Daylight

Performance in
Mid/Large Buildings
Basics, Strategies, Technologies

Bobby Astrich, Alex Morris, Briana Walters

csd
Center for Sustainable Development
 UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

Daylight Performance in
Mid/Large Buildings

Bobby Astrich
Alex Morris
Briana Walters

Fig. 01 Diagram of the daylighting concept of the Arup Campus buildings

Design Goals Spaces within a building with differ-

ent programmatic functions require
Indirect sky light, such as light different lighting levels. It is im-
received from the North side of a portant to analyze these different
building, can be used as the primary programs at an early stage of design
source for ambient lighting within a to organize the building to give day-
space. If direct light is to be used, lighitng priorities to certain spaces.
the building should shade task areas Vertical circulation, bathrooms, and
from harsh direct rays. This can be storage gain little benefit from day-
done with a wide range of systems lighting and can be placed in areas
and technologies designed to allow that have less access to daylight or
only diffuse light into a space. The could be placed on the east and west
control of direct sunlight is impor- sides of the building to shade the
tant to regulate levels of glare and other spaces.
contrast and prevent direct rays from
falling within visual field. 1 Required illumination levels for a
space are directly related to the pro-
In large buildings, internally gener- grammatic function within the space.
ated heat loads most often constitute
the majority of the buildings energy Listed from lower required light levels
consumption. The use of daylight to higher required light levels:
reduces the use of electrical lighting
systems within the building and low- General Space:
ers the internal heat loads. Daylight
can be used as a source of ambient A: Public spaces – nighttime cor-
light with electric systems being used ridors and lobbies, waiting rooms,
for specific task lighting. bedrooms

1
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

B: Simple orientation – dance halls, Perceived brightness depends on

dining halls, transportation terminal not only the amount of light leaving a
concourses, residential living spaces lamp, but also on the amount of light
falling on and reflecting from the vari-
C: Occasional visual tasks – day- ous surfaces of a space. Too little
time corridors and lobbies, reception or too much brightness will make
areas, auditoriums, banks, worship performing various tasks difficult or
areas impossible, as well as creating unde-
sirable physical side effects, such as
Task: eye strain and headaches. Uncon-
trolled brightness can produce levels
D: Visual tasks of high contrast or of glare: direct glare, which comes
large size – conference rooms, office from the light source itself; reflected
work with high-contrast tasks, factory glare, which appears on a surface
simple assembly, residential kitchens on which a task is being undertaken,
such as on a computer screen;
E: Visual tasks of medium contrast or discomfort glare, which does not pre-
small size – drafting of high-contrast vent seeing but can cause eye strain
work, classrooms, offices, clerical and headaches; and disability glare,
tasks, factory work of low contrast or which prevents vision entirely.
moderately difficult assembly
Color Temperature Fig. 02 Interior Light
F: Visual tasks of low contrast or Color temperature describes how
very small size – Drafting of low-con- “warm” or “cool” the light appears
trast work, laboratories, factory work (warm light has a more yellow ap- Daylight vs. Artificial Light
with difficult assembly2 pearance, cool light appears more The Swedish Energy Agency’s
blue). In order to more accurately Department for Sustainable Energy
compare light sources to one an- Management describes the differ-
Daylighting Basics other, their Correlated Color Tem- ences between 300 lux of daylight
peratures (CCT) are used. Color and 300 lux of artificial light:
Daylight Factor temperatures are listed in the Kelvin
“The proportion of interior horizontal temperature scale. Warm sources Distribution of Light
illuminance (usually taken on a work have a lower CCT, typically some- Daylight in diffused form tends to
plane) to exterior horizontal illumi- where in the range of 2650K and illuminate surfaces more evenly in all
nance under an unobstructed sky.” 3200K, neutral sources range from directions. Electric lighting typically
Expressed as a percentage. 3200 to 4000K, and cool sources illuminates in a certain direction e.g.
have a CCT above 4000K. horizontal or vertical plane. In other
Quality of Light words surfaces are more brightly lit
Quality of light is a holistic term Color Rendering either in the horizontal or the vertical
which includes a number of fac- An element separate from color tem- plane. Daylight tends to illuminate
tors. It consists of brightness, color perature is color rendering, or how both horizontal and vertical surfaces
temperature, color rendering, type accurately a light source reproduces more evenly, thus, the roof, the walls
(direct, indirect, diffuse, etc), light colors. Using the Color Rendering and the floor look more evenly lit.
distribution, sparkle, variability, and Index (CRI) scale, a value between 1 Therefore, daylight in diffused form
flicker. Studies have shown that and 100 is assigned to a source, de- offers better sense of space.
light quality has an effect on mood, pending on how a particular source
energy levels, and sleep patterns. reproduces colors when compared to Discriminating Color
ideal (natural) light. Colors look more natural in daylight
Brightness than under electrical lighting, as
electric light sources are stronger

