A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, Nano: Primary Knowledge Participant Guide
A Comparison of Scale: Macro, Micro, Nano: Primary Knowledge Participant Guide
Primary Knowledge
Participant Guide
In order to grasp many of the concepts associated with MEMS and MEMS devices and components,
you need to understand scale and the size of objects associated with different scales. This unit
introduces you to various concepts associated with scale, and a comparison of the macro, micro and
nano-scales.
Introduction
At one time or another everyone has asked the question "How big is the universe?" Trying to
develop the answer can be overwhelming because there is no answer. The size of the universe is
unknown; however, the size of objects within the universe is known. These objects are constantly
being studied, measured, and compared. These comparisons are a means of evoking some sense of
scale as to how big the universe could be. For
example, the Milky Way (pictured above) is one of
billions of galaxies. Our sun is one of several 100
billion stars within The Milky Way. There are over
50,000 billion, billion stars. There are more stars in
the universe than there are grains of sand on our
planet.1
Our sun is considered a middle-sized star. Giant stars are as much as 10 times larger. However,
when compared to Earth, the sun is approximately 109 times larger in diameter meaning that 1.3
million earths could fit inside the sun! Do the math!
The sun is much larger than Earth. From the sun's center to its
surface, it is about 109 times the radius of Earth. Some of the
streams of gas rising from the solar surface are larger than
Earth.
[Image source: NASA - Image credit: World Book illustration
by Roberta Polfus]
• Explain the differences in the macro, micro and nano scales in terms of size, applications, and
properties.
• Define microtechnology and nanotechnology.
• Identify objects and applications in the micro-scale and the nano-scale.
Key Terms (Key terms defined in Glossary at the end of this unit)
Linear Scale
Logarithmic Scale
Macroscopic
MEMS
Micro
Micrometer
Micron
Nano
Nanometer
Nanotechnology
Scale
Size is Relative
"The sun is big" is a relative statement. Big relative to what? "An ant is small." Again, another
relative statement. Relative to the size of a human being, yes, an ant is small (anywhere from 2mm
long to 25 mm long); however, relative to a human hair (0.1 to 0.06 mm), an ant is huge.
The comparative size of an object in relative terms (big, small, huge) can be illustrated in a scale. In
the top scale of "Size is Relative", the ant is the smallest object. However, in the bottom scale the
ant is the largest object. Additional comparison scales could be created at both ends of these two
scales illustrating even smaller and largest objects.
Question: In the top scale, the ant is the smallest object. What are three additional objects that
could be added to this scale that are bigger than the ant, but smaller than the bumblebee?
In the above chart "The Scale of Things – Nanometers and More", you can get a feeling of how
things can look the same size, but when placed next to a scale, the real size becomes more apparent.
Take a few minutes to study the objects on this chart. Which would you consider macro (large than
micro)? Which objects would you place in the micro-scale and which objects in the nano-scale?
Macro – anything that can be seen with the naked eye or anything greater than ~100 micrometer.
Micro – 100 micrometers to 100 nanometers
Nano – 100 nanometers to 1 nanometer
Electrical and mechanical devices, components and systems are being manufactured in a variety of
sizes from macro to nano. The figure shows such components:
• Standard light bulb with a diameter of ~8 millimeters (mm) or 3.2 inches
• Microgears with individual gear teeth ~8 micrometers (µm) wide
• Microcantilever with a gold nano-dot 50 nanometers (nm) in diameter.
In commercial and residential electrical applications, components such as switches, light bulbs and
fans are macro-size objects (greater than 100 micrometers). Airbag actuation sensors, shock sensors
for computers and implantable drug delivery systems are micro-sized objects. Biomolecular sensors
for proteins and antigens, carbon nanotubes as connectors, and gene analysis devices are nano-sized
objects.
This is a good time to take and break and do one of the activities in this Scale Learning Module. A
good activity to do is "Cut To Size."
Scales
As seen in previous graphics, a good way to compare the size of different objects is to place the
objects on a scale. There are two basic scales that are used: the linear scale and the logarithmic
scale. Following is a brief discussion and illustration of both types of scales.
Linear Scale
In a linear scale each increment and incremental increase is equal to the one before (in other words –
equal divisions for equal values). For example, the linear scale above goes from 0 millimeters to 25
millimeters in 5 mm increments. This scale works fine when the total range in the size of objects is
small, such as illustrating the sizes of five objects from the size of a bumble bee (~24 mm long) to the
size of a pinhead (~1 mm in diameter).
