Chapter 1 - FS Analysis
Chapter 1 - FS Analysis
FINANCIAL STATEMENT
ANALYSIS
LEARNING OBJECTIVES:
After studying this chapter, you should be able to:
1. Identify the tools for financial statement analysis.
2. Explain why financial analysts use ratios to evaluate
companies.
3. Explain liquidity and show how ratios can measure a
company’s liquidity.
4. Explain profitability and show how ratios can measure a
company’s profitability.
4. Explain solvency and show how ratios can measure a
company’s solvency.
5. Explain some limitations of ratio analysis.
6. Discuss the need for comparative analysis.
1
FINANCIAL STATEMENTS ANALYSIS
Financial Statement Analysis involves the evaluation of the firm’s past
performance, present condition, and business potentials. The analysis provides
information about the following, among others:
HORIZONTAL ANALYSIS
Horizontal or index analysis involves comparison of figures shown in the financial
statements of two or more consecutive periods. The difference of the amount
between two periods is calculated, and the percentage change from one period
to the next is computed using the earlier period as the base.
2
VERTICAL ANALYSIS
Vertical Analysis is the process of comparing figures in the financial statements of
a single period. It involves conversion of figures in the statements to a common
base. This is accomplished by expressing all figures in the statements as
percentages of an important item such as total assets (in the balance sheet) or
net sales (in the income statement). These converted statements are called
common-size statements or percentage composition statements.
RATIO ANALYSIS
Ratio analysis involves development of mathematical relationships among
accounts in the financial statements. Ratios calculated from these statements
provide users and analysts with relevant information about the firm’s liquidity,
solvency and profitability.
1. When calculating a ratio using balance sheet numbers only, the numerator and
denominator should be from the same balance sheet date. The same are true for
ratios using only income statement numbers.
2. If an income statement account and a balance sheet account are both used to
calculate a ratio, the balance sheet account should be expressed as an average for
the time period represented by the income statement account.
3. If the beginning balance of a balance sheet account is not available, the ending
balance is normally used to represent the average balance of the account.
3
4. If sales and/ or purchases are given without making distinction as to whether
made in cash or on credit, assumptions are made depending on the ratio being
calculated:
5. Generally, the number of days in a month or year is not critical to the analysis:
a year may have 360 days, 52 weeks, and 12 months; alternatively, a year may be
comprised of 365 calendar days, 300 working days or any appropriate number of
days.
LIQUIDITY RATIOS
LIQUIDITY refers to the company’s ability to pay its current liabilities as they fall
due.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
4
WORKING CAPITAL ACTIVITY RATIOS/ EFFICIENCY
RATIOS
1. Receivables Turnover
It is the time required to complete one collection cycle from the time receivables
are recorded, and then collected, to the time new receivables are recorded again.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
3. Inventory Turnover
It measures the number of times that the inventory is replaced during the period.
Computed as follows:
5
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
6
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
10. Average Age of Trade Payables/ Payable Deferral Period/ Days’ Purchases in
Payables
It indicates the length of time during which payables remain unpaid.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
7
SOLVENCY RATIOS
SOLVENCY refers to the ability of the company to pay its debts. These ratios
involve leverage ratios. LEVERAGE refers to how much of company’s resources
are financed by debt and/or preferred equity, both of which require fixed
payment of interests and dividends.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
3. Debt Ratio
Refers to the proportion of total assets provided by the creditors.
Computed as follows:
4. Equity Ratio
Refers to the proportion of total assets provided by owners.
8
Computed as follows:
PROFITABILITY RATIOS
1. Return on Sales
This determines the portion of sales that went into the company’s earnings.
Computed as follows:
2. Return on Assets
This refers to the efficiency with which assets are used to operate the business.
Computed as follows:
3. Return on Equity
Measures the amount earned on the owners’ or stockholders’ investment.
