IBM E-Business Model
IBM E-Business Model
Executive Summary 1
IBM at a Crossroads 2
IBM as an e-business 8
Lessons Learned 13
IBM in the early 1990s was a company in dire need of simplification and
adopted a strategy of streamlining its core business processes by simplifying
them. IBM’s simplification initiatives fell under five general categories:
• Internal business processes
• Applications
• IT infrastructure
• Management processes
• Operations
As a result of its transformation, IBM is now better equipped to compete in the
emerging information economy, which demands speed, flexibility and the
effective leveraging of information. Another significant benefit of IBM’s
transformation experience has been the ability to apply its own lessons
learned—as well as those gleaned from thousands of customer engagements—
to other businesses. This has allowed IBM to effectively create a new model
for companies seeking to embrace e-business. This model, called the e-
business cycle, outlines four steps that organizations must address as they
reinvent themselves for e-business. These steps are defined as:
• Transform business processes
• Build new applications
• Run a scalable, available, secure environment, and
• Leverage knowledge and information.
Of all the process transformation initiatives conducted by IBM thus far, none is
more important than IBM’s Web-enabling of its core business processes and
internal systems. An ongoing part of its transformation process, IBM’s Web-
enabling efforts have yielded a series of highly successful programs targeted to
customers (e-commerce and e-care for Customers), suppliers (e-procurement),
partners (e-care for Business Partners), influencers (e-care for Influencers)
and employees (e-learning and Knowledge Management).
1
IBM at a Crossroads
2
Simple is Better: A Key Theme of IBM’s Transformation
IBM in the early 1990s was a company in dire need of simplification. Tradi-
tionally, the company had promoted country and unit independence and
rewarded individual excellence often at the expense of overall corporate
objectives. For example, IBM’s product designs called for little commonality of
components, thus squandering a major opportunity for cost efficiencies. On
the IT operations side, fragmentation and inefficiency were equally rampant—
pushing data processing costs to three times the industry average. The sheer
numbers tell the story: In 1991, IBM operated 155 separate data centers
worldwide, employed 128 CIOs, ran 31 private and separate networks, and had
hundreds of different configurations of PC installations. To address this, IBM
adopted a strategy of streamlining its core business processes by simplifying
them. IBM’s simplification initiatives fell under five general categories:
• Internal business processes
• Applications
• IT infrastructure
• Management processes
• Operations
!Simplified Applications
IBM’s initial focus was on reversing the unchecked proliferation of applications
throughout the company. An audit, conducted at the start of the consolidation
IBM embarked on an effort, provided a measure of the scope of the problem: approximately 16,000
effort that led to a applications were running within the company, of which nearly one-third
reduction of its base of lacked clear ownership. At the same time, the company, which had as a rule
applications by nearly developed the majority of its software on its own, recognized that no single
one half and began a company could do it all alone. As a result of these revelations, IBM embarked
on an effort that led to a reduction of its base of applications by nearly one
practice of buying and
half, and also began a practice of buying and running best-of-category applica-
running best-of-category tions from leading software developers. Examples of best of category third-
applications. party applications now used by IBM include SAP for ERP, Siebel for CRM, i2
for supply chain management, and Ariba for procurement.
3
IBM, like most other established companies, continues to rely on some key
legacy systems and applications to run its business. To enable itself and its
customers to develop and deploy e-business solutions in this environment, IBM
created the Application Framework for e-business. Conceived as a foundation
for developing and deploying e-business solutions, the Framework is built
IBM’s Application around a set of industry standards and technologies, proven methodology, and
leadership products.
Framework for
e-business, designed to
IBM's internal adaptation of the Application Framework for e-business is
facilitate the develop-
called Global Web Architecture (GWA), a common Web architecture for all of
ment and deployment of its internal and external Web hosting in support of IBM's e-business initiatives
e-business solutions in provided in partnership with IBM Global Services. Seven GWA centers in
a legacy environment, is Raleigh, Southbury, Boulder, Schaumburg, Portsmouth, Kawasaki, and Sydney
built around a set of have been configured with standard hardware and software, systems manage-
industry standards and ment, and network and security components. Core elements of GWA include
VisualAge for Java, Lotus Notes/Domino, the DB2 family of products (data-
technologies, proven bases and connectivity to mainframe DB2 databases), and MQSeries, which is
methodology, and used to link IBM's newer solutions with legacy systems. More recent additions
leadership products. to the Application Framework include WebSphere Application Server and
WebSphere Commerce Suite, as well as software products from NetObjects and
Tivoli Systems, which are used to provide end-to-end application, system and
network management. Having GWA in place allows IBM to build speed and
flexibility for e-business into its processes.
