Ccna 1º Semestre
Ccna 1º Semestre
Overview
In this Preface Chapter are located various resources to help you teach the course. In addition to
this Preface Chapter, Instructor Notes are included with every target indicator. These notes
include the rationale for teaching a particular topic, suggested activities, and common student
misconceptions. Instructor Lab solutions are included with each of the lab activities. For those of
you familiar with the Teacher's Guide 1.50, this Preface Chapter and the integrated Instructor
Notes contain much of the information of the old Teacher's Guide. More detailed lesson plans
aligned with the new curriculum are being created and will be included in future releases. Note
that there are three ways to navigate within the Preface Chapter. You may use the INDEX icon at
the bottom right of your screen, the pull-down preface menu at the bottom center of your screen,
or of course, the BACK and NEXT icons.
The Preface Chapter begins with FAQs and Syllabi. FAQs will hopefully answer some of your
basic questions about the new curriculum version. Two sample syllabi -- an 18-week version,
typical of a high school semester, and a 9-week version, typical of a community college or block
schedule -- are included to help you begin creating your own syllabus.
A list of Academy Best Teaching Practices has been compiled. It is imperative that you use a
wide variety of these Best Practices to present the Cisco Networking Academy Curriculum; these
practices have been demonstrated to be successful with a wide variety of learners. The Best
Practices include Challenges, Design Activities, Graphical Organizers, Group Work, Journals,
Kinesthetic Activities, Lab Exams, Mini-lectures, Online Study, Oral Exams, Portfolios,
Presentations, Rubrics, Study Guides, Troubleshooting, and Web Research. All of the Best
Practices are explained; for more information contact your Regional Academy or CATC. Note that
lecture (and PowerPoint or other such leader-led presentations) comprises just a tiny fraction of
how Cisco intends the curriculum to be presented. The subject matter, our goals for our
graduates, and good pedagogy all dictate that a mixture of these Best Practices be used.
Especially important are the hands-on labs and lab exams, project-based learning (challenges),
and troubleshooting. For example, all Academies are required to have their students build simple
LANs, use multimeters and cable test meters, terminate Cat 5 Cabling, and perform a Structured
Cabling Project as part of their first semester skill-building. There are 34 lab activities in Semester
1. You will probably not be able to complete them all; do as many as you can. Refer to the
Instructor's download site, the FAQs, and the sample syllabi to find out which labs are more
crucial than others.
The Instructor's Resource Guide is a series of short articles on various teaching strategies which
will help you teach an engaging and effective class.
An Ideal Toolkit for Semester 1 is described. While tool and consumable brands will vary with
location, we have tried to specify easily-obtained items. This set of tools has proven to be
versatile and useful through all four Semesters of the Cisco Networking Academy Curriculum. To
perform more exact calculations of what your budget should be, use the Cost Calculator utility
available on the Community Server ==> Academy Start Guides ==> Local Academy
Implementation Guide ==> Cost Calculator. Due to the widely varying nature of the Structured
Cabling Project, it is impossible to give exact quantities on consumable items such as cable,
connectors, and jacks. Use the Cost Calculator to help you plan your Structured Cabling Project.
A Lesson Plan Template is included. While instructors are not required to follow this format (many
instructors have their own preferred individualized formats), it summarizes well what Cisco
expects in the way of Instructional (Lesson) Planning. Secondary instructors may be more familiar
with these concepts, but we highly recommend them for post-secondary courses as well. Cisco
envisions your role in the Academy classroom, not as a "sage on the stage" lecturing the class,
but rather as a "guide on the side" facilitating hands-on and Web-based learning experiences.
A skills-based troubleshooting final exam is included. While your implementation of this exam
may vary somewhat from ours, your students, at the end of Semester 1, should be able to
troubleshoot the list of problems cited. Only in realistic problem-solving environments can
students actually learn to design, install, and maintain networks. Networking is a fundamentally
lab and problem-based field. An oral exam format is included as well. We find that the oral exam -
- a combination of individual and group responsibility -- can be a very powerful vehicle for
learning.
An article, "Cisco's Assessment Philosophy," has been included to provide more background on
how we view teaching and learning within the Cisco Networking Academy Program.
0.1 FAQs
1. Version 1.1 and 2.0 differ in structure. Version 2.0 is structured entirely around the OSI
Reference Model. The chapters work up through Layers 1-7, with a break in the middle of
the course for a structured cabling project. Version 2.1 was a extremely major bug fix
release of Version 2.0. Version 2.1.1 is essentially the same as Version 2.1, but with
your feedback incorporated, bugs fixed, printing and platform issues resolved, and minor
additions we felt would help the semester added. Though we may not reach the goal, we
are committed to striving for zero bugs. These minor releases will happen every 90 days
and will require NO retooling; major releases (which may involve major content and/or
structural changes will only happen once per year.
2. The number of hands-on labs has been increased and has been moved closer to the
beginning of the course in order to more effectively motivate students to learn the subject
and to introduce the Fluke (or equivalent) test equipment and software.
3. The structured cabling project has been moved to the middle of the semester, again for
motivational purposes.
4. Binary math is taught separately from IP addressing in order to allow students time to
master the math before being asked to apply it.
5. IP addressing - for many students the most difficult part of the course - has been moved
to a later point in the semester, when the students are, presumably, more motivated and
more patient with difficult topics.
6. The tone of the course - especially the emphasis on the TCP/IP protocol stack - has been
updated to stress how the Internet works.
7. Some basic electronics have been introduced to make the media section of the course
more meaningful.
8. New topics (e.g. wireless technologies, FDDI, and many others) have been added to
make the course more of a survey of the breadth of networking technologies.
9. Version 2.0 is generated from a curricular database full of "target indicators" - the term for
behavioral objectives, or measurable student outcomes. These target indicators more
clearly define what should be taught, what should be learned, and how students will be
assessed. Many comments during the past year stated that the tests were not tied closely
enough to the curriculum. In version 2.0, all assessment items (test questions) are
traceable to a specific target indicator.
10. In version 2.1, the topics and order of presentation of 2.0 have been maintained.
However, a major look-and-feel change has been made, creating what we believe is a far
more friendly GUI. Version 2.1 graphics and movies are Flash adaptations of version 2.0
graphics and movies, leading to a much improved visual presentation and far more
interactivity. Version 2.1 contains large numbers of technical and grammatical corrections
to version 2.0. Version 2.1 contains the same basic lab activities, but they have been
documented in greater detail.
Q2. Why did Cisco change the curriculum?
There are four primary reasons why we changed the curriculum:
1. We said we would. Cisco has an ongoing commitment to continually improve its Web-
based curriculum this includes fixing technical errors and grammar.
2. You said we should. Feedback from many Local Academy, Regional Academy, and
CATC training courses pointed out strengths and weaknesses of the original version of
Semester 1 (version 1.1). Field feedback and our own testing also revealed some bugs
in version 2.1; hence the release of version 2.1.1.
3. The field of networking is changing. The field of networking is constantly changing - you
will notice a greater emphasis on optical fiber and wireless technology as these become
increasingly important in the field.
4. We want to comply with more certification standards. We are striving to prepare students
not only for their CCNA exam and certification (which implies one set of behavioral
objectives, or target indicators), but also for their CompTIA Net+ networking certification
exam (which implies a somewhat different set of target indicators).
Q3. What about lesson plans?
We have included a suggested lesson plan format (see Lesson Plan Template) that emphasizes
the use of Best Practices. Use this format if you find it useful; otherwise, use whatever lesson
planning method you prefer. Lesson planning is an essential part of teaching this conceptually
difficult, comprehensive, and lab-intensive course There are too many topics to teach, and too
many labs to do, to try to conduct classes without serious planning. Of course, only you can tailor
the course materials to your students, your class periods, your semester calendar, and to your
particular teaching strengths.
Assuming that you've been through training, yourself, and have read the curriculum, we
recommend that you use the Lesson Plan Template. No single standard set of lesson plans,
written from afar, can substitute for you, the skilled teacher, writing your own lesson plans. With
your knowledge of your own technical strengths and weaknesses, your knowledge of your
students' needs, your appreciation for the availability of your lab, computers, tools, and other
resources, and the reality of your daily and monthly schedules, you know what's best to make
your classroom work. Suggested Daily Lesson Plans will be available by 9/01/00.
The individual parts of the Lesson Plan Template include the following:
In Advance - indicates what you should do before the lesson (i.e. which online lessons to
read; what materials you will need)
Preparation for Learning - alerts you to the day's teaching objectives (target indicators),
to any vocabulary that may come up in the day's lesson, and to a focus question (warm-
up, anticipatory set) to get the students started
Delivery of Instruction - provides some key lecture note points, links to key graphics, and
instructions relating to how the students should use the online materials
Reflection - done in journal; there are four types: content, process, product, and progress
Comments - notes/remarks about how your lesson plan went will help you and others
evaluate its effectiveness
Please consider submitting some of your favorite lesson plans to the ftp site so that our entire
community - that includes thousands of instructors and tens of thousands of students - may
benefit.
Q4. How can different schedules be accommodated?
We have not scripted the content into 50- or 100-minute lesson plans; you will need to write your
own (we have suggested a template for lesson planning). Teach target indicators (behavioral
objectives) at a pace and depth appropriate for your students. Perhaps the most difficult
scheduling issue you will encounter is making sure that you complete all of the hands-on labs.
This will be especially challenging for teachers who have short class periods (e.g. 42 or 48
minutes). For those teaching in 100-minute or longer blocks, the most common problem is often
spending too much time on a given topic before moving on.
Q5. How will I know if I'm progressing through the chapters at the proper pace?
We have provided a suggested syllabus. Keep in mind that it is only a rough guide; you may take
longer on some chapters and condense others. Monitor the discussion forums to see how others
are doing. If at all possible, enforce the out-of-class time requirements; this will assure efficient
use of class time. Suggested Daily Lesson Plans will be available 9/01/00. The final indicators
are:
whether or not your students are meeting the Benchmark Questions and Benchmark
Skills
whether your students can design, install, and maintain school-sized internetworks
How you get high performance from your students on exams and Benchmarks is up to you
"many paths, one mountain."
Q6. What material is essential?
Chapter 2, on the OSI model is absolutely essential for all networking students and for
the CCNA exam.
Chapter 5, especially the parts on collisions and segmentation, is also very important for
the CCNA exam.
The skills of Chapter 5 and Chapter 9 are crucial for any student who wants to go into
any network cabling related work.
Understanding the material of the other layers - Chapters 12, 13, 14, and 15 - is
important, but can be done efficiently.
Q7. What material can I skim?
Chapter 1 can be covered quickly if your students are already computer knowledgeable.
Chapter 3 can be covered fairly quickly, but don't skimp on the labs.
Chapter 8 goes into far more depth than is required to teach students about MDFs and
IDFs; you can make up time there.
Chapter 9 can be taught in a wide variety of ways, and since it's expected that at least
some of your structured cabling project will occur outside of class time, you may pick up a
few days in that chapter.
Chapter 10 is important; cover it in depth.
Chapter 15 can have its high points summarized and be covered rapidly.
While there is more material presented than most classes will be able to cover, with some
judicious selections along the way, the class has (in our Beta tests) been taught within
the specified 70 hours + 16 hours out-of-class.
Q8. What assumptions go into this Instructors Guide?
For Semester 1, we have assumed a class size of 32 students.
Labs - groups of 4
installing NICs and building small networks - 10 PCs available for the "experimental"
network part of the lab room
Class periods - 70 50-minute classes, plus 2 hours a week of either lunch, after school, or
home study of the curriculum
Q9. What if I have other ideas about how to teach Semester 1?
Let the community know about them. Use the discussion forums to share whatever instructional
materials you develop and are willing to share with the rest of our electronic community. You can
also share your ideas on the ftp site on the Community Server. Let us know, so we can
incorporate these ideas in future versions of the Instructor's Guide.
No. While we feel the Fluke equipment is a bargain and a very powerful learning tool, you can
use equivalent products supplied by other vendors.We hope you take the time to investigate the
various purchase options Fluke has, and at a minimum purchase the Starter Kit which gives your
lab one medium-capable cable meter, a multimeter, network analysis and protocol analysis
software, and a troubleshooting book. The learning center kit guarantees hands-on experience
with professional quality instruments for all of your students. Especially the protocol sniffer
(Protocol Inspector) allows an amazing glimpse into the network processes and protocols
described throughout semester 1.
0.2 Syllabus
Syllabus: 9 Weeks
A. General Information
Units 3
Prerequisites Required: none
Helpful: A+ Certification; Microsoft Office Skills; introductory
programming or multimedia courses; introductory electronics
Instructor your name here
Textbook Required: none (online multimedia)
Optional: Computer Networks (Andrew Tannenbaum); CCNA First-Year
Companion Guide (Amato et. al); CCNA Exam: Certification Guide
(Odom); Cisco Routing (Lewis)
Materials pen, paper, journal (composition book), soft 3-ring binder
Standards A >= 90%, B >= 80%, C >= 70%, D >= 60%
Required Class Hours Five 50-minute days per week plus 16 additional hours (below)
Open Lab Hours with 1 hour per week by appointment or schedule
Instructor Present
Structured Cabling Project 8 hours one Saturday (Net Day or equivalent)
B. Grading
ITEM PERCENT COMMENTS
Homework Optional highly recommended
Engineering Journal 20% lab journal will help students learn the IOS; lab journal
may be used on some skills exams
Online Chapter Exams 20% using assessment server
Online Final Exam 20% similar to the CCNA exam; using the Assessment Server
Oral Final Exam 20% rubric to be distributed prior to the exam
Skills-Based Final Exam 20% rubric to be distributed prior to the exam
C. Week by Week
WEEK CHAPTER DESCRIPTIONS
1 1 1 - Getting Started; Introduction to Computing
2 2, 3 2 - The OSI Model; 3 - Local Area Networks (LANs)
3 4, 5 5 - Layer 1: Media, Connections, and Collisions
4 5, 6, 7 5 - Layer 1: Media, Connections, and Collisions; 6 - Layer 2: Concepts
7 - Layer 2: Technologies
5 7, 8 7 - Layer 2: Technologies; 8 - Design and Documentation
6 9, 10 9 - Structured Cabling Project; 10 - Layer 3: Addressing and Routing
7 10, 11 10 - Layer 3: Addressing and Routing; 11 - Layer 3: Routing and Protocols
8 12, 13, 14, 12 - Layer 4: The Transport Layer; 13 - Layer 5: The Session Layer
15 14 - Layer 6: The Presentation Layer; 15 - Layer 7: The Application Layer
9 ---- Review and Finals
D. Benchmark Questions and Skills
WEEK CHAPTER BENCHMARKS
1 1 Can all students perform simple PC (hardware, software, network settings)
and NIC troubleshooting?
Can all students do binary math? Can all students use the units of information
and bandwidth?
2 2, 3 Can all students name and describe the OSI layers from memory? Can all
students describe the TCP/IP graph?
Can all students describe the devices required to build a LAN? Given those
devices, can all students build and troubleshoot a simple LAN?
3 4, 5 Can all students describe networking signals and what can happen to them on
physical media? Can all students use a multimeter to measure resistance,
voltage, and continuity?
Can all students describe the 5 basic networking media? Can all students
terminate CAT 5 UTP cable according to standards?
4 5, 6, 7 Can all students, given a topology, circle all collision and broadcast domains?
Can all students describe the basic elements of a frame? Can all students do
hexadecimal math? Can all students compare and contrast Token Ring,
FDDI, and the Ethernet family tree?
5 7, 8 Can all students explain the specific details of Ethernet and Layer 2
Devices?Can all students use 'Network Inspector' (or equivalent) and 'Protocol
Inspector' (or equivalent) software?
Can all students create physical and logical topologies? Can all students
properly locate MDFs and IDFs in an Ethernet extended star topology? Can
all students plan a structured cabling installation? [Out-of-Class Structured
Cabling Project]
6 9, 10 Can all students install, terminate, test, and troubleshoot CAT 5 UTP cabling
runs, from the jack to the patch panel? Have all students mastered the Fluke
620 (or equivalent) meter? [Out-of-Class Structured Cabling Project]
Can all students justify the need for and classify the various types of IP
addresses? Can all students create subnets?
7 10, 11 Can all students do the following form of problem: "Given an IP address and
the number of subnets required, find the subnetwork id numbers, the range of
host numbers, the subnetwork broadcast numbers, and the subnet mask?"
Can all students, using packet diagrams and tracing header transformations,
give a basic explanation of routing? Can all students flowchart basic network
processes such as ARP and RARP?
8 12, 13, 14, Can all students explain the similarities and differences between IP, TCP, and
15 UDP?
Can all students explain the basic processes of the session layer?
Can all students describe the presentation layer functions of formatting,
encryption, and compression?
Can all students explain how e-mail and HTTP work?
9 ------ Review and Finals: Have all students mastered the concepts and skills of
Chapters 1-15?
Syllabus: 18 Weeks
A. General Information
Units 3
Prerequisites Required: none
Helpful: A+ Certification; Microsoft Office Skills; introductory programming
or multimedia courses; introductory electronics
Instructor your name here
Textbook Required: none (online multimedia)
Optional: Computer Networks (Andrew Tannenbaum); CCNA First-Year
Companion Guide (Amato et. al); CCNA Exam: Certification Guide
(Odom); Cisco Routing (Lewis)
Materials pen, paper, journal (composition book), soft 3-ring binder
Standards A >= 90%, B >= 80%, C >= 70%, D >= 60%
Required Class Hours Five 50-minute days per week plus 16 additional hours (below)
Open Lab Hours with 1 hour per week by appointment or schedule
Instructor Present
Structured Cabling Project 8 hours one Saturday (Net Day or equivalent)
B. Grading
ITEM PERCENT COMMENTS
Homework Optional highly recommended lab journal may be used on skills exams
Engineering Journal 20% lab journal will help students learn the IOS; lab journal may be
used on some skills exams
Online Chapter Exams 20% using assessment server
Online Final Exam 20% similar to the CCNA exam; using Assessment Server
Oral Final Exam 20% rubric to be distributed prior to the exam
Skills-Based Final Exam 20% rubric to be distributed prior to the exam
C. Week by Week
WEEK CHAPTER DESCRIPTIONS
1 1 1 - Getting Started; Introduction to Computing
2 1 1 - Introduction to Computing
3 2 2 - The OSI Model
4 3 3 - Local Area Networks (LANs)
5 4 4 - Layer 1: Electronics and Signals
6 5 5 - Layer 1: Media, Connections, and Collisions
7 5, 6 5 - Layer 1: Media, Connections, and Collisions; 6 - Layer 2: Concepts
8 7 7 - Layer 2: Technologies
9 7 7 - Layer 2: Technologies
10 8 8 - Design and Documentation
11 9 9 - Structured Cabling Project
12 10 10 - Layer 3: Addressing and Routing
13 10 10 - Layer 3: Addressing and Routing
14 10 10 - Layer 3: Addressing and Routing
15 11 11 - Layer 3: Routing and Protocols
16 12,13,14,15 12 - Layer 4: The Transport Layer; 13 - Layer 5: The Session Layer
14 - Layer 6: The Presentation Layer; 15 - Layer 7: The Application Layer
17 12,13,14,15 12 - Layer 4: The Transport Layer; 13 - Layer 5: The Session Layer
14 - Layer 6: The Presentation Layer; 15 - Layer 7: The Application Layer
18 ----- Review and Finals
0.3.1 Challenges
Challenges are problem-based labs or projects, advocated by AAAS Project 2061 (a science
education reform project). These exercises are the opposite of cookbook, or step-by-step, labs.
Instead, they encourage students to work on their own to develop solutions to various problems,
or challenges.
The challenges vary in content and duration (from fifty minutes to three weeks), and are
comprised of two basic parts. First, the lab asks students to solve a given problem. Second, it
asks the students to create a product. For example, a simple 50-minute challenge lab for the first
semester might be titled "Make a Patch Cable That Works Successfully". A three-week challenge
that could teach more complex tasks might be called "Wire the School Computer Lab". Net Day is
a great example of challenge-based learning, and we encourage you to incorporate it into your
classes.
Design is an iterative process that starts with brainstorming, proceeds through research and
problem-solving matrices, design specification tests, and multiple repetitions of this process until
an adequate solution to a problem is achieved. While LAN design is the focus of Semester 3, and
WAN design the focus of Semester 4, Semesters 1 and 2 are good places to introduce elements
of the Dartmouth Problem-Solving and Design Method. We highly recommend the problem-
solving approach summarized at http://thayer.dartmouth.edu/teps/index.html. This site has online
resources as well as written materials that you may download, and a video that you may order.
