Town Planning F
Town Planning F
Town Planning F
Module I
Origin and evolution of Human settlements: Development of Town planning in the historical perspective-Town planning in
ancient, medieval, renaissance, industrial & post-industrial age- Town planning in India -ancient, medieval, colonial and
modern. Development of new towns and cities-Chandigarh and Navi Mumbai. Contributions to modern town planning
thoughts: by-Patrick Geddes, Ebenezer Howard, C A.Doxiadis, Lewis Mumford, Le Corbusier and Clarence Stein.
Fortified settlement, with a stone wall enclosing a group of circular huts having conical roofs
CATAL HAYUK, ANATOLIA
Unfortified, dense compact settlement with rectangular mud brick houses, no streets. bldgs. show diversification
as houses, shrines and workshops
UR, SUMERIA
Each city built a set of double walls and at least one towering temple as the centre of its surrounding agricultural
estates.
Sacred enclosure- Temenos, religious centre of the city surrounded by massive walls & dominated by the
ziggurat.
Temenos also included temples, palaces and government buildings.
Houses were single-story structures of mud brick, with several rooms wrapped around an open court.
Streets show organic pattern.
BABYLON
The city was surrounded by 450’ high walls & a moat. City had 8 massive gates connected by streets.
The river Euphrates flowed through the middle of the city.
The palace, temple & ziggurat located inside the temenos.
EGYPT
ANCIENT TOWNS
The classical civilization of Ancient Greece emerged into the light of world history in the 8th century BC.
In this landscape of mountains and sea many small territories, each with its own dialect, cultural peculiarities,
and identity developed.
These "city-states" were fiercely independent of each other
GREEK CITIES
Early cities had an organic pattern, following the undulating topography of the region.
The city was surrounded by high, wide walls, fortified gateways at regular intervals.
The high hills had the sacred precinct- often temples located here, the city grew around the foot of the hills. E.g.:
Acropolis in Athens
The market place or Agora was the centre of urban activity, surrounded by shops/civic buildings.
The residential areas were irregular in form with courtyard houses with no windows opening to the streets.
Outside these wall was another public space, the gymnasium, the theatre, built into a hillside and semi-circular in
shape.
Surrounding the city was the farmland of the city-state
AGORA
Agora was located at the centre of the town & often occupied 5% of the city area with all major streets leading to
it.
In planned cities agora was square or rectangular with colonnaded porticos of bldgs. Around them.
Agora was the centre of commercial and political life-surrounded by shops & civic bldgs.
ACROPOLIS
Typical Greek city was built around a fortified hill, called an "acropolis".
Here was located the city's chief temple, the city's treasury, and some other public buildings.
PRIVATE DWELLINGS
The house was basic unit of city and was placed facing south.
There was little difference between the houses of the town- democratic nature of society.
Streets were paved with drains, water was carried from wells.
HIPPODAMUS (5TH CENTURY B.C)
Romans continued the legacy left by the earlier architects of the Greek world.
Romans were also great innovators & engineers who built well planned cities &monumental structures such as
temples, basilica, aqueducts, amphitheatre, and stadia using concrete.
Early cities like Rome located on the banks of river Tiber had an organic growth around 7 hills
The Roman town was a pattern of grid-iron streets, developed for military defense and civil convenience and
wrapped in a wall for defense.
In the Roman system the main north-South Street was called the cardo and the main east-West Street the
decumanus.
These two streets were always wider than others and acted as the axes of the plan.
Rest of the space was divided into squares were blocks of flats, insulae, were built.
Public bldgs. -monuments, columns, and triumphal arches, large variety of temples, thermae, theatres and
arenas.
The provision of clean water for consumption and bathing was made by building the Roman aqueduct.
It shows the radial & lateral pattern of irregular road ways with the church plaza as the principal focal point
of the town.
The time span between falls of the Roman Empire (500 AD) till the start of renaissance (14th cen.)
Economy was rooted in agriculture and the feudal system was the new order.
Wars among the rival feudal lords were frequent.
For protective measures, towns were sited in irregular terrain, occupying hill tops or islands.
Towns assumed informal & irregular character.
Castle was surrounded by wall & moat as a protective elements.
Church plaza became a market place.
Roads generally radiated from church plaza& market plaza to gates with secondary lateral roadways
connecting them.
Irregular pattern in planning was devised to confuse enemies
Early medieval town was dominated by church or monastery & castle of lords.
Towns were human in scale, immediate, tangible with sequential views.
Medieval towns characterized by congestion, overcrowding, filth & squalor.
Epidemics like plague & fire hazard was common in 13th & 14th century.
‘Bastide’ is a French term and means literally ‘small fortress’.
Originally it referred to the planned new towns which were built in southwest France during the early part
of the 13th century.
Now is accepted as the general term for all planned, colonial towns (new towns) of the medieval period
including French, English, Welsh and German examples.
Bastides have pre-determined plan forms.
Grid-iron system and rectilinear plot sub-division form the basis of their layout.
Renaissance
RENAISSANCE TOWNS (1300-1600AD)
Formal open spaces like Plazas and squares were carved out of congested city of Rome
Many 16th century cities like London & Paris followed the idea of monumental plaza as an urban open
space.
BAROQUE CITY
From French gardens came idea of long vistas meeting at acute angles at one point-Patte d'oie
In garden of Versailles(1670) , Andre Le Notre used this idea as a frame work to link together a palace,
gardens & a town- making the vast landscape comprehensible to eye.
These ideas were transferred to baroque city design -substituting houses for trees, grand avenues for long
axes-incorporating plazas surrounded by classical bldgs.
+3, the baroque city was formed
E.g.: London & Paris
In 1666 came plague & great fire which nearly destroyed the city. several proposals with sketch-plans for
radical reorganization of the City's streets were put forward
Sir Christopher Wren's design, inspired by the Gardens of Versailles, imagined a well-ordered London with
vistas and wide, straight streets.
In the following years city was rebuilt incorporating many ideas like avenues, parks, plazas, squares, streets
changing the face of the city.
After the fire, regulations came such as restricting use of combustible materials, bldg. heights, setbacks,
need for open spaces, better sanitation &sewage.
By the 1800s, the population of Paris had grown into an overcrowded medieval city.
In 1853, under Napoleon III, Haussmann began the process of renovating France's capital city – surgery of
Paris.
His basic instructions were to bring light and air into the central districts, improve the sanitation and living
areas, and make Paris a more beautiful city.
Haussmann's interventions included the destruction of old, medieval neighbourhoods, widening of streets,
building large parks and public squares, and addition of fountains and sewer lines
Earlier streets were winding, narrow, dark and unhealthy with medieval structures.
Haussmann created large network of avenues known as ‘boulevards’ that connected the districts.-new
building along these followed a common character.
Haussmann’s efforts went well beyond beautification, modernizing the city so as to enable the efficient
transportation of goods as well as the rapid mobilization of military troops
Industrial age
Planned Industrial Towns
1859-Vesinet in France was planned as a town incorporating characteristics of French gardens & English
Parks- forerunner of Garden cities.
1887, W.H. Liver Company built Port Sunlight, a workers community near Liverpool.
1889- Cadbury ,chocolate company built , Bourneville , a garden community for workers in Birmingham
Tony Garnier, ’Une cite Industrialle’-ideal industrial town for a pop. of 32,000 people-concept of zoning
1882, Spanish Architect, Soria y mata, proposed the concept of a linear city- houses &buildings are set
alongside a linear network of roads & utility systems ,surrounded by gardens
Post-industrial age
FACTORY TOWNS
In 1769 James Watt created an improved version of the steam engine that ushered in the Industrial
Revolution in Britain-drastic changes in industrial & transportation sectors.
In 1825, first steam railroad began its operations in England.
Mechanical production increased & trade expanded –the factory was the new magnet- attracting rural
labours to the city.
Explosive growth of industrial towns due to migration. Manchester, as an example, experienced a 6 times
increase in its population between 1771 and 1831
Giant sprawling cities developed during this era, exhibiting the luxuries of wealth and the meanness of
poverty in sharp juxtaposition.
Working class lived in ‘slums’- dilapidated, over crowded tenements without proper light, ventilation &
sanitary facilities like bathroom, toilet or running water.
Air, water & land city became polluted- epidemics like cholera often broke out.
The wealthy moved away from the cities because they thought the "slum" was unhygienic and unpleasant.
This led to the beginning of suburbs, or socially segregated neighbourhoods in the outskirts.
IDEAL TOWNS
18th & 19TH century saw the emergence of many visionary ideas with a concern for the life of workers.
Claude-Nicolas Ledoux in his visionary plan for the Ideal City of Chaux, (1776), proposed an ideal city were
workers lived close to the factory in an informal grouping of houses among gardens.
His ideas were realised in the design of the Royal Salt works of Arc-et-Senans, France.
Robert Owen was a Welsh social reformer and one of the founders of utopian socialism and the
cooperative movement.
He proposed that ideal communities of about 1,200 people should be settled on land from 1,000 to 1,500
acres (4 to 6 km2).
While mainly agricultural, it should possess all the best machinery, should offer every variety of
employment, and should, as far as possible, be self-contained townships.
In response to existing conditions of urban squalor, regulatory laws (such as Great Britain’s Public Health Act
of 1848 and the New York State Tenement House Act of 1879) set minimal standards for housing for
workers.
PARK MOVEMENT
Early 20th century, efforts to improve the urban environment emerged from recognition of the need for
recreation.
