Ian Clarke

University of Nebraska - Lincoln
DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln

Student Research, Creative Activity, and
Music, School of
Performance - School of Music
12-1-2010
Three Works For Flute By Ian Clarke: An Analysis

And Performance Guide
Shelly L. Monier
University of Nebraska at Lincoln, [email protected]
Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/musicstudent

Part of the Music Commons
Monier, Shelly L., "Three Works For Flute By Ian Clarke: An Analysis And Performance Guide" (2010). Student Research, Creative
Activity, and Performance - School of Music. Paper 29.
http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/musicstudent/29
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Music, School of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been
accepted for inclusion in Student Research, Creative Activity, and Performance - School of Music by an authorized administrator of
DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln.
THREE WORKS FOR FLUTE BY IAN CLARKE: AN ANALYSIS AND PERFORMANCE
GUIDE
by
Shelly L. Monier
A DOCTORAL DOCUMENT
Presented to the Faculty of
The Graduate College at the University of Nebraska
In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements
For the Degree of Doctor of Musical Arts
Under the Supervision of Professor John R. Bailey
Lincoln, Nebraska
December, 2010
THREE WORKS FOR FLUTE BY IAN CLARKE: AN ANALYSIS AND PERFORMANCE
GUIDE
Shelly L. Monier, D.M.A.
University of Nebraska, 2010
Advisor: John R. Bailey
British flutist Ian Clarke is currently recognized as one of the leading
flutist/composers of today. His compositions have been performed at national
conventions and used in competitions hosted by the British Flute Society and the
National Flute Association and have been included in the Peters Edition reference of the
Edexcel GCSE (General Certificate of Secondary Education) Anthology of Music as a
music example of extended instrumental techniques. Many of his works, while heavily
influenced by popular music, explore unconventional sounds, using inventive avant-garde
flute techniques and notations that are unfamiliar to many flutists. Since there has been
little scholarly research done on Clarke and his music, the present document will be a
start, focusing on two solo flute works and one flute ensemble piece.
The first chapter of this document provides biographical information about
the composer, including his major influences and a list of his most significant works for
flute. The following chapters provide an analysis to aid in the performance of the
following works: The Great Train Race for solo flute composed in 1993, Zoom Tube for
solo flute, composed in 1999, and Within… for seven flutes, composed in 1999 (all
published through IC Music/Just Flutes Edition). The author has selected these specific
works because they are the most representative of Clarke‘s compositional style as well as
the best known and the most often performed of his compositions.
Chapters II-IV begin with a brief discussion of the background and genesis of
each of the three compositions, including specific remarks by the composer in his short
performance guides (contained in the preface to each work) and in correspondence with
the author. Each chapter gives special attention to the extended techniques in the
composition examined. Further discussion includes aspects of the formal structure,
unifying motives, and other prominent features of each piece. It is hoped that the
information provided will be of help to the performer in clarifying the structure and style
of each work, and in understanding the notation of each extended technique incorporated.
The concluding chapter provides context for Clarke‘s compositions and their use of
extended techniques within 20th-century flute literature.

iv
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ......................................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS .................................................................................................................. vii
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1
Biography of Ian Clarke .......................................................................................................... 2
List of Compositions for flute through 2010 .................................................................. 5
CHAPTER 2: THE GREAT TRAIN RACE ........................................................................................... 6
Concept ......................................................................................................................................... 6
Formal Analysis........................................................................................................................ 7
Performance Guide ................................................................................................................ 10
CHAPTER 3: ZOOM TUBE .................................................................................................................. 24
Concept ...................................................................................................................................... 24
Formal Analysis ...................................................................................................................... 27
Performance Guide ................................................................................................................ 32
CHAPTER 4: WITHIN… FOR SEVEN FLUTES ............................................................................. 47
Concept ..................................................................................................................................... 47
Formal Analysis..................................................................................................................... 49
Performance Guide .............................................................................................................. 59

v
CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................... 70
Common Threads, Context with the Flute Literature of Extended Techniques
APPENDIX A: Transcript of Questions Emailed to Ian Clarke ......................................... 76
APPENDIX B: Transcript of In-Person Interviews with Ian Clarke .................................. 80
APPENDIX C: Transcript of notes taken from master class at the National Flute ........... 84
Association's Annual Convention in New York with Ian Clarke
BIBLIOGRAPHY..................................................................................................................................... 85
vi
Acknowledgements
I wish to express my sincere gratitude to Dr. John Bailey for his continual support
and guidance through my doctoral program. He has truly been an inspiration to me as a
flutist and an incredible role model that I may only hope to aspire to as a teacher. Without
his dedication and patience, I would not have been able to complete this degree. I would
also like to give a special thank you to the members of my graduate committee, Dr. Peter
Lefferts, Dr. Paul Haar, and Dr. Albert Casullo who have shown their support through
guidance and positive criticism when attending each of my performances and as my
document readers. I am forever grateful to Dr. Robert Fruehwald, my former theory
professor at Southeast Missouri State University, for his support and assistance in this
project.
I owe a tremendous amount of gratitude to Ian Clarke for not only composing the
exciting flute literature which I was able to research for this document, but also for taking
the time to answer my many questions throughout the document process.
I am especially grateful for all of my students, friends, and family, as they have
given their unending support and encouragement through my completion of this doctoral
degree.
vii
ILLUSTRATIONS
Table Title Page
1 A List of Compositions for flute by Ian Clarke through 2010 5
2 Formal Structure, The Great Train Race, B-foot Version 7
3 Use of Extended Techniques in The Great Train Race 10
4 Formal Structure, Zoom Tube 27
5 Use of Extended Techniques in Zoom Tube 32
6 Formal Structure, Within… For Seven Flutes 49
7 Use of Extended Techniques in Within… For Seven Flutes 59
8 Positioning of Flute Choir 60
9 Selected Unaccompanied Flute Literature Containing 71

Extended Techniques Similar to Those in Clarke‘s Compositions
10 Comparison of Clarke‘s Zoom Tube with Works by Dick and 72

Stockhausen
11 Notation in Robert Dick‘s Flying Lessons, Vol. I-Six 73

Contemporary Concert Etudes
12 Employment of Notation in Stockhausen‘s X I 74
13 Reference List of Selected Literature for Flute Choir that 75

Incorporates Avant-garde Techniques
Example Title Page
1 The Great Train Race, mm. 1-4, introduction. 7
2 The Great Train Race, m. 30, transition. 8
3 The Great Train Race, mm. 31-33, B Section. 8

viii
4 The Great Train Race, mm. 54-57, end of B section. 9
5 The Great Train Race, mm. 75-79, Section C. 9
6 The Great Train Race, mm. 1-2, demonstrates residual breathy tone. 11
7 The Great Train Race, mm. 5-11, explosive harmonics. 13
8 The Great Train Race, mm. 17-23, A Section. 14
9 The Great Train Race, m. 30, chromatic scale. 15
10 The Great Train Race, mm. 31-33, use of multiphonics. 16
11 The Great Train Race, mm. 38-41, multiphonics. 16
14 The Great Train Race, mm. 58-61, steam whistle effect. 17
15 The Great Train Race, mm. 62-64, return of the A section. 18
16 Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century, timbral trill, pg. 196. 19
17 Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century, microtonal trill, 19

pg. 76.
18 The Great Train Race, m. 74, suggested trill fingering. 20
19 The Great Train Race, m. 75, complex notation of trill. 20
20 The Great Train Race, mm. 76-79, Clarke‘s timbral trill. 20
21 The Great Train Race, m. 84, timbral trill. 21
22 The Great Train Race, mm. 86-88, end of Section C. 22
23 The Great Train Race, mm. 100-101, transition to codetta. 23
24 The Great Train Race, mm. 102-104, codetta. 23
25 Zoom Tube, mm. 1-4, introduction and first theme. 28
26 Zoom Tube, m. 22, transition. 28

ix
27 Zoom Tube, mm. 23-24, second theme. 28
28 Zoom Tube, mm. 47-50, transition. 29
29 Zoom Tube, mm. 51-56, return of second theme. 30
30 Zoom Tube, m. 78, end of B section. 30
31 Zoom Tube, m. 1, introduction. 33
32 Zoom Tube, mm. 3-4, opening of A section. 34
33 Berry, Musical Structure and Performance, 34

symbolic durational notation.
34 Zoom Tube, m. 4, use of unconventional notation. 35
35 Zoom Tube, mm. 13-16, singing and playing. 36
36 Zoom Tube, m. 22, use of multiphonics, quartertones, and syllables. 36
37 Zoom Tube, mm. 31-34, end of A section. 37
38 Berry, Musical Structure and Performance, Quartertone Notation 38

for Arrowed Accidentals.
39 Berry, Musical Structure and Performance, Tartini Sharps. 39
40 Berry, Musical Structure and Performance, Tartini Sharps and 39

Backwards Flats.
41 Zoom Tube, m. 35, B section. 40
42 Zoom Tube, mm. 37-39, unconventional notation. 41
46 Zoom Tube, mm. 51-56, transition. 42
47 Zoom Tube, m. 58, blues quartertone scale. 43
48 Zoom Tube, mm. 59-62, development of blues scale. 43

x
49 Zoom Tube, mm. 75-77, chromatic quartertone scale. 44
50 Zoom Tube, m. 78, vocal scream. 45
51 Zoom Tube, mm. 87-88, explosive breaths in coda. 45
52 Zoom Tube, m. 94, jet whistle. 46
53 Zoom Tube, m. 95, finale. 46
54 Within, mm. 1-9, opening flute solo. 49
55 Within, mm. 10-13, solo flute. 50
56 Within, mm. 10-13, tertian harmonies. 50
59 Within, mm. 26-27, start of B section. 52
60 Within, mm. 30-32, developing variations. 53
61 Within, mm. 42-43, dominant prolongation. 54
62 Within, mm. 46-48, melodic fragments. 55
65 Within, mm. 55-58, end of B section. 57
66 Within, mm. 99-102, finale. 58
67 Within, mm. 10-13, demonstrating dynamics to indicate phrasing. 61
68 Within, mm. 14-17, demonstrating slur markings to show phrasing. 62
69 Within, mm. 83-86, residual breathy tone. 63
70 Within, mm. 26-27, flute two. 63
71 Within, mm. 30-32, flute two. 64

xi
72 Within, mm. 30-32, flute five. 65
73 Within, mm. 36-38, flutes four-five. 65
74 Within, mm. 42-43, flutes three-five. 66
75 Within, mm. 46-48, flutes two-three. 67
76 Within, mm. 49-51, flutes one-three. 67
77 Within, mm. 52-54, flutes one-three and piccolo. 68
78 Within, mm. 55-57, flutes one-three and piccolo. 68
79 Within, m. 58, unified parts. 69

1
Chapter 1
Introduction
British flutist and composer Ian Clarke is currently recognized as one of the
leading flutist/composers of today. In the last ten years, Clarke has contributed greatly to
the contemporary flute repertoire. He has received invitations to travel to numerous
countries, promoting his music through performances and master classes. Many of his
compositions, while heavily influenced by popular music, explore unconventional
sounds, using inventive avant-garde flute techniques and notations that are unfamiliar to
many flutists.
Since there has been little scholarly research done on Clarke and his music, the
present document will be a start, discussing the biographical background of the composer
and then focusing on three works that are the most representative of his compositional
style. Chapter I consists of a brief biography of the composer, including his major
influences and a list of his most significant works for flute. Chapters II-IV provide an
analysis to aid in the performance of the following works: The Great Train Race for solo
flute composed in 1993, Zoom Tube for solo flute, composed in 1999, and Within…For
Seven Flutes, composed in 1999 (all published through IC Music/Just Flutes Edition). It
is hoped that the information provided for each piece will be of help to the performer in
clarifying the structure and style of each work, and in understanding the notation of each
extended technique incorporated.

