Cybersecurity:

moving from
anchor to enabler
of innovation

Insights on governance, risk

and compliance
 1

Disruption is unleashing value —

but also new risks

2 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

Section 1

The digital and FinTech-driven disruption

and transformation of financial services
continues — but at what price?
Today, technology-driven innovation is transforming financial services
(FS) — enabling firms to create new products and services, enhance access
From naysayer to enabler
and experiences for customers, strengthen controls and drive down costs.
As banks and other financial services firms define their digital strategies, At root, our view is that
their operations are becoming ever more integrated into an evolving and
at times poorly understood cyber environment: a connected ecosystem
the cybersecurity and
of entities, people, machines and data, where mobile and social channels digital communities need
are increasingly used to conduct transactions that touch core financial to come together, with a
systems.
shared focus on facilitating
This means organizational perimeters are quickly disappearing. So, we’ve
and enabling business
succeeded in opening up new avenues of cost-saving, agility and speed-to-
market. But at what price? outcomes. In all too many
This question is important — because confidence and trust in financial
organizations, cybersecurity
services firms and their offerings depend critically on robust assurance personnel are perceived as
that transactions, data and systems are safe to use and secure, protect the people whose instinctive
users’ information and have integrity. But digital transformation, while vital
to maintaining relevance with today’s customers, introduces new risks and
reply to a question is “No,
potential weaknesses for institutions looking to innovate. Jumping head- because ... .” They need to
first into the digital “deep end” without sufficient focus on cybersecurity become the people known
adds a level of risk that traditional teams and methodologies may be ill-
equipped to address.
for saying “Yes, and ... .”
This apparently simple
Striking the right balance between regulation, privacy, digital and
switch from naysayer to
cybersecurity
enabler would do as much
Furthermore, building value successfully in the digital domain in financial
services demands a fine balance between regulation, privacy, digital as anything else to bring
and cybersecurity. And a focus on preventing cyber threats has at times cybersecurity into the fold.
delayed or impacted firms’ digital innovation efforts.

This is one reason why cybersecurity — rightly or wrongly — has at times

been seen as drag on digital innovation. For firms to turn it into a positive
enabler, they first need to check that they are striking the right balance
between regulation, privacy, digital and cybersecurity when designing and
developing new services.

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 3

 Section 1
The digital and FinTech-driven disruption and transformation
of financial services continue — but at what price?

Cybersecurity must be integrated into put firms in a better position to defend their
digital innovation teams ... offerings against cyber threats and become
trusted digital providers with their customers —
How can they achieve this? A vital step is to
an increasingly vital status amid today’s
close the current gap between digital and
FinTech-led disruption and competition.
cyber teams, which often effectively operate
as separate functions. Digital teams tend As highlighted in a recent EY research report,
to be quite clearly defined and delineated, the global FinTech industry is growing apace,
as opposed to being integrated with cyber using technology innovation to capture market
capabilities in the up-front visioning and design share in many areas of financial services.2
phases. Cyber skills are then brought in as So the traditional financial services business
needed through toll gate-type reviews. model is being challenged where it matters
most: with customers. EY’s FinTech Adoption
This separation undermines the value of the
Index, based on a survey of more than 10,000
combined functions. Effective and embedded
individuals in six countries, shows that 33.1%
cybersecurity is the bedrock of any successful
of digitally active consumers in New York have
strategy for creating value from digital. In a
used at least two FinTech products in the past
study by Cisco1, 69% of executives indicated
six months3 — the highest figure in any urban
that they “are reluctant to innovate in areas
center in the study.
such as digital products and services because
of the perceived cybersecurity risks.” Such
The opportunities and challenges for
findings underline that uncoupling digital
FS firms
development from cybersecurity risks
impeding firms’ growth in the digital space. This shifting digital landscape presents
substantial opportunities for FS firms. But they
… to realize digital value in a FinTech- can only realize these opportunities if their
disrupted world digital services are underpinned by robust
and pervasive cybersecurity — which means
To avoid this risk, financial services
it should be built in at the beginning, not
organizations should embed cybersecurity
bolted on as an afterthought. For those firms
resources into their digital teams. By doing
that succeed in developing digitally enabled
this, they will gain the ability not only to
customer offerings that are compelling,
reduce cycle times by designing security
relevant, user-friendly and secure, the prize
from the start, but also to generate higher
on offer includes new and more profitable
value, by shifting the core rationale for
products and services, new economic models,
cybersecurity from preventing breaches to
and the ability to engage more intimately
enabling innovation and growth. Closing the
and regularly with consumers across multiple
gap between cybersecurity and digital will also
channels.

