Concepto de Diversidad Cultural
Concepto de Diversidad Cultural
Concepto de Diversidad Cultural
Hein Goemans
Kristian Skrede Gleditsch
Giacomo Chiozza
Archigos is a data base of political leaders.1 For each state considered an independent
state in the Gleditsch and Ward (1999) compilation of independent states, we identify the
effective primary ruler. The data identify the manner by which rulers enter and leave
political power, the post-tenure fate of the ruler, as well as other personal characteristics.
This case description file often contains additional information. No claim of
completeness of such additional information for the whole data set is made, except for
information on potential family relations to previous rulers. Additional documented
information is of course always welcome. The current version of Archigos covers 1875—
2004. For their excellent research assistance, we thank Jinhee Choung, Martin Steinwand,
and users who have pointed out discrepancies, problematic codings or raised questions.
Notes on coding
Many countries have multiple heads of states. In some cases, the formal head of a state
may be a primarily a ceremonial position (as in most present day monarchies in Europe),
where executive power is delegated to another position such as a prime minister. In other
cases, a strongman (or woman) may formally step down but remain the effective leader
of a state.
We have tried to identify the actual effective ruler based on our knowledge of the
particulars of each state. In most cases, identifying effective rulers is relatively clear and
uncontroversial, but in other cases the coding may be more contentions. The case
description file identifies our rationale and reasoning for handling potentially
controversial cases in particular ways.
Nota bene, we base our universe of cases on the Gleditsch and Ward data set of countries.
When a country is conquered and occupied, but the government is by autochtone leaders,
as in the cases of Denmark 1940-1943, Vichy France, and Estonia 1940, those leaders are
included in our data. This may create some minor compatibility issues with Polity IV
which codes regime transitions in these cases. We recommend changing the exit code to
“removal by foreigners” in such cases.
We employ the CCODE and IDACR variables from the Correlates of War project to
identify countries. The LEADER variable records the leader’s name. In many cases,
different spellings are used. The case description file below often provides those different
spellings and more detail on the leader’s name. The STARTDATE and ENDDATE
variable indicate the beginning and end of one leader-spell. Since leaders may enjoy more
than one spell in office, the same leader may have more than one STARTDATE and
ENDDATE.
The name Archigos is taken from the Greek term for ruler (αρχηγός).
2
Archigos codes the manner in which transfers between rulers occur. Our main interest is
whether transfers of power between leaders take place in a regular or irregular fashion.
We code transfers as regular or irregular depending on the political institutions and
selection mechanisms in place. We identify whether leaders are selected into and leave
political office in a manner prescribed by either explicit rules or established conventions.
In a democracy, a leader may come to power through direct election or establishing a
sufficient coalition of representatives in the legislature. Although leaders may not be
elected or selected in particularly competitive processes, many autocracies have similar
implicit or explicit rules for transfers of executive power. Leader changes that occur
through designation by an outgoing leader, hereditary succession in a monarchy, and
appointment by the central committee of a ruling party would all be considered regular
transfers of power from one leader to another in an autocratic regime. Future versions of
Archigos will provide much more finer-grained codings on how leaders entered and
exited office.
Leader transfers have two components, entry and exit into power. The variable ENTRY
identifies the manner with which a leader reaches power. The variable can take the
following values:
In order for a leader to qualify as entry = 2, we need direct imposition. It is not sufficient
that another state supports a particular choice of leader or tries to influence leader
selection indirectly. Note also that cases where a previous leader exits in an irregular
fashion but a vice president takes over or an interim leader is appointed by the legislature
as prescribed by rules and procedure the latter will be coded as entry=0. However, in
cases such as Afghanistan 1979, where Prime Minister Amin stages a coup against
President Taraki, and takes over power, we do code this entry as irregular, even though
techinically he was supposed to be next in line. In cases where the perpetrator of the coup
takes over power as a result of the coup, we always code this as an irregular entry,
regardless of the legal position of this person. In future versions of Archigos, we will
provide much finer-grained codings on how leaders entered office. There are 4 cases
where we could not identify how a leader came into power, these are considered missing
and coded -666. These are Fevzi Bej of Albania (1914), Oskars Borkovskis of Latvia
(1919) and Smetona and Mindaugas II of Lithuania (1917 and 1918). Any additional
information on these will be much appreciated.
The variable EXIT indicates the manner with which a leader lost power. It can take on
the following values
3
2.1 Leader retired due to ill health
2.2 Leader lost office as a result of suicide
3 Leader lost power through irregular means
4 Leader deposed by another state
Removal from office is coded as Regular when the leader is removed in accordance with
explicit rules or established conventions of his or her particular country. Examples of
Regular removal include voluntary retirement, term limits and defeat in elections.
Removal from office is coded as Irregular when the leader was removed in contravention
of explicit rules and established conventions. Most Irregular removals from office are
done by domestic forces. Irregular removal from office is overwhelmingly the result of
the threat or use of force as exemplified in coups, (popular) revolts and assassinations.
Note that assassinations are coded as removal by irregular means. Assassinations may or
may not have a clear political motivation, and we prefer to make no judgments about the
“real” intention behind assassinations. In some cases, whether a leader dies of natural
causes or is assassinated may be disputed. We identify our judgments in the case
descriptions when potentially controversial. These case descriptions are presented below.
To follow up, our coding of foreign removal includes only cases where a foreign state
invades and directly removes a foreign leader. In particular, cases where someone is seen
as orchestrating a removal of a leader through a coup carried out by domestic forces (for
example, Allende or Mossadeq) are not coded as foreign removal, but exit==3. In future
versions of Archigos, we will provide much finer-grained codings on how leaders left
office, to distinguish, amongst others, the threat or use of force both by domestic and
foreign foces.
There are 4 cases where we could not identify how a leader left power, these are
considered missing and coded -666. These are Fevzi Bej of Albania (1914), Oskars
Borkovskis of Latvia (1919) and Smetona and Mindaugas II of Lithuania (1917 and
1918). Any additional information on these will be much appreciated.
The variable PREVIOUS TIMES IN OFFICE records the number of times a leader has
previously been in office. Some leaders have been in office before Archigos starts
collecting date (1875). These leaders may therefore start with values for this variable
greater than zero.
The variable POST TENURE FATE indicates the fate of the leader in the period up to
one year after the leader lost power. This period is chosen to exclude as much as possible
that the leader's behavior after he or she lost office rather than his or her behavior in
office is responsible for any form of punishment.
0 OK
1 Exile
2 Imprisonment (including house arrest)
3 Death
4
Note: Refuge in foreign Embassy is exile; embassy is foreign soil, and house arrest is
imprisonment. We record the highest level of punishment; there are many cases of
relatively brief house arrest followed by exile. The case description file below also notes
in some instances if a leader was exiled, imprisoned or killed in the period after one year
beyond his or her loss of office. No claim is made here to a comprehensive coding of the
leader’s fate beyond one year after he or she lost office. On some leaders no information
could be found on their posttenurefate, they are considered missing and coded -666. Any
information on such missing cases will be very much appreciated. Leaders who died
while in office are coded as missing (-777) as are leaders who died less than six months
after they left office. Leaders who are still in office are also coded as missing (-888).
The variable BORNIN records the leader’s birthdate or birthyear. Whenever possible, we
record the more precise birthdate. For 67 leaders we could not find information to
identify either birthyear or birthdate, they are considered missing and coded -999. Any
additional information will therefore be very much appreciated. This variable can be used
to construct the leader’s age.
The variable DIED records the leader’s death date. It contains many missing values (-999
or NA). Future versions of Archigos will complete this variable.
5
CASE DESCRIPTIONS
General Format is:
COUNTRY NAME
Country-year ccode Abbr Leader Name Entrydate Exitdate
The main effective ruler is the president. Term limits are introduced in the 22nd
Amendment (ratified February 27, 1951).
6
USA-1961 2 USA Kennedy 20/01/1961 22/11/1963
Assasinated
CANADA
7
CAN-1911 20 CAN Borden 10/10/1911 10/06/1920
Borden was in power from 1911 to 1920. Lentz notes: “Borden retired on July 10, 1920
due to poor health, and was succeeded as prime minister by Arthur Meighen.” Thus the
variable “lost” is coded according to this information.
8
BAHAMAS
CUBA
9
CUB-1933-1 40 CUB de Cespedes 12/08/1933 05/09/1933
Carlos Manuel de Cespedes y Quesada, (1871-1939). On September 6, 1933, after he had
been in office for less than a month, the so-called “revolution of sergeants” led by
Fulgencio Batista, demanded and received his resignation. Céspedes then became
ambassador to Spain until August 1935, when he finally returned to Cuba.
HAITI
Sources consulted on Haiti include Pascal-Trouillot (2001), Von Grafenstein (1988),
Rotberg (1971), and Fatton (2002).
10
HAI-1876 41 HAI Canal 23/04/1876 17/07/1879
See New York Times, Jul 19, 1879, p.2 on Canal. For his exile also see New York Times,
Aug. 2, 1879 p.2. Fled to Jamaica.
11
President Nord Alexis fled to French Cruiser. See The Washington Post, Dec. 26, 1909,
p.1 .
12
enable Senor Stimé to seek re-election in 1952. The proposal met strong opposition in the
Senate and there were some signs of public protest despite the state-of-siege regulations
in force here. The present Constitution provides that no President may serve two
consecutive terms.”
Christian Science Monitor, May 11, 1950, p.18. “Military rulers have seized the
government after almost four years on the sidelines. They came back to power after
President Estimé tried unsuccessfully tried to insure his own re-election. M. Estimé
resigned and was succeeded by the same three-man military junta which threw out his
predecessor in January, 1946. The junta, which had ruled the country until M. Estimé’s
election in August, 1946, announced the President and his family had been placed under
its “protection.” … The junta which returned to power is made up of Brig. Gen. Frank
Lavaud, leader of the 1946 coup, Maj. Antoine Levelt, and Maj. Paul Magloire. They said
in a proclamation their return was asked by the army general staff because M. Estimé had
“lost control” of a “complicated and dangerous situation which stopped the life of the
nation.”
President Estimé, was first held under house arrest, later sent to exile. See NYT, May 28,
1950, p.61. For exile in Paris, see NYT, May 20, 1950, p.31.
13
broadcast transferring powers. … Gen. Levelt said in the broadcast that Haiti’s political
crisis had worsened and that the army staff in a conference decided to transfer
governmental power to Pierre-Louis.” However, The Washington Post and Times Herald,
Dec. 7, 1956, p. A14, notes: “To cover the interval until the April 30 presidential election
Zephirin said, Magloire offered to turn the presidency over to Judge Nemours Tierre-
Louis, head of Haiti’s Supreme Court, as specified in the constitution. But Tierre-Louis
refused the post, Zephirin said …” Hence we code his entry as regular.
Chicago Daily Tribune, Feb. 4, 1957, p. B12 records, “Feb. 3—Provisional President
Joseph Nemours Pierre-Louis has resigned, informed quarters said tonight. … Pierre-
Louis’ resignation followed reports that a movement was underway to unseat him.” See
also Daily Defender, Feb. 5, 1957, p. 2 and NYT, Feb. 5, 1957, p. 1.
14
HAI-1986 41 HAI Namphy 07/02/1986 07/02/1988
15
Trouillot, who had been under house arrest following allegations of her involvement in
the January 1991 coup attempt, left for Florida, USA, on Sept. 9.”
Coup on Sept 30. On Oktober 7 army forces lawmakers at gunpoint to ratify coup.
Aristide was ousted, and sent to exile.
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
16
Buenaventura Báez was exiled permanently to Puerto Rico.
See NYT, Mar. 16, 1878, p.1 “News had been received at St. Thomas that
President Baez, of San Domingo, with his family, arrived at Mayaguez, in the Island of
Porto Rico, on March 5. The fact of his arrival is all that was known in St. Thomas, when
the steamer left. No further particulars had been received from Porto Rico to explain the
President’s departure from San Domingo.” See also, NYT, Aug. 10, 1882, p.4.
The period after Baez was forced into exile on 2 March 1878 is one where leaders of
different regions compete. It appears as if there is no functional national state until
Guillermo takes over on 27/2/1879.
17
Heureaux was assassinated, had served 4 consecutive terms, just reelected in 97. His
successor is his Vice President, Gen. Wenceslao Figuereo. See NYT, Jul 27, 1899, p.1.
Heureaux lost power on Sept. 1884. Rulers.org notes that in1884 and 1885 he selected his
country’s presidents while he continued to direct the government; from 1887 to his death
he ruled almost uninterruptedly after abolishing the constitutional barrier against
reelection. On Luperon, Merino & Heureaux, see NYT, Sept. 17, 1882, p.6.
18
a US Gunboat going to Porto Rico. (In jail in the US (?) in 1912. See NYT, Nov. 3, 1912,
p.C4). NYT, March 31, 1912, p. C4. "Gen. Carlos Morales, also an ex-President of Santo
Domingo, is now in prison."
19
Jimenez, ousted 8 May 1916. Christian Science Monitor, Jul. 26, 1916 records that “At
present former Presidents Borda and Jimenez are both on this island (== Porto Rico).”
US occupation.
20
We code Bonelly as entry is regular as he had been elected vice president of the Council
of State under Joaquin Balaguer. See also
http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ho/frus/kennedyjf/xii/35159.htm. Lentz notes: “Bonnelly
was briefly arrested before the junta was overthrown. He succeeded to the presidency.”
For his arrest at San Ysidro Air Force Base, see NYT, Jan. 18, 1962. p.3
21
Guzman Fernandez committed suicide. Lentz notes : Guzman died of a self-inflicted
gunshot wound when he shot himself in the head at his office in Santo Domingo on July
4, 1982. Fernandez had run on ticket of limiting himself to one term.
JAMAICA
22
JAM-1992 51 JAM Patterson 30/03/1992 31/12/2004
TRINIAD &TOBAGO
BARBADOS
MEXICO
Lentz lists fate of most of the leaders.
23
Exiled to Paris.
24
Aleman Valdes becomes head of airline. See NYT, Dec. 28, 1952. Goes to Paris 20 Feb
1953. See NYT, 20 Feb, 1953, p.4. Still is there when graft allegations get aired. See also
NYT, Apr 9. 1952, p.14. Still in Europe May 15, now visiting behind the Iron Curtain.
June 27 visiting the Dutch Queen. Returns October 6 to Mexico city. Corruption charges
while in Europe.
25
the Mexican army of responsibility for the massacre, and said he hoped to end 37 years of
"impunity and injustice". Mr Echeverria has acknowledged that some died in Tlatelolco
Square in 1968. He denies prosecution allegations that he posted snipers on scores of
buildings to fire into the crowd and gave orders to fire. Mexico's current President,
Vicente Fox, has vowed to punish public figures found to be responsible for killings and
oppression in the past.
BELIZE
GUATEMALA
26
Reina Barrios was assassinated.
27
of foreign military force, but also does not involve domestic actors. See CSM, Jan 2,
1931, p.4; NYT, Jan 8, 1931, p.26. No evidence anywhere that he is related in any way to
J. Orellana, hence we assume he’s not.
28
entered from Mexico, where he has spent much of his self-imposed 13-year exile.” The
Washington Post, Mar. 31, 1963, p.A10. Self-imposed exile in Mexico.
29
GUA-1978 90 GUA Lucas Garcia 01/07/1978 23/03/1982
He lost power as a result of a coup led by junior officers, and he was held under house
arrest. Lentz records that “junior officers led a coup that ousted Lucas Garcia on March
23, 1982. Lucas Garcia and Anibal Guevara were put under house arrest.” Coup by
young officers March 23, declare the elections null and void.
Election had been 7 March.
30
Luis Pons, another human rights activist, said criminal investigations of former Latin
American leaders, including Rios Montt, constitute a "a small light giving people hope"
that presidents are no longer above the law. Still, he added, the sight of a former dictator
under criminal investigation and house arrest hosting a wedding for 300 people, including
an A-list of Guatemala's elite, "shows that justice is still politicized in Latin America."”
See Washington Post Foreign Service, Saturday, January 8, 2005; Page A10.
He lost power with a coup and hold under house arrest.
BBC News: Tuesday 31 January 2006. “A court in Guatemala has dismissed
manslaughter charges against former military ruler Efrain Rios Montt. He was accused of
orchestrating a violent protest by his supporters against a ruling which banned him from
standing for president in 2003. A journalist died of a heart attack while running away
from protesters. … The 2003 protests, which caused chaos in Guatemala City, became
known as Black Thursday. Gen. Rios Montt eventually contest the election this year, but
he was defeated. He took part in the poll despite a constitutional rule that no-one who had
overthrown a government could stand for the presidency.”
31
When his political immunity was revoked on February 19 2004 Portillo immediately
fled to Mexico. On August 16, 2004, immigration authorities there granted him a year-
long work visa. He lives in Mexico City in an apartment in one of the city's most
exclusive neighborhoods.
HONDURAS
32
Sierra was sent to exile to El Salvador
33
For entry and exit, see The Washington Post, Oct. 19, 1919, p. ES16., Dec. 8, 1919, p.6,
See NYT, Nov. 2, 1919, p.X2. NYT, Sept.16, 1919, p.7 notes that Bogran has been
named as provisional President. He was born in 1849. He handed over power
constitutionally.
34
left Honduras for medical treatment on December 6, 1954 . He died on August 19, 1972.
See below on his son being involved in a subsequent Junta (56-7).
35
Hector Caraccioli, 34, removed from power the third member of the ruling junta ….”
Irregular entry. … Earlier this year a decision by the junta contributed to the series of
incidents that set off the brief border war between Nicaragua and Honduras. The military
triumvirate created a new State in the Mosquitia area, claimed by Hondurans since
1906as part of their nation and by Nicaragua as territory in dispute. The junta exhorted
“20th centurypioneers” to settle the new State of Gracias a Dios and transform the isolated
jungle Mosquitia area into cotton and coffee plantations.”
NYT, Nov.19, p. 21 “Honduran Officer Leave Junta: Tegucigalpa, Honduras, Nov. 18—
Maj. Roberto Galvez Barnes withdrew from the Honduran military junta Saturday. He
was replaced by the Defense Minister, Col. Oswaldo Lopez. ….. Major Galvez said he
had withdrawn because of disappointment at the Constituent Assembly’s election of Dr.
Ramon Villeda Morales, Liberal leader, as President.” He hands over power, peacefully,
to Villeda Morales, hence regular exit. For the Constitution of 19 December 1957, which
he signs, see:
http://www.cervantesvirtual.com/servlet/SirveObras/01478404433725684232268/p00
00001.htm
Coup attempt against him by Colonel Armando Velasquez Carrato in May 1957. It fails
and the colonel finds refuge in the Guatemalan Embassy.
He dies, is killed (?) 1975. Had been the first pilot to use an emergency chute in
Honduras, 25 January 1945.
36
glasses appeared on newspaper front pages and were hung on the walls of homes
throughout the country (Interview with Matías Funes 12 December 1995, Tegucigalpa,
Honduras; Interview with Ramón Oquelí 24 July 1997, Tegucigalpa, Honduras). And
before the sudden move to have him declared president, Villeda had unequivocally and
publicly declared that he would not take the presidency without a direct election by the
people ( El Cronista 24 September 1957). What happened? A deal was made between
Villeda and the military junta, the details of which remain a shrouded mystery of secret
meetings, threats, and backroom deals. … Ramón Oquelí, the noted Honduran scholar
and journalist, and an objective and dispassionate fountain of information on the country,
provides the most logical explanation. According to Oquelí, the arrangement was
masterminded by the calculating strong-man of the military, Oswaldo López. López had
previously declared to the people that "on one day not very far off, the (armed forces)
will become the maximum representation of the national conglomerate" and that the
"armed forces could no longer be considered a fleeting phenomenon in the institutional
life of the country" (Funes 1995, 92-93). To make this dream a reality, López tricked
Villeda by telling him that the very popular Roberto Gálvez Barnes of the military junta
would be the unified candidate of the military, the Nationalists, and the Reformists if a
direct election were held. He also warned Villeda that the military would not be able to
guarantee a clean and fair election. Villeda was left with no better option than to accept
the deal. After the deal was consummated, Roberto Gálvez Barnes left the ruling junta to
protest the decision to forego the presidential elections. In a conversation with Villeda,
Gálvez told him that he had never contemplated plans to run for the presidency. Villeda
discovered the trick, but it was too late (Interview with Ramón Oquelí, 24 July 1997,
Tegucigalpa, Honduras).” Hence entry is irregular.
Morales lost power as a result of a military coup by Osvaldo Arellano. He was sent to
exile to Costa Rica. Lentz notes that “Two months before Villeda Morales was scheduled
to complete his term of office, he was ousted in a military coup by Osvaldo Lopez
Arellano on October 3, 1953.”
37
Oswaldo Lopez Arellano overthrown on 22 April 1975, after he had refused to allow an
investigatory commission to examine his foreign bank accounts. General Lopez Arellano
was prevented by a court order of May 16 from leaving the country. (Keesing’s)
EL SALVADOR
El Salvador has terms limits for presidents.
Sources consulted include Baloyra (1982), Penate and Sanchez (2000), and White (1973)
38
Government overthrown.
