Final Copy Nursing Research Paper
Final Copy Nursing Research Paper
Final Copy Nursing Research Paper
Paige Bandera, Melissa Bruss, Mary Jo Wardle, Shyniah Watson, and Jessica Welsh
Abstract
There has been a steady increase in the number of overdoses reported each year, this is especially
true in Northeast Ohio. With the drug epidemic on the rise research into how this affects the fetus
of mothers abusing these drugs becomes even more imperative. Research on the long-term adverse
effects of cocaine, marijuana, tobacco, alcohol, methamphetamines, and prescription drugs on the
neonate compared with unaffected neonates is lacking in conclusive concrete evidence. However,
there is some conclusive evidence regarding the effects on physical health, mental health, and
future drug use which is discussed in this paper as well as some of the probable conclusions and
gaps in the current research. It examines physical health from fetus to age ten, as well as mental
health and future drug use in adulthood. All information was obtained from journal articles that
either conducted their own study or were a peer review of several studies.
2
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
The surgeon general has proclaimed that drug and alcohol use during pregnancy is not
recommended. Not only do these substances cause harm to the person using them, but they also
cause the same or more harm to the fetus. It is not just illegal drugs that are harmful to the fetus,
but also common prescription and over the counter medications that are just as harmful. “About 2
to 3% of all birth defects result from drugs that are taken to treat a disorder or symptom”
(Gunatilake & Avinash, 2017). In other words, a pregnant woman should not partake in drug
consumption.
Drugs and alcohol can affect the fetus in several ways. One way drugs can directly act on
the fetus is through the formation of birth defects or cause death of the fetus. Another way it can
affect the fetus is by transforming the placenta and altering its functions. For example, it causes
the blood vessels to constrict and reduces the supply of oxygen and blood, causing the fetus to be
under developed and underweight at the time of its birth. Drugs can also cause the uterus to
contract harder than usual which causes a reduction of blood supply to the fetus which may induce
pre-term labor.
Drug use can also affect the fetus in different ways determined by the various stages of the
pregnancy in which the drugs were used. For example, for the first 20 days after fertilization, a
baby can either be completely resistant to the drugs or alcohol, or the substances can cause
termination, or miscarriage, of the pregnancy. There is no in between in that time frame. In the 3
to 8-week period after fertilization the fetus may not have any effects, the woman could have a
miscarriage, or the fetus may be vulnerable to a birth defect because this is the time of organ
3
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
development. In the second and third trimester, drugs could possibly alter the functions of newly
Although the timing of substance use can cause different effects on the fetus, the type of
substance used can also cause different effects. In the article, Gunatilake & Avinash (2017)
The most consistent effect of smoking on the fetus during pregnancy is a reduction
in birth weight: The more a woman smokes during pregnancy, the less the baby is
likely to weigh. The average birth weight of babies born to women who smoke
during pregnancy is six ounces less than that of babies born to women who do not
smoke. Birth defects of the heart, brain, and face are more common among babies
of smokers than among those of nonsmokers. Also, the risk of sudden infant death
Another substance that can cause harm is alcohol. Alcohol can cause low birth weight as
well, but the side effect most concerning is fetal alcohol syndrome. This syndrome causes facial
defects, intellectual disability, and abnormal growth of the fetus. It has been stated that there is no
safe amount of alcohol for a woman to consume while pregnant. The only way to prevent fetal
One more class of drugs that can cause harm is opioids. Opioids can cause the baby to be
born addicted, a side effect of the mother’s drug use known as neonatal abstinence syndrome.
Because the drugs go directly through placenta, they therefore also act directly on the fetus. They
also can cause the fetus to develop birth defects, low birth weights, neonatal abstinence syndrome,
4
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
The only way for a mother to ensure her infant will be born without preventable birth
defects, low birth weights, neonatal abstinence syndrome, or fetal alcohol syndrome is to
completely avoid abusing drugs, alcohol, or cigarettes. If the mother is unable or unwilling to avoid
these teratogens, then these infants may face a multitude of complications throughout their
lifespan.
There are many drugs that can cause an infant to be diagnosed with neonatal abstinence
syndrome or NAS. However, Deborah Frank et. al conducted a study on the effects of cocaine in
5 domains: physical growth; cognition; language skills; motor skills; and behavior (2001). This
study reviewed thirty-six articles on the subject of the effects of cocaine exposure in early
childhood. The studies overall results showed that there is not a consistent negative association
between prenatal cocaine exposure and physical growth. It also showed no association with
developmental scores, or receptive or expressive language (Frank, 2001). However; it was proven
that in children diagnosed with NAS up to 7 months old will have lower motor scores. It was also
found that decreased attentiveness and emotional issues were connected to prenatal cocaine
exposure.
antidepressants often used by pregnant women. Use of SSRI's during pregnancy can cause the
baby to be diagnosed with Neonatal Abstinence Syndrome, therefore recognizing SSRI related
symptoms is important.
5
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
There are multiple things to look for in the development of a child affected by SSRI's and some of
these side effects can lead to long-term issues for the child diagnosed with NAS due to SSRI’s.
Neurodevelopment is one of the key factors affected long-term in infants diagnosed with
NAS. There are many ways to assess a child's neurodevelopment, but in Klinger's research study
the Denver Developmental Screening Test II was used along with the Wechsler Preschool and
Primary Scale of Intelligence-II, the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales or the Bayley Scale of
Infant Development-II as was age appropriate. “Two groups of children were compared: Group 1
included children who exhibited NAS after birth and Group 2 included children who did not exhibit
symptoms compatible with NAS” (Klinger 2011). This study included a total of eighty-two
children aged two to six years old; thirty with NAS and fifty-two without NAS.
Per Klinger there was a trend towards a smaller head circumference among former NAS
babies and the only neurological abnormality detected was hypotonia. Children who had NAS
were also more likely to have a threefold risk for abnormal results on the social component of the
DDST-II. The results also showed that intelligence is not affected by drug exposure. Per Klinger's
study the areas where children affected with NAS showed abnormalities were; behavior and social
adaptability which includes activities of daily living, social imitative play and the ability to clearly
[T]he Bayley psychomotor development indices and the motor quality factor of the
indicating that SSRI exposure may have subtle effects on motor development
(Klinger, 2011)
6
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
While there is quite a bit of research on the effects of illicit drugs on the fetus and newborns,
there is far less research into the long-term effects on the exposed neonate. However, in the article
by Ardendt 2004, studying the effects of cocaine exposed neonates and their developmental
outcomes at the age of seven show deficits in several areas. This was measured using the
Bruininiks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency or BOTMP which consist of eight subtests. Three
fine motor, four gross motor, and one combination test. As well as the Wechsler Intelligence Scale
in children.
The results concluded from these two-test given to a total sample of two hundred thirty-
one children, one hundred and one cocaine exposed and one hundred and thirty unexposed, display
deficits on several skills. Including verbal, visual motor integration, and fine motor skills.
However, it must be noted that the results may overlap with other cognitive risk factors
experienced by many low-income families. It should also be noted that both groups did not do well
in comparison to the normative standards, particularly on the WISC-III. While the results indicated
a correlation between cocaine exposed infants and developmental issues there is a need for further
In the journal of American Academy of Pediatrics Behnke et. Al states that while there is
regards to growth or achievement there have been some studies with direct correlation. The
conclusions that could be drawn were that opiates have a direct effect on long-term behavior, but
no effect on growth. This article also shows that cocaine influences future behavior, cognition, and
language, however, there is no consensus on the long-term effects on growth and achievement.
7
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
Finally, it should be noted that there is limited or no data regarding methamphetamine in the short
Research has indicated that prenatal exposure to drugs puts the neonate at risk for mental
health deficits as well physical deficits throughout their lifespan. Like the physical deficits that
may occur, the degree of mental impairment depends on the quantity and type of drug used. Drugs
that have been commonly studied, with regards to short term and long term adverse effects, to the
prenatally exposed fetus include: nicotine, alcohol, marijuana, opiates, cocaine and
methamphetamine.
Per Behnke and Smith (2013), prenatal exposure to nicotine has an adverse effect on
behavior that begins in early childhood and continues into adulthood. They found that the affected
individual may struggle with hyperactivity as well as negative and externalizing behaviors in
childhood. Such adverse behavioral effects in childhood are carried throughout adolescence and
into adulthood. Which is demonstrated by higher rates of criminal behavior in adults who were
Ross, Graham, Money and Stanwood (2015) found that “Of all the substances of abuse
(including cocaine, heroin and marijuana), alcohol produces by far the most serious
neurobehavioral effects in the fetus” (as cited in Institute of Medicine, 1996). The effects of fetal
exposure to alcohol may lead to maladaptive behaviors that last from early childhood to adulthood;
per Behnke and Smith (2013). Like those prenatally exposed to nicotine, the result of prenatal
hyperactivity and neuropsychiatric disorders in children (Ross et al., 2015). Ross et al. (2015) have
identified that the behavioral problems of those prenatally exposed to marijuana may lead to
8
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
delinquency and externalizing behaviors as the individual grows. Additionally, they found that the
impulsiveness, of the prenatally exposed fetus, may last into the individual’s twenties.
9
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
More research is needed on the long term mental health deficits associated with prenatal
opiate exposure. However, Behnke and Smith (2013) have found that neonates prenatally exposed
to opiates exhibit inattention and hyperactivity at ten years of age. Ross et al. (2015) have
determined that doctors need to study children prenatally exposed to opiates based on studies
previously performed on animals. These animal studies have suggested that prenatal exposure to
The affect that prenatal cocaine exposure has on the mental health of the exposed individual
is inconclusive at present (Behnke & Smith, 2013). Ross et al. (2015) references studies that imply
that prenatal cocaine exposure leads to differing adverse behavioral effects depending on the time
of exposure. For instance, first trimester exposure has been connected to depression in children;
As with opiates and cocaine there are few studies that have been published to demonstrate
the long-term effects of methamphetamine (Behnke & Smith, 2013). Ross et al. (2015) reviewed
one study “found that prenatal meth exposure was associated with children externalizing
behavioral problems at 5 years of age” (as cited in LaGasse et al., 2012; Towmey et al., 2013).
