French Spectral Music An Introduction
French Spectral Music An Introduction
French Spectral Music An Introduction
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Cambridge University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend
access to Tempo
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Viviana Moscovich
The composers belonging to what would later be research, the impact of electroacoustics on musical
called the 'spectral music movement' started their thought, and, above all, the collapse of the social and
careers in an unstable political period in France. mental barriers under which the [musical] profession
Between 1962 and 1974, under the presidency was becoming ossified.1
of Charles de Gaulle and Georges Pompidou, Another reason for this change in aesthetic
France (the 5th Republic) was what we can call thought was related to the notion of timbre, for
a 'Gaullist Republic'. But in the middle of the since the beginning of the 20th century, two
1960s the economic policy of the government correlated factors have influenced the aesthetics
aroused the hostility of the French people. The of the musical world: the emergence of timbre
'Stabilization Plan' of 1-963 induced unemploy- as a fundamental factor in composition, and the
ment for the first time since 1945, and the development of new materials such as elect-
authoritarian character of a government which, ronics, transmission, recording, computers and
in 1967, legislated in the form of ordonnances, data processing. The use of timbre - instead of
turned the people against the presidential policy tones - is a choice based on technological and
in every domain. cultural parameters.
In May 1968 the crisis became a cultural The beginning of this change in musical
revolution. The main groups involved were the language and perception began in the 19th
students and the workers. Immense manifest- century with the appearance of Fourier's sound
ations were organized following repressions by analysis of any continuous sound signal, giving a
the police. On 13 May red flags with the insignia physical characterization to each and every signal.
'Ten years is enough!' (Dix ans ca suffit!) were raised Sound is not a nucleus but a whole, composed of
against the Gaullist government. The objectives different parts. A signal is therefore decomposed
of the movement of 1968 (the 'soixante-huitards') in series of harmonics and sound is represented
were: I. the revolt of the people; 2. to free the in the form of a mathematical formula. Sound as
individual; 3. to reverse the sodal order; 4. to a whole - and not only as a definite pitch -
change the way of life. On 30 May, de Gaulle becomes the composer's raw material, involving
announced the dissolution of the Assembly, and also factors such as the acoustic phenomenon of
on 30 June, in the parlimentary elections, the physical sounds, the human perception of these
Gaullist party obtained a vast majority. sounds, the psycho-physiological response to
After this period of crisis, and during the sound stimulus, and the choice of sound sources.
presidency of Georges Pompidou, there emerged This kind of compositional work called also for a
- mainly in France - a generation of young change in such notions as melody and musical
composers born in the 1940s. The most important timing.
were Johannes Fritsch and Mesias Maiguashca The forerunners of this composition technique
from Germany, Jonathan Harvey from England,
in music are, in chronological order: Debussy,
Gilles Tremblay and Claude Vivier from Canada, Varese, Scelsi and Messiaen.
and Gerard Grisey, Tristan Murail, Hugues Debussy revolutionized the musical world by
Dufourt, Horatiu Radulescu from France.
introducing two major changes in the linear
After the events of 1968, recoiling from what organization of melody:
seemed a dead-end in the evolution of contemp-
1. By thinking of sound as a perceived object,
orary music, these young composers gathered and using it to evoke an image, a colour or a
together to open a new way in musical comp- feeling by choosing to mix the sounds into
osition. They began to create in a period of great
sound-fields of different lengths.
instrumental development, or, as Dufourt put it:
1 H. Dufourt, Auto Portrait, extract from the file on spectral
the prominent pheonomena of this decade [the decade
music (Centre de Documentation de la Musique Contemp-
of 1967-1977] [are]: the development of instrumental oraine), (Paris, La Villette: 1977), p.3: Orientations.
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
22 French Spectral Music: an Introduction
2 After A. Castanet and Odile Vivier in A. Castanet, in Le timbre, mdtaphore pour la composition, eg. J.H. Barriere
(Bourgois/Ircam, 1991), pp.125-126.
'Musiques Spectrales: nature organique et materiaux sonores
au 20e siecle', in Dissonanz (Dissonance) no.20, p.5. 4 T. Murail, 'Questions de cible', in Entretemps 8, p.154.
