Work Loads of Nursing Professionals in Hospital Services For Mental Health: An Integrative Review
Work Loads of Nursing Professionals in Hospital Services For Mental Health: An Integrative Review
Work Loads of Nursing Professionals in Hospital Services For Mental Health: An Integrative Review
Medical Society Section: Psychiatry & Mental Health Vol. 9 No. 240
http://imedicalsociety.org ISSN: 1755-7682 doi: 10.3823/2111
Keywords
Nursing Team; Worker´s Health; Workloads; Mental Health Services.
© Under License of Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License This article is available at: www.intarchmed.com and www.medbrary.com 1
International Archives of Medicine 2016
Section: Psychiatry & Mental Health Vol. 9 No. 240
ISSN: 1755-7682 doi: 10.3823/2111
consequences for the quality of care and conse- studies and offer subsidies to the advancement of
quent safety of the patients in mental distress. nursing in the context of mental health. [9]
This research method includes six phases: the-
me identification or guiding question; sampling or
Method searching the literature; categorization of studies;
The integrative review is a research method that assessment of included studies; interpretation of
allows establishing a synthesis and general conclu- results and synthesis of knowledge evidenced in
sions regarding a particular study area, performed analyzed articles [10].
in a systematic and orderly way to contribute to the The literature search took place between January
knowledge investigated. and March 2016, by the following databases: Latin
This type of evaluation should follow the same America and the Caribbean Literature (LILACS), Cu-
methodological standards of the original research, mulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Litera-
considering the aspects of clarity, so that the reader ture (CINAHL), Scopus (Elsevier), National Library of
can identify the actual characteristics of the selected Medicine - PUBMED ScienceDirect (Elsevier), Web of
Figure 1: S ynthesis of the extraction process in the databases, searching in SCOPUS, PUBMED, LILACS,
SCIENCE DIRECT, WEB OF SCIENCE and CINAHL. Natal-RN, 2016.
#1AND#2 = 887 #1AND#2 = 77 #1AND#2 = 233 #1AND#2 = 1.255 #1AND#2 = 113 #1AND#2 = 301
#1AND#3 = 1.578 #1AND#3 = 352 #1AND#3 = 14 #1AND#3 = 965 #1AND#3 = 560 #1AND#3 =363
#1AND#4 = 825 #1AND#4 = 142 #1AND#4 = 84 #1AND#4 = 799 #1AND#4 = 75 #1AND#4 = 239
#2AND#3 = 220 #2AND#3 = 124 #2AND#3 = 57 #2AND#3 = 430 #2AND#3 = 114 #2AND#3 = 60
#2AND#4 = 586 #2AND#4 = 192 #2AND#4 = 176 #2AND#4 = 408 #2AND#4 = 280 #2AND#4 = 124
#3AND#4 = 156 #3AND#4 = 143 #3AND#4 = 04 #3AND#4 = 234 #3AND#4 = 93 #3AND#4 = 30
1ª Exclusion
Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria and articles aimed at the theme
on workloads, focused on mental health services (N= 11.998)
Science (Main Collection - Thomson Reuters Scien- There were 12,293 results identified in the data-
tific). bases. After selection of the inclusion and exclusion
To search in the databases, the descriptors used criteria and articles that do not address the topic
were found in Medical SubjectHeadings (MeSH): from the perspective of workloads, there were 295
1# (“nursing staff”) 2# (“worker health”), 3# studies focusing on health services (Figure 1) distri-
(“workloads”), 4# (“mental health services”). The buted by databases as follows: SCOPUS (116); PUB-
Crossing were performed using the Boolean opera- MED (37); LILACS (44); SCIENCE DIRECT (32); WEB
tor AND: #1 AND #2, #1 AND #3, #1 AND #4, #2 OF SCIENCE (36); CINAHL (30).