Whether students will be troubleshooting problems in an existing network, or designing and
checking a network in order for it to meet specifications, the process involves an iterative
problem-solving procedure. For internetworking problems, and for engineering problems in
general, problem-solving matrices are always useful whenever there are a number of alternatives
for a given number of constraints. Chapter 1, The Engineering Problem-Solving Cycle of the
Engineering Problem Solving for Mathematics, Science, and Technology Education uses the
Problem Solving Matrix to introduce the Problem Solving Cycle and its iterative nature. Most
importantly, use of the matrix exposes students to the fine art of defining a problem. Chapter 4,
Guiding Students Through the Problem-Solving Cycle gives suggestions on iterating the entire
process, including more detail on how to choose effective problems, how to set up the right
environment for brainstorming sessions, and how to analyze the results of these sessions.
It is our hope that students will gain an appreciation for the importance of problem solving - one of
the most important aspects of engineering. In addition, we want students to experience the
process of using these procedures to gain a clearer understanding of why some potential
solutions work and why some do not. They will learn that employing good problem-solving
procedures and documentation will ultimately determine their success in finding solutions to
problems. As time goes by, they will be able to use the lessons learned from past failed problem-
solving attempts to save valuable time when trying to solve new problems. Chapter 5, Research,
Documentation, and Testing is a good resource for conducting site surveys, keeping work logs,
producing engineering reports, and creating portfolios.
0.3.3 Graphical organizers and representations
Cluster Diagrams
Cluster diagrams have several uses. During brainstorming sessions, a prompt is put in the central
cluster and then the ideas that result from brainstorming (i.e. wildest possible ideas, no
censorship, as many ideas as possible, ideas built on those of others) are added as more
bubbles. Similar ideas are clustered. This diagram is also used as a concept map, or a way of
presenting material to students and as way of assessing their understanding of a concept.
Problem-Solving Matrices
Problem-solving matrices are a standard part of design documentation. In their simplest form, a
variety of design options (e.g. network media, network architecture, or protocol) are listed
vertically, while the specifications against which the choices will be rated are listed horizontally.
Simplistically, whichever option earns the highest score against the specification rubric is chosen.
Realistically, design is an repetitious process and many layers of matrices are typically created
with increasingly refined specifications, weighted rubrics, and lots of brainstorming and research.
Flowcharts
Flowcharts are a standard part of computer programming. Flowcharts, and process flow
diagrams, are generally used to graphically represent various branching processes. Flowcharts
are used throughout the curriculum to describe configuration, troubleshooting, and
communications processes.
Block Diagrams
Block diagrams are standard throughout electronics. A few simple symbols (or pictorials) are
used along with arrows to indicate the flow of information, along with simple descriptions of the
functions of the various "black box" blocks. Block diagrams represent an intermediate level of
detail for electrical systems - they are not circuit-level schematic diagrams. A block diagram of the
internal components of a PC, the internal components of a router, or the devices which make up
the LAN or a WAN make a good accompaniment to flowcharts explaining processes taking place
among the blocks. Block diagrams often wind up being similar to logical topologies.
Additional resources on grouping strategies are available in the Teaching Strategies section.
0.3.5 Journals
Beginning with Semester 1, you should require students to keep a technical, or Engineering
Journal (EJ), in which to record details involving all aspects of their network design and
installation experiences. While it may not seem important to them at first, it will develop a good
habit, and will eventually become more important as they increase their networking experiences.
Typically, the journal is a paper-bound composition book in which pages are dated, and added,
but never subtracted. The entries would include such things as:
daily reflections
troubleshooting details
equipment logs
router configurations
A kinesthetic activity refers to the use of a body to act out, or to communicate something. In this
case, it is the networking process. These exercises might also be known as role-playing activities
or skits. They help make complex, normally invisible processes more understandable for
students, and are great fun.
Kinesthetic activities can be especially helpful when introducing some of the basic networking
concepts. For example, during Semester 1, have students act out any, or all, of the following:
During Semester 2, kinesthetic activities can be particularly helpful when trying to explain the
following concepts:
routing loops
distance-vector routing
link-state routing
performance exams
demonstration labs
authentic assessment
mastery learning
We recommend simple pass/fail grading, with opportunities for retaking the lab exam. In
Semester 1, we recommend that you give lab exams for subjects such as the following:
configuring IP addresses
The focus of Semester 2 is on developing student proficiency in configuring routers and then
groups of routers and networks.
0.3.8 Mini-lectures
While this type of lecturing is not encouraged as a primary means of delivering Networking
Academy instruction, studies have found that relatively short, engaging lectures that include
demonstrations are an excellent adjunct to the online curriculum and lab activities.
While the online lessons are the primary means of delivering the Cisco Networking Academy
Program instruction, they should not be overly used. Remember that a primary goal of the
Networking Academy is to train students to design, install, and maintain networks - which is
fundamentally a hands-on, problem-based, lab-based endeavor. When you use the online
curriculum in the classroom, you should have 1-2 students viewing it at each computer, while you
circulate throughout the room checking for problems/comprehension, and periodically interrupting
with additional information or content clarification.
Well-planned oral exams can be powerful learning experiences for students, and with your careful
preparation and scaffolding, you can minimize the usual intimidation factor. While the models for
such exams are usually job interviews and graduate school oral exams, a format that works well,
particularly with groups of diverse learners, is to give teams of students the exam questions,
answers, and rubrics in advance of the scheduled exam session. Then, at the pre-scheduled
exam time (usually after school unless you have block periods), each individual member of the
team enters the room, alone, and is asked one of the questions by the board. While studying and
grading are group-based, each individual must answer one of the questions, without knowing in
advance which question he/she must answer. This type of format usually prompts the students to
study very hard and with a great amount of spirit.
Examples are in the Semester 1 lesson plans. We encourage you to develop your own format,
but also to consider oral exams, especially when testing for "Benchmark Understandings".
0.3.11 Portfolios
A portfolio is a collection, either in paper or online form, that shows a student's best work during a
semester, and is subject to ongoing revision and improvement. Many secondary school districts
are encouraging portfolio-based assessments, and certainly the Networking Academy program is
well-suited for this type of assessment. Students maintain their portfolios which eventually include
all of their best work for all four of the curriculum semesters. This portfolio could be part of the
graduation for your Local Academy and would serve as impressive display for potential
employers.
0.3.12 Presentations
Presentations include simple student lectures, student PowerPoint presentations, and seminars.
0.3.13 Rubrics
Rubrics are the specific expectation criteria for the performance of a lab or activity. Each task has
a specific set of performance levels for the objectives, content, and skills that are to be
demonstrated. It contains the criteria that define the key elements that are necessary in order to
assess the degree of learning. Many rubrics are based on a four-point scale, with the exemplar
level being four points. Each of the points on the scale has specific criteria that describe the
characteristics of a performance.
Before you begin your assessments of student interaction, classroom work, or any performance
lab or activity, you should tell your students in advance what your expectations are. This will help
them begin the process of self-assessment as they progress through the individual tasks that are
involved.
The Study Guide provides an organized method for students to record the important concepts of
the lesson, to use later for review and reflection. Some specific strategies that you can use to
assist them are embedded within the lessons, with options available in the Instructor Guide
section. Each lesson in Semester 1 and 2 has specific, lesson related, entries for students. You
may duplicate them on a lesson-by-lesson basis, or compile them in notebook form by chapter or
semester. You may wish to add a specific activity to the Study Guide before distribute them.
Throughout this Study Guide there are links to specific journal entries in the areas of "Learning"
(content); "Applying" (performance labs); and, "Reflecting" (student reflection). In Semesters 3
and 4, the Study Guide entries may be less specific with the goal of having students learn and
model independence in making appropriate entries that will assist them to perform and complete
projects with insight and accuracy.
STUDY GUIDE
Semester 1
Lesson No.
2. Applying - Organize, plan, record process, draft, record findings, and/or show the results of
your performance lab or activity.
3. Reflecting - Think about and respond to questions about your learning, focusing on the
content, product, process/progress.
Templates
Study Guide Blank Template Study Guide Example
TRANSITIONING from TEXTBOOK to ONLINE LEARNING
(Using the Study Guide)
Online learning is a new experience for many students and adults. Traditionally, students have
had textbooks that they could carry around, refer to when needed, and if they owned the book,
make notes in the margins. This has always been satisfactory when studying history, literature,
and other similar subjects. Unfortunately, textbooks have several disadvantages when used for
studying something as rapidly growing and changing as the subject of networking.
The most important disadvantage is the static nature of textbooks. Producing textbooks can take
anywhere from several months to several years. By the time they have been distributed, the
information contained within them might already be dated or even obsolete. A networking
curriculum demands a dynamic information source that can adapt to the rapid changes and
innovations in the field.
The second disadvantage of textbooks is their cost. They are becoming more expensive each
year, and are large budget item for most educational agencies. Most school districts have a
schedule of textbook replacement that results in textbooks being used for many years.
Understandably, this has always been a handicap for studying the science, but for studying
networking it has been so in the extreme. Each day brings news of advancements and
discoveries that will someday become a necessary element of the networking professional's
skills. Textbook publishers simply cannot keep up with that pace.
Online study is always dynamic, always up to date. It can, however, be a challenge, because of
its non-traditional method of delivery. It is for that reason that as students and adults transition to
online learning, they need to use strategies that can assist them. Using a study guide is one of
those strategies.
The Study Guide Template is designed to help students structure their notes. They can have a
hard copy of the important information to refer to at home, or during other study time. It is
composed of three sections: "Learning", "Applying", and "Reflecting".
The "Learning" section is the first section of the Study Guide. It has a space for recording new
vocabulary for that lesson. This is especially important in Semester 1 which has an extensive list
of new vocabulary words and acronyms. The instructor may wish to suggest vocabulary be
included or let students select their own. Another part of the "Learning" section is the space for
notes and ideas. This is the place where students can make sketches of diagrams they have
seen in the online content, and make notes regarding relationships of ideas and concepts. The
instructor may identify one or more questions to guide the study of the content, or have students
identify them before reading the online curriculum. This process helps students recall factual
information and do higher-level thinking regarding the concepts. The last part is the space for
recording an activity. The instructor may wish to make an assignment in class to help the student
understand the material.
The second section of the Study Guide is the "Applying" section. This is a section in which
students can make notes regarding their labs, activities, a special project, etc. They would use
this in addition to their Engineering Journal entries, with some of the journal entries being an
analysis of the entire Study Guide.
The third section of the Study Guide is the "Reflecting" section. Two of the higher level skills
required to design, build and maintain networks are analysis and problem solving. Reflecting is a
key strategy (Best Practices) that provides structure for students to analyze what they have been
studying and to determine for themselves the level of success they have had learning and
understanding each concept, and to set goals for improving their learning.
Working in pairs or groups of three, to complete the activities, and/or discussing their responses
with 1-2 other students can further strengthen the impact of the "Learning" and the "Applying"
sections. It ensures that students have read the material, taken notes, and discussed it with other
students. The Instructors Guide includes a Study Guide Introduction, a Study Guide Example,
and a Study Guide Template.
0.3.15 Troubleshooting
Troubleshooting skills are an absolute necessity for students who seek to design, install, and
maintain internetworks. It is the most empowering skill that you can pass on to your students.
Teaching troubleshooting typically requires that you spend time on lab preparation; however, the
overall benefit to the students is well worth the time. We encourage you to introduce
troubleshooting early in Semester 1, and to continue to emphasize it throughout Semesters 2, 3,
and 4.
There are a variety of ways to teach troubleshooting methods. One instructional method involves
deliberately introducing a finite number of problems into the following areas:
host IP addresses
networking devices
cabling
With practice, students will be able to diagnose and fix the problems in a finite amount of time. Of
course, this method must be integrated with labs that do the following:
allow students to experience first hand the symptoms of those failure modes
The Internet has a tremendous amount of resources for those who want to understand or install
networks, and research specific products, questions, or extension activities. We encourage you to
use, even in Semester 1, the wide variety of links built into the Instructors Guide, or to use your
own favorite Web sites.
In Semesters 2, 3, and 4, the online documentation at Cisco becomes particularly important. In
terms of bandwidth capabilities, the Web resources for teaching networking far exceed any
textbook or online curriculum. Of course, you must find the resources and as always, be a
cautious consumer. Using the Internet as a resource is also a very useful skill for students to
develop.
0.4 Instructors Resource Guide
You may choose elements to design your own plans pending your classroom needs, your
schedule, and your teaching style. In order to assist you, this guide presents a variety of teaching
tools with complete explanations of the strategies and resources needed for your success.
Teaching Strategies
Teaching Strategies for enhancing the student learning are embedded in each lesson. There are
also many optional strategies you may select, including:
suggestions for helping students organize learning and review, and study and
demonstrate their understanding of the content
tips for designing focus questions and helping students clarify their learning (embedded
in most lessons)
Creating Curiosity
Creating curiosity or motivating students to learn can be done in a variety of ways. Relating the
content to be learned to their own personal lives and/or experiences is the best way. Linking the
content with what they already know and providing a means to help them see how the content or
skills can be used later is the key for inspiring curiosity.
Using Inquiry
Helping students raise questions about the content to be learned assists in their connections to
subsequent knowledge. The KWL (know, want to know, and learned) format provides a basis for
inquiring about the content prior to learning. Inquiry plans are sometimes used to help students
organize their questions and organize their work.
Focusing learning
You can focus the learning process by asking specific questions, soliciting predictions from
students, discussing previous student learning, and clearly defining the objectives that are to be
learned. A rubric that clearly defines criteria of the expected results can often help students focus
on the content to be learned. Focus questions are suggested in each lesson to help engage
students in the content. They stimulate prior knowledge, help connect thinking with other topics,
assist in predicting learning outcomes, and give more meaning to lesson content.
Grouping Students
Knowing how and when to group students is important. There are a variety of ways that you can
engage students in learning, apart from having them work individually. Some of the most common
ways to group students - for reviewing, questioning, learning content, doing performance labs, or
assessing their learning - include the following:
pairs or partners
small groups
teams
competitive teams
large groups
whole glass
Pairs of students discuss and answer the review questions on their computer.
Pairs or small groups of students discuss and answer the review questions.
The entire class or groups of students discuss the review questions and connect to prior
understanding through explanation.
Small groups each discuss a portion of the questions and demonstrate understanding by
explaining to other groups (jigsaw technique).
Student teams or small groups design analogies to explain concepts to other teams of
students.
content
product
process
progress
Using Rubrics
Rubrics are specific criterion of the performance lab expectations. A scale, usually based on 4
points (0-4 scale) that specifies the performance objectives, content, and skills to be
demonstrated is provided for each task. A rubric contains the criteria that define what key
elements are needed to assess the learning. Several rubrics are embedded in the content of
lessons through the guide.
Throughout the Study Guide there are links to specific journal entries in the areas of "Learning"
(content); "Applying" (performance labs); and, "Reflecting" (student reflection). In Semesters 3
and 4, the Study Guide entries may be less specific with the goal of having students learn and
model independence in making appropriate entries that will assist them to perform and complete
projects with insight and accuracy.
direct instruction
Socratic questioning
online learning
demonstrations
student presentations
field trips
Specific activities for Semester 1 are provided for each lesson in the "Applying" section of the
Engineering Journal.
Performance Labs/Activities
This specialized form of instructional delivery allows students to use hands-on strategies for
learning content, and includes both labs and other performance tasks. Applying knowledge
through any of the following activities/tasks enables students and teachers to see the
demonstration of their learning:
organizing
planning
recording
drafting
analyzing
designing
writing
This element is very powerful when combined with other strategies such as team planning, group
discussion, student reflection and analysis. Labs are often the heart of performance tasks, and
when rubrics are applied, can serve as an assessment tool. Students record in their Study Guide
- in the "Applying" section - any work related to planning, organizing, designing, and writing of
performance labs.
Assessment
Assessment is for the purpose of determining what and how well a student has learned. Its
purpose is to inform teachers and students to what to do next. Assessment may take many forms.
It may be an informal discussion in which teachers and students clarify the learning of individuals
or groups in order to help diagnose the status of learning. A more formal assessment that may
help diagnose increases in knowledge may include (1) multiple choice responses; (2) true or false
statements; (3) short-answer questions; or (4) narratives. The most powerful type of assessment
is a performance lab or task that requires the students to apply and use their knowledge and skills
in a more authentic situation.
Student Reflection
Research has shown that reflection or structured analysis increases learning. When students
reflect upon their (1) learning of content; (2) strategies or processes that enhance their learning;
(3) achievement of goals; and (4) the products they produce, their knowledge and skills are
increased and retained long past the initial assessment period. This strategy is essential as a
component for all lessons, and may take as few as 2-3 minutes or as long as the teacher deems
appropriate. All student reflection is recorded in the "Reflecting" section of the Study Guide.
Multimedia Objects
This element of lesson planning may be optional depending on your available resources. The use
of multimedia can provide excellent opportunities to clarify understanding and to promote
thinking. The objects in most of the lessons are integral to helping students build concepts based
on the content.
Homework
This optional element is greatly affected and influence by the nature of the tasks and the ability of
the students to perform the tasks independent of the teacher. Under the best of circumstances, it
can add depth to learning and assist students in practicing the skills they will need in future
lessons. In some cases, homework may inhibit learning if the students reinforce errors in
understanding or become frustrated when they are unable to complete the tasks.
STUDY GUIDE
Semester 1
Lesson No.
2. Applying - Organize, plan, record process, draft, record findings, and/or show the results of
your performance lab or activity.
3. Reflecting - Think about and respond to questions about your learning, focusing on the
content, product, process and/or progress.
Templates
Study Guide Blank Template Study Guide Example
TRANSITIONING from TEXTBOOK to ONLINE LEARNING
(Using the Study Guide)
Online learning is a new experience for many students and adults. Traditionally, students have
had textbooks that they could carry around, refer to when needed, and if they owned the book,
make notes in the margins. This has always been satisfactory when studying history, literature,
and other similar subjects. Unfortunately, textbooks have several disadvantages when used for
studying something as rapidly growing and changing as the subject of networking.
The most important disadvantage is the static nature of textbooks. Producing textbooks can take
anywhere from several months to several years. By the time they have been distributed, the
information contained within them might already be dated or even obsolete. A networking
curriculum demands a dynamic information source that can adapt to the rapid changes and
innovations in the field.
The second disadvantage of textbooks is their cost. They are becoming more expensive each
year, and are large budget item for most educational agencies. Most school districts have a
schedule of textbook replacement that results in textbooks being used for many years.
Understandably, this has always been a handicap for studying the science, but for studying
networking it has been so in the extreme. Each day brings news of advancements and
discoveries that will someday become a necessary element of the networking professional's
skills. Textbook publishers simply cannot keep up with that pace.
Online study is always dynamic, always up to date. It can, however, be a challenge, because of
its non-traditional method of delivery. It is for that reason that as students and adults transition to
online learning, they need to use strategies that can assist them. Using a study guide is one of
those strategies.
The Study Guide Template is designed to help students structure their notes. They can have a
hard copy of the important information to refer to at home, or during other study time. It is
composed of three sections: "Learning", "Applying", and "Reflecting".
The "Learning" section is the first section of the Study Guide. It has a space for recording new
vocabulary for that lesson. This is especially important in Semester which has an extensive list of
new vocabulary words and acronyms. The instructor may wish to suggest vocabulary be included
or let students select their own. Another part of the"Learning" section is the space for notes and
ideas. This is the place where students can make sketches of diagrams they have seen in the
online content, and make notes regarding relationships of ideas and concepts. The instructor may
identify one or more questions to guide the study of the content, or have students identify them
before reading the online curriculum. This process helps students recall factual information and
do higher-level thinking regarding the concepts. The last part is the space for recording an
activity. The instructor may wish to make an assignment in class to help the student understand
the material.
The second section of the Study Guide is the "Applying" section. This is a section in which
students can make notes regarding their labs, activities, a special project, etc. They would use
this in addition to their Engineering Journal entries, with some of the journal entries being an
analysis of the entire Study Guide.
The third section of the Study Guide is the "Reflecting" section. Two of the higher level skills
required to design, build and maintain networks are analysis and problem solving. Reflecting is a
key strategy (Best Practice) that provides structure for students to analyze what they have been
studying and to determine for themselves the level of success they have had learning and
understanding each concept, and to set goals for improving their learning.
