Islamic Finance: Panacea for the Global Financial System?

Charles A. Rarick
Thaung Han
Purdue University Calumet
School of Management
Hammond, IN 46323 USA
[email protected]
219-989-6181

ABSTRACT

With the recent troubles in the global economy, some have proposed that a financial
system based on sharia, or Islamic law is a better approach than traditional finance. The
argument is made that Islamic finance is a safer approach, and less vulnerable to
questionable financial transactions which may have led to the global recession beginning
in 2008. This paper explores the basics of Islamic finance, and while agreeing that
Islamic finance has an important role to play in the global financial system, concludes
that it is not a viable substitute for traditional financial management.

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1483789

Islamic Finance: Panacea for the Global Financial System?

ABSTRACT

With the recent troubles in the global economy, some have proposed that a financial
system based on sharia, or Islamic law is a better approach than traditional finance. The
argument is made that Islamic finance is a safer approach, and less vulnerable to
questionable financial transactions which may have led to the global recession beginning
in 2008. This paper explores the basics of Islamic finance, and while agreeing that
Islamic finance has an important role to play in the global financial system, concludes
that it is not a viable substitute for traditional financial management.

INTRODUCTION

Beginning in September of 2008, the world watched as financial markets around

the world began a dramatic downward slide. With news of troubled financial institutions
hitting the streets, the problem expanded, and words such as “The Great Recession” or
even “depression” began to be used. Further information revealed that much of the
trouble could be blamed on the financial institutions in the West, especially in the United
States. Troubled banks and investment firms holding “toxic assets” were singled out as
the major sources of the economic crisis that was gripping the world. Citizens of many
countries began to hear words such as “securitization,” “credit default swaps,” and other
terms which were used to describe the causes of the economic downturn. It may have
appeared to many that the financial system had become too complex, too greedy,
nontransparent, and under-regulated. In the United States, many loans were made to
unqualified borrowers, and those loans were then bundled and sold to other investors.
When the housing market was making its astonishing rise, the problems were masked,
however, once the market began to correct, the financial house of cards based on inflated
values and questionable lending began to fall. The financial system appeared to be
imploding, and questions were being raised about the fundamental structure of the
traditional financial system. As investors and others began to search for answers, Islamic
finance appeared as a possible panacea for the global financial system. Terms such as
riba, sukuk, and mudaraba began to be heard in traditional financial circles as proponents
of Islamic finance promoted their model of asset-based financing as a safer and more
enduring approach.

FUNDAMENTALS OF ISLAMIC FINANCE

Central to the concept of Islamic finance is the prohibition of paying or receiving

interest, or riba. According to Sheikh Nizam Yaquby, a noted expert in Islamic finance,
“There is no sin in the Koran – not even drinking, not even fornication, not even
homosexuality – which could be as abhorrent and serious as dealing with riba” (Power
2009 p. 70). Islamic finance is asset-based and requires the sharing of risk. Speculation
and extreme positions of leverage are not allowed under Islamic law. In addition to riba,

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1483789

sharia prohibits ghar, or deception; maisir, or gambling; and haram, or investing in
prohibited industries such as pork products, alcohol, and pornography.

There are a variety of ways of engaging in finance with Islamic principles,

including personal financing and equity investments. As well, there are a variety of
institutional arrangements, from an Islamic window at a traditional financial institution to
a full- fledged Islamic bank. Perhaps the best known and the most successful of the
Islamic financial instruments is the sukuk, the Islamic equivalent of a bond. Worldwide
Islamic financial assets are estimated to be in the range of $1 trillion and could quadruple
in the next few years (Hanware 2009). Without the ability to charge or receive interest,
Islamic finance has had to become more creative. A number of new financial
arrangements have been developed including the murabaha. A Murabaha is an
arrangement whereby a bank purchases an asset, such as real estate, for a client with the
understanding that the client will buy the asset over time with an allocation built in the
payments for profit. Other arrangements are provided for leasing an asset or providing
capital to a business. In the case of business capital, the financial institution takes partial
ownership instead of interest payments (Nouel 2007). With the growth of Islamic finance,
institutions have been developed across the world to offer financial services to customers
who wish to comply with sharia, or Islamic law. According to the International Monetary
Fund (IMF) there are over 300 Islamic financial institutions in over 50 countries (Sole
2007) and given the current trends, it is reasonable to conclude that the numbers will
continue to grow in the coming years.