Parks were developed to provide visual relief and places for healthful play or relaxation.
New York’s Central park, envisioned in the 1850s and designed by architects Calvert Vaux and Frederick Law
Olmsted became a widely imitated model.
supporters of the parks movement believed that the opportunity for outdoor recreation would have a
civilizing effect on the working classes, who were otherwise consigned to overcrowded housing and
unhealthful workplaces
Town planning in India
Town planning in India is an ancient science starting from
1. Indus valley
2. Vedic Period
3. Medieval period
4. Modern age
Ancient India
Indus Valley Civilisation
The Indus Valley Civilisation (3300–1900 BCE) also known as Harappan civilisation extending from what today is
northeast Afghanistan to Pakistan and northwest India. It flourished in the basins of the Indus River
As of 1999, over 1,056 cities and settlements had been found, of which 96 have been excavated mainly in the
region of the Indus and Ghaggar-Hakra Rivers and their tributaries.
The major urban centres of Harappa, Mohenjo-Daro, Ganeriwala in modern-day Pakistan; and Dholavira, and
Rakhigarhi in present-day India
The Indus cities are noted for their urban planning, baked brick houses, elaborate drainage systems, water supply
systems, and clusters of large non-residential buildings
The Indus Valley Civilization (also known as the Harappan culture) has its earliest roots in cultures such as that of
Mehrgarh, approximately 6000 BCE.
Mehrgarh is a Neolithic (7000 BCE to c. 2500 BCE) site to the west of the Indus River valley were farming and
herding in South Asia started. The culture migrated into the Indus Valley and became the Indus Valley civilisation.
Trade networks linked this culture with related regional cultures and distant sources of raw materials, including
lapis lazuli and other materials for bead-making.
Early Harappan communities turned to large urban centres by 2600 BCE, from where the mature Harappan phase
started
Vast agricultural lands, rivers, forest surrounded each city.
Town planning
A sophisticated and technologically advanced urban culture is evident in the Indus Valley Civilization.
The two greatest cities, Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa, emerged in 2600 BCE along the Indus River valley in
Punjab and Sindh
the knowledge of urban planning and efficient municipal governments which placed a high priority on
hygiene
Urban planning included the world's first known urban sanitation systems. Within the city, individual homes
or groups of homes obtained water from wells.
Waste water from bathrooms was directed to covered drains, which lined the major streets.
Houses built using burnt bricks opened only to inner courtyards and smaller lanes.
All the houses had access to water and drainage facilities.
The cities were constructed in a highly uniform and well-planned grid pattern, suggesting they were planned by a
central authority.
There was a citadel in the centre, but no large monumental structures like palaces or temples were built.
Harappa and Mohenjo-Daro
The twin cities of Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa formed the hub of the civilization.
Both cities were a mile square with 40,000 population, with defensive outer walls.
An orthogonal street layout was oriented toward the cardinal directions.
The street layout shows an understanding of the basic principles of traffic, with rounded corners to allow the
turning of carts easily.
These streets divided the city into 12 blocks. Except for the west-central blocks, the basic unit of city planning
was the individual house.
A sophisticated and technologically advanced urban culture is evident in the Indus Valley Civilization.
The two greatest cities, Mohenjo-Daro and Harappa, emerged in 2600 BCE along the Indus River valley in Punjab
and Sindh
the knowledge of urban planning and efficient municipal governments which placed a high priority on hygiene
Urban planning included the world's first known urban sanitation systems. Within the city, individual homes or
groups of homes obtained water from wells.
Waste water from bathrooms was directed to covered drains, which lined the major streets.
Mohenjo-Daro
Mohenjo-Daro was the largest of both with an area covering 200 hectares and a population of 35,000 to 40,000.
The citadel was built on a raised platform 45’ above the plains
The streets ran in cardinal directions meeting at the right angles to each other.
Secondary and tertiary streets ran between the built up areas were narrow
Distinct zoning areas like Trade and commerce, Residential areas, cultural spaces
Religious, institutional and Cultural spaces around the Monastery and Great bath in the west
Trade and Administration in south. Agriculture and Industries in north.
The granary was the largest structure in Mohenjo-Daro, and in Harappa there were about six granaries or
storehouses. These were used for storing grain.
The great bath was another important structure in Mohenjo-Daro. The floor of the bath had five layers. There
were changing rooms around. Tar and gypsum mortar between the bricks made sure no water leaked out.
A palace-like building that looked like an assembly hall for the city government or for people to meet.
Underground drains were built on either side of the roads. They were covered with stones which could be
removed in order to clean them.
The granary was the largest structure in Mohenjo-Daro, and in Harappa there were about six granaries or
storehouses. These were used for storing grain.
The great bath was another important structure in Mohenjo-Daro. The floor of the bath had five layers. There
were changing rooms around. Tar and gypsum mortar between the bricks made sure no water leaked out.
A palace-like building that looked like an assembly hall for the city government or for people to meet.
Underground drains were built on either side of the roads. They were covered with stones which could be
removed in order to clean them.
The granary was the largest structure in Mohenjo-Daro, and in Harappa there were about six granaries or
storehouses. These were used for storing grain.
The great bath was another important structure in Mohenjo-Daro. The floor of the bath had five layers. There
were changing rooms around. Tar and gypsum mortar between the bricks made sure no water leaked out.
A palace-like building that looked like an assembly hall for the city government or for people to meet.
Underground drains were built on either side of the roads. They were covered with stones which could be
removed in order to clean them.
The granary was the largest structure in Mohenjo-Daro, and in Harappa there were about six granaries or
storehouses. These were used for storing grain.
The great bath was another important structure in Mohenjo-Daro. The floor of the bath had five layers. There
were changing rooms around. Tar and gypsum mortar between the bricks made sure no water leaked out.
A palace-like building that looked like an assembly hall for the city government or for people to meet.
Underground drains were built on either side of the roads. They were covered with stones which could be
removed in order to clean them.
Harappa
Area of 150 hectares for a population of 23000
Centre of tread with towns raised over mud brick platforms
Citadel mound & lower town surrounded by massive wall
large open areas inside gateway used as market or checkpoint for goods
No division of society is reflected in plan of the city.
Public bldgs., markets, houses & craft workshops are found in the same city.
The granary was the largest structure in Mohenjo-Daro, and in Harappa there were about six granaries or
storehouses. These were used for storing grain.
The great bath was another important structure in Mohenjo-Daro. The floor of the bath had five layers. There
were changing rooms around. Tar and gypsum mortar between the bricks made sure no water leaked out.
A palace-like building that looked like an assembly hall for the city government or for people to meet.
Underground drains were built on either side of the roads. They were covered with stones which could be
removed in order to clean them.
Vedic Age
Indus valley culture collapsed due to various reasons such as drying up of rivers, floods or Aryan invasion around
2000 BC
New agricultural settlements came up in the Gangetic plain during Vedic age
These settlements slowly evolved as towns or ‘Nagara’ references in Vedic hymns about architecture & planning
of towns.
Traditional Vedic towns had temple as focal point- where the sacred & secular mingle
Layout of towns in Vedic age was ideally based on social hierarchy of caste system.
Can be seen in traditional temple towns like Madura, Sree Rangam etc.
Several treatises were developed during Vedic period for planning of towns such as:
Sthapatya Vedas as part of Atharva Veda-layout of a city
smriti sasthra- street layouts
Vaastu sasthra- on Architecture,planning,construction and design of bldgs., site selection, water sources, planting
trees
Arthasathra- governanace & environmental management
Manasara silpa sasthra- Grama vidhana & Nagara vidhana
Mayamata
Viswakarma
Medieval
Medieval period in India was a transitional time and it was not possible under the unstable political conditions for
the planned and systematic urban growth.
Only fortress towns under the patronage of chieftains and petty rulers could grow.
Towns along the main routes of travel, and by the river-side had trade in food grains, cloth, swords, carpets,
perfumes and several other handicraft articles.
Small urban centres was the ‘rule’, and only capitals were having busy life. Jaunpur was the capital city under the
rule of Firozshah.
It was only under the rule of Akbar that the disturbed urban life was reconstituted and redeveloped. All centres –
‘dasturs’ (districts) as well as ‘parganas’ (tehsils) beside capitals in nature were also ‘garrison towns’ where
armies were invariably stationed for protection.
Medieval towns, whether in India or anywhere else, were walled, encircled by an outside moat. The town
resembled “an island when its gates were locked at sundown”.
Medieval town site was usually governed by physically significant terrain; it was either on a hill flanked on the
other side by a water body, or it was guarded by a ring of mounds.
Medieval town used to have its first nucleus often as a fortress of walled property of a landlord, its internal roads
being controlled to connect the market place lying directly before the gate of the castle or place of worship.
Nucleus of the town was “the stage on which were enacted the daily drama of buying and selling, religious
pageant, tournament and procession”.
Urban centres of the medieval times were surrounded by agricultural land, and farmers and labourers commonly
were having their dwellings near or outside the town limit. The areas within the walls of a town near its bound
were occupied by artisan castes engaged in handicrafts.
TOWN PLANNING IN SHAHJAHANABAD
SPATIAL STRUCTURE
Urban spatial structure of Shahjahanabad was different from that of the other Mughal Capitals, because it was
planned and built by one concentrated planning effort.
Creation of architectural expression of what has often been called the patrimonial system in its climax.
The shurafaur ignited from the qasbah garrison posts & admn. settlements in which
Islamic scholars also met their clients & where an integrative or even syncretists cultured prevailed –usually
established around a tomb or a waqf.