NYT, June 12, 1876.p.7. records that “Ex-President Falle, of Salvador, has gone to
California.” (Note search: The Historical New York Times. With “Salvador” entered in
“Article Text” and period 1/1/1876 to 1/1/1877.)
He fought a war with Guatemala and Guatemala, each invading the other. According to
NYT, May 13, 1876. Guatemala was victorious.
Coup, engineered by Guatamalan president Barrios
39
SAL-1913 92 SAL C. Melendez 11/02/1913 15/08/1914
Lentz: Steps down 28 August, 1914, in order to run for President again. “He stepped
down in favor of his brother-in-law, Alfonso Quinonez y Molina, on August 28, 1914, to
become a candidate in the presidential election. He was victorious and resumed office on
February 28, 1915. … He remained in office until December 21, 1918, when he stepped
down for reasons of health after arranging the succession of his younger brother Jorge
Melendez. Carlos Melendez died of cancer in a New York City clinic on October 9, 1919.
40
22, 1944, p.30. records that Menendez “led an army coup that overthrew Gen. Hernandez
Martinez.”. See also the NYT, Mar. 26, 1945, p.8.
41
members of the former junta were variously reported as under house arrest or in exile in
Guatemala; it was also stated that Colonel Oscar Osorio, a former President and leader of
the Social Democratic Party, had been arrested and subsequently sent into exile. +
Christian Science Monitor 27/1/1961: “Two deposed members of the former junta were
ordered out of the country by Colonel Portillo.” NYT Times, records that many of the
former Junta were exiled. See NYT, Jan 5, 1962 p.14. Also Washington Post, 28 Jan
1961, p.A10. “One of the new junta’s first acts was to arrest four members of the
previous Government and 30 alleged Communist leaders.” Coup.
42
SAL-1982 92 SAL Magana Borjo 02/05/1982 01/06/1984
Magana Borjo was elected by parliament, under US pressure.
NICARAGUA
43
NIC-1889 93 NIC Roberto Sacasa Sarria 01/08/1889 01/06/1893
Roberto Sacasa was ousted. There was a revolt in April 1893 and after the revolt Sacasa
went to the USA and Europe. See NYT, Aug. 7, 1893, p.6.
See NYT, Aug. 2, 1889, p5,The Washington Post, Aug. 2, 1889, p.1. and NYT, Aug, 26,
1891, p.5. Constitutionally, Sacasa takes over. Also See NYT, Oct. 10, 1890, p.2. on the
procedure (very unique) see NYT, Aug. 30, 1891, p.10. ALSO, AT THIS TIME,
PRESIDENTS COULD SERVE ONLY FOR ONE TERM. Dispute over whether that
included the unfinished term of his predecessor or only his own election. “The succession
of the Presidency in the event of the death of the incumbent is not provided for as in this
country, by a Vice President, but the Constitution requires that the names of five Senators
shall be written upon slips of paper and inclosed in separate envelopes, which are then
placed in a box. After the box has been shaken so as to mix the envelopes up, two are
drawn out and destroyed without exposing the names contained therein. The other three
are then filed away in the archives of the State. If the President dies, these envelopes are
taken out, again placed in a box, and a properly-designated officer draws one out. The
Senator whose name is contained therein is immediately declared President. It was
supposed by the framers of the Constitution that this method would effectually guard
against the name of the possible successor to the Presidency being known in advance, and
thereby prevent any plotting against the life or tenure of the incumbent.
So far as the writer was able to ascertain, it was not charged that on the death of
President Carazo, in October, 1888, Dr. Sacasa secured his succession to the office by
unfair means, but it was his subsequent course which stirred the opposition. The
Constitution provides that no one shall be eligible to more than one term as President. It
was held by his political opponents that this provision was applicable to unexpired terms
as well as to full terms. President Sacasa took the opposite view and when he announced
his intention to seek election at the end of the term for which Carazo had been elected,
the real trouble began. Then it was charged that he resorted to unfair means to secure his
election.” See also: NYT, Jul. 11, 1893, p.8 & NYT, Aug. 7, 1893, p.1. But apparently
(??) later minister for foreign affairs under Zelaya, or someone of the same name. The
Washington Post, Feb. 23, 1910, p.4.
HG: The above claim that Carazo dies in October, 1888 is incorrect, he dies in 1889.
Ousted in coup.
For his family relationship with later Juan Bautista Sacasa Sacasa, see
http://www.grupoese.com.ni/1999/bn/09/27/otr990927.htm and
http://www.grupoese.com.ni/1999/bn/09/28/otra990928.htm, which is a site
maintainted by the Institute of Geneaology and History of Nicaragua, IGHN.
44
Forced out by brother
45
Carlos Alberto Brenes Jarquin (b. 1884 - d. 1942), See NYT, Jan 15, 1937, p.12. In 1937
was appointed as a chief minister to Washington.
Lentz says chosen by Congress to serve as President on June 9, 1936. He relinquishes
office to Amastasio Somoza Garcia, following Somoza’s election to the presidency. So
Constitutional exit. (Somoza ran unopposed.) He first wants to resume his medical
practice (NYT, Dec. 28, 1936, p.5, then is appointed. Nicaraguan Minister to
Washington. NYT, Jan. 15, 1937, p.12. He leaves Feb. 26, with wife and children. See
NYT, Feb. 27, 1937, p.7. But Dec. 15, 1937, new Nicaraguan Envoy to US. He left the
country.
DELETE
NIC-1947-2 93 NIC Lacayo Sacasa 26/05/1947 15/08/1947
NYT, May 28, 1947, p.11. “Washington, May 27 – Benjamin Lacayou Sacasa has been
designated Provisional President of Nicaragua by the Congress, pending the calling of
new elections, …. Senor Lacayo Sacasa is one of the three designates who had been
named under the Constitution as a panel from which to make a selection in event of a
vacancy in the Presidential office. [Senor Lacayo Sacasa is 60 years of age and was
President of the Camber of Deputies, The Associated Press said.]” NYT, May 29, 1947,
p.7 reports “Former President Gen. Anastasio Somoza was appointed today as Minister of
46
War, Navy and Aviation and commander in Chief of the National Guard by Provisional
President Benjamin Lacayo Sacasa. General Somoza thus retains virtual control of the
country as head of all its armed forces.” NYT, Jun 20, 1947, US declares policy of Non-
Recognition of Lacayo Sacasa rule.
NYT, Aug. 3, 1947, p. 14. “Nicaragua will hold a Constituent Assembly election
tomorrow which the regime backed by Gen. Anastasio Somoza apparently hopes will
bring about recognition from American republics …”
This Sacasa was also related—as a “political nephew” to the previous Roberto
Sacasa Sarria, see http://www.grupoese.com.ni/1999/bn/09/28/otra990928.htm.
47
forces.” NYT, Jun 20, 1947, US declares policy of Non-Recognition of Lacayo Sacasa
rule.
NYT, Aug. 3, 1947, p. 14. “Nicaragua will hold a Constituent Assembly election
tomorrow which the regime backed by Gen. Anastasio Somoza apparently hopes will
bring about recognition from American republics …”
For Somoza Garcia’s decision to run again in 1950, see NYT, Feb. 13, 1950, p.4.
As above, his “uncle-in-law was Juan Sacasa Sacasa, in other words, Somoza is married
to Sacasa Sacasa’s niece. For his entry, see NYT, May 8, 1950, p. 11. “Managua,
Nicaragua, May 7—Gen. Anastasio Somoza, Natioanl Liberal (Government( candidate in
this month’s Presidential elections, was unanimously elected President by a special
session of Congress today to serve out the unexperied term of Dr. Victor M. Roman y
Reyers, who died last night in Philadelphia.
Shot and seriously wounded 21 September 1956. Dies of wounds
DELETE
NIC-1972 93 NIC Triumvirate 01/05/1972 01/12/1974
Set up by Somoza.
48
Violetta de Chamorro. Born Violeta Barrios Torres. So not directly related to previous
Chamorros. She married Pedro Joaquin Chamorro Cardenal. On her husband: Pedro
Joaquin Chamorro Cardenal (1924-1978). He was a Nicaraguan revolutionary who in
1952 took over the family owned newspaper, La Prensa. He turned the paper into a
leading opposition voice to the dictatorial and repressive Somoza regime. He was
repeatedly jailed and in 1957 was sent into exile. He returned to Nicaragua in 1960
following an amnesty, however he suffered from further harassment and was assassinated
in 1978. He was the great-nephew of Emiliano Chamorro Vargas, previous president.
(ECV is great-uncle.) She is also related to the Sacasa family.
COSTA RICA
49
Bernardo Soto Alfaro. See NYT, Nov. 26, 1889, p.5. Removed under pressure from
armed supporters of the newly elected Pres. Rodriguez. Washington Post of Jan 31, 1890,
p.1 records Soto’s incognito arrival in Chicago Jan. 30. But he runs again for office in
1906.
50
requests were granted and the two Tinocos were preparing to depart when Joaquin was
shot down.”
We code this as an irregular exit, since he (either Joaquin or Federico) had not yet handed
over power.
On Federico’s Tinoco’s entry, see Boston Daily Globe, Jan 31, 1919, p.3, which reports
Tinoco, ex-War Minister, came into power several years ago through a bloodless
revolution. He has been elected President since, but recognition has been refused by the
United States under President Wilson’s policy of withholding recognition from any
Government set up by violence.”
On Tinoco’s exile see Washington Post, Aug. 16, 1919, p.1, and Lentz. Exiled in Europe.
NYT, Jan 28, 1919, p.7 reports: “Jan. 27—Travelers arriving from Costa Rica report that
the Tinoco Government has a large number of men under arms and that a very strict
censorship is being enforced. … The travelers say that President Tinoco evidently fears
an invasion of Costa Rica by Costa Ricans driven from the country when he gained
control there.” For more on that invation, see NYT, Feb. 19, 1919, p. 4, which reports
“Eight thousand Costa Rican troops have been mobilized on the border between Costa
Rica and Nicaragua and threaten the invasion of the latter country. Dispatches to the
Nicaraguan Legation today announcing this threat to the peace of Central America said
the leader of the troops was Julian Irias, Premier of Nicaragua under the Zelaya
Government, which was overthrown by revolution ten years ago. With the exception of
police and a legation guard of 100 United States marines, there are no armed forces in
Nicaragua, as that country does not maintain a standing army.” See also: The Washington
Post Feb. 19, 1919, p. 5, which reports “The threatened war between Nicaragua and
Costa Rica is associated with the overthrow of Gonzales by Tinoco, now president of
Costa Rica. A considerable portion of Gonzales’ following fled to Nicaragua, where they
began collection money and resources to start a revolution against Tinoco. The
Nicaraguan government has winked at this and threats of the Costa Rican government to
take warlike measures against a neighboring state for harboring enemies and assisting
them have been held in abeyance because of the influence of the United States. Now,
however, Costa Rica apparently belies the United States Government is no longer a real
retraining factor, as it is interested only in peace doctrines and adverse to anything
resembling war.”
The Atlanta Constitution, May 3, 1919, p. 10 reports: Costa Rica Exiles Begin
Revolution. “Costa Rican exiles met and defeated a force of Costa Rican frontier guards
on the Rio Frio, near the southeastern shore of Lake Nicaragua Thursday. The frontier
guards retired after the fight.”
For more progress on the revolutionaries advances: The Washington Post, May 11, 1919,
ES 14. The Atlanta Constitution, Jun. 3, 1919, p.7 which records that the governments of
Guatemala, Honduras and Nicaragua recognized the belligerency of the anti-Tinoco
revolutionists in Costa Rica. The Wasington Post, Jun 5, 1919, p. 1 records that American
marines have been landed in Costa Rica. NYT, June 9, 1919, p. 1 records that the
revolution collapses in Costa Rica, and Nicaraguans fear invasion by Costa Ricans,
headed by Tinoco’s brother. See also CSM, July 4, 1919, p. 14. “Order Restored in Costa
Rica Capital.” CSM, July 5, 1919, p.4 President Tinoco’s Forces Dislodged. Costa Rican
revolutionists, under the leadership of the Mexican general, Manuel Chao, on Thursday
51
night attacked and dislodged the forces of President Tinoco of Costa Rica from their
advanced positions.”
Boston Daily Globe, Aug. 14, 1919 “Tinoco Out of Costa Rica. But Details Not Stated.”
Records: Washington, Aug. 13, -- President Tinoco has left Costa Rica. … There also
was no indication whether the President quit the country before his brother, Joaquin
Tinoco, Vice President of the Republic, was assassinated on Aug. 10.” Note, from above,
that it was Tinoco’s brother who led the armed forces. See also NYT, Aug. 14, 1919, p.2
“Tinoco Regime Gone.” which notes Joaquin’s assassination on the 10th, burial on the
11th and Federico’s fleeing on the 12th.
For Tinoco’s fleeing, see LA Times, Aug. 17, 1919, p.IV14 “Deposed President of Costa
Rica to Europe.” Which notes “Federico Tinoco … said several attempts thad been made
to assassinate him and that his brother, Jose, Minister of War, was shot in the back of the
head the night before the President left and died later.” Blamed for the assassination is
Nicaragua.
Hence, his exit looks rather irregular. However, Boston Daily Globe, Aug. 18, 1919, p. 9
records Federico Tinoco … said he believed the assassin of his brother Jose Joaquin
Tinoco, had come from Nicaragua and that the assassination had been planned in
Nicaragua and Washington. Gen. Tinoco said that he decided to leave Costa Rica on
account of his health about a month ago. At that time, he said, perfect order was being
maintained. Gen Tinoco had arranged for his brother to assume the reins of government
during his absence, but Joaquin, having decided to accompany the Generla to Europe,
resigned the Vice Presidency last Saturday night. It was arranged that the brothers and
their families should leave Costa Rica on Monday.”
The Washington Post, Aug. 21, p.1 “Bars Tinoco regime” records “Federico Tinoco
smuggled himself into a freight car and escaped to Port Limon, where he took the United
Fruit Company’s steamer Zacapa to Jamaica. Tinoco had arranged to leave the
presidential succession in the hands of Juan Bautista Quiros, who had been manager of
the National Bank and had assisted the Tinoco brothers in inssuing $15,000,000 in paper
money …. Quitos announced himself president and is now clinging to the wreckage of
the Tinoco regime. The popular armed movement to restore the authority of
constitutional government is headed by Julio Acosta, who was minister of foreign affairs
under President Gongalez [sic, HG]. Mr. Gonzales, from the time he was thrust from the
presidency, has lived in the United States.”
52
His government was not recognized by the US – neither was Tinoco’s, see The
Washington Post, Aug. 21, 1919, p.6 “Costa Rica Saved” and he was forced to resign.
CSM, Jun 16, 1920, p.10. For his exit, see also Washington Post, Sept. 7, 1919, p. E4
Quiros Quits Costa Rica.
53
COS-1966 94 COS Trejos 08/05/1966 08/05/1970
PANAMA
54
PAN-1910-2 95 PAN Pablo Arosemena Alba 01/10/1910 01/10/1912
Change Pablo Arosemena entry date 1 October, 1910. See NYT, Mar. 8, 1912, p.6.
“Pablo Arosemena this morning resumed the office of President of the Panama Republic
in response to the appeals of friends, who thought he would not be chosen at the
approaching Presidential election. The resumption of office by President Arosemena
before the expiration of the six months leave of absence granted him by the Supreme
Court, February 1, excludes him from participation as a candidate in the Presidential
campaign. The constitution of Panama provides for the election of a President of the
Republic for four years and the holder of the office is not eligible for the succeeding
term. By taking leave of absence from the Executive Office for six months Arosemena
would have made himself eligible for re-election, but his present step now excludes him.”
For fate, see NYT, Dec. 14, 1913, p.C5.
55
PAN-1928-1 95 PAN Tomas Duque 08/09/1928 01/10/1928
56
PAN-1932 95 PAN Arias, H. 01/10/1932 01/10/1936
Harmonio Arias.
57
Son of Rodolfo Chiari, president 10/1/1924—10/1/1928.
58
afterwards General Vallarino and his two deputies issued a communiqué in which they
stated that the National Guard was "not qualified to intervene in the dispute between the
Government and the Assembly"; announced that, because of the court injunction obtained
by Senor Robles, they could not carry out the Assembly's decision and would remain
under President Robles's orders until the Supreme Court had met to give its ruling; and
declared that in the meantime they would maintain law and order. After Dr. Arias, in a
broadcast the same night, had called on Panamanians to carry out "civil resistance" until
"the Republic returns to its constitutional course," National Guard troops in the early
hours of March 25 dispersed a crowd which had built barricades in front of the
headquarters of the Union Nacional; occupied the building; wrecked a radio transmitter
which had criticized the Guard's refusal to obey the National Assembly; seized
documents and some weapons; and made a number of arrests. They also surrounded the
National Assembly building and on March 26 used tear-gas to prevent the deputies of the
Union Nacional and the new President from entering. A call by the Opposition parties for
a general strike on April 2 was unsuccessful, being supported only by four small trade
unions. A silent demonstration took place on March 28, when 3,000 women in mourning
dress and carrying banners draped in black, led by Senora Yvonne del Valle and Senora
Mary Morgan de Arias (wife of the President of the National Assembly, Senor Carlos
Agustin Arias) marched through Panama City; thousands of youths, however, joined the
demonstration, overturned and burned motor cars, looted shops, knocked down parking
meters, and attacked the headquarters of the Samudio group. Troops of the National
Guard used tear-gas to disperse the rioters, two people being killed and eight others
injured during the disorders. Similar silent protest marches by women and children in
several other towns on March 29 were dispersed by the National Guard using tear-gas,
several people being arrested. The Supreme Court duly met on April 1 to consider the
dispute, and on April 5 eight of the nine judges declared that the National Assembly,
motivated by "political pressure," had acted unconstitutionally in deposing President
Robles, on the ground that it should have suspended its decision when President Robles
had lodged an appeal against it. Opposition members, however, protested that four of the
judges were related to Senor Robles and that the rest belonged to his party, whilst Senor
del Valle, denying the Supreme Court's authority to overrule decisions of the Legislature,
maintained that his Government remained the only legitimate one."
Exile in the US.
59
See NYT, Apr. 5, 1982, p.A8. Briefly “detained” and forced to “retire.” Still.
Florez Aguilar, not really constitutional exit, he’s simply a colonel in (and commnader
of) the Panamanian National Guard, not President or anything official. For exit date and
fate (scant on fate, but all we have). See NYT, April 5, 1982. CSM, Mar. 5, 1982. Lost
power on 3 March 1982. Forced to resign.
60
“In Panama, former president Mireya Moscoso, whose term ended last year, faces
inquiries about as much as $70 million in government funds that were not accounted for
under her administration. No formal charges have been brought.”
COLOMBIA
Sources consulted include Gomez Aristizabal (1999).
61
the capital there insures a sort of Presidential interregnum, which the Vice President fills,
the entire responsibility of Government devolving on him.” NYT, Aug. 3, 1891,p.2.
On Nunez see also: http://dodgson.ucsd.edu/las/colombia/1850-1899.html
He was born on 28/9/1825. Encyclopedia Brit records him dying Sept. 12, 1894. Takes an
overdose of a sedative in 1893. The Washington Post, Nov. 17, 1893,6. See also NYT,
Sept.20, 1894, p.1. NYT, Oct. 28, 1894, p.17. Carlos Holquin dies in October.
62
COL-1914 100 COL Concha 07/08/1914 07/08/1918
63
Lentz records: Laureano Gomez becomes seriously ill in November 1951 and Roberto
Urdaneta Arebelaz served as acting president in his stead. Appointed an interim due to
health problems.
After 1945, when the Conservaties resumed power Gomez was appointed foreign
minister, but as nominal party leader wields power behind the scenes. Gomez, feeling
himself targeted by violence, fled to Spain in 1948, but returned the following year.
He was elected President in 1950, suffered a heart attack in 1951. Colombia grew so
imperiled by instability that on June 13, 1953, General Gustavo Rojas Pinelilla overthrew
the government in a bloodless coup. Gomez was summarily exiled to Spain. (Until 1957.)
Fredriksen.
64
(a) The Presidency should be held, during the 16 years from 1958 to 1974, for a four-year
term each by a Liberal and a Conservative in rotation (so that irrespective of the election
result a Liberal President would be followed by a Conservative one, and vice versa).
(b) Both parties would have an equal number of seats in both Houses of Congress (the
Chamber of Representatives and the Senate), and complete parity in all governmental and
administrative bodies.
(c) The Cabinet would consist of an equal number of Ministers from both parties, with
the Foreign Minister being of the same party as the President, plus one Army officer.
(d) Elections for the Chamber of Representatives would be held every two years, and
those for the Senate every four years together with the presidential elections.
(e) All legislation would require a two-thirds majority in Congress.
The junta thereupon recommended that the agreement should be incorporated in the
country's Constitution as "a means of ending party strife" and "the bloody internal
struggles", which had caused "complete devastation in agriculture and unprecedented
economic chaos". The agreement was accordingly approved by a majority of 3,885,440
votes (against 172,867 negative and 8,820 blank votes) in a referendum held on Dec. 1,
1957. The Supreme Court ruled on Feb. 13, 1958, that the five members of the military
junta should act as constitutional Presidents with equal rights until Aug. 7, 1958.