2
 Daylight Performance in Mid/Large Buildings

Fig. 03 Recommended daylight factors for various spaces

in some areas of the light spectrum their light over a limited wavelength different shades.
and weaker in others. The human range. Daylight thus has a continu-
eye’s ability to discriminate colors is ous spectrum and therefore provides Flicker
dependent on the spectral content of better color rendition. Colors tend to Daylight does not flicker; fluorescent
light, and daylight contains light of al- look more vivid in daylight. It may be lights can have a noticeable flicker.
most all visible wavelengths, where- added that under daylight human eye People blame this for a multitude of
as most electric lamps emit most of can differentiate between 500,000 problems like headache, eye strain

3
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

ing to do with the circadian system.

Regardless of which explanation is
correct, the presence of a window
would seem to provide a benefit in
terms of desirable behavior at work.
Preference for Daylight: There is no
doubt that people find daylight more
pleasant than electric lighting as
their primary source of light. Surveys
taken as far back as 1967 and as
recently as 1993 have all shown that
high percentages of survey respon-
dents prefer to work by daylight. Sim-
ilarly, people prefer to sit at desks
that are beside windows rather than
further back in the room, especially
when those windows have access to
direct sunlight.

Mood and Satisfaction

Fig. 04 Interior view of an Arup Campus building in Solihull, England A small but statistically significant
reduction in negative mood has been
for people who worked for about
and attention deficit problems. Fluo- will support workplace productivity.
20 minutes in a private office with
rescent lights than run on electronic In a study, it was found that workers
a large window during daytime; but
ballasts have considerably reduced in windowless offices spend a small
no reduction in negative mood for
flicker problems. Daylight and other but statistically significantly greater
the same people in the same office
electric sources, such as halogen amount of time talking to others,
at night. It was also found that oc-
lamps guarantee a total absnece of either directly or by telephone; and
cupants of small offices disliked the
flicker. a small but statistically significantly
absence of windows. Some studies
lesser amount of time working on
have suggested that people have an
Sparkle their computer, relative to the work-
innate desire to be in contact with
Sparkle or highlighting three di- ers in the windowed offices. It was
nature; windows provide a means
mensional objects is enhanced by hypothesized that the people in the
for establishing visual contract with
daylight. This makes objects more windowless offices would not receive
nature while at work.
attractive and easier and quicker to sufficient light to entrain their circa-
understand three dimensionally. dian systems and so would seek to
Circadian Photobiology
entrain them either by seeking out
Lighting can be used to strengthen
Variability exposure to daylight and conse-
the human circadian rhythm, which
The inherent variability of daylight as quently spending less time in their
determines various physiological
clouds move through the sky, suc- offices, or by seeking more social
functions such as sleep, digestion,
cessively obscuring and revealing interactions, a factor that can also be
alertness, depression, and probably
the sun. Some studies have shown used to entrain the circadian system.
general health. Daylight is much
that this variability of daylight has An alternative explanation for these
more effective than electric lighting
relaxing effect on the eyes. findings would be that the workers in
at ‘entraining’ the circadian system;
the windowless offices were seek-
this is because the circadian system
Motivation ing additional short-term stimulation,
responds only to high levels of blue
Since daylight is almost universally something that was provided by the
light, such as those found in day-
preferred to electric lighting, it is view out in the windowed offices, and
light. Rea et al. calculate ‘circadian
likely that increased use of daylight the differences in behavior had noth-