AND #3, #2 AND #4 e #3 AND #4. The analysis of the full text was made and all
Inclusion criteria were: full articles available on se- duplicated were removed. After reading, the final
lected databases that show workloads that nursing sample was composed of 08 studies.
professionals are exposed in their work process in
hospital mental health services. Editorials, letters to
the editor, abstracts, reviews expert opinion, were Results and Discussion
excluded, correspondence, reviews, book chapters, The productions of this study are shown in the table
theses and dissertations and articles that do not below, identifying the journal, year of publication,
address the issue. databases, title, classification of study based on ob-
The studies were pre-selected with an attenti- jectives, authors, location of the study and reason
ve reading of the titles and abstracts to identify that causes the workload (Table 1).
whether they were related to the main issue of In Table 1, it is possible to show that regular
the review, and the inclusion and exclusion crite- nursing area was the most reported work on the
ria. Then they were excluded repeated articles in theme. From the classification of studies based
the databases, and text reading was carried out on the objectives, it is found that 62.5% (05) of
in full. the studies are descriptive, 37.5% (03) are cross-
Table 1. C
haracterization of articles according to journal, year of publication, databases, title, classifica-
tion of study based on objectives, authors, location of the study and reason that causes the
workload. Natal-RN, 2016.
Journal, Year of Classification of
Location of Reason that Causes
Article Publication and Title the Study Based Authors
the Study the Workload
Database on the Objectives
A1 Rev. Latino-Am. Care needs and Descriptive study Helena Neuropsychiatric Excessive work
Enfermage, workload required with a AyakoMukai. public Hospital schedule in the
2013 PUBMED by institutionalized quantitative Marli de psychiatric sector
psychiatric patients. approach Carvalho Jericó. The average workload
Márcia Galan ranged from 119.6 to
Perroca 183 hours
A2 Rev. de Nursing workload in Descriptive study Souza et al Psychiatric Physical and mental
Enfermagem da a psychiatric with a hospital workloads
UERJ, inpatient unit and quantitative Affected by the care
2015 SCOPUS workers’ health approach of patients
in psychiatric
emergencies,
insufficient human
and material resources
and reduced
autonomy
A4 Journal of Stressors, burnout, and social A descriptive study of Richard Jenkins Psychiatric hospital Physical and mental workloads
Advanced Nursing, support: nurses in acute mental quantitative Peter Elliott Lack of qualified personnel in service to help
2004 SCOPUS health settings. approach in psychiatric nursing care; Stress and Burnout
A5 International Impacts of unit-level nurse Cross-sectional study Bogaert Psychiatric hospital Workload
Journal of Nursing practice environment, workload with a quantitative It was associated with Burnout
Studies 2013 and burnout on nurse-reported approach
SCOPUS outcomes in psychiatric hospitals:
A multilevel modeling approach
A6 Journal of Investigating the impact of Cross-sectional study S. Leka, J. Hassard, Psychiatric hospital Workload
Psychiatric and psychosocial risks and occupational with a quantitative A. Yanagida High psychological job demands.
Mental Health stress on psychiatric hospital approach
Nursing. nurses’ mental well-being in Japan
2012 SCOPUS
A7 Rev Latino-am Study on the absenteeism Descriptive study Sandra Greice Psychiatric hospital Workload
Enfermagem 2008 of nursing professionals in a with a quantitative Becker Maria High demand for labor and illness reasons
SCOPUS psychiatric center in Manaus, Brazil approach Luiza Carvalho de
Oliveira
Mechanical loads
physical aggression committed by
patients.
Psychic loads
fear of being physically assaulted and
the threats of physical violence made
by psychiatric patients
Source: Authors´ Databases (2016).
sectional studies. The descriptive research showed ring the workday, weight handling and the distance
a description of relevant characteristics of a po- traveled by the institution; biological workloads due
pulation or phenomenon studied, and there are to exposure to parasite infestation and contact with
relationships between variables. human bodily fluids, mechanical workloads caused
The methodological analysis showed that 07 stu- by physical assaults committed by psychiatric pa-
dies (87.5%) have a quantitative approach, and 01 tients.
