When A Half Isn't Enough!: Denise Neal
When A Half Isn't Enough!: Denise Neal
Denise Neal
Department of Education, Tasmania
Teachers are constantly striving to teach for understanding of key mathematical ideas and
teaching for depth and conceptual understanding is now being seen as an important part of
successful mathematics teaching. However, we know that many students still have many
mis-conceptions and shallow procedural knowledge of ideas such as fractions and decimals
and percentages in secondary schooling.
How then might we teach for deeper understanding of these “big ideas” and how are the
foundations of such understandings appropriately laid in the early years of schooling?
Obviously, drilling children in procedures and rules at an early age is not the answer.
What might the understandings be that young children already have which we can build on in
the K-2 years and what be might appropriate learning experiences and teacher interventions?
This paper has been written to engage early childhood teachers in asking some questions
about the mathematical ideas which underpin understanding of fractions and reflecting on
their current practices.
Traditionally fractions have not been part of any early childhood curriculum; ideas of
fractions were dealt with in the upper primary or early secondary curriculum. Why might we
consider them to be part of the mathematical experience of young children?
Young children know about halves in an intuitive and everyday sense- they often describe
themselves using phrases such as “I’m four and a half” and describe any item which has two
pieces as being “in half”. This is usually a response to hearing adult conversation using such
terms. Parents might say for example “I’ll cut your sandwich in half” or “it’s half full”. When
children are introduced to informal measurement at school they will often refer to anything
which is “left over” or not a whole unit, as “half”.
Is half enough? Should parents and early childhood teachers present other models of cutting
and partitioning? Do children then come to see half as more important or different to other
fractions, and does this make later understanding more difficult?
Researchers point to an over emphasis focus on half and quarters as a reason for many
children’s difficulties in understanding fractions (Newstead and Murray (1998).
The types of manipulatives used to introduce fractions may also lead to difficulties e.g. many
materials are pre- partitioned or involve “Count and colour” (e.g. shade 1/12 of this rectangle
(which is pre-partitioned)) activities which do not lead to real understanding. In preference
students should be engaged in folding, cutting and dividing objects and materials to see
partitioning relationships and should be encouraged to visualize for example _ on a number
line.
VC2004: Neal 1
What might some key underpinning ideas for understanding
fractions be?
Single objects or groups can be divided into parts
A fraction can be used to represent part of a collection: eg. 4 out of 5 shots went in
There are numbers between consecutive whole numbers: eg. 1.5
When you divide things into groups, sometimes there are some left over and the
interpretation of this remainder will depend on the situation being represented
These ideas underlie any later work with representing, manipulating and thinking about
fractions and a focus on them will help build conceptual understanding about what
mathematical ideas provide a foundation for fraction investigations.
VC2004: Neal 2
goal 5 out of 6 times”, “we will cut the pizza into 5 equal bits” etc Parents can be encouraged
to do the same.
Summary
There are many early experiences of fractions which can be built into an early childhood
setting in natural and meaningful contexts and play situations. It is our role as teachers to
help build important foundational ideas which underpin later more symbolic work with
fractions. Knowing the mathematical ideas which underpin fractions, decimals etc is vital for
teacher planning and for building deep understanding.
Some questions…
What activities could you share through the Virtual Conference to help others explore
important ideas about fractions with young children?
How much symbolic language do children need to be exposed to?
What materials have you used which build understanding of fractions?
What can we do to build conceptual understanding of fractions for all students?
What aspects of current practice create difficulties for students when they meet ideas about
fractions?
What research can inform our thinking about fractions for young children?
Is half enough?
References
Newstead and Murray (1998) summed up the factors that contribute to the poor
understanding of fractions as follows:
• The initial presentation of fractions to children — both the way and the sequence in
which the content is presented to them. For example, the use of pre-partitioned
manipulatives and are restriction to halves and quarters only.
• A lack of opportunity in the class to resolve and monitor misconceptions (sometimes
based on incorrect intuitions) that children might have.
• The tendency of children to apply their whole-number conceptual framework to
fractions, interpreting a fraction as two whole numbers.
(available at http://www.wcape.school.za/malati/Files/Fractions993.pdf)
Tasmanian K-8 Mathematics Guidelines
(available at http://www.discover.tased.edu.au/mathematics/k-8%20number.pdf)
VC2004: Neal 3