BAB V

A. ANALISA VARIAN SATU ARAH

1.

Descriptives

Noise

95% Confidence Interval for Mean

N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum

1 5 19.20 7.791 3.484 9.53 28.87 8 30

2 5 70.00 11.023 4.930 56.31 83.69 56 80

3 5 36.60 11.589 5.183 22.21 50.99 25 50

4 5 79.80 20.511 9.173 54.33 105.27 46 97

Total 20 51.40 28.089 6.281 38.25 64.55 8 97

Test of Homogeneity of Variances

Noise

Levene Statistic df1 df2 Sig.

1.294 3 16 .311

ANOVA

Noise

Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Between Groups 12042.000 3 4014.000 21.780 .000

Within Groups 2948.800 16 184.300

Total 14990.800 19
Post Hoc Tests

Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Noise

95% Confidence Interval

(I) (J) Mean Difference
Desain Desain (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD 1 2 -50.800* 8.586 .000 -75.36 -26.24

3 -17.400 8.586 .219 -41.96 7.16

4 -60.600* 8.586 .000 -85.16 -36.04

2 1 50.800* 8.586 .000 26.24 75.36

3 33.400* 8.586 .006 8.84 57.96

4 -9.800 8.586 .670 -34.36 14.76

3 1 17.400 8.586 .219 -7.16 41.96

2 -33.400* 8.586 .006 -57.96 -8.84

4 -43.200* 8.586 .001 -67.76 -18.64

4 1 60.600* 8.586 .000 36.04 85.16

2 9.800 8.586 .670 -14.76 34.36

3 43.200* 8.586 .001 18.64 67.76

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

Noise

Subset for alpha = 0.05

Desain N 1 2

Tukey HSDa 1 5 19.20

3 5 36.60

2 5 70.00

4 5 79.80

Sig. .219 .670

Duncana 1 5 19.20

3 5 36.60

2 5 70.00

4 5 79.80

Sig. .060 .271

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 5.000.

INTERPRETASI :
 2.
Descriptives

Konsentrasi

95% Confidence Interval for Mean

N Mean Std. Deviation Std. Error Lower Bound Upper Bound Minimum Maximum

1 5 56.900 1.5199 .6797 55.013 58.787 54.9 58.4

2 4 55.775 1.0996 .5498 54.025 57.525 54.5 57.0

3 3 53.233 2.7791 1.6045 46.330 60.137 50.1 55.4

4 4 51.125 1.4431 .7215 48.829 53.421 49.9 52.9

Total 16 54.488 2.8312 .7078 52.979 55.996 49.9 58.4

Test of Homogeneity of Variances

Konsentrasi

Levene Statistic df1 df2 Sig.

2.054 3 12 .160

ANOVA

Konsentrasi

Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Between Groups 85.676 3 28.559 9.916 .001

Within Groups 34.562 12 2.880

Total 120.237 15
Post Hoc Tests

Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Konsentrasi

95% Confidence Interval

(I) (J) Mean Difference
katalis katalis (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD 1 2 1.1250 1.1384 .759 -2.255 4.505

3 3.6667 1.2394 .051 -.013 7.346

4 5.7750* 1.1384 .001 2.395 9.155

2 1 -1.1250 1.1384 .759 -4.505 2.255

3 2.5417 1.2962 .255 -1.307 6.390

4 4.6500* 1.2000 .010 1.087 8.213

3 1 -3.6667 1.2394 .051 -7.346 .013

2 -2.5417 1.2962 .255 -6.390 1.307

4 2.1083 1.2962 .401 -1.740 5.957

4 1 -5.7750* 1.1384 .001 -9.155 -2.395

2 -4.6500* 1.2000 .010 -8.213 -1.087

3 -2.1083 1.2962 .401 -5.957 1.740

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets
Konsentrasi

Subset for alpha = 0.05

katalis N 1 2 3

Tukey HSDa 4 4 51.125

3 3 53.233 53.233

2 4 55.775 55.775

1 5 56.900

Sig. .352 .213 .794

Duncana 4 4 51.125

3 3 53.233 53.233

2 4 55.775 55.775

1 5 56.900

Sig. .110 .059 .375

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3.871.

