Evolution of Initial Coin Offering PrelimStudy
Evolution of Initial Coin Offering PrelimStudy
Jean-Armand Figeac
February 2018
The aim of this preliminary research paper is to provide a first draft and ap-
proach on the challenging problems the general master thesis will be geared
towards. The main goal of this white paper is then to critically identify the
high relevance of Initial Coin Offering in the international financial sphere and
decipher not only its past and present implications but as well establish per-
spectives for ICO future development.
1
Contents
1 Introduction 4
1.1 Economic Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
1.2 Rise of Fintech . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
1.3 ICO Recent Surge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2 Problem Statement 6
3 Objectives 7
5 Theory of ICO 9
5.1 Technological aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9
5.2 ICO Representative Process . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
5.3 ICO Funding and Venture Capital . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
6 Methodology 12
7 Results 12
8 Conclusion 13
9 Reference 14
2
Acronym
GDP: Gross Domestic Product
ICO: Initial Coin Offering
IPO: Initial Public Offering
P2P: Peer to Peer
SMEs: Small and Medium-sized Enterprises
3
1 Introduction
1.1 Economic Background
Not only SMEs play a major and crucial role at a macro economical scale rep-
resenting on average 70% of a GDP country, they account for not less than two
thirds of total employment stretching -in the Eurozone for instance- from 53%
in the United Kingdom to 87% in Greece (Eurostat, 2015). It can therefore
be advanced that these entities are key components for both developing and
developed countries (OECD, 2017). Raising capital is as well one of the most
important factor for business’ success, which in turn, has positive consequences
for a country’s economy; both momentum and speed highly matter (Forbes,
2016). Important economic actors and well-established companies firmly assert
that enterprises without sufficient funds are not only bounded to fail but as well
limited in terms of knowledge and know how (World Bank, 2014). Financing
thus represents an undeniable source of growth and success for businesses.
For the past centuries, only a tiny fractions of economical actors have been the
catalysers of firms’ success such as banks, financials services, private and wealthy
investors. Recently, this sphere broadens up including now a wider aspect of
financial actors like Venture Capital which boomed during the late 1980s and
early 2000s; Angel Investors and Early Stage investors as well appeared to have
strengthen their bonds with much more start-up companies (Metrick, 2007).
4
(Financial Times, 1999).
The term cryptocurrency is actually a fusion of two terms both having robust
meaning. While currency refers to a mean of exchange into which a value is
pegged to and is publicly accessible, crypto on the other hand, is a field into
which technical application and process enable secure communication; its ety-
mology is a combination of “write” and “hidden secret” (Rogaway and Bellare,
2005). Rogaway and Bellare (2005) encompassed this term and advanced that
crypto is the scientific aspect to analyse protocol in a way preventing other par-
ties to decipher it. From then onwards, -and after WWII usage of encrypting
highly important messages, our era of ‘Living Service’ applied this methodology
to secure confidential data, authentication and information security (Preneel,
2000).
5
year 2015, 2017 recorded a 400% token sales increase while achieving a 3’739%
volume increased (Coinschedule, 2018). The below graph strongly highlights
the exponential speed at which ICO developed recently.
2 Problem Statement
The new technologies described above possess an immense array of applications
and have the full potential to disrupt several key actors in the financial sphere
(Financial Times, 2018). As mentioned in the previous section, raising capital
is crucial and of paramount importance for businesses to take off and subse-
quently be sustainable from a financial point of view. The past half decade gave
birth to different and alternatives way for raising capital such as crowd equity,
crowdfunding and other disruptive models empowered by Fintech; this trend is
far from fading away and will continue to grow (Forbes, 2017). Additionally, a
new phenomenon came into light through the Blockchain process named “Ini-
tial Coin Offering”. In its most simple and elementary form, an ICO can be
illustrated half way between a crowdfunding project and an IPO. While the first
one benefits from a certain flexibility in terms of regulation and is, in general,
targeting to raise several hundreds of thousands of a certain currency such as
the dollar or the euro, an IPO on the other hand, is highly regulated and seek to
penetrate the primary market while raising several millions. To obtain such an
important amount of capital, it can be understood that both of these processes
are long and tedious: indeed, neither crowdfunding nor IPO could reach their
goal amount overnight.
This is where ICO outperforms both of them. In order to emphasize and accen-
tuate the recent strong role ICO took in the Fintech segment, it can be advanced
the dissertation’s milestones will gravitate around the following main questions:
6
- “What shall be the key considerations to be taken into account from an
investor perspective when investing in ICOs?
