PDF

Rs 8.
00
PB
rabuddha
harata
or Awakened India
A monthly journal of the Ramakrishna Order
started by Swami Vivekananda in 1896
ISSN 0032-6178
April 2008
Value Perceptions
9 770032 6 17002
Vol. 113, No. 4
THE ROAD TO WISDOM
Swami Vivekananda on
The Way and the Goal of Morality
Complex Social Structures
darkness or inactivity; Rajas is activity, expressed
H uman society is a graded organization. We

all know about morality, and we all know
about duty, but at the same time we find that in
as attraction or repulsion; and Sattva is the
equilibrium of the two. In every man there are
these three forces.So in all creationin animals,
different countries the significance of morality
plants, and menwe find the more or less typical
varies greatly. What is regarded as moral in one
manifestation of all these different forces.
country may in other be considered perfectly im-
moral.So it is with duty. The idea of duty varies Encourage Everyone in their Struggles
much among different nations.and yet we know Unity in variety is the plan of creation. However
that there must be some universal idea of duty. men and women may vary individually, there is
Two ways are left open to usthe way of the unity in the background. The different individual
ignorant, who think that there is only one way characters and classes of men and women are
to truth and that all the rest are wrong, and the natural variations in creation. Hence, we ought
way of the wise, who admit that, according to not to judge them by the same standard or put
our mental constitution or the different planes the same ideal before them. Such a course cre-
of existence in which we are, duty and morality ates only an unnatural struggle, and the result is
may vary. The important thing is to know that that man begins to hate himself and is hindered
there are gradations of duty and of moralitythat from becoming religious and good. Our duty is
the duty of one state of life, in one set of circum- to encourage every one in his struggle to live up
stances, will not and cannot be that of another. to his own highest ideal, and strive at the same
In the Hindu system of morality we find that this time to make the ideal as near as possible to the
fact has been recognized from very ancient times; truth.
and in their scriptures and books on ethics differ- The Goal of Morality
ent rules are laid down for the different classes The only definition that can be given of moral-
of menthe householder, the Sannyasinand the ity is this: That which is selfish is immoral, and
student. that which is unselfish is moral.The goal of all
One of the Causes of Differentiation nature is freedom, and freedom is to be attained
According to the Sankhya philosophy, nature only by perfect unselfishness; every thought,
is composed of three forces called, in Sanskrit, word, or deed that is unselfish takes us towards
Sattva, Rajas, and Tamas. These as manifested in the goal, and, as such, is called moral.
the physical world are what we may call equilib- From The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda,
rium, activity, and inertness. Tamas is typified as Vol 1 36,41,55,36,112.
PB April 2008
PBrabuddha
harata
or Awakened India
A monthly journal of the Ramakrishna Order
started by Swami Vivekananda in 1896
Vol. 113, No. 4 Contents

