Assessing Windows Server Licensing PDF
Assessing Windows Server Licensing PDF
The Software Usage Tracker, a tool in the Microsoft® Assessment and Planning (MAP) Toolkit, collects and
reports server and client use of common deployment scenarios for Windows Server Standard, Windows Server
Enterprise, and Windows Server Datacenter. Using the data from this tool, in conjunction with the step-by-step
instructions on the pages that follow, can help you calculate the number and type of server licenses or
processor licenses, and Client Access Licenses (CALs) that you need.
Terms of Use
Microsoft is providing this document to support the MAP Toolkit. This document is for informational purposes only and is subject to
change. It cannot be considered a source of definitive Microsoft licensing guidance.
It does not supersede or replace your use rights to any product as defined in the Microsoft Volume Licensing agreement under
which it was acquired, and/or the Microsoft Volume Licensing Product List document and the Microsoft Volume Licensing Product
Use Rights (PUR). Product licensing, program licensing, and business rules are subject to change.
Contents
Windows Server Licensing Requirements ........................................................................................ 1
Server or Processor Licensing ....................................................................................................................... 1
Client Access Licensing ................................................................................................................................. 2
CAL exceptions ....................................................................................................................................... 3
Other CAL options ................................................................................................................................... 3
External Connector license ............................................................................................................... 3
Remote Desktop Services license .................................................................................................... 4
Rights Management Services license............................................................................................... 4
CALs for Windows Server 2003 R2 and Windows Server 2008 R2 ................................................. 4
CAL Suites ........................................................................................................................................ 5
Licensing for Common Windows Server Use Cases ...................................................................................... 5
Stand-alone Windows Server .................................................................................................................. 5
Commercial hosting ................................................................................................................................. 5
Web Server.............................................................................................................................................. 6
Application Server ................................................................................................................................... 6
Consolidation server roles ....................................................................................................................... 6
How to Assess Your Licensing Requirements ................................................................................. 7
Step 1 Setting Up Your MAP Scan ................................................................................................................. 7
Guidelines for a more accurate usage count ........................................................................................... 8
Step 2 Generating a Windows Server License Report ................................................................................... 8
Step 3 Counting Your Server or Processor Licenses ................................................................................... 10
Count server licenses: basic method ..................................................................................................... 10
Count server or processor licenses: advanced method ........................................................................ 11
Count virtual machines ................................................................................................................... 11
Calculate your Windows Server Standard licenses ........................................................................ 13
Calculate your Windows Server Enterprise licenses ...................................................................... 13
Calculate your Windows Server Datacenter licenses ..................................................................... 14
Step 4 Counting Your CALs ......................................................................................................................... 16
Get MAP usage data and convert to a CAL count ................................................................................. 16
Make manual adjustments ..................................................................................................................... 17
References .......................................................................................................................................... 18
Windows Server Licensing Requirements
Accessing Windows Server software requires two licenses:
■ Per-server model. A server license entitles you to run one instance of Windows Server on a given server.
A running instance is defined as loading Windows Server into memory and executing one or more of its
instructions.
■ Per-processor model. A processor license entitles you to run Windows Server on a given processor.
Each server will have one or more processors.
Windows Server software may run only on a licensed server. Once a license has been assigned to a server, it
allows running one or more instances of any physical or virtual operating system environment (OSE) on that
server. Each edition of Windows Server includes the right to run a specific number of software instances on
each server. The difference between the server and processor model is significant when the Windows®
operating system runs more than once on a server using virtualization technology.
Enterprise Server One physical and four virtual instances on a single physical server. (When you run
the four virtual instances concurrently, the physical instance may only be used to
manage and serve the virtual instances. Each additional four instances requires
another Windows Server Enterprise license.)
1
You may reassign a Windows Server Volume License to another server once every 90 days. However, you
may not reassign an OEM Windows Server license unless you first acquire Software Assurance for it. On the
other hand, you may move a virtual instance of the server software to another server that is properly licensed to
support it as often as you want. To track this, Microsoft recommends that you keep a current record of all
assigned servers, license type, SA coverage, and the date they were assigned or reassigned.
