Lecture 9: Quarter-Wave-Transformer Matching.: R JZ L Z Z Z JR L
Lecture 9: Quarter-Wave-Transformer Matching.: R JZ L Z Z Z JR L
Lecture 9: Quarter-Wave-Transformer
Matching.
d W r
as a function of W/d is
Z0
175
150
125
100
70.7 75
50.0 50
25
W d
1.3 2 2.4 4 6 8 10
A
plus a discussion of how well-known dis-
(Im [ρ ])
2
characteristics of the load tributed matching
+ Re [ρload ]
load
affects matching band- network is the ρmax = (44)
Re [ρload ]
width and the choice of quarter-wavelength long
network topologies transmission line trans-
former. I will refer to this and the electrical length of the line is given by
network as a type 11. The characteristic (see text)
impedance of this line is given by
Z0 = 4 a2 + b2 − b
RS RL (41) θ12 = tan −1 + 90° (45)
2a
For example, a 100 ohm load is matched to
a 50 ohm source using a 90° line with charac- where
teristic impedance 70.71 ohms. The matchable
space of the quarter-wavelength transformer a = Z12 X L (46)
is small, essentially only the real axis on the
Smith chart. Nevertheless, it enjoys
widespread use. A quarter-wavelength line is
also used in filter design as an impedance
inverter to convert series resonant circuits to
parallel resonance, and vice versa [4].
b = X L2 + RL2 − Z12
2
(47)
The Shortened Quarter-Wavelength Transformer Figure 11 · Smith chart plot for a one section L-network
Another less well-known but useful adaptation of the (red) to match 300 ohms to 50 ohms and a three sec-
quarter-wavelength transformer is the shortened, double- tion L-network in blue. Also plotted are corresponding
section transformer depicted in Figure 10. I will refer to constant Q curves (dashed).
this as type 13. Like the standard transformer, it is used
to match real impedances. But the required length is
shorter and it uses lines with characteristic impedance matches at a single frequency. Obtaining a good match
equal to the impedances being matched. These are both over an extended frequency range may require many ele-
practical features in many applications. ments and finding values is very challenging. Before I
Notice that the transmission line with characteristic cover this subject, let me introduce another fundamental
impedance equal to the load is adjacent to the source. concept.
Both transmission lines have the same length. The maxi-
mum line length is 30°, and it decreases as the load Q of the Load
impedance is much higher or lower than the source The term Q is used for several properties. Mastery of
impedance. each is critical to understanding oscillators, filters,
With normalized load resistance R′L, the line length is matching networks and other circuits [5]. One definition
of loaded Q is the center frequency divided by the 3 dB
1 bandwidth of a resonant circuit response. It is a finite
θ13 = tan −1 (48) value even if the circuit is built using components with
R′ + RL′ + 1
L
2
infinite Q. Component Q, or unloaded Q, is a measure of
RL′ component quality; the ratio of stored energy to dissipat-
ed energy in the component. It is as high as 200 for excel-
For example, a 100 ohm resistive load is matched to 50 lent inductors. But unloaded Q increases with physical
ohms using a single, 90° long line with a characteristic size, so modern miniature inductors have much lower Q.
impedance of 70.7 ohms. With a cascade of 50 and 100 Q of the load described in this section is yet a third defi-
ohm lines, each is 28.13° long for a total length of 56.25°. nition of Q. I often feel engineers would be less confused
if these properties were labeled Q, R and S. However,
The Challenge their definitions have similar roots.
Since all complex loads are matchable by two element Q of the load is a property of a complex termination.
networks and sometimes a single transmission line, why For series impedance it is given simply by
is matching sometimes difficult? For loads with a large
reflection coefficient, the element values may be difficult XL
to realize. This is particularly true for distributed circuits. Qof load = (49)
RL
But more often the problem is bandwidth. A simple circuit
Figure 12 · Amplitude transmission Figure 13 · Transmission amplitude Figure 14 · Smith chart plot for a
responses for 300 ohm to 50 ohm responses for 50 to 300 ohm single- one-section quarter-wavelength
matching L-networks. section (red), three-section (blue), transformer (red) and a three-sec-
five-section (green) and eleven- tion transformer (blue) to match 300
section transformers (magenta). to 50 ohms.
and for parallel admittance it is L-network. Plotted in red and blue are the transmission
and return loss responses of the three section L-network.
