A New Correlation Between SPT and CPT For Various Soils PDF
A New Correlation Between SPT and CPT For Various Soils PDF
A New Correlation Between SPT and CPT For Various Soils PDF
explorations, design parameters, and quality control assessments. other tests in order to use them for primary evaluation or
Many soil index and engineering properties have been correlated to initial design purposes.
both of SPT and CPT. Various foundation design methods were Numerous geotechnical researchers have presented
developed based on the outcome of these tests. Therefore it is vital to relationships between the two most common used in situ soil
correlate these tests to each other so that either one of the tests can be investigation tests, the SPT and the CPT. These relationships
used in the absence of the other, especially for preliminary evaluation
help engineers in adopting empirical methods to evaluate and
and design purposes.
The primary purpose of this study was to investigate the analyze soil performance by converting the available database
relationships between the SPT and CPT for different type of sandy of either one of the two tests into the other test’s parameter(s).
soils in Florida. Data for this research were collected from number of A significant amount of published literature suggests linear
projects sponsored by the Florida Department of Transportation statistical correlations between the two tests variables: N blow
(FDOT), six sites served as the subject of SPT-CPT correlations. The count of the SPT, and cone tip resistance (qc) of the CPT.
correlations were established between the cone resistance (qc), sleeve
friction (fs) and the uncorrected SPT blow counts (N) for various
soils. II. DATA SELECTION
A positive linear relationship was found between qc, fs and N for The chosen data was obtained from soil investigations for
various sandy soils. In general, qc versus N showed higher FDOT major roadwork projects. The closest available testing
correlation coefficients than fs versus N. qc/N ratios were developed locations were chosen to establish the SPT – CPT correlations
for different soil types and compared to literature values, the results
of this research revealed higher ratios than literature values. for each site. Locations of these sites are superimposed on
Florida map as shown in Fig. 1.
Keywords—In situ tests, Correlation, SPT, CPT. Three variables are representative of the data used in this
research: SPT N (blows/0.3m), CPT tip resistance qc (MPa)
I. INTRODUCTION and sleeve resistance fs (kPa). The data also included SPT
boring log. Each boring log contained a soil profile with soil
S OIL is naturally heterogeneous and discontinuous material
that is composed of various degraded minerals and organic
matter. Soil is deposited by several natural actions such as
type classifications according to the Unified Soil
Classification System (USCS); these classifications were
based on laboratory tests (i.e., sieve analysis, Atterberg limits).
mechanical and chemical weathering on different kinds of
rocks. These actions produce various sedimentation patterns
III. HISTORY OF SPT – CPT CORRELATIONS
and formations. Soil is composed of different solid minerals of
finite gradations, gases and water that give different behaviors Many researchers have pointed out the importance of SPT -
when subjected to vertical or horizontal forces. CPT correlations, [13] show that there is a need for reliable
The soil in central Florida, for instance, is varying in types CPT/SPT correlations so that CPT data can be used in existing
and stratigraphy. Therefore, it is a difficult task for engineers SPT-based design approaches. Kulhawy and Mayne [8]
to generalize a soil profile that can be developed and used in emphasize on the advantages of having a procedure to
foundation design. In situ soil investigations give readily, interrelate N and qc. These tests represent the most common in
relatively economic, and reliable results that can aid situ soil testing used worldwide and both of them representing
engineer’s decisions and judgments on the subsurface features soil resistance to penetration (although the SPT is dynamic
and their choice of foundation type. The variability of in situ and the CPT is quasi-static).
Back in the late 1950s and early 1960s, several researchers
like [11], [12] suggested constant values of qc/N for different
Fauzi Jarushi is with the Civil Engineering Department, Tripoli University,
Tripoli, Libya (phone: +218917630068; e-mail: [email protected]).
soil types. A number of researchers proposed that the qc/N
S. AlKaabim is with Amerapex Corporation, Iraq (e-mail: ratio is a function of the mean grain size (D50) of the soil.
[email protected]). They concluded that the smaller the qc/N ratio, the finer
Paul Cosentino is with the Civil Engineering Department, Florida Institute
grained the soil. The proposed classification chart by [14] was
of Technology, Florida, USA (phone: +1321674-7555, fax: 321-6747565, e-
mail: [email protected]). recommended to estimate the mean particle size. Clearly, the
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 101 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
Suggested
Meigh [11] N/A N55 N/A
constant values
Schmertmann N/A Uncorrected Mechanical qc/N or
[16] N55 Electric (qc+fs)/N in
Chin [2] Donut N60 N/A different soil
N/A types for
Danziger [4]& Automatic N60 Mechanical
Akca [1]
IV. METHODOLOGY
A. CPT and SPT Tests
The first type of cone penetration test was made by P.