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
French Spectral Music: an Introduction 23
George Benjamin has written about Murail's Afterwards, the frequencies obtained are approx-
work: imated to a quarter of a tone so they can be played by
musical instruments, which results in:*
Murail's music is based on the physical, acoustic
properties of sound itself, rather than on any artificial Additionals Differentials
slow, and the music was static. In the 1990s, one 9: >1 O s
can instantaneously hear complex transform-
ations. This has affected the form of the pieces,
which became more whole and contrasting,
instead of linear and progressive.5 This chord's sound makes us instantan
In Entretemps 8, Marc-Andre Dalvabie analyses of a bell. It has an amplitudes envelope w
at length the beginning of Murail's Gondwana the percussion/resonance. In the orchest
(1980). Some of the main points of his analysis that the medium and low sounds are
will serve to illustrate Murail's compositional brass, that the modulant is played by th
process in this work: has the largest mass, and that the high f
played by the woodwind instruments w
The whole harmonic generating principle in Gondwana imbalance: the first clarinet is placed ab
is based on a technique of sound synthesis started by two oboes in a very resonant register (Ar
John Chowning. This technique is based on an oboes are in their weak register (F+5
algorithm that generates the partials as well as the Next, the composer starts a process of
amplitudes, which constitute the basic structure of the which consists in a continuous evolution from an
timbre. The frequencies result from an algebraic object A to an object B. The above-mentioned chord
operation: will be repeated 12 times. The first, second, fourth,
HARMONICS = CARRIER (porteuse) + fifth and eighth chords are frequence modulations
[MODULANT x INDEX] whose pitch relations become more and more
The index of the modulation represents the harmonical harmonic. The last chord is a superposition of two
density. harmonic spectra: G# 1 and F# 2.
In the beginning of the score, (for example) if we The intermediate chords (third, sixth, seventh,
have as carrier sol(G)3 i.e. 392 Hz, as modulant ninth, tenth, eleventh) are each one made of the
sol(G)#2: 207,6 Hz and as index of modulation 9, resulting interpolation of the two surrounding chords.
according to the algorithm exposed before we obtain The third chord, for example, is the result of the
the following harmonics: interpolation between the second and fourth chords....
This progression process has as its model the trombone
Hi = P + (Mxl)
sound in the eleventh chord. ... It is interesting to
H1=392 + (207,65xl)=599,65
notice the strong relation existing between perception
H2=392 + (207,65x2)=807,30
etc
and writing procedures ... This kind of sound control
could not have been achieved without the timbre
Hi=P - (Mxl)
torsion procedures available in electroacoustic music
H-1=392 - (207,65xl)=184,35
and those of the orchestra, which induce the division of
H-2=392 - (207,65x2)= 23,30
etc.
parameters. [...] Transposing studio techniques to the
orchestra corresponds to a synthesis. Spectral music is
but the continuation of this synthesis.... Tristan Murail
perceived this need, and Gondwana corresponds to a
5 After Marc Texier, 'L'univers de Tristan Murail', in
Risonance No. 1, IRCAM, Mars 1992. * Note that in this table the plus sign represents a quarter-sharp.
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
24 French Spectral Music: an Introduction
kind of ultimate point of what can be realized with a About his own work, Dufourt has written that
symphonic orchestra in the utilization of a highly there are six basic precepts in spectral music:9
permeating timbre model.6 1. The piece is conceived as a synthetic
J.C. Risset represents the most scientific point
whole;
of departure within the spectral movement. His 2. There is a basic congruence between the
whole and its inner division;
basic interest is in the discovery and the creation
of new sounds, distorting sound, and obtaining 3. The manner in which the piece is
unknown sound illusions with the help of organized coincides with the manner in
computerized sound analysis. In Musique, calcul which it evolves through time;
secret, he explains that: 4. Spectral music is founded on a theory of
functional fields and on an aesthetics of
Mathematics seems proper to throw the light on many unstable forms;
musical phenomenae. [...] It give us generating or
5. This music marks a progress towards
explanatory musical models - but it does not seem to
give us the key, the model. ... The long distance modes
immanence and transparence;
6. The renewal of the traditional instru-
of arrangements, of musical equilibrium, remain
mysterious, the sense of the 'big form' seems to escape mental practice, that of string and wind
any explanation based on models. The validity, the instruments.
musical sense of a formalism, of a syntax depends on In his Auto portrait from 1977, in his own
the context and even more on the compositional analysis of his work Erewhon (Symphony for
purpose - and as to the creative process: does it not percussion, written between 1972-1976) he
consist in creating and elaborating new rules rather explains the following:10
than in exploiting existing ones?
[...] The computer seems to ascribe to the role of a What counts in the percussion is not the impact, it is
notes' mill, a musical rilling mill to the Km, better than the resonance's dynamic spectrum. According to the
the synthesizers and their sequencers... There is nature of the sticks and to the playing quality, we
nothing fatal in that the computer will be used in a obtain from the same instrument - gong, cymbal, tam-
normative, oppressive sense, to codify, to homogenize. tam - a multitude of unstable and very varied
... The computer is not there to make music profit from resonances: quick or slow developments, oscillations
the prestige of science... it is not unimportant to show ... Percussion modifies profoundly the relations
that the computer can be turned into a tool to the between production and sound perception.
service of the musician - a multiple tool in favour of [...] Percussion changes are perception of duration
individuality, of the difference, helping each musician ... by carrying us to extremes, it intensifies the
to make his own musical instrument, to evoke and contradictions - it is the conflict of these dynamic
transform sounds to his will.... It is essential to make it systems that decides of the temporal form. A flow
[the computer] work in synergy with man - the human (flux) for example, is but a way of oscillating, without
intervention has to inflect or direct the implemented deciding, between two antagonizing Tempi. All my
processes. ... At each stage, at each level, the musician writing principles rely on opposing and complemen-
will be able to keep control (or not). tary determination systems.