A number of cities have become centers for Islamic finance (Figure 1), most of
which are in countries with a large percentage of the population that is Muslim. Islamic
finance is, however, also a growing market for financial institutions outside
predominately Muslim countries. Not all Muslim countries, however, are receptive to
Islamic finance. Egypt and Morocco are two examples. Egypt’s government has taken a
significant controlling position of the country’s Islamic banks over fear of the spread of
Islamic fundamentalism and this has hampered, in part, the development of Islamic
banking in the country (Mouawad 2009). The government of Morocco has been reluctant
to allow Islamic banking also, for much the same reason as Egypt. In some countries such
as India and Nigeria, where conflict between Muslims and non-Muslims is a problem,
Islamic banking has also not been allowed to develop (Modi 2007).

FIGURE 1
TOP ISLAMIC CAPITAL MARKETS

Islamic Assets Percent of Sector

Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia $50.0B 12.9
Dubai, UAE $46.3B 13.5
Manama, Bahrain $16.4B 6.5
Doha, Qatar $14.8B 18.2
London, England $10.0B .05
Singapore $1.80B 6.5

L. Laurent. Forbes.com. April 21, 2008.

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=1483789

 Kuala Lumpur established itself early as a major Islamic banking center, and has
been successfully conducting Islamic financial transactions for over thirty years. Kuala
Lumpur gained financial assets after the terrorist attacks in the United States in 2001, as
capital flight from the United States took place in response to the perception of possible
seizure of banking assets held by wealthy Muslims. Recently Singapore has taken steps to
challenge Kuala Lumpur and to become the Islamic financial capital of Asia
(International Financial Law Review 2009). Islamic finance is believed to be managing
over a trillion dollars in assets, however difficulties arise in securing accurate statistics
(Al-Salem 2008). While exact figures are hard to come by, there isn’t much doubt that as
many oil rich states became even wealthier with the increase in crude oil prices, Western
banks and other financial institutions in the West began to take notice and to establish
financial services that were sharia compliant. In addition to the increasing price of crude
oil, the advancement of technology and online banking has made it feasible to establish
financial centers that can serve clients from across the globe.

ISSUES WITH ISLAMIC FINANCE

While as we have seen through recent events, the traditional model of finance is
not without its problems, however, Islamic finance also has its drawbacks as well. Islamic
finance can be seen as simply the repackaging of traditional financial instruments to look
like they are sharia compliant. A study by the Accounting and Auditing Organization for
Islamic Financial Institutions (AAOIFI) reported that 85% of bonds sold as compliant
with sharia were in fact not compliant (Power 2009). Islam has different branches and
different schools of thought and different interpretations have emerged as to what is
allowed under sharia. In addition to problems of consistency and legitimacy, problems
include the lack of standardization, the limited number of financial instruments allowed
under sharia, the shortage of qualified scholars to evaluate proposed investments,
prohibitions that tend to limit liquidity, quantity, and diversification of assets, and a
system which lacks a unified regulatory authority.