(12.5%) have a qualitative approach. Of them, 8 This study demonstrated that the psychic
(100%) of the studies were conducted in a psychia- workloads were mainly responsible for the emotio-
tric hospital. nal charge of professionals and poor working con-
Concerning the quantitative approach, its collec- ditions contribute to intensify these problems.
tion, and processing of information statistics show A study [12] conducted with nursing professionals
that it accurately tests hypotheses for research and working in mental health services showed that 75%
provides indices that can be compared with others of nurses said they were moderately overloaded
[11]. due to the care given to patients. In the same con-
In this study, the types of workloads were: phy- text, the workload related to the physical structure
sical workloads demonstrated by excessive working (19.4%), the dynamics of travel and work (13.9%),
hours and expressed by exposure to poor lighting mental exhaustion (13.8%), fear of physical aggres-
and humidity; psychic workloads by the direct care sion (11 1%) and verbal abuse (11.1%) of patients
to patients in psychiatric emergencies and lack of were identified.
qualified personnel in service to help in psychia- Research [13] conducted with 69 psychiatric nur-
tric nursing care, stress and burnout; physiological ses working in a hospital service to the Irish com-
workloads due to physical effort, time standing du- munity revealed that the main causes of burnout
were lack of resources, workload and organizatio- vealed that workload, mental health and job satis-
nal/process structures. faction were correlated with the energy to work.
Converging on the findings of this study, research The managers of mental health services must
[14] held examined the workload of nursing staff seek to ensure improvements in the working con-
and its potential relationship to patient safety in ditions of nurses, with implementation of indivi-
hospitals showing significant associations between dual and collective coping strategies, with a view
workload and patient safety, increased load work to mental health promotion worker in his working
or number of patients by nursing staff, reducing the environment. The quality of psychic well-being of
patient’s satisfaction with the care received. the worker may have direct relation to safety in
Measuring workloads that health workers are ex- the care of patients, and the risk-free and damage
posed and promoting adequate dimension of nur- in the process of health care [20]. However, given
sing staff will contribute to improved quality of care. the problems identified in this study on the pro-
Lack of resources at work such as personnel, mate- fessional nursing workloads are exposed to mental
rial or physically associated with the perception of health services, the safety of psychiatric patients is
poor conditions of service is an important stressor worrying.
for these professionals since it can limit their action, In 2004, The World Health Organization - WHO
influencing directly on the quality of service [15]. launched the World Alliance for Patient Safety. The
For that, the mental health services should combine program includes strategies, guidelines, and inter-
physical resources to the demands of work, decrea- national goals, which aim to disseminate and ensure
sing the workload of the nursing team [16]. practices that enable patient safety in different cou-
From the critical analysis of the selected studies, ntries. The Alliance operates in different areas, from
articles were categorized by the similarity of content hand washing, safe surgery to taxonomy, which
and a category for analysis was built: Implications of aims at organizing the taxonomic aspects related
workloads for the safety of the patients in mental to patient safety and care quality provided [21, 22].
distress. Donabedian [23], one of the leading scholars of
the health quality, developed a fundamental con-
Implications of workloads for the safety ceptual framework for understanding the evalua-
of the patients in mental distress tion of health quality, from the concepts of struc-
The common reality in the activity of professionals ture, process, and outcome, classically considered
from psychiatric hospitals is marked by physical, a triad, which is the concepts of General Systems
emotional and mental stress generated by work and Theory: input-process-output.
can produce apathy, depression, emotional hyper- In this context of quality of care, responsible for
sensitivity, anger, irritability and anxiety and even the management of patient care, the nurse plays an
cause depersonalization and the resulting inertia important role in achieving the quality of health ser-
production, performance and employee satisfaction vices [24]. He contributes significantly to the cons-
decrease [17]. truction of quality of care indicators and keeps up
Mental suffering of workers who are included in the results and the quality improvement process.
hospital services mental health can cause various In mental health services, the promotion of safety
morbidities with structural determinations. A study culture with an emphasis on learning, organizational
[18,19] conducted with health professionals to iden- improvement, and secure systems should be achie-
tify organizationally and personal factors causing ved. The mental health services managers need to
professional engagement and occupational stress implement policies to promote mental health for
of nursing and other health team professionals re- the worker in the workplace, as well as sensitize
them as the coping outside the work environment, to contribute to the professional development of
with the adoption of sports and family life, among coping strategies to work situations, both individual
others. and organizational point of view.
