data Section reply at a
fixed time delay from the measurement event of the data.
On receiving a T0 command (SOH T 0 ETX BCC) from the COMMUNICATING EQUIPMENT, the
meter shall transmit the following response:
The data section of the response to a T0 request from a standard test-mode shall be:
(dddddddd) 8 digits BCD encoded data representing the meter volume index. Lsd (right hand digit)
value is litres.
NOTE The data section content of the response can be modified by the manufacturer specific test-mode
command, to provide additional data, different formats etc. The timing of the T0 request and data reply message
are shown in Figure 11.
59
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
During periods when test-mode is active the normal EN 62056-21 inter-message time-out
specification is relaxed to allow a meter to perform its next scheduled measure event and give the
data reply string:
Tstx-data can be 0 ms up to 1 500 ms, within the EN 62056-21 for inter-character delay.
A test-mode set using the T1,1 command shall remain active for a minimum of 4 h. After this period,
the meter can disable the test-mode. While a test-mode set by the T1 command is active, normal
message inactivity time-outs apply. It shall also be possible to sign-off and sign-on without altering the
test-mode state.
Table 11 — Parameters
Parameter Unit Min. Max.
Trequest-event ms 200 8 000
a a
Tx ms 10 12
Tstx-data ms 0 1 500
T1,1 enabled h 4 -
a
Given as example only. Value is manufacturer specific.
60
EN 14236:2007 (E)
This command allows a manufacturer to perform specific test measurements, by using the T1 F
command, to set up the meter to perform specific measurements and specify different formats in
response to a T0 command. The data length yyyy between parenthesis is manufacturer specific.
The optical port and its associated reading head shall comply with 4.3 of EN 62056-21:2002 and shall
be accessible with the meter mounted in its normal orientation.
The galvanic port shall conform to the requirements in 4.1 and 4.2 of EN 62056-21:2002. As a
minimum, the connector shall conform to the degree of protection IP 54 in accordance with EN 60529.
11.8 Diagnostics
11.8.1 General
The meter shall be capable of indicating key features by the use of an unambiguous alphabetic flag
on the display/index. The meter shall record details of any events relating to any displayed flags.
The meter shall indicate the most significant operational problems by showing one alphabetical
character on the index. The number of flag types, the incident hierarchy and the required actions are
shown in Table 12.
Flag Action
F Replace battery
The manufacturer shall publish the types of incidents that can lead to the flags below.
61
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Flag Examples
F Replace battery
12 Battery
12.1 General
Battery connections shall be such that connection can only be made with the correct polarity.
If it is intended that the battery shall be replaceable then the battery compartment shall be accessible
from the front of the meter and be so designed that the battery can be replaced by authorized
personnel without removing the meter from the installation. In this case it shall be possible to change
the battery within 2 min.
The battery compartment shall be capable of being separately sealed such that there will be visual
evidence of tamper or other unauthorized interference. Access to the compartment shall not require
the breaking of any metrological seal when replacing the battery. The manufacturer shall seal the
battery compartment of each meter after fitting the battery.
Batteries shall comply with EN 60086-1. Lithium batteries shall comply with EN 60086-4.
The design of the meter shall be such that in the event that the battery leaks, there will be no
detrimental effect upon the integrity of the meter case.
12.2.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 12.2.2 the difference of the mean errors shall not exceed one fifth of
the MPE specified in Table 4.
12.2.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax. Remove and replace the battery
three times in succession, waiting 5 min before each replacement. Retest the meter in accordance
with 5.3.2 a), at 0,1 Qmax and Qmax.
62
EN 14236:2007 (E)
12.3.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 12.3.2, the errors of indication shall be within the MPE specified in
Table 4.
12.3.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), but with the meter’s battery replaced by a voltage
controlled power supply set to the manufacturer’s specified minimum operating voltage.
12.4.1 Requirements
The expected battery life, declared by the meter manufacturer, shall be at least 5 years.
After 90 % of the useful life of the battery has expired, a warning flag shall be shown (see 11.8.2).
12.4.2 Test
13.1 General
The meter shall be designed and manufactured in such a way to minimize the effects of magnetic
fields, electrostatic discharge and other electromagnetic disturbances. Meters meeting 13.2.1, 13.3.1
and 13.4.1 are deemed to have met this requirement.
13.2.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 13.2.2, the difference in mean errors shall not exceed one third of the
MPE specified in Table 4.