9
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
MARKETABILITY RATIOS
1. Price-Earnings Ratio
It indicates the number of pesos required to buy P1 of earnings.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
10
Computed as follows:
STABILITY RATIOS
1. Fixed Asset to Total Equity
Measures the proportion of owners’ equity to fixed assets. This indicates whether
investments by owners are over or under and also shows weakness in leverage.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
11
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
TFCE = Net Income before taxes & charges ÷ Fixed charges + sinking fund
payment**
** Fixed charges shall include rent, interests and other relevant fixed
expenses; sinking fund payment must be expressed before tax.
12
SOLVENCY RATIOS
1. Working Capital Turnover
Indicates adequacy of working capital to support operations (sale).
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
3. Payable Turnover
Measures efficiency of the company in meeting the accounts payable.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
13
RATIOS INDICATIVE OF INCOME POSITION
1. Rate of return on Average Current Asset
Measures profitability of current assets invested.
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
Computed as follows:
14
Gross profit is the difference between sales and cost of goods sold. It is a very
important figure in the income statement because it is one of the factors that
determine the final result of operations.
1. Selling price
2. Volume or quantity of products sold.
3. Cost of product sold
NOTE:
FAVORABLE if actual (current) GP is greater than budgeted (prior-period) GP.
UNFAVORABLE if actual (current) GP is less than budgeted (prior-period) GP.
There are different ways of analyzing gross profit variances. Presented here are 4-
way, 6-way and 3-way analyses.
4-WAY ANALYSIS:
Sales Variance:
Price factor = (Change in SP x Actual Volume or quantity)
Volume/quantity factor = (Change in units x Standard/Budgeted SP)
Cost Variance:
Price factor = (Change in CP x Actual Volume or quantity)
Volume/quantity factor = (Change in units x Standard/Budgeted CP)
Note: The above procedures are the same as the one used in 2-way analysis for
materials and labor variances.
15
6-WAY ANALYSIS:
Sales Variance:
Price factor = (Change in SP x Standard/Budgeted Volume/quantity)
Volume/quantity factor = (Change in units/volume x Standard/Budgeted SP)
Price-volume factor = (Change in SP x Change in Units)
Cost Variance:
Price factor = (Change in CP x Standard/Budgeted Volume/quantity)
Volume/quantity factor = (Change in units/volume x Standard/Budgeted CP)
Price-volume factor = (Change in CP x Change in Units)
Note:
The price factor refers to the change in Selling or cost prices assuming that there
has been no change in units sold.
The quantity or volume factor refers to the change in the number of units sold
assuming that there has been no change in the selling or cost prices.
The price-volume factor refers to the sales or cost of sales variances due to the
combined effect of the differences in price and units sold.
3-WAY ANALYSIS:
Note: The quantity factor refers to the change in gross profit due to the difference
in units sold.
The price factor refers to the change in gross profit due to the difference in
selling price.
16
the sales volume and cost volume variances are analyzed further, which results in
the computation of a sales mix variance and final sales volume variance. The
formulas for these last two variances are as follows:
ILLUSTRATIVE EXERCISES
VERTICAL AND HORIZONTAL ANALYSIS
The comparative balance sheets of Philip Morris Companies, Inc. are presented
below.
VIKING CORPORATION
Comparative Income Statements
For the years ended December 31
(In million Dollars)
2014 2013
Net Sales 550,000 550,000
Cost of goods sold 440,000 450,000
Gross Profit 110,000 100,000
Operating Expenses 58,000 55,000
Net Income 52,000 45,000
LIQUIDITY ANALYSIS
Indicate the effects of each of the following transactions on the company’s (A)
current ratio and (B) acid-test ratio. There are the possible answers: (+) increase,
(-) decrease, and (0) no effect. Before each transaction takes place, both ratios
are greater than 1 to 1.
18
Effects on
Transactions Current ratio Acid-test ratio
Example: Sell merchandise for cash. + +
1. Buy inventory on account.
2. Pay an account payable.
3. Borrow cash on a short-term loan.
4. Issue long-term bonds payable.
5. Collect an accounts receivable.
6. Record accrued expenses payable.
7. Sell a plant asset for cash at a profit.
8. Sell a plant asset for cash at a loss.
9. Buy marketable securities, for cash.
10. Sell merchandise on credit.
FINANCIAL RATIOS
Leen has 1,000,000 common shares outstanding. The price of the stock is P8. Leen
declared dividends per share of P0.10. The balance sheet at the end of 2013
showed approximately the same amounts as that at the end of 2014.
