COMPETENCY OF THE LEGAL MANAGEMENT GRADUATES IN THEIR LAW

SUBJECTS: BATCH 2015-2016: AN ASSESSMENT

A Thesis Presented to the Department of English

Foreign Languages and Literature
College of Arts and Sciences
San Beda College

In Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for

English 04
(Research Methods and Applications)

By:

Aurelio, Athena Beatriz

Pagulayan, John Lyonell
Regado, Aleezah Gertrude

4ALM

November 2016
 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The researchers would like to express their deepest gratitude to the following

persons, who in their special ways have contributed and extended their valuable

assistance in the preparation and completion of this study

First and foremost, the researchers acknowledge the good Lord for guiding us

throughout this semester.

Their deepest gratitude for our thesis adviser Dr. Nerissa Revilla for being patient

to our needs and for expertly guiding us towards our goals.

Their appreciation also extends to Mrs. Emelie Regado for helping the

researchers review these papers and to Rishamai Gonzales for helping them with

regard to tallying the surveys and inputting data unto this work.

This is also dedicated to their family and friends who have touched them by

lending a helping hand, who supported them, and who serve as their inspiration in doing

this work.

The Researchers
 TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT……………………………………………………………………ii

ABSTRACT………………………………………………………………………………….iii

LIST OF TABLES…………………………………………………………………………...x

CHAPTER

1. THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND……………………………………….6

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK…………………………………………………...9

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK…………………………………………………..10

STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM……………………………………………….11

IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY………………………………………………….12

DEFINITION OF TERMS………………………………………………………….13

SCOPE AND DELIMITATION…………………………………………………….14

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES………………………..14

2. METHOD OF THE STUDY…………………………………………………………...17

INSTRUMENTS AND TECHNIQUES……………………………………………..18

SAMPLING PROCEDURE…………………………………………………………19

TREATMENT OF DATA…………………………………………………………….19

3. PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA…………….23

 4. SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS…………………………………………………………43

CONCLUSIONS……………………………………………………………………..47

RECOMMENDATIONS…………………………………………………………….49

BIBLIOGRAPHY………………………………………………………………………………50

APPENDIX

A LETTER TO THE RESPONDENT……………………………………………… 51

B QUESTIONNAIRE…………………………………………………………………52

C TABULATION OF DATA

D SAMPLE QUESTIONNAIRE

CURRICULUM VITAE
 LIST OF TABLES

Table No. Title Page

1.1 Age of the Respondents 23

1.2 Gender of the Respondents 24

1.3 Years of study of Legal Management Students 24

1.4 Favorite Law Subjects 25

2.1 Level of Reading Comprehension Skills Competency 27

2.2 Level of Writing Skills Competency 28

2.3 Level of Grammar and Vocabulary Skills Competency 28

2.4 Level of Listening Skills Competency 30

2.5 Level of Speaking Skills Competency 30

3.1 Level of Competency on Mastery of Law 31

3.2 Level of Competency on Knowledge of Legal Terms 32

3.3 Level of Competency on Case Comprehension 33

4.1 Effect of Low Level of Competency on Time Management 34

4.2 Effect of Low Level of Competency on Information Overload 35

4.3 Effect of Low Level of Competency on Method of Teaching 37

and Professors
5.1 Respondent’s Weakness in Terms of Mastery of the Law 38

5.2 Respondent’s Weakness in Terms of Knowledge of Legal 39

Terms

5.3 Respondent’s Weakness in Terms of Case Comprehension 40

6.1 Solution to increase the Level of Competency of the Legal 41

Management
 CHAPTER 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

The Legal Management program of San Beda College was created in 2002 to

respond to the need for a strong program that will match San Beda College of Law’s

long and illustrious reputation as a top law school in the country (Course Catalogue

2014-2015). It is the second biggest department in the College of Arts and Science of

San Beda College, and has produced numerous lawyers, some of whom are now

faculty members of the department. Under the objectives of the program, it has two-fold

purpose: first is to prepare the Legal Management students for a career in the

corporate world requiring knowledge in law, and secondly is to prepare students for the

rigors of law school, should they decide to pursue four years of law school (2016).

