Cesium Formate
Cesium Formate
YOUR RESERVOIR’S
VALUE
Recommended pH range 9 – 11
properties help protect polymers
Viscosity (cP) @ 25°C 5.4 against thermal degradation at high
Water activity (aw) @ 25°C 0.33 temperatures
With a natural pH of 10 – 10.5, it’s well
Boiling point (°C) 131
True crystallization temperature (°C) 5.1 1) suited to metals and elastomers
Full compatibility with water-soluble
Coefficient of thermal conductivity (W/m/K) @ 10°C 0.338
polymers, such as xanthan, means it
Heat capacity (J/g/K) @ 10 – 70°C 1.38
can be used to formulate drilling fluid
Coefficient of friction, metal to metal 2) 0.16 It's safer to handle with less
Cesium formate brine is an investment in your well, your reservoir and your
bottom line. It’ll unlock the full value of your reserves and keep on paying
dividends year after year. Cesium formate brine is proven to:
HPHT well construction operations using cesium formate brine are faster ROP was a major issue
and more effective than those using traditional fluids. In 29 North Sea deep- and the reduced ECD with
gas well constructions carried out in overbalance with cesium formate brine cesium formate made a very
between 1999 and 2010 there were no differential sticking or well control significant contribution in
incidents while drilling, logging or completing. Average completion time for improving ROP.
BP, OTC 15322
these wells is 21 days against an average of 46 days 1) for wells drilled with
oil-based muds (OBMs). That’s 25 days of costs saved and 25 days closer to
production revenues. Let’s look now at why such results are achieved.
1) SPE 145562
-10
Less time circulating to cool
-20
measurement-while-drilling (MWD) tools
-30
Low torque and drag values in extended
-40 TCT CsFo
reach and high-angle drilling
-50 TCT CsFo – extrapolated
Stabilizes viscosifiers and fluid-loss CsFo supercooling
-60
polymers at high temperatures
-70
Reduces mud-conditioning times 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
Density [g/cm3]
Quickly reach operational flow after
stoppages as no need to break gel Cesium formate performs well at low temperatures. The graph shows true crystallization temperature
Low gel strengths prevent surge and (TCT) for cesium formate (single salt). Supercooling points indicate the temperature where the fluid has
been successfully kept for at least two weeks in the presence of standard seeding material.
swab risks
Excellent well control
Faster kick detection due to low gas
solubility and low gas diffusion rate
Drilling fluids based on cesium formate brine reduced risk and improved
well economics on the Huldra field by: providing extremely good well control,
lowering ECDs, increasing trip speed, avoiding surge and swab, reducing time
for flow checks, and improving hole cleaning. 5
Statoil, SPE/IADC 105733
Problem-free completions
High-density cesium formate brine has been successfully used in
hundreds of cased-hole and openhole completion operations since 1999,
including many jobs where it has been deployed as the internal fluid phase
of low-solids oil-based muds (LSOBMs). It delivers the following benefits
for completions:
Highly durable – cesium formate brine is safely deployed in extreme HPHT wells, such
There have been no well control incidents in any HPHT deep-gas well drilled
and completed with cesium formate brine, including 14 wells drilled and
completed in openhole at overbalance for a total of 432 days in Statoil’s
Huldra and Kvitebjørn fields. This remarkable ‘zero incidents’ record set in
hostile environments is proof of the improved HPHT well control environment
provided by cesium formate drilling and completion fluids.
The specific well-control benefits of cesium formate brines in challenging HPHT wells are:
Cesium formate brine has provided effective well control in more than 20
HPHT workover and suspension operations in Elgin/Franklin.
Total, Drilling Contractor magazine, May/June 2007
7
The driver for this drilling fluid choice was improved well control. The high-
density, solids-free nature of the potassium/cesium formate brine provides
low ECD, eliminates the risk of barite sag, and dissolves very low amounts
of reservoir gases.
Statoil, SPE/IADC 105733
In at least three offshore fields drilled with cesium formate – Kristin, Huldra and
Kvitebjørn – the drilling window between pore pressure and formation fracture
pressure in the reservoir sections was very narrow. For example, in Kristin the riser
margin of 0.09 g/cm3 reduced the already narrow drilling window to only 0.09 g/cm3.
