Trading For Profit - Oli Hille
Trading For Profit - Oli Hille
Trading For Profit - Oli Hille
This book is the work or the author’s experience and opinion. Names,
characters, places and incidents are either the product of the author’s
imagination or are used fictitiously. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or
dead, or to actual events or locales is entirely coincidental.
This ebook is licensed for your personal enjoyment only. This ebook may not be
re-sold or given away to other people. If you would like to share this book with
another person, please purchase an additional copy for each person you share
it with. If you are reading this book and did not purchase it, or it was not
purchased for your use only, then you should return it and purchase your own
copy. Thank you for respecting the hard work of the author.
The publisher does not have any control over and does not assume any
responsibility for author or third party websites and their content.
www.TradingBook.net
Register for the author’s Free “Trading Tips” email service:
www.TradingBook.net/trading-tips
www.Amazon.com/author/1
Oli has been trading the financial markets for more than 20 years.
His average annual return for the period 1 January 2007 to 31 December 2010
(four years) was 76.06%
Oli is a happily married father of three beautiful children, who makes Life and
Lifestyle a priority. He teaches (and uses) the key Trading skills outlined in this
book to help people improve their trading returns and in so doing achieve a
better life for themselves and the people around them.
Contents
Part 1 - My Trading Background
Part 2 - Introduction
Part 3 - Trading Basics and Psychology
Part 4 - My 13 Hard Earned Trading Rules
Part 5 - Brokerage and Carry Costs
Part 6 - How to Start Trading
Part 7 - You Must Find YOUR Way of Trading
Part 8 - You MUST Have an Edge
Part 9 - Timeframes
Part 10 - Discipline as a Trader
Part 11 - Money Management
Part 12 - Risk
Part 13 - Cut Your Losses But Let Your Gains Run
Part 14 - Technical Analysis
Part 15 - Fundamental Analysis
Part 16 - Trend Trading
Part 17 - Trading Platforms
Part 18 - Losing Streak
Part 19 - Trading Legends
Part 20 - Mentoring
Part 21 - God and Trading
Part 22 - Solomon Wealth Fund
Part 23 - My 2007 Trading Diary
Part 24 - My 2008 Trading Diary
Part 25 - The Perfect Trade
Part 26 - The Main Event
Important - Disclaimer
By reading this Book you agree that this Book and any trading or investing
ideas described are for informational and educational purposes only and do not
constitute any advice or recommendation. The information contained in this
communication is based on generally available information and, although
obtained from sources believed by Oli Hille to be reliable, its accuracy and
completeness is not guaranteed. This communication is not intended to forecast
or predict future events. Past performance is not a guarantee or indication of
future results. No liability is accepted by Oli Hille for any loss (whether direct,
indirect or consequential) that may arise from any use of the information
contained herein or derived here from. Oli Hille and representatives are not
stockbrokers, financial or investment advisors and do not recommend any
stocks, bonds, options, CFD’s, currencies or any securities of any kind. Any
financial securities that are mentioned throughout the course of this document
are cited only for illustrative and educational purposes. Investing in financial
markets is risky and it is possible to lose money. It is recommended that you
seek a professional licensed financial advisor prior to implementing any
investment program or financial plan. You acknowledge that Oli Hille and
representatives have not promised you in any manner whatsoever that you will
earn a profit from your personal investments. If you do not agree to be bound
by these terms then please discontinue reading. These terms can be modified
at any time without notice.
[CONSUMER NOTICE: Some of the URL links to third party products in this report are affiliate links. This
means I may be compensated when you purchase from a provider. You should always perform due
diligence before buying goods or services from anyone on the Internet or offline.]
My Trading Background
I have been trading the financial markets part time since 1990. I became a full
time trader on 1 January 2007. My average annual return for the period 1
January 2007 to 31 December 2010 was 76.06%.
My Trading Lifestyle was covered by the media in 2008 and the story was
syndicated country-wide.
www.stuff.co.nz/business/367484
There are no employers to tell you how to do it. There are no employees to
train and supervise. There are no overheads. There are no excuses. There is
just you, your decision making and the result.
Even better than that, you are playing a giant game with players all over the
world. When you get good enough to win regularly you get paid – a lot!
And it gets even better. The game is so vast and covers so many possibilities
that you can choose which sub-game you want to play. So you can choose a
part of it that fits with your personality, with your strengths, with your sleep
patterns, with your timeframes and your risk thresholds, using strategies that
suit you. While there are some basic rules of play, you can develop entirely
your own personal rules to win the game!
It’s the purest game of all and you can make a living or a fortune playing it.
· Currencies
· Equities (shares)
· Bonds
· Interest rates
· Via futures
· A few days
· A number of weeks
· A number of months
· A number of years
You can use a combination of any of the above depending on your personality
and your circumstances.
Just like any game, the greater your level of skills and experience, the better
you will do.
Trading is a wonderful way to supplement your income and it fits into just about
any lifestyle. If you have a computer, the internet, a phone and access to a
minimum of a few thousand dollars you can start trading. However like anything
in life if you want to be really good at trading you must give it your undivided
focus. If you treat trading like a hobby, it will be just like every other hobby i.e.
it will cost you money!
I have been trading foreign currencies and commodities part time since 1990.
Let me tell you how I first started.
At that time there was one dealing room in the city I lived in. I phoned them up
and did the deal – I still remember the rate 0.8334! So my NZ $30,000 became
25,002 Swiss Francs.
Three weeks later the bank documents arrived from Switzerland. I phoned the
bank to talk about transferring the money. The broker told me that the
exchange rate had moved in my favor. I asked him what he meant. He said that
the exchange rate was now 0.7962 and that if transferred the Swiss Francs
back into NZ Dollars I would have $31,400. I said “Do it! Do it now!”
When I put the phone down I jumped around the house whooping with delight. I
couldn’t believe I had just made $1,400 for doing nothing.
The vacation job I had just finished paid $8.60 an hour which was $275 a week
after tax. I had just made the equivalent of five weeks of early starts and hard
dirty work – just by making two phone calls! I changed my mind about opening
a Swiss bank account and instead I started to move my money in and out of
currencies. In retrospect it was a very inefficient way to trade currencies but at
the time I didn’t know any better. Surprisingly I did six profitable trades in a row
and made a few thousand dollars – I literally could not believe it!
Back in 1990 there was no internet and it was very difficult to check prices and
movements unless you phoned your broker. However, I was studying at
university and Reuters had sponsored a live trading screen at the university
library. I could check my profits and losses between classes! I had a friend at
university who had some money so we started trading together.
As I learned more I started trading metals and commodities such as gold and
cocoa. I was flying by the seat of my pants and I had no real idea what I was
doing. Consequently I had some significant losses followed by that awful feeling
in the pit of your stomach.
Like anything, the more you do it the better and smarter you become. I have
made lots of mistakes in trading but most of these have been real learning
opportunities. Losing hard-earned cash is a good way to learn fast. You never
want to make the same mistake twice.
To help you not to make all of the mistakes I have made, I have thirteen trading
rules which I will outline after the next section.
Trading Basics and Psychology
Leverage and Risk
People are often drawn to trading because leverage means you can use a
small amount of money to control a large amount of money, and therefore make
money much faster than you would with your original stake. However, leverage
is a two edged sword! You can lose money just as quickly. Always remember
to consider the potential loss, not just the potential profit.
I have spent some years developing two copyrighted trading spreadsheets for
recording trades. If you are interested in purchasing these, please contact me
via my website:
www.TradingBook.net
These strengths and weaknesses will be MAGNIFIED when you start trading,
because the human emotions of greed and fear magnify your natural
personality.
Psychology
Your self-talk must be positive. Your attitude to trading and the markets must
be positive.
Your trades must have so little risk that you do not worry or lose sleep.
The capital you allocate to trading must be money you can spare.
If you violate these principles, once again they will be magnified when you are
trading.
My 13 Hard-Earned Trading Rules
Introduction
I am a trend trader. These are the rules I have developed over the years to
help me as I trade. Some of them relate specifically to trend trading, but most
of them have universal application.
A good broker can be the difference between making money and losing money,
it’s that simple. Of course most new traders use a trading platform and may
never talk to a broker. See the section on Trading Platforms.
But if/when you use an actual broker they must have sky-high integrity and be
totally honest. He or she must be experienced and highly knowledgeable. In my
opinion you should only use a broker that also trades actively and profitably on
their own account. Always ask a potential broker what percentage of their
personal income comes from doing their own personal trades. If they don’t
back themselves why should you listen to them?