They conclude that the conduction of more animal studies will enable researchers to understand
Behnke and Smith (2013), as well as Ross et al. (2015), have demonstrated that nicotine,
alcohol and marijuana have adverse effects on the mental health of the prenatally exposed
individual; effects that may last their entire lives. “Better animal models will allow us to predict
and treat later-in-life disorders in [those prenatally exposed to drugs]” (Ross et al. 2015); clearly,
indicates the need for further study. More research is especially needed for those who were exposed
to opiates, cocaine and methamphetamine in utero. Mental health issues are often seen in persons
10
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
who abuse drugs. Since these two issues are so entwined it is necessary to not only look at studies
regarding the mental health of the affected infants, it is also necessary to look at the studies
It is strongly believed that people who are born to drug addicted parents, especially those
born with neonatal abstinence syndrome and other complications resulting from maternal drug use,
will more than likely become drug addicts themselves later in life. Although it is quoted quite
often, not much research has been done to back up this popular assumption. As Herranz, Vilchez,
Ledo, and Sierra showed in their study of 30 participants that were born to heroin addicted mothers,
this may certainly be true (2014). However, just like the research of Solis, Shadur, and Hussong
Herranz et al. found out of their sample of thirty subjects that were born to heroin addicted
mothers between 1985 and 1990, only one of them had ever been treated for drug-related problems
while nearly all of them had consumed some sort of drug over the span of their life. Out of the
thirty participants, twenty-six had consumed cannabis, fourteen had consumed cocaine, two had
consumed benzodiazepines that were not prescribed to them, two had consumed GHB, six had
consumed ecstasy, nine had consumed amphetamines, seven had consumed hallucinogens, while
only two had consumed heroin like their mothers were addicted to when they were born. According
to their study, with the exception of cannabis and cocaine none of them habitually used drugs and
had only consumed each substance on less than four days over the previous year.
It was discovered by Solis et al. that children whose parents had issues with drug and
alcohol abuse had a fifty-three percent chance of developing a drug and alcohol abuse issue
themselves in young adulthood, while only approximately twenty five percent of young adults
without a substance abusing parent would (2012). The double in occurrence of substance abuse
11
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
disorders in young adults from those who grew up without parents with substance abuse disorders
to those who did is a clear indicator that children with parents with substance abuse disorders are
significantly more likely to develop an addiction themselves. However, that still leaves forty-seven
percent that didn't develop a substance abuse problem, even though one or both of their parents
Even though Herranz et al. were only able to use thirty surveys for their research when they
sent out one hundred and fifty, a few other key points were highlighted (2014). Despite only being
between the ages of twenty-four and twenty-nine, five of their one hundred and fifty subjects had
passed away, four of them due to the complications they suffered from AIDS due to their mother
contracting HIV from the use of contaminated needles while the other was of an unknown cause.
Many selected people who chose not to participate in the survey may have been substance abusers,
the people who weren't heavy substance abusers more than likely would have been more inclined
to answer the questions and return it. This may have skewed the results slightly, since a higher
ratio of substance abuse was expected among the one hundred and fifty than was seen in the group
of thirty.
From the research conducted by Solis et al. in 2012 and Herranz et al. in 2014, it can be
concluded that people that were born to or lived with parents who have substance abuse issues,
especially those who were exposed to drugs prenatally, have a much higher risk of developing
substance issues themselves later in life. Although some people never developed any substance
abuse disorders per the surveys conducted, they were twice as likely to develop them than other
people in their demographic that did not have a substance abusing parent(s).
12
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
References
Arendt, R., Short, E., Singer, L., Minnes, S., Hewitt, J., Flynn, S., Carlson, L., Min, M., Klein,
Behnke, M., Smith, V. (2013). Prenatal Substance Abuse: Short- and Long-Term Effects on the
doi:10.1542/peds.2012-3931
doi:10.1001/jama.285.12.1613
Gunatilake, R., Avinash, P. C. (2017). Drug Use During Pregnancy - Women's Health Issues.
issues/drug-use-during-pregnancy/drug-use-during-pregnancy
Jones, H.E. (2006). Drug Addiction During Pregnancy. Current Directions in Psychological
6105.1000180
Klinger, G., Frankenthal, D., Merlob, P., Diamond, G., Sirota, L., Levinson-Castiel, R., Inbar, D.
13
NAS AFFECTS THROUGHOUT LIFE
neonatal abstinence syndrome. Israel Journal of Psychiatry and Related Sciences, 45(2),
107-113. doi:10.1001/archpedi.160.2.173
Consequences of Fetal Exposure to Drugs: What We Know and What We Still Must
Solis, J. M., Shadur, J. M., Burns, A. R., Hussong, A. M. (2012). Understanding the Diverse
Needs of Children whose Parents Abuse Substances. Current Drug Abuse Reviews, 5(2),
Dependent Women and Their Infants: Health, Developmental, and Social Implications.
Zuckerman, B. (1991). Drug-Exposed Infants: Understanding the Medical Risk. The Future of
14