The shurafa usually were situated to the west of the place, along one of the two boulevards at Chandni Chowk, &
originated from the employer’s palace, thus furnishing the city with an unequivocal structure.
Those professional groups delivering fresh agrarian products to the city must have settled along the southern and
south‐south‐western rim of the city walls (Delhi gate & Turkman gate): this is where institutions, such as Masjid
gadarion (shephered’s mosque), Masjid Kasai (butcher’s mosque) were located. They all represent “low ranking
traders”.
The closer to the core of the city the more socially recognized are the professional settled there: weavers,
producers of wool, traders of saddle‐ horses, oil‐ extractors & manufacturers of straw goods, each of them
represented by their respective mosques.
PLANNING OF SAHAJAHANABAD
The city was planned according to Hindu planning principles of shilpashastra from vastushastra.
The site was placed on a high land as in the Shastra and was karmukha or bow shaped, for this ensured its
prosperity.
The arm of the archer was Chandni Chowk.
The string was Yamuna River.
The junction of the two main axes is the most auspicious point in the whole region and was therefore the red
fort.
THE CITY FORM‐ MORPHOLOGY ELEMENTS:-
The urban infrastructure was laid out in a geometric pattern.
Shows traces of both Persian and Hindu traditions of town planning and architecture with the Persian influence
largely accounting for the formalism and symmetry of the palaces gardens and boulevards
STREETS
The streets in Mughal capital were usually narrow and crooked.
However, the major streets in the new capital were designed as wide and straight.
The Fort was visible from any place on the street. This perspective view marked a new concept of town planning
for the Mughal capital.
Chandni Chowk is 1.4km in length and jogged right at the Fatehpuri Begum Mosque.
It was built as the central axis of the city.
CITY WALLS
The layout o the city walls was based on a geometrical planning; i.e. to say, a polygonal plan with gateways.
The four main gates were Delhi Darwaza on south, the Ajmeri Darwaza on the south-west, the Lahori Darwaza on
the west and the Kashmiri Darwaza on the north.
These important gates were positioned according to the basic network of the city, being laced on the cardinal
points.
The graphic representation of the city was indicated geometric planning and the geometric placement of the
main gates.
Colonial
Planning and architecture was used in Indian port cities to express power and authority, by examining the two largest Indian
port cities; Bombay and Madras throughout the colonial period.
The earliest planning activity on the shorelines of India can be seen in the defence work carried out in the 17th century.
Of all the early architectural activities in the port cities, defence was undoubtedly of paramount importance surrounded as the
cities were by the hostile local powers on the one hand and by European rivals on the other
As Port towns became more established, they encapsulated the sheer essence of the British Empire, by creating spaces of
imported knowledge, technology and economic investment, while exporting goods to British consumers and expanding trade
networks into the hinterland
As a reflection of imperial thought in regards to the role of British planners and architects in the development of India’s port
cities, it is clear that infrastructure networks were pivotal in providing a healthy economic foundation in which trade and
commerce could thrive.
Installations and services that signalled power, scale and value of city – or harbour – output. To make these water stations
productive, states, cities and businesses invested in docks, quays, canals, railroads and locks
Although there were initial problems with the relative success of port building in Madras there were several successful
attempts at creating the basis for an enclosed dock by 1910, featuring various expansions after this period.
As in Bombay there was also simultaneous network infrastructure built, “linking Madras docks directly to Bombay and Calcutta
by 1856.”
The ports infrastructure was so successful that from 1881 to 1910 registered port cargo grew from 0.5 million tonnes 1 million
tonnes
Commercial planning was not the only factor in the British expression of power, as “it was always essential to make visible
Britain’s imperial position as ruler, for these structures were charged with the explicit purpose of representing empire itself
British colonial planning took a different approach come the turn of the 20th century, where it can be argued that the
articulation of British power was exercised to an intrusive extent.
This took the form of slum clearance, in addition to road widening and social housing blocks for labourers.
the most common town planning activity falls under Road improvements, slum clearance and housing, examples of which are
Bombay, Calcutta, Madras, Lagos and Singapore
Organized efforts for town planning started during British period in late 19th century.
During 1890 s city of Bombay was hit by a series of epidemics like cholera, malaria & plague due to existing unhygienic
congested living conditions.
1898, The Bombay Improvement Act was passed recognizing the connection between disease transmissions and overcrowding
Bombay improvement trust was created in 1898 with the goal of improving the city.
In 1911 Calcutta improvement Act was passed & Calcutta improvement trust was created
The Municipal Act of 1920 created municipal bodies to provide municipal services & civic amenities to towns.
Modern
A prosperous town is normally situated along a sea or river coast.
India was the centre – piece of the British Empire on account of – limit less material resources, insatiable
markets, and enormous man power resource.
These attributes funded Britain industrialisation making India- the Jewel in the Crown.
Both the architectural style for British buildings in India and town planning ideas were imported from British.
THE FIRST HILL STATIONS:-
As in the case of cantonments, hill stations were a distinctive feature of colonial urban development.
The founding and settling of hill stations was initially connected with the needs of the British army.
Shimla (present-day Shimla) was founded during the course of the Gurkha War (1815-16); the Anglo-Maratha
War of 1818 led to British interest in Mount Abu; and Darjeeling was wrested from the rulers of Sikkim sin 1835.
Hill stations became strategic places for billeting troops, guarding frontiers and launching campaigns against
enemy rulers.
The temperate and cool climate of the Indian hills was seen as an advantage, particularly since the British
associated hot weather with epidemics.
Cholera and malaria were particularly feared and attempts were made to protect the army from these diseases.
The overwhelming presence of the army made these stations a new kind of cantonment in the hills.
These hill stations were also developed as sanitariums, i.e., places where soldiers could be sent for rest and
recovery from illnesses.
Hill stations were important for the colonial economy.
With the setting up of tea and coffee plantations in the adjoining areas, an influx of immigrant labour from the
plains began.
This meant that hill stations no longer remained exclusive racial enclaves for Europeans in India.
• The whole range of human settlements is a system of 5 elements: nature, anthropos (man), society, shells( buildings), and
networks.
The five principles of Ekistics
• According to Doxiadis “In shaping his settlements, man has always acted in obedience to five principles”.
• Maximization of man’s potential contacts with the elements of nature (such as water and trees), with other people, and with
the works of man (such as buildings and roads).
• Minimization of the effort required for the achievement of man's actual and potential contacts. He always gives his structures
the shape, or selects the route, that requires the minimum effort.
• Optimization of man's protective space, which means the selection of such a distance from other persons, animals, or objects
that he can keep his contacts with them (first principle) without any kind of sensory or psychological discomfort.
Ekistics logarithmic scale- ELS
• Doxiadis introduced a Logarithmic scale that is composed of 15 ekistics units for explaining different scales of human
settlements.
• The scale division is such that the basic or the elementary unit of the scale is the man himself.
• The units then combine and the collection of those units according to the population size develops into a hierarchy of the units.
• Doxiadis’book Action for human settlements (p. 186, 1976) explains the ideal future ekistics units which were calculated by him
till the year 2100.
According to Doxiadis
• study of human settlements should be comprehensive and should have an interdisciplinary scope related to 5 ekistics
elements.
• Any study of human settlements shall refer to ekistics units of scale from man to ecumenopolis, the 15 levels in ekistics
logarithmic scale.
• Time dimension must be integrated in analysis and design of human settlements from past to present to distant future.
• The city must be treated as a dynamic settlement for which the concept of Dynapolis allows for growth & change.
Lewis Mumford
He was an American historian, sociologist, philosopher of technology, and literary critic, who analysed the effect
of technology and urbanisation on human societies throughout history.
• Mumford taught at a number of prestigious universities & served as the architectural critic for The New Yorker magazine for
over 30 years.
• A lifelong opponent of large-scale public works, much of his writings concern the effect of buildings on the human condition
and the environment.
• His 1961 book, ‘The City in History’, received the National Book Award.
• Lewis Mumford is recognized as one of the greatest Urbanists of the 20th Century.
• A key idea, introduced in Technics and Civilization (1934) was that technology was twofold:
• Polytechnic, which enlists many different modes of technology, providing a complex framework to solve human problems.
• Monotechnic, which is technology only for its own sake, which oppresses humanity as it moves along its own trajectory.
• Mumford commonly criticized modern America's transportation networks as being "monotechnic" in their reliance on cars.
• Automobiles become obstacles for other modes of transportation, such as walking , bicycle and public transit, because the
roads they use consume so much space and are such a danger to people.
Three epochs of civilization
• Discussed in ‘Technics & civilisation’ is Mumford's division of human civilization into three distinct epochs (following concepts
originated by Patrick Geddes):
1. Eotechnic (the middle ages)
2. Paleotechnic (the time of the industrial revolution) and
3. Neotechnic (later, present-day)
• One of the better-known studies of Mumford is of the way the Mechanical clock was developed by monks in the Middle ages
as the key invention of the whole Industrial Revolution contrary to the common view of the steam engine holding the prime
position.
Urban civilization
• The city in History won the 1962 U.S. National Book Award for Non- fiction.
• In this influential book Mumford explored the development of urban civilizations.
• Harshly critical of urban sprawl, Mumford argues that the structure of modern cities is partially responsible for many social
problems seen in western society.
