Antila Sara PDF
Antila Sara PDF
Antila Sara PDF
Case: TravelBird
Autumn 2016
ABSTRACT
From the results of the study it can be concluded that the images of
TravelBird are quite positive. TravelBird can be held as an attractive online
travel agency since according to the results of the survey, most of the
respondents could imagine using their services in the future. However, the
brand awareness level in Finland is still relatively low and would need
bigger investments on marketing to raise the status on the Finnish
markets.
Syksy 2016
TIIVISTELMÄ
1 INTRODUCTION 1
3 BRAND AWARENESS 10
3.1 The definition and meaning of brand 10
3.2 The formation of the brand 11
3.3 Brand awareness 12
3.4 Images and brand image 14
4 EMPIRICAL RESEARCH 15
4.1 Research design and methodology 15
4.2 Data collection 16
4.3 Target population and sample 17
4.4 Research Implementation 19
4.5 Research results 21
4.5.1 Online purchase behaviour 21
4.5.2 Brand awareness of TravelBird 25
4.5.3 The attractiveness of TravelBird 28
6 CONCLUSIONS 35
REFERENCES 37
APPENDICES 40
1 INTRODUCTION
The tourism industry has significantly changed during the past 10 years
due to the development of internet as well as information and
communication technologies. It has led the tourism industry to the point
were travel agencies have moved partly or completely online. TravelBird,
Dutch online based travel agency, is one of these, as well as the case
company of this thesis.
The theoretical framework consists of two bigger subjects. The first one is
online tourism intermediaries delimited to online travel agencies and tour
operators. The second one consists of brand, brand awareness and the
affect of brand awareness on consumers buying behaviour. The empirical
framework consists of quantitative research made for current and potential
customers of TravelBird with an online questionnaire.
2
After the development of the printing press, internet is the most important
innovation ever since. Many of the existing media are combined through
internet. It brings new capabilities of interactivity and addressability but it
also transforms the very essence of what it means to be a human being in
society and the way individuals conduct their business with each other.
Millions on people worldwide use internet for working, learning,
entertainment, socializing, leisure and shopping. (Buhalis & Jun 2011.)
Intermediaries are the ones who unite buyer and seller with the aim of
reducing transaction and supply costs between buyer and seller instead of
totally eliminating the intermediary. If a producer chooses to use
intermediary, they can reduce promotion costs and possibly transfer a
certain risk to the distributor depending on the contracts made. However, a
producer might suffer from a loss of margins and influence on the
distribution process. For the consumer, the use of intermediaries often
offers competitive prices, special expertise and no need of search and
transaction costs. (Cooper 2005, 422-423.)
5
Travel planning, including travel information search and booking, are one
of the main reasons people use the internet. One of the most successful e-
commerce implementations are online travel booking and associated
travel services. For a successful organisation especially in the tourism
industry, e-business is an essential prerequisite in the emerging, globally
and internet-empowered business environment. (Buhalis & Jun 2011.)
The main distributors of the tourism product are travel agencies. For
customers, they offer objectivity in the advice and expert product
knowledge. Outgoing travel agencies offer travel services such as
provision of passports and visas and travel insurance. Travel agencies can
not stock travel products since they do not own the services instead they
can stock travel information in the form of brochures, data and leaflets as
well as personal expertise of travel consultants. They do not purchase
tourism products in advance but they reserve/issue travel documents such
as tickets and vouchers. (Buhalis 2003, 261-262.) Outgoing travel
agencies can be divided into numerous categories depending on several
variables such as size, type of business, appointment and geographical
spread. Only a few travel agencies operate globally but most of them are
multinational, national or regional. (Buhalis 2003, 263.)
The travel agency industry has been revolutionised by the internet since
the agencies now can reach their travel inventory directly. They are able to
book and search everything such as hotels and airlines online, increasing
their bookable inventory. Internet enables them to promote their
organisations and sell their own services. (Lai, Huang, Lu & Chang 2013.)
The internal organization of travel agencies experienced major
improvements because of the development of information and
communication technologies. With the internal systems and intranets
travel agencies can maximize their efficiency. (Buhalis 2003, 6.)
6
Paid holidays, more free time and income disposal were the significant
changes in society which enabled tour operators to become a significant
part of the travel industry in the 1950’s. Since then, there has been a huge
progress in the tour operator industry which has been assisted by
developed information technologies and transportation, such as faster
airplanes with bigger capacity. (Cooper 2005, 427.)