It is important to remember that a good trader makes their own decisions. I use
my broker to bounce ideas off and sometimes he will call me with a
recommendation. But it is always me pulling the trigger.
I have a terrific broker who meets all of my expectations and he is also a great
guy. His name is Graham and if you do your homework and ask a lot of good
questions, you may be fortunate enough to find someone as good as him.
Everyone has a different risk threshold and only you know where that is.
Basically you need to know that you can sleep well at night and not make a
panicked decision during the day.
Using a 3:1 profit goal let’s assume you are happy to try to make $3,000 while
risking $1,000. You know that if your trade is completely wrong the most you
can lose is $1,000. If you are not going to lose any sleep – great, you are
within your threshold. But if you take a position that could conceivably lose
$10,000 in the eight hours you are in bed, can you sleep easily?
Your threshold might be $300 or it might be $30,000, but never go outside it.
Otherwise you will find yourself stewing and worrying and perhaps even getting
out of a trade at an inopportune time. Like any pursuit in life it should be fun,
not worrisome.
It is a fundamental mistake to look at any tradable product and say “It can’t go
any higher!” or “It can’t go any lower!” The truth is, markets go much further
and for much longer than most people expect.
By trying to guess the top or bottom of a market you are going against the
market’s momentum. It’s like standing in the way of a freight train – if you get it
wrong you (and your money) will be mowed down.
I made this mistake once in 2000. The New Zealand Dollar had fallen rapidly
and was a lot lower than it had been for years. I thought to myself “It has fallen
so far, so fast, surely it can’t fall further”. So I bought NZ$100,000 against the
US Dollar. The next day it continued to slide and I lost $2,500 in one afternoon.
That hurt and I’ve never forgotten it.
Critical Principle 1: If you try to pick a bottom, all you get is a handful of
crap.
It is therefore safer and more profitable in general to trade with the market’s
momentum. Sometimes this is known as “trading the trend” or “the trend is your
friend”.
If for example the US Dollar has been going down against the Japanese Yen
for a few weeks, it is more likely to continue to go down rather than change
direction. Note this does not mean that it will go down in any particular hour or
day but rather that it is likely to be lower in a few weeks time than it is now.
You have to be willing to ride out daily and even weekly fluctuations if you are
trading a long term trend.
Let’s say that I want to buy into a market that seems too low. I don’t want to
try to pick an exact point and buy it there because I am going against the
momentum and I will probably get it wrong. If however I wait until it has started
moving up and the momentum has changed I can buy it on the way up.
The same thing is true when you exit a trade. No-one can predict the future so
you can’t expect to sell out at the very peak. It is almost always a mistake to
sell because you think the market has peaked. You need to have a good
reason to sell out of a position and usually it will be because you believe the
momentum has changed.
This principle is especially important when observing long-term trends. You may
observe a market that has been trending upwards for two months and is a long
way above its lows. But if you think the trend has another two months left to run
you should buy into it and ride it up further. It is irrelevant that you missed the
low by two months. If you ride the momentum up and make a profitable trade –
celebrate!
When trading a position that technically has an unlimited loss potential (e.g. a
spot currency position or a futures contract) you must always use a stop-loss
order.
It works like this:
Place your order e.g. sell US$100,000 (remember because you can trade on
margin you only have to put up $3,000-$3,500 to do this) against the Japanese
Yen at the current rate, say 106.00.
Pick a dollar amount that is the maximum you would be willing to lose if you got
it wrong i.e. the US Dollar strengthening against the Yen instead of weakening.
Let’s assume that amount is US$1,500.
Using a spreadsheet work out where exactly the exchange rate would have to
move to, giving a US$1,500 loss. The spreadsheet formula looks like this:
= ((100,000*106)/(100,000-1500))
= 107.61 (rounded)
Tell your broker that you want to place a stop loss order at 107.61.
This means that if you get it wrong (and you will sometimes), once the rate
goes to 107.61 you will automatically be sold out of your position limiting your
loss to $1,500. Note that neither you nor your broker needs to be watching the
rate or even be awake! Your order is computer generated and will trigger
automatically.
Whenever you enter a trade, always accompany it with a stop loss order. If you
take this advice you will avoid large, unexpected losses.
Trailing Stop-losses
In addition, you can use stop loss orders that you move up as the rate moves
up. These are called trailing stop-losses.
Using our US Dollar versus Yen example. If you sell US$100,000 against Yen at
106 and two weeks later the rate is 101.44 your profit will be $4,500. Firstly
you don’t want to sell at this level because if the market keeps moving
(trending) you will make more. But secondly you don’t want to risk losing all of
the profits you have already made. The way to accomplish both of these is to
move your stop loss order.
Tell your broker to cancel your original stop loss order at 107.61
Ask him/her to place a new stop loss order at 102.91
If the market changes direction you automatically sell out at 102.91 giving you a
profit of $3,000.
But if the market moves down to say 100.00 you would cancel the stop loss at
102.91 and move the stop loss to say 101.50, locking in a profit of $4,435.
You keep doing this until the market changes direction. This way you maximize
your gains. If you trade using an electronic trading platform you can program an
exact trailing stop spacing (e.g. 150 points), and it will track it point for point.
Note: You will never get out at the very top using this strategy but as we have
discussed you never buy at the low or sell at the high. Be happy that you
profitably traded the momentum.
A Note on Retracements:
For example if I was long USD Yen and I was onside by 350 points (3.5 Yen) I
would look back to see when the trend started. Let’s say the trend started at
87.00 and the rate is currently 98.00. I would look at every major retracement
in that time and make a note of the amount of each retracement. It might look
like this:
Therefore because the current rate is 98.00 and I want a stop loss greater than
3.26 Yen (the largest retracement) I will put my trailing stop loss at say 3.3
Yen. My stop loss would then be 98.00 – 3.3 = 94.70.
IMPORTANT: Most traders will not allow such a big stop loss because they
hate the thought of losing 330 points, especially if they have large positions.
However those traders NEVER get to enjoy a move of 30 big figures (3000
points).
In 1997-98 for example USD Yen moved up 34 Yen (3,400 points). In order to
have participated in the full move you would have had to have used a 5.5 Yen
stop loss.
Clearly the goal of trading is to make a profit over time. Not all of your trades
will be successful. In fact based on the general assumption that all underlying
fundamental economic data is fully priced into the market, there is a 50%
chance of any market going up and a 50% chance of it going down.
Of course you hope that your knowledge and research will help you make an
informed decision, but everyone buying and selling feels the same way!
Given the statistical balance of 50%, it would not be profitable to aim to double
your money on a trade because if you get half right and half wrong you break
even.
You should only enter a trade where you believe that you can at least triple
your investment.
Using the example of the $1,500 stop loss, you would therefore be aiming for a
profit of $4,500. If you don’t think that is possible don’t do the trade.
Of course once the trade is underway you don’t have to hold out for $4,500
because the market conditions may change. But the key is to aim for at least a
3:1 ratio before you enter a trade.
Also of course you shouldn’t sell out with a $4,500 gain just because that was
your original goal. Really big money is made when you hold a profitable position
and keep making more, as discussed in the next section.
This is a mistake I have made a number of times and I pretty much lost money
every time. Basically the mistake goes like this.
You sell US$100,000 Dollars against the Yen at 106.00, hoping it goes down.
Instead it goes up to 108.00. At this time you mistakenly think “It must turn
around soon” so you sell another $100,000 at 108.
One of the perceived advantages is that you have “averaged down” your
position. This means that because you sold at 106.00 and then at 108.00, the
rate only needs to go to 107.00 for you to break even.
However, you are trying to pick the bottom of the market and you are trading
against the trend.
The trend almost always continues and when it goes up to 110.00 you are
carrying a large loss position you should never have exposed yourself to.
Without a profit goal you do not have something to aim for. Like all goals make
it measurable and achievable, but also a stretch.
There is something about setting a goal that makes achieving it more likely. Set
a dollar amount trading goal for this year now! Then tell a friend. That makes it
even more powerful.
www.Amazon.com/dp/B0060O1LLM
The people around the world trading the markets are doing it to make profits
and they take it seriously. They research and understand what they are trading.
If you trade a market you don’t understand you will probably get fleeced.
This happened to me only once. I saw that cocoa (a commodity) was trading at
an annual high so I thought I would sell a contract so that I would make money
if it went down.
