Dry Density-Sand Replacement Method
Dry Density-Sand Replacement Method
Dry Density-Sand Replacement Method
Roeffimod 1995
(( Reaffirmed 2006 ))
Indian Standard
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS
PART XXVIII DETERMINATION OF DRY DENSITY
OF SOILS IN-PLACE, BY THE SAND
REPLACEMENT METHOD
( First Revision )
Sixth Reprint AUGUST 1998
UDC 624.131.431.5
0 CopVright 1974
Gr 6 October 1974
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
Indian Standard
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS
PART XXVIII DETERMINATION OF DRY DENSITY
OF SOILS IN-PLACE, BY THE SAND
REPLACEMENT METHOD
( First Revision )
Soil Engineering Sectional Committee, BDC 23
Chairman Re@esenting
PROF DINESHMOHAN Central Building Research Institute ( CSIR ),
Roorkee
Members
SHKI G. R. S. JAIN (Alternate to
Prof Dinesh Mohan )
PROP ALAM SINCH Universiky of Jodhpur, Jodhpur
DR A. BANER~EE Cementation Co Ltd, Bombay
SHRI S. &PTA (Alternate )
SHRI K. N. DADIT;A In personal capacity ( P-820 New Al&we, Cnlcutta 53)
SHRI A. G. DASTIDAR Hindustan Construction Co, Bombay
SHRI R. L. DEWAN Irrigation Research Institute, Khagaul. Patna
FziT:RD~~~~~~ Indian Geotechnical Society, New Delhi
Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi
PROF S. K. GULHATI ( Alternate )
DIRECTOR Irrigation 8r Power Research Institute, Amritsar
&WI B. B. L. BHATNAGAR( Alternate )
I)IRECTOR(CS & MRS) Central U’ater & Power Commission, New Delhi
DEPUTY DIRECTOR( CS & MRS )
(Alternate )
SHRI A. H. DIVANJI Rodio Foundation Engineering Ltd; and Hazarat &
Co, Bombay
SHRI A. N. JANGLE ( Alternate )
SJlRl v. G. HEGDE National Buildings Organization, New Delhi
SHRIJ. P. SHARMA( Alternate )
DR IQBAL ALI Engineering Research Laboratory, Hyderabad
SHRI K. R. SAXENA(Alternate )
JOINT DIRECTOR RESEARCH ( FE ), Railway Board ( Ministry of Railways )
RDSO
DEPUTY DIRECTOR RESEARCH,
SOIL MECHANICS, RDSO (dlternafe)
( Continued on page 2 )
@ Copyright 1974
BUREAU OF INDIAN STANDARDS
This publication is protected under the Indian Copyrighr Act (XIV of 1957 ) and
reproduction in whole or in part by any means except with written permission of the
publisher shall be deemed to be an infringement of copyright under the said Act.
;”
I
M#UlbWS Rcprarmfing
SHRI 0. P. MALXOTRA Public Works Dcpartmcnt, Govcrnm cnt of Punjab
Smu J. S. MAYA Roada Wing ( Ministry of Shipping & T-port)
SRRI A. S. Banmor ( AZrsnrote
)
Sanr M. A. MEHTls Concrete Association of India, Bombay
Smu T. M. biRNON (Al&ma&)
Smu T. K. NATA~AJAN Central Road Research Institute ( CSIR ), New Delhi
RFdEARcst OFFmEa Building & Roada Rcacarch Laboratory, Public
Worka Department, Government of Punjab
MAJK.M.S.SAHAQ Engineer-in-Cbief’a Branch, Army Headquartem
ssrm P. PuYHmoAMANr ( AI&auti )
fbRRTARY ckntrd Board of Irrigation & Power, New D&i
I.br~wr~ SBCRETAIlY(Altemate)
DRSHAyQIERPRAKXjH University of Roorkee, Roorkee
Srmt H. D. Sa= Irrigation Researc h Institute, Roorkee
Sup~anrrw~~~o ENOINIXER (PLAN- Concrete & Soil Rmearcb Laboratory, Public Worka
NINO& Dsk?tGNtiCLE) Department, Government of Tamil Nadu
Exnmvn ENOINEER( INCHAROE
SOIL MEcnANlcn & RmEAacn
DIMnON ) ( &tt’?IU~ )
&mI~ g $W~Al=stAN Institution of Engineera ( India ), Calcutta
. . All India Instrument Manufacturers ik Deakn
Association, Bombay
Smu V. K. V~EV~ ( Alternate )
SHRI H. G. V- Publi0yv’ks Department, Gov emment of Uttar
Members
SHRI. N. K. BERRY Beas Dams Project, Talwara Township
SHRI N. K. Am+ ( A~tenafe )
DR R. K. BHANDARI Central Road Research Institute ( CSIR), New Delhi
SHIU T. N. BHAROAWA Roads Wing ( Ministry of Shipping & Transport )
SHRI A. S. BI~HNOI( Alternate )
DR A. K. CW~TERJEE Publzraysks Department, Government of Uttar
2
IS : 2720 i Part XXVIII ) - 1974
Indian Standard
METHODS OF TEST FOR SOILS
PART XXVIII DETERMINATION OF DRY DENSITY
OF SOILS IN-PLACE, BY THE SAND
REPLACEMENT METHOD
( First Revision )
0. FOREWORD
0.1 This Indian Standard ( Part XXVIII ) ( First Revision ) was adopted
by the Indian Standards Institution on 21 February 1974, after the draft
finalized by the Soil Engineering Sectional Committee had been approved
by the Civil Engineering Division Council.