• Mumford argues that urban planning should emphasize an organic relationship between people and their living spaces
• Mumford uses the example of the medieval city as the basis for the "ideal city," and claims that the modern city is too close to
the Roman city (the sprawling megalopolis) which ended in collapse; if the modern city carries on in the same vein, Mumford
argues, then it will meet the same fate as the Roman city.
• The suburb served as an asylum for the preservation of illusion. Here domesticity could prosper, oblivious of the pervasive
regimentation beyond. This was not merely a child-centered environment; it was based on a childish view of the world, in
which reality was sacrificed to the pleasure principle.
• Mumford also had an influence on the American environmental movement. His work contains "some of the earliest and finest
thinking on Bio-regionalism, anti-nuclearism, biodiversity, alternate energy paths, ecological urban planning and appropriate
technology.
•
Le Corbusier
LE CORBUSIER’S CONTRIBUTION TO TOWN PLANNING
CIAM
LA VILLE CONTEMPORAINE (CONCENTRIC CITY) – PLAN VOISIN
LINEAR INDUSTRIAL CITY
LA VILLE RADIUSE (RADIANT CITY)
CHANDIGARH
CIAM 1928
The organization was hugely influential. It was not only engaged in formalizing the architectural principles of the Modern Movement, but
also saw architecture as an economic and political tool that could be used to improve the world through the design of buildings and
through urban planning.
It affirmed that town planning is the organization of functions of collective life – this applies to both rural and urban settlements
Four functions of any settlement
• dwelling
• work
• recreation
• Transportation, which connects the first three with one another.
• Le Corbusier organized in CIAM, Assembly of Constructors for an Architectural Renewal (ASCORAL) which systematically studied
the problems of construction, architecture and city planning.
• It resulted in the publication of ‘The Three Human Establishments’. The examination of working conditions in a mechanistic
society led to the recognition of the utility and necessity of three unit establishments indispensable for human activity :
• The Farming unit – the cooperative village : a unit for agricultural production
• The linear industrial city
• The radio concentric city ‐ same as Radiant city (Ville Radieuse) for the exchange of goods and services.(modifications of la ville
contemporaine)
LA VILLE CONTEMPORAINE(CONCENTRIC CITY) 1922
City for 3 million people was proposed by Le Corbusier in 1922, which was based on four principles:
• Decongestion of the centre of the cities
• Augmentation of the density
• Enlargement of the means of circulation
• Increase in the number of parks and open spaces
THREE ZONES
• CENTRAL CITY
• PROTECTED GREEN BELT
• FACTORIES & SATELLITE TOWNS
CENTRAL CITY
• Rectangle containing two cross axial highways
• At its heart was a six‐level transport interchange – centre for motor, rail lines (underground and main‐line railways) and roof of
which is airfield
• 24 cruciform skyscrapers ‐ 60 storeyed office building with density 1200 ppa and covers 5% of the ground
• Surrounding skyscrapers was apartment district – 8 storey buildings arranged in zigzag rows with broad open spaces with
density of 120 ppa
• The buildings in the central area were raised on stilts (pilotis) so as to leave panoramas of unbroken greenery at ground level
• The general impression was more of a city in a park than of a parkland in the city
• The city espoused space, speed, mass production and efficient organisation, but also offered combination of natural and urban
environments
PLAN VOISIN 1925
• Le Corbusier reworked certain elements of the Ville Contemporaine & applied to a section of Paris
• 18 double cruciform 60 – storey skyscrapers, placed in an orthogonal street grid and park‐like green space
• three clusters of luxury apartments
• Heavy traffic would proceed at basement level
• lighter traffic at ground level
• fast traffic should flow along limited‐access arterial roads that supplied rapid and unobstructed cross‐city movement
• Pedestrianised streets, wholly separate from vehicular traffic and placed at a raised level.
• The number of existing streets would be diminished by two‐thirds due to the new arrangements of housing, leisure facilities
and workplaces, with same‐level crossing points eliminated wherever possible.
Clarence Stein.
Walking distance radius is one mile.
In the figure A, elementary school is the centre of the unit and within a one half mile radius of all residents in the
neighbourhood, local shopping centres located near the school.
Residential streets are suggested as CUL‐DE‐SACS to eliminate through traffic and park space flows into the neighbourhood
RADBURN’s planning
1929 Radburn Created
25000 people
149 acres
430 single houses
90 row houses
Factors that influenced
Rapid Industrialisation after World War I
Migration of Rural to Cities
Dramatic growth of Cities
Housing Shortage
The need to provide housing and protect from motorised traffic
SEPARATION of pedestrian and vehicular traffic
SUPER BLOCK large block surrounded by main roads
houses grouped around small CUL ‐DE SACS accessed from main road, Living, Bedroom faced gardens & parks, service areas to
ACCESS ROADS
remaining land ‐ PARK AREAS
WALKWAYS ‐ designed such that pedestrians can reach social places without crossing automobile street
FINANCIAL PLANNING
Parks without additional cost from Residents
Savings from minimising roads ‐ requires less road area
25% less area gave 12‐ 15% of total park area
Module II
Need for Town Planning: Impact of Urbanisation on cities, Urban Environmental Problems- Land Use, Traffic and Road
Network, Urban Land use- CBD, Urban Nodes, fringe areas and suburbs, Urban Rural Continuum. Contemporary urban
problems- growth and changes, overcrowding, slums, sporadic growth and conurbation. Need for sustainable city planning.
Town Planning:
PLAN:
Means ‘a physical representation of something like a map’ it also means’ a method to do something.
PLANNING:
Means the process of making a plan to achieve or do something.
It is the process of thinking about and organizing the activities required to achieve a desired goal.
The process of setting goals, developing strategies, and outlining tasks and schedules to accomplish the goals.
Town planning
The physical, social & economic planning of an urban area.
It is a process concerned with use of land & design of urban environment.
Is the integration of land use & transportation planning to improve the social, economic & built environment of communities.
Known by different names such as city planning, urban planning, Town & Country planning or Urban & Regional planning.
Spatial planning scale ranges from preparation of Regional plans, metropolitan plans, urban plans, zonal plans, area
development plans.
PLANNING PROCESS
1. IDENTIFICATION & DEFINITION OF PROBLEM
2. DEFINING THE OBJECTIVES
3. DATA COLLECTION- Studies & Surveys
4. DATA ANALYSIS
5. FORECASTING
6. DESIGN
7. FIXING THE PRIORITIES
8. IMPLEMENTATION
9. REVIEW, EVALUATION & FEEDBACK
Need for Town Planning
Defective road system resulting in the formation of narrow streets and lanes.
development of slums and squatter settlements;
Haphazard location of industries;
Heavy traffic congestion during the working hours of the day;
Inadequate open spaces for parks and playgrounds resulting in unhealthy living conditions;
Lack of essential amenities like electricity, water supply and drainage;
Noisy atmosphere disturbing the peace of city dwellers;
Uncontrolled development of the town
Unhealthy living conditions; etc
HEALTH: to create a healthy & safe living environment for all, through land use regulations, zoning controls, infrastructural improvement.
CONVINIENCE: providing social, economic, cultural & recreational amenities for improving the socio-economic conditions.
AESTHETICS: to preserve or create a character or aesthetics of the town through building regulations, character guidelines etc.
The health implications of these environmental problems include respiratory infections and other infectious and parasitic diseases. Capital
costs for building improved environmental infrastructure — for example, investments in a cleaner public transportation system such as a
subway — and for building more hospitals and clinics are higher in cities, where wages exceed those paid in rural areas. And urban land
prices are much higher because of the competition for space. But not all urban areas have the same kinds of environmental conditions or
health problems. Some research suggests that indicators of health problems, such as rates of infant mortality, are higher in cities that are
growing rapidly than in those where growth is slower.
People who live in urban areas have very different consumption patterns than residents in rural areas.10 For example, urban populations
consume much more food, energy, and durable goods than rural populations. In China during the 1970s, the urban populations consumed
more than twice as much pork as the rural populations who were raising the pigs.11 With economic development, the difference in
consumption declined as the rural populations ate better diets. But even a decade later, urban populations had 60 percent more pork in
their diets than rural populations. The increasing consumption of meat is a sign of growing affluence in Beijing; in India where many urban
residents are vegetarians, greater prosperity is seen in higher consumption of milk.
Urban populations not only consume more food, but they also consume more durable goods. In the early 1990s, Chinese households in
urban areas were two times more likely to have a TV, eight times more likely to have a washing machine, and 25 times more likely to have
a refrigerator than rural households.12 This increased consumption is a function of urban labor markets, wages, and household structure.
Energy consumption for electricity, transportation, cooking, and heating is much higher in urban areas than in rural villages. For example,
urban populations have many more cars than rural populations per capita. Almost all of the cars in the world in the 1930s were in the
United States. Today we have a car for every two people in the United States. If that became the norm, in 2050 there would be 5.3 billion
cars in the world, all using energy.13
In China the per capita consumption of coal in towns and cities is over three times the consumption in rural areas.14 Comparisons of
changes in world energy consumption per capita and GNP show that the two are positively correlated but may not change at the same
rate.15 As countries move from using non-commercial forms of energy to commercial forms, the relative price of energy increases.
Economies, therefore, often become more efficient as they develop because of advances in technology and changes in consumption
behavior. The urbanization of the world's populations, however, will increase aggregate energy use, despite efficiencies and new
technologies. And the increased consumption of energy is likely to have deleterious environmental effects.
