Ankeet Singh Report
Ankeet Singh Report
Ankeet Singh Report
ON
MARKET COMPARISON BETWEEN BIG BAZAR & SPENCER - AN
EMPIRICAL STUDY
Master of Business
Administration,
2017-2018
1
RAJARSHI SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT
AND TECHNOLOGY VARANASI
Varanasi, 221002
This is to certify that the Research Report entitled “Market comparison between
Bigbazar & Spencer .”Submitted by Ankeet Singh, Roll No. 1610870009 in partial
fulfilment of the Award degree of MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION of Dr.
A. P. J. Abdul Kalam Technical University, Lucknow is a bonafide work for
academic session 2016-18.
In my opinion the report fulfils the requirement of the regulation & ordinance in
relation to the nature and standard of work for MBA Degree.
2
(Dr. Vinita Kalra)
(Project Guide)
PREFACE
Each student is required to complete a project in his or her field of interest after the
completion of his or her second semester examination. The purpose of this project is to
expose the students on practical and research front of his or her area of interest. The project
gives a unique experience to aspirants who can visualize things what they have been taught in
classroom.
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to express my sincere esteemed thanks to our institution, which provided me this most
awaited opportunity of undergoing training in the corporate world.
Along with the institution I also want to express my gratitude to my faculty members who
help me with their immense knowledge and their experience.
Last but not least I want to express my immense heartly thanks to all the personalities who
Ankeet Singh
MBA IV
4
DECLARATION
5
Ankeet Singh Date:
Roll No:1610870009
INDEX
CONTENT
CHAPTER-1
Introduction of the Project
CHAPTER-2
Company profile of Spencer
Company profile of big bazar
Objective, Scope & Limitations of the Study
CHAPTER-3
Research Methodology
CHAPTER-4
Data collection & Analysis
CHAPTER-5
Findings of the study
Limitation of the study
CHAPTER-6
Conclusion
Suggestion
Appendix
6
Bibliography
Questionnaire
Introduction of
the Project
7
Introduction to Retailing sector
Retailing sector of India can be split into two segments. They are the informal and the formal
retailing sector. The informal retailing sector is comprised of small retailers. For this sector, it
is very difficult to implement the tax laws. There is widespread tax evasion. It is also
cumbersome to regulate the labor laws in this sector. As far as the formal retailing sector is
concerned, it is comprised of large retailers. Stringent tax and labor laws are implemented in
this sector.
If the retail industry is divided on the basis of retail formats then it can be split into the
modern format retailers and the traditional format retailers. The modern format retailers
comprise of the supermarkets, Hypermarkets, Departmental Stores, Specialty Chains and
company owned and operated retail stores
The traditional format retailers comprise of Kiranas, Kiosks, Street Markets and the multiple
brand outlets. The retail industry can also be subdivided into the organized and the
unorganized sector. The organized retail sector occupies about 3% of the aggregate retail
industry in India.
In terms of value, the Indian Retail industry is worth $300 billion. India retail industry is the
largest industry in India, with an employment of around 8%. Its contribution to the Gross
Domestic Product is about 10%, the highest compared to all other Indian Industries. The
retail sector has also contributed to 8% of the employment of the country. The organized
retail sector is expected to triple its size by 2010. The food and grocery retail sector is
expected to multiply five times in the same time frame. The major reason behind the low
8
participation in the Indian retail sector is the need for lumpy investments that cannot match
up their break even points. The government policies are being revised from time to time to
attract investments in this sector.
In terms of the retail development index India ranks fifth. In Asia it occupies the second
position, next to China. Among all the global markets, the Indian retail market is the most
expanding. This is owing to absence in restriction at the entry level. So the large foreign
companies can reap the benefits of economies scale by entering the green retail fields of
India. There are many reasons why the retail industry in India can reach the zenith.
Firstly the organized retail sector in India has a very low contribution to the entire retail
sector in the country. Hence there is ample scope for the new players to achieve success in the
backdrop of soaring disposable income of the upcoming generation. Secondly, not only have
the incomes increased but there has been a sea change in the preferences of the consumers.
These factors have acted as a stimulus for the ushering of foreign players retailing in
apparels, accessories, electronic appliances etc. Large shopping malls have already
mushroomed in the metropolitan cities. There still lies untapped potential in the Indian Retail
Market.
The size of retail industry in an economy depends on many factors and the level of consumer
spending is the most important among these factors. The retail sector in India has grown by
leaps and bounds in the last five years. The reason behind this growth has been the synergy of
many propellants. However the growth is not always genuine as there are exaggerations as
well. But these exaggerations also have benefits since they given a feel of growing
competition all around. Secondly the present situation is just a depiction of nascent stage. The
future of the trajectory may not be as steep as it is now or may be even slope downward.
'What will be the future size of the retail industry' is the mind boggling question. Another
moot point that will gain importance in due time concerns the future of the unorganized retail
market which constitute a significant proportion of the whole industry. The retail stores have
9
proved to be a vantage point for the customers. This implies that the small farmers who used
to sell their product in the sabji-mandis and on roadsides are going to lose a significant
market share as they can't employ the two profit maximizers-economies of scale and
economies of scope.
