HKICS Seminar On China Outbound Investment Regulatory Developments On 21 Jun 2018 PDF
HKICS Seminar On China Outbound Investment Regulatory Developments On 21 Jun 2018 PDF
HKICS Seminar On China Outbound Investment Regulatory Developments On 21 Jun 2018 PDF
21 June 2018
Presenters:
Ms Karen Ip
Ms Karen Ip is a corporate partner of Herbert Smith Freehills who advises on cross-border transactions
relating to China. Based in Beijing, she has more than 20 years' experience advising clients on inbound
and outbound transactions.
Karen helps businesses – mainly in the financial, real estate, retail, telecommunications and healthcare
sectors in China – handle cross-border mergers and acquisitions (M&A) transactions, establishment of
presence, and meet regulatory compliance requirements (including in relation to consumer protection,
product liability, competition and employment issues).
Karen’s expertise is reflected by her consistent listings in Legal 500 Asia Pacific, Chambers Asia-Pacific,
and IFLR1000. According to Chambers Asia-Pacific 2016, Karen is ‘a very capable corporate partner’.
Ms Nanda Lau
Ms Nanda Lau is a partner of Herbert Smith Freehills based in Shanghai. Her practice covers a wide
range of corporate and commercial work including M&A, foreign direct investment, private equity,
joint ventures, corporate restructuring, competition law and regulatory compliance matters in China.
Her clients include multi-national corporations and Chinese companies in a broad range of sectors,
including aerospace, automobile, chemical, food and beverages, financial services, pharmaceutical, real
estate, retail and TMT.
Nanda has extensive experience in advising clients on doing business in China and cross-border
transactions with a China element.
21 June 2018
Chair:
Ms Cynthia Chen
Ms Cynthia Chen FCIS FCS is the Named Company Secretary of the Listed Company. Ms Chen holds a
Bachelor’s Degree in Business Administration and a Master’s Degree in Corporate Governance. She is
currently studying for a PhD in Finance. She is a Fellow of The Hong Kong Institute of Chartered
Secretaries and a Fellow of The Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators. She has more
than sixteen years’ extensive experience in the company secretarial practice and has over twenty years’
experience in large well-known enterprises management, and she has worked in Singapore for more
than three years.
JUNE 2018
// 2
Part 1: Recent regulatory trends
• Government paying close attention to potential risks associated with certain types
of outbound investments
• "Window guidance" and bank practice
Remittance of foreign exchange in the amount of US$5 million or more to be
reported to SAFE for approval
• NDRC & MOFCOM enhanced examination process
NDRC beefed up information reporting of outbound acquisition and bidding
projects
MOFCOM upgraded online system to strengthen authenticity examination
Additional documents required
Form review substantive review
// 3
Part 1: Recent regulatory trends
// 4
Part 1: Recent regulatory trends
// 5
Part 2: Key statistics and trends of ODI
ODI
• After a record high of US$170 billion in 2016, non-financial ODI value in 2017
down by 29.4%
• China's outbound non-financial direct investment rises for seventh consecutive
month. In first five months of 2018, non-financial ODI value increased by 38.5%
Source: http://hzs.mofcom.gov.cn/article/date/201804/20180402737726.shtml
// 6
Part 2: Key statistics and trends of ODI
ODI
• In first five months of 2018: ODI Value
• The industrial structure was
optimized, and irrational investment
was effectively curbed.
Leasing
• ODI in the leasing and business and
service, mining, wholesale, and retail Others Business
business accounted for 29.9%, 15%, Service
12.3% and 7.6%, respectively, of the
total outflow.
• There were no new projects in the
real estate, sports, or entertainment Mining
industries.
