Viswanath K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan: Full Length Article
Viswanath K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan: Full Length Article
Viswanath K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan: Full Length Article
Fuel
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fuel
h i g h l i g h t s
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: An experimental investigation was performed to assess the effects using diethyl ether additive in a diesel
Received 17 August 2015 engine fuelled with waste plastic oil. The variations in the performance, combustion and emission char-
Received in revised form 24 February 2016 acteristics of the engine using plastic oil and its 5%, 10% and 15% blends with DEE were examined and
Accepted 6 April 2016
compared with reference fuel. The experimental results show that the brake thermal efficiency increases
with increasing percentage of DEE in the blends and also BSEC reduced considerably while using blended
fuels. The combustion was delayed for DEE blends when compared to neat plastic oil and diesel. A drastic
Keywords:
reduction in the levels of smoke and NOX was noted for blends at maximum brake power. There was an
Waste plastic oil
Diethyl ether
improvement in the CO emissions while operating with PO-DEE blends, however the UHC emissions were
Combustion slightly higher. PD15 showed better performance and combustion characteristics with cleaner emissions.
Emission Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Diesel engine
1. Introduction The demand for plastic is increasing day by day because of its
highly desirable qualities and easy handling.
Fossil fuels play a vital role in the expansion of industrial, trans- Despite these advantages, the plastic waste generated is creat-
portation and agricultural sectors. Because of the high demand for ing so many environmental complications. The huge demand for
energy, the petroleum resources are depleting rapidly. Further- plastic has created a large amount of waste plastic and it has
more the environmental issues due to the emissions from the become a common material in all landfills. It creates so many prob-
use of fossil fuels are increasing at an alarming rate. In this context, lems in disposing because of their non-degradable nature [5,6].
the notion of alternative energy has gained its significance and a lot According to a survey carried out in India in 2012 indicates approx-
of researches are going on around the globe, in the field of biodiesel imately 5.6 million tonnes of plastic waste is generated every year.
and bioenergy, for finding an alternative for the petroleum fuels Out of this 60% is recycled that means 6500 tonnes of plastic waste
[1–4]. Among the different fuels available, plastic oil produced by is going as landfills per day. For decreasing the harmful effects of
pyrolysis process has become the centre of attention because of plastic waste most of the countries implement recycling and incin-
its availability and environmental effects. Plastics have become eration [7–9]. Of all the techniques used for recycling the waste
an unavoidable material both in industrial and household sectors. plastic pyrolysis (chemical recycling) has considered as the best
way since it recovers the energy content in usable liquid or gaseous
form [10]. Pyrolysis technique is used as an energy recovery
method and gives liquid fuel as major product similar to that of
⇑ Corresponding author at: Hindustan University, Chennai 603103, India. petroleum fuels [11,12]. Recent studies suggest that plastic
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (V.K. Kaimal), pvijayabalan. oil can directly be used in diesel engines without any major
[email protected] (P. Vijayabalan).
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.fuel.2016.04.030
0016-2361/Ó 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
V.K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan / Fuel 180 (2016) 90–96 91
Nomenclature
modifications. The literatures also suggest that the amount of UHC, 2.2. Combustion analysis
CO and NOX were higher than diesel fuel [13–15].
The major concern related to plastic oil is the higher density and The nature of combustion of a fuel in a diesel engine is one of
viscosity when compared to diesel. In order to reduce these down- the most important aspect which is to be analysed, as it directly
sides small quantities of oxygenated additives are used as combus- indicates the performance and affects the resilience and stability
tion enhancers [16–19]. Different types of oxygenated additives of the engine. The essential parameters used to study the nature
such as Dimethyl ether (DME), ethanol, and n-butanol has been of combustion are in-cylinder pressure, heat release rate and igni-
investigated in the past [20–22] but Diethyl ether (DEE) is consid- tion delay [15]. The cylinder pressure–crank angle data of the
ered as a better additive because of its superlative qualities than engine was obtained directly and the remaining parameters were
the others. DEE is a renewable oxygenated additive obtained from determined from it. The first law of thermodynamics was used to
ethanol [23]. It has high cetane number and oxygen content which calculate the net heat release rate with Eq. (1) mentioned by Hey-
aids the combustion rate in diesel engines [24,25]. It also has better wood [42].
energy density, wide flammability range and low auto ignition
temperature than other additives [26]. A lot of researchers have dQ =dh ¼ ðc=c 1ÞpðdV=dhÞ þ ð1=c 1ÞVðdp=dhÞ ð1Þ
tried adding DEE to diesel and biodiesel for improving the perfor-
mance and emission. Studies suggest that adding diethyl ether to where dQ=dh is the rate of heat release, J/°CA is the cylinder pres-
biodiesel enhances brake thermal efficiency and results in better- sure in Pa, c is the specific heat ratio, V is combustion chamber vol-
ment of specific fuel consumption [27–29]. Current researches ume in m3, h is crank angle in degrees.
show that adding DEE is an appropriate method for reducing the
emissions drastically, especially NOX and smoke [30–33]. There- 2.3. Experimental setup
fore, in this investigation, the authors have tried to study the effect
of adding DEE in a diesel engine fuelled with plastic pyrolysis oil at The experimental investigation was conducted on a high speed
different loading conditions. Along with performance and emission single cylinder direct injection diesel engine generating 3.7 kW at
characteristics, an in-depth combustion analysis has also been 1500 rated RPM. The graphical representation of test setup is
included in the paper for a better understanding of the effects on shown in Fig. 1. Engine specifications are listed in Table 2.
engine operations. A rheostat was used to electrically load the engine. No modifi-
cations or adjustments were done in the test setup. A KISTLER pres-
sure transducer was mounted on the cylinder head to obtain the
2. Materials and methods pressure crank angle data. The crank angle data were acquired
using a TDC encoder. The amplified signals from charge amplifier
2.1. Plastic oil synthesis were collected with the help of a high precision data acquisition
system. The weight averaged smoothing method was used to
In this investigation, the waste plastic materials (HDPE) were smooth out the curve and to eliminate any data loss during the
gathered from the city landfills and cut into small pieces (0.5– procedure. The mean of 100 (cylinder pressure–crank angle data)
1 cm2). The impurities in the plastic chips were removed by working cycles was used to avoid errors and inaccuracies in the
repeated washing and the moisture content is completely dried test results. Based on previous studies [34–36], the cyclic irregular-
with the help of an oven. A custom made pyrolysis reactor of ity and unstable operation of the engine were kept to minimum by
40 cm diameter and 60 cm height was used for carrying out the limiting the DEE percentage below 15%. The gaseous emissions
reaction. A 10% by weight of coal and 1% by weight of Silica catalyst (UHC, CO and NO) were measured using AVL DiGas 444 infrared
were fed into the reaction chamber along with the plastic chips. gas analyser and smoke density was measured with the help of
The reaction temperature inside the chamber was maintained in AVL 437C smoke metre. The specifications of the gas analyser
the range of 350–400 °C with the help of a temperature controller and the accuracies are given in Table 3. The analyser was calibrated
and the reaction was allowed to carry out for 4 h continuously at and smoke metre set to the null correction point before every read-
atmospheric pressure. Pyrolysis process yielded plastic oil (80% ing to reduce the errors. The engine tests were carried out by vary-
by weight of input), solid coke residue (15% by weight) and gas- ing the load from 0% to 100%. The brake power and brake mean
eous fractions (5% by weight) which is a mixture of propylene, effective pressure corresponding to each engine load are given in
iso-butane, ethane and small amounts of methane. All the gaseous Table 4. The rated RPM of 1500 was maintained at loading condi-
products from the process were either condensed to liquids and tions by adjusting the fuel flow rate. Five test fuels, diesel, PO (neat
non-condensable products are treated by passing it through the plastic oil), PD5 (5% DEE blended with plastic oil), PD10 (10% DEE
water chamber before it is let out. The oil was also distilled, to blended with plastic oil), PD15 (15% DEE blended with plastic
remove any of the remaining impurities, before using in the engine. oil) were used to perform the test on the engine. The fuel injector
The properties of diesel, plastic oil, DEE and PO-DEE blends are was dismantled and cleaned after every test run. The fuel tank was
given in Table 1. fully emptied by running the engine before using a new fuel.
92 V.K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan / Fuel 180 (2016) 90–96
Table 1
Properties of fuel.a
Properties ASTM test standard Diesel Plastic oil DEE PD5 PD10 PD15
Specific gravity ASTM D 1298 0.84 0.83 0.714 0.83 0.827 0.821
Kinematic viscosity (cSt) at 40 °C ASTM D 445 04e 2.15 2.64 0.22 2.52 2.4 2.37
Calorific value (kJ/kg) ASTM D 240 02 43,500 44,200 33,870 43,167 42,834 42,501
Cetane number ASTM D 613 05 54 50 125 – – –
Flash point (°C) ASTM D93 45 40 45 40 40 39
a
Values measured.
Table 2 Table 4
Specifications of the engine. BP and BMEP values for each load step.
Type Single cylinder, 4 stroke, water cooled, naturally Load (%) Brake power (kW) Brake mean effective pressure (bar)
aspirated DI diesel engine
20 0.75 1.3
Bore (mm) 87.5 40 1.53 2.7
Stroke (mm) 110 60 2.29 3.8
Rated power at 1500 3.7 80 3.11 5.1
RPM (kW) 100 3.65 6.2
Compression ratio 16.5
Start of injection 23° before TDC
Number of Nozzle holes 3 holes of 0.28 mm (diameter)
and diameter
Injection pressure (bar) 200
Combustion chamber Hemispherical open chamber
shape
Table 3
Specifications of AVL DiGas 444 analyser.
3.1. Brake thermal efficiency PO-DEE blends. At rated power, the maximum brake thermal effi-
ciency noted is 30.9% for diesel, whereas for plastic oil it is 27.5%. In
Fig. 2 shows the plot between brake thermal efficiency and the case of DEE blends the efficiency at full load are 27.9%, 29.4%
brake power of the engine while using diesel, neat plastic oil and and 30.03% for PD5, PD10 and PD15 respectively. The lower ther-
V.K. Kaimal, P. Vijayabalan / Fuel 180 (2016) 90–96 93
mal efficiency of plastic oil is because of the high viscosity and poor
atomisation resulting in poor mixture formation during premixed
combustion phase. Also, more energy is required to break the
higher aromatic bonds in plastic oil, which causes the reduction
in thermal efficiency of the engine. Brake thermal efficiency
increases steadily with increase in the diethyl ether blend ratio.
The higher oxygen content, low viscosity, high cetane number
and high volatility of DEE aids the combustion rate and increases
the efficiency [37]. At higher loads, the temperature inside the
cylinder will be high which increases the rate of vaporisation of
fuel resulting in higher efficiency. The reason for lower brake ther-
mal efficiency for PO and DEE blends may be due to their higher
heat release during combustion causing higher heat losses [38].
3.5. Oxides of nitrogen CO emissions in the exhaust of a diesel engine are generally
caused by the incomplete combustion of fuel due to lack of oxygen,
Oxides of nitrogen (NOX) are the important component in the it also depends on the physical and chemical properties of the
diesel engine emissions. Nitric oxide (NO) and nitrogen dioxide fuels. Fig. 9 indicates the deviation of CO emissions with the brake
(NO2) are the two compounds that are commonly put together as power of the engine. The concentration of CO for diesel at maxi-
NOX. It is formed by the oxidation of nitrogen present in the atmo- mum brake power is 0.74 g/kW h and 1.17 g/kW h for plastic oil.
spheric air inside the combustion chamber and the mechanism is
[34] Mohanan P, Kapilan N, Reddy RP. Effect of diethyl ether on the performance fuelled with diesel–jatropha biodiesel blend. Energy Convers Manage
and emission of a 4-S DI diesel engine. SAE paper no. 2003-01-0760; 2003. 2015;94:84–94.
[35] Rakopoulos DC, Rakopoulos CD, Giakoumis EG, Dimaratos AM. Studying [40] Mani M, Subash C, Nagarajan G. Performance, emission and combustion
combustion and cyclic irregularity of diethyl ether as supplement fuel in diesel characteristics of a DI diesel engine using waste plastic oil. Appl Therm Eng
engine. Fuel 2013;109:325–35. 2009;29:2738–44.
[36] Iranmanesh M, Subrahmanyam JP, Babu MKG. Application of diethyl ether to [41] Edwin Geo V, Nagarajan G, Nagalingam B. Studies on improving the
reduce smoke and NOx emissions simultaneously with diesel and biodiesel performance of rubber seed oil fuel for diesel engine with DEE port
fuelled engines. In: Proceedings of 2008 ASME international mechanical injection. Fuel 2010;89(11):3559–67.
engineering congress and exposition (IMECE2008). Boston, MA; October 31– [42] Heywood JB. Internal combustion engine fundamentals. USA: McGraw-Hill;
November 6, 2008. p. 77–83 [Paper no. IMECE2008-69255]. 1984.
[37] Jawre Sandip S, Lawankar SM. Performance analysis of Kusim methyl ester as [43] Bailey B, Guguen S, Erwin J. Diethyl ether (DEE) as a renewable fuel. SAE Paper;
alternative bio fuel in diesel engine with diethyl ether as additive. Int J Innov 1997. p. 972–78.
Res 2014;3:139–44. [44] Clothier PQE, Moise A, Pritchard HO. Effect of free-radical release on diesel
[38] Raheman H, Phadatare AG. Diesel engine emissions and performance from ignition delay under simulated cold-starting conditions. Combust Flame
blends of karanja methyl ester and diesel. Biomass Bioenergy 2004;27:393–7. 1990;81:242–50.
[39] Imtenan S, Masjuki HH, Varman M, Rizwanul Fattah IM, Sajjad H, Arbab MI. [45] Turns SR. An introduction to combustion: concepts and applications. 2nd
Effect of n-butanol and diethyl ether as oxygenated additives on combustion– ed. Singapore: McGraw-Hill; 2000.
emission-performance characteristics of a multiple cylinder diesel engine