Tour operators are organizers who create and put together travel
packages. They can sell them directly or offer them for sale through
retailers. Packages are pre-arranged and sold at an inclusive price,
normally including different combinations of accommodation, transport and
sometimes services such as catering or attractions. Tour operators
sometimes even pre-purchase a number of travel services but normally
they only pre-reserve them and set up a package at a single price.
(Buhalis 2003, 242.)
There are two types of tour operators where there is a clear distinction
between them. Large/mass operators cover a very wide range of tourism
products and destinations when small/specialist operators are
concentrating on themed or activity holidays and provides holidays for a
few destinations only. Small/specialist operators tend to charge premium
prices for specialized services when covering niche markets while bigger
operators concentrate on sales volume instead of profit margins. (Buhalis
2003, 242-243.)
People are becoming more and more reliant on internet since it includes a
huge amount of information and essentially represents the “external
memory” of people. Social media, which has tremendously grown in the
past years, has also changed the dynamics of online communications.
Search engines of internet also have a major impact on travelers’ access
to tourism products. Smart phones and their apps for travel, also creates
easier access to travel information and experiences of other people which
again influence on individuals decicions. (Xiang, Magnini & Fasenmaier
2014.)
Trust can be defined as consumers will to believe that the sellers are
sincere and they acknowledge their high degrees of trustworthiness on
online shopping and transaction processes. This in turn generates
consumers’ goodwill belief that the sellers are kind. Website trust can also
be defined as the extent of belief that people produce throughout using
online shopping websites. These are mainly based on the hypermarket’s
image, good reputation, performance, commitment and emphases toward
service attitudes and operating performance. Stable privacy polices and
terms and conditions on the website, allow consumers to generate more
trust and confidence toward the website. (Lai et al. 2013.)
The tourism industry has gone through big changes after the first package
travel directive was published in 1990. Since the increase of competition,
changes in consumer behaviour and internet development it is important to
keep the tourism legislation up to date. Before the new directive, travellers
have thought they have much bigger protection than they had in reality.
All travel agencies and tour operators, who sell a combination of two or
more tourist services, belong to the legislation of package tours since they
have an obligation to have an insurance. This new legislation of package
tours creates more equal competition situation amongst all travel
companies since they are all bound by the same rules. For the traveller,
this also brings a right to claim a compensation of displeasure in case the
trip does not correspond to what has been agreed but only when it is the
fault of tour operator. (Mäki-Fränti 2015.)
10
3 BRAND AWARENESS
Brands has been used for centuries to distinguish the products or services
of different companies from each other. In principle, whenever a marketer
creates a new name, symbol or logo for a new product, she or he created
a brand. (Keller 2008, 2.) Brand is a multi-dimensional phenomenon which
is traditionally defined as name, symbol, concept, sign, or some other
feature (Malmelin & Hakala 2008,17-18). The meaning of that is to
distinguish the product or a service from competitor (Keller 2008, 2).
Creating differences is what branding is all about (Kotler & Keller 2016,
387).
In the Finnish media guide (Brand 2016) it has been told that brand is a
positive reputation, which is formed around a trademark. The factors that
influence on the formation of brand value are its name or logo’s
awareness, customer loyalty, the feeling of quality which comes with a
brand and images attached to a brand. Brand can also be seen as a
summary of content or identity of the product or service. Brand makes the
product attractive in the eyes of the customer and promises quality.
Succesfull and well-known brand creates added value for the product.
Malmelin and Hakala (2008, 18) believe that a future brand and road to
success is radical brand. Radical brand consists of everything that the
organization does, how does it look like, how they communicate, how does
it sound like and how it is talked about. It is a mindset that guides the
organization, as well as unifying vision of activities and communication.
11
Kotler and Keller (2016, 20) define brand awareness as fostering people’s
ability to recall or recognize the brand in sufficient detail to make a
purchase. Keller (2008, 54) sees brand recognition in a way that, are the
consumers, who have prior exposure to the brand, able to recognize the
brand when given it as a cue. Brand recall is defined as consumers’ ability
to seek the brand from memory when for example given a cue of a
purchase usage situation or product category. Brand recall is more
important for online brands when the consumer decicions are not made at
the point of purchase but settings away from the point of purchase. Recall
is not that easy to achieve than recognition since consumers more likely
recognize for example the color than the name of the brand. Top of mind
awareness (TOMA) is the brand that comes to mind when thinking of a
particular product class, without a cue. These levels of brand awareness
are presented on the figure 2. below.
13
4 EMPIRICAL RESEARCH
Research design is the framework or plan for a study which guides the
selection of sources and types of information. It outlines procedures for
every research activity. A research design ensures that the study will be
relevant to the research problem and will use economical procedures.
