Scribd
Upload
163 views3 pages

Megger Table

This document summarizes and compares several standards for dielectric breakdown voltage testing of insulating oils: 1) ASTM D 877, ASTM D1816, and IEC 60156 describe procedures for conducting dielectric breakdown tests that vary in terms of electrode shape and size, oil stirring methods, temperature controls, and number of breakdowns recorded. 2) Key differences include the electrode gap size, whether the oil sample is stirred, ambient and liquid temperature requirements, and definitions of breakdown voltage. 3) Additional information provided includes equivalent standards adopted in other regions, notes on testing silicon oils, and special test conditions for various standards.

Uploaded by

Adel Fawzi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
163 views3 pages

Megger Table

This document summarizes and compares several standards for dielectric breakdown voltage testing of insulating oils: 1) ASTM D 877, ASTM D1816, and IEC 60156 describe procedures for conducting dielectric breakdown tests that vary in terms of electrode shape and size, oil stirring methods, temperature controls, and number of breakdowns recorded. 2) Key differences include the electrode gap size, whether the oil sample is stirred, ambient and liquid temperature requirements, and definitions of breakdown voltage. 3) Additional information provided includes equivalent standards adopted in other regions, notes on testing silicon oils, and special test conditions for various standards.

Uploaded by

Adel Fawzi
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 3

ASTM D 877

Standards ASTM D1816 IEC 60156


Procedure A Procedure B

Origin USA USA USA Europe

Shape
Electrodes

Gap size 2 mm or 1 mm* 2.54 mm 2.54 mm 2.5 mm

Impeller yes optional


Oil sample stirring not stirred not stirred
Magnetic bead no option optional

20 - 30 ºC must record 20 - 30 ºC must record


15 - 25 ºC
Laboratory test Liquid At ambient - must record temperature as collected temperature as collected
for referee tests
temperature and when tested and when tested

Ambient 20 - 30 ºC Must record Must record Within 5 ºC of oil sample

Liquid At ambient - must record Must record Must record 15 - 25 ºC


Outside test
temperature
Ambient Referee tests 20 - 30 ºC Must record Must record Within 5 ºC of oil sample

Rise rate 0.5 kV/s 3 kV/s 3 kV/s 2 kV/s


Test voltage
Frequency 45 - 65 45 - 65 45 - 65 45 - 62

Definition <100 V <100 V <100 V 4 mA for 5 ms

Breakdowns Number in sequence 5** 5* 1 - 5 different samples 6

Time between
1 to 1.5 min 1 min n/a 2 min
breakdown

Test voltage switch off Normal (e.g. mineral oil) Not specified Not specified Not specified <10 ms
time following
breakdown Silicon oil Not specified Not specified Not specified <1 ms

Time between filling and start of test 3 - 5 min 2 - 3 min 2 - 3 min 2 min

BS EN 60156 SABE EN 60156


CEI EN 60156 VDE0370 part 5
Equivalent standards (adopted into) None None None IRAM 2341 AS1767.2.1
UNE EN 60156 PA SEV EN 60156 NRS
FN EN 6056 079-1* IS6729*

Can be used if modified in


Can be used provided discharge energy in sample accordance with D2225 if OK if test instrument can comply with voltage switch
Notes on testing silicon oil
<20 mj procedure A cannot be off time requirements
used

* If breakdown does not


occur at 2 mm, reduce
gap to 1 mm
** Tests must be repeated
*Tests must be repeated if range of BD voltages
if range of BD voltages Expected range of standard deviation/ mean ratio as
Special conditions recorded are more than 92% of mean. If range of 10
recorded are more than a function of the mean provided as a chart
BD voltages is more than 151% investigate why
120% of mean with 1 mm
electrode gap and 92% of
mean with 2 mm
electrode gap

Test vessel requires cover Used if any insoluble Used if any insoluble *With some stand/stir timing differences. Test
or baffle to prevent air breakdown products in oil breakdown products do cell/vessel must be transparent.
Comments
from contacting circulating completely settle between not settle between Reconditioned/reclaimed oil to BS148 is tested to
oil breakdown tests breakdown tests IEC60156 following update in 2009.
The Megger guide to insulating oil dielectric breakdown testing www.megger.com
7

You might also like