The present value of the Indian retail market is estimated by the India Retail Report to be
around Rs. 12,00,000 crore($270 billion) and the annual growth rate is 5.7 percent. Retail
market for food and grocery with a worth of Rs. 7, 43,900 crore is the largest of the different
types of retail industries present in India. Furthermore around 15 million retail outlets help
India win the crown of having the highest retail outlet density in the world. The contribution
of retail sector to GDP has been manifested below:
As can be clearly seen, retailing in India is superior to those of its contenders. Retail sector is
a sunrise industry in India and the prospect for growth is simply huge. There are many factors
that have stimulated the rise of the shopping centers and multiplex-malls in a jiffy. Some of
them can be listed as follows:
Rise in the purchasing power of Indians- the rise in the per capita income in the last
few years has been magnificent. This has led to the generation of insatiable wants of
the upper and middle class. The demand of new as well as second hand durables has
risen throughout the country thus providing the incentive for taking up retailing.
10
Favorable to farmers- retailing has helped in removing the middlemen and has thus
enhanced the remuneration to farmers. This is a new revolution in the agricultural
sector in India and will go a long way in amending the condition of agriculture, a
major concern among policy makers.
Use of credit- a typical Indian is most conversant with using credit cards than carrying
money. These have led to a shift of the consumer base towards supermarkets and
make the payments in the form of credit.
Comfortable Atmosphere- a visit to a retail store appears to be more soothing for the
generation-Y. People and kids prefer to shop in an air conditioned a tech savvy
manner.
The retail industry is the second largest employer in India. It currently employs about
7 percent of the total labor force in India. Finance Minister P. Chidambaram's recent
statement “salaries ought not to be legislated” is a welcome move as most of the
organized retail is in private hands. However only about 4.6% of the total retail trade
is in organized sector. It generates about Rs.55, 000 crore ($12.4 billion). The major
and minor players desperately need to work hard in this direction so that next time the
figures look more decent. The government must also make an attempt to ameliorate
the situation as political instability and infrastructure namely power and roads are the
major roadblocks in the path of smooth functioning of the market.
China - The total sales from retail market in China reached US$755 billion in 2005. However
organized retailing in China accounts for only 20% of it. Also the fragmentation of China's
retail market is so high that top 100 retailers make up for only 10.5% of the total market. The
registered sales of department stores grew by 25.7% and that of convenience stores grew by
36.5% in 2005. The Chinese retail market is expected to reach new highs as the population of
strong middle class is expected to double by 2020 and mergers and acquisitions among
retailers are3 going in great guns. The WTO restrictions are also expected to have a favorable
impact on its retail sector.
Japan - total annual sales for the Japanese retail industry for 2003 amounted to JPY 133,273
11
billion. Japan had 1.2 million retail establishments in June 2004 and there were 42,738
specialty superstores. Between 2002 and 2004 annual sales per store increased by 3.8%. The
growth was mainly driven by the grocery superstores but the number of superstores
specializing in clothes gradually came down. The organized retail sector in Japan couldn't
perform at its full efficiency because of collapse of the 'bubble economy' in the early 90s.
The distribution sector bridges the gap between the producer and consumer and thus forms a
crucial link. Distribution of retail in India has multiple dimensions. Its uniformity is difficult
to decide and easy to argue. Distribution in any sector is usually measured by the reach of its
products to people. But in case of the retail sector in India it also implies the dispersion
among the organized and unorganized spheres. The question of distribution hovers mainly
around the intentions of private players to reach out to the less rich people. But the point that
has caught the public eye recently is the ambiguous mood of the beneficiaries and the
chauvinist government that produces civil service.
The expansion of the retailing in India has been magnificent especially after the advent of
liberalization and the abolition of licensing. A comparative study with other developed
countries indicates that the retail sector has achieved a fantastic breakthrough in the Indian
economy. India topped the A.T. Kearney's Global Retail Index in both 2005 and 2006as can
be seen below:
12
Japan is 57% and China is 39%. Also Indians tend to exhaust 40% of their consumer
spending on groceries (foodstuffs). These figures are intensified by the fact that Indians have
special preference for lifestyle products and they feel comfortable in buying against credit as
the credit card and mortgage market has been growing by more than 30%.
We present the results from another survey below in order to strengthen our findings.
The above table reinforces our view that India has done a great job in retailing. One
noteworthy point here is that Japan in spite of being one of the most densely populated
countries has fared poorly than India. But this euphoria loses its charm if we compare the
percentage of organized retail in the total value generated by the retailing sector.
Studies have further showed that non-urban areas account for only about 15% of organized
retailing So it is high time that the retail industries pay importance to diversification and
reach out to non-urban markets. If they remain confined to the metropolis then they will soon
13
hit a ceiling and will be able to grow no more. But at the same time they must realize that the
rustic people are sceptic about the urbane lifestyle habits. The mega retail players will have to
drop their policy of full extraction of consumer surplus and will have to employ the local
people to overcome the myth that entry of a branded retail will displace the millions of
traders, shopkeepers and hawkers. Protests must be welcomed and meetings encouraged
making life saner.
Retail markets in Germany, South Africa and many other countries allow 100% foreign
investment in retail. This has helped in setting up of cash and in creating wholesale markets.
