SIP 2018 Final
SIP 2018 Final
SIP 2018 Final
considered as the greatest human assassins for they have the potential and lethal
capacity to kill more than one million victims a year around the globe. Mosquito borne
diseases such as Yellow Fever, Zika infection, Dengue and Chikungunya are consistently
the major health problems for the people. Dengue alone has infected about 50 - 100
million people, more than 500, 000 of them develop into dengue hemorrhagic fever, a
more severe form of the disease and results in up to approximately 22, 000 deaths
Philippines being located in the tropical zone, has not escaped from these
vectors. Based on the latest report on dengue cases early this year 2018, there were
15, 599 recorded by the Department of Health (DOH) which is actually lower as
compared to last year’s record on dengue cases at the same period which has reached
23, 131 cases. Though this year’s record on dengue cases has dropped or is lower than
the previous year, it is not a guarantee that dengue is eradicated and will soon be
agypti, are still out there waiting for a chance to spread the dengue virus. In barangay
Calawisan, around 27 cases of dengue was recorded early this year and in Kalawisan
suffered the said infection that has alarmed the school and its community. This
1
alarming data have provoked us researchers to conduct a study regarding the larvicidal
carrying mosquitoes, Aedis aegypti, and we found that acid compounds in Oregano
plant.
Oregano (Origanum vulgare) a very common tropical plant that grows anywhere
in tropical countries such as the Philippines has been investigated for its larvicidal
efficacy which is being used in this study as a larvicide against Aedis egypti.
Many have been done to eradicate these tiny harmful vectors, one of which is
the use of insecticidal fumes which has proven to have dangerous effects to other
organisms and to the people who are living nearby the treated area. Humans, when
exposed to pesticides are prone to acquire serious ailments like cancer and even birth
defects. Aside from the hazardous effects it brings, it is also expensive that ordinary
Filipinos cannot just easily purchase even one for their family’s protection against these
mosquito menace which is the main purpose of this study. If proven effective and
2
Review of Related Literature
Long before the discoveries of commercial larvicides to kill insects’ larvae, plants
have always been a constant partner of people in their everyday endeavours. According
to the World Health Organization (WHO) survey, 80% of the populations living in the
developing countries rely almost exclusively on traditional medicine for their primary
health care. Plants are considered as a rich source of bioactive chemicals and they may
Phytochemicals derived from plant sources can act as larvicide, insect growth
regulators, repellent, and ovipositor attractant and have a different activities observed
by many researchers (Murugan, 1998). Plant alkaloids have been found to affect
physiological systems in higher animals as well as in insects (Saxena and Tikku 1990). A
large number of plant essential oils may be potential sources of mosquito larvicides
because they constitute a rich source of bioactive components (Lahlou et al. 2001, Cetin
et al. 2004). Natural products are the best option because of their less harmful nature
different plant families have been evaluated to show new and promising larvicides
(Markouk et al., 2000; Prabakar et al., 2004; Mohan and Ramaswamy, 2007; Innocent
et al., 2008a and 2008b), however very few plant products have been developed for
controlling mosquitoes. Given these facts, the researchers are provoked to study the
benefits we can get from plants in order to solve the existing dilemma our country and
3
barangay are facing nowadays and dengue is undeniably frightening and petrifying the
community since it has killed the infected residents ranges from infants and even
adults.
Aedis aegypti. According to the National Center for Emerging and Zoonotic Infectious
as small, dark mosquito with white lyre shaped markings and banded legs. This is most
frequently found in tropical and subtropical areas of the world and is historically
Yellow Fever and Zika infection. Severe dengue (also known as Dengue Haemorrhagic
Fever) was first recognized in 1950s during dengue epidemics in the Philippines and
Thailand. Today, severe dengue affects most Asian and Latin American countries and
has become a leading cause of hospitalization and death among children and adults in
these regions according to the World Health Organization. WHO considered dengue as
a global burden since incidence has grown dramatically around the world with an
estimated 390 million dengue infections recorded per year. Another study, of the
prevalence of dengue, estimates that 3.9 billion people, in 128 countries, are at risk of
infection with dengue viruses (Brady OJ, Gething PW, Bhatt S, Messina JP, Brownstein
JS, Hoen AG et al., 201). Given this alarming data, the domination of these tiny vectors
which bring dengue must be stopped but the use of insecticides and other chemical
substances that can control them is very hazardous to human health and to the non-
4
target organisms. So, to answer the urgent call for an eco-friendly, cost-effective, safe
One of the plants that can aid humans in controlling these vectors is the Oregano
(Origanum vulgare). This plant is also known as Wild Marjoram, Mountain Mint,
Origanum, Wintersweet and Winter Marjoram. This erectly spreading plant has strong
aromatic characteristics, with leaves and stems that are fleshy. The leaves of oregano
are heart-shaped, with toothed edges, and which, grow for up to 9 meters in length.