Now there are cocoa traders out there who know everything about cocoa
supply and demand, which countries grow it and what their political situation is
like, what current weather patterns will affect crops etc. So what are the
chances of me taking a chance on a whim, of making money? Frankly I’d be
better off taking my money to the casino and putting it all on one hand of
blackjack. Needless to say I lost nearly $2,000 – lesson learned!
See the two sections on Technical Analysis and Fundamental Analysis later in
the Book.
When you are starting out it is very tempting to take positions that risk a large
percentage of your capital. Say you start with $10,000. My advice would be to
risk no more than 2% of your $10,000 (i.e. $200) on one trade. That way you
can get it wrong 50 times in a row before you are wiped out! However most
traders are not happy with the small gains possible using only a 2% risk level.
Most beginning traders want to make $500 or $1,000 a week from their
$10,000, so they take a lot more risk. I know because I talk to beginning
traders almost every week. This is the reason so many beginning traders blow
up their account (i.e. lose it all). You have to remember that legendary traders
who have been managing money for decades are considered legends because
they consistently return around 25-30% per year for their clients. Trying to
make $500 a week on $10,000 is a 260% annual return. It is just not
sustainable.
Regardless of your starting capital, trade small. If you don’t have enough
capital to make the exercise worthwhile, work on other ways to increase your
capital base. In my opinion you should not attempt to make a full time living as
a trader until you have at least $100,000 in capital.
If you find yourself risking 10% of your capital on every trade, remember that
just five losing trades in a row will halve your capital. You then have to make a
100% return in your next few trades just to return to your starting capital again!
Brokerage is the commission you pay your broker or your trading platform to
enter and exit trades. It also includes the spread (the difference) between the
buy and sell price on the instrument you are trading. Even though you want to
pay as little brokerage as possible, if you are going to use an actual broker
rather than just trade through a platform it is worth paying for a good one. A
good broker will more than make up for a ‘cheap’ broker in experience, advice
and integrity.
Another hidden cost of trading is carry costs. These are costs that can add up
every day you are in a trade. For example if you buy the Japanese Yen against
the Australian Dollar you have to pay the high rate of Australian interest and
you receive the low rate of Yen interest. Given that Australian interest rate is
many percentage points higher than Yen interest you need to be aware of the
cost of holding this or similar positions.
How to Start Trading
William Eckhardt (Top Trader and Market Wizard) said that the difference
between those who succeed in trading and those who do not is the amount
they read.
In 2008 I made over $100,000 in a two month period and it was SOLELY due
to reading two books, one on trading commodities and one on the Turtle
Trading System (I follow a personally modified and backtested version of this
system).
- Inspired;
- Motivated:
- New Ideas;
- New Strategies;
- Knowledge.
First, read a lot of books about trading. Here are some of my favorites. They
are in order of importance for the new trader. Each title is a clickable link to
Amazon.com:
All of these books and lots of other trading books and resources can be
purchased here:
www.Amazon.com
Second, I recommend starting out by “paper trading” which means trading
using play money on a trial trading account. You can start with $100,000 of
paper money and familiarize yourself with the systems and strategies before
you put up real money. You are not allowed to fly a plane solo without practice,
you are not allowed to skydive without practice, you are not allowed to drive a
car without practice. The same is true of trading. Mastery requires repetition
and practice.
Note: While paper trading can be fun and a great learning experience,
psychologically it is completely different from real trading. Losing 20% of your
trading capital in a paper trade doesn’t hurt, but in real money it really hurts!
Similarly a 20% profit is inconceivably better in real money than play money!
You Must Find YOUR Way of Trading
The opportunities for Trading are so vast and cover so many possibilities that
you can choose which particular market you want to trade in. So you can
choose a part of it that fits with your personality, with your strengths, with your
sleep patterns, with your timeframes and your thresholds, using strategies that
suit you.
While there are some basic rules you need to adhere to, you can develop
entirely your own personal rules and personal strategies to make money.
This is one of the beauties of Trading for a living. You get to choose the
instruments and the risk levels and the timeframes that suits your personality.
I am continually reading Trading books and interviews with top traders. They
almost all emphasis this point, that you must find a way of trading that suits
you. This means that just because your friend or uncle or colleague trades in a
certain way does not mean you have to follow suit. It is far better to start with a
clean slate and decide exactly how you are going to make money on the
financial markets.
I also mentor a number of beginning traders and I see them over time
gravitating to what most suits their personalities.
1. Read up on all the different markets, and strategies, and instruments you
can.
3. Work out what time of the day you are most comfortable doing analysis and
actually taking trades.
4. Think about your anxiety and risk levels. If you cannot sleep with your current
position size, or if you don’t like taking multiple trades in one day you might
need to be a trader that holds positions for a number of days.
Cautions
1. Never “fall in love” with a market or a trade. Remember all you are actually
dealing with as a trader is pieces of paper. They go up in value and they go
down. I know a number of traders who like gold and they can’t bear to go short
gold, ever. This is a weakness. You are not actually buying and selling yellow
metal, you are buying and selling pieces of paper that go up and down in value.
2. Successful trading is almost always boring! Yes it’s true. If you are getting in
to trading for the excitement, you are gambling and you are better off at the
casino. Your sole reason for entering a market must be to dispassionately take
money out of the market. I am not saying you cannot be pleased with your
gains. Of course you can, but that is a byproduct, not the reason.
3. Most human beings have a psychological trait known as “Dollar Fear”. This is
when the pain of losing $1 is greater than the pleasure of making $1. For most
people this means that trading losses are more painful than the enjoyment of an
equivalent trading gain. You need to examine your personality to see how
averse you are to losing money. Losing money is one of the cost of doing
business as a Trader. You cannot quickly take off a losing position just because
it is losing. Many profitable trades are under water for at least a short period of
time.
5. Trading is like anything else in life, it is a learning process. Over time you will
learn more and more, and you will make fewer and fewer mistakes. In my
opinion it is this process that makes great traders. So if you are unprofitable for
the first year or two, keep at it.
Conclusion
Before you start trading, examine your personality and work out how, where,
and when you are going to trade. Also work out your risk thresholds. And finally
give it all of your attention.
You MUST Have an Edge
When you start trading your precious capital you must have an edge in the
market. To explain what I mean, think about a casino. The Casino has an edge
in every game in the casino. For every bet placed there is a probability that the
Casino will win. That means that the Casino is happy to lose some bets
because it knows over a period of time it will win.
You might think that in any trade you take in the financial markets there is a
50% chance of winning or losing. This is NOT the case. In fact if you believe
that you should not trade at all because after you have paid commissions etc
you must LOSE over time.
A lot of new traders make the mistake of starting to trade without an edge i.e.
without working out a way to put the probability in their favour. Any Trading
System is a system that has been designed to have a probability of profitability.
Critical Principle Do not start risking your capital until you have
developed or adopted a Trading System that has an
edge in the market.
You can have an edge in both types of system. However it is my belief that
unless you have significant in depth knowledge of macro-economics or of a
specific commodity (for example you know almost all there is to know about
how wheat is grown, cultivated, marketed, and consumed) then you are far
better off trying to develop a Technical System that has an edge.
3. Has been backtested (tested over historic data) and shown to be profitable.
4. Has been forward tested (tested in a live situation) over current data and
shown to be profitable.
For that reason my strong recommendation is that YOU research, find and
develop your own Technical System with an edge.
Yes it is a lot of work. But remember trading for a living is a business. There
are no free lunches.
If you insist on trading your precious capital without finding a system with an
edge, I can make life much easier for you. Give all of your trading capital to
charity. The result will be the same (your money will be gone) but at least you
will have a warm feeling, and a tax deduction!
Timeframes
Trading Timeframes are critical to your technical analysis of price information.
· A few days
· A number of weeks
· A number of months
· A number of years
But the critical factor is that the probability of a successful trade increases to
the extent the timeframes are in alignment.
So for example if you are looking to go long USD CAD and the one hour chart
shows an uptrend, the trade has a higher probability of success if the four hour
and the daily chart also show an uptrend.
At least once a week you also want to look at the long term price trend. This is
useful for gauging historic highs and lows and historic support and resistance
points. It can also show you how high or low the price might go.
I also recommend looking at the monthly chart of any financial instrument you
are about to trade.
You certainly should always look at multiple timeframes when taking a trade.
Ideally only trade when there are multiple convergences across all timeframes.
www.chartsrus.com
Your Personality
You will find that you naturally gravitate to a particular timeframe. That is great
because you want to trade in line with your personality. My favored timeframe
is daily charts. That is because I like to take multi-day and ideally multi-week
trades. However a day trader might gravitate to 5 minute or 30 minute charts.
