The Role of e-CRM in The Quality of Customer-Bank Relationship
The Role of e-CRM in The Quality of Customer-Bank Relationship
Abstract
Knowing that the customer is the bank's intangible assets and survival of this industry depends on maintaining a
more stable long-term relationship with its valued customers. This study aims to examine the results of the
electronic customer relationship management systems, to maintain and strengthen the relationship between
banks and customers. Also the benefits that obtain from establishing system will be discussed. Thus, after a
review of the literature and history of literature in the field of e-banking and e-CRM and customer service
oriented and quality of service, and the various components of the structure, as a customer based service
attribute and relationship quality and outcome targets of the study was determined after the approval criteria
using confirmatory factor analysis model of the structure was considered. The questionnaire was designed to test
the validity and reliability, confirming the results of its analysis based on structural equation modeling (SEM),
using software AMOS19 showed a significant positive correlation between the deployment of e-CRM and
customer based service attribute and relationship quality and outcome of each component of the structure there.
Keywords: Electronic customer relationship management; e-banking; customer based service attribute;
relationship quality; relationship outcome; SEM.
12
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
INTRODUCTION
Along with advances in information technology, in recent decades, dramatic changes in service industries, has
been created, which is expected that the growth will continue in future. Knowing that the customer is the bank's
intangible assets and survival of this industry depends on maintaining a more stable long-term relationship with
its valued customers. The need for customer orientation and attention to their needs and demands, and provide
better and more customer service, has been more important.
On the other hand, by expanding of people knowledge, their expectations are always increasing. And given to
the human tendency for easier use of the facility, they search to obtain more benefits and better service and
easier access to services that provided by the service firms. This has led to a highly competitive business
environment arise. That the industry will have to constantly In the rush to measure and evaluate their
management practices, and applying modern methods of management, education and training to be competitive
in this environment, survive and grow.
One of the main arguments used by management in this complex competitive situation is the successful
deployment of customer relationship management (CRM) systems and its electronic version in an organization
or industry that can provide significant benefits and advantages for customers to encourage them to maintain
long term relationship and with greater satisfaction with the their banks that due that firms cans ensure loyalty
and support from customers.
So, it is important for industry, particularly service firms, to have full knowledge of CRM and e-CRM subject
and outcome of customer relationship management implementation.
1. Research background
Managerial efforts to manage business interactions with customers through a Kim,Suh and
combination of technology and business processes that are seeking to understand the Hwang[6]
customers.
Customer relationship management (CRM) is composed a set of processes that supporting business strategy to
make long term and profitable relationships with valued customers [7]. Customer data and information
technology (IT) are the main infrastructure of any successful CRM strategy that be made based on these two.
Moreover, the quick growth of the Internet and information technologies has largely increased the opportunities
for improve marketing and has changed the way relationships between companies and their customers [8].
E-CRM systems support all ways of the communication with the customer contain of sales, delivery and after
sales service. E-CRM system support email, online marketing, online purchase, online banking, interaction chat,
personalize and customize service, create customer profiles, automatic response and help.[9]
13
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
According to [10], customer are satisfied and appreciated of faster transaction by e-CRM features and electronic
replay to customer questions, delivery notification and information of payment by e-mails or automatic
responses.
Also, Dyche [2] consider two subsystems for CRM system as: Operational including all ways of customer
contact with firms and Analytical focuses on Process, storage, extraction, customer behavior interpretation and
reporting of customer data. And Reponen [3] also added another component to this two and consider three e-
CRM strategy components: Analytical, operational and collaborative.
So, the CRM system can maximize these perceptions by increase customer relationship quality.
2.4.1. Trust
Trust, is an important relationship quality structure, that most of relationship models considered it. Research
showed [18], [19], a high level of trust is vital to create and maintain a positive long-term relationship.
