Wear Debris Analysis

1/5/2018 Wear debris Analysis
This is the html version of the file http://mdl.mech.upatras.gr/index.php/el/component/attachments/download/210.

Google automatically generates html versions of documents as we crawl the web.
Page 1
2009
TRACKING AND POSITIONING OF MOBILE SYSTEMS IN
TELECOMMUNICATION NETWORKS
http://techalone.com
[Techalone]
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://mdl.mech.upatras.gr/index.php/el/component/attachments/download/210&gws_r… 1/29
[Wear Debris Analysis]

Since the world’s resources of material and energy are getting progressively, by necessity, there is growing involvement in
studies of wear on a global basis. Wear of sliding components result in reduced mechanical efficiency and an irretrievable loss of
material in the form of wear debris. Wear at the interface between moving particles is a normal characteristic of machine
operation.
Page 2
Wear Debris Analysis
INTRODUCTION
Since the world’s resources of material and energy are getting progressively, by necessity, there
is growing involvement in studies of wear on a global basis. Wear of sliding components result in
reduced mechanical efficiency and an irretrievable loss of material in the form of wear debris. Wear at
the interface between moving particles is a normal characteristic of machine operation. The kind and
rate of wear depend on the machine type. Lubrication is provided between the moving surface to
minimize the wear but during operations millions minute wear particles entering the lubricating oil.
These particles are in suspension in the oil, larger particles may be trapped by filter while others
generally too small to be removed, remain in suspension in the circulating oil.
Condition based monitoring has, in the past, been referred to as an art, when quite clearly it is a
science, and despites the cost of machine, surprisingly little attention has been devoted to this science
from the viewpoint of understanding and modeling failure mechanisms and the study of probability to
failure. Predictive maintenance technique has now become common exercises as they maximize the
machine availability time and minimize the cost of maintenance, since the machine can be stopped just
before as impending problem in an other wise healthy machine
Fault detection using vibration analysis is difficult in very low speed – high load noisy machines.
In the case of slow speed bearing the vibration generated by damaged components is very low, usually
close to the floor noise and difficult to identify. In these situations, Wear Debris Analysis has proven
useful in providing supporting evidence on the bearing or gear status. It also provides information on
the wear mechanism, which is involved.
Mechanical Engineering | Physics Seminar topic from http://techalone.com Page 2
Page 3
WEAR MECHANISMS AND PARTICLES
Sliding adhesive wear particles are found in most lubricating oils. They are an indication of
normal wear. They are produced in large numbers when one metal surface moves across another. The
particles are seen as thin asymmetrical flakes of metals with highly polished surfaces.
Cutting abrasive wear produces another particle type. These particles resemble most of all
shavings from a metal shop. E.g.: Spiral, loops and threads.
These presences of a few of these particles are not significant, but if there are several hundred,
it is an indication of serious cutting wear. A sudden dramatic increase in the quantity of cutting particles
indicates that the break down is imminent.
SURFACE FATIGUE
Page 4
A consequence of periodic stresses with very high local tension in the surface, which occurs,
with the meshing of years. These wear mechanisms give plate particles a rough surface and an irregular
perimeter. Small particles often develop in connection with roller bearings. Refer table 1.
NATURE OF WEAR DEBRIS ASSOCOATED

TYPE OF COMPONENT TYPICAL EXAMPLE
WITH FAILURE
Loaded, moving components in Rolling bearings, gear Ferrous particles of various size and shapes
which load is concentrated in a non teeth, cams and
confirmed contact tappets
Loaded, moving components in Piston rings and Ferrous flakes less than 150 m across, and
which load is concentrated in a small cylinders splines, gear fine iron or iron oxide particles
area couplings
Loaded, moving components with Plain bearings, Usually very small and ferrous and non-
the load spread over a large area pistons and cylinders ferrous flakes and particles, bearing fatigue
can give rise to larger flakes
WEAR METALS
Wear metals are caused by the relative motion between metallic parts. The motion is
accompanied by friction and wear on the surfaces, which are in contact with one another. The metal
particles are rubbed off due to friction and enter the lubricating oil, the degree of wear can be evaluated
as being normal or abnormal. The wear metals have the same chemical composition as the components
from which they come, and type of wear metal can provide information on which part being worn.
