CALL CENTERS (CENTRES)

Research Bibliography with Abstracts

Avishai Mandelbaum
Faculty of Industrial Engineering and Management
Technion—Israel Institute of Technology
Haifa 32000, Israel
E-mail: [email protected]
Version 6: December 23, 2004∗
Downloadable from: http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng
Chronologically Ordered within Research Fields
Note to the Reader: The present list is undoubtedly biased in favour of my own research interests. I would therefore appreciate, and thank in advance, any
feedback that points to missing sources or references. In particular, authors of qualified papers are encouraged to send their pre- or re-prints to Jody Bar-On (the
reference librarian in charge), either electronically ([email protected]) or as hard copies (Library of Industrial Engineering and Management, Technion,
Haifa 32000, Israel.)

Efforts will be made to maintain the document complete and updated. We shall perhaps also create alternative versions (for example, alphabetical list), expand
the scope (e.g. accommodate contact centers, when enough research accumulates) or simply improve usefulness (e.g. add commentary). Indeed, readers may wish
to help with the creation of such alternative versions. In this case, a latex-source of the document can be obtained from the author, under a single condition—that
the outcome is publicly available (both source and postcript/pdf/...).

∗ Version 1: July 17, 2001; Version 2: September 16, 2001, Version 3: May 27, 2002; Version 4: March 3, 2003; Version 5: July 14, 2003
Acknowledgement: Ma jor contributions by Jody Bar-On and Lillian Bluestein are gratefully acknowledged. Jody is the reference librarian who first researched
the call center literature and assembled this document; Lillian then took over the typing and editorial work. Their professionalism and drive-for-perfection,
always cheerful and ready to go the extra step, have been for me a guiding source of support and inspiration.

Funding: This work has been supported by the ISF (Israeli Science Foundation) grant 388/99-02 (jointly with Nahum Shimkin, Technion EE), by the Technion
funds for the promotion of research and sponsored research, and by Whartons’ Financial Institutions Center.

Contents
Introduction 1
I Operations Research, Operations Management 2
II Statistics, Forecasting 55
III Consumer and Agent Psychology 64
IV Human Resource Management 76
V Information and Telecommunication Technology, Artificial Intelligence, Multi-agent Systems 103
VI Human Interface, Industrial Engineering 120
VII Management Models 131
VIII Simulation, Petri Nets, Genetic Algorithms 166
IX Cases 176
X Books and Reports 185
XI Call Center Journals and Magazines 196
XII Web Sites 198

Introduction †

Cal l center is the common term for a telephone-based human-service operation. A call center provides tele-services, namely services in which the customers and
the service agents are remote from each other. The agents, who sit in cubicles, constitute the physical embodiment of the call center. With numbers varying from
very few to many hundreds, they serve customers over the phone, while facing a computer terminal that outputs and inputs customer data. The customers,
possibly up to thousands at a given instant, are only virtually present: they are either being served or they are delayed in, what we call, tele-queues. Those waiting
to be served share a phantom queue, invisible to each other and the agents serving them, waiting and accumulating impatience until one of two things happens –
an agent is allocated to serve them (through a supporting software), or they abandon the tele-queue, plausibly due to impatience that has built up to exceed their
anticipated worth of the service.

Contact centers are the contemporary successors of call centers. In addition to phone services, they interface with customers via the internet, email, chat and fax.
Call or contact centers are the preferred and prevalent way for many companies to communicate with their customers. (Fortune-500 companies are estimated to
operate, on average, 30 call centers each.) The call center industry is thus vast, and rapidly expanding in terms of both workforce and economic scope. For
example, it is estimated that 70% of all customer-business interactions occur in call centers and that $700 billion in goods and services were sold through call
centers in 1997. These figures have been expanding 20% annually. Three percent of the U.S. working population is currently employed in call centers. This
amounts to 1.55 million agents, and some estimates actually go up to 6 million.

The modern call center is a complex socio-technical system. Some view call centers as the business frontiers but others as the sweat-shops of the 21st century.
Either way, within our service-driven economy, telephone services are now unparalleled in scope, service quality and operational efficiency. Indeed, in a large
best-practice call center, hundreds of agents can cater to thousands of phone callers per hour; agent utilization levels can average between 90% to 95%; no
customer encounters a busy signal and, in fact, about half of the customers are answered immediately; the waiting time of those delayed is measured in seconds,
and very few abandon while waiting.

The design of the modern call center, and the management of its performance, surely must be based on sound scientific principles. This is manifested by a
growing body of academic multi-disciplinary research, devoted to call centers, and ranging from Mathematics and Statistics, to Operations Research, Industrial
Engineering, Information Technology and Human Resource Management, all the way to Psychology and Sociology. My goal here is to “describe” this research
through a list of abstracts, as complete and updated a list as possible. The abstracts originate in papers that are either directly related to or have been judged
potentially helpful for academic research on call centers.
† The text is adapted from “Empirical Analysis of a Call Center”, by A. Mandelbaum, A. Sakov, S. Zeltyn, Technion
Technical Report, 2001; and from “Introduction to Mathematical Models of Call Centers”, preprint by G. Koole and A.
Mandelbaum, 2001.

