Precision Machining of An Aluminum Alloy Piston Reinforced With A Cast Iron Insert
Precision Machining of An Aluminum Alloy Piston Reinforced With A Cast Iron Insert
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/225177455
CITATIONS READS
11 75
4 authors, including:
M. Uthayakumar S. Aravindan
Kalasalingam University Indian Institute of Technology Delhi
90 PUBLICATIONS 329 CITATIONS 104 PUBLICATIONS 1,432 CITATIONS
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Call for Book Chapters: Green Engineering Techniques for Modern Manufacturing View project
All content following this page was uploaded by M. Uthayakumar on 01 January 2017.
KEYWORDS: 3D shape morphing, Template mesh, Implicit function, Mesh smoothing, Modified Laplacian coordinate
Bimetallic pistons consisting of aluminum alloy reinforced with a cast iron (CI) insert are used to reduce the
weight and improve the wear resistance of pistons. A major problem with machining such bimetallic pistons is
producing the desired shape with minimal cutting forces and without damaging the bonding registry. The objective
of this paper is to determine the optimal cutting parameters (cutting speed, feed, and depth of cut) for turning
bimetallic pistons. When machining, we wish to obtain optimal values of the cutting forces and a better surface
integrity while maintaining the required surface finish. Experiments were conducted following Taguchi’s
parameter design approach using a cubic boron nitride tool for the machining. The results indicate that the
process parameters affected the mean and variance of the cutting force at the Al-CI interface of the piston. The Al–
CI interface was examined using an ultrasonic piston bond tester after machining to assure the bond quality. The
surface roughness of the components was measured with a surface roughness tester. A mathematical model was
developed using the Systat 12.0 software package to establish the relationship between the input quantities (speed,
feed, and depth of cut) and the output data (cutting force). The output data of the mathematical model were
compared with the experimental results. The results from the Taguchi robust design concept were compared with
the results obtained from a nonconventional Genetic Algorithm optimization technique.
automotive components such as pistons with lightweight aluminum optimized are identified for any engineering or nonengineering
alloy castings to improve the performance and efficiency of the optimization problem. Quality characteristics are classified as
vehicle.3 The low expansion group of aluminum-silicon alloy, referred maximation, minimization, or normal criterion. Then the factors
to as piston alloy, provides the best overall balance of properties.4 A (parameters) likely to affect the quality characteristics are identified
metal-based insert reinforces the base alloy to improve the wear and segregated under control (signal) and noise factors. An
performance. Engineering components, such as pistons and the orthogonal array is selected based on the number of parameters and
cylinder head, are first processed by die casting. They are than levels of variations, and a loss function is then defined to calculate the
machined to achieve the desired dimensions and surface finish.5,6 deviation between the experimental and desired values. The selection
of the loss function is based on the quality characteristics. The value
of the overall loss function is further transferred into a signal to noise
ratio (S/N) that is identified by η with units of decibels (dB). The best
value of the identified parameter is predicted from the S/N curves. A
statistical analysis of variance (ANOVA) is performed to find the
percentage effect on the output response. The ANOVA separates the
variation in an experiment into categories related to the cause of the
variation. Finally, a confirmation test is conducted using the best set
of selected values of the identified parameters; this last step is of the
utmost important in the DOE approach.17 The best set of values will
yield a product of superior quality compared to other possible
combinations of values.
4. Experimental Plan
Fig. 1 Typical piston with insert
The identified parameters that affect the characteristics of turned
Metal cutting industries continue to suffer from not being able to
parts are the cutting tool parameters (tool geometry and tool material),
run machine tools at their optimum operating conditions.7 The
workpiece-related parameters (microstructure and hardness), cutting
functional behavior of machined parts is determined by their fine
parameters (speed, feed, and depth of cut), and environmental
finish, which represents the last step in the process chain and can be
parameters (dry cutting and wet cutting). The ranges of the selected
performed by cutting.8 Cubic Boron Nitride (CBN) is a sintered
turning process parameters (cutting speed, feed, and depth of cut)
product that has excellent wear durability, high hardness, and good
were ascertained by conducting preliminary experiments. The details
thermal resistance. It is unlikely to generate a chemical reaction with
of work material, machine tool, cutting tool, and cutting conditions
the workpiece under high thermal conditions, but the cost of CBN
are as follows.
tools is extremely high, between 10 and 20 times greater than the cost
Work material: Aluminum alloy piston reinforced with a CI
of carbide tools.9 The improved qualities of the machined surface and
insert
associated productivity improvement help alleviate their initial high
Machine tool: Leadwell (T5) turning center
cost.
Cutting tool: CBN with a top rake angle of 0°, aclearance
CBN cutting tools are commonly used for single-point turning of
angle of 15°, and a nose of 0.6 mm
hardened materials.10 Due to recent cutting tool developments, as well
Cutting condition: Dry
as the improved machine tool structural rigidity and better CNC
Dynamometer: Kistler Quartz 3 component
controllers, hard turning is emerging as an alternative process to
An orthogonal array gives a more reliable estimate of the factor
grinding due to its reduced cost and cycle time.11 The high CBN
effects with fewer tests compared to traditional methods. The process
content of CBN tools (as much as 90%) gives a better surface finish,
12 parameters along with their values at three levels are given in Table 1.
but the geometry of the cut evolves considerably over the lifetime
of a CBN tool.13 In the past, two different tools and two different
Table 1 Factors and their levels
machining parameters were used to machine bimetallic components.