High ECD of an oil-based mud (OBM) in this environment would have been very
difficult to endure while maintaining a riser margin. Actual ECD measured with
pressure-while-drilling (PWD) sensors when drilling the Kristin wells with cesium
formate brine was only 0.05 – 0.06 g/cm3 higher than the static mud weight.
Fracturation
39 18 23
σh σv
Narrow drilling window
895 934 952 975 (bar)
In the Huldra and Kvitebjørn wells, cesium formate drill-in fluid combined with
reduced pumping rates and capped ROP kept ECD between 0.04 and 0.06 g/cm3 over
the static mud weight, although excursions up to 0.09 g/cm3 could occur when drilling
shale from temporary increases from low-gravity solids.
HIGHLY COMPATIBLE FLUID
8 CUTS WELL CONSTRUCTION COSTS
Cesium formate brine’s monovalent nature and mildly alkaline pH mean it’s
highly compatible with polymers, elastomers and downhole metals.
The table below shows some typical elastomer test results with buffered
formate brines.
In High Island A-5 well #1, pipe identification markings were still intact after six years immersed in
formate brine at high pressures and temperatures.
OUTSTANDING WELL PERFORMANCE
10 AND RESERVE RECOVERY
Cesium formate brine helps deliver HPHT wells that routinely meet or
exceed production performance expectations. Experience shows that
this is particularly true in deep gas wells drilled and completed in openhole
entirely with cesium formate brine.
Specifically, solids-free cesium formate brine enables good in-flow performance in the
following ways:
Cesium formate screen-running fluid prevents your
screens from plugging. No weighting agents to reduce formation permeability and block sand screens
No scale precipitation from reservoir fluids and gases
No emulsion blocking resulting from mixing fluid with reservoir fluids
Stabilizes interstitial clays
Minimal migration of fines through the formation
No wettability changes as wetting agents are not required
Ultra-thin filter cakes lift off and backflow easily at low drawdown pressures saving
time and cost
The proof
Cesium formate brine has been used successfully in numerous high-angle, HPHT, open-
hole completions on fields such as Huldra, Tune, Kvitebjørn and Kanowit. Wells completed
with cesium formate in these fields have shown low skins in low-permeability sandstone
and limestone without any need for clean-up or stimulation treatments. Very thin filter
cake residues left on the borehole wall lifted off easily or were naturally breached, and
allowed free flow of hydrocarbons through sand screens on production start-up.
11
0 Cumulative production of
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
1) Huldra is estimated by the Norwegian Petroleum Directorate to Year of production reserves from the Huldra field,
have recoverable reserves of 16 billion m3 of gas and 5 million m3 2001 to 2011.
of oil/condensate. Source: Norwegian Petroleum Directorate
Recovering reserves –
Recovery of gas reserves [% of estimated original reserves in place]
Cesium formate brine is unique among HPHT drilling fluids by having a very dense
filtrate (up to 2.30 g/cm3/19.2 lb/gal) that has a stunningly high photoelectric cross
section (Pe) of up to 259 barns/elec. Any invasion of this mud filtrate into the formation
around the well bore becomes highly visible to nuclear logging tools against a
background Pe of 2 – 6 barns/elec for common rock materials and formation fluids.
The logged photoelectric effect provided by the invasion of cesium formate filtrate is
extremely useful for correcting the density curve for mud/borehole effects and mud
filtrate invasion, and for estimating filtrate saturation. It is also ideal for defining permeable
sands. Combining the photoelectric effect and its high vertical resolution with resistivity
measurements from both the drill pass and ream pass of a logging-while-drilling (LWD)
tool produces a very reliable and accurate net reservoir definition.
This low-solids and very conductive drilling fluid has been found to be
ideal for all acoustic measurements and for electrical image logging...The
logged photoelectric factor is not only useful for correcting the density
curve and to estimate Sxo, but it is also ideal for defining permeable sands.
Statoil, SPE/IADC 105733
13
Delivers a reliable and consistent net reservoir definition,
formation porosity, and HC saturation by taking advantage
of the unique nuclear properties of cesium formate.
Statoil, SPE/IADC 105733
The results (from cesium formate-based fluid LWD data) match core porosity from
different lithologies in three different wells, so we’re very confident that this new
approach works. Furthermore, cesium formate brine helps us better define the net
reservoir and produce improved reservoir models.