FINANCIAL RATIOS
(Interpreting Financial Statements)
The Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo, Inc. provide refreshments to every corner
of the world. Selected data from the 2003 consolidated financial statements for
The Coca-Cola Company and for PepsiCo, Inc. are presented here (in millions of
Dollars).
20
Coca-Cola PepsiCo
Total current assets 8,396 6,930
Total current liabilities 7,886 6,415
Net sales 21,044 26,971
Cost of goods sold 7,762 12,379
Net income 4,347 3,568
Average receivables for the year 2,094 2,681
Average inventories for the year 1,273 1,377
Average total assets 25,874 24,401
Average common shareholders’ equity 12,945 10,713
Average current liabilities 7,614 6,234
Average total liabilities 12,929 13,702
Total assets 27,342 25,327
Total liabilities 13,252 13,453
Income taxes 1,148 1,424
Interest expense 178 163
Cash provided by operating activities 5,456 4,328
2. Compute the following solvency ratios for the two companies and
comment on the relative solvency of the two competitors.
a. Debt to total assets.
b. Times interest earned.
c. Cash debt coverage ratio.
3. Compute the following profitability ratios for the two companies and
comment on the relative profitability of the two competitors.
a. Profit margin
21
b. Asset turnover
c. Return on assets
d. Return on common stockholders’ equity
1. 4-way analysis
2. 6-way analysis
3. 3-way analysis
In January, actual operations resulted in the production and sale of 13,000 units
at an average selling price of P34 per unit. The cost of goods sold per unit
increased by P3.
22
4. Cost price variance.
5. Cost volume variance.
Spaniard Company has requested you to determine the cause of the difference
between its 2013 and 2014 gross profit based on the following data:
2013 2014
Sales 200,000 252,000
Cost of Goods Sold 120,000 180,000
Gross Profit 80,000 72,000
No additional data was made available except that unit sales increased by 20% in
2014.
2014 2013
Product Product Product Product Product Product
A L R A L R
Sales volume 400 350 1,000 500 200 1,000
in units
Selling prices P4 P5 P3 P4.50 P4.20 P2.80
per unit
Cost per unit P1.60 P2 P1.20 P1.68 P1.80 P1.12
23
Required: (Round all computations to 2 decimal places).
Compute for the sales mix variance and final sales volume variance
2013 2014
Product Product Product Product
A B A B
Sales volume 6,000 4,000 3,000 5,000
Unit selling price 10 6 9 5
Unit cost 6 3 4 3
PRACTICE EXERCISES
(Sources: CMA/CIA/RPCPA/AICPA/Various test banks)
THEORIES
1. A high sales-to-working capital ratio could indicate
a. Unprofitable use of working capital
b. Sales are not adequate relative to available working capital.
c. The firm is undercapitalized.
d. The firm is not susceptible to liquidity problems.
25
7. The collection of a current account receivable of P29,000 would
a. Increase the current ratio
b. Decrease the current ratio and the quick ratio
c. Increase the quick ratio
d. Not affect the current or quick ratio
8. Obsolete inventory of P125,000 was written off during the year. This
transaction
a. Decreased the quick ratio.
b. Increased the quick ratio.
c. Increased net working capital.
d. Decreased the current ratio.
10. The issuance of a serial bonds in exchange for an office building, with the
first installment of the bonds due late this year,
a. Decreases net working capital.
b. Decreases the current ratio.
c. Decreases the quick ratio.
d. Affects all of the answers as indicated.
12. To determine the operating cycle for a retail department store, which one
of the following pairs of items is needed?
a. Days sales in accounts receivable and average merchandise inventory.
b. Cash turnover and net sales.
26
c. Accounts receivable turnover and inventory turnover.
d. Asset turnover and return on sales.
13. If the ratio of total liabilities to shareholders’ equity increases, a ratio that
must also increase is
a. Times interest earned.
b. Total liabilities to total assets.
c. Return on equity.
d. The current ratio.