Although this paper has not the pretention to draft the exact and adequate
structure to be only relied upon, it should provide though a sound ground-
ing starting point to further elaborate and establish development of technical
elements when grading/rating ICOs.
3 Objectives
The objectives of the research paper are multifold. The first part of the dis-
sertation will explain how ICO gained such an important momentum and will
identify the main drivers of such a dynamic boost over the past half-decade. To
achieve this, a theoretical perspective will be conducted putting into light ICO
process and its divergences/differences from previous way of raising capital in
the XXth century. We will as well draw our attention in the first section to the
technical aspects’ ICO require to fully enable us to obtain the necessary knowl-
edge and lexicon in this specific financing mechanism. Along those lines, an
overview of the recent and future regulatory actions taken by central authority
and supervisors will demonstrate how governments tend to actively deal with
these new bloomers.
The second part of the paper will gravitate around the practical aspect of ICO
and most especially how a certain rating scheme to those new models could be
created. Several key variables and criterias will be selected to which specific
weight shall be allocated. This part should then exhibit what are the main ele-
ments to take into consideration for ICO analysis. The list of objectives could
be represented as follows both from a theoretical and practical perspective.
Goals of the theoretical framework:
- Explore the technical aspects embedded in cryptocurrency
- Gain knowledge of ICO landscape while analysing its key components such as
market cap, token value and their evolution
- Evaluate and represent ICO process and their properties
- Realize ICO benchmark in order to seize its current and future perspective
- Compare traditional financial raising mechanism and ICO
7
Practice-oriented goals:
- Critically decipher potential risks at the centre of ICO
- Establish ICO guidelines on long term basis
- Select potential core variables and criteria from ICO rating through in-depth
analysis.
8
from start-ups having recently achieved ICOs, qualitative internet studies from
high profile and well-known investors/entrepreneurs will add up an additional
layer to the researches. The purpose of doing so is to combine a wide arrays
of ideas, visions, aspects and points of view from the most implied persons yet
details oriented and specialists in this sphere.
Eventually the practical part ending the report will be geared towards supervi-
sion and regulators press release in order to analyse the several risks embedded
in ICO process. Regarding ICO ratings, in-depth researches on active websites
in ICO data analysis and firms’ insights will offer valuable information as well.
A further step will then be to suggest guidelines and select potential variables
and key criteria to take into consideration for ICO success. To summarize, the
goal of this dissertation is to fill up the gap between the theoretical character-
istics of ICOs process on one hand and the practical aspects to consider when
rating and grading this new financing mechanic on the other hand.
5 Theory of ICO
5.1 Technological aspects
ICO technological aspects will be scrutinized in the main master research paper.
The first part of the technological aspect will encompass encryption properties
9
including cryptographic hash functions such as SHA 256, Proof Of Work and
the concept of Signatures.
These core Blockchain concepts are of paramount importance to fully under-
stand the relevance of this new mechanism. The second part will then underpin
the anatomy of tokens with a focus on both its fundamentals and technological
attributes. Tokens creation through ER20 earlier mentioned, Soft Fork/Hard
Fork will thus belong to this subpart.
10
Idea identification Idea identification Roadmap Planning
& & &
Token Relevance Token Relevance White Paper Creation
Building Team
Business Planning Active ICO Sale Building Technology Product Launching
Building Business
to stretch –in very broad terms- from few days to one or two months. In addi-
tion of fund raising speed, another important variable to take into consideration
is the total number of ICOs. Besides the important and vast amount of ICO
that recently occurred, it seems that traditional money lenders and traditional
financing mechanisms has been overtaken by these events and are running be-
hind. The graph below outlines this trend while putting into perspective the
amount raised by Angel Investors and Venture Capital company against ICO
fundraising. Figure 4 exhibits ICO pattern recently adopted; not only the as-
tronomical amount of money raised should be emphasized but as well the high
velocity with which it developed.
11
cipher ICOs mechanisms of raising funds and examine the core reasons of such a
high and velocity trend. While those core notions will be further analysed in the
master thesis, this preliminary report will not dwell into technological details.
Once the technological concepts will be reviewed though, they will allow us to
understand not only the full potential benefits this technology could bring to
the economy as a whole but as well the challenges and the evolution of such
mechanisms.