Erik Sandtorv Pedersen, Petrophysicist, Statoil ASA, Formate Matters no. 2, April/May 2008
CESIUM FORMATE BRINE
14 – THE SAFER CHOICE
PHOTO: 1-IMAGES.NO
Used in highly sensitive environments, such as the Barents Sea, cesium formate meets exacting
environmental demands, including CEFAS's gold standard.
The findings of the study indicate that the discharge of moderate amounts of
formate brines is not likely to lead to potentially significant negative impacts on
the marine environment.
ENI, SPE 94477
15
No rubber suits or respirators are required when handling cesium formate brine.
Sustainable operations
Operations are based on leasing, reclamation and reuse of cesium formate. This
sustainable business model reduces operating costs and minimizes environmental
impact. By careful management, the majority of brine is recovered and reused. This
approach encourages better chemical management, where operators join with us in a
common cause to conserve chemicals and minimize waste.
A WEALTH OF
KNOWLEDGE
We are the leading global authority on formate brines. Since our incorporation in 1996, we
have built up a wealth of knowledge and expertize in this specialist area from hundreds of
challenging jobs around the world, the majority of which are HPHT drilling, completion and
intervention operations. We operate our own research laboratory in Aberdeen and have
invested extensively in external research. The result is valuable collateral, such as the
Formate Technical Manual, case histories, environmental assessment reports, DensiCalc™
density and pressure calculator and the BrineWise™ costing tool, all of which can be
downloaded from our informative website, cabotcorp.com/cesiumformate.
GLOBAL SUPPORT
We are headquartered in Aberdeen, Scotland and operate globally, with sales offices/stock
points in the UK, Norway and Singapore, and additional stock points in Canada, Belgium
and the United States.
With close to 100 staff devoted to formate brines, no other company matches our
experience, expertize and pure dedication to this product. A skilled team of field
engineers is waiting to assist operations anywhere in the world and well-equipped
laboratories in Aberdeen and Bergen provide customized fluid formulations, fluid
analyzes, trouble-shooting and technical advice.
Our Operations and Technical Support Laboratory in
Aberdeen is always ready to help with fluid testing
ASSURED SUPPLY
and formulation.
We are part of the publicly listed Cabot Corporation, which owns and operates the
Tanco mine at Lake Bernic, Canada, where 80% of the world’s known pollucite deposits
are located. Pollucite is mined and processed into cesium formate and fine cesium
chemicals.
logging interpretation solution for a LWD with cesium formate brine. A total of 57 m3
density tool, which makes unique use of cesium formate brine at 2.15 g/cm3 / 17.92 lb/gal
the extremely high photoelectric effect was bull-headed down the 51/2" casing to
Statoil Kvitebjørn, from cesium-rich filtrate. the bottom of the perforated zone at 5,300
North Sea meters to minimize wellhead pressure and
HPHT gas/condensate field Per Cato Berg, Lead Drilling Engineer for enable snubbing of a packer and test string
155°C/311°F – 81 MPa/11,700 psi Kvitebjørn, says: “Supported by our tests into the hole.