13.2.2 Test
Test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a), and calculate the mean error at each flow rate.
With no flow through the meter, test the meter in accordance with EN 61000-4-2 using 10 contact
discharges to each of:
b) a horizontal;
63
EN 14236:2007 (E)
With no flow through the meter, test the meter in accordance with EN 61000-4-2 using 10 air
discharges (to insulating surfaces) with a charge voltage of 8 kV according to EN 61000-6-1 and
EN 61000-6-2 at intervals of a minimum of 1 s, with the battery fitted.
During the test, connect the inlet boss of the meter under test to the ‘ground plane’.
Repeat the test in accordance with 5.3.2 a), and calculate the difference in mean errors.
13.3.1 Requirements
a) during the test specified in 13.3.2 a), the meter index shall neither increment nor decrement;
b) during the test specified in 13.3.2 b), the flow rate calculated from the meter readings shall not
vary by more than three times the MPE and after testing in accordance with 13.3.2 b), the mean
errors shall be within the MPE specified in Table 4.
13.3.2 Test
Arrange the test equipment so that it is possible to pass air through the test meter while it is being
subjected to the electromagnetic field. The flow rate shall be held constant.
NOTE One way of achieving this is to use a sonic nozzle between the meter outlet and a vacuum line.
Set the flow rate to Qmax. Test the meter under the conditions given below. During the test, read the
index and elapsed time at suitable intervals. From these readings calculate the corresponding flow
rates.
a) Set the flow rate to zero and subject the meter to the tests below;
b) test the meter in accordance with 5.3.2 a) at Qmax only and subject the meter again to the tests
below.
Test the meter in accordance with EN 61000-4-3, under the classification E1:
Read the volume register and non-volatile memory and compare with the value before the high
frequency test.
NOTE E1 is applicable for meters used in residential, commercial and light industrial environments.
13.4.1 Requirements
When tested in accordance with 13.4.2 a), the meter index shall neither increment nor decrement.
64
EN 14236:2007 (E)
During the test described in 13.4.2 b), the flow rate calculated from the meter readings shall not vary
by more than six times the MPE specified in Table 4, during any of the eight periods of the test
without showing an error flag.
After the test in 13.4.2 b), the mean errors shall be within the MPE specified in Table 4.
13.4.2 Test
a) Set the flow rate to zero and subject the meter to test level 3 of EN 61000-4-8 for 15 min.
b) With air passing through the meter at a flow rate of 0,05 Qmax test the meter to level 3 of
EN 61000-4-8 for 15 min.
13.5.1 Requirements
During test 1 of 13.5.2 a), the meter index shall neither decrement nor increment.
During the test specified in 13.5.2 b), the flow rate calculated from the meter readings shall not vary
by more than half of the MPE specified in Table 4, during any of the eight periods of the test without
displaying an error flag.
After testing in accordance with 13.5.2 b), the errors of indication shall be within the MPE specified in
Table 4.
13.5.2 Test
a) Set the flow rate of the meter to zero and subject the meter to test level 3 of EN 61000-4-9 for
15 min.
b) With air passing through the meter at a flow rate of 0,05 Qmax, subject it to test level 3 of
EN 61000-4-9 for 15 min.
13.6.1 Requirements
The meter shall not generate radiated noise that can interfere with other equipment.
13.6.2 Test
Check that the meter satisfies class B radio interference limits in EN 55022 at zero flow.
14.1 Requirements
During the period in which the meter is tested in accordance with 14.2.1 a) and 14.2.1 c), the meter
index shall neither increment nor decrement.
65
EN 14236:2007 (E)
During the period in which the meter is tested in accordance with 14.2.1 b) and 14.2.1 d), the meter
shall not read high or low by more than three times the MPE specified in Table 4, without displaying
an error flag.
When tested in accordance with 14.2.1 b) and 14.2.1 d), the difference in mean errors shall not
exceed one third of the MPE specified in Table 4.
14.2 Test
a) carry out the test described in 14.2.2 with zero air flow through the meter;
b) carry out the test described in 14.2.2 with a flow rate of Qmax through the meter;
c) carry out the test described in 14.2.3 with zero air flow through the meter;
d) carry out the test described in 14.2.3 with a flow rate of Qmax through the meter.
Ensure that the source of ultrasonic interference is an ultrasonic transducer of the same design(s) as
used in the meter.
Use an electronic white noise source to drive the acoustic noise transducer at its maximum acoustic
output without damaging it. Filter the white noise source so that its band-pass centre frequency is the
same as that of the transducers in the meter. Set the high pass filter at or below the frequency where
the output of the transducer used to test the meter falls to 50 %. Set the low pass filter at, or above
the frequency where the output of the transducer used to test the meter falls by 50 %.
Connect two 450 mm lengths of 22 mm diameter pipework to the inlet and outlet ports respectively, of
the meter. Position the transducer driven by the white noise source as close as possible to each of
the meter’s transducers in turn, without touching the meter, for 15 min at each position. Repeat the
tests but with the transducer driven by the white noise source in direct physical contact with the
pipework, halfway along both lengths of pipework.
Replace the electronic white noise source of 14.2.2 with a programmable signal generator to scan
continuously between the maximum and minimum frequencies of the white noise source specified
above. Set the signal generator to give the maximum ultrasonic output that does not damage the
transducer. Use ultrasonic transducers of the same design as those used in the meter. Scan
repeatedly the frequency range over a period of at least 15 min, covering the complete frequency
spectrum under test at least 5 times for any specific scan rate. Carry out the scanning at rates of one,
two, three, four and five scans per minute.
Connect two 450 mm lengths of 22 mm diameter pipework to the inlet and outlet ports respectively of
the meter. Position the transducer driven by the white noise source as close as possible to each of
the meter’s transducers in turn, without touching the meter, for 15 min at each position. Repeat the
tests but with the transducer driven by the white noise source in direct physical contact with the
pipework, halfway along both lengths of pipework.
66
EN 14236:2007 (E)
By agreement with the manufacturer, more meters can be supplied, to enable speeding up of the test
procedure.
Table 14 indicates the number of meters required for each of the tests in this European Standard. As
a guide to planning the order in which tests are performed to evaluate a prototype, the table indicates
where it is possible to re-use a meter for a subsequent test. The testing strategy shall be agreed
between the manufacturer and the Test House.
67
EN 14236:2007 (E)
68
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Annex A
(informative)
Test gases
A.1 General
Ultrasonic domestic meter technology has been designed almost exclusively for use on second family
gases, although it is feasible to use it to measure gases of the other families as well. The meters are
typically designed to operate on gases with speeds of sound in the range 300 m/s to 475 m/s.
Natural gases fall into the second family of gases. The majority of distributed natural gases exist
within the high methane groups H and E as defined by EN 437.
One gas that exceeds the limits of ultrasonic meters is the test gas G 222 that has a speed of sound
of 497 m/s due to the 23 % hydrogen content. However, this is not felt to be a problem as this gas is
designed to test the performance limits of domestic appliances and is not intended to represent
distributed natural gases.
b) attenuation range;
c) viscosity range;
A set of test gases has been developed for second family gases in order to provide a suitably wide
range of physical properties to exercise several meter technologies, without requiring tests across a
very wide range of different gas mixtures. These are:
Testing on air and 99,5 % distributed gas will provide a thorough assessment of the meter under
extreme conditions.
69
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Annex B
(normative)
B.1 Specification
B.1.1 All gas meter manufacturers shall be approved to EN ISO 9001.
B.1.2 In addition to the above requirements, the meter shall be manufactured to any agreed options
between the manufacturer and customer, e.g. consumer requires Class 1,0 meters, LPG meters etc.
NOTE Meters should be constructed in accordance with the legal requirements pertaining to the country in
which the meter will be used.
The tests for the error of indication shall give assurance that the metrological requirements are met.
B.2.2 The period of manufacture shall be traceable from the serial number and all relevant quality
records shall relate either to the period of manufacture or a serial number. The manufacturer shall
retain such records for a minimum period of 5 years.
B.2.3 The manufacturer shall provide a facility to supply spare parts for a minimum of 5 years after
the manufacture of the product ceases.
e) description of the meters, the quantity, and where appropriate, the manufacturer's batch, lot, or
item identification;
70
EN 14236:2007 (E)
i) following statement, signed by the person nominated by the manufacturer as responsible for
quality control, or his deputy:
71
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Annex C
(normative)
C.1 Scope
This annex specifies requirements and tests for meters with built-in gas temperature conversion
devices.
C.2.1.1 Requirements
For meters with temperature conversion the initial maximum permissible errors shall be increased
from the values given in Table 4 by 0,5 % in a range of 30 °C extending symmetrically around the
temperature tb specified by the manufacturer that lies between 15 °C and 25 °C. Outside this range,
an additional increase of 0,5 % is permitted in each interval of 10 °C.