4
 Daylight Performance in Mid/Large Buildings

larged to increase interior

illumination levels

Strategies

Siting/Orientation
Siting considerations:
• Surrounding buildings/landscape
features
• Available daylight
• Horizontal obstructions
• Adjacent building materials that
Fig. 02 East-west orientation, north-south orientation, coutryard at light conductor
may contribute to glare

Orientation considerations:
• Movement of the sun Clustered Forms
• Solar position during peak usage These forms consist of a series
• Quality of daylight available of smaller masses in a variety of
configurations which offers extensive
Glazing on the east and west surface area for toplighting,
facades should be limited due to the sidelighting.
lower angles of solar radiation and
more difficulty in shading. Glazing
should be maximized on the north Plan/Section
and south facades where shading
and therefore glare area easier to Strategies in plan and section can
control. maximize the amount of daylit areas
throughout a building. Atriums,
courtyards and lightwells allow
Form daylight to penetrate into what would
otherwise be interior spaces. In plan,
There are three commonly used careful consideration must be made
building forms3: to the location of certain areas.

Linear Forms Zoning4

These forms are narrow width Group spaces with similar lighting
and long length and offer good requirements into daylighting zones
sidelighting opportunities. based on these characteristics:

Centric Forms 1. Function

Centric forms have an internal core Identify the activities that will take
around which other spaces are place within a space and specify the
organized. There is a fairly equal lighting requirements.
length-to-width ratio which provides
opportunities of atria, lightwells and 2. Usage schedule
courtyards. Where the above can’t Identify which spaces will have the
be used, careful building zoning is most usage and when this will occur.
used. Fig. 05 Building orientation

5
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

3. Location and orientation

Identify the location of the space in
relation to the daylight source.

Zoning spaces within a building

would contribute to energy efficiency,
building organization, optimized
daylighting design. However, what
might make sense from a daylighting
point of view may not make sense
from a functional point of view.

Case Studies

Arup Campus
Arup
Solihull, England

• Passive structure
• Oriented northwest to southeast to
maximize daylight
• Projecting roof pods over main Fig. 06 Gotz building plan showing spatial organization around a courtyard
circulation spaces
• Light-well strategy
• Program is separated into two skylights, sawtooth roof glazing glass block, low clerestories, and
buildings – maximize daylit areas arrangements and clerestories. vertical openings into courtyards or
• Open floor plan (good in plan and These apertures allow daylight to atria.
section) penetrate deeper into the space.
Depending on orientation and siting,
Gotz Headquarters Pros: reduced consumption of glazing selection is very important
Webler and Geisler electricity, improved occupant and should be integrated with
Wurzburg, Germany satisfaction, potential for reduced shading elements.
cooling loads
• Grid plan organized around a Pros: visual connection to the
central courtyard Cons: can only be used in single outside creating improved occupant
• Open floor plates story buildings or on the top floor of satisfaction
• Minimize columns and other a multistory building, potential leaks
obstructions without proper detailing, direct solar Cons: direct solar radiation can lead
• Maximize access to daylight and/ radiation and heat gain if not properly to heat gain and glare problems
or views shaded, limits the visual connection
to the outdoors
Height and Depth Relationships
Apertures Sidelighting The 2.5H rule of thumb says that the
Sidelighting is a strategy where daylight penetration into a space will
Toplighting apertures are located in the wall be 2.5 times the head height of the
Toplighting is a system that delivers planes and admit ambient daylight. window.
daylight onto a horizontal task plane This system delivers daylight onto a
generally from above. It includes horizontal task plane generally from The 15/30 rule of thumb says
the side. This can include windows, that a 15 foot wide zone from a