and data, we feel that cesium formate
Twelve reservoir sections have been gives the best productivity for the wells. High-density cesium formate was chosen
drilled and ten completed with cesium/ We have tested formation damage with as alternative brines with lower densities
potassium formate brine in the Kvitebjørn water- and oil-based alternatives, and develop much higher surface pressures,
field since 2004. cesium formate comes out best.” which place more wear and tear on the
snubbing equipment and increase
Prior to 2007, all Kvitebjørn reservoir The Kvitebjørn operations add to Statoil’s operational risk. Cesium formate remained
intervals were successfully drilled using unique track record – 15 HPHT wells drilled in the well for 39 days before a reverse
conventional techniques to TD with and 22 completed using high-density circulation displacement to a packer fluid
inclinations ranging from 23 – 46°. Drilling cesium/potassium formate brines without enabled well-test operations to begin. The
performance was very good with moderate one single well-control incident. 1) brine was sampled when circulated out
1) SPE 145562, 2007
19
of the hole after the 39-day suspension. true vertical depth (TVD), with maximum
Cesium formate brine for
Despite lengthy exposure to hydrothermal deviations ranging from near vertical to
conditions, laboratory analyzes showed 45°, with a further six wells drilled in the
challenging wells –
no significant changes in fluid properties Franklin field to deeper horizons. 100s of jobs in over 50 fields
or composition. Alder Maharaja Lela/
The 81/2" reservoir intervals were drilled Alve Jamalulalam
Don Wright, operations manager for TXM, with synthetic oil-based mud (SBM) and Baker Family Trust Mako
comments: “Successfully setting the completed with 7" liners before running Malek
Boje
packer in Mako-6 at a record depth was production tubing and suspending them. Martin Linge
Braemar
a significant achievement for us. Cesium Prior to the Elgin wells being brought Mobile Area
Brynhild
formate provided stable well conditions onto production, it was established that Moran
Bulan Bulan
and enabled operations to progress safely incorrect heat-treatment procedures had Morvin
and smoothly. Crew only needed to wear been used during production of the 103/4" Champion West
Devenick Mumbai High
standard personal protective equipment, casing-hangers. A workover plan was
Dunbar Njord
something that made working conditions prepared to re-enter the wells, recover the
Edith Gray North Vega
much more comfortable, especially since production strings, replace the hangers
Ekofisk Oseberg
outdoor temperatures rose to 40°C/104°F and re-run the production strings. Vestflanke
on occasion.” Elgin/Franklin
Oselvar
Two of the seven Elgin wells (G1 and G3) El Campamento
Raven
The well was later suspended three had already been perforated, making it El Cerrito
Rhum
times using cesium formate, including a imperative to kill them with a high-density Gasselternijveen
Rimfaks
six-month period. Again, due to extreme workover fluid before carrying out remedial Glenelg
Shearwater
temperatures, the brine was thoroughly work. Total first tried OBM as workover GSV
analyzed after it was circulated out of the fluid, but barite sag problems turned their Snadd North
Gudrun
well. No significant changes in fluid attention to brine. Cesium formate was Snorre
Gullfaks
properties and composition were found. selected due to its benign nature and South Arne
Gullfaks Satellite
compatibility with metals used in casing, Statfjord
Hild
production tubulars and packers. Statfjord
Huldra Satellites
Janus Tapis
Elgin G1 and G3 were displaced to
2.19 g/cm3 cesium formate brine prior Jasmine Tapti
to running and setting the packer. The Jerneh Trym
production tubings were run without Judy Vega
incident, followed by the tubing hangers. Jura Vetyêm
The wells were then displaced to inhibited Kanowit Victoria
Total Elgin/Franklin, drill water. In G1, a faulty packer leaked Kashagan Vigdis
North Sea causing hydrate formation. This well was Kessog Visund
HPHT gas condensate wells killed again with cesium formate brine and Krishna- Yanam South
190 to 205°C/374 to 400°F – 110 MPa/ the hydrate plug melted by circulating hot Godavari Basin
15,954 psi cesium formate brine into the annulus. Kristin
Kvitebjørn
Cesium formate brine with density of The remaining re-entries (G4 – G8) involved
2.19 g/cm3/18.28 lb/gal has provided effective simply displacing the wells to 2.19 g/cm3
hydrostatic well control in over 20 HPHT cesium formate brine, recovering completion
workover and suspension operations in strings, replacing casing-hangers, re-running
the Elgin/Franklin fields over nine years. completion strings and displacing the
wells back to inhibited drill water.
Initially, seven production wells were
drilled in Elgin to around 5,600 meters
FORMATE
FORMATE
TECHNICAL MANUAL
TECHNICAL MANUAL
cabotcorp.com/cesiumformate
Cabot Specialty Fluids Ltd. Cabot Specialty Fluids Ltd. Cabot Specialty Fluids (S) Pte Ltd. Cabot Specialty Fluids Inc.
Cabot House, Hareness Circle Bygg K12, PO Box 4 Level 08-09 4582 Kingwood Drive
Altens Industrial Estate NO-5347 Kystbasen The Metropolis Tower 2 Suite E145
Aberdeen AB12 3LY Ågotnes, Bergen 11 North Buona Vista Drive Kingwood
Scotland Norway Singapore 138589 Texas 77345
T (44) 1224 897 229 T (47) 55 70 70 52 T (65) 6808 7870 USA
V3.5, 01/19
F (44) 1224 870 089 F (47) 55 70 70 53 F (65) 6808 7777 T (1) 281 361 2330
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]