The 15 dB return loss has a bandwidth of about 17% for
GL
Qof load = (50) the one-section L-network and about 59% for the 3-sec-
BL
tion L-network. The ratio of the bandwidths is 59/17 =
3.5 and the ratio of the Q values is 3/0.9 = 3.3. The exact
The dashed red lines in Figure 11 are arcs of constant relationship between the bandwidth and Q arcs depend
Q of the load. These Q arcs pass through X′L = ±2.3 where on the return loss used to define the bandwidth.
R′L = 1 so Qof load = 2.3. The dashed blue arcs mark a Q of However, the relation is clear: matching networks with
0.9 since they pass through 0.9+j1.0 and 0.9–j1.0. To impedance arcs that remain closer to the real axis have
understand the significance of Q arcs, consider the solid better bandwidth.
arcs in Figure 11. Using impedance arcs is insightful when designing
both lumped and distributed matching networks. But this
Element Impedance Transforms Plotted on process is increasingly ineffective when attempting to
the Smith Chart match multiple frequencies over a wide bandwidth. The
The solid red arc that begins at 300 ohms (6 normal- blue arcs in Figure 11 were drawn for a single frequency,
ized) on the real axis, right of center, is the resulting 100 MHz. The solid blue return loss response in Figure 12
action at 100 MHz of a shunt 11.84 pF capacitor that reveals a near perfect match has been achieved at 100
transforms the 300 ohm load resistance to 50–j110 ohms. MHz as expected since the last blue arc in Figure 11 ends
The arc from this point to 50+j0 is the result of a series at 50 ohms. But further examination of the blue trace in
inductor of 178.4 nH, or +j110 ohms. These arcs are not Figure 12 reveals that the response is not centered on 100
responses plotted versus frequency but rather the length MHz, the design frequency. The dashed magenta and
of these arcs correspond to increasing values of the capac- brown plots in Figure 12 are the result of optimizing all 6
itor and inductor. These concepts are the basis of network element values to center the response on 100 MHz. When
design using the Smith chart [1, 2]. broad bandwidth is required, drawing arcs on a Smith
The red dashed Q arcs were drawn so they intersect chart, either with pencil and paper charts or by computer
the maximum extent of the solid L-network arcs, so the program, is cumbersome at best. Synthesis routines such
one-section L-network has a Q of 2.3. You can see that the as those in the Impedance Matching module of GENESYS
arcs of the 3-section L-network remain closer to the real are effective. Alternatively, optimization of an initial
axis. The Q of the 3-section L-network is only 0.9. Smith chart design via computer simulation is effective
Plotted in brown and green in Figure 12 are the for problems with well-behaved loads. This will be dis-
transmission and return loss responses of the one section cussed in more detail later.
Zi ( n) = Step × Zi ( n − 1) N
(53) −Qof load ln ( Γ min ) (58)
n= 2 Qloaded =
π
Zi ( N ) = RL (54)
An octave bandwidth is Qloaded = 1.5. Using Eq. 2 we
The characteristic impedance of each section is find a return loss of 15 dB is a reflection coefficient of
0.178. To achieve a 15 dB return loss would require
Z ( n) = Zi ( n − 1) Zi ( n) N
n =1 (55) Qof load less than 2.73. For another example, with a load of
300+j300, Qof load = 1.0. The resulting Qloaded = 0.549.
where Zi(0) is the source impedance. Normalized to a center frequency of 1 MHz, a 15 dB
The transmission amplitude responses for single, return loss could be achieved from 0.089 to 1.911 MHz. I
three, five and eleven section transformers are given in obtained a 15 dB return loss from 0.115 to 1.885, a load-
Figure 13. The response of this simple algorithm is some- ed Q of 0.565, with a 26-element L-C network designed
what Legendre in shape. The ripple is not equal across using a direct synthesis routine that is described later. A
the passband and it increases with increasing N and 26-element network is hardly practical, but it illustrates
increasing load reflection coefficient. The ripple band- Fano’s formula provides an absolute limit that is
width of the eleven-section transformer extends from approached with significant effort. Fano’s limit is used to
about 0.16 to 1.8 MHz, more than a decade. Notice how- discover if a solution is possible, thus avoiding effort on
ever a trend of diminishing return for an increasing num- an unsolvable problem. This introduction to Fano’s limit
ber of sections. An Agilent GENESYS workspace for this prepares us to consider broadband matching with reac-
N-section transformer also may be downloaded from the tive loads.