16. A drop in the market price of a firm’s common stock will immediately
increase its
a. Return on equity.
b. Dividend payout ratio.
c. Market-to-book ratio.
d. Dividend yield.
27
18. Which of the following is not a limitation of ratio analysis affecting
comparability among firms?
a. Different accounting policies.
b. Different fiscal years.
c. Different sources of information.
d. All of the above are limitations of ratio analysis.
19. Which of the following is the worst limitation of ratio analysis affecting
comparability from one interim period to the next within the firm?
a. Management has an incentive to window dress financial statements
to improve results.
b. In a seasonal business, inventory and receivables may vary widely
with year-end balances not reflecting the averages for the period.
c. Comparability is impaired if different firms use different accounting
policies.
d. Generalizations about which ratios are strong indicators of a firm’s
financial position may change from industry to industry and firm to
firm.
20. In assessing the financial prospects for a firm, financial analysts use
various techniques. Which of the following is an example of vertical
common-size analysis?
a. An assessment of the relative stability of a firm’s level of vertical
integration.
b. A comparison in financial ratio form between two or more firms in
the same industry.
c. A statement that current advertising expense is 2% greater than in
the prior year.
d. A statement that current advertising expense is 2% of sales.
21. Under the direct method of determining net cash provided by operating
activities on the statement of cash flows, a gain on sale of plant assets
would be:
a. Added to the amount of operating expenses reported under the accrual
basis.
28
b. Deducted from the amount of the operating expenses reported under
the accrual basis.
c. Deducted from the amount of sales reported under the accrual basis.
d. Totally ignored since the gain is not a part of sales, cost of goods sold,
or operating expenses.
24. A Company has a current ratio greater than 1:1 and a quick ratio less than
1:1. Soon thereafter, all cash was used to reduce accounts payable. How
did these cash payments affect (1) current ratio (2) quick ratio?
a. (1) Decreased (2) Decreased c. (1) Increased (2) Decreased
b. (1) Decreased (2) Increased d. (1) Increased (2) Increased
25. If Jonas Co. decides to change from FIFO to LIFO inventory method during
the period of rising prices, its
a. Current ratio would be reduced c. Inventory turnover will be
reduced
b. Debt-to-equity ratio would be reducedd. Cash flow would be reduced
26. How is the average inventory balance used in the calculation of each of
the following?
Acid-test ratio Inventory turnover
a. Numerator Numerator
b. Numerator Denominator
c. Not used Denominator
d. Not used Numerator
29
27. A company’s return on investment is affected by a change in
Capital turnover Profit margin on sales
a. Yes Yes
b. Yes No
c. No No
d. No Yes
30. A fire has destroyed many of the financial records of National & Co. You
are assigned to put together a financial report. You have found out that
the return on equity to be 12% and the debt ratio was 0.40.
What was the return on assets?
a. 5.35% c. 6.60%
b. 8.4% d. 7.20%
PROBLEMS
1. Windham Company has current assets of P400,000 and current liabilities
of P500,000. Windham Company’s current ratio would be increased by
a. The purchase of P100,000 of inventory on account.
b. The payment of P100,000 of accounts payable.
30
c. The collection of P100,000 of accounts receivable.
d. Refinancing a P100,000 long-term loan with short-term debt.
4. What will happen to the ratios below if Tosh Enterprises uses cash to pay
25% of the accounts payable?
Current Ratio Quick Ratio
a. Increase Increase
b. Decrease Decrease
c. Increase Decrease
d. Decrease Increase
31
5. The amount of working capital is
a. 600,000
b. 1,120,000
c. 1,200,000
d. 1,220,000
32
9. Watson Corporation computed the following items from its financial
records for the year:
Price earnings ratio 12
Payout ratio .6
Asset turnover ratio .9
11. Baylor Company paid out one-half of last year’s earnings in dividends.
Baylor’s earnings increased by 20%, and the amount of its dividends
increased by 15% in the current year. Baylor’s dividend payout ratio for
the current year was
a. 50%
b. 57.5%
c. 47.9%
d. 78%
33
12. Selected data from Starbucks are presented below. The difference
between average and ending inventories is immaterial. Current assets are
comprised mainly of cash, receivables and inventories.