I Operations Research, Operations Management

1. Erlang, A.K., On the rational determination of the number of circuits. In The Life and Works
of A.K. Erlang, E. Brockmeyer, H.L. Halstrom and A. Jensen (eds.). Copenhagen: The Copen-
hagen Telephone Company, 1948.
2. Edie, Leslie C. Traffic delays at toll booths, Journal of the Operations Research Society of Amer-
ica, 2 (2), 1954, 107–138.
Abstract. The collection of vehicular tolls at Port Authority tunnels and bridges is one of the
most important operations conducted by the police personnel. More than 250 traffic officers are
utilized, and the payroll costs exceed a million dollars annually. In staffing its toll plazas, the
Port Authority attempts to handle traffic with a minimum number of toll collectors consistent
with uniformly good service to the public and properly spaced relief periods for the toll collec-
tors. This requires finding the level of traffic delays that gives the best compromise between the
conflicting ob jectives of economy and service. In the past, the number of toll collectors provided
for operating a toll plaza was determined by judgment based on experience and a rule-of-thumb
work standard which had not been related to service. Judgment was likewise used to allocate
manpower and control the number of toll booths opened at any time. This method resulted in
patron delays observed to vary from 2 to 50 sec. The tools of probability theory provide methods
for dealing with the problem in quantitative terms. They enable determination of the relations
between traffic volumes, number of toll booths, and grade of service. With this knowledge, the
optimum grade of service can be established in a logical manner and the number of toll booths
required at any time of day can be specified in advance. Use of this method permitted savings
in toll collection expenses and better service.
(Appears also in Section II.)
3. Edie, Leslie C. Review of Port of New York Authority study. Case Histories Five Years After—A
Symposium, 1959, 263–277.
4. Larson, Richard C. Improving the effectiveness of New York City’s 911, in Analysis of Public
Systems, Alvin W. Drake, Ralph L. Keeney and Philip M. Morse (Eds.), Cambridge, M.I.T.
Press, 1972, Chapter 9: 151–180.
Abstract. This chapter summarizes the results of a one-month operational study of police emer-
gency telephone operations in the central communications room of the New York City Police
Department. The study serves as an example of elementary quantitative modeling to improve
an ongoing operation.
5. Larson, Richard C. A hypercube queuing model for facility location and redistricting in urban
emergency services, Computing & Operations Research, 1, 1974, 67–95.
Abstract. This paper develops computationally efficient algorithms for studying the analytical
behavior of a multi-server queuing system with distinguishable servers. The model is intended
2
for analyzing problems of vehicle location and response district design in urban emergency ser-
vices, includes interdistrict as well as intradistrict responses, and allows computation of several
point-specific as well as area-specific performance measures.
6. Segal, M. The operator-scheduling problem: A network-flow approach, Operations Research, 22
(4), 1974, 808–823.
Abstract. The number of telephone operators required on duty at switchboards fluctuates
widely during the day. Work periods of operators are defined by start and end times of tours
and by the timing of break and relief periods within tours. This paper proposes a method for
determining the number of operators assigned to tours and their corresponding timing of breaks
and reliefs; it relies on various network flow formulations. An example application of the method
is presented.
Keywords: Network analysis, Personnel, Scheduling, Telephone operators, Network flow formu-
lations, Operator scheduling
7. Buffa, E.S., M.J. Cosgrove and B.J. Luce. An integrated work shift scheduling system, Decision
Sciences, 7, 1976, 620–630.
Abstract. An integrated work shift scheduling system is developed and applied in the schedul-
ing of 2600 telephone operators in 43 locations of the General Telephone Company of California.
The system involves the forecasting of calls on a half-hourly basis, the conversion to operator
requirements, the scheduling of tours by a heuristic algorithm, the assignment of operators to
tours, and the operation of the system.
8. Henderson, W.B. and W.L. Berry. Heuristic methods for telephone operator shift scheduling:
an experimental analysis, Management Science, 22 (12), 1976, 1372–1380.
Abstract. Heuristic methods are presented for scheduling telephone traffic exchange operators
to meet demand that varies over a 24-hour operating period. Two types of heuristics are de-
scribed: (1) for determining the work shift types to be considered in preparing an operator shift
schedule and (2) for constructing an operator shift schedule from a given set of work shift types.
These heuristics are evaluated both in terms of solution quality and computational efficiency,
using actual operating data.
Keywords: Telephone operator shift scheduling, Computational efficiency, Heuristic methods,
Linear programming
9. Segal, M. and D.B. Weinberger. Turfing, Operations Research, 25 (3), 1977, 367–386.
Abstract. We discuss both the analytical methods and some implementation considerations
involved in enriching the job of telephone repairpersons/installers by letting each take full re-
sponsibility for all jobs within his own territory, or “turf”. For the problem of carving the region
into turfs, which bears a great similarity to the political districting problem, we use a highly
interactive software system at the heart of which is a heuristic algorithm combining shortest
3
path, minimum cost flow, and enumerative techniques. We also discuss a stochastic model of
the work backlog in a turf, based on the variability of the demand for service. Preliminary ex-
perience seems to indicate that this mode of operation is both workable and desirable. It should
therefore be noted that, while the discussion takes place in the context of telephone repairper-
sons/installers, it is of considerably wider applicability.
10. Gaballa, Adel and Wayne Pearce. Telephone sales manpower planning at Qantas, Interfaces, 9
(3), 1979, 1–9.
Abstract. When the traditional procedure for planning annual manpower requirements for the
telephone sales reservation offices of Qantas Airways was replaced by a model utilizing queueing
and integer linear programming techniques, savings in excess of US$235,000 were realized in staff
reductions over a two-year period, and investigation into applications in several other Qantas
service areas continues. Relationships of staff size to waiting time and service time are also
evaluated.
11. Halfin, Shlomo and Ward Whitt. Heavy-traffic limits for queues with many exponential servers,
Operations Research, 29 (3), 1981, 567–587.
Abstract. Two different kinds of heavy-traffic limit theorems have been proved for s-server
queues. The first kind involves a sequence of queueing systems having a fixed number of servers
with an associated sequence of traffic intensities that converges to the critical value of one from
below. The second kind, which is often not thought of as heavy traffic, involves a sequence of
queueing systems in which the associated sequences of arrival rates and numbers of servers go
to infinity while the service time distributions and the traffic intensities remain fixed, with the
traffic intensities being less than the critical value of one. In each case, the sequence of random
variables depicting the steady-state number of customers waiting or being served diverges to
infinity but converges to a nondegenerate limit after appropriate normalization. However, in an
important respect neither procedure adequately represents a typical queueing system in practice
because in the (heavy-traffic) limit an arriving customer is either almost certain to be delayed
(first procedure) or almost certain not to be delayed (second procedure). Hence, we consider a
sequence of (GI /M/s) systems in which the traffic intensities converge to one from below, the
arrival rates and the numbers of servers go to infinity, but the steady-state probabilities that
all servers are busy are held fixed. The limits in this case are hybrids of the limits in the other
two cases. Numerical comparisons indicate that the resulting approximation is better than the
earlier ones for many-server systems operating at typically encountered loads.
12. Smith, D.R. and W. Whitt. Resource sharing for efficiency in traffic systems, Bel l System Tech-
nical Journal, 60 (1), 1981, 39–55.
Abstract. Experience has shown that efficiency usually increases when separate traffic systems
are combined into a single system. For example, if Group A contains 10 trunks and Group B 8
trunks, there should be fewer blocked calls if A and B are combined into a single group of 18
trunks. It is intuitively clear that the separate systems are less efficient because a call can be
blocked in one when trunks are idle in the other. Teletraffic engineers and queueing theorists
4
widely accept such efficiency principles and often assume that their mathematical proofs are
either trivial or already in the literature. This is not the case for two fundamental problems that
concern combining blocking systems (as in the example above) and combining delay systems.
For the simplest models, each problem reduces to the proof of an inequality involving the corre-
sponding classical Erlang function. Here the two inequalities are proved in two different ways by
exploiting general stochastic comparison concepts: first, by monotone likelihood-ratio methods
and, second, by sample-path or ‘coupling’ methods. These methods not only yield the desired
inequalities and stronger comparisons for the simplest models, but also apply to general arrival
processes and general service-time distributions. However, it is assumed that the service-time
distributions are the same in the systems being combined. This common-distribution condition
is crucial since it may be disadvantageous to combine systems with different service-time distri-
butions. For instance, the adverse effect of infrequent long calls in one system on frequent short
calls in the other system can outweigh the benefits of making the two groups of servers mutually
accessible.
Keywords: Queueing theory, Telephone traffic efficiency, Traffic systems, Queueing, Blocking
systems, Delay systems, Classical Erlang function, Stochastic comparison, Monotone likelihood
ratio, Sample path, Coupling, Arrival processes, Service-time distributions, Telephone traffic
13. Sze, David Y. A queuing model for telephone operator staffing, Operations Research, 32 (2),
1984, 229–249.
Abstract. In the Bell Telephone System, service criteria for telephone operator staffing are
based on target delays. The goal is to ensure that customers receive good levels of service dur-
ing normal load times and to protect against very poor service during peak load periods. The
system’s staffing problem cannot be solved using standard queuing models because of: 1. the
large number of servers involved, 2. bimodal service time distributions, 3. nonstationarity of
customer arrivals, 4. customer abandonment and reattempts for service, and 5. nonpreemptive
priority rules for service. Therefore, a new queuing model was developed to generate staffing
tables for each operating system and range of service times per customer. The tables specify the
number of servers required to meet given load levels under average delay criteria, based on load
forecasts derived from historical data, usage trends, and traffic growth patterns. The staffing
tables are then used to arrange individual operators’ schedules to meet service requirements per
half hour.
Keywords: 683 nonstationary inputs, abandonments, and reattempts, 693 M/G/c queues with
large (100–300) server teams, 698 nonabsolute priorities for nonhomogeneous traffic
14. Whitt, W. Heavy-traffic approximations for service systems with blocking, AT&T Bel l Labora-
tories Technical Journal, 63 (5), 1984, 689–708.
Abstract. Develops approximations for the blocking probability and related congestion mea-
sures in service systems with s servers, r extra waiting spaces, blocked customers lost, and
independent and identically distributed service times that are independent of a general station-
ary arrival process (the G/GI/s/r model). The approximations are expressed in terms of the
normal distribution and the peakedness of the arrival process. They are obtained by applying
previous heavy-traffic limit theorems and a conditioning heuristic. There are interesting connec-
5
tions to Hayward’s approximation, generalized peakedness, asymptotic expansions for the Erlang
loss function, the normal-distribution method, and bounds for the blocking probability. For the
case of no extra waiting space, a renewal arrival process and an exponential service-time distri-
bution (the GI/M/s/O model), a heavy-traffic local limit theorem by A.A. Borovkov implies that
the blocking depends on the arrival process only through the first two moments of the renewal
interval as the offered load increases. Moreover, in this situation, Hayward’s approximation is
asymptotically correct.
Keywords: Probability, Queueing theory, Telecommunication traffic, Service systems, Blocking,
Blocking probability, Congestion measures, Servers, Waiting spaces, G/GI/s/r model, Heavy
traffic limit theorems, Conditioning heuristic, Hayward’s approximation, Peakedness, Asymp-
totic expansions, Erlang loss function, Normal distribution method, Exponential service time
distribution, GI/M/s/O model, Arrival process
15. Mabert, V.A. Short interval forecasting of emergency phone call (911) work loads, Journal of
Operations Management, 5 (3), 1985, 259–271.
Abstract. There has been a growing emphasis over the last 5–10 years on improving produc-
tivity in the service sector of the US economy. Effective scheduling of the workforce in these
organizations requires good estimates of demand, which may show substantial variations between
days for certain times of the year. An examination is made of the use of 6 different forecasting
methods for predicting daily emergency call workloads for the Indianapolis Police Department’s
communications area: 1. one-year lag, 2. zero/one regression, 3. multiplicative/additive, 4.
zero/one with adjustment, 5. multiplicative/additive with adjustment, and 6. autoregressive,
integrated moving average intervention. The research suggests that there are clearly significant
differences in performance for the 6 models analyzed. Simple modeling approaches can perform
well in the complex environments found in many service organizations. Special tailoring of the
forecasting model is required for many service firms. Historical data patterns for these organi-
zations tend to be more involved than just trend and seasonal elements.
Keywords: Studies, Police, Mathematical models, Implementations, Forecasting techniques,
Emergencies, Departments, Communications, Case studies
(Appears also in Section II.)
16. Hoffman, K.L. and C.M. Harris. Estimation of a caller retrial rate for a telephone information
system, European Journal of Operational Research, 27 (2), 1986, 207–214.
Abstract. As part of a continuing study of the usage of its Taxpayer Service Telephone Net-
work, the US Internal Revenue Service wished to determine more accurate methods for demand
measurement. It has long been recognized that the total number of calls coming into such a busy
telephone system overestimates the actual number of distinct callers. The service had previously
estimated its real demand by adding ( 1
3 ) of both the number of blocked or overflow calls and
the number of abandonments to the total actually answered. The thrust of this current study
then was to develop an accurate statistical method for providing a more ob jective formula for
this true demand, which turns out to be equivalent to estimating the probability of retrial by
blocked and abandoned callers.
6
The ma jor result which has come from this effort is that the average daily retrial percentage
taken across location and time of year seems to be moderately stable about a mean value of 69%,
somewhat dependent on both location and (particularly) time of year. The value is consistently
higher during periods close to important filing milestones and lower otherwise. We show this
to mean that, whenever a rate of 69% is used, the actual demand would be estimated by aug-
menting completed loads by 31% of the number of blocked and abandoned calls for the period
of concern.
Keywords: Communications, Queues, Stochastic processes, Operations research, Statistics, Tele-
phone systems, Caller retrial rate, Taxpayer service telephone network, US Internal Revenue
Service, Statistical method
17. Harris, C.M., K.L. Hoffman and P.B. Saunders. Modeling the IRS telephone taxpayer informa-
tion system, Operations-Research, 35 (4), 1987, 504–523.
Abstract. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) toll-free, nationwide telephone system provides
prompt tax-information assistance. In 1986, the IRS processed 37.8 million calls from taxpayers
at 32 answering sites. This paper documents a critical review of the IRS approach to allocating
its staff and equipment. The authors built a simulation-based model to test various allocation
policies for deploying IRS resources. The simulation study included detailed sensitivity analysis
of key network variables, and showed the feasibility of modeling a typical IRS location as a
multiserver loss/delay queue with retrial and reneging. The second phase of this effort therefore
centered around developing a prototype probabilistic model for determining the most effective
way of providing service at reasonable levels and at minimum cost. The resulting model allows
the IRS to determine from tables the best configuration of people and telephone lines for any
expected levels of incoming traffic. In addition, the authors provided flow balance analyses of
the underlying feedback queues that permit the IRS to separate their caller streams into fresh
and repeat callers, and thus to estimate actual demand for service.
Keywords: Queueing theory, Telephone traffic, Telephone taxpayer information system, Internal
Revenue Service, Simulation-based model, Allocation policies, Probabilistic model, Flow balance
analyses, Feedback queues, Caller streams
18. Kuhn, Patricia and Thomas P. Hoey. Improving Police 911 Operations in Washington, D.C.
National Productivity Review, New York, 6 (2), 1987, 125–134.
Abstract. The 911 operation in Washington, DC, has generated an increasing number of com-
plaints from city officials and residents in recent years. Call handling performance was not
satisfactory, with 33% of the calls in 1985 kept waiting and 17% abandoned for lack of response.
In 1986, two initiatives were begun to improve 911 operations. New technology, Enhanced 911,
was introduced to replace antiquated telephone and call distribution equipment. The 2 foremost
features of Enhanced 911 are automatic number identification and automatic location identifi-
cation. An operations improvement pro ject also was initiated, emphasizing: 1. matching staff
deployment with call demand, 2. improving call-handling performance, and 3. improving civilian
pay equity. Call-handling performance gains were brought about by: 1. modifying call distrib-
utor software to increase call processing efficiency, 2. starting revised employee and supervisor
work schedules, and 3. beginning a workstation coverage policy to guarantee constant manning
7
throughout a shift.
Keywords: Telephone service, Studies, Productivity, Problems, Police, Operations research, Im-
provements
19. Mok, S.K. and J.G. Shanthikumar. A transient queueing model for business office with standby
servers, European Journal of Operational Research, 28 (2), 1987, 158–174.
Abstract. Customers call business offices of a telephone company for services and billing in-
formation. Mok (“A queueing model for an SL-1 ACD equipped Business Office”, Bell Canada
Management Sciences Report no. 1158441 and 1158442, Canada, 1985) considered a business
office in which customers are usually serviced by scheduled servers. These scheduled servers are
backed up by some standby servers who will answer a call only when the number of calls waiting
to be answered is big. Impatient customers may renege. A transient solution to a queueing
model is presented that can be used to help a business office manager efficiently determine the
optimal numbers of scheduled and standby servers for achieving the designated service ob jective
cost effectively. It is estimated that our model would save each of the 108 Business Office man-
agers of Bell Canada 20 minutes per day. Our tests of the model, using real data from randomly
selected days, reveal that the model is about 93% accurate.
Keywords: Queues, Standby servers, Scheduled servers, Reneging customers, Optimisation,
Transient queueing model, Business office, Bell Canada
20. Kwan, Stephen K., Mark M. Davis and Allen G. Greenwood. A simulation model for determin-
ing variable worker requirements in a service operation with time-dependent customer demand,
Queueing Systems, 3, 1988, 265–276.
Abstract. In a service operation where worker requirements have to be determined for short
scheduling time periods with nonstationary customer demand, the assumptions necessary for
applying steady-state solutions to elementary queueing models are usually violated. This pa-
per describes a simulation study of the behavior of such a service operation. The results are
compared with the steady-state solutions to a queueing model where individual scheduling time
periods are assumed to be independent. It is found that if the system utilization is below a
derived maximum value (based on a service level criterion), then the steady-state solutions are
robust enough to explain the behavior of the system and can be used to schedule worker require-
ments.
Keywords: Simulation, Service operations, Worker requirements, Queueing models
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
21. Larson, Richard C. Operations research and the services industries. In Managing Innovation:
Cases from the Services Industries, B.R. Guiles and J.B. Quinn (eds.). National Academic Press,
1988, 115–143.
22. Andrews, Bruce H. and Henry L. Parsons. L.L. Bean chooses a telephone agent scheduling sys-
tem, Interfaces, 19 (6), 1989, 1–9.
8
Abstract. Concerns the development for mail order company L.L. Bean of a computerized
procedure for selecting complex large-scale telephone-operator scheduling systems. To assess
capability in forecasting work load, setting requisite capacity levels, and generating satisfactory
work-shift schedules, cost/benefit analysis was used and the expected penalty costs of lost orders
due to understaffing and loaded-wage costs of overstaffing were considered. Queuing theory was
used to model customer-call behavior for every hour over 24-hour days, seven days per week, and
the results of linear regression, which correlated customer-service level with expected customer
abandonment rate, were implemented to estimate the impact on order revenues of telephone-
service level.
Keywords: Work load forecasting, Queueing theory, Telephone agent scheduling system, Mail-
order company, L.L. Bean, Computerized procedure, Complex large-scale telephone opera-
tor scheduling systems, Capacity levels, Work shift schedules, Cost-benefit analysis, Expected
penalty costs, Understaffing, Loaded wage costs, Overstaffing, Linear regression
(Appears also in Section VII.)
23. Green, L. and P. Kolesar. Testing the validity of a queueing model of police patrol, Management
Science, 35 (2), 1989, 127–148.
Abstract. This paper describes efforts to validate a multiple car dispatch queueing (MCD)
model of police patrol operations using New York City data. The MCD model was designed for
use in a computer system that has been disseminated to many police departments in the U.S.
to help planners allocate patrol cars among precincts. It has also been used to evaluate specific
changes in patrol policy in New York. We define validation as a series of hierarchical procedures
ranging from tests of mathematical correctness to evaluations of model robustness. We discuss
the difficulties and limitations of assessing the validity of a model of a loosely managed system
in which human behavior is central and in which controlled experiments cannot be performed.
Focusing on specific uses, we conclude that the MCD model is a good although imperfect de-
scription of patrol operations in New York and is a potentially useful planning tool for many
other urban police departments.
Keywords: Queueing, Validation, Police patrol, Multiple car dispatch queueing model, New
York City, Hierarchical procedures, Mathematical correctness, Model robustness, Urban police
departments
24. Blake, R.H., S.C. Graves and P.C. Santos. A model for the configuration of incoming WATS
lines, QUESTA, 7, 1990, 3–21.
Abstract. WearGuard is a direct marketer and retailer of uniforms and work clothes, which
relies primarily on phone orders for sales. For this purpose it maintains a series of toll-free “800-
number” lines, known as WATS lines, to receive its incoming calls. These lines are of several
types, where each type serves a different portion of the country and has a different usage fee.
In this paper, we determine how many of each type of WATS lines should be employed. After
defining the problem more completely, we develop a queueing model to describe the system and a
dynamic program to solve the configuration problem to optimality. The model has been applied
to the problem by WearGuard since 1984. We present an example and examine the sensitivity
of the solution to variations in various parameters. We validate the model by comparing the
9
results of this model to other approximate models.
Keywords: Overflow, Telephone traffic, WATS lines, Queueing model, Dynamic program, Sensi-
tivity
25. Feinberg, M.A. Performance characteristics of automated call distribution systems. GLOBE-
COM ’90: IEEE Global Telecommunications Conference and Exhibition. ‘Communications:
Connecting the Future’. IEEE, New York, NY, USA, 1990, 415–419.
Abstract. It is shown that choosing appropriate performance characteristics is crucial to the
correct sizing of an automated call distribution (ACD) system. The fraction of rejected calls,
which is widely considered as the ma jor performance characteristic, should be replaced by the
fraction of served clients. The opportunity to measure the fraction of served clients will arise
with the introduction of ISDN and SS7. It is argued that the number of access circuits and ACD
systems needs to exceed the number of agents by only approximately 10%. Increasing this per-
centage further leads to tremendous growth in the waiting time without any further significant
increase in the fraction of served clients. It is shown that the performance characteristics of the
ACD system are very sensitive to parameters that are mostly defined by the nature of the user’s
business, and are not very sensitive to parameters that are defined by human nature.
Keywords: Telephone system, Automated call distribution, Rejected calls, Performance charac-
teristic, Served clients, Access circuits, Waiting time, ACD system, Human nature
26. Agnihothri, Saligrama R. and Patricia F. Taylor. Staffing a centralized appointment scheduling
department in Lourdes Hospital, Interfaces, 21 (5), 1991, 1–11.
Abstract. Lourdes Hospital in Binghampton, New York, uses a centralized system to schedule
appointments by telephone for outpatients, inpatients, and other ambulatory services. Customer
surveys and an increase in customer complaints revealed lengthy delays in answering telephone
calls. Using queueing theory to plan optimal staffing levels to meet estimated demand has been
successful. Based on the results of a study, staffing patterns were adjusted to more adequately
match demand peaks with capacity. It was found that the existing staff and the number of
hours they were working was adequate to meet the demand. Supervision was increased to mon-
itor telephone response levels for specific time periods, and non-telephone tasks were assigned
and scheduled so as to supplement the required telephone coverage. It was also discovered that
low server utilization, in terms of telephone answering, is quite essential to providing a high level
of service.
Keywords: USA, Centralized appointment scheduling department, Lourdes Hospital, Bingham-
ton, New York, Queuing model, Optimal staffing levels, MMC approximation
27. Feinberg, M.A. Analytical model of automated call distribution system, Queueing, Performance
and Control in ATM. ITC-13 Workshops. Proceedings of the Thirteenth International Teletraffic
Congress. North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1991, 193–197.
Abstract. An analytical model of the automated call distribution (ACD) system was developed
which allows one to obtain results for systems with possible retrials after a busy signal, with an
10
impatient hang up, and with limitations on the number of access circuits and waiting time. A
special iteration algorithm is applied to this model. As the comparison with simulation results
shows, this approach allows one to obtain good results.
Keywords: Automated call distribution system, Analytical model, ACD, Busy signal, Access
circuits, Waiting time, Iteration algorithm, Simulation results
28. Milito, Rodolfo A., Yonatan Levy and Yair Arian. Dynamic algorithms for distributed queues
with abandonments. Teletraffic and Datatraffic in a Period of Change. ITC-13. Proceedings
of the Thirteenth International Teletraffic Congress. North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Nether-
lands, 1991, 329–334.
Abstract. In this paper we consider the problem of distributing traffic to multiple parallel
queues based on incomplete and possibly inaccurate state information. This problem arises in
the context of intelligent networks where large customers rely on the network for traffic dis-
tribution to multiple locations. The main contributions of the paper are: (i) classification of
approaches to the problem; (ii) a revenue-driven, Markovian decision model which captures
the crucial elements of the problem; profit maximization, multiple job classes, blocking, and
abandonments; and (iii) demonstration of the superior performance of implementable dynamic
policies.
29. Nowikow, P. and K. Wa jda. Agent scheduling for ACD switches. Telecommunication Services
for Developing Economies. Proceedings of the ITC Specialist Seminar, Elsevier, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands, 1991, 655–660.
Abstract. The authors describe a system for staff scheduling in automatic call distribution
PBX exchanges based on gathered statistical data. General traffic engineering aspects for ACD
exchanges employing the Erlang C formula are presented. An algorithm for choosing the number
of active operators implementing an idea of ‘daily call profile’ is also included. Trials carried out
for a ROLM 9000 ACD exchange proved that system is technologically feasible and economically
attractive.
Keywords: ACD switches, Staff scheduling, Automatic call distribution PBX exchanges, Traffic
engineering aspects, ACD exchanges, Erlang-C formula, Daily call profile, ROLM-9000 ACD
exchange
30. Quinn, P., B. Andrews and H. Parsons. Allocating telecommunications resources at L.L. Bean,
Inc., Interfaces, 21, 1991, 75–91.
Abstract. We developed and implemented a model for optimizing the deployment of tele-
marketing resources at L.L. Bean, a large telemarketer and mail-order catalog house. The
deployment levels obtained with economic optimization were significantly different from those
formerly determined by service-level criteria, and the resultant cost savings were estimated as
$9 to $10 million per year. To develop the economic-optimization approach, we used queueing
theory, devised an expected total-cost ob jective function, and accounted for retrial behavior and
potential caller abandonments through a regression model that related the abandonment rates
11
to customer service levels. Management at L.L. Bean has fully accepted this approach, which
now explicitly sets optimal levels for the number of telephone trunks (lines) carrying incoming
traffic, the number of agents scheduled, and the maximum number of queue positions allowed
for customers waiting for a telephone agent.
Keywords: Telecommunications resources, L.L. Bean Inc., Telemarketing resources, Mail-order
catalog house, Queuing theory, Expected total cost ob jective function
31. Sparrow, L.B. Manning the telephone enquiry bureau at British Gas West Midlands. In Opera-
tions Research in Management, S.C. Littlechild, editor. New York: Prentice Hall, 1991, 167–173.
Abstract. All telephone enquiries to British Gas West Midlands are dealt with by a team of
specialist clerks in two centralized enquiry bureaux. Customers anywhere in the region can
contact a bureau at local call costs. At all times it is essential to maintain a high standard of
answering service, not only because this is expected by the customer for any type of enquiry but
also to ensure that emergency calls relating, perhaps, to gas leaks are accepted and dealt with.
In about 1970, the enquiry bureaux were finding it difficult to maintain the servicing of cus-
tomers’ calls at peak periods with the existing monitoring equipment. It was decided to set up a
queueing theory model of the telephone answering system. The aim was to derive the relation-
ships between traffic level, grade of service, waiting time and manning levels within the bureaux.
The model would be used as a planning tool, both for indicating peak manning requirements
and for optimizing number of staff at off-peak times. This chapter describes the model which
was developed and the results which were obtained.
(Appears also in Section II.)
32. Sumita, S. and T. Ozawa. Performance analysis and design for distributed switching systems.
Teletraffic and Datatraffic in a Period of Change. ITC-13. Proceedings of the Thirteenth Inter-
national Teletraffic Congress. North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands; 1991, 761–766.
Abstract. The authors address performance analysis and design issues for distributed switching
systems. Four ma jor issues are discussed from the viewpoint of switching system performance:
allocation of call-control functions to individual processors; distribution of call-processing load
to individual processors; interprocessor communications; and access contention for shared re-
sources. Several functional distribution architectures are introduced and are compared in terms
of call connection delay, interprocessor communications traffic, and total cost. Several key princi-
ples for allocating call-processing functions are drawn from this comparison. Finally, a balanced
design approach is presented as a promising method for dealing with a wide range of traffic
conditions that will be typical in the broadband ISDN era.
Keywords: Call control function allocation, Call processing land distribution, Interprocessor
traffic, Performance analysis, Design issues; Distributed switching systems, Interprocessor com-
munications, Access contention, Shared resources, Functional distribution architectures, Call
connection delay, Total cost, Broadband-ISDN
33. Khalil, Z., G. Falin and T. Yang. Some analytical results for congestion in subscriber line mod-
ules, QUESTA, 10 (4), 1992, 381–402.
12
Abstract. In modern telephone exchanges, subscriber lines are usually connected to the so-
called subscriber line modules. These modules serve both incoming and outgoing traffic. An
important difference between these two types of calls lies in the fact that in the case of blocking
due to all channels busy in the module, outgoing calls can be queued whereas incoming calls get
busy signal and must be re-initiated in order to establish the required connection. The authors
study the corresponding queueing model which takes into account subscriber retrials and inves-
tigate some of its properties such as existence of stationary regime, derive explicit formulas for
the system characteristics, limit theorems for systems under high repetition intensity of blocked
calls and limit theorems for systems under heavy traffic.
Keywords: Telephone traffic, Queueing model, Retrial queue, Queueing theory, Congestion, Sub-
scriber line modules, Telephone exchanges, Limit theorems
34. Perry, M. and A. Nilsson. Performance modeling of automatic call distributors: assignable grade
of service staffing. International Switching Symposium 1992. ‘Diversification and Integration of
Networks and Switching Technologies Towards the 21st Century’ Proceedings. Inst. Electron.
Inf. Commun. Eng, Tokyo, Japan, 1992, 294–298.
Abstract. A new generation of automatic call distributors (ACDs) has been developed that can
handle multiple cell queues and associate priorities with these queues. The priority of a call is
determined through an aging factor, which is a real number used to age the time a call has been
queued. For example, if the oldest call in call queue 1 has waited 10 seconds, and the oldest
call in call queue 2 has waited 7 seconds, and the aging factors for queue 1 and queue 2 are 3
and 5, then the second call would have a higher priority, since the calculated priority factors
are (10*3) and (7*5). The paper gives an analytical model for computing the expected waiting
time for call types that have different aging factors. The results can be used to determine both
the number of agents and the aging values needed to yield specified expected waiting times.
Numerical examples focus on the ACD application operator services, in which both directory
assistance and toll/assist calls are served from the same positions.
Keywords: Performance modeling, Automatic call distributors, Operator services staffing, Het-
erogeneous positions, Telephony industry, Multi-purpose operator positions, Automatic call dis-
tributor, ACD, Toll and assist calls, Directory-assistance calls, Classical Erlang-type queueing
models, Expected waiting-time, Average operator occupancy, Average occupancies, Simulation
results
35. Whitt, W. Understanding the efficiency of multi-server service systems, Management Science,
38 (5), 1992, 708–723.
Abstract. In the design and operation of service systems, it is important to determine an
appropriate level of server utilization (the proportion of time each server should be working).
In a multiserver queue with unlimited waiting space, the appropriate server utilization typically
increases as the number of servers (and the arrival rate) increases. They explain this economy
of scale and give a rough quantitative characterization. The authors also show how increased
variability in the arrival and service processes tends to reduce server utilization with a given
grade of service. As part of this analysis, the author develops simple aproximations for the mean
steady-state waiting time and the fully steady-state waiting-time distribution. These approxi-
13
mations exploit an infinite-server approximation for the probability of delay and a single-server
approximation for the ocnditional waiting-time distribution given that waiting occurs. The em-
phasis is on simple formulas that directly convey understanding.
Keywords: Operations research, Probability, Queueing theory, Multi-server service systems,
Server utilization, Unlimited waiting space, Service processes, Mean steady-state waiting time,
Fully steady-state waiting-time distribution, Infinite-server approximation, Delay
36. Andrews, Bruce and Henry Parsons. Establishing telephone-agent staffing levels through eco-
nomic optimization, Interfaces, 23 (2), 1993, 14–20.
Abstract. We developed and implemented an economic-optimization model for telephone-agent
staffing at L.L. Bean, a large tele-marketer and mail-order catalog house for quality outdoor
sporting goods and apparel. The staffing levels we obtained with economic optimization were
very different from those used by the company in the past, when staff size was determined by
service-level criteria. For L.L. Bean, the resultant savings were estimated to amount to more
than $500,000 per year. In the model, we used queuing theory, devised an expected total-cost
ob jective function, and accounted for retrials and potential caller abandonments through a re-
gression model that related the abandonment rates to the telephone-service factor (percentage
of calls answered within a predetermined time interval).
Keywords: Telephone agent staffing levels, Economic optimization, L.L. Bean, Telemarketer,
Mail-order catalog house, Outdoor sporting goods, Apparel, Queuing theory, Expected total
cost ob jective function, Retrials, Potential caller abandonments, Regression model
(Appears also in Section VII.)
37. Sacks, Stephen R., Richard C. Larson and Christian Schaack. Minimizing the cost of dispatch
delays by holding patrol cars in reserve, Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 9 (2), 1993, 203–
224.
Abstract. At many police departments high-priority callers sometimes incur undue delays that
could be avoided by the use of a differential response strategy that takes full account of the
different “costs” of delay for different priority calls. In this article, we examine such a strategy,
in which lower-priority callers may not be served immediately, even though some response units
are available. Arriving priority i callers are queued whenever the number of busy patrol units
equals or exceeds the cutoff number for that priority. Our purpose is (1) to find a practical way
of choosing the set of cutoff numbers that will minimize the expected total cost of delays for the
entire system and (2) to use that method to investigate how the optimal set of cutoffs changes
in response to changes in several important variables, including the relative costs of delay for
different priorities, the overall workload, and the relative frequencies of different priority calls.
Keywords: Differential response, Police deployment, Police dispatching, 911
38. Whitt, W. Approximations for the GI/G/m queue, Production and Operations Management, 2
(2), 1993, 114–161.
Abstract. Approximations for a basic queueing model are developed and evaluated. The model
14
is the GI/G/m queue, which has m identical servers in parallel, unlimited waiting room, and
the first-come first-served queue discipline, with service and interarrival times coming from in-
dependent sequences of independent and identically distributed random variables with general
distributions. The approximations depend on the general interarrival-time and service-time dis-
tributions only through their first two moments. The main focus is on the expected waiting
time and the probability of having to wait before beginning service, but approximations are
also developed for other congestion measures, including the entire distributions of waiting time,
queue-length and number in system. These approximations are especially useful for incorporat-
ing GI/G/m in larger models, such as queueing networks, wherein the approximations can be
components of rapid modeling tools.
Keywords: Approximation theory, Probability, Queueing theory, GI/G/m queue, First-come first
served queue discipline, Interarrival times, Service times, Approximations, Service-time distri-
butions, Queue length
39. Berman, O. and R.C. Larson. Determining optimal pool size of a temporary Call-In work force,
European Journal of Operations Research, 73, 1994, 55–64.
Abstract. This paper is one in a series that introduces concepts of just-in-time personnel.
Management of worker job time and assignment are in many ways analogous to inventory man-
agement. Idle workers represent unutilized ‘inventoried’ personnel, imposing potentially large
costs on management. But a lack of workers when needed may force the use of otherwise un-
necessary overtime or other emergency procedures, creating excessive costs analogous to costs
of stockout in traditional inventory systems. A system having just-in-time personnel at-
tempts to meet all demands for personnel at minimum cost by sharply reducing both excess
worker inventory with its concomitant ‘paid lost time’ and underage of worker inventory with
its associated costs of stockout. The model in this paper focuses on one important component
of a just-in-time or ‘jit’ personnel system: response to day-to-day fluctuations in workload,
worker outages due to sick leave, personal constraints or other unscheduled events. To maxi-
mize utilization of the JIT concept, we assume there exists a pool of call-in personnel who can
be called on the day that they are needed. Each such call-in ‘temp’ is guaranteed a minimum
number of offered days per month. A temp is paid each month for the days actually worked
plus the differential, if any, between the number of days offered and the number of days guaran-
teed. Temps, like regular workers, may be unavailable on any given day due to illness, etc. The
analysis leads to an exact probabilistic model that can be solved to find the optimal pool size of
temps. Numerical results are included.
Keywords: Work force management, Optimal pool size, Temporary work force
40. Gordon, J.J. and M.S. Fowler. Accurate force and answer consistency algorithms for operator
services. Proceedings of the 14th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-14, Elsevier, Amster-
dam, The Netherlands, 1994, 339–348.
Abstract. Operator services are big business. In the United States operator salaries per annum
amount to approximately one billion dollars. Service providers constantly strive to cut costs
while maintaining customer satisfaction. Queueing theory provides two tools to help them do
this: force algorithms for accurately provisioning their teams, and answer consistency algorithms
15
for evaluating the consistency of the service provided to customers.
We analyze force and answer consistency algorithms based on three models: Erlang C, M/G/c,
and M/G/c with abandonments. Using two weeks of directory assistance (DA) field data, we
investigate how well these algorithms model the behavior of a real DA operator team. Although
the M/G/c model performs best, our analysis suggests that certain modifications to the simple
M/G/c model could significantly enhance its practical value.
41. Levy, Y., Johri S. Durinovic and R.A. Milito. Dynamic network call distribution with periodic
updates. Fundamental Role of Teletraffic in the Evolution of Telecommunications Networks.
Proceedings of the 14th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-14, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The
Netherlands, 1994, 85–94.
Abstract. The ability to effectively distribute calls in the network to multiple customer sites
has become one of the ma jor challenges for the intelligent network. The general goal is to make
effective use of available information to improve the load balancing across the sites and the over-
all service level customers provide to their own clients. This paper introduces a new approach
consisting of two coupled algorithms: a traffic allocation algorithm and a call distribution al-
gorithm. The traffic allocation algorithm dynamically generates the proportion of global traffic
to be sent to each site in response to periodic updates of system state. The call distribution
algorithm converts this time varying allocation into a sequence of routing decisions. The paper
demonstrates that this easy-to-implement approach achieves superior performance even when
only a fraction of the offered traffic is controllable, provided that the update interval is not
excessively long.
Keywords: Dynamic network call distribution, Periodic updates, Multiple customer sites, In-
telligent network, Load balancing, Overall service level, Coupled algorithms, Traffic allocation
algorithm, Call distribution algorithm, Global traffic, System state, Time-varying allocation,
Routing decisions, Update interval, Traffic management
42. Perry, M. and A. Nilsson. Performance modeling of automatic call distributors: Operator ser-
vices staffing with heterogeneous positions. Fundamental Role of Teletraffic in the Evolution of
Telecommunications Networks. Proceeding of the 14th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-
14. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1994, 1023–1032.
Abstract. The telephony industry has introduced a new generation of multi-purpose operator
positions, that with their associated automatic call distributor (ACD) allow operators to serve
both toll and assist (TA) and directory assistance (DA) calls from the same position. When all
operators can serve both TA and DA calls and all of the positions are multi-purpose, classical
Erlang-type queueing models can be used to calculate two important measures: the expected
waiting time for calls and the average operator occupancy. However when all of the positions
are not multi-purpose (i.e. the operators are a heterogeneous group: some can do both TA and
DA, some can do just TA and some can do just DA) the calculation of these two measures is
a new and challenging problem. In this paper, approximations for expected waiting times and
average occupancies are presented, and are shown, by comparison to simulation results, to be
quite accurate.
16
Keywords: Performance modeling, Automatic call distributors, Operator services staffing, Het-
erogeneous positions, Telephony industry, Multi-purpose operator positions, Automatic call dis-
tributor, ACD, Toll and assist calls, Directory-assistance calls, Classical Erlang-type queueing
models, Expected waiting time, Average operator occupancy, Average occupancies, Simulation
results
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
43. Andrews, Bruce H. and Shawn M. Cunningham. L.L. Bean improves call-center forecasting,
Interfaces, 25 (6), 1995, 1–13.
Abstract. Two forecasting models are developed and implemented for use at L.L. Bean Inc.,
a widely known retailer of high-quality outdoor goods and apparel. The models forecast calls
incoming to L.L. Bean’s call center so that efficient staffing schedules for telephone agents can be
produced two weeks in advance. The ARIMA/transfer function methodology is used to model
these time series data since they exhibit seasonal patterns but are strongly influenced by inde-
pendent variables, including holiday and advertising interventions. The improved precision of
the models is estimated to save $300,000 annually through enhanced scheduling efficiency.
Keywords: Call center forecasting, L.L. Bean, Forecasting models, Retailer, Telephone agents,
Staffing schedules, ARIMA transfer function methodology, Time series data, Seasonal patterns,
Holiday, Advertising interventions
(Appears also in Section II.)
44. Borst, S.C. Optimal probabilistic allocation of customer types to servers. Proceedings of the
Joint International Conference on Measurement and Modeling of Computer Systems (SIGMET-
RICS95). Ottawa, ON, Canada, 1995, 116–125.
Abstract. The model under consideration consists of n customer types attended by m parallel
non-identical servers. Customers are allocated to the servers in a probabilistic manner; upon
arrival customers are sent to one of the servers according to an m
∗ n matrix of routing proba-
bilities. We consider the problem of finding an allocation that minimizes a weighted sum of the
mean waiting times. We expose the structure of an optimal allocation and describe for some
special cases in detail how the structure may be exploited in actually determining an optimal
allocation.
Keywords: Probabilistic allocation, Customer types, Servers, Non-identical servers, Routing
probabilities, Parallel servers, Distributed computer systems, Communication networks, Global
scheduling
45. Thompson, G.M. Improved implicit optimal modeling of the labor shift scheduling problem,
Management Science, 41 (4), 1995, 595–607.
Abstract. This paper presents an integer programming model for developing optimal shift
schedules while allowing extensive flexibility in terms of alternate shift starting times, shift
lengths, and break placement. The model combines the work of Moondra (1976) and Bechtold
and Jacobs (1990) by implicitly matching meal breaks to implicitly represented shifts. Moreover,
17
the new model extends the work of these authors to enable the scheduling of overtime and the
scheduling of rest breaks. We compare the new model to Bechtold and Jacobs’ model over a
diverse set of 588 test problems. The new model generates optimal solutions more rapidly, solves
problems with more shift alternatives, and does not generate schedules violating the operative
restrictions on break timing.
Keywords: Labor scheduling, Integer programming, Implicit modeling
46. Jennings, O.B., A. Mandelbaum, W.A. Massey and W. Whitt. Server staffing to meet time-
varying demand, Management Science, 42 (10), 1996, 1383–1394.
Abstract. We consider a mutiserver service system with general nonstationary arrival and
service-time processes in which s(t), the number of servers as a function of time, needs to be
selected to meet pro jected loads. We try to choose s(t) so that the probability of a delay (before
beginning service) hits or falls just below a target probability at all times. We develop an approx-
imate procedure based on a time-dependent normal distribution, where the mean and variance
are determined by infinite-server approximations. We demonstrate that this approximation is
effective by making comparisons with the exact numerical solution of the Markovian Mt /M/st
model.
Keywords: Operator staffing, Queues, Nonstationary queues, Queues with time-dependent ar-
rival rates, Multiserver queues, Infinite-server queues, Capacity planning
47. Alanyali, M. and B. Ha jek. Analysis of simple algorithms for dynamic load balancing, MOR, 22
(4), 1997, 840–871.
Abstract. The principle of load balancing is examined for dynamic resource allocation sub ject
to certain constraints. The emphasis is on the performance of simple allocation strategies which
can be implemented on-line. Either finite capacity constraints on resources or migration of load
can be incorporated into the setup. The load balancing problem is formulated as a stochastic
optimal control problem. Variants of a “Least Load Routing” policy are shown to lead to a fluid
type limit and to be asymptotically optimal.
Keywords: Dynamic load balancing, Dynamic resource allocation, Constraints, Finite capacity
constraints, Load migration, Stochastic optimal control problem, Least load routing policy
48. Berman, Oded, Richard C. Larson and Edieal Pinker. Scheduling workforce and workflow in a
high volume factory, Management Science, 43 (2), 1997, 158–172.
Abstract. We define a high volume factory to be a connected network of workstations, at which
assigned workers process work-in-progress that flows at high rates through the workstations. A
high rate usually implies that each worker processes many pieces per hour, enough so that work
can be described as a deterministic hourly flow rate rather than, say, a stochastic number of
discrete entities. Examples include mail processing and sorting; check processing, telephoned
order processing, and inspecting and packaging of certain foods. Exogenous work may enter
the factory at any workstation according to any time-of-day profile. Work-in-progress flows
through the factory in discrete time according to Markovian routings. Workers, who in general
18
are cross-trained, may work part time or full time shifts, may start work only at designated shift
starting times, and may change job assignments at mid-shift. In order to smooth the flow of
work-in-progress through the service factory, work-in-progress may be temporarily inventoried
(in buffers) at workstations. The ob jective is to schedule the workers (and correspondingly, the
workflow) in a manner that minimizes labor costs sub ject to a variety of service-level, contractual
and physical constraints. Motivated in part by analysis techniques of discrete time linear time-
invariant (LTI) systems, an ob ject-oriented linear programming (OOLP) model is developed.
Using exogenous input work profiles typical of large U.S. mail processing facilities, illustrative
computational results are included.
Keywords: Linear programming, Scheduling, Manufacturing, Ob ject-oriented, Queueing, Queue-
ing networks, Markov chains
49. Brandt, A., M. Brandt, G. Spahl and D. Weber. Modelling and optimization of call distribution
systems. Teletraffic Contributions for the Information Age. Proceedings of the 15th Interna-
tional Teletraffic Congress, ITC-15, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997, 133–144.
Abstract. This paper deals with the problem of finding optimal parameters for automatic
call distribution (ACD) systems. A very general ACD model is considered, based on a multi-
server combined loss/waiting system with impatient customers allowing an announcement before
entering the service. For constant announcement time, approximations for all performance char-
acteristics are provided. The accuracy of the results is compared with simulations. Within a
flexible ACD cost model the modelling is used to find cost optimal ACD system parameters
under pre-defined service quality constraints. Realistic examples are used to demonstrate the
optimizing procedure.
Keywords: Call distribution systems, Optimal parameters, ACD systems, ACD model, Loss
waiting system, Impatient customers, Flexible ACD cost model, Predefined service quality con-
straints, Optimizing procedure, Open queueing network
50. Coffman, E.G. Jr., E.N. Gilbert and Y.A. Kogan. Optimal redialing policies. Proceedings of the
15th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-15, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997,
943–952.
Abstract. Since callers encountering busy signals often want to redial, modern communication
networks have been designed to provide redialing automatically. Redialing services commonly
have two parameters: a maximum number n of retries and a total duration τ over which re-
tries are to be made. Typically, retries are made at evenly-spaced time intervals of length τ /n
until either the call succeeds or n retries have failed. We analyze this redialing policy in detail
for several models of called-number availability; we describe situations where it maximizes the
probability of call completion, and situations wehre it does not.
51. Duffield, N.G. and W. Whitt. Control and recovery from rare congestion events in a large multi-
server system, Queueing Systems, 26, 1997, 69–104.
Abstract. We develop deterministic fluid approximations to describe the recovery from rare
19
congestion events in a large multi-server system in which customer holding times have a general
distribution. There are two cases, depending on whether or not we exploit the age distribution
(the distribution of elapsed holding times of customers in service). If we do not exploit the age
distribution, then the rare congestion event is a large number of customers present. If we do
exploit the age distribution, then the rare event is an unusual age distribution, possibly accom-
panied by a large number of customers present. As an approximation, we represent the large
multi-server system as an M/G/
∞ model. We prove that, under regularity conditions, the fluid
approximations are asymptotically correct as the arrival rate increases. The fluid approximations
show the impact upon the recovery time of the holding-time distribution beyond its mean. The
recovery time may or may not be affected by the holding-time distribution having a long tail,
depending on the precise definition of recovery. The fluid approximations can be used to analyze
various overload control schemes, such as reducing the arrival rate or interrupting services in
progress. We also establish large deviations principles to show that the two kinds of rare events
have the same exponentially small order. We give numerical examples showing the effect of the
holding-time distribution and the age distribution, focusing especially on the consequences of
long-tail distributions.
Keywords: Multi-server systems, High congestion, Recovery from congestion, Overload control,
Long-tail distributions, Transient behavior, Fluid limits, Fluid approximations, Large deviations,
Sanov’s theorem, Residual lifetimes, Age distributions
52. Durinovic, Johri S. and Y. Levy. Advanced routing solutions for toll-free customers: algorithm
design and performance. Teletraffic Contributions for the Information Age. Proceedings of the
15th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-15, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997,
157–167.
Abstract. This paper describes algorithms that are at the core of recent offerings in the AT&T
intelligent network for dynamic, real-time network call distribution. These algorithms: (1) pro-
vide call by call routing to multiple customers sites based on periodic site-state updates; (2)
address diverse goals such as geographic preferences and constraints, least cost routing, perfor-
mance thresholds, and service ob jectives; and (3) allow user control within a structured algo-
rithmic framework. We provide examples of simulation predictions of performance and efficiency
improvements as well as results of field experience by customers.
Keywords: Advanced routing solutions, Toll-free customers, Algorithm design, Algorithm per-
formance, AT&T, Intelligent network, Dynamic real-time network call distribution, Call-by-call
routing, Periodic site state updates, Least cost routing, Performance thresholds, Service ob jec-
tives, Simulation predictions, Automatic call distribution
53. Kogan, Y., Y. Levy and R.A. Milito. Call routing to distributed queues: Is FIFO really better
than MED? Telecommunication Systems—Modeling, Analysis, Design and Management, 7 (1–
3), 1997, 299–312.
Abstract. New services providing automatic call distribution in the network have been one of
the most hotly contested areas in the USA telecommunications arena in recent years. This has
been fueled by increasing demand from large corporations for intelligent network routing that
will keep their geographically distributed telemarketing/service centers operating with maximum
20
efficiency. This paper compares two basic strategies for a network call distributor: a centralized
FIFO queue and a distributed queueing strategy called minimum-expected-delay (MED). Ac-
cording to MED, a central controller routes each arrival to the node that minimizes its expected
delay (waiting time). Our main result qualifies the conventional wisdom that perceives FIFO
as optimal. We show that the waiting time under FIFO is not stochastically smaller than that
under MED. Furthermore, we prove that the waiting time distribution functions intersect at a
single point. Numerical experiments suggest that, for certain performance criteria and over a
range of parameters of interest, MED can actually outperform FIFO.
Keywords: MED, Automatic call distribution, USA, Intelligent network routing, Telemarketing,
Service centers, Centralized FIFO queue, Distributed queueing strategy, Minimum expected de-
lay strategy, Central controller, Delay minimization, Distribution functions, Performance criteria
54. Shanthikumar, J.G. and S.H. Xu. Asymptotically optimal routing and service rate allocation in
a multiserver queueing system, Operations Research, 45 (3), 1997, 464–469.
Abstract. We consider a single stage queueing system with c heterogeneous servers. Customers
arrive at this system according to a renewal process with mean 1/λ and squared coefficient of
variation (scv) C 2
a . An incoming customer is routed to server i with probability θi , �ci=1 θi = 1.
The service times at server i are i.i.d random variables with mean 1/µi and scv C 2
Si . The holding
cost rate of queue i is hi per customer, i = 1, 2, . . . , c. The problems of interest are twofold: (a)
for a fixed service rate allocation µi , �c
i=1 µi = µ, find the routing probabilities, θ∗
i , �ci=1 θ∗
i = 1,
that minimize the average total holding cost; and (b) for fixed routing probabilities θi , �c
i=1 θi ,
and total service rate µ, find the service rate allocation µ∗
i = µδ∗
i , �ci=1 δ∗
i = 1, that minimizes
the average total holding cost of the system. For each problem, we characterize the optimal pol-
icy under heavy traffic conditions. We also derive the routing probabilities, ˆ
θi (proportions ˆ
δi ),
i = 1, . . . , c, that are strongly asymptotically optimal. That is, the difference between the average
total holding costs under ˆ
θi , i = 1, . . . , c, and θ∗
i , i = 1, . . . , c( ˆ
δi , i = 1, . . . , c, and δ∗
i , i = 1, . . . , c)
is bounded by a fixed constant independent of the routing probabilities (proportions) and the
arrival rate. In addition, we discuss the necessity and sufficiency of the accurate knowledge of the
means and scvs of the interarrival and service times in obtaining asymptotically optimal policies.
Keywords: Queues: approximations, limit theorems, optimization; Probability: stochastic model,
applications; Optimal routing; Service rate allocation; Multiserver queueing system; Single-stage
queueing system; Renewal process; Holding cost; Optimal policy
55. Thompson, G.M. Assigning telephone operators to shifts at New Brunswick Telephone Com-
pany, Interfaces, 27 (4), 1997,1–11.
Abstract. The author developed a procedure for assigning telephone operators to shifts at New
Brunswick Telephone Company (NBTel). Although the problem has received scant attention
in the literature, its solution greatly affects employees’ satisfaction with their work schedules.
NBTel requires that all shifts be assigned to employees, and it is obligated contractually to satisfy
preferences for shifts in order of employee seniority. The specialized shift assignment heuristic
(SSAH) developed runs on a personal computer, generating approximately three solutions per
second. Employee and shift databases are maintained in a spreadsheet, and macros are used to
integrate the heuristic into the spreadsheet. Both management and employees see SSAH as an
21
improvement over the previous manual procedure.
Keywords: Operator shift assignment, New Brunswick Telephone Company, Specialized shift
assignment heuristic, Spreadsheet, Management, Employees, Optimisation
56. Fischer, M.J. and D.A. Garbin. Gharakhanian, A., Performance modeling of distributed auto-
matic call distribution systems, Telecommunication Systems—Modeling, Analysis, Design and
Management, 9 (2), 1998, 133–152.
Abstract. The number of businesses using automatic call distribution (ACD) systems has
grown significantly in the last five years. The industry shows all the signs of continued or
greater growth in the foreseeable future. While ACD systems have proliferated they have also
evolved from fundamentally local to distributed systems. An ACD manager can no longer opti-
mize his traffic by using inputs from a simple set of queueing tables. The most common system
is now a distributed network where subsystems interact with each other and cannot be analyzed
in isolation. This paper examines the strengths and weaknesses of queueing models that have
been used historically with ACD systems and develops modifications to these models (including
agent wrap-up times) that are combined with queueing network theories to construct an original
ACD network performance algorithm to work with distributed systems.
Keywords: Automatic call distribution systems, Businesses, ACD, Distributed network, Agent
wrap-up times, Queueing network theories, Network performance algorithm, Traffic optimization
57. Kolesar, Peter J. and Linda V. Green. Insights on service system design from a normal approxi-
mation to Erlang’s delay formula, Production and Operations Management, 7 (3), 1998, 282–293.
Abstract. We show how a simple normal approximation to Erlang’s delay formula can be used
to analyze capacity and staffing problems in service systems that can be modeled as M/M/s
queues. The numbers of servers, s, needed in an M/M/s queueing system to assure a probability
of delay of, at most, p can be well approximated by s
≈ ρ + z1−p √ρ, where z1−p is the (1 − p)th
percentile of the standard normal distribution and ρ, the presented load on the system, is the
ratio of λ, the customer arrival rate, to µ, the service rate. We examine the accuracy of this
approximation over a set of parameters typical of service operations ranging from police patrol,
through telemarketing to automatic teller machines, and we demonstrate that it tends to slightly
underestimate the number of servers actually needed to hit the delay probability target—adding
one server to the number suggested by the above formula typically gives the exact result. More
importantly, the structure of the approximation promotes operational insight by explicitly link-
ing the number of servers with server utilization and the customer service level. Using a scenario
based on an actual teleservicing operation, we show how operations managers and designers can
quickly obtain insights about the trade-offs between system size, system utilization and customer
service. We argue that this little-used approach deserves a prominent role in the operations an-
alyst’s and operations manager’s toolbags.
Keywords: Erlang’s delay formula, M/M/s queue, Service system design, Normal approximation,
Staffing levels
58. Mandelbaum, A. and S. Zeltyn. Estimating characteristics of queueing networks using transac-
22
tional data, Queueing Systems, 29, 1998, 75–127.
Abstract. We are motivated by queueing networks in which queues are difficult to observe but
services are easy to record. Our goal is to estimate the queues from service data. More specifi-
cally, we consider an open queueing network with Poisson external arrivals, multi-server stations,
general service times and Markovian switches of customers between stations. Customers’ transi-
tions between stations may be either immediate or of exponentially distributed durations. Each
customer is supplied with an Identification Number (ID) upon entering the network. Operational
data is collected which includes transaction times (starts and terminations of services) and ID’s
of served customers. Our ob jective is to estimate the evolution of the queues in the network,
given the collected data. We cover estimation at both end of busy periods and in real time. The
applicability of the theory is demonstrated by analyzing a service operation.
Keywords: Queues, Queueing networks, Nonparametric inference, Data analysis, Hidden Markov
models, Performance evaluation, Queueing inference engine
59. Mandelbaum, A., W.A. Massey and M.I. Reiman. Strong approximations for Markovian service
networks, Queueing Systems, 30, 1998, 149–201.
Abstract. Inspired by service systems such as telephone call centers, we develop limit theorems
for a large class of stochastic service network models. They are a special family of nonstationary
Markov processes where parameters like arrival and service rates, routing topologies for the net-
work, and the number of servers at a given node are all functions of time as well as the current
state of the system. Included in our modeling framework are networks of Mt /Mt /nt queues with
abandonment and retrials. The asymptotic limiting regime that we explore for these networks
has a natural interpretation of scaling up the number of servers in response to a similar scaling
up of the arrival rate for the customers. The individual service rates, however, are not scaled.
We employ the theory of strong approximations to obtain functional strong laws of large num-
bers and functional central limit theorems for these networks. This gives us a tractable set of
network fluid and diffusion approximations. A common theme for service network models with
features like many servers, priorities, or abandonment is “non-smooth” state dependence that
has not been covered systematically by previous work. We prove our central limit theorems in
the presence of this non-smoothness by using a new notion of derivative.
Keywords: Strong approximations, Fluid approximations, Diffusion approximations, Multi-server
queues, Queues with abandonment, Queues with retrials, Priority queues, Queueing networks,
Jackson networks, Nonstationary queues
60. Mandelbaum, A. and G. Pats. State-dependent stochastic networks. Part I: Approximations
and aplications with continuous diffusion limits, The Annals of Applied Probability, 8 (2), 1998,
569–646.
Abstract. In a state-dependent queueing network arrival and service rates, as well as routing
probabilities, depend on the vector of queue lengths. For properly normalized such networks, we
derive functional laws of large numbers (FLLNs) and functional central limit theorems (FCLTs).
The former support fluid approximations and the latter support diffusion refinements.
The fluid limit in FLLN is the unique solution to a multidimensional autonomous ordinary
23
differential equation with state-dependent reflection. The diffusion limit in FCLT is the unique
strong solution to a stochastic differential equation with time-dependent reflection.
Examples are provided that demonstrate how such approximations facilitate the design, analysis
and optimization of various manufacturing service, communication and other systems.
Keywords and phrases: Birth and death process, State-dependent networks, Fluid and diffusion
approximations, Weak convergence, State- and time-dependent oblique reflection, Congestion-
dependent routing, Learning systems, Multiserver systems, Large finite buffers, Transient anal-
ysis
61. Mandelbaum, A. and M.I. Reiman. On pooling in queueing networks, Management Science, 44
(7), 1998, 971–981.
Abstract. We view each station in a Jackson network as a queue of tasks, of a particular type,
which are to be processed by the associated specialized server. A complete pooling of queues,
into a single queue, and servers, into a single server, gives rise to an M/PH/1 queue, where the
server is flexible in the sense that it processes all tasks. We assess the value of complete pooling
by comparing the steady-state mean so journ times of these two systems. The main insight from
our analysis is that care must be used in pooling. Sometimes pooling helps, sometimes it hurts,
and its effect (good or bad) can be unbounded. Also discussed briefly are alternative pooling
scenarios, for example complete pooling of only queues which results in an M/PH/S system,
or partial pooling which can be devastating enough to turn a stable Jackson network into an
unstable Bramson network. We conclude with some possible future research directions.
Keywords: Service facility design, Specialized server, Service operations, Efficiency, Stability,
Economics of scale
62. Marbach, P., O. Mihatsch and J.N. Tsitsiklis. Call admission control and routing in integrated
services networks using reinforcement learning. Proceedings of the 37th IEEE Conference on
Decision and Control, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 1998, 563–568.
Abstract. In integrated services communication networks, an important problem is to exercise
call admission control and routing so as to optimally use the network resources. This problem
is naturally formulated as a dynamic programming problem, which, however, is too complex to
be solved exactly. We use methods of reinforcement learning, together with a decomposition
approach, to find call admission control and routing policies. We compare the performance of
our policies with a commonly used heuristic policy.
Keywords: Dynamic call admission control, Call routing, Integrated services networks, Neuro-
dynamic programming, Resource requirements, Call classes, Dynamic programming problem,
Revenue maximization, Admitted calls per unit time maximization, Reinforcement learning,
Decomposition approach, State-dependent call admission control, State-dependent link costs,
Simulation-based learning method, Experiments, Performance, Heuristic
63. Mason, A.J., D.M. Ryan and D.M. Panton. Integrated simulation, heuristic and optimisation
approaches to staff scheduling, Operations Research, 46 (2), 1998, 161–175.
24
Abstract. This paper details a new simulation and optimisation based system for personnel
scheduling (rostering) of Customs staff at the Auckland International Airport, New Zealand.
An integrated approach using simulaiton, heuristic descent and integer programming techniques
has been developed to determine near-optimal staffing levels. The system begins by using a new
simulation system embedded within a heuristic search to determine minimum staffing levels for
arrival and departure work areas. These staffing requirements are then used as the input to an
integer programming model which optimally allocates full and part-time staff to each period of
the working day. These shifts are then assigned to daily work schedules having a six-day-on,
three-day-off structure. The application of these techniques has resulted in significantly lower
staffing levels, while at the same time creating both high quality rosters and ensuring that all
passenger processing targets are met. This paper charts the development of this system, outlines
failures.
Keywords: Simulation, Heuristic, Optimisation, Staff scheduling, Personnel scheduling, Ros-
tering, Customs staff, Auckland International Airport, New Zealand, Heuristic descent, Integer
programming, Near optimal staffing levels, Minimum staffing levels, Integer programming model,
Full-time staff, Part-time staff
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
64. Servi, L.D. and S. Humair. Optimizing Bernoulli routing policies for balancing loads on call cen-
ters and minimizing transmission costs. Proceedings of the 37th IEEE Conference on Decision
and Control, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 1998, 1653–1655.
Abstract. We address the problem of assigning probabilities at discrete time instants for routing
toll-free calls to a given set of call centers in order to minimize a weighted sum of transmission
costs and load variability at the call centers during the next time interval. We model the problem
as a tripartite graph and decompose finding the optimal probability assignment in the graph
into an estimation problem and a convex quadratic program problem. Using a heuristic that
uses gradient information around a given probability assignment we further address a practical
variant in which the number of probability assignments that can be changed at each time instant
is constrained.
Keywords: Bernoulli routing policy optimization, Call center load balancing, Transmission cost
minimization, Toll-free call routing, Load variability, Tripartite graph, Optimal probability as-
signment decomposition, Estimation problem, Convex quadratic program problem, Heuristic,
Gradient information
65. Van Dijk, N.M. On hybrid combination of queueing and simulation. Simulation: Past, Present
and Future. 12th European Simulation Multiconference 1998. ESM’98. As Part of the 50th
Anniversary Celebrations of the University of Manchester - the Home of Computing. SCS, San
Diego, CA, USA, 1998, 731–735.
Abstract. This paper illustrates how simulation and queueing theory can and should go hand in
hand for a variety of practical problems, both in daily-life and industry, which are still open for
fundamental research. To this end, it highlights real-life cases taken from: daily-life situations
(postal office or bank); administrative logistics (reengineering); tele-servicing (call-centres); and
transportation (railways).
25
Keywords: Simulation, Queueing theory, Postal office, Bank, Administrative logistics, Tele-
servicing, Call centres, Transportation, Railways
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
66. Bakshi, Y. and R.A. Skoog. Call distribution in a non-homogeneous distributed switching sys-
tem. Teletraffic Engineering in a Competitive World. Proceedings of the International Teletraffic
Congress, ITC-16. Vol. 3a. Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1999, 303–312.
Abstract. A new adaptive call distribution algorithm is developed for a nonhomogeneous mul-
tiprocessor switch. The algorithm does not require the knowledge of call handling capacities of
individual call processing nodes and, hence, does not require tuning for different system con-
figurations or during system upgrades. As shown by the simulation experiments, the algorithm
performs well in nonhomogeneous environments during both normal operation and when dy-
namic changes in capacities of system nodes take place.
Keywords: Distributed switching system, Adaptive call distribution algorithm, Nonhomogeneous
multiprocessor switch, Simulation, System node capacities
67. Borst, Sem and Pierre Seri. Robust algorithms for sharing agents with multiple skills. Working
paper, Bell Laboratories, Lucent Technologies, Murray Hill, NJ, USA, 1999.
Abstract. We consider a queueing model for a call center which is offered calls from several
skill classes. The agents may have heterogeneous skill sets, determining which classes of call they
can serve. We assume that there are traffic estimates specified for the various call classes in the
form of the expected arrival rate and mean service time. There are also service level ob jectives
defined for each class, including the target mean waiting time and the probability of the waiting
time exceeding a certain threshold.
We obtain conditions characterizing the range of feasible agent configurations. In addition, we
propose two simple credit schemes for sharing the agents among the various call classes in a
disciplined fashion. The credit schemes help ensure that each class receives a service level that is
similar to or better than it would have experienced when served in isolation. Numerical experi-
ments demonstrate the robustness properties of the credit schemes in case of inaccurate traffic
forecasts.
68. Brandt, Andreas and Manfred Brandt. On a two-queue priority system with impatience and its
application to a call center, Methodol. Comput. Appl. Probab., 1 (2), 1999, 191–210.
Abstract. We consider an s-server priority system with a protected and an unprotected queue.
The arrival rates at the queues and the service rate may depend on the number n of customers
being in service or in the protected queue, but the service rate is assumed to be constant for
n > s. As soon as any server is idle, a customer from the protected queue will be served ac-
cording to the FCFS discipline. However, the customers in the protected queue are impatient.
If the offered waiting time exceeds a random maximal waiting time I , then the customer leaves
the protected queue after time I . If I is less than a given deterministic time, then he leaves the
system, else he will be transferred by the system to the unprotected queue. The service of a
26
customer from the unprotected queue will be started if the protected queue is empty and more
than a given number of servers become idle. The model is a generalization of the many-server
queue with impatient customers. The global balance conditions seem to have no explicit solution.
However, the balance conditions for the density of the stationary state process for the subsystem
of customers being in service or in the protected queue can be solved. This yields the stability
conditions and the probabilities that precisely n customers are in service or in the protected
queue. For obtaining performance measures for the unprotected queue, a system approximation
based on fitting impatience intensities is constructed. The results are applied to the performance
analysis of a call center with an integrated voice-mail server.
Keywords: Two-queue priority system, Call center, s-server priority system, Arrival rates, Service
rate, Random maximal waiting time, Many-server queue, Global balance conditions, Stability
conditions, Performance analysis, Integrated voice-mail server
69. Coffman, S. and M.L. Saxton. Staffing the reference desk in the largely-digital library, Reference
Librarian, 66, 1999, 141–161.
Abstract. The article examines how a centralized, networked reference service might improve
efficiency and reduce costs by addressing two long-standing and seemingly intractable problems
associated with the reference process: that librarians spend only a small portion of their time at
the reference desk actually answering questions, and that many of the questions they do answer
could be handled by paraprofessionals. The authors explore the feasibility of a live, centralized,
networked reference service in a library setting by comparing traditional reference services at the
County of Los Angeles Public Library with a commercial inbound call center designed to handle
the same volume of questions. Applying Erlang C, the standard algorithm used to calculate
staffing requirements for commercial call centers, the authors find that a networked reference
service based on a call center model could reduce the reference staff requirements at the County
of Los Angeles Public Library by 42% or more. These results are very preliminary, and the
article cautions against jumping to conclusions until we have much better data on the questions
we are answering and the reference process as a whole, but the evidence we do have suggests
that networked reference services have the potential to truly revolutionize the way we have been
doing reference for the past 100 years.
Keywords: Reference desk staff, Largely digital library, Networked reference service, Intractable
problems, Reference process, Librarians, Paraprofessionals, Library setting, Traditional refer-
ence services, County of Los Angeles Public Library, Commercial inbound call center, Erlang-C,
Standard algorithm, Staffing requirements, Call center model, Reference staff requirements
(Appears also in Sections IV and VI.)
70. Gans, Noah and Yong-Pin Zhou. Managing learning and turnover in employee staffing. Work-
ing Paper, The Wharton School, The University of Pennsylvania, July 1999 (Revised November
2000).
Abstract. We study the employee staffing problem in a service organization that uses employee
service capacities to meet random, nonstationary service requirements. The employees experi-
ence learning and turnover on the job, and we develop a Markov Decision Process (MDP) model
that explicitly represents the stochastic nature of these effects. Theoretical results are developed
27
that show the optimal hiring policy is of a state-dependent “hire-up-to” type, similar to the
inventory “order-up-to” policy. This holds for discounted-costs MDP’s under both finite and
infinite planning horizons.
We also develop structural properties of the optimal policy to facilitate computation of the opti-
mal hiring numbers. For two important special cases of the general model, we prove the optimal-
ity of a myopic policy under both stationary and stochastically increasing service requirements.
Moreover, we show that in these two cases, when service requirements are k-periodic, it is suf-
ficient to solve a k-period MDP problem with appropriate end-of-horizon cost function. When
general, non-stationary service requirements are present, we prove the existence of a one-sided
“smoothing effect” of the optimal hire-up-to-levels.
Numerical results show that the use of state-dependent hire-up-to policies may offer significant
cost savings over simpler hiring policies. In particular, our results show that when employee
capacity increase due to learning is substantial and flexible incremental capacity (overtime) is
tight, a fully state-dependent policy out-performs a policy that hires only on the basis of the
total number of employees in the system.
Our problem formulation and results suggest natural connections to the classic results in inven-
tory literature. We also discuss many of the connections and distinctions in the paper.
71. Garnet, O. and A. Mandelbaum. An introduction to skills-based routing and its operational
complexities. Teaching note sponsored by the Fraunhofer IAO Institute, Stuttgart, Germany,
June 1999. Available at http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng.
72. Harris, Foster R. and S. De Reyt. Re-inventing the call centre with predictive and adaptive
execution, British Telecommunications Engineering, 18 (2), 1999, 180–184.
Abstract. Call centres have evolved from simple single-function centres to offer access, conve-
nience, choice and courtesy to callers. Forecasting and staffing tools support planning, enterprise
databases permit the business to craft specific caller treatments, and cross trained agents using
desktop applications can respond to a wider range of caller needs and business opportunities
on a single call. One key element of the call centre, however has changed only superficially-the
question of ‘What should each agent do next?’ The ‘oldest waiting call’ rule has answered that
question for the last 20 years. Signs that this methodology is obsolete are seen in call centres
where designs become more complex and results more difficult to achieve; where manual inter-
vention moves agents from skill to skill chasing problems; where the most talented agents are
overworked. This paper describes predictive and adaptive techniques that answer the question,
‘What should an agent do next?’. These techniques re-invent the call centre, creating a robust
operation where performance is aligned with business intentions, without the manual, corrective
intervention common in conventional centres.
Keywords: Call centre, Specific caller treatments, Cross-trained agents, Oldest waiting call rule,
Predictive techniques, Adaptive techniques, Customer service
73. Mandelbaum, A., W.A. Massey, M.I. Reiman and B. Rider. Time varying multiserver queues
with abandonment and retrials. Teletraffic Engineering in a Competitive World. Proceedings of
28
the International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-16., Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, The Netherlands,
1999, 355–364.
Abstract. In this paper we consider a multiserver queueing model where waiting customers
may abandon and subsequently retry. This model is of particular interest for analyzing perfor-
mance and setting staffing levels in call centers. All of the parameters (arrival rate, service rate,
etc.) are allowed to be time-dependent. We propose a simple fluid approximation for the queue
length process arising in this model. The fluid approximation, which is obtained as the solution
of an intuitively appealing ordinary differential equation, is in fact asymptotically exact as the
size of the system (arrival rate and number of servers) grows large. The fluid approximation is
compared with simulations for several sets of parameters and performs extremely well.
Keywords: Time varying queues, Abandonment, Retrials, Multiserver queueing model, Per-
formance, Staffing levels, Call centers, Arrival rate, Service-rate, Fluid approximation, Queue
length, Ordinary differential equation, Simulations
74. Mandelbaum, A., W.A. Massey, M.I. Reiman and A. Stolyar. Waiting time asymptotics for time
varying multiserver queues with abandonment and retrials. Allerton Conference Proceedings,
1999.
Abstract. The queue length results for the abandonment/retrial model in Theorem 5.1 (A.
Mandelbaum, W.A. Massey, R.I. Reiman, “Strong approximations for Markovian service net-
works”, Queueing Systems (1998), Section 5) are extended to include the fluid and diffusion
limits for the waiting time in nonstationary, many server Jackson networks with abandonment.
Keywords: Strong approximations, Fluid approximations, Diffusion approximations, Multiserver
queues, Queues with abandonment, Queues with retrials, Priority queues, Queueing networks,
Jackson networks, Nonstationary queues.
75. Samuelson, Douglas A. Predictive dialing for outbound telephone call centers, Interfaces, 29 (5),
1999, 66–81.
Abstract. In the late 1980s, I used queueing and simulation to invent predictive dialing, a
method to determine when computer-directed outbound telephone dialing systems should dial.
I included a real-time estimation updating feature that was highly robust against sudden changes
in the system’s operation environment; thorough validation to ensure that the models tracked
all important features of the real systems; and a modular software design that allowed “plug-in”
replacement of the control software, eliminating debugging of field upgrades. The improved sys-
tems kept operators busier and drastically reduced the number of calls the systems abandoned
because no operator was available to talk to the answering party. This invention was critical to
the success, in the late 1980s, of International Telesystems Corporation (ITC), a small company
founded in 1984, which a competitor, EIS International, bought in 1993 for approximately $12
million.
Keywords: Predictive dialing, Outbound telephone call centers, Real-time estimation updating
feature, Modular software design
29
76. Whitt, Ward. Using different response-time requirements to smooth time-varying demand for
service, Operations Research Letters, 24, 1999, 1–10.
Abstract. Many service systems have demand that varies significantly by time of day, mak-
ing it costly to provide sufficient capacity to be able to respond very quickly to each service
request. Fortunately, however, different service requests often have very different response-time
requirements. Some service requests may need immediate response, while others can tolerate
substantial delays. Thus it is often possible to smooth demand by partitioning the service re-
quests into separate priority classes according to their response-time requirements. Classes with
more stringent performance requirements are given higher priority for service. Lower capacity
may be required if lower-priority-class demand can be met during off-peak periods. We show how
the priority classes can be defined and the resulting required fixed capacity can be determined,
directly accounting for the time-dependent behavior. For this purpose, we exploit relatively
simple analytical models, in particular, Mt /G/
∞ and deterministic offered-load models. The
analysis also provides an estimate of the capacity savings that can be obtained from partitioning
time-varying demand into priority classes.
Keywords: Time-varying demand, Smoothing time-varying demand, Priority queues, Nonsta-
tionary queues, Deterministic fluid models, Infinite-server queues, Offered-load models
77. Whitt, Ward. Dynamic staffing in a telephone call center aiming to immediately answer all calls,
Operations Research Letters, 24 (5), 1999, 205–212.
Abstract. This paper proposes practical modeling and analysis methods to facilitate dynamic
staffing in a telephone call center with the ob jective of immediately answering all calls. Infinite-
server queueing models are considered. These models are very useful because they are so
tractable. A key to the dynamic staffing is exploiting detailed knowledge of system state in
order to obtain good estimates of the mean and variance of the demand in the near future. The
near-term staffing needs can often be predicted by exploiting information about recent demand
and current calls in progress, as well as historical data. The remaining holding times of calls in
progress can be predicted by classifying and keeping track of call types, by measuring holding-
time distributions and by taking account of the elapsed holding times of calls in progress. The
number of new calls in service can be predicted by exploiting information about both historical
and recent demand.
Keywords: Staffing, Telephone call center, Infinite server queueing models, Holding-time distri-
butions, Queueing theory, Forecasting, Nonstationary queues, Management
78. Whitt, Ward. Improving service by informing customers about anticipated delays, Management
Science, 45 (2), 1999, 192–207.
Abstract. The effect upon performance in a service system, such as a telephone call center, of
giving waiting customers state information is investigated. In particular, two M/M/s/r queueing
models with balking and reneging are studied. For simplicity, it is assumed that each customer
is willing to wait a fixed time before beginning service. However, customers differ, so the delay
tolerances for successive customers are random. In model 2, all reneging is replaced by balking.
The number of customers in the system for model 1 is shown to be larger than that for model 2 in
30
the likelihood-ratio stochastic ordering. Thus, customers are more likely to be blocked in model
1 and are more likely to be served without waiting in model 2. Algorithms are also developed for
computing important performance measures in these, and more general, birth-and-death mod-
els.
Keywords: Telephone service, Anticipated delays, Customer service, Queueing models, Delay
tolerance, Probability, Exponential distribution, Service time, Telephone call centre, Reneging,
Balking, Birth-and-death process
(Appears also in Section III.)
79. Whitt, Ward. Predicting queueing delays, Management Science, 45 (6), 1999, 870–888.
Abstract. The possibility of predicting each customer’s waiting time in queue before starting
service in a multiserver service system with the first-come first-served service discipline, such
as a telephone call center, is investigated. A predicted waiting-time distribution or an appro-
priate summary statistic such as the mean or the 90th percentile may be communicated to the
customer upon arrival and possibly thereafter in order to improve customer satisfaction. The
predicted waiting-time distribution may also be used by the service provider to better manage
the service system, e.g., to help decide when to add additional service agents. The possibility of
making reliable predictions is enhanced by exploiting information about system state, including
the number of customers in the system ahead of the current customer.
Keywords: Queueing delays, Delay prediction, Multiserver service system, Telephone call center,
Waiting-time distribution, Response time
80. Whitt, Ward. Partitioning customers into service groups, Management Science, 45 (11), 1999,
1579–1592.
Abstract. We explore the issues of when and how to partition arriving customers into service
groups that will be served separately, in a first-come first-served manner, by multiserver service
systems having a provision for waiting, and how to assign an appropriate number of servers to
each group. We assume that customers can be classified upon arrival, so that different service
groups can have different service-time distributions. We provide methodology for quantifying
the tradeoff between economies of scale associated with larger systems and the benefit of having
customers with shorter service times separated from other customers with longer service times,
as is done in service systems with express lines. To properly quantify the tradeoff, it is important
to characterize service-time distributions between their means. In particular, it is important to
also determine the variance of the service-time distribution of each service group. Assuming
Poisson arrival processes, we then can model the congestion experienced by each server group
as an M/G/s queue with unlimited waiting room. We use previously developed approximations
for M/G/s performance measures to quickly evaluate partitions.
Keywords: Queues, Multiserver queues, Service systems, Service-system design, Resource shar-
ing, Service systems with express lines
81. Whitt, Ward. Decomposition approximations for time-dependent Markovian queueing networks,
Oper. Res. Lett., 24 (3), 1999, 97–103.
31
Abstract. Motivated by the development of complex telephone call center networks, we present
a general framework for decompositions to approximately solve Markovian queueing networks
with time-dependent and state-dependent transition rates. The decompositions are based on
assuming either full or partial product form for the time-dependent probability vectors at each
time. These decompositions reduce the number of time-dependent ordinary differential equations
that must be solved. We show how special structure in the transition rates can be exploited to
speed up computation. There is extra theoretical support for the decomposition approximation
when the steady-state distribution of the time-homogeneous version of the model has product
form.
Keywords: Time-dependent queues, Time-dependent Markovian queueing networks, Time-dependent
Markov chains, Markovian queueing networks, Decomposition approximations, Systems of or-
dinary differential equations, Product-form queueing networks, Product-form approximations,
Telephone call centers, Air traffic management, Decompositions, Transition rates, Probability
vectors, Differential equations
82. Zhou, Yong-Pin and Noah Gans. A single-server queue with Markov modulated service times.
Working Paper, The Wharton School, The University of Pennsylvania, Oct. 1999.
Abstract. We study an M/MMPP/1 queuing system, where the arrival process is Poisson and
service requirements are Markov modulated. When the Markov Chain modulating service times
has two states, we show that the distribution of the number-in-system is a superposition of two
matrix-geometric series and provide a simple algorithm for computing the rate and coefficient
matrices. These results hold for both finite and infinite waiting space systems and extend results
obtained in Neuts [5] and Naoumov [4].
Numerical comparisons between the performance of the M/MMPP/1 system and its M/G/1
analogue lead us to make the conjecture that the M/MMPP/1 system performs better if and
only if the total switching probabilities between the two states satisfy a simple condition. We
give an intuitive argument to support this conjecture.
83. Weidong Xu. Long range planning for call centers at FedEx, The Journal of Business Forecast-
ing Methods & Systems, 18 (4), Winter 1999/2000, 7–11.
Abstract. FedEx is the world’s largest express transportation company, generating $14 bil-
lion in annual revenue. To support the global transportation network, FedEx has established 51
worldwide customer service call centers. The customer service at FedEx in the US handles about
500,000 calls per day. There are three ma jor networks: 1. Domestic, 2. International, and 3.
Freight. For each network, the company has developed four different types of forecasts based on
different forecasting horizons: 1. Strategic Plan, 2. Business Plan, 3. Tactical Forecast, and 4.
Operational Forecast. Different methodologies are adopted for different levels of forecasts. An
overview of these methodologies is presented.
Keywords: Postal & delivery services, Forecasting techniques, Customer services, Case studies
(Appears also in Sections VII and II.)
84. Aksin, O.Z. and P.T. Harker. Computing performance measures in a multi-class multi-resource
32
processor-shared loss system, European Journal of Operational Research, 123 (1), 2000, 61–72.
Abstract. This paper develops methods to compute performance measures in a specific type of
loss system with multiple classes of customers sharing the same processor. Such systems arise
in the modeling of a call center, where the performance measures of interest are the blocking
probability of a call and the reneging probability of customers that are put on hold. Expressions
for these performance measures have been derived in previous work by the authors. Given the
difficulty of computing these performance measures for realistic systems, this paper proposes
two different approaches to simplify this computation. The first method introduces the idea of
multi-dimensional convolutions, and uses this approach to compute exact blocking and reneging
probabilities. The second method establishes an adaptation of the Monte Carlo Summation
technique in order to obtain good estimates of blocking and reneging probabilities in large sys-
tems along with their associated confidence intervals.
Keywords: Performance measures, Multi-class multi-resource processor-shared loss system, Call
center, Blocking probability, Reneging probability, Multi-dimensional convolutions, Monte-Carlo
summation technique, Confidence intervals
85. Bhulai, Sandjai and Ger Koole. Scheduling time-constrained jobs in the presence of background
traffic. Proceedings of the 39th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control, Sydney, Australia,
December 2000.
Abstract. In this paper we study the scheduling of jobs with a constraint on the average waiting
time in the presence of background jobs. The ob jective is to schedule to s servers such that the
throughput of the background traffic is maximized while satisfying the response time constraint
on the foreground traffic.
The arrivals are determined by a Poisson process and the service times of the jobs are indepen-
dent exponentially distributed. We consider both the situation where service requirements by
both types of jobs are equal and unequal. The first situation is solved to optimality; for the
second situation we find the best policy within a certain class of policies. Optimal schedules
always keep part of the service capacity free for arriving foreground jobs. Applications of this
model can be found in computer systems, communication networks and call centers.
Keywords: Call centers, Communication networks, Markov decision processes, Parallel systems
and queueing
86. Brandt, Andreas and Manfred Brandt. Asymptotic results and a Markovian approximation
for the M (n)/M (n)/s + GI system. Working paper, Wirtschaftswissenschaftliche Fakult¨
at,
Humboldt-Universit¨
at zu Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 2000.
Abstract. In this paper for the M (n)/M (n)/s + GI system, i.e., for a s-server queueing system
where the calls in the queue may leave the system due to impatience, we present new asymptotic
results for the intensities of calls leaving the system due to impatience and a Markovian system
approximation where these results are applied. Furthermore, we present a new proof for the
formulae of the conditional density of the virtual waiting time distributions, recently given by
Movaghar for the less general M (n)/M/s + GI system. Also, we obtain new explicit expressions
for refined virtual waiting time characteristics as a by-product.
33
Keywords: M (n)/M (n)/s + GI system, Limited waiting times, Finite buffer, Virtual waiting
times, Blocking-, Abandon probability, Impatience rates, Asymptotic results, M (n)/M (n)/s
system with waiting place dependent impatient rates, Markovian approximation
87. Brusco, Michael J. and Larry W. Jacobs. Optimal Models for meal-break and start-time flexi-
bility in continuous tour scheduling, Management Science, 46 (12), 2000, 1630–1641.
Abstract. A compact integer-programming model is presented for large-scale continuous tour
scheduling problems that incorporate meal-break window, start-time band, and start-time in-
terval policies. For practical scheduling environments, generalized set-covering formulations
(GSCF) of such problems often contain hundreds of millions of integer decision variables, usually
precluding identification of optimal solutions. As an alternative, an implicit integer-programming
model has been prevented that frequently has fewer than 1,500 variables and can be formulated
and solved using PC-based hardware and software platforms. An empirical study using labor-
requirement distributions for customer service representatives at a Motorola Inc. call center was
used to demonstrate the importance of having a model that can evaluate tradeoffs among the
various scheduling policies.
Keywords: Continuous tour scheduling, Integer programming, Meal-break window, Start-time
band, Generalized set-covering, Customer service, Workforce scheduling, Production control
88. Easton, Fred F. Labor requirements for multi-server multi-class finite queues. Working paper,
Robert H. Brethen Operations Management Institute, School of Management, Syracuse Univer-
sity, Syracuse, NY, USA, June 2000.
Abstract. Most of North American’s 70,000 call centers use Erlang queueing models to deter-
mine appropriate staffing levels for each period their systems operate. These standard queueing
models (M/M/C or M/M/C/N ) assume a one-stage single-queue service, FCFS priority, mul-
tiple identical servers, and exponential inter-arrival times and service times. If a call center
provides two or more types of service, each with distinct mean service times, its workforce
management system typically averages the interarrival and service times over all calls. These
parameters are then automatically passed to a M/M/C/
∞ or a M/M/C/N model to determine
the minimum staff needed to assure a prescribed level of service.
In this research we consider a multi-server finite Poisson queueing system that provides two
types of service, classified H2 /H2 /C/N . We decompose the two arrival streams and show that
the system is reversible, allowing efficient computation of its two-dimensional state probabilities.
The model enables us to better understand the magnitude of the staffing errors that result when
standard Erlang models are applied to multi-class queueing systems. For example, we find that
when an equal number of callers arrive for each of two classes of service, but the mean service
rate for one class is nine times faster than the other, M/M/C/N can recommend a staffing level
that is less than one-half the minimum number of employees actually needed to provide the
desired level of service.
89. Jongbloed, Geurt and Ger Koole. Managing uncertainty in call centers using Poisson mixtures.
Working paper, Vrije Universiteit, Division of Mathematics and Computer Science, Amsterdam,
34
The Netherlands, November 2000.
Abstract. We model a call center as a queueing model with Poisson arrivals having an unknown
varying arrival rate. We show how to compute prediction intervals for the arrival rate, and use
the Erlang formula for the waiting time to compute the consequences for the occupancy level of
the call center. We compare it to the current practice of using a point estimate of the arrival
rate (assumed constant) as forecast.
(Appears also in Section II.)
90. Larson, Richard C. and Edical J. Pinker. Staffing challenges in financial services, in Creat-
ing Value in Financial Services: Strategies, Operations, and Technologies, Edward L. Melnick,
Praveen R. Nayyar, Michael L. Pinedo, Sridhar Seshadri (Eds.). Boston: Kluwer Academic
Publishers, 2000, Chapter 17: 327–356.
Abstract. Financial services institutions are providing a rapidly expanding variety of products
and services; technology is making customers more mobile, and delay is unacceptable in financial
transactions. These attributes of the financial services sector mean that firms must provide effec-
tive, efficient and reliable service or quickly lose customers to competitors. To avoid huge labor
costs, financial services firms must develop innovative approaches to managing their workforces
and their service delivery process. We outline and provide examples of effective techniques for
managing part-time and flexible personnel in back room operations, bank teller scheduling and
management, improving customer queueing experiences, and the design and operation of call
centers to take into account cross-training, learning and cross selling.
Acknowledgement: The abstract was taken from the introduction of the book.
(Appears also in Section VII.)
91. Mandelbaum, A. and N. Shimkin. A model for rational abandonments from invisible queues,
QUESTA, 36 (1–3), 2000, 141–173.
Abstract. We propose a model for abandonments from a queue, due to excessive wait, assum-
ing that waiting customers act rationally but without being able to observe the queue length.
Customers are allowed to be heterogeneous in their preferences and consequent behavior. Our
goal is to characterize customers’ patience via more basic primitives, specifically waiting costs
and service benefits: these two are optimally balanced by waiting customers, based on their
individual cost parameters and anticipated waiting time. The waiting time distribution and
patience profile then emerge as an equilibrium point of the system. The problem formulation is
motivated by teleservices, prevalently telephone- and Internet-based. In such services, customers
and servers are remote and queues are typically associated with the servers, hence queues are
invisible to waiting customers. Our base model is the M/M/m queue, where it is shown that
a unique equilibrium exists, in which rational abandonments can occur only upon arrival (zero
or infinite patience for each customer). As such a behavior fails to capture the essence of aban-
donments, the base model is modified to account for unusual congestion or failure conditions.
This indeed facilitates abandonments in finite time, leading to a nontrivial, customer dependent
patience profile. Our analysis shows, quite surprisingly, that the equilibrium is unique in this
case as well, and amenable to explicit calculation.
35
Keywords: Multiserver exponential queues, Abandonments, Nash equilibrium, Call centers
(Appears also in Section III.)
92. Mockus, Jonas. “Call centers” in A Set of Examples of Global and Discrete Optimization: Ap-
plications (edited by Jonas Mockus), Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic, 2000, part 3, ch. 15.
93. Pinedo, Michael L., Sridhar Seshadri and J. George Shanthikumar. Call centers in financial ser-
vices: Strategies, technologies and operations, in Creating Value in Financial Services: Strate-
gies, Operations, and Technologies, Edward L. Melnick, Praveen R. Nayyar, Michael L. Pinedo,
Sridhar Seshadri (Eds.). Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000, Chapter 18: 357–388.
Abstract. Call centers are becoming more important in financial services. They are of impor-
tance to retail banking operations, credit card operations and mutual fund organizations. A
significant part of the dynamics of call centers in financial services is similar to call centers in
other industries. Analyzing both static and dynamic aspects of managing call centers, we discuss
necessary service, security and database requirements for call centers in financial services firms.
We also analyze the differences between call centers in financial services and call centers in other
industries such as airlines. These differences center around the more extensive database require-
ments necessary to handle each call, as well as the fact that customers of financial institutions
tend to be more captive than customers of airlines.
Acknowledgement: The abstract was taken from the introduction of the book.
94. Pinker, E. and R. Shumsky. The efficiency-quality tradeoff of cross-trained workers, Manufac-
turing and Service Operations Management, 2 (1), Winter 2000, 32–48.
Abstract. Does cross-training workers allow a firm to achieve economies of scale when there is
variability in the content of work, or does it create a work force that performs many tasks with
consistent mediocrity? To address this question we integrate a model of a stochastic service sys-
tem with models for tenure- and experience-based service quality. When examined in isolation,
the service system model confirms a well-known “rule of thumb” from the queueing literature:
Flexible or cross-trained servers provide more throughput with fewer workers than specialized
servers. However, in the integrated model these economies of scale are tempered by a loss in
quality. Given multiple tasks, flexible workers may not gain sufficient experience to provide
high-quality service to any one customer, and what is gained in efficiency is lost in quality.
Through a series of numerical experiments we find that low utilization in an all-specialist system
can also reduce quality, and therefore, the optimal staff mix combines flexible and specialized
workers. We also investigate when the performance of the system is sensitive to the staffing
configuration choice. For small systems with high learning rates, the optimal staff mix provides
significant benefits over either extreme case (a completely specialized or completely flexible work
force). If the system is small and the rate of learning is slow, flexible servers are preferred. For
large systems with high learning rates, the model leans toward specialized servers. In a final set
of experiments, the model analyzes the design options for an actual call center.
Keywords: Queues: Approximations, Service quality, Learning curves, Cross-training, Worker
turnover; Personnel
36
95. Puhalskii, A.A. and M.I. Reiman. The multiclass GI/PH/N queue in the Halfin-Whitt regime,
Advances in Applied Probability, 32 (2), 2000, 564–595.
Abstract. A consideration is made of a multiserver queue in the heavy-traffic regime introduced
and studied by Halfin and Whitt (1981) who investigated the case of the single customer class
with exponentially distributed server times. The purpose is to extend their analysis to a system
with multiple customer classes, priorities and phase-type service distributions. A weak conver-
gence limit theorem is proven showing that a properly defined and normalized queue length
process converges to a particular K-dimensional diffusion process, where K is the number of
phases in the service time distribution. It is also shown that a properly normalized waiting time
process converges to a simple functional of the limit diffusion for the queue length.
Keywords: Call Centers, Multiserver queues, Priority queues, Heavy traffic, Diffusion approxi-
mation, Weak convergence
96. Reiman, Martin I. Diffusion limits for multiskill call centers with many agents. Applied Proba-
bility Society at INFORMS 2000, San Antonio, Nov. 5–8, 2000.
Abstract. We consider a queueing model of a call center providing service to several customer
types (skills), where each server (agent) can handle some subset of the skills. We examine this
model in the Halfin-Whitt regime, which involves the number of servers growing large while the
traffic intensity approaches unity.
97. Ridley, A. Performance optimization of a telecommunication call center. Proceedings of the
Applied Telecommunication Symposium (ATS’00). SCS, San Diego, CA, USA, 2000, 163–167.
Abstract. Telecommunication call centers have become the primary channel of customer inter-
action service for many businesses. The level of professionalism and efficiency that call center
agents deliver to customers provides a significant advantage over traditional customer service
practices. The growth of call centers has been substantial over the last two decades. This growth
is driven by a company’s desire to lower operating costs and to increase revenues (Kim 1997).
The author investigates analytical and simulation-based models for the design and manage-
ment of a call center. Given three classes of traffic (voice, E-mail, and facsimile) with different
target waiting-times in queue and target service levels, the goal is to optimize the call center
performance. The system performance can be measured with quantities such as the expected
waiting-time in queue, the expected time in system, the percentage of calls answered within a
given time, and the expected waiting-time probability distribution. The system performance of
the call center is measured using analytical and simulation-based queuing models. For analytical
models, the traffic classes will have exponential inter-arrival and service time distributions where
the arrival and service rates will differ among classes. Also, each customer call will be assigned
a queue priority based on its traffic class. The call agents will be able to handle calls from any
class. For the simulation-based models, the inter-arrival and service time distributions will not
be exponential, the agents will have different skill-levels, and the queue length will be finite.
Keywords: Performance optimization, Telecommunication call center, Simulation-based models,
37
Management, Voice traffic, E-mail, Facsimile, Service levels, Expected waiting time, Probability
distribution, Queuing models, Exponential inter-arrival distributions, Service-time distributions
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
98. Aksin, O.Z. and P.T. Harker. Modeling a phone center: analysis of a multichannel, multiresource
processor shared loss system, Management-Science, 47 (2), 2001, 324–336.
Abstract. Presents a model for the study of operations at an inbound call center. The call
center is modeled as a multiclass processor shared loss system, where the interacting effects of
human, telecommunication, and information technology resources are explicitly incorporated.
Product form solutions and approximations for this type of system are provided along with
expressions for performance measures like blocking and reneging. Some structural properties
of system throughput are analyzed in an effort to pave the way for future optimization studies
dealing with the design and management of phone centers.
Keywords: Phone center, Multichannel multiresource processor-shared loss system, Inbound
call center, Information technology resources, Hhuman resources, Telecommunication resources,
Blocking, Reneging
99. Bae, Jongho, Sunggon Kim and Eui Yong Lee. The virtual waiting time of the M/G/1 queue
with impatient customers, Queueing Syst. Theory Appl., 38 (4), 2001, 485–494.
Abstract. The paper deals with the limiting distribution of the virtual waiting time of the
M/G/1 queueing systems with impatient customers having constant patience. This model has
been dealt with in the past by many authors (some in the reference list and some missing), and
the approach the authors take to this problem is not new. Further, the “explicit” solution is
given by an infinite series of convolutions, which, except in some simple cases, is not computable.
This work deals with a problem that has been receiving a lot of attention recently because of
its use in the analysis of call centers, but the form in which the final result appears makes its
contribution rather limited.
100. Benjaafar, Saifallah. Modeling and analysis of flexible queueing systems, Naval Research Logis-
tics, 2001 (Under review).
Abstract. We consider queueing systems with multiple classes of arrivals and heterogeneous
servers where customers have the flexibility of being routed to more than one server and servers
possess the capability of processing more than one customer class. We provide a unified frame-
work for the modeling and analysis of these systems under arbitrary routing and server flexibility
and for a rich set of control policies that includes customer/server-specific priority schemes for
routing and queue selection. We use our models to generate several insights into the effect of sys-
tem configuraiton. In particular, we examine the relationship between flexibility and throughput
under varying assumptions for system parameters.
101. Brusco, Michael J. and Larry W. Jacobs. Starting-time decisions in labor tour scheduling: An