0.3 This standard is divided into two sections. Section 1 prescribes the
method suitable for fine- and medium-grained soils using the small sand
pouring cylinder; Section 2 lays down the method which uses the large
sand pouring cylinder and is suitable for fine-, medium- and coarse-grained
soils containing stones which make the test of Section 1 difficult to
perform.
3
IS : 2720( Part XXVIII) - 1974
0.3.1 For the purpose of tests described in this standard soils shall be
grouped as shown below:
IS : 2720 (Part XXIX )-1966 Methods of test for soils: Part XXIX
Determination of dry density of soils in-place by the core cutter
method
IS : 2720 ( Part XXX111 )-1971 Methods of test for soils: Part
XXX111 Determination of density in-place by the ring and
water replacement method
IS : 2720 ( Part XXXIV)- 1972 Methods of test for soils: Part
XXXIV Determination of density of soil in-place by the rubber-
baloon method
0.5 In the formulation of this standard due weightage has been given to
international co-ordination among the standards and practices prevailing
in different countries in addition to relating it to the practices in the field
in this country. This has been met by basing the standard on the follow-
ing publications:
4
IS : 2729 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
1. SCOPE
1.1 This method covers the determination, in-place, of the dry density
( in g/cm3 or kg/m3 ) of natural or compacted fine- and medium-grained
soils for which a small sand-pouring cylinder is used. The method is
applicable to layers not exceeding 150 mm in thickness ( see Note ).
2. APPARATUS
2.2 Tools for Excavating Holes -suitable tools, such as a scraper tool
similar to that shown in Fig. 2 to make a level surface; bent spoon, dibber
shown in Fig. 3.
2.8 Metal Tray with Hole - 300 mm square and 40 mm deep with a
100 mm hole in the centre.
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
6
xs:2720(PRrtxxvm)-1974
WOODEN
HANDLE
\
NOTE-This design has been found satisfactory, but alternative de&e may be
employed.
NOTE- ‘IIds design has bccu found aatiskctory, but altcmative dcsigw may he
employed.
7
Is12720(PartxxvIII)-1974
1 r
7
FLANGE
Nom 1 -This design has bun found satisfactory, but alternative designs may be
employed, provided that thq essential requirements are fulfilled.
NOTEZ- Essential dimensions arc underlined.
_ND~ 3 -Tolerance on essential dimensions * 0.1 mm.
All dimensions in millimctrcs.
FIG. 4 CALIBRATINO CONTAINER FOR USE WITH SMALL POURIW
CYLINDER
8
IS : 2720( Part XXVIIl ) - 1974
Luo 9-d
RAMMER
3. MATERIAL ( SAND )
3.1 Clean, uniformly graded natural sand passing the l’OO-mm IS Sieve
and retained on the 600-micron IS Sieve shall be used. It shall be free
from organic matter, and shall have been oven dried and stored for a
suitable period to allow its water content to reach equilibrium with atmos-
pheric humidity ( see Note ).
NOTE - Generally a storage period, after oven drying, of about 7 days is sufficient
for the water content of the sand to reach equilibrium with the atmospheric humidity.
The sand should not be stored in air-tight containers and should be thoroughly mixed
before use. If sand is salvaged from holes in compacted soils after carrying out the test,
it is advisable to sieve, dry and store this sand again before it is used in further sand
replacement tests.
4. PROCEDURE
4.1.1 The method given in 4.1.1.1 to 4.1.1.4 shall be followed for the
determination of the weight of sand in the cone of the pouring cylinder.
4.1.1.1 The pouring cylinder shall be filled so that the level of the
sand in the cylinder is within about 10 mm of the top. Its total initial
weight ( W, ) shall be found and shall be maintained constant throughout
the tests for which the calibration is used. A volume of sand equivalent
to that of the excavated hole in the soil ( or equal to that of the calibrat-
ing container ) ( fee Note 1 under 4.2.2 ) shall be allowed to run out of
the cylinder under gravity. The shutter on the pouring cylinder shall
then be closed and the cylinder placed on a plane surface, such as a glass
plate.