However, in India, only 51% FDI is allowed in single-brand retail and that too with prior
approval. In case of multi-brand retail, FDI is completely prohibited. This is a perfect
beginning but foreign investment should be gradually liberalized to modernize farming and
help farmers scale up. Moreover, restricting FDI for protecting mom-and-pop stores seems
unjustifiable since Tata, Reliance and Bharti have already made a foray in the sector.
14
Components of Retail Sector
Food and Grocery, Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCGs), Consumer Durables, Apparel,
Footwear and leather, Watches, Jewellery, and Health and Beauty
The anatomy of the retail market has shown that the clothing and textiles constitutes 39 per
cent of the organised retail pie, followed by food and grocery, which accounts for 11 percent
of the total retail market.
However, according to the survey conducted by KPMG for Federation of Indian Chamber of
Commerce and Industry (FICCI), among these, the food and grocery is expected to witness
the fastest growth followed by clothing as the second-fastest growing segment.
15
Marketing Strategies
Types of strategies
Marketing strategies may differ depending on the unique situation of the individual business.
However there are a number of ways of categorizing some generic strategies. A brief
description of the most common categorizing schemes is presented below:
Strategies based on market dominance - In this scheme, firms are classified based on
their market share or dominance of an industry. Typically there are four types of
market dominance strategies:
o Leader
o Challenger
o Follower
o Nicher
Porter generic strategies - strategy on the dimensions of strategic scope and strategic
strength. Strategic scope refers to the market penetration while strategic strength
refers to the firm’s sustainable competitive advantage. The generic strategy
framework (porter 1984) comprises two alternatives each with two alternative scopes.
16
These are Differentiation and low-cost leadership each with a dimension of Focus-
broad or narrow.
o Product differentiation
o Market segmentation
Innovation strategies - This deals with the firm's rate of the new product development
and business model innovation. It asks whether the company is on the cutting edge of
technology and business innovation. There are three types:
o Pioneers
o Close followers
o Late followers
Growth strategies - In this scheme we ask the question, “How should the firm grow?”.
There are a number of different ways of answering that question, but the most
common gives four answers:
o Horizontal integration
o Vertical integration
o Diversification
o Intensification
17
DIVISION OF RETAILERS IN INDIA
The retail sector in India can be divided into two major categories:
1) Organized
2) Unorganized
18
Company profile
Spencer
19
Spencer’s Retail Limited, part of RP Sanjiv Goenka Group, is a multi-format retailer
providing a wide range of quality products across categories such as food, personal care,
fashion, home essentials, electrical and electronics to its key consumers. Specialty sections
such as Spencer’s Gourmet, Patisserie, Wine and Liquor, and the recently launched
Epicuisine section are some of the key differentiators in our hypermarket stores.
Spencer’s, being one of the earliest entrants into the retail space in India, introduced the
Indian consumer to the concept of organized retailing. The first ever hypermarket in India
was launched by Spencer’s in Hyderabad in 2000. Today, Spencer’s runs 120 stores,
including 37 Hyper stores in over 35 cities in India.
Spencer’s brand positioning – Makes Fine Living Affordable – embodies its philosophy of
delighting shoppers with the best products and services that enable a fine living at reasonable
prices, while providing them with a warm, friendly and educational retail environment.
Since 1863, Spencer’s has been a part of the Indian retail landscape. At one time, the
Spencer’s Empire stretched from Peshawar to Cochin, from Karachi to Chittagong, spanning
the length and width of undivided India. Originally owned by a British gentleman – yes, there
was a Mr. Spencer (John William Spencer, to be precise) – it acquired Indian ownership in
the 1960s, and became part of the RPG Group in 1989.
In 1995, RPG Enterprises, the flagship company of the RPG Group, launched 'Foodworld' as
a joint venture with Hong-Kong based Dairy Farm International. The joint venture, which
operated supermarkets under thename 'Foodworld' and hypermarkets under the name 'Giant',
was terminated in 2006. RPG retained 48 of the 93 stores it owned. These were re-furbished
and their launch under the brand name, Spencer’s, kicked off a new phase in both the history
of the Spencer’s brand, and retail in India.
Since inception Spencer’s has been a consumer-centric brand, constantly innovating,
pioneering formats, evolving over time but always keeping consumer needs and satisfaction
center-stage. Back in 1920, we were the first grocery chain in India. In 1980, we became the
20
first supermarket chain, and in 2001, we introduced India to the joys of hypermarket
shopping.
What has remained unchanged for 150 years is the trust that the Spencer’s brand evokes. To
the consumer, it carries the promise of innovation, quality, and service; the confidence that
they will always be able to find a Spencer’s store at a convenient location; that it will have a
pleasant ambience; and that it will offer a wide range of products at affordable prices.
As a pioneer in organized food retailing in India, the modern-day Spencer’s Retail started
operations back in the early 1990s in South India. Today, it has over 135 stores spread across
over 40 cities in India.
Differentiators
Spencer’s has chosen to differentiate by establishing itself as the preferred shopping
destination for young customers looking for a range of quality products that allows them to
indulge in a global lifestyle, yet at affordable prices. It’s brand image of - Makes Fine Living
Affordable stands - testimony to this philosophy. From daily to weekly to specialty shopping,
Spencer’s strives to fulfill every need and provide maximum convenience.