 B. ANALISA VARIAN DUA ARAH

1. Univariate Analysis of Variance

Between-Subjects Factors

Value Label N

Perlakuan 1 kontrol 3

2 K2P1 3

3 K2P2 3

4 K2P3 3

5 K2P4 3

6 K3P1 3

7 K3P2 3

8 K3P3 3

9 K3P4 3

Blok 1 timur 9

2 tengah 9

3 barat 9

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable:Konsentrasi

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model 625.250a 10 62.525 7.082 .000

Intercept 7532.702 1 7532.702 853.197 .000

Perlakuan 586.040 8 73.255 8.297 .000

Blok 39.211 2 19.605 2.221 .141

Error 141.261 16 8.829

Total 8299.213 27

Corrected Total 766.511 26

a. R Squared = .816 (Adjusted R Squared = .701)

Post Hoc Tests

Perlakuan
Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Konsentrasi

(I) (J) 95% Confidence Interval

Perlakua Perlakua Mean Difference
n n (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD kontrol K2P1 -15.1067* 2.42608 .000 -23.7373 -6.4760

K2P2 -11.7133* 2.42608 .004 -20.3440 -3.0827

K2P3 -3.6667 2.42608 .835 -12.2973 4.9640

K2P4 -1.9300 2.42608 .995 -10.5607 6.7007

K3P1 -8.4633 2.42608 .057 -17.0940 .1673

K3P2 -5.9067 2.42608 .330 -14.5373 2.7240

K3P3 -4.7633 2.42608 .585 -13.3940 3.8673

K3P4 -2.2367 2.42608 .988 -10.8673 6.3940

K2P1 kontrol 15.1067* 2.42608 .000 6.4760 23.7373

K2P2 3.3933 2.42608 .883 -5.2373 12.0240

K2P3 11.4400* 2.42608 .005 2.8093 20.0707

K2P4 13.1767* 2.42608 .001 4.5460 21.8073

K3P1 6.6433 2.42608 .209 -1.9873 15.2740

K3P2 9.2000* 2.42608 .032 .5693 17.8307

K3P3 10.3433* 2.42608 .013 1.7127 18.9740

K3P4 12.8700* 2.42608 .002 4.2393 21.5007

K2P2 kontrol 11.7133* 2.42608 .004 3.0827 20.3440

K2P1 -3.3933 2.42608 .883 -12.0240 5.2373

K2P3 8.0467 2.42608 .078 -.5840 16.6773

K2P4 9.7833* 2.42608 .020 1.1527 18.4140

K3P1 3.2500 2.42608 .904 -5.3807 11.8807

K3P2 5.8067 2.42608 .349 -2.8240 14.4373

K3P3 6.9500 2.42608 .170 -1.6807 15.5807

 K3P4 9.4767* 2.42608 .026 .8460 18.1073

K2P3 kontrol 3.6667 2.42608 .835 -4.9640 12.2973

K2P1 -11.4400* 2.42608 .005 -20.0707 -2.8093

K2P2 -8.0467 2.42608 .078 -16.6773 .5840

K2P4 1.7367 2.42608 .998 -6.8940 10.3673

K3P1 -4.7967 2.42608 .577 -13.4273 3.8340

K3P2 -2.2400 2.42608 .988 -10.8707 6.3907

K3P3 -1.0967 2.42608 1.000 -9.7273 7.5340

K3P4 1.4300 2.42608 .999 -7.2007 10.0607

K2P4 kontrol 1.9300 2.42608 .995 -6.7007 10.5607

K2P1 -13.1767* 2.42608 .001 -21.8073 -4.5460

K2P2 -9.7833* 2.42608 .020 -18.4140 -1.1527