State that ,There are two type of trust: 1) trust in honesty that based on the belief that someone will doing her/his
role effectively 2)trust in benevolence based on the customer confidence that a firm Use all their efforts to
provide customer convenience and welfare.[ 20][21]
2.4.3. Commitment
The concept of commitment has been widely accepted among researchers as a strong predictor variable .and it is
a major characteristic of relationship marketing models [25].
Morgan & Hunt [14] describe commitment as a major term of relation quality. And define it as a belief that
close relationship with a partner is a Valuable effort to keep and maintain it.
2.4.4. Loyalty
Loyalty is a strong commitment to purchase a product or a better service in the future however the efforts of its
competitors [26].
Firms can maximize their profits with their loyal customers. They willing to purchase more frequently,
repurchase intention, recommend their experience of using of products and services to their friends and relatives
and give companies suggestions [27].
2.5.1. Information
Information quality refers to whether the information through customer service staff and the financial
Institution’s Web site, or electronic services is comprehensive, accurate, true, correct and up to date. [ 32]
2.5.2. Convenience
In the Internet age, when the customer access to various goods and services, when customers need to
convenience not be satisfied, they will certainly seek new levels of service. and will choose only that level of
service Institutions that can provide Higher and better quality services including fast and efficient contact points
Call centers, ATM, responsive systems, operation hours, location of the bank, Internet banking and easier access
to branches, ambience of the banks, etc. [33], [34] .
15
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
Location, if helps the customer to reduce their travel costs and time is also considered a large impact of
convenience [35].
This study attempts to understand the perception and attitude of Iranian customers and the benefits that
customers can get, from their bank’s e-CRM implementation from their perspective.
3.2. Methodology
We began our research with the literature review to identify the major components of Customer based service
attribute and the most common components of relationship quality and outcomes in banking industry in Iran.
From the literature review, the main concepts and application of e-CRM collected and information about,
Iranian banks industry, e-CRM definitions, and e-CRM service activities in Iranian banks and measurement
clarified.
16
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
To explore the constructs of customer based service attribute since were newly developed and relationship
quality and outcome, an exploratory factor analysis, conducted by applying a factor analysis using principal
component extraction and varimax rotation. the Kaiser-Meyer- Olkin (KMO) measure was 0.932 and the
Bartlett’s test was statistically significant(sig=0.000). according the factor score 13 item of customer based
service attributes organized into three groups that we called as information, convenience and communication
channel.
And 15 items of relationship quality and outcome organized into 6 groups that we called them as trust,
satisfaction, commitment, loyalty, retention, recommendation.
The reliability of data was tested with Cronbach’s Alpha coefficient to measure the internal consistency. The
result is 0.948, which shows the high credibility of internal structure design about the questionnaire. Moreover,
Cronbach’s alpha of each construct was calculated to check the measurement instrument’s reliability. It is
shown in table1.
Based on the results of Reliability Analysis, questionnaires for the study contributions were finalized.
This questionnaire is consisting of two parts. The first part is respondent’s demographic data and their financial
electronic service usage. They showed in table 2 and 3.
17
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
And the second part is independent variables and dependent variable for researching model involves. The
second part is related to 28 observed variables contains 6 questions of information, 3 questions of convenience,
4 questions of Communication channel measured the customer based service attribute latent variable. 2
questions of trust,4 questions of satisfaction,3 questions of retention ,2 questions of commitment,2 questions of
recommendation measured the relationship quality and relationship outcome latent variable. This questionnaire
contains a total of 28 questions, according to the survey sampling, the sample size should be 5-10 times for each
questions [39], this release includes a total of 300 questionnaires, that collected by 150 handed out to bank’s
customer in front of 8 branches of the bank in Tehran, Iran. And 150 collected by e-mail and online surveys.
After weeding out ineffective and unqualified 29 questionnaires, 271 valid questionnaires were finally obtained.
The survey also showed (table 4), that the respondents are more familiar with electronic touch-points as ATM
and POS (almost 91%).and the highest percentage results in electronic channel usage showed that (35 %) of
respondents used electronic banking 2-3 times a week. only 1% of respondents never used electronic channel of
their banks. that these collected data promising that the electronic channel will more common among people and
after a few years. people shows more interest for using electronic channel instead of traditional financial
methods.