21
Specifically, the following distinguish the Spencer’s brand and create a memorable all-
encompassing shopping experience for its shoppers:
Products – Spencer’s offers the widest assortment of food and lifestyle (fashion,
home, entertainment), dealing both, with brands and private labels. It has different
special sections within it’s hypermarkets to delight the customer
Quality – Quality is a major reason why Spencer’s is well-regard by it’s shoppers.
Spencer’s lays a huge emphasis on all-round quality in products, stores, service
standards, and customer engagement programs. It’s “Quality since 1863” tagline has
stood the test of time.
Heritage – Spencer’s is India’s oldest retailer tracing its roots back to1863. The brand
has many firsts to it’s credits.
Innovations/Specialty – In Spencer’s hypermarkets, the shopper can find specialty
sections such as a live bakery, the patisserie, a nut’s counter, a dedicated wine & liquor
section, and Epicuisine.
Promotions – Spencer’s seek to offer the right products at the right time at the right
price, with promotions carefully designed to suit the needs and wants of the consumers
monthly, weekly and daily shopping basket.
Brand Imagery – Spencer’s stores have contemporary and international interiors, and
it's extensively trained staff strive to make customers feel at home while they shop, with
a welcoming and trusted attitude.
Own Brands
Spencer’s own brands, commonly referred to as private label, offer a wide range of
products ranging from food to personal care to fashion to home utility items.
Spencer’s Smart Choice, Tasty Wonders, Clean Home and Maroon are some of its
own brands which host a varied choice that caters to the need of a modern household.
The Spencer’s own brands cover a lot of articles in the food space, including rice,
pulses, whole spices, dry fruits and nuts, sauces, instant noodles, breakfast cereals,
honey, breads, beverage, wafers, pickles, jams and cookies. Spencer’s is mindful of
catering to local tastes, and therefore its vegetable and fruit pickles are customized to
regional flavors as well. It’s personal care range includes items such as face wipes,
tissues, baby needs, and hand wash, while it’s home care range includes detergents,
dishwashing soaps, toilet cleaners and floor cleaners. Maroon is another of it's own
22
brands, which provides premium home care solutions. From cooking to serving,
Maroon is your complete kitchen partner. Its assortment includes premium storage
and kitchen utensils, beautifully designed melamine ware, and foil wraps. There are
also smart backpacks and convenient travel accessories that Spencer’s sells through its
private label brands.
In the fashion and apparel space, Spencer’s offers both contemporary and classic
looks through its own brands, which cater to casualwear, loungewear, leisurewear,
formal-wear, and accessories such as leather items, casual jewellery and footwear.
Some of the popular private label brands are Island Monks, Mark Nicolas, Asankhya,
Scorez, La Bonita and Island Monks Kids.
Overall, the Spencer’s private brand ties into its positioning of Makes Fine Living
Affordable, and therefore all the products are conveniently priced and promise great
quality.
What we Sell -
Food
23
A wide assortment for breakfast solutions, easy to cook or ready to eat meal solutions,
regular or diet food, organic assortment, the best of worlds cheeses, deli and cuisines
hailing from all parts of the world is available under one roof at Spencer’s
Together with our specially selected suppliers and food producers, we're committed to
providing you the freshest and best quality of fruits and vegetables in both regular and
exotic variants. We ensure that the produce is sourced responsibly and is of the
Personal Care
Look good and feel good with Spencer’s at the personal care section which offers
solutions to all your beauty and personal hygiene needs. This section offers a wide
range of national and international products that is of utmost importance for a healthy
and youthful lifestyle.
Beauty
24
Highlight your best features with the great range of beauty products available at
Spencer’s beauty counters. We offer the best choices in eyeliners, kohl, lip color, nail
art and other beauty products that accentuates your beauty. Whether you choose to
stand out amongst all or seamlessly gel with the masses our make-up and beauty
products will help you look good at all times.
Home
Home Decor
25
Give your home the makeover you want. Step into a Spencer’s store and be prepared to be
wowed by our collection of Home décor products for your living room, dining and bedrooms.
From minimalistic to ultra-modern, our wide variety of Home and General merchandise will
cater to the very look you’re after. Utility furnitures – sofa sets, bean bags, closets and
cabinets, center and side tables, wardrobes, study table, ironing tables – you will find them all
under one roof.
BUY HOME DÉCOR PRODUCTS ONLINE
Home furnishings
Bathroom essentials
Kitchen essentials
Dining Essentials
Travel needs
26
Big bazaar
Big Bazaar is an Indian retail store that operates as a chain of hypermarkets, discount
department stores, and grocery stores. The retail chain was founded by Kishore Biyani under
27
his parent organisation Future Group,[3] which is known for having a significant prominence
in Indian retail and fashion sectors. Big Bazaar is also the parent chain of Food Bazaar,
Fashion at Big Bazaar (abbreviated as fbb) and eZone where at locations it houses all under
one roof, while it is sister chain of retail outlets like Brand Factory, Home Town, Central,
eZone, etc.
Founded in 2001, Big Bazaar is one of the oldest and largest hypermarkets chain of India,
housing about 250+ stores in over 120 cities and towns across the country.
History[edit]
Big Bazaar was founded in 2001 by Kishore, the founder and chief executive officer (CEO)
of the parent company, the Future Group.
Popular Indian actress Asin and the then-Captain of Indian cricket team, Mahendra Singh
Dhoni have previously endorsed for the fashion vertical of Big Bazaar
Big Bazaars journey began in October 2001, when the young, first generation entrepreneur
Kishore Biyani opened the countrys first hypermarket retail outlet in Kolkatta (then Calcutta).