Oregano contains an acid compound Carvacrol and thymol which are investigated for
their larvicidal and insecticidal activity. Similarly, Carvacrol has been reported to be a
very potent larvicidal compound, more toxic than Thymol, when tested against An.
Stephensi (Lee et al., 1997). L. sidoides essential oil and its main constituent Thymol
were shown to be very active against A. aegypti larvae (Carvalho et al. 2003). These
thymol and carvacrol acid compounds or essential oils are found in Oregano (Origanum
vulgare). May this study would pave way to the discovery of the eco-friendly,
5
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
vulgare) powdered dried leaves against Aedis aegypti. This experimental research
1. What is the pre-test result before the treatment of the following groups:
2. What is the post-test result after the treatment of the following groups:
groupings?
6
RESEARCH DESIGN
vulgare) powdered dried leaves as a larvicide against Aedis eagypti mosquitoes. The
data were taken after the pre-test and post-test treatment given to the Aedis egypti
vectors in three replicates. In each replicate, there are two groups of Aedis egypti in
second larval instar where there is the experimental group (treated with the powdered
dried leaves of Oregano) and a positive control group (treated with a commercial
approaches.
RESEARCH ENVIRONMENT
University of San Carlos, Talamban Campus, was the location for the specimen
identification. The mosquito larvae were sent there for proper identification in the
Biology Department. The powdered dried leaves of Oregano (Origanum vulgare) was
also identified by the Biology Department of the said university.
7
RESEARCH SPECIMEN
The sample specimens of the experimental study were randomly selected in a jar
of clean water placed beside in one of the classrooms at Kalawisan Elementary School,
where the researchers are studying and alarming cases of dengue have been reported
every year. There were many larvae in the jar, nevertheless, only 60 larvae were used
in the experiment. The experiment was in three replicates, 10 larvae were placed in
each plastic cup. The specimens must be second instar larvae of the dengue-carrying
RESEARCH INSTRUMENTS
Only the apparatus necessary for the specimen identification were acquired from
the Biology Department of the University of San Carlos, Talamban Campus. On the
other hand, some of the instruments used in the conduct of the study are readily
Two Medicine Droppers were used to transfer the specimen from its cultured habitat
in to the plastic cups for experimentation. These were used for the proper transfer of
the specimens and to avoid exerting force on the larvae which may cause its death
8
6 Plastic Cups, where the specimens were placed for experimentation and treatment.
Plastic Jar with clean water, where mosquito larvae were cultured before
Two Magnifying Glasses were used to check if there are already larvae in the jar of
water.
Two Reagent Bottles, where the powdered dried leaves of the Oregano (Origanum
Three Mortars and Pestles were used in grinding and powdering the air-dried leaves
Two Plastic Trays were the Oregano (Origanum vulgare) fresh leaves were placed.
9
RESEARCH PROCEDURES
GATHERING OF DATA
Sampling Procedure
in a jar of clean water which were identified as second larval instar of the dengue-
carrying mosquito, Aedis egypti. The Oregano (Origanum vulgare) leaves were obtained
in the school vicinity and in the Barangay, where the study is conducted. Oregano plant
is very common in the said Barangay that you can see it in anywhere within the
Barangay’s jurisdiction, in the nearby Barangays and even in the whole country and
The researchers sought the expert services of the Biology Department of the
University of San Carlos, Talamban Campus, for the proper identification of the species
The Oregano (Origanum vulgare) fresh leaves were randomly gathered in the
vicinity of Barangay Calawisan where the plant is very common and widely spread. This
is where Kalawisan Elementary School situated, where the study is conducted. The
were placed in a tray and were air – dried. The air – dried leaves of Oregano (Origanum
10
vulgare) were manually grounded and powdered using mortar and pestle. After being
grounded, the powdered leaves were placed in a clean Reagent bottles for storage
before use.