But even though I look at daily charts for my signals, I will always look at the
hourly chart to see where my best entry point and stop loss point will be.
Discipline as a Trader
When you read interviews with Top Traders and Market Wizards (the traders
interviewed in Jack Schwager’s books), and read autobiographies of the most
successful traders, the trait that comes up over and over and over again as the
most important for trading success is Discipline.
Why is this the case? It is because trading the financial markets is filled with
opportunities to experience:
· Greed
· Fear
· Anxiety
· Worry
· Elation
· Euphoria
· Pain
When you are hit with this barrage of emotions on an hourly, daily and weekly
basis the natural human response is to react in a manner that we are
programmed to. Every person is programmed to seek pleasure and avoid pain.
Making and losing large sums of money is a massive trigger for pleasure and
pain. This means that in a trading environment our natural inclination is to do a
number of things that are counterproductive to success:
· Avoid actually taking a loss and keeping the position and hoping it will
come back into profit;
· Adding to a losing position to average the loss;
· Breaking risk rules when on a winning run;
· Cutting a loss even through the loss is not near our stop loss.
· And so on.
It is because of these swirling emotions that discipline is so difficult to maintain.
But it is critical to long term success.
Let me give you a personal example. I used to have my risk rules written on my
wall. They governed how much risk I could have in the market at any one time.
However a few times a year in periods when I was making a lot of money I
would deliberately break my rules. This happened once too often I got crushed,
and in one night I lost over 20% of my capital. I thought to myself, “This is
ridiculous, I have risk rules but I don’t keep them”. So I emailed two people I
have huge respect for and I asked them to be my trading accountability group. I
emailed them my risk rules and I committed to them that I would not break
them. I would not dare disappoint them, and so I have kept to my risk rules
ever since then.
For a general outline of the importance of self discipline and how you can
change undisciplined behaviors into disciplined ones see:
www.LifestyleBook.com/discipline
Money Management
I have mentored numerous beginning and intermediate traders. I have also co-
founded a Trading Club which meets six times a year and has nearly 200
members. I talk to other traders regularly and I often answer trader’s
questions. The ONE key area that leads to the greatest losses among
beginning and intermediate traders in poor Money Management.
The reason it is so difficult to master is that the elation of making money and
the pain of losing money are among the most powerful human emotions. When
we become gripped with these emotions, or even the imagination of what those
states would feel like, most people stop thinking rationally and start acting in a
high adrenaline mode. This high adrenaline mode is great if you are in physical
danger or you are exerting yourself in an exciting adventure. But it is NOT
conducive to good trading.
1. Risk
2. Discipline
· Not triple checking a trade (levels, position size and risk) just before you
execute it;
· Not writing down the reasons you took the trade;
· Not spreadsheeting the trade so you have a record of it;
· Not doing a daily revaluation of all positions so you know your profit and
loss on an ongoing basis;
· Not going back and regularly analyzing where you made money and how,
and where you lost money and how.
· Not doing a weekly analysis of the previous week’s trading.
· Not knowing your year to date profit or loss at one glance.
· And so on.
3. Laziness
It must also be said that poor money management is in many cases rooted in
Laziness. Traders often cannot be bothered to calculate the exact percentage
risk and the exact dollar risk of each position. More dangerously, many traders
do not calculate the risk of combined and correlated positions. So for example
if you have the following positions:
- what you actually have is one BIG position that is short USD. If the USD
strengthens you could be stopped out of all of your positions in one
session. This might be a five times bigger loss than you were expecting.
Let me tell you the full story about Laziness and lack of Discipline.
· Triple checking every trade (levels, position size and risk) just before you
execute it;
· Write down the reasons you took the trade;
· Spreadsheet every trade so you have a record of it;
· Do a daily revaluation of all positions so you know your profit and loss on
an ongoing basis;
· Go back and regularly analyze where you made money and how, and
where you lost money and how.
The losses that are racked up by people not doing the above means that the
exact same people who are lazy actually have to go to work for days and
weeks and sometimes months to get back the money they lost!
The few minutes they saved being lazy in their trading has become hundreds of
hours they have to put in just to get back to even!
If this is you, do yourself a favor. Do the easy and quick work – be disciplined
in your trading!
4. Lack of Understanding
New and intermediate traders often simply do not understand what they are
trading and how the financial instrument works.
When you are a seller of an option YOU take all the risk. In fact the profit
potential is limited and the loss potential is unlimited.
Let me give you a real life example. In the bull run in equities in 2005-2007 a lot
of new traders were advised to sell put options on stocks. If stocks (shares)
kept going up the trader just kept the premium. So I heard of a school teacher
who started doing this. Month after month stocks kept going up and he made
$1,000 a month, $2,000 a month, $4,000 a month! Fantastic. But what this
trader didn’t know was the risk he was carrying. In the meltdown of 2008 this
humble school teacher had to PAY OUT on the options he was selling and lost
over $100,000 and lost his house.
Incidentally I NEVER sell options. I do buy options but that is fine because my
risk is limited to the premium I am paying and I have unlimited potential to
make money.
Risk
I talk to other traders and brokers regularly and I often answer trader’s
questions. One of the main habits that cause traders to lose money is taking
too much risk.
A good trader knows how much percentage and dollar risk they are exposed to
at any one time.
· Risk of slippage;
· Risk of gapping markets;
· Risk of lack of liquidity;
· Event risk;
· Risk of taking trades overnight, over weekends and over holiday periods;
· Carry cost risk;
· Risk of discontinuous markets;
· Risk of limit down or limit up moves;
· And so on.
Did you know that most Top Traders risk less than 1% of their capital on each
trade? Top traders also often limit their overall risk to less than 4% of their
capital.
This means that to emulate their risk habits with an account size of $20,000 you
would need to risk less than:
I take slightly more risk. I allow myself a maximum 1.6% risk on FX trades and
2.2% risk on Commodity trades. I recommend these as the absolute maximum
risk levels you allow yourself.
Sadly most new traders happily risk 20%, 30% and sometimes 100% of their
capital at any one time. It is no wonder they get wiped out!
“Sorry to bother you. But you are the best person to turn to for a bit of
help and guidance in my situation right now.
Bought the eur/usd, gbp/usd, sold the usd/cad, usd/chf. And the next
morning all 4 trades went south and I got stopped in all 4 trades and
sustained substantial loss to my trading account.
I had $17,000 and now down to $10,000 I guess I used more leverage on
these trades than my usual.
Anyway lesson learned very harsh about not to over leverage, I will never
let this happen. Now I am just skeptical about putting on any trades no
matter how sure I am. It’s stopping me.
What do you think? I am sure you've been there, so what spotlight can
you flash on me to move on? Any wise words from the wise man??? :)”
And my Response:
“Thank you for your honesty! Being honest with yourself is half of being a
good trader.
I can tell you one problem you have straight away. You are taking WAY
too much risk.
Top traders tend to take very low risk per position, usually under 1%. I
allow myself a maximum of 1.6% per FX trade.
So 1.6% of $17,000 is $272. That is the MOST you can risk on any one
trade. And those should be the trades that tick EVERY box. So generally
limit your risk to 1% per trade.
Okay so assuming every one of these four trades were trades that met
ALL of your criteria, your maximum loss would have been $272 x 4 =
$1,880 rather than the $7,000 you lost.
So now you have $10,000, your MAXIMUM risk per trade can only be
$160. This should enable you to place the trades you like because the risk
is nice and small.
Also one final word of caution, if you have say seven trades all correlated
you still would have too much risk even if each trade only had $160 risk.
Because as you found out last night correlated trades can all go bad at
the same time.
Think of the $7,000 you lost last night as tuition fees you have paid the
market. As you say you will never make that same mistake again so in a
few years time when your trading account is large, it will seem like a
cheap lesson the market taught you.”
I have a friend who is an FX broker. He has been a broker for more than a
decade and he has literally hundreds of traders on his client list. He told me
once that he sees dozens of new traders and almost all of them live out the
following pattern on a weekly or monthly basis:
Small gain, small gain, small gain, small gain, small gain, MASSIVE LOSS. And
then he never hears from them again.
The reason is simple. These traders load up with positions and in one big move
the market goes against them and their whole capital is wiped out.
PLEASE heed my advice. Take small amounts of risk.
Cut Your Losses But Let Your Gains Run
Whatever markets you trade and whatever timeframes you use, you will
frequently get your trades wrong. Even if your model tells you there is a 90%
chance of success, the 10% will occur.