(Blumberg, Cooper & Schindler 2008, 195.) It is the general plan of how
you will go about answering the research questions. Research designs are
classified into three traditional categories: descriptive, exploratory or
explanatory. (Saunders, Lewis & Thornhill 2009, 136-140.) The choice of
the most appropriate design depends on the research problem and the
research objectives (Malhotra 2007, 78).
The research questions and objectives, the amount of time and resources
available, as well as the philosophical underpinnings are guiding the
choice of the research strategy. Research strategies should not be
considered as being mutually exclusive. (Saunders et al. 2009, 141.) In
16
After the target group of the study has been determined, a sample frame
has to be constructed. A sample frame is a representation of the elements
of the target group. It consists of a list or set of direction for identifying the
target group. (Malhotra 2007,337). In this study the sample frame is
difficult to determine from the target population since there do not exist a
list of the company’s potential customers.
19
The aimed number of respondents were 150 but the actual number of
respondents were 133. As mentioned, I collected data in three different
ways on 18.-23.9.2016. After the questionnaire had been sent twice,
18.9.2016 and 21.9.2016, through TravelBird’s newletter I had 37
respondents. After advertising at Suomi24 forum 21.9.2016, I had 57
respondents and eventually after putting it to my personal Facebook page
22.9.2016, I had 133. It was not the targeted amount but it was enough
since 100 was minimum.
21
In the questionnaire, there was one totally open question but many of the
questions included an open question depending on the answer of the
respondent. The majority of these answers are left out from the analysis of
the study. There was a lot of material so it would have needed qualitative
analysing for which I did not have time. However, the material is very
valuable for the case company and that is why the material will be sent to
the case company separately later on.
When asked about the frequency of buying travel products online, most of
the respondents answered affirmative (91%, n=121) and only 9 % (n=12)
answered negative.
One third (31%, n=38) of the respondents have previously bought travel
products from a foreign company. In this context, it was also asked “from
where” the respondent have bought travel products previously and those
were for instance Ebookers, Booking and Supersaver. Half of the
respondents (48 %, n=58) have never bought travel products from a
foreign company and surprisingly one fifth (21 %, n=25) do not know if
they have made a purchase from a foreign company. (figure 3.)
22
21 %
31 %
Yes
No
I don't know
48 %
Continually
Occasionally
Once
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Part of the general online purchase behaviour was to figure out what type
of services the respondents are used to buying online. Since TravelBird
offers mostly travel packages, the aim was to find out how much interest
the respondents have towards travel packages. The respondents were
able to choose more than one option. The most typical travel services
were hotel (78%, n=95) and package trip (64%, n=78). Third of the
respondents have bought some kind of excursion or concert tickets online.
One third (27%, n=33) answered “other” and most of the answers were
flights, bus or train tickets. (Table 2.)
23
90
78
80
70 64
60
50 40
40
27
30
20
10
0
Hotel Package trip Excursion/concert Other
The respondents who had previously bought travel products online, were
asked about the type of product they have bought. This was a likert-style-
rating question with options 1-4 so the numbers on the table (tab 5.) are
averages of the answers. There were many factors that seemed to be
more important than the others for the respondents, especially good
quality-price ratio, easy purchase, clear web page and cheap prices. On
the other hand, the factors Finnish company, well-known brand and
opening hours were also seen as important with the average of at least
two.
Cheap prices
Opening hours
Easy purchase
Versatile selection
Finnish company
Recommendations
Well known brand
Clear website
Good customer service
Good quality-price-ratio
Other, what?
40
36
35
30
27
25
22
20
14
15
10
1
0
UNDER 25 26 - 40 41 - 60 OVER 60 I DO NOT WANT
TO SAY
A bit more of the backround was figured out by asking the living status of
the respondent since usually it is related to who they travel with. Large
group of the respondents live with a partner (40 %, n=53) or alone (34 %,
n=45). All the other options were under 20 % which can be seen on the
table below (tab 4). It can be concluded that most the respondents travel
in the groups of two.
25
45
40
40
34
35
30
25
20
15
12
10
8
4
5
2
0
I LIVE ALONE I LIVE WITH A I LIVE WITH I LIVE WITH OTHER I DO NOT
PARTNER KIDS AND KIDS WANT TO
PARTNER TELL
Table 6. The awareness levels of the logo and the name of TravelBird
(n=133)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Yes No I'm not sure
Clear
Realiable
Easy
Inspiring
High-quality
Suprising
Value for
money
Other, what?