2
Biography of Ian Clarke
Ian Clarke was born in 1964 in Broadstairs, a small seaside town in Kent, in the
southeastern part of England. His mother taught private piano and cello lessons, while his
father, who had played double bass in the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain
during his younger years, maintained a career as a professional chemist. At the age of six,
Clarke started playing the recorder, and then began piano lessons at the age of eight. By
the age of ten, he became intrigued with the flute—so much so that he embarked on
teaching himself how to play the instrument. His first private lessons were from clarinet
teachers, which he says is what ―laid the foundation for so many bad habits in the
beginning‖.1 It was not until age sixteen that Clarke began studying privately with
professional flutists Simon Hunt and Averil Williams at the Guildhall School of Music &
Drama in London.
During Clarke‘s childhood years, he listened predominantly to classical
music; however, with his introduction to rock groups such as Pink Floyd and his friends
taking an interest in the guitar, Clarke became fascinated with listening to and performing
rock music. In an interview, Clarke stated that it was at this point in his life that he
immersed himself in music; first in improvising and later composing for his newly
founded rock band, which he formed with his friends. Clarke stated the following about
playing in the rock band, ―Being creative with my mates started to push me outside the
normal classical track. It was through this experience that I discovered what a blues scale
was.‖2
1
Jessica Dunnavant, ―Composer and Flutist Ian Clarke,‖ Flute Talk, Vol. 28 No.7 (March 2009): 6-8.
2
Ian Clarke, Personal interview, 23 March 2007.
3
After Clarke‘s first year of college at The London School of Economics and
Political Science, where he was working on a degree in mathematics, he decided to take
the next year off and spend time polishing his flute playing skills. During this year,
Clarke remained in London and studied the flute part-time through the Guildhall School
of Music & Drama. He earned an income by teaching private lessons and playing in his
rock band. Despite his passion for music, Clarke returned to school the following year,
transferring to the Imperial College in London, and ultimately graduating with honors
with a degree in mathematics. While studying mathematics, he remained active with flute
playing by studying privately with Guildhall‘s Williams and Hunt, as well as flutist Kate
Lukas. He won an auditioned spot in the Imperial College orchestra and continued
playing in his rock band. It was at this point in his playing that he began to explore the
technical and expressive possibilities of the flute.3
After graduating from the Imperial College in 1986, Clarke continued performing
with his band. It was in 1986 that the group was offered the opportunity to record an
album. This breakthrough instrumental album, titled Environmental Images, was
recorded in 1987 for a music library company; it consisted primarily of new-age music
that utilized predominantly flute sounds and quasi-structured improvisation.4 During the
recording sessions, the producers continually requested that Clarke experiment with
creating a variety of non-traditional sounds with the flute. Clarke began concentrating on
the sounds that the members of his band were producing on their guitars and synthesizers,
both instruments that were capable of pitch bending, and then attempted to imitate those
sounds. In this experimentation, he discovered a number of new, interesting timbres
3
4
Ian Clarke, ―Re: Questions,‖ Email to author, 12 July 2009.
4
capable of being produced by the flute. In the end, despite having the opportunity to
record an album, the group soon learned that succeeding in the recording industry was far
more difficult than anticipated. In 1992, the group evolved into what is now called Diva
Music, a partnership between musicians Clarke and Simon Painter. Presently, Clarke and
Painter remain active with Diva Music, writing and producing music for film and
television.
While Clarke has had extensive professional training but no formal academic
musical training, his success as a flutist helped him earn a position in 2000 at the
Guildhall School of Music & Drama, where he serves as a professor of flute. Since then,
he has received invitations to numerous countries to give master classes and perform his
music. He has performed at conventions of the British Flute Society, The National Flute
Association Convention in the United States, and the Hungarian National Flute Event.5
In 2005, Clarke released his first solo album, titled Within…, containing twelve
works that the artist composed for flute. By 2006, Flute World, a prominent purveyor of
music for flutists, rated the album among their top-selling flute CDs. The music found on
this album is representative of Clarke‘s compositional style, which he says has been
primarily influenced by European pop and rock culture. The list of musicians and
composers he has looked to for inspiration include American jazz vocalist Bobby
McFerrin, German composer Karlheinz Stockhausen, American avant-garde flutist
Robert Dick, and British rock flutist Ian Anderson of the rock band Jethro Tull.6 Table 1
contains a list of Clarke‘s compositional output to date.
5
Ian Clarke, “Flutist and Composer,” Web, 30 May 2010. <www.ianclarke.net>
6
5
Clarke‘s music is acknowledged as new and interesting repertoire for the flute,
incorporating an extensive use of avant-garde techniques as well as traditional classical
structures that contain beautiful, lyrical melodies. His use of extended flute techniques
includes multiphonics, singing and playing, residual breathy tone, note-bending, timbral
trills, and flutter tonguing. These will be discussed in subsequent chapters.
Table 1:
A List of Flute Compositions by Ian Clarke through 20107
Flute and Piano:

Sunstreams, 1986
Sunday Morning, 1987
Orange Dawn, 1992
Spiral Lament, 1994
Hypnosis, 1994
The Mad Hatter, 1994
Spiral Lament, 2003
Touching the Ether, 2006
Hatching Aliens, 2009
Solo Flute:
The Great Train Race, 1993
Zoom Tube, 1999
Multiple Flutes:
Within…for seven flutes, 1999-2003
'Maya‟ for two flutes and piano, 2000
Walk Like This for four flutes, 2002
Midnight Creep for flute trio, 2009
Zig Zag Zoo for flute choir, 2009
Flute and Electronics:

TRKs, Ian Clarke and Simon Painter (flute and CD backing), 2001
Tuberama, 2008
Within… for solo flute and CD backing, 2008
* All of these pieces are published through IC Music/Just Flutes Edition.
7
Ian Clarke, "Flutist and Composer,” Web. 30 May 2010. <www.ianclarke.net>
6
Chapter 2
The Great Train Race
Concept
The Great Train Race was written in 1993 as a showpiece for ―the flute as you
don‘t usually hear it.‖8 This piece was written for flute alone, utilizing such extended
techniques as multiphonics, residual breathy tones, and singing and playing. It is
approximately four minutes in length and demonstrates how the flute can sound like a
stream train racing along the train tracks. The inspiration for this work materialized out of
a studio rehearsal with Clarke‘s rock band, when the producer told him that he was
playing ―too pretty.‖9 The producer said that he wanted to hear sounds that were unique
and rock-inspired. After some improvisation, Clarke realized that the flute sounded
somewhat like a steam train when multiphonics and note bending were combined in a
specific way.
According to Clarke‘s preface to the score, there are two versions of this piece:
one written for a B-foot joint and the other for a C-foot joint. The reason behind this is
that the original composition was intended for a B-foot flute; however, in order to make
the piece more accessible to all flute players, Clarke wrote a second version specifically
for flutists with C-foot instruments. Both versions are almost identical, only differing in
the first two pages and in the codetta on the very last page, right before the last
multiphonic. In the B-foot version, the first notes of the piece is a B3, while in the C-foot
version the first note starts on D4.10
8
Ian Clarke, The Great Train Race (Surrey, England: Just Flutes, 2001).
9
10
7
Formal Analysis
Table 2: Formal Structure, The Great Train Race, B-foot Version
Sections Introduction A B A‘ C A‘‘ Codetta

Bars 1-16 17-29 31-57 62-73 76-88 89-101 102-104
Key B major B minor A major G minor G minor G minor B minor
Areas D minor Bb major D minor C major D minor
With reference to traditional formal structure, Clarke has sectionalized this piece
in a simple design that can be viewed in classical terms as a quasi-rondo form (see Table
2). A standard Classical rondo most often has five distinct sections, with the main theme
stated three different times as here. Each return of the main theme is firmly stated in the
same key and separated by contrasting episodes in a related key. In contemporary music,
the idea of the rondo still exists, but the form may be altered slightly. The musical
structure of The Great Train Race demonstrates such an altered approach to a standard,
Classical rondo form. The overall musical structure of this work is as follows:
introduction, ABACA, followed by a short codetta based on the introduction.
Example 1: The Great Train Race, mm. 1–4, introduction.
The introduction states the tonic key of B major before the first statement of the A
theme. The A theme begins in bar 17, briefly in the key of B minor with a sudden abrupt
shift in bar 24 to the key of D minor. With the traditional, Classical use of rondo form,
the A theme is typically restated in tonic. However, that is not the case in this piece,
8
which sets it apart from the standard tonal plan of the rondo. As the initial A theme
contains two different keys, Clarke manipulates the standard tradition further by stating
each return of the A theme in the key of G minor. Bar 30 marks a transition from the A
section into the B section. This transition consists of a chromatic scale starting on F6
descending downward to D4 (see Example 2).
Example 2: The Great Train Race, m. 30, transition.
The B section begins firmly in the key of A major and employs new material that
incorporates multiphonics. Clarke establishes a new theme by alternating between
multiphonics on the tonic chord in bar 31 and the Neapolitan sixth chord in bar 32 (see
Example 3).
Example 3: The Great Train Race, mm. 31–33, B section.
In bar 38, the alternation between these two chords, with multiphonics, continues to build
intensity through an accelerando, which results in a climatic moment in bar 54 (see
Example 4), where Clarke incorporates a succession of these multiphonics. This sequence
ends the B section in bar 57.

9
Example 4: The Great Train Race, mm. 54-57, end of B section.
Section C begins in bar 74, with a new idea that Clarke calls timbral trills
(Example 5). This technique will be discussed in more detail in the performance practice
section later in this chapter. This section starts in the key of G minor and modulates to the
key of C major with a trill. This trill is accomplished by playing a succession of three
notes, beginning with E-flat, then D quarter-sharp, followed by C double-sharp. The trill
then turns into a more rhythmic sequence consisting of a 5-note sixteenth pattern that
outlines different pitched quartertones between the notes C and D. This pattern ends with
a molto rallantando into a sustained C (see Example 5).
Example 5: The Great Train Race, mm. 75–79, section C.
After the final return of the A theme, the piece concludes with a codetta in the key
of B minor, containing a much shorter repetition of the introduction. In a personal
interview Clarke comment on the unusual number of modulations in such a short piece:
―Life is like a river, it just keeps going somewhere new. I feel that way with keys;
moving to a new key makes it something new and more gratifying.‖11
11
10
Performance Guide
Table 3: Use of Extended Techniques in The Great Train Race
Introduction A Transition B Trans. A‘ Trans. C A‘‘ Codetta

