Process Capability
Process Capability
Process Capability
Process Capability
This is a long article, but I thought it was important to keep Cp and Cpk
together. Cpk is addressed first, then Cp. There are also crib notes on what
the equations mean in a real performance sense, what you should be able to
tell about a process depending on Cp and Cpk values and more. If you are not
finding what you are looking for, please let me know in the notes below.
Cp Cpk vs Pp Ppk
Cp and Cpk are called Process Capability. Pp and Ppk are called Process
Performance. In both cases we want to try to verify if the process can meet to
meet Customer CTQs (requirements).
Cp, and Cpk are used for Process Capability. Generally you use this when a
process is under statistical control. This often happens with a mature process
that has been around for a while. Process capability uses the process sigma
value determined from either the Moving Range, Range or Sigma control
charts
Pp and PPk are used for Process Performance. Generally you use this when
a process is too new to determine if it is under statistical control. Ex. there is a
short pre-production run or you are piloting a new process. Because there is
not a lot of historical data we take large samples from the process to account
for variation. Process Performance generally uses sample sigma in its
calculation.
In theory Cpk will always be greater than or equal to Ppk. There are
anomalies seen when the sample size is small and the data represents a
short amount of time where estimating using R will overstate standard
deviation and make Cpk smaller than Ppk. It is not real, there can never be
less variation in the long term since the long term is using all of the data not
just two pieces of data from every subgroup.
Evaluating process capability with Cp & Cpk mirror what is done (and why it is
done) when following the Pp & Ppk approach. The main difference is that you
use Cp & Cpk after a process has reached stability or statistical control.
Cp vs Cpk
The k stands for centralizing factor. The index takes into consideration the
fact that your data is maybe not centered.
Cpk vs Ppk
Cpk tells us what a process is capable of doing in future, assuming it remains in
a state of statistical control.
Ppk tells us how a process has performed in the past and you cannot use it
predict the future because the process is not in a state of control.
Cpk measures how close you are to your target and how consistent you are to
around your average performance. A person may be performing with
minimum variation, but he can be away from his target towards one of the
specification limit, which indicates lower Cpk, whereas Cp will be high. On the
other hand, a person may be on average exactly at the target, but the
variation in performance is high (but still lower than the tolerance band (i.e.,
specification interval). In such case also Cpk will be lower, but Cp will be
high. Cpk will be higher only when you r meeting the target consistently with
minimum variation
What is Cpk?
The Parking a Car in the Garage Analogy
If you think of the walls of your garage where you have to fit your car in
they become the customer specification limits. If you go past those limits, you
will crash, and the customer will not be happy!
If your process has a lot of variation, that means the process average is all
over the place. Not good for parking a car, and not good for any other
process. To give your parking process the best chance of success you should
work on reducing variation and centering.
If the car is too wide for the garage, nothing you do to center the process will
help. You have to change the dispersion of the process (make the car
smaller.)
If the car is a lot smaller than the garage, it doesnt matter if you park it exactly
in the middle; it will fit and you have plenty of room on either side. Thats one
of the reasons the six sigma philosophy focuses on removing variation in a
process.
If you have a process that is in control and with little variation, you should be
able to park the car easily within the garage and thus meet customer
requirements. Cpk tells you the relationship between the size of the car, the
size of the garage and how far away from the middle of the garage you parked
the car.
To find Cpk you need to calculate a Z score for the upper specification limit
(called Z USL) and a Z score for the lower specification limit (called Z LSL).
Since we are trying to measure how many standard deviations fit between the
center line and thespecification limit you should not be surprised that the value
of those limits, the process mean, and the standard deviation are all
components of the Z calculation.
Cp is an abbreviation. There are really two parts; the upper and the lower
denoted Cpu and Cpl respectively. Their equations are:
Cpk is merely the smallest value of the Cpl or Cpu denoted: Cpk= Min (Cpl, Cpu)
and
Notes on Cpk
Cpk measures how close a process is performing compared to its
specification limits and accounting for the natural variability of the
process.
Larger is better. The larger Cpk is, the less likely it is that any item will
be outside the specification limits.
When Cpk is negative it means that a process will produce output that is
outside the customer specification limits.
When the mean of the process is outside the customer specification
limits the value of Cpk will be Negative
We generally want a Cpk of at least 1.33 [4 sigma] or higher to satisfy
most customers.
Cpk can have an upper and lower value reported.
If the upper value is 2 and the lower is 1, we say it has been
shifted to the left.
This tells us nothing about if the process is stable or not.
We must report the lower of the 2 values.
Cpk = Negative number: Your process will regularly crash the car into the wall.
Cpk =0.5: You have a good chance hitting the wall on entry.
Cpk =1: Your car may be just touching the nearest edge of the entry.
Cpk =2: Great! You have great clearance. You could double the width of your
car before you hit the side of the garage.
Cpk =3: Excellent! You have excellent clearance. You could triple the width of
your car before you hit the side of the garage.
Cpk Videos
Great, clear, concise video on this subject.
If you were producing a Cpk equal to 1, than you could expect to produce at
least 99.73% good parts.
How to Calculate Cp
Just as you use Cp & Cpk when a process is stable and Pp & Ppk when a
process is new, the way you calculate each are a bit different, too.
Lets revisit Pp
Pp = (USL LSL) / 6* s
D2 reflects values derived from integrating the area under the normal curve.
We often use a table which gives a d2 value based on how many subgroups
were in the sample.
d2 subgroup values
Cp = (USL LSL) / ( 6* r )
Capability Index
Notes on Cp Values
If the ratio is greater than one, then the Engineering Tolerance is greater
than the Process Spread so the process has the potential to be
capable (depending on process centering).
If, however, the Process Spread is greater than the Engineering
tolerance, then the process variation will not fit within the tolerance and
the process will not be capable (even if the process is centered
appropriately).
Capability Ratio Cr
The capability ration is the inverse of Cp
Cr = 1/ Cp = ( 6* r ) / (USL LSL)