The respondents who had bought service or services from TravelBird were
asked about their purchase experience. This was also a likert-style-rating
question with options 1-4 so the respondent was asked to evaluate how
strongly those specific factors describes purchase experience. The
numbers on the table below (tab 5.) are averages of the answers. The
adjectives of the purchase experience which had the highest average of
over 3,5 were “easy” and “good quality-price ratio”. The average of the rest
of the adjectives were also over 3 but there no significant differences seen
between them. (tab 9.)
Easy
Inspiring
Positive
Good quality-price ratio
Fast
Value for money
Other, what?
Those who had made a purchase from TravelBird where asked if they
would recommend it to their friends and family or not. The survey showed
that majority (83%, n=10) would recommend TravelBird.
To find out the most affective advertisement ways and places, the
respondents were asked, “Where have they heard about TravelBird?”.
Third of the respondents (31%, n=23) had heard about the company for
the first time through advertisement. (table 9.)
Table 9. The place where the respondent heard about TravelBird for the
first time. (n=75)
Family/friends 21,33
Facebook 17,33
Instagram 1,33
Forum 1,33
Advertisement 30,67
Blog 0
Search engine (Google) 13,33
Other, where? 14,67
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35
29
In this part I will analyse and discuss about the results using theoretical
framework. There is not any earlier study made for TravelBird of this
subject in Finland so there is not a basis of comparison for the results.
People are becoming more and more reliant to internet since it includes a
huge amount of information and essentially represents the “external
memory” of people (Xiang, Magnini & Fasenmaier 2014). The study
revealed that as mentioned, buying travel services online is extremely
common since almost all the respondents of this research have done so.
The study showed that Finnish consumers have bought separate hotel
packages the most and second came the whole travel package. As stated
by Buhalis (2003, 313) consumers can access information on everything
on 24-hours/365-days-a-year basis and hence they are becoming more
experienced and sophisticated travellers. It can be generally concluded
that since the consumers now have more information, they are more
confident on buying all the elements of the trip separately.
One interesting thing that was not part of my survey instead it came up
from the open questions. Over half of the respondents, who answered to
the open questions, commented about the pop-up advertisement that
comes to the screen when you open TravelBird’s website. It is about
subscribing for the daily newsletter of TravelBird and it can be closed by
clicking “I have already subscribed”. However, this was something that
many of the respondents did not realize and they were clearly annoyed
about it. This kind of pop-up advertisements are quite common these days
but normally there is a clear “x-button” where the advertisement is possible
to close and in this specific advertisement there is not. This can be quite
crucial for some people when they are about to choose online travel
agency on the internet. There are so many options to choose from
nowadays and the first impression of the website is crucial so it should be
as positive as possible.
Only a few people recognized the logo of TravelBird but surprisingly a bit
over half of the respondents recognized the brand by its name. I would say
that TravelBird brand still has a low level of recognition. Based on my own
experience when I did my internship at TravelBird, I did not expect even
this high brand awareness among Finnish people. This can be partly
31
It can be concluded that TravelBird should bring out their logo more since
according to Kotler and Keller (2016, 20) consumers more likely recognize
for example the color than the name of the brand. Although for the future
they should aim for brand recall since Kotler and Keller (2016, 20) states it
is more important for online brands than recognition when the consumer
decicions are not made at the point of purchase but settings away from the
point of purchase.
Even though the brand was recognized by over half of the respondents, it
is still not in the consideration set of most of the respondents. According to
Keller (2008, 55) one of the advantages of creating a high level of brand
awareness is that it can affect choices among brands in the consideration
set. This in turn is affected by consumers purchase motivation and
purchase ability. It can be concluded that the images of TravelBird are
positive mostly based on respondents visit on the website. I believe that
TravelBird could enter to many consumer’s consideration set if they only
put some effort into the marketing and that way raise their awareness in
consumer’s minds.
The study showed that the respondents really have interest towards
TravelBird’s services. The interesting thing was that when was asked
“why”, many of the respondents answered “unknown services but I will
definitely check their offerings”. Also from this, it can be concluded that
TravelBird’s services are considered attractive. As stated by Buhalis & Jun
(2011) travel planning, including travel information search and booking,
32
are one of the main reasons people use the internet. Nowadays the scope
of offerings is enormous. It is a quite big deal if the company is seen as
attractive only by their website.
Validity and reliability need to be taken into account in order to ensure the
quality of research. The internal reliability and validity of the data you
collect and the achieved response rate depend on the structure of your
questions, the design of your questions and the rigour of your pilot testing.