Urban consumption of energy helps create heat islands that can change local weather patterns and weather downwind from the heat
islands. The heat island phenomenon is created because cities radiate heat back into the atmosphere at a rate 15 percent to 30 percent
less than rural areas. The combination of the increased energy consumption and difference in albedo (radiation) means that cities are
warmer than rural areas (0.6 to 1.3 C).16 And these heat islands become traps for atmospheric pollutants. Cloudiness and fog occur with
greater frequency. Precipitation is 5 percent to 10 percent higher in cities; thunderstorms and hailstorms are much more frequent, but
snow days in cities are less common.
Urbanization also affects the broader regional environments. Regions downwind from large industrial complexes also see increases in the
amount of precipitation, air pollution, and the number of days with thunderstorms.17 Urban areas affect not only the weather patterns,
but also the runoff patterns for water. Urban areas generally generate more rain, but they reduce the infiltration of water and lower the
water tables. This means that runoff occurs more rapidly with greater peak flows. Flood volumes increase, as do floods and water
pollution downstream.
Many of the effects of urban areas on the environment are not necessarily linear. Bigger urban areas do not always create more
environmental problems. And small urban areas can cause large problems. Much of what determines the extent of the environmental
impacts is how the urban populations behave — their consumption and living patterns — not just how large they are.
Land Use and Traffic
Road Network
Urban road system
• Results into free flow of traffic with safety
• The urban roads play an important role in development of town
• They attract many evils such as heavy traffic congestion, ribbon development ...etc.
• The efficiency of an urban area is greatly influenced by the urban infrastructure of roads together with public services.
Objects of urban roads
• To facilitate communication of men and materials between the various centres of the town
• To provide space for laying the public utility services like water mains, drainage pipes, electric cable, telephone lines, etc.
Requirements of a good city road
• It should accommodate amenities such as shady avenues, parking places, enough lighting, etc.
• It should afford safety to the vehicles and pedestrians by provision of measures such as footpaths, traffic signs, etc.
• It should be cheap and durable
• It should have good alignment and visibility
• It should possess easy gradients and smooth curves
• It should possess well designed junctions
• It should remain in dry condition
• Its overall performance should be such that congestion of traffic is brought down to the minimum possible extent
• Its wearing surface should be impervious and impermeable to the rain water
Classification of urban roads
• Arterial roads: The road which connects the town to a state highway or a national high way is termed as an a arterial road.it
passes within the city limit and carries great masses of traffic between different parts of the town. Arterial roads include ring
roads, by-pass roads.etc.they allow free movement of fast traffic.
• Sub-arterial roads (secondary or major roads); within city limits and they connect important town centres.
• Local roads(minor roads); They collect traffic from various parts of the town and lead it to another minor road or major roads
• Streets
• pathways
Urban Land use
Concepts related to Land use:
Reversible uses: cases when the inherent feature and characteristics of the land have not been considerably altered such that soil horizon,
landform and structure remain intact so that the land can be reverted to its former use.
Multiple land uses: combining different land uses, whether reversible or irreversible, in an orderly and desirable pattern because:
• Land is finite and supply is fine.
• Demand is ever increasing.
• Competition is there.
• Land can indeed have more than one use and uses can be combined in different ways.
Compatible and incompatible land uses: A related concept of multiple uses of land is the compatibility of uses. Some land uses
are innately incompatible while others are completely compatible.
Comprehensive land use planning: A document embodying specific proposals for guiding, regulating growth and development
of a city or municipality.
• Commercial Land Use
• Residential Land Use
• Industrial Land Use
• Institutional Land Use
• Recreation Land Use
• Transport Land Use
Three key theories
Burgess – Concentric Zone
Hoyt – Sector Model
Harris and Ullman – Multiple Nuclei
1945
As an urban area grows, it develops around a number of different business centres or nuclei
Assumptions
Modern cities more complex than suggested by other theorists
Each nucleus acts as a growth point
Growth occurs outwards from each nucleus, until they all merge into one large urban area
• The agglomeration of activity area around one or more (adjacent) road junctions which act as commercial centre of a local body
is termed here as a node.
• The node need not be confined fully within a local body area and in most of the cases its service area goes beyond the
boundary of the local body within which it locates.
• In certain cases the nodes may be located at the meeting point of the boundary of one or two local bodies.
• This means that the nodes have an entity independent of the local body area and necessitates a separate study other than the
settlement study.
• The hierarchy of the nodes is determined by the extent of activity taking place there.
• The number and type of shops , the number of people using the node, the business turn over , the extent of traffic activity
taking place there all determines the extent of activity taking place there and hence the hierarchy of nodes.
• But extensive survey and study are required to assess all these factors.
• Whereas it can be seen that the extent of development in a node is directly proportional to the hierarchy of the roads meeting
at a node.
• Here an attempt is made to determine the hierarchy of the nodes based on the hierarchy of roads meeting at the node.
The concept
• The hierarchy of the activity nodes is the sum of the hierarchy value of all the junctions containing the node.
• The hierarchy of a junction is directly proportional to the hierarchy and the number of the roads meeting at the junction
Fringe areas
FRINGE is defined as relation to the city and exists in agriculture hinterland (area around or beyond a major town) where land use is
changing.
URBAN FRINGE is an area that situates between urban and rural system. It’s the most sensitive, dynamic and swiftly changing area during
the urbanization process
Rural urban fringe
The area where the country side meets the city
Very edge of the city beyond the suburbs
Business/retail parks, out of town shopping centres and housing developments
Advantage of cheap land & room for expansion
Availability of parking space
Little pollution
Better accessibility
Suburbs
A suburb is an area of a town or city, a little away from the main part, where there are fewer big buildings and
mainly houses, schools and shops.
These are called suburbs or 'the suburbs'. Sometimes, the suburbs cover a very large area. The suburbs are part of
the metropolitan area and may be legally part of the main city, or not.
• By end of 19th century increasing congestion increased chaos in cities
• High land cost in urban areas
• Skyscrapers
• Building higher for more light was creating only deeper shadows
• Problem of under privileged increased, social welfare had to be expanded, and more of income tax had to be directed to charity
• Movement to suburbs was motivated by growing search for a desirable environment. As density in central areas increased
people searched for opportunities to forsake centres for suburbs
• A protest was uprising against the dull environment of the industrial metropolis.
• by end of 19th century decentralisation was in process
• Outskirt communities developed like dependent or satellite communities.
• Only rich could now afford low-density single family housing in the healthy environment of rural areas
• In North America, the grid-iron system offered the most convenient pattern. It helped in further sub-division and real estate
business
• Suburbs were not planned in those days, they simply grew at edges of growing metropolis.
• Some street, walls, sewers, water and gas distribution were provided, but as they were annexed to metropolitan municipalities,
they found extension of adequate services very costly.
• Hence, legislation was enacted to require sub-division to make certain improvements as a condition to approval of
development.
• These suburban expansions were encouraged by growing urban population, but they did not draw off the excess population
from city centres.
A suburb is a residential area, either existing as part of a city or urban area or as a separate residential community within
commuting distance of a city
Some suburbs have a degree of administrative autonomy, and most have lower population densities than inner city
neighbourhoods.
Suburbs first emerged on a large scale in the 19th and 20th centuries as a result of improved rail and road transport, which led
to an increase in commuting
Reasons for Growth of the Suburbs
Better public transport and increased car ownership meant people could separate work from where they live.
Building societies provided mortgages making it easier to buy homes
People were better off and looking for a better living environment.
SUBURBANIZATION
Movement of upper and middle-class people from core areas to surrounding outskirts.
The process began in the mid-nineteenth century but became a mass phenomenon in the late-twentieth century.
Urban Rural Continuum.
• Rural- urban continuum, the merging of town and country, a term used in recognition of the fact that in general there is rarely,
either physically or socially, a sharp division, a clearly marked boundary between the two, with one part of the population
wholly urban, the other wholly rural.
• Continuum means continuity.
• By rural-urban continuum is meant: continuity from village to the city”.
• One end of this continuous scale is the village, the other is the city.
• Both these social formations are in ceaseless interaction.
• That is the reason why the villagers show the profound impact of the city life on them & certain cultural traits from villages are
developed in cities.
• The continuum also shows that the development is from the village to the city.
• Overtime, villages are transformed into towns & cities.
• Robert Redfield has made an important contribution to develop the folk, rural & urban continuum.
• He has constructed a continuum from small rural village to large cities.
• More urban means that population is more secular, more individualistic & with a greater division of labour.
• The spread of modern industrial traits has decreased.
• Considerably the differences between the 2 is not visible.
• Thus invisible rural & urban cultural boundaries have made it difficult to draw a line of distinction.
• Hence, the marginal areas show amalgamation & continuation of cultural traits of both the societies.
• In India, during last 3 decades the development of transport & road communication has connected the remote tribal areas,
villages &b urban centres rapidly with a very short period of time.
• New occupations, transportation, educational institutions, have attracted the people of rural areas.
Causes of rural-urban continuum:
• Migration has been thought to be the biggest factor contributing to rural-urban continuum & thus formation of such
settlements.
• The cities are the biggest service providers in an area.
• Hence these act like nuclei & pull unemployed people towards the city.
• Houses come up only on major traffic corridors.
• This is because surface transport provided by public transport services of the city is cheap & affordable.
• Politics too has a role to play in the process of diminishing rural urban difference of characteristics.
• Vole bank in any part of the world is very essential.
• In order to sustain a large vote-bank, local political leaders with the help of some local goons, arrange utility services for the
area from nowhere else but the city.