6 Methodology
The purpose of this research study will be first to establish a grounding theoret-
ical part on ICO evolution while combining paramount elements of this dynamic
perspective. The theoretical part shall include the representative ICO process
along with the review of its evolution over the past few years. This sub-step
will allow us to put into perspective traditional way of raising capital and the
various types of ICOs current market have dealt with; along those lines, the
important yet immature regulations national supervisors are confronted with
will be reviewed.
The last subpart of the theoretical aspect of this research paper will provide tech-
nological grounding knowledge for us to realize and appreciate the full potential
this innovation sphere could generate. Once theories have been established,
we will then be in a position to critically decipher a more practical aspect of
ICO. The author should then be able to establish and draft specific guidelines
for future ICOs while taking into account the previous mentioned technological
aspects and theories. In order to do that, several current and futures methods
being in the back log of supervisors and regulators will be analysed. The later
shall give us specific directions yet not fully implemented. Eventually, when
ICO risks have been identified from a market, operational financial and regu-
latory point of view, a SWOT analysis would outline the potential advantages
ICO are facing at the moment and their potential future challenges. In the end,
the last part will draft a scorecard matrix applicable to the ICO sphere. With a
keen focus on risk practices, appropriate weightings to core variables and criteria
(data points) will be determined through quantitative and qualitative analysis.
Figure 5 graphically depicts the methodological road map the author will
follow. While the above part includes theoretical important aspects needed to
dig in the topic of the dissertation, the one below is centred towards practical
approach.
7 Results
The purpose of the last part of the report will be aimed towards developing a
practical approach to ICO. As previously described above, the decision to take
12
Technological Aspects
Cryptographic Hash Functions & Anatomy of tokens
Encryption Token Creation
ICO Landscape
ICO Evolution Types of ICOs
Goal/Purpose/Objective Market Structure
ICO Representative Process
ICO Launching
ICO Risks
Market/Operation/Financial/Regulatory
part in ICO –to invest or not- is still today of crucial importance as several
investors decided to embrace this new investment vehicle. Nevertheless, scarce
resources are available to them and due-diligence on such conditions seems to
be intense if not impossible. Thus, the author has in mind to establish guide-
lines to be adopted by companies which could be as well reviewed by potential
investors. Along those lines, matrix scorecards related to specific future ICO
shall be created. Scorecards are indeed a key milestone for several stakeholders
such as credit risk agency and risk managers. Eventually, once the key points
would have been selected, certain weights should be allocated to each of them
enabling the user to have a holistic view on the ICO itself via the final formula
and final result.
8 Conclusion
The master dissertation will analyze Initial Coin Offering evolution and have
a prominent focus on its current and future perspectives. In order to do so,
a theoretical framework shall include technological aspects cryptocurrency are
based on: Blockchain key elements will then be highlighted in this section being
referred to as the catalyzer of digital currencies. Along the report, key consid-
erations from both potential investors and fund raising seeking companies will
be analyzed. Additionally, a regulatory approach will be conducted to outline
how supervisors are adapting to these new dynamics of financing mechanism.
The second part of the dissertation will be focused on a more practical approach
and will tend to identify crucial areas of ICO risks. Besides, the author plans to
elaborate scoring matrix and select different key criteria’s and variables required
to rate ICO appropriately.
13
9 Reference
Altucher, J. (2016). [ebook] United States of America, Cryptocurrencies 101,
How to make a fortune from Digital Currencies. Available at: https://d8yoo85ik
fg26.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Cryptocurrencies101.pdf [Ac-
cessed 4 Feb. 2018].
14
Forbes, (2017). Alternative Finance And The Rise Of The Fintech Unicorn,
Madhvi Mavadiya. [online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/madhvima
vadiya/2017/04/24/alternative-finance-fintech-unicorn/5447f3ae4905 [Accessed
2 Feb. 2018].
Forbes, (2017). The Emperor’s New Coins: How Initial Coin Offerings Fu-
eled A $100 Billion Crypto Bubble. [online] Available at: https://www.forbes.com
/sites/laurashin/2017/07/10/the-emperors-new-coins-how-initial-coin-offerings-
fueled-a-100-billion-crypto-bubble/1344cf596ece [Accessed 1 Feb. 2018].
15
Wilmoth, J. (2018).3 Types of ICO Tokens - Strategic Coin. [online] Strate-
gic Coin. Available at: http://strategiccoin.com/3-types-ico-tokens/ [Accessed
4 Feb. 2018].
World Bank, (2014). Private Equity and Venture Capital in SMEs in Devel-
oping Countries. [online] Available at: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated
/en/336471468155132454/pdf/WPS6827.pdf [Accessed 2 Feb. 2018].
16