experimental analysis and case study, European Journal of Operational Research, 131 (3), 2001,
38
459–475.
Abstract. Many service organizations limit the number of daily planning periods in which
employees may begin their shifts to a fixed number, S . Even for relatively small values of S ,
which are quite common in practice, there may be hundreds, thousands or millions of possible
subsets of starting times. This paper presents the results of a large experimental study that
revealed that, in many instances, only a very small portion of starting-time subsets was capable
of providing the minimum workforce size.
Keywords: Starting-time decisions, Labor-tour scheduling, Starting-time subsets, Minimum
workforce size, Effective starting-time selection, Spreadsheet-based program
102. Cezik, Tolga, Oktay Gunluk and Hanan Luss. An integer programming model for the weekly
tour scheduling problem, Naval Research Logistics, 48 (7), 2001, 607–624.
Abstract. We study a workforce planning and scheduling problem in which weekly tours of
agents must be designed. Our motivation for this study comes from a call center application
where agents serve customers in response to incoming phone calls. Similar to many other appli-
cations in the services industry, the demand for service in call centers varies significantly within
a day and among days of the week. In our model, a weekly tour of an agent consists of five daily
shifts and two days off, where daily shifts within a tour may be different from each other. The
starting times of any two consecutive shifts, however, may not differ by more than a specified
bound. Furthermore, a tour must also satisfy constraints regarding the days off. For example,
it may be required that one of the days off is on a weekend day. The ob jective is to determine a
collection of weekly tours that satisfy the demand for agents’ services, while minimizing the total
labor cost of the workforce. We describe an integer programming model where a weekly tour is
obtained by combining seven daily shift scheduling model and days-off constraints in a network
flow framework. The model is flexible and can accommodate different daily models with varying
levels of details. It readily handles different days-off rules and constraints regarding start time
differentials in consecutive days. Computational results are also presented.
103. Duder, J.C. and M.B. Rosenwein. Towards “zero abandonments” in call center performance,
European Journal of Operational Research, 135 (1), 2001, 50–56.
Abstract.The call center industry is a big business in today’s global economy. Staffing costs
account for over half of a call center’s total operational costs. Some large call centers, in prac-
tice, operate at very close to maximum capacity, believing that such an operations policy is
efficient. However, by operating at levels close to 100% utilization, a call center is “living dan-
gerously”. If, for example, call volumes even slightly exceed forecasts, customer calls will queue.
As queue lengths and durations increase, customers will tend to abandon their calls. We provide
some “rule-of-thumb” formulas that evaluate the cost of abandonments. These formulas may
be used to justify an investment in additional agents required to improve the quality of service
and reduce abandonments. Standard Erlang-C queueing formulas imply that abandonments
can be significantly reduced with a small investment in additional agents. Thus, by improving
customer service and hiring additional staff, a call center can improve profitability. We illus-
trate our analysis with realistic data, based on our work with large-scale customer service centers.
39
104. Feng, W. and R.T. Hurley. Birth-death models for a class of service systems. Proceedings of the
IASTED International Conference Applied Informatics. International Symposium on Parallel
and Distributed Computing and Networks. ACTA Press, Anaheim, CA, USA, 2001, 320–325.
Abstract. In this paper, we discussed three birth-death models for service systems, such as
telephone call centers of Internet access points. The first model assumes that customers have
no information about the system and so they may balk or renege upon arrival. The other two
models assume that customers receive the state information as they arrive and thus, the balking
probability is state-dependent. Model 2 uses the assumption that the balking probabilities de-
pend on a waiting time threshold while model 3 assumes that the balking probabilities depend
directly on the number of customers in the waiting queue. Both analysis and simulation are
used to investigate the performance of the systems based on the three models. We compare the
server utilization and mean response time. Our results indicate that model 2 tends to have a
lower response time than model 1 and the performance of a system based on model 3 greatly
depends on the sequence of balking probabilities. We show the results for two such scenarios.
105. Green, Linda V., Peter J. Kolesar and Joao Soares. Improving the SIPP approach for staffing
service systems that have cyclic demands, Operations Research, 49 (4), 2001, 549–564.
Abstract. This paper evaluates the practice of determining staffing requirements in service sys-
tems with random cyclic demands by using a series of stationary queueing models. We consider
Markovian models with sinusoidal arrival rates and use numerical methods to show that the
commonly used “stationary independent period by period” (SIPP) approach to setting staffing
requirements is inaccurate for parameter values corresponding to many real situations. Specif-
ically, using the SIPP approach can result in staffing levels that do not meet specified period
by period probability of delay targets during a significant fraction of the cycle. We determine
the manner in which the various system parameters affect SIPP reliability and identify domains
for which SIPP will be accurate. After exploring several alternatives, we propose two simple
modifications of SIPP that will produce reliable staffing levels in models whose parameters span
a broad range of practical situations. Our conclusions from the sinusoidal model are tested
against some empirical data.
Keywords: Service systems, Staffing: Use of queueing models, Queueing systems, Cyclic: Accu-
racy of stationary models, Call centers
106. Green, Linda V., Peter J. Kolesar and Joao Soares. An improved heuristic for staffing telephone
call centers with limited operating hours. Report, Centre for Mathematics, University of Coim-
bra (CMUC), Portugal, 2001.
107. Grossman, Thomas A., Douglas A. Samuelson, Sherry L. Oh and Thomas R. Rohleder. Call
centers. In Encyclopedia of Operations Research and Management Science, Centennial edition,
Saul I. Gass and Carl M. Harris, editors. Norwell: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2001.
40
108. Masi, Denise M. Bevilacqua, Martin Fisher and Carl M. Harris. Computation of steady-state
probabilities for resource sharing call center queueing systems, Stochastic Models [online], 17 (2),
2001 [viewed July 24, 2001].
Abstract. Two routing rules for a queueing system of two stations are considered as alternative
models for modeling a call-center network. These routing rules allow customers to switch queues
under certain server and other resource availability conditions, either external to the system upon
arrival to the network, or internal to the system after arrival to a primary call center. Under
the assumption of Poisson arrivals and exponentially distributed service times, these systems are
analyzed using matrix-geometric techniques, yielding a non-trivial set of ergodicity conditions
and the steady-state joint probability distribution for the number of customers at each station.
An extensive numerical analysis is conducted, yielding some physical insight into these systems
and related generalizations.
109. Shumsky, R. and E. Pinker. Gatekeepers and referrals in services. Working paper OP01-02,
Simon School, University of Rochester, 2001.
Abstract. We examine services in which customers encounter a gatekeeper who makes an initial
diagnosis of the customer’s problem and then may refer the customer to a specialist. The gate-
keeper may also attempt to solve the problem, but the probability of treatment success decreases
as the problem’s complexity increases. Given the costs of treatment by the gatekeeper and the
specialist, we find the firm’s optimal referral rate from a particular gatekeeper to the specialists.
We then consider the principal-agent problem that arises when the gatekeeper, but not the firm,
observes the gatekeeper’s treatment ability as well as the complexity of each customer’s prob-
lem. We examine the relative benefits of compensation systems designed to overcome the effects
of this information asymmetry and identify when bonuses based solely on referral rates do not
ensure first-best system performance. We also consider the value of such output-based contracts
when gatekeepers are heterogeneous in ability, so that two gatekeepers face different probabilities
of treatment success when given the same problem. Finally, we compare environments in which
the gatekeeper is, and is not, faced with risk in the form of significant variance in compensation.
110. Atlason, Julius, Marina A. Epelman and Shane G. Henderson. Combining simulation and cut-
ting plane methods in service systems. Proceedings of the 2002 National Science Foundation
Design, Service and Manufacturing Grantees Conference, 2002.
Abstract. In this paper we describe a method that combines simulation and cutting plane
methods to solve resource allocation and scheduling problems. We solve a relaxed linear (in-
teger) program iteratively and pass the solution of each iteration to a simulation. The results
of the simulation are used to generate constraints in the linear (integer) program. We provide
conditions under which the solutions of the linear (integer) program converges to an optimal
solution of the unrelaxed problem. The concavity of the underlying service level function is
critical for the method and we present a linear programming method to numerically check the
concavity of a function.
111. Borst, S., A. Mandelbaum and M.I. Reiman. Dimensioning large call centers, Operations Re-
41
search 2002 (under review). Available at http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng.
Abstract. We develop a framework for asymptotic optimization of a queueing system. The mo-
tivation is the staffing problem of call centers with 100s of agents (or more). Such a call center
is modeled as an M/M/N queue, where the number of agents N is large. Within our framework,
we determine the asymptotically optimal staffing level N ∗ that trades off agents’ costs with
service quality: the higher the latter, the more expensive is the former. As an alternative to this
optimization, we also develop a constraint satisfaction approach where one chooses the least N ∗
that adheres to a given constraint on waiting cost. Either way, the analysis gives rise to three
regimes of operation: quality-driven, where the focus is on service quality; efficiency-driven,
which emphasizes agents’ costs; and a rationalized regime that balances, and in fact unifies, the
other two. Numerical experiments reveal remarkable accuracy of our asymptotic approxima-
tions: over a wide range of parameters, from the very small to the extremely large, N ∗ is exactly
optimal, or it is accurate to within a single agent. We demonstrate the utility of our approach
by revisiting the square-root safety staffing principle, which is a long-existing rule-of-thumb for
staffing the M/M/N queue. In its simplest form, our rule is as follows: if c is the hourly cost of
an agent, and a is the hourly cost of customers’ delay, then N ∗ = R + y � a
c � √R, where R is the
offered load, and y∗ (
·) is a function that is easily computable.
112. Brown, L., N. Gans, A. Mandelbaum, A. Sakov, H. Shen, S. Zeltyn and L. Zhao. Statistical
analysis of a telephone call center: A queueing-science perspective. Submitted to JASA, Novem-
ber 2002. Available at: <http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>
Abstract. A call center is a service network in which agents provide telephone-based services.
Customers that seek these services are delayed in tele-queues.
This paper summarizes an analysis of a unique record of call center operations. The data
comprise a complete operational history of a small banking call center, call by call, over a
full year. Taking the perspective of queueing theory, we decompose the service process into
three fundamental components: arrivals, customer abandonment behavior and service durations.
Each component involves different basic mathematical structures and requires a different style
of statistical analysis. Some of the key empirical results are sketched, along with descriptions of
the varied techniques required.
Several statistical techniques are developed for analysis of the basic components. One of these
is a test that a point process is a Poisson process. Another involves estimation of the mean
function in a nonparametric regression with lognormal errors. A new graphical technique is
introduced for nonparametric hazard rate estimation with censored data. Models are developed
and implemented for forecasting of Poisson arrival rates.
We then survey how the characteristics deduced from the statistical analyses form the building
blocks for theoretically interesting and practically useful mathematical models for call center
operations.
Keywords: Call centers, Queueing theory, Lognormal distribution, Inhomogeneous Poisson pro-
cess, Censored data, Human patience, Prediction of Poisson rates, Khintchine-Pollaczek formula,
Service times, Arrival rate, Abandonment rate, Multiserver queues
(Appears also in Section II.)
42
113. Chen, Bert P.K. and Shane G. Henderson. Two issues in setting call centre staffing levels, Annals
of Operations Research, 108, 2002, 175–192.
Abstract. Motivated by a problem facing the Police Communication Centre in Auckland, New
Zealand, we consider the setting of staffing levels in a call centre with priority customers. The
choice of staffing level over any particular time period (e.g., Monday from 8am–9am) relies on
accurate arrival rate information. The usual method for identifying the arrival rate based on his-
torical data can, in some cases, lead to considerable errors in performance estimates for a given
staffing level. We explain why, identify three potential causes of the difficulty, and describe a
method for detecting and addressing such a problem.
114. Garnet, O., A. Mandelbaum and M. Reiman. Designing a call center with impatient cus-
tomers, Manufacturing & Service Operations Management, 4 (3), 208–227, 2002. Available
at http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng.
Abstract. The most common model to support work force management of telephone call cen-
ters is the M/M/N/B model, in particular its special cases M/M/N (Erlang C, which models out
busy-signals) and M/M/N/N (Erlang B, disallowing waiting). All of these models lack a central
prevalent feature, namely that impatient customers might decide to leave (abandon) before their
service begins.
In this paper we analyze the simplest abandonment model, in which customers’ patience is ex-
ponentially distributed and the system’s waiting capacity is unlimited (M/M/N + M). Such a
model is both rich and analyzable enough to provide information that is practically important
for call center managers. We first outline a method for exact analysis of the M/M/N + M
model, that while numerically tractable is not very insightful. We then proceed with an asymp-
totic analysis of the M/M/N + M model, in a regime that is appropriate for large call centers
(many agents, high efficiency, high service level). Guided by the asymptotic behavior, we derive
approximations for performance measures and propose “rules-of-thumb” for the design of large
call centers. We thus add support to the growing acknowledgment that insights from diffusion
approximations are directly applicable to management practice.
115. Koole, Ger and A. Mandelbaum. Queueing models of call centers: An introduction, Annals
of Operations Research, 113, 41–59, 2002. Special volume dedicated to a selection of papers
presented at the “First Madrid Conference on Queueing Theory” (MCQT ’02), July 2–5, 2002.
Abstract. This is a survey of some academic research on telephone call centers. The surveyed
research has its origin in, or is related to, queueing theory. Indeed, the “queueing-view” of call
centers is both natural and useful. Accordingly, queueing models have served as prevalent stan-
dard support tools for call center management. However, the modern call center is a complex
socio-technical system. It thus enjoys central features that challenge existing queueing theory
to its limits, and beyond.
116. Mandelbaum, A., W.A. Massey, M.I. Reiman and B. Rider. Queue lengths and waiting times
for multiserver queues with abandonment and retrials, Telecommunication Systems, 21 (2–4),
149–171, 2002.
43
Abstract. We consider a Markovian multiserver queueing model with time dependent param-
eters where waiting customers may abandon and subsequently retry. We provide simple fluid
and diffusion approximations to estimate the mean, variance, and density for both the queue
length and virtual waiting time processes arising in this model. These approximations, which
are generated by numerically integrating only 7 ordinary differential equations, are justified by
limit theorems where the arrival rate and number of servers grow large. We compare our ap-
proximations to simulations, and they perform extremely well.
Keywords: Fluid approximations, Diffusion approximations, Multiserver queues, Queues with
abandonment, Virtual waiting time, Queues with retrials, Nonstationary queues, Call centers
117. Mandelbaum, A. and A.L. Stolyar. Scheduling flexible servers with convex delay costs: Heavy-
traffic optimality of the generalized cµ-rule. Submitted to Operations Research, January 2002.
Available at: <http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>
Abstract. We consider a queueing system with multi-type customers and flexible (multi-skilled)
servers that work in parallel. Let µij denote the service rate of type i customers by server j (the
reciprocal of an average service time); µij = 0 indicates that server j cannot serve type i. We
analyze the system in heavy traffic, seeking to minimize either queueing or waiting costs. To this
end, assume that the queue of type i incurs a queueing cost at rate Ci (Qi ), which is an increasing
convex function Ci (
·) of the queue length Qi . Then, we show that a simple generalized cµ-rule
minimizes queueing costs, asymptotically, over essentially all scheduling disciplines, preemptive
or non-preemptive. Specifically, when becoming idle at time t, server j chooses for service the
longest-waiting type i customers where
i
∈ arg max
iC′
i (Qi (t))µij .
(C ′
i is the derivative of Ci .) Alternatively, each type i customer could incur a waiting cost Ci (Wi ),
where Wi is its so journ time. Then, waiting costs are asymptotically minimized by serving type
i such that
i
∈ arg max
iC′
i (Wi (t))µij ,
where Wi (t) is the head-of-the-line waiting time in queue i at time t.
118. Massey, W.A. The analysis of queues with time-varying rates for telecommunication models,
Telecommunication Systems Modeling, Analysis, Design and Management, 21 (2–4), 2002, 173–
204.
Abstract. Time-dependent behavior has an impact on the performance of telecommunication
models. Examples include: staffing a call center, pricing the inventory of private line services
for profit maximization, and measuring the time lag between the peak arrivals and peak load for
a system. These problems and more motivate the development of a queueing theory with time-
varying rates. Queueing theory is presented and organized from a communications perspective.
Canonical queueing models with time-varying rates are given and the necessary mathematical
tools are developed to analyze them. Finally, the use of these models are illustrated through
various communication applications.
44
Keywords: Time-varying rate queues, Telecommunication models, Time-dependent behavior,
Time lag, Peak arrivals, Peak load, Queueing theory, Communication networks, Call center
staffing, Private line services, Profit maximization
119. Whitt, Ward. How multiserver queues scale with growing congestion-dependent demand. Re-
vised May 2002. To appear in Operations Research. Available at:
<http://www.ieor.columbia.edu/
∼wow/>.
Abstract. We investigate how performance scales in the standard M/M/n queue in the pres-
ence of growing congestion-dependent customer demand. We scale the queue by increasing the
number of servers. We let the arrival rate depend on the steady-state congestion, considering
several alternative congestion measures. We assume that the arrival rate is equal to the max-
imum possible output rate (the individual service rate times the number of servers) multiplied
by a decreasing function of the congestion measure. Under minor regularity conditions, there is
a unique equilibrium arrival rate for each n and, as n increases, the queue is brought into heavy
traffic. The three different heavy-traffic regimes for multiserver queues identified by Halfin and
Whitt (1981) each can arise depending on the congestion measure used. In considerable gener-
ality, there is asymptotic service efficiency—the server utilization approaches one—even if there
is significant uncertainty about the arrival rate.
Keywords: Queues, State-dependent queues, Multiserver queues, Heavy traffic, Equilibrium,
Congestion-dependent demand, Asymptotic service efficiency, Uncertainty about demand in
queues, Economics of queues
120. Whitt, Ward. A diffusion approximation for the G/GI /n/m queue. Submitted to Operations
Research, 2002. Available at: <http://www.ieor.columbia.edu/
∼wow/>.
Abstract. We develop a heuristic diffusion approximation for the queue-length stochastic
processes representing the number in system at arrival epochs and at arbitrary times in the
G/GI /n/m queueing model, which has a general (stationary or asymptotically stationary) ar-
rival process, independent and identically distributed service times with a general distribution,
n servers and m extra waiting spaces. We use the steady-state distribution of that diffusion pro-
cess to obtain approximations for steady-state performance measures, focusing especially upon
the steady-state delay probability.
We primarily base our diffusion approximation on heavy-traffic limits in which n tends to infin-
ity as the traffic intensity increases. For the GI /M/n/
∞ special case, Halfin and Whitt (1981)
showed that scaled versions of these queue-length processes converge to a piecewise-linear diffu-
sion process when the traffic intensity ρn approaches 1 with (1
− ρn )√n → β for 0 < β < ∞.
A companion paper, Whitt (2002b), extends that limit to a special class of G/GI /n/m models
in which the service-time distribution is a mixture of an exponential distribution with probabil-
ity p and a unit point mass at 0 with probability 1
− p. Finite waiting rooms are treated by
incorporating the additional limit mn /√n
→ κ for 0 < κ ≤ ∞. The heuristic one-dimensional
diffusion-process approximation for the more general G/GI /n/m model developed here is con-
sistent with those heavy-traffic limits. Heavy-traffic limits for the GI /P H/n/
∞ model with
phase-type service-time distributions established by Puhalskii and Reiman (2000) imply that
this one-dimensional diffusion process is not asymptotically correct for non-exponential phase-
45
type service-time distributions, but nevertheless the heuristic diffusion approximation developed
here yields useful approximations for key performance measures, such as the delay probability.
The accuracy is confirmed by simulation.
Keywords: Queues, Multiserver queues, Delay probability, Blocking probability, Heavy-traffic,
Diffusion approximations
121. Whitt, Ward. Heavy-traffic limits for the G/H ∗
2 /n/m queue. Submitted to Mathematics of
Operations Research, 2002. Available at: <http://www.ieor.columbia.edu/
∼wow/>.
Abstract. We establish heavy-traffic stochastic-process limits for queue-length and waiting-
time stochastic processes in a class of G/GI /n/m queueing models with n servers and m extra
waiting spaces. We let the arrival process be general, only requiring that it satisfy a functional
central limit theorem. We consider a special class of service-time distributions, denoted by H ∗
2,
which are mixtures of an exponential distribution with probability p and a unit point mass at
0 with probability 1
− p. As in Halfin and Whitt (1981), Mandelbaum, Massey and Reiman
(1998), Puhalskii and Reiman (2000) and Garnett, Mandelbaum and Reiman (2000), we con-
sider a sequence of queueing models indexed by the number of servers, n, and let n tend to
infinity along with the traffic intensities ρn so that √n(1
− ρn ) → β for −∞ < β < ∞. To
treat finite waiting rooms, we let mn /√n
→ κ for 0 < κ ≤ ∞. We also consider the case of
exponential customer abandonments. With the special H ∗
2 service-time distribution, the limit
processes are piecewise-linear one-dimensional diffusion processes with an infinitesimal variance
that has a discontinuity at the origin when p < 1.
Keywords: Queues, Multiserver queues, Stochastic-process limits, Heavy-traffic, Diffusion ap-
proximations, Abandonments, Reneging, Customer impatience
122. Zohar, E., A. Mandelbaum and N. Shimkin. Adaptive behavior of impatient customers in tele-
queues: Theory and empirical support, Management Science, 48 (4), 2002, 566–583.
Abstract. We address the modeling and analysis of abandonment from a queue which is in-
visible to its occupants. Such queues arise in remote service systems, notably the Internet and
telephone call centers, hence, we refer to them as tele-queues. A basic premise of this paper is
that customers adapt their patience (modeled by an abandonment-time distribution) to their
service expectations, in particular to their anticipated waiting time. We first present empirical
support for that hypothesis, and propose an M/M/m-based model which incorporates adaptive
customer behavior. In our model, customer patience (and possibly the arrival rate) depend on
the mean waiting time in the queue. We then characterize the system equilibrium and establish
its existence and uniqueness when the growth rate of customer patience is bounded by that of
the mean waiting time. The feasibility of multiple system equilibria is illustrated when this
condition is violated. We also discuss a decision-theoretic model for customer abandonment,
and relate it to our basic model. Finally, a dynamic learning model is proposed where customer
expectations regarding their waiting time are formed through accumulated experience. We ad-
dress certain issues related to censored-sampling that arise in this framework and demonstrate,
via simulation, convergence to the theoretically anticipated equilibrium.
Keywords: Exponential (Markovian) queues, Abandonments, Equilibrium analysis, Invisible
46
queues, Performance-dependent behavior, Tele-services, Tele-queues, Call centers
(Appears also in Section III.)
123. Aksin, O. Zeynep and Patrick T. Harker. Capacity sizing in the presence of a common shared
resource: Dimensioning an inbound call center, European Journal of Operational Research, 147
(3), 2003, 464–483.
Abstract. This paper studies a capacity sizing problem for service systems where capacity is
determined by multiple types of resources that are required simultaneously in order to provide
service. In addition to the simultaneous use of resources, the systems are characterized by the
presence of a common resource that is shared across multiple types of customers. The paper
focuses on inbound call centers as an important example of such systems. The capacity sizing
problem in this context is one where the optimal number of servers that need to be allocated to
different call types is determined. Optimality is defined as the number of servers that maximize
revenues net of staffing costs. For the case where customers do not wait, it is shown that a
greedy allocation procedure yields the optimal server allocation. Heuristics are proposed for
the case with waiting customers that can exhibit impatience. The numerical analysis illustrates
that for systems experiencing heavy loads and serving a diverse set of customers, the proposed
heuristics outperform current methods that ignore the role of a shared resource in these types
of dimensioning problems.
Keywords: Queueing, Staff dimensioning, Resource sharing, Call center design
124. Atar, R., A. Mandelbaum and M.I. Reiman. A Brownian control prob lem for a simple queueing
system in the Halfin-Whitt regime, Systems and Control Letters, 2003 (in press).
Abstract. We consider a formal diffusion limit for a control problem of a multi-type multi-
server queueing system, in the regime proposed by Halfin and Whitt, in the form of a control
problem where the dynamics are driven by a Brownian motion. In one dimension, a pathwise
minimum is obtained and is characterized as the solution to a SDE. The pathwise solution to a
special multi-dimensional problem (corresponding to a multi-type system) follows.
Keywords: Queueing networks, Stochastic control, Heavy traffic asymptotics
125. Atar, R., A. Mandelbaum and M.I. Reiman. Scheduling a multi-class queue with many ex-
ponential servers: Asymptotic optimality in heavy-traffic. Accepted to Annals of Appl. Prob.,
September 2003.
Abstract. We consider the problem of scheduling a queueing system in which many i.i.d.
servers cater to several classes of impatient customers. Service times and impatience clocks are
exponential while arrival processes are renewal. Our cost is an expected cumulative discounted
function, linear or nonlinear, of appropriately normalized performance measures. As a special
case, the cost per unit time can be a function of the number of customers waiting to be served
in each class; the number actually being served, the abandonment rate, the delay experienced
by customers, the number of idling servers, as well as certain combinations thereof. We study
the system in an asymptotic heavy-traffic regime where the number of servers n and the offered
47
load R are simultaneously scaled up and carefully balanced: n
≈ R + β √R, for some scalar β .
This yields an operation that enjoys the benefits of both heavy traffic (high server utilization)
and light traffic (high service levels.)
We first consider a formal weak limit, through which our queueing scheduling problem gives rise
to a diffusion control problem. We show that the latter has an optimal Markov control policy,
and that the corresponding Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation has a unique classical so-
lution. The Markov control policy and the HJB equation are then used to define scheduling
control policies which we prove are asymptotically optimal for our original queueing system.
The analysis yields both qualitative and quantitative insights, in particular on staffing levels,
the roles of non-preemption and work-conservation, and the tradeoff between service quality and
servers’ efficiency.
126. Bhulai, S. and G. Koole. A queueing model for call blending in call centers, IEEE Transactions
on Automatic Control, 48 (8), 2003, 1434–1438.
Abstract. Call centers that apply call blending obtain high productivity and high service levels
by dynamically mixing inbound and outbound traffic. We show that agents should be assigned
to outbound calls if the number of available agents exceeds a certain threshold. This control
policy is optimal for equal service time distributions and a very good approximation otherwise.
Keywords: Call centres, Decision theory, Dynamic programming, Markov processes, Queueing
theory, Stochastic processes
127. Chevalier, P. and N. Tabordon. Overflow analysis and cross-trained servers, International Jour-
nal of Production Economics, 85 (1), 2003, 47–60.
Abstract. In this paper, we evaluate the performance of a call center composed of specialized
and cross-trained operators (i.e., operators trained to answer different classes of calls). The
paper focuses on the approximation of the loss probability of a call center where the different
classes of calls arrive according to a Poisson distribution and service time distribution is expo-
nential. We make the simplifying assumption that calls not immediately answered are lost. Our
closed form approximation is based on an approximation for hierarchical overflow systems in
telecommunication developed by Hayward and later extended by Fredericks (1980).
Keywords: Statistical decision theory, Operations research, Personnel management, Executive
compensation, Industry studies, Services
128. Gans, N., G. Koole and A. Mandelbaum. Telephone call centers: Tutorial, review, and re-
search prospects. Invited review paper by Manufacturing and Service Operations Management
(M&SOM), 5 (2), 2003, 79–141. Available at: <http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>
Abstract. Telephone call centers are an integral part of many businesses, and their economic
role is significant and growing. They are also fascinating socio-technical systems in which the
behavior of customers and employees is closely intertwined with physical performance measures.
In these environments, traditional operational models are of great value—and at the same time
fundamentally limited—in their ability to characterize system performance.
48
We review the state of research on telephone call centers. We begin with a tutorial on how call
centers function and proceed to survey academic research devoted to the management of their
operations. We then outline important problems that have not been addressed and identify
promising directions for future research.
Keywords: Telephone call center, Contact center, Tele-services, Tele-queues, Capacity manage-
ment, Staffing, Hiring, Workforce management systems, ACD reports, Queueing, Erlang C,
Erlang B, Erlang A, QED regime, Time-varying queues, Call routing, Skills-based routing, Fore-
casting, Data mining
129. Gans, Noah and Yong-Pin Zhou. A call-routing problem with service-level constraints, Opera-
tions Research, 51 (2), 2003, 255-271.
Abstract. This paper considers a queueing system, commonly found in inbound telephone call
centers, that processes two types of work. Type H jobs arrive at rate λH , are processed at rate
µH , and are served on a first-come first-served basis within class. A service level constraint of
the form E[delay] less than or equal to α or P
{delay less than or equal to β } greater than or
equal to α limits the delay in queue that these jobs may face. An infinite backlog of type L
jobs awaits processing at rate µL, and there is no service level constraint on this type of work.
A pool of c identical servers processes all jobs, and a system controller must maximize the rate
at which type L jobs are processed, sub ject to the service-level constraint placed on the type
H work. The problem is formulated as a constrained, average-cost Markov decision process and
the structure of effective routing policies is determined. When the expected service times of the
two classes are the same, these policies are globally optimal, and the computation time required
to find the optimal policy is about that required to calculate the normalizing constant for a
simple M/M/c system. When the expected service times of the two classes differ, the policies
are optimal within the class of priority policies, and the determination of optimal policy param-
eters can be determined through the solution of a linear program with O(c3 ) variables and O(c2 )
constraints.
Keywords: Studies, Operations research, Dynamic programming, Markov analysis, Queueing,
Call centers, Routing, Optimization
130. Jagerman, David L. and Benjamin Melamed. Models and approximations for call center design,
Methodology and Computing in Applied Probability, 5 (2), 2003, 159.
Abstract. A call center is a facility for delivering telephone service, both incoming and outgoing.
This paper addresses optimal staffing of call centers, modeled as M/G/n queues whose offered
traffic consists of multiple customer streams, each with an individual priority, arrival rate, service
distribution and grade of service (GoS) stated in terms of equilibrium tail waiting time proba-
bilities or mean waiting times. The paper proposes a methodology for deriving the approximate
minimal number of servers that suffices to guarantee the prescribed GoS of all customer streams.
The methodology is based on an analytic approximation, called the Scaling-Erlang (SE) approx-
imation, which maps the M/G/n queue to an approximating, suitably scaled M/G/1 queue,
for which waiting time statistics are available via the Pollaczek-Khintchine formula in terms of
Laplace transforms. The SE approximation is then generalized to M/G/n queues with multiple
types of customers and non-preemptive priorities, yielding the Priority Scaling-Erlang (PSE)
49
approximation. A simple goal-seeking search, utilizing SE/PSE approximations, is presented
for the optimal staffing level, sub ject to GoS constraints. The efficacy of the methodology is
demonstrated by comparing the number of servers estimated via the PSE approximation to
their counterparts obtained by simulation. A number of case studies confirms that the SE/PSE
approximations yield optimal staffing results in excellent agreement with simulation, but at a
fraction of simulation time and space.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Queueing, Methods, Mathematical models
131. Jelenkovi´c, A., A. Mandelbaum and P. Momˇcilovi´c. Heavy traffic limits for queues with many
deterministic servers. Accepted to QUESTA, June 2003. Available at:
<http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>
Abstract. Consider a sequence of stationary GI/D/N queues indexed by N
↑ ∞, with servers’
utilization 1
− β /√N , β > 0. For such queues we show that the scaled waiting times √N WN
converge to the (finite) supremum of a Gaussian random walk with drift
−β . This further implies
a corresponding limit for the number of customers in the system, an easily computable nonde-
generate limiting delay probability in terms of Spitzer’s random-walk identities, and √N rate of
convergence. Our asymptotic regime is important for rational dimensioning of large-scale service
systems, for example telephone- or internet-based, since it achieves, simultaneously, arbitrarily
high service-quality and utilization-efficiency.
Keywords: Multi-server queue, GI/D/N, Deterministic service time, Heavy-traffic, Quality-and-
efficiency-driven (QED) or Halfin-Whitt regime, Telephone call or contact centers, Economies of
scale, Gaussian random walk, Spitzer’s identities
132. Koole, Ger. Redefining the service level in call centers. Technical report, Department of Stochas-
tics, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, 2003.
Abstract. We propose a new waiting time metric for call centers that circumvents some of the
problems that the standard way of defining service level has.
133. Qiang, Yang, Wang Yong, Zhang Zhong. SANet: A service-agent network for all center schedul-
ing, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man & Cybernetics, Part A: Systems & Humans, 33 (3),
2003, 396–406.
Abstract. We consider a network of service-providing agents, where different agents have dif-
ferent capabilities, availability, and cost to solve problems. These characteristics are particularly
important in practice for semi-automated call centers which provide quality customer service
in real time. We have developed SANet, a service agent network for call center automation, to
serve as an experimental testbed for our research. SANet can select appropriate agents to provide
better solutions for customer problems according to the changing capabilities and availability of
service agents in the network. It can also add or delete appropriate agents to balance problem-
solving quality, efficiency, and cost according to the number and types of incoming customer
problems. On this network, each service agent can be a human service agent, an automated
software service agent, or a combination of the two. This paper describes the architecture, a
50
problem scheduling algorithm and an agent assignment algorithm on the SANet. We highlight
an application in which we apply SANet to a call-center scheduling problem for a cable TV com-
pany. Finally, we show the efficiency and adaptability of our system via experimental results
and discuss related works.
Keywords: Cable television, Call centres, Multi-agent systems, Problem-solving, Real-time sys-
tems
(Appears also in Section V.)
134. Stolletz, Raik. Performance analysis of M -designed inbound call centers, Operations Research
Proceedings, 9–16, 2003.
Abstract. Many call centers provide service for customers of different classes. We analyze a
queueing model of an inbound call center with two customer classes, three agent groups, and
skills-based routing. In our model we assume that a waiting customer may hang up before his
service begins. We describe the states and the state space of this Markov queueing system and
develop the steady-state equations. The behavior of this system is analyzed in numerical exper-
iments and optimal economical allocations of the agents are discussed.
135. Aguir, Salah, Fikri Karaesmen, O. Zeynep Aksin and Fabrice Chauvet. OR Spectrum, 26 (3),
353–376, 2004.
Abstract. This paper models a call center as a Markovian queue with multiple servers, where
customer balking, impatience, and retrials are modeled explicitly. The resulting queue is an-
alyzed both in a stationary and nonstationary setting. For the stationary setting a fluid ap-
proximation is proposed, which overcomes the computational burden of the continuous time
Markov chain analysis, and which is shown to provide an accurate representation of the system
for large call centers with high system load. An insensitivity property of the retrial rate to key
system parameters is established. The fluid approximation is shown to work equally well for
the nonstationary setting with time-varying arrival rates. Using the fluid approximation, the
paper explores the retrial phenomenon for a real call center. The model is used to estimate the
real arrival rates based on demand data, where retrials cannot be distinguished from first time
calls. This is a common problem encountered in call centers. Through numerical examples, it is
shown that disregarding the retrial phenomenon in call centers can lead to huge distortions in
subsequent forecasting and staffing analysis.
Keywords: Performance evaluation, Servers, Markov analysis, Call centers, Queueing, Studies,
Models
136. Armony, Mor and Constantinos Maglaras. On customer contact centers with a call-back option:
Customer decisions, routing rules, and system design, Operations Research, 52 (2), 271–292,
2004.
Abstract. Organizations worldwide use contact centers as an important channel of communi-
cation and transaction with their customers. This paper describes a contact center with two
channels, one for real-time telephone service, and another for a postponed call-back service of-
51
fered with a guarantee on the maximum delay until a reply is received. Customers are sensitive
to both real-time and call-back delay and their behavior is captured through a probabilistic
choice model. The dynamics of the system are modeled as an M/M/N multiclass system. We
rigorously justify that as the number of agents increases, the system’s load approaches the max-
imum processing capacity. Based on this observation, we perform an asymptotic analysis in the
many-server, heavy traffic regime to find an asymptotically optimal routing rule, characterize
the unique equilibrium regime of the system, approximate the system performance, and finally,
propose a staffing rule that picks the minimum number of agents that satisfies a set of opera-
tional constraints on the performance of the system.
Keywords: Operations research, Call centers, Service level agreements, Equilibrium, Mathemat-
ical models, Routing, Optimization, Real time
137. Atlason, Julius, Marina A. Epelman and Shane G. Henderson. Call center staffing with simu-
lation and cutting plane methods, Annals of Operations Research, 127 (1–4), 333–358, March
2004.
Available at: http://critical.orie.cornell.edu/
∼shane/pubs.html.
Abstract. We present an iterative cutting plane method for minimizing staffing costs in a
service system sub ject to satisfying acceptable service level requirements over multiple time pe-
riods. We assume that the service level cannot be easily computed, and instead, is evaluated
using simulation. The simulation uses the method of common random numbers, so that the
same sequence of random phenomena is observed when evaluating different staffing plans. In
other words, we solve a sample average approximation problem. We establish convergence of
the cutting plane method on a given sample average approximation. We also establish both
convergence, and the rate of convergence, of the solutions to the sample average approximation
to solutions of the original problem as the sample size increases. The cutting plane method relies
on the service level functions being concave in the number of servers. We show how to verify
this requirement as our algorithm proceeds. A numerical example showcases the properties of
our method, and sheds light on when the concavity requirement can be expected to hold.
Keywords: Simulation optimization, Call centers, Cutting planes, Sample average approximation
138. de Vericourt, Francis and Yong-Pin Zhou. A routing problem for call centers with customer
callbacks after service failure. Working paper, University of Washington, March 2004.
Abstract. Traditional research on queue routing models usually ignore service quality-related
factors. In this paper, we analyze the routing problem in a system where customers call back
when the service customer representatives (CSR) do not satisfy them. We introduce the concept
of call resolution probability, and we argue that this constitutes a good proxy for call quality.
This call resolution probability (p) but also the average service time is CSR dependent. The
ob jective is then to minimize the average total time of call resolution including callbacks. We
use an MDP formulation to study the optimal routing policy. We obtain analytical results and
insights regarding how to account for both the service time and the call resolution probability.
In particular, we provide conditions for which routing to the available CSR with the highest call
resolution rate is optimal. We also develop heuristics that can be easily implemented in practice.
52
139. Gans, Noah and Yong-Pin Zhou. Overflow routing for call-center outsourcing. Working paper,
Wharton School of Business Administration, May 2004.
Abstract. Companies may choose to outsource parts, but not all, of their call-center operations.
In some cases, they classify customers as high or low-value, serving the former with their “in
house” operations and routing the latter to an outsourcer. Typically, they impose service-level
constraints on the time each type of customer waits on hold. We consider this outsourcing prob-
lem from both the client company’s and the outsourcer’s points of view. We pose the client’s
problem as that of maximizing the throughput of low-value calls, sub ject to a high-value cus-
tomer service-level constraint, and the outsourcer’s as one of finding the minimal staffing level
able to fulfill the low-value customers service-level constraint. The paper’s analytical results
characterize effective routing policies at the client, as well as the overflow process of low-value
calls to the outsourcer. Its numerical results help to show how the percentage of low-value calls
that overflows from the client affects the burstiness of the overflow process and, in turn, the
effectiveness of various staffing heuristics at the outsourcer.
140. Jim´enez, Tania and Ger Koole. Scaling and comparison of fluid limits of queues applied to call
centers with time-varying parameters, OR Spectrum, 26, 2004, 413–422. Abstract. Transient
overload situations in queues can be approximated by fluid queues. We strengthen earlier results
on the comparison of multi-server tandem systems with their fluid limits. At the same time, we
give conditions under which economies-of-scale hold. We apply the results to call centers.
Keywords: Call centers, Fluid limits, Economies-of-scale, Inhomogeneous Poisson processes
141. Mandelbaum, A. and Zeltyn, S. The impact of customers’ patience on delay and abandonment:
Some empirically-driven experiments with the M/M/n+G queue”, OR Spectrum, 26 (3), 377–
411, 2004. Downloadable from: <http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>.
Abstract. Our research is motivated by a phenomenon that has been observed in telephone call
center data: A clear linear relation between the probability to abandon and average waiting time.
Such a relation is theoretically justifiable when customers’ patience is memoryless, but it lacks an
explanation in general. We thus analyze its robustness within the framework of the M/M/n+G
queue, which gives rise to further and empirically-driven experiments. In the theoretical part of
the paper, we establish order relations for performance measures of the M/M/n+G queues, and
some light-traffic results. In particular, we prove that, with λ, µ, n and average patience time
fixed, deterministic patience minimizes the probability to abandon and maximizes the average
wait in queue. In the experimental part, we describe the behavior of M/M/n+G performance
measures for different patience distributions. The findings are then related to our theoretical
results and some observed real-data phenomena. In particular, clear nonlinear relations (convex,
concave and mixed) emerge between the prbability to abandon and average wait. However, when
restricted over low to moderate abandonment rates, approximate linearity prevails, as observed
in practice.
Keywords: Abandonment, Call centers, Erlang-A, Queues and queueing
142. Shimkin, N. and A. Mandelbaum. Rational abandonment from tele-queues: Nonlinear waiting
53
costs with heterogeneous preferences, QUESTA, 47 (1–2), 117–146, May-June, 2004. Available
at: <http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng>
Abstract. We consider the modeling of abandonment from a queueing system by impatient
customers. Within the proposed model, customers act rationally to maximize a utility function
that weights service utility against expected waiting cost. Customers are heterogeneous, in the
sense that their utility function parameters may vary across the customer population. The queue
is assumed invisible to waiting customers, who do not obtain any information regarding their
standing in the queue during their waiting period. Such circumstances apply, for example, in
telephone centers or other remote service facilities, to which we refer as tele-queues. We analyze
this decision model within a multi-server queue with impatient customers, and seek to character-
ize the Nash equilibria of this system. These equilibria may be viewed as stable operating points
of the system, and determine the customer abandonment profile along with other system-wide
performance measures. We provide conditions for the existence and uniqueness of the equilib-
rium, and suggest procedures for its computation. We also suggest a notion of an equilibrium
based on sub-optimal decisions, the myopic equilibrium, which enjoys favorable analytical prop-
erties. Some concrete examples are provided to illustrate the modeling approach and analysis.
The present paper supplements previous ones which were restricted to linear waiting costs or
heterogeneous customer population.
Keywords: Tele-queues or invisible queues, Abandonment, Impatient customers, Nash equilib-
rium, Telephone call centers, Contact centers, Multi-server queues
143. Shumsky, Robert A. Approximation and analysis of a call center with flexible and specialized
servers, OR Spectrum, 26 (3), 307–330, 2004.
Abstract. This paper describes a decomposition algorithm to estimate the performance of a
call center with two types of customers and two server categories. In this system, specialized
servers can process only one customer type, while flexible servers handle both types. The al-
gorithm divides the systems state space into regions, and simple approximate models find the
conditional system performance within each region. While the procedure described here is tai-
lored for a system with a priority queue discipline and two customer classes, it can be adapted
for systems with FCFS queue disciplines and for systems with more than two customer types.
Performance measures generated by the procedure are sufficiently accurate for many service sys-
tem design decisions, such as setting telephone call center staffing levels and long-term capacity
planning. The procedure is also extremely fast, and its computational requirements do not grow
with system congestion. Numerical tests demonstrate that its running time is significantly lower
than traditional numerical methods for generating approximations. As an example of its use, we
employ the procedure to demonstrate the benefits of server flexibility in a particular telephone
call center.
Keywords: Servers, Call centers, Studies, Algorithms, Queueing
54
II Statistics, Forecasting
1. Edie, Leslie C. Traffic delays at toll booths, Journal of the Operations Research Society of Amer-
ica, 2 (2), 1954, 107–138.
Abstract. The collection of vehicular tolls at Port Authority tunnels and bridges is one of the
most important operations conducted by the police personnel. More than 250 traffic officers are
utilized, and the payroll costs exceed a million dollars annually. In staffing its toll plazas, the
Port Authority attempts to handle traffic with a minimum number of toll collectors consistent
with uniformly good service to the public and properly spaced relief periods for the toll collec-
tors. This requires finding the level of traffic delays that gives the best compromise between the
conflicting ob jectives of economy and service. In the past, the number of toll collectors provided
for operating a toll plaza was determined by judgment based on experience and a rule-of-thumb
work standard which had not been related to service. Judgment was likewise used to allocate
manpower and control the number of toll booths opened at any time. This method resulted in
patron delays observed to vary from 2 to 50 sec. The tools of probability theory provide methods
for dealing with the problem in quantitative terms. They enable determination of the relations
between traffic volumes, number of toll booths, and grade of service. With this knowledge, the
optimum grade of service can be established in a logical manner and the number of toll booths
required at any time of day can be specified in advance. Use of this method permitted savings
in toll collection expenses and better service.
(Appears also in Section I.)
2. Edie, Leslie C. Review of Port of New York Authority study. Case Histories Five Years After—A
Symposium, 1959, 263–277.
3. Roberts, J.W. Recent observations of subscriber behavior. 9th International Tele-traffic Confer-
ence (ITC-9), Torremolinos, 1979.
Abstract. This paper presents an analysis of experimental observations of subscriber repeated
attempts and subscriber patience in relation to the post-dialing delay. The analysis includes, in
particular, an investigation of the influence of the interval between successive attempts and we
derive estimates of the probability distributions of the subscribers’ patience. The results concern
local, trunk and international calls made by certain subscribers on a Paris exchange.
(Appears also in Section III.)
4. Kort, Barry W. Models and methods for evaluating customer acceptance of telephone connec-
tions, IEEE, 1983, 706–714.
Abstract. This paper describes models and methods developed at Bell Laboratories to evalu-
ate customer acceptance of telephone connections in the Bell System Public Switched Telephone
Network. We present three related customer opinion models (Call Setup Rating, Transmission
Rating, and Call Completion Rating), two customer behavior models (Abandonment/Retrial
Behavior and Complaint Rate models), several network Performance Characterization models
(for call setup and transmission performance parameters) and a Monte-Carlo Simulation model
55
which combines all the above models to estimate the grade of service, abandonment and retrial
behavior, the complaint rate, and the ineffective attempt rate of the Public Network.
These models and the method of analysis are presented as a prototype to support current efforts
of the IEEE Subcommittee on Telecommunications System Performance Characteristics. That
Subcommittee has been chartered to develop industry-wide standards for expressing telephone
network performance characteristics. The goal of the IEEE work is to provide a uniform method
for vendors of voice-grade telecommunications services to describe the performance of their ser-
vice offerings.
(Appears also in Section III.)
5. Mabert, V.A. Short interval forecasting of emergency phone call (911) work loads, Journal of
Operations Management, 5 (3), 1985, 259–271.
Abstract. There has been a growing emphasis over the last 5–10 years on improving produc-
tivity in the service sector of the US economy. Effective scheduling of the workforce in these
organizations requires good estimates of demand, which may show substantial variations between
days for certain times of the year. An examination is made of the use of 6 different forecasting
methods for predicting daily emergency call workloads for the Indianapolis Police Department’s
communications area: 1. one-year lag, 2. zero/one regression, 3. multiplicative/additive, 4.
zero/one with adjustment, 5. multiplicative/additive with adjustment, and 6. autoregressive,
integrated moving average intervention. The research suggests that there are clearly significant
differences in performance for the 6 models analyzed. Simple modeling approaches can perform
well in the complex environments found in many service organizations. Special tailoring of the
forecasting model is required for many service firms. Historical data patterns for these organi-
zations tend to be more involved than just trend and seasonal elements.
Keywords: Studies, Police, Mathematical models, Implementations, Forecasting techniques,
Emergencies, Departments, Communications, Case studies
(Appears also in Section I.)
6. Sparrow, L.B. Manning the telephone enquiry bureau at British Gas West Midlands. In Opera-
tions Research in Management, S.C. Littlechild, editor. New York: Prentice Hall, 1991, 167–173.
Abstract. All telephone enquiries to British Gas West Midlands are dealt with by a team of
specialist clerks in two centralized enquiry bureaux. Customers anywhere in the region can
contact a bureau at local call costs. At all times it is essential to maintain a high standard of
answering service, not only because this is expected by the customer for any type of enquiry but
also to ensure that emergency calls relating, perhaps, to gas leaks are accepted and dealt with.
In about 1970, the enquiry bureaux were finding it difficult to maintain the servicing of cus-
tomers’ calls at peak periods with the existing monitoring equipment. It was decided to set up a
queueing theory model of the telephone answering system. The aim was to derive the relation-
ships between traffic level, grade of service, waiting time and manning levels within the bureaux.
The model would be used as a planning tool, both for indicating peak manning requirements
and for optimizing number of staff at off-peak times. This chapter describes the model which
was developed and the results which were obtained.
56
(Appears also in Section I.)
7. Bianchi, Lisa, Jeffrey Jarrett and R. Choudary Hanumara. Forecasting incoming calls to tele-
marketing centers, The Journal of Business Forecasting Methods & Systems, 12 (2), 1993, 3–12.
Abstract. For forecasting incoming calls to telemarketing centers, AT&T Bell Laboratories
uses an adaptation of Holt-Winters’ forecasting model with its telemarketing scheduling system,
called NAMES. A study evaluates the current use of the Holt-Winters’ model for forecasting
as done by the NAMES system and indicates whether improvement is possible through the use
of ARIMA time series modeling. The data consisted of daily call volumes from March 1, 1991
to June 26, 1991. Initial plots of the data revealed weekly seasonality, the presence of outliers,
and no apparent trend over time. Intervention analysis is the way in which ARIMA models can
be utilized to account for outliers. The current methodology contained in the NAMES software
may perform well. Problems usually arise when outliers appear in the time series data. The
ARIMA modeling with an outlier detection feature could improve forecasts of a series containing
outliers which was the case with incoming calls at different telemarketing centers. The ARIMA
modeling method was significantly better than either Holt-Winters’ model in more than 1/2 of
the time series studies.
Keywords: Time series, Telemarketing, Studies, Models, Forecasting techniques
8. Andrews, Bruce H. and Shawn M. Cunningham. L.L. Bean improves call-center forecasting,
Interfaces, 25 (6), 1995, 1–13.
Abstract. Two forecasting models are developed and implemented for use at L.L. Bean Inc.,
a widely known retailer of high-quality outdoor goods and apparel. The models forecast calls
incoming to L.L. Bean’s call center so that efficient staffing schedules for telephone agents can be
produced two weeks in advance. The ARIMA/transfer function methodology is used to model
these time series data since they exhibit seasonal patterns but are strongly influenced by inde-
pendent variables, including holiday and advertising interventions. The improved precision of
the models is estimated to save $300,000 annually through enhanced scheduling efficiency.
Keywords: Call center forecasting, L.L. Bean, Forecasting models, Retailer, Telephone agents,
Staffing schedules, ARIMA transfer function methodology, Time series data, Seasonal patterns,
Holiday, Advertising interventions
(Appears also in Section I.)
9. Massey, W.A., G.A. Parker and W. Whitt. Estimating the parameters of a nonhomogeneous
Poisson process with linear rate, Telecommunications Systems—Modeling, Analysis, Design and
Management, 5 (4), 1996, 361–688.
Abstract. We want to be able to determine if a Poisson process traffic model is appropriate and,
when it is, we want to be able to estimate its parameters from measurements, with linear rate
over a finite interval, based on the number of counts in measurement subintervals. Such a linear
arrival-rate function can serve as a component of a piecewise-linear approximation to a general
arrival-rate function. We consider ordinary least squares (OLS), iterative weighted least squares
57
(IWLS) and maximum likelihood (ML), all constrained to yield a nonnegative rate function. We
prove that ML coincides with IWLS. As a reference point, we also consider the theoretically op-
timal weighted least squares (TWLS), which is least squares with weights inversely proportional
to the variances (which would not be known with data). Overall, ML performs almost as well
as TWLS. We describe computer simulations conducted to evauate these estimation procedures.
None of the procedures differ greatly when the rate function is not near 0 at either end, but
when the rate function is near 0 at one end, TWLS and ML are significantly more effective than
OLS. The number of measurement subintervals (with fixed total interval) makes surprisingly
little difference when the rate function is not near 0 at either end. The variances are higher
with only two or three subintervals, but there usually is little benefit from going above ten. In
contrast, more measurement intervals help TWLS and ML when the rate function is near 0 at
one end. We derive explicit formulas for the OLS variances and the asymptotic TWLS variances
(as the number of measurement intervals increases), assuming the nonnegativity constraints are
not violated. These formulas reveal the statistical precision of the estimators and the influence
of the parameters and the method. Knowing how the variance depends on the interval length
can help determine how to approximate general arrival-rate functions by piecewise-linear ones.
We also develop statistical tests to determine wehther the linear Poisson model is appropriate.
Keywords: Digital simulation, Iterative methods, Least-squares approximations, Maximum likeli-
hood estimation, Parameter estimation, Piecewise linear techniques, Queueing theory, Stochastic
processes, Telecommunication traffic, Nonhomogeneous Poisson process, Piecewise linear approx-
imation, Linear arrival-rate function, Ordinary least squares, Iterative weighted least squares,
Computer simulations, Statistical precision, Traffic model
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
10. Chlebus, E. Empirical validation of call holding time distribution in cellular communications
systems. Teletraffic Contributions for the Information Age. Proceedings of the 15th Interna-
tional Teletraffic Congress, ITC-15. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997, 1179–1188.
Abstract. Various probability distributions are fitted to empirical call holding time data col-
lected in cellular communications systems. Their parameters are determined through maximum
likelihood estimation. A visual plots examination of empirical and fitted cumulative distribu-
tion functions enables qualitative comparison. Goodness-of-fit techniques based on supremum
and quadratic empirical distribution function statistics, namely the Kolmogorov-Smirnov and
Anderson-Darling tests, respectively are implemented to compare quantitatively the produced
fits.
Keywords: Empirical validation, Call holding time distribution, Cellular communications sys-
tems, Probability distributions, Empirical call holding time data, Maximum likelihood estima-
tion, Cumulative distribution functions, Goodness-of-fit techniques, Supremum empirical dis-
tribution function statistics, Quadratic empirical distribution function statistics, Kolmogorov-
Smirnov test, Anderson-Darling test, Exponential distribution, Gamma distribution, Lognormal
distribution
11. Klungle, Roger and Jim Maluchnik. Call center forecasting at AAA Michigan, The Journal of
Business Forecasting Methods & Systems, 16 (4), 1997/1998, 8–13.
58
Abstract. The number of incoming calls for Emergency Road Service at AAA Michigan at
different times of a day differ significantly during winter and spring seasons. A regression model
is the bet, though weather, which is used as one of the independent variables, is difficult to
forecast more than a few days in advance. One the first day of a cold spell, call volumes are
usually very high which later on return to normal even though the temperatures are still very
low.
Keywords: Case studies, Associations, Forecasting techniques, Automobiles, Call centers, Cus-
tomer relations, Member services
12. Bianchi, Lisa, Jeffrey Jarrett and R. Choudary Hanumara. Improving forecasting for telemar-
keting centers by ARIMA modeling with intervention, International Journal of Forecasting, 14
(4), 1998, 497–504.
Abstract. This study analyzes existing and improved methods for forecasting calls to telemar-
keting centers for the purposes of planning and budgeting. The use of additive and multiplicative
versions of Holt-Winters exponentially weighted moving average models is analyzed and com-
pared to Box-Jenkins (ARIMA) modeling with intervention analysis. The forecasting accuracy
of HW and ARIMA models for samples of telemarketing data is determined.
Although there is much evidence in recent literature that simple models such as Holt-Winters
perform as well as or better than more complex models, it is found that ARIMA models with
intervention analysis perform better for the time series studied.
Keywords: Holt-Winters models, Intervention analysis, Box-Jenkins (ARIMA) modeling, Time
series
13. Faerber, J., S. Bodamer and J. Charzinski. Statistical evaluation and modeling of Internet dial-
up traffic. Proceedings of the SPIE—The International Society for Optical Engineering, 3841,
1999, 112–121.
Abstract. In times of Internet access being a popular consumer application even for “normal”
residential users, some telephone exchanges are congested by customers using modem or ISDN
dial-up connections to their Internet service providers. In order to estimate the number of ad-
ditional lines and switching capacity required in an exchange or a trunk group, Internet access
traffic must be characterized in terms of holding time and call interarrival time distributions.
We analyze log files tracing the usage of the central ISDN access line pool at the University of
Stuttgart for a period of six months. Mathematical distributions are fitted to the measured data
and the fit quality is evaluated with respect to the blocking probability caused by the synthetic
traffic in a multiple server loss system. We show how the synthetic traffic model scales with the
number of subscribers and how the model could be applied to compute economy of scale results
for Internet access trunks or access servers.
Keywords: Statistical evaluation, Internet dial-up traffic, Traffic modeling, Holding-time distri-
bution, Consumer applications, Residential users, Telephone exchanges, Modem dial-up connec-
tions, ISDN dial-up connections, Internet service providers, Switching capacity, Trunk group,
Internet access traffic, Call interarrival time distribution, Log files, Central ISDN access line
pool, University of Stuttgart, Mathematical distributions, Measured data, Blocking probability,
59
Synthetic traffic, Multiple server loss system, Synthetic traffic model, Economy-of-scale results,
Internet access trunks, Internet access servers, WWW-based services
14. Weidong Xu. Long range planning for call centers at FedEx, The Journal of Business Forecast-
ing Methods & Systems, 18 (4), Winter 1999/2000, 7–11.
Abstract. FedEx is the world’s largest express transportation company, generating $14 bil-
lion in annual revenue. To support the global transportation network, FedEx has established 51
worldwide customer service call centers. The customer service at FedEx in the US handles about
500,000 calls per day. There are three ma jor networks: 1. Domestic, 2. International, and 3.
Freight. For each network, the company has developed four different types of forecasts based on
different forecasting horizons: 1. Strategic Plan, 2. Business Plan, 3. Tactical Forecast, and 4.
Operational Forecast. Different methodologies are adopted for different levels of forecasts. An
overview of these methodologies is presented.
Keywords: Postal & delivery services, Forecasting techniques, Customer services, Case studies
(Appears also in Sections I and VII.)
15. Betts, Alan, Maureen Meadows and Paul Walley. Call centre capacity management, Interna-
tional Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 185–196.
Abstract. Call centres often experience large fluctuations in demand over relatively short peri-
ods of time. However, most centres also need to maintain short response times to the demand.
This places great emphasis upon capacity management practices within call centre operations.
A total of 12 UK-based call centres from one retail bank were studied to investigate how they
managed forecasting, capacity management and scheduling tasks. Provides evidence of the dif-
ficulties associated with capacity management in call centres. Regression modelling is used to
link forecasting and capacity planning practices to performance. Shows that random variation
is a very important factor when assessing call centre performance. The results suggest that call
centre managers can have only a small influence upon short-term performance. Existing mathe-
matical models, such as the Erlang queuing system methodologies, have only limited value as the
assumptions concerning demand patterns made in their derivation contradict observations made
within the 12 sites. Spiked demand patterns present special capacity management problems,
including a direct trade-off between high service levels and operator boredom. Conventional
methods of flexing capacity cannot respond sufficiently well to some of the short-term fluctua-
tions in demand.
Keywords: Capacity management, Service operations, Banking, Call centres
(Appears also in Section VII.)
16. Jongbloed, Geurt and Ger Koole. Managing uncertainty in call centers using Poisson mixtures.
Working paper, Vrije Universiteit, Division of Mathematics and Computer Science, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands, November 2000.
Abstract. We model a call center as a queueing model with Poisson arrivals having an unknown
varying arrival rate. We show how to compute prediction intervals for the arrival rate, and use
60
the Erlang formula for the waiting time to compute the consequences for the occupancy level of
the call center. We compare it to the current practice of using a point estimate of the arrival
rate (assumed constant) as forecast.
(Appears also in Section I.)
17. Mandelbaum, A., A. Sakov and S. Zeltyn. Empirical analysis of a call center. Technical report,
Faculty of Industrial Engineering and Management, Technion—Israel Institute of Technology,
Haifa, Israel, 2001.
18. Antipov, A. and N. Meade. Forecasting call frequency at a financial services call centre, The
Journal of the Operational Research Society, 53 (9), 2002, 953–960.
Abstract. A forecasting model is developed for the number of daily applications for loans at a
financial services telephone call center. The purpose of the forecasts and the associated predic-
tion intervals is to provide effective staffing policies within the call center. The model building
process is constrained by the availability of only 2 years and 7 months of data. The distinctive
feature of the data is that demand is driven in the main by advertising. The analysis given
focuses on applications stimulated by press advertising. Unlike previous analyses of broadly
similar data, where ARIMA models were used, a model with a dynamic level, multiplicative
calendar effects and a multiplicative advertising response is developed and shown to be effective.
Keywords: Studies, Forecasting techniques, Call centers, Financial services, Mathematical mod-
els, Workforce planning, Advertising
19. Bayerl, S., T. Bollinger and C. Schommer. Applying models with scoring, Third International
Conference on Data Mining, WIT Press, Southampton, UK, 2002, 757–766.
Abstract. “Scoring”, in general, is defined as the usage of mining models—based on historical
data—for classification or segmentation of new items. For example, if the historical data consist
of classified customers, then we can use the model for the prediction of the behaviour of a new
customer. Scoring offers novel ways to exploit the power of data mining models in everyday
business activities, and proliferate mining applications to users who are not educated in mining.
In this paper, we present a) the generic scoring process, b) its technical implementation, and c)
an example of how scoring can be integrated in a real application. The generic process consists of
three steps: The mining models are learned first, then they are transferred into the application
database, and finally, the models are applied to the data loaded in that database. Arguments for
the necessity of such a mining improvement are collected. IBM DB2 Intelligent Miner Scoring
(IM Scoring) is the first technical implementation of scoring. It is based on the emerging open
standard for mining models (Predictive Model Markup Language—PMML), and the mining ex-
tensions for SQL. Implementation issues are discussed, as well as problems that come along with
its integration into operational applications. The article closes with the description of a sample
application, the integration of scoring into a call center environment. A discussion of the scoring
method concludes this article.
Keywords: Call centres, Classification, Customer relationship management, Data mining, Hy-
permedia markup languages, Marketing data processing, SQL, Very large databases
61
20. Brown, L., N. Gans, A. Mandelbaum, A. Sakov, H. Shen, S. Zeltyn and L. Zhao. Statistical
analysis of a telephone call center: A queueing-science perspective. Submitted to JASA, Novem-
ber 2002.
Abstract. A call center is a service network in which agents provide telephone-based services.
Customers that seek these services are delayed in tele-queues.
This paper summarizes an analysis of a unique record of call center operations. The data
comprise a complete operational history of a small banking call center, call by call, over a
full year. Taking the perspective of queueing theory, we decompose the service process into
three fundamental components: arrivals, customer abandonment behavior and service durations.
Each component involves different basic mathematical structures and requires a different style
of statistical analysis. Some of the key empirical results are sketched, along with descriptions of
the varied techniques required.
Several statistical techniques are developed for analysis of the basic components. One of these
is a test that a point process is a Poisson process. Another involves estimation of the mean
function in a nonparametric regression with lognormal errors. A new graphical technique is
introduced for nonparametric hazard rate estimation with censored data. Models are developed
and implemented for forecasting of Poisson arrival rates.
We then survey how the characteristics deduced from the statistical analyses form the building
blocks for theoretically interesting and practically useful mathematical models for call center
operations.
Keywords: Call centers, Queueing theory, Lognormal distribution, Inhomogeneous Poisson pro-
cess, Censored data, Human patience, Prediction of Poisson rates, Khintchine-Pollaczek formula,
Service times, Arrival rate, Abandonment rate, Multiserver queues
(Appears also in Section I.)
21. Foss, Bryan, Iain Henderson, Peter Johnson, Don Murray and Merlin Stone. Managing the
quality and completeness of customer data, The Journal of Database Marketing, 10 (2), 2002,
139–158.
Abstract. Although companies have been collecting customer-related data for years, this was
normally for administration rather than customer management. While larger companies have
more recently collected customer data for database marketing—to recruit new customers, sell
more to existing customers, support customer service operations, and retain customers—returns
are usually limited because most data are still held and used departmentally. The growth of
contact centers, e-commerce, and more complex value chains has raised additional issues of en-
terprise data management and exploitation, while demonstrating beyond doubt that available
data are insufficient to support new customer management processes. The article considers these
issues and proposed tried and tested approaches for addressing these customer data management
issues in a practical and achievable manner.
Keywords: Database marketing, Marketing management, Data integrity, Customer relationship
management
62
(Appears also in Section VII.)
22. Hur, D. A comparative evaluation of forecast monitoring systems in service organizations, 33rd
Annual Meeting of the Decision Sciences Institute, Decision Sciences Institute, San Diego, CA,
USA, 2002, 5 pp.
Abstract. Demand forecasts are ma jor inputs to workforce scheduling and material planning
in many service organizations, and the effectiveness of such planning activities hinges upon the
accuracy of the forecasts. Since forecasts are rarely precise in reality, managers need to monitor
forecast errors when they implement the labor and material plans. The paper aims to identify
and evaluate an automatic detector of forecast bias to help managers. The paper identified and
evaluated five error detection techniques using both actual data from a call center, and simulated
data. All five techniques detected a considerable demand shift in a timely manner, and appeared
very robust across diverse demand environments. In particular, the threshold curve and wine-
glass chart turned out to be the quickest and most powerful of the five methods. In addition,
the patterns of within day demand arrival and their stability throughout the day significantly
influenced the performance of the detection techniques.
Keywords: Call centres, Forecasting theory, Human resource management, Manufacturing re-
sources planning, Scheduling, Service industries, Statistics
23. Avramidis, Athanassios, Alexandre Deslauiers and Pierre L’Ecuyer. Modeling daily arrivals to
a telephone call center, Management Science, 50 (7), 896–908, 2004.
Abstract. We develop stochastic models of time-dependent arrivals, with focus on the applica-
tion to call centers. Our models reproduce essential features of call center arrivals observed in
recent empirical studies, namely, a time-varying arrival intensity over the course of a day, and
nonzero correlation between the arrival counts in different time periods within the same day.
For each of the new models, we characterize the joint distribution of the vector of arrival counts
with particular focus on characterizing how the new models are more flexible than standard or
previously proposed models. We report empirical results from a study on arrival data from a
real-life call center, including the essential features of the arrival process, the goodness-of-fit of
the estimated models, and the sensitivity of various simulated performance measures of the call
center to the choice of arrival process model.
Keywords: Studies, Management science, Call centers, Process engineering
63
III Consumer and Agent Psychology
1. Cavanaugh, J.R., R.W. Hatch and J.L. Sullivan. Models for the sub jective effects of loss, noise
and talker echo on telephone connections, Bel l System Technical Journal, 55, 1976, 1319–1371.
Abstract. Tests have been conducted at Bell Laboratories within the last 10 years to obtain
sub jective evaluations of the effects of loss, noise, and talker echo on telephone transmission
quality. We use these sub jective test results to formulate graphical and analytical models of
sub jective opinion that can be used in network planning studies to evaluate transmission perfor-
mance of the network and to study the effects of network changes on performance. These models
are based on the concept of a generalized transmission-rating scale. Separate opinion curves for
each test take into account differences caused by factors such as sub ject group, type of test, and
range of conditions. We also describe the methods of data analysis used in the formulation of
the transmission-rating scale and opinion models, provide a comparison of the test results with
the models, and discuss the models in sufficient detail to permit their application in transmission
planning studies.
2. Cohen, H.S. and B.W. Kort. Psychological evaluation of telephone switching and transmission
performance. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society, 21st Annual Meeting, San Francisco,
1977, 505–507.
Abstract. In order to set standards for the performance of the telephone network, it is necessary
to understand the sub jective effects of the telephone service impairments we wish to control. In
a laboratory environment, we asked sub jects to play a computer-controlled game which required
the frequent use of the telephone as a natural part of the game. Impairments to telephone
switching service, such as dial-tone delay, post-dialing delay, and blocked call attempts, and
impairments to telephone transmission quality, such as loss and noise were introduced into the
telephone service which the sub jects experienced. After each use of the telephone, the sub jects
rendered their opinion, on a five-point rating scale, as to the quality of telephone service just
provided.
The data produced by the experiment were used to construct a mathematical model of customer
opinion as a function of the ob jective measures of telephone network performance. This model
will enable us to analyze the present performance of the telephone system. More importantly,
the model will enable us to estimate customer opinion for future telephone systems, were we
to implement new or revised standards for the control of switching and transmission impairments.
3. Duffy, F.P. and R.A. Mercer. A study of network performance and customer behavior during
direct-distance-dialing call attempts in the U.S.A., Bel l System Technical Journal, 57 (1), 1978,
1–33.
Abstract. A survey was conducted throughout the Bell System in October 1974 to gather de-
tailed information about Direct-Distance-Dialing call attempts. The dispositions, setup times,
and customer abandonment times associated with DDD attempts are discussed in detail in this
article to provide network performance and customer behavior characteristics to network plan-
ners and administrators and to designers of equipment and systems which use, and interact
64
with, the telephone network. It is shown that both network performance and customer behavior
affect the call dispositions and the total call setup time; however, customer-dependent failures
to complete account for 85 percent of all failures, and customer-determined components of the
call setup time make up 71 percent of the total setup time. It is found that traffic composition
in terms of the relative mix of business and residential originations exerts a strong influence
on call dispositions. Network performance affects the probability of equipment blockages and
failures and the interval from end of dialing to receipt of a network response. These are both
found to depend on calling distance, while the latter is also affected by the types of originating
and terminating local switching.
4. Roberts, J.W. Recent observations of subscriber behavior. 9th International Tele-traffic Confer-
ence (ITC-9), Torremolinos, 1979.
Abstract. This paper presents an analysis of experimental observations of subscriber repeated
attempts and subscriber patience in relation to the post-dialing delay. The analysis includes, in
particular, an investigation of the influence of the interval between successive attempts and we
derive estimates of the probability distributions of the subscribers’ patience. The results concern
local, trunk and international calls made by certain subscribers on a Paris exchange.
(Appears also in Section II.)
5. Cohen, H.S. Measuring and modeling user satisfaction with telephone switching and transmission
performance. Proceedings of the 9th International Symposium on Human Factors in Telecom-
munications, Red Bank, NJ, 1980, 237–242.
6. Isobe, S., S. Sato and M. Hoshi. Opinion test on dial tone delay and post-dialing delay by PABX
customers. Proceedings of the 9th Internation Symposium on Human Factors in Telecommuni-
cations, Red Bank, NJ, 1980, 243–250.
7. Liu, K.S. Direct distance dialing: Call completion and customer retrial behavior, Bel l System
Technical Journal, 59 (3), 1980, 295–311.
Abstract. Most customers placing a direct-distance-dialing (DDD) call in the United States
are able to complete the call on the first attempt. However, it is reasonable to expect that
the probability of an initial completion will be less than 1. When an initial attempt fails to
complete, a customer may decide to abandon his desired telephone connection or to make one
or more retrials. In general, a sequence of one or more attempts may be initiated by a customer
in an effort to establish the desired connection. A study of DDD call completion and retrials is
important to provide an overall characterization of network performance and customer behavior
in setting up customers’ desired telephone connections. A survey adopting a two-stage stratified
sampling plan was undertaken to obtain DDD retrial statistics. Data associated with sampled
DDD calls that were originated from one of 890 switching entities in the Bell System network
were collected for a period of one week. The basic DDD retrial results reported here are initial
attempt disposition probabilities, retrial probabilities, number of additional attempts, ultimate
success probabilities, and distribution functions for retrial intervals following different types of
65
incomplete initial attempts. Results of subclass analyses of retrial statistics by originating and
terminating classes of service (residence and business) are also presented. Results obtained
in this study are useful in many network planning applications. An application of significant
importance is provision of a tool to evaluate the revenue and cost impact of call completion
improvement programs. A technique to analyze the revenue and cost impact is outlined in the
paper.
8. Cavanaugh, J.R., R.W. Hatch and J.L. Sullivan. Tranmission rating model for use in planning
telephone networks, IEEE, 1983, 683–688.
Abstract. Customer opinions are an important element in transmission planning for the tele-
phone network. Since the invention of the telephone, considerable effort has been expended in
estimating customer assessment of transmission quality. Sub jective test results have been used
to formulate models. These models, in the form of smooth functions which permit interpola-
tion to allow examination of specific impairment values of interest, have been used to provide
transmission performance estimates for guiding evolution of the telephone network.
This paper first considers a previous model which covered the sub jective effects of loss, circuit
noise and talker echo (reported at NTC76) updated to reflect an IEEE loudness loss method
(rather than the loudness loss method for the original model). This is followed by discussion of
model extensions to cover listener echo, quantization noise, band width/attenuation distortion,
room noise, sidetone and echo control devices. Then the paper outlines several studies in which
the expanded model has been extensively used to study transmission quality of telephone con-
nections as a function of the various impairments. The paper concludes with some illustrative
examples demonstrating use of the model including comments on possible interpretation of re-
sults.
(Appears also in Section V.)
9. Kort, Barry W. Models and methods for evaluating customer acceptance of telephone connec-
tions, IEEE, 1983, 706–714.
Abstract. This paper describes models and methods developed at Bell Laboratories to evalu-
ate customer acceptance of telephone connections in the Bell System Public Switched Telephone
Network. We present three related customer opinion models (Call Setup Rating, Transmission
Rating, and Call Completion Rating), two customer behavior models (Abandonment/Retrial
Behavior and Complaint Rate models), several network Performance Characterization models
(for call setup and transmission performance parameters) and a Monte-Carlo Simulation model
which combines all the above models to estimate the grade of service, abandonment and retrial
behavior, the complaint rate, and the ineffective attempt rate of the Public Network.
These models and the method of analysis are presented as a prototype to support current efforts
of the IEEE Subcommittee on Telecommunications System Performance Characteristics. That
Subcommittee has been chartered to develop industry-wide standards for expressing telephone
network performance characteristics. The goal of the IEEE work is to provide a uniform method
for vendors of voice-grade telecommunications services to describe the performance of their ser-
vice offerings.
66
(Appears also in Section II.)
Maister, David H. The psychology of waiting lines. Report #9-684-064, Harvard Business School,
Boston, MA, 1984. Also appears in The Service Encounter, J. Czepiel, M. Solomon and C.
Suprenant (eds.). Lexington, MA: Lexington Books, 1985, 113–123.
10. Larson, Richard C. Perspectives on queues: Social justice and the psychology of queueing, Op-
erations Research, 35 (6), 1987, 895–905.
Abstract. Queues involve waiting, to be sure, but one’s attitudes toward queues may be in-
fluenced more strongly by other factors. For instance, customers may become infuriated if they
experience social injustice, defined as violation of first in, first out. Queueing environment and
feedback regarding the likely magnitude of the delay can also influence customer attitudes and
ultimately, in many instances, a firm’s market share. Even if we focus on the wait itself, the
“outcome” of the queueing experience may vary nonlinearly with the delay, thus reducing the
importance of average time in queue, the traditional measure of queueing performance. This
speculative paper uses personal experiences, published and unpublished cases, and occasionally,
“the literature” to begin to organize our thoughts on the important attributes of queueing. To
flesh out more of these issues, the author asks for your cards and letters.
11. Larson, Richard C. There’s more to a line than its WAIT, Technology Review, 1988, 59–68.
12. Cotton, B. and K. Lam. Caller acceptability of network interactions for advanced intelligent
network services. ICC 91. International Conference on Communications Conference Record.
IEEE, New York, NY, USA, 1991, 1582–1585.
Abstract. The goal of this study is to characterize the relationship between customer satisfac-
tion and the number and duration of NIs (network interactions). A laboratory experiment was
conducted with sub jects who placed a series of simulated N-ACD type calls. Each call differed
by the number and duration of the interactions. After each call, the sub ject rated the overall call
setup performance on a five-point scale. The ratings were used to develop a preliminary service
completion time (SCT) opinion model. This model shows that opinion varies as an exponential
function of total SCT and the presence or absence of network interactions.
Keywords: Network automatic call distribution, Grade-of-service, Network interactions, Ad-
vanced intelligent network services, Customer satisfaction, N-ACD, Overall call setup perfor-
mance, Service completion time
13. Davis, Mark M. How long should a customer wait for service? Decision Sciences, 22, 1991,
421–433.
Abstract. A ma jor concern for service managers is the determination of how long a customer
should wait to be served. Services, due to the customer’s direct interaction with the process,
must face a trade-off between minimizing the cost of having a customer wait and the cost of
providing good service. A total cost model is presented for determining how long a customer
67
should wait when these two conflicting cost components are considered. An integral part of this
model includes a measure of customer satisfaction with waiting time which is used to develop a
waiting cost function. The model is then applied to a ma jor fast food chain, using data collected
at several locations. Analysis of the data reveals that the “ideal” waiting time for this firm is sig-
nificantly less than the current corporate waiting time policy. Thus, as indicated by the model, a
corporate policy change is recommended to provide much faster service. The adoption of such a
policy would result in increased labor costs, and would simultaneously increase the firm’s overall
profits. Although appearing contradictory, increases in current labor costs and long-term profits
are both possible when management takes the long-range perspective suggested in this paper.
Keywords: Consumer behavior, Service operations management
14. Katz, Karen L., Blaire M. Larson and Richard C. Larson. Prescription for the waiting-in-line
blues: Entertain, enlighten, and engage, Sloan Management Review, 1991, 44–53.
Abstract. As consumers experience a greater squeeze on their time, even short waits seem
longer than ever before. If firms can improve customers’ perceptions of the time they spend
waiting to be served, then customers will experience less frustration and may feel more satisfied
with the service encounter. This paper examines customer perceptions of waiting in line and
investigates methods for making waiting more tolerable.
15. Green, Linda V., Donald R. Lehmann and Bernd H. Schmitt. Time perceptions in service sys-
tems: An overview of the TPM framework, Advances in Services Marketing and Management,
5, 1996, 85–107.
Abstract. We present Time Perception Management (TPM)—a conceptual framework for or-
ganizing research and managerial issues regarding time perceptions in service systems. The
TPM framework proposes that customers’ perceptions of time in service systems are affected
by factors that operate both before and after, as well as during, the actual service encounter.
Moreover, whereas some of these factors are related to the specific service system, others are the
result of the generic service type and personal/sociocultural characteristics. The framework has
important implications for managing and measuring time perceptions and for the relationship
between time perceptions and customer satisfaction.
16. Hui, Michael K. and David K. Tse. What to tell consumers in waits of different lengths: An
integrative model of service evaluation, Journal of Marketing, 60, 1996, 81–90.
Abstract. We conduct an experimental study to examine the impact of two types of waiting
information—waiting-duration information and queueing information—on consumers’ reactions
to waits of different lengths. We test a model that includes three different constructs—perceived
waiting duration, acceptability of the wait, and effective response to the wait—as mediators
between waiting information and service evaluation. Results show that though acceptability of
the wait and affective response to the wait have a significant mediating effect on the relation-
ship between waiting information and service evaluation, perceived waiting duration does not.
Moreover, neither type of information has significant impact in the short-wait condition, whereas
waiting-duration information has greater impact than queueing information in the intermediate-
68
wait condition and a smaller impact in the long-wait condition. We conclude with a discussion
of research and managerial implications.
17. Tom, Gail, Michal Burns and Yvette Zeng. Your life on hold: The effect of telephone waiting
time on customer perception, Journal of Direct Marketing, 11 (3), 1997, 25–31.
Abstract. Customer phone contact with companies is a service encounter that can turn out to
be a liability if customers perceive their time on hold as too long or unenjoyable. This paper
reports on two studies that demonstrated that different waiting conditions (silence, music, or
choice of listening alternatives) affected customer-perceived waiting time and customer percep-
tion/satisfaction with the company.
18. Whitt, Ward. Improving service by informing customers about anticipated delays, Management
Science, 45 (2), 1999, 192–207.
Abstract. The effect upon performance in a service system, such as a telephone call center,of
giving waiting customers state information is investigated. In particular, two M/M/s/r queueing
models with balking and reneging are studied. For simplicity, it is assumed that each customer
is willing to wait a fixed time before beginning service. However, customers differ, so the delay
tolerances for successive customers are random. In model 2, all reneging is replaced by balking.
The number of customers in the system for model 1 is shown to be larger than that for model 2 in
the likelihood-ratio stochastic ordering. Thus, customers are more likely to be blocked in model
1 and are more likely to be served without waiting in model 2. Algorithms are also developed for
computing important performance measures in these, and more general, birth-and-death mod-
els.
Keywords: Telephone service, Anticipated delays, Customer service, Queueing models, Delay
tolerance, Probability, Exponential distribution, Service time, Telephone call centre, Reneging,
Balking, Birth-and-death process
(Appears also in Section I.)
19. Bennington, Lynne, James Cummane and Paul Conn. Customer satisfaction and call centers: an
Australian study, International Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 162–173.
Abstract. Call centers are growing at unprecedented rates, yet relatively little is known about
customer satisfaction with this method of service delivery. Therefore, a review of the advantages
and disadvantages of call centers is provided before reporting on a study carried out with users
of a very large human services call center network. The results indicate that customers have
slightly higher satisfaction levels with in-person services than with call center services. Although
it was predicted that older customers might be more dissatisfied with call centers than younger
customers, this was not borne out by the data. Attributes of a best-in-the-world call center
operation are provided to guide those who design and manage call center services.
Keywords: Call Centres, Customer satisfaction, Australia
(Appears also in Section VII.)
69
20. Feinberg, Richard A., Ik-Suk Kim, Leigh Hokama, Ko de Ruyter and Cherie Keen. Operational
determinants of caller satisfaction in the call center, International Journal of Service Industry
Management, 11 (2), 2000, 131–141.
Abstract. There has been, and will be, a spectacular growth in the number of call centers on
both sides of the Atlantic. So far, however, empirical evidence is lacking as to the operational de-
terminants of caller satisfaction in call centers, despite the multitude of call performance metrics
registered in many call centers. Undertakes an empirical assessment of the relationship between
caller satisfaction and a number of critical variables. The results are astonishing. Of all the
critical operational determinants only “percentage of calls closed on first contact” and “average
abandonment” have a significant, albeit weak, influence on caller satisfaction. Concludes, there-
fore, with a call for more research into reliable and valid predictors of caller satisfaction.
Keywords: Performance measures, Customer service, Customer satisfaction, Call centres
(Appears also in Section VII.)
21. Mandelbaum, A. and N. Shimkin. A model for rational abandonments from invisible queues,
QUESTA, 36 (1–3), 2000, 141–173.
Abstract. We propose a model for abandonments from a queue, due to excessive wait, assum-
ing that waiting customers act rationally but without being able to observe the queue length.
Customers are allowed to be heterogeneous in their preferences and consequent behavior. Our
goal is to characterize customers’ patience via more basic primitives, specifically waiting costs
and service benefits: these two are optimally balanced by waiting customers, based on their
individual cost parameters and anticipated waiting time. The waiting time distribution and
patience profile then emerge as an equilibrium point of the system. The problem formulation is
motivated by teleservices, prevalently telephone- and Internet-based. In such services, customers
and servers are remote and queues are typically associated with the servers, hence queues are
invisible to waiting customers. Our base model is the M/M/m queue, where it is shown that
a unique equilibrium exists, in which rational abandonments can occur only upon arrival (zero
or infinite patience for each customer). As such a behavior fails to capture the essence of aban-
donments, the base model is modified to account for unusual congestion or failure conditions.
This indeed facilitates abandonments in finite time, leading to a nontrivial, customer dependent
patience profile. Our analysis shows, quite surprisingly, that the equilibrium is unique in this
case as well, and amenable to explicit calculation.
Keywords: Multiserver exponential queues, Abandonments, Nash equilibrium, Call centers
(Appears also in Sections I.)
22. Gibson, F.P. Is it better to forget? Stimulus-response, prediction, and the weight of past expe-
rience in a fast-paced bargaining task, Computational & Mathematical Organization Theory, 8
(1), 2002, 31–47.
Abstract. Decision makers in dynamic environments, such as air traffic control, firefighting, and
call center operations, adapt in real-time using outcome feedback. Understanding this adapta-
tion is important for influencing and improving the decisions made. Recently, stimulus-response
(S-R) learning models have been proposed as explanations for decision makers’ adaptation. S-R
70
models hypothesize that decision makers choose an action option based on their anticipation of
its success. Decision makers learn by accumulating evidence over action options and combining
that evidence with prior expectations. This study examines a standard S-R model and a simple
variation of this model, in which past experience may receive an extremely low weight, as expla-
nations for decision makers’ adaptation in an evolving Internet-based bargaining environment.
In Experiment 1, decision makers are taught to predict behavior in a bargaining task that fol-
lows rules that may be the opposite of congruent to, or unrelated to a second task in which they
must choose the deal terms they will offer. Both models provide a good account of the predic-
tion task. However, only the second model, in which decision makers heavily discount all but
the most recent past experience, provides a good account of subsequent behavior in the second
task. To test whether Experiment 1 artificially related choice behavior and prediction, a second
experiment examines both models’ predictions concerning the effects of bargaining experience
on subsequent prediction. In this study, decision models where long-term experience plays a
dominating role do not appear to provide adequate explanations of decision makers’ adaptation
to their opponent’s changing response behavior.
23. Holman, David, Clair Chissick and Peter Totterdell. The effects of performance monitoring on
emotional labor and well-being in call centers, Motivation and Emotion, 26 (1), 2002, 57–81.
Abstract. Investigated the relationship between performance monitoring and well-being. The
study also examined a mechanism (emotional labor) that might mediate the relationship between
them, assessed the effect of the work context on the relationship between performance monitoring
and well-being, and examined the relative effects of performance monitoring and work context
on well-being. Three aspects of performance monitoring were covered, namely, its performance-
related context, its beneficial-purpose, and its perceived intensity. Sub jects were 347 customer
service agents (70.6% female and 29.4% male, aged 19–57 yrs). Regression analyses revealed
that the performance-related content and the beneficial-purpose of monitoring were positively
related to well-being, while perceived intensity had a strong negative association with well-being.
Emotional labor did not mediate the relationship between monitoring and well-being. Work
context did not mediate the relationship between monitoring and well-being, but job control and
supervisory support did moderate the relationship between perceived intensity and well-being.
Perceived intensity showed stronger associations with emotional exhaustion, while job control
and supervisory support showed stronger associations with depression and job satisfaction
.
24. Torre, I. Users modeling for adaptive call centers, Proceedings of the Second International Confer-
ence, AH, Adaptive Hypermedia and Adaptive Web-Based Systems, Lecture Notes in Computer
Science, Vol. 2347, Springer-Verlag, Germany, 2002, 603–607.
Abstract. The pro ject described in this paper applies the principles of adaptivity to a “tradi-
tional” call center in order to support the operator in the interaction with the customer. The
system uses the models of both the customer and the operator and builds up the stepwise answer
through an adaptive workflow.
25. Whalen, Jack, Marilyn Whale and Kathryn Henderson. Improvisational choreography in tele-
service work, The British Journal of Sociology, 53 (2), 2002, 239–258.
71
Abstract. This naturalistic study of the ordinary work practice of sale representatives employed
by the call centre of a large office-equipment company focuses on the actions of those sales reps
during their calls with customers. We show how this work performance is organized through
an improvisational choreography of action involving not only the turn-by-turn interchange with
customers on the telephone, but also the concurrent utilization of a variety of tools and artefacts.
While ‘improvise’ and ‘choreograph’ may appear to be conceptually incongruent, our analysis
demonstrates that even though these teleservice workers recurrently fabricate their actions out of
materials and means that are conveniently on hand, the convenience is often carefully arranged
to afford such extemporaneous composition. Finally, we conclude from this analysis that the
traditional topics of ‘work routines’ and ‘routinization’ need to be respecified in order to take
into account how any ‘routine’ is a contingently produced result (and in this centre, a craft-like
performance).
Keywords: Studies, Ethnology, Call centers, Customer services, Social sciences
26. Zohar, E., A. Mandelbaum and N. Shimkin. Adaptive behavior of impatient customers in tele-
queues: Theory and empirical support, Management Science, 48 (4), 2002, 566–583.
Abstract. We address the modeling and analysis of abandonment from a queue which is in-
visible to its occupants. Such queues arise in remote service systems, notably the Internet and
telephone call centers, hence, we refer to them as tele-queues. A basic premise of this paper is
that customers adapt their patience (modeled by an abandonment-time distribution) to their
service expectations, in particular to their anticipated waiting time. We first present empirical
support for that hypothesis, and propose an M/M/m-based model which incorporates adaptive
customer behavior. In our model, customer patience (and possibly the arrival rate) depend on
the mean waiting time in the queue. We then characterize the system equilibrium and establish
its existence and uniqueness when the growth rate of customer patience is bounded by that of
the mean waiting time. The feasibility of multiple system equilibria is illustrated when this
condition is violated. We also discuss a decision-theoretic model for customer abandonment,
and relate it to our basic model. Finally, a dynamic learning model is proposed where customer
expectations regarding their waiting time are formed through accumulated experience. We ad-
dress certain issues related to censored-sampling that arise in this framework and demonstrate,
via simulation, convergence to the theoretically anticipated equilibrium.
Keywords: Exponential (Markovian) queues, Abandonments, Equilibrium analysis, Invisible
queues, Performance-dependent behavior, Tele-services, Tele-queues, Call centers
(Appears also in Section I.)
27. Hyman, J., C. Baldry, D. Scholarios and D. Bunzel. Work-life imbalance in call centres and
software development, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 41 (2), 2003, 215.
Abstract. The paper evaluates the centrality of work to employees in two growing employment
sectors, call centres and software development. It then examines evidence for extensions of work
into household and family life in these two sectors. Extensions are identified as tangible, such
as unpaid overtime, or intangible, represented by incursions imported from work, such as ex-
haustion and stress. The study finds that organizational pressure, combined with lack of work
centrality, result in work intruding into non-work areas of employee lives, though intrusions
72
manifest themselves in different ways according to type of work, levels of worker autonomy and
organizational support.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Software industry, Work life programs, Working conditions,
Statistical analysis
(Appears also in Section VII.)
28. Korczynski, Marek. Communities of coping: Collective emotional labour in service work, Orga-
nization, 10 (1), 2003, 55-79.
Abstract. This article argues that communities of coping among front-line service workers are
an important part of what Hochschild has called “collective emotional labor” in service work.
The analysis is framed in a sociological understanding of the customer as the key source of both
pleasure and pain for service workers. Irate and abusive customers, who are systematically part
of the social relations of the service workplace, may occasion real pain in service workers. The
structure of workers’ social situation means that they are likely to turn to each other to cope
with this pain, forming informal communities of coping. Drawing an extensive research in four
call centers in Australia and the US, this article highlights this important process in action. The
communities of coping were an important social process in these workplaces, creating informal,
dense cultures among the workforce. These cultures had important implications for how far the
social relations of the workplace were open to management control.
Keywords: Corporate culture, Organizational behavior, Studies, Call centers, Service industries,
Cutomer relations, Emotions
(Appears also in Section IV.)
29. Lewig, K.A. and M.F. Dollard. Emotional dissonance, emotional exhaustion and job satisfaction
in call centre workers, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003,
366–392.
Abstract. The rapid rise of the service sector, and in particular, the call centre industry, has
made the study of emotional labour increasingly important within the area of occupational stress
research. Given high levels of turnover and absenteeism in the industry, this article examines
the emotional demands (emotional labour) of call centre work and their relationship to job satis-
faction and emotional exhaustion in a sample of South Australian call centre workers (NV=v98)
within the theoretical frameworks of the job demand v-v control model, the effort v-v reward im-
balance model, and the job demands v-v resources model. Qualitatively, the research confirmed
the central role of emotional labour variables in the experience of emotional exhaustion and
satisfaction at work. Specifically, the research confirmed the pre-eminence of emotional disso-
nance compared to a range of emotional demand variables in its potency to account for variance
in emotional exhaustion and job satisfaction. Specifically, emotional dissonance mediated the
effect of emotional labour (positive emotions) on emotional exhaustion. Furthermore, emotional
dissonance was found to be equal in its capacity to explain variance in the outcomes compared
to the most frequently researched demand measure in the work stress literature (psychosocial
demands). Finally, emotional dissonance was found to exacerbate the level of emotional ex-
haustion at high levels of psychosocial demands, indicating jobs combining high levels of both
kinds of demands are much more risky. Future theorizing about work stress needs to account for
73
emotional demands, dissonance in particular. Potential ways to alleviate emotional exhaustion
due to emotional dissonance is to reduce other psychosocial demands, increase rewards, support
and control as conceptualized in the JDR model. Ways to boost job satisfaction are to increase
control, support, and rewards.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
30. Sheeder, Tony and Jennifer Balogh. Say it like you mean it: Priming for structure in caller
responses to a spoken dialog system, International Journal of Speech Technology, 6 (2), 2003,
103–111.
Abstract. In this paper, we report results of a study undertaken to evaluate the initial prompts
of ‘open prompt’ style call-routing applications. Specifically, we examined how placement and
phrasing of examples in the initial query affected caller responses and routing success. We looked
at the comparative effectiveness of placing examples before and after the initial query and of
phrasing these examples such that they promoted either a succinct structure in the form of a
keyword or phrase, or a more complex but natural structure in the form of a question or state-
ment. Findings indicate that examples encouraging a more natural structure, when presented
prior to the initial query, result in significantly improved routing performance. We discuss this
result in the context of using initial prompts to prime for desired structure in caller responses.
Keywords: Call routing, Call Steering, Natural language, Prompting, Dialog strategy
(Appears also in Section VI.)
31. Zapf, Dieter, Amela Isic, Myriam Bechtoldt and Patricia Blau. What is typical for call centre
jobs? Job characteristics, and service interactions in different call centres, European Journal of
Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003, 311–340.
Abstract. Call centres have been one of the few booming branches in recent years. The main
task of call centre operators is to interact with customers by telephone, usually supported by
computer systems. It has been argued that call centre work is a modern form of “Taylorism”,
because it is characterized by routine tasks, and low level of control for the employees. Moreover,
it has been suggested that there is a high level of stress at work, both with regard to the work
tasks and to the interactions with customers. In the present study, a sample of 375 call centre
employees from eight different call centres was compared with a sample of noncall centre workers
(Nv=v405) in terms of job characteristics, job stressors, and emotional labour (emotion work).
The results showed that call centre workers had worse job characteristics, but were better off
with regard to most job stressors compared to representative comparison groups of no-service
workers, service workers, and workers in human services, respectively. Moreover, compared to
the other groups, customer service representatives (CSRs) had to express less negative emotions,
but were most frequently exposed to states of emotional dissonance. A comparison of the work-
ing conditions of the eight call centres revealed that in most call centres, the working conditions
could be substantially improved. In addition, various call centre parameters, such as inbound
vs. outbound, or inhouse vs. external service centres were examined. The strongest effects were
found for the percentage of time spent on the telephone. With some exceptions, the results
support the view that the ma jority of call centres have been established to organize mass service
for customers, that the work in the call centres is characterized by routine work and low task
74
control, and that call centre employees are required to suggest a “friendly smile” when they are
on the phone.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
32. Higgs, Malcolm. A study of the relationship between emotional intelligence and performance in
UK call centres, Journal of Managerial Psychology, 19 (4), 442–454, 2004.
Abstract. Within business, the organisational concept of call centres has developed rapidly.
Within the UK, the use and development of these centres has grown at a significant rate over
the last decade. The economic benefits of this organisational concept have been threatened by
the nature of the work and operating environment leading to high levels of attrition with asso-
ciated recruitment, training and loss of productivity costs. As a result, much effort has been
focused on recruitment criteria and selection processes. In reviewing the criteria, it is clear that
many overlap with elements from within the concept of emotional intelligence (EI). This research
note reports a study designed to explore the relationship between the EI of call centre agents
(using the EIQ measure developed by Dulewicz and Higgs, and ratings of their performance.
A sample of 289 agents from three organisations was studied. Results included a strong rela-
tionship between overall EI and individual performance, as well as between several EI elements
from the model and performance. Furthermore, a relationship between age and performance
was established along with a number of gender differences. The practical implications of these
findings are discussed along with the study limitations. Further areas for research are identified
including differences between agents in reaction and proactive roles and relationships to more
direct measures of agent attrition.
Keywords: Occupational psychology, Call centers, Studies, Skills, Personality traits, Performance
evaluation, Correlation analysis
33. Witt, L.A., Martha C. Andrews, Dawn S. Carlson. When conscientiousness isn’t enough: Emo-
tional exhaustion and performance among call center customer service representatives, Journal
of Management, 30 (1), 2004, 149–160.
Abstract. The authors examined the relationship of the interaction between emotional exhaus-
tion and conscientiousness with ob jectively-measured call volume performance and sub jectively-
measured service quality ratings among 92 call center customer service representatives (CSR)
of a financial services institution. Results supported the interactive effects on call volume but
not service quality. Specifically, the relationship between emotional exhaustion and call volume
was stronger among high- than low-conscientiousness CSR’s. Among CSR’s reporting low lev-
els of emotional exhaustion, those high in conscientiousness achieved higher call volumes than
those low in conscientiousness. In contrast, among CSR’s reporting high levels of emotional
exhaustion, those high in conscientiousness achieved lower call volumes than those low in consci-
entiousness. Implications for both the personality and stress literature are discussed. Practical
implications for human resource managers are also offered.
Keywords: Studies, Emotions, Fatigue, Call centers, Customer services, Volume, Quality of ser-
vice, Management theory
75
IV Human Resource Management
1. Karlin, J.E. The changing and expanding role of human factors in telecommunications engineer-
ing at Bell Laboratories. Proceedings of the Eighth International Symposium on Human Factors
in Telecommunications. Standard Telecommunication Labs, Harlow, UK, 1977, 329–333.
Abstract. In recent years it has become clear that the continued growth and profitability of
common carrier telecommunications will depend much more on people considerations than was
the case in the past. In part this derives from the need to automate work force job design to
offset sharply rising labor costs; in part from the need to increase revenues by expanding the