For more information on virtualization, please refer to Licensing Microsoft Server Products in Virtual
Environments.
Windows Server CALs may be licensed by device or by user. You must have a CAL for any user or device that
will access Windows Server even once.
■ Device CAL licenses allow anyone using that device to access servers running Windows Server. A device
CAL makes the most economical and administrative sense for an organization with many users for one
device, such as shift workers who share the same PC to access Windows Server.
■ User CAL licenses allow a person to access servers running Windows Server from any device. If the
number of users is fewer than the number of devices, a user CAL is the most economical choice. It also
makes sense for an organization with employees who access the corporate network from multiple
devices—for example, from a cell phone or a home computer.
■ Unless your Volume Licensing Agreement specifies otherwise, you may mix device and user CALs in a
single environment, but you must assign individual CALs to either a device or a user. However, mixing user
and device CALs adds complexity to license management, so Microsoft generally recommends against it.
■ CALs may not be reassigned to another user or device more than once every 90 days.
■ A Windows Server CAL gives a user or device the right to access any edition of Windows Server of the
same or earlier version. (You cannot use an earlier-version CAL to access a later-version server.)
■ Your Windows Server CALs are valid only for your servers; they do not license access to the Windows
Server systems of non-affiliated organizations. (Affiliation is defined in your Volume Licensing Agreement.)
2
CAL exceptions
You do not need a CAL to access Windows Server in the situations described below. (The diagram may help
you better understand these exceptions and when you’d need a CAL.)
Note These exceptions apply only to Windows Server CALs. If you are running other server software with
Windows Server that requires its own CAL, the exceptions may not apply to that software’s CAL requirements.
3
■ Window Server External Connector (EC) licenses for each server that external users access both directly
and indirectly. This eliminates the need to manage CALs for external users, and may be cheaper than
individual User CALs if you have many external users.
■ You can acquire a Windows Server EC license in place of CALs for each physical server that external
users access. The EC license applies to the entire server regardless of the number of Windows Server-
based virtual machines running on it.
■ ECs may be reassigned to other servers in the same data center, but unlike server licenses and CALs,
they may be reassigned to other servers as often as needed.
■ You may use an EC license with an earlier version of the server software, provided the version is no earlier
than Windows 2000. Due to technical incompatibility, the Terminal Server and Remote Desktop Services
External Connector licenses cannot be used with earlier versions.
To access RDS in Windows Server, you must acquire both a Windows Server CAL and a Windows Server
Remote Desktop Services CAL for each user or device accessing it.
4
And although you do not need to update your CALs, you do need the R2 versions of Windows Server licenses
to run Windows Server 2003 R2 and Windows Server 2008 R2.
CAL Suites
The Microsoft Core CAL Suite and Microsoft Enterprise CAL Suite include rights that are equivalent to
Windows Server CALs. The Enterprise CAL Suite also includes rights that are equivalent to a RMS CAL. The
version of Windows Server that your CAL suite licenses you to access depends on the last date of Software
Assurance coverage for your CAL suite.
For more information on CAL Suites, please see Licensing the Core CAL Suite and the Enterprise CAL Suite.
■ You must acquire a server license for each Windows Server Standard, Windows Server Enterprise, or
Windows Server Foundation server running the software to perform the specified role. To license Windows
Server Datacenter, you must acquire a processor license for each physical processor in each server
running the software.
■ You cannot license Windows Web Server and Windows Server 2008 for Itanium-Based Systems to serve
these roles. These specialty server products are specifically engineered for Web Services and Application
Server roles, respectively.
■ Any direct or indirect access of Windows Server requires a CAL, except for anonymous access through the
Internet. For example, the use of DNS—a service that helps route network traffic—requires the purchase of
a Windows Server license and CALs to use and access this particular role in managing your organization’s
domain names. Even with infrequent or occasional use, access of Windows Server DNS capabilities
requires a CAL.
Commercial hosting
When you use Windows Server to provide commercial hosting services, you must license it under a Services
Provider License Agreement (SPLA.) The SPLA is for organizations that offer hosted software and services to
end customers, such as web hosting, hosted applications, messaging, collaboration, and platform infrastruc-
ture. If you are charging customers to access your Windows Server, then you must license it under SPLA.