post “Matching Tutorial published in High Frequency
Electronics magazine” at the Founder’s Forum at Reactance Absorption using Filters:
www.eagleware.com. Equal Resistance
In Figure 14, impedance arcs are plotted on a Smith I am often asked “How do you design a lowpass filter
chart for single and three section transformers. These with unequal terminations?” Consider a lowpass filter
plots suggest that an infinite number of sections would between a 50 ohm source and a 300 ohm load. The defini-
result in no departure from the real axis, the Q would be tion of lowpass is a response from DC to an upper fre-
zero and the bandwidth infinite. In fact, this is the case. quency limit. But, at low frequency the shunt capacitors
April 2006 33
High Frequency Design
MATCHING NETWORKS
Figure 15 · Schematic and response of a bandpass filter used to match a 50 ohm load with 20 pF series capacitance.
become high impedance and they vanish, and the series but very slowly.
inductors become low impedance and they vanish. So if the Capacitors or inductors are also absorbed using cook-
components effectively vanish, how can the network book bandpass filter topologies. The simplest form also
match 50 ohms to 300 ohms and have a low-loss response requires equal termination resistance. Bandpass filters
at low frequency? It can’t! The solution is theoretically absorb a much more reactive load at the expense of reduced
unrealizable. A match and maximum power transfer can bandwidth. For example, a fractional bandwidth of 10%, or
be achieved over a limited bandwidth that does not extend bw = 0.1, allows absorption of ten times larger components
to DC. The response is pseudo lowpass. The return loss as seen in Eqs. 59 and 60. Bandpass filters also support
and insertion loss at low frequency are the same values series capacitors and shunt inductors at the load.
that would exist without the network with 50 ohms driv-
ing a 300 ohm termination as computed by Eqs. 2 and 4. bw
Fmax = (61)
The bandwidth degrades and the low-frequency insertion 2πgRCseries
loss increases with increasing source/load resistance ratio.
However, a lowpass filter can match a reactive load up
bw × R
to the cutoff frequency if the load resistance equals the Fmax = (62)
2πgLshunt
source resistance. Consider a complex load with 50 ohms
in parallel with 20 pF capacitance. A standard lowpass fil-
ter with shunt 20 pF or higher capacitor at the output can For example, suppose we wish to match a 50 ohm load
absorb the load capacitance. The shunt capacitor in the with series capacitance of 20 pF to 20 dB return loss from
lowpass is simply reduced by the value of the load capac- 80 to 120 MHz using a three-section Chebyshev bandpass
itance. Likewise, if the load has series inductance, a low- filter. What is the minimum value of series capacitance
pass filter with a series output inductor is used. A match that can be absorbed? Using Eqs. 2 and 4 we find that the
is achieved from DC to a maximum frequency given by required passband ripple is 0.0432 dB. The final g-value
for a three-section, 0.0432 dB ripple Chebyshev is 0.852.
g When using an L-C filter, the center frequency is found
Fmax = (59)
bw × 2πRCshunt geometrically. That is,
X N −1
Xa = Xa = X
1− N N
X X
Xb = Xb =
N N
X 1− N
Xc = Xc = X
N ( N − 1) N2 Figure 17 · Shunt Norton transform applied to capaci-
tor C2 in Figure 15 (top) and after absorbing C2a into
Figure 16 · Series Norton transform (left) and shunt C1 and transferring the transformer to the load (bot-
Norton transform (right). tom). Notice the output load resistance has changed.
Ill-Behaved Loads
The red trace in Figure 18 is more interesting. It is optimization would be ineffective.
modeled data for a 9.24 meter tall, 0.3 meter diameter To match this antenna from 7 to 14.35 MHz I used the
monopole antenna tower mounted over ground. At low L-C Bandpass algorithm in the Impedance Match module
frequency it is capacitive. With increasing frequency it of GENESYS. This algorithm finds an appropriate topolo-
intersects the real axis at 35 ohms, it becomes inductive gy and computes element values based on user specified
and then intersects the real axis at 400 ohms. At high fre- frequency limits and the network order. This algorithm
quency it is again capacitive. It is generally parallel to cir- uses four general automated steps. First, a best-fit RLC
cles of constant resistance at the first resonance and par- model is determined for the load. The algorithm then
allel to circles of constant conductance at the higher fre- finds the poles and zeros of the matching network using a
quency resonance. As is typical with monopole antennas, Chebyshev approximation [8,9]. A network is then syn-
it has two resonances, a series resonance at 6.75 MHz fol- thesized using a continued-fraction expansion. The first
lowed by a parallel resonance at 14.25 MHz. The double three steps are very effective at finding the correct topol-
resonance, and the fact that the resistance ranges from ogy and in dealing with reactive loads. It is not particu-
34.4 ohms at series resonance to 405 ohms at parallel res- larly effective in transforming the resistive component of
onance makes this load difficult to match. In fact, the match. Therefore, as the fourth step, the user launch-
attempting to match this load manually using an auto- es an optimization that has been pre-defined by the algo-
mated Smith chart program or a modern simulator with rithm. This four-step process is extremely effective in
Figure 19 · A matching network for the parallel resonator load plotted in magenta in Figure 18 (left) and the cor-
responding responses (right).