Working in pairs or groups of three to complete the activities and/or discussing their responses
with 1-2 other students can further strengthen the impact of the "Learning" and the "Applying"
sections. It ensures that students have read the material, taken notes, and discussed it with other
students.
The Instructors Guide includes a Study Guide Introduction, a Study Guide Example, and a Study
Guide Template.
Planning
Implementing
Utilizes the EJ and Study Guide appropriately and monitors student use
Assessing
Example:
Templates
Scientific inquiry
0.4.5.3 Teaching Strategies: Student reflection
Student reflection is an important element of instruction that takes only a brief amount of time per
lesson, but helps the students analyze their own learning over time, and become more
responsible for their learning. Responses to the questions asked in each lesson are recorded in
the Study Guide.
Application
A crucial element in a lesson is the student reflection. During the reflection the students think
back upon some aspect of the lesson, and write a reaction to that aspect in the Study Guide. As a
way of goal setting, this internalization of learning assists the students in making sense of the
learning process, and in linking prior learning to present and future learning, It helps them
analyze, and then move the learning from short term to long term memory.
After each lesson, reflection is done in one or more of the following categories:
content
product
process
progress
Throughout the year, it is beneficial to have the students look back at the reflections and note the
growth in their understanding. Prior to reporting periods, it would be useful to have the students
write a brief paper explaining their growth in knowledge and skills over the previous weeks.
Elements:
key ideas from class presentations, discussions, lesson content, and activities in terms of
content, process, product, or progress
Content:
Product:
Process:
Strategies that did not work well for me in doing this performance task/product were. . .
Progress:
Rubrics are the specific expectation criteria for the performance of a lab or activity. Each task has
a specific set of performance levels for the objectives, content, and skills that are to be
demonstrated. It contains the criteria that define the key elements that are necessary in order to
assess the degree of learning. Many rubrics are based on a four-point scale, with the exemplar
level being four points. Each of the points on the scale has specific criteria that describe the
characteristics of a performance.
Development of rubrics by students and teachers together can help students organize and
prepare for learning by knowing in advance their assessment expectations. It also allows them to
take part in developing the grading scale for their performance labs or activities.
This Instructors Guide has rubrics embedded in the contents of several of its lessons. The sample
rubrics may be used as guides for adding more specific criteria pertaining to a lesson.
Applying Rubrics
For each product that students or groups produce, the class may use the rubrics to assess the
products of those individuals or groups. The rubrics provide a standard for students. It may take
several learning opportunities before they reach the highest level of competence on the rubric
scale for a specific process or product. Teachers/students may want to add specific criteria to the
rubrics to apply to an individual, class project, lab, task, or case study.
Examples
1. Description of a Model
A model is a scaled representation of an artifact, idea, design, or system. Similar to a
construction, a model replicates an object or process in a precise way. A model is usually 3-
dimensional and portrays an object or concept specifically/entirely. A model representation,
generally in miniature, serves as a copy of something and may be used as a display or mode for
others to copy.
Often a model is used as a visual for an oral or written report. The model itself, however, should
be complete and precise enough to demonstrate understanding of the content/subject. For many
students, the hands-on aspect of construction or producing a model enables them to demonstrate
skills and understandings more thoroughly than from written or oral products.
is proportionally correct
An event might be the signing of the Declaration of Independence; the Wright brothers first flight;
or a historic meeting between individuals. A relationship between people might be the dialogue
and activity between two people who invented a product; mediating a conflict between individuals;
or demonstrating cooperative activities. A discovery might be the Leaky family and their
discoveries of ancient bones; Lewis and Clark and their discoveries, or the scientists who
discovered the polio vaccine.
Role playing requires that students understand the context, the personalities, and the key
elements in the event, relationship or discovery portrayed.
Rubrics for Role Playing
An exemplar (4, on a 4-point scale) meets the following criteria:
Dialogue and actions provide insight into the event, relationship or discovery.
3. Description of a Demonstration
A demonstration is performed in front of an audience. It shows a process of how a particular task
is done. It allows for a non-verbal exhibition of skill that may or may not be accompanied by oral
explanation. The demonstration may be part of a sales promotion, a safety procedure, or a
presentation showing the results of something, as well as an exhibit of a skill or procedure (e.g.
CPR, using a seat-belt, etc.).
4. Description of a Diagram
A diagram is a drawing or depiction of a process, procedure or function. It may also be a direction
or map that outlines a route or system. A diagram generally accompanies a narrative, either
written or oral, that provides more detailed description, thus, is used as a "prop" to further explain
the process, procedure or function.
Labels or written explanations are accurate, clear, precise, sized appropriately and
visible.
Pairs of students discuss and answer the review questions on their computer.
Pairs or small groups of students discuss and answer the review questions before each
student takes the review.
The entire class or groups of students discuss the review questions and connect to prior
understanding through explanation of the questions.
Small groups each discuss a portion of the questions and demonstrate understanding by
explaining to other groups (jigsaw technique).
Student teams or small groups design analogies to explain concepts to other teams of
students.
There are a variety of ways in which you can engage students in the learning process, other than
having them work independently. For such activities/tasks as reviewing, questioning, learning
content, doing performance labs, you can split your class into any of the various types of student
groups. It is important, however, that you know how and when to use them for instruction. The
following examples illustrate some of the types of groups and the purposes for which you might
use them:
Pairs or partners - For this type of grouping, each student chooses another student, the
instructor assigns partners, or students work with other students according to classroom
seating arrangement the term "pairs" implies two students, but in fact a pair can be part
of a team or larger group. Partners can refer to two or three students (e.g. odd number of
students in class). A pair may partner with another pair so that when one student is
absent, the work may continue without major disruption.
Small groups - This type of group usually has 3-5 students. The students can choose
their own partners from other classmates, the instructors can assign the partners, or the
students can work with other students according to the classroom seating arrangement.
The student roles within the group may be formal and/or assigned, or informal and
unassigned. The formal or assigned role may be that of a leader, a speaker, a note taker,
a summarizer, a timekeeper, etc. In informal groups, roles may be unassigned, but
naturally assumed by members of the group; some groups, depending on the task or
project, do not require the group members to assume any specific roles.
Teams - A team usually has a specified purpose and has 3-10 members. The team
members may be appointed, selected by other members of the team, grouped informally
according to classroom seating arrangements, alphabetically selected, or according to
some other random method. Team members may/may not have assigned roles,
depending on the performance task. If there are specific roles, they may be made based
on skill, interest, or necessity. The end product or result of the team efforts may
contribute to a team grade or to each member's contribution.
Competitive teams - The selection of the team members is similar to the preceding
description. This type of team, however, has a specific purpose - to compete with other
teams to determine which team can produce or accomplish the criteria and objectives of
a performance task the best, quickest, etc. The team members receive in advance the
rubrics and criteria for the tasks.
Large groups - A large group can include smaller teams, groups, partners, individuals or
a whole class. Parameters and criteria for large group discussions/participation are
established prior to the task or activity so all of the team members understand their roles
and/or responsibilities within the group.
Whole class - This is a type of group in which the activities can include teacher- or
student-led discussions, demonstrations, or presentations. This type of group is designed
to involve all of the students. The parameters for participation and topic focus are clarified
in advance so that all participants understand their role and/or responsibilities within the
class.
Cooperative Group Work is an important element in most of the lessons. It is a teaching strategy
that can improve learning opportunities for all students. To train students in group cooperation, it
is necessary for the criteria of effective group work to be shared with students prior to actually
forming the groups and reviewed following the group work. Descriptions and criteria for group
work clarify the importance/purpose of working as a cooperative group.
Cooperation is working together to accomplish shared goals. Within cooperative work groups,
individuals seek outcomes that are beneficial to themselves and to other members of the group.
Students work together to maximize their own and each others learning. Educators have been
presenting the benefits of cooperative work groups for some time. Business leaders have joined
them to advocating the use of cooperative work groups to prepare students for the work place.
The ability to work effectively with others is considered a crucial attribute for future employees.
Not all group learning is cooperative group learning. If one or two members are doing the work for
the group or providing the explanations, the learning of the other members is limited. All the
barriers of group work in business and other community activities are present in classroom work
groups. To overcome these barriers, there are some tools that can help structure the learning
environment to enhance effective group work. Providing a structure for the groups can be done
with an organizer or inquiry plan. Inquiry plans should be developed by groups to help focus and
clarify the learning for each member of the group. To assess the effectiveness of the group
process and products, teachers can use rubrics. To ascertain individual learning and progress
use rubrics, student reflections, and individual product assignments.
Shows evidence of reflection on the process with evidence that all students within the
group understand the process and results
STUDY GUIDE
Semester 1
Lesson No.
2. Applying - Organize, plan, record process, draft, record findings, and/or show the results of
your performance lab or activity.
3. Reflecting - Think about and respond to questions about your learning, focusing on the
content, product, process/progress.
Templates
Study Guide Blank Template Study Guide Example
TRANSITIONING from TEXTBOOK to ONLINE LEARNING
(Using the Study Guide)
Online learning is a new experience for many students and adults. Traditionally, students have
had textbooks that they could carry around, refer to when needed, and if they owned the book,
make notes in the margins. This has always been satisfactory when studying history, literature,
and other similar subjects. Unfortunately, textbooks have several disadvantages when used for
studying something as rapidly growing and changing as the subject of networking.
The most important disadvantage is the static nature of textbooks. Producing textbooks can take
anywhere from several months to several years. By the time they have been distributed, the
information contained within them might already be dated or even obsolete. A networking
curriculum demands a dynamic information source that can adapt to the rapid changes and
innovations in the field.
The second disadvantage of textbooks is their cost. They are becoming more expensive each
year, and are large budget item for most educational agencies. Most school districts have a
schedule of textbook replacement that results in textbooks being used for many years.
Understandably, this has always been a handicap for studying the sciences, but for studying
networking it has been so in the extreme. Each day brings news of advancements and
discoveries that will someday become a necessary element of the networking professional's
skills. Textbook publishers simply cannot keep up with that pace.
Online study is always dynamic, always up to date. It can, however, be a challenge, because of
its non-traditional method of delivery. It is for that reason that as students and adults transition to
online learning, they need to use strategies that can assist them. Using a study guide is one of
those strategies.
The Study Guide Template is designed to help students structure their notes. They can have a
hard copy of the important information to refer to at home, or during other study time. It is
composed of three sections: "Learning", "Applying", and "Reflecting".
The "Learning" section is the first section of the Study Guide. It has a space for recording new
vocabulary for that lesson. This is especially important in Semester 1which has an extensive list
of new vocabulary words and acronyms. The instructor may wish to suggest vocabulary be
included or let students select their own. Another part of the "Learning" section is the space for
notes and ideas. This is the place where students can make sketches of diagrams they have
seen in the online content, and make notes regarding relationships of ideas and concepts. The
instructor may identify one or more questions to guide the study of the content, or have students
identify them before reading the online curriculum. This process helps students recall factual
information and do higher-level thinking regarding the concepts. The last part is the space for
recording an activity. The instructor may wish to make an assignment in class to help the student
understand the material.
The second section of the Study Guide is the "Applying" section. This is a section in which
students can make notes regarding their labs, activities, a special project, etc. They would use
this in addition to their Engineering Journal entries, with some of the journal entries being an
analysis of the entire Study Guide.
The third section of the Study Guide is the "Reflecting" section. Two of the higher level skills
required to design, build and maintain networks are analysis and problem solving. Reflecting is a
key strategy (Best Practice) that provides structure for students to analyze what they have been
studying and to determine for themselves the level of success they have had learning and
understanding each concept, and to set goals for improving their learning.
Working in pairs or groups of three to complete the activities/discuss their responses with 1-2
other students can further strengthen the impact of the "Learning" and the "Applying" sections. It
ensures that students have read the material, taken notes, and discussed it with other students.
The Instructors Guide includes a Study Guide Introduction, a Study Guide Example, and a Study
Guide Template.
Description
Role playing is the acting or dramatizing of a scenario, story, event, or real life situation.It is used
in order to demonstrate a thorough understanding of an event, a discovery, or an interpersonal
relationship. Students may create a script for role playing or ad lib the actions and dialogue.
Examples
event - the signing of the Declaration of Independence, the Wright brothers' first flight, or
a historic meeting between individuals
interpersonal relationship - the dialogue and activity between two people who have
invented a product; the mediation of a conflict between individuals; or a demonstration of
cooperative activities
discovery - the unearthing of ancient bones by the Leaky family ; the explorations of
Lewis and Clark, or scientists' discovery of the polio vaccine
Role playing requires that students understand the context, the personalities, and the key
elements in the event, relationship or discovery that they portray.
Rubrics
An exemplar (4, on a 4-point rubric) meets the following criteria:
Dialogue and actions provide insight into the event, relationship or discovery
Exams
Exam Suggestions
There are at least seven major sources for our "dual" assessment philosophy: The American
National Science Education Standards (K-12 Science Education Reform), The American
Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) Project 2061 Benchmarks (K-12 Science
Education Reform), The Dartmouth Project for Teaching Engineering Problem Solving (adapting
undergraduate engineering pedagogy to K-12 technology teaching), the National Science
Foundation's Action Agenda for Systemic Engineering Education Reform (undergraduate
engineering education), Cisco Worldwide Training's CCNA/CCNP/CCIE Certification Sequence
(corporate training standards), School to College and Career (School to Work, Tech Prep,
partnerships between high schools and community colleges) efforts, and the field of
psychometrically-valid testing (the science of test construction). This list demonstrates the deep
pedagogical roots of the Cisco Networking Academy Program. The overwhelming consensus of
the first six influences is summarized by the National Science Foundation's report on
Undergraduate Engineering Education [The Action Agenda for Systemic Engineering Education
Reform Guidelines for Submissions of Proposals, NSF 98-27], from which we quote extensively:
Sounds like the Cisco Networking Academy Program! While this quote represents the consensus
amongst undergraduate engineering educators in the United States, it also articulates succinctly
the consensus of corporate, community college, vocational, and K-12 educators -- that project-
based, hands-on, lab-based, troubleshooting, "authentic," journal-and-portfolio-based education
is fundamentally important for all engineering, information science, computer science, and
technician education. We hope this can help convince some of you to put the online assessments
in perspective -- they are limited checks for understanding that will help the students get ready for
that CCNA exam. But to produce students who can make real networks run, your assessment
must be MUCH broader and deeper than any online assessment.
Thus, please do not equate the taking of online tests with a successful program. Recall a primary
goal of the program -- designing, installing, and maintaining networks. Quite frankly, the
Assessment Server tests and CCNA test do not adequately test what is the complex problem-
solving and manual set of skills required to maintain actual school networks. That is why the
Instructor Materials and Training model emphasize project-based, hands-on, lab-based,
troubleshooting, "authentic", journal-and-portfolio-based assessments making cables,
configuring routers and switches, building networks, wiring schools, all graded by rubrics. We
have tried to provide examples of all of these, and as our community shares their inventiveness,
the library of suggestions will grow.
We will continue to share a variety of assessments with you. But you will have to determine the
mix of assessments that is best for your students, your resources, and your teaching style. We
ARE dictating a bottom line of a mixture of online testing with skills-based testing, but we
CANNOT and WILL NOT micromanage your assessment. You must make it work in your
classroom.
Chapter 1
Overview
Throughout the Instructor's Notes, reference will be made to the CCNA Certification Exam
Objective List. While this list is for Exam #407 (retired July 31, 2000), at the time of the writing of
this document the Objectives for #507 have not been formally published. The new objectives are,
however, a slightly revised SUBSET of the #407 Exam Objectives and thus the #407 Exam
Objectives are a completely sufficient guide to what will be on the CCNA Certification Exam. The
document should be printed out and shared electronically with all students.
First, it is important to help the students appreciate how they are going to be viewing the
curriculum -- via a computer. Since no prerequisites are required for the CCNA program, and due
to the wide variety of prior knowledge of computers of students entering the program, a small
amount of time should be spent bringing all students up to a basic knowledge of computer
hardware.
Second, the idealized (simplified) computer, with CPU, memory, and interfaces all communicating
via a bus, can be thought of as a simple network, foreshadowing the networks to come.
The lab activity is designed to make students more aware of the machine on which they will be
studying the curriculum. It is hoped that students can start to perform basic troubleshooting of
their own workstation.
For students with little or no hands-on experience, doing a mechanical and electrical dissection of
a PC taking an old PC apart and learning a bit about the hardware components -- can be an
empowering revelation. The Engineering Journal should be introduced as a place to note
technical information. Have the students leave the first few pages blank (to create a table of
contents later). For every lab during the semester, the student should make notes about the lab
and their reflections on the lab in the journal.
For students with prior PC hardware courses or A+ certification, this lab could be skipped or
summarized.
The lab activity requires approximately 60 minutes. This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam
Objective #19.
First, it is important to help the students appreciate how they are going to view the curriculum --
via a computer. The view of information flow within the computer is a dynamic view, contrasted
with the static view of the computer presented in target indicator 1.1.1. In describing a working
computer, a more dynamic view -- not just hardware components, but communicating hardware
components -- can bring the computer to life.
Second, the emphasis on information flow brings up questions of processes (booting, transferring
information from CPU to and from memory and to and from interfaces) and protocols governing
those processes. These computer processes and protocols foreshadow the networking
processes and protocols that networks and networking devices -- especially routers -- go through.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objective #22.
The lab activity requires approximately 15 minutes. This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam
Objectives #3 and #60.
Another purpose of the lab activity is to allow students to start troubleshooting their own
machines. Often times some setting is off which prevents students from viewing the curriculum --
display settings, browser plug-ins and settings, IP address settings. Thus, the student becomes
more empowered to troubleshoot problems themselves and takes responsibility for accessing the
curriculum.
This target indicator also introduces the importance of IP addressing and subnet masking. There
is no need to explain them in detail -- something along the lines of "every computer needs an
address to participate in the Internet". Some labs will have statically configured IP addresses, in
which case the students can actually view their IP address; others will have DHCP and will need
to run winipconfig to view their dynamically assigned address.
The first lab activity requires approximately 45 minutes; the second requires approximately 30
minutes. This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #31.
Lab Tips are focussed on the fact that troubleshooting involves inducing problems to PCs. Thus,
you may not want the students to be troubleshooting the curriculum-viewing machines (for
example, if the lab is multipurpose and next periods class is about to come in, then you may not
have time to get all the machines IP addresses and cables corrected). So we recommend you
have students perform troubleshooting on the ten machines in the "back-of-the-room,"
experimental (semester 2) network area.
Also, philosophically, the term "information age" and "information superhighway" are now part of
the common vernacular. The key idea is that any form of information -- text, picture, voice, video -
- can be represented by binary codes. Students should know the units of measure of the basic
quantity of this new technological, economic, and social era -- bits and bytes.
The same formalism used for base 10 number system in the prior target indicator is used in this
target indicator to make binary look and feel similar -- it is "just" a base 2 instead of a "base 10"
number system. Make this similarity clear. As you work through the binary exponents, you may
want to call attention to the fact that many common sizes of computer technologies are actually
powers of 2 -- 32 and 64-bit games, 256 colors, 32 Megabytes of RAM, etc.
Two algorithms are presented for converting decimal to binary. Present whatever method you feel
best works for your students. The algorithm in the graphic uses a flowchart to convey the steps to
be followed; the algorithm described in the text is successive division. Actually they are the same
algorithm, presented two different ways.
An entertaining class activity is to have 8 students come to the front of the class. Give one of
them a ONE sign, the next a TWO sign, the next a FOUR sign, the next an EIGHT sign, the next
a SIXTEEN sign, the next a THIRTY-TWO sign, the next a SIXTY-FOUR sign, and the last
student a ONE TWENTY-EIGHT sign. Arrange them in order, facing the class, Least significant
bit to most significant bit. Have a student from the class call out a DECIMAL number between 0
and 255 (the largest decimal equivalent of an eight-bit binary number). The job of the students in
front is to stand up if their bit is a ONE in the representation of the called-out decimal number;
they should stay seated if their bit is a ZERO. This requires every student up front to do the
conversion; require the students in the rest of the class do the conversion as well.
The "lab" activity, actually a paper exercise, requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI relates to
CCNA Certification Exam Objective #30.
An appropriate activity, rather than just having students read the chart, is to have the class
brainstorm this list. Brainstorming has special rules.
Most ideas possible. Wildest ideas possible. No censorship of ideas. Build on others ideas.