In the same month, two more stores were added one each in Hyderabad and Mumbai, thus
starting on a successful sojourn which began the chapter of organized retailing in India.
Speaking on this momentous occasion and remembering the days of conceptualising the
hypermarket idea Mr. Kishore Biyani said, We initially decided to name the format as Bazaar
because we had designed the store keeping the Indian mandi style in mind. Since the size of
the hypermarket was big than an average mandis, the thought came to name it as Big
Bazaar.However, we had freezed on the punch line Isse Se Sasta Aur Achha Kahi Nahi much
before we met the creative agency to design the final logo of Big Bazaar.
Though, Big Bazaar was started purely as a fashion format including apparel, cosmetics,
accessory and general merchandise, the first Food Bazaar format was added as Shop-In-Shop
within Big Bazaar in the year 2002. Today, Big Bazaar, with its wide range of products and
service offering, reflects the aspirations of millions of Indians.
The journey of Big Bazaar can be divided into two phases one pre and the other post January
26th, 2005, when the company rewrote the retail chapter in India, with the introduction of a
never-before sales campaign Sasbe Sasta Din. In just one day, almost the whole of India
28
descended at various Big Bazaar stores in the country to shop at their favourite shopping
destination.
Further, what followed was the time and again rewriting of the Indian Retail experience,
wherein understanding of the Indian consumers reflected in the products and services offered,
creating innovative deals, expanding in the tier II and tier III towns, tying up with branded
merchandise to offer exclusive products and services to its customers.
Big Bazaar is present today in 59 cities and occupying over 5 million sq.ft. retail space and
driving over 110 million footfalls into its stores. The format is expecting the number of
footfall in the storesto increase by over 140 million by this financial year. Over the years, Mr.
Biyani for his vision and leadership, and Big Bazaar for its unique proposition to its
customers, have received every prestigious consumer awards both nationally and
internationally.
Says Rajan Malhotra, President, Strategy & Convergence, Big Bazaar, What is important in
our journey is not the number of stores, but the customers faith in us. Its the India and the
Indians, which have helped us, reach this feat in such a short time span and today our country
is creating a history in the World organized Retail.
Rajan Malhotra, who is also the first employee of Big Bazaar, joining the organization in
early 2001 adds, Since beginning, we have kept Big Bazaar as a soft brand, which reflects the
India and the Indianess. We believed in growing with the society, participating and
celebrating all regional and local community festivals, giving customers preferences above
everything else.
29
OBJECTIVE
Objectives of Study
30
1. To Study the promotional strategies of SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
2. To study the challenges and future prospects of SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
3. To study the different Brand offerings by SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
4. To study the distribution strategies of SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
5. To study the market comparison of SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
6. To study the customer choosing priority for the SPENCER& BIGBAZAR.
31
Scope
Scope of study
32
This project gave us great exposure to the customer’s perception to the marketing strategies
adopted by the SPENCER & BIGBAZAR because it includes the service offered by them.
The study also identifies the attitudes and preference of the consumers. The study also
focused on Media through which the product reaches the consumers this project helped us in
knowing the market practically.
33
34
RESEARCH
METHODOLOGY
35
Research Methodology
Research Methodology is a way to systematically solve the research problem. When we talk
to research methodology we not only talk of research methods but also consider the logic
behind the method we use in the context of our research results are capable of being
evaluated either by researcher himself or by other.
36
The purpose of this section is to describe the methodology carried out to complete the work.
The methodology plays a dominant role in any research work. The effectiveness of any
research work depends upon the correctness and effectiveness of the research methodology.
This section deals with research design used, data collection, methods used and sampling
methods used.
Research design
A research design specifies the methods and procedures for conducting a particular research.
According to Ker linger “Research design is a plan, structure and strategy of investigation
conceived so as to obtain answers to research questions and have to control variance.”
My research design
I have chosen descriptive research design for my study because I am interested in knowing
the marketing strategies adopted by Spencer& BIGBAZAR
To accomplish the predefined objectives of the research, descriptive research design is used
to collect the require information from the sources. It’s a fact finding approach generalizing a
cross sectional study of the present situation.
Structured questionnaires and observation method have been used to conduct the research.
Sampling method
37
Specific sampling method was used to collect the data from the respondents because sample
size is large. Customers & employees of Spencer& BIGBAZAR were selected for the survey.
Sampling unit
The data was collected from the Customers & employees by questionnaire and observation
method in the Spencer(Crown Interiors Mall) & BIGBAZAR (sec-31.faridabad)
Sample size
50 customers
50 employees
Data collection:
Primary data
Secondary data
Primary data collection is used when there is need for collecting first hand data. In such
cases, no adequate and usable data is available to the researcher.
Secondary data collection is used where adequate and usable data is available to researcher.
Primary data collection by one person may become secondary data for another.
In my research study I have used both primary as well as secondary data collection method.
For primary data observation method is used, and for secondary data the sources used are
books, journals, magazines and Internet.
Data analysis
All the recommendations in this project have been suggested keeping in mind the thorough
analysis of all the steps in recruitment process.
38
The method used for the survey process is through questionnaire.