Barentsen in 1932 in the Netherlands [10]. Although many
different styles and configurations have been used, the current
standard grew out from the Netherlands model, so it is
sometimes called the Dutch Cone [21]. Two types of CPT
were developed, mechanical cone and electrical cone. In 1953,
Begemann improved the Dutch cone by adding the “friction
jacket” behind the cone, to measure the local skin friction, fs,
in addition to the tip resistance, qc. The CPT involves pushing
10 cm2, 60° cone through the ground at a rate of 1-2 cm/s. The
total force acting on the cone divided by the projected area of
the cone (10 cm2) is the point resistance (qc). This force or
resistance is measured by load cells located just behind the
Fig. 1 Current Study Sites Locations [22] tapered cone. Theoretically, the tip resistance is related to the
A. Factors Affecting SPT-CPT Correlations undrained shear strength of a saturated cohesive material,
while the sleeve friction is theoretically related to the friction
Many studies have pointed out several factors that could
of the horizon being penetrated [15].
affect the SPT/CPT relationship. Schmertmann [17] and
The SPT is considered the oldest in situ soil test technique.
Kovacs [7] showed that the amount of energy delivered to the
Its early version dates back to the beginning of the 19th
drill rods is an important factor affecting the N-value. Douglas
century. The basic SPT implementation procedure is to force a
[20] has reported that the qc/N ratio is significantly affected
thick, hollow tube to penetrate into the soil by applying an
by SPT hammer type and rather with soil density. Study
external driving force while calculating the soil resistance in
conducted by [6] has shown that the qc/N depends on the fines
terms of blow count. During the late 1920s and early 1930s,
content of sandy soil. They concluded that permeability and
the first trial that aimed to standardize this test procedure was
modification of compressibility of the sand are the major
developed by Harry Mohr. He recommended using a larger
factors that may affect qc/N ratio. Sanglerat [23] reviewed and
diameter split spoon sampler 5 cm in diameter and counting
presented a number of studies implemented in several
the number of blows per 300 mm of penetration, using a 64-kg
countries. Many of these studies have assigned a constant ratio
hammer with a drop distance of 76 cm.
of qc/N for each soil type; for instance, sandy soils have
As the SPT test progresses, soil samples and groundwater
mostly qc/N ratios larger than 4, while clays have ratios less
information are also collected. A record is made of the number
than 4. Furthermore, these studies have drawn important
of blows required to drive each 150 mm segment into the soil.
conclusions that soil compactness and relative density increase
This is done until 450 mm depth is achieved or otherwise
would decrease qc/N ratio. Table I summarizes the previous
penetration refusal. The first record of advance (seating) is
studies.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 102 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
usually discarded (first 150 mm), while the second and third drainage characteristics, good shear strength, and very low
increments are recorded and summed as the number of blows compressibility when compacted and saturated [5], produced a
N per 300 mm. positive correlation between qc and N. A total of 58 data pairs
All of the selected sites were tested with safety hammers was used to determine the relationship between the two
during the SPT sampling. Unfortunately, no detailed variables as shown in Fig. 2. The SPT N has 1 and 57 as a
information regarding the borehole diameter and the rod lower and upper limit, respectively. The qc values ranged
length used to perform the SPT was available. These between 1 and 25 MPa.
parameters are used to correct the SPT results for field
procedures to yield more reliable and consistent findings.
On the other hand, the CPT data in cohesionless soils,
which are the dominant type of soils in the studied sites, does
not require corrections.
B. Data Matching
International Science Index, Geological and Environmental Engineering Vol:9, No:2, 2015 waset.org/Publication/10000578
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 103 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
when compacted and saturated [5]. A total of 147 points were with both linear and nonlinear (power) correlation equations.
included in this analysis (see Fig. 4). The range of N values A number of authors have addressed the effect of fines on
was from 2 to 82 blows/0.3m, while the qc values ranged the qc/N ratio. For instance, a study by [19] shows that the
between 0.3 and 20 MPa. The relationship analysis shows that correlation between qc/N ratio and the mean grain size has
there is a weak correlation between the cone resistance and N- some limitations when the fines content in sands is more than
values in this type of soil. 10%. They also found that qc/N decreased linearly as the fines
Clayey Fine Sand (SC) with plastic fines that exceed 12%. content increased.