For more information, please see Licensing Options for Services Providers.
5
Web Server
The Web Server role lets you share information with users on the Internet, an intranet, or an extranet. Windows
Server 2008 features Microsoft Internet Information Services (IIS) 7.0. All Windows Server products may run
the Web Server role. A web server using Windows Server 2008 requires a server or processor license,
depending on the edition.
You do not require CALs for an Internet-facing web server if users are accessing it through an Internet
connection and not being uniquely identified or authenticated; External Connectors or CALS are required when
users or devices are individually or uniquely identified. Local network access to a Windows Server system
requires a CAL, anonymous or not.
Application Server
The Application Server role of Windows Server provides an integrated environment for deploying and running
server-based business applications, whether they are Microsoft or third-party applications. An Application
Server using Windows Server 2008 requires server or processor licenses depending on the edition.
Additionally, users or devices accessing an application server require CALs.
When a server is not enabled with the Application Server role but is running Windows Server and Microsoft®
Exchange Server, SQL Server software, or another Microsoft or third-party application, Windows Server license
and CAL requirements still apply.
One additional point of guidance: If you have more server or CAL licenses of a specific application than
Windows Server licenses, then you are probably under-licensed for Windows Server.
For example, both Windows Server 2008 Enterprise and Windows Server 2008 Datacenter can run any number
of virtual instances of the software for various server functions on each licensed physical server. As a result, you
can accomplish the same goals with fewer servers, thus eliminating the need to license each separate server for a
particular role. (You can virtualize with Windows Server 2008 Standard as well, but because you need to
separately license each server instance, you’re only saving on hardware costs.)
Virtualization does not reduce the number of CALs required—the users and devices accessing the Windows
Server software must still be properly licensed. However, if you are using a server only as a hypervisor for a
version of Windows Server earlier than 2008, you need a CAL just for the version of Windows being hosted.
For example, if you are using Windows Server 2008 solely as a hypervisor for Windows Server 2003, then you
only need Windows Server 2003 CALs, even though you are indirectly accessing Windows Server 2008.
For more detailed Windows Server licensing information, please refer to the Volume Licensing Product Use
Rights and the Windows Server 2008 R2 Licensing Guide.
6
How to Assess Your Licensing Requirements
To help you assess licensing requirements for Windows Server 2003, Windows Server 2003 R2, Windows
Server 2008, and Windows Server 2008 R2, Microsoft has developed a Software Usage Tracker. Part of the
Microsoft Assessment and Planning (MAP) Toolkit, it collects and reports server and client use of common
deployments of Windows Server Standard, Windows Server Enterprise, and Windows Server Datacenter.
Look for guidance on assessing licensing requirements for Windows Web Server in the next edition of this
document. MAP has not been tested for use with Windows Server for Itanium-Based Systems and Windows
Server Foundation, so these products are omitted.
In this section, you’ll find step-by-step instructions to help you generate usage reports and explain specifically
how to use them to help determine your Windows Server licensing obligations. You’ll take four broad steps:
Completing this assessment requires network administration expertise and permissions as well as licensing
expertise. If licensing compliance and network administration responsibilities fall to different people in your
organization, they will need to work together to complete this assessment correctly.
Note It is important to understand that the Software Usage Tracker only provides a software usage report; it
does not create a licensing report. And although the guidance offered in this section may be helpful, it is not
definitive. It does not replace or supersede your use rights as legally defined in your PUR document.
2. To configure your MAP deployment, follow the Getting Started Guide and Software Usage Tracker Guide
instructions built into the MAP installation.
7
Guidelines for a more accurate usage count
If licensing compliance falls to others in your organization, you may want to work with them to make sure you
consider the points below in the scan you set up.
Make sure your configuration is complete. MAP only scans usage on servers and network segments
identified during configuration. Incomplete configuration will give you incomplete results.
Make sure your Microsoft Office SharePoint® Servers, Exchange Servers, SQL Servers, and Microsoft System
Center Configuration Manager (SCCM) are all configured according to the installation guide because they also
impact Windows Server CAL counts.