Other indicators of workloads also need to be
corrected as the decrease in weekly hourly load and
increasing the number of workers in the nursing References
team, as the organizational aspects also play a sig- 1. Glanzner CH, Olschowsky A, Kantorski LP. O trabalho como
fonte de prazer: avaliação da equipe de um Centro de Atenção
nificant role in the burnout of the worker. Organi-
Psicossocial. Rev. esc. enferm. USP São Paulo, v. 45, n. 3, p. 716-
zational solutions such as increasing the number of 721, June 2011.
nurses, reducing the number of hours worked posi- 2. Secco IAO de.,Robazzi MLCC de., Souza FEA de., Shimizu
tively impact the perception of work overload [25]. DS. Cargas de trabalho de materialidade externa na equipe
de enfermagem de hospital de ensino do Paraná, Brasil. Rev.
If the workload is not excessive, and professionals
Ciencia y EnfermerIa XVII (3): 69-81, 2011
feel emotionally balanced and resolute in their pro- 3. Laurell AC, Noriega M. Processo de produção e saúde: trabalho
fessional activity, there will be greater satisfaction e desgaste operário. São Paulo: Hucitec; 1989
in their daily working day [12]. The efforts of health 4. Magalhães AMM, Dall’Agnol CM, Marck PB. Carga de trabalho
organizations to improve the quality of manage- da equipe de enfermagem e segurança do paciente - estudo
com método misto na abordagem ecológica restaurativa. Rev.
ment need to mobilize pursuing patient safety and
Latino-Am. Enfermagem 21(Spec):[09 telas]
finding ways to work together more effectively and 5. Kohn LT, Corrigan JM, Donaldson MS, editors. To error is human:
efficiently to ensure that their organizations provide building a safer health system. Washington (DC): Committee on
safe, and high-quality care to patients [26]. Quality of Health Care in America, National Academy, Institute
of Medicine; 2001.
6. World Health Organization (WHO). World alliance for patient
safety. [Internet]. Washington DC; 2004 [acesso 8 fev 2016].
Conclusions Disponível em: http://www.who.int/patientsafety/enf
The development of this study found that nursing 7. Richardson A, Storr J. Patient safety: a literature review on the
impact of nursing empowerment, leadership and collaboration.
professionals involved in mental health services had
IntNurs Rev. 2010 Jun; 57(2):12-21.
various types of workloads in their work process, 8. Richardson A, Storr J. Patient safety: a literature review on the
being psychic as the most present. The main causes impact of nursing empowerment, leadership and collaboration.
of workload generation identified in the study are: Int Nurs Rev. 2010 Jun; 57(2):12-21.
physical assaults committed by patients in mental 9. Whittemore R, Knafl K. The integrative review: update
methodology. J AdvNurs. 2005 Dez; 52(5):546-53. Ganong LH.
distress, excessive working hours, high demand for Integrative reviews of nursing research. Res Nurs Health. 1987
psychological work, working hours and working Mar; 10(1):1-11.
conditions with reference to the work overload. 10. Souza MTS, Silva, MD, Carvalho R. Revisao integrativa: o
Workloads identified are associated with the spe- que e como fazer. Einstein [Internet]. 2010[cited 2016 Abril
5]; 8(1):102-6. Available from: http://apps.einstein.br/revista/
cifics of work in the hospital mental health services,
arquivos/PDF/1134-Einsteinv8n1_p102-106_port.pdf
which require the skills of workers to deal with the 11. Dalfovo MS, Lana RA, Silveira A. Métodos quantitativos e
human being, in order to understand it from the qualitativos: um resgateteórico. Revista Interdisciplinar Científica
perspective of comprehensive health care, mainly Aplicada, Blumenau 2008; 2(4): 01-13.
12. Souza IA, Pereira MO, Oliveira MA, Pinho PH, Gonçalves
because dealing with the everyday suffering and
RM. Processo de trabalho e seu impacto nos profissionais de
madness, which makes the environment pervaded enfermagem em serviço de saúde mental. Rev Acta Paul Enferm.
by intense the subjective and intersubjective. 2015; 28(5):447-53
In the care of the caregiver context of users with
mental suffering, more studies are needed in order