Liquidity is a concern in Islamic finance, as well as diversification, risk

management, and availability of capital and its cost. Since it is essentially an asset and
long term based financial system, problems with liquidity can arise in Islamic finance.
Money markets provide liquidity to financial institutions, and the money market system
by its very nature is interest based. In addition, by limiting the source of funds available
to any individual or organization, the supply of funds would be reduced, and in theory,
raise the cost of capital (Figure 2). If investors had availability to all financial markets (S)
the cost of capital would be lower than those who operate in a restricted arena (SI).
Likewise, by limiting the investments which are possible due to sharia restrictions, the
level of diversification is reduced, and in theory, risk is increased (Figure 3). By limiting
asset holdings to only those which are sharia compliant, and limiting different variations
of financial instruments, fewer choices decrease the chance to diversify. Less
diversification generally is associated with greater risk.
 FIGURE 2
SUPPLY OF CAPITAL

SI
Islamic
Market
P
S

Total Market

Demand

Q/t

FIGURE 3
RISK AND DIVERSIFICATION

N
 One of the investment alternatives which is generally not available in Islamic
finance is the deviates market. Sharia prohibits speculation and puts into question the use
of derivates and other non-asset based financial instruments. While there is a move to
create sharia compliant derivates by the International Swaps and Derivates Association
(Flynn 2008 & Jobst 2009), the interpretation of Islamic law concerning speculation
makes this task difficult and subject to controversy. While close approximations of a
derivates market may be possible, a need exists for greater transparency, legal
frameworks, and standardization (Hesse, Jobst, & Sole 2008 & Jobst 2007). This is true
not only in derivates, but in the entire system of Islamic finance.

Another concern in Islamic finance is that the number of qualified people who can
issue approval on Islamic financial instruments is very small. Ram (2008) reports that
only 20 people are qualified to make such judgments, given the need for extensive
knowledge of Islamic law, training in advanced finance, and language proficiency. This
shortage of qualified evaluators means that sharia compliance boards of financial
institutions have little choice for selection, and fees for such services can be high. It is
also common for these elite scholars to sit on a number of different boards, creating at
least the perception of a possible conflict of interest.

Another issue which faces Islamic finance is the perception that some banks are
involved in some way with terrorist groups. Such was the case of Prince Muhammad al-
Faisal Saud and the company he founded, DMI. Among the assets of DMI are Islamic
banks which have been accused of aiding the flow of money to Al Qaeda organizations
(Thomas 2007). While the evidence is not strong to support such charges, Islamic
banking is linked in the minds of some as facilitators of terrorist groups. Additionally, an
asset based system of financial management has the potential for greater moral hazard
with the practice of equity sharing and leasing. Individuals seeking capital may feel less
responsible for the assets if they do possess complete ownership.

While Islamic finance has problems with liquidity, diversification, and other
issues, perhaps the greatest issue facing the niche market of finance is the lack of
standardization and regulation. Modi (2007) states that the most pressing issue facing
Islamic finance is the need for standardized regulation, as well as the integration of the
fragmented Islamic banking system. Speaking to the issue of standardization, Amol
Prabhu, a member of the Islamic Documentation Committee of the International Islamic
Finance Market, “There is not a lot of black and white in all of this. There is a lot of grey.
Sometimes we find that the same issues occur in different transactions but are dealt with
in completely different ways” (International Financial Law Review 2008). Some have
argued that regulation of Islamic finance should focus on the manner in which financial
activities are carried out, rather than the substance of those activities (Henderson 2007).
This would make regulation similar to that found in non-Muslim countries. Such a system
appears to be working in Dubai, and could perhaps be a model for the rest of the Islamic
world.
 Another risk, not especially limited to Islamic finance, is holding real estate assets
in a declining market. While Islamic banks were not caught up in the massive holding of
“toxic assets” because of the lack of securitized debt (Khalaf 2009), holding assets in
large quantities in a declining market is worrisome. Customers of Islamic banks could
suffer a loss even if the bank does not fail due to the profit and loss sharing scheme of the
system (Modi 2007). In addition to the above mentions problems, Islamic banks are not
immune to some of the same problems that plagued Western banks with respect to
playing fast and loose with financial regulations and engaging in fraudulent practices.