Increased quantities of iron are common, since many parts are composed of iron, while an increase in
Page 5
content of less common metals such as silver can often indicate precisely which component is being
worn abnormally.
The size and shape of wear material will differentiate between the following wear mechanisms.
►Rubbing
►Surface Fatigue
►Corrosion
►Sliding
►Cutting
The particle material will pin point to the source and therefore deteriorating component-
wearing race, rolling element or cage, rubbing scales, gear teeth etc.
Spheres
SPHERES
Spherical particles can be heat generated if there is insufficient lubrication or there is a
depletion of extreme pressure additives in high load or high stress conditions. Spheres are also
produced by fatigue (cavitation erosion) of rolling element bearings. Fatigue spherical particles formed
Page 6
within bearing fatigue cracks range in size from 1 to 10 microns. A marked increase in spherical particles
indicates possible equipment distress.
Dark Metallo-Oxides
These particles are also heat generated and may indicate lubricant starvation. They appear
as darkened, rough particles in varying degrees of oxidation, in contrast to rubbing wear platelets
which appear in silver/grey shades
Wear Particles
For systems, which operate normally, wear metals are produces at constant rate. This rate is the
same for all normally operating systems of the same type.
The theoretical curve showing the concentration of wear metals as a function of time for a close
system without oil consumption is shown in figure.
Page 7
TYPES OF WEAR PARTICLES
There are six basic particles type generated through the wear process. These include ferrous and
non-ferrous particles and comprise of:
1. Normal Rubbing Wear
Rubbing wear particles are generated because of normal sliding wear in a machine and result
from exploitation of particles of the shear mixed layer. Rubbing wear particles consists of flat platelets,
generally 5 microns or smaller, although they might range up to 15 microns depending upon equipment
associations. There should be little or no visible texturing of the surface and thickness should be 1
micron or less
2. Cutting Wear Particles
Cutting wear particles are generated as result of one surface penetrating another. There are two
ways of generating this effect.
Page 8
• A relatively hard component can become misaligned or fractured resulting in hard, sharp edge
penetrating a soft surface. The particle generated this way is coarse and large, averaging 2-5 microns
wide and 25-100 microns long.
• Hard abrasive particles in the lubrication, either as contaminants such as sand or wear debris from
another part of this system, may become embedded in soft wear surface(two body abrasion) such as
Lead/Tin alloy bearing. The abrasive particles protrude from the soft wear surface and penetrating the
opposing wear surface. The maximum size of cutting wear particles generated in this way is proportional
to the size of abrasive particles in the lubricant. Very fine wire-like particles can be generated with
thickness as low as 25 microns.
Cutting wear particles are abnormal. Their presence and quantity should be carefully monitored. If the
majority of the cutting particles in a system are a few micrometers long and a fraction of a micrometers
wide the presence of particulate contaminants should be suspected. If a system shows increased
quantity of large (50 microns long) cutting wear particles, a component failure is potentially imminent.
3. Spherical Particles
These particles are generated in the bearing cracks. If generates their presence gives an
improved warning of impending trouble as they are detectable before any spalling occurs. Rolling
fatigue generates few spheres over 5 microns in diameter while the sphere generated by welding,
grinding and corrosion are frequently over 10 microns in diameter.
Page 9
4. Severe Sliding
Severe sliding wear particles are identified by parallel on their surfaces. They are generally larger
than 15 microns, with the length-to-width thickness ratio falling between
5-30 microns. Severe sliding wear particles sometimes show evidence of temper colors, which may
change the appearance of the particle after heat treatment.
5. Bearing Wear Particles
These distinct particle types have been associated with rolling bearing fatigues.
• Fatigue spall particles constitute actual removal from the metal surface with a pit or a crack is
propagated. These particles reach a maximum size of 100 microns during the microspalling process.
Fatigues spalls are generally are flat with a major dimension-to-thickness ratio of 10 to 1. They have a
smooth surface and a random, irregularity shape circumference.