Retail
business
Wholesale
Source: http://www.xinhuanet.com/fortune/2018-06/14/c_1122987677.htm
// 7
Part 2: Key statistics and trends of ODI
ODI IN EU
• ODI in EU down 17% in
2017, which is still lower
than the 29% drop in ODI
globally
• After a period of large
investments in Southern
Europe, Chinese investors
returned to the largest
European economies in
2016 and 2017
• UK, Germany and France
accounted for 75% of
China’s total EU
investment in 2017, the
highest share in ten years
Source: https://www.merics.org/en/papers-on-china/chinese-fdi-in-europe
// 8
Part 2: Key statistics and trends of ODI
ODI IN EU
• Transportation,
public utilities and
infrastructure
facilities have
become the top
sectors for Chinese
investment in Europe
in 2017
• High-tech, advanced
manufacturing, real
estate and hospitality
also accounted for a
significant share
Source: https://www.merics.org/en/papers-on-china/chinese-fdi-in-europe
// 9
Part 2: Key statistics and trends of ODI
// 10
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
// 11
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
• Determining Factors
Business of the Target – sensitive sectors?
Location of Target – sensitive jurisdictions?
Investment amount – over US$300 million?
Acquisition of controlling stake?
Place of incorporation of acquisition vehicle (inside or outside China)
Direct investment or indirect investment via offshore SPV?
Source of funding to finance the acquisition (any remittance of funds from
China?)
Any guarantee to foreign lenders in support of the financing of the acquisition
from China-incorporated entity?
Is the Chinese buyer state-owned, a PRC Listco and/or subject to
administration of any special regulatory commission such as CIRC?
Is the “Chinese buyer” a Chinese national?
// 12
Part 3: New NDRC china outbound investment
measures
New NDRC Outbound Investment Measures (Document No. 11)
• Effective 1 March 2018
• Expand the scope of transactions subject to NDRC scrutiny
Regardless of the source of funding or guarantee
Cover offshore equity investment funds and investment through contractual or trust
arrangements
Cover outbound investment made by offshore entities which are controlled by Chinese
individuals
• Expand scope of sensitive sectors
• Enhance post-approval and filing supervision
Deadline for completing approval/filing - before the implementation of the investment
• Streamline the approval and filing procedures
Abolishing the “road pass” (project information report) requirement
A local enterprise may submit tis application directly to the central NDRC for approval
(no longer needs to go through local NDRC)
// 13
Part 3: New NDRC china outbound investment
measures
Sensitive Industry Catalogue
• Published by NDRC on 31 Jan 2018: research, manufacturing and maintenance of
defense equipment; development and utilisation of cross-border water resources; news
and media
Notice on Further Guiding and Regulating the Direction of Outbound Investment in
August 2017: real estate, hotel, cinema, entertainment, sports clubs
// 14
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- NDRC Approval/Filing Mandate
Involving Sensitive Countries
and Regions1 or Sensitive
Industries2
Yes No
Yes No
Non-CAEs with
Investment Amount over Investment
US$ 300m Amount over
US$ 300m
Or CAEs
Yes No Yes No
Subject to Subject to
Online report No approval /filing/
Central Provincial
to NDRC reporting required
NDRC Filing DRC Filing
#1: “sensitive countries and regions” include those with which China has no diplomatic relations, countries in which investment is
restricted under international treaties to which China is a party, and countries or regions affected by war or civil strife.
#2: NDRC has published 2018 Catalogue of Sensitive Industries effective since March 2018.
#3: “investment” means directly or via its controlled overseas enterprises, acquiring ownership, controlling power, rights of operation
and management and other rights and interests overseas by making asset or equity investment, providing financing or guarantee, etc.
// 15
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- MOFCOM Approval/Filing Mandate
Direct
investment
Yes No
Yes Yes No
Subject to
Subject to Central Subject to
Central
MOFCOM Provincial COC
MOFCOM
Approval Filing
Filing
#1: “sensitive countries and regions” include those with which China has no diplomatic relations, countries subject to United Nations
sanctions.
#2: “sensitive industries‘” include industries involving products or technologies the exportation of which is restricted by China, or in
which multiple countries/regions have an interest (for example, a cross-border railway project).
// 16
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- SASAC supervision
Recent Development: SASAC control on outbound investment by CAE
• Pre-investment Supervision
Yes No
Yes No
Investment SASAC approval before Above rules also apply to the outbound
Prohibited NDRC/MOFCOM investment made by the wholly-owned or
controlled subsidiaries of the CAE.