Islamic finance has been growing at an impressive rate in recent years and
appears to have been able to deal the problems mentioned in this paper. While research is
somewhat limited in terms of specific examples, a study on Islamic banks in Pakistan
showed that these banks were able to maintain good financial performance, adequate
liquidity, and better risk management (Siddiqui 2008). Islamic finance has appeal beyond
just to the needs of followers of Islam. The prohibitions against certain investments could
also appeal to investors concerned with socially responsible investing. Islamic finance
may in fact be less risky for investors as well. A recently published report found that the
Dow Jones Islamic Index (DJIS) outperformed the Dow Jones World Index (DJIM)
during the period of 1996-2005 (Al-Zoubi & Maghyereh 2007). The lower risk was
attributed to the asset-based and risk-sharing model of Islamic finance. Islamic banking
will probably continue to grow and satisfy the market for those who want, or need, to
comply with the requirements of sharia.

CONCLUSION

While Islamic finance is an interesting and needed niche in the financial industry,
it appears not likely to be a substitute for traditional finance. While much is appealing
about Islamic finance, it does not seem capable of supporting the complexity of the
global financial system. The fact that money itself is not viewed as an asset in its own
right makes traditional concepts in financial management such as the time value of
money less useful. Traditional techniques of financial management have to be radically
altered to fit the Islamic view of money. As a niche market appealing to followers of
Islam, as well as those concerned about investing in what may be socially unacceptable
investments, Islamic finance appears to be a good alternative. In its present state,
however, Islamic finance suffers from a number of problems which do not make it a
panacea for the global financial system. Issues of standardization and regulation,
liquidity, diversification, shortages of qualified overseers, and the negative perceptions
are some are the reasons that Islamic finance will remain only a niche in the financial
services industry.
References

Al-Salem. (2008). The size and scope of the Islamic Finance industry. International Journal of
Management, 25(1), 124-130.
Al-Zoubi H. and A. Maghyereh. (2007). The relative risk performance of Islamic finance: A new
guide to less risky investments. International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance, 10(2),
235-249.
Flynn, S. (2008). An Islamic capitalism. International Financial Law Review, July.
Hanware, K. (2009). You can bank on it: Islamic finance is the fastest growing phenomenon.
McClatchy-Tribune Business News, March 23.
Henderson, A. (2007). Limiting the regulation of Islamic finance: Lessons from Dubai. Law and
Financial Markets Review, 1(3), 213-220.
Hesse, H. A. Jobst, and J. Sole. (2008). Trends and challenges in Islamic finance. World
Economics, 9(2), 175-193.
______ (2008). Uniting Islamic finance. International Financial Law Review, April.
______ (2009). Growth of Islamic finance. International Financial Law Review, March.
Jobst, A. (2007). The economics of Islamic finance and securitization. Journal of
Structured Finance, 13(1), 6-27.
Jobst, A. (2009). Derivatives in Islamic finance. Islamic Economic Studies, 15(1). (Forthcoming)
Available at SSRN:http://ssrn.com.
Khalaf, R. (2009). Islamic finance must learn to resolve inner tensions. Financial Times, March
31.
Laurent, L. (2008). Capitals of Islamic finance. Forbes.com, April 21.
Modi, V. (2007). Writing the rules: The need for standardized regulation of Islamic finance.
Harvard International Review, Spring.
Mouawad, S. (2009). The development of Islamic finance: Egypt as a case study. Journal of
Money Laundering, 12(1), 74.
Nouel, G. (2007). Alternative finance products. International Law Review, May.
Power, C. (2009). Faith and the market. Foreign Policy, January/February, 70-75.
Ram, V. (2008). The enforcers. Forbes. April 21.
Siddiqui, A. (2008). Financial contracts, risk, and performance of Islamic banking. Managerial
Finance, 34(10), 680-694.
Sole, J. (2007). Introducing Islamic banks into conventional banking systems. IMF Working
Paper, July.
Thomas, L. (2007). Islamic finance and its critics. New York Times, August 9.