1
”Cybersecurity as a Growth Advantage: Key Insights,” Cisco website, https://discover.cisco.com/en/us/security/whitepaper/cybersecurity.
2
Capital Markets: innovation and the FinTech landscape, EYGM Limited, 2016, http://www.ey.com/gl/en/industries/financial-services/
banking---capital-markets/ey-capital-markets-innovation-and-the-fintech-landscape
3
EY FinTech Adoption Index, EY website, http://www.ey.com/gl/en/industries/financial-services/ey-fintech-adoption-index

4 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

But for many financial services incumbents,
winning this prize means overcoming some
significant hurdles. Their existing core systems
infrastructure — often built up through years
of legacy architectures, add-ons and
workarounds — may lack the agility to adapt
quickly to new engagement models and a
single, omnichannel, real-time view of the
customer. But often, the biggest hurdle to
realizing digital value is culture. To drive
customer-focused innovation, firms need
people with high digital IQs who are adept
at working across multiple disciplines and
applying new approaches. This means moving
toward a controlled “fail-fast-and-move-on”
culture, and using techniques such as design
thinking, customer-centered journey mapping,
DevOps and new design/development
methods.

To make this change, financial services firms

must move away from a low tolerance to
all risks and adopt an approach based on
truly understanding risks, thinking through
appropriate mitigations, and being confident in
their decision-making. This involves a shift in
culture toward accepting a controlled failure as
“normal” when defining and refining solutions,
because more prototypes will get thrown in the
trash than make it to market. Such a mindset
may not fit easily with the embedded risk-
averse culture — and this is one reason why
many financial services firms are establishing
global innovation hubs with their own distinct
culture, resourcing and incentives.

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 5

 2

Trust is the bedrock of FS — and digital

offerings must foster trust, not erode it

6 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

Section 2

Customer needs are driving innovation

and disruption
Consumers’ rapid adoption of disruptive FinTech offerings reflects the
way these solutions combine transparency, capability and personalization Learning from e-commerce:
to meet customers’ needs on their own terms — thus building trust with
customers in ways that financial services firms have not previously creating digital trust with
achieved. Customer trust is the foundation of any financial services consumers takes more than
firm’s ability to operate, and it’s vital that nothing — including a lapse in
cybersecurity — is allowed to undermine that trust.
an SSL certificate
This heightened customer focus on cybersecurity is occurring at a time Online retailers grow consumer
when commercial customers are embracing consumer-focused digital trust by providing tools to help
innovation for their personal use, and seeking services that provide
similar functionality, capability and user experience in their work context.
shoppers make good decisions,
This shift means that customers will increasingly refuse to do business engaging in persistent, active
with a financial services provider that fails to offer a top-of-the-line user social conversations with their
experience, underpinned by effective yet seamless security that they feel
confident will protect them online.
customers, and providing as
much transparency as possible
To provide such an experience, incumbent financial services companies
must apply innovation to adapt, disrupt and reinvent their offerings and around things such as pricing
operations in ways that combine the right blend of functionality, ease and cost. Smart retailers
of use and cybersecurity. Firms across the industry are rising to the
understand that in order to
challenge by harnessing digital to drive transformation and new business
models, powered by advances in devices, channels, data, and platforms win in the marketplace, they
such as cloud and the Internet of Things (IoT). By leveraging these need to anticipate and then
innovations, financial services business are seeking to keep themselves
meet consumers’ needs even
relevant to their customers, create new value and build digital trust. These
efforts include rising investments in new digital products as well as front- before consumers themselves
and back-office operations, together with innovation programs in areas have become aware of them.
such as blockchain, robotics and augmented reality.
This requires advanced
The ultimate goal is to provide an intuitive and transparent yet secure personalization techniques
experience that builds digital trust among customers, thus supporting
the wider trust on which the business depends. Firms that achieve this
that meet today’s regulations
can make digital trust an integral part of their value proposition — an and expectations around
opportunity that further underlines why cybersecurity needs to be privacy, and depend critically
embedded into digital innovation. Financial services companies seeking to
build deep digital trust can draw some valuable lessons from e-commerce
on “opt-in” permission from
players (see information panel). Firms should also pay close attention their customers to share
to the ongoing convergence between security and privacy now being their data. All of this presents
driven by regulatory initiatives such as the European Union’s General Data
Protection Regulation (GDPR). The maturity levels around privacy vary
potentially valuable lessons for
widely between geographies — and concerns over privacy are a major financial services firms.
driver of government intervention and regulation, especially in developing
economies striving to catch up with more mature jurisdictions.