This is where you take high probability trades (70% or above probability that
the particular trade will be successful).
When you are sniping you take profits quickly and regularly.
2. Trend Trading
Take low probability trades (under 50% probability of success) but where the
losses are small but the profits on the winning trades are large.
In this type of trading, you cut your losses quickly but you let your gains run
until such time as either:
I am a trend trader. The only way to make money over a long time period trend
trading is to limit your losses and maximize your gains.
There is also a simple way to let your gains run – using a trailing stop loss.
Break Even
I can always tell a novice trader. They are concerned with breaking even on a
trade when the trade is losing.
1. If your entry point was correctly set at the break of a key support/resistance
level it is almost certain that the market will come back and test the
support/resistance level. A mistake most novice traders make is that once they
are onside with a trade they will move their stop loss level to break even. Then
the market returns to that level taking out their stop, and immediately turns
around again and goes in the direction of the trade. It is times like this that the
novice trader thinks that “the market is out to get them”. No, it is simply bad
trading.
2. The only one solitary reason why traders want to break even when they are
carrying a losing trade is ego. If you can only break even you can walk away
feeling like you didn’t lose. So what?
If you are 50 points offside on a trade and you no longer believe in the trade
cut it immediately. Holding on for it to move 50 points in your favor is blind hope
and most of the time it doesn’t happen. You have to get to the place where you
are happy walking away with a small loss. Because a small loss more often
than not turns into a big loss, and that really hurts.
And practically what does breaking even matter? In a month’s time you won’t
even remember your small losses and your profit/loss statement will barely
show them. But a big loss because of your ego will stay in your memory and in
your profit/loss statement all year.
Such a trader relies only on Technical Analysis to make buying and selling
decisions. Technical Analysis then is simply the study of price information.
I particularly like this quote from Wikipedia:
“Traders generally share the view that trading in the direction of the trend
is the most effective means to be profitable in financial or commodities
markets. John W. Henry, Larry Hite, Ed Seykota, Richard Dennis, William
Eckhardt, Victor Sperandeo, Michael Marcus and Paul Tudor Jones
(some of the so-called Market Wizards in the popular book of the same
name by Jack D. Schwager) have each amassed massive fortunes via the
use of technical analysis and its concepts.”
The most common format for viewing Technical information is in the form of a
picture because human beings process information faster in this format. Thus
we have Charts or Graphs. Most traders now use Candlestick Charts.
Candlestick charts simply show high, low and close prices in an easily
visualized way. Candles that show an advance in the price are green. Candles
that show a decline in price are red (sometimes white and black respectively).
Before the advent of computers, charts had to be drawn by hand and were
very time consuming. Now charts are created in seconds and include huge
levels of detail.
As with any series of numbers, price information can be analyzed using all
different types of statistical and mathematical analysis. Some of the most
common Technical Indicators are these:
1. Moving Averages
A moving average simply averages the prices in the previous number of periods
you are interested in. So for example if you overlay a ten day moving average
over a daily chart you will have a line which at any point on that line is the
average price of the preceding ten days. It is a lagging indicator which can
show a trend change.
I find myself using Moving Averages more and more. In order to use Moving
Averages as a trend trader I recommend the following:
Set up all four of the following simple Moving Averages on your trading
platform:
10 period
20 period
50 period
200 period
Briefly, if all four Moving Average lines are moving in the same direction, and
fanning out (i.e. there is a space between each of them and they are all either
sloping upwards together or sloping downwards together) - this signifies a
strong trend.
For a more thorough explanation of this strategy please read my blog post on
the subject:
http://www.tradingbook.org/blog/trending-markets-how-to-get-on-and-not-get-
left-behind/
While on the page, sign up on the right of the page to get instant notification of
future blog posts.
2. Relative Strength Index (RSI)
I was fortunate enough to interview J. Welles Wilder the inventor of the Relative
Strength Index. You can read the interview at www.TradingBook.org/interviews
Note Technical Traders (including me) often use the RSI and MACD to confirm
a price move. If the RSI and MACD move at the same time and in the same
direction of the price move, and make corresponding highs (or lows) with the
price, this adds weight to the expectation of further prices moves in the same
direction.
4. Bollinger Bands
Bollinger bands are used to measure the relative distance of the current price
to its standard deviation (statistical distance) and can be compared to a
previous standard deviation from the price at an earlier time.
There are three Bollinger Bands consisting of the middle band which is a simple
moving average, an upper band which is a specified standard deviation above
the middle band, and a lower band which is a specified standard deviation
below the middle band. When the outer bands widen out it indicates a trend is
underway, and when the outer bands tighten in it indicates no trend is
underway.
5. Fibonacci
6. Pivot Points
So a Daily Pivot Point would be the average of the previous day’s high, low and
closing prices.
Daily Pivot
Weekly Pivot
Monthly Pivot
Convergence of two or three pivot points at the same level adds significant
strength to the support or resistance.
For an example of how to use Pivot Points in your trading see my blog post
here:
http://www.tradingbook.org/blog/buying-silver-on-the-run-up-could-you-use-a-
weekly-pivot-as-a-stop/
While on the page, sign up on the right of the page to get instant notification of
future blog posts.
7. Convergence
Critics argue that such convergence is simply a self fulfilling prophesy i.e. it
becomes a support or resistance point simply because so many people have
identified it as such.
These are just some of the dozens of technical indicators available on almost all
trading platforms.
Every trader develops favorite technical indicators which are usually based on
that trader’s personality.
Price is King
I will only Trade Price
Fundamental Analysis
A Fundamental Trader trades only on Fundamental information. Fundamental
information is specific news and information that relates to the underlying
financial instrument that is likely to move prices now or in the future.
And for example if you are analyzing a stock, the fundamental information
would include:
And for example if you are analyzing an agricultural commodity, the fundamental
information would include:
In my opinion there are only a very few economic analytical geniuses who can
hope to master fundamental analysis well enough to really make a fortune. Of
these I include Warren Buffett, George Soros and Jim Rogers (who started the
Quantum Fund with George Soros).
This is the reason there are so many trend traders, and traders who use
primarily price information to make their trading and investment decisions.
It is my belief that no-one can know every factor that moves market prices, in
fact nowhere near every factor. But whatever forces are at work buying and
selling, will by definition show up in the price.
Trend Trading
One of the most common trading styles is Trend Trading. This is essentially
taking a position in the market with the predominating trend. So for the specific
timeframe you are interested in, you either join the uptrend or join the
downtrend.
Trend trading has been around for hundreds if not thousands of years. It is
sometimes used in conjunction with trading cycles. The belief behind both trend
trading and cycle trading is that prices move in a particular direction for a
period of time before changing direction. A trend can be on any timeframe from
a one minute trend to a multi-decade trend. There are very few people who do
not believe that market prices trend.
You have probably heard the saying:
Or:
One of the first people to do research and document trend trading was Charles
Dow who developed the Dow Theory well over 100 years ago.
Since then there have been hundreds of proponents of some type of trend
trading system or another.
I like to try to identify trending markets and just like an escalator I like to ride up
when the trend is up and ride down when the trend is down.
It is apparent to me that the strong emotions of fear and greed often push
market prices well above and well below equilibrium levels. Being a trend trader
allows me to ride these prices in either direction without having to figure out
what is going on in the minds of other market players.
Let me give you an example. For argument’s sake assume the Chinese
government has realized it does not have enough Soybean Oil for the needs of
its population. It cannot afford to tell the market this because that would
immediately lift the price of Soybean Oil. Similarly it cannot simply buy every
contract available because this would also dramatically increase the price in a
short time. What is has to do is slowly and quietly start buying Soybean Oil
contracts. So the price of Soybean Oil starts to rise. As a trend trader I notice
this and at a certain point my trading model tells me to buy contracts. My
trading model forces me to hold these contracts as the price continues to climb.
I can only get out if and when the price reverses. Such massive buying from
the world’s biggest consumer of Soybean Oil is likely to lift and support
Soybean Oil prices for weeks if not months. I might never know what caused
the price rise or I might find out months later, but that is irrelevant. I have joined
the trend, and profited.
Of course trend trading is only one type of trading, and even within trend
trading there are dozens of different systems which use different timeframes
and different entry points.
And some fantastically successful traders do not trend trade at all. One of my
market heroes is Fund Manager Paul Tudor Jones. This is a quote from him:
“I believe the very best money is made at the market turns. Everyone says you
get killed trying to pick tops and bottoms and you make all your money by
playing the trend in the middle. Well for twelve years I have been missing the
meat in the middle but I have made a lot of money at tops and bottoms.”