!Simplified IT Infrastructure
Prior to IBM’s transformation efforts, its sprawling IT infrastructure epitomized
the fragmentation and lack of standardization that permeated the IBM organiza-
tion as a whole. In the early 1990’s, IBM was running 155 data centers.
Outside the data centers, inefficiencies were equally common. For instance,
the company operated 31 private networks and supported over 100 client
configurations. Faced with the challenge of reining in its IT infrastructure,
IBM embraced a two-phased approach: consolidation, followed by standardiza-
tion. As a result of its consolidation efforts, IBM reduced the number of its
data centers by close to 90%, to 16 worldwide and transitioned to one global
network. Four standard client configurations were established. IBM’S IT costs
which had once been three times the industry average were dramatically
reduced.
4
IBM continues to evolve towards what it calls an “intelligent infrastructure”—
characterized by high-speed networks, seamlessly integrated applications, and
powerful servers designed and optimized for specific computing workloads.
!Simplified Operations
One of the key outgrowths of IBM’s transformation initiative was an increased
IBM’s decision to willingness to outsource IT services—including application development and
integration and infrastructure deployment and management—to IBM Global
outsource IT services
Services. This approach has allowed IBM staff to focus on strategic issues and
has enabled it to focus has helped enforce standards and reduce redundancies, resulting in significant
on strategic issues and process and cost efficiencies. Under this drive for “operational simplicity,”
reap major efficiencies. IBM has essentially adopted the credo, “If it’s not your main business,
outsource it.”
6
IBM’s Transformation Framework Emerges
7
IBM as an e-business
!ibm.com
The underlying theme of “one IBM” has driven transformation efforts and
supported the company’s continuing e-business transformation. In an
e-business environment, branding remains critical and requires special skills.
One of the most visible and important elements of the company’s e-business
transformation centers on ibm.com, its Web site. In the first few years after its
e-business Metrics May 1994 launch, the site’s purpose was to provide company and product
information. Like many corporate Web presences in the mid-1990s, ibm.com
Focus on:
was a reflection of the company’s organizational structure. Nearly every
Web-enabled organization and geography was putting content on the site. Many of these
Call Centers content pages had their own “look and feel” and while each of the sites had its
own merits, they were organizationally driven, not customer driven. Over time,
the disparate nature of the overall site was a barrier not only to content presen-
!Scope
In late 1999, IBM fully
tation and navigation, but to IBM’s e-commerce ambitions. As the world of
integrated its Web sites with its e-business experienced explosive growth, IBM needed to make ibm.com easier
worldwide call centers. to use for its customers.
ibm.com has more than 2000
sales professionals who are As it set to redesign ibm.com in September, 1998—its ninth redesign since
brand specialists, each of whom
1994—IBM conducted extensive customer research and solicited the feedback
generates an average of $5M
revenue per year.
of IT decision makers, developers, IT implementers, business and general
users. A key finding of the study was that the majority of respondents visited
ibm.com for product information, comparative shopping and support, and
!ROI/Business Results
wanted relevant information presented in a unified and easy-to-use manner.
Revenue generated by special-
ists using IBM’s Web-enabled
call center—or “TeleWeb”— IBM has increasingly leveraged its Web sites into other customer channels in
facilities costs 40% less to order to increase access and reach with all its customer segments. In addition,
produce than that of traditional in 1999, IBM integrated its Web presences in more than 70 countries with its
face-to-face reps. worldwide call center operations, to provide customers with a seamless pre-
and post-sales and support experience, or what the company calls “e-relation-
!Key Featur es
Features ships.” The integrated ibm.com channel offers “teleweb” features that allow
As part of IBM’s "Call-Me" customers to browse for products or solutions on the Web and click on either a
coverage, IBM customers can “Call Me Now” or “Chat Online” button that connects them to a call center
browse products, solutions, etc.
sales specialist who knows what page and product the customer is considering.
on the Web and click on either
a “Call Me Now” or “Chat
On the Web site itself, IBM has focused on developing a consistent “look and
Online” button that connects feel” and navigation scheme throughout the site. The site is organized in a way
them to a call center sales that makes sense to its customers including single click-throughs for key
specialist who knows what page audiences like small businesses, consumers, developers, business partners and
and product they're seeing. investors, as well as buttons for key functions like ShopIBM, Download and
Support.
In May of 2000, IBM launched the 10th redesign of ibm.com, which included
200,000 new Web pages designed to provide customers and partners world-
wide with a consistent user experience from information gathering to shopping,
buying and support. An ongoing part of its transformation process, IBM’s Web-
enabling efforts have yielded a series of highly successful programs targeted to
customers, suppliers, partners, influencers and employees, which are outlined
on the following pages.
8
!e-commerce
The key goals of IBM’s e-commerce programs are to build revenues and reduce
costs by selling IBM products and services online. Through 3Q2000, IBM
generated e-commerce revenue of $14.6B, versus $9.9B for the same period
in 1999. In 1999, the total of IBM’s e-commerce revenue was nearly $14.8B.