Typically, brainstorming on types of networks would work like this. Put the word "networks" in an
oval in the middle of the board in anticipation of building a cluster diagram. Start the clock, and
have students raise their hands in rapid fire succession (or call on each of them to ensure
everyone participates). Time the activity, say five or seven minutes of brainstorming. Do not edit
or censor anyone's suggestion, but do cluster them into related groups. At the end of the
brainstorming session, then discuss, group, and further edit ideas to clarify the breadth of the
word network.
It should be noted that since real data must be encapsulated, there is a certain amount of
"overhead" packaging data which must be included. This varies depending upon the protocols
used and is not used in these calculations. Think of these calculations as a crude upper bound on
the possible throughputs; actual throughput will be less.
One activity that works well here is called "At the Drive-Through". Using two walkie-talkies and
two bilingual students at different ends of the room, have them simulate the drive-through
ordering process. One student plays the role of the customer and the other the restaurant
employee. First have the student violate the idea-layer protocol by ordering chicken at a
hamburger restaurant, or hamburgers at a taco restaurant, etc. Then have the student violate the
representation layer protocol by ordering in a different language. Third, have the student violate
the transport layer protocol by not waiting to have their order repeated back to them and speaking
too quickly. Finally have the student violate the physical layer protocol by talking and not using
the Walkie talkies (short-distance FM radios). Two points should be made: one, communication
can be analyzed in layers; two, the layers between the two communicating entities must match.
Variations on this theme specific to other cultures are encouraged.
2.1.3 Media
The purpose of this target indicator is to introduce another fundamental networking term --
medium. Five media are of particular importance in this course -- STP, UTP, coaxial cable, optical
fiber and wireless.
The best way to introduce this term is to emphasize the medium you are using to talk to the
students -- sound waves in air. Then do a show and tell with real cable samples and either
sketches or overhead transparencies. Students should understand that networks often involve
copper or optical medium, but that no medium at all is required in the case of wireless
communication since electromagnetic waves travel just fine in vacuum.
2.1.4 Protocol
The term protocol is used throughout the four semesters. For purposes of the beginning student,
refer back to the "at the drive-through activity" and describe protocol as the rules that govern a
specific layer of communication. While this definition may seem abstract at first, keep coming
back to it throughout the semester and remind students what is meant by "protocol" as various
protocols are introduced.
2.2.2 The names of the seven layers of the OSI reference model
The purpose of this target indicator is to introduce the OSI model. Students should memorize the
numbers and names of the layers.
Have the class create a mnemonic device together or have the students, individually, create a
mnemonic device which helps them remember the seven layers. In English, a commonly used
OSI mnemonic is All People Seem To Need Data Processing.
2.2.4 Encapsulation
The purpose of this target indicator is to again introduce a crucial piece of terminology. Have the
students repeat the word out loud -- we believe this helps empower the students to use the
vocabulary, of which there is a tremendous amount in semester 1.
A useful activity for this term requires the following materials: writing paper, small envelopes,
larger envelopes or Federal Express envelopes. Have the students choose an idea (Layer 7),
represent that idea on paper (Layer 6), decide how to send the letter (Layers 4 and 5), add
general addressing information (Layer 3), add specific addressing information (Layer 2), and mail
the letter (via courier, in the classroom), to someone else. Then pose the question -- why are all
the envelopes and addresses necessary? This will help emphasize that data, like their letters,
must be encapsulated in order to be delivered.
2.3.2 Names and descriptions of the layers of the TCP/IP reference model
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to learn the details of the TCP/IP model.
Students should memorize the layers with a mnemonic device; they should be able to briefly
describe the four layers.
The "lab" activity, a paper exercise on the networking models, requires approximately 20 minutes.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #35, and #36.
2.3.5 Use of the OSI and the TCP/IP models in the curriculum
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to articulate why the OSI model is used
throughout the CCNA curriculum. Again, it is the standard for teaching and learning; it is an
international standard; and it makes distinctions which are helpful in analyzing and
troubleshooting internetworks.
Chapter 3: Local Area Networks
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back.
3.1.3 NICs
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing NICs, to describe
how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, OSI layer, and function on the back. NICs are Layer 2 devices which perform naming,
framing, media access control, and signaling functions to allow devices to connect to networking
media.
3.1.4 Media
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing different media on a
logical topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Physical media is Layer 1 in the OSI model, and is the
material (or space) where networking signals travel.
3.1.5 Repeaters
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing repeaters on a
logical topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Repeaters are Layer 1 devices, which regenerate and
retime network signals so LANs can be extended to greater lengths. Regeneration means that
incoming bits, which may have been distorted by any number of processes as they traveled, are
re-sent with proper amplitude and duration.
3.1.6 Hubs
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing hubs on a logical
topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Hubs are multiport repeaters, hence Layer 1 devices, and
they regenerate and retime signals while providing inexpensive connectivity for numbers of
networking devices.
3.1.7 Bridges
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing bridges on a logical
topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Bridges are Layer 2 device which filter traffic based on the
algorithm: forward traffic with non-local MAC addresses. Bridges are used to segment networks
into smaller parts.
3.1.8 Switches
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing switches on a
logical topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Switches are multiport bridges, hence they are Layer 2
devices which provide connectivity and dedicated bandwidth. They are also used to segment
networks into smaller parts.
3.1.9 Routers
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing routers on a logical
topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. Routers are Layer 3 devices which determine best path for
packets through a network and then switch packets to the port which will lead to their destination
network (IP) address.
3.1.10 Clouds
The purpose of this target indicator is to allow the student to start recognizing clouds on a logical
topology, to describe how they really appear, and to briefly describe their function.
A good class activity is to make flash cards -- with the device symbol on the front, and the device
name, layer, and function on the back. A cloud is comprised of devices which can range from
Layer 1 to Layer 7. The cloud is used to represent a part of the network whose details we don't
wish to get into. The Internet is often represented by a cloud on network diagrams.
The bridge was introduced as a way to filter network traffic into local and non-local traffic, with this
filtering being accomplished by physical layer addresses, thus making it a Layer 2 device. Bridges
were introduced to segment networks into smaller collision domains. The basic idea of bridges
was added to the connectivity (port-density) of hubs and the switch -- a multiport bridge -- was
born. Also a Layer 2 devices which makes forwarding decisions based on Layer 2 MAC physical
addresses, the switch provides high port density (connectivity) and dedicated bandwidth between
2 communicating PCs. As networks grew, the diversity of platforms, protocols, and media, the
geographic distance between computers, the number of computers wishing to communicate, and
the dynamism inherent in large networks all necessitated the development of the router -- a Layer
3 device which makes best path and switching decisions based on Layer 3, hierarchical, network
addresses.
Graphic one shows the OSI layers for one end node on the left, then the OSI layers for the
networking device in the middle, and then the OSI layers for the other end node on the right. Note
that for the Layer 1 networking device "in the middle", the data packet is not de-encapsulated at
all - the data packet is processed at Layer 1 only.
Graphic one shows the OSI layers for one end node on the left, then the OSI layers for the
networking device in the middle, and then the OSI layers for the other end node on the right. Note
that for the Layer 2 networking device "in the middle", the data packet is de-encapsulated up to
the Layer 2 level and then re-encapsulated - the data packet is processed at layers 1 and 2 only.
3.3.5 Packet flow through clouds and through Layer 1-7 devices
The purpose of this target indicator is to make the student aware that a variety of networking
processes, possibly involving all 7 layers, may occur as an encapsulated packet finds its way
through a network "cloud." Of course, the dominant process as data makes its way through the
cloud is routing -- a Layer 3 process -- but repeating, switching, DNS lookups, and various other
processes may occur before a packet finds its way to its destination.
Graphic one shows the OSI layers for one end node on the left, then the OSI layers for the
networking device in the middle, and then the OSI layers for the other end node on the right. Note
that for the Layer 7 networking device "in the middle", the data packet is de-encapsulated up to
the Layer 7 level and then re-encapsulated - the data packet is processed at all layers.
Answers to questions:
1. winipcfg
2. start ==> control panel ==> network ==> TCP/IP Ethernet Adapter ==> properties;
Bindings, Advanced, NetBIOS, DNS Config, WINS Config, IP Address
3. see Teaching Topology or Chapter 3, Objective 3.1
4. Ethernet, by far the most common and versatile LAN technology
5. The mesh for 10 gets quite messy; the others are pretty straightforward. Make sure the
students use 10 dots and follow the "rules" for each topology.
6. see Chapter 3, TI 3.4.2 for some examples
7. data ports, link lights, uplink port if it exists, power connection, external power supply if it
exists, any other features
8. refer to Lab 5.3.2
9. refer to Lab 5.3.2
10. port, link light, activity light, any other features
The lab concludes by having the students build a slightly more complex and realistic network -- a
small workgroup with Internet connectivity. The importance of having the students build some
simple LANs early in the course cannot be overstated: it sets the stage for most of the learning
that follows. Regardless of your resource and time constraints, do not skip these lab activities.
The lab activity requires approximately 60 minutes. It is extremely important for helping students
solidify their understanding of concepts already presented, and for creating a base for future
learning to occur.
Chapter 4: Layer 1 - Electronics and Signals
We view the CNAP as educating the future networking professionals of the world, not simply
training them to pass a given test. We believe an educated networking professional understands
some basic electronics [for example, most of the landmark texts in networking - for example,
Computer Networks (by Tannenbaum) and Computer Networks (by Peterson and Davie) -- have
substantial discussions of networking signals.
There are two specific purposes to this target indicator. First, to relate what the student is about to
learn (electrical signals) to prior knowledge from science classes. Secondly, to establish the
foundation for understanding that electricity is comprised of electrons.
If you have access to a Van de Graff Generator, there are many static electricity demonstrations
that can be performed with great drama in the classroom. If you lack a Van de Graff, a balloon
works well on fairly dry days. Take the balloon, rub it furiously, and then it can be made to stick to
various objects (like a white board or the teacher). Another demonstration can be done using a
rubbed comb to pick up small pieces of paper. The goal is to make plausible the idea of charged
particles and electrons.
4.1.4 Electrical current including insulators, conductors, and semiconductors
The purpose of this target indicator is that students realize that the networking devices and
components with which they will be working are based on very precise control of electron flow
using a combination of conductors (usually copper conducting paths), semiconductors (usually
Silicon-based Integrated Circuits), and insulators (usually plastic or rubber to form plugs,
connectors, cable jackets).
There are many demonstrations possible with a digital multimeter. You can show that the
electrical resistance of objects gives us a measure of whether a material is a conductor (low
resistance), semiconductor (moderate resistance), or insulator (high resistance). You could
demonstrate a low voltage series circuit with a 6 V lantern battery, a low voltage light bulb, a
pencil, some plastic, some alligator clip leads, and a piece of copper. Make a complete circuit
with the copper piece and the bulb burns brightly. Make a complete circuit with a short piece of
pencil graphite and the bulb burns dimly. Make a complete circuit with a piece of plastic and the
bulb does not glow.
A particularly poignant analogy will be the EKG machines; most students will have seen them on
TV. Graph a heartbeat -- it's a voltage pulse that varies with time in the heart pulse. Similarly the
brain waves and in general nervous system is electrical, so the medical analogy may help.
Particularly relevant technologies similar to the oscilloscope are the television picture tube and
the computer monitor, both of which are cathode ray tubes like the oscilloscope. Describe how
both of these devices "draw" a picture with a beam that scans horizontally and is varied vertically.
If you have access to oscilloscope and function generators, spend a class studying sine and
square waves. Even if you have one oscilloscope, demonstrate it to the class. Use a microphone
as the scope input and let the students see how their voice makes a voltage versus time graph on
the oscilloscope display.
If you do not have access to any oscilloscopes, you can make a sand pendulum which gives the
basic idea. Suspend a styrofoam or paper cup from both sides and hang it like a pendulum. Make
a small hole in the bottom of the cup and fill it with sand. As the cup-pendulum swings back and
forth, it will trace out a straight line on a piece of paper. Now slowly move the paper along
perpendicular to the direction of the swinging pendulum and you will trace out a beautiful sine
wave.
4.1.8 Constructing a simple series electrical current
The purpose of this target indicator is for students to construct, with their hands and in their mind,
a simple series electric circuit. Throughout networking there are references to ground loop circuit,
circuit versus packet switching, virtual circuits, in addition to all of the real circuits formed by
networking media and networking devices. Of course, a thorough understanding of all of the
circuitry involved in networking would require an undergraduate degree in electrical engineering;
but here our goals are humble: students attaining the idea of a simple series circuit. At least they
will have this idea to build on when testing for Layer 1 connectivity, or upper layer protocols and
their real and virtual connections.
Grounding connections and practices vary around the world; feel free to teach whatever
standards apply to you locally.
After covering this target indicator, a quiz game - such as "Jeopardy" -- might be in order. The
Categories could be Voltage versus time graphs; electronic materials; electric circuits; the water
analogy; and grounding. Students can select a category and a level of difficulty and attempt to
answer your review questions, earning "points" for themselves and their team.
First, students will have been using electrical vocabulary, developing their multimeter skills, and
getting familiar with CAT 5 UTP. This lab requires them to build several series circuits using the
Cat 5 medium.
Secondly, the students will run into issues from all 7 layers. They must decide what ideas, or
range of ideas, they want to communicate and what "network" services are required (Layer 7).
They must decide on a form of data representation, for example ASCII or Morse code (Layer 6).
The must decide on how to open and close sessions (layer 5). The must decide upon a window
size and whether data will be delivered reliably (with acknowledgments and re-transmissions) or
unreliably. Since this is a point to point link, they need not worry about Layer 3 addressing, but if
they had multiple stations then they might consider address information. They definitely have to
decide upon a frame format (Layer 2) and of course decide the signal and media specifications
(Layer 1) which will govern their communications link. Feel free to adapt the basic lab ideas to
your students needs and interests.
The lab activity requires approximately 50 minutes. This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam
Objective #51.
4.3 Basics of Signals and Noise in Communications Systems
If you have access to a dual-trace oscilloscope, you can display a square pulse put onto coaxial
(or Cat 5) cable.
If you have access to a slinky, induce a wave and time its propagation.
Using sound waves down a long hall, you can notice a slight delay in the time it takes the sound
to travel the length of the hall.
Using sound waves down a long hall, you can show how sound signals are attenuated.
If you have access to a dual trace oscilloscope and function generator, measure the signal at two
points along the long cable and you can see the attenuation.
If you have access to a dual trace oscilloscope and function generator, measure the signal at two
points along the long cable and you can see the reflection of both an open and a short circuit at
the end of the coaxial cable or twisted pair.
If you have access to a slinky, you can send a longitudinal wave down the slinky and watch as
some of it reflects.
If you have access to a rope, you can send a pulse down the rope and see a reflection off a the
fixed end of the rope.
4.3.7 Noise
The purpose of this target indicator is to make the idea of electrical noise plausible to students.
If you have access to a dual-trace oscilloscope and function generator, you can run the cable
near some notorious noise source (electric motors, florescent lighting, power cables) and see
what noise the signal acquires.
If you rub a nail across a file near an AM radio, you can "hear" electromagnetic interference.
If you have access to a dual-trace oscilloscope and function generator, you can show the pristine
pulse and then the broadened pulse if a long enough cable segment is used.
4.3.9 Collision
The purpose of this target indicator is to make the idea of collisions plausible to students.
If you have access to a dual-trace oscilloscope and function generator, place two signals on the
media, synchronize them, and watch as the voltage level is twice what it should be for binary
zero.
Encoding is a somewhat broader term. In its most succinct definition, encoding is how binary one
and binary zero are represented. We use the term in the broadest sense, meaning how binary
one and binary zero are represented physically. This should be made tangible to the students --
data communications encodes binary ones and zeros as voltages onto copper (using various
encoding schemes, such as NRZ, Manchester, 4B/5B), data communications encodes light into
optical fibers (again, using various schemes like 4B/5B and 8B/10B), and data communications
encodes EM waves into free space (using a wide variety of schemes). Again, encoding is how are
the mathematical abstractions (binary ones and zeros) represented in something measurable in
the physical world.
Also the students should come to appreciate that messages have been historically encoded as
voltages on copper wires for at least 150 years. Secondly, they should realize that many modern
networks still use voltage pulses on copper wires to achieve data communications. Again, an
oscilloscope demonstration is very helpful if at all possible.
Also the students should come to appreciate that messages have been historically encoded as
visible light pulses for thousands of years, albeit at rather low data rates. Secondly, students
should realize that many modern data networks use pulsed LED and Laser light on optical fibers
and in free space to achieve data communications. A laser pen and an optical fiber patch cable
are useful demonstration tools for this target indicator.
Also the students should come to appreciate that messages have been historically encoded as
electromagnetic waves for about 100 years. Finally, students should realize that many modern
data networks use free-space (unbounded) electromagnetic waves to achieve data
communication. Such networks are often called wireless networks, and they tend to use the
Infrared, Microwave, and Radio Wave parts of the electromagnetic spectrum. An AM/FM radio
and an oscilloscope are useful demonstration tools for this target indicator.
Chapter 5: Layer 1 - Media, Connections and Collisions
5.1.1 STP
There are four purposes for this target indicator. First, students should be able to draw and label
a side view of STP cable. Second, they should be able to draw and label the cable in cross-
section. Third, they should be able to state the advantages and disadvantages of STP. Finally,
they should have a basic notion of how STP achieves the shielding of networking signals. For
demonstration purposes, terminated and unterminated STP samples should be obtained.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.1.2 UTP
There are four purposes for this target indicator. First, students should be able to draw and label
a side view of UTP cable. Second, they should be able to draw and label the cable in cross-
section. Third, they should be able to state the advantages and disadvantages of UTP. Finally,
they should have a basic notion of how UTP achieves some measure of noise-immunity from the
twisting of the pairs of wires. For demonstration purposes, terminated and unterminated UTP
samples should be obtained.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
Finally, they should have a basic notion of how Coaxial cable achieves the shielding of
networking signals.
For demonstration purposes, terminated and unterminated coaxial cable samples should be
obtained.
For demonstration purposes, terminated and unterminated optical fiber samples should be
obtained.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.1.5 Wireless communication
There are four purposes for this target indicator. First, students should be able to draw and label
a side view of an Electromagnetic wave. Second, they should be able to draw and label where
EM waves are emitted and detected -- antennas. Third, they should be able to state the
advantages and disadvantages of wireless. Finally, they should have a basic notion of how
wireless communications is not drowned in a sea of noise and interference from other signals.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
Why all this physics in the middle of networking class? Wireless communications, which require a
basic understanding of electromagnetic (EM) waves, will play a tremendous role in the future of
networks. Note that none of this material is on the Chapter exam or the CCNA certification exam.
It is offered as knowledge enrichment in order to enhance the students' understanding of
networking.
Figure 1 represents the microscopic pattern of mutually inducing electric and magnetic fields that
we call an electromagnetic (EM) wave (consult any basic physics book for more information). The
graph represents how the wave pattern might look in x-y-z space frozen at one point in time.
Figure 3 is an interactive calculator, which helps bring the quantitative aspects of the chart to life.
The calculator uses one of the fundamental principles of EM waves - when in vacuum (or near-
vacuum), their frequency (in cycles per second, or Hertz) x their wavelength (in meters) always
equals the speed of light (in meters per second). Note that there are pull-down menus for
expressing the frequencies and the wavelengths using different Metric units. This is a great
exercise in exponents, the Metric System, and dimensional (unit) analysis.
Massive commercial efforts for wireless communications - most notably cellular phones and
wireless LANs (WLANs) - are driving technological developments in the 900 MHz, 2.4 GHz, 5.7
GHz, and 820 nanometer bands (ranges) of the EM spectrum (you might assign the students to
figure out what are the wavelengths of their favorite FM station - for example, 105.3 MHz - or a
cell phone, 900 MHz).
The main benefit of wireless - credited to Marconi just over 100 years ago -- is obvious - no wires!
However, there exist major challenges of distance (the waves interact with matter which
attenuates the wave's power), obstacles (the waves interact with natural and human-made
structures), bandwidth allocation (only certain frequencies are available since humans use the
EM spectrum for so many other purposes), and security (wireless networks need some sort of
encryption since they are being radiated and may be detected by anyone in the area with the right
equipment) . Despite these limitations, wireless communications are changing the world in which
we live every day. Are you ready?