range of customer services. The former raises questions regarding the impact on the customer
of dealing more with machines and less with telephone operators and other employees as well
as impact on employee satisfaction with the change in the job. The latter raises questions re-
garding new and future customer communication needs as well as efficient and economical ways
of satisfying them. At Bell Laboratories, the total human factors effort is being reorganized to
enhance its effectiveness.
Keywords: Human factors, Telecommunications engineering, Common carrier telecommunica-
tions
2. Klenke, M. ACDs get skills-based routing, Business Communications Review, 25 (7), 1995, 48–
51.
Abstract. The goal of automated call distributor (ACD) technology has always been to spread
incoming calls among call center agents so that each agent handled an equitable share of the
load and the caller had the best chance of being served quickly. Now, a new kind of thinking
skills-based routing has entered the call center arena. It takes ACDs one step further and en-
sures that an incoming call is routed to the available agent whose skills are best matched to the
caller’s needs. Skills-based routing software works by linking call center agents with predefined
skills groups. The author discusses the identification of customer needs, defining agent skills,
and setting up a routing scheme which allows callers and agents to come together efficiently.
Keywords: ACD, Skills-based routing, Automated call distributor technology, Incoming calls,
Call center agents, Routing software, Skills groups, Customer needs, Agent skills
(Appears also in Section V.)
3. Hoekstra, Edward J., Joseph Hurrell, Naomi G. Swanson and Allison Tepper. Ergonomic job
task, and psychosocial risk factors for work-related musculoskeletal disorders among teleservice
center representatives, International Journal of Human Computer Interaction, 8 (4), 1996, 421–
431.
Abstract. Evaluated the association between work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WRMDs)
and work conditions, perceived exhaustion, job dissatisfaction, and job-stress issues at two tele-
service centers (TSCs). One facility had upgraded workstation furniture while the other did not
have such ergonomic upgrades. A questionnaire survey among 114 teleservice representatives
and an ergonomic evaluation were conducted to determine WRMDs and their risk factors. A
76
high prevalence of symptoms was found at both TSCs. Suboptimal ergonomic conditions were
associated with neck, shoulder, elbow, and back WRMDs, as well as with increased job dissatis-
faction. Perceived increased workload variability and lack of job control were associated with the
occurrence of neck and back WRMDs, respectively. WRMDs were more frequently reported by
Ss at the center with older furniture and suboptimal ergonomic conditions. Authors suggest that
WRMDs may be prevented by improving ergonomic conditions at workstations and addressing
work-organization elements.
(Appears also in Section VI.)
4. Hook, K. and L. Matta. Organisational variables in call centres: Mediator relationships. In
Contemporary Ergonomics 1997, S.A. Robertson (ed.),. Taylor & Francis, London, 1997, 295–
300.
Abstract. This study explored the role of perceived satisfaction of the environment as a medi-
ator variable in the relationship between seven ob jective organisational variables and individual
affective outcomes (stress and job satisfaction). Eleven organisations were involved in the study
(n = 566) focusing specifically on telephone call centres. Using analysis of covariance, mediated,
partially mediated and direct effects were observed. Practical implications are discussed. Theo-
retically, the results highlight the validity of developing a more complex conceptual link between
the environment and its impact upon individuals.
5. Frenkel, Stephen, May Tam, Marek Korczynski, Karen Shire. Beyond bureaucracy? Work or-
ganization in call centres, The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 9 (6),
1998, 957–979.
Abstract. Call centres are a rapidly growing, IT-based channel for service and sales delivery,
particularly in the financial services and telecom industries. Although little research has been
undertaken on the human resource aspects of call centres, two contrasting images are emerging.
The first emphasizes the bureaucratic, constraining nature of these work settings, while the sec-
ond image points towards worker empowerment characteristic of knowledge-intensive settings.
Which of these two images more faithfully portrays the nature of work organization in call cen-
tres is the sub ject of our paper. Drawing on qualitative research undertaken in six call centres
and a survey of front-line workers, we show that elements of both models coexist and that a
hybrid model predominates. The theoretical basis for this contention, and its institutionalization
as mass customized bureaucracy, lies in management’s on-going attempts to reconcile two con-
flicting principles: standardization of processes and customization of products. The paper also
explores, as key consequences of mass customized bureaucracy, front-line workers’ satisfaction
with various facets of their job and their overall job satisfaction, in addition to discretionary
work effort. Only in relation to job security and co-worker relations could front-line workers be
considered satisfied. Overall, these employees were ambivalent in their responses. They were
however more likely to give more discretionary work effort than indicated by their extent of
satisfaction. We conclude that, although the existing pattern of work organization may be supe-
rior to more bureaucratic forms, it is by no means ideal from the standpoint of either front-line
workers or management.
Keywords: Organization, Customer, Service, Representatives, Bureaucracy, Information, Tech-
77
nology, Satisfaction, Discretionary, Effort
6. Henderson, S.G., A.J. Mason, R. Thomson, T. Seabrook and D. Burgess. Heuristics in rostering
for call centres. 33rd ORSNZ Conference, 1998, Aukland, New Zealand.
Abstract. An important new feature on the business scene is the development of call centres,
whereby a pool of staff is used to answer incoming calls from customers. This pro ject develops a
model that enables staffing levels to be determined to meet specified quality targets on customer
wait times.
7. Sarel, D. and H. Marmorstein. Managing the delayed service encounter: the role of employee
action and customer prior experience, Journal of Services Marketing, 12 (3), 1998, 195–208.
Abstract. Despite the increased attention being paid to service delivery, lengthy waits for ser-
vice are still common. This paper provides a conceptual and empirical examination of the effects
of perceived employee action and customer prior experience, on reactions to service delays. The
results of a field study of customers experiencing actual delays in a ma jor retail bank are then
discussed. The findings indicate that events and actions taking place prior to, during, and after
the delay, affect consumer response. First, customers’ prior experience with that service provider
is critical. Contrary to much of the literature on expectations, customers who had frequently
experienced delays in the past were even more angered by the current service failure. Second,
perceived employee effort during the delay had a tremendous impact on customers’ reactions.
Irrespective of the length of the delay, when employees are perceived as not making a real effort,
customer anger is high. Third, the impact of an apology is more complex. An apology is not a
substitute for genuine employee effort. An insincere apology may even backfire, especially when
customers experience frequent delays and believe employees are not making a concerted effort
to help. Managerial implications for addressing this problem, before, during and after the delay,
are discussed.
Keywords: Banking, Customer satisfaction, Employee attitudes, Services marketing, Service
Quality
8. Van Emster, Gregory, R. and Albert A. Harrison. Role ambiguity, spheres of control, burnout,
and work-related attitudes of teleservice professionals, Journal of Social Behavior and Person-
ality, 13 (2), 1998, 375–385.
Abstract. Forty-six customer service representatives from financial services and high-tech firms
completed a modified version of J. Singh and G.K. Rhoads’ (1991) MULTIRAM measure of role
ambiguity; D.L. Paulhus’ (1983) Spheres of Control (SOC) scale; components of J. Singh, J.R.
Goolsby and G.K. Rhoads’ (1994) adaptation of the Maslach Burnout Inventory; and an ex-
ploratory Attitudes Toward Telephone Work Survey. High overall role ambiguity was associated
with low overall SOC scores, and all of the role ambiguity measures correlated negatively with
interpersonal control scores. Role ambiguity correlated positively with depersonalization and
emotional exhaustion, but not with reduced personal accomplishment. High role ambiguity was
associated with relatively unfavorable assessments of one’s personal performance on the tele-
phone, and both depersonalization and emotional exhaustion were accompanied by unfavorable
78
attitudes toward telephone work.
9. Batt, Rosemary. Work organization, technology, and performance in customer service and sales,
Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 52 (4), 1999, 539–564.
Abstract. The strengths and weaknesses of Total Quality Management and Self-Managed
Teams, as compared to mass production approaches to service delivery, among customer service
and sales workers in a large unionized regional Bell operating company, are analyzed. Par-
ticipation in self-managed teams was associated with a statistically significant improvement in
self-reported service quality and a 9.3% increase in sales per employee. When combined with
new technology, teams boosted sales an additional 17.4%. These effects persisted over time.
Total Quality Management, by contrast, did not affect performance. This study represents a
strong test of the efficacy of teams because theory predicts weak outcomes for self-managed
teams among service and sales employees in establishments where technology and organizational
structure limit opportunities for self-regulation, the nature of work and technology do not re-
quire interdependence, and downsizing creates pervasive job insecurity—conditions found at the
company studied.
10. Chen, E.T. Reengineering a call center using a performance measurement system. Proceedings
of the Fifth Americas Conference on Information Systems (AMCIS 1999). Assoc. Inf. Syst,
Atlanta, GA, USA; 1999, 668–670.
Abstract. Enhancing customer loyalty and eventually increasing profitability can be facilitated
by the services of a call center, which takes charge of customer service calls and acts as a repos-
itory of marketing information. The most expensive and important resource a call center has is
its people. Support of the call center staff is critical to maintaining quality of service. This paper
describes the determination of installing a performance measurement system for a call center in
a beauty-supply corporation. This PMS is essential to improve organizational productivity as
one of several information system priorities. Many practical implications have been derived in
this case study.
Keywords: Call centre reengineering, Performance measurement system, Customer loyalty, Prof-
itability, Marketing information, Staff, Quality of service, Beauty supply corporation, Organiza-
tional productivity, Information system, Case study, Wholesale distribution
(Appears also in Section VII.)
11. Coffman, S. and M.L. Saxton. Staffing the reference desk in the largely-digital library, Reference
Librarian, 66, 1999, 141–161.
Abstract. The article examines how a centralized, networked reference service might improve
efficiency and reduce costs by addressing two long-standing and seemingly intractable problems
associated with the reference process: that librarians spend only a small portion of their time at
the reference desk actually answering questions, and that many of the questions they do answer
could be handled by paraprofessionals. The authors explore the feasibility of a live, centralized,
networked reference service in a library setting by comparing traditional reference services at the
County of Los Angeles Public Library with a commercial inbound call center designed to handle
79
the same volume of questions. Applying Erlang C, the standard algorithm used to calculate
staffing requirements for commercial call centers, the authors find that a networked reference
service based on a call center model could reduce the reference staff requirements at the County
of Los Angeles Public Library by 42% or more. These results are very preliminary, and the
article cautions against jumping to conclusions until we have much better data on the questions
we are answering and the reference process as a whole, but the evidence we do have suggests
that networked reference services have the potential to truly revolutionize the way we have been
doing reference for the past 100 years.
Keywords: Reference desk staff, Largely digital library, Networked reference service, Intractable
problems, Reference process, Librarians, Paraprofessionals, Library setting, Traditional refer-
ence services, County of Los Angeles Public Library, Commercial inbound call center, Erlang-C,
Standard algorithm, Staffing requirements, Call center model, Reference staff requirements
(Appears also in Sections I and VI.)
12. Fenety, A., C. Putnam and C. Loppie. Self-reported health determinants in female call centre
tele-operators: A qualitative analysis. In Advances in Occupational Ergonomics and Safety,
G.C.H. Lee (ed.), IOS Press, Amsterdam, 1999, 219–224.
Abstract. In Atlantic Canada, telephone call centres are a new, and rapidly expanding in-
dustry that employs predominantly women. Little is known about the psychosocial and work
organization stressors present in the call centre industry, nor the impact of these stressors on the
health of female call centre tele-operators (CCTs). Using a qualitative research technique (in-
depth interviews), the authors asked a diverse group of CCTs (n = 25) to identify job stressors,
job supports, home-work interactions and health concerns that they experienced in call centre
work. They present interview results for three stressors (shiftwork, perceived control, and work
support) and the impact of call centre work on their personal life and well-being.
13. Hampe, J.F. Call centre: technical and organisational challenges. Human-Computer Interaction:
Ergonomics and User Interfaces. Proceedings of HCI International ’99 (8th International Con-
ference on Human-Computer Interaction). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, USA,
1999, 1316–1320.
Abstract. Following a period of significant growth in the conventional call centre market in
Europe, a new phase in technological development is emerging, bringing with it complex chal-
lenges for call centre architects. The call centres are being upgraded to communication centres
by integrating additional media channels. First we must mention the standard Internet messag-
ing communication streams, these are mainly standard based email but increasingly all types of
web forms or inbound fax files. At the same time the first web enabled call centres are being
set up and operating, allowing for voice over IP connections and conferencing. This leads us to
the notion of customer coaching, sometimes also referred to, by other authors, as ‘one to one
marketing’, although the latter might be regarded as a much more general approach. Effectively
this technical set up offers simultaneous phone conversation and joint web browsing between cus-
tomer and agent. Beside this technical evolution it seems most relevant to study the necessary
redesign of the communication centre agent software, especially customer management software
etc. Therefore, the primary goal is integration into carefully redesigned workflows and user in-
80
terfaces, resulting in a transparent, time synchronised customer interaction database, allowing
us to improve future customer service. Simultaneously we are observing various difficulties for
an adequate personnel recruiting process for communication centre agents as the traditional
qualification patterns of call centre agents are no longer sufficient. The much broader palette of
tasks to be handled by the new type of agents must also result in a reconsideration of personnel
planning schemes and underlying assumptions on the work process.
Keywords: Call centre, Organisational challenges, Technical challenges, Technological develop-
ment, Communication centres, Internet messaging communication streams, Inbound fax files,
Conferencing, Web-browsing, Workflows, User interfaces
(Appears also in Section VI.)
14. Ristimaki, T., T. Leino and P. Huuhtanen. Implementation of information technology in call
centers. In Human-Computer Interaction: Ergonomics and User Interfaces, H.J. Bullinger and
J. Ziegler (eds.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 6–10.
Abstract. In this paper the implementation of information technology is analyzed in two call
centres of a bank, which provide a variety of banking services by telephone to customers. It is
important to emphasize that call centre work is extremely intensive, using the latest information
and telecommunication technologies. In addition, the number of call centres is continuously
rising. This study aims to analyze some of the organizational and social factors during the im-
plementation process of a new information system (IS) in call centre work.
(Appears also in Section V.)
15. Bagnara, S., F. Gabrielli and P. Marti. Human work in call centres. Ergonomics for the New
Millennium. Proceedings of the XIVth Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics As-
sociation and 44th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, San Diego,
California, USA, Vol. 1, 2000, 553–556.
Abstract. Many people are currently working in call centres and many more are expected to
work in them in the near future. Call centres are in a sense ‘modern factories’ where services
are delivered through information and communication technologies. This paper describes the
technological evolution and discusses some aspects of human and work organisation in call cen-
tres. The final part of the paper focuses on a crucial issue commonly faced in call centres: the
building up of organisational memories.
(Appears also in Section VI.)
16. Bain, Peter and Phil Taylor. Entrapped by the ‘electronic panopticon’ ? Worker resistance in
the call centre, New Technology, Work, and Employment, 15 (1), 2000, 2–18.
Abstract. This paper presents a thoroughgoing critique of Fernie and Metcalf ’s (1998) perspec-
tive, that the call cetner is characterized by the operation of an “electronic panopticon” in which
supervisory power has been rendered perfect. Drawing on evidence from a telecommunications
call center, this paper analyzes the significance of emerging forms of employee resistance.
Keywords: Electronic panopticon, Electronic surveillance, Telecommunications call centre, Em-
ployee resistance
81
17. Batt, Rosemary. Strategic segmentation in front-line services: Matching customers, employees
and human resource systems, Int. J. of Human Resource Management, 11 (3), 2000, 540–561.
Abstract. This paper examines variation in the use of high involvement work practices in
service and sales operations. It is argued that the relationship between the customer and the
front-line service provider is a central feature that distinguishes production-level service activities
from manufacturing. In particular, through strategic segmentation, firms are able to segment
customers by their demand characteristics and to match the complexity and potential revenue
stream of the customer to the skills of employees and the human resource system that shapes
the customer-employee interface. Unlike manufacturing, where high involvement systems have
emerged in a wide variety of product markets, therefore, service organizations are likely to use
high involvement systems only to serve higher value-added customers because of the high costs
of these systems and the labour intensive nature of services. Data from a nationally random
sample of 354 call centres in US telecommunications documents this pattern: from classic mass
production approaches for back office workers and increasingly for front office residential service
agents, to greater involvement for small business service providers and high involvement prac-
tices for middle-market service agents.
Keywords: High performance work systems, Strategic human resource management, Service
management, Telecommunications, Call centres
18. Belt, V., R. Richardson and J. Webster. Women’s work in the information economy: The case
of telephone call centres, Information, Communication & Society, 3 (3), 2000, 366–385.
Abstract. This paper is concerned with the work experiences and career opportunities of
women employed in technology-intensive offices known as telephone ‘call centres’. Call centres
have grown rapidly across Europe in recent years, creating a significant number of new jobs and
receiving considerable attention within the media, business and academic communities. How-
ever, despite the fact that the ma jority of call centre jobs have been taken by women, researchers
have so far paid little attention to their position in this new ‘industry’. The article addresses
this research gap. In particular, it is concerned with the question of whether call centre work
is offering women new opportunities for skill development and career progression, or whether a
more familiar trend is taking place in which women are being drawn into a highly routinized,
‘de-skilled’ and de-valued area of work. The paper also uses the specific example of call centre
work in order to reflect on broader issues about the changing nature of women’s work and em-
ployment in the so-called ‘information economy’.
19. Boddy, D. Implementing interorganizational IT systems: lessons from a call centre pro ject, Jour-
nal of Information Technology, 15 (1), 2000, 29–37.
Abstract. The growing power of computer-telephony integration (CTI) systems is encouraging
many companies to create call centres. These deal with a growing range of business processes
and, in doing so, can be used to challenge established organizational arrangements. The range
of human and management issues that need to be dealt with has yet to become clear. Some
insights into these are offered from a study of one call centre over 2 years, from shortly before its
82
physical introduction to the present day. These empirical observations are set within the wider
literature on organizational change and information technology (IT), particularly the process-
ing and integrationist perspectives. The paper uses the evidence of the case to elaborate the
integrationist model so that it reflects the areas of human action more fully. It concludes by
outlining the implications of this perspective for managers seeking to build effective call centres
or other forms of interorganizational IT system.
Keywords: Interorganizational IT systems, Call centre pro ject, Computer telephony integration,
CTI systems, Business processes, Organizational arrangements, Management issues, Human is-
sues, Organizational change, Information technology, Integrationist perspective, Human action
(Appears also in Section V.)
20. Dugdale, J., B. Pavard and J.L. Soubie. A pragmatic development of a computer simulation of an
emergency call centre. Designing Cooperative Systems. Use of Theories and Models. Proceed-
ings of the 5th International Conference on the Design of Cooperative Systems (COOP’2000).
IOS Press, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2000, 241–256.
Abstract. In cases where it is infeasible to experiment in a real life setting, computer simulation
is a valuable tool in the design and understanding of cooperative systems. This paper describes
the development of a computer based simulation of an emergency call centre. The centre, which
is a perfect example of a complex cooperative system, is currently undergoing a physical reor-
ganisation. The aim of the simulator is to help in the redesign process by allowing the user to
test the effects of new physical organisations. Whilst grounded in a solid theoretical framework,
the simulator was developed using a bottom-up approach. We are particularly interested in
modelling and analysing how environmental factors, such as the level of noise, affect mutual
awareness, overhearing, interruption, cooperation and communication. A methodology is em-
ployed which is strongly participative and which, we believe, is well suited for the development
of a computer based simulation of complex real world settings. We explain our methodology and
show how the environmental and cognitive factors have been analysed, translated into a design
and subsequently implemented using an ob ject-oriented approach. Finally, we demonstrate the
computer based simulator by running an experiment using data obtained from our observations
of the real world setting.
Keywords: Computer simulation, Emergency call centre, Cooperative systems, Bottom-up ap-
proach, Environmental factors, Noise, Cognitive factors, Ob ject-oriented approach, Experiment,
Ergonomics, Multi-agent systems
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
21. Houlihan, Maeve. Eyes wide shut? Querying the depth of call centre learning, Journal of Euro-
pean Industrial Training, 24, 2000, 228–240.
Abstract. Call centres are high-pressure work environments characterised by routinization,
scripting, computer-based monitoring and intensive performance targets. This promises a series
of business advantages, but also risks counterproductive outcomes. Drawing on evidence from
ethnographic field data, it is suggested that both desired and risked outcomes are mediated
by personal modes of coping and organizational sustaining mechanisms. A central concern is
to explore the underlying assumptions of call centre design and management, and to establish
83
whether or to what extent information systems have been constructed as learning sites or be-
havioural control sites. When behavioural control is a primary goal, this introduces a climate
of resistance, further inflated by the culture of measurement and enforcement that is likely to
ensue. In this environment, agent, manager and organization become defensive and the main
outcome is a destructive crisis of trust that creates important and difficult implications for the
capacity to learn.
Keywords: Learning, Control, Measurement, Corporate culture
(Appears also in Section VII.)
22. Hutchinson, Sue, John Purcell and Nick Kinnie. Evolving high commitment management and
the experience of the RAC call centre, Human Resource Management Journal, 10 (1), 2000,
63–78.
Abstract. This study of the RAC Customer Services Centre in Bristol is designed to show
how a bundle of high commitment management (HCM) practices evolved at a time of significant
competitive challenge to the business, and how the HRM choices were woven in, both in process
and content terms, with changes to other functional strategies inside and outside the organiza-
tion.
Keywords: Management styles, Changes, Call centers, Studies, Human resource management
23. Mascia, F.L., R. Marx and G. Arbix. Old paradigms for new jobs in call centers. Ergonomics
for the New Millennium. Proceedings of the XIVth Triennial Congress of the International Er-
gonomics Association and 44th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society,
San Diego, California, USA, Vol. 2, 2000, 543–546.
Abstract. Organizational structure, working process and task conception based on Tayloristic
paradigms have become common in call centres in Brazil. Considering work as a simple rep-
etition of procedures has consequences in terms of productivity, quality and workers’ health.
Actually the task is complex and cannot be strictly formalized.
24. Sczesny, Sabine and Dagmar Stahlberg. Sexual harassment over the telephone: Occupational
risk at call centres, Work and Stress, 14 (2), 2000, 121–136.
Abstract. Examined call center employees’ experiences of telephone sexual harassment (SH).
93 telephone company employees (aged 20–59 yrs) completed questionnaires concerning past
experiences of telephone SH, including prevalence, characteristics, stress, behavioral reactions,
coping strategies, consequences, and anticipated consequences. Results show that female Ss ex-
perienced more workplace telephone SH than did males. 94% of SH involved males harassing
females, with 10+% involving sexual violence threats. Most calls were ended by recipients’ hang-
ing up. Coping strategies included self-instruction, verbal exchanges, and expressions of feelings.
Telephone SH was stressful, left Ss feeling disgusted or disrespected, and negatively affected job
satisfaction and performance. Findings suggest that female employees in call centers and other
work environments with intensive employee telephone use experience frequent occurrences of
telephone SH. SH experiences are a risk factor in telephone-related jobs.
84
25. Spini, M. Guidelines for a human resources development model in call centre, International
Journal of Psychology, 35 (3–4), 2000, 363–363.
26. Sturdy, A. Training in service—importing and imparting customer service culture as an interac-
tive process, International Journal of Human Resource Management, 11 (6), 2000, 1082–1103.
Abstract. Customer service culture initiatives have received renewed academic attention. Re-
cent surveys of employee responses have highlighted the importance of training. However, its
precise nature and how messages and various responses are mediated through an interactive and
dynamic process have been largely neglected. In addition, employees’ experience of customer
service as consumers and of its contradictions has yet to be fully explored in accounting for
employee responses. In an effort to develop existing knowledge and models of customer service
culture, these issues are addressed by drawing on observational research. Four training pro-
grammes are examined in varied contexts, including a UK call centre and a Malaysian bank.
They reveal a dynamic whereby trainers’ anticipation of employee attitudes such as cynicism
and the immediate reactions and dialogue of trainees help shape both the service message and
subsequent responses.
Keywords: Customer service, Employee orientiations, Knowledge diffusion, Participant observa-
tion, Training
27. Sznelwar, L.I., M. Zilbovicius and R.F.R. Soares. The structure of tasks at ‘call centers’: Con-
trol and learning difficulties. Ergonomics for the New Millennium. Proceedings of the XIVth
Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics Association and 44th Annual Meeting of the
Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, San Diego, California, USA, Vol. 2, 2000, 547–550.
Abstract. The organizational structures of call centres are based on standardized and rigor-
ously controlled tasks. This paper, based on studies in companies located in Sao Paulo, Brazil,
during the 1990s, discusses the difficulties of learning and work-related anxieties present in these
types of organization.
(Appears also in Section VI.)
28. Wallace, Catriona M., Geoff Eagleson and Robert Waldersee. The sacrificial HR strategy in call
centers, International Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 174–184.
Abstract. Balancing the competing ob jectives of efficiency and service typically requires man-
agement compromises to be made. However, some call centers have found that a compromise
is not necessary. By using a “sacrificial HR strategy”, they achieve both efficiency and high
levels of service at the same time. This is possible because part of the sacrificial HR strategy
is the deliberate, frequent replacement of employees in order to provide enthusiastic, motivated
customer service at low cost to the organization. Describes a multiple-case analysis of four call
centers and the sacrificial HR strategy they used. The contingencies leading to the appearance
of this strategy are discussed.
85
Keywords: Call centres, Service, Efficiency, HR strategy
29. de Ruyter, Ko, Martin Wetzels and Richard Feinberg. Role stress in call centers: Its effects on
employee performance and satisfaction, Journal of Interactive Marketing, 15 (2), 2001, 23–35.
Abstract. Call centers have become an important customer access channel as well as an im-
portant source of customer-related information. Frequently, call center employees experience
role stress as a result of the conflicting demands of the company, supervisors, and customers.
In a study, antecedents and consequences of role stress in a call center setting are examined.
Specifically, which forms of empowerment and leadership styles decrease role stress and how this
subsequently effects job satisfaction, organizational commitment, performance, and turnover
intentions, are investigated. It was found that particularly the autonomy dimension of em-
powerment has a role-stress-reducing effect. Interesting substantive direct positive effects of
empowerment competence and leadership consideration on job satisfaction were found.
Keywords: Call centers, Studies, Roles, Stress, Employee problems
30. Dilevko, J. An ideological analysis of digital reference service models, Library Trends, 50 (2),
2001, 218–244.
Abstract. Using the theories of Pierre Boudieu about occupational fields of struggle and species
of capital, this article examines the ideological implications of the digital reference call-center
model. This model has the potential to lead to deprofessionalization of reference work because of
increased automation and the replication of employment conditions prevailing in private sector
call centers. Call-center work typically involves unskilled women earning low wages in jobs that
present little opportunity for career building. Library directors who advocate digital reference
call centers as models of the future have neglected the negative aspects of call centers in their
rush to cut costs and provide efficient services. One answer to the deskilling dilemma is the
simple act of reading: the more a librarian reads, the more he or she becomes an irreplaceable
contributor in the reference transaction.
(Appears also in Section VII.)
31. Gilmore, Audrey. Call centre management: Is service quality a priority? Managing Service
Quality, 11 (3), 2001, 153–159.
Abstract. In recent years the call centre industry has grown rapidly in size and popularity. In so
doing, the industry has been perceived to suffer from some of the problems associated with indus-
trial mass production. The nature of the requirement to answer a high number of calls in these
centres had led to the use of a traditional “production-line” management approach. Recently,
as a result of both customers’ and employees’ expectations rising in relation to service delivery,
the trend is for call centre operations to become more focused on staff empowerment, moving
away from the traditional production-line approach. For many companies, this has become a
difficult management problem. This paper reports on one such company. Following a number of
years’ reliance on carrying out surveys of customer perceptions, and a history of subsequent lack
of service improvement, this research used an in-depth case study approach incorporating ob-
servation studies, interviews with different levels of managers, and focus-group discussions with
86
front-line service delivery staff (agents). The findings identified the service quality issues to be
addressed in order to reconcile customers’ and agents’ needs, and the implications for managers.
Keywords: Service quality, United Kingdom, Production, Empowerment
(Appears also in Section VII.)
32. Houlihan, Maeve. Managing to manage? Stories from the call centre floor, Journal of European
Industrial Training, 25, 2001, 208–220.
Abstract. Call centres are centralized operations where trained agents communicate with cus-
tomers via phone and using purpose-built information and communication technologies. The
normative model of call centre organization is that tasks are tightly prescribed, routinized,
scripted and monitored. What are the implications for managers and management? Drawing
on ethnographic fieldwork, this article focuses on middle management in call centres: how they
work, how they talk about their work and what alternatives they see. It describes an emerg-
ing understanding of a manager who is as constrained as a worker under this mass customized
bureaucracy. Lack of strategic support and development, a powerfully normative focus on micro-
management and deeply embedded goal conflicts combine to undermine these managers’ scope
to truly manage. Like the agents they supervise, call centre managers are engaged in a coping
pro ject. In this context, they perform their identity with ambivalence: sometimes role embrac-
ing, sometimes resisting.
Keywords: Telemarketing, Customer service management
(Appears also in Section VII.)
33. Knights, D. and D. McCabe. A different world: Shifting masculinities in the transition to call
centres, Organization, 8 (4), 2001, 619–645.
Abstract. This article explores how business process reengineering (BPR) is informed by a
masculine discourse that emphasizes competition, control and conquest while simultaneously
appealing to care, trust, nurturing, creativity and teamwork. We explore how this contradiction
is reflected in the language and practice of management. We demonstrate some of the ways in
which this contradiction infuses with, subverts and may ultimately undermine BPR. We locate
the debate within a contextual consideration of how reengineering is displacing an earlier form
of masculinity within financial services which we understand and describe as paternalism. It is
apparent that the preeminence of masculinity was never questioned. Indeed, both paternalism
and reengineering simply fought over which masculinity would predominate.
Keywords: Business reengineering, Empowerment, Gender, Identity, Power, Strategy
34. Taylor, P. and P. Bain. Trade unions, workers’ rights and the frontier of control in UK call
centres, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 39–66.
Abstract. In developing a model of call centre diversity, spanning the dimensions of quantity
and quality, the article develops a critique of aspects of Frenkel et al.’s recent study of ‘front
line’ work. Drawing upon employee survey and interview data from six UK financial sector call
centres, patterns of resistance and the contrasting responses of trade unions to the experience
87
of intensive working conditions are examined. It is argued, in conclusion, that the newly estab-
lished managerial ’frontiers of control’ require to be combated by new union bargaining agendas
which seek to address employees’ concerns at the point of production.
Keywords: Labor unions, Call centers, Control, Workers, Financial services, Studies
35. Thompson, Paul and George Callaghan. Edwards revisited: Technical control and call centres,
Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 13–37.
Abstract. Call centers represent a new strategy by capital to rescue unit labor costs. This
article argues that management has developed a new form of structural control. Theoretically
this draws heavily on Edwards’ concept of technical control, but not only is this shown to be
extended and modified, it is also combined with bureaucratic control which influences the social
structure of the workplace. Contrary to Edwards, such systems are not distinct; rather, they
are blended together in the process of institutionalizing control. Part of the rationale for this
is to camouflage control, to contain conflict by making control a product of the system rather
than involving direct confrontation between management and workers. Despite such attempts,
the struggle for transforming labor power into profitable labor remains, and the article ends by
exploring confrontation between workers and managers and worker agency more generally.
Keywords: Call centers, Control, Work environment, Studies
(Appears also in Section VII.)
36. Adria, Marco and Shamsud D. Chowdhury. Making room for the call center, Information Sys-
tems Management, 19 (1), 2002, 71–80.
Abstract. A call center can dramatically improve an organization’s ability to serve its cus-
tomers. Skills for employees in call centers can and should be upgraded. The article suggests
ways of ensuring that the ideal configuration of decentralized decision making and centralized
control takes hold in the organization after the call center is established. Practical advice is
offered for enhancing an organization’s culture even as employees begin to spend less time in
face-to-face interactions.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Customer services, Corporate culture
(Appears also in Section VII.)
37. Armistead, Colin, Julia Kiely, Linda Hole and Jean Prescott. An exploration of managerial
issues in call centres, Managing Service Quality, 12 (4), 2002, 246–256.
Abstract. This paper explores managerial issues in call centres through two intensive case
studies in UK organisations, supplemented by interviews with five operations managers in other
call centres. The research explores key issues from the perspective of managers, team leaders,
and customer-service agents. Our findings show a growing professionalism among those working
in call centres—in keeping with the prominent role played by call centres in the market value
chains of many organisations. Managers are under pressure to meet the potentially conflicting
goals of customer service and efficiency in variable circumstances which cause the work load on
call centres to alter significantly. In this environment, decisions on the use of technology, and
88
on the roles, skills, and competencies of customer agents, are critical. So too are the ways in
which human resource practices are employed in this relatively new and fast-growing form of
organisation.
Keywords: Communications industries, Information technology, Professionalism, Motivation
38. Bagnara, S., R. Bugatti, F. Gabrielli and A. Morawetz. Customer contact centers: Perspectives
in work organisation. WWDU 2002—World Wide Work. Proceedings of the 6th International
Scientific Conference on Work with Display Units, H. Luczak, A.E. Cakir and G. Cakir (eds.),
Ergonomic Institut fur Arbeits- und Sozialforschung, Forschungsgesellschaft mbH, Berlin, 2002,
79–81.
Abstract. Many people are currently employed in call centres and many more are expected to
work in them in the near future. As shown by an overview of work in call centres carried out
during a European pro ject (Euro-Telework), operators coordinate and take care of the relation-
ship with customers. They fully represent the company. Their work in practice is based on a
processing of distributed knowledge that is dynamic and continuously evolving. Nevertheless,
they have to face a sort of ‘tayloristic’ organization that hampers knowledge sharing and reduces
the quality of work. Additionally, there is scarce attention to training, retention and career de-
velopment of agents. The paper reports a case study where a team-based perspective has been
set out for building and empowering new professional roles in order to make the contact centres
evolve from customer care to customer relationship management structures.
Keywords: Training, Team work
39. Bain, Peter and Phil Taylor. Ringing the changes? Union recognition and organisation in call
centres in the UK finance sector, Industrial Relations Journal, 33 (3), 2002, 246–261.
Abstract. The massive rise in UK call center employment in recent years has been closely
related to developments in the finance sector. This paper analyzes these developments in order
to contextualize the organizational experiences of unions in the sector. Recruitment activity in
both hostile and compliant employer environments, and findings from the first national survey
of call center employees’ attitudes towards trade unionization, are discussed, as the prospects for
union recruitment and organization are assessed. On the basis of the findings reported here, and
on what is known about sectoral developments, it is not possible to make a definitive calculation
of the extent of union membership of density in finance sector call sectors. However, despite
uneven development in relation to individual unions and companies, the research indicates some
growth in both union membership and employer recognition.
Keywords: Studies, Labor unions, Labor relations, Call centers, Recruitment, Memberships
40. Batt, Rosemary. Managing customer services: Human resource practices, quit rates, and sales
growth, Academy of Management Journal, 45 (3), 2002, 587–597.
Abstract. This study examines the relationship between human resource practices, employee
quit rates, and organizational performance in the service sector. Drawing on a unique nationally
representative sample of call centers, multivariate analyses show that quit rates are lower and
89
sales growth is higher in establishments that emphasize high skills, employee participation in
decision-making and in teams, and HR incentives such as high relative pay and employment
security. Quit rates partially mediate the relationship between human resource practices and
sales growth. These relationships also are moderated by the customer segment served.
41. Batt, Rosemary, Alexander Colvin and Jeffrey Keefe. Employee voice, human resource practices,
and quit rates: Evidence from the telecommunications industry, Industrial Labor Relations Re-
view, 55 (4), 2002, 573–594.
Abstract. In this paper, we examine the predictors of aggregate quit rates at the establishment
level. We draw on strategic human resource and industrial relations theory to identify the sets
of employee voice mechanisms and human resource practices that are likely to predict quit rates.
With respect to alternative voice mechanisms, we find that union representation significantly
predicts lower quit rates after controlling for compensation and a wide range of other human
resource practices that may be affected by collective bargaining. Direct participation via offline
problem-solving groups and self-directed teams is significantly negatively related to quit rates,
but non-union dispute resolution procedures are not. In addition, higher relative wages and
internal promotion policies significantly predict lower quit rates, while contingent staffing, elec-
tronic monitoring, and variable pay predict significantly higher rates.
42. Batt, Rosemary and Lisa Moynihan. The viability of alternative call centre production models,
Human Resource Management Journal, 12 (4), 2002, 14–34.
Abstract. This article outlines three alternative production models and discusses their ap-
plicability to call centre management. These include the classic mass production model, the
professional service model and the mass customisation model. It then develops a theoretical
framework that identifies potential causal links between management practices, workers, af-
fective and cognitive reactions, and performance outcomes. It uses this framework to review
literature on service workplaces in organizational behavior and HR studies and to assess the
empirical evidence regarding these causal explanations. Finally, the paper presents two recent
quantitative studies of call centre performance—one that examines affective explanations and
one that explores cognitive explanations for the HR–performance link. It concludes with direc-
tions for future research.
Keywords: Call centers, Human resource management, Models, Correlation analysis, Organiza-
tional behavior, Studies
43. Belt, Vicki, Ranald Richardson and Juliet Webster. Women, social skill and interactive service
work in telephone call centers, New Technology, Work, and Employment, 17 (1), 2002, 20–34.
Abstract. This paper contributes to current debates about gender, work and skill in the service
economy, focusing specifically on the case of women’s employment in telephone call centers. The
paper asks whether call centre employers are capitalizing on women’s feminine social skills, and
examines the degree to which these skills are being developed, acknowledged and recognized.
Keywords: Human resource management, Call centers, Women, Statistical data
90
44. Callaghan, George and Paul Thompson. ‘We recruit attitude’: The selection and shaping of
routine call centre labour, The Journal of Management Studies, 39 (2), 2002, 233–254.
Abstract. Call centers are growing rapidly and are receiving attention from politicians, policy
makers and academics. While most of the latter focus on work relations, notably patterns of
control and surveillance, this paper explores the role of recruitment, selection and training in
the shaping call center labor. The paper uses data from a case study of a call center to argue
that the increased significance of social competencies within interactive service work gives these
procedures greater salience and that they are used by management to address the indeterminacy
of labor, in part, outside the labor process. Primary data from management and customer ser-
vice representatives is used to examine and contrast their respective perceptions of recruitment,
selection and training.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Recruitment, Employee attitude, Training
45. Couture, Jon Nicholas. The impact of role ambiguity, locus of control and job satisfaction on
call center agent productivity. Dissertation - Abstracts - International Section A: Humanities
and Social Sciences, 63 (5-A), 1678, 2002.
Abstract: As the global economy continues to migrate from a product and manufacturing orien-
tation to a services orientation, the need for high performance call centers is increasing at a rapid
pace. An obvious part of building a high performance call center is ensuring the employees, or
Call Center Agents (CCA), are as productive as possible so businesses can provide high quality
call center services as effectively and efficiently as possible. This study focused on the impact
of role ambiguity, locus of control and job satisfaction as it relates to CCA productivity. It was
conducted in a large, international IT Services firm that provides a wide range of IT services
(e.g., consulting, help desk support, etc.) to Fortune 1000 companies. Sixty-one CCAs partic-
ipated in this study. The hypotheses suggested that certain correlations would exist between
the independent and dependent variables. The results of the study did not reveal a significant
predictor of call CCA performance. Although there were some interesting correlations between
one pair of the variables (e.g., role ambiguity and job satisfaction were highly correlated), based
on the results of this study, it does not appear as though the degree of role ambiguity, locus of
control or the level of job satisfaction of CCAs can predict productivity. It’s important to note
that questions were raised around the productivity measures used in terms of their reliability
due to an aggregating process used to normalize how call center managers view the performance
of their CCAs. Further implications associated with the results of this study, and directions for
future research were discussed.
46. Dean, Alison M. Service quality in call centres: Implications for customer loyalty, Managing
Service Quality, 12 (6), 2002, 414–423.
Abstract. Studies on call centres suggest that there is a focus on efficiency at the expense
of effectiveness, where effectiveness is indicated by characteristics such as customer orientation,
service priorities and quality. It therefore appears that customers will expect and experience
low levels of service quality from call centres, with possible implications for their loyalty to the
91
providing organisation. These issues are the focus of this study. A mail survey was conducted of
recent clients of two call centres in Australia. The respondents were individual consumers in an
insurance company (n = 248, 14 percent) or business customers of a bank (n = 325, 16 percent).
Key findings are similar for the two samples. Both perceptions of quality and customer orien-
tation of the call centre were related to loyalty to the providing organisation, and perceptions
of quality partially mediated the customer orientation to loyalty relationship. The discussion
includes managerial implications and potential future research.
Keywords: Service quality, Customer orientation, Call centres, Customer loyalty
47. Deery, Stephen, Roderick Iverso and Janet Walsh. Work relationships in telephone call centres:
Understanding emotional exhaustion and employee withdrawal, The Journal of Management
Studies, 39 (4), 2002, 471–496.
Abstract. This paper examines the nature of employment and the conditions of work in five
telephone call centers in the telecommunications industry in Australia. The paper draws upon
survey data from 480 telephone service operators to identify the factors that are associated with
emotional exhaustion and the frequency of absence amongst the employees. A modeling of the
data using LISREL VIII revealed that a number of job and work-setting variables affected the
level of emotional exhaustion of employees. These included interactions with the customer, a
high workload and a lack of variety of work tasks. Moreover, higher rates of absence were asso-
ciated with emotional exhaustion.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Stress, Work environment, Emotions
48. Easton, Fred F. and John C. Goodale. Labor scheduling with employee turnover and absen-
teeism. Working paper, Syracuse University, March 15, 2002.
Abstract. Most labor staffing and scheduling models presume that all employees scheduled for
duty reliably report for work at the beginning of their shift. For industries with even moderate
turnover or absenteeism, this assumption may be quite costly. We present a profit-oriented labor
scheduling model that accounts for the day-to-day flux of employees and capacity induced by
voluntary resignations, new hires, experience curves, and absenteeism. The proposed model also
anticipates revenue losses due to reneging by customers whose patience decays exponentially
with queue time. Our computational studies suggest that firms with comparatively high trans-
action volumes, long transaction times, and/or relatively tight profit margins may experience
significant benefit from this approach. Compared with conventional labor scheduling models, the
proposed method boosts average expected profits by more than 10 percent in certain operating
environments.
49. Matthews, G. and S. Falconer. Personality, coping and task-induced stress in customer service
personnel, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 46th Annual Meeting,
Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA, USA, 2002, 963–967.
Abstract. This study investigated predictors of stress responses in customer service personnel
working for a ma jor telecommunications company. Ninety-one participants performed a simu-
92
lation of their work task. They were presented with telephone inquiries, and tested for their
knowledge of the correct response. Several findings of a previous study (Matthews and Falconer,
2000) were replicated. Performing the task appeared to be intrinsically stressful, as evidenced
by a large magnitude increase in sub jective distress. Individual differences in stress state were
related to strategy for coping with task demands. The ‘big five’ personality traits were com-
pared with measures of dispositional coping style as predictors of sub jective stress state. Coping
measures added significantly to the variance in stress state explained by the big five. Emotion-
focused strategies such as self-criticism appeared to be especially damaging in the customer
service context. Coping measures might be used by organizations to select operators likely to
be resistant to task-induced stress.
Keywords: Behavioral sciences computing, Call centres, Human factors, Marketing, Personnel,
Psychology
(Appears also in Section VI.)
50. Moshavi, Dan and James R. Terborg. The job satisfaction and performance of contingent and
regular customer service representatives: A human capital perspective, International Journal of
Service Industry Management, 13 (4), 2002, 333–347.
Abstract. Although research on customer service representatives (CSRs) in call centers has
increased in recent years, little attention has been paid to the growing use of contingent (tem-
porary) CSRs in this setting. This study investigated the role that human capital plays in
explaining the job satisfaction and performance of contingent and regular CSRs. Consistent
with our expectations, contingent CSRs had less human capital but higher job satisfaction than
regular workers. In addition, we found that human capital mediated the relationship between
work status and job satisfaction. Contrary to expectations, no performance differences were
found between contingent and regular CSRs. Implications for research and practice are dis-
cussed.
Keywords: Work, Customer service, Job satisfaction
51. Mulholland, Kate. Gender, emotional labour and teamworking in a call centre, Personnel Re-
view, 31 (3), 2002, 283–303.
Abstract. This article examines teamworking in a call centre and how this is shaped for the
employees by an increase in technical control, the dynamics of emotional labour and gender
politics. The research is based on a case study of call centre work organization in different
sectors, and this paper draws specifically on ethnographic research on two teams and their man-
agers in broadcasting. Drawing on theoretical insights, it suggests that teamworking results in a
fundamental contradiction involving a “soft” discourse versus a regime of increasing managerial
control. Participation is measured against Thompson and Wallace’s three-dimensional notion of
participation, showing that employees have little discretion over the way work is organized. The
normative aspect of team organization accommodates managerial coping strategies in conditions
of staff shortage via numerical flexibility. However, management’s efforts to disguise control are
resisted by employees who transform workplace discourses into oppositional politics, shattering
the illusion of unity promoted by the pundits of team organization.
93
Keywords: Teamwork, Management control, Gender, Participation, Resistance
52. Richardson, H. and K. Richardson. Customer relationship management systems (CRM) and
information ethics in call centrres—‘You are the weakest link. Goodbye!’, Australian Journal of
Information Systems, 9 (2), 2002, 166–171.
Abstract. This paper catalogues the rise of call centres in the North West of England, UK
and their use of CRM systems. CRM systems often imply new technologies and new ways of
working. However, in this account, we explore the historical development of the telegraph and
work in early telephone exchanges and find the same old story. Our consideration of the ethics
of CRM system use and some inherent contradictions are in terms of privacy, communication
richness, management methods and computer ethics in an organizational context. Call centres
today are viewed by some as offering satisfying employment of intrinsic value; for others, they
are the ‘new sweatshops of the 21st century’ (Belt et al., 2000). Our interpretative field study
makes a contribution to this debate.
(Appears also in Section VII.)
53. Smith, W.L. Customer service call centers: Managing rapid personnel changes, Human Systems
Management, 20 (2), 2002, 123–129.
Abstract. This paper examines academic and practitioner literature relative to service quality
and the changing personnel requirements for customer service call centers (CSCC). From this
review, propositions are developed which (1) may be useful to call center managers in meeting
this critical need, and (2) may be used to direct future academic research in this growth area.
This review is organized around eight key human resource management practices consisting of:
1. recuiting, 2. selection, 3. retention, 4. teamwork, 5. training and development, 6. appraisal,
7. rewarding quality, and 8. employee involvement. Propositions based on the literature review
are developed for each key practice. Conclusions are drawn and implications for managerial and
academic implications are discussed.
54. Swanson, N., P. Grubb, C. Beam, R. Dunkin, L. Schleifer and S. Sauter. The influence of job
stressors on the taking of rest breaks among call center operators. WWDE 2002—World Wide
Work. Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific Conference on Work and Display Units, H.
Luczak, A.E. Cakir and G. Cakir (eds.), Ergonomic Institut fur Arbeits- und Sozialforschung,
Forschungsgesellschaft mbH, Berlin, 2002, 674–675.
Abstract. Nearly 5000 customer service operators in a large government agency were sur-
veyed about working conditions at their agency. The survey included questions about rest break
behaviours and job stressors. The results indicated that job demands were predictive of rest
break behaviours. Employees who reported low levels of job control, supervisory support, and
decision-making ability, along with greater time pressures, work backlogs, and contact with up-
set customers also reported taking fewer rest breaks during the workday.
Keywords: Rest pauses and work duration, Etiology, Job characteristics
94
55. van den Broek, Diane. Monitoring and surveillance in call centres: Some responses from Aus-
tralian workers, Labour & Industry, 12 (3), 2002, 43–58.
Abstract. Australian call centres currently number around 4,000, in industries such as bank-
ing, public utilities, airlines, information technology, and telecommunications. Of the 200,000
employees in the call centre industry, the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) estimates
that around 15 to 20 percent are unionised. Unionised call centres are generally located in the
public or ex-public sector such as the airlines, while employees in other industries including
telecommunications and banking are considerably less unionised. The contract call centres have
proven to be the most difficult to organise. (Interview ACTU Organiser, 2001).
(Appears also in Section VII.)
56. Anonymous. Shift-pattern switch improves staff turnover and recruitment at Seeboard, Human
Resource Management International Digest, 11 (1), 2003, 12.
Abstract. Switching from 3-week rolling shifts to fixed shift patterns at Seeboard Energy’s
customer-contact center was seen as a high-risk strategy by some managers, but has dramati-
cally reduced staff turnover and improved recruitment. Seeboard Energy Ltd is a utility company
with around 1.8 million customers, mainly in south-east England. Its customer-contact center
operates from 8 a.m.–10 p.m. (Saturday 8 a.m.–6 p.m.). Staff answer around 3 million calls a
year and respond to around 800,000 letters or e-mails from customers. The company piloted
the approach in an area of the organization that had the highest number of vacancies (150).
Throughout the pro ject, from identification of the problem to implementation of a solution, the
company placed great emphasis on communication. This pro ject demonstrated that the switch
to a fixed shift pattern at Seeboard Energy halved staff turnover, to 10%, in a 9-month period,
and cut the proportion of women leaving by almost a third. In addition, response to recruitment
advertisements improved markedly.
Keywords: Retention, Working hours, Personnel policies, Electric utilities, Corporate profiles
57. Bakker, Arnold B., Evangelia Demerouti and Wilmar B. Schaufeli. Dual processes at work in a
call centre: An application of the job demands v-v resources model, European Journal of Work
and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003, 393–417.
Abstract. This study among 477 employees working in the call centre of a Dutch telecom
company (response 88%) examined the predictive validity of the job demands v-v resources
(JDv-vR) model for self-reported absenteeism and turnover intentions. The central hypoth-
esis was that job demands would be the most important predictors of absenteeism, through
their relationship with health problems (i.e., exhaustion, and Repetitive Strain Injury—RSI),
whereas job resources would be the most important predictors of turnover intentions, through
their relationship with involvement (i.e., organizational commitment and dedication). Results
of a series of SEM analyses largely supported these dual processes. In the first energy-driven
process, job demands (i.e., work pressure, computer problems, emotional demands, and changes
in tasks) were the most important predictors of health problems, which, in turn, were related
to sickness absence (duration and long-term absence). In the second motivation-driven process,
job resources (i.e., social support, supervisory coaching, performance feedback and time con-
95
trol) were the only predictors of involvement, which, in turn, was related to turnover intentions.
Additionally, job resources had a weak negative relationship with health problems, and health
problems positively influenced turnover intentions. The application of the JDv-vR model as a
human resource management tool in call centres as well as in other organizations is discussed.
58. Cartwright, Susan. New forms of work organization: Issues and challenges, Leadership and Or-
ganization Development Journal, 24 (3), 2003, 121–122.
Abstract. The changing nature of work and the emergence of new forms of work organiza-
tion present particular challenges to leadership and management. This special issue examines
some of the challenges and issues in the relationship between technology, stress and satisfaction
within call centre environments, the problems of remote leadership and the rise in contingent
workforce.
Keywords: Work organization, Work teams, Call centres, Workforce, Leadership, Temporary
workers
(Appears also in Section VII.)
59. Holdsworth, Lynn and Susan Cartwright. Empowerment, stress and satisfaction: An exploratory
study of a call centre, Leadership and Organization Development Journal, 24 (3), 2003, 131–140.
Abstract. The aim of this study was to explore the relationship between stress, satisfaction
and the four dimensions of psychological empowerment (meaning, impact, self-determination
and competence) within a call centre. The occupational stress indicator and Spreitzer’s empow-
erment measure were used to collect data from a northwest (UK) call centre (n = 49). The
study found the call centre agents were more stressed, less satisfied and reported poorer mental
and physical health than the general working population. In addition, the sample perceived
themselves as less empowered than other workers in a traditional office environment. The em-
powerment dimensions of meaning, impact and particularly self-determination, seem to directly
influence job satisfaction, but not health.
Keywords: Stress, Empowerment, Call centres, Job satisfaction
60. Holman, David. Phoning in sick: An overview of employee stress in call centres, Leadership and
Organization Development Journal, 24 (3), 2003, 123–130.
Abstract. This paper reviews three studies that examine the main causes of employee stress
and well-being in call centres. All three studies were conducted by the author and his colleagues
and reveal that employee well-being in call centres is associated with: effective job design; per-
formance monitoring that is not perceived to be intense and which aims to develop employees;
supportive management; and, supportive human resource practices. Furthermore, levels of well-
being in call centres are shown to compare favourably to other forms of work. The studies
challenge the image of call centres as “electronic sweatshops” and question the idea that call
centre work is inevitably stressful. It is argued that managers have a choice in how to organise
call centre work and can take steps to actively design employee stress out of call centre work.
Practical recommendations on how to reduce employee stress in call centres are discussed.
96
Keywords: Call centres, Stress, Job design, Performance monitoring, Human resource manage-
ment
61. Konradt, U., G. Hertel and K. Joder. Web-based assessment of call center agents: Development
and validation of a computerized instrument, International Journal of Selection and Assessment,
11 (2-3), 2003, 184–193.
Abstract. This study describes the development and validation of the Call Center Aptitude
Test (C-A-T), an Internet-based multi-method measure for the pre-selection of call centre agents.
The C-A-T includes a short biographical form, a cognitive speed test, a personality inventory,
and a multimedia situational judgement test. A total of 327 call centre agents completed the
C-A-T and were concurrently assessed by their superiors. In a pilot study (N = 151), a pro-
totype was tested and subsequently optimized. In the main study (N = 176), the revised and
extended version of the C-A-T was reliable (alpha = 0.85) and showed good convergent and
discriminant validity. The concurrent validity (r = 0.33) can be considered to be satisfactory
for a computerized pre-selection instrument. Evidence was also found for high face validity and
acceptance in both studies.
62. Korczynski, Marek. Communities of coping: Collective emotional labour in service work, Orga-
nization, 10 (1), 2003, 55-79.
Abstract. This article argues that communities of coping among front-line service workers are
an important part of what Hochschild has called “collective emotional labor” in service work.
The analysis is framed in a sociological understanding of the customer as the key source of both
pleasure and pain for service workers. Irate and abusive customers, who are systematically part
of the social relations of the service workplace, may occasion real pain in service workers. The
structure of workers’ social situation means that they are likely to turn to each other to cope
with this pain, forming informal communities of coping. Drawing an extensive research in four
call centers in Australia and the US, this article highlights this important process in action. The
communities of coping were an important social process in these workplaces, creating informal,
dense cultures among the workforce. These cultures had important implications for how far the
social relations of the workplace were open to management control.
Keywords: Corporate culture, Organizational behavior, Studies, Call centers, Service industries,
Cutomer relations, Emotions
(Appears also in Section III.)
63. Lewig, K.A. and M.F. Dollard. Emotional dissonance, emotional exhaustion and job satisfaction
in call centre workers, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003,
366–392.
Abstract. The rapid rise of the service sector, and in particular, the call centre industry, has
made the study of emotional labour increasingly important within the area of occupational stress
research. Given high levels of turnover and absenteeism in the industry, this article examines
the emotional demands (emotional labour) of call centre work and their relationship to job satis-
faction and emotional exhaustion in a sample of South Australian call centre workers (NV=v98)
97
within the theoretical frameworks of the job demand v-v control model, the effort v-v reward im-
balance model, and the job demands v-v resources model. Qualitatively, the research confirmed
the central role of emotional labour variables in the experience of emotional exhaustion and
satisfaction at work. Specifically, the research confirmed the pre-eminence of emotional disso-
nance compared to a range of emotional demand variables in its potency to account for variance
in emotional exhaustion and job satisfaction. Specifically, emotional dissonance mediated the
effect of emotional labour (positive emotions) on emotional exhaustion. Furthermore, emotional
dissonance was found to be equal in its capacity to explain variance in the outcomes compared
to the most frequently researched demand measure in the work stress literature (psychosocial
demands). Finally, emotional dissonance was found to exacerbate the level of emotional ex-
haustion at high levels of psychosocial demands, indicating jobs combining high levels of both
kinds of demands are much more risky. Future theorizing about work stress needs to account for
emotional demands, dissonance in particular. Potential ways to alleviate emotional exhaustion
due to emotional dissonance is to reduce other psychosocial demands, increase rewards, support
and control as conceptualized in the JDR model. Ways to boost job satisfaction are to increase
control, support, and rewards.
(Appears also in Section III.)
64. Shah, Vishal and Ra jenda K. Bandi. Capability development in knowledge intensive IT enabled
services, European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003, 418–427.
Abstract. Most of the call centre literature discusses cases where the customer support task is
routine and low in complexity. Call centres are considered to be modern equivalents of factory
sweatshops in this literature. Technical support, however, is an example of a knowledge intensive
support service. The article presents a case study of a call centre providing remote technical
support and illustrates the nature of capabilities required for consistent service performance.
The practices adopted at this technical support call centre do not confirm to the sweatshop
stereotype mentioned in the literature.
65. Workman, Michael. Results from organizational development interventions in a technology call
center, Human Resource Development Quarterly, 14 (2), 2003, 215–230.
Abstract. Technology support call centers are becoming an increasingly important part of the
American economy. However, there are many scholarly reports of problems associated among
these endeavors. Research into mitigating these problems has tended to focus on structural
alignment, or forms of team participation, leading to conflicting outcomes. HRD researchers are
left with an unclear picture of the outcomes, and HRD practitioners have been left with the
question of which of these interventions to implement. This study concurrently investigated the
effects on job satisfaction from structural-alignment, high-involvement, autonomous-team inter-
ventions compared to a control group. The analysis indicated job satisfaction improvements in
the alignment and high-involvement groups, with the high-involvement groups suggesting the
most significant improvements. As a result, recommendations are made for HRD practitioners
and future HRD research.
Keywords: Personnel economics, Labor management (team formation, worker empowerment,
job design, tasks and authority, job satisfaction)
98
66. Zapf, Dieter, Amela Isic, Myriam Bechtoldt and Patricia Blau. What is typical for call centre
jobs? Job characteristics, and service interactions in different call centres, European Journal of
Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003, 311–340.
Abstract. Call centres have been one of the few booming branches in recent years. The main
task of call centre operators is to interact with customers by telephone, usually supported by
computer systems. It has been argued that call centre work is a modern form of “Taylorism”,
because it is characterized by routine tasks, and low level of control for the employees. Moreover,
it has been suggested that there is a high level of stress at work, both with regard to the work
tasks and to the interactions with customers. In the present study, a sample of 375 call centre
employees from eight different call centres was compared with a sample of noncall centre workers
(Nv=v405) in terms of job characteristics, job stressors, and emotional labour (emotion work).
The results showed that call centre workers had worse job characteristics, but were better off
with regard to most job stressors compared to representative comparison groups of no-service
workers, service workers, and workers in human services, respectively. Moreover, compared to
the other groups, customer service representatives (CSRs) had to express less negative emotions,
but were most frequently exposed to states of emotional dissonance. A comparison of the work-
ing conditions of the eight call centres revealed that in most call centres, the working conditions
could be substantially improved. In addition, various call centre parameters, such as inbound
vs. outbound, or inhouse vs. external service centres were examined. The strongest effects were
found for the percentage of time spent on the telephone. With some exceptions, the results
support the view that the ma jority of call centres have been established to organize mass service
for customers, that the work in the call centres is characterized by routine work and low task
control, and that call centre employees are required to suggest a “friendly smile” when they are
on the phone.
(Appears also in Section III.)
67. Anonymous. Call centres losing millions of working days to absence, Occupational Health, 56
(1), p. 4, 2004.
Abstract. A survey by technology organization Dimension Data found absenteeism is a problem
for the contact center industry, which accounts for almost 3% of the UK’s work force. The study
of more than 200 call centers around the world also reported very high staff turnover rates, at
19% globally, but up to 25% in Europe and the UK.
Keywords: Call centers, Absenteeism, Employee turnover
68. Bordoloi, Sanjeev K. Agent recruitment planning in knowledge-intensive call centers, Journal of
Service Research (JSR), 6 (4), 309–323, May 2004.
Abstract. The key ingredient in a call center’s operational efficiency is labor. Agent turnover
remains a ma jor concern for call centers. The top three reasons for turnover are low salary,
lack of career path, and burnout. On average, it costs about $10 to a call center for each call,
and the cost to bring on a new agent is more than $6,000. The author treats call centers as
knowledge-intensive operations that are characterized by extensive knowledge required for each
99
agent, combines control theory and chance-constrained programming in a model for workforce
planning that allows for agent learning, and derives steady state workforce levels for different
knowledge groups within the call center to minimize total labor-related costs. The ob jective is to
meet stochastic demands with a desired service level. The author applies his model to an actual
call center situation in the high-tech industry with adjusted data and discusses the managerial
implications.
69. Chaudhry, Abdus Sattar and Chua Jeanne. Call centres for enhanced reference services: A
comparison of selected library call centres and the Reference Point at the National Library of
Singapore, Library Review, 53 (1), 2004, 37–49.
Abstract. The concept of a call center is defined and the technologies employed in call center
applications are examined. The principles and practices relevant in the context of telephone
services offered by libraries are highlighted. Features of call centers in selected libraries are
described and compared with the Reference Point at the National Library of Singapore and
recommendations on call center practices with regard to the provision of LIS are presented.
Keywords: Comparative analysis, Call centers, Libraries, Communication systems, Customer
services, Reference services
70. Fisher, Michael. The crisis of civil service trade unionism: A case study of call centre develop-
ment in a civil service agency, Work, Employement & Society, 18 (1), 157–177, 2004.
Abstract. This article examines why and how management in a British civil service agency has
sought to respond to the Modernising Government agenda of the present Labour government by
seeking to apply Taylorist principles of work organisation to a complex form of administrative
case work. This has led to the establishment of a call centre within the agency for the first
time. The article discusses the response to this of the main trade union within the agency, the
positive and cooperative nature of which is argued to be founded in the historic character of
management-union relations within the agency, and in the ‘high-quality’ form that call centre
working has to far assumed. The reasons for this are identified as having their origins primarily
in a number of potentially temporary technical limits to the further realization of a Taylorist
decomposition of call handling tasks. The persistence of these limits is argued to have compelled
management to preserve complex working and employment terms that they may otherwise have
sought to challenge and change. The article concludes by arguing that trade unionism in the
agency is in crisis: A crisis consisting of a too uncritical understanding of the potential that the
further development of call centre working has to enhance the degradation and devaluation of
staff labour.
Keywords: Civil service, Call centers, Labor relations
71. Forsyth, Anne Marie. Lloyds TSB banks on call-center quality, Human Resource Management
International Digest, 12 (1), 14–16, 2004.
Abstract. More than 10 million Britons currently use telephone banking and an estimated
11.5 million online active bank accounts are in use—more than in any other European country.
100
These figures demonstrate that Internet and telephone banking are firmly embedded in everyday
lives and are here to stay. Lloyds TSB has been working not only to ensure that its call centers
provide the best possible service to customers, but also that it provides the staff with the best
possible place to work. A dedicated pro ject team at Lloyds TSB, consisting of people from HR
and quality management from the 3 call-center sites, was set up to work towards CCA accredi-
tation. One of the main challenges the bank faced in this was how to reconcile the geographical
disparity and reasons for departmental differences of its call centers.
Keywords: Call centers, Electronic banking, Working conditions, Training, Career development
planning
72. Pollitt, David. Nationwide dials up training over the telephone for call-center staff, Human
Resource Management International Digest, 12 (1), 12–13, 2004.
Abstract. The Nationwide’s regional call centers are designed to supplement the services of the
society’s two main call centers, in Swindon and Nottingham. These two centers employ hundreds
of staff, trained face-to-face by instructors working in classrooms. In order to meet the needs of
the new regional centers, the Nationwide had to find an efficient way of introducing new staff and
managers across the country to basic call-center skills and to the Nationwide customer culture
while maintaining an acceptable level of service. The society also needed a training approach
that involved managers to a greater extent in transferring learning into the workplace. Audio-
conferencing was the obvious solution. Course tests and quizzes showed that the Nationwide
delegates achieved higher scores with remote training than they had in traditional classroom
settings.
Keywords: Building societies, Training, Call centers, Telephones
73. Tuten, Tracy L. and Presha E. Neidermeyer. Performance, satisfaction and turnover in call
centers: The effects of stress and optimism, Journal of Business Research, 57 (1), 26–34, 2004.
Abstract. This paper reports the results of a study, which measured the role of optimism
and its effect on stress in call centers. Service providers at inbound call centers answered ques-
tionnaires designed to measure their personal orientation towards optimism, perceptions of job
stress, work/nonwork conflict, performance, absenteeism and intent to turnover. We found that
optimists did perceive lower levels of job stress and lower work/nonwork conflict. However,
pessimists reported higher levels of performance and satisfaction and lower turnover intent. Im-
plications for future research are discussed.
Keywords: Studies, Stress, Call centers, Personality traits, Job satisfaction, Employee turnover
74. Wickham, James and Grainne Collins. The call centre: A nursery for new forms of work organ-
isation? The Service Industrial Journal, 24 (1), 1–18, 2004.
Abstract. Within the existing literature, call centre work is defined as a combination of Tay-
lorism, emotional labour and surveillance. Yet call centres also involve new forms of customer
relationship. Call centre work is abstracted from any geographical location; it can involve many
people separate in time and space and the customer can often monitor it directly. We term
101
such work ‘virtual’, ‘poly-authored’ and ‘market supervised’. These new forms of work are now
spreading beyond conventional call centres, partly because of the new expectations of customers,
partly because of the migration of call centre employees into other areas of the enterprise.
Keywords: Studies, Call centres, Customer relations, Organisational structure
102
V Information and Telecommunication Technology, Artificial Intel-
ligence, Multi-agent Systems
1. Hirvela, R.J. The application of computer controlled PCM switching to automatic call distribu-
tion. Communications Systems and Technology Conference. IEEE, New York, NY, USA, 1974,
66–74.
Abstract. This paper describes a new computer controlled Automatic Call Distribution (ACD)
System which represents the first application of these technologies to call distribution. The ACD
switching function is provided by a time division PCM switching matrix which has a capacity
of up to 1536 digital voice channels. The call processing is performed by a computer control
system which also provides system management information as an integral part of the system.
Keywords: Automatic telephone systems, Communications applications of computers, Pulse
code modulation, Switching systems, Telephone-exchanges, Computer-controlled PCM switch-
ing, Automatic call distribution
2. Cavanaugh, J.R., R.W. Hatch and J.L. Sullivan. Tranmission rating model for use in planning
telephone networks, IEEE, 1983, 683–688.
Abstract. Customer opinions are an important element in transmission planning for the tele-
phone network. Since the invention of the telephone, considerable effort has been expended in
estimating customer assessment of transmission quality. Sub jective test results have been used
to formulate models. These models, in the form of smooth functions which permit interpola-
tion to allow examination of specific impairment values of interest, have been used to provide
transmission performance estimates for guiding evolution of the telephone network.
This paper first considers a previous model which covered the sub jective effects of loss, circuit
noise and talker echo (reported at NTC76) updated to reflect an IEEE loudness loss method
(rather than the loudness loss method for the original model). This is followed by discussion of
model extensions to cover listener echo, quantization noise, band width/attenuation distortion,
room noise, sidetone and echo control devices. Then the paper outlines several studies in which
the expanded model has been extensively used to study transmission quality of telephone con-
nections as a function of the various impairments. The paper concludes with some illustrative
examples demonstrating use of the model including comments on possible interpretation of re-
sults.
(Appears also in Section III.)
3. Basso, Richard J., Hugh J. Beuscher, Iris, S. Dowden, Richard J. Plereth and Samuel M. Salchen-
berger. OSPS system architecture, AT&T Technical Journal, 1989, 9–24.
Abstract. Operator services position system (OSPS) architecture builds on the 5ESS switch
Integrated Services Digitial Network (ISDN) base to provide modern, flexible operator services.
This article details some ma jor operator system innovations provided by the OSPS system ar-
chitecture.
103
4. Basso, Richard J., John C. Lund, Jr. and James H. Tendick. OSPS operator services applica-
tions, AT&T Technical Journal, 1989, 25–37.
Abstract. Toll and assistance and listing services are two important applications of the opera-
tor services position system (OSPS). These applications are built on the distributed architecture
of the 5ESS switch and use the building blocks provided by the OSPS software architecture to
incorporate new features easily. This article focuses on two toll and assistance features, inter-
flow and more efficient call handling (MECH), as well as the listing services application and a
combination of the two applications through the combined services feature to demonstrate the
power of the OSPS software architecture.
5. Bornhoft, M., B. Day and P. Curnow. Computer-switch telephony applications. Third IEE
Conference on Telecommunications. IEE, London, UK, 1991, 62–66.
Abstract. Describes the integration of computing systems with public and private telecommu-
nication switching networks and the configuration options that affect application performance
and need to be carefully considered to ensure successful deployment. Automatic call distribution
(ACD) is examined in detail. Joint peer-peer applications in the distributed environment are
examined with regard to standards. The benefits of standards in this are are discussed and the
progress of standardisation of switch computer interfaces in ECMA (European Computer Man-
ufacturers’ Association) with computer supported telecommunications applications (CSTA) is
reviewed. The authors draw conclusions on the future of interworking of computing and switch-
ing systems as the scope of applications for joint applications expands.
Keywords: Public telecommunication switching networks, ACD, Automatic call distribution,
Telephony, Integration, Computing systems, Private telecommunication switching networks,
Standardisation, Switch computer interfaces
6. Bose, R. and W.A. Davidson. Automatic call distribution using the ISDN basic rate interface.
ICC 91. International Conference on Communications Conference Record. IEEE, New York,
NY, USA, 1991, 969–971.
Abstract. An ISDN application that combines Q.931 messages on the basic rate interface
(BRI) with features of the 5ESS switch to provide automatic call distribution capabilities for
small telemarketing centers is described. A personal computer equipped with a BRI card and
custom software acts as an intelligent ISDN terminal. By sharing call appearances with ISDN
and analog agent sets connected to subscriber loops on the same switch, the PC provides call
distribution features and management information systems reports via intelligent interaction
with Centrex features of the 5ESS switch. The architecture allows for enhancements based on
calling number information and for integration with other telemarketing computers and voice
mail systems.
Keywords: Automatic call distribution, Small telemarketing centers, Personal computer, BRI
card, Custom software, Intelligent ISDN terminal, Analog agent sets, Subscriber loops, Manage-
ment information systems reports, Intelligent interaction, Centrex, Calling number information
104
7. Hassler, K.W., C.C. Jones, J.E. Kohler and R.D. Nalbone. Revolutionizing DEFINITY(R) call
centers in the 1990s, AT&T Technical Journal, 1995, 64–73.
Abstract. The award-winning. AT&T DEFINITY(R) G3 Expert Agent Selection (EAS) fea-
ture has fundamentally changed the way in which call centers provide set-vices for a variety of
business applications. The skills-matching concept of EAS simplifies the problem of meeting
incoming caller needs with trained call center agents. The Logical Agent part of EAS provides
call center agents with an incentive for advancement while also providing new-found flexibility in
how they perform their jobs. Both these EAS innovations are patented, with the skills-matching
patent winning the 1995 AT&T Patent Recognition Award. This paper describes how EAS im-
proves the efficiency of call centers, and it discusses the implementation approach used to realize
this important new call center feature.
Keywords: DEFINITY call centers, AT&T, G3 expert agent selection, Business applications,
Logical agent, Skills-matching patent, PBX, Automatic call distribution
(Appears also in Section VII.)
8. Klenke, M. ACDs get skills-based routing, Business Communications Review, 25 (7), 1995, 48–
51.
Abstract. The goal of automated call distributor (ACD) technology has always been to spread
incoming calls among call center agents so that each agent handled an equitable share of the
load and the caller had the best chance of being served quickly. Now, a new kind of thinking
skills-based routing has entered the call center arena. It takes ACDs one step further and en-
sures that an incoming call is routed to the available agent whose skills are best matched to the
caller’s needs. Skills-based routing software works by linking call center agents with predefined
skills groups. The author discusses the identification of customer needs, defining agent skills,
and setting up a routing scheme which allows callers and agents to come together efficiently.
Keywords: ACD, Skills-based routing, Automated call distributor technology, Incoming calls,
Call center agents, Routing software, Skills groups, Customer needs, Agent skills
(Appears also in Section IV.)
9. Anupindi, R. and B.T. Smythe., Call centers and rapid technological change. Teaching note.
Operations Management, Managerial Economics and Decision Sciences, J.L. Kellogg Graduate
School of Management, Northwestern University, July 1, 1997.
Abstract. Call centers are an increasingly important link in the value chain for many firms.
From the earliest call centers of the Bell Telephone Company, the centers have evolved into
technically specialized points of contact with the customer. New types of technology now enable
firms to decrease costs, improve customer service and improve call center agents’ job satisfaction.
Although the results have been convincing, these benefits have not come without costs and com-
plications. The three key steps to minimizing these have proven to be choice among technologies,
implementation and measurement of success. By utilizing these steps, such firms as the Frost
National Bank have excelled in call center management. The future remains uncertain, however,
as new technologies continue to emerge and competition becomes ever fiercer. Call centers are
nevertheless an aspect of many firms that managers must not overlook as they seek competitive
105
advantage and enhanced profits.
(Appears also in Section VII.)
10. Bakshi, Y., A.H. Diaz, K. Meier Hellstern, R.A. Milito and R. Skoog. Overload control in a
distributed system. Teletraffic Contributions for the Information Age. Proceedings of the 15th
International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-15. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997, 571–
582.
Abstract. A new algorithm for the joint call distribution and overload control in a distributed
environment is proposed and evaluated. The algorithm, which falls into the category of direct
adaptive control methods, integrates three mechanisms: (i) adaptive throttling; (ii) adaptive call
allocation; (iii) call routing. The throttling mechanism adjusts the arrival rejection rate to meet
performance requirements, the call allocation mechanism adaptively determines the fractions of
calls to be assigned to different nodes, and the call routing ensures the regularity of the routing
sequence that meets the allocated fractions (including the fraction of rejections).
Keywords: Overload control, Distributed system, Joint call distribution, Direct adaptive con-
trol methods, Adaptive throttling, Adaptive call allocation, Call routing, Arrival rejection rate,
Routing sequence, Distributed overload control
11. Gordon, J.J., K. Murti and A. Rayes. Overview of Internet traffic issues on the PSTN. Tele-
traffic Contributions for the Information Age. Proceedings of the 15th International Teletraffic
Congress, ITC-15. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1997, 643–652.
Abstract. Recent evidence indicates that Internet traffic is saturating the public switched
telephone network (PSTN). Methods must be developed to traffic-engineer and administer the
network so that an extensive range of data and voice services can be provided at reasonable
cost. Traffic engineering methods must determine the sufficient capacity to meet the anticipated
demand while meeting different grade-of-service (GoS) ob jectives, and ensure that the capacity
is not so excessive as to render network services uneconomical. In order to engineer and adminis-
ter the network effectively traffic engineers must recognize and deal with a variety of new traffic
characteristics and be able to evaluate their effects and the factors that affect them. This paper
addresses the impacts of Internet traffic on the PSTN. It includes an overview of the behavior of
the combined voice and data traffic such as long holding time distribution, call arrival patterns,
call retrials, peakedness and traffic variation, and engineering periods.
Keywords: Internet traffic, PSTN, Public switched telephone network, Data services, Voice
services, Traffic engineering, Capacity, Grade-of-service, Network services, Holding time distri-
bution, Call arrival patterns, Call retrials, Peakedness, Traffic variation
12. Xia, P. Knowledge discovery in integrated call centers: a framework for effective customer-driven
marketing. Proceedings of the Third International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data
Mining. AAAI Press, Menlo Park, CA, USA, 1997, 279–282.
Abstract. As call centers become more pervasive, the customers seek individualized service and
greater attention. The call centers are becoming the contact centers-a one-stop, single interface
106
for all interactions-from pre-sales to post-sales, and continuing relationship. The paper presents
some results in utilizing data mining in managing customer profile toward a greater business
advantage. One solution is to build a predictive customer profile based on the customer’s Life-
time Value (LTV). Many different types of data mining techniques can be combined to meet this
challenge. The paper explores the solution to using knowledge discovery methods in integrated
inbound/outbound call center environments. Significant performance gain is reported on a cus-
tomized knowledge acquisition system over a conventional approach.
Keywords: Knowledge discovery, Integrated call centers, Customer-driven marketing, Individual-
ized service, Contact centers, Continuing relationship, Data mining, Customer profile, Business
advantage, Predictive customer profile, Lifetime Value, Data mining techniques, Knowledge
discovery methods, Integrated inbound/outbound call center environments, Performance gain,
Customized knowledge acquisition system
13. Bauer, B. and C. Klein. A multi-agent solution for advanced call centers. Multiple Approaches
to Intelligent Systems, Proceedings. Lecture Notes in Artificial Intel ligence, 1611, 1999, 450–459.
Abstract. In the past few years, call centers have been introduced with great success by many
service-oriented enterprises such as banks and insurance companies. It is expected that this
growth will continue in the future and that call centers will be improved by adding new func-
tionality and by embedding call centers better into the workflow of a company. In this paper
we show how agent technology can help to realize goals. Agent-based approaches are becoming
more and more mature for applications distributed over networks, supporting (dynamic) work-
flow and integrating systems and services of different vendors. We show by a typical example of
a call center, the call center of a car rental agency, what the deficiencies of current call centers
are and how agents can help to improve this situation.
Keywords: Multi-agent systems, Advanced call centers, Service-oriented enterprises, Banks, In-
surance companies, Agent technology, Distributed applications, Workflow, Car rental agency
14. Brazier, F.M.T., C.M. Jonker, F.J. Jungen and J. Treur. Distributed scheduling to support a
call center: a cooperative multiagent approach, Applied Artificial Intel ligence, 13 (1–2), 1999,
65–90.
Abstract. This article describes a multi-agent system architecture to increase the value of
24-hour-a-day call center service. This system supports call centers in making appointments
with clients on the basis of knowledge of employees and their schedules. Relevant activities are
scheduled for employees in preparation of such appointments. The multi-agent system architec-
ture is based on principled design, using the compositional development method for DESIRE
multi-agent systems. To schedule procedures in which more than one employee is involved, each
employee is represented by its own personal assistant agent, and a work manager agent coor-
dinates the schedules of the personal assistant agents and clients through the call center. The
multi-agent system architecture has been applied to the banking domain, in cooperation with
and partially funded by the Rabobank.
Keywords: Distributed scheduling, 24-hour-a-day call center support, Cooperative multi-agent
approach, Client appointment-making, Employee knowledge, Employee schedule knowledge,
107
Principled design, Compositional development method, DESIRE, Personal assistant agent, Work
manager agent, Rabobank
15. Duxbury, D., R. Backhouse, M. Head, G. Lloyd and J. Pilkington. Call centres in BT UK
customer service, British Telecommunications Engineering, 18, 1999, 165–173.
Abstract. Call centres are a growing industry. In a recent Ovum Report it was estimated
that by 2000 5% of the working population in Europe would be employed in call centres. It
is also predicted that call-centre revenues globally will be $6 billion. Call centres have become
the core of the service economy in the UK. Counting part-timers, UK call centres currently
employ 1.7% of the working population, or nearly 400,000 people. And the numbers are growing.
Datamonitor predicts that call-centre positions will double by 2002 before beginning to level off.
Since 1994, customer calls to large organizations have roughly doubled, with call centres being
largely responsible.
BT UK is a leader in call-centre technology and expertise. It operates its own call centres and
manages them for other organizations. BT’s own call-centre operations fall into the two broad
categories of outbound and inbound. Outbound operations involve companies’ staff calling out
to customers, usually to offer new services, while inbound call centres handle enquiries from
customers. This article looks at how the inbound call centres are presently used in the following
environments, which between them are responsible for handling approximately 1 billion calls per
year:
• answering Operator Assistance enquiries (100, 155 and 999 emergency services),
• giving accurate number information (192 and 153 services),
• receiving sales and billing enquiries and taking orders (150), and
• taking fault reports from residential and business customers (151 and 154).
It does not consider some of the more specialist centres (for example, Welsh language, Directory
Enquiries for the blind and disabled) or inbound services and business after-sales units, although
these all form an important part of the BT Customer Service call-centre management operation.
The article explores ‘where we are now’ and in particular focuses on systems, switching and
queueing capabilities. Finally, it looks at the future of call centres and gives some indication of
the way things will change.
Keywords: Customer service, Call centres
(Appears also in Section VII.)
16. Hampe, J.F. Call centre: Technical and organisational challenges. In Human-Computer Interac-
tion: Communication, Cooperation, and Application Design, H.J. Bullinger and J. Ziegler (eds.),
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 1316–1320.
17. Ristimaki, T., T. Leino and P. Huuhtanen. Implementation of information technology in call
centers. In Human-Computer Interaction: Ergonomics and User Interfaces, H.J. Bullinger and
J. Ziegler (eds.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 6–10.
108
Abstract. In this paper the implementation of information technology is analyzed in two call
centres of a bank, which provide a variety of banking services by telephone to customers. It is
important to emphasize that call centre work is extremely intensive, using the latest information
and telecommunication technologies. In addition, the number of call centres is continuously
rising. This study aims to analyze some of the organizational and social factors during the im-
plementation process of a new information system (IS) in call centre work.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
18. Yannakopoulos, D., M. Ferretti and M. Schultz. Ob ject lessons learned from an intelligent agents
framework for telephony-based applications. Proceedings of Technology of Ob ject-Oriented Lan-
guages and Systems - TOOLS 30. IEEE Comput. Soc, Los Alamitos, CA, USA, 1999, 222–236.
Abstract. Contact Center-related activities, at the business level, are common regardless of
parent organizations or industries. The implementation of such activities is unlikely to change
throughout the lifetime of the Contact Center and therefore, it could be the basis (“framework”)
upon which customized solutions can be built. Specifying such a framework is mainly a busi-
ness rather than a technical problem. Programmers create “what” a system does while business
analysts determine “when” the system takes certain actions. Factors influencing the framework
architecture are the requirements for small, mobile, intelligent components, the ability for run-
time modifications, and a reasonable foreknowledge of the technology that will minimize risks.
We present a distributed, ob ject-oriented, telephony framework based on Intelligent Agents and
coupled with a rules engine. The goals are reuse, platform independence, support for a dis-
tributed environment, system scalability, and adherence to standards. The framework’s core is
an influence engine that accepts external stimuli and based on business rules, determines the re-
sulting actions. This engine is an intelligent agent that can be attached to any ob ject for which
intelligence is needed and thus, it is able to create an integrated, customizable solution. We
discuss our architectural decisions, limitations, design choices, and experiences in development,
customization, and operation of the framework. Tools and procedures used during implementa-
tion of specific solutions are also reported.
Keywords: Ob ject lessons, Intelligent agent framework, Telephony-based applications, Contact
Center-related activities, Parent organizations, Customized solutions, Business analysts, Frame-
work architecture, Small mobile intelligent components, Run-time modifications, Distributed
ob ject-oriented telephony framework, Rules engine, Platform independence, Distributed envi-
ronment, System scalability, Influence engine, External stimuli, Business rules, Integrated cus-
tomizable solution, Architectural decisions, Design choices
19. Boddy, D. Implementing interorganizational IT systems: lessons from a call centre pro ject, Jour-
nal of Information Technology, 15 (1), 2000, 29–37.
Abstract. The growing power of computer-telephony integration (CTI) systems is encouraging
many companies to create call centres. These deal with a growing range of business processes
and, in doing so, can be used to challenge established organizational arrangements. The range
of human and management issues that need to be dealt with has yet to become clear. Some
insights into these are offered from a study of one call centre over 2 years, from shortly before its
physical introduction to the present day. These empirical observations are set within the wider
109
literature on organizational change and information technology (IT), particularly the process-
ing and integrationist perspectives. The paper uses the evidence of the case to elaborate the
integrationist model so that it reflects the areas of human action more fully. It concludes by
outlining the implications of this perspective for managers seeking to build effective call centres
or other forms of interorganizational IT system.
Keywords: Interorganizational IT systems, Call centre pro ject, Computer telephony integration,
CTI systems, Business processes, Organizational arrangements, Management issues, Human is-
sues, Organizational change, Information technology, Integrationist perspective, Human action
(Appears also in Section IV.)
20. Bong, Ki Moon, Kyu Lee Jae and Jun Lee Kyoung. A next generation multimedia call center
for Internet commerce: IMC, Journal of Organizational Computing and Electronic Commerce,
10 (4), 2000, 227–240.
Abstract. Human assistance, as well as automated service, is necessary for providing more con-
venient services to customers in Internet-based commerce systems. Call centers have typically
been human-based service systems. However, the services of existing public switched telephone
network-based call centers are not enough to meet the needs of customers on the Internet. Most
of them have been designed without considering the interactions involved in shopping on the
Internet. In our research, we designed a call center named IMC (Internet-based Multimedia Call-
center) that can be integrated with an Internet shopping mall. It contains two parts: an Internet
multimedia dialogue system and a human-agent assisting system. The dialogue system is an In-
ternet and multimedia version of the interactive voice response service of computer-telephony
integration-based call centers, because it provides access to multimedia Web pages along with a
recorded voice explanation via the Internet. The human-agent assisting system aims to select the
most appropriate human agents in the call center and to support them in providing high-quality
individualized information for each customer. IMC is a real-time, human-embedded system that
can provide high-quality services cost-effectively for Internet commerce.
Keywords: Internet commerce, IMC, Human assistance, Automated service, Online shopping in-
teractions, Internet-based Multimedia Call-center, Internet shopping mall, Internet multimedia
dialogue system, Human-agent assisting system, Interactive voice response service, Computer-
telephony integration, Multimedia Web pages, Recorded voice explanation, Human-agent se-
lection, High-quality individualized customer information, Real-time human-embedded system,
High-quality services, Cost-effectiveness, Electronic commerce
(Appears also in Section VII.)
21. Burgess, Michelle. Ensuring call center quality: A case study. In Data Management Handbook,
Sanjiv Purba, editor. Boca Raton, Fl: Auerbach, 2000, p. 223.
22. Chan, C.W., L.L. Chen and L.Q. Geng. Knowledge engineering for an intelligent case-based
system for help desk operations, Expert Systems with Applications, 18 (2), 2000, 125–132.
Abstract. Help desks are computer-aided environments in customer support centers that pro-
vide frontline support to external and internal customers. The paper reports on an automated
110
help desk system developed at an information technology company. With the proliferation of
diverse software and hardware, the center provides support to a large variety of client systems.
The number of calls increases while the turnover rate of employees is high, which means the cost
of training escalates. The ob jective of this pro ject is to develop an automated case-based help
desk system to support both call center personnel and customers. The system would contribute
to shortening the response time on incoming calls and reduce training time for new employees.
The focus of the paper is on the knowledge engineering process of the system. We discuss in
detail the knowledge acquisition, knowledge representation, system implementation and verifica-
tion processes, and we emphasize the structured and automated development methods adopted.
Keywords: Knowledge engineering, Intelligent case-based system, Help desk operations, Computer-
aided environments, Customer support centers, Frontline support, External customers, Internal
customers, Automated help desk system, Information technology company, Client systems, Em-
ployee turnover rate, Automated case-based help desk system, Call center personnel, Response
time, Incoming calls, Training time, Knowledge engineering process, Knowledge acquisition,
Knowledge representation, System implementation, Verification processes, Automated develop-
ment methods
23. Cramp, D.G. and E.R. Carson. A model-based framework for public health: a vehicle for
maximising the value of telecare? Proceedings 2000 IEEE EMBS International Conference on
Information Technology Applications in Biomedicine. ITAB-ITIS 2000. Joint Meeting Third
IEEE EMBS International Conference on Information Technology Applications in Biomedicine
(ITAB’00). Third Workshop of the International Telemedical Information Society (ITIS’00).
IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 2000, 272–277.
Abstract. Information and communication technologies (ICT) play a pivotal role in enabling
health care provision, particularly in the light of changes in delivery mechanisms which empha-
sise the primary and community sectors and embrace substitution policies that include home
care, day care and call centres. However, the complexity of these systems means that it is dif-
ficult to determine the best ICT strategies to adopt in terms of efficiency and effectiveness. If
public health strategies are to be devised so as to maximise the benefits of advances such as those
in telemedicine and telecare, it is necessary to address the issues adopting an approach which
is holistic and which encapsulates all causal relationships and influences. Conceptual models
for such a systemic approach are developed using signed digraph and cybernetic feedback for-
malisms. The importance of addressing not only the needs of the population which are of public
health concern, but also the factors giving rise to such needs is emphasised. The implications of
this modelling approach are illustrated in the context of two telecare systems: home haemodial-
ysis and Web-based services for the management of diabetes.
Keywords: Model-based framework, Public health strategies, Telecare value maximization, In-
formation technology, Communication technology, Health care provision, Health care delivery
mechanisms, Primary care, Community health care, Substitution policies, Home care, Day care,
Call centres, Efficiency, Effectiveness, Telemedicine, Holistic approach, Causal relationships,
Influences, Conceptual models, Systemic approach, Signed digraph, Cybernetic feedback, Popu-
lation needs, Home haemodialysis, Worldwide Web-based services, Diabetes management
(Appears also in Section VII.)
111
24. Irish, C. Web-enabled call centre, BT Technology Journal, 18 (2), 2000, 65–71.
Abstract. Call centres using computer telephony integration are now the primary channel for
customer contact for many organisations. The roll-out of Internet access to an ever-increasing
proportion of the population is providing the opportunity to use new channels, such as the World
Wide Web, e-mail and others, to enhance the customer relationship. This paper explores the evo-
lution from telephony to Web-enabled call centre and the optimisation of self and assisted service.
25. Mitchell, K., K. Sohraby, A. Van de Liefvoort and J. Place. Approximation models of wireless
cellular networks using moment matching. Proceedings IEEE INFOCOM 2000. Conference on
Computer Communications. Nineteenth Annual Joint Conference of the IEEE Computer and
Communications Societies. IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 2000, 189–197.
Abstract. In this paper we present an analytical model for microcellular and picocellular
wireless networks for any arbitrary topology in a high-mobility environment. We introduce an
approximation technique which uses a single-cell decomposition analysis which incorporates mo-
ment matching of hand-off processes into the cell. The approximation technique is novel in that
it can provide close approximations for non-Poisson arrival traffic and it is easily parallelized.
Performance measures such as new calls blocked and hand-off calls lost are presented for any
general call arrival distribution in a non-homogeneous traffic environment. We produce some
numerical examples for some simple topologies with varying mobility for several call arrival dis-
tributions and compare our results to those from simulation studies.
Keywords: Approximation models, Moment matching, Microcellular wireless networks, Picocel-
lular wireless networks, Arbitrary topology, High-mobility environment, Single-cell decomposi-
tion analysis, Hand-off processes, Non-Poisson arrival traffic, Performance, Call blocking, Call
arrival distribution, Non-homogeneous traffic
26. Schmidt, H.W. and L.M. Wegner. Shared XML documents in service centers of the future.
Proceedings of the First International Conference on Web Information Systems Engineering
(Workshops). IEEE Comput. Soc, Los Alamitos, CA, USA, 2000, 105–112.
Abstract. Call centers are at the core of today’s customer relations management. Increasingly,
they are also utilized internally as competence and knowledge centers. Turning them into service
centers of the future (SCotF) requires parallel communication over several channels, including
Internet services, in a distributed synchronous fashion. In this paper, we show that the emerg-
ing XML standards provide a good basis for this type of interaction. In turning e-service into a
groupware application, we propose to apply a spatial awareness model to assist in the collabora-
tion. We demonstrate that it can be integrated into the XML/XSL-framework. The results are
compared with a previous solution, which applied proprietary tools. Questions of fidelity and a
critique of the existing standards and tools complement the practical results.
Keywords: Shared XML documents, Service centers, Call centers, Customer relations man-
agement, Internal utilization, Competence centers, Knowledge centers, Parallel communication,
Communication channels, Internet services, Distributed synchronous communication, XML stan-
dards, Electronic service, Groupware application, Spatial awareness model, Collaboration, XSL,
Fidelity, Future
112
27. Wang, Y., Q. Yang and Z. Zhang. Real-time scheduling for multi-agent call center automation.
Recent Advances in AI Planning. 5th European Conference on Planning, ECP’99. Proceedings
(Lecture Notes in Artificial Intel ligence, Vol. 1809). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 2000,
187–199.
Abstract. In a call center, service agents with different capabilities are available for solving
incoming customer problems at any time. To supply quick response and better problem solu-
tion to customers, it is necessary to schedule customer problems to appropriate service agents
efficiently. We developed SANet, a service agent network for call center, which integrates mul-
tiple service agents including both software agents and human agents, and employs a broker to
schedule customer problems to service agents for better solutions according to their changing
capabilities and availability. This paper describes the real-time scheduling method in SANet as
well as its architecture. There are two phases in our scheduling method. One is problem-type
learning. The broker is trained to learn the problem types and hence can decide the type of in-
coming problems automatically. The other is the scheduling algorithm based on problem types,
capabilities and availability of service agents. We highlight an application in which we apply
SANet to a call center problem for a cable-TV company. Finally, we support our claims via
experimental results and discuss related works.
Keywords: Real-time scheduling, Multi-agent call center automation, Service agents, Customer
problem scheduling, SANet, Service agent network, Multiple service agents, Software agents,
Human agents, Service agent capabilities, Service agent availability, Cable-TV company
28. Ballin, D. Been there, done that: a personalised mobile agent system for the next generation of
call centres. IEE Seminar Mobile Agents—Where Are They Going? IEE, London, UK, 2001,
3/1–11.
Abstract. The call centre industry is currently facing a dichotomy. The growth of call centres
is exploding worldwide, with an estimated 5% of all people in the UK expected to be employed
in one by year 2005. At the moment, the call centre is still central to the customer contact
strategies of most organisations, but the rules are being rewritten with the emergence of the so-
called ‘dot-com’ companies who regard the electronic channel as their principal interface with the
customer. If that was not problematic enough, customers’ expectations are growing, demanding
more choice, flexibility, easy navigation and greater intimacy. In this paper, we present the
Virtual Inhabited Call Centre (VICC), a novel Web-based call centre that leverages the power
of a mobile multi-agent architecture. VICC is not so much an attempt to develop a technology,
but about the potential of using a set of new technologies for the benefit of everyone.
29. Popovic, M. and V. Kovacevic. An approach to Internet-based virtual call center implementa-
tion. Proceedings of the First International Conference on Networking. Part I (Lecture Notes in
Computer Science, Vol. 2093). Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 2001, 75–84.
Abstract. The era of classical PBX-based call centers has passed. Those systems were propri-
etary and closed, i.e., with fixed functionality. Today, the Internet and multimedia applications
are becoming more and more popular across the world, and there is a lot of effort in both
113
academia and industry to build and deploy modern Internet-based call centers. This paper
should be viewed as a contribution to these efforts. It presents our approach to Internet-based
virtual call center implementation. In contrast to other efforts, we consider the virtual call center
as a universal infrastructure, which could be used as a telecommunication management network
center and as an intelligent network service control point, too. In the paper, we present our
concept, the most interesting implementation details and a pilot network configuration.
30. Wortman, V. The future of enterprise CTI, Business Communications Review, 31 (2), 2001,
46–49.
Abstract. The future of computer telephony integration (CTI) in the enterprise seems to de-
pend on the following: CTI functionality is required as today’s business increasingly revolves
around the contact center; the available technology is strong, with more functionality being