6
 Daylight Performance in Mid/Large Buildings

Fig. 08 Reflectance values of common building materials

• Sill heights at 0.95 meters onto the ceiling which bounces it

• 65% of wall area is glazing into the room. Form, material and
position of the light shelf determine
Fig. 07 Illustrations of 2.5H and the 15/30 rule its efficiency. Light shelves can be
Internal Reflectances located on the interior or exterior.
window wall can be sufficiently lit
through daylight. The next 15 feet Depends on color and texture. Glazing above a light shelf is used
need can be partially daylight and Color determines the quantity of solely for daylight while glazing
supplemented with electrical light. light reflected – dark colors absorb below the light shelf is for daylight as
Zones further than 30 feet receive while light colors reflect. Texture well as views.
little daylight and rely heavily on determines the quality of light
artificial light. reflected. Rough/matte textures Light shelves should be located
create diffuse Light, smooth or above eye level to reduce glare.
Additional strategies glossy create reflected light (and
Splay the walls of an aperture to potentially create glare problems) Pros: more even lighting, deeper
reduce contrast and glare. daylight penetration, potential glare
Use adjacent walls as reflectors. Pros: visual comfort, potential for reduction, reduce contrast around
Exterior vegetation will provide optimized lighting effectiveness apertures, an exterior light shelf
daylight filters. could double as a shading element
Cons: glare, surfaces need to
Case Study be maintained to prevent the Cons: if shelves aren’t placed
accumulation of dust and dirt which high enough glare is a problem,
World’s End School can create light loss5 maintenance is important because
Architects’ Co-Partnership dust and debris reduce reflectivity

• E-shaped plan to allow for bilateral Light Shelves

lighting Technologies
• Daylight requirement studies were Light shelves are used to more
used to determine room depth and evenly distribute daylight entering Louvers
height a building through sidelighting Louvers are often used as
• Room depths at 7 meters apertures. Light bounces off of a supplemental tool to other
• Room heights at 2.985 meters the reflective surface of a shelf, daylighting systems. They can be

7
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

the building in such a way as to

create diffuse light.

Case Study

Administration Building
Herzog + Partner
Wiesbaden, Germany

• South side: combination of two

shading elements pivoted about
the horizontal axis
• Upper element: light-redirecting
louvers
• Lower element: awning-like to al
low views
• Diffuse daylight capture on over
cast days
• North side: stationary light redi
recting elements to capture over
head daylight

Glass

There are many different

technologies that can be applied
to glass to make it as transparent
or as opaque as desired. These
technologies allow the glass to
create a diffuse light that blocks out
harsh direct sun and permits an
ambient light enter the space. In
addition, different hues or patterns
can be applied.

Printed or colored films

• Located between glass panes
• Redirect incoming light similar
through prisms and lenses

Electrochromic glass
• Liquid crystals between glass
panes
• State can be altered with an
electric current
• Off: liquid crystal layers scatter
incoming light
• On: liquid crystals become
Fig. 09 Detail of the louvers on the Administration Building

8
 Daylight Performance in Mid/Large Buildings

transparent and light transmission

rises from 40% to 70%

Laminated glass with photovoltaic

modules
• Solar cells fixed between panes of
glass
• Possible to create transparent,
translucent or opaque modules
depending on the type of cells
used and the arrangement of them

Holographic Optical Elements (HOE)

• Guide incoming light through
diffraction that depends on the
wavelength of radiation
• Applied on a photographic film
with high resolution and placed
between two panes of glass Fig. 10 Use of printed glass on the Herz Jesu Church

• Used with skylight elements or

façade elements
• Greater efficiency when tilted
at 45 ° because more light can be
captured

Prismatic lens (plate or film)

• Reflect direct solar radiation
• Create diffuse light in the interior
• To maintain optimal effect,
modules need to be able to track
the sun
• Can lead to color variation

Roof Structures

Roof structures can provide

regulated toplighting that may block
or permit light to pass in desired
areas. Some structures may focus
on shading all direct sun and only
allowing diffuse reflected light into a
space. Other structures can focus
creating shade patterns in a space.

Light pipes collect light through

a heliostat and channel the light
through a reflective tube of prismatic
glass, plastic film, or mirrors. At the Fig. 11 Close-up of the Nasher roof structure

9
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture

end of the pipe diffuse light enters

the space.