Table 4. Electronic channel usage
18
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
ECRM
1.671 0.954 0.901 0.921 0.047
Model
Note: CFI=Comparative fit index, NFI= Normed fit index, GFI=Goodness of fit index, RMSA=Root mean square
error of approximation
Composite reliability was issued to evaluate the reliability and convergent validity of each construct. From
result value in table 6 indicated the measurement models considered reliable.
To test the hypotheses, SEM was used. The model was tested by AMOS 19, usuing a covariance matrix, and the
maximum likelihood estimation procedure. All fit indices of these structural model indicated a good fit and the
C.R (t-scores) were above 1.96: p≥0.05). [39]
The Path coefficient indicated that there were statistically significant direct effects of e-CRM implementation on
customer based service attribute and relationship quality and outcome, and significant and positive indirect
effect on all of the e-CRM service attribute and relationship quality and outcome constructs. They Show in table
7.
19
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
E: e-CRM, C.B.S: Customer based service, R.Q&O: relationship Quality and outcome
(t ≥│ 1.96│), P-values: ** <0.01 ,* <0.05
References
[1] Goodhue, D. L., Wixom, B. H., & Watson, H. J.Realizing business benefits through CRM: hitting the
right target in the right way. 79−94.2002.
[2] Dyche, Jill, the CRM handbook. A business guide to customer relationship management, 2002.
[3] Reponen, Tapio, Information Technology, Enabled Global Customer Service, 2003, p288.
[4] Kotler, P. and G. Armstrong. Principles of Marketing. 10th edition. New Jersy: Prentice-Hall.
Englewood liffs, 2004.
[5] Wright, Len tiu, Merlin stone, and Julie Abbott, ―the CRM imperative –practice vs. theory in the
telecommunications industry‖, Journal of database marketing, 2002, 339-49.
[6] Kim, Jonghyeok, Euiho suh, and Hyunseok hwang,‖ A model for evaluating the effectiveness of CRM
using the balanced scorecard‖, Journal of interactive marketing, 2003.
[7] Ling, R., and Yen, D.C. “Customer Relationship Management: An Analysis Framework and
Implementation Strategies”, Journal of Computer Information Systems, 2001, 41(3):82-97.
[8] Ngai, E.W.T. ―Customer Relationship Management Research (1992-2002): An Academic Literature
Review and Classification‖, Marketing Intelligence and Planning, 2005,23(6/7):582-605.
[9] Sims, David;‖A new Roi for new economy CRM and just why doesn’t high-tech get it? 2000.
[10] Mohini singh,‖e-services and their role in B2C e-commerce, volume 12 number 6 2002, pp.434-446.
[11] Onut, S., Erdem, I., and Hosver, B. Customer Relationship Management in Banking Sector and A
Model Design for Banking Performance Enhancement, Yildiz Technical University, Istanbul, Turkey ,2006.
[12] Foss, B. ―CRM in Financial Services: A Practical Guide to Making CustomerRelationship
Management Work‖ Milford, CT, USA, Kogan Page Ltd, 2002.
[13] Crosby, L. A., Evans, K. R., & Cowles, D. Relationship quality in services selling ―an interpersonal
influence perspective‖. The Journal of Marketing, 1990,52, 21–34.
20
International Academic Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Resource management,
Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 12-22.
[14] Morgan, R. M., & Hunt, S. D. ―The commitment–trust theory of relationship marketing‖. The Journal
of Marketing, 1994,58(3), 20–38.
[15] Peter C. Verhoef, a, Rajkumar Venkatesan, CRM in Data-Rich Multichannel Retailing Environments:
A Review and Future Research Directions, Journal of Interactive Marketing 24 2010, 121–137.
[16] Petersen, J. Andrew and V. Kumar, ―Are Product Returns a Necessary Evil? The Antecedents and
Consequences of Product Returns,” working paper, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.2008.