When the initial maximum permissible errors between 0,1 Qmax (Qt) and Qmax all have the same sign,
they shall all not exceed error limits which are reduced by 0,5% from the above initial maximum
permissible errors.
C.2.1.2 Test
Place the meter in a test rig (an example of which is shown in Figure C.1) and pass a volume of the
test gas (dried air), the actual volume of which is measured by a reference standard, through the
meter. The minimum volume of the test air to be passed through the meter shall be specified by the
manufacturer and agreed with the Test House.
Determine the error of indication of the meter six times at a temperature of 20 °C at the flow rates of
Qmin, 3 Qmin, 5 Qmin, 10 Qmin, 0,1 Qmax, 0,4 Qmax, 0,7 Qmax and Qmax.
Then determine the error of indication of the meter six times at temperatures of tmin and tmax and at
temperatures equidistant between tmin and tb and between tb and tmax, at flow rates of 5 Qmin, 0,1 Qmax,
0,4 Qmax and Qmax.
At each temperature, ensure that the temperatures of the test gas, the meter and the temperature
inside the temperature-controlled cabinet are within 1 K.
Stabilize the temperatures after each change of temperature, and keep within ± 0,5 K during the
measurements.
72
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Calculate the error of indication for each temperature and flow as follows:
V T P
E = M ⋅ R ⋅ M − 1 ⋅ 100
VR TB PR
where
NOTE All temperature and pressure values used in the above equation are absolute.
73
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
74
EN 14236:2007 (E)
C.2.2 Error of indication where the temperature of the gas at the meter inlet is
significantly different from the ambient temperature of the air surrounding the meter
C.2.2.1 Requirements
If a meter is declared suitable for this application, it shall be tested in accordance with 5.3.2 a), and its
error of indication shall be within the initial maximum permissible errors given in Table 4.
C.2.2.2 Test
Place the meter under test in the test rig (see Figure C.2). Carry out the test using dry air at a flowing
temperature of tsp + 20 °C and a meter in an ambient temperature of tsp °C. The intermittent operation
shall consist of repeated cycles of a 2 min run followed by 4 min to 8 min pause. During each cycle,
the air temperature at the meter inlet (Ti) shall be (tsp + 20 ± 1) °C at the commencement and
throughout each flow period. Laboratory temperature and inlet air temperature to the reference
standard shall be (tsp ± 1) °C. The difference in laboratory temperature at the test meter and at the
reference standard shall not exceed 1 K.
Stabilize the operating conditions before the volume measurements are taken. Determine the volume
indicated and passed over 7 temperature cycles for each of the flowrates Qmax, 0,7 Qmax and 0,2 Qmax.
Calculate the error in the volume using the equation given in C.2.1.2.
75
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Key
1 pressure regulator
3 heat exchanger
4 flow regulator
5 exhaust
6 insulated pipework
Figure C.2 — Example of test rig used for differential temperatures under intermittent
operation tests
C.2.2.3 Marking
Each meter shall be marked with the following information in addition to that listed in Clause 8, either
on the index or on a separate data plate:
a) meters declared suitable for differential temperature and intermittent operation, the base gas
temperature expressed as, e.g. tb,i = 15 °C;
76
EN 14236:2007 (E)
C.2.3.1 Requirement
When tested in accordance with 5.14.2, the meter shall meet the requirement that no single test result
shall differ from the regression line of distributed gas by more than the MPE, specified in Table 4, and
all results shall remain within the errors shown in C.2.1.1.
C.2.3.2 Test
C.2.4.1 Requirement
The only gas volume that can be shown on a temperature converted meter is the temperature
converted volume.
C.2.4.2 Test
Confirm by visual inspection and communication with the meter that it is the temperature converted
volume is being shown on the index.
77
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Annex ZA
(informative)
This European Standard has been prepared under a mandate given to CEN/CENELEC by the
European Commission [and the European Free Trade Association] to provide a means of conforming
to Essential Requirements of the New Approach Directive 2004/22, Measuring Instruments Directive.
Once this standard is cited in the Official Journal of the European Communities under that Directive
and has been implemented as a national standard in at least one Member State, compliance with the
clauses of this standard given in Table ZA.1 confers, within the limits of the scope of this standard, a
presumption of conformity with the corresponding Essential Requirements of that Directive and
associated EFTA regulations.