Low compressibility and good to fair shear strength are typical This research indicates that the higher correlation
of the performance of this soil when subjected to compaction, coefficient was obtained from clean sand to sand with low
with a poor to practically impervious drainage quality [5]. A fines content (less than 5% fines). This result may be credited
total of 175 data points was considered in this analysis; (0-60) to the uniformity and homogeneity of the respective soil layer.
was the range of N-values and (0.35-16.3) MPa was the range Lower R2 values mainly resulted from mixed soils with high
of cone resistance soundings. Fig. 5 shows the weak linear fines content (silty, clayey more than 10% fines) which
relationship between qc and N with R2 = 0.18. respond differently and sometimes unexpectedly to
International Science Index, Geological and Environmental Engineering Vol:9, No:2, 2015 waset.org/Publication/10000578
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 104 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
resistance values were below 150 kPa. all the data as presented in Fig. 10. The high percentage of
fines in this type of soil yielded high fs readings in the range
of 50 to 200 kPa. This soil shows a moderate correlation
coefficient of 0.41 while Silty Clayey Fine Sand SM/SC
shows a positive relationship between sleeve friction and the
number of blows, as do the other soil types (Fig. 11).
International Science Index, Geological and Environmental Engineering Vol:9, No:2, 2015 waset.org/Publication/10000578
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 105 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
TABLE III
CURRENT RESEARCH N = QC/N VALUES COMPARED TO LITERATURE
Soil description Current Reference /Year/ Location
(USCS) study Chin [2] 1988, Taiwan Schmertmann [18] 1970, USA Robertson [15] 1986, Canada Akca [1] 2002, Danziger [4] 1998,
UAE Brazil
SM 0.8 0.4 - 0.5 0.30 - 0.40 0.3 - 0.4 0.70 0.5 - 0.64
SP 0.6 0.5 0.30 - 0.60 0.5 - 0.6 0.77 0.57
SC 0.8 - - 0.2 - 0.46 - 0.53
SM/SC 0.4 - 0.20 - - 0.10 - 0.35
SP-SM 0.7 - - 0.3 - -
International Science Index, Geological and Environmental Engineering Vol:9, No:2, 2015 waset.org/Publication/10000578
VI. CONCLUSION [3] Dancey, Christine P., and John Reidy. Statistics Without Maths for
Psychology, Fifth Edition. Edinburgh Gate, Harlow.England: Pearson
The relationship between the SPT and CPT for several Education Limited, 2011.
FDOT projects was investigated. A correlation was developed [4] Danziger, F. A. B., C. F. Politano, and B. R. Danziger. "CPT-SPT
correlations for some Brazilian residual soils." Geotechnical site
between N values, qc and fs for different USCS soil types. characterization: Proceedings of the First International Conference on
Both qc and fs have a positive relationship with N. The qc Site Characterization - ISC'98. Atlanta, Georgia, 1998.
versus N produced higher correlation coefficients than fs [5] Holtz, Robert D., and William D. Kovacs. An Inroduction to
geotechnical Engineering. Englewood, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
versus N except for SM/SC and SC soils which show slightly 1981.
lower R2 value. [6] Kasim, A. G., Chu Ming-Yau, and J. N. Curtis. "Field Correlation of
The overall fs versus N trends showed positive linear Cone and Standard Penetration Tests." ASCE Journal of Geotechnical
relationships. Sandy soils with high fines content showed high Engineering, 1986: 368- 372.
[7] Kovacs, William D., Lawrence A. Salomone, and Felix Y. Yokel.
sleeve friction values, which yield high y-intercept values. Energy measurement in the standard penetration test. U.S. Dept. of
This evidently proves that the higher the fines content, the Commerce, National Bureau of Standards (Washington, D.C.), 1981.
higher the fs values. [8] Kulhawy, F. H., and P. W. Mayne. Manual on Estimating Soil Properties
for Foundation Design. Palo Alto, California: Electric Power Research
Weak correlation coefficients existed when the analysis Institute, 1990.
was performed for all soil types (R2, 0.1 - 0.3). [9] Lunne, T., and K. H. Andersen. “Soft clay shear strength parameters for
SP soil depicts better correlation than other sandy soils with deepwater geotechnical design.” Proceedings 6th International
Conference, Society for Underwater Technology. London: Offshore Site
higher fines content. Positive linear relationships were found Investigation and Geotechnics, 2007. 151-176.
between fs and N for various soils. [10] Lunne, T., P.K. Robertson, and J.J.M Powell. Cone Penetration Testing
In general, fs versus N showed lower correlation coefficients in Geotechnical Practice. U. K.: Blackie Academic/Chapman-Hall
Publishers, 1997.