1-16 17-29 30 31-57 58-61 62-73 74-75 76-88 89-100 102-104
Residual Flutter Singing/ Multi- Multiphonics Singing/ Microtonal Microtonal Singing/ Residual
Breathy Tonguing Playing phonics Notebending Playing Trills Trills Playing Breathing
Tones Quartertones Quartertones Quartertones Tones
Multiphonics
Explosive
Harmonics
The Great Train Race is meant to be a short, entertaining piece lasting
approximately 4 minutes in length. The biggest challenge for the performer is
understanding Clarke‘s notation and producing clear, effective extended techniques in the
service of a simple, fun piece.
The Great Train Race was conceived and written as a showcase for the flute ‗as
you don‘t usually hear it‘! It should be both exhilarating and fun for performer
and audience alike.12
In the preface to the score, Clarke provides a short explanation of each extended
technique employed and briefly describes how to accomplish it. The remainder of this
chapter will discuss these techniques and how to produce them effectively.
The introduction, comprising of bars 1–16, is rhythmically simple, consisting of a
straight sixteenth-note pattern; the unusual notation, however, is one that the performer
must study. Clarke notates the sixteenth notes with two different types of extended
techniques in mind: residual breathy tone and explosive harmonics. Clarke defines the
residual breathy tone as follows:
12
11
The breathy noise of the flute left when a proper tone is purposely not formed.
The notation of an open slashed note-head further reinforces the idea that a
conventional tone should not be striven for. A ‗B‘ should be fingered throughout
the first page (‗D‘ in the C flute version). The technique may be best described as
a ‗slight letting go‘ or ‗unforming‘ of the embouchure; pushing the jaw and
embouchure forward whilst narrowing the gap between the upper and lower teeth
will also help.13
The purpose of this sound is to create an image of a steam train beginning its race along
the tracks. The notation for this consists of typical-looking sixteenth notes, with the
exception of the use of open, slashed note heads, which indicate that the player should
produce the residual breathy tone, as Clarke stated above. The open note head is written
to reinforce the idea that a traditional tone should not be produced. Clarke also places an
R above the notes in the first bar to further stress the technique (see example 6 below).
Example 6: The Great Train Race, mm. 1–2, demonstrates residual breathy tone.
The notation used for residual breathy tones in this piece follows standard
notation used by Kurt Stone in his book Music Notation in the Twentieth Century. Stone
provides examples of what has become standard notation for extended techniques that
incorporate nonstandard types of pitched sounds through the instrument. He provides a
chart that illustrates the notation of different shaped note heads. This chart helps the
performer know what type of sound is to be produced with the written note head. He
13
12
illustrates a ―round note-head pierced by stems‖ that symbolizes when the performer
should provide ―sounds of air blown through an instrument.‖14
In order for the performer to produce this type of sound with the flute, the
performer must bring the jaw up and forward so the bottom teeth almost touch the front
of the top teeth. There may be an inclination to loosen the embouchure to create the
effect, which will allow too much air out of the mouth. This will become
counterproductive if the performer attempts to play the entire introduction in one breath,
as the composer suggests in his short performance notes. Clarke recommends that, ―If
this proves a problem then a contraction of the musical idea is more preferable than a
breath.‖15 In an in-person interview with Clarke, the composer mentioned that after
working with students on this piece, he realized that not everyone can sustain the musical
idea effectively in one breath. He has decided it is satisfactory to take one breath,
preferably after the last explosive harmonic in bar 10.16
Within the framework of the constant sixteenth-note pattern utilizing the residual
breathy tone, Clarke has implemented what he calls explosive harmonics. He defines
these as ―layered spreads of harmonics interspersed in the opening section building
intensity and reinforcing the rhythm. They are a result of short, increasingly energetic
accents produced by very short huffs of air. At their peak they should explode from the
bed of rhythmic residual tones.‖17 In order to produce these sounds, the performer must
move the embouchure slightly forward while bringing the jaw down to a more
traditionally formed embouchure, and then attack each harmonic with a breath kick from
14
Kurt Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century (New York and London: W.W.
Norton & Company, 1980): 31.
15
16
17
13
the diaphragm. The air speed must be quick and blown more into the flute rather than
across it, in order to create all of the harmonics. The harmonics begin to appear in bar 5,
where they appear one octave above the written B, and continue to get higher in pitch as
the piece‘s intensity increases. After the climactic moment of the introduction in bar 10,
the explosive harmonics begin to diminish and fade away.
Example 7: The Great Train Race, mm. 5–11, explosive harmonics.
In order to make the musical idea more effective and better mimic the sounds of a
steam train, Clarke indicates a brisk tempo, ―quarter note equals 184,‖ as well as heavy
accents on beats one, three, and four. To accomplish this effect along with the residual
breathy tones and explosive harmonics, the performer must make sure that the double-
tonguing of the sixteenth notes is produced with an extremely pointed and consistent
motion of the tongue that is supported with controlled air.
The final step in preparing this introduction is for the performer to give special
attention to the indicated dynamics. These dynamics are the last crucial aspect of making
the opening effectively sound like a steam train. The first bar is marked pianississimo
(ppp), and is continued at this dynamic level until the first explosive harmonic in bar 6, at
which point the extreme marking indicates a sforzando (sf). From this point, Clarke‘s
14
intention is for the dynamics to increase in volume to further accentuate the intensity of
the explosive harmonics. After the climatic moment in bar 10, the performer must return
to molto diminuendo until the end of the introduction. Clarke uses the terms perdendosi
and niente in bars 15-16 to indicate that this musical gesture fades away to nothing.
The first time through the repeated A theme in bars 17-21, Clarke employs
traditional notation, consisting of a basic straight sixteenth note pattern. Consistency
should be maintained in the rhythmic drive of this pattern. The performer needs to make
sure that beats one and four are held out longer, which will allow the melody notes not to
get lost in the repetition of the sixteenth note, B. In addition, the performer should make
sure that breaths are only taken after the flutter tongue on beat one in bar 21 on both
repeats. The next breath should be taken on the downbeat of bar 24 and then sustained
through the end of bar 29.
Example 8: The Great Train Race, mm. 17–23, A section.
The short transition into the B section consists of a descending chromatic scale
starting on F6 using the extended technique of singing and playing at the same time (see
example 9). Clarke does not demonstrate this effect through the use of different notation;
he simply provides a descending chromatic scale written in octaves, indicating that the
15
upper part be played by the flute and the lower part executed by the voice. Generally,
when singing and playing, the voice accompanies the flute one octave lower than what is
notated. In this score, however, Clarke suggests that the performer should try to have the
voice descend in a glissando, rather than sing every pitch individually. The gesture is to
be played quite fast, and therefore it is virtually impossible for the voice to sing the exact
pitches that are notated.
Example 9: The Great Train Race, m. 30, chromatic scale.
The B theme is meant to suggest a different aspect of a steam train‘s sound; it is
achieved through the use of multiphonics (more than one simultaneous pitch) alternating
between the chords A major and B-flat major. In bar 31, the first note, A, is played with a
traditional pitched sound and the C-sharp and E are played together through the use of an
alternate fingering (pictured in example 10) required to play both pitches at the same
time. Then, in bar 32, he changes to the Neapolitan sixth, outlining a B-flat major triad.
Again, the same concept applies, where the B-flat is played traditionally and the D and F
are played simultaneously. The fingerings Clarke provides for these multiphonics are
taken from Robert Dick‘s The Other Flute,18 and are the easiest to produce on the
instrument, since they are not sustained.
18
Robert Dick, The Other Flute: A Performance Manual of Contemporary Techniques (St. Louis: Multiple
Breath Music Co., 1989): 97–98.
16
Example 10: The Great Train Race, mm. 31–33, use of multiphonics.
The B theme contains multiphonics that require a significant amount of control
and stamina from the performer. The preparation for multiphonics should be approached
carefully. It is extremely easy for the performer to end up only playing one of the two
notes, usually only the higher note. The performer might practice the multiphonic by
playing each of the two notes separately. This will help the performer hear each note, as
well as make it easier to put the two notes together and listen for both to appear.
In bar 38, the tempo slows down drastically and requires a poco a poco
accelerando up to bar 54.
Example 11: The Great Train Race, mm. 38–41, multiphonics.
It is relatively easy for the performer to become carried away and accelerate too soon and
too fast. Care must be taken in the pacing, to portray the accelerating steam engine. In bar
46, Clarke flips the two notes involved in the multiphonic, in which the E is the lower of
the two and the C-sharp is the higher (see Example 12 below); likewise, in bar 50 when
17
the B-flat major triad is inverted. These multiphonics are more difficult to produce and
require greater care to ensure that both notes speak clearly.
At the end of the B section, after an important, brief silence, the audience finally
gets to hear the well-recognized sound of a steam-train whistle. To achieve this, Clarke
integrates the use of both multiphonics and note-bending techniques. He suggests that
there should be ―lip and head movement covering the embouchure hole‖ and ―the octave
E should be maintained.‖19 This will work more successfully if the first bend is much
quicker than the second (see Example 14).
Example 14: The Great Train Race, mm. 58–61, steam whistle effect.
19
18
The return of the A theme brings back the musical idea heard in the first statement
of the theme; however, Clarke wants the performer to use the extended technique of
singing and playing. Clarke notates this technique with standard rhythmic notation, only
specifying that the singing and playing should be done in octaves, the voice one octave
lower than the pitches written (Example 15). This may be difficult to accomplish if this
technique is new to the performer. Thus, the best way to approach it is to start by learning
the melody and achieving the ability to sing it without the flute. Next, the performer
should add the flute tone to the voice, letting the voice sound only as a hum.
Example 15: The Great Train Race, mm. 62–64, return of the A section.
According to Clarke, although this piece is not intended to tell a specific story,
section C may best be described as serving the purpose of a cliffhanger:
That whilst the title and composition emerged together, there was not an explicit
narrative that led the form of the piece. This section is the point in the piece when
you begin to ask yourself….will the train make it over the pass?...it‘s a hold your
breath moment….it slows, slows, slows, hangs, the train disappears from view for
a moment, then bursts out at a top speed on the other side.20
Section C begins in bar 74, where Clarke employs a technique that he calls a
timbral trill, which he defines as ―expressive decorations that are produced by trilling
between two slightly different pitches.‖21 According to Kurt Stone in his book Music
20
Ian Clarke, ―Re: Questions about GTR and Within,‖ Email to author, 26 February 2010.
21
Ian Clarke, Orange Dawn (Surrey, England: Just Flutes, 2005): Performance Notes.
19
Notation in the Twentieth Century, timbral trills are defined as ―trilling with the same
pitch‖22 (see Example 16). These trills are intended to give two different tonal colors to
the same pitch. What Clarke has notated, as a timbral trill, is comprised of three written
pitches that total a half step; E-flat, D quarter-sharp, and C-double sharp. Therefore, the
variation of pitch within the trill is too large of a difference to fit the strict definition of a
timbral trill and should rather be seen as a microtonal trill. This is clarified more with an
example given by Stone in his discussion on microtonal trills (see Example 17).
Example 16: Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century, timbral trill, pg. 196.
Example 17: Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century, microtonal trill, pg. 76.
If Clarke did intend for this to signify a timbral trill, he would have only written
one note, as in bar 76 (Example 20), with a specific fingering to alter the color in pitch.
However, in bar 74 (see Example 18), he notates the three distinct pitches previously
22
Kurt Stone, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century (New York and London: W.W. Norton &
Company, 1980): 196.
20
mentioned and states that this is where the timbral trill begins. Bar 76 is primarily a short-
hand notation of one pitch for the more complex notation written in bar 74 in the
rhythmic pattern of straight sixteenth-note triplets. Clarke gives specific fingerings that
are recommended to achieve each of the pitches. These fingerings are taken from Robert
Dick‘s Tone Development Through Extended Techniques.23
Example 18: The Great Train Race, m. 74, suggested trill fingerings.
Example 19: The Great Train Race, m. 75, complex notation of trill.
Example 20: The Great Train Race, mm. 76-79, Clarke’s timbral trill.
23
Robert Dick, Tone Development Through Extended Techniques (St. Louis: Multiple Breath Music Co.,
1986): 34.
21
In order to execute this trill, the performer should make sure that it is not played
too fast, as there are three separate notes that need to be heard and a rhythmic pattern that
is included to create the musical effect. By bar 76, Clarke notates a sustained D with a
standard trill sign over it, stating that the previous fingerings should be applied. The
performer also needs to give special attention to the dynamics that Clarke has written.
The trill is to continue at forte from the previous bar; by bar 78, however, the trill should
diminish to pianissimo. At this point, the performer is to repeat the trill as often as he or
she deems necessary, incorporating spontaneous fortepiano gestures.
In bar 84, both the pitches and the rhythmic notation change as well as the
fingerings needed to play the written pitches, also, these trills should be much faster then
the previous one.
Example 21: The Great Train Race, m. 84, timbral trills.
As the performer is playing this musical gesture, five distinct pitches need to be heard.
Clarke has notated them in groups of five so the performer can clearly distinguish what
the composer is suggesting. In order to produce these trills fast enough, the performer
needs to develop a clear understanding of the finger pattern. In the first group of five
notes, the best way to begin this trill is to start with the traditional fingering, starting on
C6 going to C-sharp; then, while fingering C-sharp, add the first trill key, then move to
the second trill key, then go back to normal C-sharp. The second group of five notes is
22
quite similar in fingering, only the performer must start on the traditional fingering for
D6, move to C-sharp, then apply the same pattern with the trill keys (first then second, as
above), and end on C-sharp. Once this pattern is learned, the performer needs to be able
to play this gesture as fast as possible. One must remember to practice these trills slowly
at first so the regularly pitched sounds of C and D are not overlooked. It is also
recommended to observe that in bar 86, the rhythm changes slightly to further develop
the effect of the written ritardando, ending with a fermata over the final C. The final note
should be exaggerated in length, with a crescendo to a fortissimo. For a more dramatic
effect, the end of the bar is marked with a fermata over a rest with the recommendation
subito niente, referring to a sudden pause before heading into the final return of the A
theme.
Finally, Clarke suggests that this section should incorporate circular breathing; as
with the introduction. However, the composer understands that not everyone can circular
breathe or even play this gesture in one breathe. He therefore recommends breathing
when necessary, as long as the breathing does not interfere with the musical idea.
Example 22: The Great Train Race, mm. 86–88, end of Section C.
The final return of the A section is an almost literal restatement of the previous A
section. The only difference is that in the transition into the codetta, Clarke notates the
final statement up one octave before the last of the timbral trills ahead of the codetta.
23
Example 23: The Great Train Race, mm. 100–101, transition to codetta.
The codetta (example 24) is a short, two-measure repetition of the introduction
that requires energetic reinforcement to help lead to the final note, which is a multiphonic
illustrating the final call of a steam-train whistle. This requires drive and energy until the
very end of the piece.
Example 24: The Great Train Race, mm. 102–104, codetta.

24
Chapter 3
Zoom Tube
Concept
Zoom Tube, originally titled “Groove Tube” was composed in 1999 and dedicated
to his wife, Carrie Clarke.24 This work is roughly four minutes in length and represents a
rhythm and blues piece for solo flute utilizing unconventional avant-garde techniques
employed by Clarke. With much acclaimed success from his first solo flute work, The
Great Train Race, Clarke recognized that if he composed another piece for flute alone it
would have to be on a completely new level in order for it to get the same reaction.25 As a
result, Clarke composed a piece that demonstrates how the flutist can "groove," and
revels in compelling percussive sounds possible on the flute. In the preface to the score
Clarke comments on the genesis of Zoom Tube:
New compositions are necessarily, consciously or sub-consciously, influenced by

other work. In the case of Zoom Tube there are many inspirations: rhythm &
blues, Bobby McFerrin, Stockhausen, Robert Dick, Ian Anderson & South
American flute playing spring to mind fairly immediately but I‘m sure there‘s
more if one wanted to delve further. Beyond this, I had an impression of what I
wanted to achieve and, since I am a composer & flautist, naturally enough its birth
was largely through experimentation and improvisation on the instrument. The
extended techniques and hence palette of colours was very much a means to an
end rather than just an end in itself. Amongst other things I wanted the flute to
groove, much as a rhythm guitarist might, so chords (multiphonics) and damping
techniques were necessary. When the human voice is used to groove an array of
percussive vocalizations are employed to imitate a drum kit or used as
interjections to further rhythmic suggestion. Therefore note bending, an array of
articulations and the voice were going to feature.26
24
Ian Clarke, Zoom Tube (Surrey, England: Just Flutes, 1999).
25
26
25
Zoom Tube is a unique composition that requires patience to learn, as it contains
notational intricacies that are at first not easy to decipher. It is the conviction and
dedication that the performer must give to the piece that will result in a successful
performance. Wallace Berry provides a motivational statement for the performer in his
book Musical Structure and Performance that states: ―The ideal musical performance, at
once moving and enlightening, mirrors the noblest impulses in human endeavor: that of
rational examination, that of powerfully significative abstract imagery, and that of fervent
commitment‖.27 In his article titled The Performer‟s Point of View, Leonard Stein states
that ―New methods of notation have had to be devised by composers in order to define
new modes of thought and traditional notation has in some cases had to be amplified by
other, often very unusual, symbols, which themselves require further verbal explanation.‖
He further states, ―The performers‘ reactions to the music may be seriously inhibited, and
may be discouraged from playing it at all. Although he no longer thinks of ‗interpreting‘
a work in the willful manner of an older style, he must still convey with some facility of
technique and a degree of personal conviction and identification with the work at hand,
based, first of all, on a faithful adherence to the directives, as he understands them, of the
composer.‖28 These statements have been chosen to provide encouragement to the
performer as he or she is about to engage in an innovative way of learning a composition
that will be exciting for the performer and its audience.
Zoom Tube, with its unusual sounds and techniques, is gaining popularity among
flute players in many countries. In 2006, Zoom Tube began to reveal its significance as it
27
Wallace Berry, Musical Structure and Performance (New Haven and London: Yale
University Press, 1989).
28
Leonard Stein, ―The Performer‘s Point of View,‖ Perspectives on Notation and Performance (New
York: W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1976).
26
was included in the Peters Edition reference of the Edexcel GCSE (General Certificate of
Secondary Education) Anthology of Music as an example of extended instrumental
techniques. It replaced Berio‘s Sequenza I for solo flute, which is the first modern
composition to employ the use of a multiphonic.29 Zoom Tube is located in the chapter
titled ―Expressionism, Serialism, Experimental and Electronic Music.‖30 Also, in that
same year, Zoom Tube was used as one of the required pieces in the preliminary round of
the National Flute Association Young Artist Competition, and was performed by flutist
Katherine Kemler in an afternoon concert at the National Flute Association‘s annual
convention held in Pittsburgh.
29
Robert Dick, The Other Flute: A Performance Manual of Contemporary Techniques, 2d ed. (St. Louis:
Multiple Breath Music, 1989), pg. 83, Berio: Sequenza I for solo flute.
30
Julia Winterson, eds., Edexel GCSE Anthology of Music (London: Pearson Company/Peters Edition,
2007).
27
Formal Analysis
Zoom Tube is cast in ternary form with both an introduction and coda. Table 4,
below, outlines its basic formal structure.
Table 4: Formal Structure, Zoom Tube
Sections Introduction A B A‘ Coda

Bars 1-2 3-34 35-78 79-86 87-96
(approximately
20 seconds
in length)
Themes Not Theme I: mm. 3-21 Development of Theme I: mm. 79-86 Development
applicable Transition: m. 22 themes I and II in No return of theme II of theme I
Theme II: mm. 23-34 the A section from A
section
Tonal Centered E Pentatonic minor D minor E Pentatonic minor B Major
Areas on D E Blues Scale F-sharp Blues E Blues Scale E minor
A Major quarter tone scale A Major
F Melodic minor F minor
D minor Chromatic quarter-
Centered on F tone scales
Division Not Simple duple Simple quadruple Simple duple Simple triple
of the applicable Simple quadruple Compound duple Compound triple Simple duple
Beat Compound triple Simple duple
Compound triple
Simple triple
The introduction is short, consisting of only two notated bars, and lasts for
approximately 20 seconds. The A section begins in bar 3 (Example 25) and introduces
the main theme, which has a "blues" flavor in E pentatonic minor. In bar 8, the theme is
altered rhythmically and is transposed to A, confirmed by the prominent A major chord at
the end of bar 8. The B-flat in bar 9 indicates a shift away from E pentatonic minor and a
move towards harmonies found in an E blues scale. In bars 13-17, there is an exact
repetition of the main theme, only notated one octave higher.