• This catalyses the process of erasing the clear demarcation of urban & rural areas.
• The development of extensive road networks around major cities & cheap means of transport (buses, motorcycles, bicycles)
allows people to live in the rural areas & to commutate on a daily basis to the city for work.
• As a result, increasing number of people find temporary or permanent urban employment in the urban areas, while living or at
least being registered to live in a rural area.
Overcrowding, slums,
Sporadic growth
The expansive and rapid spreading outwards of a metropolitan area (and its suburb) to outskirts and low-density rural lands.
Characterized by:
single-use zoning
reliance on automobiles
homogeneity in design
low-density land use
Facilitators of Urban Sprawl
Automobiles
Governmental single-use zoning laws
Accessible mortgages
Housing subsidies
Urban Sprawl (sporadic growth)
• Urban sprawl is basically another word for urbanization.
• It refers to the migration of a population from populated towns and cities to low density residential development over more
and more rural land.
• The end result is the spreading of a city and its suburbs over more and more rural land.
• In other words, urban sprawl is defined as low density residential and commercial development on undeveloped land.
Causes of Urban Sprawl
• Lower Land Rates: Lower cost land and houses in the outer suburbs of the cities, because the centres of urban development
have really made people want to stop settling in these areas and want to venture further out.
• Improved Infrastructure: There is increased spending on certain types of infrastructures, including roads and electricity. This is
something that hasn’t always been available, and there are still some areas that don’t have these luxuries. That doesn’t mean
that they aren’t working on it.
• Rise in Standard of Living: There are also increases in standards of living and average family incomes, which means that people
have the ability to pay more to travel and commute longer distances to work and back home.
• Lack of Urban Planning; People love to find areas that are less trafficked and more calm, which leads them to sprawl out to
other sections of the town.
• Lower House Tax Rates
• Rise in Population Growth
• Consumer Preferences: People in high income groups have stronger preferences towards larger homes, more bedrooms, bigger
balconies and bigger lawns.
Effects of Urban Sprawl
• Increase in Public Expenditure
• Increased Traffic
• Health Issues:
• Environmental Issues
• Impact on Social Lives: When people move further out, they also have an impact on their social lives.
Effects of Urban Sprawls Economically
Taxes are risen (bad for the people good for the government)
The cost for transport is higher
Higher cost for providing infrastructure
More people are buying vehicles
Effects of Urban Sprawls Socially
Providing homes for immigrant
Students who need housing
Overcrowded schools
Spatial diversities between the upper or middle class
Effects of Urban Sprawls Environmentally
Take away rural areas so less trees and more urban/suburban areas
More cars which pollutes the air. This also affects people’s health.
The air in rural areas are known to be much cleaner because there is less polluted air than in the urban areas.
Conurbation.
• The term "conurbation" was coined in 1915 by Patrick Geddes in his book Cities In Evolution.
• Internationally, the term "urban agglomeration" is often used to convey a similar meaning to "conurbation".
• A conurbation is a region comprising a number of cities, large towns, and other urban areas that, through population growth
and physical expansion, have merged to form one continuous urban and industrially developed area.
• In most cases, a conurbation is a polycentric urban agglomeration, in which transportation has developed to link areas to create
a single urban labour market or travel to work area.
• The term is used in North America, a metropolitan area can be defined by the Census Bureau or it may consist of a central city
and its suburbs, while a conurbation consists of adjacent metropolitan areas that are connected with one another by
urbanization.
Examples of Conurbation
NEW YORK
• The expansive concept of the New York metropolitan area (the Tri-State Region) centred on New York City, including 30
counties spread between New York State, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Pennsylvania, with an estimated population of
21,961,994 in 2007.
• Approximately one-fifteenth of all U.S. residents live in the Greater New York City area.
• This conurbation is the result of several central cities whose urban areas have merged.
INDIA
• Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR) is a metropolitan area consisting of the metropolis of Mumbai and its satellite towns.
Developing over a period of about 20 years, it consists of seven municipal corporations and fifteen smaller municipal councils.
• The region has an area of 4,355 km² and with a population of 20,998,395, it is among the top ten most populated urban
agglomeration in the world.
• It is linked with Mumbai through the Mumbai Suburban Railway system and a large network of roads.
Need for sustainable city planning.
The term sustainable development goes beyond the boundaries of science and business development and trade to include
human development, values and differences in cultures.
Unlike traditional community development approaches, sustainability strategies emphasize:
The whole community (instead of just disadvantaged neighbourhoods)
Ecosystem protection
Meaningful and broad-based citizen participation and
Economic self-reliance
The Sustainable Cities Program:
A joint UN-HABITAT/UNEP facility established in early 1990s for building capacities in urban environmental planning and
management.
It contributes to promoting urban environmental governance processes as a basis for achieving sustainable urban growth and
development.
Chennai is the only city participating in SCP in South Asia and is funded by UNDP.
In these terms sustainable planning
Links knowledge and action: connectedness
Improves the humanized and natural environments
Holds out for useful interconnections
Focuses on the future
Honours cycles: seasons, life patterns, highs and lows
Designs artfully and redesigns thoughtfully
Balances socio-economic-environmental outcomes
Engages in a participatory style of decision-making
Works for diversity and variety of outcome
‘Works around’ rather than ‘pushing through’.
Sustainable development is not a fixed state of harmony, but rather a process of change in which the exploitation of resources,
the direction of investments, the orientation of technological development, and institutional change are made consistent with
future as well as present needs.
We do not pretend that the process is easy or straightforward. Painful choices have to be made.
Thus, in the final analysis, sustainable development must rest on political will.’
Key features of sustainable cities
• Resources and services in the city are accessible to all.
• Public transport is seen as a viable alternative to cars.
• Public transport is safe and reliable.
• Walking and cycling is safe.
• Areas of open space are safe, accessible and enjoyable.
• Wherever possible, renewable resources are used instead of non-renewable resources.
• Waste is seen as a resource and is recycled wherever possible.
• New homes are energy efficient.
• There is access to affordable housing.
• Community links are strong and communities work together to deal with issues such as crime and security.
• Cultural and social amenities are accessible to all.
• Inward investment is made to the CBD.
Module III
Urban Development Planning system and process: Understanding planning as a multi-level comprehensive process of
development through local, urban, rural, regional and national planning- Perspective Plan, Development Plan, Annual Plan,
Plan Schemes and Projects. Introduction to surveying and analytical techniques including household survey, local area
surveys, land-use surveys, landscape survey, transportation surveys and service survey.
Development plan is a statutory plan prepared within the framework of the approved perspective plan, approved and adopted
by the local authority and its proposals are precise and definite with an implementation strategy and evaluation criteria.
The objective of a development plan is to provide further necessary details and intended actions in the form of strategies and
physical proposals for various policies given in the perspective plan depending upon the economic and social needs and
aspiration of the people, available resources and priorities.
The approved development plan allows the local authority to implement the development of the land area with the help of
schemes and projects.
Development plan ‘notifies the property owners the manner in which their properties will be affected’
The time frame of the existing Development Plans is for a period of 20 years by most of the urban development authorities/ULB
These plans should be in phases of 5 years to coincide with the State Five Year plans
Both Development plans and Master plans have the same functions and impose similar controls. Hence, the two are to be
understood as similar plans with variation in the use of nomenclatures by State Governments.
Annual Plan
The purpose of Annual plan, to be prepared by the local authority every year, is to identify the new schemes/projects, which
the authority will undertake for implementation during the year taking in to account the physical performance of the preceding
year, the priorities, the policies and the proposals contained in the approved development plan.
This plan also provides the resource requirements during the year and the source of funds including those mobilised by the
local authority, grants, aids and project funds of the state and central governments.
It is thus an important document for resource mobilization as on its basis the plan funds will be allocated by the funding body.
This plan therefore serves as an important link with the budgetary process.
The annual plan provides a built in system of continuous annual review of the performance, actions and initiatives of local
authority in implementing development plan.
An Annual Plan would contain the details of the new and ongoing projects that the local authority intends to implement during
each financial year for necessary financial resource mobilisation.
The annual plan is to be prepared by the local authority every year to identify the new projects, which the authority will
undertake for implementation during the year, taking into account the physical and fiscal performance of the preceding year,
the priorities, the policies and proposals contained in the approved Regional Plan, Development Plan or Local Area Plan.
It is an important document for the resource mobilisation as on the basis of this, the plan funds are to be allocated by the
funding body.
This plan, therefore, serves as an important link with the budgetary process.
Annual plan should contain:
The physical target set;
The status at the end of the annual plan and the level of physical performance by percentage of target achieved;
The allocations made;
The money spent and level of fiscal performance by percentage of money spent.
Plan Schemes and Projects
Definition:
Conceived within the framework of approved Development plan or Annual plan, these are detailed working layouts with all supporting
infrastructure and documents including cost of development, source of finance and recovery instruments for their execution by a public or
private agency.
Conceived within the framework of the perspective plan, development plan or any of the plans in the planning system, projects
are the working layouts with all supporting infrastructure and documents including cost, source of fund and recovery providing
all necessary details for execution including finance, development, administrative and management.
These projects could be for any area, old or new; any activity or land use like residential, commercial, industrial, recreational,
educational or health related; or infrastructure development, separately or in an integrated manner
Inter-relationships among various plans
A Perspective Plan is formulation of development strategy generally at the State level or at the regional level
This is detailed further in Regional Plan or Sub Regional Plan as the case may be and in Development Plan.