April 2008
Traditional Wisdom 231
This Month 232
Editorial: Imbibing Values 233
Is This Moral? 235
Swami Ishatmananda
Amrita Kalasha
The Patachitra Tradition: An Effective Means 238
for Value-based Education
Editorial Office Swami Sanmatrananda
Prabuddha Bharata
Advaita Ashrama Vidyamandira Values: Some Reflections 244
PO Mayavati, Via Lohaghat Swami Shastrajnananda
Dt Champawat 262 524
Uttarakhand, India Facing Ethical Dilemmas 251
E-mail: p [email protected] Dilip Dhopavkar and Prashant Puppal
[email protected]
Buddha in Swami Vivekanandas Eyes 257
Publication Office Swami Sandarshanananda
Advaita Ashrama
5 Dehi Entally Road Sri Ramakrishna: 262
Kolkata 700 014 Patron Saint of the Bengali Stage
Tel: 91 33 2 244 0898 / 2216 4000 Swami Chetanananda
2286 6450 / 2286 6483
E-mail: [email protected] American Indians and Indians: 270
Echoes across Time
Internet Edition at: Rajaram Suryanarayanan
www.advaitaashrama.org
Reviews 274
Cover: Through the Rainforest
Photo by Sam Veres Reports 277
PB April 2008
Subscribe to Prabuddha Bharata
Become a Patron Subscriber, and support the rich legacy left to all of us by
Swami Vivekananda; Patrons names are published in Prabuddha Bharata.
Prabuddha Bharata subscribers receive 10% discount on all
Advaita Ashrama Publications.
Send remittances in favour of Prabuddha Bharata by cheque, bank draft, or money order to Advaita
Ashrama, 5 Dehi Entally Road, Kolkata 700 014, India.
Or, you can subscribe online at www.advaitaashrama.org.
Please add Rs 30.00 as bank charges on outstation cheques.
Subscription India & Sri Lanka & USA & United European
Nepal Bangladesh Canada Kingdom Union
Rates
Annual Rs 80 Rs 180 $ 25 (USD ) 18 23
Three Years Rs 230 Rs 500 $ 70 49 64
Life (20 years) Rs 800 Rs 2500 $ 300 216 276
Patron (25 years) Rs 1500 Rs 5000 $ 600 432 552
Online www.advaitaashrama.org
Subscription Rates Life Patron
Annual 3 Yrs (20 yrs) (25 yrs)
India & Nepal (USD ) $ 2.50 $ 6.50 $ 22 $ 44
Sri Lanka & Bangladesh (USD ) $ 5 $ 13 $ 44 $ 88
All Other Countries (USD ) $ 27 $ 75 $ 320 $ 640
(Rates in foreign currencies depend on current exchange rates and are therefore subject to change without notice)
Information for Subscribers Information for Contributors
Moving to a new address? Please let our Kolkata Unpublished original articles of universal and higher
office know at least a month in advance so that human interests pertaining to religion, spirituality, phi-
your copy moves too. losophy, psychology, education, values, and other social
The number on the top line of your address la- topics coming from competent writers of any country
bel is your subscription number: please quote are considered for publication in Prabuddha Bharata.
this number when writing to us. The month and Articles should not exceed 3,500 words. Paucity of
year on the same line is the last month of your space precludes acceptance of longer articles for publi-
subscription. cation, except in rare cases. Articles must be submitted
Subscriber copies are dispatched on the first or in typedand preferably electronicform.
For all quotations in articles, adequate referencesin-
second day of every month. If you do not recieve
cluding name of author, title/publication, publisher
your copy by the last week of the month, please
with address, year of publication, and page number(s)
let us know, so we can send another copy.
should be provided. Internet references should include
Renew your subscription online, at our website. name of author, website publisher, date, and full URL.
Patron Subscribers The Editor does not accept responsibility for views ex-
pressed in any articles.
247 - R P Mishra, Faizabad, UP Unsolicited articles are not individually acknowledged.
248 - Nikhil Kaplingat, Pune The Editor will contact the contributor if an article is
249 - A P N Pankaj, Chandigarh taken up for publication. E-mail addresses should be
250 - V Subramaniam, Chennai furnished where possible.
251 - Varun Rai, New Delhi The Editor reserves the right to accept, reject, or effect
252 - Tarun Kr Bhattacharjee, Jaipur necessary changes in articles on which no correspond-
253 - Smt Uma Bose, Kolkata ence is possible.
254 - Sukanto Roy, Kolkata Prabuddha Bharata does not undertake to return unso-
255 - D N Gautam, Patna licited materials.
256 - Dr Suresh Kambhiranda, Kodagu, Karnataka Articles published in Prabuddha Bharata cannot be re-
257 - Priya Shastri, Houston, Texas, USA produced elsewhere without written permission from
258 - T I T Group of Institutes, Bhopal, MP the Managing Editor.
PB April 2008
Traditional Wisdom
Wrt; std{; tg Jhtrtctut; > Arise! Awake! And stop not till the goal is reached!
Dharma April 2008