• Laminar particles are very thin free metal particles with frequent occurrence of holes. They range
between 20 to 50 microns in major diameter with a thickness ratio of 30:1. These particles are formed
by the passage of wear particles through a rolling contact. Laminar particles may be generated
throughout the life of a bearing.
Page 10
6. Gear Wear
Two types of wear have been associated with gear wear:
• Pitch line fatigue particles from a gear pitch line have much in common with rolling-element bearing
fatigue particles. They generally have a smooth surface and frequently irregularly shaped. Depending
upon the gear design, the particles usually have a major dimension-to thickness ration between 4:1 and
10:1. The chunkier particles results from tensile stresses on the gear surfaces causing the fatigue cracks
to propagate deeper into the gear tooth prior to spalling.
• Scuffing or scoring particles are caused by too high a load and / or speed. These particles tend to have
a rough surface and jagged circumference. Even small particles may
be discerned from rubbing wear by there characteristics. Some of the large particles have striations on
their surface indicating a sliding contact. Because of the thermal nature of
scuffing, quantities of oxides are usually present and same of particles may show evidence of partial
oxidation that is tan or blue temper colors.
Contaminant particles are generally considered the single most significant cause of abnormal
component wear. The wear initiated by contaminants generally induces the
formation of larger particles, with the formation rate being dependent on the filteration efficiency of the
system. In fact, once a particle is generated and moves with the lubricant, it is technically a contaminant.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://mdl.mech.upatras.gr/index.php/el/component/attachments/download/210&gws_… 10/29
SIGNIFICANT OIL CONTAMINENTS
Lubricating oil used in engine may possibly include concentration of such elements as iron
chromium, copper, lead, tin, antimony, borated silver, silicon. A list of common contaminants and their
possible origins is given in table 2.
Page 11
CONTAMINENT SOURCES
1.Aluminium Pistons, bearings
2. Boron Coolant leak
3. Copper Bearings, bushings, washers etc.
4. Iron Piston rings, ball and roller bearings
5. Lead Bearings, bushings
Iron concentration usually rises as a consequence of higher wear rate of cylinder liners or piston
rings (or of piston where these are of ferrous materials). A common cause is that of piston rings stuck in
their grooves with consequent blow-by of combustion gases and burning of the oil film adding to
scuffing and piston seizure.
Iron and silicon together in high concentration suggests linear and ring wear from dust in the
intake air. This could be caused by inefficient or chocked air filters. Air filter filled relatively low in the
body of a vehicle may choke and allow direct to enter.
Copper and lead concentration in an engine fitted with copper – lead bearings suggests incident
failure of one or more bearings. Copper and tin increased could be caused by high wear of bronze and
bushes.
Antimony in some engines might indicate a rise or copper content from crankshaft or camshaft bearings.
Chromates are used in some engines coating water to suppress corrosion, their presence in
lubrication oils indicates that cooling water has leaked into the crankcase(this effect can be masked in
an engine fitted with chrome-plated piston rings and cylinder lines)
Page 12
Solver in contaminated oil results from the wear of plating, bearings and silver soldered fittings.
USED OIL CONTAMINATION – TIME TRENDS
The quantity of each contaminant reflects the extent of surface wear of the components of a
machine under normal conditions; wear rate is small and uniform so that oil contamination collects
slowly. As large surface defects develop, abnormal wear occurs and contamination increases. A curve
typical of the change of the iron concentration with time as shown in fig.
Initially, when the machinery is now or recently overheated, a sharp rise in metallic concentration occurs
from A to B as the parts wear in. Once this phase is completed, the concentration should remain steady,
the oil shouls then be changed. Some residual wear metal products remain from the old oil and circulate
in the new oil following the oil
change at c, with normal functioning the metallic concentration would be expected to increase slowly as
by C-D. If abnormal conditions arise, the concentration may increase by D-F.
Page 13
The physical analysis of the wear debris that has been generated by the deterioration of the moving
parts within the system. A diagnosis of the wear mechanisms and extent of the damage to components
is made using the following parameters.
The test package includes:
Wear index: A measurement of the amount of ferrous wear within a system.
Particle Quantifier Index (PQ): A measurement of the wear debris filtered from the used oil.
Magnetic Separation Index (Mag I): A measurement of ferrous wear debris magnetically
separated from other debris.
Contamination Index (Contamin): A measurement of the amount of metallic contamination.
Average Size: The average size of the particle size of the wear debris.
Maximum Size: The maximum particle size of the wear debris.
Density Index (Density): A measurement of the density of the largest wear particles.
Particle Type: The wear particle classification according to the size and shape used to determine
the mechanism of wear.
WEAR PROCESS MONITORING TECHNIQUES
The method of wear process can be classified into three main types, which are shown in fig.
Page 14
1. Direct detection method:
Wear debris in the lubricant is detected in the machine by arranging for the oil flow through a device,
which is sensitive to the presence of debris.
2. Debris collection methods:
Wear debris is collected in a device, fitted to the machine which is convenient to remove, so that the
debris can be extracted for examination.
3. Lubricant Sample Analysis:
A sample of lubricant is extracted from the machine and analyzed for wear debris contamination.
These methods are normally used to monitor the conditions of components lubricated by a
circulatory oil system.
Page 15
When applying a wear debris monitoring method to any machine for the first time there is an
initial learning period required, partly to gain experience in using the
equipment, but mainly to establish wear debris characteristic levels which indicate normal and incipient
failure conditions. This learning period can take up to 2 Yrs. During this
time it will also be necessary to establish the inspection and sampling intervals for intermittent
monitoring methods such as debris collection and lubricant sampling. This time interval will depend on
the application but fortnightly or monthly is probably a reasonable choice for an industrial application in
the absence of more precise guidance.
Debris collection and lubricant sampling can also indicate the nature of the wear problem and
engineers carrying out monitoring need to be given a regular feedback of information on the accuracy of
their diagnosis. They must therefore either see the components of thin machines when they are
stripped for overhaul, or atleast be given
precise data on their condition.
Direct Debris Collection Method
Wear debris is collected in a device, fitted to the machine, which is convenient to removed so
that the debris can be extracted.
Existing Filter system
Filtration is widely used to remove harmful particles from oil. The simplest method of debris
monitoring is to extend such an approach by carefully collecting and checking the contents of machine’s
oil filtration system at regular intervals
Special Filters
Page 16
These collects all particles down to the mesh size of the filter. The complete filter unit can
usually be extracted from it’s housing without breaking any pipe connections and the machine need not
be stopped. If a bi-pass- valve is fitted. To collect all particles the filter should be fitted in the oil system
immediately downstream of the components being monitored. These are mainly used for detecting non-
ferrous debris not collected by magnetic plugs often they are used in conjunction with these.
Debris Collection Method
Magnetic Plugs
As it is an “on-line” control method, magnetic plugs are used in oil-lubricated machines. The monitoring
equipment is mounted directly in the lubricating system of the machine. The underlining principle is that
the Ferro-magnetic particles in the oil are attracted by the magnetic plugs. The magnetic plugs or chip
detectors are usually of the self-closing type which prevent oil loss during removal. This method only
detect ferrous material.
Page 17
The quantity of particles collected depends upon the path of the oil flow and the placement of the plugs
are therefore placed so that they provide a maximum amount of information about wear(particle
production) of the critical parts. Regular examination and evaluation of the coating of the plug allows
one to eliminate the quantity and size of the particles, as it often follows a typical “bath-tub” curve. By
means of such a graph it is possible to identify appropriate times for the performance of preventive
maintenance.
This technique supplements the two other oil monitoring methods. The magnetic plugs captures
particles from about 100mm and upwards, ie, a large number of particles are detected which would not
normally be recorded by means of ferrography.
The magnetic plug is thus in a position to capture the large flakes which are formed due to the
break down of the surfaces by fatigue. The magnetic plug is therefore, used particularly in connection
with the monitoring of the gear boxes and bearings. A
scattering of black particle fragments (whiskers) is seen. An unacceptable coating is visible. This
indicates abnormal wear. An unacceptable coating can be characterized by the following conditions.
☞ Large individual fragments
☞ Pieces which can be identified as flakes from a bearing
☞ Flat fragments
☞ A large number of whiskers
☞ Particularly long whiskers
Magnetic plugs are used in the modern aircraft engines where particle sizes are in the order of
0.2-1 µm are found.