In congressional elections held tinder the new Constitution on March 16, 1958, the
Liberals polled 1,745,319 votes and the Conservatives 1,262,122. Both parties obtained,
as laid down in the Constitution, an equal number of seats in the 148-member Chamber
of Representatives and in the 80-member Senate. In presidential elections held on May 4,
1958, the candidate of the National Front, the Liberal Dr. Alberto Lleras Camargo,
obtained 2,482,948 votes or 85 per cent of the total, against 614,861 votes or 12 per cent
polled by Dr. Jorge Leyva, who stood as an Independent Conservative, while the
remaining three per cent consisted of blank and invalid papers. President Lleras Camargo,
who had been President in 1945-46 after the resignation of President Alfonso Lopez
Pumarejo, assumed office and appointed a Cabinet of six Conservatives, six Liberals and
Brigadier Alfonso Saiz Montoya as Minister of War. On Aug. 28, 1958, the new
Government lifted the state of siege in all parts of the country except the departments of
Caldas, Cauca, Huila, Tolima and Valle del Cauca, where emergency restrictions
remained in force in order to cope with continuing violence. However, following the
discovery of a plot allegedly inspired by General Reins Pinilla, who had returned to
Colombia in October 1958, President Lleras Camargo temporarily reimposed the state of
siege from Dec. 3, 1958, to Jan. 12, 1959. General Rojas Pinilla, who had been arrested,
was subsequently sentenced to residence under surveillance, as well as loss of military
rank and of civic rights, on charges of violating the Constitution and degrading the
presidency by having, it was alleged, illegally enriched himself--this decision being
approved by the Senate on April 2, 1959, by 44 votes to 17. These penalties were
gradually relaxed during subsequent years, however, and the General was tacitly
permitted to engage in political activities.”
65
COL-1966 100 COL Lleras Restropo 07/08/1966 07/08/1970
Keesing’s Vol. 17, September 1971: “President Lleras Restrepo, a distant cousin of ex-
President Lleras Camargo and a co-founder of the National Front, was an experienced
economist with liberal ideas on social policies; he had established numerous study groups
with the object of preparing plans for overcoming Colombian's difficulties as a country
relying heavily on its coffee exports, and unable to produce enough agricultural output to
maintain the people's standard of living”
66
VENEZUELA
http://countrystudies.us/venezuela/39.htm
The President
“The 1961 constitution continues the long tradition of a powerful president, who serves
as head of state and chief executive. He or she must be a Venezuelan by birth, at least
thirty years old, and not a member of the clergy. The president is elected by a plurality
vote under direct and universal suffrage, serves for five years, and cannot be reelected
until after two intervening terms have passed. President Carlos Andrés Pérez became the
first Venezuelan elected to serve two terms of office under this provision of the 1961
constitution; he won the December 1988 election after having served as president from
1974 to 1979.”
67
Antonio Diez was born in 1838.
68
of the Cabinet and Minister of Finance. Up to the latest moment it was supposed that
Gen. Manuel Antonio Matos, the brother-in-law of Gen Guzman Blanco, would without
doubt be selected by the convention for recommendation to Congress.
69
in the skirmishes, they continued to make headway and secured the advantage of a port,
Puerto Cabell, in which to receive arms and ammunition. At length Palacio proposed a
compromise; but his terms were not agreed to, and in disgust he left the country and went
to Paris.”
New:
VEN 101 VEN Guzman Alvarez 20/2/1898 28/2/1898
NYT, Feb. 22, 1898. Andrade defeats Rojas Paul. NYT, April. 20, 1898. p.7.
Corresponds also with www.rulers.org.
70
VEN-1908 101 VEN Gomez 19/12/1908 18/12/1935
Survived multiple coups, death from natural causes
71
When Col. Delgado Chalbaud was assassinated in November, 1950, Dr. German Suarez
Flamerich, a civilian, took his place in the junta. Since that time Col. Perez Jimenez has
emerged as the most important member of the triumvirate.” LA Times, Dec. 4, 1952, p.24
also names him as “a key member of the three-man junta which had ruled Venezuela
since 1950, …”
Lentz also records “Junta member Lt. Col. Marcos Pérez Jimenez remained largely in
control of the country while Suarez served as head of state.”
See also LA Times, Nov. 14, 1950, p. 4 “Venezuelan Chief Slain by Assassins.”
Since he is a member of the ruling junta, and takes over after Chalbaud is assassinated,
we code this as a regular entry. (As when a number two takes over after leader is
removed.)
See NYT, Nov. 30, 1952, p. 36. Candidates in the Nov. 30 election are Villalba and
Caldera. “Among observers there is speculation not so much as to what will happen
before or during the elections tomorrow but as to what will take place after them. They
feel that if the Government wins a substantial majority—say 70 per cent or more—it will
have no problems. Col. Marcos Perez Jimenez, in that case would unquestionably be
named provisional president and, if he proved equal to that test of leadership, no great
difficulties would be expected. If, on the other hand, the Government wins a precarious
majority, it is expected that opposition leaders will pose many problems. If the
Government does not win a majority of the delegates, there is a possibility of a coalition
by it with the Cope party. However, the Copei has not indicated its willingness to make
such a coalition.” Chicago Daily Tribune, Dec. 3, 1952, p.B9 records Perez Taking over
power and also notes that results of the elections published by the government do not
match preliminary unofficial returns published in the Caracas newpapers. “The returns
had showed the leftist opposition, URD, leading with 294,595 votes in a political upset,
FEI [=Government, HG] a poor second with 147,528, and COPEI [Christian Democrats,
HG] trailing with 89,095]. Irregular entry; forced to resign; exile in the US. Lentz records
that “he was extradited to Venezuela in August 1963 on charges of embezzling
government funds. Pérez Jimenez remained imprisoned until 1968, when he was elected
to the Venezuelan Senate.” Election is subsequently annulled and he goes into exile in
Madrid Spain. There had been a military rebellion against him on January 1, 1958, but it
was crushed and its leaders arrested.
72
VEN-1979 101 VEN Campins 12/03/1979 02/02/1984
GUYANA
SURINAM
73
SUR-1980 115 SUR Bouterse 13/08/1980 25/01/1988
A military coup in 1980 brought Desi Bouterse to power. In 1987, free elections were
held. Bouterse staged another coup in 1990, and remains influential. We do not consider
him the effective leader after he formally steps down from power as he does not appear to
effectively rule the country on a day to day basis.
ECUADOR
For Ecuadorian Presidents, see the excellent site:
http://www.edufuturo.com/educacion.php?c=206
Sources consulted include Pérez Marchant (1928)
74
ECU-1883-3 130 ECU Perez Pareja 15/10/1883 23/11/1883
75
ECU-1912-3 130 ECU Plaza Gutierrez 01/09/1912 01/09/1916
76
ECU-1934 130 ECU Velasco Ibarra 01/09/1934 21/08/1935
See NYT, Aug. 21, 1935. Arrested, then exile to Colombia. Velasco placed under arrest
because of attempt at dictatorship. See Barron’s. Aug. 26, 1935; 15, 34 p.2.
77
ECU-1947-1 130 ECU Mancheno 24/08/1947 03/09/1947
78
ECU-1981 130 ECU Hurtado Larrea 24/05/1981 10/08/1984
See Lentz.
79
should declare it vacant. The measure avoids a drawn-out impeachment process and is
similar to what Congress did in 1997 when it dismissed President Abadal Bucaram for
“mental incapacity.” Gutierrez remained inside the palace even though soldiers who had
set up a protective perimeter withdrew from the plaza in from of the buidling
immediately after the vote.” “Gutierrez took refuge in Brazil’s embassy and sought
asylum as the new president ordered his arrrest following a week of escalating protests.”
BBC News world edition, Thursday 21 April, 2005 “Ex-Ecaudaor leader granted
asylum.” He is given asylum in Brazil. Vice President Palacio takes over.
CNN, 23 April 2005 reports that Ecuador is dragging its feet on allowing Gutierrez to
leave the country. And that the OAS sent a high-level diplomatic delegation to investigate
wither Gutierrez removal was constitutional. ... So far no country has recognized the new
government as legitimate.
http://www.cnn.com/2005/WORLD/americas/04/23/ecuador.president.ap/index.html
Follow up: 22 September, 2005. BBC News,World edition. “Ecaudor’s ousted President,
Lucio Gutierrz, who faces charges of damaging his country’s security, has requested
asylum in Colombia. ... the Colombian authorities have granted him a 90-day safe
conduct, to give him time to make a formal request. Mr. Gutierrez, who arrived from
Peru, was reportedly told at Bogota airport that there was an international warrant for his
arrest. Mr. Gutierrez was ousted by congress in April followng mass protests. He
previously stayed in Brazil and the United States, before traveling to Peru. Colombian
officials have said they have no knowledge of any arrest warrant for Mr. Gutierrez. But
advisers to Mr. Utierrez say it could have been issued after he recently said in the US that
he was still president of Ecuador. ... The asylium request also covers Mr. Gutierrez’s
brother, Yomar, as well as a former colonel and a businessman from Ecuador who also
face charges in their home country.”
Follow up: Saturday, 4 March 2006. BBC News: “A judge in Ecuador has released the
country's former president, Lucio Gutierrez, from prison. Mr Gutierrez had been held
since last October on charges of endangering national security. The judge dismissed the
charges, which were based on Mr Gutierrez' refusal to acknowledge the legitimacy of his
interim successor, Alfredo Palacio.”
PERU
Sources consulted include Alberto (1966-7)
80
NYT, Sep. 25, p. 8. Lima falls and is occupied January 17, and Pierola flees. He appoints
Mentoero as Commander of the Army of the North. Washington Post, Feb 15, 1881, p.3.
So, I’d change exit date to January 17, 1881. “Gen Saavedra … has been acting as
Political Chief of Lima since the 17th of last month [most likely refers to Jan 17, since it’s
filed “March 2”], has resigned office.” See NYT, Mar. 13, 1881, p. 7.
Chilean Gen. Baquendano is more or less in real control. Exile, Chilean general assumes
control.
81
Attempted assassination of De Romana on 28 Oct. 1903.
82
the government of President Tinoco.” For his fate see Lentz (I). and, NYT, Aug 27, 1930,
p.1. Died in prison.
83
Bustamante faced a coup attempt on 3 October by leftists. Suppressed, then coup by the
right. Left for exile in Chile on Oct. 30: CSM, Oct. 30, 1948, p.1. Is in Buenos Airs on
Oct. 31. NYT, Nov. 1, 1948. Becomes judge and then president of ICJ at the Hague.
Deposed in coup exile in Chile.
84
See Lentz, After leaving office elected to the Senate, but goes into hiding after Fujimori
suspends constitutional government on April 5, 1992, and granted asylum in Columbia in
June 1992.
BRAZIL
Sources consulted include: Brasil Bandecchi, Leonardo Arroyo & Uribatan Rosa (eds.).
Novo Dicionario de Historia do Brasil. Sao Paulo: Melhoramentos de Sao Paulo. 1970
85
Francisco Rodrigues Alve. Lentz notes: “He was reelected to the presidency on
November 15, 1918, but poor health prevented him from carrying out his duties. He died
in Rio de Janeiro on January 16, 1919.” He served abroad and was not punished. See
Lentz.
86
sent into exile. See NYT, Nov 6, p.1945, p.13. Coup attempt reported NYT, Mar. 27,
1940, p.6. We drop Prestes de Albu, who is listed in Lentz as leader, based on NYT, and
Washington Post, Oct. 25, 1930, p1, which show that Prestes never really ruled, and was
in hiding. Vargas was offered the presidency. See also NYT, Dec. 9, 1930, p.10. Prestes,
however, a refugee in the British consulate general at Sao Paulo. Washington Post, Nov.
4, 1930, p.7
87
Lentz. Completed his term and turned over power to his successor, subsequently elected
to the Senate. Stripped of political rights and briefly in exile when the junta of 1964
comes to power.
88
Lentz notes: Costa e Silva suffered a paralytic stroke on August 31, 1969, that left him
unable to perform his duties as president. The military refused to allow vice president
Pedro Aleixo to succeed in a constitutional fashion and instead a three-man junta,
consisting of General Aurelio de Lyra Tavares, Admiral Augusto Hamman Rademaker
Grunewald, and Air Marshall Marcio de Zouza e Mello, took control of the government.”
He had a natural death
BOLIVIA
The period between Fernandez Alonso (15/08/1896 to 10/04/1898) and Pando Solares
(12/12/1898 to 04/08/1904) is coded as an interregnum. Although Ortiz heads an Federal
Junta, there seems to be no clear leader until 12/12/1898 when both Ortiz and Pando form
a ruling committee.
89
Sources counculted include: Jose Roberto Arze. Figuras Centrales en la Historia de
Bolivia. La Paz: Cochabamba, 1991.
90
He lost power as a result of a bloodless coup, and was exiled to Chile. See CSM Aug 23,
1920, p.4.
91
BOL-1939 145 BOL Quintanila 23/08/1939 15/04/1940
Quintanila becomes President “by unanimous determination of the generals, chiefs of
garrisons and members of the Cabinet.” Washington Post, Aug. 24, 1939, p.1. He was
instituted by military. Assassination plan of Quintanila and capture of Penaranda foiled
by General Antenor Ichazo. See NYT, Mar. 27, 1940, p.6. Runs for Pres.
92
BOL-1951 145 BOL Ballivian Rojas 16/05/1951 11/04/1952
See Lentz. After a 3 day revolution, he was sent to exile in Chile.
93
Lentz. Turns over power to military junta. Exile in Argentina.
94
BOL-1981 145 BOL Torrelio Villa 04/09/1981 19/07/1982
Celso Terrelio Villa. Foreign Affairs, 1983, 61,003, p.739. “July 19. Bolivian President
Celso Torrelio is ousted by military junta consisting of Army Gen. Angel. Mariscal, Air
Force Gen. Natalio Morales, and Navy Vice Adm. Oscar Pamma; Gen. Guido Vildoso
Calderon sworn in as country’s president, 7/21.” He resigns. Dies in 1999. Keesing’s Vol.
29 (1983) February: “Gen. Celso Torrelio Villa, who had succeeded Gen. Garcia Meza as
President in September 1981, after being appointed by the junta composed of the chiefs
of the three branches of the armed forces, stated his intention of seeking to effect a return
to democracy, but came under pressure both from rival members of the military
command and also from the increasingly restive civilian population. Gen. Torrelio
formally resigned as President on July 19, 1982, and the junta replaced him with Gen.
Guido Vildoso Calderon, who promised that fresh elections would be held in early 1983.”
See also Keesing’s Vol. 29 (1983) November, which states Celso is retired.
According to same article Washington Post, Nov. 30, 1982, p. A 12.Exile in Argentina.
95
BOL-1993 145 BOL Gonzalo Sanchez de Lozada 06/08/1993 06/08/1997
96
President Evo Morales described their destruction as a US plot to weaken Bolivian
defences.”
PARAGUAY
97
PAR-1894-2 150 PAR Egusquiza 25/11/1894 25/11/1898
Is a general, made candidate for the Presidency: Washington Post, Jun 28, 1894, p.6.
Leaves at the appropriate time.
98
then and there proceeded to eliminate the rebels in an up-to-date military campaign. All,
including Jara, have been annihilated, the dispatch announces.” The Washington Post,
May 18, 1912, p.4. First arrested then killed in revolt.
99
Felix Paiva, in neither Lentz, nor rulers.org. For his entry, see The Washington Post,
Nov. 2, 1921, p.6. Resigns after brief period as acting president. NYT Nov 6, 1921, p. 25
attributes this to negotiation outcome between the political factions. Nothing clearly on
his fate, but becomes dean of law school see below, I surmise he’s OK.
100
Ayala, 1936, Held as Prisoner. NYT, May 18, 1936, pp. 1 & 9. Also Lentz. Dies in exile,
for more see obit. NYT, Jun. 5, 1942, p.17. Placed in protective custody, exiled. . To
contain Bolivian incursions into the Chaco, the Eligio Ayala government (1924-28)
armed the nation and entered the disputed territory. A clash occurred on June 15, 1932,
when Ft. Carlos Antonio Lopez was captured by the Bolivians. While Eusebio Ayala held
civil power in Paraguay, the military commander, Gen. Jose Felix Estigarribia,
demonstrated an intelligent strategy and by a string of victories pushed the Bolivians
back almost to the edge of the disputed territory. On February 17, 1936, a military coup
jailed Ayala and Estigarribia, removed the Liberals from power, and abrogated the
constitution of 1870. The new government was short-lived, in 1939 Estigarribia was
elected president with the support of the Liberals.
101
PAR-1949-2 150 PAR Molas Lopez 26/02/1949 10/09/1949
Felipe Molas López, was overthrown 10 Sept. 1949. Christian Science Monitor, Jan. 8,
1951, p.1 “Senor Molas Lopez made the charge during an interview after his arrival here
[=Buenos Aires, HG] last week to live in exile.” So, more than a year after losing office.
Was minister of Interior. Dentist. Seems to be OK, Dies, Mar 2. 1954. See brief obit,
NYT, Mar. 3, 1954, p.27.
102
leaves Exile and back in Argentina in December 1999. NYT, December 12, 19999, p.6.
NYT reports that “Mr. Oviedo left Argentina after its new president, Fernando de la Rua,
who was sworn in on Friday, made it known that he would force Mr. Oviedo out of the
country
CHILE
On term limits:
1884, NYT, Sept. 21, p.12. “The President is elected every five years by the people, and
is not eligible for re-election except after an interval of one term.”
103
proposals were approved by the Senate (in which supporters of former military ruler and
current Army C.-in-C. Gen. Augusto Pinochet Ugarte held a strong position).
The 1981 Constitution, promulgated during the military regime (1973-90), provided for
an eight-year presidential term. The Senate version approved on Oct. 14, while accepting
that the term would be four years, provided that a second term would be permitted. The
Senate vote was 29 to 10 with four abstentions, those voting against being senators
appointed by Pinochet before he handed over power, and senators of the right-wing
Independent Democratic Union (UDI). The right-wing party National Renewal (RN), by
contrast, voted in favour, following intense negotiations with the ruling Coalition for
Democracy (CPD). The Chamber of Deputies voted by a large majority on Oct. 20 in
favour of reducing the presidential term to four years, without a provision for re-
election. Aylwin's non-renewable term of four years, due to end in March 1994, had been
specifically laid down by a constitutional amendment approved by referendum in July
1989. In August 1991 he had rejected a cross-party initiative to extend his term of office
for a further two years. Aylwin's centre-left CPD was anxious to amend the Constitution
regarding the presidential term before the next presidential elections, due in December
1993.
104
Both Pinto and Errazuriz get a cruiser named after them. CSM, Jun 25, 1915, p.9
105
Dies in 1919. NYT, Sept. 21, 1919, p.22. Alo CSM, Feb. 15, 1916, p.15
106
Washington Post, May 5, 1927, p.5. Then, Chile’s representative in the League of
Nations. CSM, Jun. 4, 1927. p.2. Exile.
107
CHL-1932-6 155 CHL Alessandri y Palma 25/12/1932 24/12/1938
Chilean Nazis apparently attempt putsch Sept. 5, 1938. CSM, Dec. 28, 1938, p.2. This
article also notes: “Under Chile’s Constitution, an outgoing President must remain in the
country at least six months, unless Congress grants special permission.” He is granted
this request, 51 – 41, Jan. 4, 1939. NYT, Jan 5, 1939, p.5. Looks like self-imposed exile,
and attempting to avoid responsibility for his orders to quell the putsch of Sept. 5, where
61 Nazi students were killed. See also for attacks when he returns, CSM, Dec. 5, 1939,
p.6.
108
CHL-1973 155 CHL Pinochet 11/09/1973 11/03/1990
ARGENTINA
109
ARG-1906 160 ARG Alcorta 12/03/1906 12/10/1910
Lentz. Later Ambassador to Spain.
110
President Ramon Castillo in July 1940. Lentz: “He resigned from office on June 24,
1942, and died in Buenos Aires of bronchial pneumonia on July 15, 1942.” He was
“inactive for nearly two years because of ill health and near blindness” see Washington
Post, Jul 16, 1942, p. 3.
111
ARG-1963 160 ARG Arturo Illia12/10/1963 28/06/1966
Releases Frondizi. NYT, Aug. 1, 1963, p.4. For posttenurefate see, NYT, Aug. 26, 1966,
p.14. Dies Jan 18, 1983,. NYT, Jan 19, 1983, p. B6
112
Is VP, wife of Juan Peron, above. Lentz. Five years of house arrest. See also Washington
Post, Mar. 21, 1981, p. A20, on her conviction on corruption charges. Five years house
arrest.
113
Indicted and “ordered to stand trial on charges that he led a conspiracy and falsified
government documents to smuggle arms to Croatia and Ecuador between 1991 and
1995.” Menem had been under house arrest since June 2001. NYT, Jul. 5, 2001, p. A3.
Indicted but not convicted.