E-commerce revenue is comprised of sales through ibm.com, including e-sites
for enterprise customers, Small Business Centers for Small Business Customers
and ShopIBM for the general public, all of which include both end-to-end Web
e-business Metrics and Web-assisted call center revenue, IBM Business Partners and OEM
partners. Top product categories among IBM’s e-commerce transactions
Focus on: include PC products, midrange servers, software and technology products.
e-pr ocur
e-procur ement
ocurement
!e-procurement
!Scope Under its e-procurement initiative, IBM procured $27.7B in goods and
19,000 suppliers are enabled services over the Web through 3Q2000, yielding cost savings of $246.6M. Of
for Web-based e-procurement, the roughly 19,000 IBM suppliers now enabled for Web-based e-procurement,
including 7,500 enabled YTD over 7,500 joined through 3Q2000. One of the major benefits of IBM’s Web-
in 2000.
based procurement approach has been a quantum leap in the efficiency of
purchasing within IBM, and a commensurate increase in satisfaction among
!Volume IBM employees. When IBM’s e-procurement initiative began, 60 percent of
IBM procured $27.7B in goods IBM employees were dissatisfied with the existing process due to such factors
and services over the Web
as the time it took to process a purchase order (30 days) and the average length
through 3Q2000, compared to
of a contract (more than 40 pages). As a result of these inefficiencies, one in
$13B for all of 1999.
three IBM employees engaged in “maverick buying”—bypassing the standard
procurement process to avoid the bureaucracy—often incurring higher costs as
!ROI/Business Results
a result. By Web-enabling the procurement process, IBM has reduced its
• Overall cost savings of complexity. Purchase order process time is now one day, maverick buying is
$246.6M. down to 2%, internal employee satisfaction has increased by 45%, and the
• Major reduction in average length of contracts has been reduced to six pages.
procurement cycle time
• Increased employee !e-care for Business Partners
satisfaction
IBM’s e-care for Business Partners is designed to promote loyalty and revenue
• Major decrease in growth through Web-based programs. Through 3Q2000, 20,000 partners used
“maverick” buying
Global PartnerInfo and purchased $9.3B on the Web. IBM’s PartnerInfo
• Improved ability to application allows Business Partners to access product and marketing informa-
leverage IBM’s buying tion in 10 languages. PartnerCommerce, IBM’s Web-based ordering tool for
clout via improved Business Partners, gives partners the ability to check on supply status, pur-
company-wide informa-
chase products, and track orders on the Web. PartnerCommerce also offers
tion sharing capabilities
Business Partners the means to apply for and receive credit and financing
online through IBM Global Financing. IBM’s QuickShip application has
reduced Business Partners’ order/shipping cycle from three days to less than
24 hours.
9
!e-care for Customers
IBM’s e-care for customers initiative provides Web-based customer service and
support to reduce costs and improve customer satisfaction. Through 3Q2000,
IBM handled 66M self-service transactions on ibm.com resulting in more than
$1.4B in cost avoidance and productivity gains. These Web-based self-service
e-business Metrics inquiries enable customers to obtain product information, installation and
service information, and to download software updates, fixes, ‘early release’ or
Focus on:
‘beta’ code. Customers are also able to track the status of open problems and
e-car
e-caree for Customers communicate with IBM via the Web. Through personalized technical support,
PC users can put a profile of their PC on the PC Support site, which enables
!Volume IBM to tailor its technical support to the customer’s specific needs. Moreover,
Through 3Q2000, IBM handled by integrating ibm.com and IBM’s International Technical Support Organiza-
66M self-service transactions tion (ITSO), IBM is now able to provide extensive online technical content
on ibm.com. through its Redbooks to customers and Business Partners worldwide, enhanc-
ing their online shopping experience. About 200,000 IBM Redbooks are
!ROI/Business Results downloaded each month from the ibm.com/redbooks Website, which experi-
Through 3Q2000, e-care for ences more than 11 million hits per month.
customers provided IBM with
more than $1.4B in cost
avoidance and productivity
!e-care for Influencers
gains. The e-care for Influencers program provides Web-based access to information
and resources for such key stakeholders as the press, IT consultants, financial
!Customer Benefits analysts and shareholders, and prospective employees, with tailored Web sites
Through Web-based self- on ibm.com providing easy and worldwide access to information. IBM’s Press
service inquiries, customers Room for the media offers access to company press releases, executive biogra-
can get product information, phies and speeches, high-resolution photography and a worldwide database of
installation and service press reps by beat.