added every day; the most significant players are still around, many of them no longer indepen-
dent, but functioning as entities within powerful parents which are themselves committed to CTI
or whatever acronym it takes to support CRM; CTI implementations now in place will probably
continue to perform as required for the foreseeable future, augmented by modular add-ons that
will bridge the classic PBX/ACD installations and the new world of the WWW.
Keywords: Enterprise CTI, Computer telephony integration, Contact center, Modular add-ons,
PBX/ACD installations, WWW
31. Zitouni, I., H.K.J. Kuo and C.H. Lee. Natural language call routing: Towards combination and
boosting of classifiers. Proceedings of the 2001 IEEE Workshop on Automatic Speech Recogni-
tion and Understanding - ASRU 2001, 202–205.
Abstract. We describe different techniques to improve natural language call routing: boosting,
relevance feedback, discriminative training, and constrained minimization. Their common goal
is to reweigh the data in order to let the system focus on documents judged hard to classify by
a single classifier. These approaches are evaluated with the common vector-based classifier and
also with the beta classifier, which had given good results in the similar task of e-mail steering.
We explore ways of deriving and combining uncorrelated classifiers in order to improve accuracy.
Compared to the cosine and beta baseline classifiers, we report an improvement of 49% and 10%,
respectively.
32. Bernett, H.G., M.J. Fischer and D.M.B. Masi. Blended call center performance analysis, IT-
Professional, 4 (2), 2002, 33–38.
Abstract. The performance analysis of blended PSTN and IP call centers is likely to be in
demand in the near future as the technology for these centers develops further. The authors
did not find an analysis for a system of this type in the literature. The development of a user-
friendly and portable tool based on their analysis methodology should be useful to organizations
that have implemented, or are considering implementing, a blended call center. We have shown
BCAT’s wide range of skills-based routing to, for example, agents who can handle PSTN calls
only, IP calls only, or both call types. This is a much more complicated queueing problem to
model, but will provide increased flexibility to call center supervisors in terms of workforce man-
114
agement planning.
33. Foo, S., S.C. Hui and P.C. Leong. Web-based intelligent helpdesk support environment, Inter-
national Journal of Systems Science, 33 (6), 2002, 389–402.
Abstract. With the advent of Internet technology, it is now feasible to provide effective and
efficient helpdesk service over the global Internet to meet customers’ requirements and satisfac-
tion. In this research, we have designed and developed a Web-based intelligent helpdesk-support
environment, WebHotLine, to support the customer service centre of a large multinational corpo-
ration in the electronics industry. The paper describes the basic architecture of the environment
that supports the ma jor functions of Web-based fault information retrieval, online multilingual
translation capability, different operating modes of video-conferencing for enhanced support and
direct intelligent fault diagnosis by customers or customer support engineers. As a result, Web-
HotLine helps to save cost in eliminating the expensive overseas telephone charges, reduction
in machine down time and number of on-site visits by service engineers as in the traditional
helpdesk environment.
34. Fukunaga, A., E. Hamilton, J. Fama, D. Andre, O. Matan and I. Nourbakhsh. Staff scheduling
for inbound call centers and customer contact centers, AI Magazine, 23 (4), 2002, 30–40.
Abstract. The staff scheduling problem is a critical problem in the call center (or, more gen-
erally, customer contact center) industry. This article describes DIRECTOR, a staff scheduling
system for contact centers. DIRECTOR is a constraint-based system that uses AI search tech-
niques to generate schedules that satisfy and optimize a wide range of constraints and service-
quality metrics. DIRECTOR has successfully been deployed at more than 800 contact centers,
with significant measurable benefits, some of which are documented in case studies included in
this article.
35. Rossler, G. and T. Steinert. A flexible traffic generator for testing PABX and call center per-
formance. Testing of Comunicating Systems XIV - Application to Internet Technologies and
Services, IFIP-TC6/WG6.1, I. Schieferdecker, H. Konig and A. Wolisz (eds.), 2002, 139–147.
Abstract. Testing PABXs and call centers under high load is of paramount importance because
customers rely on these systems for safety and business critical applications. A traffic generator
for high traffic volumes is presented. The two key characteristics of the traffic generator are the
generation of traffic with configurable statistical properties and its flexibility in many aspects,
ranging from the number and kind of emulated users to the user behaviour models and signalling
protocols. This extraordinary flexibility could only be achieved by a pure software approach.
The architecture clearly separates the basic run-time system and support functions which are
implemented in the traffic generator core from user models and signalling protocols which the
traffic generator reads and executes during tests.
36. Suhm, B., J. Bers, D. McCarthy, B. Freeman, D. Getty, K. Godfrey and P. Peterson. A com-
parative study of speech in the call center: Natural language call routing vs. touch-tone menus.
CHI 2002 - Changing the World, Changing Ourselves, Proceedings of the Conference on Human
115
Factors in Computing Systems, L. Terveen, D. Wixon, E. Comstock and A. Sasse (eds.), 2002,
283–290.
Abstract. This paper presents a field study that compares natural language call routing with
standard touch-tone menus. Call routing is the task of getting callers to the right place in the
call centre, which could be the appropriate live agent or automated service. Natural language
call routing lets callers describe the reason for their call in their own words, instead of presenting
them with a list of menu options to select from using the telephone touch-tone keypad. The
field study was conducted in a call centre of a large telecommunication service provider. Results
show that with natural language call routing, more callers respond to the main routing prompt,
more callers are routed to a specific destination (instead of defaulting to a general operator who
may have to transfer them), and more callers are routed to the correct agent. The survey data
show that callers overwhelmingly prefer natural language call routing over standard touch-tone
manus. Furthermore, natural language call routing can also deliver significant cost savings to
all call centres.
Keywords: Comparison between dialogue modes, Menus, Natural language, Rating and prefer-
ences, Voice input devices
(Appears also in Section VI.)
37. Suhm, B. and P. Peterson. A data-driven methodology for evaluating and optimizing call center
IVRs, International Journal of Speech Technology, 5 (1), 2002, 23–37.
Abstract. The usability of many call-center IVRs (interactive voice response systems) is dis-
mal. Callers dislike touch-tone IVRs and seek human agent assistance at the first opportunity.
However, because of high agent costs, call center managers continue to seek automation with
IVRs. The challenge for call centers is providing user-friendly, yet cost-efficient, customer ser-
vice. This article describes a comprehensive methodology for usability reengineering of telephone
voice user interfaces based on detailed call center assessment and call-flow redesign. At the core
of our methodology is a data-driven IVR assessment, in which we analyze end-to-end recordings
of thousands of calls to evaluate IVR cost effectiveness and usability. Because agent time is the
ma jor cost driver in call center operations, we quantify cost-effectiveness in terms of the agent
time saved by automation in the IVR. We identify usability problems by carefully inspecting
user-path diagrams, a visual representation of the sequence of events of thousands of calls as
they flow through the IVR. Such an IVR assessment leads directly into call-flow redesign. As-
sessment insights lead to specific suggestions on how to improve a call-flow design. In addition,
the assessment enables us to estimate the cost savings of a new design, thus providing the neces-
sary business justification. We illustrate our IVR usability and reengineering methodology with
examples from large commercial call centers, demonstrating how the staged process maximizes
the payback for the call center while minimizing risk.
38. Cochinwala, M., N. Jackson, S. Hyong and E. Sigman. Adaptive resource management of a
virtual call center using a peer-to-peer approach, Managing It Al l, IFIP/IEEE, Eighth Interna-
tional Symposium on Integrated Network Management, Kluwer Academic Publishers, Norwell,
MA, USA, 2003, 425–437.
116
Abstract. As the number and diversity of end-user environments increase, services should be
able to dynamically adapt to available resources in a given environment. We present the con-
cepts of migratory services and peer-to-peer connections as the means of facilitating adaptive
service and resource management in distributed and heterogeneous environments. Our approach
has been realized using ob ject-oriented principles in an Adaptive Communicating Applications
Platform (ACAP). The architectural design and implementation of a real-life high-level service,
Virtual Call Center (VCC), are used to illustrate issues in adaptive service and management
issues and discuss in detail our approach in ACAP.
Keywords: Adaptive systems, Call centres, Distributed processing, Ob ject-oriented methods,
Telecommunication computing, Telecommunication network management
39. Kuo, H.K.J., O. Siohan and J.P. Olive. Advances in natural language call routing, Bel l Labs
Technical Journal, 7 (4), 2003, 155–170.
Abstract. The paper describes Bell Labs’ efforts in developing core technologies toward natural
language call routing (NLCR) applications. NLCR refers to technology allowing callers of a call
center to be automatically routed to their desired destination based on natural spoken responses
to an open-ended prompt, such as “How may I direct your call?”. Such services are expected to
replace interactive voice response (IVR) systems in the future, allowing a better experience for
the end user and cost savings for the call center. An NLCR system essentially combines several
key technologies, mainly automatic speech recognition (ASR) and topic identification. The role
of the ASR system is to convert the input utterance into the corresponding sequence of words.
The topic identification module then attempts to reproduce human categorization judgments in
order to route the caller to the requested destination, given the hypothesized (possibly partially
wrong) word sequence from the ASR system. The paper presents our recent advances in natural
language ASR and robust topic identification, focusing particularly on its data-driven aspect and
its portability. We also report experimental results from our field trials in the banking domain,
illustrating the maturity of the technology and its acceptance by end users, making it an enabler
of new revenue-generating services.
Keywords: Call centres, Classification, Interactive systems, Natural language interfaces, Speech
recognition, Speech-based user interfaces
40. Maass, S. Software support for interaction work in call centers. In Quality of Work and Products
in Enterprises of the Future, H. Strasser, K. Kluth, H. Rausch and H. Bubb (eds.), Ergonomia
Verlag, Stuttgart, Germany, 2003, 975–978.
Abstract. Call centres deliver a new kind of interactive service, but present software systems
are far from adequate in supporting this. Software development seems to be based on a reduced
understanding of call centre work and neglects the social component. Detailed work analysis re-
vealed new software requirements. It also showed the need for revised task analysis instruments.
(Appears also in Section VI.)
41. Qiang, Yang, Wang Yong, Zhang Zhong. SANet: A service-agent network for all center schedul-
ing, IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man & Cybernetics, Part A: Systems & Humans, 33 (3),
117
2003, 396–406.
Abstract. We consider a network of service-providing agents, where different agents have dif-
ferent capabilities, availability, and cost to solve problems. These characteristics are particularly
important in practice for semi-automated call centers which provide quality customer service
in real time. We have developed SANet, a service agent network for call center automation, to
serve as an experimental testbed for our research. SANet can select appropriate agents to provide
better solutions for customer problems according to the changing capabilities and availability of
service agents in the network. It can also add or delete appropriate agents to balance problem-
solving quality, efficiency, and cost according to the number and types of incoming customer
problems. On this network, each service agent can be a human service agent, an automated
software service agent, or a combination of the two. This paper describes the architecture, a
problem scheduling algorithm and an agent assignment algorithm on the SANet. We highlight
an application in which we apply SANet to a call-center scheduling problem for a cable TV com-
pany. Finally, we show the efficiency and adaptability of our system via experimental results
and discuss related works.
Keywords: Cable television, Call centres, Multi-agent systems, Problem-solving, Real-time sys-
tems
(Appears also in Section I.)
42. Huang, Qiang and S. Cox. Improving phoneme recognition of telephone quality speech, IEEE
International Conference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, 1, I-445–448, 2004.
Abstract. There are some speech understanding applications in which training transcriptions
are unavailable, and hence the vocabulary is unknown, but the task is to recognise key words
and phrases within an utterance rather than to attempt a complete accurate transcription. An
example of such a task is cal l-routing, when transcriptions of training utterances (which are very
expensive to produce) are unavailable. In such cases, phoneme rather than word recognition
is appropriate. However, phoneme recognition of spontaneous speech spoken by a large multi-
accented population over telephone connections is very inaccurate. To improve accuracy, we de-
scribe a technique in which we segment the waveform into subword-like units and use clustering
and an iteratively refined language model to correct the errors in the recognised phonemes. The
method was shown to work well on telephone quality spontaneous speech, raising the phoneme
accuracy from 28.1% after the first iteration to 47.3% after three iterations.
43. Williams, J.D. and S.M. Witt. A comparison of dialog strategies for call routing, International
Journal of Speech Technology, 7 (1), 9–24, 2004.
Abstract. Advances in commercially-available ASR technology have enabled the deployment
of “how-may-I-help-you?” interactions to automate call routing. While often preferred to menu-
based or directed dialog strategies, there is little quantitative research into the relationship among
prompt style, task completion, user preference/satisfaction, and domain. This work applies sev-
eral dialog strategies to two domains, drawing on both real callers and usability sub jects. We
find that longer greetings produce ligher levels of first-utterance routability. Further, we show
that a menu-based dialog strategy produces a uniformly high level of routability at the first
118
utterance in two domains, whereas an open-dialog approach varies significantly with domain.
In a domain where users lack an expectation of task structure, users are most successful with a
directed strategy for which preference scores are highest, even though it does not result in the
shortest dialogs. Callers rarely provide more than one piece of information in their responses to
all types of dialog strategies. Finally, a structured dialog repair prompt is most helpful to callers
who were greeted with an open prompt, and least helpful to callers who were greeted with a
structure prompt.
119
VI Human Interface, Industrial Engineering
1. Hoekstra, Edward J., Joseph Hurrell, Naomi G. Swanson and Allison Tepper. Ergonomic job
task, and psychosocial risk factors for work-related musculoskeletal disorders among teleservice
center representatives, International Journal of Human Computer Interaction, 8 (4), 1996, 421–
431.
Abstract. Evaluated the association between work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WRMDs)
and work conditions, perceived exhaustion, job dissatisfaction, and job-stress issues at two tele-
service centers (TSCs). One facility had upgraded workstation furniture while the other did not
have such ergonomic upgrades. A questionnaire survey among 114 teleservice representatives
and an ergonomic evaluation were conducted to determine WRMDs and their risk factors. A
high prevalence of symptoms was found at both TSCs. Suboptimal ergonomic conditions were
associated with neck, shoulder, elbow, and back WRMDs, as well as with increased job dissatis-
faction. Perceived increased workload variability and lack of job control were associated with the
occurrence of neck and back WRMDs, respectively. WRMDs were more frequently reported by
Ss at the center with older furniture and suboptimal ergonomic conditions. Authors suggest that
WRMDs may be prevented by improving ergonomic conditions at workstations and addressing
work-organization elements.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
2. Millard, N., L. Hole and S. Crowle. From command to control: Interface design for customer
handling systems. In Human-Computer Interaction INTERACT ’97, S. Howard, J. Hammond
and G. Lindgaard (eds.), Chapman & Hall, London, 1997, 296–300.
Abstract. This paper describes an interface design activity which focuses on the tasks per-
formed by call centre advisors. The advisors’ work is supported by a large database, which
offers them a command line interface. Contextual observation revealed that more effort was
needed to interrogate the database than to communicate with the customers. A subset of ad-
visors’ tasks was used to provide scenarios for the design of a 2D/3D graphical user interface,
which was prototyped in Macromind Director and evaluated by a user group. Initial feedback
indicates that the design metaphor and dialogue style have the potential to radically improve
the advisors’ interaction with the system.
3. Liddle, R.J. Usability testing of a call center application: The importance and necessity of using
scenario-driving scripts. Proceedings of the Silicon Valley Ergonomics Conference and Exposi-
tion - ErgoCon ’98, Palo Alto, California, 1998, 31–32.
Abstract. The unique methodologies and logistics required for usability testing of a customer-
driven call centre are described. In a call centre environment, the tasks of the Customer Service
Representatives (CSRs) are driven by outside sources and events. This requires the usability
test team to develop scripts for role-playing callers to use when conducting the tests.
4. Baumann, K. Matrix evaluation method for planned usability improvements based on customer
feedback. In Human-Computer Interaction: Ergonomics and User Interfaces, H.J. Bullinger and
120
J. Ziegler (eds.). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 701–705.
Abstract. The matrix evaluation method described here is based on information about cus-
tomers’ usability problems gathered in a call centre. Call centre data can provide information on
‘usual’ usability problems having as root cause the insufficient consideration of usability princi-
ples during development. Usability principles include self-descriptiveness, consistency, simplicity,
compatibility, error tolerance, and feedback. More than this, call centres for telecommunication
products can help detecting usability problems that arise during installation and setup of the
product, connecting it properly to other devices, and registering for services and accounts.
5. Coffman, S. and M.L. Saxton. Staffing the reference desk in the largely-digital library, Reference
Librarian, 66, 1999, 141–161.
Abstract. The article examines how a centralized, networked reference service might improve
efficiency and reduce costs by addressing two long-standing and seemingly intractable problems
associated with the reference process: that librarians spend only a small portion of their time at
the reference desk actually answering questions, and that many of the questions they do answer
could be handled by paraprofessionals. The authors explore the feasibility of a live, centralized,
networked reference service in a library setting by comparing traditional reference services at the
County of Los Angeles Public Library with a commercial inbound call center designed to handle
the same volume of questions. Applying Erlang C, the standard algorithm used to calculate
staffing requirements for commercial call centers, the authors find that a networked reference
service based on a call center model could reduce the reference staff requirements at the County
of Los Angeles Public Library by 42% or more. These results are very preliminary, and the
article cautions against jumping to conclusions until we have much better data on the questions
we are answering and the reference process as a whole, but the evidence we do have suggests
that networked reference services have the potential to truly revolutionize the way we have been
doing reference for the past 100 years.
Keywords: Reference desk staff, Largely digital library, Networked reference service, Intractable
problems, Reference process, Librarians, Paraprofessionals, Library setting, Traditional refer-
ence services, County of Los Angeles Public Library, Commercial inbound call center, Erlang-C,
Standard algorithm, Staffing requirements, Call center model, Reference staff requirements
(Appears also in Sections I and IV.)
6. Grundel, C. and M. Schneider-Hufschmidt. A Direct manipulation user interface for the con-
trol of communication processes—making call handling manageable. Proceedings of the 17th
International Symposium on Human Factors in Telecommunication, Copenhagen, Denmark. L.
Elstrom (ed.), 1999, 113–121. Appears also in Human-Computer Interaction: Communication,
Cooperation, and Application Design, H.J. Bullinger and J. Ziegler (eds.), Lawrence Erlbaum
Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 8–13.
Abstract. With the advent of a multitude of devices integrating information and communica-
tion technology, the support of communication functionality with screen-based devices becomes
more and more important. Scalable user interfaces that are applicable on a large variety of these
devices, from the PC to small handheld personal digital assistants, make communication trans-
121
parent to the users of these devices. Instead of having to learn the basics of telecommunication
over and over for each device the users can transfer their knowledge between these devices. The
authors developed a user interface for screen-based telephony applications (the Communication
Circle) which combines the advantages of direct manipulation with an intuitive metaphor for
setting up and controlling synchronous communication processes. In the Communication Circle
environment, tasks like call swapping, transfer, or the control of conference calls can be done in
an almost self-explanatory manner. This report describes the basic concepts of the approach and
the state of the development, and discusses results of usability studies and future developments
of the system.
7. Hampe, J.F. Call centre: technical and organisational challenges. Human-Computer Interaction:
Ergonomics and User Interfaces. Proceedings of HCI International ’99 (8th International Con-
ference on Human-Computer Interaction). Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ, USA,
1999, 1316–1320.
Abstract. Following a period of significant growth in the conventional call centre market in
Europe, a new phase in technological development is emerging, bringing with it complex chal-
lenges for call centre architects. The call centres are being upgraded to communication centres
by integrating additional media channels. First we must mention the standard Internet messag-
ing communication streams, these are mainly standard based email but increasingly all types of
web forms or inbound fax files. At the same time the first web enabled call centres are being
set up and operating, allowing for voice over IP connections and conferencing. This leads us to
the notion of customer coaching, sometimes also referred to, by other authors, as ‘one to one
marketing’, although the latter might be regarded as a much more general approach. Effectively
this technical set up offers simultaneous phone conversation and joint web browsing between cus-
tomer and agent. Beside this technical evolution it seems most relevant to study the necessary
redesign of the communication centre agent software, especially customer management software
etc. Therefore, the primary goal is integration into carefully redesigned workflows and user in-
terfaces, resulting in a transparent, time synchronised customer interaction database, allowing
us to improve future customer service. Simultaneously we are observing various difficulties for
an adequate personnel recruiting process for communication centre agents as the traditional
qualification patterns of call centre agents are no longer sufficient. The much broader palette of
tasks to be handled by the new type of agents must also result in a reconsideration of personnel
planning schemes and underlying assumptions on the work process.
Keywords: Call centre, Organisational challenges, Technical challenges, Technological develop-
ment, Communication centres, Internet messaging communication streams, Inbound fax files,
Conferencing, Web-browsing, Workflows, User interfaces
(Appears also in Section IV.)
8. Isic, A., C. Dormann, and D. Zapf. Stressors and resources of call centre jobs, Zeitschrift fur
Arbeitswissenschaft, 53 (3), 1999, 202–208.
Abstract. Call centres are one of the booming branches in the service sector. In this study, the
working conditions of 250 call centre employees whose jobs mainly consisted of calling or being
called by customers were analyzed. In comparison with two samples of administrative office
122
workers and bank employees, call centre employees turned out to have very low task-related
and time-related job control. In particular, this was the case for inbound jobs (customers were
calling only) in comparison to jobs with in- and outbound (employees being called and actively
calling customers). Moreover, task- and time-related control were particularly low when the
average call time was low. Compared with the other samples, psychosomatic complaints were
significantly higher among call centre employees.
9. Menzel, D. New design solution for call centre work places from the point of view of a furniture
manufacturer. In Human-Computer Interaction: Communication, Cooperation, and Application
Design, H.J. Bullinger and J. Ziegler (eds.), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jer-
sey, 1999, 1327–1331.
10. Rothe, H.J., A.M. Metz and M. Degener. Mental load of call center agents. In Human-Computer
Interaction: Communication, Cooperation, and Application Design, H.J. Bullinger and J. Ziegler
(eds.), Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, New Jersey, 1999, 1321–1326.
11. Settle, R.B., T.W. Dillon and P.L. Alreck. Acceptance of the phone-based interface for auto-
mated call direction, Behaviour & Information Technology, 18 (2), 1999, 97–107.
Abstract. A survey of 800 adults from the general population was performed to measure public
attitudes and reactions toward the phone-based interface for automated call direction (ACD).
Attitude, image, calling frequency, behavioural reaction, and demographic data were collected.
Results indicate that organizations designing menus for ACD should not anticipate positive re-
actions from outside callers. Three recommendations can be made from this study: consider the
effects on outside callers; minimize the breadth of the menu; and have human operators available.
12. Spiessbach, B., M. Knebelau and S. Bender. Call centre—bearer of hope or strain?. Ergonomics
in Medicine, 23 (6), 1999, 246–253.
Abstract. Strain and stress are with us in everyday life. Occupational medicine tries to prevent
the strain and to minimize stress as much as possible in the primary and secondary sectors of
national economy. Strain and stress as well as occupational diseases are well-known and their oc-
currence can be prevented by appropriate measures. But as the tertiary sector gains importance,
more and more employees are working in the information and service sectors and fewer and fewer
in production. This change in the structure of employment causes far-reaching consequences for
many employees with regard to working hours, organization of work and occupational strain.
The classical factors of strain such as noise, heavy labour and hazardous materials have given way
to psychological factors of strain such as pressure of time or pressure due to control, competition
or responsibility, helplessness with respect to technology, or one-sided forms of communication.
This holds true, for example, for a branch which is booming more and more—the call centre.
Up to now, the consequences caused by these new workplaces have not been studied sufficiently.
Without doubt there is still need for further research, and an inspection of workplaces (analy-
sis of occupational hazards) preferably carried out by an inter-disciplinary team is a matter of
urgent necessity. Further, preventive measures such as training and aptitude tests, introduction
123
to stress and time management connected with relaxation training are to be recommended.
13. Tudor, L. Calling for design, Ergonomics in Design, 7 (3), 1999, 16–19.
Abstract. User-centred design reveals preferences for appearance and functionality in call cen-
tre operators’ equipment.
Keywords: Comparison between input devices, Approaches to equipment testing, Labelling and
headings, One-handed keyboards, Ratings and preferences, Tracker ball and mouse, Voice input
devices, Voice output and speech synthesis
14. Bagnara, S., F. Gabrielli and P. Marti. Human work in call centres. Ergonomics for the New
Millennium. Proceedings of the XIVth Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics As-
sociation and 44th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, San Diego,
California, USA, Vol. 1, 2000, 553–556.
Abstract. Many people are currently working in call centres and many more are expected to
work in them in the near future. Call centres are in a sense ‘modern factories’ where services
are delivered through information and communication technologies. This paper describes the
technological evolution and discusses some aspects of human and work organisation in call cen-
tres. The final part of the paper focuses on a crucial issue commonly faced in call centres: the
building up of organisational memories.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
15. Ho, W., E. Marshall and J. Crosbie. The extent of keying, mouse use and writing by customer
service officers in one call centre. Ergonomics for Life: At Work, Home and Leisure. Proceed-
ings of the 36th Annual Conference of the Ergonomics Society of Australia, Adelaide, South
Australia. V. Blewett (ed.)., Ergonomics Society of Australia, Downer, ACT, Australia, 2000,
38–39.
Abstract. Stress has been reported as a health issue in call centre operations in Australia and
North America. Stressors were attributed to telephone monitoring system and call pressure.
Workers’ compensation claims in the call centre under study indicate differently. The incidence
of workers’ compensation claims between 1 July 1997 and 28 February 1999 were 171 per 1000
employees while the regional average was 101. The most frequent injury reported in the same
period was sprain and strain while the causal agent was computer equipment. In the call centre
under study, staff handle 50–70 calls during an average day. As there was a lack of documented
evidence on how much time was spent on keyboarding, mouse use and writing, the aim of this
study was to map the nature and duration of upper limb activity of customer service officers in
a call centre work environment.
16. Sznelwar, L.I., M. Zilbovicius and R.F.R. Soares. The structure of tasks at ‘call centers’: Con-
trol and learning difficulties. Ergonomics for the New Millennium. Proceedings of the XIVth
Triennial Congress of the International Ergonomics Association and 44th Annual Meeting of the
Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, San Diego, California, USA, Vol. 2, 2000, 547–550.
124
Abstract. The organizational structures of call centres are based on standardized and rigor-
ously controlled tasks. This paper, based on studies in companies located in Sao Paulo, Brazil,
during the 1990s, discusses the difficulties of learning and work-related anxieties present in these
types of organization.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
17. Benninghoven, A. Working conditions in call centers: Successful and healthy. WWDU 2002 -
World Wide Work. Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific Conference on Work with
Display Units, H. Luczak, A.E. Cakir and G. Cakir (eds.), Ergonomic Institut fur Arbeits- und
Sozialforschung, Forschungsgesellschaft mbH, Berlin, 2002, 188–189.
Abstract. Successful and healthy work is determined by many factors, which can be condensed
into four main topics: equipment (software ergonomics, hardware ergonomics, office equipment),
work environment (acoustics, climate, office design), work organization (working tasks, work-
flow, work structure) and employees (resources, qualification, training). The main problems in
the field of working environment and equipment are: 1) climate: it is too warm or too cold, the
air has an insufficient quality; 2) ergonomics: unhealthy postures often must be adopted while
working; 3) acoustics: the noise level is often too high, the audibility is bad; 4) office design: the
workspace is often not sufficient; and 5) light: it is too light or too dark, there is too much glare
(blinding).
Keywords: Workstation design, General environment, General workplace design and buildings
18. Bushey, R.R., K.M. Joseph and J.M. Martin. Design approach does affect customer behavior:
“Action-Ob jects” increase “Cut-Throughs”, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics
Society 46th Annual Meeting, Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA, USA,
2002, 578–582.
Abstract. This paper investigates the impact of touch-tone IVR design styles on user behavior.
The design of the touch-tone IVR systems is a critical component of delivering customer service.
A well-designed system allows the customers to accomplish their goals and sets a positive tone
to their interaction with the organization. Four design styles were considered: Action-Specific
Ob ject, Action-General Ob ject, Specific Ob ject, and General Ob ject. Three user behaviors were
considered: Cut-Through, Full Menu, and Beyond Full Menu. A usability study was conducted
to quantify the impact of design styles on user behavior. Results indicate that design style
does impact user behavior. The Action-Specific Ob ject style produced the most Cut-Through
behaviors and the fewest Beyond Full Menu behaviors compared to the other design styles. The
results from this paper suggest that the interface design style should match the customer’s men-
tal model.
Keywords: Call centers
19. Ferreira Jr., Mario and Paulo H.N. Saldiva. Computer-telephone interactive tasks: Predictors
of musculoskeletal disorders according to work analysis and workers’ perception, Applied Er-
gonomics, 33 (2), 2002, 147–153.
125
Abstract. Sixty-two workers engaged in computer-telephone interactive tasks in an active tele-
marketing center and a telephone call center of an international bank subsidiary in Sao Paulo,
Brazil, were assessed by means of a work analysis and a self-administered questionnaire aiming
to determine the statistical relationship of ergonomic, organizational and psychosocial character-
istics of their jobs with the report of symptoms in neck-shoulder and hand-wrist for more than
seven consecutive days and any time from work during the current job due to musculoskeletal
disorders (MSD).
Keywords: Ergonomics, Occupational accidents, Perceptions, Telemarketing, Call centers
20. Matthews, G. and S. Falconer. Personality, coping and task-induced stress in customer service
personnel, Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, 46th Annual Meeting,
Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Santa Monica, CA, USA, 2002, 963–967.
Abstract. This study investigated predictors of stress responses in customer service personnel
working for a ma jor telecommunications company. Ninety-one participants performed a simu-
lation of their work task. They were presented with telephone inquiries, and tested for their
knowledge of the correct response. Several findings of a previous study (Matthews and Falconer,
2000) were replicated. Performing the task appeared to be intrinsically stressful, as evidenced
by a large magnitude increase in sub jective distress. Individual differences in stress state were
related to strategy for coping with task demands. The ‘big five’ personality traits were com-
pared with measures of dispositional coping style as predictors of sub jective stress state. Coping
measures added significantly to the variance in stress state explained by the big five. Emotion-
focused strategies such as self-criticism appeared to be especially damaging in the customer
service context. Coping measures might be used by organizations to select operators likely to
be resistant to task-induced stress.
Keywords: Behavioral sciences computing, Call centres, Human factors, Marketing, Personnel,
Psychology
(Appears also in Section IV.)
21. Schweer, R. and A. Genz. Demands on call center agents—Results and solutions. WWDU
2002—World Wide Work. Proceedings of the 6th International Scientific Conference on Work
with Display Units, H. Luczak, A.E. Cakir and G. Cakir (eds.), Ergonomic Institut fur Arbeits-
und Sozialforschung, Forschungsgesellschaft mbH, Berlin, 2002, 190–192.
Abstract. Call centres as an organizational form are determined by a high degree of differen-
tiation. This is not only meant in terms of differentiation between in-house call centres, which
are created as part of already existing enterprises, and external service providers which have to
cope with the free market. Stress and strain for call handlers are strongly dependent on the
characteristics of the working tasks that have to be carried out. CCall has investigated the men-
tal workloads in more than 60 call centres with more than 6000 call handlers. It was found that
the determinants for healthy work in general were the heavy mental workload and especially the
limited task variety. One significant indicator for healthy working conditions is the proportion of
call handling in relation to the working time. With examples from practice, the most important
types of workload in call centres are presented. Proposals for effective solutions of good practice
are given.
126
Keywords: Work organization and sociotechnical systems, Workload demands
22. Suhm, B., J. Bers, D. McCarthy, B. Freeman, D. Getty, K. Godfrey and P. Peterson. A com-
parative study of speech in the call center: Natural language call routing vs. touch-tone menus.
CHI 2002 - Changing the World, Changing Ourselves, Proceedings of the Conference on Human
Factors in Computing Systems, L. Terveen, D. Wixon, E. Comstock and A. Sasse (eds.), 2002,
283–290.
Abstract. This paper presents a field study that compares natural language call routing with
standard touch-tone menus. Call routing is the task of getting callers to the right place in the
call centre, which could be the appropriate live agent or automated service. Natural language
call routing lets callers describe the reason for their call in their own words, instead of presenting
them with a list of menu options to select from using the telephone touch-tone keypad. The
field study was conducted in a call centre of a large telecommunication service provider. Results
show that with natural language call routing, more callers respond to the main routing prompt,
more callers are routed to a specific destination (instead of defaulting to a general operator who
may have to transfer them), and more callers are routed to the correct agent. The survey data
show that callers overwhelmingly prefer natural language call routing over standard touch-tone
manus. Furthermore, natural language call routing can also deliver significant cost savings to
all call centres.
Keywords: Comparison between dialogue modes, Menus, Natural language, Rating and prefer-
ences, Voice input devices
(Appears also in Section V.)
23. Das, Amit. Knowledge and productivity in technical support work, Management Science, 49
(4), 2003, 416–431.
Abstract. In this paper, we examine the process of technical support work and the role of
knowledge in enhancing the productivity of such work. We develop the concepts of problem-
solving tasks and moves to describe technical support work, while using call resolution time and
problem escalation as measures of productivity. Using hierarchical log-linear modeling, we es-
tablish the link between problem-solving moves and productivity. We find that the mix of moves
exercised in techical support strongly depends on the formulation of tasks by those requesting
support. Because the formulation of tasks is performed by users, knowledge management initia-
tives must target users as well as support providers to have the desired impact on productivity.
Keywords: Customer satisfaction, Personnel, Sales, Marketing, Competition, Mathematical
models, Information management, Problem solving, Cognitive systems
24. Folcher, Viviane. Appropriating artifacts as instruments: When design-for-use meets design-in-
use, Interacting with Computers, 15 (5), 2003, 647–663.
Abstract. This article discusses the use of artifacts as an instrument-mediated activity based
on a field study in a call center specialized in networks and telecommunications. In this work
setting, operators have access to a knowledge-sharing database, which is designed to support
127
the collective elaboration of individual knowledge diffused on hot-lines in an instrument as a
means for the collective activity. We characterize this situation along two interrelated analytical
dimensions: the design-in-use process by analyzing operators’ activities—hot-line assistance and
knowledge base appropriation; the design-for-use process by analyzing the design assumptions
inscribed in the artifact developed by designers.
Main results showed that the experts’ dialogue-conducting strategies are based on the intrinsic
complexity of the questions. The problems are co-elaborated in the course of action by the
expert and the caller, and constituted as a domain of problems organized by one or more spe-
cific problems. This progressive elaboration aims at elucidating the problem situation implicitly
contained in the initial request. Two individual instruments were developed within the shared
database. Both of them showed transformation of the artifact structure. Moreover, a relation
between the organized forms of hot-line assistance activity and the forms and functions of the
instruments designed is identified: It may be fully or partially reciprocally congruent. These
empirical results are discussed while opposing the ‘design-in-use’ criteria developed by the oper-
ators to the ‘design-for-use’ criteria built up by the actors of institutional design. In conclusion,
we emphasize points to consider in order to support further reflection on relations between use
and design in an anthropocentric perspective.
Keywords: Instrumented-mediated activity, Hot-line assistance, Design-for-use, Design-in-use,
Instrumental genesis
25. Halford, Victoria and H. Harvey Cohen. Technology use and psychosocial factors in the self-
reporting of musculoskeletal disorder symptoms in call center workers, Journal of Safety Re-
search, 34 (2), 2003, 167–173.
Abstract. Evidence exists to suggest that working with computer terminals and keyboards is as-
sociated with the development and exacerbation of a range of musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs).
Research has suggested that psychosocial factors may be of more importance than computer
use factors in the development of MSDs in the computing workplace. A questionnaire-based
study was undertaken to test this hypothesis in a sample of 67 call center workers. A Spear-
man’s rho was performed on the data, as well as Chi-sup-2 tests on the individual variables.
It was found that overall, computer use factors were significantly associated with self-reporting
of MSD symptoms, whereas psychosocial factors had no such association. However, certain in-
dividual psychosocial factors emerged as having a significant association with MSD symptoms.
The findings suggest that specific areas of call center work have associations with poor worker
health and possible long-term MSD problems. These areas appear to be workload and particu-
lar management-worker relations, rather than computer use. This suggests that the relationship
among computer use, psychosocial factors, and MSD is a complex area that would benefit from
more research.
26. Maass, S. Software support for interaction work in call centers. In Quality of Work and Products
in Enterprises of the Future, H. Strasser, K. Kluth, H. Rausch and H. Bubb (eds.), Ergonomia
Verlag, Stuttgart, Germany, 2003, 975–978.
Abstract. Call centres deliver a new kind of interactive service, but present software systems
are far from adequate in supporting this. Software development seems to be based on a reduced
128
understanding of call centre work and neglects the social component. Detailed work analysis re-
vealed new software requirements. It also showed the need for revised task analysis instruments.
(Appears also in Section V.)
27. Pregnolato, F. Call center—a participatory office. In Quality of Work and Products in Enter-
prises of the Future, H. Strasser, K. Kluth, H. Rausch and H. Bubb (eds.), Ergonomia Verlag,
Stuttgart, Germany, 2003, 633–636.
Abstract. This study of a call centre layout had the following goals: To act in real time on the
environmental quality with regard to effective use of space, performers’ well-being and company
evolution, to single out a unitary model for all local offices. On the basis of direct experience
of performance, daily full immersion in activities, interviews and naturalistic observations, the
model worked out is an ‘interaction’ structure of basic spaces and services, which promotes high
relational continuity and compatibility among user needs, activities, organization and ergonomics
standards: A participatory office based on a modular structure that gives equilibrium to work
environments characterised by high degrees of entropy.
28. Sheeder, Tony and Jennifer Balogh. Say it like you mean it: Priming for structure in caller
responses to a spoken dialog system, International Journal of Speech Technology, 6 (2), 2003,
103–111.
Abstract. In this paper, we report results of a study undertaken to evaluate the initial prompts
of ‘open prompt’ style call-routing applications. Specifically, we examined how placement and
phrasing of examples in the initial query affected caller responses and routing success. We looked
at the comparative effectiveness of placing examples before and after the initial query and of
phrasing these examples such that they promoted either a succinct structure in the form of a
keyword or phrase, or a more complex but natural structure in the form of a question or state-
ment. Findings indicate that examples encouraging a more natural structure, when presented
prior to the initial query, result in significantly improved routing performance. We discuss this
result in the context of using initial prompts to prime for desired structure in caller responses.
Keywords: Call routing, Call Steering, Natural language, Prompting, Dialog strategy
(Appears also in Section III.)
29. Smith, M.J. and A.D. Bayehi. Do Ergonomics Improvements Increase Computer Workers’ Pro-
ductivity? An Intervention Study in a Call Centre, Ergonomics, 46 (1–3), 2003, 3–18.
Abstract. This paper examines whether improving physical ergonomics working conditions
affects worker productivity in a call centre with computer-intensive work. A field study was con-
ducted at a catalogue retail service organization to explore the impact of ergonomics improve-
ments on worker production. There were three levels of ergonomics interventions, each adding
incrementally to the previous one. The first level was ergonomics training for all computer users
accompanied by workstation ergonomics analysis leading to specific customized adjustments to
better fit each worker (Group C). The second level added specific workstation accessories to
improve the worker fit if the ergonomics analysis indicated a need for them (Group B). The
third level met Group B requirements plus an improved chair (Group A). The findings showed
129
that worker performance increased for 50% of the ergonomics improvement participants and
decreased for 50%. Overall, there was a 4.8% output increase for the ergonomics improvement
group as compared to a 3.46% output decrease for the control group. The level of productivity
increase varied by the type of the ergonomics improvement with Group C showing the best
improvement (9.43%). Even though the average production improved, caution must be used in
interpreting the findings since the ergonomics interventions were not successful for one-half of
the participants.
Keywords: Evaluation and cost benefit of change, Education in ergonomics, Output and pro-
ductivity, Seating, Supplementary equipment, Workstation design
30. Timm, E., T. Arendt and R. Wieland. Optimising communication in call centres. In Quality of
Work and Products in Enterprises of the Future, H. Strasser, K. Kluth, H. Rausch and H. Bubb
(eds.), Ergonomia Verlag, Stuttgart, Germany, 2003, 1045–1048.
Abstract. Recent research in call centres indicates that call centre workplaces comprise special
task and organizational characteristics that are associated with increased workload and strain
potential. To reduce strain and stress during work—especially deriving from customer-employee
interaction—a professional communication training programme was developed in close cooper-
ation with an in-house call centre. The training concept consists of different modules that are
adjusted to workplace characteristics and agents’ cognitive and emotional requirements.
31. Parthasarathy, S. Experiments in keypad-aided spelling recognition, IEEE International Con-
ference on Acoustics, Speech, and Signal Processing, 1, I-873–876, 2004.
Abstract. Accurate recognition of speelings is necessary in many call-center applications.
Recognition of spellings over the telephone is inherently a difficult task and achieving very
low error rates, using ??
130
VII Management Models
1. Malone, T.W. Modeling coordination in organizations and markets, Management Science, 33
(10), 1987, 1317–1332.
Abstract. This paper describes a simple set of coordination structures that model certain
kinds of information processing involved in organizations and markets. Four generic coordi-
nation structures are defined: product hierarchies, functional hierarchies, centralized markets,
and decentralized markets. Then tradeoffs among these structures are analyzed in terms of
production costs, coordination costs, and vulnerability costs. This model is unusual in that it
includes detailed definitions of the structures at a micro-level and mathematical derivations of
comparisons among them at a macro-level. In the final section of the paper, several connections
are made between these formal results and previous work on organizational design.
Keywords: Organizational structure, Organization design, Coordination, Information processing
2. Andrews, Bruce H. and Henry L. Parsons. L.L. Bean chooses a telephone agent scheduling sys-
tem, Interfaces, 19 (6), 1989, 1–9.
Abstract. Concerns the development for mail order company L.L. Bean of a computerized
procedure for selecting complex large-scale telephone-operator scheduling systems. To assess
capability in forecasting work load, setting requisite capacity levels, and generating satisfactory
work-shift schedules, cost/benefit analysis was used and the expected penalty costs of lost orders
due to understaffing and loaded-wage costs of overstaffing were considered. Queuing theory was
used to model customer-call behavior for every hour over 24-hour days, seven days per week, and
the results of linear regression, which correlated customer-service level with expected customer
abandonment rate, were implemented to estimate the impact on order revenues of telephone-
service level.
Keywords: Work load forecasting, Queueing theory, Telephone agent scheduling system, Mail-
order company, L.L. Bean, Computerized procedure, Complex large-scale telephone opera-
tor scheduling systems, Capacity levels, Work shift schedules, Cost-benefit analysis, Expected
penalty costs, Understaffing, Loaded wage costs, Overstaffing, Linear regression
(Appears also in Section I.)
3. Adler, M. and E. Simoudis. Cooperation and coordination in help desk organizations. Proceed-
ings of the 11th International Workshop on DAI, Glen Arbor, MI, 1992.
Abstract. A help desk is an organization that consists of support engineers who provide “over
the phone” service support for a company’s products and services. The goal of the support
engineers is to cooperate in order to help the calling customer to recover from a failure or to
provide assistance by answering a customer’s request. Help desks are organized by the particular
product or service they support, or the product’s type. The support engineers for a particular
help desk are organized hierarchically, with novice engineers at the low levels of this hierarchy
and experts at the highest levels. The inter- and intra-structure of help desks and the interac-
tions between their staffers make them interesting from the Distributed AI (DAI) perspective. In
this paper we examine the structure of help desks in detail, describe where and how information
131
and knowledge flow in such an organization, and show how the staffers of a help desk cooperate
to solve a particular problem. We present the current state of help desks, and describe the
dimensions and opportunities for cooperation among the staffers of help desks. Our hypothesis
is that high degrees of cooperation are possible between the staffers of help desks, and that this
cooperation can be facilitated through the use of DAI frameworks.
4. Andrews, Bruce and Henry Parsons. Establishing telephone-agent staffing levels through eco-
nomic optimization, Interfaces, 23 (2), 1993, 14–20.
Abstract. We developed and implemented an economic-optimization model for telephone-agent
staffine at L.L. Bean, a large tele-marketer and mail-order catalog house for quality outdoor
sporting goods and apparel. The staffing levels we obtained with economic optimization were
very different from those used by the company in the past, when staff size was determined by
service-level criteria. For L.L. Bean, the resultant savings were estimated to amount to more
than $500,000 per year. In the model, we used queuing theory, devised an expected total-cost
ob jective function, and accounted for retrials and potential caller abandonments through a re-
gression model that related the abandonment rates to the telephone-service factor (percentage
of calls answered within a predetermined time interval).
Keywords: Telephone agent staffing levels, Economic optimization, L.L. Bean, Telemarketer,
Mail-order catalog house, Outdoor sporting goods, Apparel, Queuing theory, Expected total
cost ob jective function, Retrials, Potential caller abandonments, Regression model
(Appears also in Section I.)
5. Brigandi, Anthony J., Dennis R. Dargon, Michael J. Sheehan and Thomas Spencer III. AT&T’s
call processing simulator (CAPS) operational design for inbound call centers, Interfaces, 24 (1),
1994, 6–28.
Abstract. Since 1978, AT&T has been developing the call processing simulator (CAPS) to
design and evaluate inbound call centers. The current version of CAPS is a user-friendly PC-
based system employing a discrete event simulation model with animation and queuing models
of both the telecommunications network and AT&T’s business customer’s call center environ-
ment. Using CAPS, AT&T can model a network of call centers utilizing advanced 800 network
features before its customers make capital investments to start or change their call centers. In
1992, AT&T completed about 2,000 CAPS studies for its business customers, helping it increase,
protect, and regain more than $1 billion in an $8-billion 800-network market. The CAPS tool
is also the turnkey for more than $750 million in annual profit for AT&T’s business customers
who received CAPS studies.
Keywords: AT&T, Call processing simulator, CAPS, Inbound call centers, User-friendly PC-
based system, Animation, Queuing models, Telecommunications network, Advanced 800 net-
work features
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
6. Apte, U.M. and R.O. Mason. Global disaggregation of information-intensive services, Manage-
ment Science, 41 (7), 1995, 1250–1262.
132
Abstract. Information-intensive services are being globally disaggregated as corporations re-
spond to the pressures of increasing global competition, and take advantage of the opportunities
made available by the progress of information technology and the emerging global work force. In
order to globally disaggregate services, corporations must decide whether or not to carry out a
service activity within the organization, and where to locate it, within or outside the geographic
boundary of the home-base country. This paper analyzes the opportunities and challenges of
global disaggregation of information-intensive services. Specifically, the paper proposes a tax-
onomy of disaggregation, and develops a theoretical framework that identifies the criteria and
guidelines for successfully selecting service activities to be globally disaggregated.
Keywords: Services, Globalization, Disaggregation, Information intensity, Customer contact, In-
sourcing, Outsourcing
7. Burns, John. Developing and implementing a customer contact strategy, Managing Service
Quality, 5 (4), 1995, 44–48.
Abstract. Describes how telephone-based account management and service can be an excellent
way of improving perceived quality, highlighting the effectiveness of a customer contact centre
(sometimes called a “call centre”). As a case study, describes how the Rover Group integrated
new customer support software with existing sources of information and automated the pro-
duction of letters and faxes. Management can now rapidly access trend, product and market
information to allow timely decision making and utilize this information in product planning
and marketing.
Keywords: Customer service, Motor industry, Telecommunications
8. Hassler, K.W., C.C. Jones, J.E. Kohler and R.D. Nalbone. Revolutionizing DEFINITY(R) call
centers in the 1990s, AT&T Technical Journal, 1995, 64–73.
Abstract. The award-winning. AT&T DEFINITY(R) G3 Expert Agent Selection (EAS) fea-
ture has fundamentally changed the way in which call centers provide set-vices for a variety of
business applications. The skills-matching concept of EAS simplifies the problem of meeting
incoming caller needs with trained call center agents. The Logical Agent part of EAS provides
call center agents with an incentive for advancement while also providing new-found flexibility in
how they perform their jobs. Both these EAS innovations are patented, with the skills-matching
patent winning the 1995 AT&T Patent Recognition Award. This paper describes how EAS im-
proves the efficiency of call centers, and it discusses the implementation approach used to realize
this important new call center feature.
Keywords: DEFINITY call centers, AT&T, G3 expert agent selection, Business applications,
Logical agent, Skills-matching patent, PBX, Automatic call distribution
(Appears also in Section V.)
9. Rathnam, S., V. Maha jan and A.B. Whinston. Facilitating coordination in customer support
teams: A framework and its implications for the design of information technology, Management
Science, 41 (12), 1995, 1900–1921.
133
Abstract. The management of coordination gaps is critical to the effective functioning of a
customer support team. To address the managerial challenge of designing Information Technol-
ogy (IT) to facilitate coordination in customer support teams, this paper develops a framework
describing the drivers of coordination gaps in customer support teams. Measures for the charac-
teristics of problem resolution processes, the characteristics of IT that assist in the management
of coordination gaps, and coordination gaps are developed and validated. Results from a field
study administered to 399 respondents from 41 teams in Apple, Dell, Hewlett-Packard, IBM,
Seton Hospital, and Southwestern Bell support the proposition that coordination gaps arise from
a lack of fit between the characteristics of problem resolution processes used and the character-
istics of IT used. What is more important, the results also indicate that processes with differing
characteristics require different kinds of IT.
Keywords: Customer support, Coordination, Business process analysis, Groupware
10. Serving the American Public: Best practices in telephone service; Federal Consortium Bench-
mark Study Report: National Performance Review (Al Gore), U.S. Government Printing office,
Washington, DC, 1995.
Available at: http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/npr/library/papers/benchmark/phone.html
11. Mortlock, Berit. Winning with quality at IBM: Best practice at the National Call Management
Centre, Business Process Management Journal, 2 (2), 1996, 57–72.
Abstract. Based on a submission for the European Best Practice Benchmarking Award of 1995,
in which IBM UK Ltd. won the second prize. Discusses how IBM UK Ltd. has benchmarked
aspects of customer service and satisfaction within its National Call Management Centre. De-
scribes how, by focusing on model companies and areas of best practice, many processes and
practices were modified in order to boost performance standards and achieve higher levels of
customer satisfaction.
Keywords: Benchmarking, Customer care, Kaizan, Quality
12. Nix, Joan and David Gabel. The introduction of automatic switching into the Bell system:
Market versus institutional influences, Journal of Economic Issues, 30 (3), 1996, 737–753.
Abstract. In neoclassical economics, the postulated behavior of firm profit maximization is a
comprehensive idea that subsumes important institutional details concerning management and
organization. The intelligent and creative accumulation of experience reflected in the ideas of key
personnel is used to explain AT&T behavior toward a ma jor innovation, automatic switching.
Automatic switching, a technology that involves using machines to connect customers’ telephone
lines, was available for sale from electric manufacturers in the late 1890s. By the turn of the cen-
tury, many of AT&T’s competitors has deployed this new technology. However, the large-scale
adoption of automatic switching by AT&T did not begin until 1919. It is argued that AT&T’s
utilization of the technological opportunity of automatic switching cannot be understood without
reference to specific ideas that hastened the commitment of management attention to particular
courses of action.
Keywords: Telecommunications industry, Technological change, Organizational behavior, Mar-
134
ket strategy, Economic theory, Case studies, Telephone companies, Telecommunications, History,
Automatic call distribution
13. Anupindi, R. and B.T. Smythe. Call centers and rapid technological change. Teaching note.
Operations Management, Managerial Economics and Decision Sciences, J.L. Kellogg Graduate
School of Management, Northwestern University, July 1, 1997.
Abstract. Call centers are an increasingly important link in the value chain for many firms.
From the earliest call centers of the Bell Telephone Company, the centers have evolved into
technically specialized points of contact with the customer. New types of technology now enable
firms to decrease costs, improve customer service and improve call center agents’ job satisfaction.
Although the results have been convincing, these benefits have not come without costs and com-
plications. The three key steps to minimizing these have proven to be choice among technologies,
implementation and measurement of success. By utilizing these steps, such firms as the Frost
National Bank have excelled in call center management. The future remains uncertain, however,
as new technologies continue to emerge and competition becomes ever fiercer. Call centers are
nevertheless an aspect of many firms that managers must not overlook as they seek competitive
advantage and enhanced profits.
(Appears also in Section V.)
14. Loebbecke, Claudia and Tawfik Jelassi. Concepts and technologies for virtual organizing: The
Gerling journey, European Management Journal, 15 (2), 1997, 138–146.
Abstract. As one of the largest insurance and reinsurance companies in the world, the Gerling
Group has traditionally been an innovator in the strategic use of state-of-the-art information
and communication technologies to enhance customer services. A case study illustrates Gerling’s
efforts to move the insurance company toward a virtual organization and prepare it for the 21st
century business environment. The concept of logical call centers is the organizational backbone
and technical enabler for building the virtual organization.
Keywords: Case studies, Insurance industry, Information technology, Customer services
15. Twitchell, M.C. Moving from helpless desk to help desk: practical strategies for improving cus-
tomer service in a multi-function university help desk. Proceedings. ACM SIGUCCS 1997 User
Services Conference XXV. Are You Ready? 25th SIGUCCS ’97 Conference. ACM, New York,
NY, USA, 1997, 303–306.
Abstract. The Information Technology Service’s (ITS) Help Desk at North Dakota State Uni-
versity started with few resources, but with a strong desire to support users on campus. Un-
fortunately, these limitations made it hard for the Help Desk to provide consistent support.
The ITS Help Desk has implemented several strategies that have improved its ability to meet
customer needs. A problem management process was developed that would focus on people
using technology and not just on the technology itself. This change in focus dictated changes
in practice, and the new practices resulted in increased customer satisfaction. As customer
satisfaction grew, the Help Desk began to fulfill its mission as the single point of contact for
users wanting services from ITS. More programs within ITS are relying on the Help Desk for
135
support. Providing that support is difficult without defining the service that the Help Desk can
reasonably provide. Service level agreements are being developed with other ITS work groups
to define relationships and responsibilities. Increased satisfaction also leads to an increase in
volume of calls and makes it difficult for the Help Desk to balance walk-in, e-mail, and phone
support. Implementation of an automatic call distribution system has helped manage phone
traffic and improved the working environment for staff. In addition, a virtual help desk pro ject
involving several campuses within the North Dakota University System is exploring help desk
software as a means of sharing knowledge between campuses.
Keywords: University help desk, Practical strategies, Customer service, Campus, ITS Help Desk,
Customer needs, Problem management process, Customer satisfaction, Service level agreements,
ITS work groups, E-mail, Phone support, Automatic call distribution system, Phone traffic,
Working environment, Virtual help desk pro ject, North Dakota University System, Help desk
software
16. Van Dijk, N.M. Why queuing never vanishes, European Journal of Operational Research, 99 (2),
1997, 463–476.
Abstract. This tutorial aims to address and illustrate that queuing theory has a wider po-
tential than generally perceived, while at the same time a variety of practical problems, both
in daily-life and industry, are open for fundamental research. To this end, it will: (i) Highlight
basic queuing insights for daily-life purposes. (ii) Provide exact and bounding results for queuing
network applications. (iii) Present a number of practical illustrations (case studies) taken from
areas as: Daily-life situations (postal offices and supermarkets); Transportation (railways and
air traffic); Administrative logistics (reengineering); Telecommunications (call-centers).
Keywords: Queuing theory, Daily life, Industry, Bounding results, Exact results, Queuing net-
work, Postal offices, Supermarkets, Transportation, Railways, Air traffic, Administrative logis-
tics, Reengineering, Telecommunications, Call centers
17. Bielski, L. Building a bridge to the customer [bank call centres], ABA Banking Journal, 90 (12),
1998, 46–48.
Abstract. In the brave new world of bank call centers, what’s possible, what’s probable, and
what progressive banks have in mind for these facilities isn’t always the same. What can be done
to better match plan and performance? The push to transform the call center into a vehicle for
sales is a relatively recent one, but providing retail banking solutions is fast becoming a red hot
industry. Although disagreements centering on the hard facts of integration continue, everyone
in CTI agrees that the one-to-one marketing model makes all the sense in the world.
Keywords: Bank call centers, Sales, Retail banking, Computer telephony integration, Customer
service
18. Tax, Stephen S. and Stephen W. Brown. Recovering and learning from service failure, Sloan
Management Review, 40 (1), 1998, 75–89.
Abstract. Effective service recovery is vital to maintaining customer and employee satisfaction
136
and loyalty, which contribute significantly to a company’s revenues and profitability. Yet most
customers are dissatisfied with the way companies resolve their complaints, and most companies
do not take advantage of the learning opportunities afforded by service failures. The authors
provide a research-based approach for helping managers develop a comprehensive service re-
covery system. To encourage dissatisfied customers to complain, leading firms set performance
standards, often through the use of guarantees; communicate the importance of recovery to
employees; train customers in how to complain; and use technological support offered through
customer call centers and the internet. in resolving problems, companies need to focus on pro-
viding fair outcomes, procedures, and interactions, Successful companies develop hiring criteria
and training programs that take into account employees’ service-recovery role, develop guide-
lines for service recovery, are easily accessible to customers, and use the information in customer
databases to solve problems. Firms promote organizational learning by documenting and classi-
fying complaints; useful methods include creating internal complaint forms, accessing complaints
made to front-line employees, and categorizing customers who complain. Finally, companies need
to generate additional information on service quality, disseminate it to those responsible for im-
plementing improvements, and identify those process improvements that will have the greatest
impact on profitability. Customer conflicts are inevitable. A powerful service-recovery strategy
can turn these conflicts into opportunities to improve performance and raise profitability.
Keywords: Customer services, Problems, Organizational learning, Customer satisfaction, Guide-
lines
19. Aldrich, S.E. Framework for customer contact centers, E-Business Strategies & Solutions, 1999,
55–60.
Abstract. The call center, with its improbable goal of answering and dispatching in seconds,
is no longer the model for customer service, at least not in e-business. Customers have unprece-
dented power today, and they are more demanding than ever (their own customers give them
lessons on what to ask for). The new model demands that you help customers via their chosen
medium, at their pace, and on their schedule. The new goal of customer contact centers is to
get the customer’s issue or question resolved to her satisfaction. Where call center managers
once worried about time on hold because of the cost of phone lines, they now worry because
time on hold means poor service. Managers, once measured on minutes to finish a call, are now
measured on time to resolve a customer issue. These new pressures and measurements dictate
a range of technologies and processes in the contact center. This report presents a framework
to describe the elements necessary for contact center excellence and analyzes the parameters for
choosing technologies.
Keywords: Call center, Customer contact center, E-business
20. Chen, E.T. Reengineering a call center using a performance measurement system. Proceedings
of the Fifth Americas Conference on Information Systems (AMCIS 1999). Assoc. Inf. Syst,
Atlanta, GA, USA; 1999, 668–670.
Abstract. Enhancing customer loyalty and eventually increasing profitability can be facilitated
by the services of a call center, which takes charge of customer service calls and acts as a repos-
itory of marketing information. The most expensive and important resource a call center has is
137
its people. Support of the call center staff is critical to maintaining quality of service. This paper
describes the determination of installing a performance measurement system for a call center in
a beauty-supply corporation. This PMS is essential to improve organizational productivity as
one of several information system priorities. Many practical implications have been derived in
this case study.
Keywords: Call centre reengineering, Performance measurement system, Customer loyalty, Prof-
itability, Marketing information, Staff, Quality of service, Beauty supply corporation, Organiza-
tional productivity, Information system, Case study, Wholesale distribution
(Appears also in Section IV.)
21. Duxbury, D., R. Backhouse, M. Head, G. Lloyd and J. Pilkington. Call centres in BT UK
customer service, British Telecommunications Engineering, 18, 1999, 165–173.
Abstract. Call centres are a growing industry. In a recent Ovum Report it was estimated
that by 2000 5% of the working population in Europe would be employed in call centres. It
is also predicted that call-centre revenues globally will be $6 billion. Call centres have become
the core of the service economy in the UK. Counting part-timers, UK call centres currently
employ 1.7% of the working population, or nearly 400,000 people. And the numbers are growing.
Datamonitor predicts that call-centre positions will double by 2002 before beginning to level off.
Since 1994, customer calls to large organizations have roughly doubled, with call centres being
largely responsible.
BT UK is a leader in call-centre technology and expertise. It operates its own call centres and
manages them for other organizations. BT’s own call-centre operations fall into the two broad
categories of outbound and inbound. Outbound operations involve companies’ staff calling out
to customers, usually to offer new services, while inbound call centres handle enquiries from
customers. This article looks at how the inbound call centres are presently used in the following
environments, which between them are responsible for handling approximately 1 billion calls per
year:
• answering Operator Assistance enquiries (100, 155 and 999 emergency services),
• giving accurate number information (192 and 153 services),
• receiving sales and billing enquiries and taking orders (150), and
• taking fault reports from residential and business customers (151 and 154).
It does not consider some of the more specialist centres (for example, Welsh language, Directory
Enquiries for the blind and disabled) or inbound services and business after-sales units, although
these all form an important part of the BT Customer Service call-centre management operation.
The article explores ‘where we are now’ and in particular focuses on systems, switching and
queueing capabilities. Finally, it looks at the future of call centres and gives some indication of
the way things will change.
Keywords: Customer service, Call centres
(Appears also in Section V.)
138
22. Evenson, Ann, Patrick T. Harker and Frances X. Frei. Effective call center management: Evi-
dence from financial services, Working paper, Wharton School Center for Financial Institutions,
University of Pennsylvania, January 1999.
Abstract. Call centers are quickly becoming the ma jor point of contact for serving customers
and generating new revenue in a variety of industries. No where is this growth in the impor-
tance of call centers more apparent than in the financial services industry. This paper presents
the results of a survey of the management of call center operations at ma jor financial service
firms. The results clearly indicate the importance of human resource management practices and
technology in creating high-performance call center environments.
23. Fischer, M.J., D.A. Garbin, A. Gharakhanian and D.M. Masi. Traffic engineering of distributed
call centers: not as straight forward as it may seem. Proceedings of the Applied Telecommuni-
cations Symposium (ATS’99). 1999 Advanced Simulation Technologies Conference. SCS, San
Diego, CA, USA, 1999, 53–59.
Abstract. As of 1994, AT&T estimated that 350000 businesses employed 6.5 million people
in call centers. In 1997, call center revenue was estimated at $900M, with annual spending on
call centers growing at 12 percent each year. Accurate performance analyses are essential in
determining staffing levels and trunk requirements in call centers, because poor performance
means lost business opportunities. The purpose of this paper is to show that as the complexity
of these systems increases, traditional methods, like Erlang B and C table lookup, can result in
poor evaluation of the call center performance. We start by examining the simplest of all call
centers and show traditional methods can result in poor estimates of system performance and
then present a more accurate model for this call center configuration. As the complexity of call
centers increases more advance methods are required. This is demonstrated by considering two
more complex systems: distributed systems of multiple interdependent call centers and a virtual
call center configuration. We also discuss methods to analytically solve each of these systems.
Keywords: Traffic engineering, Distributed call centers, AT&T, Performance analyses, Staffing
levels, Trunk requirements, Erlang B model, Erlang C model, Table lookup, Multiple interde-
pendent call centers, Virtual call center configuration
(Appears also in Section VIII.)
24. Harris, Foster R. and S. De Reyt. Re-inventing the call centre with predictive and adaptive
execution, British Telecommunications Engineering, 18 (2), 1999, 180–184.
Abstract. Call centres have evolved from simple single-function centres to offer access, conve-
nience, choice and courtesy to callers. Forecasting and staffing tools support planning, enterprise
databases permit the business to craft specific caller treatments, and cross trained agents using
desktop applications can respond to a wider range of caller needs and business opportunities
on a single call. One key element of the call centre, however has changed only superficially-the
question of ‘What should each agent do next?’ The ‘oldest waiting call’ rule has answered that
question for the last 20 years. Signs that this methodology is obsolete are seen in call centres
where designs become more complex and results more difficult to achieve; where manual inter-
vention moves agents from skill to skill chasing problems; where the most talented agents are
139
overworked. This paper describes predictive and adaptive techniques that answer the question,
‘What should an agent do next?’. These techniques re-invent the call centre, creating a robust
operation where performance is aligned with business intentions, without the manual, corrective
intervention common in conventional centres.
Keywords: Call centre, Specific caller treatments, Cross-trained agents, Oldest waiting call rule,
Predictive techniques, Adaptive techniques, Customer service
25. Krishnan, M.S., Venkatram Ramaswamy, Mary C. Meyer and Paul Damien. Customer satisfac-
tion for financial services: The role of products, services, and information technology, Manage-
ment Science, 45 (9), 1999, 1194-1209.
Abstract. The drivers of customer satisfaction for financial services are studied. A full Bayesian
analysis based on data collected from customers of a leading financial services company is dis-
cussed. The approach allows the explicit accommodation of missing data and enables quantita-
tive assessment of the impact of the drivers of satisfaction across the customer population. It
is found that satisfaction with product offerings is a primary driver of overall customer satisfac-
tion. The quality of customer service with respect to financial statements and services provided
through different channels of delivery, such as information technology enabled call centers and
traditional branch offices, are also important in determining overall satisfaction. The analysis
indicates, however, that the impact of these service delivery factors may differ substantially
across customer segments.
Keywords: Financial services, Information technology, Customer satisfaction, Bayesian analysis,
Product offerings, Service quality
26. Pinker, Edieal J. and Robert A. Shumsky. The efficiency-quality tradeoff of cross-trained work-
ers. Working paper, William E. Simon Graduate School of Business, University of Rochester,
Rochester, NY, February 1999.
Abstract. Does cross-training workers allow a firm to achieve economies of scale when there is
variability in the content of work, or does it create a workforce that performs many tasks with
consistent mediocrity? To address this question we integrate a model of a stochastic service sys-
tem with models for tenure and experience-based service quality. When examined in isolation,
the service system model confirms a well-known ‘rule-of-thumb’ from the queueing literature:
flexible or cross-trained servers provide more throughput with fewer workers than specialized
servers. However, in the integrated model these economies of scale are tempered by a loss in
quality. Given multiple tasks, flexible workers may not gain sufficient experience to provide
high-quality service to any one customer, and what is gained in efficiency is lost in quality.
Through a series of numerical experiments we find that low utilization in an all-specialist system
can also reduce quality, and therefore, the optimal staff mix combines flexible and specialized
workers. We also investigate when the performance of the system is sensitive to the staffing
configuration choice. For small systems with high learning rates, the optimal staff mix provides
significant benefits over either extreme case (a completely specialized or completely flexible work-
force). If the system is small and the rate of learning is slow, flexible servers are preferred. For
large systems with high learning rates, the model leans towards specialized servers. In a final
140
set of experiments, the model analyzes the design options for an actual call center.
27. Richardson, R. and J.N. Marshall. Teleservices, call centres and urban and regional develop-
ment, The Service Industries Journal, 19 (1), 1999, 96–116.
Abstract. The character of call centers, which are attracting considerable interest among eco-
nomic development agencies seeking to attract inward investment is examined. The type of
employment provided in call centers, their locational requirements and their wider impact on
local economies are examined. It is argued that information and communications technologies
are allowing these teleservice firms to develop in new locations, but that call centers remain con-
strained in their locational choices especially because of the uneven distribution of labor. It is
concluded that call centers providing teleservices contribute to local economic development, but
the employment created on the whole tends to be of low quality. Few managerial, professional or
technical jobs are created in most call centers, and there are few local spin-offs. Inward invest-
ment by these sorts of services in less-favored areas displays many of the drawbacks associated
with traditional manufacturing inward investment.
Keywords: Call centers, Urban development, Economic development, Studies
28. Stier, Richard D. The medical call center, Marketing Health Services, 19 (2), 1999, 25–28.
Abstract. Health care marekting executives value the medical call center as a centralized tele-
phonic front door to their enterprise. Medical call centers will be a core competency for health
care organizations in the new millennium and are already a priority fo visionary marketing and
managed care executives. However, unless they tangibly help achieve the organization’s priority
outcomes, they will not be successful. The call center leverages marketing strategy to connect
with and support the ma jor clinical and operational processes of the enterprise. The call center
must not be isolated from central enterprise strategies, clinical pathways redesign, marketing
plans, managed care priorities, the organization’s plan for quality or consolidated scheduling.
Keywords: Health care industry, Call centers, Systems integration, Marketing management,
Strategic planning, Profitability
29. Taylor, Phil and Peter Bain. ‘An assembly line in the head’: work and employee relations in the
call centre, Industrial Relations Journal, 30 (2), 1999, 101–117.
Abstract. To date, academic studies of the call center sector remain limited in scope. This
article attempts to remedy that omission by analyzing the recent and spectacular growth of
call centers in the UK, drawing on a wide variety of sources, including 2 extensive surveys of
developments in Scotland during 1997.
Keywords: Call centers, Work environment, Studies
30. Weidong Xu. Long range planning for call centers at FedEx, The Journal of Business Forecast-
ing Methods & Systems, 18 (4), Winter 1999/2000, 7–11.
Abstract. FedEx is the world’s largest express transportation company, generating $14 bil-
141
lion in annual revenue. To support the global transportation network, FedEx has established 51
worldwide customer service call centers. The customer service at FedEx in the US handles about
500,000 calls per day. There are three ma jor networks: 1. Domestic, 2. International, and 3.
Freight. For each network, the company has developed four different types of forecasts based on
different forecasting horizons: 1. Strategic Plan, 2. Business Plan, 3. Tactical Forecast, and 4.
Operational Forecast. Different methodologies are adopted for different levels of forecasts. An
overview of these methodologies is presented.
Keywords: Postal & delivery services, Forecasting techniques, Customer services, Case studies
(Appears also in Section I and II.)
31. Alouisa, J., W. Anderson, R. Castro, R. Ennis, J. Gevarter and R. Pandolfo. PruServTM:
A call center support system, in Creating Value in Financial Services: Strategies, Operations,
and Technologies, Edward L. Melnick, Praveen R. Nayyar, Michael L. Pinedo, Sridhar Seshadri
(Eds.). Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2000, Chapter 19: 389–401.
Abstract. We discuss Prudential’s solution to complex call center problems. Since Prudential
is a service-oriented business, its success and competitive advantage lies in its ability to give cus-
tomers the highest quality of service possible, “wherever and whenever” they want it. Managers
at Prudential determined that without the proper tools to do the job, service quality would
be diminished. PruServTM, a powerful call center application, effectively solved the business
problem by providing users with a robust and exciting application that resulted in “world-class”
customer service. This translated to the firm capturing an increased percentage of clients’ assets
and generating incremental revenues.
Acknowledgement: The abstract was taken from the introduction of the book.
32. Anton, J. The past, present and future of customer access centers, International Journal of Ser-
vice Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 120–130.
Abstract. Customers want better access to the companies from which they buy products and
services. Reviews how companies have responded to this demand for easy access. Looks at
the past, present and future information needs of the customer and how they have been met.
Touches on the developments in the communication channels available to customers and provides
some simple usage statistics. Forecasts the future technological developments which will once
again change the kind of access and information available.
Keywords: Customer requirements, Call centres, Customer satisfaction, Marketing communica-
tions, Communications technology
33. Bennington, Lynne, James Cummane and Paul Conn. Customer satisfaction and call centers: an
Australian study, International Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 162–173.
Abstract. Call centers are growing at unprecedented rates, yet relatively little is known about
customer satisfaction with this method of service delivery. Therefore, a review of the advantages
and disadvantages of call centers is provided before reporting on a study carried out with users
of a very large human services call center network. The results indicate that customers have
142
slightly higher satisfaction levels with in-person services than with call center services. Although
it was predicted that older customers might be more dissatisfied with call centers than younger
customers, this was not borne out by the data. Attributes of a best-in-the-world call center
operation are provided to guide those who design and manage call center services.
Keywords: Call Centres, Customer satisfaction, Australia
(Appears also in Section IV.)
34. Bernett, H.G. E-commerce and the Web-enabled call center. Proceedings of the Applied Telecom-
munication Symposium (ATS’00). SCS, San Diego, CA, USA, 2000, 3–8.
Abstract. The Internet’s explosive growth has provided corporations with a new delivery chan-
nel for both electronic commerce and customer service. Electronic commerce (E-commerce)
transactions are expected to grow from $1 billion in 1997 to an estimated $1.3 trillion by 2003.
Businesses have created Web sites as “click-and-mortar” storefronts where WWW visitors can
browse through the store and purchase products using a virtual shopping cart. The owners of
these electronic stores are discovering that having the ability to provide personal help to their
cyber shoppers is as important as it is in traditional “brick-and-mortar” stores. In a study done
by Yankelovich Partners, 63 percent of respondents said that they will not buy over the Internet
until there is more human interaction. To address this concern, corporations are linking their
Web sites to call centers where large pools of trained agents are available to assist, in real time,
Web shoppers that need help. This article provides an overview of how this new E-commerce
technology of Web-enabled call centers is being implemented.
Keywords: E-commerce, Web-enabled call center, Internet, Electronic commerce, Customer ser-
vice, Web sites, WWW
35. Betts, Alan, Maureen Meadows and Paul Walley. Call centre capacity management, Interna-
tional Journal of Service Industry Management, 11 (2), 2000, 185–196.
Abstract. Call centres often experience large fluctuations in demand over relatively short peri-
ods of time. However, most centres also need to maintain short response times to the demand.
This places great emphasis upon capacity management practices within call centre operations.
A total of 12 UK-based call centres from one retail bank were studied to investigate how they
managed forecasting, capacity management and scheduling tasks. Provides evidence of the dif-
ficulties associated with capacity management in call centres. Regression modelling is used to
link forecasting and capacity planning practices to performance. Shows that random variation
is a very important factor when assessing call centre performance. The results suggest that call
centre managers can have only a small influence upon short-term performance. Existing mathe-
matical models, such as the Erlang queuing system methodologies, have only limited value as the
assumptions concerning demand patterns made in their derivation contradict observations made
within the 12 sites. Spiked demand patterns present special capacity management problems,
including a direct trade-off between high service levels and operator boredom. Conventional
methods of flexing capacity cannot respond sufficiently well to some of the short-term fluctua-
tions in demand.
Keywords: Capacity management, Service operations, Banking, Call centres
143
(Appears also in Section II.)
36. Bong, Ki Moon, Kyu Lee Jae and Jun Lee Kyoung. A next generation multimedia call center
for Internet commerce: IMC, Journal of Organizational Computing and Electronic Commerce,
10 (4), 2000, 227–240.
Abstract. Human assistance, as well as automated service, is necessary for providing more con-
venient services to customers in Internet-based commerce systems. Call centers have typically
been human-based service systems. However, the services of existing public switched telephone
network-based call centers are not enough to meet the needs of customers on the Internet. Most
of them have been designed without considering the interactions involved in shopping on the
Internet. In our research, we designed a call center named IMC (Internet-based Multimedia Call-
center) that can be integrated with an Internet shopping mall. It contains two parts: an Internet
multimedia dialogue system and a human-agent assisting system. The dialogue system is an In-
ternet and multimedia version of the interactive voice response service of computer-telephony
integration-based call centers, because it provides access to multimedia Web pages along with a
recorded voice explanation via the Internet. The human-agent assisting system aims to select the
most appropriate human agents in the call center and to support them in providing high-quality
individualized information for each customer. IMC is a real-time, human-embedded system that
can provide high-quality services cost-effectively for Internet commerce.
Keywords: Internet commerce, IMC, Human assistance, Automated service, Online shopping in-
teractions, Internet-based Multimedia Call-center, Internet shopping mall, Internet multimedia
dialogue system, Human-agent assisting system, Interactive voice response service, Computer-
telephony integration, Multimedia Web pages, Recorded voice explanation, Human-agent se-
lection, High-quality individualized customer information, Real-time human-embedded system,
High-quality services, Cost-effectiveness, Electronic commerce
(Appears also in Section V.)
37. Bristow, G., M. Munday and P. Gripaios. Call centre growth and location: corporate strategy
and the spatial division of labour, Environment and Planning A, 32 (3), 2000, 519–538.
Abstract. The authors contribute to the developing literature on call centres by providing
detailed empirical evidence on the spatial unevenness in the distribution of call centre activ-
ity. They argue that the driving forces of call centre growth, whether as the rationalisation of
back-office functions or as entirely new entities, have been corporate strategy and the pursuit of
low-cost competitive advantage. Thus, although technological developments at the heart of call
centre operations render them relatively ‘footloose’ in locational terms, the search for specific
characteristics makes certain regions (and parts of regions) more attractive than others. By
using a sample database of call centres, the authors describe the characteristics of call centres
in the United Kingdom in terms of size, sector, and spatial distribution. They then attempt
to explain the determinants of call centre location at the county level through a multiple re-
gression analysis. The results indicate that there is a propensity to site call centres close to
existing concentrations of allied activity, with preferences for densely populated areas mediated
by needs to maintain employee access and avoid staff turnover problems. This has important
implications for the spatial division of labour, with call centre growth likely to reinforce existing
144
spatial unevenness in employment in key service activities. The authors conclude by considering
the implications of these findings for contemporary urban and regional development, as well as
providing a number of suggestions for future research.
Keywords: Information and Internet services, Computer software, Other production and pricing
analysis (spatial analysis)
38. Chang, Zeph Yun and Loi Hui Huang. Quality deployment for the management of customer
calls, Managing Service Quality, 10 (2), 2000, 98–103.
Abstract. Customer calls confer accessibility for promoting sales opportunities. It is the key el-
ement of a company’s customer service system. Presents a methodology for quality management
of customer communication through telephone, e-mail and Web support for both internal and
external customers. The concept of a customer call centre is introduced and quality dimensions
of customer call services are established with call status coded and problem severity issues being
addressed.
Keywords: Customer service, Problem solving, Systems design, Quality
39. Cramp, D.G. and E.R. Carson. A model-based framework for public health: a vehicle for
maximising the value of telecare? Proceedings 2000 IEEE EMBS International Conference on
Information Technology Applications in Biomedicine. ITAB-ITIS 2000. Joint Meeting Third
IEEE EMBS International Conference on Information Technology Applications in Biomedicine
(ITAB’00). Third Workshop of the International Telemedical Information Society (ITIS’00).
IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 2000, 272–277.
Abstract. Information and communication technologies (ICT) play a pivotal role in enabling
health care provision, particularly in the light of changes in delivery mechanisms which empha-
sise the primary and community sectors and embrace substitution policies that include home
care, day care and call centres. However, the complexity of these systems means that it is dif-
ficult to determine the best ICT strategies to adopt in terms of efficiency and effectiveness. If
public health strategies are to be devised so as to maximise the benefits of advances such as those
in telemedicine and telecare, it is necessary to address the issues adopting an approach which
is holistic and which encapsulates all causal relationships and influences. Conceptual models
for such a systemic approach are developed using signed digraph and cybernetic feedback for-
malisms. The importance of addressing not only the needs of the population which are of public
health concern, but also the factors giving rise to such needs is emphasised. The implications of
this modelling approach are illustrated in the context of two telecare systems: home haemodial-
ysis and Web-based services for the management of diabetes.
Keywords: Model-based framework, Public health strategies, Telecare value maximization, In-
formation technology, Communication technology, Health care provision, Health care delivery
mechanisms, Primary care, Community health care, Substitution policies, Home care, Day care,
Call centres, Efficiency, Effectiveness, Telemedicine, Holistic approach, Causal relationships,
Influences, Conceptual models, Systemic approach, Signed digraph, Cybernetic feedback, Popu-
lation needs, Home haemodialysis, Worldwide Web-based services, Diabetes management
(Appears also in Section V.)
145
40. Feinberg, Richard A., Ik-Suk Kim, Leigh Hokama, Ko de Ruyter and Cherie Keen. Operational
determinants of caller satisfaction in the call center, International Journal of Service Industry
Management, 11 (2), 2000, 131–141.
Abstract. There has been, and will be, a spectacular growth in the number of call centers on
both sides of the Atlantic. So far, however, empirical evidence is lacking as to the operational de-
terminants of caller satisfaction in call centers, despite the multitude of call performance metrics
registered in many call centers. Undertakes an empirical assessment of the relationship between
caller satisfaction and a number of critical variables. The results are astonishing. Of all the
critical operational determinants only “percentage of calls closed on first contact” and “average
abandonment” have a significant, albeit weak, influence on caller satisfaction. Concludes, there-
fore, with a call for more research into reliable and valid predictors of caller satisfaction.
Keywords: Performance measures, Customer service, Customer satisfaction, Call centres
(Appears also in Section IV.)
41. Gibson, Mary Margaret. Linking Web sales to call centers, The Journal of Business Strategy,
21 (1), 2000, 28–33.
Abstract. In 1996, when business to business e-commerce was relatively new, Richard L. Moore,
vice president of Lucent Direct, was handed a strategic challenge to solve. How could Lucent
serve its customers exceptionally well, at lower sales cost? Moore had a few corporate piece
parts that, theoretically, could be remodeled to solve the problem. Lucent Direct was primarily
a “telebusiness”. The business was focused on phone sales, composed of an inside-sales call
center, located in Cincinnati, that managed telephone customer relationships and sold telephone
items the customer found in a series of large paper catalogues that Lucent published twice a
year. Moore’s team was organized to take the business apart and to examine every piece, un-
derstanding what customers wanted and determining how to reassemble the pieces. The goal
was to build a customer-focused, sales-channel business that could grow at a rapid pace, while
using both the organizations already in place and new ones crafted for the future. This would
be a fairly extensive remodel.
Keywords: Organizational change, Corporate profiles, Consumer relations, Quality of service,
Telecommunications industry, Strategic planning, Call centers, Electronic commerce, Sales
42. Gilmore, Audrey and Lesley Moreland. Call centres: How can service quality be managed? Irish
Marketing Review, 13 (1), 2000, 3–11.
Abstract. The call center industry is growing rapidly in both size and complexity. Since its
early development it has been perceived to suffer from many service delivery and management
problems. In particular the inherent need to answer a high number of calls in these centers has
led to the use of a simplistic ’counting’ of calls management approach to service management.
Recently there is more recognition of the need to improve the service interaction from both the
customers’ and the service agents’ perspective. For many companies this has become a difficult
management problem. How call centers can approach the management and assessment of call
146
centers in terms of dealing with a large number and variety of calls, managing the service quality
of these calls, and how management can overcome the high staff turnover rate, is investigated.
Keywords: Call centers, Customer services, Automatic call distribution, Employee turnover,
Studies, Managerial skills, Quality of service
43. Houlihan, Maeve. Eyes wide shut? Querying the depth of call centre learning, Journal of Euro-
pean Industrial Training, 24, 2000, 228–240.
Abstract. Call centres are high-pressure work environments characterised by routinization,
scripting, computer-based monitoring and intensive performance targets. This promises a series
of business advantages, but also risks counterproductive outcomes. Drawing on evidence from
ethnographic field data, it is suggested that both desired and risked outcomes are mediated
by personal modes of coping and organizational sustaining mechanisms. A central concern is
to explore the underlying assumptions of call centre design and management, and to establish
whether or to what extent information systems have been constructed as learning sites or be-
havioural control sites. When behavioural control is a primary goal, this introduces a climate
of resistance, further inflated by the culture of measurement and enforcement that is likely to
ensue. In this environment, agent, manager and organization become defensive and the main
outcome is a destructive crisis of trust that creates important and difficult implications for the
capacity to learn.
Keywords: Learning, Control, Measurement, Corporate culture
(Appears also in Section IV.)
44. Larson, Richard C. and Edical J. Pinke. Staffing challenges in financial services, in Creat-
ing Value in Financial Services: Strategies, Operations, and Technologies, Edward L. Melnick,
Praveen R. Nayyar, Michael L. Pinedo, Sridhar Seshadri (Eds.). Boston: Kluwer Academic
Publishers, 2000, Chapter 17: 327–356.
Abstract. Financial services institutions are providing a rapidly expanding variety of products
and services; technology is making customers more mobile, and delay is unacceptable in financial
transactions. These attributes of the financial services sector mean that firms must provide effec-
tive, efficient and reliable service or quickly lose customers to competitors. To avoid huge labor
costs, financial services firms must develop innovative approaches to managing their workforces
and their service delivery process. We outline and provide examples of effective techniques for
managing part-time and flexible personnel in back room operations, bank teller scheduling and
management, improving customer queueing experiences, and the design and operation of call
centers to take into account cross-training, learning and cross selling.
Acknowledgement: The abstract was taken from the introduction of the book.
(Appears also in Section I.)
45. Manione, R. and P. Renditore. Management issues for multi-subscriber Web call center services,
CSELT Technical-Reports, 28 (2), 2000, 257–271.
Abstract. Web call centers are among the most promising services belonging to the integrated
147
Internet telephony scenario. The basic version of a Web call center (WCC) service allows us
to publish call center-enabled Web sites, i.e., sites which enable their visitors to speak to live
agents while still browsing the Internet. In particular, the users can browse those pages sent by
the chosen agent, as the conversation goes on (co-browsing). The WCC service presented here is
multi-subscriber, in the sense that it is hosted within a service center run by a service provider;
different instances of the service run on the same servers and share the same computation and
communication resources in a controlled way. With respect to the commercial policies, this ap-
proach allows us to supply the service “by-the-agent-line”, all-inclusive, at a monthly fee, with
minimal provisioning time. The present paper, after analyzing the typical business model and
architecture of services belonging to the integrated Internet telephony scenario, introduces an
innovative approach to their management. Such an approach is discussed in detail within the
scope of the Web call center service, where the presented concepts have been validated within
the implementation and the field trial of the WebCentric/sup R/ system. After one year of
field trial, WebCentric/sup R/ has been recently deployed to the field, as the engine behind the
C@LLWEB service, the present offer of Web call center service from Telecom Italia.
Keywords: Management issues, Web call center, Multi-subscriber services, Integrated Internet
telephony, Agent, Co-browsing, Service architecture, Business model, WebCentric system, Field
trial, C@LLWEB service, Telecom Italia
46. Melscoet, L. Alcatel CCweb: marriage of the Internet with the call center, Alcatel Telecommu-
nications Review, 1, 2000, 43–48.
Abstract. The Internet has brought new communication channels between the enterprise and
its customers, but the challenge is not just to offer new media in parallel with the existing tele-
phony, but to be able to combine these media into a multimedia, feature-rich interaction. In
the case of a traditional voice call center, this means adding Internet self-served and automated
transactions before reaching a call center agent: this is known as “Web enabling the call center”.
On the other hand, for an existing Web site, “call center enabling the Web” brings the human
touch necessary to carry out most E-commerce transactions successfully. In bringing the new
communication channels into the CCdistribution, the Alcatel CCweb turns the call center into
a true contact center, thus becoming the necessary link between all available contact points and
the internal resources and applications of the enterprise.
Keywords: Alcatel CCweb, Internet telephony, Call center, Enterprise communication, Web site,
E-commerce, CCdistribution, Contact center
47. Palson, C. and D. Seidlitz. Customer satisfaction at a software support call center, Quality
Progress, 33 (6), 2000, 71–75.
Abstract. In this articles, we describe how we boosted customer satisfaction statistics at a
software support call center by 43% in one month in an industry where the monthly norm is
a low single digit percentage.(1) This was accomplished by using a methodology developed by
Gary Klein to discover how experts in high pressure emergency occupations make instant deci-
sions.(2) Although incidents of help line support do not ordinarily qualify as emergencies, Klein’s
methodology nevertheless proved effective. Our experts, like experts in other fields, were usually
unable to completely explain their reasons for success in making good instant decisions.
148
Keywords: Marketing & Sales, Customer satisfaction, Prepackaged software, Computers & soft-
ware
48. Swerdlow, R.B. Placing value on customer satisfaction for call centers. Proceedings of the Ap-
plied Telecommunication Symposium (ATS’00). SCS, San Diego, CA, USA, 2000, 194–198.
Abstract. Call centers are groups of people with associated facilities who answer and make
telephone calls in a methodical, organized manner. It is a popular and economically important
form of conducting business. Most work in improving these centers focuses on cost, but customer
satisfaction with a call center can strongly affect business results. For this reason, a contract
for call center services should include performance as well as cost. This paper proposes a mod-
ification to the fixed price incentive (FPI) contract format that includes customer satisfaction
as a part of the incentive in addition to cost. The key idea in relating sub jective measures of
performance to cost is to estimate the reduction in staffing a contractor might achieve at the
expense of these sub jective measures of performance. The paper also discusses a way to find
reasonable bounds on performance that does not appeal to industry wide benchmarks. This
contracting technique is currently in alpha test on a large help desk.
Keywords: Customer satisfaction, Call centers, Business, Fixed price incentive, FPI contract
format, Cost, Sub jective performance, Staffing reduction, Help desk
49. Dilevko, J. An ideological analysis of digital reference service models, Library Trends, 50 (2),
2001, 218–244.
Abstract. Using the theories of Pierre Boudieu about occupational fields of struggle and species
of capital, this article examines the ideological implications of the digital reference call-center
model. This model has the potential to lead to deprofessionalization of reference work because of
increased automation and the replication of employment conditions prevailing in private sector
call centers. Call-center work typically involves unskilled women earning low wages in jobs that
present little opportunity for career building. Library directors who advocate digital reference
call centers as models of the future have neglected the negative aspects of call centers in their
rush to cut costs and provide efficient services. One answer to the deskilling dilemma is the
simple act of reading: the more a librarian reads, the more he or she becomes an irreplaceable
contributor in the reference transaction.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
50. Friedman, Tsily. Call center management: Balancing the numbers, Industrial Management, 43
(1), 2001, 6–10.
Abstract. Consumer behavior has driven companies to allocate large budgets to the fast grow-
ing needs of call centers. Call center management has become more active than reactive, which
requires specific skills and expertise. Through the years, Tefen Ltd’s R&D department has devel-
oped models and methodologies for effective and efficient call center management. These models
and tools are based on the company’s experience with a wide variety of call and contact centers
in different industries. This article focuses on the importance of the customer contact center to
the entire enterprise and presents a methodology for call center performance management and
149
ongoing improvement.
Keywords: Call centers, Performance management, Models
51. Gander, P. Changing places [call centres], Marketing Business, 95, 2001, 32–34.
Abstract. Call centres are by their very nature beset by a series of conflicts. They are one of
the most labour intensive marketing operations, and yet clients expect to pay a minimum for the
service. They are supposed to be about supporting brands is through positive person-to-person
conflict and yet, even when the actual telecoms engineering is up to scratch, the nature of the
work and conditions mean that, staff morale is frequently low and turnover high. Now another
poser has been added to the list. How do you gear up for the Internet age when recruitment,
training and technology are all directed towards the telephone-based voice transaction? Clearly,
common sense would suggest that the industry has had time enough to prepare for the e-mail
world. And in fact there are good examples of dedicated or integrated centres already up and
running. But where the importance of e-mail communication is played down by managers, or
the organisational challenge puzzled over for too long, it may the client impatience rather than
calm, internal appraisal which ends up being the catalyst for change.
52. Gilmore, Audrey. Call centre management: Is service quality a priority? Managing Service
Quality, 11 (3), 2001, 153–159.
Abstract. In recent years the call centre industry has grown rapidly in size and popularity. In so
doing, the industry has been perceived to suffer from some of the problems associated with indus-
trial mass production. The nature of the requirement to answer a high number of calls in these
centres had led to the use of a traditional “production-line” management approach. Recently,
as a result of both customers’ and employees’ expectations rising in relation to service delivery,
the trend is for call centre operations to become more focused on staff empowerment, moving
away from the traditional production-line approach. For many companies, this has become a
difficult management problem. This paper reports on one such company. Following a number of
years’ reliance on carrying out surveys of customer perceptions, and a history of subsequent lack
of service improvement, this research used an in-depth case study approach incorporating ob-
servation studies, interviews with different levels of managers, and focus-group discussions with
front-line service delivery staff (agents). The findings identified the service quality issues to be
addressed in order to reconcile customers’ and agents’ needs, and the implications for managers.
Keywords: Service quality, United Kingdom, Production, Empowerment
(Appears also in Section IV.)
53. Hiroshi, Enoki, Kitamura Yasuhiko, Tatsumi Sho ji and Kitamua Shozo. Job allocation mech-
anism to support a call center: Multiagent approach based on market economic model. Pro-
ceedings of the IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man and Cybernetics, Tucson, AZ,
USA, 2, 2001, 1119–1124.
Abstract. This paper proposes a fair allocation method of the job in a call center adapting
the multiagent system with self-interested agents on the basis of the theory of fair allocation to
150
the market economy for realizing fairness to the job of the agent who works in a call center.
This method leads to a problem solving of the burnout, and it is one of the sub jects in a call
center. Fair allocation is one of desirable allocation from viewpoint of individual rationality and
social welfare, because it is considered as an allocation, which fills envy-free and Pareto efficiency.
54. Holman, David, Olga Epitropaki and Sue Fernie. Understanding learning strategies in the work-
place: A factor analytic investigation, Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology,
74 (5), 2001, 675–681.
Abstract. The aim of this study was to validate a scale of learning strategies, as derived from the
educational literature, in an organizational context. Participants were 628 call center employees.
Both exploratory and confirmatory factor analyses suggested that a six-factor structure most
accurately represented the learning strategies examined. Specifically, three cognitive (extrinsic
work reflection, intrinsic work reflection, reproduction) and three behavioral strategies (inter-
personal help seeking, help seeking from written material, practical application) were found.
Keywords: Organizational behavior, Call centers, Learning, Occupational psychology, Statistical
analysis
55. Houlihan, Maeve. Managing to manage? Stories from the call centre floor, Journal of European
Industrial Training, 25, 2001, 208–220.
Abstract. Call centres are centralized operations where trained agents communicate with cus-
tomers via phone and using purpose-built information and communication technologies. The
normative model of call centre organization is that tasks are tightly prescribed, routinized,
scripted and monitored. What are the implications for managers and management? Drawing
on ethnographic fieldwork, this article focuses on middle management in call centres: how they
work, how they talk about their work and what alternatives they see. It describes an emerg-
ing understanding of a manager who is as constrained as a worker under this mass customized
bureaucracy. Lack of strategic support and development, a powerfully normative focus on micro-
management and deeply embedded goal conflicts combine to undermine these managers’ scope
to truly manage. Like the agents they supervise, call centre managers are engaged in a coping
pro ject. In this context, they perform their identity with ambivalence: sometimes role embrac-
ing, sometimes resisting.
Keywords: Telemarketing, Customer service management
(Appears also in Section IV.)
56. Lutz, P. Michel, Call centres in Germany: Employment market and qualification requirements,
Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 143–153.
Abstract. In spite of a considerable number of existing studies on the call center market, there
has been up to now no reliable information about the number of call centers or about the number
of employees in these centers. The hierarchy in call centers tends to be rather flat. Shift work
is typical in call centers. The average age of a call center employee is around 40, but in large
call centers they are considerably younger. In Germany there is relatively little fluctuation in
151
employment levels. Most of the call centers train their own staff. Most firms concentrate on
practice-oriented further training within the company and not a basic post-school education.
Keywords: Call centers, Job requirements, Business conditions, Studies
57. Norling, Per. Call centre companies and new patterns of organization, Economic and Industrial
Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 155–168.
Abstract. With a starting point chiefly in the recent theory development concerning service
businesses and virtual businesses, some new patterns in call center theory are shown and new
concepts are developed. Starting at the micro level, the trinity, human-computer-network is
described as the new building block of the organization. The pyramid—the form of organization
where strata of executives direct permanent divisions consisting of specialists fulfilling specific
purposes, is fading away. As a replacement, organizations built from pro jects, pro jects run by
teams, which are constantly changing in structure according to customer demands or internal
problems. A third change is that companies to a constantly growing extent act as if the world
were room-free. Work and pro jects are organized to function on a different common digital
arena.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Organization theory
58. Richardson, Ranald and Vicki Belt. Saved by the bell? Call centres and economic development
in less favoured regions, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 67–98.
Abstract. This article considers the role of call centers in the economic development of less
favored regions (LFR). It suggests that call centers represent a new form of mobile service work
which these regions are increasingly seeking to attract. It considers the factors which are im-
portant in attracting this work. It then explores the policies adopted by two LFRs which have
been reasonably successful in doing so. It suggests that there are a number of benefits from the
attraction of call centers, particularly employment opportunities not otherwise available in such
regions. It also strikes a note of caution, however, questioning, in particular whether these jobs
will last.
Keywords: Call centers, Economic development, Regions, Rural areas, Studies
59. Taylor, P. and P. Bain. Trade unions, workers’ rights and the frontier of control in UK call