URUGUAY
114
Listed in worldstatesmen.org as Francisco Antonino Vidal Silva. Others have him as
Francisco Antonio Vidal (More hits under the latter.). Forced out by Santos, who really
held power. See http://www.biografiasyvidas.com/biografia/v/vidal_francisco.htm
115
José Batlle y Ordóñez. Lentz: Also departs for Europe after his term, returns in 1911.
Insurrectionary force tries to gain entry from Argentine territory, overwhelmed by
Uruguayan forces, Washington Post, Aug. 29, 1904. p. 1. Judgment call as before on fate.
Leaves for Europe. www.rulers.org also list José Batlle y Ordóñez
For the two weeks: 15/02/1899-01/03/1899. Probably just temporary, in the interim. The
Uruguayan list does not list him for this period, hence we do not.
Son of President Lorenzo Batlle, president 1868—1872. His nephew—Luis Battle
Berres—becomes president 47—51, as well as his grandnephew, Jorge Battle Ibanez.
116
to Terra by marriage. ... In a coup engineered in March 1933, ...., he [=Terra, HG] took
dictatorial power, ousted the council and ruled by decree provisionally. New elections
resulted in a pro-Terra assembly, a new constitution and Terra's re-election for the term
1934-38.”
117
URU-1962 165 URU Harrison 01/03/1962 01/03/1963
He died on August 20, 1963. See Lentz . Lentz notes that : “He died of a heart attack in
Montevideo at the age of 63 on August 20, 1963.” This is less than six months after out.
118
sealed off the centre of Montevideo. On Feb. 9 the entire Cabinet offered their
resignation, reportedly to give the President a free hard in dealing with the crisis.
Senores Ravenna, Juan Carlos Blanco and Luis Balparda Blengio, respectively the
Ministers of the Interior, Foreign Affairs and Industry, conferred with the Army and Air
Force commanders, including General Esteban Cristi, head of the First Military Region;
meanwhile a column of 30 tanks and motorized infantry had moved towards the centre of
Montevideo. Later the same day President Bordaberry officially announced the
resignation of General Francese. The Army and Air Force leaders, who were in control of
all radio stations, broadcast on Feb. 10 a 19-point "political programme" containing
demands for decisive action against corruption in the State and in private life; the setting-
up of special courts with military participation; a rapid reduction of the country's foreign
debt; drastic savings in foreign currency expenditure; tax reforms; a comprehensive
employment policy with preference for labour-intensive projects; support for small and
medium-sized enterprises; improved distribution of national revenue; stricter public
control of the means of production; land reform; the creation of instruments for action
against monopolies; and encouragement of workers' participation in industry. The
programme also included undertakings by the military not to intervene in trade union and
student affairs except in extreme cases; to protect the country from "the influence of
Marxist-Leninist doctrines"; and to respect all international treaties "except those forced
upon the country". In addition to General Cristi, who commanded about one-half of
Uruguay's Army of some 17,000 men, Colonel Ramon Brabal, head of the joint
intelligence service, was held primarily responsible for the statements setting forth the
armed forces' programme. Other influential leaders of the movement were General (retd.)
Mario Aguerrondo and General Gregorio Alvarez, chief of the armed forces' joint staff.
On Feb. 11 the Army and Air Force leaders reached an agreement with the Navy's
leaders, whereby Rear-Admiral Juan Zorilla--who had declared on Feb. 8 that the Navy
would defend President Bordaberry'. Government "to the ultimate extremes "--resigned
as C.-in-C. of the Navy "to avoid armed clashes between the services" and was replaced
by Lieut.-Commander Conrado Olazabal. As a result the naval units accepted the
programme of the Army and Air Force leaders. At the same time the armed forces'
leaders replaced General Martinez as C.-in-C. of the Army by General Hugo Chiappe
Posse, who was the oldest-ranking officer and was regarded as a "hard-line right-
winger". [HG: Keesing’s Vol. 20, September 1974, notes that Posse was dismissed on
May 21 “in what was interpreted as a move to the right by the armed forces, and was
replaced by General Jukio Cesar Vadora, Uruguay’s military attaché in Washington.”]
Following a meeting between President Bordaberry, Senores Ravenna and Balparda, and
leading Air Force officers, Senor Ravenna declared on Feb. 12 that agreement had been
reached on fundamental questions, and the military leaders confirmed on the same day
that "the basis of complete agreement" had been reached.
In the agreement, the terms of which were disclosed on Feb. 13, President Bordaberry
accepted all demands made by the armed forces' leaders. Specifically, the President
consented to (a) the establishment of a National security Council (CONASED),
consisting of the commanders of the three armed services and the Ministers of Defence,
the Interior, Foreign Affairs and the Economy, and functioning as an organ of military
control over the administration; (b) the requirement of military approval for appointments
to the Ministries of the Interior and Defence; (c) the replacement of a number of
119
ambassadors and other foreign service officials accused of having enriched themselves;
and (d) the political and economic programme as announced by the military leaders.
It was further disclosed on Feb. 14 that the armed forces had promised to uphold the
Constitution and democratic institutions, and to guarantee that elections would be held in
1976 as planned. … Following the agreement President Bordaberry reappointed his
previous Cabinet on Feb. 13, except for General Francese, who was replaced as Minister
of Defence by Senor Walter Ravenna; the latter's previous portfolio of the Interior was
entrusted to Colonel Nestor Bolentini.
…The National security Council was formally established by presidential decree on Feb.
23, its secretary being General Gregorio Alvarez.”
Military stages a coup in February 1973 that takes over many of the powers of
government, but Bordaberry remains president. Rules dictatorially with the approval of
the military. Deposed when trying to extend his term of office. See also NYT, Jun. 13,
1976, p.24. NYT, Jun. 145, 1976, p.12. Electoral fraud alleged, later establishes
autocratic rule; forced to resign. See also NYT, Sept.2, 1976, p.3:
“Mr. Méndez, a 72 year-old constitutional lawyer, was the choice of Uruguay’s senior
military officers to replace Mr. Bordaberry, who was elected in 1971 but closed Congress
in 1973 and governed with military backing. Mr. Bordaberry was forced to resign June 12
after a disagreement with the military chiefs, who announced publicly that they had
withdrawn their support of him. He was replacd provisionally by Alberto Demichelli, the
80-year-old president of the Council of State, a 27-member body created to replace the
Congress dissolved by Mr. Bordaberry.”
120
new Council of the Nation came into being on June 27 and, as stated, selected Dr Mendez
as the forthcoming new President.”
121
co-ordinating activities against the Tupamaro guerrillas; in 1973 he was responsible for
drafting parts of the military political programme presented to President Bordaberry,
notably those sections on land reform and action against monopolies , and the same year
he he-came secretary of the National security Council (Cosena), which held the power of
veto over the President. (The action of the armed forces culminated in the suspension of
the parliamentary regime in June 1973 and the armed forces effectively taking control of
the countryA-although President Bordaberry remained in office until 1976.) Gen. Alvarez
became C.-in-C. of the Army in February 1978 before retiring from the armed forces a
year later. According to statements made by Gen. Alvarez at his inauguration and at a
subsequent press conference, presidential and legislative elections would be held in three
years' time, in November 1984, and power would be transferred to civilians in March
1985. He further stated that a new constitution would be submitted to a referendum (also
in November 1984), that a political parties statute and an electoral law would be drafted
and the right to strike recognized, but that those parties regarded as Marxist-Leninist,
"extremist" or opposed to democracy would continue to be illegal and that there would be
no political amnesty for "those who have conspired against our state". He added that the
independence of the judiciary would be fully restored.”
Keesing’s Vol. 30, June 1984: “It was announced on Jan. 20 that Lt.-Gen. Pedro
Aranco would be appointed C-in-C of the Army with effect from Feb. 1 to replace Gen.
Boscan Hontou, who had held the command since 1982. Lt.-Gen. Aranco was a close
associate of Gen. Alvarez.”
UNITED KINGDOM
122
UKG-1892 200 UKG Gladstone 16/08/1892 03/03/1894
123
Lentz says he retired from office for reasons of health on January 10, 1957. Died 14
January, 1977, of cancer of the liver.
IRELAND
124
IRE-1973 205 IRE Cosgrave, L. 14/03/1973 05/07/1977
NETHERLANDS
125
NTH-1913 210 NTH van der Linden 29/08/1913 03/07/1918
126
NTH-1994 210 NTH Kok 22/08/1994 22/07/2002
BELGIUM
127
BEL-1918-1 211 BEL Geraard Cooreman 11/11/1918 13/11/1918
128
BEL-1946-3 211 BEL Huysman 02/08/1946 12/03/1947
129
BEL-1992 211 BEL Dehaene 07/03/1992 12/07/1999
LUXEMBOURG
130
LUX-1995 212 LUX Juncker 20/01/1995 31/12/2004
FRANCE
131
FRN-1886-2 220 FRN Goblet 16/12/1886 17/05/1887
132
FRN-1909 220 FRN Briand 24/07/1909 24/02/1911
133
FRN-1925-1 220 FRN Painleve 17/04/1925 02/11/1925
134
FRN-1934-3 220 FRN Flandin 10/11/1934 30/05/1935
Foreign minister in Vichy for two months. After the war sentenced to five years of
national indignity for collaborating with Vichy. Suspended.
135
FRN-1947-2 220 FRN Schuman 24/11/1947 19/07/1948
136
FRN-1974-1 220 FRN Poher 02/04/1974 27/05/1974
SWITZERLAND
137
SWZ-1891 225 SWZ Welti 01/01/1891 31/12/1891
138
SWZ-1914 225 SWZ Hoffman 01/01/1914 31/12/1914
139
SWZ-1937 225 SWZ Motta 01/01/1937 31/12/1937
140
SWZ-1960 225 SWZ Petipierre 01/01/1960 31/12/1960
141
SWZ-1983 225 SWZ Aubert 01/01/1983 31/12/1983
142
SPAIN
143
SPN-1904 230 SPN Azcarraga y Palmero 16/12/1904 27/01/1905
144
throughout Spain were reported restored to normal in a Madrid dispatch today to the State
Department. Martial law has been suspended at Valencia and Alicante and conditions at
Barcelona and elsewhere, where strikes had taken place, were reported improved.” Lentz
has him “ousted by a military junta.” In spite of the contradictory reports, on the baisis of
es.encarta and Lentz we code this as an irregular exit.
145
Es.encarta.com says he was named president of the council by the King. After out,
becomes President. Deposed as President by the Cortes on April 7. 1935, and sent into
exile then, first France, later Argentina.
146
Miaja = José Miaja Menant. Exile, first in North Africa, then Mexico. Es.encarta.com
suggests that he entered power irregularly. ‘’En los primeros días de marzo de 1939
apoyó al coronel Segismundo Casado en su golpe militar contra el gobierno presidido por
Juan Negrín y pasó a presidir el Consejo de Defensa Nacional creado al efecto. El 28 de
ese mismo mes se dirigió al norte de África tras el fracaso de los intentos de negociar la
paz con el general Francisco Franco, principal dirigente de los insurrectos. Dos meses
después se estableció en México, desde donde participó en distintos organismos
republicanos en el exilio. Falleció en 1958 en la ciudad de México.” Forced out by
military defeat.
PORTUGAL
Portugal, starting with Eanes, the president can serve at most two consecutive terms.
147
POR-1911 235 POR Arriaga 24/08/1911 29/05/1915
148
claim the post, it more or less fell in his lap. Dies July 31, 2001. On him, see NYT, Aug
1., 2001, p. A15.
BAVARIA
GERMANY
149
GMY-1921 255 GMY Wirth 10/5/1921 14/11/1922
Goes into exile in the 30s first Paris, then when the Nazis come into power, to
Switzerland.
150
GFR-1966 260 GFR Kiesinger 1/12/1966 21/10/1969
GERMANY (DDR)
151
into immediate police custody. (Keesing’s Vol. 93, 1997, August) Released on
September 11, pending appeal. Sentence upheld, begins serving sentence in January
2000. Released from prison on December 18, 2003. Krenz is in Moscow Dec 3-4, resigns
as Chairman of the Council of State on Dec. 6. (Keesing’s Vol. 35, 1989, December.)
“Leading role” of the party abolished 1 December 1989.
BADEN
Becomes part of the German Empire on 16 April 1871.
WUERTTEMBERG
Becomes part of the German Empire on 16 April 1871.
HESSE-DARMSTADT
Becomes part of the German Empire on 16 April 1871.
POLAND
POL-1918-1 290 POL Daszynski 11/11/1918 13/11/1918
152
government. See also CSM, May 12, 1926, p.1. Washington Post, May 13, 1926,
p.1.Liver cancer.
AUSTRIA_HUNGARY
AUH-1848 300 AUH Francis Joseph I 02/12/1848 to 21/11/1916.
AUSTRIA
For Austrian leaders see http://de.encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia.
153
Ignaz Seipel was born on 19 July 1876. He studied theology and in 1909 became
professor of Moral theology. He was shot in the chest and seriously injured by an
assassination attempt on June 1 1924 and was forced to give power over to Ramek. See
also The Washington Post, Jun. 2, 1924, p.1. Also, NYT, Jul. 27, p. p.A2. & The
Washington Post, Sept. 2, 1924, p.3.
154
AUS-1938 305 AUS Seyss-Inquart 12/03/1938 30/04/1939
Seyß-Inquart, Arthur was born on 22 July, 1892. From 1 May 1939 to 30 April 1945, he
served as “Reichsminister ohne Geschaftsbereich’ (Minister without portfolio). He first
became “stellvertreter for Hans Frank in Polen, and from May 1940 on he was
“Reichskomissar” in the Netherlands. In Hitler’s Testament envisioned as Foreign
Minister, captured by the Allies in May 1945. In Nurnberg, war crimes tribunal, he was
condemned to death and executed on 16 October 1946.’ Hence he was punished more
than two years after he lost his leadership of Austria.
HUNGARY
155
He was sent into exile.
156
Boross was a non-party technocrat. He was fine after he lost power. See Keesing’s Vol.
39, 1993, December, Europe, Hungary.
CZECHOSLOVAKIA
CZE-1918 315 CZE Masaryk 28/10/1918 14/12/1935
He stepped down in 1935 due to poor health. He died on 14 September 1937. See
Chicago Tribune, February 21, 1991, p. 8: “Foreign Minister Jan Masaryk wrote Josef
Stalin the day before his death in 1948 that he would commit suicide rather than see
freedom crushed in Czechoslovakia, a newspaper said Wednesday. Mystery has
surrounded Masaryk's 1948 death since his body was found in the garden of Czernin
Palace, which housed the foreign ministry and his living quarters. Opponents of the
Communist regime claimed secret police threw Masaryk from his bathroom window.
Communist authorities said he committed suicide, though no farewell note was revealed.
Wednesday's weekly supplement of the Communist Party daily Rude Pravo published
what it said is the text of a letter Masaryk, the popular son of a national hero, wrote to the
Soviet dictator March 9, 1948, the day before he died. The Communists had taken over
Czechoslovakia that Feb. 25. In the letter, said to have been found in previously closed
Communist Party archives, Masaryk accused Stalin of setting up a Soviet-style regime
and reneging on promises that the Czechoslovaks had nothing to fear from Moscow. He
said the Soviet dictator was forcing him "to die quietly" rather than live in a country run
by the Kremlin.”
157
sentenced to 20 years imprisonment for his collaboration with the Germans, died in June
1971.
158
He was born on 10 January 1913. He was expelled from the party in 1990, and he died in
Bratislava on November 18, 1991. He was the victim of a Stalinist purge and in jail 1954-
1960. He was the first appointed leader of Communist party of Slovakia, later Elected
General Secretary.
SLOVAKIA
159
Dzurinda becomes PM again after the election of 20-21 September 2002, even though
Meciar’s HZDS was the biggest party. But EU, NATO, and the USA had threatened
Slovakia with isolation if Mecira became Minister President.
ITALY
See http://it.encarta.msn.com for Italian leaders.
160
He was born in Palermo, Sicily.
161
ITA-1916 325 ITA Boselli 17/06/1916 30/10/1917
Defeat at Caporetto leads to his removal (Lentz).
162
deprive him of his title of Senator for life. On Jan. 30, 1945, it was announced that his
name headed the list of war criminals submitted by Emperor Haile Selassie, but no action
was taken against him.”
163
He was kidnapped by Brigate Rosso terrorists while en route to the Parliament on March
16, 1978, and was executed by the terrorists.
164
ITA-2000 325 IT Amato 26/04/2000 11/06/2001.
MALTA
ALBANIA
165
ALB-1920-2 339 ALB Vrioni 11/12/1920 17/10/1921
166
ALB-1924-3 339 ALB Fan S. Noli 12/06/1924 24/12/1924
For his entry, see NYT, June 15, 1924, p. E5 “Harvard Man Head of New Republic.”
Bishop Fan S. Noli, head of the Albanian Orthodox Greek Church. Harvard educated.
Exiled.
167
ALB-2002-1 339 ALB Majko 22/02/2002 31/07/2002
SERBIA
MONTENEGRO
168
MACEDONIA
de.encarta.com, also highlights Macedonia’s parliamentary regime. See heading under
Crvenkovski. Also see : http://www.macedonian-heritage.gr/FYROM_bios.html
Macedonia is a parliamentary democracy, hence the PM is coded as leader.
CROATIA
CRO-1990 344 CRO Tudjman 30/05/1990 26/11/1999
Tudjman dies 10/12/1999.
169
YUGOSLAVIA
YUG-1918 345 YUG Alexander 01/12/1918 09/10/1934
Alexander had been ruler of Serbia. Murdered by a Croatian terrorist.
170
BOSNIA
Note: Bosnia and Herzegovina's (BiH) has a three-member presidency for an eight-month
rotating chairmanship.
171
BOS-2003-2 346 BOS Dragan Covic 27/06/2003 28/02/2004
Dragan Covic was born in 1956. Croat member of Bosnia-Herzegovina’s Presidency.
SLOVENIA
GREECE
172
Atlanta Constitution, Jan. 13, 1921, p.5. Later goes to London. For Obituaries, see
Chicago Daily Tribune, March 18, 1936, p.1
173
GRC-1924-4 350 GRC Sophoulis 24/07/1924 07/10/1924
Lentz: arrested by the Nazis and put in the Haidari concentration camp. Archaeologist.
174
For entry, see The Washington Post, May 27, 1932, p.1. Bans Pangalos, NYT, June 2,
1932, p.6. For resignation, CSM, June 6, 1932, p.1.
175
NYT, Feb 1, 1936, p. 5 & The Washington Post, Feb. 1, 1936, p.1. The latter mentions
that “unconfirmed reports the former had been poisoned by his political enemies were
quickly denied.” Dies of heart attack 31/1/1936
176
GRC-1946-2 350 GRC K. Tsaldaris 18/04/1946 22/01/1947
Lentz: Law degree from University of Athens. (Briefly jailed in 1926. Arrested by the
Italians in the 1940s.) Undersecretary in the government of his uncle, Panagis Tsaldaris.
(Thus, related to a previous ruler.) Deputy PM and Foreign Minister in the cabinet. See
Lenz and also CSM, April 5, 1946, p.6 for the post tenure fate of this leader.
177
GRC-1952-1 350 GRC Kiousopoulos 11/10/1952 19/11/1952
Kiousopoulos was a Caretaker government. NYT, October 11, 1952, p.4.
178
military in April of 1967. Papandreou was arrested by the junta leaders and imprisoned.
He was in poor health at the time and was sent to a military hospital for treatment. He
was released and placed under house arrest until he was granted amnesty in December of
1967. LA Times, 16 July, 1965, p.2 “Pushing Greece into a major crisis, young King
Constantine Thursday swore a new man into office before Premier George Papandreou
could carry out threats to resign. “I said I would resign tomorrow, tomorrow!” cried
Papandreou who had gathered at his home with aides after broadcasting to the Greek
people his decision to step down. The newly named premier is parliament president
George Athanasiades-Novas, a member of Papandreou’s own Center Union Party. “They
can’t do this. This is a coup d'état!” shouted supporters of Papandreou, ….” The king’s
move is apparently unprecedented. See also the Washington Post, July 16, 1965, p. A18.
Riots afterwards by Papandreou’s supporters.
179
Kanellopoulos and most of his ministers at 3 A.M. Mr. Kanellopoulos was said to have
been taken away by force when he put up resistance to arrest by an army patrol under a
captain.” NYT, April 22, 1967, p.1 & 4. Also, LA Times, 19 April, 1968, p.2. See, Lentz.
Caretaker government, arrested then released.
180
GRC-1989-3 350 GRC Zolotas 28/11/1989 10/04/1990
Lentz: Attended University of Athens, the University of Leipzig, the University of Paris.
Taught economics at the University of Athens.
CYPRUS
See Lentz and Keesing's for the leaders of Cyprus.
181
“Simultaneously in Cyprus the discredited coup leader Nikos Sampson has been ousted,
and his pleace as head of state taken by the respected National Assemply president
Glafkos Clerides.” NYT, July 24, 1974, p. 1 & 15 has more on Sampson and his
background. It notes that Sampson resigned and “It had been apparent to political
observers that Mr. Sampson, a terrorist gunman in the struggle against British control
//p.15// in the nineteen-fifties, had been in deep trouble, commanding little support either
from world opinion or among his own people.”