[...] The computer's synthesized sound material
In his preface to L'orage - d'apres Giorgione of
presents a malleability without precedent, it lends itself
1976-1977, Dufourt explains:
to new modes of arrangement, to new architectures.
But we have to 'clarify this material' in the light of the bass register of wind instruments - flute, double
perception.7 bass, clarinet, cor anglais (tenor oboe) and trombone -
unfold in a very slow time, of heaviness and
Hugues Dufourt has written that:
sluggishness.
From the work of Jean-Claude Risset we conclude to The emission is ample and enables the mutual
the certitude that the fundamental concepts of the new recovery of the masses, the somewhat atmospheric
musical acoustics have an intercategorical status, that treatment of timbre. This treatment is emphasized by
they proceed by differentation and integration of the the utilization of electronic instruments that set up, in
various information categories. Psycho-acoustics will the background, a field of tensional values.
have the task of identifying the constraints of The sonority of the vibraphone, of the guitar or of
coherence and assembling them into an ensemble of the electric organ is not diffused in the space, it would
conditions.8 rather tend to be contracted. From here we come to the
somewhat paradoxical interest that could represent the
confrontation between all these instruments.11
6 Marc-Andre Dalbavie, 'Notes sur Gondwana', in Entretemps
No.8, Paris, Sept. 1989. 9 H. Dufourt, 'Musique spectrale', in Consequences No. 7,
7 Jean-Claude Risset, 'Musique, Calcul secret?', in Critique 1985-1986, pp.114-115.
No.359, 1977. 10 H. Dufourt, Auto Portrait, extract from the file on Spectral
Music, CDMC Library, La Villette, Paris, 1977.
8 H. Dufourt, 'La dialectique du son usine', in Consequences
No. 7, automne 85-printemps 86, p.199. 11 H. Dufourt, Preface to the score of this work.
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
French Spectral Music: an Introduction 25
process, we could consider his work Modulations, of pertinent polarizations: E, B, and F which cor-
respond to the Tonic note, the Dominant and the
analysed at length by M. de la Cruz Padron Lopez
second, as in classical harmony. These harmonies are
Le Dilly in her DEA paper. She writes:13
frequently present. If we try to approximate the
12 G. Grisey, 'La musique: le devenir des sons', in
Consdquences No. 7/8, p. 128.
13 Maria de la Cruz Padron Lopes Le-Dilly, 'Aspects de la de DEA de 1'Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales,
"musique spectrale": Modulations de Gerard Grisey', Memoire 1993, pp.93-109.
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
26 French Spectral Music: an Introduction
1/4
I _ I
v..-
1/8
At the beginning,
grammes wean
brass their timbr
instruments use
non-tempered distort them
sounds a
sounds, By
mostly the
in atte
harm
harmonic the materia
sounds thro
[...] a which
process of separ
contin
one
Modulations. (degree
The come
of a little
crossing- idea
different chronometr
ways of writ
- formal relative valu
crossing-ov
- block crossing-ove
- instrumental
14 cross
After M. d
- linear 79-81.
crossing-ove
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
French Spectral Music: an Introduction 27
can distinguish and summarize five processes and one sound was no longer a specific musical note,
breaking-up of the discourse, whose durations are proportional neither was musical composition expected to
to the odd harmonics' spectrum intervals. show the contradictions between different pitch
areas. Sound, considered as a whole integral
Maria Padron Lopez Le Dilly summarizes entity, is decomposed into its different com-
Grisey's cycle Espaces Acoustiques saying that: ponents to show - by achieving a hearing
In the whole cycle there is a growth in sonorous synthesis - the real essence of each and every
density. There is an omnipresent use of micro- sound complex.
intervals, noise, beats, harmonic and inharmonic
spectrae, differential and additional sounds. There is a
process of continuity, and two common landmarks: the
spectrum and the periodicity. The idea of human (I would like to thank my family and Nefer, without
breathing is one of the key parameters for the whose assistance I would not have arrived this far.)
composer.15
This content downloaded from 141.218.30.136 on Tue, 02 Apr 2019 13:59:04 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms