The accused, Mondiguing and Dunuan, filed a petition for a change of venue from Ifugao Province to Baguio City, arguing they could not receive a fair trial in Ifugao. They claimed the judge was biased, witnesses would be afraid to testify due to threats of harassment, and their lives would be endangered. The Court found the petition meritorious, determining a change of venue was necessary to avoid a miscarriage of justice and protect the safety of the accused, so it ordered the trial be moved to Baguio City.
The accused, Mondiguing and Dunuan, filed a petition for a change of venue from Ifugao Province to Baguio City, arguing they could not receive a fair trial in Ifugao. They claimed the judge was biased, witnesses would be afraid to testify due to threats of harassment, and their lives would be endangered. The Court found the petition meritorious, determining a change of venue was necessary to avoid a miscarriage of justice and protect the safety of the accused, so it ordered the trial be moved to Baguio City.
The accused, Mondiguing and Dunuan, filed a petition for a change of venue from Ifugao Province to Baguio City, arguing they could not receive a fair trial in Ifugao. They claimed the judge was biased, witnesses would be afraid to testify due to threats of harassment, and their lives would be endangered. The Court found the petition meritorious, determining a change of venue was necessary to avoid a miscarriage of justice and protect the safety of the accused, so it ordered the trial be moved to Baguio City.
The accused, Mondiguing and Dunuan, filed a petition for a change of venue from Ifugao Province to Baguio City, arguing they could not receive a fair trial in Ifugao. They claimed the judge was biased, witnesses would be afraid to testify due to threats of harassment, and their lives would be endangered. The Court found the petition meritorious, determining a change of venue was necessary to avoid a miscarriage of justice and protect the safety of the accused, so it ordered the trial be moved to Baguio City.
Abad Criminal Procedure Rule 110, Sec 10 and 15; 1975 Aquino Consti Art. VIII Sec 5 (4)
SUMMARY
The accused Mondiguing and Dunuan filed a petition for change of venue from Ifugao due to reasons enumerated below. The Court found the petition meritorious and granted the same, changing the venue to the Circuit Criminal Court in the City of Baguio.
FACTS
Alipio Mondiguing and Andres Dunuan are two of the ten defendants accused of double murder, frustrated murder and attempted murder in a criminal case at the CFI of Ifugao Province; Mondiguing and Dunuan filed with the SC a petition to transfer venue of trial to Baguio City or Quezon City; They claimed that they could not expect a fair and impartial trial because: o the sitting judge was the protegee of a rival political clan; o their witnesses would be afraid to testify for fear of harassment and reprisals; o and their lives and the lives of their witnesses and lawyers would be in grave danger in Ifugao because of the tensions and antagonisms spawned by the case;
RATIO
W/N Mondiguing's plea for a change of venue is justified.
Yes. The Court is invested with the prerogative of ordering "a change of venue or place of trial to avoid a miscarriage of justice. A change of venue was ordered by this Court in a case where it was shown that the accused might be liquidated by his enemies in the place where the trial was originally scheduled to be held. Considering the facts and circumstances, the Court found the petition meritorious and in the interest of a fair and impartial trial and to avoid a miscarriage of justice and considering that his life would be in danger if he were to be tried in Lagawe, Ifugao, he should be tried by the Circuit Criminal Court in the City of Baguio.
FALLO
WHEREFORE, the petition of Alipio Mondiguing for the transfer of the venue of Criminal Case No. 140 of the Court of First Instance of Ifugao is granted. The said case should be transferred to the Circuit Criminal Court of the Second Judicial District so that it may be heard in Baguio City. SO ORDERED.