Regional Plans are to be prepared at district and metropolitan region level, and where economic regions are formulated.
The Development Plan shall provide policies and development proposals, which are detailed in the local area plan to a greater
scale.
City Development Plan, Comprehensive Mobility Plan, City Sanitation Plan, Slum Redevelopment Plan, Disaster Management
Plan are to be formulated- areas which require special plan within the framework of the development plan
Project reports and Annual plans are necessary requirements of the planning system.
These can be prepared for implementation of plans following any of the above mentioned stages.
Introduction to surveying and analytical techniques including household survey, local area
surveys, land-use surveys, landscape survey, transportation surveys and service survey.
TYPES OF SURVEYS
1. REGIONAL SURVEYS
PHYSICAL FACTORS like topography, physically difficult land, geology, landscape etc.
PHYSICAL ECONOMIC FACTORS like agricultural value of the land, mineral resources and water gathering lands, areas with
public services, transportation linkages etc.
SOCIAL ECONOMIC FACTORS like areas of influence of towns and villages, employment, population changes etc
2. TOWN SURVEYS
done at much small scale and apart from the above data collected from the regional surveys it also includes
LANDUSE SURVEYS, DENSITY SURVEYS, SURVEYS FOR THE AGE AND CONDITION OF THE BUILDINGS, TRAFFIC SURVEYS, OTHER
SOCIAL SURVEYS
SURVEYING TECHNIQUES
SELF SURVEYS - mailing questionnaires to the persons to be surveyed
INTERVIEWS - by asking questions to the people to be surveyed
DIRECT INSPECTION - when the surveyor himself inspects the situations concerned
OBSERVERS PARTICIPATION - when the observer himself participate in acquiring the data required
SCALES FOR STRUCTURING QUESTIONNAIRE
NOMINAL where there is no ordering, like asking of sex, age, employment in any particular service etc.
ORDINAL where there is a specific order of choices like asking of priorities, housing conditions, climate etc.
INTERVAL where an interval of time is given importance like time taken to shift from LIG housing to MIG housing, time interval
to change from two wheelers to four wheelers etc. this provides an yardstick of measurements
SELECTION OF SAMPLES
For varied expected responses - larger sample size is required.
Larger the total population, smaller the percentage of the population are required to be surveyed.
TYPES OF SAMPLES
SIMPLE RANDOM SAMPLING - selecting samples at random without any criteria to select the samples
SYSTEMATIC SAMPLING -selection of the Kth element y along a particular street, where k can be any number
STRATIFIED SAMPLING - making of a homogenous listing of the different sects of the population and collecting a certain
percentage at random from each sect
CLUSTERED SAMPLING - when samples are selected from clusters and not from a homogeneous listing
Household survey
Social Survey
Population
1. Trends in population growth for last 40 to 50 years
2. Characteristics of present population
3. Future growth of population considering rural migration, development of new industries
4. Demographic survey ie, classification of population by sex, literacy of different age groups
5. Distribution and density of population in the town
Housing
1. Housing condition
2. Density of accommodation
3. Height of the buildings
4. Materials used for construction
5. Tenancy status; rented or owned
Community facilities
1. Education – schools, colleges, institutions and libraries
2. Health – hospitals, dispensaries, clinics
3. Recreational – parks, playfields, clubs, theatres, stadiums, boating, etc.
4. Others – museums, historical and religious buildings
Local area surveys,
Socio economic survey
The type of survey conducted at local level for re-development scheme, slum improvement scheme and Master Plan is
different from town survey.
Here house to house survey is conducted for this purpose which is the foundation stone of planning structure.
It is from this survey that the town planner can make a correct diagnosis of various ills from which the town is suffering and
prescribe the correct remedies for their cure.
It is therefore like the diagnostic approach enumerated by Patrick Geddes.
It covers a vast field, hence a mere list would be sufficient to know its wide scope.
Physical features
Geological structure: showing the arrangement of underlying rocks and their formation
Contours showing variations of ground surface
Rainfall and wind charts
Rivers, flood ranges, tides
Communications
Roads with traffic details, widths, tree planting
Railways
Waterways, canals, rivers
Airways, indicating aerodrome sites
Accessibility by different ways and time and distances.
Traffic problems
Type of roads
Traffic congestion; its causes
Remedies for traffic congestion
Traffic control.
Land-use surveys
LAND USE – by land use is meant the use of land or plot specified in town. These are classified as:
1. Residential – for living purposes like houses, hostels, lodging, etc
2. Commercial – workshops, mills, factories
3. Public and semi-public – govt & semi govt. offices, schools, colleges, libraries, hospitals, museums, assembly halls, shrines,
historical monuments, etc.
Landscape survey
Physical survey
Open Spaces – parks, playgrounds, stadiums, race-course etc.
Landscape survey
1. Types of country
2. Landscape features
3. Soils and vegetation
4. Disfigurement
Transportation surveys
Transportation –
1. Road, their widths, tree planting, medians
2. Railways – level crossings, goods yards
3. Airports and seaports
4. Waterways and canals
Agriculture – cultivated land, nurseries, orchards, etc.
Water sheets – rivers, lakes, tank
Vacant – barren land
Other uses – refuse disposal areas, cemeteries, grave-yards, area under defence, etc.
Service survey
Water supply – industrial purpose, domestic purpose, source of supply, capacity per capita consumption
Drainage and sewerage system – disposal system
Electricity – source, supply
Telephone
Fire protection
Street lighting
Module IV
Need for town planning legislation: Different town planning acts- Role of development authorities- Role of town planning
departments, Role of local bodies in the implementation of town plan. Land Acquisition Act. 74th Amendment Act. Coastal
Regulation Zones and its relevance. SEZ, JNNURM. Land use Plan Tools for land use control -Zoning regulations, building
byelaws, Subdivision regulations, Plot reconstitution, Betterment Tax.
Under the constitution, the State Governments are the competent authorities for enacting legislation relating to Town and
Country Planning Act.
Hence Central Govt. has not enacted any legislation on these subjects so far except the Model Town Planning Act.
But the Land Acquisition Act, Urban Land Ceiling Act etc. have been enacted by the Central Government.
Role of development authorities
preparation and implementation of land re-adjustment or land pooling or land banking schemes for the purpose of
implementation of projects in the Development Authority area
promoting planned development is envisaged in the Plans for the Development Authority area
co-ordination of implementation of Plans under this Act in the Development Authority area
Role of town planning departments
Top prepare development schemes for urban local bodies and urbanised grama panchayats
To prepare master plan for urban local bodies
To prepare development schemes for transportation, parking, recreation and sustainable human habitat
To prepare development schemes for availing fund from central govt
The Act has a provision of preparation of Master Plan for all Village Panchayats and Municipalities of Kerala and thus it will
check the so called development of ‘rurban’, ‘periurban’ ‘suburban’ ‘urban fringe’, etc.
When a Planning Unit exceeded the limit of the Local Government (LSG) area, there is provision of Joint Planning Committee
similar to DPC/MPC in this Act.
The Act also provides for the constitution of Development Authority but not entrusted with any planning functions. Its function
is limited to land re-adjustment, land pooling, land banking, Transfer of Development Rights, Accommodation Reservation, etc
and a special purpose vehicle for implementing high end projects.
Role of local bodies in the implementation of town plan
The role of Department of Town and Country Planning is limited to technical assistance to the DPC/LSGI with respect to spatial
planning only.
Constitution the District Planning Committee has “to consolidate the plans prepared by the Panchayats and the Municipalities
in the district and to prepare a draft development plan for the district as a whole.
Constitution the Metropolitan Planning Committee to prepare development plan for a metropolitan region
Village Panchayat/Municipality (of Kerala) is considered as the basic planning unit of Kerala in this Act.
State town & country planning board
Constitution of state town & country planning board as the apex authority for spatial planning in the state. This has the
following functions:
Advise the govt. regarding matters related to policy formulation, development of rural and urban land in the state.
Advise DPC & MPC regarding matters related to spatial planning.
Co-ordinate, monitor & evaluate various spatial planning & development activities under different govt. departments, quasi-
govt. agencies and LSGs.
Preparation, publication & sanctioning of state perspective plan
Department of Town and Country Planning
The Department with chief town planner as the head of the department has the following functions:
Advise & render technical assistance to govt. in matters related to spatial planning& implementation of relevant central & state
programmes
Advise & render technical assistance to state town & country planning board, DPC, MPC, Development authorities, joint
planning committees, & LSGs in executing their functions related to spatial planning.
Advise & render technical assistance in scrutinizing various plans prepared
Prepare & get prepared Master plans & DTP schemes in the event of default by any planning agency or if directed by govt.
Provide required research input /studies for preparation of policies, strategies, norms, standards & bye- laws, rules, guidelines
for govt.
Provide man power training facilities related to spatial planning.
Perform any other functions related to spatial planning as directed by govt.
District Planning Committee
Prepare development plan for a district as a whole which shall comprise of long term perspective plan and short term
execution plans.
To be done in consultation with LSGs, all govt. departments with technical help from dept. of town & country planning.
Formulate goals, objectives, policies & priorities related to rural & urban areas of district
Advise Government and Local Self Government Institutions on identification of probable location of major investment inputs
which are likely to have substantial impact on the development scenario of the Districvstate.
Metropolitan Planning Committee
Formulate development goals, objectives, policies and priorities in matters relating to planning, development and use of rural
and urban land in the metropolitan area
District Planning Committees will not have jurisdiction over such Metropolitan Area.