Figure 20 · Six element network designed to match the monopole antenna from 7 to 14.3 MHz (left) and the
resulting VSWR plotted on the right (blue). Also plotted are the original monopole VSWR (red) and the monopole
matched with a single L network (green).
dealing with ill-behaved loads. Simulation and HF Filter Design and Computer
On the left side of Figure 20 is a six-element matching Simulation and has taught seminars on oscillator and fil-
network designed by this algorithm for the monopole ter design.
antenna. Plotted in blue on the right is the resulting
VSWR maintained at roughly 2:1 from 7 to just over 14 References
MHz. The original antenna VSWR is plotted in red. The 1. P. Smith, Electronic Applications of the Smith Chart,
resistance at the series resonance is close to 50 ohms and 2nd edition, 1995, SciTech/Noble Publishing, Raleigh,
the raw VSWR is quite good. But the resistance at paral- North Carolina.
lel resonance is high and the VSWR is poor. Plotted in 2. G. Parker, Introduction to the Smith Chart, (CD-
green is the resulting VSWR with a simple L-network ROM tutorial), 2003, SciTech/Noble Publishing, Raleigh,
that successfully centered the frequency but it has poor North Carolina.
bandwidth and the VSWR at the desired band edges is 3. Agilent Technologies, EEsof EDA Division, Santa
over 5:1. Rosa, CA. www/agilent.com/find/eesof
4. G. Matthaei, L. Young, and E.M.T. Jones, Microwave
Summary Filters, Impedance Matching Networks and Coupling
I had two goals in this tutorial series on matching. Structures, Artech House, Dedham, MA, 1967/1980.
First, I introduced many important concepts in matching 5. R. Rhea, Practical Issues in RF Design (3 set CD-
to help you grasp the underlying objectives in matching ROM tutorial), 2003, SciTech/Noble Publishing, Raleigh,
network design. Second, I provided formula and tech- North Carolina.
niques for the practical design of many types of both L-C 6. R. M. Fano, “Theoretical Limitations on the
and distributed networks. Not included were techniques Broadband Matching of Arbitrary Impedances,” Journal
applicable to transmission line transformers. The later of the Franklin Institute, January 1950.
are particularly effective in dealing with resistive loads in 7. R. Rhea, Filter Techniques (3 set CD-ROM tutorial),
the HF and VHF frequency range. This topic is well cov- 2003, SciTech/ Noble Publishing, Raleigh, North Carolina.
ered by Sevick [10,11,12]. 8. R. Levy, “Explicit Formulas for Chebyshev
Impedance-Matching Networks,” Proc. IEEE, June 1964.
Author Information 9. T.R. Cuthbert, Jr., Circuit Design Using Personal
Randall Rhea is a consultant to Agilent Technologies. Computers, John Wiley, New York, 1983.
He received a BSEE from the University of Illinois and 10. J. Sevick, Transmission Line Transformers, 4th ed.,
and MSEE from Arizona State. He worked at the Boeing 2001, SciTech/ Noble Publishing, Raleigh, North Carolina.
Company, Goodyear Aerospace and Scientific-Atlanta. He 11. J. Sevick, “Design of Broadband Ununs with
is the founder of Eagleware Corporation which was Impedance Ratios Less Than 1:4,” High Frequency
acquired by Agilent Technologies in 2005 and Noble Electronics, November, 2004.
Publishing which was acquired by SciTech Publishing in 12. J. Sevick, “A Simplified Analysis of the Broadband
2006. He has authored numerous papers and tutorial Transmission Line Transformer,” High Frequency
CDs, the books Oscillator Design and Computer Electronics, February, 2004.