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 7

 Section 2
Customer needs are driving innovation and disruption

Technology can cut both ways these cutting-edge technologies need to infuse
cybersecurity concepts and practices through
While the opportunities in areas such as digital
their entire development life cycle, in order to
trust underline the benefits that technology
identity and mitigate these new risks as part of
can bring to financial services firms, it’s
their innovation process.
important to grasp that technology can
be a double-edged sword. All technologies Once again, these are important messages
have inherent weaknesses that may become that cybersecurity specialists are uniquely
more apparent as complexity grows and the placed to communicate to the business. And
availability of processing power expands. And as technology advances, cybersecurity risks
as institutions digitize increasing amounts of also change and evolve — potentially raising
their customer-facing processes and tools, challenges for existing ways of mitigating risks.
significant amounts of new technologies and Take encryption: throw enough processing
interactions are being introduced, each with power at it, and any encryption system can
their own weaknesses to be exploited. When eventually be broken. With the advent of
these technologies are presented on enterprise commercially available quantum computing,
and global scales, the potential attack surface the days of encryption may be numbered.
grows exponentially. Another risk is what the Information Security
Forum (ISF) calls “opaque algorithms.” In its
So, amid the hype, organizations shouldn’t
Threat Horizon 2019 report, the ISF highlights
put too much faith in the “next big thing,”
how companies’ use of algorithms to make
be it encryption, biometrics, robotic process
decisions in critical systems means they have
automation or blockchain. Crucially, many of
less visibility into how their systems function
the benefits technology offers to enterprises —
and interact, creating a lack of transparency
such as the massive processing power of
that poses information security risks.4
the cloud — are also accessible to criminals.
Organizations that successfully introduce

4
Threat Horizon 2019: Disruption. Distortion. Deterioration. Information Security Forum Limited, January 2017, https://www.
securityforum.org/research/threat-horizon-2on-deterioration

8 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 9
 3

A mindset focused on opportunities —

not barriers

10 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

Section 3

Positioning cybersecurity as a
business enabler
We’ve described an environment in which financial services firms are
driving digital innovation, continuing to build digital trust with customers Three steps to close the
and becoming increasingly enmeshed into digital ecosystems. However, as
they take these positive steps, the daily drip-feed of media stories about gap between digital and
cyber breaches is a constant worry. Senior executives in financial services cyber teams:
are all too aware that their organizations are targets of cyber adversaries
ranging from nation state-backed attackers to terrorists, and from • Embed cyber skills in
hacktivists to organized criminals. digital development teams
The ongoing proliferation of cyber threats has fed into a belief among from day one, rather than
CIOs across all industries that their cyber defenses are inadequate.
having them organized in a
EY’s 19th Global Information Security Survey 2016-17 — Path to cyber
resilience: Sense, resist, react — finds that 86% of CIOs surveyed say their separate silo
cybersecurity function does not fully meet their organization’s needs.5
This figure is down only slightly from 88% the previous year. The report
• Enable and empower cyber
comments: “Despite the steps organizations have taken, it is still not enough specialists to apply new
to deal with the worsening situation.” What’s clear is that the threats are methodologies in design
real and growing — and that the question is how to address them.
and development
Switching from a reactive stance ...
• Encourage the adoption
This blend of deep concerns and fast-expanding threats puts us at a
defining moment — one where cybersecurity professionals have a golden by the cyber team of
opportunity to step up and save the day. But this is proving difficult to a controlled, carefully
achieve in practice. Digital development projects involving a cybersecurity
managed “fail-fast” culture
layer often expose a stark contrast between the pace and agility of the
digital component and the slower-moving and more rigid methodology in the development and
on the cyber side. Instead of being on the front foot, the cybersecurity prototyping stages
community is back on its heels and remaining largely reactive in its stance.