Logarithmic Scales
Logarithmic Scale
But what happens when the range becomes bigger (e.g. from 1.5 Gm to 5 µm)? In such a
comparison, a linear scale is not practical, nor as effective; therefore, a logarithmic scale could be
used (above). A logarithmic scale uses the logarithm of a physical quantity rather than the quantity
itself. It is effective for comparing the relative size of objects when the actual range in size is huge.
The above graph covers a range from the diameter of the sun (1.39 Gm) to the size of a pin head (1.5
mm). Imagine how long a linear graph would be that compared these objects.
When comparing macroscopic devices to their micro equivalents, the micro devices are
• much smaller,
• much lighter,
• more energy efficient, and
• constructed with fewer materials.
MicroFluidic pump used for inkjet printheads (The piezoelectric crystal expands and contracts to
move fluid from the reservoir through the nozzle)
Nanotechnology
The term Nanotechnology is so new, that how it is defined, depends on who you ask. Below are
some definitions of Nanotechnology:
"The name nanotechnology originates from [the] nanometer. In the processing of materials, the
smallest bit size of stock removal, accretion or flow of materials is probably of one atom or one
molecule namely 0.1-0.2nm in length. Therefore, the expected limit size of fineness would be of the
order of 1nm. Accordingly, nanotechnology mainly consists of the processing of separation,
consolidation and deformation of materials by one atom or one molecule."
N. Taniguchi, "on the Basic Concept of Nanotechnology," Proc. Intl. Conf. Prod. Eng. Tokyo, Part
II – Japan Society of Precision Engineering, 1974
Nanotechnology, or more specifically, nanoscience has been around for quite a long time.
Nanoscience is concerned with the study of novel phenomena and properties of materials that occur
at extremely small length scales.
Physicists and biologists have been studying nanodevices such as cells, molecules, and atoms for
years, and in some cases, centuries. In the 18th century, John Dalton, a British chemist and
physicist, made the earliest steps toward recognizing that matter was composed of atoms. In 1952,
a series of experiments by Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase, known as the "Hershey-Chase
Blender Experiments", supported the role of DNA as the carrier of genetic information.
In addition to the actual size of the objects, fabrication is another primary difference between micro
and nanotechnology. Nanotechnology normally uses what is referred to as the "bottom up"
approach to fabrication. Microtechnology normally uses the "top down" approach.
Bottom up
The bottom up approach means a structure is made by building it atom by atom or molecule by
molecule from the bottom up. Each individual atom or molecule is manipulated or controlled for
correct placement.
The figure on the left (above) shows four stages in the assembly of a quantum corral. The figure on
the right (above) shows the final assembly of a corral that has been made by placing 48 iron atoms
in a circle, one at a time, onto the surface of gold.
The top down approach selectively removes material until the desired structure is achieved. In
semiconductor and some MEMS processes, one
• applies a pattern,
• selectively etches away exposed material and
• ends up with a circuit or component (as illustrated above).
The above graphic shows how microcantilevers (red) are initially incorporated into a block of
layered material. By removing the layer below (green), the microcantilevers are released and
suspended over the substrate (blue).
The space of one transistor, now holds hundreds of transistors (graphic not to scale)
Semiconductors have evolved over the years with technological advancements in the deposition of
materials and the selective removal of materials through the photolithography and etch processes.
Deposition layers have become thinner and etched widths have become smaller (see figure).
A deposited gate oxide layer used to be 20 microns or larger. Now it can be as thin as 1 nm! Gate
widths, patterned and subsequently etched have shrunk from more than 1 micron dimensions to less
that 50 nm! Since today's semiconductor manufacturing processes are creating structures less than
100 nm, this technology can be considered Nanotechnology.
BioMEMS
One of the greatest applications for micro / nano devices is in the biomedical field. The overlap
between microbiology and microsystem feature sizes makes integration between the two possible.
Devices fabricated for the medical field are referred to as bioMEMS.
A gold dot, about 50 nanometers in diameter, fused to the end of a cantilevered oscillator about 4
micrometers long. A one-molecule-thick layer of a sulfur-containing chemical deposited on the
gold adds a mass of about 6 attograms, which is more than enough to measure.10
[Printed with permission Craighead Group/Cornell University and © Cornell University]
A biosensor is a devices used to detect, capture and analyze analytes (i.e. antibodies, antigens,
proteins) within a sample solution. The biosensor in the figure consists of a gold dot, about 50
nanometers in diameter, fused to the end of a cantilever oscillator about 4 micrometers long. A
one-molecule-thick layer (monolayer) of a sulfur-containing chemical is deposited on the gold. An
external excitation causes the cantilever to oscillate.