[17] Reichheld, Frederick F. and Paul Schefter, ―E-loyalty: Your Secret, Weapon on the Web,‖ Harvard
Business Review, 2000, 78, 105–13.
[18] Krause, D. R. and L. M. Ellram,"Critical Elements of Supplier Development: The Buying-Firm
Perspective", European Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management,1997, 3, (1), 21-31.
[19] Srinivasan, S., "Role of Trust in E-Business Success", Information Management and Computer
Security, 2004,12, (1), 66-72.
[20] Kumar, Nirmalya, Lisa K. Sheer and Jan-Benedict E.M. Steenkamp, "The Effects of Supplier Fairness
on Vulnerable Resellers," Journal of Marketing Research, 1995,32 (1), 54-65.
[21] Rempel, John K., John G. Holmes and Mark P. Zanna, "Trust in Close Relationships," Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology,1985, 49 (1), 95-112.
[22] Roberts, K., Varkie, S., & Brodie, R., Measuring the quality of relationships in consumer services: An
empirical study. European Journal of Marketing,2003, 37(1), 169–196.
[23] Jamal, Ahmad and Kamal Naser,"Customer Satisfaction and Retail Banking: An Assessment of Some
of the Key Antecedents of Customer Satisfaction in Retail Banking", International Journal of Bank Marketing,
2002,20, (4), 146–160.
[24] Gao Xirong, Yu Jin, ―The influence of consumer’s perceived service quality on thecontinued
interaction of online banking‖, 2011.
[25] Phavaphan Sivaraks, Donyaprueth Krairit,John C. S, Effects of e-CRM on customer–bank relationship
quality and outcomes, Journal of High Technology Management Research 22 ,2011, 141–157.
[26] Oliver, R. L., Whence Customer loyalty? Journal of Management, 1999,36-43.
[27] Reichheld, F.F. and Sasser, W.E. Jr, ―Zero Defections: quality comes to services‖, Harvard business
Review,1990.
[28] E. Turban, D. King, J. Lee, D. Viehland, Electronic Commerce. A Managerial Perspective, Prentice-
Hall, New Jersey, 2004.
[29] S.A. Brown,‖ Customer Relationship Management‖, John Wiley & Sons, Ontario, 2000.
[30] Vikas P. Jain. ―Importance of Information Flow, Customer Relationship Management &Customer
Satisfaction in Strategic Management of E-Commerce‖, San Francisco, CA 94111.
[31] Boonajsevee, B.Relationship marketing: Loyalty intentions in new era of Thai Bank Marketing,
Unpublished doctoral dissertation. Nova Southern University United State, 2005.
[32] Xing Qiu-dan, Lei Ting and Li Yunfei, ―The Study of Influencing Online Banking Information
Security Products Service Quality Factors Based on Customer Perception‖, Energy procedia (13), 2011,1203-
1213.
[33] Foehn, P., Client Valuation in Private Banking, 2004, 3, 51-63.
[34] Heskett, James L., W. Earl Sasser, and Leonard A. Schlesinger.‖The Service Profit Chain: How
Leading Companies Link Profit and Growth to Loyalty, Satisfaction and Value‖. New York: Free Press.1997.
[35] Michael. A, jones, David L.mothers baugh, Sharon E, ―the effect of location convenience on customer
repurchase intentions across service‖, Journal of service marketing, 2003.
[36] Berry, Leonard, ―Relationship Marketing of Services—Growing Interest, Emerging Perspectives,‖
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 1995,23, 236–45.
[37] Srinivasan, Raji and Christine Moorman, ―Strategic Firm Commitments and Rewards for Customer
Relationship Management in Online Retailing,‖ Journal of Marketing,2005, 69, 255–71.
[38] Petersen, J. Andrew and V. Kumar, ―Are Product Returns a Necessary Evil? The Antecedents and
Consequences of Product Returns,‖ working paper, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill.2008.
[39] Statnotes, Path Analysis handbook, from North Carolina State University.2010.
21