Urban: Redevelopment Design Concepts Guidelines
Urban: Redevelopment Design Concepts Guidelines
Urban: Redevelopment Design Concepts Guidelines
Urban
Redevelopment Design Concepts & Guidelines
Prepared for:
Acknowledgments
The Southeastern San Diego Commercial Corridor Urban Design
Guide was prepared by Roesling Nakamura Architects, Inc. (RNP),
located in San Diego.
These services were provided for the Southeastern Economic
Development Corporation (SEDC) as part of the Commercial
Rehabilitation program for Southeastern San Diego.
Principal-in-Charge: Ralph J. Roesling, FAIA·
Project Team: Rick Espana, Jennifer Custodio,
Jamie Ho, Joe Mansfield, Ricardo
Balvaneda
SEDC and the project team would like to extend their special thanks to the
following organizations fortheircooperation and valuable input in producing
this document:
Table of Contents
1 Introduction and Goals
1.0 Project Purpose ..................................................................... 1-1
1.1 Planning Study Areas ............................................................ 1-2
1.2 Design Guide Goals and Objectives ..................................... 1-3
1.3 About the Guide .................................................................... 1-4
1.4 Making it Work ....................................................................... 1-5
T able of Contents
Southeastern Economic Development Corporation
4 Resource Guide
Urban design guidelines are not distinct from planning - they are a further
step that adds refinement, focus, detail and direction to community plans
that are already established.
Vicinity Map
There are six commercial study areas that the design concepts and
guidelines address. Three are commercial corridors and three are
commercial nodes or centers that have been identified by SEDC for
commercial redevelopment. (See Figure 1.1)
Commercial corridors
Chollas Creek.:::..e
Study Areas
Encanto Village (from 61 st to 69th Streets). IMPERIAL AVENUE PLANNING STUDY AREA
NOT TO SCALE
6. Mount Hope commercial corridor along
Market Street from Interstate 805 west to
FIGURE
41 st Street.
DIAMOND DISTRICT
Commercial nodes
Goals and objectives have been developed from analysis of past reports
and studies, plus a review of existing conditions and meetings with
community members. The goals are summarized as follows:
The Guide is divided into four sections. Introduction & Goals, Section 1 ,
provides a brief background of the study, the purpose of the project, and
outlines the study areas within Southeastern San Diego.
The concepts and guidelines are expressed in both written and graphic
formats. Both should be used as a guide in the redevelopment of the
commercial property within the corridors and nodes.
The area known as the Euclid Commercial Corridor, from the Martin
Luther King Jr. Freeway Route 94 to Imperial Avenue, serves as the main
north-south commercial corridor within this region. The corridor links
several major land-uses within the area such as commercial, office,
residential and industrial.
The individual areas of the Euclid Corridor are explained in further Topography
detail under Sections 2.2 through 2.4. Concepts and Guidelines interrupts
for the Encanto Village at Imperial Avenue and Mount Hope rural Qrid
Commercial Corridor are addressed in Sections 2.6 and 2.7
respectively.
l
.....
Rural History
There are several elements within the area to remind us about the
region's rural history. These elements include the open natural
land tracts, Chollas Creek, topography north of the project sites, RURAL HISTORY
and the open space north of Market Street and west of Euclid • Agrarian expression over rural
Avenue. grid (hedges of trees)
• Rustic structures
These agrarian elements still have a large presence within the
urban grid. The rural history of the region should not be forgotten.
Where possible, new development should respect, retain, enhance
and use these features as design inspiration.
Chollas Creek
2.2.1 Concept
A community plaza near the trolley station will establish the "heart"
of the community. The plaza shall consist of enhanced paved
surfacing, information/wayfinding signage, shade structures,
seating areas, and landscaping.
Public art shall be incorporated into the public plaza to express the
location as the "Cultural Center" of the community. The art shall
be approved by SEDC and local community planning groups.
l'
TRANSIT STOP
• Emphasize special place
• Linear wayfinding elements
intersects node
• Wayfinding elements greet
passengers at stop
• Sense of arrival Linear Track
• Plaza acts as orientation
compass Linear
Trolley stop
a D o
® Overhead shade
c::l structure directs
o pedestrians to and from
Euclid Avenue
o o ceremonial
o Pocket plaza creates
gateway into
town center
Q
o ® Wayfinding sign
infonns pedestrians
Steel Frame
Directional Kiosk
TOWN CENTER AT
EUCLID & MARKET
NOT TO SCALE
2.1
NOT TO SCALE
FIGURE
CONCEPT
DESIGN GUIDEUNES
----------------------------------------------------------------------~2~-77------RiieeddlEe;vevelopment Concepts and Guidelines
Commercial Corridor Urban Design Guide
2.3.1 Concept
The corridor should provide a safe and attractive night and day
Corridor gateway pedestrian experience and should focus on establishing a strong
walking link between Imperial Avenue and Market Street.
Cultural town
Gateways at the crossing of Euclid Ave. and Chollas Creek in the
center
MARKET ST. north and near St. Rita's church at the south should help establish
entries into the district. (See sketch).
WALKING PROMENADE
Open Space and Landscaping
• Make a comfortable walking
experience between points of Pedestrian crossing zones shall consist of enhanced paved
interest and along Euclid Ave. materials and shall incorporate patterns that are consistent with
• Primary pedestrian path focuses the overall design theme found in the immediate area. Landscaping
on commercial west-side.
shall be approved by SEDC and local community planning groups.
• Primary path gets pedestrian to
cross street at designated
Landscape medians along Euclid corridor shall be composed of
points.
• Secondary pedestrian paths two types: 1} at areas of illegal crOSSing potential, median will
emphasize linkages to adjacent consist of low wall planters made of poured-in-place concrete with
uses. a sandblasted finish. 2} in other areas, medians shall be raised
Perspective up Euclid ~
• Landscaping at medians and
sidewalks should slow down
traffic and create a uniform street
appearance
A
Guideline Objectives:
• Encourage consistency for
building facades
and signage
• Commercial development should
reinforce pedestrian activity
7' 8' ~ 3'~\ 10' l t
18' 90'
Street Section A
NOT TO SCALE
EUCUD AVENUE
COMMERCIAL CORRIDOR
Site Plan NOT TO SCALE
o 80 160
2.2
FIGURE
CONCEPT
DESIGN GUIDEUNES
intersection
2.4.1 Concept
2.5.1 Concept
The Market Street Commercial Industrial Corridor extends from
47th street at the west end to 54th Street at the east. The concept
is to enhance the area as a commercial industrial park that has
features and amenities unique from any other industrial park in
San Diego. This unique identity is partly attributed to:
• its close proximity to the Town Center at Market Street and
Euclid Avenue.
• close proximity to the cultural learning centers of the Malcolm
X Library, the Elementary Institute of Science, and the Tubman
Chavez Community Center that share the corridor.
• the natural open space beauty north of the project site.
• its retained rural feel.
Cultural/Learning activities
MARKET ST.
Uniform building
setbacks
Trolley Corridor
B I
.! -..= ~:-'- ~.lj
r=-.~F=
o .. _--{)
o------'l
~ L:-;--.-j
~
~.~
Perspective looking west on Market St. & 54th Partial Site Plan
o 100 200 400
.
/
8'-0" 12'-0" 24'-0" 6'·0 24'-0" 20'-0" 65'-0" 25'-0" MIN. 'r
MARKET STREET COM-
Street Section MERCIAL INDUSTRIAL
o 10 20 40 CORRIDOR
NOT TO SCALE
2.4
FIGURE
CONCEPT
DESIGN GUIDEUNES
2.6.1 Concept
The unique features that define the "Encanto Village" are its low-
scale street-front, and older commercial buildings that feature a
"historic" identity. This environment along with the nearby Encanto
Trolley Station is conducive to a pedestrian-oriented entertainment
theme of restaurants, clubs and shops.
The pedestrian zone along the south side of Imperial Avenue shall
be strengthened by enhancing the off-street parking zones that
separate the street from the sidewalk.
Trolley Corridor
Strengthen connections to
residential neighborhood
Uniform
building
setback
and signage
parking lots
L ],
24'-0" if 4' -oJ( 6'-0" '( 10' _0" " 24'-0" 'I 15'-0"
DESIGN GUIDELINES
2.7.1 Concept
This Market Street corridor bounded by 41 st Street and Interstate
805 serves as the eastern commercial gateway into the Mount
Hope area. The concept is to build upon the area's existing low-
scale commercial theme through creating a traditional "main
streef' identity. The "main streef' identity is partly defined by low-
scale commercial buildings along the street corridor with links to
the residential neighborhoods directly beyond the buildings.
Pedestrian zone
MARKET ST.
1tr.C=-~c::IJI;::::.c:::a c=sw:::s-=at=l-=ac:::L1:!:I
~ ·i"·"·.'~~~~~
Parking zone I
Gateway
t_
2.6
FIGURE
CONCEPT
DESIGN GUIDEUNES
The Design Criteria and Guidelines provide planning and design standards
that ensure commercial redevelopment and improvements conform to a
high level of commercial environmental design excellence.
This section presents design criteria and guidelines that are specific in
nature. The guidelines provide commercial property and business owners
direction and assistance in reaching "design standard goals".