28
Example 25: Zoom Tube, mm. 1-4, introduction and first theme.
There are two main themes in the A section. The first theme is much longer than
the second, and includes a transition based upon a fragment of an F melodic minor scale
that includes quartertones. This leads into theme II in the key of d minor (see Example
26).
Example 26: Zoom Tube, m. 22, transition.
While the first theme is rhythmically straightforward in a simple duple meter
incorporating basic eighth and sixteenth note patterns, Clarke changes the rhythm of the
second theme (see Example 27), employing an alternation between compound triple and
simple triple meters.
Example 27: Zoom Tube, mm. 23-24, second theme.

29
The A section concludes in the key of F (bb. 31-33), with a single-note gesture on tonic.
Clarke notates that the flutist is to sustain the high F while introducing the voice singing
middle F and then descending chromatically to low F, and back up to middle F. This is
followed with a bar of silence.
The B section takes the flute in a new direction, now centered on D, while
focusing on rhythmic intensity and employing a unique combination of extended
techniques. The section begins in bar 35, where Clarke incorporates four short rhythmic
phrases of two measures, each separated by a measure of silence. Each phrase consists of
a repetitive, motivic idea that combines both residual breathy tones and spoken syllables.
In Bar 47 (Example 28), Clarke notates a continuous rhythmic gesture using
chromatic quartertones that becomes transitional material into bar 51.
Example 28: Zoom Tube, mm. 47-50, transition.
In bars 51-56, there is a brief return of a slightly altered second theme from the A
section that also integrates rhythmic motives seen in bar 47 (Example 29).
30
Example 29: Zoom Tube, mm. 51-56, return of second theme.
Bar 58 contains an F-sharp blues quartertone scale, which becomes the harmonic
basis for measures 59-74.31 It is at this point in the piece where Clarke assimilates all
ideas and techniques that have been heard thus far and shows how the flute can "groove."
In bar 74, Clarke begins to modulate to F minor, incorporating an ascending
chromatic quartertone scale in bars 76-77. Bar 78 (Example 30) is the end of the B
section and is marked by the same technique that ended the A section, only this time the
technique is opposite in pitch direction and the performer is to end the note with a loud,
robust vocal scream using the word ―yow.‖
Example 30: Zoom Tube, m. 78, end of B section.
31
31
The return of the A section begins in bar 79 in the key of E pentatonic minor;
however, it is altered slightly from its initial presentation. Clarke employs more extended
techniques in this section and brings back only the first theme.
On beat three of bar 86, Clarke uses a fragment of a descending chromatic
quartertone scale that serves as a transition into the coda; a technique employed in earlier
sections that also functioned as a transition.32 The coda draws upon material found in
both the A and B sections, and contains extended techniques that have not been heard
thus far in the piece. Harmonically, Clarke introduces new key areas in the coda that
contain a parallel relationship to key areas already heard. In bar 87, Clarke establishes the
key of B major, which in retrospect is heard as the dominant of the final tonic E,
established with a final descending E Dorian scale. This final stroke provides tonal
closure, bringing the listener back to the first well-established tonic of the opening
primary theme.
32
32
Performance Guide
It is imperative that before attempting to learn Zoom Tube, the performer read the
notes in the preface of the score to help understand how to perform this piece:
It is possible to approach this piece without too much experience with extended
techniques but clearly it is a different proposition to learning a more conventional
composition and some background work would be advisable; for example practice
of singing & playing which will be unfamiliar to many players. Expect to take a
little more time to get used to the notation and techniques – particularly the
various fingerings employed for multiphonics and quartertones. Bars 76 & 77
may be particularly challenging! Even though most things are easier than they
look, this is unlikely to be a piece to learn in days! Having said that, I hope that it
is fun and rewarding to learn and that you will enjoy the unraveling process!33
Many of the notations and techniques are quite new to most performers. It will take time
and patience to understand what the composer wants from his notation. Table 5 lists all of
the extended techniques used in Zoom Tube.
Table 5: Use Extended Techniques in Zoom Tube
Introduction A B A Coda
Residual Breathy Multiphonics Multiphonics Multiphonics Multiphonics

Tone Note Bending Note Bending Note Bending Articulations
Note Bending Articulations Articulations Articulations - Conventional
- Conventional - Conventional - Conventional -Slashed note heads
-Slashed note heads -Slashed note heads -Slashed note Residual Breathy Tone
- Shadow note heads - Shadow note heads heads Singing and Playing
Residual Breathy Tone Residual Breathy Tone - Shadow note Quarter Tones
Singing and Playing Singing and Playing heads Explosive High F#s
Quarter Tones Quarter Tones Residual Breathy Tone Jet Whistle
-Quarter Tone Blues Scale Singing and Playing Glissando
-Quarter Tone Chromatic Quarter Tones
Scale
Flutter Tonguing
Vocal Scream
33
33
It is apparent that the opening of Zoom Tube shares similarities to that of the
opening of The Great Train Race, where the residual breathy tone is also incorporated. In
his book The Other Flute, Robert Dick states the following about residual tones:
Residual tones are noise-like resonances of the tube of the flute, usually
consisting of a very weak fundamental and a few higher partials, and are often
heard with natural harmonics. They are very easily produced, and can be played
alone or, at low dynamic levels with whisper tones.34
This statement applies to what Clarke has notated in the opening of Zoom Tube. The
notation suggests the use of a residual breathy tone, and indicates that the performer
begin on the fundamental note D and then start progressively sliding the fingers from the
holes on the flute from the D to A. As the performer slides the fingers across the flute and
increases air to intensify the dynamics, the natural harmonics will appear. For the residual
breathy tone, it might be helpful to bring the jaw up and more forward, so the bottom
teeth almost touch in front of the top teeth in order to accomplish this technique. Clarke
recommends that this be in one breath for the musical effect to be exciting.
Example 31: Zoom Tube, m. 1, introduction.
The first two measures of the A section demonstrate three different types of
extended techniques. The melody begins with the use of a multiphonic, followed by note
bending that leads into a unique technique not typically seen in avant-garde flute
34
Robert Dick, The Other Flute: A Performance Manual of Contemporary Techniques, 2d ed. (St. Louis:
Multiple Breath Music, 1989).
34
repertoire. At the end of beat two, in bar three (see Example 32), Clarke has notated a
rhythmic value but has left off the note head.
Example 32: Zoom Tube, mm. 3-4, opening of A section.
According to Wallace Berry, this type of notation is called symbolic durational
notation, which indicates that when a composer is using a traditional five-line staff, stems
should be drawn in the appropriate direction to illustrate approximate pitches.35
Example 33: Berry, pg. 66, symbolic durational notation.
Clarke follows this style of notation when writing the different types of note heads used
throughout Zoom Tube. With the absence of a note head, Clarke indicates this articulation
as a shadow note that produces a light, dry sound with a ―ke‖ articulation. In bar 4
(Example 34), the open note head with a slash through it signifies the note to be played
with the residual breathy tone technique (as in The Great Train Race) using the
articulated ―ke‖ syllable.
35
Wallace Berry, Musical Structure and Performance (New Haven and London: Yale University Press,
1989) pg 66.
35
Example 34: Zoom Tube, m. 4, use of unconventional notation.
However, it is not just one sounding pitch that needs to be heard with this musical idea.
Clarke has written the same multiphonic found at the beginning of bar three on beat one,
which requires the same fingering that he suggested to sound the A and B pitches
simultaneously, only now with the residual breathy tone technique. In the preface to the
score, Clarke indicates that in order to achieve these articulations correctly, the performer
should place the embouchure in a looser, open position, as if the mouth is in a normal
speech position when speaking the given articulation and allowing for the flute to act as
an extra tool.36 These unusual types of articulations are integrated throughout the piece
and have been developed with added decoration of multiple syllables as well as an
increase in dynamic levels.
Zoom Tube exploits the combination multiphonics with aspects of singing and
playing to great effect. In bar 13, Clarke notates the voice one octave lower to help the
performer remember which notes to sing. This technique is required on all notes that have
standard solid note heads, including multiphonics.
36
36
Example 35: Zoom Tube, mm. 13-16, singing and playing.
Bar 22 is transitional material that leads into the second theme and utilizes six
consecutive multiphonics. Clarke gives the specific fingerings necessary to achieve the
pitches notated and intersperses short sixteenth note gestures of residual breathy tones.
The performer must execute this measure with precision, making a distinction between
the rhythmic groove against the multiphonics and the residual breathy tones incorporating
the dry syllable ―ke.‖ It might be helpful to approach this measure by first learning how
the exact rhythms are notated, then trying to learn the new fingerings for the multiphonics
and where they occur on the beat. Finally, the performer should begin to add the residual
breathy tones and ―ke‖ syllable.
Example 36: Zoom Tube, m. 22, use of multiphonics, quartertones, and syllables.
37
Bar 31 (see Example 37 below) signifies the end of the A section and requires the
extended technique singing and playing, however in an unusual way. Clarke notates a
sustained high F which is to be sounded with the flute, and underneath notates a solid
note head F one octave lower with a line descending in the direction of low F and then
ascending back to middle F. As the performer is sustaining the high F on the flute, he/she
must sing the middle F with his/her voice and glissando down to the low F in a matter of
four beats, then ascend back to middle F in four more beats. While singing the descent of
the middle F to the low F, the performer must still be able to support the high F by
pushing a faster, more pointed air stream down into the flute instead of across so that the
high F does not drop in pitch.
Example 37: Zoom Tube, mm. 31-34, end of A section.
In bar 35, Clarke has created a distinctive effect that continues to employ the
unconventional articulations discussed earlier in the chapter. These musical gestures
utilize several techniques at once, which consist of a constant residual breathy tone, more
dramatic use of speech-like syllables sounded into the flute, note bending, and
quartertones. Clarke has chosen to notate the quartertones by implementing a half-sharp
or backwards flat symbol. In a discussion on microtones in his book Musical Structure
and Performance, Wallace Berry suggests that there are several ways in which to notate
quartertones. He states that:

38
Quartertones are used in different ways. They may be ornamental inflections of a

given pitch; part of a quarter tone scale or other set of pitches that includes quarter
tones; one of a number of microtonal divisions such as sixth, quarter, and third
tones. Because of this diversity, some quarter-tone notations may be more
appropriate than others, depending on the musical and notational contexts in
which they occur.37
Berry discusses two different types of notational symbols to represent
quartertones. The first, arrowed accidentals, demonstrates the use of arrows attached to
each accidental that identifies whether the pitch is intended to be a quartertone higher or
lower. Berry continues to mention that, although through the years there have been
numerous ways invented to notate quartertone accidentals, none of them contain identical
alterations for both the sharps and flats like that of the symbols used for arrowed
accidentals.38 The following example shows the correct notational symbol for arrowed
accidentals.
Example 38: Berry, Quartertone, Notation for Arrowed Accidentals.
The second notational symbol for quartertones (Example 39) that Berry discusses
in his book, is said to be the oldest symbols used for quartertones, implemented by
Giuseppe Tartini in 1756.39 This notation has its advantages and disadvantages according
to Berry. A quartertone sharp is written similarly to a regularly notated sharp accidental,
but with only one vertical line connecting the two horizontal lines. Berry further states
37
Wallace Berry, Musical Structure and Performance (New Haven and London: Yale
University Press, 1989), pg. 67.
38
Ibid, 68.
39
Ibid, 68.
39
that although this type of notation for quartertones is easier to read than the arrowed
accidental, it only applies to sharps, leaving out any symbol for flats.40
Example 39: Berry, Tartini Sharps.
In addition, Berry explains how there is not a method that has been developed thus far
that is comparable in consistentency involving quartertone flats. He states that the most
practical and unmistakable way to notate a quartertone flat is by writing a backwards flat.
Combining both, the concept of the Tartini sharps and backward flats signs have become
standard in avant-garde music for woodwinds.41
Example 40: Berry, Tartini Sharps and Backwards Flats.
In Zoom Tube, Clarke employs these two types of notational symbols (Example 41), to
represent which pitches are to sound as quartertone sharps and flats.
40
Ibid, 68.
41
Ibid, 69.
40
Example 41: Zoom Tube, m. 35, B section.
The first gesture of the B section, shown above in Example 41, is similar to the
idea implemented in the introduction. It begins on a low D at a fff dynamic level with the
performer ascending upward sounding approximated quarter steps by progressively
sliding the fingers (not lifting them) off the keys to A. This musical idea is written out
with precise rhythms that suggest the effect should be in a percussive style. Once the A is
sounded, further instructions are given that the performer must now gradually open the
rings of the keys by lifting the fingers from the D ring to the G ring. In addition, Clarke
writes a molto dim. that must take place while ascending through this passage. The
performer must now incorporate the sounding syllables suggested below the notes by
allowing an unformed embouchure set in a normal speaking position so the syllables will
be heard clearly. This also enables the air required to create the residual breathy tone to
become easier to achieve. This motivic idea is utilized in developed variations three more
times in bars 38-46 and should be accomplished in the same manner. The following
examples (see Examples 42-45) illustrate how Clarke has modified each idea just slightly
from the initial one in bar 35.

41
Example 42: Zoom Tube, mm. 37-39, unconventional notation.
Example 45: Zoom Tube, measures 47-50, unconventional notation.