So, on the one hand, “resigned,” on the other hand, the guys who put him in power, “his
patrons in Athens had collapsed.” Resigned looks like a technicality and code his exit as
irregular because he was shored up only by Athens and once they collapsed he was out.
Sampson was arrested and jailed. See also The Alternative Biography Of Nikos Samson.
By E. Antoniou.
BULGARIA
182
Cyril was in power from 29/08/1943 to 09/09/1944. Regent. Tried and executed on
1/2/1945. Brother of Boris III.
183
Mladenov, by putting forward Sofia as host of the recent CSCE international conference
on environmental protection, had compelled them to show greater tolerance towards
dissident groups, because of the presence of foreign delegations and journalists. On Nov.
3 around 4,000 people took part in a brief pro-democracy demonstration outside the
National Assembly building, as members of the unofficial Eco-Glasnost environmental
group handed in a 11,500-signature pro-conservation petition; this was to date the largest
unofficial demonstration in Bulgaria since the advent of communist rule in 1947.
Zhivkov, 78, had become BCP first secretary in 1954 amid a series of power struggles
and party purges (his title had been changed to general secretary in 1981). Prime Minister
in 1962-71, he then became President of the State Council (de facto head of state). For
over 30 years a loyal adherent to the Soviet line, he found it hard to adjust to the policies
of Mikhail Gorbachev. His economic reform policy of preustroistvo ("restructuring"--
ostensibly akin to the Soviet perestroika) in practice appeared to consist of little more
than frequent and confusing administrative reorganizations; and he continued to suppress
political dissent, within and outside the BCP, despite his regular statements supporting
democratization and glasnost. As recently as Oct. 30 Zhivkov had published a document
(intended as the basis of the report he had been due to give at the Nov. 10 plenum) calling
for preustroistvo to be stepped up and declaring the desirability of political pluralism.”
Note: since a vote was held, we code his removal as regular.
Keesing’s Vol. 35, December 1989, notes that party general secretary Todor Zhivkov is
“ousted.” “The plenum [of the BCP central committee, HG] rescinded the vote of thanks
to Zhivkov made on the occasion of his “resignation” as general secretary on November
10. Mladenov noted that the central committee was responding to pressure by party rank-
and-file members and the Bulgarian public who had "every reason to raise the question of
his great personal guilt and responsibility for the perverted distortions of the past, and for
the situation in which we now find ourselves". Zhivkov was among 26 people stripped of
central committee membership. A three-day central committee plenum beginning on Dec.
11 went further in the repudiation of Zhivkov, expelling him from the BCP along with his
son Vladimir Zhivkov and his former second- in-command Milko Balev. On Dec. 14 the
mandates for Todor and Vladimir Zhivkov to sit as National Assembly deputies were
withdrawn.”
184
demonstrations in December 1989, which were interpreted as advocating the violent
suppression of the protests.” See also NYT, June 12, 2000, p. B6. “Hard-line Communist
rule in Bulgaria did not collapse because of street demonstrations, as it had in Romania,
Czechoslovakia and East Germany. Rather, it fell in a coup when reform-minded
Communist leaders, including Mr. Mladenov, seized control of the government.”
Graduate from military school, later graduated from the Moscow State Institute for
International Relations.
MOLDOVA
MLD-1990 359 MLD Snegur 03/09/1990 15/01/1997
See, de.encarta. msn on Snegur. He was born on 17 January 1940.
185
MLD-1997 359 MLD Lucinschi 15/01/1997 07/04/2001
Lucinschi was born on 27 January 1940. Rulers.org: “Moldova’s presidency became an
increasingly ceremonial post as lawmakers seeking to weaken Lucinschi’s authority
stripped the presidency of power. Encyclopedia Britannica: “A turning point in
Moldova’s post-Soviet history was marked on July 5, 2000, when an overwhelming
majority in Parliament passed an amendment to the 1994 constitution transforming the
country from a semi presidential into a parliamentary regime. … Lucinschi vetoed the
law and continued to press for a nationwide referendum to decide which system was
preferred but to no avail.” See also de.encarta. msn. So it looks like the system becomes
parliamentary. But in the press, at least, the next President Voronin seems to play a
significant role.
RUMANIA
RUM-1866 360 RUM Carol I 22/05/1866 10/10/1914
Carol I died of heart failure.
186
RUM-1947 360 RUM Georghiu-Dej 30/12/1947 19/03/1965
Georghiu-Dej died of pneumonia.
RUSSIA
RUS-1855 365 RUS Alexander II 02/03/1855 13/03/1881
Alexander II was killed by a bomb thrown by a revolutionary.
187
RUS-1917 365 RUS Lenin 07/11/1917 10/03/1923
Lenin died of a major stroke on 21/1/1924.
ESTONIA
See Lentz, Parming and Keesing’s on Estonian leaders. Parming has somewhat different
dates of entry and exit for Pats 25 January 1921 to Pats 21 October 1933. Most of these
are explained by what Parming calls the “Duration of Cabinet Crisis After Resignation”
where we count the `lame duck’ leader as still effective leader. See Parming, pp.14—15.
188
EST-1924-1 366 EST Akel 28/03/1924 10/12/1924
Parming has entry 26 March, exit 2 December.
189
“Vares Directed to take Päts’ Estonian Post.” See also Rulers.org. Lentz: studied
medicine and was a doctor and leading poet. “He was chosen to head a puppet
government under the control of the Soviet Union on June 21, 1940. He presided over
elections that resulted in the incorporation of Estonia into the Union of Soviet Socialist
Republics on August 6, 1940. He subsequently served as the president of the Presidium
of the Supreme Soviet of the Estonian SSR until his death in Tallin on November 29,
1946.”
Johannes Vares "Barbarus", resigns as acting President and Prime Minister of the
Republic of Estonia – The Chamber of Deputies adopts a new constitution establishing
the Estonian Soviet Socialist Republic and proclaims itself the Supreme Soviet of the
Estonian SSR and names Vares head of the Presidium. Apparently shot himself, through
the heart, which was reported as death due to natural causes, specifically, “heart failure,”
rather than follow Stalin’s orders to deport 40,000 Estonians. Chicago Daily Tribune,
Sept. 28, 1948, p1.
LATVIA
LAT-1918 367 LAT Ulmanis 17/11/1918 21/04/1919
Lentz: leading agricultural expert. Studied and taught agriculture at the University of
Nebraska. NYT, Nov. 19, 1928, p. 18.
190
LAT-1919-2 367 LAT Andrievs Niedra 26/04/1919 28/06/1919
Andrievs Niedra: Not much information can be found on him.
191
LAT-1933 367 LAT Blodnieks 25/03/1933 02/03/1934
Lentz: fled the Nazi occupation. Headed a non-Socialist minister of the Center and Right.
Hence, not so likely to have been arrested by Ulmanis’ coup. See next entry.
192
Berzins was born on 4 August, 1951. Studied at the Faculty for History and Philosophy.
(de. Encarta.msn.) Remained chairman of Latvia’s Way until May 17, 2003. Keesing’s
Vol. 49, 2003, May for the coding of his post tenure fate.
LITHUANIA
LIT-1917 368 LIT Smetona 18/09/1917 09/07/1918
Educated at the University of Moscow. See The Washington Post, April 13, 1919, p.16.
on this leader.
193
LIT-1998 368 LIT Adamkus 26/02/1998 25/02/2003
Emigrated during WWII to the US. Becomes president again after Paksas is impeached.
Next is Paksas, who is impeached in April, but acquitted by a court in Vilnius of
revealing state secrets to Russian-born businessman Yuri Borisov—one of the charges on
which he had been impeached. Keesing’s Vol. 50, 2004, October. But the public
prosecutor lodged an appeal on Nov. 12. See for his impeachment also, Keesing’s vol.
50, 2004, April.
UKRAINE
UKR-1990 369 UKR Kravchuk 18/07/1990 19/07/1994
Born on 10 January 1934. See, Keesing’s, Rulers.org: he remained a deputy of the
Supreme Council.
BELARUS
BLR-1991 370 BLR Shushkevich 18/09/1991 26/01/1994
Born 15 December, 1934. Physicist.
194
BLR-1994-3 370 BLR Lukashenko 20/07/1994 31/12/2004
Born on 30 August, 1954. See,
http://de.encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_721538990/Lukaschenko_Alexander_Grigorjew
itsch.html.
ARMENIA
ARM-1991 371 ARM Ter-Petrosyan 16/10/1991 03/02/1998
Born on 9 January, 1945. Studies history at the State University Eriwan in Armenia and
Orientalism in Leningrad. See de.encarta.msn. Nothing to be found on him after 1997.
Encylcopedia says he signs a peace treaty for Nagorno –Karabach that required major
compromises from Armenia. Personal communication from Ronald Suny (U Chicago)
May 4, 2005: “on Ter Petrosian, he is alive and well in Armenia. After the "constitutional
coup d'etat" of early 1998, he was given a nice house on a hill, treated with respect,
though somewhat isolated, and is still living and well in Erevan. Indeed, I just had a
chance to meet and talk with him briefly last week in Erevan. Every once and a while
there is speculation that he might re-enter politics, but he has quashed such rumors,
instead is learning English and working on his archive. On Mamedov, I have no
information.”
GEORGIA
GRG-1991 372 GRG Gamsakhurdia 12/04/1991 06/01/1992
Born, 31 March 1939. Lentz: “After a period of civil unrest, he was deposed by a military
council led by Tengiz Sigua on January 6, 1992. Followers of Gamsakhurdia attempted a
coup on June 24, 1992, but they were crushed by the Georgian security forces.
Gamsakhurdia led rebel forces in an office on Tbilisi in September 1993, but after several
weeks of fighting he was forced to retreat. He reportedly shot himself to death on
December 31, 1993, when he was surrounded in Western Georgia.” Rulers.org: “He
escaped with members of his government first to Armenia (Jan. 6-15, 1992) and then to
Chechnya, until he was able to move to Zugdidi, western Georgia, on Sept. 24, 1993.”
Coup by Sigua(PM). Fights in countryside. Suicide 31/12/1993?
195
Together with National Guard commander Tengiz Kitovani, Iosseliani had deposed
President Zviad Gamsakhurdia in January 1992 and taken over the running of the country
[see p. 38731]. Iosseliani and Kitovani invited former Soviet Foreign Minister
Shevardnadze to return to his native Georgia in March 1993 [see pp. 38826-27], setting in
motion a power struggle that ended with Iosseliani’s arrest in November 1995, shortly
after his election to the legislature. Iosseliani was sentenced in November 1998 to 11
years’ imprisonment on charges of involvement in an attempt on the life of President
Shevardnadze in August 1995 [see p. 40693]. He was released under an amnesty in early
2000.”
AZERBAIJAN
196
Keesing’s Vol. 39, August 1993 notes: “Popular Front chair ISa Gambarov, who on Aug.
9 had begun a hunger striked in protest at his arrest, was released from prison on Aug. 17.
Gambarov was told that he would nevertheless face charges.” Keesing’s Vol. 39, July
1993, notes that Gambarov had been areested on 16 July, who had resigned as Chair of
the Supreme Soviet on June 13. hence more than one year after he lost office.
197
FINLAND
198
FIN-1956 375 FIN Kekkonen 01/03/1956 11/09/1981
After the First World War he moved to Helsinki, where studied law at Helsinki
University, and worked at the Ministry of Agriculture before entering parliament. In 1936
he completed his doctoral dissertation. http://urho-kekkonen.biography.ms/: “In
September [1981], Kekkonen left for sick leave, and in October he resigned.” There is no
public report about his illness. He dies in 1986. Lentz: “He suffered from poor health and
resigned from office on September 11, 1981. He retired to his home in Tamminiemi,
where he died from a circulatory disorder in his brain at the age of 85 on August 31,
1986.”
SWEDEN
Additional source:
Irene Scobbie, Historical dictionary of Sweden, European Historical Dictionaries, Noo. 7.
Metuchen, N. J. : The Scarecrow Press, Inc., 1995.
Also: http://members01.chello.se/dier/index.htm
199
SWD-1889 380 SWD Akerhjelm 12/10/1889 15/07/1891
http://members01.chello.se/dier/sm08.htm
Died 2 April 1900
200
SWD-1920-2 380 SWD de Geer 27/10/1920 23/02/1921
Son of de Geer af Finspan
201
SWD-1969 380 SWD Palme 14/10/1969 20/09/1976
NORWAY
202
NOR-1923-1 385 NOR Halvorsen 05/03/1923 23/05/1923
203
NOR-1945-1 385 NOR Nygaardsvold 07/05/1945 25/06/1945
Lentz. “Following the war, Nygaardsvold’s government was held partially responsible for
Norway’s inadequate defense preparations during the war.”
204
NOR-1998-1 385 NOR Lahnstein 30/08/1998 23/09/1998
Female
DENMARK
205
DEN-1913 390 DEN Zahle 21/06/1913 30/03/1920
206
Lentz. “Buhl was selected as prime minister on May 3, 1942, during the German
occupation of Denmark. He stepped down from office on November 9, 1942.” Hence,
perhaps this is his second time in office.
207
DEN-2001 390 DEN Fogh Rasmussen 27/11/2001 31/12/2004
ICELAND
208
Lentz: “Thoroddsen called for new elections in April of 1983 and retired from office on
May 26, 1983. He died in Reykjavik at the age of 72 on September 25, 1983.” Dies less
than six months after resigns.
GUINEA-BISSAU
209
See Keesing’s Vol. 45, May 1999, “During the fighting Vieira sought refuge at the
Portuguese embassy and on May 10 he signed an unconditional surrender. Portugal
agreed to grant him indefinite asylum but rebel troops did not allow him to leave Bissau.”
He was ousted after dismissing head of military, refuge in Portuguese Embassy.
210
the telephone said. This is according to Malam, the former head of the transitional state
and African Party for the Independence of Guinea-Bissau and Cape Verde PAIGC
presidential candidate in the 28th November 1999 elections. Sanha's concern is amplified
by the fact that several members of his personal guard have been thrown out of their
homes by the authorities.” Note, this is after attempted coup by Mane. Subsequently,
Minister of Civil Service, Artur Snha said the former president had nothing to fear and
that his security was guaranteed.
EQUATORIAL GUINEA
211
1968 and detained by the Macias Nguema government. Ondu Edu was charged with
conspiracy and was murder with member of his family in January of 1969. “
Keesing’s Vol. 14, November 1968, records he ran in the Sept. 22 Presidential election,
notes had was Prime Minister at the time.
LA Times Oct. 3, 1968, p. 2 records that EQ will become independent Oct. 23.
GAMBIA
GAM-1965 420 GAM Jawara 18/02/1965 22/07/1994
Lentz: from the University of Glasgow, qualified as a veterinary surgeon. Rulers.org, “he
was granted asylum by Senegal and later lived in exile in London. An unconditional
amnesty for him was announced in December 2001 and returned on June 1, 2002.
Bloodless coup, asylum in Senegal.
MALI
212
Ousted in a Coup and under arrest. Keesing’s Vol. 43, December 1997 notes: “The death
sentences passed in 1993 against former President Moussa Traoré and a number of his
former colleagues [see 39307], including Sekou Ly, Mamadou Coulibaly and Ousmane
Coulibaly, were commuted to life imprisonment on Dec. 9. No judicial executions had
been carried out in Mali since 1980. Traoré had been deposed as President in March 1991
[see pp. 38083-84]. The announcement of the amnesty by President Alpha Oumar Konaré
followed the decision of Nov. 18 to close the Kidal prison, an institution in the heart of
the Sahara desert which had often been used to house political prisoners. “
SENEGAL
BENIN
213
Sourou Migan Apithy. Lentz: received a degree in accounting from the Paris National
School of Economic and Social Organization. He was under house arrest, later exile in
France. See NYT, Dec. 23, 1965, p.13. Ally of Ahomadegb.
214
chief, Maurice Kouandete, last July 11.” Note: about three weeks before one year after
losing office. Because he transferred power to the civilian Zinsou, we code his exit as
regular.
215
BEN-1996 434 BEN Kerekou 04/04/1996 31/12/2004
MAURITANIA
216
Chief of the general staff, colonel. See CNN, Wednesday, 3 August 2005. Soldiers in
Mauritania stage a coup when Taya is out of the country for King Fahd’s funeral. CNN
reports he “is reportedly in Niger’s capital, Niamey, on his way back from Riyadh.”
NIGER
COTE D’LVOIRE
217
CDI-1993 437 CDI Konan Bedie 07/12/1993 25/12/1999
Henri-Konan Bédié was born in 15 May 1934. (In 1998 Bédié changes his term in office
from five to seven years.) After coup flees by airplane to Togo and thence to France.
Remained in France until October 2001, when invited back to Côte d’Ivoire.
GUINEA
BURKINA FASO
218
Maurice Yaméogo, 11 Dec 1959 - 4 Jan 1966. He was deposed by a military coup, after a
labor unions crises. The Washington Post, Jan. 6, 1966, p.A17.“Lt. Col. Sangoule
Lamizana, who deposed Yameogo, announced in a radio broadcast that Yameogo was in
a safe place being guarded by the military.” But also reports that President Yaméogo
“welcomed the coup.” See Keesing’s Vol. 12 (1966) January. He also survives suicide
attempt.
LIBERIA
From: http://www.liberiapastandpresent.org
“The term of office: In 1847 the President's term of office was two years. During the
Administration of President Arthur Barclay the term of office was changed to four years,
in 1907/08. His cousin President Edwin Barclay had it changed to eight years, in
1935/36. It was restored to four years under President Tubman - who was elected a record
number of six times. During the Tolbert Administration, in 1975/76, it was again changed
219
to eight years. At present the presidential term of office is six years whereas the president
can only succeed to himself once.”
220
Richard Wright Johnson who had won the elections held in May 1883. Afred Francis
Russell died on April 4, 1884. The following year the disputed territory was officially
ceded to Great Britain (`the Galinas territory’).” He dies 3 months after out of office, his
fate is censored.
221
Plenipotentiary to the USA, in Washington DC. Later, he also became Liberia’s first
Permanent Representative to the United Nations. In 1952 he retired permanently from
public service. He was active in the Protestant Episcopal Church and as a Mason until
1961 when he died at the age of 90 years.” Government resigned as allegations against
gov. participation in slave trade came to the fore. He was born in 12 March 1871.
222
Feb. 28 elected David Kpormakoras Chair. Kpormakor a representative of the interim
government headed by Amos Sawyer, replaced another Sawyer nominee, Philip Banks
(appointed in November). The Council also elected Thomas Ziah of the United
Liberation Movement Liberia for Democracy (Ulimo), and Issac Mousa of the National
Patriotic Front of Liberia (NPFL), as first and second deputy chair respectively; the
remaining places were filled by Banks and Ulimo member Mohamed Sheriff.”
We rely on Keesing’s documentation, and go with the government and Amos Sawyer.
Teaches at Indiana University in 2002. Imprisoned under Doe.
See http://alumni.indiana.edu/magazine/200401/presprof.html, where Sawyer
notes: “I was trying to run the Centre for Democratic Empowerment until November
2000 …. It was then that Taylor had my office raided. I was beaten. The director was
stabbed. They tried to rape the women. This was the clearest of signals to leave.”
He was installed by ECOWA as president of interim government.
223
Tolbert to Samuel K. Doe, as a speech writer, with the title of Assistant Minister.
Following his replacement, Sankawolu went back to the University of Liberia to teach
and was there until the last round of battle in Monrovia in 2003”.
224
Liberian government. Liberia’s new president, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, raised the issue this
month with President Olusegun Obasanjo of Nigerai, describing it as an important part of
bringing stability to Liberia.”
Washington Post, March 29, 2006
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2006/03/29/AR2006032900879.html
“Monrovia, Liberia, March 29 – Fugitive former Liberian president Charles Tayolro was
handed over to U.N. custody here Wednesday afternoon, immediately after being
repatriated from Nigeria, and palced on a U.N. helicopter en route to Sierra Leone where
he faces war crimes charges before a U.N.-backed tribunal. The dramatic developments
followed his arrest in a Nigerian town on the border Cameroon [HG, sic] early this
morning, a day after he disappeared from a guarded compound in souther Nigeria.”
SIERRA LEONE
225
SIE-1967-1 451 SIE Lansana 21/03/1967 23/03/1967
He was arrested and detained. Later he was given diplomatic position in New York
226
SIE-1998 451 SIE Kabbah 10/03/1998 31/12/2004
Ahmad Tejan Kabbah, was the first democratically elected president. But a violent
military coup ousted President Kabbah's civilian government in May 1997. On March 10,
1998, after ten months in exile (flees to Guinea), Kabbah resumed his rule over Sierra
Leone. He returned to office after Nigerian forces defeat military.
GHANA
227
GHA-1979-1 452 GHA Rawlings 05/06/1979 24/09/1979
Lentz. Was retired from the air force in November 1979. He entered politics on a full
time basis and was briefly arrested in November of 1980 on charges of plotting against
the government. Transfers power to Limann.
TOGO
CAMEROON
228
death in absentia, though the sentence was later commuted.” So he resigns presidency for
health reasons. Tries to regain power the following year. Later on goes to exile.