information, download software
updates and fixes. IBM’s e-care
for Customers also enables the
!Knowledge Management
downloading of 'early release' With more than 300,000 employees, IBM has the largest deployment of Lotus
or 'beta' code, as well as Notes and Domino which have proven to be crucial tools for Knowledge
tracking of the status of open Management. The centerpiece of IBM’s Knowledge Management initiatives is
problems. IBM also provides ICM/Asset Web, a Lotus Notes/Domino application that supports the gathering,
extensive online technical managing and publishing of intellectual capital. Used by professionals within
content through its Redbooks
IBM’s Global Services organization, ICM/AssetWeb has thus far produced more
to customers and Business
Partners worldwide, enhancing than $27 million in productivity improvements as its base of users has nearly
their online shopping experi- tripled since the beginning of 1998. The system also has increased win rates
ence. by as much as 90 percent for certain practice areas within Global Services and
improved cycle times by up to 60 percent.
The highly mobile nature of the IBM work force (approximately 40 percent of
employees overall) makes it an ideal proving ground for a variety of collabora-
tive tools and applications, including instant messaging (Lotus Sametime),
e-meetings, and virtual workplaces. The Notes/Web platform enables IBM
employees to work with colleagues across time zones and geographic distances
and improve team effectiveness and execution.
10
!e-learning
One of IBM’s key Knowledge Management initiatives, e-learning provides
employees with Web-based services such as distance learning, whose features
e-business Metrics include online instruction, study groups and exams. Services such as Web-
based distance learning dovetail closely with IBM’s highly mobile workforce,
Focus on: which don’t have time to spend in a classroom, but nonetheless need to keep
e-lear ning
e-learning up-to-date. Through 3Q2000, approximately 36% of all employee training
was through distributed learning, for a total cost avoidance of $312M. IBM
!e-lear ning in Action
e-learning estimates that for every 1,000 classroom days converted to distance learning,
IBM’s Basic Blue program more than $400K in costs can be avoided.
provides management training
to all new managers worldwide An area that has especially capitalized on e-learning technologies is manage-
via a Notes/Web-based plat- ment training. Today, IBM delivers Notes/Web-based management develop-
form. A similar program, based ment programs to all new managers worldwide. This e-learning model, called
on Basic Blue, is offered to
Basic Blue, blends Web-based performance support, virtual collaboration and
customers under the name IBM
Management Development classroom experiences; it has won four major awards to date, including three
Services. best practice citations by the American Society for Training and Development,
one of the world’s premier professional associations in workplace learning and
!ROI/Business Results performance. Based on this success and to respond to customer demand, IBM
modified Basic Blue and created a customer offering, called IBM Management
• Through 3Q2000, Development Services. To date, more than 2700 courses (mostly developed on
approximately 36% of all Lotus LearningSpace) have been delivered to IBM employees via its IBM
employee training was
Global Campus Web site.
through distributed
learning, producing a
total cost avoidance of Similarly, marketing training has heavily leveraged IBM’s e-learning technolo-
$312M. gies, with one third of its curriculum delivered through Web-based distance
• IBM estimates that for learning. In the market intelligence area, a new 18-month training and
every 1,000 classroom accreditation program is all done on the Web. This program, called Core Body
days converted to of Knowledge, has resulted in 60-70% cost savings and significantly improved
distance learning, more program effectiveness.
than $400K in costs can
be avoided.
• IBM’s Core Body of
Knowledge program,
which features include
on-line instruction, study
groups and exams, has
resulted in 60-70% cost
savings and significantly
improved program
effectiveness.
11
A New Corporate Culture
12
Lessons Learned
13
IBM’s Road Ahead
As the Web continues to produce new value models that will fundamentally
transform relationships with customers, partners, suppliers, and employees,
adaptability and speed will remain key competitive advantages. IBM also
expects changes in technology—both evolutionary and revolutionary—to alter
the landscape of Web-based computing. For example, IBM expects the Next
Generation Internet (NGi) to become so pervasive, reliable and transparent that
Knowledge manage- it will be taken for granted. Moreover, as part of what it calls “pervasive
ment and management computing,” IBM expects a far wider range of devices—from appliances to
will become synony- cars to products—to contain embedded semiconductor devices and interface
mous as the process of with the Internet.
inventorying, classify-
ing and sharing knowl- Within enterprises, more powerful processors married to more sophisticated
algorithms in powerful software will enable enterprises to “data mine” for new
edge becomes the insight and competitive advantage—including more personalized customer
generally accepted way relationships—while voice recognition will link with automatic translation to
of running a company. all but eradicate the issue of language differences as a barrier to communica-
tions. If “knowledge management” still seems like an awkward phrase, it won’t
be for long. Knowledge management and management will become synony-
mous as the process of inventorying, classifying and sharing knowledge
becomes the generally accepted way of running a company. IBM is well
positioned to exploit these trends and many others as it continues its transfor-
mation journey.
12-00
G325-1831-00
14