It’s probably fair to say that as digital innovation forges ahead,

cybersecurity as a discipline is lagging behind. This failure to keep pace with
the advance of digital reflects two problems. First, the traditional thinking,
approach and organizational structures around cybersecurity are not
evolving quickly enough. And second, in financial services especially, the
cybersecurity function is at times left standing on the sidelines, watching
the rapid digital transformation that is underway at an enterprise level.

... to proactively riding the innovation wave

So, what can cybersecurity do to get more involved, support innovation
more effectively and proactively, and start to ride the digital wave? A
number of things — all centered around closing the gap with digital. Three
steps to achieve this are set out in the accompanying information panel.

5
Path to cyber resilience: Sense, resist, react, EYGM Limited, 2016, http://www.ey.com/Publication/vwLUAssets/ey-
path-to-cyber-resilience/$FILE/ey-path-to-cyber-resilience.pdf

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 11

 Section 3
Positioning cybersecurity as a business enabler

However, our experience shows that efforts to However — more positively — EY research
embed cybersecurity into digital development confirms that as financial institutions look to
teams often come up against resistance from bring digital and cyber together, cybersecurity
cybersecurity professionals themselves. This vigilance remains top of mind. EY’s seventh
generally reflects their understandable concern annual global EY/IIF bank risk management
that focusing more on the opportunities and survey, A set of blueprints for success — based
business outcomes of digital innovation could on interviews with 67 banks from 29 countries
cause the organization to lower its guard — finds that cybersecurity risk ranks second
and risk more cyberattacks succeeding. only to regulation on the entire risk agenda
The resulting divide between digital and for respondents’ boards (see Exhibit 1).7 Also,
cybersecurity can strengthen the feeling 89% of interviewees say cybersecurity is now
among CIOs that the cybersecurity function is subject to a particular or enhanced focus on
not fully meeting their organization’s needs, as operational risk, more than for any other area
noted by the ISF.6 of the business.

Exhibit 1: Top three risk areas for boards of directors in the next 12 months
Source: A set of blueprints for success: Seventh annual global EY/IIF bank risk management survey, 2016

6
Threat Horizon 2019: Disruption. Distortion. Deterioration. Information Security Forum Limited, January 2017,
https://www.securityforum.org/research/threat-horizon-2on-deterioration
7
A set of blueprints for success: Seventh annual global EY/IIF bank risk management survey, EYGM Limited, 2016,
http://www.ey.com/gl/en/industries/financial-services/banking---capital-markets/ey-bank-risk-management-survey-2016

12 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

A new model emerges for cybersecurity For this approach to work, it will require
new philosophies. These include distributing
Overall, the message is clear: cybersecurity
responsibility for security much more
presents clear and growing risks in financial
broadly — so it’s embedded (like digital) in
services — and efforts to tackle these are
the business rather than being in a separate
lagging behind the rapid advance of digital
silo. Cybersecurity professionals should also
solutions. But the good news is that modern
become better risk practitioners, working with
cybersecurity can and should seize the chance
operations and technology risk specialists to
to close the gap with digital and ride the wave
quantify risk more accurately.
of innovation and opportunity.
All of this will allow people with more diverse
Whatever its current challenges, the
cybersecurity field has great technology and perspectives to participate in decision-making
around cybersecurity, leading to better and
highly skilled people. To realize their collective
more holistic outcomes. To maximize the
potential and target it more effectively, what’s
benefits, cybersecurity specialists should also
needed is a new sense of urgency and direction
move to more nuanced and proportionate
to integrate cybersecurity professionals
approach to risk, and work hand-in-hand
more closely with their digital colleagues,
with digital colleagues to apply new, more
and energize and inspire them to do things
experimental methodologies that balance the
differently. At the same time, the cybersecurity
twin goals of securing technologies and data on
discipline should be expanded beyond
the one hand and realizing business benefits on
protecting the organization against threats, to
the other.
include a “detect and respond” mindset.