Scan over a time period when your operating system environment is running the maximum number of
servers and virtual machines. MAP only counts servers running at the time it scans. If the number of users
and devices fluctuates seasonally, run the scan in your busiest season.
Scan servers with different license obligations separately. Configure your network scan range to take
licensing variations of products into account. Scan servers with similar licensing together since you’ll apply that
licensing logic to the results. For example, if you scan web, application, and MSDN-licensed servers together,
your data will not be useful.
■ Exclude servers subject to different licensing obligations, like Development or Test servers licensed under
the MSDN® developer program. The Software Usage Tracker Guide explains how to exclude network
segments or specific devices from the scan.
■ Separately scan servers whose Windows Server use tends to be exempt from CAL use to avoid over-
counting your CAL needs. Examples include Microsoft Office SharePoint Server for Internet Sites or
Windows Servers deployed as anonymous web servers.
■ Scan servers with ECs separately, because MAP cannot distinguish use that qualifies for an EC.
Make note of network segments that you exclude due to licensing variations to ensure that you correctly
account for their use later. For example, make sure that you have MSDN licenses for servers licensed under
MSDN programs or ECs where you have Windows Server deployed as an anonymous web server.
2. In the Software Usage Tracker, click Software Usage Summary to see the total number of servers (both
physical and virtual) running each edition of Windows Server for the defined date range of 90 days.
Note To change the date range, click Configure Date Range in the Actions pane.
8
3. Under Software Usage Summary, click Windows Server.
9
4. In the Actions pane, click Generate Report to create a Microsoft Office Excel® spreadsheet for the
servers listed.
The spreadsheet gives a breakdown by edition and version number, and a count of users and devices.
■ The physical host for any server deployment running on a virtual machine.
■ If the server deployment hosts virtual machines running Windows Server, how many it hosts, and the
number simultaneously active.
■ The number of physical processors for any server running or licensed by Windows Server Datacenter.
There are two ways to count server licenses: basic and advanced. Use the basic method if:
■ You know for certain that none of your Windows Server systems are running on virtual machines. (Use of
virtualization technology can reduce the number of licenses you need for some Windows Server editions.)
■ Windows Server Datacenter was not detected in the scan. (it is licensed per processor and the basic
method does not count processors.)
If your environment does not meet these criteria, use the advanced method.
1. In MAP, click View, and then click Saved Reports and Proposals.
2. Open the Windows Server Usage Tracker report (the Excel spreadsheet) that you generated in Step 4
above.
3. The Server Summary tab of the Excel report lists the number of servers discovered of each version and
edition.
For each installation of Windows shown in the report, you need a license of the same or later version of the
same edition.
Example When licensed through Volume Licensing, Windows Server gives you rights to deploy earlier
versions and lower editions. If the Server Summary gave you the information in the example below, you would
need either four Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise licenses, or two Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise
licenses and two Windows Server 2003 Enterprise licenses.
10
Product Editions Architecture Total Servers Discovered
Windows Server 2008 R2 Enterprise Enterprise 64-bit 2
4. Click View, and then click Saved Reports and Proposals to open the VM Report spreadsheet.
– The Host Summary tab shows how many VMs (Guest Machines) each physical server hosts. It
counts both active and inactive VMs, although you only need to count (and license) active VMs.
– The Host and Guest Details tab provides details for each VM running on each server.
11
5. On the Host and Guest Details tab, click any cell within the data table, and press Ctrl + A to select the
whole table.
8. In the Pivot Table Field List, click to check the following fields in this order:
– Physical Server Name
– Physical Server or Management Partition Operating System
– Virtual Machine Status
– Virtual Machine Operating System
12
9. From the Pivot Table Field List, drag Virtual Machine Name into the Values area.
For each physical server shown on the left, you’ll see the number of active and inactive VMs in each
version of the operating system.
Example In the example below, Windows Server 2008 Enterprise is running eight active VMs whose latest
version is Windows Server 2008. If the physical operating system is:
■ Used only as the hypervisor, the license count is 8VMs/4, which means you would need two licenses.