Applicable areas for the regulatory guidelines are within the SEDC
Redevelopment Project Areas and include the three commercial nodes
and three commercial corridors outlined below:
Commercial Nodes
Commercial Corridors
. . Land Use
--~--;--, -:--------,-~,
~'
- ' - - '~',
'--+-+-: SF-40,OOO Single Family Residential
~---l........t.......:._~
-
~ MF-1S00 Multiple Family Residential
-
(Automobile Oriented)
-
(Pedestrian Oriented)
-
1-1 Light Industrial
LAND USE
1-2 Office/Industrial Park NOT TO SCALE
Q
~t-
_L
-.- -!-- - --
SF-5000
SF-6000
Single Family Residential
-
~ MF-1500 Multiple Family Residential
-
(Automobile Oriented)
-
(Pedestrian Oriented)
-
1-1 Light Industrial
LAND USE
1-2 Office/Industrial Park NOT TO SCALE
General
Exterior Architecture
Climate Consideration
Roof-Mounted Equipment
. . Landscaping Guidelines
Please refer to the approved planting lists in Figures 3.3 and 3.4
Accent Trees
Screening
EMERALD HILLS
3.3
FIGURE
ULt UU UU UU LJ LJ LJ I-
Approved Plants for
Mount Hope
Commercial Corridor
Tree Types:
(Botanical, Common Name)
Gold Medallion Tree
Koelreuteria bipinnata, Chinese Flame Tree
Mediterranean Fan Palm
Pinus canariensis, Canary Island Pine
~ - ... _. - -- . -
-.- .. - --
,. Podocarpus gracilior, Fern Pine
Swan Hill, Fruitless Olive
L -
Tabebuia impetiginosa, Pink Trumpet Tree
Storefront planters and seat wall planters are
encouraged along public spaces and sidewalk
edges (See Figure 2.6).
PLANTING PLAN
Tipuana tipu, Tipu Tree
'---_ Retain existing median tracks from public NOT TO SCALE
landscaping. right-of-ways.
Washington robusta, Mexican Fan Palm 3.4 1
FIGURE
MOUNT HOPE
AND ENCANTO
3-15 Design Criteria
Commercial Corridor Urban Design Guide
Street Crossings
Parking Areas
~
108" min.
rn
108" min.
•
•
Provide handicapped stalls to meet the State of California and
Federal requirements.
v II I
Landscape Maintenance
• Low walls and fencing are allowed and encouraged along the
commercial property lines to establish and strengthen an
urban edge along commercial retail corridors. Low walls and
fencing if applied, shall provided public access and shall not
block visual access to buildings beyond.
Building Maintenance
Trash
Graffiti
Outdoor Storage
Inoperable Vehicles
• A maximum of two inoperable vehicles may be stored on
private property if they are fully, legally screened from the
public right-of-way in an area not exceeding 400 square feet.
_ Commercial Signage
General Guidelines
Building-Mounted Signs
• Shall not be closer than 10 feetfrom any property line and shall
not be located within the street right-of-way.
.
I Commercial signage
......._ ...... [ viewable by trolley users
f--- -- --
Building signage and view corridors in back of industrial lots along trolley
line
m Site Furnishings
Benches
There are few existing benches found in public spaces within the
Public space trash receptacles
redevelopment district. Benches give a sense of comfort to public
areas and open spaces within the community and create an
opportunity to continue a design theme of streetscape elements.
Bicycle Racks
Drinking Fountains
Trash Receptacles
Metal Canopy----'
Stained Wood
Beams -------'
Directional Kiosk
Option 1 Option 2
Color 1 Color 1
SITE FURNISHINGS:
DIRECTIONAL KIOSKS
NOT TO SCALE
Polished Aluminum Galvanized Metal
Canopy Canopy 3.6
FIGURE
COLOR SCHEDULE
• All sign lighting shall comply with the City of San Diego
Municipal Code, Division 11. Sign lighting and fixtures shall
be compatible in design and finish with the architectural theme
established by the buildings.
Bollards
Utility Boxes
Table 3.1
l ~ 'B~
3 Phase Service Restorer
(preferred)
3415
60'
64"
64" lB"
18"
18"
9S"
18" 96"
\ (alternate)
18"
4"
9S"
Cabinet
(200 AMP)
'A' 3 Phase Cable Terminating 3417 48" 48" 96" 96" 18" 18"
Applicable di"!-ensions diagram/or Cabinet
(600 AMP)
utility box screening (See Table 3.1)
1 Phase Cable Terminator 3421 46" 48" 4" 4" 12" 96"
(Future Transformer
Installations)
3 Phase Fused Switching 3421 46" 48" 96" 96" 4" 4"
Cabinet
3 Phase PME 3 Switch 3422 78" 59" 96" 96" 18" 52"
(600 AMP)
3 Phase PME 9 Switch 3423 73" 78" 96" 96" 52" 52"
(600 AMP)
3 Phase PME 10 Switch 3423 73" 78" 96" 96" 52" 52"
(600 AMP)
3 Phase PME 11 Switch 3423 73" 78" 96" 96" 52" 52"
(600 AMP)
3 Phase Livefront
Transformer
• Provide sites for new and relocated industries that will provide
jobs for Southeastern San Diego residents.
• Encroachments into the public right-of way and public prope rty.