Hurth
Hurth
Distingui
Domain 1: Planning and Preparation shed Comments
3 Becca worked with a select group of students
1a Demonstrating Knowledge of Content and Pedagogy 1 2 3 4
during intervention time, so there was little
2 variation to the lesson or accommodations. The
1b Demonstrating Knowledge of Students 1 2 3 4
outcomes were appropriate to the task but could
2 have been broken out a bit more. The outcomes
1c Setting Instructional Outcomes 1 2 3 4
basically restated the standard although in
2 teaching she incorporated a number of formative
1d Demonstrating Knowledge of Resources 1 2 3 4
benchmarks and skills. i.e. eliciting and
3 connecting to prior knowledge/personal
1e Designing Coherent Instruction 1 2 3 4
experience and quality of penmanship)
2
1f Designing Student Assessments 1 2 3 4
Domain 3: Instruction
3 Becca made skillful use of questioning and
3a Communicating with Students 1 2 3 4
engagement. She encouraged students to share
3 their thinking and helped them assess their
3b Using Questioning and Discussion Techniques 1 2 3 4
work, guiding individuals with hints as needed
4 and prompting others to expand their thinking.
3c Engaging Students in Learning 1 2 3 4
The lesson was very specifically designed for
3 this small group, so there was no real need for
3d Using Assessment in Instruction 1 2 3 4
flexibility or adjustment.
x
3e Demonstrating Flexibility and Responsiveness 1 2 3 4
Notes:
River City Scholars is an urban school with a high percentage of students who have traumatic
backgrounds. Many students have behavioral and academic challenges related to this. It is imperative
that teachers establish trust with the students through consistency and genuine affection. Becca has
integrated wonderfully into this setting. Her handling of the students is calm, consistent and respectful.
She shows genuine interest in their comments and stories. Her disciplinary style is gentle and effective.
She maintains composure in the face of challenge and redirects in such a way that behavior issues do
not escalate and student learning is not disrupted. She utilizes both positive reinforcement and
accountability reminders. The lesson started with the whole class sharing good news. Students
followed the routine respectfully and with little prompting. They then split into designated intervention
groups. Becca designed and led a reading lesson with 5 students. She started with a visual hook to
elicit prior knowledge and personalize the content for each student. She led them in the ‘I can’
statement and challenged them to explain it so that they weren’t just reciting an irrelevant outcome. As
they worked through the lesson, Becca set benchmarks and differentiated her support of students to
reach them. Some worked without help, some got hints (look for 7 instances) others she helped to
count out and finish the work. Great use of formative assessment in that students and teacher both
were actively engaged in the assessment and learning. Some students were also encouraged to
expand their thinking with evidence while others stopped at just identifying the main topic. Students
also got to display their knowledge orally, in writing and visually with a drawing.
What specific suggestions can you offer for this student's growth?
When creating your lessons, be more detailed in the outcomes (the how & why). You did a great job of
incorporating those elements in the lesson, but if you have them detailed in your lesson plan, it will help
you recognize specific trouble areas as they arise.
Also, don’t forget the little things. For example, spacing of words. You and the students were assessing
that in their writing, (fantastic!) but it wasn’t in the outcomes. Sometimes these things seem obvious so
we don’t add them, but as you get into more complex lessons it helps you keep tabs on them.
Additional Comments:
Here’s a link to a chart of Bloom’s taxonomy verbs. There are a ton of these out there. I always find it
useful to refer to when writing up those outcomes. This one is aligned with higher order thinking skills
so I thought it would support how you use that language with the kids.