The plastic cups were washed properly with distilled water. After washing, 200
mL of distilled water was poured in each plastic cup where second instar mosquito
Using the medicine droppers, the larvae were transferred from its cultured
habitat in to the plastic cups filled with 200 mL distilled water. There must be 10 second
The six plastic cups with ten second larval instar of the Aedis aegypti were
After transferring the Aedis aegypti second instar larvae from its cultured habitat
to the plastic cups, the Aedis aegypti second instar larvae were left for 24 hours without
treatment. After 24 hours, the larvae were observed and observations were recorded.
11
7. Application of the Powdered Dried Leaves of Oregano (Origanum vulgare) and
Pour 3 grams of powdered dried leaves of Oregano (Origanum vulgare) into the
plastic cups marked with A which is the Experimental Group while in the plastic cups
marked with B, pour 3 grams of commercial larvicide, Antimos 1. This is done after the
24-hour pre-test period. The pouring of the powdered dried leaves of the Oregano
(Origanum vulgare) and commercial larvicide, Antimos 1, must be done at the same
time. After applying treatment to both groups, they are left for another 24 hours.
Thymol, which have been investigated for its larvicidal property against mosquito
larvae.
9. Statistical Tool
and post-test results were tabulated and calculated numerically based on the
against dengue-carrying mosquitoes (Aedis egypti). T-test was applied to test the
12
DEFINITION OF TERMS
To take a full grasp of this study, it would be best to know the terms used, they
Aedis aegypti – a yellow fever mosquito, is a mosquito that can spread dengue fever,
Larvicide – is an insecticide that is specifically targeted against the larval life stage of
Oregano – is an herb that has juicy stems and leaves, that has scientific name
Origanum vulgare. Its smell is similar to a lemon scent. Its leaves and stems
has tiny hairs making it feel like a rough texture. It is high in Thymol and
and causing sudden fever and acute pains in the joints that may lead to
death.
Larvae – the active immature form of an insect, especially one that differs greatly from
the adult and forms the stage between egg and pupa. In the case of
13
mosquitoes, it undergoes 4 larval instars.
Experimental Group – the group in which the powdered dried leaves of Sugar Apple
Positive-Control Group – the group treated with the commercial larvicide , Antimos1.
14
PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF
DATA
This study aims to determine the larvicidal efficacy Oregano (Origanum vulgare)
1. What is the pre-test result before the treatment of the following groups:
2. What is the post-test result after the treatment of the following groups:
groupings?
15
STATEMENT OF THE HYPOTHESIS
Table 1
The Pre – test result of the number of larvae in each plastic cup before the treatment.
The data above indicate the initial number of Aedis aegypti larvae in its second
larval instar placed in a plastic cup with distilled water. There are 10 Aedis aegypti
larvae in each plastic cup for both Experimental Group and Control Group. All set-ups
received a negative remark or there is no change occurred since the subjects were not
16
Table 2
The Post – test result of the number of larvae in each plastic cup after the treatment.
1 A 7 70% Potent
Experimental 2 A 8 80% Potent
(Origanum 3 A 7 70% Potent
vulgare)
1 B 9 90% Effective
Control 2 B 8 80% Effective
(Antimos 1) 3 B 8 80% Effective
17
Table 3
1 10 7 -0.33 0.11
1 10 9 0.67 0.44
B. Control 2 10 8 -0.33 0.11
(Antimos 1) 3 10 8 -0.33 0.11
M: 8.33 SS: 0.67
Table 3 reveals the difference in the larvicidal efficacy between the Oregano
(Origanum vulgare) powdered dried leaves and the commercial larvicide, Antimos 1.