This lab activity requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
The purpose of this target indicator a lab activity -- is for the students to demonstrate a
fundamental termination skill: the creation of a straight-through patch cable according to TIA/EIA-
568-A standards. While such cables are easily purchased, many times a cable of a peculiar
length might be desired for test purposes; or an existing cable or cable run may need re-
termination. Stranded, not solid, cable should be used for making real patch cables; but if
stranded is not available then proceed with the lab using solid.
This lab activity requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
This lab activity requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
This lab activity requires approximately 45 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
This lab activity requires approximately 45 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
This lab activity requires approximately 45 minutes. This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA
Certification Exam Objective #1.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.4.2 Connectors
The purpose of this target indicator is for students to state the purpose of RJ-45 connectors
(plugs). This may seem obvious, but once you consider what the signal is doing at a connector --
interfacing with other networking devices active ports or passive jacks, its importance increases.
A lot of design goes into the connector so that the signal insertion loss will be minimized and the
impedance will match that of the NIC cards. Cables and connectors are said to be "tuned", that is,
impedance matched. Secondly, terminations are a common point-of-failure for networks --
improper strain relief and poor crimping being typical culprits. Every point along the network --
including the connectors -- is important. Not to mention that they are not free!
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.4.3 Cabling
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to recognize the importance of the
networking medium; in the case of 10BASE-T the Cat 5 UTP. The students have encountered the
Cat 5 UTP in Chapter 4, but now they are encouraged to see it as another Layer 1 component of
the network. Cat 5 UTP is a passive Layer 1 network component, passive in the sense that it
involves no transfer of energy from the cable to the networking signal (cabling requires no energy
to perform its function).
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.4.4 Jacks
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to recognize the importance of jacks,
particularly RJ-45 jacks. RJ-45 jacks are passive Layer 1 components, passive in the sense that
they involve no transfer of energy from the component to the networking signal (Jacks require no
energy to perform their function).
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.4.6 Transceivers
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to attain a deeper understanding of the
handy little devices known as transceivers. Transceiver is an short for transmitter (often
abbreviated Tx) and -receiver (often abbreviated Rx). Transceivers are typically media converters
-- where one media, say CAT 5, is to be converted to another form (optical, or AUI electronic are
the two most common conversions. Transceivers are active Layer 1 devices in that they involve
the transfer of energy to the signal (they require energy to perform their function).
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.4.7 Repeaters
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to attain a deeper understanding of
repeaters. Repeaters do not amplify; they regenerate and retime signals. This is because
technically amplification refers to increasing the amplitude of an analog signal. The repeater does
not amplify incoming bits (which may have distortions and noise on them), but rather it detects
(hopefully correctly) incoming ones and zeros and regenerates without any noise or distortion for
the next leg in the journey across the network. Repeaters are active Layer 1 devices because
they involve the transfer of energy to the signal (they require energy to perform their function).
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 part of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.5.4 Collisions as natural functions of shared media environments and collision domains
The purpose of this target indicator is to deepen the students understanding of a shared media
environment. The Hawaiian Islands serve as an example of a shared, broadcast media for
Electromagnetic Wave Signals. In a similar way, the nodes on an Ethernet can share a copper
media for voltage pulse signals. There is historical importance to this analogy -- Hawaii is where
the early networking protocol Aloha was developed. Aloha evolved into Ethernet!
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #43, #46, #47, #48, #49, #53, and #54.
Two types of topologies will be important in the curriculum: physical and logical. By physical
topology we mean how networking devices are actually wired together. By logical topology we
mean how data flows, and how access to shared media is determined. Both types of topological
diagrams are crucial for the networking professional to be able to draw, read, and interpret.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts physically wired in a linear bus topology.
Note that each host will need some type of "tee" connection or tap to connect to the medium.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts physically wired in a ring topology. Have
them note that each host would need two NICs if ring topologies were actually wired as rings (in
turns out that ring topologies often work as logical rings for information flow but are actually wired
as physical stars).
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in a dual ring topology. Note that each host
will need 4 NICs or 2 dual NICs to have connections to both rings.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
5.6.5 Star network topology
The purpose of this target indicator is to introduce the star topology.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in a star topology. Note that some kind of
special connection device will be required at the middle (or hub) of the star.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in an extended star physical topology.
Note that some kind of special connection device will be required at the middle (or hub) of the
star.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in a star physical topology. Note that some
kind of special connection device will be required every time the tree branches.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in an irregular physical topology. Note that
multiple NICs would be required for each device.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
A good activity is to have the students draw 10 hosts in a complete (mesh) topology. Note that
the number of NICs required becomes huge as you move past a few hosts being connected.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
This TI relates to the Layer 1 and Layer 2 parts of CCNA Certification Exam Objective #1.
Chapter 6: Layer 2 - Concepts
6.1.1 Layer 2
The purpose of this target indicator is to justify the existence of Layer 2 in the OSI model. It is a
particularly important layer, and contains numerous subtleties. Focus the students on the fact that
if we simply have a Layer 1 network (connectivity and signals), our messages have no structure
to them nor is there any provision for addressing. These are issues that must be dealt with if we
are to have a network, and Layer 2 is the first Layer to deal with them.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #3, #5, and #60.
6.4 Framing
The "fairness" of token passing is usually obvious to students. But a classroom activity is to have
four students kinesthetically act out the algorithm. Teach the students the following rules.
Maximum frame size is three sentences. No one may speak until they have the token. Everyone
must listen to the message and wait their turn for the token to come to them.
The efficiency of CSMA/CD may seem counter-intuitive to the students, even chaotic. One
classroom activity is to have four students kinesthetically act out the algorithm. Teach them the
following rules. Each student has 6 sentences to transmit, and the maximum frame size is 3
sentences. Each student is to wait for silence. Each student, if hearing silence, may start to talk. If
there is no collision when each student has started talking, they may finish up to three sentences
(the maximum frame size). If there is a collision, each student yells "collision!" and backs off a
"random" number of seconds. Whomever has counted out the least number of seconds will listen
for silence, and if everyone is following the algorithm, start to transmit. Eventually everyone
should get a chance to get their sentence through.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #51, #55, and #56.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #51, #55, and #56.
7.4.1 NICs
The purpose of this target indicator is to have the students give a detailed description of a
10BASE-T NIC. In Chapter 3, all the devices were introduced. The purpose here is to go deeper,
both for understanding and retention. Note that the half-duplex diagram indicates some actual
electrical circuits used in sending signals; much of this detail has not been previously introduced.
Relate this diagram to the actual pinouts used on the RJ-45 terminations and the actual wires in a
Cat 5 cable: pin 1 is TD+ (transmit data), pin 2 is TD (transmit data), pin 3 is RD + (receive
data), pin 6 is RD (receive data) and pins 4, 5, 7, and 8 are unused.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #3, #51, and #60.
7.4.3 Bridges
The purpose of this target indicator is to have the students give a detailed description of a bridge.
In Chapter 3, all the devices were introduced. The purpose here is to go deeper, both for
understanding and retention. While bridges themselves are becoming less common as stand-
alone networking devices, the concept of bridging is extremely important in understanding
switching and routing.
Bridging concepts are the basis for switching technology. Thus this TI provides background to
CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #46 through #60.
Switching is an extremely important topic on the CCNA Certification Exam. This TI relates to
CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #46 through #60.
7.4.5 Switches
The purpose of this target indicator is to have the students give a detailed description of a switch.
In Chapter 3, all the devices were introduced. The purpose here is to go deeper, both for
understanding and retention.
Switching is an extremely important topic on the CCNA Certification Exam. This TI relates to
CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #46 through #60.
Switching is an extremely important topic on the CCNA Certification Exam. This TI relates to
CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #46 through #60.
The T0 interface is connected to a Token Ring Network, which is one broadcast domain and no
collision domains (Token Rings don't have collisions).
The F0 interface is connected to a FDDI backbone network; this is a separate broadcast domain
with no collision domains (FDDI is a fiber-optic Token Ring, with no collisions).
The EO interface is connected to a different Ethernet segment. Since neither switches nor hubs
break up broadcast domain, this is one large broadcast domain. The collision domains are
trickier. Each connection off of the switch is a separate collision domain. For example, there are 4
collision domains formed between the main switch and its connections one to the main server,
one to host G, one to the workgroup switch, and one to the hub. The workgroup switch, in turn,
forms separate collision domains with everything connected to it: the server, the printer, host D,
host E, and host F. The hub (a multiport repeater) simply extends collision domains so hosts A,
B, C, and the hub are all in one collision domain.
Redefine problem.
Brainstorm alternatives.
2. no censorship of ideas
logical topology -- how does data flow? What is the location of key networking
devices?
cut sheets -- in the selection of wiring closet location, catchment areas must be
drawn to see where repeaters and hubs might be needed
What follows are a set of activities, which could be done at once or spread out over several
weeks, to address some of the drawing and model-making techniques which might help students
visualize various networking issues.
3. Estimate the length of a cable run using only a floor plan (optional)
Rationale:
Many networking students usually have little drawing experience and no experience with standard
architectural drawing projections. This is a disadvantage to a practicing Technician, as they must
be able to accurately interpret floor plans and cross sections of the building that contains the
network. This is so that they can make informed decisions about network topologies, the amount
of materials needed for a particular job, and the equipment required for installation. Furthermore,
they must be able to accurately annotate such drawings for future reference.
Abstract:
During this activity, students will measure for and build a three-dimensional model of their
networking classroom using simple materials. They will then draw a scaled floorplan, and will use
their model as a guide. The model and drawing can then be used to stimulate discussion about
means of representing in two dimensions the complex three-dimensional path that a networking
cable must follow. If time permits, there is the opportunity to link together many students' models
to help them see the horizontal and vertical wire routing problems that must be solved in setting
up a network in a large building with dozens of computers, multiple servers, and a variety of
networking equipment.
Procedure:
2. Have them locate the drawings legend and identify as many of the symbols and
lines on the drawing as they can
3. Have student groups measure the outline shape of the room using a variety of
methods (tape measure, ruler, heel-to-toe, counting floor tiles, string, etc.).
Students should then draw on a sheet of cardboard (at least 10" by 12") using
the scale of 1 inch = 3 feet. Provide them with rulers and stress the accuracy of
their drawing.
4. Have students cut out their cardboard along the outlines they have drawn.
5. Provide the students with 3"x5" index cards, transparent tape, and scissors so
that they may construct the walls around the edge of the outline (use the card's
3" dimension to represent the height of the walls). Be sure that they cut out doors
and windows and construct large features of their room like columns, tables,
equipment racks, etc.
6. Check that their models are well attached to the cardboard bases and that all
cuts are clean and accurate.
8. Using the transparency pens and looking down from above, students should
draw the traces where the tops of the walls touch the sheet. Next they should
draw other features that they see, such as tables and racks. Also have them note
the locations and extent of door openings and windows (show them examples of
this from the professional drawings).
9. Have students remove the floor plans that they have thus produced, and
compare them with the professional drawings. Point out similarities and
differences, including scale, level of detail, and wall thickness. Also have
students compare their drawings with each other, and discuss issues of accuracy
of measurement and care and precision of drawing.
Optional Activities.
10. Arrange the students "rooms" on a tabletop as they would be in a real building.
Allow space for corridors, and stack some vertically to help illustrate vertical
wiring problems. You may wish to fasten them to the tabletop with tape.
11. Pose networking problems for students to solve by suggesting the locations of
PCs, wiring closets, networking equipment, jacks and the like. Their solutions
could be expressed by drawing cable routes directly on the models with a felt tip
pen, or for more realism, by having them tape lengths of string, scaled to the
maximum possible run for the particular medium (UTP, coax, fiber) along their
proposed cable routes. For showing runs across ceilings, have the students
attach transparent sheets to the top of their room; these sheets should be hinged
with tape along one side for easy access to the interior.
Orienting Students to Orthographic Projections (top, front, and side views at a minimum)
1. Show students examples of orthographic drawings of familiar objects. Some
good objects are a car, a person standing, a person sitting, a basketball, or a
house.
2. Have students make an orthographic drawing (with at least a top, a side, and a
front view) of a simple object they have with them, such as a book, pen, key, ring,
or trinket.
3. Point out the limitations that external views have in representing the entirety of an
object. Show examples of section views and cut-away views.
4. Have students make some cross-sectional views using objects they are familiar
with or that you have on hand to be disassembled. Good examples are a house,
an egg, an orange, a person (MRI and CAT scans are good examples of cross-
sections), a marking pen, a computer, or a sneaker.
9. Show students how to remove cubic and rectangular volumes from already
drawn rectangular objects
10. Show students how use of shading can enhance these basic drawing techniques.
8.2.2 Size
The purpose of this target indicator is to introduce the size standards for wiring closets. In your
structured cabling installation, the wiring closets may have already been determined or may
already exist. In this case you can have the students verify that the closets meet the standard.
8.4.2 Closet A
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.3 Closet B
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.4 Closet C
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.5 Closet D
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.6 Closet E
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.7 Closet F
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.8 Closet G
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.9 Closet H
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.10 Closet I
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.4.11 Closet J
No Instructor Notes for this TI.
8.7.6 Reasons for using UTP for backbone cabling between buildings
As if the earth ground issue wasn't enough reason to discourage the use of copper-based media
between buildings, another reason is presented. Lightning strikes can more efficiently couple into
buildings, their networks, and their power systems if there is a copper conductor between
buildings. The lesson is to just use fiber between buildings!
8.8 Design Practice No. 1: Wiring Plan for Ethernet Star Topology LAN
8.8.1 Overview
The purpose of this target indicator and subsequent pages is to give the students more practice
on some of the basic choices of network design: backbone cabling and the location of MDFs and
IDFs.
8.9.1 Overview
The purpose of this target indicator is to give the students additional design practice. Treat 8.9.1
through 8.9.10 as a classroom activity or as a homework assignment.
8.11 Network Power Supply Issues: Surge Suppressors and Uninterruptible Power Supply
(UPS) Functions
First, you could work through chapter 9, skill-building for all the students simultaneously so they
can do the individual components of a cable installation prior to the actual installation. This is the
preferred method. Or you could teach the skills to a subset of the class and have one member of
the group teach the others. Or you could teach the skills on an as-needed basis during the
project. Only you can decide what will work best in your classroom.
There are many ideas for projects. You could wire the back of your classroom, the area where the
semester 2 routers and rack are located. If there is another room or wiring project within your
school, you could get permission to perform that project. You could adopt a nearby school that
needs wiring and do the work on a Saturday or after school. Or you could participate in local "Net
Day" activities if they are available. It is not so much the actual project but the fact that the
students do a project -- from start to finish -- that is so vitally important.
When wiring in the real world safety must be a priority. First, you will need your principal's
permission and possibly permission from the school district or local union representative. Second,
you may need permission slips for the students themselves, especially if the project is off-site.
Here are some electrical safety tips; you should brainstorm with your students the electrical safety
rules you will follow during your installation. Never work on a device (like a hub, switch, router, or
PC) with the case open and the line voltage (power cord) plugged in. Test electrical sockets with
an appropriate voltage tester or multimeter. Be sure to find the location of electrical conduit and
power wires before trying to install any networking cable. Properly ground all networking
equipment. Take care never to nick or cut a live 120 VAC line. These are just some of the
precautions you should take.
There are also mechanical precautions. Whenever drilling or cutting, wear safety class. Be careful
with bits and blades. Measure twice, cut once is an old saying; it means you should carefully
measure before using a tool. Make sure you and your teacher have investigated what you are
drilling or cutting into before you drill or cut; you do not want your power tools to come in contact
with electrical wiring or other utilities in the wall. Follow practices of general cleanliness; for
example, minimizing dust since you will be installing sensitive networking devices. If you must
use a ladder, follow proper ladder precautions. Brainstorm with your students other mechanical
precautions you can take.
If proper precautions are taken, the structured cabling installation can be an extremely fun and
rewarding project. But up front you must have strict classroom and team management, for there
are plenty of potential hazards given the nature of the work.
9.1.2 Network documentation
It is an old adage that you will get from your students what you expect of them. This appears to
be true of network documentation. Many students and networking folks alike do not like
documentation, but is an integral part of any professional structured cabling installation. It is best
to develop a rubric around the following components:
Engineering journal
logical topology
physical topology
cut sheets
problem-solving matrices
labeled outlets
Materials and tools manager: responsible for tool kits, cable, connector, testers.
Cable Runner: responsible for planning and running cable safely and according to specifications,
and testing the cable run.
Jack and Patch Panel Terminator: responsible for performing quality punch downs, jack
installations, and testing them.
Project manager -- responsible for safety. Responsible for keeping other team members focused.
Responsible for seeing that all documentation is performed. Responsible for communicating with
the instructor.
Take turns at each job so you can develop all of your skills. Networking professionals often work
in teams and often have to perform very diverse tasks, so be flexible.
RJ-45 jacks
RJ-45 Flush or surface mounting boxes and related hardware to hold the jacks
Cable ties
Velcro
Wire cutters/strippers
Hacksaw
Key saw
Vacuum cleaner
Safety glasses
9.2 RJ-45 Jack and Outlet Installation
An outstanding, brand-new, all-purpose tool from Fluke is shown in the Figure. Undoubtedly other
vendors will be following suit. The idea is to have a "Swiss Army Knife" for a wide range of basic
network tests. Emphasize to students the utility and versatility of a very portable device for doing
basic network troubleshooting at layers 1, 2 and 3. This tool is available to Academies, in various
quantities and at a discount, on the Academy Store. It will also be available for purchase by
students as well. Upcoming lab activities will be written to teach the wide range of uses for this
tool.
9.7.3 Cable testing equipment
You might think that testing cable is simply a matter of substituting one cable for another. This
does not, however, provide certain proof of anything, since a common problem can effect all
cables on a LAN. For this reason, it is recommended that you use a cable tester to measure
network performance.
A cable tester is a hand held device that can certify that cable meets the required IEEE and
TIA/EIA standards. Cable testers vary in the types of testing functions they provide. Some can
provide printouts, others can be attached to a PC to create a data file. Little or no special training
is required to use the cable testers that are currently available on the market today. Most
competent network administrators or installers find that the operating manuals, supplied by the
cable tester manufacturers, provide sufficient instruction.
10.1.1 Identifiers
The purpose of this target indicator is to justify the necessity of Layer 3 addresses. The key
distinction to make for the students is that MAC addresses represent a flat address space. That
is, they are non-hierarchical like national personal identification (e.g., social security) numbers.
MAC addressing -- the naming of computers with hexadecimal numbers -- works fine in a LAN
environment, but they don't scale well. As the number of computers and separate networks
grows, the necessity of some kind of hierarchical addressing scheme becomes apparent.
Telephone and Postal codes are routing codes which are analogous to Layer 3 addressing
schemes. As an activity you might have the students drawing a diagram for n = 30 computers
might help. Label them A, B, C, etc. and then relabel and reorganize the computers hierarchically
with two-part numerical codes. Discuss the implications of both addressing schemes.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #2, #29, and #36.
Call attention to the fact that this seemingly large Layer 3 PDU (datagram, packet) acts as "data"
for the Layer 2 PDU (frames). That is, packets are encapsulated into frames.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #2, #29, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #2, #29, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #2, #29, and #36.
10.3.5 IP address component fields
This target indicator introduces two important IP addressing concepts: dotted decimal notation,
and the classification of parts of the address as "network" numbers and parts of the address as
"host" numbers. Relate the network numbers to the earlier discussion of hierarchical addressing,
including the analogy to zip codes. Practicing binary to decimal and decimal to binary conversions
would be appropriate here, using the dotted decimal notation.
Practice Problems:
1. Convert 1101 0101.1100 0011.0000 1111.0101 0101 to dotted decimal notation.
The "lab", a paper-based activity, requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI is related to CCNA
Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
10.5 Reserved Address Space
Also be forewarned that once subnetworks are created, the reserved network numbers and
broadcast numbers become less obvious and require more work to compute.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
10.5.2 Network ID
The importance of this target indicator is identifying the importance of network id numbers.
Network ID numbers provide a convenient way to refer to all of the addresses on a particular
network or subnetwork. Two hosts with differing network id numbers require a device, typically a
router, in order to communicate.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
10.6 Basics of Subnetting
A different, fairly large number, of medium sized address blocks -- over 65,000 class B addresses
-- were created, with 65,000 hosts per network. This is still a large amount of hosts per network
number -- again too many, wasting many hosts per network number.
The largest amount of addresses -- the over 16 million class Cs -- only have 256 hosts per
network number -- which is often too FEW hosts per network. So the division of networks into the
sizes of classes A, B, and C, none of which is of optimum size for network administration, can be
very wasteful in the assignment of hierarchical IP addresses. These inconvenient sizes for
address classes are a remnant of an earlier day in the Internet's history, when it seemed
unimaginable that any of the address classes would be almost completely assigned. But the
proliferation of networks and hosts has made these classes limiting, and in advanced networking
courses various ways of dealing with the consumption of addresses are taught (for example,
VLSM (variable length subnet masking), private networks and network address translation, and IP
version 6).
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
10.6.2 Subnetwork
The purpose of this target indicator is to introduce the abstract but vitally important topic of
subnetting. Emphasize that we desire to give network administrators more flexibility, so we will
allow them to extend the network number by a certain number of bits. Of course, this extension of
the network number comes at the expense of the number of host bits. But this is not really
harmful in the case of class A and class B addresses, which tend to have blocks of host
addresses that are too large. The terminology is often that subnet bits are "borrowed" or "stolen"--
it is important to emphasize that the bits are being re-purposed.
The notion of subnet mask is introduced -- the mask allows decoding of the subnetted network
number. Without a subnet mask, the subnetwork number cannot be used to route data.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
10.6.5 Boolean operation: AND, OR, and NOT
There are three fundamental operations in Boolean algebra. These three functions are crucial in
the design of all digital circuits, and important in programming. These functions are often used in
"Boolean searches" to use Internet search engines to narrow the range of hits for a search. In
internetworking, the AND function is particularly important part of the routing process. Teach one-
bit Boolean AND as similar to multiplication ( 0 AND 0 = 0, 0 AND 1 = 0, 1 AND 0 = 0, 1 AND 1 =
1); one-bit Boolean OR as similar to addition (0 OR 0 = 0, 0 OR 1 = 1, 1 OR 0 = 1, 1 OR 1 = 1);
and one-bit Boolean NOT as simply inversion of the bit (NOT 0 = 1 and NOT 1 = 0). This is also a
good time to review the different ways 1s and 0s are sometimes represented -- ones as TRUE,
ON, SHORT CIRCUIT, +5 Volts and zeros as FALSE, OFF, OPEN Circuit, or 0 Volts. For
multiple-bit binary numbers, (anything AND 1111 1111) yields (anything).
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
10.7.4 Computing hosts per subnetwork
There are several techniques for calculating the number of subnets when given the subnet mask
and IP address. From the IP address, you can determine its class and hence the default subnet
mask. Find how many bits beyond the default mask the actual subnet mask has been extended.
This is the number of bits "borrowed" or stolen to create subnetworks.
m
The formula 2 - 2, where m is the number of bits NOT stolen, gives the number of USABLE host
numbers created. Another way to see this is to write out the powers of two, and find the exponent
of two that matches the number of bits NOT stolen. Whatever that power of two equals (less the 2
reserved numbers) gives the number of hosts per subnetwork.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
The "lab", a paper-based activity, requires approximately 45 minutes. This TI is related to CCNA
Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
Problem:
Given 195.137.92.0 and needing 8 usable subnets, find the subnetwork numbers, the ranges of
host numbers, and subnetwork broadcast numbers.
Solution:
IP Address is a class C. Default subnet mask is 255.255.255.0. We need to extend the network
number by enough bits to give 8 usable subnets. Stealing 2 bits yields 2 usable subnets, stealing
3 bits yields 6 usable subnets, so we must steal 4 bits to get 14 usable subnets, of which we
needed 8. This makes the subnet mask 255.255.255.240. So the Network number is
195.137.92.NNNN HHHH where Ns stand for network extension bits (subnets) and Hs stand for
host numbers. Next we must number the subnets; there are 16 combinations of 4 bit binary
numbers but they retain their place value within the last octet.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
The "lab", a paper-based activity, requires approximately 45 minutes. This TI is related to CCNA
Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
10.7.8 Private addresses
There are certain IP address ranges reserved for private IP addressing schemes. Not everyone
needs connectivity to the Internet. Another relevant discussion is IP address depletion. Various
schemes are being pursued to deal with IP address depletion. First there is NAT. Second there is
CIDR. Third there is IP v6. While all of these have there benefits, students should be well-
grounded in classful IP addresses.
This TI is related to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #29, #30, and #36.
Chapter 11: Layer 3 - Protocols
11.1.1 Routers
This target indicator reviews a simple definition of router functionality -- a device which makes
best path routing decisions based on Layer 3 addressing. The students have just finished
studying the dominant Layer 3 Addressing scheme -- IP addressing. The purpose of this chapter
is to illuminate how those best path decisions are made.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #31, and #36.
11.2.2 DHCP initialization sequence
This target indicator explains the DHCP process in greater detail. Since DHCP is so commonly
used, it is important for students to be familiar with this network process.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #31, and #36.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #31, and #36.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #31, and #36.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #31, and #36.
Instead, the host relies on the router interface which is the default gateway for the host. The
default gateway router will reply to the host's ARP. When the packet is delivered to the router, it
then uses its routing tables to determine which network and hence which interface to which the
packet will be delivered.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #36, and #41.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #36, and #41.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #36, and #41.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #7, #36, and #41.
11.5 Routing Protocols
Emphasize to students that without routing protocols to update each other about the state of the
network topology, disruptions in that topology (which grow more likely as the internetwork grows
larger) become fatal to packets (they become undeliverable for lack of a path) trying to traverse
the network. Routing protocols, when properly running, assure the routers have a consistent and
up-to-date way to decide how to choose the best path.
11.8 Interior Gateway Protocols (IGP) and Exterior Gateway Protocol (EGP)
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
11.8.3 RIP
The purpose of this target indicator is to describe in some detail the early and conceptually
important routing protocol called RIP.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
11.8.5 OSPF
Again, the purpose of introducing OSPF is to broaden the student's internetworking vocabulary.
OSPF is a widely used and conceptually important routing protocol which students will study in
depth if they pursue more advanced Cisco certifications.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #39, #40, and #42.
11.9 Protocol Analyzer Software
Another purpose of this target indicator to is assist the student in visualizing one of the somewhat
abstract but absolutely crucial functions of Layer 4 -- flow control. You can have the students act
this out, with one student speaking very quickly and the other student trying to keep up, using
their native or second languages.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
The lab activity requires approximately 30 minutes. This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam
Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
12.2.1 TCP
The purpose of this target indicator is to identify the key properties of TCP. It also locates TCP on
the protocol graph of the TCP/IP stack.
The purpose of this target indicator is not that the student memorize all of the fields of a TCP
segment. Rather, if they can describe the most important features of segments that is sufficient.
Also, it is important to relate segments to the other PDUs -- segments are encapsulated into
packets which are encapsulated into frames which are converted to a bit stream on the media.
The students have already seen Ethernet, Token Ring, and FDDI frame formats; and IP
datagrams -- relate the TCP segment format explicitly to those diagrams.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #2, #6, and #35.
12.2.2 UDP segment format
The purpose of this target indicator is to identify the key properties of UDP. It also locates UDP on
the protocol graph of the TCP/IP stack.
The purpose of this target indicator is not that the student memorize all of the fields of a UDP
segment. Rather, if they can describe the most important features of segments that is sufficient.
Also, it is important to relate segments to the other PDUs -- segments are encapsulated into
packets which are encapsulated into frames which are converted to a bit stream on the media.
The students have already seen Ethernet, Token Ring, and FDDI frame formats; and IP
datagrams -- relate the TCP segment format explicitly to those diagrams.
Students should know the port numbers for ftp, telnet, smtp, dns, tftp and snmp.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #2, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
Understanding the important TCP process of acknowledgment is another purpose of this target
indicator. Again emphasize that that the vertical axis is time, and that horizontal lines are not
permitted since they imply zero time for a message to travel. A kinesthetic activity -- with 2
students playing the roles of two hosts and acting out a simple acknowledgment with large
numbers on pieces of paper -- will help them visualize this process.
Since the segments are encapsulated in packets, and since packets travel connectionless paths
through internetworks, sequence and acknowledgment numbers become necessary for TCP to
track them. Two successive IP packets may, in many instances, NOT travel the same path and
therefore arrive at the destination host out of order.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
Chapter 13: Layer 5 - The Session Layer
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
This TI relates to CCNA Certification Exam Objectives #1, #6, and #35.
Chapter 14: Layer 6 - The Presentation Layer
There are a variety of activities to help the students understand these three topics. For example,
you might have them write their names or some text in ASCII or Morse Code. Then they could
transform the data via some sort of key (encryption). Finally, they could pick a recurring bit
pattern and represent it with a special, shorter number of bits (compression). You could even try
encapsulating such data and giving the encryption key and the compression algorithm to a
receiving host to see if they can decode the message.
The purpose of this target indicator is also to go into more depth into text representations.
The purpose of this target indicator is also to go into more depth into graphical and audio
representations.
The purpose of this target indicator is also to go into more depth into multimedia representations.
The purpose of this target indicator is to describe the universal language of the Internet and the
World Wide Web -- Hypertext Markup Language or html. Again, this is to emphasize the diversity
of presentation layer issues. When in a browser viewing the curriculum, have the students do a
VIEW -- SOURCE and look at the html representation of the page they were viewing.
The purpose of this target indicator is for the student to identify compression as a function of the
presentation layer. An activity you might use is to have the student write a paragraph, and then
create a compression key for frequently used words or letter combinations.
The details of DNS are explored. Students will probably be familiar with the more common
domain names. Emphasize the importance of these both for ease of use by humans and for
imposing some hierarchical structure on Internet naming. You may want to have the students do
some browsing in different domains to explore this topic in a practical context.
Just as an e-mail message begins at an e-mail server (post office), it must end at an e-mail server
(another post office). Then local delivery of the e-mail can be performed.
Again, the common process of entering a password to retrieve your email is explained.
E-mail is related to a prior topic, encapsulation, as it is a key theme of the entire semester and of
the OSI model. Sending and receiving an e-mail involve encapsulation at all seven layers of the
OSI model. This is an excellent opportunity to review the entire OSI model and what functions
each layer performs.
This target indicator describes the file formats typically used with email. This is an excellent
opportunity to review Layer 6 topics.
15.4.1 Telnet
One purpose of telnet is described. Another purpose, common as a second semester
troubleshooting tool, is to telnet into various routers. As a simple activity, you may want to have
the students telnet into another computer via your LAN.
This target indicator describes the details of the Telnet process. Emphasis is on the client-server
model and the 7 OSI layers.
This target indicator describes the details of the Telnet process. Emphasis is on the client-server
model and the 7 OSI layers.
The purpose of this target indicator is to give the student a precise definition of hyperlinks. For
those with a fair amount of programming background, you might want to compare hyperlinks to
pointer variables and linked lists.
The purpose of this target indicator is to have a student dissect a URL. the students use URLs
every day but rarely take the time to understand them in detail. This makes cyberspace a little
less magical.
Best Practices have always been an important component in the CNAP. Short
explanations were included in the old Teachers Guide 1.50 and are now
included in the preface for each semester. The following quote comes from the
preface of Semester 1 version 2.1:
Feedback from instructor trainees indicates that the greater use of Best Practices
means better comprehension of the concepts. The Best Practices provide a
variety of opportunities to learn as explained through the following:
See the processes through kinesthetic activities;
Apply the processes through labs, challenges, troubleshooting, presentations,
etc.;
Obtain the knowledge through online study, mini-lectures, and discussion;
Think about the processes and concepts through study guides, reflection,
portfolios, and journals;
Organize the components and ideas through graphical organizers,
presentations, and study guides; and
Discuss ideas and concepts with others through group work.
The second component is a chart that demonstrates the main and secondary
purposes of each Best Practice as well as the class structure generally used
during implementation.
It is important that the CATC and Regional Academy instructors use and
understand the Best Practices, as they are the link to the Local Academy
instructors who work directly with students. The students will have a more
effective educational opportunity if Best Practices are used to assist their
learning.
The handout is a draft and a beginning of the support that will be offered
regarding Best Practices. Any suggestions or comments are welcome.
Blooms Taxonomy
The six levels beginning with the lowest level of thinking are as follows:
Knowledge
Comprehension
Application
Analysis
Synthesis
Evaluation
Definitions are included for each level with examples from the networking
curriculum.
Level 1 Knowledge
Knowledge allows students to define, describe, list, identify, label, outline, select
and state facts regarding content. The objective is to have students know
common terms, specific facts, methods and procedures, basic concepts and
principles.
Examples:
List the full names for the acronyms-ARP, RARP, IOS, RIP, IGRP, ACL,
ISDN, etc.
Identify how many bits comprise an IP address. (Sem 1)
Level 2 Comprehension
Comprehension allows students to paraphrase, defend, estimate, explain,
distinguish, give examples, infer, predict, or summarize. It requires the ability to
grasp the meaning of material, understand facts and principles, interpret verbal
material, and justify methods and procedures.
Examples:
Distinguish between standard and extended Access Control Lists (Sem 3)
Give examples of IOS commands useful for examining different router
components (Sem 2)
Paraphrase the function of each of the 7 layers (Sem 1)
Classify 191.52.7.1 as either a class A, B, and C IP address (As begin with
0 to 127; Bs begin with 128 to 191; Cs with 192 to 223. (Sem 1)
Level 3 Application
Application allows students to demonstrate, relate, show, modify, prepare, solve,
give examples, manipulate, or generalize. It requires them to use ideas and
material they have learned in new situations, apply theories to practical
situations, and demonstrate correct methods or procedures.
Examples:
Demonstrate the construction of a patch cable (Sem 1)
Modify the following IOS statement so that it assigns 193.1.7.5 as the static
route for all packets on 199.4.5.0: ip route 193.1.7.5 255.255.255.0 199.4.5.0
(Sem2)
Level 4 Analysis
Analysis allows students to brainstorm, point out, differentiate, separate, and
discriminate. Its the purpose of breaking material into its components so that the
organizational structure is understood; recognizing unstated assumptions and
logical fallacies; distinguishing between fact and inference; and evaluating
relevancy of data.
Examples:
Brainstorm the problems tha t can cause a PING to fail (Sem 2)
You are troubleshooting the 5-router network. Distinguish between
observable network symptoms and what problems you might infer are
causing those symptoms.
Level 5 Synthesis
Synthesis allows students to combine, devise, compose, organize, plan,
reorganize, revise, rewrite, and generate. It involves the ability to put parts
together to form a whole item; write a well-organized essay; write creatively;
integrate learning from different areas in to a plan for solving a problem or form a
new scheme for classifying ideas and events.
Examples:
Generate a design for an elementary school LAN. (Sem 3) Generate a design
for a School District WAN. (Sem 4)
Plan a school-wide structured cabling installation for Net Day. (Sem 1)
Compose a subnetted IP address scheme for a class C network (192.18.9.0)
which leads to
Level 6 Evaluation
Evaluation requires students to appraise, compare, contrast, criticize, support,
conclude, or interpret. Its the ability to judge the value of material for a given
purpose and to evaluate logical consistency of written material and the adequacy
of conclusions. Judgements should be based on specific criteria given by the
instructor of determined by the students.
Examples:
Your company has decided to use Category 6 UTP (instead of CAT 5, 5e, or
7) support their decision.
Interpret the following result of a show ip interface command: Serial 0 is
administratively down; line protocol is down.
Contrast the metrics used by RIP with the metrics used by IGRP (Sem 2).
Use a rubric to compare the Threaded Case Studies LAN and WAN solutions
designed by the class groups. (Sem 3 and Sem 4)
Compare the following two LAN technologies for use in a high school
environment on a limited budget: 10BASE-T Ethernet and 100BASE-TX Fast
Ethernet (Sem 1 and Sem 3).
Compare the following two WAN technologies for a high school on a limited
budget: ISDN and Frame Relay. (Sem 4)
Best Practices
Challenges
Description:
Challenges are problem-based labs or projects, advocated by AAAS Project
2061 (a science education reform project). These exercises are the opposite of
cookbook, or step-by-step, labs. Instead, they encourage students to work on
their own to develop solutions to various problems or challenges.
The challenges vary in content and duration (from fifty minutes to three weeks),
and are comprised of two basic parts. First, the lab asks students to solve a
given problem. Second, it asks the students to create a product. For example, a
simple 50-minute challenge lab for the first semester might be titled Make a
Patch Cable that Works Successfully. A three-week challenge that could teach
more complex tasks might be called Wire the School Computer Lab.
Research:
While little research deals with challenges per se, many of the components that
make up a challenge have been thoroughly studied and have consistently
shown positive results. Research shows that the most effective learning patterns
occur when students are closely involved with the curriculum such as what
happens when an assignment translates theoretical learning to a hands-on
setting. Tasks that require students to do the following:
apply previously mastered basic learning to a new situation
use both analysis and synthesis to create a workable product
evaluate both the process and product
are demanding and allow the assessment of higher order thinking skills.
Challenges are a part of the category of active learning that has been explored
for use with almost any subject matter and with any population. Numerous
strategies have been devised to successfully promote active learning with any
age level, but is most successful with older children and young adults.
Implementation:
The degree of independence in solving challenges should vary according to the
level of knowledge and the complexity of the task. Begin using the less complex
and shorter challenges with the students. Have them work in pairs until they are
familiar with the process and gain confidence in their skills. Make certain that
they record key ideas in their journals as a record of their progress. After each
challenge, discuss the process and what they learned in completing it. Have
them identify strategies that would be helpful when they complete the next
challenge.
As students gain in knowledge there should be less guidance and more
individual solving of the problem. When they become proficient, the students
could be placed in competitive teams to solve a challenge. This is especially
appropriate during Semesters 2, 3 and 4.
Students can record information regarding their successes and failures in solving
challenges in their journals. Periodically, have the students review their journals
for comments regarding challenges. Have them look for evidence of growth in
solving them, improved strategies, and general increase in content knowledge.
Rubric:
A quality challenge solution will meet the following criteria:
Use a problem solving format
Use a logical process
Solve the challenge correctly
Demonstrate the thinking process
Show evidence of critical thinking including analysis, comparison, synthesis
and evaluation
Show thorough understanding of content
Use references effectively (web research or instructional manual)
Best Practices
Graphic Organizers
Description:
These terms refer to a large group of visual tools (diagrams and schematics)
used to represent concepts and ideas. They are implemented to facilitate
comprehension of expository text. They seek to replicate the patterns used by
the brain to recall linked information or detail.
Research:
Research indicates that the use of organizers benefits all learners in all content
areas. In addition, specific testing was completed to study visually/spatially
talented and visually/spatially challenged student learners to determine who
benefited most as a result of using visual tools. It was found that both groups
benefited. A secondary outcome was a more positive outlook toward the subject
matter with greater gains by the challenged learners. Instructors have indicated
in studies that their instruction was improved through the use of graphic
organizers
Implementation:
Each type of organizer has its unique purposes and uses. These are described
for ten of the organizers in an in-depth explanation in the instructors' guide. One
main guide is that the graphical organizer chosen should be congruent with the
instructors' purpose and enhance the concepts of the topic being discussed.
The most effective graphic organizers have been those made by the instructor for
the specific material being presented. Instructors and learners can often design
a graphic organizer together. Certainly, critiquing a completed organizer for its
effectiveness for learning the content encourages learners to design their own
tools for understanding new content.
Rubric:
An effective graphic organizer should meet the following criteria:
Provides an appropriate and logical visual for the content and concepts
presented
Shows relationships among concepts
Utilizes a design that is easily understood by all learners
Focuses the learners in the content through questions and/or clearly stated
objectives
Results in a organized plan, processes, and/or a product that demonstrates
learning
Provides for analysis and redirection of learning
Bests Practices
Groupwork
Description:
Groupwork refers to using a variety of trainee/student groups to enhance
learning. Learners can be grouped for reviewing, questioning, learning content,
doing performance labs, designing projects, assessing their learning and other
suitable tasks. Within cooperative teams, individuals seek outcomes that are
beneficial to themselves and other members of the group. Working together,
students and trainees are able to maximize their own and each other's learning.
Research:
Numerous research studies have been conducted on ways to improve learner
motivation, attendance, and academic growth through grouping for learning
activities. Cooperative and integrated learning groups have been found to
enhance inter-group relations and team building. For the Networking program,
the ability to work together is beneficial to future employment.