K2P3 -1.7367 2.42608 .998 -10.3673 6.8940

K3P1 -6.5333 2.42608 .224 -15.1640 2.0973

K3P2 -3.9767 2.42608 .772 -12.6073 4.6540

K3P3 -2.8333 2.42608 .953 -11.4640 5.7973

K3P4 -.3067 2.42608 1.000 -8.9373 8.3240

K3P1 kontrol 8.4633 2.42608 .057 -.1673 17.0940

K2P1 -6.6433 2.42608 .209 -15.2740 1.9873

K2P2 -3.2500 2.42608 .904 -11.8807 5.3807

K2P3 4.7967 2.42608 .577 -3.8340 13.4273

K2P4 6.5333 2.42608 .224 -2.0973 15.1640

K3P2 2.5567 2.42608 .973 -6.0740 11.1873

K3P3 3.7000 2.42608 .829 -4.9307 12.3307

K3P4 6.2267 2.42608 .272 -2.4040 14.8573

K3P2 kontrol 5.9067 2.42608 .330 -2.7240 14.5373

K2P1 -9.2000* 2.42608 .032 -17.8307 -.5693

K2P2 -5.8067 2.42608 .349 -14.4373 2.8240

K2P3 2.2400 2.42608 .988 -6.3907 10.8707

K2P4 3.9767 2.42608 .772 -4.6540 12.6073

 K3P1 -2.5567 2.42608 .973 -11.1873 6.0740

K3P3 1.1433 2.42608 1.000 -7.4873 9.7740

K3P4 3.6700 2.42608 .834 -4.9607 12.3007

K3P3 kontrol 4.7633 2.42608 .585 -3.8673 13.3940

K2P1 -10.3433* 2.42608 .013 -18.9740 -1.7127

K2P2 -6.9500 2.42608 .170 -15.5807 1.6807

K2P3 1.0967 2.42608 1.000 -7.5340 9.7273

K2P4 2.8333 2.42608 .953 -5.7973 11.4640

K3P1 -3.7000 2.42608 .829 -12.3307 4.9307

K3P2 -1.1433 2.42608 1.000 -9.7740 7.4873

K3P4 2.5267 2.42608 .975 -6.1040 11.1573

K3P4 kontrol 2.2367 2.42608 .988 -6.3940 10.8673

K2P1 -12.8700* 2.42608 .002 -21.5007 -4.2393

K2P2 -9.4767* 2.42608 .026 -18.1073 -.8460

K2P3 -1.4300 2.42608 .999 -10.0607 7.2007

K2P4 .3067 2.42608 1.000 -8.3240 8.9373

K3P1 -6.2267 2.42608 .272 -14.8573 2.4040

K3P2 -3.6700 2.42608 .834 -12.3007 4.9607

K3P3 -2.5267 2.42608 .975 -11.1573 6.1040

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 8.829.

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

Konsentrasi

Subset
Perlakua
n N 1 2 3 4 5

Tukey HSDa kontrol 3 10.7267

K2P4 3 12.6567

K3P4 3 12.9633

K2P3 3 14.3933 14.3933

K3P3 3 15.4900 15.4900

K3P2 3 16.6333 16.6333

K3P1 3 19.1900 19.1900 19.1900

K2P2 3 22.4400 22.4400

K2P1 3 25.8333

Sig. .057 .078 .209

Duncana kontrol 3 10.7267

K2P4 3 12.6567 12.6567

K3P4 3 12.9633 12.9633

K2P3 3 14.3933 14.3933 14.3933

K3P3 3 15.4900 15.4900 15.4900

K3P2 3 16.6333 16.6333

K3P1 3 19.1900 19.1900

K2P2 3 22.4400 22.4400

K2P1 3 25.8333

Sig. .094 .157 .086 .199 .181

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 8.829.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3.000.