13. Based on the data presented below, what is Goldilocks Corporation’s cost
of sales for the year?
34
14. What would be the age of receivables in 2014?
a. 110 days c. 130 days
b. 120 days d. None of these
Assuming 360 days in a year, what was the average number of days in
operating cycle for 2014?
a. 72 days c. 144 days
b. 84 days d. 168 days
35
King Products Corporation
Statement of Financial Position
(In Thousands)
June 30, June 30,
2014 2013
Cash 60 50
Trading securities (at Fair Value) 40 30
Accounts receivable (net) 90 60
Inventories (at lower of cost or market) 120 100
Prepaid items 30 40
Total current assets 340 280
Notes payable 46 24
Accounts payable 94 56
Accrued interest 30 30
Total current liabilities 170 110
Notes payable, 10% due 12/31/19 20 20
Bonds payable, 12% due 6/30/21 30 30
Total long-term debt 50 50
Total Liabilities 220 160
Preferred stock-5% cumulative, P100 par,
nonparticipating, authorized, issued and 200 200
outstanding 2,000 shares
Common stock-P10 par, 40,000 shares
authorized, 30,000 shares issued and 300 300
outstanding
Additional paid in capital 150 150
Retained earnings 130 100
36
Total Equity 780 750
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 1,000 910
18. King Products Corporation’s inventory turnover ratio for the fiscal year at
June 2014 was
a. 3.7
b. 4.0
c. 4.4
d. 6.0
19. King Products Corporation’s receivables turnover ratio for this period was
a. 4.9
b. 5.9
c. 6.7
d. 8.0
20. King Products Corporation’s average collection period for the fiscal year
ended June 30, 2014 using a 360-day year was
a. 36 days
b. 45 days
c. 54 days
d. 61 days
21. King Products Corporation’s quick ratio at June 30, 2014 was
a. 0.6
b. 1.1
c. 1.8
d. 2.0
22. Assuming that King Products Corporation’s net income for the year ended
June 30, 2014 was P70,000 and there are no preferred stock dividends in
arrears, King Products’ return on common equity was
a. 7.8%
b. 10.6%
c. 10.9%
d. 12.4%
37
23. Assuming that there are no preferred stock dividends in arrears, King
Products Corporation’s book value per share of common stock at June 30,
2014 was
a. 10.00
b. 14.50
c. 18.33
d. 19.33
24. Given an acid test ratio of 2.0, current assets of P5,000 and inventory of
P2,000, the value of current liabilities is
a. 1,500
b. 2,500
c. 3,500
d. 6,000
38
Liabilities and equity
Current liabilities
Notes payable 36 18
Accounts payable 70 42
Accrued expenses 5 4
Income taxes payable 15 16
Total current liabilities 125 80
Long-term debt 35 35
Deferred taxes 3 2
Total liabilities 163 117
Equity
Preferred stock, 6%, P100 par value 150 150
cumulative
Common stock, P10 par value 225 195
Additional paid-in capital common stock 114 100
Retained earnings 96 129
Total equity 585 574
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY 748 691
39
26. Assuming there are no preferred stock dividends in arrears, Devlin
Company’s return on common equity for the year ended May 31, 2014
was
a. 6.3%
b. 7.5%
c. 7.8%
d. 10.5%
27. Devlin Company’s inventory turnover for the year ended May 31, 2014
was
a. 3.67 times
b. 3.88 times
c. 5.33 times
d. 5.65 times
28. Devlin Company’s asset turnover for the year ended May 31, 2014
a. 0.08 times
b. 0.46 times
c. 0.67 times
d. 0.83 times
29. Devlin Company’s rate of return on assets for the year ended May 31,
2014
a. 7.2%
b. 7.5%
c. 7.8%
d. 11.2%
30. Devlin Company’s time-interest-earned ratio for the year ended May 31,
2014 was
a. 6.75 times
b. 11.25 times
c. 12.25 times
d. 18.75 times