Prior to the 90s, it was generally believed that the most effective classes were
those that had a low number of students. Current educational philosophers look
instead to styles of grouping within the classroom where dimensions such as
group problem solving has been measured more effective than other modes of
instruction for higher order thinking tasks. Various modes of small groups are
shown to make a significant difference in learning patterns. Studies in Great
Britain, Canada, Australia, and the United States have revealed the same results
related to the benefits of grouping for learning.
Implementation:
Trainees and student learners can be assigned to groups or they can choose
their own group. As a class, the rubric (criteria) for effective groupwork should be
discussed prior to the activity. The difference between individual and group effort
should be emphasized. It is useful to discuss group roles such a leader,
recorder, timer, etc.
Have the groups clarify the task or assignment to be accomplished. During the
group work, the instructor can move around the classroom to answer questions,
assist in maintaining focus, and ensure that all group members are actively
engaged.
After the group presents projects, plans or ideas, use the rubrics to assess how
well the group process worked. Group work for organizing, planning,
researching, and focusing is beneficial. Individual responsibilities for learning,
presenting, producing, can be established with specific criteria for the
presentation or product that provides evidence of the individual learning.
Rubrics:
Group Effort
Utilizes individual strengths to enhance the process
Reaches consensus through negotiation and compromise
Collaborates effectively and efficiently
Utilizes resources and materials to maximum advantage
Keeps within timelines and meets all set deadlines
Reflects on progress, process and product
Individual Effort
Performs multiple roles and responsibilities within the group
Respects other members feelings, abilities, opinions, contributions
Contributes equitably within the group
Enhances the strength of the group
Utilizes resources and materials effectively and efficiently
Meets set deadlines
Reflects on progress, process and product
(Rubrics are also available for group planning and group problem solving.)
Best Practices
Journals
Description:
Typically, a journal is a paper, bound, composition book in which pages are not
added or subtracted, but dated. The purposes of a journal are to document the
process and progress of learning and work and to develop a reference of
solutions that have worked in the past.
Engineering journals come in part from patent law. Most corporations have their
technical employees keep a journal (dated, signed, bound and kept in ink) to
resolve patent issues. It is a legal document and may be used in audits.
In the field of networking, engineers keep journals in which they record their
thoughts regarding the many activities in which they are engaged. Journals in
general are a record of an individuals thoughts regarding a specific topic. These
thoughts, overtime, allow the learner to analyze and chart his/he r progress in
understanding the topic. The journal will include events that failed as well as
those that succeeded.
The types of journal entries most applicable for Networking Academies students
include:
daily reflections
troubleshooting details
lab procedures and observations
equipment logs
hardware and software notes
router configurations
contacts & resources
questions
designs
While the journal becomes much more important as the students do more
network design and installation work, good habits can be developed by starting
with a journal the first day of the first semester.
Research:
Journals were "reinvented" within the last few decades not for the value of the
content, but for the value to the author as a response to the prevailing attitudes of
learners that were reported by researchers. Learners felt that the success or
failure of their learning program was outside of their control. Assessments were
done "on them"--their role was passive rather than as an active learner.
Students were found to lack a sense of ownership, were not self-directed, lacked
the ability to self-reflect and exhibited low expectations of themselves. Where
these attitudes were most prevalent, it was noted that students were excluded
from the conferencing, the portfolio selection, and the criteria setting processes.
Implementation:
Each student is responsible for maintaining his/her journal. Often, instructors
may provide a specific time in class for the students to make notes in their
journals. Students may also record their ideas as they read, listen, or complete
activities. For example, during a mini-lecture, the students may record analogies
that help them understand a concept. During a lab activity they may record their
procedures with results. After an exam, they may write the concepts that they do
not understand. Questions that they want to explore may be written at any time.
Students may use their journals to assist in reviewing for an exam. Periodically,
they may review their journals to analyze their progress in learning the content
and record reflections.
Students who are able to develop the habit of using a journal may be more
successful in networking or whatever technical career is in their future.
Rubric:
A quality journal will meet the following criteria:
Kinesthetic Activities
Description:
Kinesthetic activities literally refer to those activities that use the body to act out,
or to communicate some process, concept or idea. Role-playing and skits are
examples of kinesthetic activities. Showing a process by having individuals
perform the steps of the process with materials such as slips of paper, boxes,
rope, etc is another example. Immediate feedback by the group and instructor is
necessary to make certain that the processes and concepts are presented clearly
and correctly.
In the CNAP, the kinesthetic activities also apply to many of the hands-on
learning activities whose real life situations and labs are used to provide
learning experiences. Many of the protocols and devices involved in networking
are resolvable into distinct algorithms that can be very difficult to read about or
visualize. Acting out algorithms is particularly helpful during the introduction to
these complex processes and devices. A classic pedagogical technique in
computer science is to have students act out a bubble sort algorithm. These
fun, interactive activities are a needed variation from online learning.
Research:
Activities that promote kinesthetic learning are often grouped with active or
performance learning although they are a specialized form of this total group.
Researchers report activities in this category often need revision as programs
seek greater inclusion of individuals with special health, cultural or learning
needs.
For students to assimilate information and realize their maximum potential, they
must do more than listen.
Implementation:
To help students begin learning how to use this type of activity, have them
demonstrate a simple activity. Discuss how the activity makes the concept more
visible and therefore more understandable. For example, choose topology.
Demonstrate by putting a message in a box and passing between students with
each person designated as parts of the system. Select two or more types of
topology to demonstrate and compare. Have the students suggest other ways
this could be shown.
For other concepts, have the students design their own kinesthetic activity.
Kinesthetic activities can be especially helpful when introducing some of the
basic networking concepts. For example, during semester 1, have the students
act out any or all of the following:
The encapsulation process
The handling of data by repeaters, hubs, bridges and routers
The functioning processes of ARP and RARP
Any concept that students may have difficulty understanding is a logical topic for
a kinesthetic activity. If it can be made visible to the class, more will
understand.
Rubric:
A quality kinesthetic activity meets the following criteria:
Represent the key elements of the concept, process or idea
Require the participants to use their bodies in the demonstration
Is logical in its presentation
Show a correct sequence if it is a process
Use correct vocabulary, terms and explanations
Is engaging and interesting
Contribute to the understanding of a concept, process or idea
Best Practices
Lab Exams/Activities
Description:
Examples of lab exams include all of the following:
practical exams
performance exams
demonstration labs
skill-based and performance assessments
authentic assessments
mastery learning.
They are assessments of the students knowledge in a particular subject using a
hands-on, demonstration method. The student is able to apply his/her
knowledge of content to a task that is or simulates a real life activity. Vocational
subjects have long included labs to ensure that students know how to use their
knowledge. Networking is a perfect example of a subject that benefits from an
emphasis on labs and lab exams.
_______________________________________________________________
Research:
Relevant performance labs and activities are emphasized to promote student
understanding of science and applied science content. Research has shown that
reading and hearing about the content provides only a portion of the learning
required for these contents. Lab activities and exams allow the student to
practice and demonstrate the application of principles learned. Multiple studies
have demonstrated the added comprehension of these activities.
______________________________________________________________
Implementation:
Start with simple labs to acquaint the students with the process of solving them.
Some labs may be step-by-step activities that require the students to follow
directions to reach a planned solution. Students may work in pairs or small
groups until the students gain confidence in the process.
Discuss problem-solving techniques before assigning labs. After the labs are
completed, discuss the problems encountered and the final results. Identify the
problem solving techniques that helped in the solution. Lab activities should be
designed to practice the skills tested in the lab exams.
During semester 1, lab exams sho uld be assigned for the following:
Making patch cables
Configuring IP addresses
Punching down jacks and patch panels
Testing cable runs and using test equipment
Simple hardware and software procedures
Assign a pass/fail grade and allow retakes of the exams.
Some students may be able to design their own labs and lab exams for the class.
Rubric:
A quality lab acti vity or exam should meet the following criteria:
Shows understanding of an important concept or process
Demonstrates the connections between and among the various components
of networking
Shows knowledge of basic networking vocabulary
Demonstrates the ability to construct simple materials, repair, connect, design
and/or use materials or equipment
Provides evidence of learning
Results in a product or completed process
Best Practices
Mini-lecture
Description:
A mini-lecture is a 5-15 minute presentation intended to supplement the online,
written, or demonstrated information. It is used as a precursor to a small group
or individual learning activity. It is a modification of the commonly used lecture,
during which the instructor presents all the information to the trainees or
students. The mini-lecture has evolved from identifying the types of lectures and
strategies used that are most effective and incorporating them into a shorter
format. A mini-lecture is used to present information, clarify concepts, discuss
issues, setup a performance lab, summarize ideas and assess performances,
and connect to prior knowledge. It provides a context for the content to be
learned and is used in conjunction with activities that allow trainees/students to
apply and clarify ideas.
Relatively short, engaging, mini-lectures with demonstrations are excellent
adjuncts to the online curriculum and lab activities that are the backbone of the 4-
semester curriculum
Research:
Researchers have pointed out the advantages and disadvantages of lecturing.
Advantages are as follows:
ideas can be presented and/or clarified quickly;
the same information is heard by all;
it helps to focus the group on goals and objectives;
lectures can be recorded or taped for review.
Some of the disadvantages are as follows:
if abstract information is presented, the listeners may have difficulty
comprehending;
the training instructors receive in public speaking is limited and insufficient;
lack of the lecturer's focus and organization is often common, resulting in just
"covering" the material;
trainees/students reach a saturation point of listening during extended
lectures.
Implementation:
A mini-lecture is especially appropriate to accomplish the following:
provide a motivational introduction to a topic;
discuss a focus question to test for understanding;
clarify understanding of a concept;
explain how previous lessons/content/concepts, etc. connect to the new
information.
Rubric:
A quality mini-lecture will meet the following criteria:
Focuses on one concept or topic
Organizes the topic so that it is easily understood
Engages the trainees/students in the topic
Accomplishes the purpose for which it is intended
Utilizes a variety of strategies to assist in the organization and retention of
ideas and concepts
Maintains focus through the short presentation
Uses questioning to focus and enhance learning
Provides for multiple learning modalities through the use of demonstrations,
graphic organizers, visuals, audio, PowerPoint presentation or graphs
Best Practices
Portfolios
Description:
Portfolios are systematic, purposeful, meaningful collections of student work that
reveal the result of learning. They exhibit the students efforts, progress, and
achievement Criteria are defined in the portfolio and the work demonstrates a
students progress in meeting the criteria through various learning or
performance tasks. The collections can be in paper or online form and can
represent the work of a limited period of time such as one semester or be
cumulative over a period of years.
Research:
The last ten years of educational literature includes more thinking about and
research on assessment than any other topic. Understandably so, since as
education has changed there has been more criticism about teaching style and
curriculum than in the past. Teachers and administrators have found it essential
to measure what has been learned, however, as learning and teaching styles
have changed so have patterns of assessment.
One of the most successful of the newer assessment methods has been the
portfolio.
Implementation:
Trainees and students begin the portfolio process by designing a web site based
on the requirements for Semester 1. The Semester 1 requirements for trainees
are as follows:
A syllabus for traini ng classes, if you are a CATC or Regional Instructor, and
a syllabus for student classes, if you are a Local Academy instructor.
The lesson plan developed by your group
Some practice wiring diagrams
Examples of your use of the decision matrix
A plan for a wiring project
A flowchart of a Semester 1 topic
Local instructors may set requirements for their students. Requirements might
include diagrams and explanations of specific concepts, practice wiring
diagrams, a plan for a wiring project, reflection on lab exercises, designs,
examples of graphic organizers, and other materials that the instructors may
assign.
Discuss the requirements and the scope of CNAP to assist the trainees and
students in including all the items they might need, e.g., elements of the
Threaded Case Study. Note: A list of the elements will be included in the final
version of this document.
Trainees or students may wish to work in pairs as they design each of their web
site portfolios. The results can be presented to the class. Students in high
school settings can present their portfolios as part of the parent/student/instructor
conference.
Rubric:
A quality portfolio meets the following criteria:
Contains examples of all the requirements for the Semester
Contains materials that demonstrate understanding of specific skills/concepts
learned
Uses explanations for those items that are self-selected
Explains progress toward goals for the Semester
Shows evidence of organizational skills
Provides evidence of growth and progress
Demonstrates excellent work, format and design
Best Practices
PowerPoint Presentation
Description:
A PowerPoint presentation is a 5 to 45 minute presentation utilizing an overhead
projector, an In-focus projector, a Proxima projector, or another form of
equipment that allows a pre-written set of documents, charts, graphs, outlines,
etc. to be projected on a wall or screen. It is usually used to present information
for a small or large group so that all can see. The PowerPoint presentation may
be an outline of talk points or a series of words, phrases, diagrams, charts, etc.
that helps to facilitate a lecture or mini-lecture. It can be used to generate
questions, facilitate discussion, show answers to questions, or present
information. It provides a conte xt for the content that is to be learned and is used
in conjunction with either an oral presentation or discussion. Animation may be
used (if projecting from a computer) to specify points of discussion or to make the
presentation more engaging.
Research:
Researchers have pointed out the advantages and disadvantages of using
PowerPoint presentations.
Advantages are as follows:
ideas and information can be viewed by a large number of participants
note taking is facilitated by using talk points or an outline form, particularly
when using the PowerPoint handouts (either 3 or 6 slides to a page.)
presentations may be developed in advance, can be modified easily, and can
duplicated for handouts or use by other persons
provides a framework or structure to assist students in connecting ideas and
concepts
Some of the disadvantages are as follows:
such presentations cannot contain all of the information to be
learned/presented when used in this way they are very ineffective
too much lecture for each talk point can distract from the content
is best used for brief periods of time for introduction, review, or a brief
presentation of important information
may not be as effective if used in a passive presentation, i.e., students listen
and instructor talks
Animation, as long as it does not detract the viewer, can be very effective for
focusing the participant on the important point being made. It can engage the
participants by creating interest and can focus attention to both the screen and
the speaker.
Handouts (with three or six slides per page) can assist the participant.
Connections to prior knowledge and new content can be made with notes that
participants take. Handouts help the participant to keep focused on important
concepts and facilitate summary discussions and questions.
Using the concept of less is more with the number of slides helps the presenter
focus only on the important issues and helps the participant clarify the learning.
Brief presentations used at the beginning or as a summary of content
presentation can help connect important concepts and can generate and hold
participant interest. PowerPoint presentations are not to be a replication of
information provided in another media (IE. Textbook, on-line material, etc.)
Using a reflection question throughout the presentation but particularly at the end
of the presentation assists the participants in their understanding of what was
learned. A question focusing on the content, process, a product, or their
progress in learning can lead to small group discussions, a brief summary to be
submitted, a self-reflection to be recorded in their journal, or as a brief reflective
thought by each individual. Reflection questions can generate other questions
from the participants and can provide the instructor/presenter with learning
feedback.
Rubric:
A quality PowerPoint presentation will meet the following criteria:
Focuses on one concept or specific content
Organizes information for ease of understanding
Shows relationships among content elements using animation, diagrams,
charts, etc.
Provides an overview or framework of understanding
Outlines talk points and major learning points
Includes questions or poses problems that engage participants
Uses reflection questions to enhance learning
Is used as a supplement to clarify and enhance content and not to present all
of the content
Best Practices
Presentations
Description:
A presentation allows the trainee/student learner to demonstrate content
knowledge by presenting the findings of an inquiry regarding a specific topic to
an audience. Presenting allows the learner to explain the methods that were
used, to report the results of the inquiry, to present his/her analysis of the
findings and to state importance of the findings to the audience. It requires the
learners to synthesize and organize data in a way that increases understanding.
Research:
Research suggests that clearly expected outcomes of a presentation prior to the
preparation period are essential for presenters and listeners. Most studies
encourage the development of a rubric to deal with both content of the
presentation and the process of the presentation. These rubrics provide a clear
expectation for preparing the presentation and for assessing the quality of the
presentation. Rubrics become the standard by which instructors and
trainees/student learners diagnose growth in applying the content knowledge and
skills.
Implementation:
Prior to a presentation, the instructor and class members should establish and
review rubrics regarding the content of the presentation and the process of
presenting. The use of rubrics not only gives guidance to the presenter, but also
increases the engagement of the listeners. The role of the audience or listeners
during presentations should be identified prior to the development of the
presentations.
Listeners can use a rubric form to record their opinions regarding the degree to
which the presentation met the rubrics. The form should include an area for
"evidence" so that they can be specific regarding the various aspects of the
presentation. These completed forms can be used as references during the post-
presentation discussion or during small group discussions to help analyze
successful elements of a presentation and determine the degree to which the
presentation met the rubric criteria.
Rubric:
An effective presentation should meet the following criteria:
Shows evidence of organization, focus, and a clear understanding of the topic
Uses proper body language, voice volume, vocabulary, eye contact, "energy"
and audience awareness
Utilizes demonstrations, kinesthetic activities, and visual or technological
tools, when appropriate
Demonstrates higher level thinking (analyzing, synthesizing, evaluating),
answers questions effectively
Presents sound and logical content/ideas that engage and are understood by
the audience
Presentation:
Shows evidence of organization, focus, and
clear understanding of the topic
This form can be used by the instructor and other trainees during the
presentation to guide the discussion of the teachback.
Best Practices
Reflection
Description:
Reflection is an important element of instruction that takes only a brief amount of
time but helps the students analyze their own learning and become responsible
for their learning. During reflection the student thinks back upon some aspect of
the lesson and expresses or writes a reaction to that aspect. This inte rnalization
of the learning assists the student in making sense of the learning process and
linking prior learning to the present as well as future learning in the way of goal
setting. Reflections assist the student in moving the learning from short term to
long term memory. Reflection can be done using any of the following categories:
content, product, process, and progress. Goal setting for future learning is often
the result of reflection.
Research:
In studies dealing with primary aged children through adult learners, there are
references to student reflection. Reflection can be promoted through surveys,
journals, portfolios, self-evalua tion, inventories, self-portraits and conferences.
Students are encouraged to think about their learning experience. Researchers
have linked these self-reflective ideas to a greater depth of understanding of the
learning experience and of the students taking greater responsibility for their
school or trainee program.
Implementation:
Reflections can be entered into a journal or just jotted down during the lesson.
Longer reflections can be used regarding major projects and labs. Short
exercises in reflection can be effective when focused on important concepts in
the course. For example, when the students are trying to gain the knowledge
base required in Semester 1, it would be useful to stress the content through
daily reflections. Reflections could include any of the following:
From this assignment I learned
What I needed to know better before I started was
What I need to learn more about is
This content helps me understand the connection from__ to___
Allow about 2-3 minutes for students to complete the statements. Occasionally,
have them share responses with a partner.
Periodically, have the student complete statement focused on the process used
or their progress learning the content. The statements below are suggested for
each category.
Process:
Strategies that did not work well for me in doing this were
Working in a small group was ____ because
The instructor helped/hindered my learning by
If I had done _________, I would understand
I learn best by
Product:
This product demonstrates my skills in the following ways
This product would have been better if
A better way to demonstrate my skills might have been
Progress:
Some goals for further learning include
I still need to work on
I am more able to
By doing this lesson I now know that I
At the end of a chapter or several chapters, have the students review their
reflections and think about their progress.
Rubric: (This rubric is a guideline for learners since each students reflection is
a personal expression of their learning.)
Contains key ideas from class presentations, discussions, lesson content,
and activities in terms of content, process, product or progress
Is a personal analysis showing a connection with the content purpose
Questions or statements which indicate a need for further clarification or
inquiry
Attention to the process involved in accomplishing an important task or
product
Specific applications of what is being learned to other content or subjects
demonstrating the connections between concepts or content
Thoughtfulness as reflected in goals for improvement and/or another action that
demonstrate the application of learning to self
Best Practices
Rubrics
Description:
Rubrics are specific criteria used to assess the quality of a performance. The
performance may be a lab activity, a presentation or any task that requires the
learner to tell, write or demonstrate their understanding of ideas or concepts. A
scale, based on 4-6 points (0 to 6) that specifies the performance objectives,
content, and skills to be demonstrated is provided for each task. A rubric contains
the criteria that define what key elements are needed to assess the learning.
Examples of rubrics are the criteria used to judge certain Olympic events. Some
events are measured in quantitative terms such as the height gained by high
jumpers, the distance reached by discus throwers, and the order of finish in races
Diving, gymnastics, and figure skating are judged on criteria that describe the
best performance for the event. These criteria are known to the judges and the
performers and have been formulated after the observation of many
performances.
