Contact Dermatitis To Botanical Extracts
Contact Dermatitis To Botanical Extracts
Contact Dermatitis To Botanical Extracts
148 American Journal of Contact Dermatitis, Vol 13, No 3 (September), 2002: pp 148-152
Contact Dermatitis to Botanical Extracts 149
bruises, painful swellings, wounds, and other injuries, as significantly diminished skin reactivity on sites treated
well as in cosmetic preparations. Numerous cases of con- with G biloba 2 days after patch removal. This study sug-
tact dermatitis caused by arnica have been reported.4 gested that G biloba carboxymethyl--1,3-glucan may di-
Arnica tincture has been reported to cause bullous derma- minish allergic contact hypersensitivity reactions.
titis after treatment of a knee injury and mild skin trauma.
Both cases were confirmed by patch testing with 0.5% Lavender Oil
arnica extract in ether.5 Lavender includes a variety of aromatic Old World plants
Hausen6 tested each of the components of the Composi- of the genus Lavandula (Lamiaceae), which have clusters of
tae mix to ascertain the allergenicity of each. He reported small purplish flowers that yield oil used for its fragrance.
that 51.8% of the Compositae-positive allergic patients Two cases of contact dermatitis attributed to lavender oil
reacted to 0.5% arnica in white petrolatum. Machet et al7 have been reported.14 One was precipitated by the use of
reported a case of allergic contact dermatitis from sun- lavender oil–treated pillows resulting from a news report
flower with cross sensitivity to arnica. that touted the hypnotic benefits of lavender scent.15 In the
other, acute facial dermatitis developed in a physiothera-
Centella asiatica pist after applying a gel formulated with lavender fra-
Centella asiatica is a herbaceous plant of the Apiaceae (Um- grance. Patch testing to lavender absolute 2% pet. (Che-
belliferae) family that is purported to enhance wound motechnique, Ontario, Canada) was positive.16 Fragrances
healing by stimulating fibroblast collagen production. Con- and aromatherapy oils containing lavender have been re-
tact dermatitis to C asiatica extract has been documented ported to cause contact dermatitis.17
in numerous cases by patch testing. Vesicular dermatitis Peppermint
involving the legs, thighs, face, and trunk were reported
from the use of a cream containing C asiatica for the Peppermint oil is derived from Mentha piperita, a member of
treatment of chronic leg ulcers. Patch testing with the the Lamiaceae (Labiatae or mint) family, which has small
cream and 1% C asiatica in petrolatum both gave positive purple or white flowers and downy leaves that yield a
reactions, whereas the cream base and the standard test pungent oil. The oil is volatile and distilled with steam
series did not. Another patient with a positive patch test from the flowering plant, rectified by distillation and not
result to C asiatica extract 2% alcohol had dermatitis of the dementholized. Peppermint often is used as a flavoring
legs.8-11 agent in toothpaste, candy, gum, and mouth sprays be-
Contact dermatitis to C asiatica also has been reported cause of its cooling effect. Peppermint oil contains at least
in patients utilizing a cream version for the treatment of 45% menthol, and contact reactions to it are associated
scars and morphea. Patch testing to 1% C asiatica powder in with a burning mouth, recurrent oral ulceration, or oral
petrolatum was diagnostic.11 lichenoid reactions. Menthol, a component of peppermint
oil, may be present in toothpaste, aroma therapy, lotions,
Cucumber mouthwashes, and cigarettes. Allergic contact dermatitis
and stomatitis from menthol have been reported.18,19
Cucumber (Cucumis spp.) is a tendril-bearing, climbing or Several cases of contact dermatitis to peppermint oil
sprawling annual plant widely cultivated for its edible have been reported. A 34-year-old woman with a 9-year
cylindrical fruit that has a green rind and crisp white flesh. history of stomatitis reported worsening with mint-flavored
A 50-year-old cook was reported to have hand dermatitis foods and oral products. Patch testing results to 5% men-
that spread to his face from handling pickles. Open imme- thol in petrolatum and 1% peppermint oil in petrolatum
diate skin tests on normal skin produced positive reactions was positive. Her oral discomfort was alleviated after elim-
to cucumber.12 ination of mint from her diet and personal hygiene use.20
Chronic cheilitis, perioral contact dermatitis, oral ulcer-
Ginkgo biloba ations, and burning mouth have been reported in patients
Ginkgo biloba is a deciduous, dioecious tree native to China. who patch tested positively to peppermint oil.18,21,22
It has fan-shaped leaves and fleshy yellowish seeds with a Sources of exposure included oral antiseptic sprays, local
disagreeable odor. However, despite its cross reactivity to anesthetics, and candy.21
one of the most potent allergens, no cases of allergic Orofacial granulomatosis of the lower lip was reported
contact dermatitis to G biloba– containing products have in an individual allergic to both peppermint oil and men-
been published. This is likely because of the fact that thol. His lip swelling was reduced after elimination of
extracts of ginkgo found in cosmetic preparations do not peppermint oil and menthol from his diet.23
contain the fruit pulp, which is the only part of the ginkgo Peppermint oil also has been noted to cause contact
plant known to contain allergen. However, Castelli et al13 dermatitis in fragrances and occupational contact derma-
showed in a double-blind study that 68.2% of subjects who titis in food handlers.24,25 Patch testing results in the
had experienced allergic contact dermatitis from “various aforementioned cases typically was performed with 2%
substances in the European standard series” experienced a peppermint oil in petrolatum.