Table ZA.1 — Identification form on the compliance of EN 14236 with the essential
requirements of EU Directive 2004/22/EC (MID) on the approximation of the laws of member
states on Measuring Instruments
78
EN 14236:2007 (E)
79
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Annex MI002
Part Specific requirements gas meters
1
1 Rated operating conditions 1, 4
1.1 Class and Qmax/Qmin ratio 1, 4.1
1.2 T ≥ 40 gas 4.3
1.3 Gas family/MOP 1, 4.2, 4.4, 6.2.4, 9.1
1.4 T ≥ 50 climatic 4.3
1.5 Limits of dc supply 12.3, 12.4
2 Maximum permissible errors
2.1 MPE 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 6.2.7, 6.2.9
2.2 MPE TC 7.3 (Annex C)
3 Permissible effects of disturbances
3.1 EMC 1, 13
3.2 Flow disturbances 5.8, 5.13
4 Durability
4.1 Durability – Class 1,5 meters 4.5, 5.3, 5.5, 5.7, 6.8, 6.13
4.2 Durability – Class 1,0 meters 4.5, 5.3, 5.5, 5.7, 6.8, 6.13
5 Suitability
5.1 Mains power N/A
80
EN 14236:2007 (E)
WARNING — Other requirements and other EU Directives may be applicable to the product(s) falling
within the scope of this standard.
81
EN 14236:2007 (E)
Bibliography
[2] EN ISO 228-1, Pipe threads where pressure-tight joints are not made on the threads —
Part 1: Dimensions, tolerances and designation (ISO 228-1:2000)
[3] ISO 5168, Measurement of fluid flow — Procedures for the evaluation of uncertainties
82
blank
BS EN
14236:2007
BSI — British Standards Institution
BSI is the independent national body responsible for preparing
British Standards. It presents the UK view on standards in Europe and at the
international level. It is incorporated by Royal Charter.
Revisions
British Standards are updated by amendment or revision. Users of
British Standards should make sure that they possess the latest amendments or
editions.
It is the constant aim of BSI to improve the quality of our products and services.
We would be grateful if anyone finding an inaccuracy or ambiguity while using
this British Standard would inform the Secretary of the technical committee
responsible, the identity of which can be found on the inside front cover.
Tel: +44 (0)20 8996 9000. Fax: +44 (0)20 8996 7400.
BSI offers members an individual updating service called PLUS which ensures
that subscribers automatically receive the latest editions of standards.
Buying standards
Orders for all BSI, international and foreign standards publications should be
addressed to Customer Services. Tel: +44 (0)20 8996 9001.
Fax: +44 (0)20 8996 7001. Email: [email protected]. Standards are also
available from the BSI website at http://www.bsi-global.com.
In response to orders for international standards, it is BSI policy to supply the
BSI implementation of those that have been published as British Standards,
unless otherwise requested.
Information on standards
BSI provides a wide range of information on national, European and
international standards through its Library and its Technical Help to Exporters
Service. Various BSI electronic information services are also available which give
details on all its products and services. Contact the Information Centre.
Tel: +44 (0)20 8996 7111. Fax: +44 (0)20 8996 7048. Email: [email protected].
Subscribing members of BSI are kept up to date with standards developments
and receive substantial discounts on the purchase price of standards. For details
of these and other benefits contact Membership Administration.
Tel: +44 (0)20 8996 7002. Fax: +44 (0)20 8996 7001.
Email: [email protected].
Information regarding online access to British Standards via British Standards
Online can be found at http://www.bsi-global.com/bsonline.
Further information about BSI is available on the BSI website at
http://www.bsi-global.com.
Copyright
Copyright subsists in all BSI publications. BSI also holds the copyright, in the
UK, of the publications of the international standardization bodies. Except as
permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 no extract may be
reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any
means – electronic, photocopying, recording or otherwise – without prior written
permission from BSI.
This does not preclude the free use, in the course of implementing the standard,
of necessary details such as symbols, and size, type or grade designations. If these
details are to be used for any other purpose than implementation then the prior
BSI written permission of BSI must be obtained.
389 Chiswick High Road Details and advice can be obtained from the Copyright & Licensing Manager.
London Tel: +44 (0)20 8996 7070. Fax: +44 (0)20 8996 7553.
Email: [email protected].
W4 4AL