NIGERIA
229
NIG-1983 475 NIG Buhari 31/12/1983 27/08/1985
Coup, arrested, detained.
230
dogged by problems since its installation in August, and in the days preceding the coup
the beleaguered Shonekan had come under increasing pressure. …. Late on Nov. 17,
following a four-hour meeting with Abacha and other senior military figures, Shonekan
announced his resignation as head of state and commander-in-chief of the armed forces.
Abacha immediately took over both positions.”
GABON
231
CEN-1960 482 CEN Dacko 13/08/1960 01/01/1966
Coup, house arrest until 1976.
CHAD
232
Félix Malloum, left the country, exile. Coup of Northerners against Southerners. See
NYT, Jun. 19, 1979, p. A2. Flees on March 24.
DELETED: Figurehead
CHA-1979-2 483 CHA Shawa 29/04/1979 22/08/1979
Lol Mahamat Shawa. For his entry, see LA Times, May 1, 1979, p. OC2 “News in
Brief.” May have been a figurehead. CSM, May 8, 1979, p. 4 “Chad opts for power
sharing” notes: “Mr. Shawa … is not the most powerful man in Chad. That role belongs
to Goukouni Weddeyeh, Interior Minister in the new government, and top man in the
once Libyan-backed front for the National Liberation of Chad (FROLINAT).”
Negotiations among rebel factions, goes to Paris in exile. See Lentz.
CONGO
CON-1960 484 CON Youlou 15/08/1960 15/08/1963
Ousted in revolt, imprisoned.
233
CON-1979 484 CON Nguesso 08/02/1979 20/08/1992
He was a general. See
http://www.ikuska.com/Africa/Historia/biografias/biografias_r.htm#sasso:
“En 1993, apoyado por su milicia "Cobra", se levantó militarmente contra el Presidente
iniciando una guerra civil que acabaría con la vida de más de 2.000 personas antes de que
se firmara la paz en 1994. Abandonó el país y se refugió en Francia, de donde volvió en
enero de 1997 para presentarse a las elecciones presidenciales que iban a celebrarse en
julio de ese mismo año. Pero el 5 de junio, las tropas del Presidente Lissouba rodearon la
casa de Sassou abortando la posibilidad de unas elecciones democráticas. Las fuerzas de
Sassou ganaron en octubre y fue nombrado de nuevo Presidente del Congo, a la vez que
Lissouba se exiliaba en Londres. El 10 de marzo de 2002 es reelegido con el 89% de los
votos contra el 2.7% de su contrincate, Joseph Kignoumbi Kia Mboungou.”
UGANDA
234
Godfrey Binaisa. He was overthrown in a military coup on May 10, 1980. Returned to
Uganda in 2002 from self-imposed exile in New York where he was a practicing lawyer.
KENYA
TANZANIA/TANGANYIKA
ZANZIBAR
235
BURUNDI
236
Sylvestre Ntibantunganya was overthrown in a military coup in July 1996. Since,
Sylvestre Ntibantunganya attentively follows political revolution of Burundi without
however playing a very active institutional role. Tutsi-led military coup.
RWANDA
237
political party.” More than a year after his loss of office. He resigned in protest over
Parliament's use of an anticorruption campaign to attack Hutu cabinet members.
SOMALIA
238
DJIBOUTI
DJI-1977 522 DJI Gouled Aptidon 27/06/1977 08/05/1999
For his retirement, see Keesing’s Vol. 46, March 2000.
ETHIOPIA
ETH-1871 530 ETH Yohannes IV 11/07/1871 09/03/1889
Emperor after civil war; assassinated.
239
On his entry, see LA Times, Nov. 29, 1974, p. A1. “Deposed Emperor Haile Selassie has
agreed to turn over part of his fortune to the military rulers who overthrew him in
exchange for his life, diplomatic sources said Thursday. In another development, the
military men who now run Ethiopia appointed a new permanent chairman. Named to
head the Provisional Military Administrative Council was Brig. Gen. Tafari Banti, 52,
who reportedly took the job after six other military men had declined the honor. … (cont.
p.6) … Some diplomatic observers think Tafari may have been chosen as little more than
the spokesman for the seven-man leadership of the military council. Lt. Gen. Aman M.
Andom refused to agree with hard-line policies of the junta. He resigned, refused to
reconsider, was ordered arrested and died last Saturday night in the siege of his home.
Aman was a fighting man whose soldiers called him “the lion of the desert.” Tafari is a
mild-mannered man known as an administrator. He is not expected to disagree with the
military council’s decision to escalate the long-run war with guerilla forces in Eritrea, the
seccessionist northern province, which Aman insisted could not be won by military force.
… the 2nd Division … has fought unsuccessfully to quell the Eritrean Liberation Front.
Gen. Tafari was commander of the 2nd Division for six weeks before getting his new job.
He takes over from Maj. Mengistu Haile Mariam, who became acting chairman last
Friday when the council ordered Aman’s arrest. Mengistu has by far the more forceful
personality of the two, and many feel he will remain the power behind the chairman. …
Like Mengistu, Tafari came up from the ranks. … Tafari, then 19, took part in the
liberation of Ethiopia from Italian rule in 1941. He served in various infantry divisions,
and in 1965, as a lieutenant colonel, succeeded Aman as military attaché in Washington.
He returned here in 1970 to serve in intelligence and supply posts. He was trained at U.S.
Army schools in the United States on five differet occasions. He became a general in
1972.”
Killed in a battle with Mengistu's supporters. He may be a figurehead for Marriam, see
NYT, 5 February, 1977, p. 7, which records (Dateline, Feb. 4) “no public reaction to the
killing yesterday of the chief of state, Brig. Gen. Tafari Banti, and six other members of
the governing military council. … The official radio said yesterday that General Tafari
and the others had been put to death for attempting to stage a coup against the revolution.
But there were reports that they had actually been slain during the fighting among
members of the council. The opposing factions were both said to be Marxist-Leninist, but
General Tafari, the largely figurehead council chairman, and his supporters were
generally viewed as more moderate than Colonel Mengistu, the first vice chairman of the
council, and his followers. … The fighting yesterday apparently stemmed from a
reorganization plan undertaken in December by two captains with the apparent aim of
containing Colonel Mengistu’s previously unlimited powers. For a time thereafter the
colonel appeared to have lost some grounds.”
240
ERITREA
ANGOLA
MOZAMBIQUE
ZAMBIA
241
politically motivated witch-hunt. The National Assembly (the unicameral legislature) had
in July 2002 voted to lift Chiluba’s immunity from prosecution [see p. 44886]. The
Supreme Court on Feb. 19 had unanimously decided not to restore Chiluba’s immunity,
thereby opening the way for formal charges to be leveled against him.” He abandons
reelection attempt; arrested 5 Aug 2003.
ZIMBABWE
MALAWI
SOUTH AFRICA
SAF-1910 560 SAF Louis Botha 31/05/1910 27/08/1919
Lentz: died of influenza. Previously head of other state.
242
SAF-1939 560 SAF Smuts 06/09/1939 03/06/1948
See Lentz.
243
SAF-1989-3 560 SAF deKlerk 15/08/1989 10/05/1994
See Lentz.
TRANSVAAL
244
TRA-1900 563 TRA Schalk Willem Burger10/09/1900 31/05/1902
He is referred to as a General. His wife is captured by the British July 1901.
NAMIBIA
245
NAM-1990 565 NAM Nujoma 21/03/1990 31/12/2004
LESOTHO
BOTSWANA
SWAZILAND
246
Lentz reports: “Sobhuza continued to seek Swaziland’s independence, which was finally
granted on September 6, 1968. He initially ruled under a British-designed constitution,
which provided for a constitutional monarchy. Sobhuza promoted a new constitution in
April of 1973 which allowed him to rule as an absolute monarch.” Another potential
example of an ‘auto-golpe’.
MADAGASCAR
247
MAG-1975-3 580 MAG Ratsiraka 15/06/1975 27/03/1993
See above.
COMOROS
248
On Djohar also see; Sidney Morning Herald. September 30, 1995: Sultan
Chouzour, a former Comoros ambassador to France, said scores had been wounded in the
fighting, and that the mercenaries had today moved Mr. Djohar to a military camp under
their control. He said Mr. Djohar had refused to sign a declaration handing over
constitutional authority to the invaders. He was arrested. Afterwards Djohar is released
and flies to Reunion for a medical check-up. Evidence emerged that Paris and the Chirac
government actually was behind the Denard coup to remove Djohar. Sunday Herald
October 15, 1995.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/5097618.stm Tuesday, 20 June 2006 “French ‘dog of
war’ spared jail.” Reports: Denard is later tried in France, and convicted and sentenced
to a five year suspended jail sentence for his part in the abortive 1995 coup.
249
May 1: The Herald, Glasgow: The army seized control of the three-island
Comoros Republic in a bloodless coup yesterday and placed government leaders under
house arrest.
The Independent, May 1, 1999: THE ARMY of the Comoro Islands overthrew the
civilian government of President Tadjiddine Ben Said Massonde yesterday in a bloodless
coup. Last weekend President Tadjiddine's government had granted greater autonomy to
the two smaller islands of Anjouan and Moheli. The government's move triggered three
days of violent protests on the main island, Grande Comoro, led by opposition politicians.
MAURITIUS
250
Closing Port to Superpowers
Sir Seewoosagur's Government had claimed Diego Garcia, a British owned island that
was once administered under the same authority as Mauritius, but indicated that it would
be satisfied to see the Americans stay for the 43 years remaining on a 50-year lease if
they paid rent. The outgoing Prime Minister said the opposition planned to lead Mauritius
into the Soviet camp. But the Mauritian Militant Movement is pledged to close the harbor
of Port Louis to Soviet as well as to United States naval vessels. Both big power have
used it until now. The winning alliance drew support from all elements of a polyglot
population of one million, nearly 70 percent of whom trace their origins to the Indian
subcontinent. Sir Seewoosagur had hired a political consultant from Massachusetts,
Joseph Napolitan, to prepare a series of American style television commercials. The
Prime Minister's supporters wore T-shirts that proclaimed: ''Forward with Ram to the
Year 2000.'' Raising the prospect of the world's first centenarian Prime Minister, they
painted the slogan ''chacha power'' on fences and gateposts in his constituency of Triolet.
Chacha is a Hindustani term of affection for an uncle.
Prime Minister Runs Fourth
But the power was apparently spent. The Prime Minister, who got 58 percent of the vote
in his constituency in the last election, in 1976, came in fourth today, with 33 percent.
he stunning victory followed a four-month display of democracy in action that left
virtually every thoroughfare canopied with campaign banners and covered - not just the
walls but the roadways themselves - with painted slogans and party symbols.
The vote appears to have been on generational rather than communal lines, with the 36
percent of the electorate that is under the age of 30 responding to the alliance's promises
of jobs. Paul Berenger, 37 years old, who has been the driving force of the Mauritian
Militant Movement since it was founded in 1969, winced when he was asked whether the
electorate had not in effect created a one party state. ''Please, don't say that,'' he replied.
''Don't use words like that. You're going to get me frightened.'' In fact, he said, to assure
the 28 parties that were shut out of Parliament, his party intended to amend the
Constitution to entrench the provision guaranteeing a free election every five years. A
three quarters majority is required for most significant amendments. The Mauritian
Militant Movement has also pledged to take the island out of the British Commonwealth,
where it recognizes Queen Elizabeth II as the chief of state, and make it a republic.
Conciliation Gesture Possible
Aneerood Jugnauth, a Hindu lawyer who is the nominal leader of the Mauritian Militant
Movement and the next Prime Minister, raised the possibility during the campaign that
the outgoing Prime Minister, Sir Seewoosagur, might be made the first President as a
gesture of reconciliation. The party also plans to amend the Constitution to revise the
commitment to provide full and immediate compensation in the event of nationalization.
But Mr. Berenger said its mandate would not lead it to push its Socialist program beyond
the cautious goals outlined in the party manifesto. ''This is not going to make us go any
faster than we meant to go,'' he said. Mr. Berenger, who took part in the Paris student
rising in 1968, said he hoped relations with the United States would be ''very cordial,''
and he momentarily made light of his campaign charges that the Central Intelligence
Agency had interfered on behalf of Sir Seewoosagur. “We'll call them in every time we
have an election,'' he said.
251
MAS-1982 590 MAS Anerood Jugnauth 16/06/1982 22/12/1995
For his CONSTITUTIONAL entry, see Keesing’s Vol. 28, 1982, October.
MOROCCO
ALGERIA
ALG-1962-1 615 ALG Ben Khedda0 3/07/1962 25/09/1962
Lentz: “He was arrested in July of 1964 and spent much of the next several decades in
prison or under surveillance.” Keesing’s Vol. 9, July 1963, shows he was OK then. He
was arrested in July 1964.
252
ALG-1979 615 ALG Benjedid 07/02/1979 11/01/1992
He resigns under pressure, military assumes power and cancels elections. Benjedid was
OK after coup.
TUNESIA
LIBYA
THE SUDAN
253
led by Gaafar al-Nimeiry on May 25, 1969. He was detained by the new government
until his death in Khartoum from a heart attack at the age of 69 on August 26, 1969.”
NYT, Jan 29, 1962, p.3 “The Government released today ten political prisoners,
including two Premiers, who were arrested in July on charges of having criticized the
military regime. The two former Premiers are Ismail el Azhari and Abduallah Khalil.” He
was arrested in July 1961.
254
SUD-1967 625 SUD Maghoub 18/05/1967 23/05/1969
See Lentz. But Lentz also notes “Maghoub became ill in December of 1968 and spent the
next three months in treatment out of the country. In Keesing’s under the name of
Mahgoub. Keesing’s Vol. 15, June 1969, notes: “In his statement of May 26 Mr.
Awadalla disclosed that all but four of the Ministers in the previous Government had
been traced and placed under "protective arrest." Ex-President al Azhari and Mr.
Maghoub, at first kept only under house arrest, were transferred to prison on May 29. “
255
See Keesing’s Vol. 17, August 1971, « Restoration of General al Nemery’s Regime. »
“According to the version given in the Cairo newspaper Al Ahram later of events in the
Sudan during the period from July 19 to 22, Major el Atta's coup had allegedly been
organized by Mr. Abdel Khaliq Mahgoub--the secretary-general of the Communist Party
of the Sudan--from the Bulgarian Embassy in Khartoum, where he was said to have
found asylum after his escape from prison at the end of June. According to Al Ahram, he
had sought contact with "opportunist" officers, who had taken advantage of the absence
of the Minister of Defence, then leading a military delegation to Yugoslavia, and of the
Air Force commander, then in Moscow; the rebels had been joined only by part of the
Khartoum garrison--the Third Armoured Regiment and the Presidential Guard--who had
disarmed the paratroops in Khartoum, whereas most garrisons in the provinces had
opposed the coup; popular resistance to the coup had increased during the next few days,
and a demonstration called for July 22 by the Communist Party had led to big counter-
demonstrations calling for the return of General al Nemery; and the latter had thereupon
been reinstated with the help of soldiers of the same units which had first supported
Major el Attn. Major el Atta, this version said, had called for "popular resistance" to
"foreign interference" but had been arrested shortly afterwards. …. While some fighting
was still being reported to be going on in Khartoum, a special military court sentenced
four of the coup leaders to death, and they were executed by firing squad on July 23. In
addition to Major el Atta, they were Colonel Abdel Moneim Mohammed Ahmed,
Lieutenant-Colonel Osman Hussein of the Presidential Guard and Captain Moaweyah
Abdul Hai. General al Nemery announced the same day that of the soldiers loyal to his
regime, imprisoned by the rebels on July 19 and attacked by them when the counter-coup
began, 16 officers and 14 n.c.o.s had been killed. Later he stated that a total of 38 persons
had been killed and 119 wounded during the counter-coup.”
For trail and execution, see also Keesing’s Vol. 17, August 1971. “Arrest, Trial and
Execution of Plotters and Leading Communists.” Keesing’s Vol. 17, August 1971
“Statements by General al Nemery” also notes: “The following day General al Nemery
disclosed that immediately after his return to power he had approached President Kadhafi
of Libya with a request to be "presented" with Colonel Babiker al Nur and Major Osman
Hamadalla. He expressed his gratitude to the U.A.R. and Libya for having provided
practical aid in crushing the coup, and in particular thanked President Kadhafi for having
arrested the two coup leaders.”
256
In Keesing’s found under General Saw el Dahab. Lentz has Siwar ad-Dahab. Lentz;
Promoted to Field Marshall in 1987.
IRAN
257
IRN-1953 630 IRN Mohammad Reza 19/08/1953 16/01/1979
As above, son of Reza Khan. He was deposed by revolution, exile.
TURKEY
258
TUR-1950 640 TUR Menderes 22/05/1950 27/05/1960
Prime Minster; deposed in coup and executed.
259
TUR-1983 640 TUR Ozal 13/12/1983 09/11/1989
Yilmaz06/03/1996-28/06/1996.He became president by election.
260
He became PM as Erdogan banned from serving.
IRAQ
261
IRQ-2003-1 645 IRQ Tommy Ray Franks 09/04/2003 21/04/2003
EGYPT
262
EGY-1970 651 EGY Sadat 28/09/1970 06/10/1981
He was assassinated.
SYRIA
263
Lentz: he left the government in March of 1962. Keesing’s Vol. 8, September 1962 notes
Kuzbari resigned as president of the Assembly in September, 1962. Keesing’s Vol. 9,
April 1963 says he is arrested after the Coup, together with Kudsi and several others.
264
SYR-1970 652 SYR Al-Khatib 18/11/1970 22/02/1971
Lentz: subsequently chosen as president of the Federation of Arab Republics and served
until 1975.
LEBANON
265
Lentz: “Sarkis suffered from ill health as his term of office came to an end. … Sarkis
retired to Paris, where he died at the age of 60 after a long illness on June 27, 1985.”
Does not qualify as exile, because it seems due to his health.
JORDAN
266
Youngest son of King Abdullah. See NYT, August 11, 1952, p. 5, which reports
“Available members [to succeed Talal, HG] are Talal’s exiled brother, Prince Naif, now
in Beirut. …. On June 4 ….. The Premier charged a few days later that Talal’s younger
brother, Prince Naif, was plotting to seize the throne. The Premier accused Naif of
conducting intrigues from Beirut. He added that Prince Naif had attempted to take control
while the Prince was regent during the period between the death of Abdullah and the
return of Talal from Switzerland.”
He was regent for his brother.
ISRAEL
267
ISR-1983 666 ISR Shamir 10/10/1983 14/09/1984
One of the principal leaders of Lohamei Herut Yisrael (Lehi). Shamir joined Israel's
security services in the mid1950's.
SAUDI ARABIA
268
Fahd's half-brother, Crown Prince Abdullah ibn Abdul Aziz, to "undertake the affairs of
state" while the King enjoyed "rest and recuperation". No details had been given about
the nature of Fahd's illness, although it was widely reported that he had suffered a stroke
[see p. 40928]. Encyclopedia Britannica notes: “Fahd suffered a stroke in 1995 and on
January 1, 1996, handed over control of the government to his half brother Crown Prince
Abdullah. Less than two months later, Fahd returned to power, though Abdullah
continued to handle the day-to-day affairs of the country.” King Fahd dies August 1,
2005.
269
YPR-1967 680 YPR Al-Shaabi 30/11/1967 22/06/1969
Power seized before independence; bloodless coup. Arrested
KUWAIT
270
KUW-1990 690 KUW Saddam Hussein 02/08/1990 20/04/1991
He withdrew under attack from UN coalition.
271
with its 65 members agreed to remove (Sheikh Saad) from the post of emir," said Jassem
al-Kharafi, the Speaker of the parliament. He added that there were no conditions
attached to the emir’s abdication letter, which arrived shortly after the vote had taken
place.”
BAHRAIN
QUATAR
OMAN
For Oman, pre-1937, see: Thomans, Bertram. 1938. "Arab rule under the Al Bu Said
dynasty of Oman, 1741--1937." In Proceedings of the British Academy, Vol. 24, 1938.
London: Humphrey Milford, Oxford University Press, Amen House. E.C. 27--53.
He notes, p. 34: “the instability of rule engendered by the principle of no fixed
succession.” Badr Saif was killed by his son, Said, who dies naturally, and is succeeded
by Thuwaini who was assassinated by his own son, who is driven into exile by a cousin.
He (Azzan) was killed in the fight against Turki, a son of the late son. P.37.
272
have succeeded by the principle of primogeniture, a feature almost without precedent in
the history of their house, and one facilitated by an equally unprecedented though wise
step on the part of British authorities in according them recognition as heirs apparent
during the lifetime of their predecessors.” P.38.
AFGHANISTAN
273
AFG-1901 700 AFG Habibullah Khan 03/10/1901 20/02/1919
See Lentz. Son of previous. He was assassinated.
274
AFG-1973 700 AFG Daoud 17/07/1973 27/04/1978
Coup by Communist party and military. He was killed.
275
won, saying he had heart troube.” Studied law and political science at Kabul University,
earned a law degree. Arrested at age 20, and imprisoned for five years.