42
Bars 51-56 draw upon material taken from the second theme of Section A.
Rhythmic drive and intensity are increased in bar 51 by a continuous sixteenth note
pattern and adding the use of multiphonics and occasional flutter tonguing. Clarke reverts
to the use of compound meter as seen in the second theme of the A section. The musical
gesture ends on a Bb-D multiphonic followed by several rests for a dramatic pause.
Example 46: Zoom Tube, mm. 51-56, transition.
In bar 58 (Example 47 below), Clarke notates an unconventional form of the blues
scale, employing quarter step passing tones to create a quartertone blues scale. Clarke
writes under the scale that the voice should be added to the performance of the scale at
the performer‘s discretion. In order to master this technique successfully, the performer
should practice a blues scale first before trying to work in the quarter passing tones as
well as the introduction of the new fingerings. Once the pattern of this scale is learned,
the performer should attempt to add the voice.

43
Example 47: Zoom Tube, m. 58, blues quartertone scale.
Clarke incorporates this scale as part of a musical gesture in bars 59-75 (Example 48)
representing the imitation of a guitar riff interspersed with a percussive drum kit. This
section of the piece is quite difficult because of the stamina and rhythmic intensity
required of the performer. It is suggested that the performer practice these measures
without any of the extended techniques. Once the rhythms are learned, one technique at a
time can be added until all techniques are executed simultaneously. This section utilizes
every extended technique that Clarke has written into the piece thus far. It is not a matter
of learning a new technique at this point, but rather how to achieve all of them at the
same time, and as a result, making the flute "groove."
Example 48: Zoom Tube, mm. 59-62, development of blues scale.

44
In bar 76, Clarke notates another chromatic quartertone scale (Example 49), the
most challenging passage in this piece. Not only are there several new fingerings to learn
in order to get all the correct sounding pitches in this scale, the notated articulations are
equally important. The articulations follow a simple pattern of a slurred group of four
followed by a tongue-two-slur two pattern and then repeated as the scale ascends to its
final note, high F. It is also important to mention that accents occur on the beat, as they
are part of the musical effect.
Example 49: Zoom Tube, mm. 75-77, chromatic quartertone scale.
In bar 78 (Example 50 below), Clarke employs similar aspects of the technique
used to transition into the B section that was mentioned earlier with Example 37.
However, he now includes a loud, robust vocal ―YOW‖ that represents the release of
excitement that has been building in both the performer and music. This should be made
with great force with the voice. It might help for the performer to think of dropping the
jaw and shoulders to have the feeling of lowering the depth of the pitch of the yell.
45
Example 50: Zoom Tube, m. 78, vocal scream.
Bar 87 marks the start of the coda that contains techniques that have already been
discussed thus far, as well as some new surprises. In measures 87-88 (Example 51),
Clarke adds a technique called explosive breaths, on high F-sharps. These notes are not to
be sounded with a solid tone; they are notated with an open note head, referring to the
residual breathy tone. This gesture is achieved by blowing the air stream very fast across
the embouchure hole, sustaining an enormously airy sound with just a hint of tone. Clarke
mentions in the preface that this effect is primarily for the health of the performer and
recommends that it is not necessarily supposed to be a clear sounding high F-sharp, but
rather a breath sound that is comfortably made by the performer.42
Example 51: Zoom Tube, mm. 87-88, explosive breaths in coda.
42
46
In bar 94 (in Example 52), the jet whistle should be approached by fingering a
low B as indicated and covering the embouchure hole completely by placing the mouth
over it. It is not necessary to roll the flute outwards in order to get the whistle to come
out, the performer only needs to blow air with great force getting the low B to respond,
then include an ascent up to the F-sharp.
Example 52: Zoom Tube, m. 94, Jet Whistle.
The final gesture in bar 95 (seen below in Example 53) consists of a descending
scale and should be approached with an immense amount of excitement with clear
syllables in the speech. Even though the gesture is descending into the low register, there
should be a loud crescendo to the E, making it the loudest of all the air sounded notes. It
might be helpful for the performer to think of putting a breath accent on the ―aaa‖ part of
the note E in order for it to be effective.
Example 53: Zoom Tube, m. 95, finale.

47
Chapter 4
Within... For Seven Flutes
Concept
Within is a unique work for seven flutes that employs powerful and reminiscent
melodic lines that continue to develop throughout the entirety of the work. It is nearly
seven minutes in length and demonstrates Clarke's unconventional use of avant-garde
techniques. Clarke initially began composing Within for flute choir in 1999, but it was not
completed until 2003. In an interview, Clarke admits that in the beginning stages, ―he had
no real inspiration for the piece.‖43 The idea emerged when British flutist Clare
Southworth approached him about commissioning a work. Southworth was putting
together a flute choir that would comprise primarily of prestigious flutists in the London
area and she wanted a newly composed piece for the group. However, with the busy
schedules of the members, it was difficult to coordinate rehearsal times and as a result,
the group never materialized.
Clarke did not work on the composition again until 2003, when he was asked to
teach at the Stratford-Upon-Avon International flute course.44 Although the premiere as a
flute choir piece was in Stratford-Upon-Avon in 2004, performed by course participants,
it had been previously performed by the composer, at the Just Flutes International Flute
course at Woldingham, as a solo flute piece with CD backing.45 Today, while the flute
choir version has become more popular, both versions are available through Just Flutes
publications. The version for flute choir is written for seven flutes, which includes
43
Ian Clarke, Personal interview, 19 May 2010.
44
Ibid.
45
Ian Clarke, Within…For Seven Flutes (Surrey, England: Just Flutes, 2005).
48
piccolo, four C flutes, alto, and bass. Clarke has scored the version for solo flute with CD
backing for one flutist, who needs a C flute with open holes and a B foot, as well as an
alto, and piccolo. The solo part contains the primary melodic lines of each of the different
flute parts in the flute choir version.46
In the performance notes in the score, Clarke describes this piece as ―A unique
evocative work with featured moments in all parts.‖47 Clarke comments on the title as
follows:
The personal musical inspiration, character, soul of the piece is rather difficult to
describe; this is reflected in the title perhaps. Some mileage maybe made out of the
fact that the original sketch was made in the same year as the solo flute piece Zoom
Tube was completed and, of course, it post dates Orange Dawn. Therefore musical
explorations of the flute and former influences were probably at play. In a technical
sense there can be some subtle and more obvious parallels drawn with these pieces
should the listener be familiar; which is not at all a requirement.48
He also states that the piece includes ―accessible extended techniques are
employed to give a powerful and extraordinary voice…a new experience.‖49
46
Ian Clarke, "Ian Clarke Flautist/Composer," available from http://www.ianclarke.net; Internet: accessed
26 March 2010.
47
Ian Clarke, Within…For Seven Flutes (Surrey, England: Just Flutes, 2005).
48
Ibid.
49
Ibid.
49
Formal Analysis
Table 6: Formal Structure, Within…For Seven Flutes
Form A B A1
Bars 1-25 26-70 71-102
Thematic area a b c d e f g h b1 b2 a1 i a2
26-29 30-33 34-37 38-41 42-45 46-57
1-9 10-25 58-70 71-78 79-90 91-94 95-102
Measures
Key Areas b minor e minor, A major e minor b minor e minor E major, c# minor
The A section of Within begins in the key of b minor with a flute solo played by
the first flute. This solo contains melodic material that sets the foundation for the rest of
the piece (see Example 54) through developing variations in both the B section and the
return of the A section.
Example 54: Within, mm. 1-9, opening flute solo.
In measure 10, Clarke repeats the opening solo, but states it up an octave,
introducing quartertones and note bending in measure 11 (Example 55).

50
Example 55: Within, mm. 10-13, solo flute.
The harmonic language of Within is characteristic of many of Clarke‘s work. In
the A section, Clarke notates tertian harmonies with added 11ths or 13ths, which is a
common practice in the genres of music influential in Clarke's compositional style: jazz
and popular music. This is seen in bar 11, where Clarke notates an e minor and d minor
chord written together, or rather an e minor ninth chord with an added 11th. A similar
occurrence is in bar 12, where Clarke writes a b minor ninth chord with the added 11th
(see Example 56).
GM7 em9 (add 11) bm9 (add 11)-----------------------------
Example 56: Within, mm. 10-13, tertian harmonies.

51
Another example of Clarke‘s harmonic vocabulary characteristic of jazz and
popular music are seen in Example 57, where, in bar 18, Clarke has written an e minor
ninth chord with an added 6th (C-sharp).
em 9(add 6) ----------------------------------------------- G+ G#m A4/3 (add 11)
As seen in Example 58 below, Clarke sets up a minor plagal cadence (iv-I) by writing an
e minor ninth chord with the added 11th that sustains through bars 22-23, and then the A
major chord in bar 24.

52
em9 (add 11) ----------------------------------------------------- AM (Plagal Cadence)
The B section starts in bar 26 and remains in the key of e minor. This section
begins in four bar phrases, incorporating various extended techniques. In measures 26-29
(see Example 59), all parts are holding whole notes with residual breathy tones as the
second flute begins articulating spoken syllables into the flute while incorporating the
residual breathy tones, all with a strict rhythmic pulse.
em---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 59: Within, mm. 26-27, start of B section.

53
In bar 30, Clarke develops the rhythmic idea previously heard in bar 26 in the
second flute by notating continuous sixteenth notes and incorporating several different
extended techniques: residual breathy tones, spoken syllables, and dry-spoken
articulations (Example 60). One more idea emerges in the fifth flute (this to be played
optional in the first flute part instead) that integrates the idea of flicking the A and G keys
while sustaining a tremolo between the notes E and F-sharp.
em-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 60: Within, mm. 30-32, developing variations.
In bar 34, the first flute enters, integrating singing and playing and quartertones in what
can be best seen as a variation of the first flute‘s solo in measures 15-16. In measures 38-
41, the first flute idea has been developed differently in terms of rhythm, still using the
same techniques as the previous four measures.
Transitional material begins in bar 42, when the texture is reduced with the exit of
the first and second flute. Flute three joins flute five with short eighth note patterns in the
left hand and sustains quick tremolo effects, alternating the notes G-F-sharp-E in the right
hand on beats one through three, with each measure ending on harmonic outbursts on
beat 4 (see Example 61). Also, in bar 42, the bass flute begins a constant, repetitive
54
eighth note pattern on each beat (resting on the upbeats) and in bar 44, the alto joins this
repetition only as a syncopation to what the bass flute is playing. It is important to
mention that in this transition Clarke begins to modulate back to the opening key of b
minor through the use of a dominant prolongation in e minor.
V in em--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 61: Within, mm. 42-43, dominant prolongation.
In bar 45, Clarke continues to develop melodic fragments of material previously
heard in the A section. The second flute enters with pick-ups to beat one of bar 46 with a
variation of the sixteenth note pattern that the first flute had in bar 34. The second flute
starts on the pitch A-quarter sharp and ascends to B-natural, while also singing and
playing. The second flute then rests on beat two while flute three answers the second
flute, on the remaining part of beat two with a short rhythmic sixteenth note motive
starting on F-sharp and descending through quartertones to F-natural. By bar 48, flute
55
five re-enters with a constant sixteenth note pattern on the pitch B3, which is suddenly
changed in bar 50 when Clarke writes the same motive found in flute three on beat two,
only down one octave (compare Examples 62 and 63). In bar 49, the first flute enters
playing the same gesture as flute two, only up a minor third.
bm---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 62: Within, mm. 46-48, melodic fragments.
bm------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 63: Within, mm. 49-51, melodic fragments.

56
At this point in the B section, Clarke builds the intensity by raising the pitches in
the first and second flute and adding in voices that contain the same gesture, for instance,
the piccolo‘s first entrance with the same idea in pick-ups to bar 54. Also in bar 54, flute
five continues the sixteenth pattern only now adding the harmonic. In bar 52, the bass
flute begins a sixteenth note pattern alternating a minor third, B-D.
bm----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 64: Within, mm. 52-54, .
At bar 57, the tension building in the different parts between the sixteenth note
patterns comes to a halt when the first flute, on beat three, plays with the breathy tones
while saying ―Shoo Sha Shi Sha.” This gesture marks the end of the B section.
While still in the key of e minor, the pick-up to bar 58 establishes the return of the
A1 section, where a variation of the b theme found in the A section is stated as a duet
between the piccolo and alto flute. The other parts continue to build and maintain the
57
underlying intensity with the repeating ostinato patterns that consist of mordant trills in
all parts except flute five. Flute five continues with the ascending b minor scale patterns
that fit together with the third flute part (see Example 65).
em-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 65: Within, mm. 55-58, end of B section.
Clarke reaches the climatic moment in bar 69 with an abrupt pause, and in bar 70,
there is complete silence. The pick-up to bar 71 begins with the bass flute playing a
variation of descending quartertone patterns heard in the first flute solo in the opening
58
theme of the A section. The bass flute is accompanied by the flute choir sustaining whole
notes using residual breathy tone. The solo is then passed to the alto flute in measure 76
with the continuation of the descending quartertone patterns. At bar 79, the solo develops
further by incorporating timbral trills.
The solo is then passed back to the bass flute in bars 83-86 in the key of C-sharp
minor and then concludes with the same statement of the solo heard in the piccolo. There
is a brief transition consisting of a four bar phrase with all parts playing the residual
breathy tone in whole notes, the first and fourth part playing sixteenth notes. The first
flute enters with the pick-ups to bar 96 restating a final variation of the opening theme,
now up a whole step. The piece concludes in the key of C-sharp minor.
c-sharp m---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Example 66: Within, mm. 99-102, finale.