Everyone uses rubrics in everyday life, especially teachers. They are constantly
making sophisticated, weighted assessments and making decisions based upon
that weighting. Rubrics simply attempt to make more explicit, and hence more
fair and transparent to the learner, what schema the assessor or instructor is
using.
Development of the rubrics with the class helps learners prepare and organize
for the learning by knowing the assessment expectations.
Research:
Studies of classroom projects show tha t instructors are better at developing
interesting tasks than they are at developing the criteria that describe quality
performance, however both components must exist. Another issue to be faced is
when to assess performance activities. It is not necessary to assess each trial for
grading purposes, but learners will benefit from self-assessment and class
discussion regarding their progress in meeting the criteria. The final judgment of
when to assess for grading purposes rests with the instructor. Certain groups of
learners, often those who have not met with great success in their past learning
experiences, may need more frequent feedback. More independent learners may
benefit from more practice time.
Rubrics can be created that will assess cross-curricular projects. When such
rubrics were used there was greater disagreement as to which scores to award
the various components. As with all other types of learning it may be better to
begin with a simple rubric on a single dimensional activity until the group has had
practice in using the technique. It is worthwhile to provide the group with practice
since it is often the rubric itself that will help learners focus on the content to be
learned.
The most appropriate rubrics are the ones created by the instructor in
collaboration with the learners for specific criteria. There are, however,
commercially prepared books on rubrics that can be helpful to the teacher who
has had less experience in developing these scales. Several studies are looking
at rubrics being developed and used in primary grade classroom with success,
showing that rubrics can be comfortably used by even very young learners.
________________________________________________________________
Implementation:
The first step in using rubrics is to discuss them with the trainees or students.
The characteristics of the task should be discussed and the essential elements of
the task identified.
Each of the Best Practices has rubrics for use in the CNAP. When the task is
assigned, each criterion and how it would look in a quality performance should be
discussed. The class may choose to modify the rubric during this discussion.
During the preparation for the performance, the trainees or students should use
the rubric to guide their work. They may work with a partner to receive feedback
prior to the actual performance.
The performance may be assessed by the trainee or student, the class, small
groups of trainees or students, or by the instructor only. For example, the writer
or the instructor may assess journals and the class may assess presentations.
During the assessment, each criterion of the rubric should be considered in
deciding the quality of the performance.
The goal is to use the rubrics to improve the performance. In the case of a
troubleshooting activity, the trainee or student should be working toward more
effective and efficient ways of solving the problem. During group work, the goal
should be to learn how to be a positive member of a group activity.
These rubrics provide a standard for learners. It may take several learning
opportunities before the learners have reached the highest level of competence
on the rubric scale for a specific process or product.
Rubrics:
The following criteria should be considered when assessing how well rubrics are
used with trainees or students:
All participants know and understand the criteria for the performance
The criteria are appropriate for the task
The criteria identify the essential elements of the task
Evidence regarding each criterion is identified
Instruction and support is provided to assist the trainees or students in
producing quality performances
Best Practices
Troubleshooting/Problem Solving
Description:
Troubleshooting refers to the location and elimination of the source of trouble in
any flow of work. In networking, an example is messages not being sent or
received. Troubleshooting is interchangeable with problem solving so the same
skills are required. Troubleshooting/problem solving is actually a composite of
several higher level thought processes such as analysis, synthesis, and
evaluation.
Troubleshooting skills are an absolute necessity for students who seek to design,
install and maintain internetworks. It is the most empowering skill that you can
pass on to your students. Teaching troubleshooting typically requires that you
spend time on lab preparation; however, the overall benefit to the students is well
worth the time. Troubleshooting should be introduced troubleshooting early in
Semester1, and continued as an emphasis it throughout Semesters 2, 3, and 4.
Research:
Researchers have found that solving real life problems has been effective in
involving students so that content was mastered more thoroughly. The technique
was found to be effective for all ability groups and should not limited be to use
with gifted students. Schools that combined troubleshooting/problem solving with
cooperative groups reported that their students had high problem solving skills.
While some researchers looked for problem solving as the end product and
others looked at higher level thinking skills as the end product, there appeared to
be consensus that skills in one led to the other and that both were valuable
abilities for students.
After modeling the troubleshooting process, have the students identify the parts
of the process. Have the students work in pairs or small groups as they learn
troubleshooting skills. After the activities, discuss the process using the rubric for
troubleshooting. As the students gain in the skills, have them do some activities
individually.
With practice, students will be able to diagnose and fix the problems in a finite
amount of time. Of course, this method must be integrated with labs that do the
following:
expose students to a working system
demonstrate the typical failure modes of that system
allow students to experience first hand the symptoms of those failure modes
provide opportunities for student to practice diagnosis and repair.
Rubric:
A quality troubleshooting solution will meet the following criteria:
Shows thorough understanding of the content
Identifies factors that may be causing the problem
Uses logic to determine the factor/s that are most likely to be causing the
problem
Uses a problem solving format
Shows evidence of critical thinking including analysis, comparison synthesis
and evaluation
Solves the problem in a reasonable amount of time
Results in a solution
Guide for Using Best Practices
Purpose Structure
Build Conceptual
Best Practice Build Knowledge Apply Concepts Class Individual Small Group
Understanding
Mini-Lecture
x x x
Online Study
x x x
Student Learner
Presentations
x x x
Study Guide
x x x
Journal
x x x
Graphical Organizers x x x
Challenges x x x
Design Activities x x x
Group Work
x x x
Oral Exams
x x x
Lab Exams x x x
Reflection
x x x
Web Research
x x
Rubrics
x x x x x
PowerPoint
Presentations x x x
Labs x x x x
Kinesthetic Activities
x x x x
Simulations x x x x
Portfolio
x x x
B. Study Guide Blank Template
STUDY GUIDE
Semester ____
LESSON NO. ______
1. Learning -
Vocabulary -
Notes/Ideas -
Activity -
2. Applying -
3. Reflecting -
C. Study Guide Example
STUDY GUIDE
Semester 1
Notes/Ideas - Sketch and/or write down important information from this lesson.
Suggested questions - What problem did ISO solve? Why was this important?
Suggestion - Sketch, name and define the 7 layers of the OSI Reference Model.
2. Applying - Organize, plan, record process, draft, record findings, and/or show the results
of your task.
Suggestion -
Content Think about and respond to the following questions:
QUESTIONS
General
Focus
HYPOTHESIS
METHODS OF INVESTIGATION
Experiment
Research
Literature Search
Other
Define Performance Learning Task
SELECTING RESOURCES
DESIGNING STRATEGIES
ANALYZING INFORMATION
APPLYING RUBRICS
E. Ideal Tool Kit
Preparation for Learning [What do the students need? Note: This is also known as an anticipatory set.]
Key graphics [a few that summarize the main points of the lecture]
Alternate lesson plan ideas [Which ideas from the Community Server, and from
other teachers, relate to this lesson?]
Learning Goals
Encouraging students' skills in quick recall of facts and concepts and "thinking on their
feet."
Assessing student understanding in ways deeper than multiple-choice questions.
Learning professional standards for answering questions and articulating concepts orally
under time pressure.
Engaging students' multiple intelligences and providing a prompt for group-based
studying and learning.
Demonstrating efficient, paperless way for teachers to assess student learning.
2. Networking Devices
Time Limit Prompt Point Sample Responses
#
[minutes] [exact wording given to student] Value [to earn that point value]
1 5 Describe the evolution of 4 +4 = complete listing of devices;
networking devices. Draw a describes evolution from PCs and NIC
sample topology which includes all cards to repeaters and hubs to bridges
of the devices covered during the and switches to routers, including what
semester. Circle all collision layer each device works at, what
domains and all broadcast problems it solved, what problems it
domains. still has, and how packets are or are
not changed when passing through
that device; a believable topology with
all collision and broadcast domains
circled
+3 = fairly complete listing of devices
and fairly accurate descriptions and
reasonable topology
+2=incomplete list, descriptions, and
topology
+1=minimal correct information given
3. IP Addressing
Time Limit Prompt Point Sample Responses
#
[minutes] [exact wording given to student] Value [to earn that point value]
1 5 Given a class C network number 4 +4= completes problem with correctly
(say 201.13.3.0) and requiring a identifed host address ranges,
certain number of subnets (say 6), subnetwork id addresses, and
give the network id numbers, broadcast addresses
range of possible host numbers, +3= mostly correct, 1 or 2 small errors
and broadcast numbers for all of +2= properly assigns subnets but not
the subnetworks. address ranges
+1= can do binary mathematics only
0= little or no effort or comprehension
4. LAN Technologies
Prompt
Time Limit Sample Responses
# [exact wording given to Point Value
[minutes] [to earn that point value]
student]
1 5 Compare and contrast Token 4 +1= Token Ring, 802.5, 4 or 16 Mbps
Ring, FDDI, and at least 5 typical; FDDI, ANSI standard, 100
major types of Ethernet. Mbps typical; Ethernet, defines lower 2
Include: OSI layers, 802.3 standard, XBaseY
Naming conventions and where X is Mbps and Y designates the
typical operating speeds media used and Base designates
Physical topology, logical baseband signaling; 10, 100, 1000
topology, and media used Mbps typical
MAC methods used +1= Ethernet is a logical bus but a
Frame Format physical star; Token Ring is logical ring
and physical star; FDDI is logical ring
and physical dual ring. Ethernet uses
coax(10BASE2, 10BASE5), UTP
(10BASE-T, 100BASE-TX, 1000BASE-
T), or fiber (100BASE-FX); Token Ring
uses UTP or STP; FDDI uses fiber
+1= Ethernet uses opportunistic
CSMA/CD; Token Ring and FDDI use
Token Passing
+1= all three technologies have source
& destination MAC addresses, some
form of start delimiter, data fields, and
an FCS field. Token Ring and FDDI
have Token related fields in their
frame; Ethernet has type/length fields
in its frame and ends in an FCS
5. Media, Design, and Structured Cabling
Time Limit Prompt Point Sample Responses
#
[minutes] [exact wording given to student] Value [to earn that point value]
1 5 Give the student a situation (a 4 +1 for comparison of media choices
school to be wired or a project they and proper use of matrix
completed during the semester) +2 for reasonable locations and
Choose media, justifying your justifications
choice with a matrix +1 for a chart which include planning
Draw a simple physical topology, process, installing jacks, stringing
locating POP, MDF, IDF, MCC, cable, and using test equipment
ICC, HCC, backbone. Justify all
choices of locations.
Draw a simple flowchart of what
you would do to design, install, and
test the cabling. youve installed
CCNA Semester 1 Skills Based Final Part 1 Cable Build / Test
Name: _____________Date: _________
(Total possible Points: 20)
Objective:
Build an Ethernet 10BaseT straight thru cable to connect from a workstation to a hub or switch. Use
UTP cable and wire all eight conductors using the correct wire colors and pins for either a T568A or
T568B. Test the cable with a cable tester to verify continuity, correct pinouts and cable length. This
cable can be used to connect your workstation to the hub or switch for exam part 3.
Directions:
Obtain a piece of CAT 5 cable (depending on use) and two RJ45 connectors. Use a crimping tool to
attach the RJ 45 connectors to the cable. Use a cable tester to test the cable to verify that is
functional. Indicate which cabling pinout standard (T568A or T568B) you will use ___________
1) Are the correct wires pins in the correct position? Initial _______ (10 pts)
2) Does cable test OK with cable tester? Initial _______ (10 pts)
Objective:
Answer the 3 questions on networking concepts as assigned by the instructor. Write the questions
assigned in the space provided below. You may be asked to answer orally or write your answers on
the back of this sheet. Answers should be as detailed as possible for maximum credit.
_________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________
Objective:
Connect your workstation to a LAN. Configure the network settings and troubleshoot as necessary.
Use your web browser to connect to router interface 152.20.71.237 and display the web interface.
After you have successfully connected to the router, the instructor will introduce problems into the
PC and/or network which must be resolved and documented in the space provided. Include the
following: symptoms, causes, details of tests done, detailed problem results (from layer 1 testing),
detailed solutions.
You will be assigned a workstation number that will become the useable subnet # with which you
will perform this assessment. Make sure you have an appropriate assigned subnet number
before starting.
You will be using a class C network 193.5.5.0 which is divided into subnets by borrowing 5 bits from
the network portion of the address. The subnet number assigned is the same usable subnet (1st , 2nd 3rd
etc.) as your workstation number. The proctor must initial each step as you answer the following
questions. The default gateway (nearside router port) for your host is 193.5.5.1.
Write the IP address of your workstation here: ____________________
Points Scored: Part 1 ____ +Part 2 _____ +Part 3 _____ = Total ______
CCNA Semester 1 - Skills Based Final Exam - Student Training
Guidelines - Exam Overview and Administration
This exam is for use with regular CCNA classes taught by local academies to high school and college
students. The skills-based exam consists of three parts; 1) Cable Build and Test, 2) Network
Concepts and 3) Network Connection. All three should be completed (total possible of 100 points)
and the total score combined with the Semester 1 online assessment exam to establish a course grade.
Scores from chapter exams and completion of labs as well as points for participation and attendance
may also count toward the final grade.
The guidelines presented here are recommendations and instructors have flexibility in assigning point
values and administering the exam. Students should be made aware of what they will be tested on
early in the course in order to study and prepare adequately for the exam. The exam may be
administered by dividing the class into three groups with each group starting on a different part of the
exam and then rotating as they complete each portion.
Exam Part 1 Cable Build / Test (Practical hands-on, Est. time 25 min., 20 Points)
Objective: Build a straightwired Ethernet cable for connection of a PC to a hub or switch and test it
with a basic cable tester for correct pinouts and continuity. The cable should be CAT 5 and wired to
the T568A or B standards. Length will vary depending on physical conditions. This cable may be
used to connect the PC to the hub or switch used in Part 3 of this exam.
Preparation / Tools: Length of CAT 5 cable, (2) RJ45 connectors, Wire cutter/Stripper tool,
Crimping tool, Basic cable tester or Fluke LAN Cable meter 620.
Exam Part 2 - Network Concepts (Oral or Written, Est. time 25 min., 30 Points)
Objective: Answer 3 networking concepts questions from a pool of approved questions. Any student
may have to answer any question and will know the questions ahead of time. Responses may be
given verbally to the instructor / proctor or written depending on instructor and student preferences.
Preparation / Tools: List of questions and rubric for assessment. These are found in the instructors
version of the Semester 1 curriculum in the Preface, Chapter 0 under First Semester Finals. Rubrics
are also provided to help assess the accuracy and completeness of students answers.
Exam Part 3 - Network Connection (Practical hands-on, Est. time 25 min., 40 Points)
Objective: Connect a PC to a LAN and configure the IP network settings for attachment to an
Ethernet hub or switch that is attached to a router. Determine the subnet mask and host range given
the number of bits borrowed and the subnet number used. Demonstrate connectivity by pinging the
router and opening a web page on it. When the PC is successfully connected to the LAN, problems
will be introduced into the PC and/or network to demonstrate troubleshooting skills. Document the
problems encountered during troubleshooting and the steps taken to correct them.
Preparation / Tools: PC (Mac, Win 9x, NT or 2000) with access to a browser and Control Panel /
Network settings. Straight wired patch cable, hub or switch with router connected. 2514 Router
with IOS 12.0 attached to hub or switch and configured as indicated in the following instructor notes.
A list of potential problems and causes which can be found in the instructors version of the Semester
1 curriculum in the Preface, Chapter 0 under First Semester Finals.
Semester 1 Skills Based Final Part 1 Cable Build / Test
Name: _____________Date: _________
(Total possible Points: 20)
Objective:
Build an Ethernet 10BaseT straight thru cable to connect from a workstation to a hub or switch. Use
UTP cable and wire all eight conductors using the correct wire colors and pins for either a T568A or
T568B. Test the cable with a cable tester to verify continuity, correct pinouts and cable length. This
cable can be used to connect your workstation to the hub or switch for exam part 3.
Directions:
Obtain a piece of CAT 5 cable (depending on use) and two RJ45 connectors. Use a crimping tool to
attach the RJ 45 connectors to the cable. Use a cable tester to test the cable to verify that is
functional. Indicate which cabling pinout standard (T568A or T568B) you will use ___________
1) Are the correct wires in the correct position on pins 1 thru 8? Initial _______ (10 pts)
(Refer to the semester 1 labs for colors and correct pinout)
2) Does cable test OK with cable tester? Initial _______ (10 pts)
(Lights should come on or LCD readout should show continuity)
Points Scored: _______
Objective:
Answer the 3 questions on networking concepts as assigned by the instructor from the pool of
questions. Sample questions are found in the instructors version of the Semester 1 curriculum in the
Preface, Chapter 0 under First Semester Finals. Rubrics are also provided to help assess the students
answers. Students will write the questions as assigned in the space provided below. Instructor may
have students answer orally or write answers on the back of this sheet.
_________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________
Objective:
Connect a workstation to LAN. Configure the network settings and troubleshoot as necessary. Use a
web browser to connect to router interface 152.20.71.237 and display the web interface. After the PC
is successfully connected to the network, the student should leave and the instructor will introduce
problems into the PC or network which must be resolved and documented in the space provided.
Include the following: symptoms, causes, details of tests done, detailed problem results (from layer 1
testing), detailed solutions.
Instructor notes: A list of potential problems and causes can be found in the instructors version of
the Semester 1 curriculum in the Preface, Chapter 0 under First Semester Finals.
Each student should be assigned a workstation number that will become the useable subnet # with
which they perform this assessment. Make sure each student has an appropriate assigned subnet
number before starting. Router configuration allows all workstations to maintain connectivity so
that you may test a class of up to 30 students simultaneously depending on your classroom
environment. Refer to the router configuration at the end of the instructor guidelines to set up the
router. Students must have the ability to alter the IP network settings on their workstations.
Students will be using a class C network 193.5.5.0 which is divided into subnets by borrowing 5 bits
from the network portion of the address. The subnet number assigned is the same usable subnet (1st ,
2nd 3rd etc.) as their workstation number. The proctor must initial each step. The following example
uses workstation / subnet 2. The default gateway for your host is 193.5.5.1.
Workstation / Subnet number assigned: 2 IP address of your workstation: 193.5.5.17
Students will be prompted for a password when accessing the router through the browser. This
indicates successful completion of the connectivity portion of the Sem 1 skills based assessment.
You may disable the password on the router if you wish for your students to see the web based
interface. (WARNING: this allows the students access to the router configuration) Therefore, you
may wish to wait until after testing is complete to disable the password and show the web-based
interface as a demo instead.
The following router configuration may be 1) keyed in manually at the router console, 2) entered via
the SETUP utility or 3) uploaded using the HyperTerminal Transfer / Send Text File option. Prior to
configuring the router, erase the existing startup configuration file.
Refer to semester 2 labs for the procedures for loading the configuration file from a tftp server or
from HyperTerminal. After the router reboots, you may use the default setup mode or enter config
mode with the following command. Router# config t
Copy the new running configuration to the startup NVRAM with the following command.
Router# copy run start
Router configuration commands for Semester 1 Skill-based exam
Router IOS Command Purpose / Function
Copy the new running configuration to the startup NVRAM with the following command.
Router# copy run start
J. CCNA Exam objectives
OSI Reference
1. Identify and describe the functions of each of the seven layers of the OSI reference
model.
3. Describe data link addresses and network addresses, and identify the key differences
between them.
6. Define flow control and describe the three basic methods used in networking.
7. List the key internetworking functions of the OSI Network layer and how they are
performed in a router.
WAN Protocols
8. Differentiate between the following WAN services: Frame Relay, ISDN/LAPD, HDLC, &
PPP.
10. List commands to configure Frame Relay LMIs, maps, and subinterfaces.
14. Identify ISDN protocols, function groups, reference points, and channels.
IOS
22. Identify the main Cisco IOS commands for router startup.
25. List the commands to load Cisco IOS software from: flash memory, a TFTP server, or
ROM.
26. Prepare to backup, upgrade, and load a backup Cisco IOS software image.
27. Prepare the initial configuration of your router and enable IP.
Network Protocols
29. Describe the two parts of network addressing, then identify the parts in specific protocol
address examples.
38. Configure IPX access lists and SAP filters to control basic Novell traffic.
Routing
42. List problems that each routing type encounters when dealing with topology changes and
describe techniques to reduce the number of these problems.
Network Security
45. Monitor and verify selected access list operations on the router.
LAN Switching
46. Describe the advantages of LAN segmentation.
58. Describe the operation of the Spanning Tree Protocol and its benefits.