(0.1 to 0.5) than qc versus N (0.1 to 0.6). [11] Meigh, A.C., and I.K. Nixon. "Comparison of in-situ tests of granular
Sandy soils with a high fines content produced higher soils." Proceedings of 5th international Conference on Soil Mechanics
friction values fs than poorly graded sand. and Foundation Engineering. Paris, 1961.
[12] Meyerhof, G.G. " Penetration tests and bearing capacity of cohesionless
The qc/N ratios were developed for different soil types.
soils." Journal of the soil mechanics and foundation division, ASCE,
Tangible variations existed between the current research Vol. 82, No. SM1, 1956: 1-19.
values and those in the published literature. The qc/N ratios in [13] Robertson, P. K., and (Robertson) K.L. Cabal. Guide to Cone
the current research are higher than those in the published Penetration Testing for Geotechnical Engineering, 4th edition. Signal
Hill, California: Gregg Drilling & Testing, Inc., 2010.
literature. [14] Robertson, P. K., and R. G. Campanella. "Interpretation of Cone
The qc/N ratio for poorly graded sand is remarkably similar Penetration Tests: Part I: Sand." Canadian Geotechnical Journal, Vol.
to the suggested ratios in the literature. Inversely, the silty 20, No. 4, 1983: 718-733.
[15] Robertson, P.K., and R.G. Campanella. Guidelines for Use and
sand produced higher ratios than the literature ratios except for Interpretation of the Electrical Cone Penetration Test, 3rd ed.
the one obtained from calcareous sand in the UAE. Gaithersburg, MD: Hogentogller & Co., 1986.
As an overall conclusion, the relationship between the SPT [16] Schmertmann, J. H. "Use the SPT to Measure Dynamic Soil Properties
Dynamic Geotechnical Testing, ASTM STP 654, American Society for
and CPT manifests a weak correlation in the Central Florida Testing and Materials, 1978: 341-355.
area for sandy soils with fines. [17] Schmertmann, J.H. Guidelines for Cone Penetration Test, Performance
and Design. Washington, D.C.: U.S.Department of Transportation,
Report No. FHWA-TS-78-209, 1978.
REFERENCES [18] Schmertmann, J.H. "Static Cone to Compute Static Settlement over
[1] Akca, N. "Correlation of SPT-CPT data from the United Arab Sand." Journal of the Soil Mechanics and Foundations Division,ACSE.,
Emirates." Engineering Geology, volume 67, 2003: 219-231. 1970: 1011-1035,Vol. 96, No. SM3.
[2] Chin, Chung-Tien, Shaw-Wei Duann, and Tsung-Chung Kao. "SPT- [19] Sharma, M S Ravi, and K Ilamparuthi. "Offshore In-situ Test using
CPT correlations for granular soils." 1st Int'l Symposium on Penetration Electric Piezo Cone and its Correlation with Standard Penetration Test."
Testing, 1988: Vol. 1 pp. 335-339.. Journal of the Institution of Engineers (India). Civil Engineering
Division, 2005: 62-66.
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 106 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578
World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
International Journal of Geological and Environmental Engineering
Vol:9, No:2, 2015
[20] Douglas, B.J. and Olsen, R.S. (1981). “Soil classification using electric
cone penetrometer,” Symposium on Cone Penetration Testing and
Experience. Proceedings of the ASCE National Convention, St. Louis,
209-227.
[21] Coduto, D. P. ( 2001). Foundation Design: Principles and Practices.
Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall.
[22] Courtesy of Google Maps, 2013.
[23] Sanglerat, G., The Penetrometer and Soil Exploration, Elsevier
Publishing Company, New York, N.Y., 1972.
International Science Index, Geological and Environmental Engineering Vol:9, No:2, 2015 waset.org/Publication/10000578
International Scholarly and Scientific Research & Innovation 9(2) 2015 107 scholar.waset.org/1307-6892/10000578