59
Performance Guide
Table 7: Use of Extended Techniques in Within…For Seven Flutes
Sections A B A1
Bars 1-25 26-70 71-102
Extended Key Flicks and Trills Residual Breathy Tone Residual Breathy Tone
Techniques Residual Breathy Tone Syllabic Articulations Quartertones
Note Bending - Slashed note heads Timbral Trills
Quartertones - Shadow note heads Key Flicks and Trills
Key Flicks and Trills
Quartertones
Singing and Playing
Explosive Harmonics
Clarke provides performance notes in the preface of the score to explicate the
different techniques utilized in this piece. These instructions are similar to what has been
discussed in previous chapters; therefore, the discussion of performance practice will
pertain primarily to ensemble issues.
The author had the opportunity to observe a rehearsal of Within , where Clarke
worked with the Nebraska Flute Choir. He opened the rehearsal with a brief discussion
on part placement within the ensemble, suggesting an unusual placement of parts that he
says seems to work well when performing this piece. This particular set-up allows for
parts with similar lines to hear each other more clearly. Table 8 demonstrates this
arrangement:50
50
Ian Clarke, Rehearsal with Nebraska Flute Choir, Community Music School of Webster University (St.
Louis, MO: 19 May 2010).
60
Table 8: Positioning of Flute Choir
Flute five/ Flute three Flute one

Alto flute II
Piccolo/
Alto flute I Flute four
Bass flute Flute two

Conductor
As a flute choir begins working on this piece, it might help to take out all solo
lines and begin with just the accompanimental parts. The solo lines in flute one, piccolo,
alto, and bass require individual practice to achieve mastery of the new necessary
fingerings for the quartertone passages.
When rehearsing the accompaniment parts, the group should first work on the
residual breathy tones that occur in all of the parts in the A section. In order to save time,
it is beneficial to start in bar 14, where all accompanying parts have entered. It is
important to note that in bar 15 on beat 4, the filled in quarter note head with a slash
through it still represents the residual breathy tone, and does not require any other
articulation except for the initial attack on the beat. As in other pieces previously
discussed, Clarke notates the slashed note-heads to indicate the residual breathy tones. In
the performance notes in the score, he suggests the following in order to achieve this
technique successfully:
61
Bringing the jaw up and forward so the bottom teeth almost touch in front of the
top teeth may facilitate this effect. Although loosening the embouchure is
sometimes helpful, it is counter productive when trying to produce long phrases.51
In addition, each flutist should hold the flute in playing position instead of holding the
flute in a more relaxed, slanted style so that the air will go more across the embouchure
hole creating a bigger, airy sound.
Clarke employs slur markings and dynamics to indicate phrasing throughout all
sections incorporating residual breathy tones. All players need to follow these markings
carefully as they are an important element of the effect in the music. Each gesture
requires a soft attack at the beginning of each measure and then a crescendo to the end of
the measure, with a sudden shift back to the softer dynamic for the following measure.
Clarke notates slur markings to demonstrate the length of crescendos and decrescendos if
they occur differently in the measure. Refer to Examples 67 and 68 to compare how
Clarke notates this phrasing technique.
Example 67: Within, mm. 10-13, demonstrating dynamics to indicate phrasing.
51
Ian Clarke, Within…For Seven Flutes (Surrey, UK: IC Music/Just Flutes Edition, 2004).
62
Example 68: Within, mm. 14-17, demonstrating slur markings to show phrasing.
Once the group is able to sustain the held notes accurately, incorporating Clarke‘s
written phrasing structures, then the A section has been adequately rehearsed in the
accompanimental parts.
Next, rehearse the return to the A1 section, which starts in bar 83. The
accompaniment in this section is similar to the beginning, only now Clarke indicates a
sixteenth note pattern utilizing residual breathy tone in some of the parts, and the
sustained residual breathy tones in the other parts (see Example 69). The use of dynamics
and slur markings to indicate phrasing are utilized in the same way as previously stated. It
is essential to note at this point to make sure that the sixteenth note patterns are
articulated clearly.
63
Example 69: Within, mm. 83-86, residual breathy tones.
The next step is to begin working through the different techniques and rhythms
among the parts in the B section. Starting in bar 26 (Example 70 below), even though
there is no indication, the tempo increases slightly. This is important because the second
flute begins with an extremely rhythmic and percussive motive. This gesture employs a
strict rhythmic pattern while playing residual breathy tones and incorporating specific
spoken syllables. It is crucial to play the written rhythms, as they are central to the
percussive feel to this part of the B section. It is also vital to observe when the pitches
change in the second flute at the end of measures 27 and 29. Clarke suggests the
following in order to achieve this technique:
The „choo chi cha ke chook e chi cha chu ku‟ articulations in flute 2 are produced
with the embouchure in speech position to produce a variety of percussive breathy
sounds. The consonant and vowel are usually important to note; hence a „choo‟ is
distinct from a „cha‟.52
Example 70: Within, mm. 26-27, flute two.
52
Ibid.
64
In bar 30 (Example 71), the initial idea in flute two has been developed slightly,
now containing a constant sixteenth note pattern with a sixteenth note rest on beat three.
It includes the same extended techniques as in measures 26-27; however, it now utilizes
the dry articulated syllables sporadically within each beat (similar to a technique used in
Zoom Tube).
Example 71: Within, mm. 30-32, flute two.
The accompaniment lines are now given other musical ideas besides the sustained
breathy tones. Flute five (optional in flute one) has been given a sustained E trill while
flicking the A and G keys to sound the pitches B and G, while playing the repeated
rhythm notated (see Example 72 below). Depending on the proficiency level of the
group, and how many flutists are on each part, it might work well for multiple flutes to be
assigned to part five so that one flutist may play the trill while the other plays the
repeated, rhythmic pattern. Otherwise, if there is only one flutist playing the part, it
would be easiest to accomplish this technique by first playing the rhythmic gesture out of
context so that the rhythm is secure. Then, while playing the trill, start to flick the A and
G keys until it feels comfortable. Finally, establish the intended rhythm that Clarke has
notated along with the trill. If at some point this just becomes too difficult to master,
Clarke suggests in the score that this may be simplified by just playing the trills,
65
tremolos, and harmonic bursts, because by bar 34, flute three contains the optional
rhythmic gesture as well.
Example 72: Within, mm. 30-32, flute five.
In bar 32 (Example 73), the bass flute continues the residual breathy tones playing
the sixteenth note pattern that was discussed earlier. In measure 36, Clarke indicates that
flute four may have the option to play the repeated, rhythmic gesture intended for flute
five. In measures 36-39. Clarke notates short, harmonic bursts on beat four of each
measure in flute five that are crucial for the four-measure phrase leading to the climax in
measure 39, where these harmonic bursts occur on all four upbeats in that measure.
Example 73: Within, mm. 36-38, flutes four-five.

66
In bar 42, Clarke develops the previous material once again (see Example 74
below), beginning in flute three, with a simplified or optional part for flute five. Clarke
specifically writes out the tremolo at this point, suggesting a rhythmic pattern within the
tremolo. While playing the tremolo, flute three is to flick the A and B keys, playing a
modified version of the repeated, rhythmic pattern previously heard in flute five. Clarke
also employs the harmonic bursts on beat four, however, in a much more rhythmic pulse.
Example 74: Within, mm. 42-43, flutes three-five.
Also in bar 42, the bass flute has eighth notes with tenuto markings over them
followed by eighth rests. This ostinato pattern continues until bar 51. In bar 44, the alto
flute joins the bass flute, only the alto plays on the upbeats.
Once the lower flute parts have been mastered, it is time to work on the upper
flute parts, starting at the pick-ups to bar 46. Measures 46-57 are crucial in the first four
flute parts because, as the lower parts have established an ostinato pattern containing the
repeated, rhythmic intensity, the upper voices provide the foundation for building to the
climax of this section in bar 57. Flute two starts with pick-ups into bar 46, with a
sixteenth note followed by an eighth note leading to four sixteenth notes on beat one of
bar 46. Flute three then answers this gesture with a sixteenth rest followed by three
sixteenth notes on beat two (see Example 75). The next four bar phrase begins with pick-
67
ups into bar 50, in which the pattern continues in flutes two and three, and flute one adds
to the texture by joining flute two (Example 76). Finally, with the pick-ups to bar 54, the
piccolo joins the texture while flutes two and three increase intensity with the addition of
sixteenth notes on beats two and three, and all parts begin to ascend higher in range (see
Examples 77-78 below).
Example 75: Within, mm. 46-48, flutes two-three.
Example 76: Within, mm. 49-51, flutes one-thee.

68
Example 77: Within, mm. 52-54, flutes one-three and piccolo.
Example 78: Within, mm. 55-57, flutes one-three and piccolo.
It is necessary in the first four parts of this twelve bar section that everyone works
to achieve the rhythmic intentions Clarke has notated. In addition, it is suggested that all
players look over the fingerings carefully so that the correct quartertone pitches are heard
throughout while singing and playing.
In bar 58, the parts become more unified in flute one, two, three, and bass, with
continuous mordent trills that play under the piccolo and alto flute duet. It might be easier
69
to work this section by establishing consistency in the mordent trills among all parts, then
adding flute five with the ascending minor scale passages. Players should make sure that
flutes three and five pass the scale patterns back and fourth between the up and down
beats in measures 58-69 (see Example 80). This section then comes to a complete
measure of silence in bar 70.
Example 79: Within, m. 58, unified parts.
Only after the accompaniment and tutti parts have been successfully rehearsed is
it time to add the solo lines.

70
Chapter 5
Conclusion
Common Threads, Context with the Flute Literature of Extended Techniques
The purpose of this document was to provide a formal and performance analysis
for three well-known compositions by Ian Clarke: The Great Train Race, Zoom Tube and
Within…For Seven Flutes. In order to understand Clarke‘s compositional style, a brief
discussion covered his biographical background as well as influential musicians and
composers. The successive chapters provide a detailed analysis of each piece mentioned
above, including information concerning motivation, formal structure, and an
examination of performance issues.
While there exists a body of literature that examines flute compositions
containing avant-garde techniques, this is the first document that explores the distinctive
style of Ian Clarke. In his compositions, he utilizes ideas that originate from
improvisation, including non-traditional sounds, later incorporating these ideas into
written pieces using avant-garde notation. This notation is very specific with each
technique, allowing the performer to fully understand what Clarke intends in the music.
Table 9 provides a selected list of unaccompanied flute repertoire that contains
avant-garde techniques similar to those found in Clarke‘s music. The table is a reference
list for the reader who might be interested in exploring other solo flute literature with the
types of techniques discussed in this document.

71
Table 9: Selected Unaccompanied Flute Literature

Containing Extended Techniques Similar to Those in Clarke’s Compositions
________________________________________________________________________
Date Composer Title Publisher
1977 Aitken, Robert Icicle Éditions Musicales Transatlantiques
1958 Berio, Luciano Sequenza I Zerboni/Universal
1999 Brown, Elizabeth Trillium Quetzal Music
1993 Colquhoun, Michael Charanga Self-Published/Colquhoun
1983 Dick, Robert Flying Lessons Vol. I MMB Music
1987 Dick, Robert Flying Lessons Vol. II MMB Music
1989 Dick, Robert Lookout MMB Music
1971 Ferneyhough, Brian Cassandra‟s Dream Song Peters Edition
1962 Fukushima, Kazuo Mei Suivi Zerboni
1979 Heiss, John Etudes for solo flute, op. 20 JBE and Son Music Publishers
1986 Stockhausen, Karlheinz Xi Stockhausen-Verlag
1989 Takemitsu, Toru Itinerant Schott
The examples in Table 10, below, compare extended techniques in Zoom Tube to
those in two compositions that were influences on Clarke‘s style: Robert Dick‘s Flying
Lessons, Volume I, and Karlheinz Stockhausen‘s Xi. Three aspects of these pieces were
compared: the use of various avant-garde techniques, notation, and performance notes
from the composer giving detailed explanations of performance practice. The chart is
designed to provide further insight into the flute literature that was so influential on
Clarke when composing the works discussed in this document.

72
Table 10: Comparison of Clarke’s Zoom Tube with Works by

Dick and Stockhausen
Clarke: Zoom Tube Dick: Flying Lessons I Stockhausen: Xi

Primary Use of
Notation:
Standard X X
-Western notation
Atypical X X
-notation provided by
composer
Proportional X
Avant-Garde
Techniques:
Residual Breathy Tones X X X

Singing and Playing X X X
Multiphonics X X
Quartertones X X X
Note Bending/Glissando X X X
Articulations X
- Conventional
-Slashed note heads
- Shadow note heads
Flutter Tonguing X X
Syllable Vocalization X
Jet Whistle X
Harmonics X
Percussive Sonorities X X
Unusual Trills
-Tremolos
-Timbral
X X X
Performance Notes
from Composer:
Notes are in great detail X X X
Finger Diagrams X X X
-Includes new
fingerings
CD/Tape provided for X
demonstration
73
Robert Dick‘s Flying Lessons, Volume I - Six Contemporary Concert Etudes,
written in 1984, was intended as an instructional tool for the modern flutist. Dick‘s use of
notation includes traditional western notation; however, he also employs unusual signs
and symbols that alter the performance practice. When compared to the notation of Zoom
Tube, Dick uses a different type of notation for the following avant-garde techniques:
singing/playing, residual breathy tones, and quartertones. Below, in table 11, are
examples of the different types of notation found in Dick‘s Flying Lessons I:
Table 11: Notation in Robert Dick’s