Direct debris collection methods
Page 18
• Optical oil turbidity monitor
• Electrically conducting filters
• Inductive detection methods
• Capacitive detection methods
Lubricant Sample Analysis
A sample of lubricant is extracted from a machine and analyzed for wear debris contamination.
There are two most widely used methods. They are:
1. Spectrometric oil analysis program (SOAP)
2. Ferrography
These methods are normally used to monitor the conditions of components lubricated by a
circulating oil system. Two main lubricating sample analysis methods are:
1. Analysis of the sample to determine the concentration of the chemical elements it contains.
2. Analysis of the sample to determine the amount, size and shape of contaminant particles contained in
it.
SOAP
It is a maintenance tool which is used to check the condition of the oil lubricated mechanical
systems(Examples: Motors, Gear boxes, Hydraulic systems). The systems can be kept under surveillance
without dismantling them. Abnormally worn compounds can be localized and replaced before a
Page 19
catastrophic failure occurs. The quantity and type of wear metals in sample of lubricating oil is
determined. The quantity can indicate something about the magnitude of the wear and the type of wear
metals can reveal which component is wearing out.
a. Emission Spectroscopy
An emission spectrometer is an optical instrument where the sample is “burned” is in a spark
between two electrodes. The energy is absorbed by the metal in the sample, and they emit light with
wavelengths, which are characteristic for each element in the sample. The intensity of light is
proportional to the concentration of the metal in the sample.
b. Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy
In this, the sample is burned in a gas flame, where the metal compounds are transferred into
atoms that can absorb light at wavelengths, which can characteristic for each metal. If one wishes e.g. to
determine the quantity of fuel copper, then light with a wavelength characteristic for copper is send
through the flame, where the copper atoms absorb a part of light . The quantity of absorbed light is
proportional with the quantity of copper in the sample.
Only particle under certain size can be measured, which is of the order of 0-10µm. With
emission spectroscopy somewhat larger particles can be measured.
Page 20
Limitations:-
Users of the SOAP claim that they find that a large proportion of the defects which would lead
to the breakdown. This method provides no indication of:
• Large particles (E.g. bearings can breakdown due to few large particles)
• Defects which occurs quickly (E.g. due to the lack of lubricating oil or due to bearings which burn up)
• Defects where no wear metals are formed.(E.g. breakdown due to metal fatigue).
Applications:-
1. It is used in situation s where breakdowns are catastrophic or expensive.
2. It is widely used in the military services.
3. In US, it is used by the Air force, Navy and the Army.
4. It is used for many civil aviation companies.
Ferrography
It is a technique which is based upon the systematic collection of oil samples from an oil-
lubricated machines. The method identifies, isolate and classify wear particles from machine parts. A
magnetic field is used to sort the wear particles in the flowing oil. This technique was used successfully
to monitor the condition of military aitcraft engines, gear boxes and transmissions.
Three of the major type of equipments used in wear particle analysis are the
Direct –Reading(DR) ferrorgraphy, the analytical ferrograph system and ferrorgram scanner.
Page 21
Registraion of the quantity of “large” and “small” wear particles is used to monitor the
development of process between checks. Abnormal wear is revealed when there is a change in
distribution of the particles called wear index of the oil.
FerroGraph Analysis Apparatus:-
Here the particles are separated on a treated object glass where due to its displacement in a
special magnetic field( with a very high field gradiation) causes the particle should be sorted according
to size. The largest particles are deposited first while smaller ones travel farther with the flowing oil. The
density i.e. the concentration of particles at a single location on the ferrogram, is measured with a
optical densitometer by allowing light to pass through it.
The wear index SA = AL 2 -AS 2 is obtained by the comparison of the density AL of the large particles and
the density AS of the small particles.
1. DR Ferrography
This is a quick method for which direct reading of the index SD can be achieved in about 5
minutes.
Page 22
In this apparatus, a controlled flow of oil passes through a calibrated glass tube which is
mounted in a specially designed magnetic field. The separation causes the particles to be sorted by the
size of the bottom of the tube.