4.1.1.2 The shutter on the pouring cylinder shall be opened and sand
allowed to run out. When no further movement of sand takes place in the
cylinder the shutter shall be closed and the cylinder removed carefully.
4.1.1.3 The sand that has filled the cone of the pouring cylinder (that
is,’ the sand that is left on the plane surface ) shall be collected and weighed
to the nearest gram.
4.1 .1.4 These measurements shall be repeated at least three times and
the mean weight ( W, ) taken.
10
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
NOTE- Since variations in atmospheric humidity affect the water content of the sand,
and hence its bulk density, the calibration should be made ( or at least checked ) during
each day’s work. To overcome the effec:s of slight variations in grading and particle
shape between batches of sand, each batch should be sampled and calibrated.
4.2.2 The metal tray with a central hole shall be laid on the prepared
surface of the soil with the hole over the portion of the soil to be tested.
The hole in the soil shall then be excavated using the hole in the tray as a
pattern, to the depth of the layer to be tested up to a maximum of 150 mm
( see Note 1 ). The excavated soil shall be carefully collected, leaving no
loose material in the hole and weighed to the nearest gram ( W,,, ). The
metal tray shall be removed before the pouring cylinder is placed in position
over the excavated hole.
The steel core cutter shall be pressed evenly and carefully into the
soil until its top edge is flush with the levelled surface. Soil to a depth of
ICO mm (see Note 1 ) within the core cutter shall then be excavated by
means of suitable tools. The excavated soil shall be carefully collected
and weighed to the nearest gram ( W, ). The core cutter shall remain
in position during the remainder of the testing procedure.
NOTE 1 - If for any reason it is necessary to excavate the holes to depths other than
150 mm, the calibrating container should be replaced by one, the depth of which is the
same as the hole excavated or its effective depth should be reduced to that of the hole
excavated.
NOTE2 -Care shall be taken in excavating the hole to see that the hole is not
enlarged by levering the dibber against the side of the hole, as this will result in lower
densities being recorded.
11
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
5. CALCULA’l’lONS
where
w, = weight of pouring cylinder and sand before pouring into
calibrating container in g,
W 8= mean weight of cylinder with residual sand after pouring
into calibrating container and cone in g, and
W, = mean weight of sand in cone in g.
5.2 The bulk density of the sand ( y, ) in kg/m3 shall be calculated from
the formula:
YS = F x 1000
where
V = volume of calibrating container in ml.
5.3 The weight of sand ( W, ) in g, required to fill the excavated hole shall
be calculated from the following formula:
w, - w, - w, - w,
*Methodsof tut for soils: Part II Determinationof water content ( recond r&ion ).
12
IS 2 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
where
W, = weight of cylinder and sand before pouring into hole
in g,
W. = weight of cylinder and sand after pouring into hole
and cone in g, and
W, = mean weight of sand in cone in g.
5.4 The bulk density Yb, that is, the weight of the wet soil per cubic mctre
shall be calculated from the following formula:
where
W,,, = weight of soil excavated in g,
wb = weight of sand required to fill the hole in g, and
Y* = bulk density of sand in kg/ma.
5.5 The dry density ya, that is, the weight of the dry soil shall be calculat-
ed from the following formula:
1OOYD
Yd = -100 + w kg/ma
or
Yd = $ x y, kg/ma
where
w = water content of the soil in percent,
W, = weight of dry soil from the hole in g, and
W, = weight of sand required to fill the hole in g.
6. REPORTING OF RESULTS
6.1 The following values shall be reported:
a) Dry density of soil in kg/m3 to the nearest whole number. The
dry density may also be calculated and reported in g/ems correct
to the second place of decimal.
b) Water content of the soil in percent reported to two significant
figures.
6.2 The method used for obtaining the test results shall be stated as the
small pouring cylinder method. The use of steel core cutter, if made, shall
also be mentioned.
6.3 The results of the test shall be recorded suitably. A recommended
pro forma for the record of the test results is given in Appendix A.
13
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
7. SCOPE
7.1 This method covers the determination, in-place, of the dry density
( in g/cm3 or kg/m3 ) of natural or compacted soil containing stones which
make the test of Section 1 difficult to perform. This is an alternative
method of test to Section 1 for fine- and medium-grained soils and should
be used instead of that test for layers exceeding 150 mm but not exceeding
250 mm in thickness ( see Note under 1.1 ).
8. APPARATUS
8.2 Tools for Excavating Holes- suitable tools, such as bent spoon,
dibber (see Fig. 3), large screw driver, pointed steel rod about 300 mm long
and 5 to 10 mm dia with a wooden handle.
8.4 Balance-accurate to 1 g.
8.5 Plane Surface - a glass plate or other plane surface about 600 mm
square and 10 mm thick or larger.