The program mainly consists of eighteen law subjects that would prepare the

Legal Management students for the rudiments of law school, such as: Law on Person

and Family Relations, Legal Writing and Research, Civil Laws, Labor Laws, Commercial

Laws, and Taxation Laws are some of the subjects which comprise the program SBC,

(2013 www.sanbeda.edu.ph,,) and as such these subjects serve as an introduction to

the Laws of the Philippines which is being taught in the College of Law. With such

background, it is presumed that Legal Management graduates have an edge in the

College of Law amongst other students who took up different courses other than Legal

Management. Each individual possesses a different level of competency. It is not only

concerned with the "what" element or the outcome, but also with the "how" element or in
other words, the process of accomplishing a certain outcome. The competency level

attained by a person is one of the core driving factors of an organization. (2016,

Measuring Competencies in Performance Evaluation; Free Management Books [E-

reader version]. Retrieved from www.free-management-ebooks.com/news/measuring-

competencies/)

It is in this light that the researchers conducted the study on the competency

Bachelor of Science in Legal Management Graduates (BSLM) in their law subjects

particularly graduates of Batch 2015-2016 who pursued four year course on Bachelor

Laws in San Beda College of Law. The San Beda College Manila-College of Law, has

been perceived as one of the best law schools in the country. Over the years, it has

produced senators, congressmen, judges, lawyers, law professors and of course

the highest position in the country, the President of the Philippines. It has also

achieved one of the highest bar passing rates and largest number of law graduates

among law schools in the country.

Specifically, this study will determine the level of competency of BSLM

graduates as pre law course or preparatory to Bachelor of Laws. In this study, not

only the output is measured, but also how the respondents attained such kind of

outcome -- what are the integrated knowledge, skills, judgment and attributes that came

into play in order for the respondents to react effectively to the demands of the society

they currently belong to (i.e. workplace, law school).

 In order to attain success through education, there must be an effective

educational system and among the important parts of the educational are the

curriculum, the teachers or faculty and the role they play in achieving student’s feat.

(Turner,2003)

The Bachelor of Science in Legal Management program (BSLM) provides

knowledge and skills in the components of law and the legal intricacies of the business

laws. The BSLM is one of the programs being offered in San Beda College Manila. Its

curriculum designed to provide students with knowledge and skills regarding the laws of

business, obligations and contracts, taxation, labor laws and negotiable instruments as

well as a global view point and practical apprenticeship opportunities for exploring legal

aspects of business. (San Beda). Accordingly, negotiable instruments and laws

surrounding business organizations and the BSLM program is a good preparation for

Law. (De La Salle).

One of the goals of the department of Legal Management is to equip students

and provide them an advantage as they pursue further studies in law, however students

fail to stay or survive in the said program, consequently this has become one of the

problems that came to the researchers’ attention that showed potential of a study that

could help address the problem areas that students have encountered.

The researchers have categorized some possible areas that could be reasons

why such problems exits. These are the following. (1) Study habits (2)
Socio/Extracurricular activities. What is really the trend with the law students’ study

habits? In the recent research conducted in the University of Kansas by Paul A. Witty

and Harvey C. Lehman, it was found that “failures in college may be traced to

undesirable study habits”.

In Socio/Extracurricular activities, it was dubbed that social life and law school

are more likely to be compared to oil and water. Most law students take academic

competition very seriously, which can make it difficult to form close friendships and even

romantic relationships. But then again, would that be a successful trick in law school or

even one of the reasons why other students flunk or leave the program.

The researchers are interested to know how studying in legal management arms

students with competency in their law subjects. One of the reasons for the

establishment of such program.

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

According to Sternberg (2004) the traditional theory of academic competence

deals with a very important part of intelligence, namely, memory and analytical skills,

and that is what the Sternberg Academic Test measures. These skills are important for

success in school and in life. Over the years, teaching the students at Yale, is that some

students were very gifted in traditional memory and analytical skills, but never good at

making ideas of their own. They were good if you told them the paper topic, if you told

them what exactly would be on the test. Sternberg’s theory is a good basis to be used to
reevaluate if the skill set of Legal Management students of San Beda College is enough

to give them a better edge in law school. Through this, the faculty of the department can

also be evaluated if its teaching methods are at their most effective and efficient state.

San Beda College boasts its success in its law school, with respect to that, its

undergraduate course whose program is strongly connected to the San Beda College of

Law’s rigorous program should be able to provide courses and experiences that will

engage the prospective law school students in critical thinking about important issues

and improve the students’ tolerance for uncertainties. The study of law itself does not

only require close reading and analysis of complex textual material or the

comprehension of judicial opinions, statutes, documents, and other written materials but

it will also demand the ability to structure and evaluate arguments for and against

propositions that are susceptible to reasoned debate, and that is not something that can

be learned from just memorizing books, articles, cases and other reading materials.

Legal Management students should continually challenge themselves to think outside of

the box.

The Core Competency is a concept in management theory introduced by C. K.

Prahalad and Gary Hamel. It is defined as a harmonized combination of multiple

resources and skills that distinguish a firm in a marketplace. It is the theory of strategy

that prescribes actions to be taken by firms to achieve competitive advantage in the

marketplace. The concept of core competency states that firms must play to their

strengths or those areas or functions in which they have competencies. The Core

Competency Theory measures best the competency level of Legal Management

Graduates Batch 2015-2016. It seeks to determine the strengths and weaknesses of the
organization, which are the graduates in this case. The Core Competency Theory is

actually made for corporations but it can be used to improve the performance of Legal

Management students of San Beda. The strength of the Legal Management course as

being bannered by various institutions is the incorporation of various subjects and

scholastic approaches in law school; having such bannered strength the administrators

must further evaluate what areas are to be improved and what various approaches can

further uphold the competency in law of the students so they may truly have a

competitive advantage once they reach further legal studies.

CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK

INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT

Legal Management Measurement of Competency Competent Legal

Graduates: Batch Level Management
2015-2016 Graduates
 Reading
Comprehension
 Writing Skills
 Grammar and
Vocabulary
 Speaking Skills
 Listening skills
 Mastery of the Law
 Knowledge of Legal
Terms
 Case Comprehension
 Time Management
 Information Overload
 Method of Teaching
and Professor
 Figure 1

The focus of this study was undertaken by the following Conceptual Paradigm

shown in Figure 1.1 which shows the input, process, and output. The Input the Legal

Management Graduates of Batch 2015-2016. The Process is the gathering of the data

from the respondents, this includes the competency level that are measured through the

different determinant factors affecting their competencies namely, reading

comprehension, writing skills, grammar and vocabulary, speaking skills, listening skills,

mastery of the law, knowledge of legal terms and maxims, case comprehension, time

management, information overload, and method of teaching and professor. The Output

is the different determinant factors that affects competencies which can be used to to

promulgate solutions and remedies so as to attain a competent and competitive Legal

Management Graduates.

STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM

This study aims to determine the Law Subject Competency of the Legal

Management Batch 2015-2016. Specifically, the following questions will be answered:

1. What is the profile of the respondents in terms of:

1.1 Age

1.2 Gender

1.3 Years in Legal Management

1.4 Favorite Law Subject

2. What is the highest grade the respondent obtained in a Law Subject?

 3. What is the lowest grade the respondent obtained in a Law subject?

4. How will the respondent rate the level of law subject competency?

5. What is the level of law subject competency of the respondents as perceived by

the respondents in terms of:

5.1 Mastery of the Law

5.2 Knowledge of Legal Terms

5.3 Case Comprehension

6. How do the following factors affect the competency of the Legal Management

students?

6.1 Time Management

6.2 Information Overload

6.3 Method of teaching and the Professor

7. In what areas are the respondents weak in terms of:

7.1 Mastery of the Law

7.2 Knowledge of Legal Terms

7.3 Case Comprehension

8. How can the respondents increase their level of competency?

IMPORTANCE OF THE STUDY

Through the assessment of the competency of Legal Management students

when it comes to law subjects in law school, the researcher may be able to determine

how they cope up with the new scholastic environment, what are the advantages and
disadvantages students derive from the legal management’s curriculum and to point out

their edge, if any, as compared to law students coming from other courses.