// 17
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- SASAC supervision
Recent Development: SASAC control on outbound investment by CAE
• Pre-investment Supervision
Negative List
Yes No
// 18
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- SASAC supervision
Recent Development: SASAC control on outbound investment by CAE
• Investment Supervision
Random examination for significant outbound investment 1 by SASAC
Report quarterly to SASAC the implementation status of outbound
investment project
• Post-Investment Supervision
Submission to SASAC of annual report on the implementation of outbound
investment
Evaluation of outbound investment project by SASAC
Local SASAC approval for all outbound investments, e.g. in Beijing and
Guangdong
Local SASAC approval for investment in non-core business and local SASAC
filing for investment in core business investment, e.g. in Shanghai
// 20
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- SASAC supervision
Buyer is a non-CAE SOEs
// 21
Part 3: CSRC approval and filing requirements -
Regulations on listco
• Buyer is a PRC Listco
• Supermajority Shareholders’ Approval
If the transaction constitutes a “Major Asset Restructuring” under PRC
Company Law or the applicable listing rules of stock exchange (Shanghai or
Shenzhen) subjecting PRC Listco companies to obtain shareholders approval
Articles of Association might provide for lower thresholds
Timing consideration: notice period to call shareholders meeting and time
required for preparing audited report (for share deal) or an asset valuation
report (for asset deal) on the target company
• CSRC Approval
the transaction constitutes back door listing
the Listco issues new shares as the acquisition price
// 22
Part 3: CSRC approval and filing requirements
- Regulations on listco
// 23
PART 3 : CSRC approval and filing requirements
// 24
Part 3: Approval and filing requirements
- Financial institutions
Investments by financial institutions subject to filing with, reporting to or approval of
relevant regulatory authorities:
• Securities institutions (e.g. securities company) - China Securities Regulatory
Commission (CSRC)
• Financial institutions (e.g. banks) - China Banking Regulatory Commission
(CBRC)
• Insurance institutions - China Insurance Regulatory Commission (CIRC)
Acquire controlling shareholding: approval of CIRC
Acquire non-controlling shareholding: reporting to the CIRC within 5 BDs
after execution of transaction documents
// 25
Part 3: Recent policies on outbound investment by
PRC insurance companies
• Administrative Measures for Utilization of Insurance Funds
Effective 1 April 2018
Outbound investment using insurance funds shall be in compliance with
relevant provisions of CIRC, PBOC and SAFE
Equity investment acquiring controlling stake is limited to following companies:
Insurance type companies: including insurance companies, insurance
asset management companies, insurance agency companies
Non-insurance financial companies
Insurance business related companies
Establishment of professional insurance assets management institution for
management of Immovable assets, infrastructure facilities, aged care, etc.
// 26
Part 3: Recent policies on outbound investment by
PRC insurance companies
Generally not permitted to deploy insurance funds:
Investment in companies not in compliance with the state’s industrial
policies (whether by way of share or asset acquisition)
Direct investment in real estate development and construction
• Notice on Regulating Overseas Loan Secured by Domestic Guarantee of
Insurance Institutions (effective 5 January 2018)
Loans secured by domestic guarantee shall not exceed 20% of the Insurance
Institution’s net asset as at the end of the preceding quarter
• Tightened control on outbound investment by insurance institutions
E.g. CIRC ordered three insurers (including Ping An, Xinhua Life Insurance
and China Re Asset Management) to fix violations of outbound investment
rules
// 27
Part 3: Recent relaxation of QDII, QDLP
// 28
Part 3: Recent relaxation of QDII, QDLP
// 29
Part 3: Recent relaxation of QDII, QDLP
// 30
Part 4: Financing of China outbound investment
• NDRC has not set any specific minimum debt equity ratio for China outbound
investment projects
• CBRC Guideline of 2015 – no more than 60% of the offshore acquisition price
shall be financed by PRC commercial banks.
• SAFE registration
// 31
Part 4 : Financing of China outbound investment
Commercial Acquisition
Foreign Bank or Loans Price
Offshore Investment Seller of Target
Offshore Branch of
Vehicle Company
PRC Bank
Security
(assignment of interest,
pledge, mortgage, charge etc.)