The cycle time of these processes was unnecessarily long due to the Factors Units Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
frequent tool changes required. Hence, a single tool that can machine
Cutting speed m/min 452 482 512
both metals is desirable. Coated cemented carbide cutting tool inserts
have been used to machine bimetallic engine blocks such as Feed mm/rev 0.15 0.20 0.25
aluminum alloys and CI.14 However, literature on the machining and Depth of cut mm 0.15 0.20 0.25
surface integrity of such bimetallic components is scarce. The present
study addresses current problems encountered when machining
bimetallic components. Three major control factors (cutting speed, feed, and depth of cut)
were selected to conduct the tests. All three factors are multilevel
variables and their outcome effects have nonlinear relationships;
3. Taguchi Method hence, we used three-level tests for each factor. Figure 2 shows the
piston machining arrangement with a dynamometer.
The Taguchi method has produced a unique and powerful quality The number of degrees of freedom was calculated from the
improvement discipline that differs from the traditional process. Since number of parameters identified and their number of levels of
the product and process design has a great impact on the life cycle, variation. Using the full factorial design (3×3×3×3) reduced a total of
cost, and quality of a component, the Taguchi design of experiment 81 sets of experiments down to 9, thereby decreasing the cost, time,
(DOE) approach provides a design engineer with a systematic method and effort.18 The array along with the factor assigned to the columns
for determining the optimum design parameters to obtain the best is presented in Table 2, where L9 indicates the 9 trials considered for
performance at the lowest cost.15,16 The quality characteristics to be the test.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PRECISION ENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING Vol. 10, No. 1 JANUARY 2009 / 9
Fm = Fx 2 + Fy 2 + Fz 2 (1)
1
(
S/N ratio (in dB) = − 10log ∑ y12 + y22 + ......... yn 2
n
) , (2)
80 Fz [N]
Cutting Force (N)
60
40
20
0
5 10 15 20 25 30
-20
Time (s)
-40
-60
The data analysis procedure using the Taguchi experimental values of the cutting force for each parameter at levels 1, 2 and 3 were
framework involves an analysis of means and variances. The analysis calculated and plotted in Figure 5. The effect of the factor level was
of means helps to identify the factor contributions whereas the defined as the deviation it caused from the overall mean expressed in
ANOVAs establish the relative significance of the factors in terms of decibels. This process of estimating the main effects of each factor is
their percentage contribution to the response. known as an analysis of the mean. The minimum cutting force
occurred at the 3rd speed level, 1st feed level, and 1st depth of cut level,
5.2 ANOVA scheme for an orthogonal array experiment giving [3 1 1] as the best level to obtain the minimum cutting force
The ANOVA scheme was used to study the significance of the for the piston.
parameters affecting the quality characteristics of interest. The
scheme subdivides the total variation in the data into useful and
meaningful components of variation. The total variation contribution S/N RATIO CHART
is shown in Table 5.
O
IT
20
cut and feed severely affected the cutting force by 52.88% and N/
15 S1
S2
F2
F3
D2
D3
26.13%, respectively, while the speed only affected the cutting force S
E 10
S1 S2 S3 F1 F2 F3 D1 D2 D3
PARAMETER
PARETO CHART
O
IT 60 Fig. 5 Effects of the factor level on the cutting force
AR 50
N 40
O Conducting a verification experiment is a crucial and the last step
TIU 30
BI 20 of the robust design procedure. Its aim is to verify the optimum
RT conditions identified by the matrix tests and it estimates how close the
N 10
O
C 0 predictions are to actual conditions. Hence, a confirmation test was
Depth of1cut Feed 2 3
Speed
conducted with the optimum parameters, with good results.
PARAMETERS
5.3 Mathematical model
Fig. 4 Pareto chart The design optimization method makes extensive use of
functional or empirically developed mathematical models that
The mean responses refer to the average value of the performance explicitly link a quantitative dependent variable to certain
characteristics for each parameter at different levels. The average independent variables.20 The time-tested approach to building such
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PRECISION ENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING Vol. 10, No. 1 JANUARY 2009 / 11
ELEVATION -1
6.1 Bond checking
The integrity of all the machined surfaces of the pistons at the Fig. 8 Ultrasonic bond-checking facility
12 / JANUARY 2009 INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PRECISION ENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING Vol. 10, No. 1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
REFERENCES
1. Viala, J. C., Peronnet, M., Barbeau, F., Bosselet, F. and Bouix, J.,
“Interface Chemistry In Aluminum Alloy With Iron Base Inserts,”
Composites, Part A, Vol. 33, No. 10, pp. 1417- 1420, 2002.
3
8. Tonshoff, H. K., Arendt, C. and Ben Amor, R., “Cutting of
hardened steel,” CIRP Annals Manufacturing Technology, Vol. 49,
(Ra)
2
Issue 2, pp. 547-566, 2000.
1
9. Lin, Z. C. and Chen, D. Y., “A study of cutting with CBN tool,”
0 Journal of Material Processing Technology, Vol. 49, No. 1-2, pp.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
149-164, 1995.
Experimental Run
10. Liang, S. Y. and Huang, Y., “CBN tool wear modeling in finish
Fig. 10 Surface roughness measurements hard turning,” ASME International Mechanical Engineering
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PRECISION ENGINEERING AND MANUFACTURING Vol. 10, No. 1 JANUARY 2009 / 13
12. Pavel, R., Marinescu, I. D., Sinram, K. and Deis, M., “PCBN
tools wear in continuous and interrupted hard turning,” ASME /
STLE Joint International Tribology Conference, TRIB2002-127,
2002.
14. Hessman, I., “Cutting tool for bimetal machining,” U.S. Patent,
No. 20050181211.
15. Roy, R., “A Primer on the taguchi method,” Van Nostrand, pp. 11-
28, 1990.