Blok

Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Konsentrasi

95% Confidence Interval

Mean Difference
(I) Blok (J) Blok (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD timur tengah 1.6533 1.40070 .481 -1.9609 5.2676

barat 2.9444 1.40070 .121 -.6698 6.5587

tengah timur -1.6533 1.40070 .481 -5.2676 1.9609

barat 1.2911 1.40070 .635 -2.3232 4.9054

barat timur -2.9444 1.40070 .121 -6.5587 .6698

tengah -1.2911 1.40070 .635 -4.9054 2.3232

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 8.829.
Homogeneous Subsets
Konsentrasi

Subset

Blok N 1

Tukey HSDa barat 9 15.2911

tengah 9 16.5822

timur 9 18.2356

Sig. .121

Duncana barat 9 15.2911

tengah 9 16.5822

timur 9 18.2356

Sig. .062

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are

displayed.
Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = 8.829.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 9.000.

2. Univariate Analysis of Variance

Between-Subjects Factors

Value Label N

Perlakuan 1 A 5

2 B 5

3 C 5

Blok 1 3

2 3

3 3

4 3

5 3

Tests of Between-Subjects Effects

Dependent Variable:Banyak

Type III Sum of

Source Squares df Mean Square F Sig.

Corrected Model .200a 6 .033 4.849 .022

Intercept 7.733 1 7.733 1.123E3 .000

Perlakuan .054 2 .027 3.924 .065

Blok .146 4 .037 5.311 .022

Error .055 8 .007

Total 7.988 15

Corrected Total .255 14

a. R Squared = .784 (Adjusted R Squared = .623)

Post Hoc Tests

Perlakuan

Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Banyak

(I) (J) 95% Confidence Interval

Perlaku Perlaku Mean Difference
an an (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD A B .0880 .05248 .271 -.0620 .2380

C .1460 .05248 .056 -.0040 .2960

B A -.0880 .05248 .271 -.2380 .0620

C .0580 .05248 .538 -.0920 .2080

C A -.1460 .05248 .056 -.2960 .0040

B -.0580 .05248 .538 -.2080 .0920

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = .007.
Homogeneous Subsets
Banyak

Subset
Perlaku
an N 1 2

Tukey HSDa C 5 .6500

B 5 .7080

A 5 .7960

Sig. .056

Duncana C 5 .6500

B 5 .7080 .7080

A 5 .7960

Sig. .301 .132

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = .007.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 5.000.

Blok

Multiple Comparisons

Dependent Variable:Banyak

95% Confidence Interval

Mean Difference
(I) Blok (J) Blok (I-J) Std. Error Sig. Lower Bound Upper Bound

Tukey HSD 1 2 -.0800 .06776 .762 -.3141 .1541

3 .1700 .06776 .181 -.0641 .4041

4 .0600 .06776 .895 -.1741 .2941

5 .1767 .06776 .159 -.0574 .4108

2 1 .0800 .06776 .762 -.1541 .3141

3 .2500* .06776 .036 .0159 .4841

4 .1400 .06776 .319 -.0941 .3741

5 .2567* .06776 .032 .0226 .4908

3 1 -.1700 .06776 .181 -.4041 .0641

2 -.2500* .06776 .036 -.4841 -.0159

4 -.1100 .06776 .523 -.3441 .1241

5 .0067 .06776 1.000 -.2274 .2408

4 1 -.0600 .06776 .895 -.2941 .1741

2 -.1400 .06776 .319 -.3741 .0941

3 .1100 .06776 .523 -.1241 .3441

5 .1167 .06776 .473 -.1174 .3508

5 1 -.1767 .06776 .159 -.4108 .0574

2 -.2567* .06776 .032 -.4908 -.0226

3 -.0067 .06776 1.000 -.2408 .2274

4 -.1167 .06776 .473 -.3508 .1174

Based on observed means.

The error term is Mean Square(Error) = .007.

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.

Homogeneous Subsets

Banyak

Subset

Blok N 1 2

Tukey HSDa 5 3 .6067

3 3 .6133

4 3 .7233 .7233

1 3 .7833 .7833

2 3 .8633

Sig. .159 .319

Duncana 5 3 .6067

3 3 .6133

4 3 .7233 .7233

1 3 .7833

2 3 .8633

Sig. .137 .083

Means for groups in homogeneous subsets are displayed.

Based on observed means.
The error term is Mean Square(Error) = .007.

a. Uses Harmonic Mean Sample Size = 3.000.