Loan Capital
Outside China Contribution
Inside China
Guarantee
PRC-incorporated
Company
// 32
Part 4: Financing of China outbound investment
Outbound investment via an offshore investment vehicle:
• Capital increase to offshore investment vehicle
• SAFE registration
// 33
Part 4: Financing of China outbound investment
// 34
PART 4 : Financing of China Outbound Investment
• Loan to offshore investment vehicle by offshore lenders without any guarantee
from PRC-incorporated company
Possible security offered to the offshore lenders:
legal mortgage over certain assets of the offshore SPV
assignment of the benefits of the claims under the SPA and interest in
respect of any sums payable pursuant to material insurance policies;
fixed charge over land, plant and machinery, interests in the SPV and its
subsidiaries, interest in respect of any sums payable pursuant to the
material insurance policies, etc.
floating charge over all other assets (not subject to assignment or fixed
charge)
No SAFE registration required
• A combination of various financing options
// 35
Part 5: Case study
Case 1:
A PRC citizen intends to use his wholly-owned BVI company to acquire a UK
incorporated SPV which owns a major real estate in London. Share purchase price of
US$500 million will be paid by the BVI company using funds currently held in a Hong
Kong bank account.
Any restrictions? What regulatory approvals/filings are needed?
// 36
Part 5: Case study
Case 2:
A PRC private company intends to use its wholly-owned Hong Kong subsidiary to
acquire shares in a UK incorporated technology company. The share purchase price
is US$ 500m and will be funded by offshore bank loan secured by guarantee
provided by the PRC company.
What regulatory approvals/filings are needed?
// 37
Part 5: Case study
Case 3:
A PRC insurance company which is a CAE intends to acquire controlling shares in an
aged care company incorporated in Singapore. The share purchase price is US$ 50m
and will be funded by its undistributed profit.
What regulatory approvals/filings are needed?
Principal business SASAC Filing
Acquire controlling shareholding CIRC Approval
No sensitive industries/regions + direct investment + CAE
Central NDRC Filing: before SAFE registration
Central MOFCOM Filing: before SAFE registration
SAFE Registration: before closing
// 38
Observations
// 39
Summary:
2018 prospects – points to take away
• Outbound investment will resume
• Focus on manufacturing, high-tech, infrastructure, healthcare
etc.
// 40
China Investment Guide 2018
// 41
Herbert Smith Freehills global office locations
OFFICES GROUPS
BANGKOK HONG KONG NEW YORK AFRICA
BEIJING JAKARTA * PARIS INDIA
BELFAST JOHANNESBURG PERTH IRAN
BERLIN KUALA LUMPUR RIYADH * ISRAEL
BRISBANE LONDON SEOUL LATIN AMERICA
BRUSSELS MADRID SHANGHAI KAZAKHSTAN
DUBAI MELBOURNE SINGAPORE NORDIC
DÜSSELDORF MILAN * SYDNEY UKRAINE
FRANKFURT MOSCOW TOKYO * Associated office
// 42
Disclaimer
Herbert Smith Freehills LLP is licensed to operate as a foreign law firm in China by the Ministry of Justice. Under Ministry of Justice regulations, foreign law firms in China
are permitted, amongst other things, to provide consultancy services on non-Chinese law and on international conventions and practices, and to provide information on the
impact of the Chinese legal environment. Under the same regulations, foreign law firms in China are not permitted to conduct Chinese legal affairs, including rendering legal
opinions upon Chinese law. The contents of this publication do not constitute an opinion upon Chinese law. We would be happy to coordinate with Chinese counsel if you
require a legal opinion on Chinese law.
The contents of this publication, current at the date of publication set out in this document, are for reference purposes only. They do not constitute legal advice and should
not be relied upon as such. Specific legal advice about your specific circumstances should always be sought separately before taking any action based on this publication.
Herbert Smith Freehills LLP and its affiliated and subsidiary businesses and firms and Herbert Smith Freehills, an Australian Partnership, are separate member firms of the
international legal practice known as Herbert Smith Freehills.
// 43