The computed t-value is -2.12 which is lower than the p-value at 0.05 level of
significance which is 0.05. The hypothesis which states that there is no significant
difference between the post-tests results of the experimental and the control group
18
The result implies that the Oregano (Origanum vulgare) powdered dried leaves is
not as effective as the commercial larvicide, Antimos 1, but can be the best alternative
source of larvicide against Aedis aegypti mosquito species since it also showed a
remarkable performance after killing 73% of the second instar larvae of the Aedis
aegypti in the Experimental group. Thymol and carvacrol are acid compunds present in
powdered, may serve as the best alternative source of larvicide against dengue-carrying
CONCLUSION
(Origanum vulgare) powdered dried leaves and the commercial larvicide which is
Antimos 1 against Aedis aegypti second larval instar. The potency of the powdered
dried leaves of the Oregano (Origanum vulgare) is not as high as the commercial
larvicide, Antimos 1. However, results show that the powdered dried leaves of the
19
RECOMMENDATION
3. Further experimental study on the powdered dried leaves of the Oregano (Origanum
4. Another experimental research about the powdered dried leaves of the Oregano
effectiveness.
Oregano leaves.
20
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The success and final outcome of this project required a lot of guidance and
assistance from many people and we are extremely privileged to have got this all along
the completion of our Research Study or Science Investigatory Project. All that we have
done is only due to such supervision and assistance and we would not forget to thank
them.
We respect and thank Mrs. Susan R. Obiedo, the school principal of Kalawisan
school and for giving us all the support and guidance which made us complete the
research study duly. We are extremely thankful to her for providing such a nice support
and guidance, although she had busy schedule managing the school.
We owe our deep gratitude to our research study adviser, Mrs. Noveim T.
Leoligao, who took keen interest on our study and guided us all along, till the
completion of our study by providing all the necessary information we need in the
whole duration of the project, from data mining or researching, collecting the specimen,
and good people who served as our support system in conducting the research study.
21
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Supavarn, P., W. K. Fred and S. Roy. 1974. Biologically active plant extracts for control
plant extracts as mosquito larvicides. Indian J Exptl Biol 1999; 37: 206–8.
Bhatt S, Gething PW, Brady OJ, Messina JP, Farlow AW, Moyes CL et.al. The global
22
Amer A, Mehlhorn H (2006a). Repelency effect of forty-one essential oils against
271.
Magadula, Joseph J., Ester Innocent, and Joseph N. Otleno. Journal of Medicinal Plants
https://academicjournals.org/article/article1380375244_Magadula%20et%20al.pd
f.
no. 1, pp. 113–114, 2004. View at Publisher· View at Google Scholar · View at
Scopus
M. P. Singh and H. Panda, Medicinal Herbs with Their Formulations, vol. 1, Daya
of Biological Sciences, vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 15–22, 2009. View at Google Scholar
23
M. Y. S. Ali, S. Ravikumar, and J. M. Beula, “Mosquito larvicidal activity of seaweeds
Yang, Young-Cheol, et al. “Larvicidal Activity of Medicinal Plant Extracts Against Aedis
against three mosquito vectors”. Asian Pacific Journal of Tropical Medicine, vol.
against Aedis aegypti. Journal of Arthropod – Borne Diseases, vol. 11(2); 2017,
June: 315-330.
24
Republic of the Philippines
Region VII, Central Visayas
Department of Education
Division of Lapu-Lapu City
District 8
Research Adviser
Noveim T. Leoligao
Appendix A
COMPUTATION
Treatment 1
N1: 3
df1 = N - 1 = 3 - 1 = 2
M1: 7.33
SS1: 0.67
s²1 = SS1/(N - 1) = 0.67/(3-1) = 0.33
Treatment 2
N2: 3
df2 = N - 1 = 3 - 1 = 2
M2: 8.33
SS2: 0.67
s²2 = SS2/(N - 1) = 0.67/(3-1) = 0.33
T-value Calculation
s2p = ((df1/(df1 + df2)) * s21) + ((df2/(df2 + df2)) * s22) = ((2/4) * 0.33) + ((2/4) *
0.33) = 0.33
s2M1 = s2p/N1 = 0.33/3 = 0.11
s2M2 = s2p/N2 = 0.33/3 = 0.11
25
Appendix 2
PHOTOS
26
The pouring of 200 mL water into the plastic cups
The transferring of
the larvae from the jar of water into the plastic cups
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Rationale
The Problem
Definition of Terms
Research Design
Research Environment
Research Respondents
Research Instruments
Data Analysis
Acknowledgement
References
Appendices