39
Data Collection
And
Analysis
40
4) Customer gratification
There exists a blanket customer relationship programme called the reliance one membership
programme for the purpose of maintaining customer loyalty. The membership programme is a
very simple one where a willing customer is required to fill a form giving personal
information and he gets a temporary card which will be made permanent after six months.
On each purchase of rs. 100 the customer gets one redeemable point on the production of
card at billing counter. The collected points can be redeemed in form of discounts on future
purchases on demand of the customer.
The customers also get the opportunity of availing four different kinds of insurance on the
payment of a nominal fee. For example a customer can get an accidental death insurance of rs
six lacs on the payment of rs. 400 only.
Other forms of insurances are disability, hospitalization and home insurances.
The members of reliance one get the opportunity of taking part and winning prizes by the
way of lucky draws on regular intervals.
Customer retention policy implementation is at the zonal level. Generally each state is
regarded as a zone and the offers and discounts in a zone are not available in other zones.
Such policy helps reliance retail to understand and capture the local markets better.
The products which show improvement due to offers and discounts on them are repeated with
these offers again so as to retain the sales of the customers who bought it the last time.
Also such the day’s best offers are constantly announced in the store making the regular
customers aware about them.
Maintaining a good store ambiance is also a part of customer retention policy of reliance
retail. Clean and hygienic environment with properly and well spaced products along with a
uniform color theme attracts the existing customers to the store again and again.
A fast billing system and good and easy grievance handling system which can be accessed
thru customer service desk and company website, ensures that customers feel satisfied with
the store management. Less harassment to customers means better customer retention.
Communication to existing customers takes the form of sms and e-mails, generally sent to
reliance one members. They get information about ongoing offers and also information and
latest news about their nearest stores and the company in general.
41
Another source of customer database is the information collected during the organizing of
special events in the stores. Customers participating in such events provide their contact
information which are also used in form of database for communication purposes.
Thank you and festive cards on special occasions are an innovative way of communicating
with the customers.
Trained salespersons make customer gratification very easy. A simple thank you with a smile
goes a long way for the store to keep the customers happy.
The special events organized by the stores across india are also a way to gratify the customers
by allowing them to play and win prizes.
Gift vouchers and discount coupons are an attraction for the customers and give them the feel
that the store cares about them and their money.
Local customers many a times make limited personal contacts with the store staff just like
that made at a kirana store and help the store to some extent to maintain a relationship with
the customers.
The implementation of the policies brings out certain limitations in them. Few major ones are
as follows
The personal contact numbers of reliance one members are open to tele marketing calls from
various marketers as they leak out of the reliance retail’s database, causing unnecessary
harassment to customers.
The customer communication policy is less followed in small towns and cities and is more
concentrated towards the metro cities.
There is a common crm policy for both reliance fresh and mart. This should not be the case as
both the stores offer different kinds of merchandize and generally attract different kinds of
customers.
Reliance retail generally delays the processing of permanent membership cards to those
customers who have not paid for such a card. Customers have been waiting for over three
months for their card. Those who have paid the nominal fee of rs. 50 get their permanent card
within 15 days but the rest who have optioned not to pay the fees do not receive the card until
too late.
Unmanned billing counters create long queues at the open counters. This creates impatiens in
the customers as they expect faster billing at the stores and do not want to stand with too
much of goods held in their hands while billing.
42
CRM @ BIGBAZAR
43
Differentiate customers in terms of: (1) their needs and (2) their value to company.
Interact with individual customers to improve the knowledge about individual needs
and to build stronger relationships.
There are four type of analysis done for analysis of CRM
o Periodic Surveys: It’s done on quarterly, its an overall survey done by the
future group authorities and CRM is a part of it.
o Customer Loss Rate :
o Mystery Shoppers: They pose as normal customers perform specific tasks—
such as purchasing a product, asking questions, registering complaints or
behaving in a certain way – and then provide detailed reports or
feedback about their experiences
o Monitor Competitive Performance
44
Formulating A Solution -- solution is made to be consistent with established
customer relations policy and important criteria are taken into account:
o Contractual and/or warranty obligations;
o The customer's expectations;
o expectations of the customer;
o The cost/benefit of alternative solutions;
o The probability and cost of customer seeking redress in some other way;
o The comprehensiveness and fairness of solution;
o ability to perform the solution; and
o What to do if the customer rejects solution.
Responding -- The response is made clear and appropriate. The customer must
understand the response, and the response must address the issues raised in the
customer's original complaint.
An explanation of decision preserves the goodwill of customer, even if the decision
itself is adverse
45
SWOT ANALYSIS
46
BIGBAZAR
47
Strength:
Weakness:
Opportunity:
Threat:
SPENCER
48
Strengths:
High quality,
latest in-style products,
international shopping experience
value for money pricing
loyal following
Own brand of merchandise, which is both trendy and individualistic.
new introductions every week
variety of designs and styles
exciting mix with a range extending from stylized clothes, footwear and accessories
for men, women and children to well-co-coordinated table linens, artefacts, home
accessories and furnishings.
Well-designed interiors, sprawling space, prime locations, lovely coffee shops add to
the customers’ shopping experience.
Weakness:
OPPORTUNITIES:
49
They also have the opportunity to consider more overseas supplier which will actually
give them cost advantage, rather than suppliers available on a local level.