DELETED: Figurehead
AFG-1986 700 AFG Chamkani 24/11/1986 30/09/1987
Keesing’s, Vol. 34, March 1988. Election of Najibullah as President (Nov. 30, 1987).
Adoption of new Constitution. (Nov. 30, 1987). Chamkani has held the posts of President
of the Revolutionary Council and Chairman of its Presidium in an acting capacity.
Chamkani elected First Deputy Chairman of the Presidium on Sept. 30.
TURKMENISTAN
276
TKM-1990 701 TKM Niyazov 27/10/1990 31/12/2004
TAJIKISTAN
277
KYRGZ REPUBLIC
UZBEKISTAN
UZB-1990 704 UZB Karimov 24/03/1990 31/12/2004
KAZAKHSTAN
CHINA
278
CHN-1917 710 CHN Feng Kuo-chang 14/08/1917 04/09/1918
A general. See Lentz. Dies of pneumonia in Peking, December 28, 1919.
279
CHN-1997 710 CHN Jiang Zemin 19/02/1997 15/03/2003
TIBET
280
He ruled between 16 January 1941 – 17 November 1950. Regent Taktra Tulku
Constitutional entry and exit.
MONGOLIA
281
Chief after Sükhebaatur’s death. … “Hoping to revive Mongolia’s economy and finances,
Danzin encouraged Chinese firms to return to Mongolia. This friendliness to Chinese
firms alienated his former ally Elbeck-Dorzhi Rinchino, and Danzin’s political supporters
began to criticize openly the Buriat advisers as clever pied pipers of the naïve young
Mongols. Criticism of Danzin’s administration increased at the People’s Party’s Third
Congress in August 1924, when Danzin suddenly withdrew in a huff to the city garrison.
He may have been planning a coup d’état against Rincino, but he did not have the
soldiers’ support and was himself arrested and executed without a trial on August 30.”
(P.129-130)
Lentz notes : Danzan Khorloo, purged and executed in August 1924. LA Times,
Sept. 17, 1924, p. 1 notes Danzan had been shot by order of the Mongol soviet. See also
The Washington Post, Sept. 18, 1924, p. 5, which notes he was arrested August 26, and
after a trial on a charge of plotting against the Urga government, was shot along with
several minor officials of his regime.
282
faction to overthrow the party chief Dambadorji, and Gendün was appointed one of three
new party secretaries. … After tension-filled meetings with Stalin in December 1935 to
January 1936, Gendün finally agreed to invite Soviet troops to Mongolia. Roundly
criticized for impeding Soviet-Mongolian friendship at the next party plenum, Gendün
was relieved of all his duties on March 20, 1936, and exiled with his family to Crimea.
On July 17, 1937, as part of Stalin’s Great Purge, arrested and shot as a Japanese spy on
26 November 1937.
Lentz notes: he was expelled from the presidium of the central committee and
removed from office that same month (March 1936). Gendung was charged with
conspiring with General Demid in counterrevolutionary and pro-Japanese activities. He
was purged and executed in 1937.
283
University. Chosen as premier in 1974. Both Tsedenbal and Batmonkh are of the Dorbod
tribe.
TAIWAN
284
Former ruler of another country, China.
KOREA
NORTH KOREA
PRK-1948 731 PRK Kim Il-Sung 09/09/1948 08/07/1994
SOUTH KOREA
285
tried to change it to 4 terms.) When Rhee resigns, the system becomes semi-presidential
for about a year. See: http://english.seoul.go.kr/today/about/about_03disc_0306.html
After the Korean war, the long-term ruling scheme of Rhee Seungman's regime brought a
dictatorship in Korea and caused social corruption and injustice. Rhee's administration
practiced the illegal election to maintain their regime. As a result, the 4.19 Revolution
broke out by college students and citizens in 1960, and the Rhee's government collapsed.
Soon, Jang Myeon's cabinet of the democratic party was formed, but one year later in
1961, some military officers led by Park Jeonghi raised 5.16 militant coup d'etat, and
acquired power under the cloak of reforming social disorder and confusion.
286
ROK-1980-2 732 ROK Chun Doo Hwan 27/08/1980 25/02/1988
General. Only one term of 5 years is allowed in the Constitution since 1987. Lentz:
Attended the Korean Military Academy. Narrowly survived a bomb blast in Rangoon,
Burma, on October 9, 1983, while on a state visit. “He made a public apology on
November 23, 1988, for human rights abuses that occurred during his term of office. He
then went into internal exile at a Buddhist temple in the Sorak mountains. Prosecuted in
1995 and served jail time.
Keesing’s Vol. 43, 1997, December: “Two former Presidents Chun Doo Hwan
and Roh Tae Woo, were released from prison on Dec. 22, after a pardon was granted by
the outgoing President Kim Young Sam. President-elect Kim Dae Jung endorsed the
move which was described as an attempt to promote national unity at a time of economic
crisis. Roh and Chun had been found guilty of charges connected with the 1979 military
coup, the 1980 suppression of the Kwangju uprising and the amassment of illegal slush
funds. In August 1996 Chun had been sentenced to death and Roh to a long term of
imprisonment [see pp. 41226-27]. In December 1996 an appeals courts had commuted
Chun's death sentence to life imprisonment and cut Roh's prison term [see p. 41408]. The
Supreme Court had upheld the reductions in April 1997 [see p. 41592], and in September
Lee Hoi Chang had called publicly for an amnesty to be granted to Roh and Chun.”
Chun Doo Hwan stepped down when his term ended. He was prosecuted in
1995 and served jail time. He was sent to internal exile.
287
ROK-2003 732 ROK Roh Moo Hyun 25/02/2003 31/12/2004
JAPAN
For “Recent Rulers of Japan, see: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0855080.html
288
JPN-1900 740 JPN Ito 19/10/1900 10/05/1901
Lentz and Rulers.org have him exiting on 2 June. But NYT, May 14, 1901, p. 6 “Marquis
Saionju Japan’s New Premier” reports “Washington, May 13, -- The resignation of
Marquis Ito, Premier of Japan has been announced to the Japanese Legation here.
Marquis Ito was the only one of the Cabinet officers to retire. His is succeeded by
Marquis Saionji, on of the counselors of the Emperor, and an ex-Minister of Foreign
Affairs.” LA Times, May 31, 1901, p.4, dateline May 11 reports also “Accompanying the
Cabinet muddle comes the somewhat alarming report of Marquis Ito’s illness, he having
been seized on the 7th inst. with an attack of vertigo resulting in a fainting fit, and
indicating, with other symptoms, the presence of serious brain trouble.”
Lentz: Becomes the first Japanese resident-general of Korea in 1906. He forced
the abdication of the Korean emperor and established the country as a Japanese
protectorate. He resigned in 1909 to again head the privy council. Ito was touring
Manchuria when he was assassinated at a railway station in Harbin by An Chung Gun, a
Korean Nationalist, on October 26, 1909.
289
JPN-1918 740 JPN Uchida 04/11/1921 13/11/1921
Lentz notes that he had a law degree. He was born in 1865.
290
JPN-1931-1 740 JPN Wakatsuki 13/04/1931 11/12/1931
291
Lentz: Arrested by the Allied occupation forces after the war and tried as a Class A war
criminal by the International Military Tribunal in Tokyo. He was sentenced to life
imprisonment at Sugamo Prison on November 12, 1948 … released from prison for
hospital treatment in June 1952 … died at Tokyo hospital on August 20, 1952. He was
sentenced to life imprisonment at Military Tribunal after war.
292
JPN-1951 740 JPN Matthew Bunker Ridgway 11/04/1951 28/04/1952
Restoration of self rule.
293
JPN-1976 740 JPN Fukuda 24/12/1976 07/12/1978
294
JPN-2000-1 740 JPN Mikio Aoki 02/04/2000 05/04/2000
INDIA
295
IND-2004 750 IND Manmohan Singh 22/05/2004 31/12/2004
BHUTAN
296
See Keesing’s Vol. 51, March 2005: “The draft of a 34-article constitution was published
and distributed on March 26, intended to replace a royal decree of 1953 which gave the
King absolute power. The draft, which was completed in 2002, was not presented to the
Cabinet by King Jigme Singye Wangchuck until November 2004 [see p. 46311]. Chief
Justice Lyonpo Sonam Tobgye, head of the drafting committee, said that the King wanted
all of Bhutan’s citizens to read the draft and send in suggestions before the constitution
was ratified by a referendum by the end of 2005.”
PAKISTAN
297
Lentz: “He retained office until Mohammed Ayub Khan imposed a military government
on October 27, 1958. He continued to serve as leader of the Republican party.” President
abrogates constitution and grants power to military.
298
shot", and in Rawalpindi civil servants paraded with placards saying "We demand a full
account" and "Give us civilian government". The demonstrations continued until Dec. 20,
when they threatened to degenerate into riots. In Karachi, where a general strike was
declared, demonstrators stoned the Soviet airline's offices; mobs set fire to liquor stores
in both Karachi and Islamabad as a protest against the alleged drunkenness of the ruling
military junta; and buildings were also reported to have been set on fire in Lahore and
Peshawar. … It was officially announced on Dec. 18 that Mr. Bhutto had been asked to
return from New York immediately, and that on his arrival "power will be transferred to a
representative Government to be formed under the new Constitution". An official
spokesman said on Dec. 19 that "President Yahya Khan has decided to resign his office
as soon as he hands over the Government to the representatives of the people
tomorrow".”
Keesing’s February 1972, “Purge of Armed Forces and Administration” records:
In addition to the generals retired on Dec. 20, President Bhutto retired the C.-in-C. of the
Navy (Vice-Admiral Muzaffar Hasan), the Naval Chief of Staff (Rear-Admiral Rashid
Ahmed), four other senior naval officers and three major-generals on Dec. 28, 1971--
Commodore Hasan Hafiz Ahmed being appointed acting C.-in-C. of the Navy--and seven
more generals on Jan. 12, 1972. It was commented that the purge did not affect the Air
Force high command, which was reported to have played a key role in forcing President
Yahya Khan to resign.”
LA Times, Dec. 20, 1971, pp. A1 & 8 “Yahya Khan will step down today.” “The former
head of the Pakistani air force, Chief Air Marshal Asghar Khan, said Sunday Yahya Khan
should be placed on “open trial for this disgrateful episode in Pakistani history.”
The Washington Post, Times Herald, Dec. 20, 1971. p. A1 “Pakistani President to
Resign” “The announcement of his planned resignation came in the wake of a mass
procession through the streets here led by the former commander in chief of the air force,
Air Mashal Asghar Khan, who was followed by people yelling “Hang Yahya,” according
to news agency reports.”
Demonstrations and pressure put to bear on Yahya Khan, based on the “key” role of the
Air Force, we code this is an irregular exit.
299
Keesing’s Vol. 39, May 1993 notes that Pakistan’s Supreme Court ruled that the
President’s dissolution of the National Assembly and dismissal of Sharif as Prime
Minister had exceeded “the ambit of the powers conferred on the president … and has
therefore been passed without lawful authority.” Hence the removal should be coded as
“irregular,” and Mazari’s entry—appointed by Khan—also as irregular. For his dismissal
here, see also Keesing’s Vol. 39 April 1993.
BANGLADESH
300
For his entry, see Keesing’s Vol. 21, October 1975. Had studied law at Dacca University.
He seems to be OK. See Keesing’s Vol. 22, January 1976. Keesing’s Vol. 23, March
1977 records that he was arrested on Nov. 30, 1976. That is three weeks after one year
after ousted.
Lentz reports: “Mustaque broke with the Awami party in 1976 and formed the
Democratic Action Committee. He was arrested shortly afterwards and remained
imprisoned until 1980.” Keesing’s Vol. 23, July 1977 reports that he was sentenced to
five years rigorous imprisonment and a fine by a special martial law court on Feb. 24.
Mustaque resigned after abortive coup. Arrested and imprisoned.
301
Chowdhury had resigned, said an official announcement. Ershad assumed the office of
president through amending the proclamation of martial law which was issued in march
1982. the amendment said that the chief martial law administrator "shall be the president
of the republic," the official announcement said.” Copied from Lexis Nexis, typos are as
is, HG. See Lentz and Rulers.org: jailed until 1997, then again in November 2000. See
also, United Press International, December 11, 1983, cited above “Lt. Gen. Hussain
Muhammad Ershad, who took power in a bloodless military coup 20 months ago,
declared himself president Sunday in a move he called a step toward democracy in
Bangladesh. Ershad, who had ruled the country as chief martial law administrator,
dissolved his 20-member council of ministers and immediately reappointed them as a
presidential Cabinet. Outgoing President Abulfazal Muhammad Ahsanuddin Chowdhury,
who was appointed by Ershad after the takeover, resigned immediately after the military
chief signed an amendment to his martial law proclamation making himself president. ''I
think it is necessary for me to assume the responsibility of president for a smooth
transition from martial law to democracy,'' Ershad said in a recorded television and radio
speech broadcast nationwide late Sunday.” For his fate see Lentz. Forced to resign and
jailed.
302
MYANMAR (BURMA)
Additional sources:
Frank N. Trager, Burma, From Kingdom to Republic. New York: Praeger, 1996.
C. L. Keeton, King Thebaw and the Ecological Rape of Burma, Delhi: Manohar Book
Service, 1979.
John. F. Cady, A History of Modern Burma. Ithaca, NY” Cornell University Press.
303
Encarta.msn.com: “As a result of antigovernment riots in March and June 1988, Ne Win
officially retired from politics and suggested that a multiparty system might be better for
the nation.” Dies 5 December 2002.
Encyclopedia Britannica: “In March 2002, however, he was placed under house
arrest following the imprisonment of several family members who were accused of
plotting a coup against the country's military junta; no charges were brought against Ne
Win, but he remained under house arrest until his death.” Under house arrest since March
7, 2002. Had a heart attack in September 2001.
The Washington Times, December 21, 2002, notes: “Ne Win was forced aside in
1988 after the military killed thousands of pro-democracy demonstrators during a failed
uprising in Rangoon, the capital of Burma, which Ne Win's successors renamed
Myanmar. From 1988 to 2002, the regime allowed the aged ex-despot to dwell in
oblivion as a wealthy recluse in Rangoon, where he spent much of his time and fortune
building a Buddhist pagoda in hopes of ensuring a happy afterlife. But last March, his
world crumbled. Ne Win's favorite, business-savvy daughter, Sandar Win, and her
husband and their three adult sons were arrested by the military junta.”
The Statesman (India) December 18, 2002, reports: “Ne Win”, means “Sun of
Glory” or “Brilliant as the Sun” as a nom de guerre to conceal his Sino-Burmese origins.
His real name was Shu Maung. Also: “Despite denials by the SLORC, Ne Win remained
politically influential well into the 1990s.”
304
Maung, 63, had been widely reported to be suffering from a nervous disorder, and many
of his public speeches have verged on the incoherent in recent months. He previously
gave up the posts of foreign minister and defense minister to colleagues. Than Shwe, 58,
has been holding the jobs of army commander, deputy chairman of the junta, deputy
supreme commander of the defense forces, and defense minister. However, analysts long
have believed that the key junta figure has been Khin Nyunt, its secretary. Since 1988, he
has been involved in key decisions and policy deliberations while Saw Maung has
usually dealt with generalities.”
But, The Daily Yomiuri, Feb 1, 1993, p. 3 records: “A Myanmar junta source,
who called Saw Maung's resignation a "coup d'etat," said that SLORC First Secretary
Khin Nyunt played a key role in prompting the resignation. Khin Nyunt is a young,
influential figure who is one of the few permitted to freely visit the residence of former
Myanmar President Ne Win, the country's most influential political figure. According to
the source, Ne Win approved last March Khin Nyunt's request to allow him to force Saw
Maung to resign. A diplomatic source in Yangon speculated that Khin Nyunt wanted Saw
Maung out of power because he was not flexible enough to achieve the level of
democracy needed in the country to convince Western nations, and Japan, to lift their
economic sanctions and resume aid to Myanmar. It is commonly believed that Khin
Nyunt, who is not popular among Myanmar's military personnel, persuaded Than Shwe
to assume the post of SLORC chairman to maintain military unity. Studying Thai
Experience It is slowly becoming clearer that SLORC, which is virtually led by Khin
Nyunt, aims to install a civilian government that would actually be run by the military.”
Facts on File, August 14, 1997 has his obituary and notes: “he resigned as
Burma's ruler in 1992 after exhibiting increasingly bizarre behavior, including declaring
himself the reincarnation of an ancient Burmese king; born in December 1928 in
Mandalay; died July 24 in Yangon, Myanmar (formerly Burma) of a heart attack.” See
also for his post exit fate the obituary in NYT, July 27, 1997, Section 1, p. 30. This also
notes: “But for all General Saw Maung's authority and the brutality with which he
exercised it, few believed that he was the ultimate power in his country. The man who
has called the shots in Myanmar, most observers agree, is Gen. Ne Win, General Saw
Maung's longtime mentor. … After General Ne Win stepped down under popular
pressure in July 1988, the appointment of his hand-picked successor, Gen. Sein Lwin,
caused a surge in protests. General Saw Maung, who became Defense Minister,
established his hart-line credentials by ordering troops into Rangoon, as the capital was
then known, to help the security police battle the demonstrators. General Sein Lwin was
forced to resign after 17 bloody days, but Gen. Saw Maung retained his ministry under
the next leader, Maung Maung, a Ne Win civilian protégé. Mr. Maung Maung failed to
win the confidence of the protestors, and demonstrations continued. Finally General Ne
Win had enough. According to widespread reports at the time, he summoned General
Saw Maung to his home one night and ordered him to organize a coup the next day.
General Saw Maung did just that, and was installed as head of a new military junta on
Sept. 18. More than 1,000 civilians were killed before the protesters were finally driven
from the streets. The end of General Saw Maung's rule came after he began acting
erratically. When he began speaking of himself as the reincarnation of an 11th-century
Burmese king, he became an embarrassment. He resigned in April 1992 and was replaced
by his deputy, Gen. Than Shwe, another Ne Win protégé, who continues to serve as
305
chairman of the junta. General Saw Maung, whose survivors include his wife and three
children, has since dropped almost completely out of public sight. So did his mentor,
General Ne Win, who nevertheless, in his mid-80's, is still believed by many to be pulling
the strings of Government.”
The Statesman (India) December 18, 2002, also refers to his removal as a coup:
“Alcoholic and delusional, Saw Maung was removed in a palace coup after Army Day in
1992.”
The source for the Japanese paper seems credible claiming it was a coup, but Saw
Maung had also clearly been sick. We code this as lost=9; the majority of sources refers
to his ill health, which probably is also the reason for his removal if he is removed
“irregularly” and a decision on “unconstitutional” removal in Myanmar has to be
guesswork.
306
told Reuters in the Indian capital. ``The group accused Than Shwe of nepotism and said
he was incapable of running the country. Ever since, there has been a total blackout and
there has been no news from the cabinet meeting,'' Soe Myint said.
UNDER ARREST?
Than Shwe has not been seen on state television since August 20 when he met U.N.
envoy and former Indonesian Foreign Minister Ali Alatas, but official newspapers on
Wednesday reported his message of congratulations to Ukraine on its independence day .
Diplomats in Yangon said they believed he was on a provincial tour. ``We understand he
is out of town and this rumor did not start in Yangon, but outside the country,'' a
Southeast Asian diplomat said. The opposition National League for Democracy (NLD)
also played down the Rumors. ``So far as we can confirm, this rumor is more likely not to
be true. The situation across the city is quite normal,'' NLD spokesman Nyan Win told
Reuters. But the Thai language newspaper Phuchatkan reported on its Web site at
manager.co.th that Maung Aye, the army commander-in-chief had ordered Than Shwe
detained at a Yangon hospital on Tuesday. ``General Maung Aye has taken over power
since midnight on August 23,'' the newspaper said, citing Thai intelligence sources.
The former Burma has been ruled by the military in various guises since a coup in 1962
and is reviled in the West for its alleged human rights abuses and confinement of
democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi since May 2003. Yangon says it is moving toward
democracy along a seven-stage roadmap it unveiled in August 2003. However, few take
its rulers seriously, especially with Suu Kyi languishing under house arrest and her party
effectively excluded from talks to draw up a new constitution, which are set to resume in
December. Than Shwe, 73 and an expert in psychological warfare, seized the junta
leadership in 1992 with the help of General Khin Nyunt, who was ousted as prime
minister and military intelligence chief last October. The Norway-based Democratic
Voice of Burma reported on its Web site, dvb.no, on Monday that Than Shwe's son-in-
law, Teza, was being investigated for corruption.
307
SRI-1956 780 SRI Bandaranaike, S.W.R.D 12/04/1956 26/09/1959
Shot by a Buddhist monk.