A valid questionnaire enables to collect accurate data and one that is
reliable will mean that the data is collected consistently. Validity and
realiability are discussed in terms of questions and answers making sense.
(Saunders, Lewis & Thornhill 2009, 371.) Reliability means the ability of
the study to give non-random results (Vilkka 2007).
There were 133 respondents in this research which is quite small sample
for a quantitative research. This research can be considered moderately
reliable. In the theoretical part the topic was precisely defined using
reliable references diversely. The questionnaire was coherent and the
questions were formulated so that they were easy to understand. This was
33
made sure by pilot testing in the beginning of the survey. The thing that
undermines the realiability is that large group of the sample was collected
from the researchers personal Facebook and hence there can be falsify
responses. The sample of this research was not determined clear enough
and it can be considered too wide. The response rate can not be
calculated since there was not a specific target population amount. This
research would have been more reliable if the target population would
have been targeted more narrowly. Another thing that undermines the
reliability is that there were only 8 respondents who have previously
bought TravelBirds services. This is why the purchase experiences of the
respondents can not be generalized.
This research can be seen as quite valid. The theoretical part addresses
diversely subjects that supports the research and also a lot of things the
case company can get some advantage in the future. However, theoretical
framework could have gone deeper in to the subjects since now it includes
too much of only basic information. The research answers to the research
questions and it makes it enable to give some development ideas for the
future. The thing that makes the validity a bit lower is that the theoretical
framework was not totally completed before doing the brand awareness
research. That is why the empirical part is not always bindable with the
presented theory.
This thesis process was longer than it was planned to be in the beginning
and it took about five months in total. The beginning was quite slow since
the subject of the thesis was not totally sure yet and the formation of it took
some time. One of the biggest challenges during this process was that the
subject I ended up researching, was not so familiar for me since I have not
studied tourism management. It took a long time to get deeper insight of
that industry and hence made the start a bit harder. Another challenge
was the English language since it is not my native language. I have lived
34
abroad for a year but obviously the glossary of the theme was not familiar
for me.
This thesis was a major learning process for myself and it really felt like I
learned something new of myself every week when working with the
thesis. I learned how big impact groundwork has in every phase of the
thesis. Especially those 3 weeks I put into creating and formatting the
questionnaire was all worth it. Overall I think the thesis was quite
succesfull and the subject was suitably delimited. I believe TravelBird can
gain some valuable information from it and it allows them to develop their
services in the future.
6 CONCLUSIONS
The aim of the research was to study people’s behaviour when buying
travel services online as well as figure out how well-known TravelBird is in
Finland. The objective was to find out what kind of images consumers
have about the company. The subject was formatted partly during my
internship at TravelBird on spring 2016 when I got an insight of the
customers’ thoughts when working as a customer advisor for five months.
This subject was pleasing and it was very interesting to study.
The first objective I set was to study Finnish consumers’ behaviour when
buying travel services and also find out the things that affect strongest on
consumers purchase decisions. The factors that stood out from the
research were easy purchase, quality-price ratio and cheap prices. As
stated on the theoretical part consumers can access information on
everything on a 24-hours/365-days-a-year basis and hence they are
becoming more experienced and sophisticated travellers. The study
showed that Finnish consumers have bought separate hotel packages the
most and second came the whole travel package. It can be concluded that
since the consumers now have more information available they are more
confident in buying all the elements of the trip separately.
The second objective was to figure out the level of brand awareness of
TravelBird among Finnish consumers and the images they have about the
36
I believe this thesis is benefitical for the case company since it shows that
they have a lot of potential to raise their status on the markets. Generally,
this study provides broad information about Finnish consumers’ behaviour
when buying travel services. As this study showed, people are very
interested in their services but they have too little knowledge about the
company, and hence they are sceptical about it. By investing little by little
more into marketing, TravelBird could achieve a better status on the
Finnish markets.
37
REFERENCES
Written References
Cooper, C., Fletcher, J., Fyall, A., Gilbert, D. & Wanhill, S. (2005) Tourism:
Principles and Practice. 3 th edition. Essex: Pearson.
Electronic sources
Lai, Y., Huang, H., Lu, R. & Chang, C. 2013. The effects of website trust,
perceived ease of use, and perceived usefulness on consumers’ online
booking intention: Evidence from Taiwan B&B sector [referred 4.9.2016].
Available:
http://www.lifesciencesite.com/lsj/life1002/205_18578life1002_1516_1523.
pdf
matkustajan-kuluttajansuojaa/yo5idzgp/5481a2ff-0ce7-408e-a78b-
6ea89524316f