Flying Lessons, Volume I - Six Contemporary Concert Etudes53
Singing/Playing =
Residual Breath = Resid.
Quartertones = quarter sharp =
quarter flat
Karlheinz Stockhausen‘s Xi: für ein Melodie-Instrument mit Mikro-Tönen
(pronounced ―ksee‖) greatly influenced Zoom Tube. It was written in December 1986 as a
Christmas present for clarinetist Suzanne Stephens.54 In the performance notes,
53
Dick, Robert. Flying Lessons: Six Contemporary Concert Etudes, Vol. 1. St. Louis, MO: Multiple
Breath Music Co., 1984.
54
Stockhausen, Karlheinz. Xi: für ein Melodie-Instrument mit Mikro-Tönen. Translated by Suzanne
Stephens and
Realization by Kathinka Pasveer. Stockhausen-Verlag: Kürten, Germany, 1998.
74
Stockhausen states that it ―can be played on any wind instrument having keys or valves,
or on a synthesizer having variable micro-scales.‖55 Currently, there are two realizations
of this piece: the first realized for basset-horn by Suzanne Stephens in 1986 and the other
realized in 1987 by flutist Kathinka Pasveer. The piece represents "a unique design for
the use of quartertones creating timbre changes and different dynamic shades."56 The
written notation can be bewildering at first; however, the performance notes provide
helpful insight to the performance practice issues. Common notational practice between
Zoom Tube and Xi were evaluated, concluding that although Clarke found inspiration
from this piece, there are differences in notational style. Table 12 demonstrates the
notation used for avant-garde techniques in Xi compared with the notational style of both
Clarke and Dick:
Table 12: Employment of Notation in Stockhausen’s Xi57
Quartertones = standard written notation with a slash representing

the direction in which to ascend/descent. In the realization, there is
standard notation as well as new fingerings provided for the quartertones
Singing/Playing = singen (the note to be sung is written in the staff)
Residual Breath: defined as ―coloured noise‖ (like wind) =
55
Ibid, II.
56
Ibid, II.
57
Ibid, II.
75
In Table 13 below, the author has provided a reference list for pieces that
contain traits in common with Clarke‘s flute choir piece, Within.
Table 13: Reference List of Selected Literature for Flute Choir that
Incorporates Avant-garde Techniques
________________________________________________________________________
Date Composer Title Publisher Avant-Garde
Techniques
1976 Medek, Tilo Departure of a Steam Train Magnolia Publications Flutter-tonguing,
Abfahrt einer Dampflokomotive Residual breathy tone
Special effects
1997 Offermans, Wil Kotekan Zimmermann Wind tones,

Harmonics
1995 Offermans, Wil Jungle Dance for Bottles Zimmermann Sing/play,

and Flutes Residual breathy tone
2003 Pearce, Ann C. Serendipity ALRY Use headjoint only
1996 Rearick, Martha Avant-Garde Sampler Falls House Press Use headjoint only
Note bending, Key
clicks, Measured
vibrato, Sing/play,
Alternate fingerings for
effects, Flutter
tonguing
It is hoped that the discussion contained in this document will provide flutists
with a deeper understanding of the music by Ian Clarke. Using this document as a
resource for formal analysis and performance practice issues should help the reader and
performer understand the importance of preparing Clarke‘s music for performance.

76
Appendix A
Transcript of Questions Emailed to Ian Clarke
February 24, 2010
Shelly Monier: Concerning the character of the timbral trill section, did you intend for
this section to represent a "cliffhanger" as in part of a story?
Ian Clarke: I think that the 'cliffhanger' description probably better fits this section
....'will the train make it over the pass? ... it's a 'hold your breath' moment! ... it slows,
slows, slows, hangs .... the train disappears from view for a moment ... then bursts out at
top speed the other side. However, it might be worth saying that whilst the title and
composition emerged together there was not an explicit narrative that led the form of the
piece. I sometimes tell a story when I perform, as you know, but this is a fun description
of what you might imagine as you listen to the piece rather than the story that led to the
composition of the piece. For example I sometimes mention the film Dumbo as I recall
that there is an anthropomorphized train in it that the gets faster and faster. This is an
image that occurred to me sometime after the piece was finished. Coincidentally, Robert
Dick also sat and watched Dumbo with our children at our house once .... as I have
obviously been influenced by Robert amongst others, particularly at the time I wrote the
GTR, then I guess there might be some poetic retro fit link there. In the end the piece
has an internal logic and narrative somehow.
SM: I have a few questions regarding the timbral trill section in GTR. After researching
the technique, I was curious if these timbral trills could also be called microtonal trills
with the way in which you have notated them E-flat to D quarter-sharp to C double-sharp.
In Kurt Stone's book, Music Notation in the Twentieth Century, he defines timbral trills
as trilling with the same pitch and microtonal trills as trilling between slightly different
pitches (quartertones basically). In measure 76 of GTR, I get the timbral trill, however, in
measure 74 when you notate the E-flat, I can see the microtonal trill
more evident. Finally, what really throws me for a loop is that in the preface you do call
the E-flat a D-sharp, so that would justify it being a timbral trill. I hope I haven't confused
you in any way. Basically, I would just like a short explanation as to why you call it a
timbral trill?
IC: I agree they could be called microtonal trills or perhaps microtonal tremolos. Indeed
this is an area naming that gets a little fuzzy: When is a timbral trill which has pitch
variation a micro-tonal trill? When is a micro-tonal trill which has a strong timbral
element a timbral trill?
When is a bisbigliando a timbral trill or is that the same thing? Since a bisbigliando on a
flute frequently has a microtonal element should we call it a the more commonly used
micro-tonal or timbral trill? When the pitch goes slightly down should we call it flattment
77
or is flattment a type or microtonal trill when we're on the modern flute? I would not
necessarily define a microtonal trill as having to be quartertones. In Robert Dick's Tone
Development Through Extended Techniques the examples of 'Timbral Trills' he gives
could be argued to fall into the various categories of: timbral, microtonal
& bisbigliando/flattment. I seem to recall that this is where I got the idea that these
passages in The Great Train Race were best described as timbral trills. However, on
reflection, they are not really good examples of any of the above since they employ more
than two positions so an obvious terminology does not leap to mind ... I could make
something up I guess! I recall having a discussion with Matthias Ziegler recently about
some of this ... the conclusion at the time was that things were a little fuzzy. In Touching
the Ether the finger vibrato or what I might in future call gliss finger vibrato could be
confused with flattment if the performance notes were not read. As with many things in
contemporary music I think it needs to be explained as far as possible ... at least for the
moment.
July 12, 2009
SM: What year did you graduate from Imperial College?
IC: 1986
SM: In what year did you and your former band members receive your first record deal?
IC: Golly ... 1987 ... not a record deal in the conventional sense as it was a library album
not a commercial album but not bad straight after college I guess.
SM: What was the name of the album? And in what year was it produced?
IC: Environmental Images. 1987 I think ... must be written down somewhere.
SM: In what year did your band break up and then Diva Music was created?
IC: Diva Music was created before the band broke up ... around 1992-1993 off the top of
my head. It began when we took over the release of a commercial single that was
recorded in our studio by another artist ... we acquired the label Diva Records along with
the Diva logo. Around this period Simon was producing the band Carter the Unstoppable
Sex Machine with had many hits including a no. 1 album. David Hicks left in 1995 when
Simon & I continued as Diva Music Composers www.divamusic.co.uk.
78
April 3, 2007
SM: As I am preparing for my lecture recital, which will involve the start to my doctoral
document, I was hoping that you could give me a short background on the growing
popularity (Who is performing them? What awards have they received?) of the following
pieces: Orange Dawn, Zoom tube, Great Train Race, and Tuberama.
IC: Orange Dawn:

Shortlisted by the Society for the Promotion of New Music (SPNM) 1993?.They short list
pieces and then promote a debut/premiere concert in London; this concert was at the
British Music Information Centre BMIC. A player called Roland Sutherland did the
official premiere (although I had actually already performed it). His web address is
http://www.rowlandsutherland.com
Zoom Tube:
Included in the new Peters Edition GCSE Anthology of Music 2006h(book and CD) in
the Area of Study 2 - Expressionism, Serialism, Experimental and Electronic Music as an
accessible example of extended instrumental techniques. They had have previously used
a couple of the Berio Sequenza and Stripsody. I haven't got a copy of this yet which
reminds me to chase them. It is now published and being used I gather.
Orange Dawn above is the only piece I think I've entered for anything. Zoom Tube has
been used in a number of competitions but that has been independent from me. A Clarke
piece has been in a final recital programme at the GSMD every year since 1998 (not sure
whether or not it will this year); initially OrangeDawn was played. I think I'm correct in
saying that pieces have been used in final recital programmes in all the major
conservatoires in the UK i.e. GSMD, RCM, RAM, TCM, RNCM, RSAMD. Don't know
whether that has any relevance but in reality that probably means more than the SPNM
thing.
Trinity Guildhall - external exam syllabus 2007

http://www.trinitycollege.co.uk/site/?id=1052 (can get a copy of syllabus here) 'Hypnosis'
& 'The Great Train Race' - are grade 8 pieces (The Great Train Race has been a grade 8
piece on the previous Guildhall exam syllabus from
2000 before the separate Trinity Guildhall exams merged) 'Sunsteams' - is grade 7.
ABRSM http://www.abrsm.org/?page=home are looking to use 'Sunstreams' for grade 8

from 2008 (different idea about standard although supposed to be similar level between
two boards). Of course 'Sunstreams' stands out less in relation to other Clarke pieces but
will become very much more high profile to many people who use the ABRSM exam
system. The majority of teachers and therefore pupils use this system in the UK and it
covers 80 countries apparently. I known through different pieces at the moment as it is
but it will be strange for 'Sunstreams' to become high profile. I guess this is inevitable as
it is currently the most technically accessible for the player.
79
February 6, 2006
SM: I am writing this email because I thought you would like to know that I have
finalized my doctoral document topic, in which the current title stands as "The Music of
Ian Clarke." I have greatly enjoyed all of your works and after hearing you perform some
of these works at the last convention, I truly found an even greater appreciation for
them. I would love the opportunity to research you and your works for my document. I
was wondering if you knew of anyone that is currently researching your compositions for
their degree requirements?
IC: Thank you for your email. I'm lovely to hear that you have enjoyed my music
..... some of it cowritten as you will know! In terms of your document, I seem to recall
somebody mentioned I was featuring somehow in a dissertation that somebody was doing
at Cambridge.
Would you like me to find out more? Would this affect you?
SM: If you don't mind and it is no trouble to you, I would like to know if someone has
already chosen to research your compositions for their doctoral work.
IC: I have established who is doing something on one of my pieces at Cambridge