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 13

 4

The future of cybersecurity: not a brake

on innovation, but an accelerator of value

14 | Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation

Section 4

Preparing for cybersecurity’s future as

a driver of innovation and growth
At some of our most advanced clients, we a mix of business and technical skills often
can already see the future of cybersecurity termed “suits and jeans.” And it’s clear that
emerging, with a clear shift underway from firms that feel more confident in their ability
old defense-centered thinking to new models to manage cybersecurity risks are more likely
focused on enablement. Companies used to to innovate and invest in mission-critical
look at their innovative digital products under initiatives.
development and ask, “How can we secure
With this in mind, companies should ask
them?” Now they’re asking: “How can these
themselves a number of searching questions
products be used to secure our business, and
about their current and future approaches to
grow our customer trust and revenues?”
cybersecurity, such as:
This shift of mindset from thinking about
• Is cybersecurity part of your value
cybersecurity as a cost of doing business
proposition, and how can it play a positive
to seeing it as a growth enabler is not easy.
role in growing revenue and market share?
For many firms, it represents a cultural and
organizational sea change — one that some • Are your digital development teams both
cybersecurity specialists understandably resist digital-savvy and cyber-savvy? How about
on the basis that it could increase vulnerability your executives?
to attacks.
• Is your cybersecurity organization seen as a
But our view is that this is a change that firms business enabler or a blocker?
must embrace — and that those that do so will
• Have you considered rethinking your new
be well-placed to become leaders in financial
digital processes with cybersecurity as the
services as its digital transformation continues.
foundation from the ground up?
Indeed, as forward-looking firms bring
cybersecurity together with their digital teams • Are you applying new digital governance
and the wider business, the question may arise models suited to operating in the face of
of whether cybersecurity as a distinct function growing cyber threats?
should disappear and become completely
The answers to such questions will help
embedded into the business. This may happen
guide your organization toward the future
in some organizations — but cybersecurity-
of cybersecurity in financial services — as a
specific skills and information-sharing networks
proactive enabler and facilitator of digital
will still be needed, and will remain critical to
growth, innovation and trust.
stay ahead of the advancing threats.

Whatever organizational structure is chosen,

our experience with clients suggests that the
blend that brings the greatest confidence is

Cybersecurity: moving from anchor to enabler of innovation | 15

Contacts
EY | Assurance | Tax | Transactions | Advisory

About EY
EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services.
The insights and quality services we deliver help build trust and confidence
William Beer Jaime Kahan in the capital markets and in economies the world over. We develop
+1 212 360 9010 +1 212 773 7755 outstanding leaders who team to deliver on our promises to all of our
[email protected] [email protected] stakeholders. In so doing, we play a critical role in building a better working
world for our people, for our clients and for our communities.
Andrea Boone Chris Lanzilotta
EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the
+1 212 773 7456 +1 410 783 3739 member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate
[email protected] [email protected] legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by
guarantee, does not provide services to clients. For more information about
Dave Burg Sundeep Nehra our organization, please visit ey.com.
+1 571 633 3628 +1 917 674 8419
[email protected] [email protected] Ernst & Young LLP is a client-serving member firm of
Ernst & Young Global Limited operating in the US.

David Deane JB Rambaud EY is a leader in serving the global financial services marketplace

+1 212 773 4432 +1 212 773 4617 Nearly 51,000 EY financial services professionals around the world provide
[email protected] [email protected] integrated assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services to our asset
management, banking, capital markets and insurance clients. In the
Cindy Doe Mark Watson Americas, EY is the only public accounting organization with a separate
+1 617 375 4558 +1 617 305 2217 business unit dedicated to the financial services marketplace. Created in
2000, the Americas Financial Services Organization today includes more
[email protected] [email protected]
than 11,000 professionals at member firms in over 50 locations throughout
the US, the Caribbean and Latin America.
John Doherty
+1 212 773 2734 EY professionals in our financial services practices worldwide align with key
[email protected] global industry groups, including EY’s Global Wealth & Asset Management
Center, Global Banking & Capital Markets Center, Global Insurance Center
and Global Private Equity Center, which act as hubs for sharing industry-
focused knowledge on current and emerging trends and regulations in
order to help our clients address key issues. Our practitioners span many
disciplines and provide a well-rounded understanding of business issues and
challenges, as well as integrated services to our clients.

With a global presence and industry-focused advice, EY’s financial services

professionals provide high-quality assurance, tax, transaction and advisory
services, including operations, process improvement, risk and technology, to
financial services companies worldwide.

© 2019 Ernst & Young LLP.

All Rights Reserved.

EYG No.
1902-3050667 BDFSO
ED None

This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be
relied upon as accounting, tax or other professional advice. Please refer to your advisors for specific
advice.

ey.com