centres, Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 39–66.
Abstract. In developing a model of call centre diversity, spanning the dimensions of quantity
and quality, the article develops a critique of aspects of Frenkel et al.’s recent study of ‘front
line’ work. Drawing upon employee survey and interview data from six UK financial sector call
centres, patterns of resistance and the contrasting responses of trade unions to the experience
of intensive working conditions are examined. It is argued, in conclusion, that the newly estab-
lished managerial ’frontiers of control’ require to be combated by new union bargaining agendas
which seek to address employees’ concerns at the point of production.
Keywords: Labor unions, Call centers, Control, Workers, Financial services, Studies
152
60. Thompson, Paul and George Callaghan. Edwards revisited: Technical control and call centres,
Economic and Industrial Democracy, 22 (1), 2001, 13–37.
Abstract. Call centers represent a new strategy by capital to rescue unit labor costs. This
article argues that management has developed a new form of structural control. Theoretically
this draws heavily on Edwards’ concept of technical control, but not only is this shown to be
extended and modified, it is also combined with bureaucratic control which influences the social
structure of the workplace. Contrary to Edwards, such systems are not distinct; rather, they
are blended together in the process of institutionalizing control. Part of the rationale for this
is to camouflage control, to contain conflict by making control a product of the system rather
than involving direct confrontation between management and workers. Despite such attempts,
the struggle for transforming labor power into profitable labor remains, and the article ends by
exploring confrontation between workers and managers and worker agency more generally.
Keywords: Call centers, Control, Work environment, Studies
(Appears also in Section IV.)
61. Tsoukas, Haridimos and Efi Vladimirou. What is organizational knowledge? The Journal of
Management Studies, 38 (7), 2001, 973–993.
Abstract. Organizational knowledge is much talked about but little understood. This paper
conceptualizes organizational knowledge and explores its implications for knowledge manage-
ment. The paper claims that knowledge is the individual capability to draw distinctions, within
a domain of action, based on an appreciation of context or theory, or both. Following the the-
oretical exploration of organizational knowledge, this paper reports the findings of a case study
carried out at a call center in Panafon, Greece.
Keywords: Studies, Impact analysis, Call centers, Knowledge management, Organizational learn-
ing
62. Adria, Marco and Shamsud D. Chowdhury. Making room for the call center, Information Sys-
tems Management, 19 (1), 2002, 71–80.
Abstract. A call center can dramatically improve an organization’s ability to serve its cus-
tomers. Skills for employees in call centers can and should be upgraded. The article suggests
ways of ensuring that the ideal configuration of decentralized decision making and centralized
control takes hold in the organization after the call center is established. Practical advice is
offered for enhancing an organization’s culture even as employees begin to spend less time in
face-to-face interactions.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Customer services, Corporate culture
(Appears also in Section IV.)
63. Bain, P., A. Watson, G. Mulvey, P. Taylor and G. Gall. Taylorism, targets and the pursuit of
quantity and quality by call centre management, New Technology, Work and Employment, 17
(3), 2002, 170–185.
153
Abstract. The paper locates the rise of the call centre within the context of the development of
Taylorist methods and technological change in office work in general. Managerial utilization of
targets to impose and measure employees’ quantitative and qualitative performance is analyzed
in four case-study organizations. The paper concludes that call centre work reflects a paradig-
mic re-configuration of customer servicing operations, and that the continuing application of
Taylorist methods appears likely.
Keywords: Organizational design, Management, Opinions, Payment systems
64. Belt, Vicki. A female ghetto? Women’s careers in call centres, Human Resource Management
Journal, 12 (4), 2002, 51–66.
Abstract. Although several studies have shown that women make up the ma jority of the call
centre workforce, their role and position in this new and expanding industry has not yet been
examined. This article makes a contribution to the research gap by exploring the extent and
nature of the career opportunities open to women within call centres. Current portrayals of call
centre work appear to indicate that these new workplaces offer very little in the way of either
job satisfaction or potential for career progression. Indeed, on the basis of existing research
evidence, it could be concluded that call centres represent little more than female job ‘ghettos’.
The article assesses this claim by drawing on women’s own accounts of their work experiences
and their perceptions of their prospects.
Keywords: Studies, Call centres, Female employees, Opportunity, Career advancement
65. Bristow, G., P. Gripas, S. Keast and M. Munday. Call centre growth and the distribution of
financial services activity in the UK, The Service Industries Journal, 22 (3), 2002, 117–134.
Abstract. This article examines the growth and distribution of telephone call centers in the
UK financial services sector. These are concentrated in the conurbations of Scotland and the
north-west and in the south-east region, including Greater London. There is consideration of the
extent to which the development of such centers is changing the spatial division of labor in finan-
cial services. The article also models the determinants of the spatial distribution of call center
activity. Though the results must be treated with some caution, it appears that labor supply, an
original concentration of financial services employemnt, female earnings and the socio-economic
composition of the labor force may be important determinants of the distribution of call center
activity.
Keywords: Financial services, Call centers, Labor market, Effects
66. Deery, Stephen and Nicholas Kinnie. Call centres and beyond: A thematic evaluation, Human
Resource Management, 12 (4), 2002, 3–13.
Abstract. This introduction aims to place the articles in this special edition in the context of
the wider literature on call centers. The discussion is arranged around 4 themes: the character-
istics and organizational features of call center work, the choices and strategies that are available
to manage the work, the effects of this type of work on employees and, finally, the responses and
reactions of call center staff to their work experiences. The articles selected, which are drawn
154
from a conference sponsored by this journal, are then summarized.
Keywords: Call centers, Human resource management
67. Douthitt, Elizabeth A. Effects of leader behaviors on service employee role perceptions, fairness
perceptions, and performance, Dissertation - Abstracts - International Section A: Humanities
and Social Sciences, 62 (11-A), 2002.
Abstract. Leaders play an important role in communicating role expectations, and in support-
ing and facilitating effective performance. Their behaviors may be critical to their ability to
effectively facilitate high-level performance. Leaders face particular challenges in service envi-
ronments such as call centers, where employee job effectiveness is influenced by the quality of
interactions with customers. Call centers commonly use monitoring practices, and yet the effects
of these practices are not understood. Monitoring along with other leader behaviors may convey
information to employees about role expectations. The clarity, effectiveness, and perceived fair-
ness of these role messages may depend in part on the combination of behaviors leaders elect to
use. This study applied role theory and justice theory to predict interactive effects of leader mon-
itoring and other behaviors on employee role perceptions and fairness perceptions. Monitoring
and three other behaviors were predicted to interactively influence role ambiguity, role accuracy
and fairness perceptions. These perceptions in turn were predicted to influence performance and
turnover intentions. A web-based survey was conducted in a customer service call center. The
survey inquired about leader behaviors, employee perceptions, turnover intent and performance.
Results supported some of the predictions. Leader monitoring and recognition interacted in
their relationship with role ambiguity. A joint relationship between monitoring
× empowerment
and perceived fairness was mediated by role ambiguity. Role ambiguity was negatively related
to fairness perceptions. Perceived fairness was positively related to performance and negatively
related to turnover intent. No relationships were revealed involving role accuracy. Results of the
study indicate that effects of monitoring are conditional upon other leader behaviors, specifically
those that empower employees and recognize their performance. The two interactive combina-
tions of leader behaviors had different effects on employee role ambiguity and on perceptions
of leader fairness. Results of the study also contributed to a deeper understanding of fairness
perceptions and the importance of adequate role-related information. Employees who reported
experiencing greater role clarity (less role ambiguity) indicated greater perceptions of leader
fairness. The results demonstrate the utility of role theory and organizational justice theory
for developing predictions and gaining insights into effective leadership behaviors in customer
service environments.
Keywords: Role perceptions, Fairness, Job performance, Leader behaviors
68. Eveleth, Daniel M. and Linda Morris. Adaptive selling in a call center environment: A qualita-
tive investigation, Journal of Interactive Marketing, 16 (1), 2002, 25.
Abstract. Technological changes and innovations have created the means by which organiza-
tions can centralize the selling function into a call-center environment. While there are numerous
benefits to this centralization, the fact that potential customers are drawn to a call center via
telephone or Web-based communication media from a wide geographic area heightens the need
for sales representatives to preform adaptive-selling behaviors. This study found evidence to
155
confirm this belief, suggesting that a premium is placed on sales representatives who can accu-
rately assess each situation using limited information and then to correctly adapt their behavior
to fit the situation. The results also offer implications for Web-based call centers that link sales
representatives with potential customers through text-based communication.
Keywords: Salespeople, Call centers, Studies, Adaptability, Technological change, Market re-
search
69. Foss, Bryan, Iain Henderson, Peter Johnson, Don Murray and Merlin Stone. Managing the
quality and completeness of customer data, The Journal of Database Marketing, 10 (2), 2002,
139–158.
Abstract. Although companies have been collecting customer-related data for years, this was
normally for administration rather than customer management. While larger companies have
more recently collected customer data for database marketing—to recruit new customers, sell
more to existing customers, support customer service operations, and retain customers—returns
are usually limited because most data are still held and used departmentally. The growth of
contact centers, e-commerce, and more complex value chains has raised additional issues of en-
terprise data management and exploitation, while demonstrating beyond doubt that available
data are insufficient to support new customer management processes. The article considers these
issues and proposed tried and tested approaches for addressing these customer data management
issues in a practical and achievable manner.
Keywords: Database marketing, Marketing management, Data integrity, Customer relationship
management
(Appears also in Section II.)
70. Grimshaw, D., F.L. Cooke, I. Grugulis and S. Vincent. New technology and changing organi-
sational forms: Implications for managerial control and skills, New Technology, Work and Em-
ployment, 17 (3), 2002, 186–203.
Abstract. Changes in organisational forms are central to the way new technologies impact on
the future of work and employment. Drawing on case-study evidence of a call centre and its
client relations and a multinational IT firm and its partnership with a government department,
this paper explores the implications for skill and managerial control.
Keywords: New technology, Organisational form change, Employment, Case study evidence, Call
centre, Information technology, Client relations, Multinational IT firm, Government, Managerial
control
71. Holman, David. Employee wellbeing in call centres, Human Resource Management Journal, 12
(4), 2002, 35–50.
Abstract. Call centres are often perceived to have a negative impact on employee wellbeing,
mainly attributed to four factors: job design, performance monitoring, HR practices and team
leader support. This article reports on a survey of 557 customer service representatives that
examined the relationship of these factors to four measures of wellbeing: anxiety, depression
156
and intrinsic and extrinsic job satisfaction. One distinctive feature of this article is its focus on
anxiety and depression, two ma jor dimensions of wellbeing not addressed in call centre research
to date. Results demonstrated that the factors most highly associated with wellbeing were high
control over work methods and procedures, a low level of monitoring and a supportive team
leader. Evidence also indicates that the level of wellbeing in some call centres is similar to that
in other comparable forms of work.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Organizational behavior, Job satisfaction, Psychological aspects
72. Houlihan, Maeve. Tensions and variations in call centre management strategies,Human Resource
Management Journal, 12 (4), 2002, 67–85.
Abstract. Management strategies in call centres face a series of tensions stemming from conflicts
between achieving efficiency and providing a quality service to the customer. Recent research
suggests high commitment management (HCM) techniques are being applied in call centres in
a paradoxical strategy of ‘low discretion, high commitment’ (LDHC). This article presents case
findings on four British call centres that confirm the LDHC model but suggest that it operates
in a variety of forms. By characterizing the research sites according to the combined dimensions
of HCM orientation and job design implementation, a typology of LDHC approaches is pro-
posed. These are containment, alleviation, structured employee development and involvement.
In essence, the LDHC model is an attempt to reconcile the costs of control with the levers of
commitment. However, an examination of the realities of LDHC in action reveals a varied but
persistent pull towards control. Fundamentally, this exposes LDHC as a substitute for, rather
than a reflection of, commitment.
Keywords: Studies, Call centres, Management styles, Efficiency, Quality of service, Models
73. Nagin, Daniel S., James B. Rebitzer, Seth Sanders and Lowell J. Taylor. Monitoring, motiva-
tion, and management: The determinants of opportunistic behavior in a field experiment, The
American Economic Review, 92 (4), 2002, 850–873.
Abstract. Economic models of incentives in employment relationships are based on a specific
theory of motivation: Employees are rational cheaters, who anticipate the consequences of their
actions and shirk when the marginal benefits exceed the costs. The rational cheater model is
investigated by observing how experimentally induced variation in monitoring of telephone call
center employees influences opportunism. A significant fraction of employees behave as the ra-
tional cheater model predicts. A substantial proportion of employees, however, do not respond
to manipulations in the monitoring rate. This heterogeneity is related to variation in employee
assessments of their general treatment by the employer.
Keywords: Economic theory, Economic models, Studies, Incentives, Employees, Call centers,
Behavior, Motivation, Experiments
74. Raestrup, B. Call Center Agent Network—a strategy against ‘Cubicalization’: A virtual commu-
nity for call-center workers in the information industry. WWDU 2002—World Wide Work. Pro-
ceedings of the 6th International Scientific Conference on Work with Display Units, H. Luczak,
157
A.E. Cakir and G. Cakir (eds.), Ergonomic Institut fur Arbeits- und Sozialforschung, Forschungs-
gesellschaft mbH, Berlin, 2002, 256–258.
Abstract. The call centre industry creates jobs with similar working conditions and a similar
workload all over the world. The jobs of the call centre agents are highly dependent on tech-
nological, economic, and strategic international developments. In contrast to this situation, call
centre research and call centre policies in most countries are conducted only at the national level.
Yet there is a need to transfer information, knowledge, and strategy in an international context.
Congresses on call centre agents’ working conditions are held without the participation of the
agents. Call centre agents sell their voice and their mind at work: It is not their voice on line—it
is the voice of the company they are working for. As a result of these facts, the Call Centre
Agent Network was started in October 2001 as an international communication and information
platform. The Network is a no-budget pro ject, so the author was forced to run the Web site
very economically. The virtual conference is an experiment in sharing information about work-
ing conditions in all centres worldwide and starting an international networking pro ject for call
centre workers.
Keywords: Information systems and communication
75. Richardson, H. and K. Richardson. Customer relationship management systems (CRM) and
information ethics in call centrres—‘You are the weakest link. Goodbye!’, Australian Journal of
Information Systems, 9 (2), 2002, 166–171.
Abstract. This paper catalogues the rise of call centres in the North West of England, UK
and their use of CRM systems. CRM systems often imply new technologies and new ways of
working. However, in this account, we explore the historical development of the telegraph and
work in early telephone exchanges and find the same old story. Our consideration of the ethics
of CRM system use and some inherent contradictions are in terms of privacy, communication
richness, management methods and computer ethics in an organizational context. Call centres
today are viewed by some as offering satisfying employment of intrinsic value; for others, they
are the ‘new sweatshops of the 21st century’ (Belt et al., 2000). Our interpretative field study
makes a contribution to this debate.
(Appears also in Section IV.)
76. Taylor, P., J. Hyman, G. Mulvey and P. Bain. Work organization, control and the experience of
work in call centres, Work Employment and Society, 16 (1), 2002, 133–150.
Abstract. Despite the integration of telephone and VDU technologies, call centres are not
uniform in terms of work organization. It is suggested that diversity can best be understood by
reference to a range of quantitative and qualitative characteristics. Consequently, perspectives
that treat all call centres as if they were the same hybrids of customization and routinization
are rejected, along with over-optimistic interpretations of labour control over work organization.
Empirical evidence from nine ‘workflows’ in two call centres—an established financial sector,
organization and a rapidly growing outsourced operation—provide excellent grounds for an ex-
amination of similarity and difference. A picture emerges of workflows which are volume-driven
and routinized, involving low levels of employee discretion, and by contrast, those less domi-
158
nated by quantitative criteria offering higher levels of operator discretion and an emphasis on
the quality of customer service. Despite these distinctions, larger numbers of operators report an
experience of work which is driven by quantitative imperatives, most manifest in the pervasive
implementation of targets. Targets are also used increasingly to assess and mould the quality
of the call centre operator’s interaction with the customer. Overall, the evidence casts doubt
on the optimistic perspective that call centre work, in time, will come to resemble ‘knowledge
work’.
Keywords: Call centres, Knowledge economy, Taylorism, Work organization
77. Taylor, Steven A., Gary L. Hunter. The impact of loyalty with e-CRM software and e-services,
International Journal of Service Industry Management, 13 (5), 2002, 452–474.
Abstract. E-service is a critical strategic marketing consideration today for many firms, based
largely on the promise of more cost-effective models of self-service relative to large (and expen-
sive) call centers for technical support and customer service. The rapidly emerging electronic cus-
tomer relationship management (e-CRM) industry provides the primary tools for implementing
e-service. Interestingly, the e-CRM industry faces the same challenges and strategic marketing
considerations as their organizational customers, in that they must deliver exceptional service
and support to the companies purchasing/using e-CRM software. A review of organizational
mission/vision statements suggests that e-CRM companies are generally positioning themselves
as exemplars of customer satisfaction provision and relationship management. However, recent
industry analysis suggests that their organizational customers generally report low to ambiva-
lent ratings on customer satisfaction measures (our study also supports these findings). This
discrepancy could be partly attributed to very little empirical inquiry having appeared to date
to assess the efficacy of existing relationship marketing theories within this fast-moving industry.
The current study provides an exploratory investigation that looks at the well-established (in
other marketing settings) relative influences of quality, customer satisfaction, and loyalty in the
formation of future purchase intentions and word-of-mouth behaviors within the e-CRM indus-
try. Concludes that e-CRM marketers must first identify means of increasing the overall level
of customer satisfaction within their industry, and then begin to consider moving beyond cus-
tomer satisfaction toward broader loyalty-based strategic marketing ob jectives to support their
relationship marketing practices. Practitioner and research implications of the reported study
are discussed.
Keywords: Relationship marketing, E-commerce, Customer loyalty, Consumer behavior, Com-
puter software
78. van den Broek, Diane. Monitoring and surveillance in call centres: Some responses from Aus-
tralian workers, Labour & Industry, 12 (3), 2002, 43–58.
Abstract. Australian call centres currently number around 4,000, in industries such as bank-
ing, public utilities, airlines, information technology, and telecommunications. Of the 200,000
employees in the call centre industry, the Australian Council of Trade Unions (ACTU) estimates
that around 15 to 20 percent are unionised. Unionised call centres are generally located in the
public or ex-public sector such as the airlines, while employees in other industries including
159
telecommunications and banking are considerably less unionised. The contract call centres have
proven to be the most difficult to organise. (Interview ACTU Organiser, 2001).
(Appears also in Section IV.)
79. Cartwright, Susan. New forms of work organization: Issues and challenges, Leadership and Or-
ganization Development Journal, 24 (3), 2003, 121–122.
Abstract. The changing nature of work and the emergence of new forms of work organiza-
tion present particular challenges to leadership and management. This special issue examines
some of the challenges and issues in the relationship between technology, stress and satisfaction
within call centre environments, the problems of remote leadership and the rise in contingent
workforce.
Keywords: Work organization, Work teams, Call centres, Workforce, Leadership, Temporary
workers
(Appears also in Section IV.)
80. Gelders, Dave and Michel Walrave. The Flemish customer contact centre for public information
from a marketing and management perspective, International Journal of Nonprofit and Volun-
tary Sector, 8 (2), 2003, 166.
Abstract. This paper describes the Flemish customer contact centre for government informa-
tion (‘the Flemish Infoline’) as an example of marketing in the public sector. First, it defines
the term ‘customer contact centre’ and describes the ob jectives and main characteristics of the
Flemish infoline. It then identifies the three reasons for setting up the Flemish infoline in 1999:
the complicated Belgian institutional landscape; the unprofessional telephone traffic handling
and service; and the lack of knowledge about citizens’ information needs. Finally, the paper
applies Kotler’s 4 Ps concept to the case, and puts the relevant stages from Lees-Marshment’s
political marketing orientations into one integrated scheme in order to understand the function-
ing of the Flemish infoline. Based on the literature and on an in-depth interview with the pro ject
head of the Flemish infoline, the authors demonstrate that marketing techniques can be used in
contact centres for public information, but they also illustrate some important differences from
those in the for-profit sector, such as the available amount of customers’ personal data, the level
of call operators’ skills and the degree of heterogeneity of the questions. Further research on
information needs and contact centres, and providing one ‘umbrella’ contact centre for govern-
ment information in Belgium are recommended.
Keywords: Call centres, Public sector, Information dissemination, Market strategy, Statistical
data
81. Grebner, Simone, Norbert K. Semmer, Luca Lo Faso, Stephan Gut, Wolfgang K¨
alin and Achim
Elfering. Working conditions, well-being, and job-related attitudes among call centre agents,
European Journal of Work and Organizational Psychology, 12 (4), 2003, 341–365.
Abstract. A comparison of 234 call centre agents with 572 workers in traditional jobs with long-
lasting training revealed lower job control and task complexity/variety and higher uncertainty
160
among call agents. However, time pressure, concentration demands, and work interruptions were
lower in call agents. Within the call agent sample, controlling for negative affectivity and other
working conditions, job control predicted intention to quit, and job complexity/variety predicted
job satisfaction and effective commitment. Social stressors and task-related stressors predicted
uniquely indicators of well-being and job-related attitudes. Furthermore, data confirm the role
of emotional dissonance as a stressor in its own right, as it explained variance in irritated re-
actions and psychosomatic complaints beyond other working conditions. Results indicate that
strong division of labour may be a rather general phenomenon in call centres. Therefore, working
conditions of call agents require a redesign by means of job enrichment or, better, organizational
development. Moreover, measures of social stressors and emotional dissonance should be inte-
grated routinely into stress-related job analyses in service jobs.
82. Grougiou, Vassiliki and Alan Wilson. Financial service call centres: Problems encountered by
the grey market, Journal of Financial Services Marketing, 7 (4), 2003, 360.
Abstract. Technological advances have resulted in financial service companies being able to
make use of alternative channels such as call centers and the Internet to deliver their services
to their customers. At the same time, there has been a ma jor growth throughout Europe in
the gray market consisting of people who grew up in an age of face-to-face contact with service
suppliers. This paper reports on a program of qualitative research looking at the gray market’s
perceptions of the call center delivery channel. It discusses the difficulties encountered by this
market and the negative views that are held. It also highlights the need for further research into
this area if financial service organizations are going to address the issues raised and effectively
satisfy the needs of this growing market segment.
Keywords: Financial services, Older people, Consumer attitudes, Call centers, Customer ser-
vices, Market research, Studies
83. Hyman, J., C. Baldry, D. Scholarios and D. Bunzel. Work-life imbalance in call centres and
software development, British Journal of Industrial Relations, 41 (2), 2003, 215.
Abstract. The paper evaluates the centrality of work to employees in two growing employment
sectors, call centres and software development. It then examines evidence for extensions of work
into household and family life in these two sectors. Extensions are identified as tangible, such
as unpaid overtime, or intangible, represented by incursions imported from work, such as ex-
haustion and stress. The study finds that organizational pressure, combined with lack of work
centrality, result in work intruding into non-work areas of employee lives, though intrusions
manifest themselves in different ways according to type of work, levels of worker autonomy and
organizational support.
Keywords: Studies, Call centers, Software industry, Work life programs, Working conditions,
Statistical analysis
(Appears also in Section III.)
84. Richardson, Ranald and Andrew Gillespie. The call of the wild: Call centers and economic
development in rural areas, Growth and Change, 34 (1), 2003, 87–108.
161
Abstract. This paper attempts to reflect critically on the role which telephone call centers
might play in the eonomic development of rural places in the “information age”, drawing mainly
on a case study of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland. It argues that although call center
employment tends mainly to be urban-based, the growth of this form of work does present op-
portunities for some rural areas. The paper considers the locational factors rural areas would
have to possess or develop in order to attract such work. It suggests call centers can make a
valuable though limited contribution towards rural economic development, principally through
the creation of additional employment opportunities and the stimulation of new skills and com-
petencies. It also suggests that call centers do not represent a panacea for rural areas and that,
indeed, it would be dangerous for rural areas to become over-reliant on employment in this sec-
tor.
Keywords: Telecommunications, Urban, rural and regional economics, Regional migration, Re-
gional labor markets, Population, Information and Internet services, Computer software, Tele-
phone, Other production and pricing analysis (spatial analysis)
85. Sewell-Staples, Warren J., John F. Dalrymple and Katherine Phipps. Auditing excellence in call
centres: Access is a corporate responsibility, Managerial Auditing Journal, 18 (1/2), 2003, 68.
Abstract. The call centre industry is one of the most rapidly growing industries in the devel-
oped world. This paper examines how the Australian Quality Council and the European Foun-
dation for Quality Management address issues of access and corporate responsibility through
their respective devices, namely the Australian Business Excellence Framework and the EFQM
Excellence Model. The Australian Business Excellence Framework was introduced to help Aus-
tralian companies meet the challenges of the global environment. The study then examines the
impact of the UK and Australian Disability Discrmination Legislation in light of UK and Aus-
tralian studies on the provision of services for the hearing impaired by call centres.
Keywords: Studies, Models, Corporate responsibility, Call centers, Handicapped people, Dis-
crimination, Auditing
86. Silvestro, R., C. Silvestro. New service design in the NHS: An evaluation of the strategic align-
ment of NHS Direct, International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 23 (4),
2003, 401–417.
Abstract. Awareness of inconsistencies and variability in the delivery of health services across
the UK has heightened in recent years, leading to general acknowledgement that a move away
from “health care by post code” is a strategic priority for the National Health Service (NHS).
NHS Direct, a call centre service for patients and their carers, is unique in the NHS in that it
represents an entirely new service concept, with a rare opportunity to design a single nation-wide
service from scratch, and to manage and coordinate a delivery system consistently throughout
the country. Evaluates the strategic alignment of NHS Direct during the first three years of
implementation through an analysis of its service concept, its operational ob jectives, the design
of its delivery systems and its volume and variety characteristics. The evaluation reveals an
absence of a central design specification which has resulted in wide variation in the call centres’
service portfolios, resource bases, competences, telephony and clinical expert systems. Contends
that variation and variability in the design of the call centres has severely compromised NHS
162
Direct’s ability to meet its strategic and operational ob jectives, resulting in strategic misalign-
ment. Also identifies missed opportunities to learn from the growing call centre literature and
from service shops in other industries.
Keywords: Service design, NHS Direct, Strategic alignment, National Health Service, Call centre
service, Operational ob jectives, Strategic misalignment
(Appears also in Section IX.)
87. Sturdy, Andrew and Peter Fleming. Talk as technique—a critique of the words and deeds dis-
tinction in the diffusion of customer service cultures in call centres, The Journal of Management
Studies, 40 (4), 2003, 753.
Abstract. This paper critically explores the common distinction made between words and deeds
(or ideas and techniques) in the diffusion of management knowledge literature. The concern with
whether management ideas are really being implemented in an organizational context intuitively
points to the possibility of a contrast between simply talking about a practice or ‘hype’ and prac-
tical implementation. Drawing on empirical research on the diffusion of customer service culture
in two call centres where ‘verbal labour’ predominates, it is argued that this distinction is im-
portant, but overdrawn. Eschewing discursive reductionism, the concepts of ‘talk in work’ and
‘talk about work’ are developed to illustrate how talk can be a technique of implementation in
its own right.
Keywords: Studies, Communication, Management theory, Customer services, Call centers
88. Adria, Marco and Shamsud D. Chowdhury. Centralization as a design consideration for the
management of call centers, Information & Management, 41 (4), 2004, 497–507.
Abstract. A call center and its associated information technology (IT) provide an opportunity
to redesign and improve service-delivery operations. Managers at all levels should understand
the role of organizational design as call centers are established or expanded, in particular, the rel-
ative centralization (distribution of authority) associated with delivering services to customers.
This article argues that centralization moderates and influences the organization’s efforts to im-
prove customer service through the implementation of the call center and its IT. If managers
fail to capitalize on the particular way that centralization moderates between IT and compet-
itive strategy, the organization may not enjoy an important benefit of the call center which
is competitive advantage through increased efficiency and improved customer service. Based
on survey responses from 68 call-center managers, the authors found that both centralization
and decentralization are associated with call-center service operations. While the call center
provides managers with the ability to influence decision-making (centralization), there are also
opportunities for agents in the call center to exercise authority in managing the organization’s
communications with customers (decentralization). Implications for organizational practice are
considered.
Keywords: Call centers, Centralization, Decentralization, Organizational design, Customer ser-
vice
89. Dean, Alison M. Rethinking customer expectations of service quality: Are call centers different?
163
The Journal of Services Marketing, 18 (1), 60–78, 2004.
Abstract. Reported studies on call centers emphasize efficiency and control, with possible im-
plications for service priorities, customer orientation and service quality. However, there is little
empirical research to test assumptions from the customer’s perspective. This study aimed to
establish whether customers expected (predicted) low levels of service from a call center, how
this level compared to the minimum level they considered adequate, and whether the perceived
customer orientation of the call center was related to service quality expectations. Data were
collected in Australia from two sources: End consumers (n = 289) of an insurance provider,
and business customers (n = 325) of a bank. Key findings were similar for both samples. First,
customers had very high levels of adequate (minimum) expectations, and adequate expectations
behaved independently from predicted (forecast) expectations. Second, customer orientation
was associated with predicted expectations but not adequate expectations. The paper concludes
with suggestions for future research and managerial implications.
Keywords: Quality of service, Call centers, Studies, Requirements, Customer relations
90. McCabe, Darren. “A land of milk and honey”? Reengineering the “past” and “present” in a
call centre, The Journal of Management Studies, 41 (5), 827–856, 2004.
Abstract. This article explores how managers in the call centre of a bank, (re)defined, and
drew boundaries around ‘past’ cultural conditions, in relation to the introduction of a Business
Process Reengineering (BPR) regime. Managers represented the ‘past’ negatively, in terms of
conflict and coercion, whilst the ‘present’ was largely described as a Shangri-La of teams and
consensus. This eschewing of the ‘past’ and sublimation of the ‘present’ stood in opposition to
the representations of the staff. Both the ‘staff ’ and ‘managers’ seemed to reject or embrace
discourses that challenged or coincided with their understanding of how things are or should
be. In view of this, their understanding of the past/present is inseparable from a consideration
of power and identity. The article examines the interplay between discourses and individuals,
arguing that it is bound up with fear and anxiety, hope and aspiration, memory and nostalgia,
among other, everyday life experiences.
Keywords: Corporate culture, Call centers, Studies, Managers, Business process reengineering,
Banking industry
91. Ramsaran, C. Contact centers or cost centers? Bank Systems + Technology, 41 (1), 29–31, 2004.
Abstract. IM, e-mail and cross-selling are among the ways banks are striving to improve ser-
vice and profitability in their contact centers. However, the challenges of staffing, equipping
and managing those centers so that they operate efficiently and cost-effectively have existed just
as long as banks have needed these contact centers. And, as contact centers become increas-
ingly technology-enabled, bankers have had to balance the sometimes competing demands of
“high-tech and high touch” with other imperatives, ranging from new privacy requirements to
changing expectations of customer service to the need to demonstrate technology ROI. But the
reality remains that, for the most part, the activity at bank contact centers generally is viewed
as a cost—almost the proverbial necessary evil—rather than a revenue generator.
164
92. Van den Broek, Diane. “We have the values”: Customers, control and corporate ideology in call
centre operations, New Technology, Work, and Employment, 19 (1), 2–13, 2004.
Abstract. This article analyses the use of normative control through recruitment, work organ-
isation, social events, and bargaining processes within two Australian telecommunication call
centres. Rather than arguing that such control reduced employees to “self-discipling sub jects”,
it suggests that these control mechanisms embodied significant levels of managerial coercion and,
therefore, attracted varying levels of resistance.
Keywords: Call centers, Recruitment, Internal controls, Customer relations
165
VIII Simulation, Petri Nets, Genetic Algorithms
1. Kwan, Stephen K., Mark M. Davis and Allen G. Greenwood. A simulation model for determin-
ing variable worker requirements in a service operation with time-dependent customer demand,
Queueing Systems, 3, 1988, 265–276.
Abstract. In a service operation where worker requirements have to be determined for short
scheduling time periods with nonstationary customer demand, the assumptions necessary for
applying steady-state solutions to elementary queueing models are usually violated. This pa-
per describes a simulation study of the behavior of such a service operation. The results are
compared with the steady-state solutions to a queueing model where individual scheduling time
periods are assumed to be independent. It is found that if the system utilization is below a
derived maximum value (based on a service level criterion), then the steady-state solutions are
robust enough to explain the behavior of the system and can be used to schedule worker require-
ments.
Keywords: Simulation, Service operations, Worker requirements, Queueing models
(Appears also in Section I.)
2. Liu, F.K. and D. Seagraves. An ISDN application-simulation modeling of NACD. Teletraffic
and Datatraffic in a Period of Change. ITC-13. Proceedings of the Thirteenth International
Teletraffic Congress. North-Holland, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1991, 279–284.
Abstract. Network automatic call distribution (NACD) utilizes the integrated services digital
network (ISDN) standard as a vehicle to effectively distribute calls between ACD sites. Due to
the dynamic nature of NACD, its routing algorithm, dependent upon the network congestion
status, is very hard to describe mathematically and its system performance is just as hard to
evaluate accurately. A simulation model, based on the SLAM II (simulation language for alter-
native modeling) simulation language, is shown to be an effective tool to evaluate the system
performance of a network with the NACD application, due to its flexibility in implementing
routing criteria reflecting the unique NACD features. The result of simulation indicates that
use of NACD produces a significant improvement in grade of service and agent utilization. The
improvement is most pronounced when agent load is unbalanced in a non-NACD environment.
Keywords: Unbalanced agent load, Automatic call distribution, Integrated services digital net-
work, Routing algorithm, Network congestion status, SLAM II, Simulation language
3. Brigandi, Anthony J., Dennis R. Dargon, Michael J. Sheehan and Thomas Spencer III. AT&T’s
call processing simulator (CAPS) operational design for inbound call centers, Interfaces, 24 (1),
1994, 6–28.
Abstract. Since 1978, AT&T has been developing the call processing simulator (CAPS) to
design and evaluate inbound call centers. The current version of CAPS is a user-friendly PC-
based system employing a discrete event simulation model with animation and queuing models
of both the telecommunications network and AT&T’s business customer’s call center environ-
ment. Using CAPS, AT&T can model a network of call centers utilizing advanced 800 network
166
features before its customers make capital investments to start or change their call centers. In
1992, AT&T completed about 2,000 CAPS studies for its business customers, helping it increase,
protect, and regain more than $1 billion in an $8-billion 800-network market. The CAPS tool
is also the turnkey for more than $750 million in annual profit for AT&T’s business customers
who received CAPS studies.
Keywords: AT&T, Call processing simulator, CAPS, Inbound call centers, User-friendly PC-
based system, Animation, Queuing models, Telecommunications network, Advanced 800 net-
work features
(Appears also in Section VII.)
4. Perry, M. and A. Nilsson. Performance modeling of automatic call distributors: Operator ser-
vices staffing with heterogeneous positions. Fundamental Role of Teletraffic in the Evolution of
Telecommunications Networks. Proceeding of the 14th International Teletraffic Congress, ITC-
14. Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1994, 1023–1032.
Abstract. The telephony industry has introduced a new generation of multi-purpose operator
positions, that with their associated automatic call distributor (ACD) allow operators to serve
both toll and assist (TA) and directory assistance (DA) calls from the same position. When all
operators can serve both TA and DA calls and all of the positions are multi-purpose, classical
Erlang-type queueing models can be used to calculate two important measures: the expected
waiting time for calls and the average operator occupancy. However when all of the positions
are not multi-purpose (i.e. the operators are a heterogeneous group: some can do both TA and
DA, some can do just TA and some can do just DA) the calculation of these two measures is
a new and challenging problem. In this paper, approximations for expected waiting times and
average occupancies are presented, and are shown, by comparison to simulation results, to be
quite accurate.
Keywords: Performance modeling, Automatic call distributors, Operator services staffing, Het-
erogeneous positions, Telephony industry, Multi-purpose operator positions, Automatic call dis-
tributor, ACD, Toll and assist calls, Directory-assistance calls, Classical Erlang-type queueing
models, Expected waiting time, Average operator occupancy, Average occupancies, Simulation
results
(Appears also in Section I.)
5. Anisimov, N., K. Kishinski, A. Miloslavski and P. Postupalsk. Macroplaces in high level Petri
nets: application for design inbound call center. Information Systems Analysis and Synthesis.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Information Systems Analysis and Synthesis.
ISAS’96. Int. Inst. Inf. Syst, Orlando, FL, USA, 1996, 415–422.
Abstract. The paper is devoted to the use of the Petri net approach for the construction of
formal models, intended as the basis for the development of the logical structure of inbound call
centers. As a formal model for a specification of agent scenarios the paper considers a formalism
called a script-net that belongs to a class of high level Petri nets. It is emphasized that scripts
describing real-world scenarios are usually extremely complicated and require some means of
modularization. The paper suggests the extension of high level nets called high level macronets,
intended for specification situations which are asynchronous to normal processing of scripts.
167
The model is shown to be a compact notation of high level nets without macroplaces and a
corresponding transformation procedure is presented. Some examples are used to illustrate the
power of the formalism.
Keywords: High level Petri nets, Inbound call center design, Formal models, Specification, Agent
scenarios, Script net, Modularization, High level macronets, Macroplaces
6. Levasseur, G.A. An ob ject-oriented phone center model using SIMPLE++. 1996 Winter Simu-
lation Conference Proceedings. SCS Int, San Diego, CA, USA, 1996, 556–563.
Abstract. A demonstration model and application ob ject template (ob ject library) was cre-
ated to show how SIMPLE++ simulation software can be applied to service industry telephone
call handling centers. In addition, this example was designed to show modeling techniques that
can be used to take advantage of some key ob ject-orientation concepts to quickly create highly
flexible simulation models. Finally, some features of the SIMPLE++ simulation package are
illustrated.
Keywords: Phone center model, SIMPLE++, Application ob ject template, Ob ject library, Simu-
lation software, Service industry, Telephone call handling centers, Ob ject-oriented programming,
Flexible simulation models, Software packages
7. Massey, W.A., G.A. Parker and W. Whitt. Estimating the parameters of a nonhomogeneous
Poisson process with linear rate, Telecommunications Systems—Modeling, Analysis, Design and
Management, 5 (4), 1996, 361–688.
Abstract. We want to be able to determine if a Poisson process traffic model is appropriate and,
when it is, we want to be able to estimate its parameters from measurements, with linear rate
over a finite interval, based on the number of counts in measurement subintervals. Such a linear
arrival-rate function can serve as a component of a piecewise-linear approximation to a general
arrival-rate function. We consider ordinary least squares (OLS), iterative weighted least squares
(IWLS) and maximum likelihood (ML), all constrained to yield a nonnegative rate function. We
prove that ML coincides with IWLS. As a reference point, we also consider the theoretically op-
timal weighted least squares (TWLS), which is least squares with weights inversely proportional
to the variances (which would not be known with data). Overall, ML performs almost as well
as TWLS. We describe computer simulations conducted to evauate these estimation procedures.
None of the procedures differ greatly when the rate function is not near 0 at either end, but
when the rate function is near 0 at one end, TWLS and ML are significantly more effective than
OLS. The number of measurement subintervals (with fixed total interval) makes surprisingly
little difference when the rate function is not near 0 at either end. The variances are higher
with only two or three subintervals, but there usually is little benefit from going above ten. In
contrast, more measurement intervals help TWLS and ML when the rate function is near 0 at
one end. We derive explicit formulas for the OLS variances and the asymptotic TWLS variances
(as the number of measurement intervals increases), assuming the nonnegativity constraints are
not violated. These formulas reveal the statistical precision of the estimators and the influence
of the parameters and the method. Knowing how the variance depends on the interval length
can help determine how to approximate general arrival-rate functions by piecewise-linear ones.
We also develop statistical tests to determine wehther the linear Poisson model is appropriate.
168
Keywords: Digital simulation, Iterative methods, Least-squares approximations, Maximum likeli-
hood estimation, Parameter estimation, Piecewise linear techniques, Queueing theory, Stochastic
processes, Telecommunication traffic, Nonhomogeneous Poisson process, Piecewise linear approx-
imation, Linear arrival-rate function, Ordinary least squares, Iterative weighted least squares,
Computer simulations, Statistical precision, Traffic model
(Appears also in Section II.)
8. Anisimov, N., K. Kishinski and A. Miloslavski. An approach to design distributed CTI applica-
tions using Petri nets: an example of a call center. SMC’98 Conference Proceedings. 1998 IEEE
International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics. IEEE, New York, NY, USA, 1998,
238–243.
Abstract. In this paper we apply a formal approach, based on Petri nets, to design a logical
structure for call centers based on sophisticated computer telephony integration applications. A
typical call center consists of a set of operators, called agents, who process inbound calls from
clients. This call processing may involve the use of computer systems and other devices, such as
faxes, as well as communication with other agents. The treatment of each call being processed is
heavily regulated by a script, which is specially designed for specific kinds of calls by the experts
in telemarketing. However, the design of such scripts can be problematic. In this paper, we
stress the need for tools supporting a scripting process. We propose a formal model intended
to serve as a basis for such tools. Specifically, we introduce formal models called script nets
for formal representation of scripts and of the call center as a whole. We have also introduced
various ways to structure script nets, using a transition hierarchy and macroplaces.
Keywords: Distributed computer telephone integration applications, Petri nets, Call center, In-
bound calls, Scripting process, Formal models, Script nets, Formal representation, Transition
hierarchy, Macroplaces
9. Bapat, V. and E.B. Pruitte Jr. Using simulation in call centers. 1998 Winter Simulation Con-
ference. Proceedings, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ, USA, 1998, 1395–1399.
Abstract. A company’s call center is its most visible strategic weapon. It is a business battle-
front where millions of dollars of products and services are purchased, sold, and traded. It is
also a place where thousands of customers are won and lost in an instant. As leading companies
become more creative in disseminating information and providing value to their customers over
telephone lines, it is only natural that they look to the call center as their beachhead into the
market. With the importance of call centers on the rise and as reengineering activities within
them growing rampant, simulation technology is emerging as the best analysis tool to manage
change within an increasingly complex environment (D. Profozich, 1997). The paper defines the
value of simulation in call center design, planning, and management by examining key weak-
nesses and strengths of traditional approaches and industry trends. It also discusses how call
centers can maximize their investment in simulation.
Keywords: Strategic weapon, Business battlefront, Leading companies, Telephone lines, Reengi-
neering activities, Simulation technology, Analysis tool, Change management, Complex environ-
ment, Call center design, Industry trends, Investment
169
10. Mason, A.J., D.M. Ryan and D.M. Panton. Integrated simulation, heuristic and optimisation
approaches to staff scheduling, Operations Research, 46 (2), 1998, 161–175.
Abstract. This paper details a new simulation and optimisation based system for personnel
scheduling (rostering) of Customs staff at the Auckland International Airport, New Zealand.
An integrated approach using simulaiton, heuristic descent and integer programming techniques
has been developed to determine near-optimal staffing levels. The system begins by using a new
simulation system embedded within a heuristic search to determine minimum staffing levels for
arrival and departure work areas. These staffing requirements are then used as the input to an
integer programming model which optimally allocates full and part-time staff to each period of
the working day. These shifts are then assigned to daily work schedules having a six-day-on,
three-day-off structure. The application of these techniques has resulted in significantly lower
staffing levels, while at the same time creating both high quality rosters and ensuring that all
passenger processing targets are met. This paper charts the development of this system, outlines
failures.
Keywords: Simulation, Heuristic, Optimisation, Staff scheduling, Personnel scheduling, Ros-
tering, Customs staff, Auckland International Airport, New Zealand, Heuristic descent, Integer
programming, Near optimal staffing levels, Minimum staffing levels, Integer programming model,
Full-time staff, Part-time staff
(Appears also in Section I.)
11. Van Dijk, N.M. On hybrid combination of queueing and simulation. Simulation: Past, Present
and Future. 12th European Simulation Multiconference 1998. ESM’98. As Part of the 50th
Anniversary Celebrations of the University of Manchester - the Home of Computing. SCS, San
Diego, CA, USA, 1998, 731–735.
Abstract. This paper illustrates how simulation and queueing theory can and should go hand in
hand for a variety of practical problems, both in daily-life and industry, which are still open for
fundamental research. To this end, it highlights real-life cases taken from: daily-life situations
(postal office or bank); administrative logistics (reengineering); tele-servicing (call-centres); and
transportation (railways).
Keywords: Simulation, Queueing theory, Postal office, Bank, Administrative logistics, Tele-
servicing, Call centres, Transportation, Railways
(Appears also in Section I.)
12. Yoshimura, K. and R. Nakano. Genetic algorithm for information operator scheduling. 1998
IEEE International Conference on Evolutionary Computation Proceedings. IEEE World Congress
on Computational Intelligence. IEEE, New York, NY, USA, 1998, 277–282.
Abstract. Telephone information operator scheduling is a real-world optimisation problem. A
genetic algorithm using a concise representation of solutions for the problem is successfully ap-
plied. It is shown that mutation is important for the problem. We propose an effective mutation
operator and demonstrate its advantages through numerical experiments. Partial reinitializa-
tion of individuals is also introduced in order to reintroduce diversity into the population and
avoid premature convergence. The experimental results show that the reinitialization strategy
170
improves the search performance.
Keywords: Genetic algorithm, Information operator scheduling, Optimisation, Mutation opera-
tor, Partial reinitialization, Population diversity, Premature convergence, Search performance,
Telephone operators
13. Anisimov, N., K. Kishinski and A. Miloslavski. Formal model, language and tools for design
agent’s scenarios in call center systems. Proceedings of the 32nd Annual Hawaii International
Conference on Systems Sciences. 1999. HICSS-32. Abstracts and CD-ROM of Full Papers.
IEEE Comput. Soc, Los Alamitos, CA, USA, 1999, 9 pp.
Abstract. During the last few years there continues to be remarkable growth in telephone call-
center systems. There are many applications of call-centers in different areas of business such
as in telemarketing, insurance, customer service, electronic commerce, etc. Moreover, in some
cases it is reasonable to think of a call-center as an integrated part of a whole business system
responsible for the telephone interface with the outside world. Typically, a call center consists
of a set of operators, called agents, who process inbound calls from clients. Call processing may
involve the use of computer systems (e.g. database), other devices (e.g. fax-machines, inter-
active voice response units) as well as communication with other agents (e.g. deliver a call to
more qualified agent, making a consulted call). The call processing may also produce outbound
calls. The treatment of each call being processed is heavily regulated by scenarios called scripts
which are specially designed for specific kind’s of the calls. The design of such scripts is one of
the main problems in call center maintenance. To cope with this problem we need special tools,
i.e., scripting language, corresponding editor, related environment. In this paper we present an
ongoing pro ject aimed at the design of such a platform. We introduce a Petri net-based model
for representation of scripts and a logical structure of the call center. The model, called script-
net, is based on ob ject-oriented Petri net dialect belonging to a class of high-level Petri nets. In
particular, the model allows one to formally represent scripts their communication with agents
and other resources, exception handling time constrains. We also consider some implementation
issues. In particular, we outline a visual iconic language specially designed for script specifica-
tion. The semantics of the language is based on script-nets. An agent of the call center can be
perceived as a specific resource and is implemented with the aid of Internet/Intranet technology.
To illustrate the use of suggested tools, some typical examples of scripts are presented including
scenarios for inbound and outbound telemarketing.
Keywords: Formal model, Formal language, Design agent’s scenarios, Call center systems, Tele-
phone call center systems, Telemarketing, Insurance, Customer service, Electronic commerce,
Ob ject-oriented Petri net dialect, Visual iconic language
14. Fischer, M.J., D.A. Garbin, A. Gharakhanian and D.M. Masi. Traffic engineering of distributed
call centers: not as straight forward as it may seem. Proceedings of the Applied Telecommuni-
cations Symposium (ATS’99). 1999 Advanced Simulation Technologies Conference. SCS, San
Diego, CA, USA, 1999, 53–59.
Abstract. As of 1994, AT&T estimated that 350000 businesses employed 6.5 million people
in call centers. In 1997, call center revenue was estimated at $900M, with annual spending on
call centers growing at 12 percent each year. Accurate performance analyses are essential in
171
determining staffing levels and trunk requirements in call centers, because poor performance
means lost business opportunities. The purpose of this paper is to show that as the complexity
of these systems increases, traditional methods, like Erlang B and C table lookup, can result in
poor evaluation of the call center performance. We start by examining the simplest of all call
centers and show traditional methods can result in poor estimates of system performance and
then present a more accurate model for this call center configuration. As the complexity of call
centers increases more advance methods are required. This is demonstrated by considering two
more complex systems: distributed systems of multiple interdependent call centers and a virtual
call center configuration. We also discuss methods to analytically solve each of these systems.
Keywords: Traffic engineering, Distributed call centers, AT&T, Performance analyses, Staffing
levels, Trunk requirements, Erlang B model, Erlang C model, Table lookup, Multiple interde-
pendent call centers, Virtual call center configuration
(Appears also in Section VII.)
15. Klungle, R. Simulation of a claims call center: a success and a failure. WSC’99. 1999 Winter
Simulation Conference Proceedings. ‘Simulation—A Bridge to the Future’, IEEE, Piscataway,
NJ, USA, 1999, 1648–1653.
Abstract. The paper addresses the call center management process and the role of simulation
in this process. Strengths and weaknesses of workforce management systems and the Erlang-C
model are reviewed and the role of discrete event simulation is highlighted. An application in
an insurance claims call center is utilized to show the effectiveness of simulation in evaluating
call center designs and also the difficulties in selling selected results to management. The paper
concludes with some lessons learned about the call center process, discrete event simulation,
workforce management systems, and the specific claims application.
Keywords: Claims call center simulation, Call center management process, Workforce manage-
ment systems, Erlang-C model, Discrete event simulation, Insurance claims call center, Claims
application
16. Miller, K. and V. Bapat. Case study: simulation of the call center environment for comparing
competing call routing technologies for business case ROI pro jection. WSC’99. 1999 Winter
Simulation Conference Proceedings. ‘Simulation—A Bridge to the Future’, IEEE, Piscataway,
NJ, USA, 1999, 1694–1700.
Abstract. The paper describes how simulation was used for business case benefits and return
on investment (ROI) pro jection for the procurement and rollout of a new call routing technol-
ogy to 25 call centers. With investment costs of about 17 million dollars and annual operating
costs of about 8 million for the new technology, we needed to determine if the technology would
provide enough cost savings and cost avoidance (through reduced trunk costs, increased agent
productivity, and ability to service more calls) to warrant its nationwide implementation. We
constructed a model of the existing call center environment consisting of 25 call centers, where
calls were distributed to the sites based on a system of percentage allocation routing; for ex-
ample, the telephone network provider directs calls to each site, based on the number of agents
scheduled. We then modeled the same call system dynamics and intricacies under the new call
routing system, where calls are distributed based on longest available agent. Subsequently, we
172
conducted average day simulations with light and heavy volumes and other “what if” labora-
tory analyses and experiments to facilitate planning decisions required to be documented and
substantiated in the business case.
Keywords: Call center environment simulation, Competing call routing technologies, Business
case ROI pro jection, Business case benefits, Return-on-investment, Call routing technology, In-
vestment costs, Annual operating costs, Cost savings, Cost avoidance, Agent productivity, Trunk
costs, Nationwide implementation, Percentage allocation routing, Telephone network provider,
Call system dynamics, Longest available agent, Average-day simulations, What-if laboratory
analyses, Planning decisions
17. Tanir, O. and R.J. Booth. Call center simulation in Bell Canada. WSC’99. 1999 Winter Sim-
ulation Conference Proceedings. ‘Simulation—A Bridge to the Future’, IEEE, Piscataway, NJ,
USA, 1999, 1640–1647.
Abstract. Call centers have relied historically, on Erlang-C based estimation formulas to help
determine number of agent positions and queue parameters. These estimators have worked
fairly well in traditional call centers. However, recent trends such as skill-based routing, elec-
tronic channels and interactive call handling demand more sophisticated techniques. Discrete
event simulation provides the necessary techniques to gain insight into these new trends, and
helping to shape their current and future designs. This paper relates the experiences of design-
ing call center simulations in Bell Canada. With the experience of constructing, executing and
analyzing a large call center model, problems that we faced are identified and potential solutions
are given. The examples are taken from large and small call centers alike in the attempt to bring
forth some common problems that a simulationist will face.
Keywords: Call center simulation, Bell Canada, Erlang-C based estimation, Queue parameters,
Skill-based routing, Electronic channels, Interactive call handling, Discrete event simulation
18. Dugdale, J., B. Pavard and J.L. Soubie. A pragmatic development of a computer simulation of an
emergency call centre. Designing Cooperative Systems. Use of Theories and Models. Proceed-
ings of the 5th International Conference on the Design of Cooperative Systems (COOP’2000),
IOS Press, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2000, 241–256.
Abstract. In cases where it is infeasible to experiment in a real life setting, computer simulation
is a valuable tool in the design and understanding of cooperative systems. This paper describes
the development of a computer based simulation of an emergency call centre. The centre, which
is a perfect example of a complex cooperative system, is currently undergoing a physical reor-
ganization. The aim of the simulator is to help in the redesign process by allowing the user to
test the effects of new physical organizations. Whilst grounded in a solid theoretical framework,
the simulator was developed using a bottom-up approach. We are particularly interested in
modelling and analyzing how environmental factors, such as the level of noise, affect mutual
awareness, overhearing, interruption, cooperation and communication. A methodology is em-
ployed which is strongly participative and which, we believe, is well suited for the development
of a computer-based simulation of complex real world settings. We explain our methodology and
show how the environmental and cognitive factors have been analyzed, translated into a design
and subsequently implemented using an ob ject-oriented approach. Finally, we demonstrate the
173
computer-based simulator by running an experiment using data obtained from our observations
of the real world setting.
Keywords: Computer simulation, Emergency call centre, Cooperative systems, Bottom-up ap-
proach, Environmental factors, Noise, Cognitive factors, Ob ject-oriented approach, Experiment,
Ergonomics, Multi-agent systems
(Appears also in Section IV.)
19. Ridley, A. Performance optimization of a telecommunication call center. Proceedings of the
Applied Telecommunication Symposium (ATS’00). SCS, San Diego, CA, USA, 2000, 163–167.
Abstract. Telecommunication call centers have become the primary channel of customer inter-
action service for many businesses. The level of professionalism and efficiency that call center
agents deliver to customers provides a significant advantage over traditional customer service
practices. The growth of call centers has been substantial over the last two decades. This growth
is driven by a company’s desire to lower operating costs and to increase revenues (Kim 1997).
The author investigates analytical and simulation-based models for the design and manage-
ment of a call center. Given three classes of traffic (voice, E-mail, and facsimile) with different
target waiting-times in queue and target service levels, the goal is to optimize the call center
performance. The system performance can be measured with quantities such as the expected
waiting-time in queue, the expected time in system, the percentage of calls answered within a
given time, and the expected waiting-time probability distribution. The system performance of
the call center is measured using analytical and simulation-based queuing models. For analytical
models, the traffic classes will have exponential inter-arrival and service time distributions where
the arrival and service rates will differ among classes. Also, each customer call will be assigned
a queue priority based on its traffic class. The call agents will be able to handle calls from any
class. For the simulation-based models, the inter-arrival and service time distributions will not
be exponential, the agents will have different skill-levels, and the queue length will be finite.
Keywords: Performance optimization, Telecommunication call center, Simulation-based models,
Management, Voice traffic, E-mail, Facsimile, Service levels, Expected waiting time, Probability
distribution, Queuing models, Exponential inter-arrival distributions, Service-time distributions
(Appears also in Section I.)
20. Gulati, Sandeep and Scott A. Malcolm. Call center scheduling technology evaluation using sim-
ulation. Proceedings of the 2001 Winter Simulation Conference, Arglington, VA, USA, 2, 2001,
1438–1442.
Abstract. Telemarketers, direct marketing agencies, collection agencies and others whose pri-
mary means of customer contact is via the telephone invest considerable sums of money to make
the calling operation efficient and productive. Investments are required in human resources,
infrastructure and technology. Having invested the dollars, businesses want to ensure that value
is maximized. Call scheduling algorithms provide an efficient method to maximize customer
contact. However, management at a large, national credit-card bank was not convinced that the
software used to schedule calls was providing an adequate level of service. Simulation studies
showed that management was justified in this assumption. The study also revealed that process
improvement opportunities exist, which if implemented would likely produce the desired perfor-
174
mance improvements.
21. Saltzman, Robert M. and Vijay Mehrotra. A call center uses simulation to drive strategic change,
Interfaces, 31 (3), Part 1 of 2, May–June 2001, 87–101.
Abstract. A large, customer-focused software company relied on simulation modeling of its
call center operations in launching a new fee-based technical-support program. Prior to launch-
ing this rapid program, call center managers were concerned about the difficulty of meeting a
proposed guarantee to paying customers that they would wait less than one minute on hold.
Managers also wanted to know how the new program would affect the service provided to their
existing base of regular, nonpaying customers. We quickly developed an animated simulation
model that addressed these concerns and gave the managers a good understanding for the impact
on system performance of changes in the number of customers purchasing the rapid program and
in the number of agents. The one-minute guarantee would be faily easy to achieve, even if the
percentage of callers in the rapid program became quite high. Managers also gained confidence
that, with appropriate staffing levels, they could successfully implement the new program, which
they soon did.
175
IX Cases
1. Sasser, W. Earl, Jr., Ramchandran Jaikumar and David C. Rikert. Sof-Optics, Inc. (A). Case,
Harvard Business School, 1980, 24 pp. Ref. No.: 9-681-052.
Abstract. The marketing director of a fast-growing firm must make some decisions about the
customer service department. The volume in the department has been rising steadily, eye doc-
tors are waiting longer for orders to be filled, and morale in the department is slipping. With
pressure on the firm to make a profit, the marketing director must carefully justify any request
for additional people or equipment.
Keywords: Capacity analysis, Customer relations, Customer service, Employee morale, Medical
supplies, Scheduling, Systems analysis, Work force management
2. Jaikumar, Ramchandran. Sof-Optics, Inc. (B). Case, Harvard Business School, 1984, 14 pp. Ref.
No.: 9-684-045.
Abstract. Involves the introduction of a technology which almost completely eliminates direct
labor for a ma jor segment of the product line. The technology is unproven though, and requires
managing the learning process. The teaching ob jective is to review the differences in managing
change between fixed and variable cost-intensive technologies and additions of manufacturing
capacity.
Keywords: Automation, Capacity analysis, Management of change, Production capacity, Tech-
nological change
3. Bless, Martin and Christopher H. Lovelock. BT: Telephone Account Management. Case, In-
ternational Institute for Management Development (IMD), Lausanne, Switzerland, 1993, 17 pp.
Ref. No.: 593-011-1.
Abstract. To better serve its small business customers, whose sales volume does not justify per-
sonal visits from field account managers, BT (formerly British Telecom) has created an account
management programme that uses the telephone as its channel. Carefully trained telephone
account managers (TAMs) maintain relationships by phone, undertaking consultation, selling
and problem solving. The manager of sales development is now debating what mix of field and
telephone-based channels are appropriate for larger customers. Sharpening the debate is how to
respond to a protest from a growing customer which has been upgraded against its will from a
TAM to a field account executive. There is a French translation available (F593-011-1).
Keywords: Account management, Sales, Technology, Implementation, Relationships
4. Drummond, G. and I. Walker. First Direct. Case, Napier University, Edinburgh, 1993, 5. pp.
Ref. No.: 593-058-1.
Abstract. The case examines the development of telephone banking. It considers how modern
technology is influencing the distribution of financial services. Issues relating to promotional
strategy and customer service are also discussed.
176
Keywords: Marketing financial services, Product strategy, Promotional strategy, Distribution of
services, Customer service
5. Roberts, M.J. ACTC Customer Service Department. Case, Harvard Business School, 1993, 10
pp. Ref. No.: 9-393-056.
Abstract. Focuses on the young general manager of a new cable TV system, and on its customer
service department. Jeanne LaFrance, the general manager, has an uneasy feeling about the way
in which the department is being managed. She sees symptoms of what she suspects are serious
problems. It takes too long for customer service reps to answer the phone, many customers hang
up before their call is answered. There is little in the way of performance standards, measures,
or controls. Yet there is not enough data in the case for students to resolve these issues. The
ob jective is to develop a plan for learning about these problems. What are their hypotheses
about the issues? What analysis would they need to do to address these issues? How would
they get the data to do this? A companion case to Jeanne LaFrance.
Keywords: Customer service, Growth management, Operations analysis, Organizational design,
Organizational problems, Telecommunications
6. Husock, H. Central Complaint and Information Service for Louisville: City Hall (A). Case,
Kennedy School of Government, 1996, 12 pp. Ref. No.: KSG1355.0.
Abstract. The belief of Louisville, Kentucky Mayor Jerry Abramson in improved service to
citizen “customers” leads to the 1989 establishment of a centralized complaint/information
system—a single phone number to which complaints or inquiries about any of the city’s 25
departments can be made. But despite apparent success and a high public profile, managers of
the “CityCALL” system become frustrated with what they view as inefficiencies in their rela-
tionships with other city agencies. Some are linked to CityCALL by computer; others show little
apparent inclination to cooperate. The case calls for consideration of how City CALL could be
improved through the vehicle of Louisville’s “CityWork” system, in which public employees, in
a retreat-style setting, are called upon to offer specific suggestions for change.
The case explores the evolution of an innovative program—its unexpected side effects and the
sort of resistance it encounters. It highlights, as wel, Mayor Abramson’s contention that a
system of cooperative program evaluation—CityWork—can lead to efficiencies which rival pub-
lic/private competitive bidding and other “privatization”-style strategies.
Keywords: Customer service, Innovation, Privatization, Technological change
7. Husock, H. Central Complaint and Information Service for Louisville: City Hall (Epilogue).
Case, Kennedy School of Government, 1996, 2 pp. Ref. No.: KSG1355.1.
Abstract. As above in previous item.
8. Kaboolian. Ruthless with Time and Gracious with People? Teleservice at the Social Security
Administration. Case, 1996, 9 pp. Ref. No.: KSG1338.0.
177
Abstract. Within three years of its implementation, the Social Security Administration’s na-
tionwide 800 telephone service was handling the largest volume of 800 calls of any organization
in the world. In addition, to this volue, approximately 15 million callers got a busy signal rather
than an answer. Even so, the SSA pro jected an annual increase in calls, due in part to a high
level of customer satisfaction with the service provided by the SSA operators. Part of the historic
legacy of protecting the public from government inefficiency and malfeasance is the widespread
imposition of controls in the authorizing environment. Executive agencies that control budgeting
and procurement are preeminent in this regard, and, in conjunction with legislative oversight,
produce a tension that can retard dynamic service initiatives. Can government trust itself and
create an “okay to fail” zone?
Keywords: Customer service, Information technology
9. Hamilton, R. and G. Sharkey. McQueen Group. Case, Napier University, Edinburgh, 1997, 29
pp. Ref. No.: 397-013-1.
Abstract. McQueen Limited, a Scottish printing company founded in 1846, has expanded from
selling office equipment and PCs to be a ma jor licensed manufacturer and distributor of USA
software products. Through organizational changes to its value chain, it can now deliver a total
integrated manufacturing and distribution service including a multilingual call center offering
direct marketing and order fulfillment facilities. Great stress is laid on team working and high
quality standards. This offers ma jor USA software companies ready and quick access to Euro-
pean markets without having to hold their own distribution systems.
Keywords: Core competence, Software business environment, Call centres, cultural infrastruc-
ture, Software publishing, Integrated, Services, Value chain
10. Larreche, J-C., Lovelock, C. and D. Parmenter. First Direct: Branchless Banking. Case, IN-
SEAD, Fontainebleau, France, 1997, 32 pp. Ref. No.: 597-028-1.
Abstract. First Direct has become the model of telebanking worldwide, despite similar initia-
tives undertaken by large international banks. The case describes the history of First Direct
and the various components of its operations, especially around the central issue of relationships
marketing at a distance. It helps students to understand all the various facets of a modern
operation which makes it effective, unique and difficult to imitate. A superficial analysis of this
successful new model, or of other ones, leads to fast conclusions and pole imitations. There is
a Spanish translation available (E597-028-1). ECCH European Case Awards Overall Winner,
2000. This case contains colour exhibits.
Keywords: Marketing, Direct marketing, Relationship marketing, Services, Banking, Telebank-
ing
11. Zeynep Aksin-Karaesmen, O. and P.T. Harker. Nationsbank Reinvents the Phone Channel (A):
The Design Decision. Case, INSEAD, Fontainebleau, 1998, 20 pp. Ref. No.: 698-065-1.
Abstract. The process of designing the new phone system and the logic underlying the var-
ious choices involved are described, along with a discussion of the options for design, to give
178
an understanding of the range of possibilities in call center design. The question of differential
service levels and sales efforts is described. Teaching ob jectives are to help students understand
how operational and marketing considerations must be integrated when designing a telephone
channel, and to raise the question of where and when differential service levels are appropriate.
Keywords: Call center design, Service level differentiation, Skills-based routing, Segment-based
cross-selling, Customer focused redesign, Human resource issues, Information technology issues
12. Agrawal, M.L. and P. Vagn Freytag. Call Center Europe. Case, Denmark, 2000, 19 pp. Ref.
No.: 500-019-1.
Abstract. The case is about the Call Center Europe (CCE), one of the largest call centres
in northern Europe. CCE specializes in representing business clients to their customers with a
series of inbound and outbound calling services. As the trend for call centres is to grow into
web-enabled customer care and contact centres, CCE needs to remain in readiness to face the
emerging challenges and seize newer growth opportunities in the overall discipline of customer
relations management (CRM). The case aims to initiate a discussion regarding these very needs
and issues relating to growth options for the CCE. The case is targeted at the final-year students
in full-time MBA programmes in marketing business and policy and services marketing. It may
be more useful to the executive MBA or the short-term training programmes for the practising
manager also in Europe and in Denmark.
Keywords: Firm’s growing strategy, Customer relationship, Outsourcing
13. PrimeGain Funds. Case, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University, 2000. Ref. No.:
T262.
14. Rohall, Douglas D. Internet Economy?: No More Golf (Guest Column). Case, Harvard Man-
agement Review, 2000, 1 pp. Ref. No.: U0004C.
Abstract. Douglas D. Rohall, a director of the Monitor Group, discusses how the abolition of
human intermediate-sales people, call center staff, brokers—will change your business, and how
firms once again need to reinvent themselves.
Keywords: Contracts, Outsourcing
15. Gallagher, J.G. Kwik-Fit Insurance Services (KFIS). Case, Napier University, Edinburgh, 2001,
20 pp. Ref. No.: 501-005-1.
Abstract. Direct Line entered the motor insurance market in 1985 selling motor insurance
directly to customers over the phone. For the next decade the industry was characterized by
an increase in this type of selling. By 1995 even though the market for direct marketing of
motor insurance was saturated, other companies still entered it. In particular, Sir Tom Farmer’s
Kwit-Fit Group set up Kwik-Fit Insurance Services. He did so by challenging the industry’s
established players from the basis of the credibility of their brands. Moreover, he used his ex-
perience of both marketing and organizational culture and philosophy as well as an established
179
customer database to drive KFIS’s offerings. The ethos which drives Kwit-Fit Holdings is one of
customer delight. Offering motor insurance was seen initially as a means of adding value for the
Kwik-Fit customer. However, KFIS rapidly captured 2% of the £7bn market and perspectives
changed.
Keywords: Direct marketing, Database management, People relationships and culture, Call cen-
tre management, Brand management, Brand stretching
16. Nov, Yuval andMichael Harrison. Call Center Design for Lion Financial Services. Case, Stanford
University Graduate School of Business, 2001. Ref. No.: S-OIT-29.
17. Arussy, Lior. Don’t Take Calls, Make Contact. Case, Harvard Business Review, 2002, 2 pp.
Ref. No.: F0201A.
Abstract. Almost every call center strives to process inquiries and complaints quickly. But by
stressing speed over service, centers usually end up annoying customers instead of helping them.
Here’s how to change that.
Keywords: Customer relations, Customer retention, Customer service
18. Mukund, A. CRM/KM Initiatives at 3M. Case, ICFAI Centre for Management Research (ICMR),
India, 2002, 9 pp. Ref. No.: 902-018-1.
Abstract. The case examines the reasons behind 3M’s decision to implement customer rela-
tionship management (CRM) and knowledge management (KM) software. With 3M’s product
portfolio becoming increasingly complicated, the agents at its call centers were finding it dif-
ficult to answer customer queries satisfactorily. This acted as the trigger for 3M’s decision to
implement the Remedy Action Request and System (RARS) and Primus eCRM solutions. The
implementation procedure and the benefits derived by the company are explored in detail. The
case is so structured as to enable students to: (1) understand why large and diversified com-
panies with diverse product portfolios need to introduce sophisticated technologies to provide
efficient and effective customer service; (2) understand the processes and design considerations
involved in implementing a CRM/KM system in a large company; and (3) discuss the success of
the CRM/KM pro ject and 3M. The case is aimed at MBA/PGDBA students, and is intended to
be a part of the knowledge, information and communication systems management curriculum.
Keywords: Customer relationship management, Knowledge management, 3M, Call centers
19. Mukund, A. The Indian Call Centre Journey. Case, ICFAI Centre for Management Research
(ICMR), India, 2002, 8 pp. Ref. No.: 402-019-1.
Abstract. The case is intended to give a detailed insight into the reasons behind the call centre
industry not being as successful as expected in India. The problems on the human resources
front are explored in detail. The case also gives a brief insight into the concept, history and
functioning of call centres. The case is so structured as to enable the students to understand
the emergence of the call centre industry in India. The students should essentially be able to
180
understand the necessity of call centres for various businesses and their functioning in brief. The
students should also understand how and why the Indian call centre industry’s performance was
below expectations. The case is aimed at the MBA/PGDBA students as part of the human
resource management/organisational behaviour curriculum.
Keywords: Indian call centre business, Call centre performance issues, Employee retention prob-
lems at call centres
20. Ryals, L. Total Customer Recognition: CRM at Wesleyan. Case, Cranfield School of Manage-
ment, 2002, 15 pp. Ref. No.: 502-021-1.
Abstract. This is a case study about how Wesleyan Assurance Society worked towards a total
view of their customers by implementing CRM. The case looks at the subsequent development
in Wesleyan’s data warehouse, Contact Centre and website. The events in this case take place
after the successful introduction of Sales Force Automation (SFA) described in ‘Going the Extra
Mile: CRM at Wesleyan’ (501-053-1). A mutual assurer founded in 1841, Wesleyan has grown
partly by acquisition. Its ma jor subsidiaries include Medical Sickness Society, and Provision
(formerly part of Clerical Medical). Wesleyan also sells products on behalf of the Prison Of-
ficers Association. Encouragement for a full CRM pro ject came not only from the successful
implementation of the SFA system, but also the need to demonstrate value added at a time of
considerable negative coverage of previous mis-selling, high commission rates and threats from
new entrants.
21. Bendixen, M. and C. Gordon-Brown. Multichoice Africa: Managing the queue. Case, Wits
Business School, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa, 2003, 6 pp. Ref. No.: 403-065-
1.
Abstract. It was late on a Tuesday afternoon at the beginning of March 2003. Eddie Moyce,
Call Centre Manager for MultiChoice Africa, a multichannel television platform, was examining
the results of some recent market research that had been presented that day. The research had
shown that while customers who had phoned the call centre were generally satisfied with the
service they received, they were dissatisfied with the length of time it took for their calls to be
answered. The call centre was strategically important in building and maintaining relationships
with MultiChoice customers and the company’s senior management had reacted strongly to this
finding. They had asked Moyce to investigate the possibility of improving the response time from
the current 80:30 to 80:20 or even 90:10. What would the impact of reducing response times
be? Would it be possible to reduce response times while staying within budget? Management
had recently imposed severe austerity measures on the company, even reducing the call centre’s
budget in the last two years.
Keywords: Topic queuing theory; Call centre management
22. Reinartz, W.J. and U. Wiehr. Customer relationship management at Capital One (UK). Case,
INSEAD, Fontainebleau, 2003, 36 pp. Ref. No.: 503-067-1.
Abstract. Capital One, a credit card company, has built its business on a strategy with a clear
181
customer focus: The company systematically gathers and analyses information on its customers
in order to correctly assess their individual credit risk and to offer products and services tai-
lored to their individual needs. The case is designed to illustrate how the concept of customer
relationship management (CRM) can be translated into strategy, organisational design, hiring,
marketing processes, and IT infrastructure of a company. The teaching ob jective is fourfold:
(1) to present a best-practice organisation that embodies the concept of CRM; (2) to enable a
discussion around the definition of CRM; (3) to recognise why effective CRM cannot only be
practised within the marketing function, but has to be adopted by the entire organisation; and
(4) to recognise the important role of the human resources function and the IT function in a
company-wide CRM strategy.
Keywords: Customer relationship management, Financial services, Credit card, Marketing strat-
egy, Database, IT, CRM, Call centre
23. Silvestro, R., C. Silvestro. New service design in the NHS: An evaluation of the strategic align-
ment of NHS Direct, International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 23 (4),
2003, 401–417.
Abstract. Awareness of inconsistencies and variability in the delivery of health services across
the UK has heightened in recent years, leading to general acknowledgement that a move away
from “health care by post code” is a strategic priority for the National Health Service (NHS).
NHS Direct, a call centre service for patients and their carers, is unique in the NHS in that it
represents an entirely new service concept, with a rare opportunity to design a single nation-wide
service from scratch, and to manage and coordinate a delivery system consistently throughout
the country. Evaluates the strategic alignment of NHS Direct during the first three years of
implementation through an analysis of its service concept, its operational ob jectives, the design
of its delivery systems and its volume and variety characteristics. The evaluation reveals an
absence of a central design specification which has resulted in wide variation in the call centres’
service portfolios, resource bases, competences, telephony and clinical expert systems. Contends
that variation and variability in the design of the call centres has severely compromised NHS
Direct’s ability to meet its strategic and operational ob jectives, resulting in strategic misalign-
ment. Also identifies missed opportunities to learn from the growing call centre literature and
from service shops in other industries.
Keywords: Service design, NHS Direct, Strategic alignment, National Health Service, Call centre
service, Operational ob jectives, Strategic misalignment
(Appears also in Section VII.)
24. Singhal, H.K. and D.G.. Prasad. Call centers and customer relationship management in insur-
ance organisations. Case, ICFAI Center for Management Research (ICMR), India, 2003, 3 pp.
Ref. No.: 503-054-1.
Abstract. The case focuses on improving customer relationships in insurance organisations. It
discusses the role of call centres in improving customer relationships in insurance organisations
and examines the way in which these organisations can improve the functional performance of
call centres. The case also discusses the role of technology in managing call centre operations.
The case is structured to enable students to: (1) understand the role of customer relationship
182
management in the competitive business environment; (2) understand the process of call centre
operations; (3) understand the role of technology in managing call centre operations; and (4)
understand how call centres function. The case is intended for MBA/PGDBM level students as
part of the management of insurance companies, services marketing and marketing management
curricula.
Keywords: Call centres, Customer relationship management, Communication channels; Web-
enabled insurance agents
25. Singhal, H.K. and C. Sridevi. Call center operations in insurance. Case, ICFAI Center for Man-
agement Research (ICMR), India, 2003, 4 pp. Ref. No.: 503-008-1.
Abstract. The case examines the issues involved in the delivery of an insurance service and the
procedures and patterns of delivery. It focuses on the activities that need to be performed for
efficient production and delivery of a service. The case also discusses various issues relating to
technology-based services. In particular, the case focuses on the use of technology by insurance
companies to enhance customer service. The case is structured to enable students to: (1) un-
derstand the significance of process management in the production and delivery of a service in
an insurance organisation; (2) understand the problems associated with the use of technology
in providing service; (3) understand the potential of call centres (of insurance organisations) for
providing effective services; and (4) understand the relationship between information systems
and marketing research. The case is aimed at MBA/PGDBA students, and is intended to be a
part of the insurance marketing curriculum.
Keywords: Motor vehicle insurance, Marketing information system, Call routing, Performance-
based reward system
26. Bendixen, M. and C. Mitchell. Vodacom Customer Care. Case, Wits Business School, Univer-
sity of the Witwatersrand, South Africa, 2004, 22 pp. Ref. No.: 404-032-1.
Abstract. Vodacom Customer Care provided an extensive training programme for new call
centre employees. It had also made an effort to ensure that the work environment at its various
call centres was pleasant with modern amenities. The company provided its staff with sophisti-
cated backup systems such as an on-line knowledge base nicknamed ‘The Chad’ that kept them
abreast of the many developments relating to Vodacom products. Performance of call centre
agents was measured against a detailed bonus calculator system. In October 2002, the number
of calls handled by each call centre agent was added to the list of criteria against which perfor-
mance of call centre agents was measured. This had prompted a change in the relative weighting
of each of the factors that contributed to the final bonus calculation. Ibeth Toerien, Executive
Director of Customer Care at Vodacom (Pty) Ltd., and Lori Kasselman, Vodacom’s executive
head: Capacity building and development reflected on whether it had been worthwhile adding
quantity of calls handled to the bonus calculator. They debated whether it achieved the desired
balance between quantitative and qualitative measures.
27. Feinberg, Richard, Ko De Ruyter and Lynne Bennington. Cases in Cal l Center Management:
Great ideas (Th) at Work (Ichor Business Series), Purdue University Press, January 2004.
183
ISBN: 1557533423 (paperback: 250 pages).
28. Singhal, H.K. Demand estimation for a call center. Case, ICFAI Center for Management Re-
search (ICMR), India, 2004, 3 pp. Ref. No.: 604-003-1.
Abstract. The case examines the wide variation in the demand for call centres. It discusses the
importance of demand forecasting for call centres. The case also takes a look at difficulties in-
volved in estimating the demand for call centres. It also discusses the various strategies that can
be adopted to overcome uneven demand conditions. The case is structured to enable students
to: (1) understand the operations of call centres; (2) understand the importance of demand fore-
casting for call centres; (3) understand difficulties in demand estimation; (4) understand the role
of technology in meeting uneven demand; (5) understand the need for training customer service
representatives; and (6) understand the significance of production and operations standards.
The case is intended for MBA/PGDBM level students as part of the operations management
curriculum.
Keywords: Capacity decisions, Response time, Demand estimation
184
X Books and Reports
1. Gable, Robert A. Inbound Cal l Centers: Design, Implementation, and Management. Boston:
Artech House, 1992.
ISBN 089006640X
Sub jects: Telephone stations, Management, Telephone switching systems, Electronic
2. Anton, Jon. Inbound Customer Cal l-Center Design: Management Information Systems. 3rd ed.
Houston: Dame Publications, 1994.
ISBN: 0873933621
Sub jects: Customer services, CICS (Computer system)
3. Gable, Robert A. Tol l-free Services: A Complete Guide to Design, Implementation, and Man-
agement. Boston, MA: Artech House, 1995.
ISBN: 0890067872
Sub jects Toll-free telephone calls – United States
4. Sisk, Kathy. Successful Telemarketing: The Complete Handbook on Managing a Profitable Tele-
marketing Cal l Center. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1995.
ISBN 0070577048
Sub jects: Telemarketing, Management, Handbooks, Manuals
5. Walters, Rob. Computer-Mediated Communications: Multimedia Applications. Boston, MA:
Artech House, 1995.
Series: The Artech House telecommunications library
ISBN: 0890067570
Sub jects: Multimedia systems, Computer conferencing
6. Szlam, Aleksander and Ken Thatcher. Predictive Dialing Fundamentals, 2nd edition. Lawrence:
C M P Books, 1996
ISBN: 0936648805
7. Anton, Jon. Cal l Center Management by the Numbers. West Lafayette, IN: Ichor Business
Books, 1997.
Series: Customer access management
ISBN: 1557531129
Sub jects: Consumer satisfaction, Customer services – Evaluation, Customer services – Manage-
ment
8. Belasco, Kent S. Financial Institution Staffing: Analyzing and Modeling Staff Levels in a Com-
petitive and Consolidating Industry. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill, 1997.
185
ISBN: 0786311061
Sub jects: Banks and banking – United States – Personnel management, Bank employees –
United States, Bank employees – Effect of technological innovations on United States, Financial
institutions – United States – Employees
9. Cleveland, Brad. Cal l Center Management on Fast Forward: Succeeding in Today’s Dynamic
Inbound Environment. Annapolis: Call Center Press, January 1997.
ISBN: 0965909301
Sub jects: Telephone stations
10. Walters, Rob et al. CTI in Action. Chichester; New York, NY: John Wiley, 1997.
ISBN: 0471968242
Sub jects: Telephone systems, Data processing, Computer networks
11. Anton, Howard. Inbound Customer Cal l Center Design. West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University
Press, 1998.
ISBN: 1557531307
12. Bodin, Madeline. Maximizing Cal l Center Performance: 136 Innovative Ideas for Increasing
Productivity & Customer Satisfaction. Lawrence: C M P Books, December 1998.
ISBN: 1578200261
Sub jects: Consumer satisfaction, Customer services
13. Coscia, Stephen. Tele-Stress: Relief for Cal l Center Stress. Lawrence: C M P Books, 1998.
ISBN: 1578200296
Book Description: Surveys indicate that 98 percent of call-center employees receive at least one
stressful call each day. Irate customers are the leading cause of tele-stress. The author explains
what it is, how it affects the body, and how to overcome it with common sense strategies.
Sub jects: Stress management
14. Cusack, Michael. Online Customer Care: Applying Today’s Technology to Achieve World-Class
Customer Interaction. Milwaukee, WI: ASQ Quality Press, 1998.
ISBN: 0873893832
Sub jects: Customer services – Management, Teleshopping, Customer relations, Internet mar-
keting, Internet advertising, Business enterprises – Computer networks, Consumer satisfaction
15. D’Augustine, Jamie, Laura DeVries and Kathryn Jackson. The 21st Century Cal l Center Rep.
Houston: American Productivity & Quality Center, 1998.
ISBN: 1928593119
Sub jects: Customer relations
186
16. Institute for Research. Opportunities in Customer Service Telemarketing: Cal l Center Manage-
ment. Chicago, Ill: Institute for Research, 1998.
Series: Research No. 347; Careers Research No. 347
Sub jects: Telemarketing – Vocational guidance; Telemarketing – Management – Vocational guid-
ance
17. McDonald, David R. and Stephen R.E. Turner, editors. Analysis of Communication Networks:
Cal l Centres, Traffic and Performance. Proceedings of the Workshop on Analysis and Simulation
of Communication Networks held in Toronto, ON, November 1998, Fields Institute Communi-
cations, 28.
Contents: A.R. Ward and W. Whitt, Predicting response times in processor-sharing queues (1–
29); D.A. Stanford and W.K. Grassmann, Bilingual server call centres (31–47); Ruth J. Williams,
On dynamic scheduling of a parallel server system with complete resource pooling (49–71); Y.C.
Teh, Dynamic scheduling for queueing networks derived from discrete-review policies (73–93);
S.R.E. Turner, Large deviations for Join the Shorter Queue (95–108); D.R. McDonald and S.R.E.
Turner, Comparing load balancing algorithms for distributed queueing networks (109–133); P.W.
Glynn and A.J. Zeevi, Estimating tail probabilities in queues via extremal statistics (135–158);
G. Kesidis and T. Konstantopoulos, Extremal traffic and worst-case performance for queues with
shaped arrivals (159–178); D.J. Daley and R.A. Vesilo, Long range dependence of inputs and
outputs of some classical queues (179–186); S. Grishechkin, M. Devetsikiotis, I. Lambadaris and
C. Hobbs, On “catastrophic” behavior of queueing networks (187–200).
18. Anton, Jon, Vivek Bapat and Bill Hall. Cal l Center Performance Enhancement Using Simula-
tion and Modeling. West Lafayette, IN: Ichor Business Books, 1999.
Series: Customer access management
Sub jects: Call centers
19. D’Ausiliob, Rosanne. Wake Up Your Cal l Center: How To Be a Better Cal l Center Agent.
Revised and expanded edition. West Lafayette, IN: Ichor Business Books, 1999.
Series: Customer access management
Sub jects: Customer services – Management; Call centers – Management
20. Dawson, Keith. Cal l Center Savvy: How to Position Your Cal l Center for the Business Chal-
lenges of the 21st Century. Lawrence: C M P Books, June 1999.
ISBN: 1578200504
21. Prosci Research Staff. Best Practices in Cal l Center Management, Operations & Technology.
Loveland: Prosci Research, January 1999.
ISBN: 1930885059
22. Talton, Frederic. Cal l Center Excel lence: 25 Things Every Cal l Center Manager Needs to
Know... & Remember. Flossmoor: Scroll & Clipboard Publications, May 1999.
187
ISBN: 0966466004
Sub jects: Business communication, Telecommunication systems, Telephone, Conference calls,
Telecommunication
23. Walters, Rob. Computer Telephony Integration, 2nd edition. Boca Raton: C R C Press LLC,
1999.
ISBN: 0890069697
Sub jects: Digital telephone systems – Automation, Computer networks
24. Washington, Jannie D. The Importance of Job Descriptions and Incentive Pay at a Bank Cal l
Center. M.A. Thesis, University of Toledo, 1999.
Sub jects: Job descriptions, Incentive awards
25. Anton, Jon and David Gustin. Cal l Center Benchmarking: Deciding if Good is Good Enough.
West Lafayette, IN: Ichor Business Books, 2000.
Series: Customer access management
ISBN: 155753215X
Sub jects: Call centers – United States – Management, Benchmarking (Management) – United
States
26. Barber, Gerry, et al. Cal l Center Forecasting and Scheduling: The Best of Cal l Center Manage-
ment Review. Call Center Press, 2000
ISBN: l0965909360
Book Description: There is simply no way to establish and operate an effective call center envi-
ronment without a solid understanding of the principles behind forecasting, staffing, scheduling,
service level, queuing dynamics and real-time management. Originally published in the pages of
Call Center Management Review, these articles were selected for their educational value, prac-
ticality, and most importantly, coverage of timeless call center management principles.
27. Belasco, Kent S. Financial Institution Staffing: Analyzing and Modeling Staff Levels in a Com-
petitive and Consolidating Industry. McGraw-Hill, 2000
ISBN: 1590612604
28. Bookman, Murray. Cal l Center Technology Architecture. Lawrence: C M P Books, January
2000.
ISBN: 1578200520
Sub jects: Computer networks
29. Clegg, Brian. The Invisible Customer: Strategies for Successive Customer Service Down the
Wire. London: Kogan Page, 2000.
Sub jects: Call centers – Customer services; Electronic commerce – Customer services; Customer
188
relations
30. D’Ausilio, Rosanne. Wake up Your Cal l Center: Humanizing Your Interaction Hub. 3rd ed.
West Lafayette, IN: Purdue University Press, 2000.
Series: Customer Access Management Ser.
ISBN: 1557532176
Sub jects: Commerce
31. Day, Charles E. Profiting from Teleservices: An Operational Guide to Cal l Center Technologies.
New York: McGraw-Hill Professional Book Group, April 2000.
ISBN: 0070164304
Sub jects: Telecommunication
32. Domuratb, Frank L. and Jon Anton. Making the Organization Profitable: Cal l Center Metrics
That Matter. Purdue University Press, 2000.
ISBN: 1557531838
33. Finch, Lloyd. Cal l Center Success: Essential Skil ls for CSRs. Menlo Park: Crisp Publications,
Inc., August 2000.
Series: Crisp Fifty-Minute Book Ser.
ISBN: 1560525789
Sub jects: Customer services, Telemarketing
34. Hack, Becki, Peggy Newton and Trip Wyckoff. Cal l Center Operations: A Guide for Your
Journey to Best-Practice Processes. Houston: American Productivity & Quality Center, August
2000.
Series: Passport to Success Ser.
ISBN: 1928593232
35. Harker, Patrick T. and Stavros A. Zenios, eds. Performance of Financial Institutions. New
York: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
ISBN: 0521771544
Book Description: The efficient operation of financial intermediaries—banks, insurance and pen-
sion fund firms, government agencies and so on—is instrumental for the efficient functioning of
the financial system and the fueling of the economies of the twenty-first century. But what
drives the performance of these institutions in today’s global environment? In this volume,
world-renowned scholars bring their expertise to bear on the issues. Primary among them are
the definition and measurement of efficiency of a financial institution, benchmarks of efficiency,
identification of the drivers of performance and measurement of their effects on efficiency, the
impact of financial innovation and information technologies on performance, the effects of pro-
cess design, human resource management policies, as well as others.
189
36. Mockus, Jonas. A Set of Examples of Global and Discrete Optimization: Applications of
Bayesian Heuristic Approach. Dordrecht; Boston: Kluwer Academic, 2000.
ISBN: 0792363590
Sub jects: Combinatorial optimization, Heuristic programming, Bayesian statistical decision the-
ory
37. Muller, Nathan J. IP Convergence: The Next Revolution in Telecommunications. Boston: Artech
House, 2000.
ISBN: 1580530125
Sub jects: Internet telephony, TCP/IP (Computer network protocol)
38. Prosci Research Staff. Cal l Center Measurement: How to Measure & Improve Cal l Center Per-
formance. Loveland: Prosci Research, April 2000.
ISBN: 1930885083
39. Read, Brendan B. Designing the Best Cal l Center for Your Business: A Complete Guide for
Location, Services, Staffing, and Outsourcing. Lawrence: C M P Books, 2000.
ISBN: 1578200636
40. Rowan, Jim. Cal l Center Continuity Management 1999. Boca Raton: C R C Press LLC, Jan-
uary 2000.
ISBN: 0849399823
Sub jects: Telephone in business
41. United States General Accounting Office. Customer Service: Human Capital Management at
Selected Public and Private Cal l Centers. Report to the Chairman, Subcommittee on Oversight,
Committee on Ways and Means, House of Representatives, Washington, DC, August 2000.
Also available via Internet from the GPO Access web site (PDF file), http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov
Sub jects: Call centers, United States, Personnel management
42. Williams, Graham. CENTRE-ING Customer Satisfaction. A Guide to Breakthrough Perfor-
mance Through Internalising a Customer Satisfaction Culture and Practices. Publisher Centre-
ing Services, 2000
ISBN: 0-620-21753-7
43. Yarberry, William. Computer Telephony Integration, 2nd ed. Boca Raton, FL: CRC, 2002.
ISBN: 0849314380
Sub jects: Telematics, Internet telephony, Digital telephone systems
44. Anton, Jon and Anita Rockwell. Minimizing Agent Turnover: “The Biggest Chal lenge for Cal l
Center Managers”. Santa Maria: Anton Press, 2001.
190
ISBN: 096304642X
Sub jects: Business, Technology, Business & Economics
45. Coen, Dan. Building Cal l Center Culture: Strategies for Designing a World Class Performance-
Based Environment Within Your Customer Contact Center. Reseda: DCD Publishing, January
2001.
ISBN: 0966043626
Sub jects: Customer services – Marketing – Management – Sales, Management – Telemarketing
46. Dawson, Keith. The Cal l Center Handbook: The Complete Guide to Starting, Running & Im-
proving Your Cal l Center. 5th ed. Lawrence: C M P Books, March 2001.
ISBN: 1578203058
47. Medcroft, Stephen. Cal l Centers Made Easy: How to Build, Operate, & Profit from Your Smal l
Business Cal l Center. Newport: Aegis Publishing Group, 2001.
ISBN: 1890154458
Sub jects: Communication and traffic
48. Petouhoff, Natalie L. In Action [electronic resource]: Recruiting and Retaining Cal l Center Em-
ployees. Alexandria, VA: American Society for Training and Development, 2001.
ISBN: 1562862944
Sub jects: Call centers, Personnel management
49. Anton, Jon and Dru Phelps. How to Conduct a Cal l Center Performance Audit: A Guide to
Self Assessment: A to Z. Santa Maria: Anton Press, 2002.
ISBN: 0963046462
Sub jects: Business, Technology, Business & Economics
50. Bodin, Madeline and Keith Dawson. The Cal l Center Dictionary: The Complete Guide to Cal l
Center & Customer Support Technology Solutions. Rev. ed. New York: CMP Books, 2002
ISBN: 1578200954
Sub jects: Management information systems, Dictionaries, Customer services, Call centers
51. Bruton, Noel. How to Manage the IT Help Desk and Cal l Center. 2nd ed. Woburn: Butterworth-
Heinemann, 2002.
ISBN: 0750649011
Sub jects: Internetworking (Telecommunication), Computers
52. Carlaw, Malcolm. Managing and Motivating Contact Center Employees: Tools and Techniques
for Inspiring Outstanding Performance from Your Frontline Staff. New York: McGraw-Hill,
2002.
191
ISBN: 0071388885
Book Description: Managing and Motivating Contact Center Employees reveals how to boost
morale, streamline business processes, and inspire outstanding performance from frontline sales
and service staff. This creative and practical book gives instant help to anyone who knows the
difficulties of managing in the diverse and dynamic contact center environment.
Sub jects: Communication and traffic, Transportation
53. Holtgrewe, Ursula, Christian Kerst and Karen Shire (eds.). Re-Organising Service Work: Cal l
Centres in Germany and Britain. Ashgate Publishing Company, December 2002.
ISBN: 0754619559
54. Richard, Darlene D. The Customer Response Management Handbook: Building, Rebuilding and
Improving Your Results. Sydney; London: McGraw-Hill, 2002.
ISBN: 007470978X
Sub jects: Call centers—Australia—management, Customer services—Australia, Office management—
Australia
55. Schultz, Garry. The Customer Care and Contact Center Handbook. Milwaukee: ASQ Quality
Press, 2002.
ISBN: 0873895614
Sub jects: Customer services, Business & Economics
56. Trotter, Michael D. The Customer Cal l Center Outback: A Frontline Supervisor’s Map to Suc-
cess. West Lafayette, IN: Ichor Business Books, 2002.
ISBN: 1557532591
Sub jects: Supervision of employees, Customer relations, Management
57. Waite, Andrew J. A Practical Guide to Cal l Center Technology: Select the Right Systems for
Total Customer Satisfaction. Lawrence: C M P Books, 2002.
ISBN: 1578200946
Sub jects: Customer relations, Business & Economics, Customer service
58. Cleveland, Brad. ICMI’s Cal l Center Management Dictionary: The Essential Reference for
Contact Center, Help Desk and Customer Care Professionals. Call Center Press, 2003.
ISBN: 0965909352
Book Description: ICMI’s Cal l Center Management Dictionary is a practical, comprehensive
reference for customer contact professionals. This essential resource covers a host of sub jects, in-
cluding, but not limited to, measurements, ob jectives, reporting, analysis, forecasting, planning,
monitoring, coaching, quality, performance, improvement, human resources, training, customer
behavior, marketing, technologies, budgeting, finance, strategy, industry acronyms, and more!
Accurate and easy to use, ICMI’s Cal l Center Management Dictionary is designed to cut through
the clutter and confusion in today’s terminology, so that you can communicate more effectively,
192
improve customer services and make better decisions that will help build your career.
1072 acronyms and terms, 41 graphs and tables.
59. Cleveland, Brad and Debbie Harne. Cal l Center Operations Management Handbook and Study
Guide, 2nd edition. Call Center Press, 2003.
ISBN: 0970950756
Book Description: Call center operations is a specialized management field with its own theories
and terminology. The fundamental dynamics of the randomly arriving call center workload create
multiple challenges in the areas of forecasting, staffing, technology and facilities management.
A firm understanding of these challenges is required for a call center leader to accomplish the
ob jectives of the organization and satisfy customers.
The Cal l Center Operations Management Handbook and Study Guide provides this solid founda-
tion through an examination of key performance indicators, call center planning and management
processes, call center technology and facilities management. The guide begins with an expla-
nation of service level and response time—key ob jectives that measure the accessibility of the
center. A detailed examination of other key performance indicators follows. The third section
of the guide provides an in-depth discussion of the planning and management processes upon
which call center operations depend, including forecasting, staffing and scheduling. The guide
then transitions from processes to technology with an integrated look at the technologies present
in the best of today’s centers. The guide closes with site selection, call center design, health and
safety issues, and disaster recovery principles.
60. Coen, Dan. Inspring Cal l Center Performance. DCD Publishing, 2003.
ISBN: 0966043650
Book Description: Is it time to drive performance in your call center?
Inspring Call Center Performance is a terrific book to teach managers the principles of creating
dynamite results in the call center.
It was written for managers, executives, supervisors and trainers who manage call centers, inside
sales and customer care departments.
This audio book focuses on the skill sets to manage people and operations. Topics include:
- Building a performance-based culture
- Understanding the key elements of call center management
- Having a daily game plan
- Developing training programs to impact performance
- Using communication channels to motivate employees
- Exploring how agents see the call center
- Tips and ideas to inspire call center staff
Designing a complete call center program is the key for management to build results in their call
center. This audio book provides a taste of how managers can do better to supervise, motivate
and inspire call center performance.
61. Reynolds, Penny. Cal l Center Staffing: The Complete, Practical Guide to Workforce Manage-
ment. The Call Center School Press, 2003.
193
ISBN: 0974417904
Book Description: Call Center Staffing: The complete, practical guide to call center manage-
ment, takes the reader through the step-by-step process of forecasting workload, calculating
staff, creating schedules, tracking daily performance, and managing by the numbers in a call
center. Topics include:
Overview of call center staffing issues
Data gathering and analysis
Forecasting workload
Calculating staff requirements
Creating staff schedules
Skill-based routing and scheduling
Managing intra-day staffing and service
Calculating trunk/network requirements
Staffing for multi-media contacts
Automating workforce management
Call Center staffing alternatives
Workforce management roles and responsibilities
This book is designed to be a how-to guide to enable today’s call center professional to master
the art and science of call center staffing.
62. Stolletz, Raik. Performance Analysis and Optimization of Inbound Cal l Centers. New York:
Springer, 2003.
ISBN: 3540008128
Sub jects: Call centers—management, Call centers—mathematical models
63. Yarberry, William A. Computer Telephony Integration, 2nd edition. Boca Raton, FL: Auerbach,
2003.
ISBN: 0849314380
Sub jects: Internet telephony, Digital telephone systems
64. Butler, David L. Bottom-Line Cal l Center Management: Creating a Culture of Accountability
and Excel lent Customer Service.
Series: Improving human performance
Butterworth-Heinemann, March 2004.
ISBN: 0750676841
Sub jects: Call centers—Management
65. Deery, Stephen and Nick Kinnie (eds.). Cal l Centres and Human Resource Management.
Basingstoke, Hampshire; New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2004
ISBN: 1403913048.
66. Dorman, Christian and Fred R.H. Zijlstra (eds.). Cal l Centre Work: Smile by Wire. Special
Issue of the European Journal of Work and Organisational Psychology, 12 (4). Psychology Press,
194
2004
ISBN: 1841699691
Book Description: Organizations are looking for ways to be accessible to their customers, to be
able to promptly answer questions, or to provide reliable and up-to-date information. This has
resulted in the creation of specialized departments for customer contacts: the call centre. Most
articles in this text are concerned with the working conditions at call centres.
195
XI Call Center Journals and Magazines
1. Cal l Center Management Review
Trade Monthly
http://www.incoming.com/slccmr.html
2. Cal l Center Magazine
Publisher: C M P Media Inc.
Trade Journal, US
http://www.callcentermagazine.com
3. CC News
Publisher: United Publications, Inc.
Trade Newspaper, US
http://www.CCNew.com
4. Customer Inter@ction Solutions
Publisher: Technology Marketing Corporation
Trade Monthly, US
http: //www.tmcnet.com/cis
5. Australian Cal l Centre and Customer Service Remuneration Review
Publisher: Cullen Egan Dell
Trade Annual, Australia
6. Cal l Centre Europe
Publisher: Stanworth Communications
Trade Monthly, UK
7. Cal l Centre Focus
Publisher: CALLcraft
Trade Monthly, UK
http://www.callcentre.co.uk
8. Cal l Center Magazine
Publisher: I I A Publishing Pty. Ltd.
Trade Weekly, Australia
9. Customer Interface Magazine
Trade Monthly, UK
196
http://www.c-interface.com/customerinterface/
10. International Journal of Cal l Centre Management
Winthrop Publications Ltd.
Quarterly, UK
http://www.winthrop-publications.co.uk/CCMFrontpage.htm
11. Communications Convergence
Publisher: CMP Media
Trade Monthly
http://www.convergence.com
197
XII Web Sites
1. Service-Engineering of Call Centers
http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng
(An academic course, with call centers as its application-focus; research and review papers,
including the present Bibliography, are downloadable from
http://ie.technion.ac.il/serveng/References/references.html;
additional material for Teachers of the sub ject is available upon request from Avi Mandelbaum,
at [email protected].)
2. Call Center Managers’ Forum
Call Centre Managers “Oasis”.
www.callcentres.com.au
3. Benchmark Portal (Purdue University Customer-driven quality)
http://www.BenchmarkPortal.com
4. CCA—The Professional Body for Call and Contact Centers
http://www.cca.org.uk
5. Incoming Calls Management Institute (ICMI)
http://www.incoming.com
6. Call Center Network Group (CCNG)
Global Association for Customer Contact Management
http://www.ccng.com
7. Call Center News Service
http://callcenternews.com
8. ACD Call Center Learning Center
http://www.call-centers.org
9. Call Center Exchange
http://www.callcenterexchange.com
10. Contact Center World
http://www.callcenterworld.com
11. The Call Center Directory
http://www.call-center-directory.com
12. International Call Center Benchmarking Consortium (ICCBC)
http://www.iccbc.org
13. CallVoice
http://www.callvoice.com
14. callcenterbiz
http://www.callcenterbiz.com
198
Static in the Call Center
by: Steve Fowler, Fowler Associates, Inc. October 28, 2006
[email protected]............... http://www.sfowler.com
Electrostatic shocks are being reported by many call centers personnel. The causes may shock you.