A trading platform gives you a feed of price information and allows you to buy
or sell online. The fierce competition for this business has meant that more and
more sophisticated platforms are available and many are free.
Some platforms only allow you to trade Stocks. Some only allow you to trade
CFDs (Contracts for Difference) or spread betting. However almost all
platforms now allow you to trade almost everything from your computer screen:
· Stocks
· Options
· Futures
· Indexes
· Forex
· CFDs
· And so on.
Of course as in everything else in life you get what you pay for. Whilst you do
get live prices for Forex on all platforms, you usually get delayed prices for
futures and indexes and options. Also the charting and the usability of free
platforms are sometimes poor.
You also need to check the functionality of each platform. Does it include all of
the technical analysis tools you need? Can you easily place stop loss orders?
You also need to aware of the margin requirements for each product you are
trading. This means how much money you need to have in your account in
order to trade a certain size contract. What happens if the position goes
against you and you exceed the entire margin in your account? Are all of your
positions automatically cut?
Finally you also need to be aware of the credit risk of the provider of the
platform. So if you put $50,000 into your trading account and the institution
becomes insolvent the next day, you may never see your $50,000 again! Know
who your provider is and what their credit rating is!
To use their platform will cost you US$250 per month. So for US$3,000 per
year you need to be sure that the advanced functionality and feed is going to
improve your P&L (Profit and Loss account) by at least US$3,000 per year.
I use a free platform that does everything I need it to, Saxo Trader –
www.saxobank.com
However because Saxo Trader does not have live prices for Futures, Options
and Indexes I also use a dedicated Futures platform which my broker provides
me, PrimeTrade which is a Credit Suisse First Boston product –
www.csfb.com/primetrade
Conclusion
Online Trading Platforms now allow you to trade all financial markets from your
computer. They are incredibly powerful and have amazing functionality. If you
are a beginning or intermediate trader a good free platform is all you need. But
ensure that you:
· Check your broker has a good help line;
· Trial a number of platforms before you commit to one;
· Look at the functionality of each platform;
· Check the margin requirements of your platform;
· Check the credit worthiness of the counterparty you are depositing your
funds with.
_______________
Interesting!
Did you know that 99.8% of readers do not leave reviews?
On the very last page of this book Amazon will ask you to submit a review.
If you enjoyed this book, please add a one or two sentence review here. And if
you do, thank you so much…
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B006TBPY6Y
_______________
Losing Streak
Let’s not sugar coat this. Losing money trading is painful. Big losses are gut
wrenching losses. Huge losses are turning pale, hand trembling, losing sleep,
ache in the pit of your stomach losses!
Losses are simply the cost of doing business as a trader. You are going to
have losses, get used to the idea.
It’s just like a fruit and vegetable shop that has to throw stock out that has gone
off. You get rid of the losses so you can put your working capital back into a
profitable trade.
If your losses or your potential losses are keeping you awake at night or
causing negative physical symptoms your position size is too big. Simple,
reduce your position size.
You learn the most in life when you go through challenging times.
You learn the most in trading when you have losses. You learn most about your
trading systems, and your threshold for pain, and your feelings about money
when you lose. So losing can be a very good thing. In fact whenever I take a
significant loss I always view it as tuition fees I have paid the market. I analyze
the loss, learn from it and strive to improve myself and my trading system so
that I do not lose money in the same way again.
A lot of top traders say the same thing, something like “The reason I am so
successful now is that I have made so many trading mistakes and lost money
so many times, that I finally understand what I am doing.”
If trading was easy there would be no bus drivers (no offence intended to bus
drivers).
All Super Traders take losses (usually super losses). Here are some examples:
In 1998 George Soros lost $2 billion in Russian Funds when they defaulted.
Julian Robertson was the fund manager of Tiger Management Group, which
had $23 billion at its peak and $6 billion when it was rolled up (i.e. it lost $17
billion over that period). He lost more than $1b of his own money.
In 1987 and 1988, when he was trading as much as $159 million, his net loss
after fees was $60 million. And in 1992, when his equity climbed as high as $86
million, he lost $48 million.
Mark Cook (Market Wizard) starting trading with a few thousand dollars and
by selling options built it up to $165,000 in a few months. Within one month he
lost over $500,000; the $165,000 plus $350,000 he didn’t have. Rather than
declare bankruptcy he worked two full time jobs for five years to get back to
even.
Jesse Livermore who made $100m by short selling the 1929 crash was
declared bankrupt in 1934! How do you lose $100m in five years???
Marty Schwartz (Market Wizard) has this to say in his classic book “Pit Bull”:
“Every trader faces it. Only the winners know how to handle it. The dreaded
losing streak rears its head every so often and attacks every great trader. It
eats away at your judgment; it saps your confidence. Sometimes it can take
you so low that you think you’ll never get out. You’re sure that something has
gone wrong, that you’ve lost your touch, that you’ll never be a winner again.
When you’re in the middle of it, you think it is never going to end, but mostly,
your judgment and rhythm are off and what you have to do is stop and regain
your composure.”
My Experience
If you are going to trade big you are going to lose big.
If you are going to trade other people’s money you are going to lose other
people’s money.
As a matter of interest here is a list of over 40 people who have lost more than
US$100m trading:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_trading_losses
Trading Legends
In a way, success in any venture is simple. Find someone who is among the
best in the world at what you want to be good at and model them.
If you want to be a great golfer, model Tiger Wood’s golf swing.
Exactly the same is true in trading. Top traders are at the top because they
followed a particular path. If you want to be a top trader you need to study
their habits, their lives and their strategies. Learn from their mistakes and pick
up tips and advice from them.
Of all the traders I know, no-one has anywhere close to the resource library I
have. I have dozens of trading books, documentaries, CDs, DVDs, articles and
interviews on successful super-traders. I went through a period when I read a
trading book every week. Even now I am always either reading or re-reading a
trading book.
In 2008 I made over $100,000 in a two month period and it was SOLEY due to
reading two books, one on trading commodities and one on the Turtle Trading
System (I follow a personally modified version of this system).
For a list of trading books I recommend, please see section above “How to
Start Trading”.
Here are a few of the Super Traders that you can read about, study and
emulate. Each link is clickable:
Jesse Livermore
Ed Seykota
Larry Hite
William O’Neill
Marty Schwartz
Jim Rogers
Martin Zweig
Warren Buffett
Mark D Cook
Richard Dennis
Monroe Trout
Barton Biggs
Stanley Druckenmiller
George Soros
Mark Ritchie
Welles Wilder
Julian Robertson
Mentoring
I offer one on one mentoring via phone or Skype.
If you are interested in one on one mentoring via Skype or phone, please email
me at:
[email protected]
God and Trading
A number of people have asked me about my relationship with God and its
impact on my trading. For those who are interested, these are my views:
Firstly God is not my “trade picker”. By this I mean that I do not seek divine
guidance before I enter a trade and I do not expect God to give me any
specific guidance on taking trades.
The bible makes it clear that we are able to and in fact should ask God for
wisdom:
Proverbs 2 v 6:
For the Lord Gives wisdom, and from his mouth come knowledge and
understanding.
James 1 v 5
If any of you lacks wisdom, he should ask God, who gives generously to
all without finding fault, and it will be given to him.
So in practical terms one of the things I do in my work life is ask God for
wisdom. I especially ask for wisdom for a general understanding of the world
as it relates to trading.
One of the most successful fund managers of the 20th Century Sir John
Templeton summarised his views on God and investing and prayer in his book
“The Templeton Plan” as follows:
It is my belief that God has given me an ability to manage and make money. I
treat this as a gift God has given me which is the underlying reason for my
trading. I believe one of my purposes on earth is to raise money to further the
Kingdom of God. Essentially this simply means that I should use a large part of
the money I make to do things that I believe God would want me to do. Put
another way, I have to think about what God would do with the money if He
was in my shoes. Examples are; feeding the hungry, sheltering the homeless,
supporting missionaries, supporting churches and those in ministry.
We even recognise this in our secular society with sayings like “What goes
around comes around” and “That will give you good Karma”.
Here is what the bible says about giving 10% (a tithe) of your income every
year:
Malachi 3 v 10
“Bring the whole tithe into the storehouse, that there may be food in my
house. Test me in this," says the Lord Almighty, "and see if I will not throw
open the floodgates of heaven and pour out so much blessing that you will
not have room enough for it.”
“I met a wise man once who taught me that instead of asking God’s
blessing on what I was doing, to find things that God was already
blessing and get involved in that.”
I have been trading my own funds and a small number of clients’ funds full time
since January 2007. I have decided to start a fund in 2013.
Starting a fund is for me, the next logical step, to manage other people’s
money. In order to learn about fund management I started talking to the most
successful people I could find in the industry. I have met with a number of very
successful fund managers including one manager with over $20 billion under
management and one with over $1.5 billion under management. Incidentally
both started with nothing and one is a billionaire and the other is worth $400m.
However it does take time. This fund started with nothing, finally after a few
years managed to attract $10m of investor funds and three years later
managed to double investor funds to $20m. Seven years later funds were at
$1.5 billion. I heard similar stories from three different fund managers.
Needless to say a light went off in my head when I heard these stories!
Investors would rather I consistently delivered 15% returns with very low
volatility (and therefore very low risk) than 100% return with the huge volatility I
have been trading with.
I have therefore decided to progressively lower the volatility and returns of the
model I am using so that the fund is more attractive to investors. Fortunately
making the model less volatile is fairly simple because I can simply reduce
leverage and reduce the position sizing, while still taking the entry and exits
signals generated by the model.
As well as starting the fund, I have also decided to allow investors to use
managed accounts. This means that an investor can keep their money in their
own account and I am simply given the ability to enter and exit trades on their
behalf. In the current climate with frauds and scandals in the news, this gives
investors full confidence because the funds are always in their name and under
their control.
You are welcome to visit the website of the fund but you are required to read
the disclaimer:
www.SolomonWealthFund.com
Questions and Answers
I have been asked a lot of questions by beginning traders over the last few
years.
I used to always form my fundamental view first, and then wait for confirming
price action. However my experiences in 2008 have taught me that my
fundamental view can be and often is completely wrong! It is simply not
possible to know even a tiny fraction of all of the fundamental market
information, let alone know what each individual trader is thinking and doing.
No-one foresaw the massive deleveraging of assets during 2008 for example.
From now on I am only going to trade the technically i.e. on price action. I even
have written on my wall:
Price is King
I will only trade price.
The second thing to say is that I ALWAYS calculate the dollar amount of my risk
before I enter a trade, and I always have a stop loss. The dollar amount of the
risk relates to the total size of my equity.
I generally do not risk more than 1% of my total equity (all the money I have set
aside to trade with) on my first entry of my trade. So for example if my
personal trading equity is currently $350,000, on my first entry I will risk less
than $3,500 on my first trade.
Question 2: How do you determine your entry, exit as well as Stop Loss
points for FX trades?
I use chart analysis. I especially like new highs, even better if they are new 20
day highs or new 55 day highs.
I also like to see (on a daily chart) a number of higher highs and higher lows if I
am going to buy. And of course the opposite if I am going to sell.
Question 3: I gather that you add onto winning positions; what amounts
do you normally do at a time and when do you add position?
I will usually start with a single entry that risks less than 1% of my total equity,
and then I will add to that position ONLY when the first position is significantly in
profit. Usually this is at a level where my stop loss on the second position is at
or above the entry of the first position. I will generally add until I have four
positions. I will also generally lift my stop loss on earlier positions as I add new
positions. This keeps the risk low.
See above.
I have found that Options only really work well when there is a very fast moving
market, or you anticipate a big move. Also, I only buy options when historical
volatility is low because this means the option is relatively cheap and will
increase in value if volatility goes up.
I personally buy 2-3 months out, and far enough out of the money so the option
is relatively cheap. But close enough to the money that if I am right as to the
movement in the market, the strike price will be reached approximately one
third of the way through the option period.
Questions 7: Considering time decay on options, when do you cut your
loss for an option?
If after two weeks it is not profitable, I am clearly wrong (at least on the timing)
and I get out. I may not even wait that long. This is safest because the time
decay is the slowest in the early part of the option period.
Question 8: Assuming the first option is in your favour; when do you add
options (you did mention doubling of the value of the first) and if so,
what will be the strike prices and period for new ones?
That depends on how quickly the first one doubled. As a general rule I will
again look for the same period (e.g. two months) and the same distance from
the money as the original option.
Question 11: How do you decide if you have missed the entry point? i.e.
are you concerned about intraday movements? If so how do they impact
your trading or do you buy at the level of that 20 / 55 day high exactly?
Can the market go past and come back intraday and you still make the
trade?
Generally I put my order in one tick or one point above the 20 day high so I get
hit as it goes through. If it goes through and comes back I would put my buy
order in above the high that it just made, to ensure I am getting it on the way
up. If I miss the market by quite a bit I will probably wait for the 55 day high or
if there is a period of consolidation, wait for it to break out of that and enter
then.
Question 12: Do you for example see that AUD/NZD is trending up and
get your broker to let you know when that point/high is reached and
decide on whether to take the trade then? As I have been keen on long
AUD/NZD but I have missed what I would see as a good entry point.
I never get my broker to tell me anything! I really only use my broker to execute
trades. In other words it is me who sees the price go to a point I like and it is
me who initiates the trade. If you have missed an entry point you are better off
waiting for another opportunity.
Questions 13: Starting out my capital is very small. Do you have any
advice as it seems that even a little volatility in a given market it’s very
easy to get stopped out trying to only risk 1-3 % of your capital per
trade? I guess it’s a matter of being very patient and looking for the
Beautiful trades as you put it. Or do you have to accept more risk
initially? Or am I better to wait and just build up more capital so that
trading risking less is easier?
My view is that you should build good habits now while your equity is small.
That way the mistakes you are going to make will be the cheapest. So yes,
only risk 1-2% of your equity on each trade. If your stops are too tight leading
you to getting stopped out too often, your position size is too big. Use a trading
platform to trade smaller sizes even $10,000 trades. Trading $10,000 with at a
2% risk only allows a $200 loss and of course a 2% stop loss position should
be plenty for Forex.
Question 14: What are your thoughts on long AUD/JPY still looks positive
to me. What else do you like in the market at the moment that you are
following?
I think my main strength is that I viciously cut losing positions. I think of them as
a cancer. The quicker I get rid of them the healthier I will be.
Add to that, if I am unsure of a position I immediately cut it as well. If all you
have left is hope, get out and put the money into something you believe in, or
wait until a trade comes up that you really believe in.
ALSO, if you are trend trading as I have detailed above you MUST expect to
take small losses on approximately 7 out of every 10 trades on average. The 3
winners will cover your losses and give you big profits. So another of my
strengths is that I am happy to take multiple small losses in a row while I am
waiting for the big winner.
Finally, sometimes the best trading decision you can make is to do nothing. It is
far better to sit on the sidelines and wait for a BEAUTIFUL trade, than to try to
chase a market that is not working.
My 2007 Trading Diary
For illustration purposes here is a summary of my trades for the 2007 calendar
year:
122
51
71
$100,000
$171,270
(net of brokerage and carry costs)
171.27%
Total: $171,270
Notes:
1. The first point is that I had 39% more losing trades than winning trades.
The reason I was nevertheless profitable for the year is that I cut my
losing positions quickly and let my winning positions run. In fact I had two
hugely profitable trades during the year. One lasted a few weeks and the
other lasted under two weeks. Essentially I made all of my profits from
the year on those two currency trades. Incidentally both of these resulted
from jumping on an already existing trend and staying with it until it turned.
2. The second thing that sticks out is that I made a huge profit in
Currencies and a large loss in Equities. This is partly because I was not
disciplined enough in keeping my equity losses small, and partly because
when I finally decided to start buying equities, the market turned from
being a bull market to being a bear market. I should have been more
aware of this and I therefore need to be more cautious going forward
when trading equities.
1. Sold the US Dollar against the Canadian Dollar. Total Profit: $100,282
I started this trade with an option over $500,000 that cost me just $2,492.
Once that option had doubled in value, I used the paper profits to buy
another option. I continued to do this until the market turned. I then sold all
of the options and took my profit.
2. Sold the New Zealand Dollar against the Japanese Yen. Total Profit:
$156,615
I started this trade with an option over $400,000 that cost me just $6,968.
Using the same strategy as above, once that option had doubled in value,
I used the paper profits to buy another option. I continued to do this until I
became cautious that the market had moved too far too fast. I then sold
all of the options and took my profit.
Starting small and adding to winning positions is called “scaling in” to positions.
The advantage is that if the trade does not go your way, you only take a small
loss.
Interestingly my two biggest losses occurred when I did not scale in to a
position, rather I took a large initial position that turned against me.
I should not have taken such a huge first position and I should have cut my
losses a lot sooner.
2. Sold the US Dollar against the Japanese Yen. Total Loss: ($56,459)
Both of these losses occurred after I had made big gains and I was flush with
cash. I have learned that the most dangerous time for trading is immediately
after a large winning period.
My 2008 Trading Diary
Here is my percentage gain/loss monthly summary to July 2008:
As you can see I had a fantastic first quarter in the 2008 trading year, although
I was down for January. The second quarter was mixed but overall down and
July 2008 was awful!
I made the decision on 17 July 2008 to stop for the year. What actually
happened is that I did stop for three full months. I did one small set of trades
over late October/early November – long USD. Then I stopped again until mid-
December where I did one last set of trades – short USD.
I was VERY patient and I waited for the right signal. In mid-December I did a
fantastic set of trades (short USD) and made $135,872 in five trading days.
The main reason I stopped in July is that I wanted to preserve my track record
and ensure I made over 100% for the year. Remember I had a gain of
171.27% for the 2007 year. I actually made the decision in mid-June that if I
got to +200% or risked going below +100% I would stop for the year. As soon
as I made that decision I felt great! You could say that it was a waste of three
months trading time, but I prefer to think of it as a gift. I really enjoyed my time
off. I did a lot of writing, went overseas four times (two of which were family
holidays) and spent a lot of time with my family.
I also used my non-trading time to motivate myself to trade better. The reason I
went down to 114.95% in July after sitting between 130% and 170% for two to
three months is that I was trading badly! The truth is, I deserved to lose
money in July!
I am a trend trader. That is how I make the bulk of my profits. Other traders
make money other ways, but I follow trends. The fact of the matter is that in
the markets I trade, there were no good trends from April to July, with the
exception of one currency pair – Kiwi Aussie.
What I should have done was – nothing! I should have sat on my hands and
waited for a good trending trade. Instead I got chopped up trying to trade
break-outs that turned out to be false break-outs and then I made the mistake
of trading the range. I should have recognised earlier that we were in a range
trading market. I should either have kept my trades very small or I should not
have traded at all.
2. Overtrading
As you will see from the summary below I did 271 trades in just over six
months. If I take out the holiday weeks where I was not trading, it means on
average I did 11 trades per week, or over two per day! Note that I am NOT a
day trader. In fact I am a medium term trader who takes a view over a number
of weeks or months. Profitable medium term trades DO NOT occur 11 times
per week. In fact they generally occur only a few times per year.
One of the reasons that the Turtle Traders described in Curtis Faith’s book (see
below) traded so well is that they were literally not allowed to take a trade until
a prescribed set of rules was met. They played a lot of ping-pong to help the
hours go by when there were no trades allowed!
I need to do the same thing. I now have a strict set of rules that will only allow
me to enter a trade under certain specific circumstances. I know I have a lot of
things I can do with the extra time!
For illustration purposes here is a summary of my trades for the 2008 calendar
year:
Analysis
1. The first point is that I had 21% more losing trades than winning trades
(in 2007 it was 39% more losers than winner!). Once again the reason I
was nevertheless profitable for the year is that I cut my losing positions
quickly and let my winning positions run.
In 2008 I had four significantly profitable trades. Two lasted a few weeks
each and the other two were short trades. Essentially I made all of my
profits from the year on these four trades:
3. Once again I had a significant loss in equities. This is an area I really had
to improve on because it had been a losing category for me for two
years.
4. As I already said, I overtraded. 271 trades in six months is way too
many. In last year’s summary I said I overtraded but this year I traded 2.8
times as often!!! I will say it again – great trades do not come up every
week or even every month – so what am I doing taking trades that do not
look great? Answer: throwing money away.
1. Sold the USD dollar against the Euro, Sterling and the Swiss Franc
This was the trade that took just five working days in December 2008.
The best thing about this trade is that the TOTAL risk on the trade was
$2,775. Yes just two thousand seven hundred and seventy five dollars.
The reason the risk was so low is that I only started with one position long
100,000 Euro vs USD. I put my stop loss in so that my maximum loss was
only $2,775. When that position was profitable I locked in the profit by
raising my stop loss and then I took another position. I continued to do
this until I had many hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of positions,
all protected by trailing stop losses.
NOTE CAREFULLY this was one of the best of all of the trades available
in 2008. The USD dollar fell 17 big figures (that is 1700 points) in five
trading days. That is almost unprecedented and falls of that magnitude
only happen a few times in a decade, so do not think you are going to go
out tomorrow and risk $2,775 to make $135,000.
However, after this trade was completed I analysed what would have
happened if I had just kept my $1.2m in the physical (cash) position and
not sold this to buy options. As it turned out I would have been better off
if I had kept the physical positions. The reason for this is that this
currency pair moved slowly. Where currencies move slowly it is better to
have a physical position because the time value of the option erodes
faster than the currencies are moving. Also there is usually a big spread
between the price of buying and selling the option and you need to make
up that spread during the time of the trade.
As I said in the 2007 summary; currency options are best in fast moving
markets but not so good in slow markets.
This is a good example of a profitable trade that was easy to see and
was very likely to be profitable. Unfortunately it is not a trade that is likely
to be repeatable in the near future. Bank Bill Futures are primarily valued
in relation to the expectation of the future Reserve Bank Official Cash
Rate (OCR). At the time I traded these, the Bank Bills were priced such
that a cut in interest rates was not expected until late 2008 or early 2009.
It was my strong conviction that the Reserve Bank would have to cut
interest rates earlier than that. Bank Bill Futures rise in price as
expectations of an interest rate cut increase. It was relatively straight
forward to hold these futures over market announcements (which were
usually bad) and take profit after the announcement.
Unfortunately the opportunity has now gone, but there will be a time in the
future when the market is mispricing interest rate policy, and I look
forward to that!
Similar to last year my two biggest losses occurred when I took large up-front
positions rather than scaling in to positions. When am I going to learn? Answer:
now! I have strict rules against this practice now.
1. Sold $1.5m NZ$ against Japanese Yen AND sold $1.5m US$ against the
Japanese Yen.
I made this trade and took this loss in under six hours – ouch! My
position size was too big and my stop loss was at a place where
everyone else had their stop loss. Consequently I had a slippage loss of
over US$10,000. I also (knowingly) traded through the weekly crude oil
inventory news release which caused the big sell off and therefore the
slippage. Also I was “playing the range” rather than staying with the trend.
In other words I got bored waiting for a good trending trade and decided
to try to buy it at a low point in the trading range, hoping to sell it higher in
the trading range. I am sure there are a lot of traders who are good at
trading the range. However, I am not one of them! I should have been
patient and traded what I am good at – trading the trend.
Trade I Missed
There is one glaring trade I should have taken that would have increased my
profitability by at least $100,000.
I watch around 15 futures contracts and when I get a buy signal I must buy
each time and every time. Unfortunately I was too busy in February trading my
agricultural commodities to look at Heating Oil. The buy signal in Heating Oil
Futures was given in early February and the contract climbed strongly until the
end of May. Had I taken it, the trade would have been my second most
profitable of the year. The lesson here is that I need to keep looking at all of
the signals on all of the commodities I trade. I also need to look for a second
entry point if I miss the first entry point. If I had entered in March I still would
still have taken 75% of the profit from the trade.
Summary
This doesn’t look good and it doesn’t feel good! I have instituted a new
“Preserving Capital” rule as follows:
If in any one month my equity falls 9%, cut all existing trades (except
strongly profitable trades) and enter no new trades until the beginning of
the next month.
Having had the discipline in 2008 to stop completely for three months, I realise
the huge benefit of stepping back from the markets to get some perspective.
The Perfect Trade
The perfect trade can be created using a decision flow chart and by adhering
to a formula.
Please gift this Book to friends, colleagues and fellow traders via Amazon.
Go here to gift it now. Simply click on the book title then click on the “Give as a
Gift” button. Click here:
www.Amazon.com/author/1
The Main Event
I’ll be honest, the advice, principles and strategies in this book are just the
introduction.
In that book I go into much more detail and cover a number of new topics that
are key to successful trading. The book will help you avoid many common
mistakes and help you make the right trading choices.
You can register for the launch of my book here. You are not committing to
anything, you are simply expressing your interest:
www.TradingBook.net/launch
I hope you do because I want to make your trading successful and enjoyable.
Happy Trading,
Oli Hille