Case Studies

The Nasher Gallery

Renzo Piano
Dallas, Tx

• Simulated sun’s movement in

design of roof forms
• Block direct sunlight that is south
of the east/west axis
• Matrix of aluminum shells
• Thin skin of curved glass panels
• No direct radiation
• Lots of north light (no hard Fig. 12 Diagram of the Central United Methodist Church tower - Showing winter and summer daylighting
shadows)

Central United Methodist Church

William Wenzler and Associates
Milwaukee, Wisconsin

• Submerged into a hill

• Tower with south facing windows
and a blank wall to the north
• Electrically operated thermal
shutter tracks the sun redirects low
angle winter sunlight but rejects
high angle summer sunlight (as
well as heat)
• System of mirrors within the tower
redirects light into the church

Translucent Materials

Translucent materials can be used

in place of glass to allow diffuse
light into a space with no direct sun.
Fig. 13 Interior photo of the Chelsea Club
Some translucent materials include
fiberglass, plastics, Kalwall, and
frosted glass. • Client wanted privacy (no views) Daylighting in a building should be
as well as a naturally lit space designed to reflect the use of space
Case Study • Vandal-resistant, light-diffusing within. Different functions and
fiberglass panels called ‘Kalwall’ activities merit different levels and
Chelsea Club • Diffuse light forms of daylighting and different
Fletcher Priest • Exterior appearance seems to be strategies and technologies provide
London, England solid white by day different daylighting conditions. It is

10
 Daylight Performance in Mid/Large Buildings

important to analyze these variables Architectural Expression of Oxford: Architectural Press, 2007.
in order to choose the best form of Environmental Control Systems.
daylighting and shading for each London: Spon Press, 2001. Guzowski, Mary. Daylighting for
building. Sustainable Design. New York:
Figure 07: From The Green Studio McGraw-Hill, 2000.
Handbook

Figure 08: From The Green Studio Herzog, Thomas, et. al. Facade
Notes Handbook Construction Manual. Basel:
1. Grondzik, Walter and Alison Birkhauser, 2004.
Kwok. The Green Studio Handbook. Figure 09: From Facade
Oxford: Architectural Press, 2007. Construction Manual Koster, Helmut. Dynamic Daylighting
Architecture: Basics, Systems,
2. Grondzik, Walter and Alison Figure 10: From Facade Projects. Basel: Birkhauser, 2004.
Kwok. The Green Studio Handbook. Construction Manual
Oxford: Architectural Press, 2007. “Light Guide: Lighting Metrics:
Figure 11: From “Nasher Sculpture Quantity, Quality, Efficiency”.
3. Guzowski, Mary. Daylighting for Center - Building Detail”. Nasher LightSearch. October 20, 2009
Sustainable Design. New York: Sculpture Center. October 20, 2009 <http://www.lightsearch.com/
McGraw-Hill, 2000. <http://www.nashersculpturecenter. resources/lightguides/lightmetrics.
org/Building-and-Garden/Building- html>.
4. Grondzik, Walter and Alison Detail>.
Kwok. The Green Studio Handbook. Müller, Helmut F. O. and Schuster,
Oxford: Architectural Press, 2007. Figure 12: From Daylighting - Natural Heide G. “Utilizing Daylight.”
Light in Architecture In Detail: Solar Architecture.
5. Grondzik, Walter and Alison Ed. Christian Schittich. Basel:
Kwok. The Green Studio Handbook. Figure 13: From Daylighting - Natural Birkhauser, 2003. 56-69.
Oxford: Architectural Press, 2007. Light in Architecture
Phillips, Derek. Daylighting - Natural
Light in Architecture. Amsterdam:
References Architectural Press, 2004.
Figures
Allen, Edward, and Iano Joseph. Stein, Benjamin, et. al. Mechanical
Figure 01: From Daylighting - Natural The Architect’s Studio Companion. and Electrical Equipment for
Light in Architecture Hoboken, New Jersey: John Wiley & Buildings. Hoboken, New Jersey:
Sons, Inc., 2007. John Wiley and Sons, 2006.
Figure 02: From Facade
Construction Manual “Brightness and Color of Light”.
Environmental Defense Fund.
Figure 03: From Sun, Wind and October 20, 2009 <http://www.edf.
Light: Architectural Design Strategies org/page.cfm?tagid=630>.

Figure 04: From Daylighting - Natural Brown, G.Z., and Mark DeKay. Sun,
Light in Architecture Wind and Light: Architectural Design
Strategies. New York: John Wiley
Figure 05: From Dynamic Daylighting and Sons, 2001.
Architecture: Basics, Systems,
Projects Grondzik, Walter and Alison Kwok.
The Green Studio Handbook.
Figure 06: From Baird, George.

11