■ Running a workload in addition to hosting the VM, then the license count is 9VMs/4, which, after rounding
up, means you would need three licenses.
C (A – B)=
D How many active VMs do you have? (You need a Standard license for
each VM.)
Although a single Windows Server Enterprise license gives you rights to four VMs, you must deploy all four on
the same physical server. For example, if you have two active VMs on a server licensed with Windows Server
13
Enterprise, you cannot deploy another two VMs on other physical servers using the same Enterprise license;
you would need to acquire another Enterprise license to do so.
C (A + B)/4 =
1. In the VM Report spreadsheet, on the Host and Guest Details tab, click any cell within the data table, and
press Ctrl + A to select the whole table.
4. In the Pivot Table Field List, click to check the Physical Server or Management Partition Operating
System field.
14
5. Click the down arrow and check Windows Server Datacenter (or the edition with which you want to
license Datacenter).
6. Drag the Physical Server or Management Partition Operating System field to the Report Filter area.
8. Drag Physical Server Number of Processors into the Row Labels area.
The numbers under each host name on the left give the number of processors for each physical server
running Windows Server Datacenter. This equals the number of Windows Server Datacenter licenses you
need.
15
Step 4 Counting Your CALs
There are two steps to counting CALs. First you get the usage data from the MAP scan and convert the usage
numbers into a license count. Then you manually correct the license count for situations that MAP cannot track.
Note Check Guidelines for a more accurate usage count to confirm that you’ve done everything you can to
prepare for an accurate scan.
2. The Combined Product Distinct Usage table shows the number of unique users and devices that have
accessed Windows Server-based servers spanning all products configured for 90 days.
CALs can be reassigned every 90 days, so evaluating use over the past 90 days determines how many
CALs you need currently.
3. Click Configure Combined Products to make sure that all the products you have deployed were included
in the combined products count.
If they were not, check all the product names. Clicking Save automatically updates the combined usage
results.
16
2008 CALs for their respective R2 servers. (No version-specific CALs for Windows Server R2 versions
are available.)
Example The Software Usage Tracker automatically discards duplicate entries. So, if person A accesses
Windows Server and SharePoint Server (which also accesses Windows Server) and person B accesses
Window Server and Exchange Server, MAP does not report four users (one for each application access).
Instead, it takes into account users who access more than one server or application so that unique users are
only counted once. In this example then, the Combined Product Distinct Usage reports two Windows Server
users.
Multiple accounts for one user. You need just one User CAL for a user no matter how many accounts he or
she has.
Shared accounts. Two users who access a server running Windows Server through the same account require
two User CALs.
Combined CAL and EC licensing. MAP does not detect combined CAL and EC licensing for client access, so
you must count these manually.
Access between Windows Servers. One server running Windows Server does not need a CAL to access
another, so do not assign Device CALs to Windows Server systems.
Multiplexing. CAL requirements do not distinguish between direct and indirect access to your servers. If your
users access Windows Server indirectly through another server, either as a matter of application design or in
an attempt to reduce CAL licensing costs, you still need Windows Server CALs for those users or their devices.
Enterprise Agreements. If you have signed a platform Enterprise Agreement or Open Value Company-Wide
Agreement, you must acquire Windows Server CALs company-wide. See your agreement for the details.
17
References
■ Microsoft Assessment and Planning toolkit: microsoft.com/map
18
Licensing Management Series
This guide is one in a series of five in-depth “how-to” guides that can help you generate and interpret MAP
Toolkit Software Usage Tracker reports that you can use to calculate the number of server licenses and CALs
you need.
Refer to the Guidance for MAP Toolkit Software Usage Tracker1 page to download the other four guides:
This document is for informational purposes only. MICROSOFT MAKES NO WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, IN THIS
DOCUMENT. This information is provided to help guide your authorized use of products you license; it is not your agreement. Your
use of products licensed under your Volume Licensing agreement is governed by the terms and conditions of that agreement. In the
case of any conflict between this information and your agreement, the terms and conditions of your agreement control. Prices for
licenses acquired through Microsoft resellers are determined by the reseller.
1
microsoft.com/sam/en/us/briefs.aspx
19