MALDIVES
http://www.maldivesculture.com/maldives_constitution.html
Constitution of the Republic of the Maldives that came into force in 1968 (and amended
in 1970, 1972, and 1975) has been repealed and replaced by a new Constitution assented
to by the President of the Republic on 27 November 1997. The new Constitution came
into force on 1 January 1998. “Article 4 of the Constitution of the Maldives provides that
the powers of the state comprise of the executive, the legislature, and the administration
of justice ("the judiciary") and those powers vest in the citizens. This Article further
provides that the executive power vests in the President of the Republic and the cabinet
ministers, the legislative power vests in Parliament, and the judicial power vests in the
308
President of the Republic and the courts. In theory the three powers are identified
separately and they appear to be independent of each other. However, those powers are,
in effect, administered collectively as a composite whole. To this effect, Article 3 states:
The State of the Maldives shall, in accordance with this Constitution, be the territory of
the Maldives, the citizens of the Maldives and the powers of the state as a composite
whole. Article 33 then designates the President of the Republic as the "head of state" and
"head of government". It is said: The President shall be the Head of State, Head of
Government and the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces and the Police of the
Maldives.” Maldives became independent on July 26, 1965. Presidential system
309
NEPAL
310
king dismissed the government of B. P. Koirala on December 15, 1960, revoked the
constitution, and restored the monarchy to full power.”
311
NEP-2002 790 NEP Lokendra Bahadur Chand 11/10/2002 05/06/2003
THAILAND
312
NYT, Oct. 13, 1933, p. 1 reports “General Phya Bahol, commander-in-chief of the army,
headed a bloodless revolt last June 20 against the new State Council headed by Phya
Manopakarama, liberal successor to Pradit. Three days later General Phya Bahol became
Prime Minister but said he would act only temporarily in that post because he was an
army man.”
313
Thanon Kittakachorn was born on 11 August 1911. Lentz notes that: “His government
was unstable and collapsed on October 20, 1958. Sarit Thanarat staged another military
coup the same day, and Thanon was named deputy premier in Sarit’s military
government.
314
Policy Council from 12 November, 1977 until his death from a heart attack in Bangkok
on 23 November, 1980.
CAMBODIA (KAMPUCHEA)
315
CAM-1970 811 CAM Lon Nol 18/03/1970 10/04/1975
Coup, exile to Bali then Honolulu
316
CAM-1997 811 CAM Hun Sen 06/07/1997 31/12/2004
Rulers.org reports: “On July 5, 1997, Hun Sen ordered troops to attack the stronghold of
Ranariddh. He and his party named a token FUNCINPEC official, Ung Huot, to replace
the prince as first prime minister, but Hun Sen continued his tactics of domination and
intimidation. In 1998 he became sole prime minister. King Sihanouk awarded him the
honorary title of Samdech in 1993.”
He assumed control when Ranariddh fled, questionable but probably regular.
LAOS
317
danger. The general said: “We are in power at present only because the National
Assembly is taking an unconstitutional attitude toward the electoral law. Under the
Constitution the National Assembly and he Government should have terminated Dec. 25
when their four-year mandate expired. When the National Assembly is willing to dissolve
and permit the King to act constitutionally and appoint a provisional Government prior to
holding national elections, then we will be more than willing to had back the reins of
power to the civilians.” Premier Phoui, with the support of the Assembly, contended that,
despite the end of their terms Dec. 25, the Cabinet and the Assembly could continue to
function until the next election. The Committeee for the Defense of the National Interest,
seven of whose members held Cabinet seats, had insisted that the Government must go
out of existence Dec. 25 and had demanded immediate elections. As a result of the
dispute the reform group’s members resigned from the Cabinet Dec. 15. The Premier is
said to have felt elections were not possible at present because of the state of insecurity
caused by the rebellion started last August by the pro-Communist Pathet Lao. General
Phoumi contended that elections were possible and that a democratic form of government
could solve the problem of Communist infiltration. The general said the military would
take over the Prime Minister’s office until the crisis was resolved. Meanwhile, troops are
patrolling Vientiane streets and guarding all major installations, including cable and
wireless offices.”
Based on this later and fuller report, we code his exit as irregular. Lentz: Goes into exile
in Thailand following the Communist takeover in May of 1975, then goes into exile in
France.
318
Interior portfolio which he had held under M. Kou Abhay-. The other Ministers were: M.
Khamphan Panya--Foreign Affairs; General Phoumi Nosavan--Defence, Sports, Youth,
and Ex-servicemen; M. Inpeng Suryadhay--Finance and Planning; M. Keo Viphakorn --
Economy and Rural Affairs; M. Ngon Sananikone--Justice; M. Koukeo Saycocile--
Health; M. Phanga Nith Singharaj--Public Works, Posts and Telegraphs; M. Nhouy Kou
Abhay-Education; M. Leuam Insisiengmay--Information. The Cabinet comprised seven
members of the Paxasangkhom, two Independents (M. Nhouy Abhay and M. Leuam
Insisiengmay), and one member of the Laotian People's Rally (M. Ngon Sananikone).
Five Ministers had been members of the caretaker government, though with changed
portfolios in some cases. “
{Coup attempt against Prince Souvannah, 19 April 1964 – May 1964. Fails.}
319
continued p. 18 which says the leader of Pathet Lao asks Gen Kong Le to cooperate
resolutely, so he must have been in the country.
Kong Le, in 1966 was dismissed as army chief and left the country, now lives in
exile, primarily in the United States.
320
LAO-1964-1 812 LAO Kouprasith 19/04/1964 20/04/1964
Son of previous ruler: Kou Abhay.
Keesing’s Vol. 10, October, 1964, reports: “In the early hours of April 19, 1964, a right-
wing military junta, led by General Khouprasith Abhay (commander of the Vientiane
military region) and General Siho Lanphouthacoul (commander of the right-wing military
police), seized control in Vientiane and placed Prince Souvanna and the neutralist
members of his Government under house arrest. Troops and police had taken up their
positions during the previous night, erected barricades across the roads leading Gilt of the
town, and occupied the airport. Sporadic firing took place between 2 and 4.30 a.m. on
April 19 as the troops guarding the neutralist Ministers tried to resist those sent to arrest
them, but the only persons killed were two members of the military police. No attempt
was made to arrest the Pathet Lao Secretaries of State, who were protected by the I.C.C.'s
guards. A communiqué broadcast at 8 a.m. announced that a "Revolutionary Committee
of the National Army" had taken over the powers previously held by the Government;
according to a subsequent statement, the committee consisted of 18 generals and 58 other
officers, with General Khouprasith as chairman and General Siho as vice-chairman.
During the morning a statement alleged to have been issued by Prince Souvanna was
broadcast, in which he announced that he had resigned his powers to the Revolutionary
Committee. General Khouprasith, who is the son of a former Premier, M. Kou Abhay,
took a prominent part in the battle for Vientiane in 1960, …”
Coup is also reported in NYT, April 19, 1964, p. 1. It is reported as collapsing the
day after in LA Times, April 20, 1964, p.1, which also reports: “The diplomatic reports
late Sunday said Souvanna had been released from house arrest by the coup leader, Gen.
Kouprasith Abhay, and was on his way to the Plain of Jars for a conference. Gen.
Kouprasith reportedly had apologized for the coup attempt and was included in the
conference party.
For his entry—and leadership of the coup—see Chicago Tribune, April. 20, 1964,
p. 1 “Report Coup Fails in Laos.” Which also notes that “Gen. Phoumi Nosava … was
not mentioned among the leaders of the coup.” See also NYT, Apr. 20, 1964, p. 14. “Key
Figure in Laos Kouprasith Abhay” which has lots of detail on him. “He is thought to be
about 37 or 38. … His father was the late Kou Abhay, who was President of the King’s
Council and one of the country’s most respected men.”
For him being OK after the coup, see LA Times, April 29, 1965, p. 30 which
reports he commanded government operations against rightist rebels. See also LA Times,
Sept. 25, 1964, p. A5.
321
msn.encarta.com: New Constitution comes into effect in 1992, and president becomes
main executive. Kaysone Phomvihane: dies a natural death in office on 21 November.
VIETNAM
322
telegram from Saigon stating that a revolution has taken place at Hue, and that the King
of Annam has been killed. The Ministry have no information relative to the report.
London, Dec. 13, -- A Hong Kong dispatch to Reuter’s Telegram Company says it is
stated that that Hiephema, King of Annam, has been poisoned by the anti-French party at
Hue. … London, Dec. 14. – A dispatch to the Standard from Hanoi dated Dec. 5 confirms
the reports of the breaking out of a revolution at Hue and the poisoning of King
Hiephema. The new King of Annam is Tiephoa.
Nguyen & Nguyen, p. 286: “Thuyet and Tuong … requested the Queen Mother,
mother of Tu-Duc, to repudiate Hiep-Hoa and enthrone Duong-Thien, youngest of the
three adopted sons of Tu-Duc. Hiep-Hoa was forced to take poison; and Tran-Tien-
Thanh, who refused to endorse Hiep-Hoa’s repudiation, was assassinated on order of
Thuyet and Tuong. Power then fell into the hands of Nguyen-Van-Tuong and Ton-That-
Thuyet, for the Emperor Kien-Phuc, former Prince Duong Thien, was only fifteen years
old.”
323
Nguyen & Nguyen, (p.29-7) notes that : “On September 14, 1885, while Ham-Nghi was
still at large the French proclaimed Chanh-Month Emperor under the Royal name of
Dong-Khanh. The new ruler proved to be obedient and compliant to French rule.
Nephew of Emperor Tu Duc and an elder brother of Emperor Ham Nghi. Note that
Duiker also records him in power until 1889, but Whitfield has him dying in January
1888.
The Washington Post, March 10, 1889, p. 1 notes: “San Francisco, March 9. –
The Courier de Haiphong of January 31 says, Emperor Dong Kanh of Annam died
suddenly at Hue. It is not known whether his death was from natural causes or the result
of a police revolution.”
324
Changing rules in Vietnamese politics,” in Contemporary Southeast Asia, April 2002,
Vol. 24, Iss.1, pp.121-146.
REPUBLIC OF VIETNAM
325
He was exiled in the US. (Keesing’s Vol. 11 (1965) September. The Military Directorate
announced on Aug. 7 [1965, HG] that Lieut. General Nguyen Khanh (the former Prime
Minister, who was living in the United States) had been removed from the active list and
ordered to return to face an inquiry into corruption charges against him, and that General
Pham Van Dong had been dismissed from the Army. Major-General Do Cau Tri, who
had gone into exile after being implicated in the coup of Sept. 13, 1964, was also ordered
to face an inquiry into his conduct.)
MALAYSIA
326
visit to the United Kingdom for medical treatment earlier in 1981 during which he had
undergone a coronary by-pass operation on Feb. 7.”
SINGAPORE
BRUNEI
PHILIPPINES
327
crash of the presidential C-47 airliner on a mountain on Cebu Island. Officials suspected
sabotage.” The Washington Post and Times Herald, March 21, 1957, p. A14 reports that
Col. Richardo Papa, deputy constabulary chief said that evidence indicated no foul play
was involved in the death of the president. But the article ends “Walker Stone, editor in
chief of the Scripps-Howard newspapers, quoted Magsaysay as saying eight days ago:
“They’re going to try to bump me off in this (election)( campaign. They know they can’t
win if I live.”” The Washington Post and Times Herald, April. 28, 1957, p. A6 reports
that “The chief of the Philippine Constabulary said today that metal fatigue caused the
plane crash in which President Ramon Magsaysay and 25 other persons died March 17.
Brig. Gen. Manuel F. Cabal told a Senate investigating committee that the possibility of
“direct or indirect” sabotage had been ruled out.”
INDONESIA
328
INS-1945 850 INS Sukarno 17/08/1945 18/12/1948
nl.encarta.msn.com Son of teacher, who belonged to the lower nobility of Java. Educated
as civil engineer at the Technical Academy at Bandung. First Dutch – Indonesian war 21
July – 5 August 1947. Second Dutch – Indonesian War, 19 December 1948 – 11 August
1949.
Lentz: Captured by Dutch paratroopers at the nationalists’ headquarters in Jogjakarta
December 18, 1948. He was exiled to Prapart until July of 1949, when the Dutch were
forced by world opinion to release him and grant Indonesia independence. For his capture
see also NYT, Dec. 27, 1948, p. 1 and NYT, Dec. 29, 1948, p.1
Exiled to Propat.
329
Female. Daughter of Sukarno.
EAST TIMOR
ETM-2002 860 ETM Gusmao 20/05/2002 31/12/2004
Had been jailed by the Indonesians.
AUSTRALIA
330
AUL-1939-1 900 AUL Page 07/04/1939 26/04/1939
331
AUL-1975 900 AUL Fraser 11/11/1975 11/03/1983
Lentz: called elections nine months before required by law.
332
NEW ZEALAND
333
NEW-1975 920 NEW Muldoon 12/12/1975 26/07/1984
SOLOMON ISLANDS
334
of Pitakaka's move. The case was examined by both the High Court of the Solomon
Islands and, later, by the Court of Appeal. This latter body on Oct. 23 ruled in favour of
Pitakaka's right to dismiss Billy Hilly. In a private ceremony on Oct. 24, Pitakaka swore
in opposition leader and former Prime Minister Solomon Mamalonias caretaker Prime
Minister. He also issued a proclamation which declared the post of prime minister vacant,
appealed for nominations, and directed the Speaker of parliament to convene the
legislature in order to elect a prime minister. Notwithstanding the judicial decision, Billy
Hilly continued to refuse to leave office, and rejected Mamaloni's claims to have
succeeded him. After further legal consideration, his assertion that he could be dismissed
only after a parliamentary vote of no confidence was upheld by the judiciary on Oct. 26,
whereupon Pitakaka immediately lodged an appeal against the decision. However,
heightening the confusion and further undermining Billy Hilly's position, the ruling also
found that the Governor-General was not required to take advice from a minority
government. The crisis ended on Oct. 31 when Billy Hilly accepted the untenability of his
position and informed Pitakaka of his resignation.”
Based on Keesing’s we code this is an irregular and unconstitutional removal
from office. At minimum, without Pitakaka’s action, he could have stayed until Nov. 18.
335
cast for Home and Cultural Affairs Minister Leslie Boseto. A third contender, former
Prime Minister Francis Billy Hilly, received no votes.”
BBC Worldwide Monitoring, March 4, 2002, from SOURCE: Solomon Islands
Broadcasting Corporation text web site, Noniare, in English 4 Mar 02 notes “Caretaker
Prime Minister in the absence at the Commonwealth summit of Sir Allan Kemakeza
Manasseh Sogavare has blamed development partners for the failure in retrieving guns
still at large with some former militants.”
FIJI
336
been dismissed from his post. … During the course of May 17 the Governor-General
refused to swear in, and thereby legitimize, Rabuka's Council of Ministers. He was
supported by the Chief Justice, Sir Timoci Tuivaga, and by the country's seven Supreme
Court judges, who stated their 'undivided and complete loyalty' to the constitution.
Nevertheless, in the evening of May 18 it was announced that Ratu Ganilau had sworn in
Lt. -Col. Rabuka as Chief Minister 24 hours earlier and had agreed to legitimize similarly
the position of the other members of the Council of Ministers. ”
Brit. Encyc.: Election of May 1999 is first under the new constitution. “Rabuka resigned
from Parliament and was elected chair of the Great Council of Chiefs, a body with wide
influence as well as a formal constitutional role.” Coup.
337
Notes on sources
Among general sources we relied primarily Lentz (1994,1999) and Spuler (1997). We
have also relied on a large number of country specific sources, which will be identified in
the complete version of the case description file.
General sources for the Americas include Nohlen (1993 & 2005).
The following web sites provided useful information during the course of the project:
http://www.famousamericans.net
http://www.biografiasyvidas.com
http://www.nytimes.com
http://www.washingtonpost.com
http://www.consortiumnews.com
http://news.bbc.co.uk
http://www.edufuturo.com
(provides excellent information on Ecuadorian Presidents)
http://www.explored.com.ec/ecuador/baqueriz.htm.
338
http://www.mmrree.gov.ec
(Ecuador ministry of external relations website)
http://www.washingtonpost.com
http://www.cnn.com
http://www.nrc.nl
http://www.wordiq.com
http://de.encarta.msn.com/
http://www.macedonian-heritage.gr
http://www.datamass.net
http://www.ikuska.com
http://www.liberiapastandpresent.org
http://www.dacb.org
http://www.blignaut.co.za
http://www.infoplease.com
http://www.nationmaster.com
http://www.maldivesculture.com
http://www.inghist.nl
http://www.worldstatesmen.org
http://www.lexisnexis.com
http://www.consortiumnews.com
http://www.chron.com
(Houston Chronicle web site)
http://proquest.umi.com
The Historical Newspapers collections was crucial.
www.chicagotribune.com
339
http://www.inghist.nl
www.timesherald.com
http://www.monitor.bbc.co.uk
(BBC Worldwide Monitoring)
http://www.sibconline.com.sb
(Solomon Islands Broadcasting Corporation web site)
http://www.auyantepui.com/historia/presidentes.html and
http://www.auyantepui.com/historia/posesiones.html (for Venezuelan Presidents, with
details on profession and election dates)
http://countrystudies.us/venezuela/39.htm
340
References
Alberto, Tauro. 1966-7. Diccionario Enciclopédico del Perú. Lima: Mejía Baca.
Buttinger, Joseph. 1958. The Snaller Dragon, a political history of Vietnam. New York:
Frederick A. Praeger.
Cady, John. F. 1978. A History of Modern Burma. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Duiker, William. 1998. Historical Dictionary of Vietnam. Lanham, Md.: The Scarecrow
Press.
Fredriksen, John C. 2003. Modern World Leaders; 1992 to the present. New York: Facts
on File Inc.
Fredriksen, John C. 2004. Modern World Leaders; 1900 to 1991. New York: Facts on
File Inc.
Gleditsch, Kristian S. and Michael D. Ward. 1999. “A Revised List of Independent States
Since 1816.” International Interactions 25:393-413.
Glickman, Harvey (Ed.). 1992. Political Leaders of Contemporary Africa South of the
Sahara: A Biographical Dictionary. Westport, CT: Greenwood.
Keeton, C. L. King Thebaw and the Ecological Rape of Burma, Delhi: Manohar Book
Service. N.d.
341
Lentz, Harris M. 1999. Encyclopedia of Heads of States and Governments, 1900
Through 1945. Jefferson, NC: McFarland.
Mullin. Glenn H. 2001. The Fourteen Dalai Lamas; A Sacred Legacy of Reincarnation.
Santa Fe, NM: Clear Light Publishers.
Nohlen, Dieter. 1978. Wahlsysteme der Welt, Daten und Analysen: Ein Handbuch.
München: R. Piper & Co. Verlag.
Nohlen, Dieter. 1993a. Enciclopedia Electoral Latinoamericana y del Caribe. San Jos´e,
Costa Rica: Instituto Interamericano de Derechos Humanos.
Nohlen, Dieter. 1993b. Los Sistemas Electorales en America Latina y el Debate sobre
Reforma Electoral. Mexico: Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico.
Nohlen, Dieter, Florian Grotz & Christof Hartmann. 2001a. Elections in Asia and the
Pacific: A Data Handbook, Volume 2: Southeast Asia, East Asia and the South Pacific.
New York: Oxford University Press.
Nohlen, Dieter, Florian Grotz & Christof Hartmann. 2001b. Elections in Asia and the
Pacific: A Data Handbook, Volume 1: The Middle East, Central Asia and South Asia.
New York: Oxford University Press.
Nohlen, Dieter, Michael Krennerich & Berhnard Thibaut. 1999. Elections in Africa: A
Data Handbook. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Nguyen-Van-Thai and Nguyen-Van-Mung. 1958. A Short History of Viet-Nam, Saigon:
The Times Publishing Company.
Palmer, Alan W. 1996. Who's Who in World Politics: From 1860 to the Present Day.
New York: Routledge.
Tönu Parming. 1975. The Collapse of Liberal Democracy and the Rise of
Authoritarianism in Estonia. London, UK: Sage Publications.
Penate, Oscar Martinez, and Maria Elana Sanchez. 2000. El Salvador Diccionario:
Personajes, Hechos Historicos, Geografia e Insitciones. San Salvador: Editorial Nuevo
Enfoque.
Pérez Marchant, Brauilio. 1928. Diccionario Biográfico Del Ecuador. Quito: Escuela de
Artes y Oficios.
342
Pérez Villa, Manuel , and Astrid Avendano Vera. 1988. Diccionario de Historia de
Venezuela. Caracas: Fundacion Polar.
Powell, John ed. 2000. Biographical Encyclopedia of the 20th Century World Leaders. 5
vols. New York: Marshall Cavendish.
Rotberg, Robert I, and Christopher K. Clague. 1971. Haiti: The politics of squalor.
Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Spuler, Bertold. 1977. Rulers and Governments of the World. London: Bowker.
Trager, Frank N. 1979. Burma, From Kingdom to Republic. New York: Praeger, 1996.
Vanhanen, Tatu. 2000. “A New Dataset for Measuring Democracy, 1810-1998.” Journal
of Peace Research 37:251-65.
Vickers, Miranda. 1995. The Albanians, A modern history. New York: I. B. Tauris.
Von Grafenstein, Johanna. 1988. Haití. Mexico City: Instituto de Investigaciones Dr.
José María Luis Mora.
Whitfield, Danny J.. 1976. Historical and Cultural Dictionary of Vietnam, Metuchen, NJ:
The Scarecrow Press, Inc.
343