Personnel in Call Centers around the world report being shocked as they perform their jobs. The

shocks typically are to the head area near the headsets they wear. Where else but call centers would one find several hundred people in an office environment
tethered to a grounded telephone system by headsets? The phenomena are real and so are the effects on the personnel.
The reported problems due to these shocks range from mild annoyance to loss of sight and hearing. Luckily the more drastic affects seem to be temporary.These
are electrostatic shocks primarily of the person to the phone system. Typically the electrical or telecommunication systems are not to blame as the source of the
electrostatic voltages which result in the painful shocks.
Sometimes the source may be atmospheric in nature. Lightning in the general area may cause what experts call a "ground plane rise" and give a shock to persons
wearing headsets. However, this is a more rare phenomenon if the system has proper surge protection. In this article I am addressing only the shocks caused by
electrostatic charges accumulated on the personnel and discharged to other persons, the equipment or through the headsets.
Causes:The primary causes of the electrostatic charge are personnel actions and clothing in relationship with the call center floors and chairs. In other words, the
personnel themselves charge up their bodies because they wear clothes and shoes, which generate electrostatic charges when they scoot in and stand up from their
chairs and when they walk on the floors. When this charge reaches enough potential (voltage) on the person to jump the gap between their ear and the headset, a
shock occurs. Most headsets have some sort of insulative piece that cushions the ear to the headset speaker. The distance of this will hold off and arc of
approximately 20,000 to 35,000 volts on the person. This means that by the time the electrostatic potential is great enough to jump, it is sufficient to cause
physical pain. Most call centers have normal office style chairs, which have no antistatic capabilities. Also most call centers have normal carpeted floors with
carpet that has little ability to keep static charges down against many shoe types.
Floors:When a carpet is sold as "antistatic", it means that it has been tested at 20% RH against a standard Neolite sole sandal and found to be below 3,000 volts.
This does not guarantee that the voltages on a person at any other humidity or wearing any other shoe will be less than 3,000 volts. In fact many shoes tested
against "antistatic" carpets have much higher results. Most people can not feel below 3,500 volts when they discharge from their fingers such as getting out of a
car or walking across a carpeted floor and touching a doorknob. However, when such a discharge is allowed to occur at the ear lobe area, the sensitivity is much
greater.

Better carpet from an antistatic point of view is needed when personnel are wearing telephone headsets. The application of antistatic chemicals to standard
"antistatic" carpet will keep personnel voltages down but it is a temporary fix that must be reapplied every few months. The best carpet for the reduction of
charges is conductive. This means that the carpet is made with conductive fibers allowing it to discharge static charges from the shoes of personnel. Companies
such as manufacture such carpets in a wide range of styles and colors. Our labs have tested Static Smart carpets in very low humidities with insulative shoes and
found that they provide a very low static generation for call center environments.
Shoes:Personnel add considerably to their electrostatic charging by the shoes they wear. Leather soled shoes are usually better than shoes with rubber soles.
However, when conductive carpet is used with conductive footwear such as heel grounders or ESD shoes, the voltage on a person is kept below 100 volts. ESD
Shoes may be acquired from Iron Age shoes. Conductive heel grounders may be obtained from several sources such as 3M and DESCO. When most normal
shoes are worn, conductive carpets generally keep the voltage on personnel below 1,500 volts which is well below the perception of pain during a discharge.
Chairs:Normal office style chairs have polyester upholstery and have no means of grounding the chair.

In the electronics industry where computer chips may be sensitive to a few volts, the chairs are conductive and have grounding mechanisms. In normal office
chairs, when a person sits in and scoots around in the chair then stands up, they accumulate a significant electrostatic charge which may then discharge through
the telephone headset or to another worker. If that other worker just stood up from their chair and walked over on non-conductive carpeting, the potential
difference or the total voltage between the two people may double because the voltages may add. In this case the shock would also be doubled in intensity and
also may cause two people discomfort. In call centers conductive chairs should be used. These chairs are usually very expensive and by the time the problem is
known the call center usually has already purchased several hundred chairs.
Chairs Covers:

One alternative to buying a conductive chair is to use a conductive cover, which has conductive threads woven into it. These covers are available through DESCO
in Miami, Florida. Patlon has filed a patent disclosure on this innovative system which may eliminate static shocks for all office works including those in call
centers. Our lab tested Desco's conductive covers and found that they keep the voltages on persons below about 1/5th that of the plain chair.

Clothes:Of course the clothes that a person wears are very important to how much electrostatic charges are generated by the person. Oddly enough, cotton
clothes, which are normally very good from an electrostatic point of view, may charge more against a polyester upholstered chair than blended fabrics. One
method of keeping the voltage due to clothing on a person down is to require the personnel to wear conductive lab coats. This in combination with the chairs
would disallow the kind of potentials now experienced in the call centers. Several companies provide conductive lab coats for use in office environments.
Conclusions:Every call center has a unique situation for electrostatic problems. A survey of the needs should be performed prior to any actions. However, if all
the main variables are controlled:Chairs, Floor, Clothes and Shoes the problem should go away painlessly.

Please give us your comments

For further information contact Steve Fowler at Fowler Associates, Inc.We have solutions ready to usehttp://[email protected]