This biosensor cantilever could be used to detect and collect e-coli cells in a sample. The cells
would stick to the chemically treated layer on the gold dot adding a few attograms of mass to the
cantilever. Even though a few attograms is very small, it is enough to affect a measurable change
in the oscillations of the cantilever. This allows the concentration of e. coli cells in the sample to
be measured.
Matching Activity
Match the following components with their scale
Component Scale
1 Strain of hair A Macro
2 A molecule B Micro
3 75 nm C Nano
4 233 mm
5 48 microns
6 Pollen
Table 2: Components and Their Scale
How big is big? How small is small? It depends on the scale. A macro-scale can be millions of
times bigger than a microscale. The microscale is a thousand times bigger than the nanoscale. In
the macro-scale, the earth is small when compared to the sun, but huge compared to a baseball. In
the micro / nano-scales, an 8 micron wide red blood cell is huge compared to a 2 nm diameter
carbon nanotube.
The discovery of nano-sized particles has made an already big universe even bigger. Distances are
now measured in lengths from light years to nanometers (see pictures above). Modern technologies
are taking advantage of the wide range of sizes in order to improve existing processes and develop
new ones.
How have discoveries in the microscale affected the study of the universe?
How have discoveries in the micro and nano-scales affected our daily lives?
References
1.
To see the Universe in a Grain of Taranaki Sand, by glen Mackie. North and South Magazine.
(New Zealand) May 1999. http://astronomy.swin.edu.au/~gmackie/billions.html
2.
Milky Way Image. "Our Milky Way Gets a Makeover". NASA/JPL-Caltech. June 3, 2008.
Updated July 31,2015. http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/spitzer/multimedia/20080603a.html
3.
Image credits from NASA.gov: Sun and Earth(Image credit: World Book illustration by Roberta
Polfus), Earth (Image credit: NASA/Goddard Space Flight Center), Sun (Image credit:
NASA/Transition Region & Coronal Explorer), Greek Islands (NASA/GSFC/LaRC/JPL, MISR
Team), MEMS Gyroscope (NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory)
4.
Image of Nanowire looped on human hair. NSF image. Credit: Limin Tong/Harvard University.
http://www.nsf.gov/od/lpa/news/03/pr03147_images.htm
5.
"Microtechnology". Micronora.com. http://www.micronora.com/ref/microtechnologies.htm
6.
"IBM's Millipede Project Demonstrates Trillion-Bit Data Storage Density". IBM Research.
Zurich. June 22, 2002.
7.
"EU supports research towards the construction of nanomotors". Max Planck Institute for
Biophysical Chemistry. Nanowerks News. March 16, 2006.
8.
"Carbon Nanotube Electronics". Nanoelectronics Research Group. Department of Physics.
University of Maryland. http://www.physics.umd.edu/condmat/mfuhrer/ntresearch.htm
9.
Quantum Corral Images. IBM STM Image Gallery. (Gallery page no longer available)
10.
Silicon Atoms Image. “Observing the Wings of Atoms”. Feng Lui. University of Utah News and
Public Relations. June 2, 2003.
11.
Image of micro-sized gears (Macro, micro, nano) – Courtesy of Sandia National Laboratories.
www.mems.sandia.gov
12.
Micro to Nano – An Introduction. Mathius Pleil, SCME, CNM
13.
Microtechnology Education Resource Center (MERC)
Linear Scale: A scale each increment and incremental increase is equal to the one before.
Logarithmic Scale: A scale that uses increments in powers of 10
Macroscopic: Objects greater than 100 microns or visible to the naked eye
MEMS: Microelectromechanical Systems
Micro: A scale between 0.1 µm and 100 µm
Micrometer: One thousandths of a meter (10-6 meter)
Micron: A unit of measurement equal to 1 milli Torr or 1 millionth of a meter.
Nano: A scale between 0.1 nm and 100 nm
Nanometer: One billionth of a meter (10-9 meter)
Nanotechnology: Technology involved with design and fabrication of devices and thin films with
dimensions in the nanometer range (1E-9 m).
Support for this work was provided by the National Science Foundation's Advanced Technological
Education (ATE) Program through Grants. For more learning modules related to microtechnology,
visit the SCME website (http://scme-nm.org).