Data from this research may be used to further improve the curriculum of the

legal management department, to guide students as to whether it brings them

advantage graduating as a legal management major when they enter law school and to

open avenues of other possible research concerning this issue.

This study will be of benefit basically to the legal management students of San

Beda and its faculty. It will not only be a guiding light whether a person should take legal

management as a pre law but more importantly this can be a way to divert from the

mistakes or shortcomings made by the batch that have graduated already. It serves as

a mirror of the past that can help improve the future for the students and the faculty.

DEFINITION OF TERMS

This section presents the following words that were used throughout the

research.

Legal Management - is an academic and professional discipline that is a hybrid

between the study of law and management (i.e. business administration, public

administration, etc.). It is generally considered as the best preparatory law program for

those who aspire to become members of a bar.

Competency- a cluster of related abilities, commitments, knowledge, and skills that

enable a person (or an organization) to act effectively in a job or situation

Law School- a graduate school offering study leading to a law degree.

Preparation— the activity or process of making something ready or of becoming ready

for something.

Curriculum- set of courses constituting an area of specialization offered by an

educational institution.

Pre-Law- refers at least any four year course of study by an undergraduate student in

preparation for law school.

SCOPE AND DELIMITATION

The study focused on the data obtained from the graduates of Legal

Management Batch 2015-2016 regarding their highest and lowest grade ever received

in all of their law subjects.

This study is interested on how the graduates would rate their law subject level of

competency in general and on how they perceived it in certain different factors, such as,

their mastery of law, comprehension of cases and knowledge of legal terms.

 This study would also like to know what are the factors that affect their

competency. In relation to how they manage their time, what information overload does

to them and how the method of teaching affects them

The respondents were only limited to the Legal Management graduates of San

Beda College, Batch 2016.

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This part is composed of related literature and studies and related readings. The

researcher has gone through intensive readings of ideas, finished thesis, methodologies

and others that were from the internet and printed which has great significance to the

problem during the course of the thesis writing.

Related Literature

Local

Ortiz (2013) elaborated that law schools don't prescribe a particular pre-Law

course. Whatever course will do, provided your pre-Law course complied with the

required number of units in Math, English, and Social Science. American Bar

Association (2003) likewise claimed that there is no single path that will prepare you for

a legal education. Students who are successful in law school, and who become
accomplished professionals, come from many walks of life and educational

backgrounds.

Fabio (2009) claims that the level of competition in law school varies greatly by

school, and many surmise there is less competition at higher ranked schools, especially

among those who don't use traditional grading and ranking structures. The theory is that

students who attend higher ranked schools are more confident of securing legal

employment simply because of their law school and that grades or class standing

matters less.

Foreign

Malcom (2004) however claims that Certain courses can be particularly useful in

developing the skills you will need to do well on the Law School Admission Test, in law

school, and in the practice of law, such as analytical, critical thinking, research and

communication skills, argumentation, and above all, writing. Some courses cover

specifically law-related topics.

On the other notes, Holts (2008) stated that the study of law is hard work, but it is

also intellectually challenging and highly rewarding. It involves large quantities of written

material which you will need to read, comprehend, synthesize and analyze. You will

need the ability to read and digest information quickly and to take good and accurate

notes. According to Barnes (2012) Law school is extremely competitive. Students are

forced to be highly competitive in law school these days because rivalry for any type of

legal position is extremely intense. Not only are students competing with other students

from their own law school, but they are battling with students from other law schools as

well.
 According to Thompson (2005) three basic areas in which prelaw students need

to develop proficiency: The effectiveness in the comprehension and use of oral and

written language, in-depth understanding of human institutions and values and

analytical and critical thinking. The theory is that if you are interested in your courses,

you will be motivated to achieve high levels of academic performance. It is this

demonstrated commitment to learning that is the most important factor in the study of

law.