8.6 Metal Containers-to collect the excavated soil and to take the
supply of sand to fill the pouring cylinder. This may be provided with
a suitable cover.
8.7 Metal Tray with Central Hole -a metal tray 450 mm square
and 50 mm deep with a 200 mm dia hole in the centre.
9. MATERIAL (SAND)
9.1 Clean, uniformly graded natural sand passing the l*OO-mm IS Sieve and
retained on the 600-micron IS Sieve shall be used. It shall be free from
organic matter, and shall have been oven dried and stored for a suitable
period to allow its water content to reach equilibrium with atmospheric
humidity ( ice Note under 3.1 ).
14
IS:272G(Pati XXVIII)-1974
F
350 9
1
200 @
rFLAT SURFACE
Ncrral -This design has been found satisfactory, but alternative designs may. be
employed, provided that the essential requirements arc fulfilled.
NOTE 2 - Essential dimensions are underlined.
NATE 3 -Tolerance on essential dimensions f0.I mm.
10. PROCEDURE
15
I§ : 2720 ( Part XXVIXI ) - 1974
10.2 The method given in 10.2.1 to 10.2.4 shall be followed for the
measurement of soil density.
10.2.1. A flat area, approximately 60 cm’, at the place at which the soil
is to be tested shall be exposed and trimmed down to a level surface.
10.2.2 The metal tray with a central hole shall be laid on the prepared
surface of the soil with the hole over the portion of the soil to be tested.
The hole in the soil shall then be excavated using the hole in the tray as a
pattern, to the depth of the layer to be tested up to a maximum of 250 -
16
IS : 2720( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
11. CALCULATIONS
12.1 The results shall be reported as specified in 6 except that the method
used for obtaining the test results shall be stated as large pouring cylinder
method.
17
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
APPENDIX A
( Clauses 6.3 and 12.2 )
DETERMINATION OF DRY DENSITY OF SOIL, IN-PLACE,
BY SAND REPLACEMENT
A-l. The test results for the two methods,namely, small pouring cylinder
and large pouring Gylinder may be tabulated as given below using the
appropriate symbols and words in each case:
Location:. Date:
Calibration
18
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
1. Determination No.
APPENDIX B
( Ckruse 11.2 )
DETERMINATION OF WATER CONTENT AND DRY DENSITY
OF MEDIUM- AND COARSE-GRAINED SOILS CONTAINING
APPRECIABLE GRAVEL FRACTION ( PLUS +75-mm IS SIEVE )
19
IS : 2720 ( Part XXVIII ) - 1974
(a)
e) Dry weight of minus 4*75-mm soil = -p
1 + w,/lOO
(c)
f) Dry density of minus 4*75-mm soil =
1 + WJIOO
g) Dry weight of total material
( soil + gravel ) = W’, f (dj
h) Water content ( wT) of total
material, percent = _!%_cf, x 100
(f)
j) Percentage of gravel in the
material on a dry weight basis =w)I x 100
(f)
20
IS t 2720 ( Part XXVIlI ) - 1974
21
BUREAU OF INDIAN STANDARDS
Branch 0tflc.s: I
‘Pushpak’, Nurmohamed Shaikh Marg, Khanpur, AHMEDABAD 36ooOl 5501346
SPeenya Industrial Area, 1st Stage, Bangalore-Tumkur Road, 639 49 55
BANGALORE 560056
Gangotri Complex, 5th Floor, Bhadbhada Road, T. T. Nagar, BHOPAL 462003 55 40 21
Plot No. 62-63, Unit VI. Ganga Nagar, BHUBANESHWAR 751001 40 36 27
Kalaikathir Buildings, 670 Avinashi Road, COIMBATORE 641037 21 01 41
Plot No. 43, Sector 16 A, Mathura Road, FARIDABAD 121001 6-26 66 01
Savitri Complex, 116 G. T. Road, GHAZIABAD 201001 6-71 19 96
S3i5 Ward No. 29. R. G. Barua Road, 5th By-lane, GUWAHATI 761003 541137
5-6-56C, L. N. Gupta Marg, Nampally Station Road, HYDERABAD 500001 20 10 63
E-52, Chitarahjan Marg. C-Scheme, JAIPUR 302001 37 29 25
117/416 B, Sarvodaya Nagar, KANPUR 206005 21 66 76
Seth Bhawan, 2nd Floor, Behind Leela Cinema, Naval Kishore Road, 23 69 23
LUCKNOW 226001
Patliputra Industrial Estate, PATNA 600013 26 23 05
T. C. No. 1411421, University P. 0. Palayam. 6 21 17
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695034
NIT Building, wand Floor, Gokulpat MarKet, NAGPUR 440010 52 51 71
Institution of Engineers ( India ) Building, 1332 Shivaji Nagar, PUNE 411005 32 36 35