150 Kiken and Cohen
subjects with suspected contact dermatitis were patch positively to 25% tea tree oil in soft, white paraffin, whereas
tested with a variety of common household spices. One had none reacted to d-limonene. One of 3 cases (33%) was
a positive reaction at both 25% and 10% sage in white allergic to ␣-terpinene versus 71% in Knight’s study. Nev-
petrolatum, and 2 more were positive to the 25% concen- ertheless, sesquiterpene hydrocarbons appear to be potent
tration of sage in white petrolatum.27 allergens in both studies.
biloba extract/sodium carboxymethyl-B-1,3-glucan formulation appears to 31. Kulze A, Greaves M: Contact uticaria caused by stinging nettles. Br J
inhibit the elicitation of allergic contact dermatitis in man. Contact Dermatol 119:269-270, 1998
Dermatitis 38:123-126, 1998 32. Mark KA, Brancaccio RR, Soter NA, et al: Allergic contact and photoal-
14. Rudzki E, Grzywa Z, Brno S: Sensitivity to 35 essential oils. Contact lergic contact dermatitis to plant and pesticide allergens. Arch Dermatol
Dermatitis 2:196-200, 1976 135:67-70, 1999
15. Coulson IH, Ali Khan AS: Facial “pillow” dermatitis due to lavender oil 33. Apted JH: Contact dermatitis associated with the use of tea tree oil. Aust
allergy. Contact Dermatitis 41:111, 1999 J Dermatol 32:177, 1991
16. Rademaker M: Allergic contact dermatitis from lavender fragrance in 34. De Groot AC, Weyland JW: Systemic contact dermatitis from tea tree oil.
Difflam gel. Contact Dermatitis 31:58-59, 1994
Contact Dermatitis 27:279-280, 1992
17. Schaller M, Korting HC: Allergic airborne contact dermatitis from essen-
35. Knight TE, Hausen BM: Melaleuca oil (tea tree oil) dermatitis. J Am Acad
tial oils used in aromatheraphy. Clin Experiment Dermatol 20:143-145,
Dermatol 30:423-427, 1994
1995
36. Rubel D, Freeman S, Southwellk IA: Tea tree oil allergy: What is the
18. Camarasa G, Alomar A: Menthol dermatitis from cigarettes. Contact
Dermatitis 4:169-170, 1976 offending agent? Report of three cases of tea tree oil allergy and review of
19. Papa CM, Shelley WB: Menthol hypersensitivity. J Am Med Associat the literature. Aust J Dermatol 39:244-247, 1998
189:100-102, 1964 37. Maibach HI, Akerson JM, Marzulli FN, et al: The concentrations and
20. Fleming CJ, Forsyth AD: 5 patch test reactions to menthol and pepper- vehicles for dermatological testing of cosmetic ingedients. Contact Der-
mint. Contact Dermatitis 38:337-365, 1998 matitis 6:369-400, 1980
21. Wilkinson SM, Beck MH: Allergic contact dermatitis from menthol in 38. Grandlund H: Contact allergy to witch hazel. Contact Dermatitis 31:195,
peppermint. Contact Dermatitis 30:42-43, 1994 1994
22. Dooms-Goosen A, De Greef C, Holvuet C, et al: Turpentine-induced 39. Rudzki E, Grzywa Z: Dermatitis from arnica montanna. Contact Derma-
hypersensitivity to peppermint oil. Contact Dermatitis 3:304-308, 1977 titis 3:281-282, 1977
23. Lewis FM, Shan M, Gawkrudger DJ: Contact sensitivity to food additives 40. Tyler VE: The new age of herbals: A pharmacognosy renaissance. J Am
can cause oral and perioral symptoms. Contact Dermatitis 33:429-430, Pharm Assoc (Wash) 39:11-12, 1999
1995 41. Fajita K, Teradara R, Nagatsu T: Bradykinase activity of aloe extract.
24. Calnan CD: Oil of Cloves, laurel, lavender, peppermint. Contact Derma- Biochem Pharmacol 25:205, 1976
titis Newsletter 7:148, 1970 42. Huang MT, Ho CT, Wang ZY, et al: Inhibition of skin tumorigenesis by
25. Peltonen L, Wickstrom G, Vaahtoranta M: Occupational dermatoses in rosemary and its constituents carnosal and ursulic acid. Cancer Res
the food industry. Dermatosen 35:166-169, 1985
65:701-708, 1994
26. Fernandez L, Duque S, Sanchex I, et al: Allergic contact dermatitis from
43. List DH, Horhammer L: Hagers Handbuch der Pharmazeutisuhen Praxis.
rosemary (Rosemarinus officnalis L.) Contact Dermatitis 37:248, 1997
Berlin, Germany, Springer, 1972, pp 792-793
27. Futrell J, Rietschel R: Spice allergy evaluated by results of patch tests.
44. Grieve M: A Modern Herbal, vols. 1,2. New York, NY, Dover Publ, 1971
Cutis 52:288-290, 1993
28. Golsch S, Vocks E, Rakoski J, et al: Reversible increase in photosensitivity 45. Typer VE: The New Honest Herbal. Philadelphia, PA, GF Stickley and Co,
to UV-B caused by St. John’s Wort extract. Hautarzt 48:249-252, 1997 1982
29. Bossuyt L, Dooms-Goosens A: Contact sensitivity to nettles and chamo- 46. Duke JA: Handbook of Medicinal Herbs. Boca Raton, Fla, CRC-Press,
mile in “alternative” remedies. Contact Dermatitis 31:131-132, 1994 1985
30. Giorando-Labadie F, Schwarze MP, Bazex J: Allergic contact dermatitis 47. El-Hefnawi H: Treatment of keloids with asiaticoside. Dermatology 125:
from chamomile used in Phytotherapy. Contact Dermatitis 42:247, 2000 387-392, 1962