Prepare or get prepared, a long term Perspective Plan & 5 year Execution Plans, for the Metropolitan Area,
Consult non-governmental institutions, organizations, and professional bodies, if deemed necessary, in the preparation of
Perspective Plan and Execution Plan for the Metropolitan Area
co-ordinate planning and development activities among the Government Departments, Quasi-Government agencies within the
metropolitan area
formulate policies and identify projects for integrated development of metropolitan area level infrastructure and facilitate
their implementation through public, private or joint sector participation
monitor continuously the physical achievements of the investments made by the various Local Self Government Institutions
and Quasi-Government agencies within the metropolitan are
Sort-out matters relating to sharing of physical and natural resources within the Metropolitan Area.
Panchayat/Municipality
Municipal Corporation, Municipal Council, Town Panchayat or Village Panchayat shall have the following additional functions:
Prepare or get prepared for the Local Planning Area or part there of a master plan and execution plans
Implement all or any of the provisions contained in the Plans under this Act by formulating and executing Projects, Land Pooling
Schernes, Detailed Town Planning Schemes or otherwise
Promote, regulate and control land use and developmental activities in the Local Planning Area as per the Plans under this Act
set-up special function agencies, if necessary for specific functions such as plan preparation, implementation of projects and
guide, direct and assist such agencies on matters pertaining to their respective functions; and
Land Acquisition Act
Compulsory acquisition of land needed for purposes of Regional Plan, Development plan or town planning scheme, etc.:-
Any land required, reserved or designated in a Regional plan, Development plan or town planning scheme for a public purpose
or purposes including plans for any area of comprehensive development or for any new town shall be deemed to be land
needed for a public purpose within the meaning of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (I of 1894). 126.
Acquisition of land required for public purposes specified in plans:- (1) When after the publication of a draft Regional Plan, a
Development or any other plan or town planning scheme, any land is required or reserved for any of the public purposes
specified in any plan or scheme under this Act at any time the Planning Authority, Development Authority, or as the case may
be, 1[any Appropriate Authority may, except as otherwise provided in section 113A] 2[acquire the land,-
(a) By an agreement by paying an amount agreed to, or
(b) In lieu of any such amount, by granting the land-owner or the lessee, subject, however, to the lessee paying the lessor or depositing
with the Planning Authority, Development Authority or Appropriate Authority, as the case may be, for payment to the lessor, an amount
equivalent to the value of the lessor's interest to be determined by any of the said Authorities concerned on the basis of the principles laid
down in the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, Floor Space Index (FSI) or Transferable Development Rights (TDR) against the area of land
surrendered free of cost and free from all encumbrances, and also further additional Floor Space Index or Transferable Development
Rights against the development or construction of the amenity on the surrendered land at his cost, as the Final Development Control
Regulations prepared in this behalf provide, or
(c) By making an application to the State Government for acquiring such land under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894,
Though in India, we have had decentralized system of political setup, the new lease of life is given to local bodies after the enactment of
74th CAA in 1992.
The Govt. of India in 1992 took note of the recommendations of the V. K. Rao committee (1985) and L. M. Singhvi committee (1986) and
the result was a decision to amend the Constitution of India in 1992 by introducing the 73rd and 74th amendments which paved the way
for the present decentralized planning and administration at the grass root level of rural and urban local bodies respectively.
In 1992 -73 rd. & 74 Th constitutional amendment act was promulgated-provision for decentralized planning process, more function &
including spatial planning to LSGs like panchayat, municipality & Municipal Corporation
73 rd. & 74 Th CAA, 1992 was a major landmark
3 tier system of panchayat raj,
Constitutional status to municipalities,
Formulation of DPCs &
Spatial planning responsibility to local bodies.
Coastal Regulation Zones and its relevance (CRZ)
The following activities have been declared prohibited under the CRZ notifications:
Setting up of new industries and expansion of existing industries with some exception,
Manufacture or handling oil storage or disposal of hazardous substance, with some exception,
Setting up and expansion of fish processing units including warehousing except hatchery and natural fish drying in permitted
areas
Land reclamation, bunding or disturbing the natural course of seawater with some exception,
Setting up and expansion of units or mechanism for disposal of wastes and effluents
Discharge of untreated waste and effluents from industries, cities or towns and other human settlements.
Dumping of city or town wastes including construction debris, industrial solid waste,
Port and harbour projects in high eroding stretches of the coast, except those projects classified as strategic and defence
Reclamation for commercial purposes such as shopping and housing complexes, hotels and entertainment activities.
Mining of sand, rocks and other sub‐strata materials.
Drawl of groundwater and construction related thereto, within 200mts of HTL with some exception
Coastal Regulation Zone, abbreviated to CRZ, refers to the coastal stretches of India and the water area up to its territorial
water limit, excluding the islands of Andaman and Nicobar and Lakshadweep and the marine areas surrounding these islands
up to its territorial limit where the setting up and expansion of any industry, operations or processes and manufacture or
handling or storage or disposal of hazardous substances as specified in the Hazardous Substances (Handling, Management and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2009 is prohibited.
Coastal regulation zone is the boundary from the high tide line upto 500m towards the land-ward side and the land between
the low tide line and high tide line.
In the case of rivers, creeks and backwaters, the distance from the high tide level shall apply to both sides and this distance shall not be
less than 100 meters or the width of the creek, river or backwater whichever is less.( Ministry of Environment and Forests Notification
Category - I (CRZ I): Areas that are ecologically sensitive and important such as national parks , marine parks , sanctuaries ,
reserve forests , wildlife habitats , mangroves, corals/coral reefs , areas close to breeding and spawning grounds of fish and
other marine life, areas of outstanding natural beauty. historically important and heritage areas, area rich in genetic diversity,
areas likely to be inundated due to rise in sea level consequent upon global warming and such other areas as notified by
government from time to time .
Category - II (CRZ II): Area that have already been developed up to or close to the shoreline. For this purpose, developed area is
referred to as area within the municipal limits or other legally designated urban areas which is already substantially build up
and which has been provided with drainage and approach roads and other infrastructure facilities such as water supply and
sewerage lines.
Category - III (CRZ III): Area that are relatively undisturbed and those which do not belong to either I or II. These will
include coastal zone in the rural areas developed or undeveloped and also areas within municipal limits or in other legally
designated urban areas which are not substantially built up.
CRZ-1 these are ecologically sensitive areas these are essential in maintaining ecosystem of the coast. They lie between low and high tide
line. Exploration of natural gas and extraction of salt are permitted
CRZ-2 these areas form up to the shore line of the coast. Authorised structures are not allowed to construct in this zone
CRZ-3 rural and urban localities which fall outside the 1 and 2. Only certain activities related to agriculture even some public facilities are
allowed in this zone
CRZ-4 this lies in aquatic area up to territorial limits. Fishing and allied activities are permitted in this zone. Solid waste should be let off in
this zone.
SEZ
The Act provides for drastic simplification of procedures and for single window clearance on matters relating to central as well as state
governments for generating additional economic activity; promoting exports of goods and services, investment for domestic and foreign
sources; creating employment opportunities; and developing infrastructure facilities. Single Window SEZ approval mechanism is provided
through a 19 member inter-ministerial SEZ Board of Approval (BoA)**. The Board of Approval is the apex body. The powers & function of
BoA is granting of approvals, rejecting or modifying proposals submitted for establishment of Special Economic Zones and provision of
infrastructure. Once approved the Central Government notifies the area of the SEZ and units are allowed to be set up in the SEZ. Each SEZ
is headed by a Development Commissioner.
The first SEZ creation proposal came from Gujarat State to set up SEZ in Kandla. Subsequently, the proposal came from other states of
India.
As many as 439 SEZs have been approved in principle out of which 198 have been notified till 8 March, 2008.The highest approval were
accorded to state of Maharashtra followed by Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu Most of these are located in coastal areas where
transportation and other supporting infrastructure facilities are available for export processing.
As can be seen from the details of the 439 SEZs in India, the smaller ones costitutes major proportion of SEZs. 19 SEZs have area more than
1000 hectares and covering more than half of the total area under SEZs. Only 26 SEZs have area between 200 and 500 hectares.
Betterment Tax.
Similarly some owners of the property will be benefited by the proposed town planning schemes. The share of increase in values of the
properties of such owners to be paid to the planning authority is known as betterment tax
Betterment levies are a form of tax or a fee levied on land that has gained in value because of public infrastructure
investments. They are considered the most direct form of value capture
For instance, if building roads, metros or airports with public money leads to an appreciation in land prices in the vicinity of
these projects, then landowners enjoy a windfall gain.
Most States mandate levy of betterment tax at the time of granting development permission under the respective Town
Planning Laws.
The procedure for arriving at the amount for betterment tax is as follows:
The value of the property before the notification of tow planning scheme is worked out
The value of the property on the completion of the town planning scheme is estimated.
Difference between the two will be the unearned increase in value of the property due to the scheme.
And the betterment tax will be finalized – the owner and the planning authority share this. ie, the owner has to surrender 50%
of increase in value of his property in the form of betterment.
The important provision in town planning act regarding betterment are as follows:
• The list of properties put to Betterment shall be published with notification and the same notices are given to the respective
owners and their objections, if any, are invited
• The maximum Betterment contribution shall be 50% of the increase in the value of the property resulting from the execution of
the development scheme.
• The value of the Betterment will be fixed only after the scheme is completed.
• In case of dispute, the owners of the property can refer to the court or tribunal whose decision will be final.