Page 23
The apparatus uses photocells to convert the measured light intensities attained by passing light
to the tube to electric signals. The measured region of the apparatus is 0 -190 DR units, where maximum
value is 190 DR corresponding to the cases where the bottom of the tube is completely covered with
metal particles.
Density at two fixed measuring points in the tube are used corresponding to the densities of
large and small particles. DL and DS respectively.. The sum of DL and DS is termed the total wear and the
difference DL – DS is termed as abnormality wear. The wear index SD=DL 2 – DS 2
Areas of Application:-
The ferrographic DR measurement provides a warning of an incipient failure earlier than the
standardized spectrometric method.
2. The Analytical Ferrograph
Page 24
Additional information about a wear sample, can be obtained with the Analytical Ferrograph
system, instruments that can provide a permanent record of the sample, as well as analytical
information. The Analytical Ferrograph is used to prepare a Ferrogram -- a fixed slide of wear particles
for microscopic examination and photographic documentation. The Ferrogram is an important
predictive tool, since it provides an identification of the characteristic wear pattern of specific pieces of
equipment. After the particles have deposited on the Ferrogram, a wash is used to flush away the oil or
water-based lubricant. After the wash fluid evaporates, the wear particles remain permanently attached
to the glass substrate and are ready for microscopic examination.
Ferrogram Maker Instrument
Wear-Debris analysis made easy
The EDAX Eagle Micro-Probe EDXRF system provides a fast and simple method for the component
identification of wear-debris particles.
EDAX has led the way in the development and supply of elemental analysis instrumentation based on
the method of energy-dispersive (X-ray) spectrometry (EDS). The EDS method utilizes the simple spectral
information produced as a result of electron transitions deep within an atom. These X-ray spectra (so
called because of their energy/
Page 25
wavelength) obtained from a sample under investigation within a suitable analysis instrument, provide
unique information about the type and quantity of the elements present. EDAX introduced the first
commercially available EDS system for electron microscopy applications
The EDS technique is a familiar elemental analysis attachment to a scanning electron microscope
(SEM) where electrons are used as the primary energy source to excite the X-ray spectra. SEM-
EDS methods are used for wear-particle analysis for both their morphological and compositional
properties, and are particularly useful where the study of very small particles (approximately five
microns or less) is necessary. On the other hand, the radiation output from an X-ray tube may
also be employed as an energy source. The resultant benefits for systems using an X-ray energy
source include greatly simplified specimen handling/presentation needs, less sophisticated
instrumentation, simpler and faster operation and lower cost. Such a standalone system is called
an energy-dispersive X-ray fluorescence spectrometer (EDXRF), of which the EDAX Eagle is a
specialised example.
The EDS technique is a familiar elemental analysis
attachment to a scanning electron microscope
Page 26
Ease of analysis:-
The magnetic plugs are degreased prior to the transfer of the debris on to a clear sticky tape (the
traditional method used for debris archiving and/or optical examination). Without the need for any
further sample preparation, the tape/debris is presented to the spectrometer for analysis where, in
typically less than two minutes, its analysis may be obtained. Also the measured spectrum can be
compared (using spectral pattern-recognition methods) to stored reference spectra of the monitored
assembly's component parts and hence to identify the component that has worn or been damaged.
Page 27
CONCLUSION
The wear debris monitoring method access the nature of the particles generated when components
wear.
They can indicate exact nature of the machine problem
The methods of wear debris analysis used as an indication of machine conditions are:
∎ indication from the amount of debris present
∎ indication from the size distribution of debris
∎ indication from the physical form of debris
∎ application of chemical analysis of debris
Page 28
REFERANCES:
1. VENKATRAMAN.A, SENTHILVELAN.T, “WINTER SCHOOL ON RECENT TRENDS IN DIAGNOSTIC
MAINTENANCE”.
2. PRABHU.B.S, “WORKSHOP ON PLANT ENGGINEERING AND INDUSTRIAL TRIBOLOGY”.

Wear Debris Analysis - 1

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Wear Debris Analysis - 1

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Wear Debris Analysis - 1

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

1/5/2018 Wear debris Analysis

This is the html version of the file http://mdl.mech.upatras.gr/index.php/el/component/attachments/download/210.