and it is a final year Undergraduate. He is doing project/performance essay connected in
some way with 'The Great Train Race' and his final recital. He is coming for a lesson
sometime soon so I will know more then.
80
Appendix B
Transcript of In-Person Interviews with Ian Clarke
March 24, 2007
Shelly Monier: When were you born? Where?
Ian Clarke: 1964. I was born in Broadstairs, England. This is a small seaside town in
Kent, which is in the Southeastern part of England. When I was three we moved to
Coventry and when I was eight we moved again to Camberley.
SM: What do your parents do? Are they musicians?
IC: I grew up in a house full of musicians. My mother taught piano and cello lessons.
My father held a career as chemist, but in his younger years, he did play the double bass
in the National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain. And, my grandfather was a professional
musician. He played organ and piano. My auntie Joan played the organ as well. In fact,
she was sort of like a child prodigy. Although she gave it up for psychological reasons
and not to mention that the war came. My brother did play the trombone for a while. My
wife is a musician too. We met in the County Youth Orchestra when I was thirteen. We
finally became an item when I was about eighteen. She continues to play and teach the
flute, and she takes care of our two girls Bella and Abby.
SM: Let's talk about your educational background, primarily in music. When did you
begin playing the flute?
IC: My parents wanted their children to learn music. My first musical instrument was
the recorder, which I believe I started playing when I was five or six. I just loved the
recorder at the time; it really created a great foundation for me. I started playing the piano
at either eight or nine but was really becoming obsessed with the idea of playing the flute.
I kept asking my parents to buy me one. For my tenth birthday, my parents found a
secondhand flute that had cost 20 pounds. I was in heaven with my new instrument, even
though it really was a piece of junk. Since it was missing some of the plating, the flute
looked more of a green color instead of silver. I believe it was a Yamaha. Anyway, I
could not put that instrument down; I taught myself how to play that thing in the
beginning. When I started real flute lessons, my first teachers were actually clarinet
teachers. I believe this is what laid the foundation for so many bad habits in the beginning
stages of my playing. It was not until I was sixteen that I started taking lessons from flute
teachers. I took lessons from Simon Hunt and Averil Williams at the Guildhall School of
Music & Drama in London. When I turned eighteen, I actually moved to London.
81
SM: What about classical training?
IC: I must give a large majority of my classical background to my piano teacher, Joyce
Clarke (no relation too me). It was through these lessons that I learned quite a lot of
theory. She encouraged me as I began composing a few basic things. I must say that now
that I look back, she was a brilliant teacher. When I was studying with her, I did not
realize just how good she was. She had studied at Julliard and had some very talented
students. I think at one point, she actually thought that I would become a classical pianist.
I don't think that it took long for that thought to leave her mind.
SM: In your last comment, you mentioned that you composed a "few things" while
studying with Joyce Clarke. What other events in your life inspired you to start
composing?
IC: It was in my late teens that I really took an interest in composing. Me and some of
my mates had started a rock band and I decided to write for the group. It was at this point
when I was being creative with my mates and this started to push me outside the normal
classical style, it was through this experience that I learned what a blues scale was. I
remember looking at their guitar books and becoming quite fascinated with the jazz and
rock harmonies that I saw. I became intrigued with this new, interesting style, and sought
out to read any jazz books that I could get my hands on. Through my college years, I
became much more serious with the band and it was around the time that I graduated that
the band received the opportunity to record an album. In the studio sessions, I remember
the producers kept asking me to experiment with creating different or unique sounds on
the flute. They kept saying that I was playing the flute "too pretty." So, I began
experimenting with trying to make my instrument sound like the others instruments in the
band, the guitar and synthesizers. I discovered a number of new, interesting timbres
capable of being produced on the flute.
SM: Who are some of the influential musicians that you have looked to for your
compositions and flute playing?
IC: I would definitely have to say Robert Dick and Ian Anderson have highly influenced
my flute playing. As far as composers, I really admire the work of Karlheinz Stockhausen
and I really enjoy listening to Bobby McFerrin.
SM: When you are composing, do you think about some of the standard theory
techniques in classical music as far as form, harmony, texture, and melody? Or, do you
compose in a style that is more related to other genres of music?
SM: Let‘s take a moment and talk about The Great Train Race. What inspired you to
compose such a piece?
IC: Composing with structure? I know that these items exist, but to be honest I don't
thing about them much when I am sketching ideas down. The first thing that comes to
mind for me is what sounds good.
82
IC: The inspiration for Great Train Race came from several different ideas that I was
interested in. I was fascinated with what Robert Dick was doing, specifically in his
Paganini Variations with the multiphonics. Also, one day in the studio I was messing
around improvising and began to discover some cool effects that the flute could do. I sort
of discovered that multiphonics could sound like a train. I liked the way that the E octave
multiphonic sounded like a train whistle. So, I started sketching some ideas down on
manuscript.
SM: What about Zoom Tube? It is on a very different level then Great Train Race. What
was your inspiration for this piece?
IC: I can't say that Zoom Tube was conceived out of one set inspiration. There were
many interests going through my mind at the time, so I would have to say that the piece
has many different aspects of influence associated with it. Most notably, rhythm and
blues. I was listening to a lot of Bobby McFerrin at the time. I wanted to demonstrate that
the flute could groove much in the same way as a guitarist might, so implementing
multiphonics and damping techniques was necessary. Therefore, Robert Dick played a
major role in the creation. When I had heard Stockhausen's Xi, this intrigued me a great
deal, so I explored the use of quartertones and breathy sounds. I wanted other worldly
sounds to draw upon, so I began investigating how to incorporate tone colors similar to
South American flute playing. In the end, the birth of this work came from a large
percentage of exploring the limitations of the flute through experimentation and
improvisation.
SM: What jobs have you held in the music business?
IC: Let's see here, I taught piano and flute lessons in my younger years as a way to earn
money. And through the gigs that my band booked. I have taught some summer flute
courses throughout the UK as well.
SM: Do you currently hold any academic positions as a part of your career?
IC: I currently teach flute at Guildhall, I have been there since 2000. I continue to teach
summer courses throughout the UK. And I am getting a lot of gigs in other countries
these days. Specifically, master classes and concerts.
SM: What kind of future projects are you working on? What can we expect from Ian
Clarke in the next ten years?
IC: WOW! That is quite a question! I want to continue performing for people that not
only enjoy my music but also like what I am doing on the flute. I don't want to just play
my music, I enjoy playing other pieces as well. I am thinking about composing a concerto
in the future. Galway and I are putting something in the works. I don't think that there are
83
enough "good" quality concertos out there. I am thinking about putting another CD on the
market, maybe an intermediate one with other people's works on it. I will continue
composing, I might investigate some flute and guitar stuff. I want to play the flute better.
May 19, 2010
Shelly Monier: When did you start composing Within?
Ian Clarke: The initial idea was conceived in 1999, but nothing was really completed
until 20003. I finished two versions actually. One for flute choir and another for solo flute
and CD backing.
SM: Since we have not really discussed this piece in previous discussions, I was hoping
that you could give me a short background of the piece and how it developed.
IC: Really, this piece does not have some elaborate story attached to it for inspiration.
The idea was presented when Clare Southworth approached me about commissioning a
work for a flute choir that she was putting together. She wanted to put together a group
that would comprise of some of the "big" name flutists in the London area. We had
discussed some of the details for the work, but nothing ever came out of it because the
group never materialized. I guess you could say that the personal musical inspiration
behind the piece is rather difficult to describe. The original sketch dates around the same
time as Zoom Tube, so you could say that some of the same musical explorations and
influences of Zoom Tube are present. I guess there are some subtle yet obvious parallels
to the two.
SM: So, why did you bring the idea back almost four years later?
IC: When I was asked to teach at the 2004 Stratford-Upon Avon International flute
course, I thought it would be nice to have something for the students to play as a group.
Although this was the first premier of the piece, I have to say that it was heard earlier that
year in the UK at the Just Flutes International Flute Course when I performed it with the
CD Backing.
84
Appendix C
Transcript of notes taken from master class at the National Flute Association's
Annual Convention in New York with Ian Clarke.
August 16, 2009
The following are comments in which Clarke suggested to help the performance of Zoom
Tube:
General Comment: In this piece, the "groove" is the most important element. You need
to find musicians of this style and listen to them. You should take a look at Robert Dick's
Fish Are Jumping and anything with Bobby McFerrin. When working on the piece,
record yourself to see if you are grooving. Also, I would prefer that you perform it
memorized. I think this will help as well. You must be able to feel the pulse, it is very
important. Don't skip the rests as they play an important role in the music. I need to feel
the groove in the silence.
Opening Gesture: For this you need your chin to be glued to the flute so you have
absolute stability. You can move flute forward to get the breathy sound but make sure
that you chin stays against the flute. A smaller aperture will give you more time to give
more sound. You must also find a way to have a much faster air speed through this
passage in order to create the dynamic changes that are written. This first line must be in
one breath.
Blues Scale: Take time to really learn the blues scales. Start jamming with them and
even improvising your own ideas. This will help the blues section not only groove more
but help you feel more comfortable.
Multiphonics: Investigate the idea of throat tuning. Robert Dick gives helpful exercises
in his extended technique books that will help you play these better. One tip I can give
now is practice starting on the first note, slide to the second and then slide back to the
first. This will help you create each note and eventually figure out what needs to happen
with your air and embouchure to get both notes out at the same time.
Final Comment: This piece is considered contemporary because I am still alive, but
really, it is not thought of as a contemporary Classical Art piece of music. My
recommendation is that since there are so many new and interesting techniques in Zoom
Tube, just take one at a time and master that first. Don't feel like you have to start at the
beginning and struggle through it. Many of the concepts build on one another. Finally,
take all of the ideas written in this piece and try to improvise on them. This will help you
feel more comfortable with the piece as a whole.
85
Bibliography
Books, Articles, and Dissertations
Berry, Wallace. Musical Structure and Performance. New Haven and London: Yale
University Press, 1989.
Boretz, Benjamin and Edward Cone, editors. Perspectives on Notation and Performance.
New York: W.W. Norton & Company Inc., 1976.
Brokaw, Roberta. ―Performance of extended flute technique of the twentieth century

based on aspects of traditional flute technique.‖ DMA diss.; California State
University, 1979.
Cole, Hugo. Sounds and Signs: Aspects of Musical Notation. London and New York:
Oxford University Press, 1974.
Cone, Edward T. Musical Form and Musical Performance. New York: W.W. Norton
& Company, 1968.
Dick, Robert. The Other Flute: A Performance Manual of Contemporary Techniques.

2d ed. St. Louis: Multiple Breath Music, 1989.
___________. Tone Development Through Extended Techniques. St. Louis: Multiple

Breath Music, 1986.
Dunnavant, Jessica. “Composer and Flutist Ian Clarke.” Flute Talk, Vol. 28, No. 7:
March 2009, pg. 6-8.
Howell, Thomas. The Avant-Garde Flute: A Handbook for Composers and Flutists.
Berkeley and London: University of California Press, 1974.
Marrs, Leslie Ann. ―Integrating extended techniques into flute pedagogy: A resource
guide for flutists, teachers, and composers.‖ DMA diss.; University of North
Carolina at Greensboro, 2004.
McBirnie, Bill. “Self-Consciousness, Crossing Over & Extended Techniques.”

Canadian Musician: Sep/Oct 2004, pg. 29-30.
Meador, Rebecca Rae. ―A history of extended techniques and an examination of their

potential as a teaching tool.‖ DMA diss.; University of Cincinnati, 2001.
Pellerite, James. A Modern Guide to Fingerings for the Flute. 2d ed. Bloomington, IN:
Zalo, 1972.
86
Read, Gardner. Music notation—A Manual of Modern Practice. New York: Taplinger
Pub. Inc., 1979.
Stone, Kurt. Music Notation in the Twentieth Century. New York and London: W.W.
Norton & Company, 1980.
Ward, E. “Flute News: Quarter tones and extended techniques with Marion Garver.”
Pan, Vol. 19: March 2000, pg. 8.
Weisberg, Arthur. Performing Twentieth-Century Music: A Handbook for Conductors

and Instrumentalists. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1993.
Musical Scores
Interviews and Master Classes
Clarke, Ian. Interview by author, 24 March 2007.
________. Interview by author, 19 May 2010.
________. Master Class (Zoom Tube), National Flute Convention. New York: 16
August 2009.
________. Master Class (Zoom Tube, The Great Train Race), UNL Flute Festival.
Lincoln, Nebraska: 23 March 2007.
Musical Scores
Aitken, Robert. Icicle. Paris: Éditions Musicales Transatlantiques, 1978.
Berio, Luciano. Sequenza I. Milano: Universal Editions, 1993.
Brown, Elizabeth. Trillium. Quetzal Music: 1999.
Clarke, Ian. The Great Train Race (The Flute As You Don‟t Usually Hear It!). Surrey,
England: IC Music/Just Flutes Edition, 1993/2001.
________. Orange Dawn. Surrey, England: IC Music/Just Flutes Edition, 2005.
________. Within…For Seven Flutes. Surrey, England: IC Music/Just Flutes Edition,

2005.
________. Within for solo flute and CD backing. Surrey, England: IC Music/Just Flutes
Edition, 2009.
________. Zoom Tube. Surrey, England: IC Music/Just Flutes Edition, 2004.

87
Colquhoun, Michael. Charanga. New York: Colquhoun, 1993.
Dick, Robert. Flying Lessons Vol. I: Six Contemporary Concert Etudes. St. Louis, MO:
Multiple Breath Music, 1983.
__________. Flying Lessons Vol II. St. Louis, MO: Multiple Breath Music, 1987.
__________. Lookout. St. Louis, MO: Multiple Breath Music, 1989.
Ferneyhough, Brian. Cassandra's Dream Song. New York: Peters Edition, 1975.
Fukushima, Kazuo. Mei per flauto soloi. Milani: Suvini Zerboni, 1966.
Heiss, John. Etudes for solo flute, op. 20. St. Louis, MO: MMB Music, Inc., MO, 1986.
Medek, Tilo. Departure of a Steam Train "Abfahrt einer Dampflokomotive." Celle:

Moeck, 1982.
Offermans, Wil. Kotekan. Frankfurt, Germany: Zimmermann Publications, 1997.
_____________. Jungle Dance for Bottles and Flutes. Frankfurt, Germany:

Zimmermann Publications, 1995.
Pearce, Ann. Serendipity. Charlotte, NC: ALRY Publications, 2003.
Rearick, Martha. Avant-Garde Sampler. Nashua, NH: Falls House Press, 1996.
Stockhausen, Karlheinz. XI: für ein Melodie-Instrument mit Mikro-Tönen . Kürten,

Germany: Stockhausen-Verlag, 1998
Takemitsu, Toru. Itinerant. New York: Schott, 1989.
Websites
"Ian Clarke." Ian Clarke. N.d. Web. 20 Oct. 2010. <http://www.ianclarke.net>.
"Ian Clarke." Diva Music Composers. N.d. Web. 20 Oct. 2010.

<http://www.divamusic.co.uk>.
Discography
Clarke, Ian. Within. Surrey, England: IC Music/Diva Music, 2005. No. IC Music IC01.
Kemler, Katherine. Lipstick. Baton Rouge, LA: Centaur Records, 2008. No. Centaur
CRC 2923.

Ian Clarke

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Ian Clarke

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Ian Clarke

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

University of Nebraska - Lincoln

DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln

Three Works For Flute By Ian Clarke: An Analysis

Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/musicstudent

Presented to the Faculty of

The Graduate College at the University of Nebraska

In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements

For the Degree of Doctor of Musical Arts

Under the Supervision of Professor John R. Bailey

University of Nebraska, 2010

Advisor: John R. Bailey

British flutist Ian Clarke is currently recognized as one of the leading

flutist/composers of today. His compositions have been performed at national

Edexcel GCSE (General Certificate of Secondary Education) Anthology of Music as a

influenced by popular music, explore unconventional sounds, using inventive avant-garde

The first chapter of this document provides biographical information about

composition examined. Further discussion includes aspects of the formal structure,

extended techniques within 20th-century flute literature.

LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS .................................................................................................................. vii

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1

Biography of Ian Clarke .......................................................................................................... 2

List of Compositions for flute through 2010 .................................................................. 5

CHAPTER 2: THE GREAT TRAIN RACE ........................................................................................... 6

Performance Guide ................................................................................................................ 10

CHAPTER 3: ZOOM TUBE .................................................................................................................. 24

Formal Analysis ...................................................................................................................... 27

Performance Guide ................................................................................................................ 32

CHAPTER 4: WITHIN… FOR SEVEN FLUTES ............................................................................. 47

Performance Guide .............................................................................................................. 59

CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................... 70

Common Threads, Context with the Flute Literature of Extended Techniques

APPENDIX A: Transcript of Questions Emailed to Ian Clarke ......................................... 76

APPENDIX B: Transcript of In-Person Interviews with Ian Clarke .................................. 80

and guidance through my doctoral program. He has truly been an inspiration to me as a

guidance and positive criticism when attending each of my performances and as my

document readers. I am forever grateful to Dr. Robert Fruehwald, my former theory

the time to answer my many questions throughout the document process.

Table Title Page

1 A List of Compositions for flute by Ian Clarke through 2010 5

2 Formal Structure, The Great Train Race, B-foot Version 7

3 Use of Extended Techniques in The Great Train Race 10

4 Formal Structure, Zoom Tube 27

5 Use of Extended Techniques in Zoom Tube 32

6 Formal Structure, Within… For Seven Flutes 49

7 Use of Extended Techniques in Within… For Seven Flutes 59

8 Positioning of Flute Choir 60

9 Selected Unaccompanied Flute Literature Containing 71

10 Comparison of Clarke‘s Zoom Tube with Works by Dick and 72

11 Notation in Robert Dick‘s Flying Lessons, Vol. I-Six 73

12 Employment of Notation in Stockhausen‘s X I 74

13 Reference List of Selected Literature for Flute Choir that 75

Example Title Page

1 The Great Train Race, mm. 1-4, introduction. 7

2 The Great Train Race, m. 30, transition. 8

3 The Great Train Race, mm. 31-33, B Section. 8

4 The Great Train Race, mm. 54-57, end of B section. 9

5 The Great Train Race, mm. 75-79, Section C. 9

7 The Great Train Race, mm. 5-11, explosive harmonics. 13

8 The Great Train Race, mm. 17-23, A Section. 14