They also have the opportunity to maximize the use of available technology to
improve their functioning and to gain competitive advantage.
Threats:
– If the unorganized retailers are put together, they are parallel to a large supermarket
with no or little overheads, high degree of flexibility in merchandise, display, prices
and turnover.
– Shopping Culture: Shopping culture has not developed in India as yet. Even now
malls are just a place to hang around with family and friends and largely confined to
Window-shopping.
– Cultural Variation leads to variation in merchandise in India at different geographical
locations.
– Competition from future group and various other retail stores which are growing
rapidly.
INDIAN CONSUMERISM
50
The lifestyle and profile of the Indian consumer is going through a rapid transformation. The
population of India is young, energetic and full of enthusiasm. 50% of the Indian
population is under the age of 25. There has been a transition from price consideration to
quality and design, as the focus of the customer has changed. The upper and middle-
class population of today needs a feel good experience even if they have to spend a little
more for that. People are moving towards luxury and want to experiment with fashion
and technology. There is an increasing need of better apparels, cars, mobile phones and
consumer durables.
The food & grocery, clothing, consumer durables and books & music sectors are the major
retail sectors. However, unorganized small outlets largely control the sector. Hence there is
tremendous potential for the organized sector in various formats, such as hypermarkets,
supermarkets, specialty stores, category killers and discount chains.
ANALYSIS
51
Q1) What Retail chain do you usually go to?
Reliance mart
BIGBAZAR
Any other
The observation shows that 44 % of people out of 100 person surveyed prefer to go to
BIGBAZAR and only 38 % & 18% prefer to go Spencer& any other retail outlet respectively.
52
Twice in a month
Thrice in a month
The observation shows that 42 % of people out of 100 person surveyed visits retail stores
once in a month and only 38 % & 20% visits the retail stores twice & thrice in a month
respectively.
53
The observation shows that 52 % of people out of 100 people surveyed spend Rs 2500-7500
on shopping in a month. There are only 5% people who spend more then 12500 on shopping
out of 100 people surveyed.
54
The observation shows that 49 % of people out of 100 people surveyed spend 1-2 hours in
shopping mart and 30 % people spend ½-1 hour on shopping at retail store. There are only 9
% people who spend more than 2 hours at shopping mart.
55
The observation shows that 51 % of people out of 100 people surveyed goes along with 2-4
person for shopping & there are only 4 % people who goes for shopping along with more
than four persons...
Q6) Please rate the following, according to your personal choice, for both Spencer&
BIGBAZAR….
56
Questions Reliance mart BIGBAZAR
Accessories 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Household 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Lifestyle 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
57
Accessories 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Household 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Lifestyle 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
58
Behaviour 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Manners 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Helpfulness 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Service 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
59
Promotional offers 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Variety of products 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Billing Problems 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
60
Heavy Rush 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Personnel’s lack of
knowledge 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
61
People 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Ambience 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
62
Findings
Findings
1. The choice of a store location has a profound effect on the entire business life of a
retail operation. A bad choice may all but guarantee failure, a good choice, and
success.
2. Choosing a retail location is, at best, a risky undertaking. Considering the
63
consequences of choosing a location that proves to be unsuitable, it pays to get as
much assistance as possible. According to a survey more than 60% of the customer
prefers to shop in a retail store which is easily accessible to them.
3. Advertising plays a very important role in achieving growth for any retail company.
This is evident from the fact that Advertising by Retail Industry registered a rise of 14
percent during January - May 2009 over January - May 2008.
4. The right location, trained manpower, software assistance, product with a distinct
differentiation, a strong value proposition, efficient supply chain management - these
are the factors that influence the success of a retail outlet. With competition in this
segment increasing, differentiation and a strong value proposition assume
significance. Retail chains are realizing that they cannot be another ‘me-too’ store.
The differentiation today among the 5-6 retail chains has come through private labels,
which in some cases account for as much as 70 per cent of the total merchandise in
the outlet.
5. Variety offered by any retail store is of very much important to attract all type of
customers in the stores. A large variety of products caters to each segment of
customers.
6. Shopping experience within a store also has a great impact on selecting a product
from a particular retail store. Overall ambience includes infrastructure facilities
provided by the store such as air conditioners, lighting etc.
7. Pricing is in fact a dramatic controller of at least 3 key strategic elements to any
company's success: Company’s image, the product and services company sells and
consumer behavior. The Importance of Pricing their Products' will give them an
insight into developing appropriate costing methods and the impact of getting it
wrong in today's competitive creative market. This topic should be of interest to
anyone who is unsure if they are getting it right. Remember the difference between
over or under-pricing their work can mean a very short future for any business.
Approximately 60% customers think that Price is the most important factor while they
go for shopping in a retail stores
8. Quality in everyday life and business, engineering and manufacturing has a pragmatic
interpretation as the non-inferiority, superiority or usefulness of something. This is the
most common interpretation of the term. The quality of a product or service refers to
the perception of the degree to which the product or service meets the customer's
expectations. Quality has no specific meaning unless related to a specific function
64
and/or object. Quality is a perceptual, conditional and somewhat subjective attribute.
And in addition to that, more than 90% of customers place quality as the most
important factor than anything else in the list to shop in a retail store.
9. More than 70% of customers place variety as an important factor to shop in a
particular retail store.
10. Brands name bears an important role while shopping of any type of goods. So
building a brand for a retail store is important as 80% of customer still prefer to buy
branded clothes in the retail store instead of local or unbranded clothes.
65
LIMITATION OF THE
STUDY
LIMITATION
Although it would have been nice to conduct a perfect research study, but this study is
conducted under certain limitations, which were faced while doing this research. So it is
highly recommended to consider these limitations while going through the project study.
66
These limitations are as follows
1. LIMITATION OF DATA
The statistical data regarding the city was not available to us on secondary source of
data and to generate such data on the primary source was a task, which cannot be
achieved in such a short time.
2. LIMITATION OF TIME
The limitation of time was another constraint in the study as the study had to be
conducted in few months therefore many aspects have been left unexplored.
Research period is not just much enough to know fully about the strategies &
consumers perception
The respondents did not reply the question with precision as they were busy with their
own work or they were not interested in taking part in such a research. Employees
sometimes feel hesitated while telling about their view about their marketing
strategies.
The research has been conducted for the BIGBAZAR(sec-31.fbd) & reliance
mart(Crown Interiors Mall, Faridabad) but not all their retail outlet have been covered
therefore it has been mentioned that the research has been conducted in a limited area.
The sample size taken of the respondents is large therefore a very rough picture of
their marketing strategies has been generated therefore this limitation has to be
considered in the study.
67
These limitations were very common and yet we came across these with a positive note and
the subsequent chapters in this report shall explain the rationality behind the structural
compilation.
68
Conclusion
&
Suggestions
Conclusion
Given the developments and prospects, the Indian retail sector is in its nascent stage of
evolution. While there are obstacles, there are clear opportunities in modern retailing in India.
There are many lessons that India can take from other countries, which have moved along the
path of retail evolution. The retail sector has proved to be of immense significant from
69
macro-economic point of view. The sector’s capability to give strong growth momentum by
creating multiplier effects on other sectors is not in dispute. It is now necessary to cautiously
expand and develop the sector, as the government, at present, has done by permitting partial
FDI in the sector. Given the scope, the retail sector is certainly expected to fetch the long-
term economic benefits for the country.
The convenience and personalized service offered by the unorganized sector holds its future
in good stead for the future. Organized retail of late has seen a tremendous boom and is
attracting more people to the malls.
What is to be seen is how organized retail can duplicate the same level of personalized
customer service levels offered by the unorganized sector to have a higher conversion ratio.
The target audience for both the organized and unorganized retail formats remains relatively
the same. When shopping in malls, people value the experience related to the trip the most
and return most frequently for the same. Besides, while enjoying the experience they seem to
buy high ticket and items of conspicuous consumption most frequently.
Gaining and maintaining consumer preference is a battle that is never really won.
Continued and consistent branding initiatives that reinforce the consumer’s purchase decision
will, over time, land the product in consumer preference sets. Attaining and sustaining
preference is an important step on the road to gaining brand loyalty
Suggestions
1. Include more trained sales person to help customers in the store while shopping.
2. Improve quality of the products especially clothes.
3. Play good songs or soothing music in the store rather than cheap filmy songs.
4. Customer care service can be introduced
70
5. More branded products can be displayed in the store as people still prefer branded
clothes than offered by local vendors.
6. Constant reminder of discounts through pamphlets, speakers inside the store for
inducing consumers for impulse buying.
7. Add more cosmetic products as its having a huge market of consumers attached to it.
8. Display of product should be improved so that the product is easily visible to the
consumers.
9. Proper advertisement in press and outdoor to make BIGBAZAR should be visible in
the eyes of consumers.
10. Should have parking spaces in front of every store.
11. Hire more salesgirls as in ladies section its very difficult for both the consumers and
salesman to interact with each other.
12. Regular training to sales person to improve there overall performance.
13. Customization of clothing should be given an important consideration.
14. Proper packaging and provide contrast labelling in displays of product.
15. Should apply electronic supply chain management for better inventory management.
16. Proper power back up as air conditioners are not working to their full capacity at
many stores.
17. Proper placements of Gondola in the stores as space between them are very less.
18. Proper display in the gondola and top most rack of the gondola should be used for
storing of inventory rather than display of product.
19. Should provide more festival schemes and at proper time.
20. Should use psychological pricing-more discounts by increasing the price
21. Proper display of cutlery items
22. Clothes should be in sync with fashion.
71
Bibliography
72
BIBILIOGRAPHY
Books referred:
73
Retailing Management
Pradhan, Swapna
Websites:
www.google.com
www.wikipedia.com
www.vishalmegamart.com
www.reliancemart.com
www.indianretailindustry.com
74
QUESTIONNAIRE
75
QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear Sir/Madam,
Name:
Age:
Profession:
Sex:
76
1-2 hours
Over 2 hours
Q6) Please rate the following, according to your personal choice, for both Spencer&
BIGBAZAR….
Accessories 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Household 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Lifestyle 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Accessories 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
77
Household 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Lifestyle 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Behaviour 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Manners 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Helpfulness 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Service 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Promotional offers 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
78
Variety of products 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Billing Problems 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Heavy Rush 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Personnel’s lack of
knowledge 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
79
Products
1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
People 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
Ambience 1 3 4 4 5
2 5 1 2 3
80