Vol. 113, No. 4
m liJ gCJ;T ;A[ugtuvbgm]s; tbobT ;=u;;T Gtg Gtk gbo&

;btbtovhk ltr; > y:tu ycjegtlT cjegtkmbtNkm;u tbuoK
g:t httiJbT gtu Ji m tbo& mgk Ji ;;T ;bt;T mgk J=;btnw& tb
J=;er; tb Jt J=;k mgk J=;er; Y;uJi;=wCgk CJr; >>
Yet he (Brahman) did not flourish. He specially projected that excel-
lent form, dharma (righteousness). This dharma is the controller of
the kshatriya. Therefore there is nothing higher than that. (So) even a
weak man hopes (to defeat) a stronger man through dharma, as (one
contending) with the king. That dharma is verily truth. Therefore they
say about a person speaking of truth, He speaks of dharma, or about a
person speaking of dharma, He speaks of truth, for both these are but
dharma. (Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, 1.4.14)
tthKtbo RgtnwtobuoK rJt];t& v{st& >
ggtthKmkgwtk m tbo Rr; rltg& >>
That which upholds is called dharma; all beings are sustained by dharma.
Anything that is capable of holding things togetherknow it for cer-
tain, that is dharma. (Mahabharata, 12.110.11)
l ;vhg mk=tv{r;fqUjk g=tbl& >
YM mkGuv;tu tbo& fUtbt=g& v{J;o;u >>
Do not do to others what is not agreeable to oneself. This, in brief, is
dharma; everything else proceeds from desire. (Mahabharata, 13.114.8)
btlmk mJoCq;tltk tbobtnwbolerMK& >
;btmJuoMw Cq;uMw blmt rNJbtahu;T >>
The wise speak of dharma as residing in the minds of all beings. There-
fore, let goodwill flow for all beings from the mind.
yshtbhJv{tttu rJtb: a ra;gu;T >
d]ne; RJ fuUNuMw b]gwlt tbobtahu;T >>
When in search of knowledge or prosperity, think that you would never
have death or disease, and when practising dharma, think that deaths
hand is on your hair. (Hitopadesha, 1.3)
PB April 2008 231
This Month
Value education, a synonym for Imbibing Morals, alumni to assess how effectively they have utilized
is a current buzzword, with numerous agencies this training. Vidyamandira Values: Some Reflec-
carrying out research on effective ways of generat- tions is his report.
ing awareness of values among children and youth.
The conscientious citizen is confronted with ethi-
But the attainment of moral maturity is a complex
cal dilemmas with surprising regularity. These can
process. This number tells us why.
be morally challenging and emotionally taxing. But
Our moral understanding is shaped by numerous they also provide important occasions for clarifying
personal as well as socio-cultural factors, and even our ethical conceptions. A recent youth seminar at
apparently simple acts can generate complex ethical the Ramakrishna Math, Pune, focused on some of
responses. Swami Ishatmanandaji, Secretary, Rama- these practical dilemmas to assess the value percep-
krishna Mission, Narottam Nagar, draws attention tions of the youth. Some highlights are presented
to this in Is This Moral? by the programme coordinators, Sri Dilip Dho-
pavkar and Sri Prashant Puppal, in Facing Ethical
Both visual art and the literary Dilemmas.
narrative have long been used
with remarkable effect for high- Swami Sandarshananandaji, Acharya, Probation-
lighting ethical issues. These ers Training Centre, Belur Math, concludes his
genres strike an immediate study of Buddha in Swami Vivekanandas Eyes
resonance in young hearts and with a review of some of Swamijis thoughts on the
facilitate cognitive and emo- philosophical and social implications of Buddhas
tional development. They also teachings.
provide important avenues for Sri Ramakrishna had a significant impact on the
personal expression. The picture-narrative method development of modern Bengali theatre through
of ethical training is a powerful pedagogic tool that his influence on the famous playwright and actor
needs to be used more widely in schools. This is Girishchandra Ghosh as well as on many contem-
the thrust of The Patachitra Tradition: An Effec- porary and later actors and actresses. Swami Che-
tive Means for Value-based Education by Swami tananandaji, Minister-in-Charge, Vedanta Society
Sanmatranandaji, Ramakrishna Mission Vidyalaya, of St Louis, provides us a glimpse of this impact in
Viveknagar. Sri Ramakrishna: Patron Saint of the Bengali
The transition to professional life from the pro- Stage.
tected environs of schools and colleges poses Rajaram Suryanarayan, a soft-
complex ethical challenges even as it tests ones ware professional from Ban-
knowledge and skills. Success in handling these galore, draws our attention to
challenges reflects the efficacy of the ethical train- some parallels between Vedic
ing one has received. The Ramakrishna Mission thought and the spiritual ideas
Vidyamandira, Belur, has a reputation for impart- of Native Americans in Ameri-
ing good ethical training. Swami Shastrajnanandaji, can Indians and Indians: Echoes
vice principal of the institution, quizzes some of the across Time.
232 PB April 2008
EDITORIAL
Imbibing Values
Sv puri vividhnyajaytmaakty capacity, again, that has led them beyond the goals
vkn sarspapan khagadaamatsyn; of pleasure and utilitykma and arthato the
Taistairatuahdaya purua vidhya higher goals of dharma, righteousness, and moka,
brahmvalokadhiaa mudampa deva. liberation from all limitations. The discovery of
Brahman projected this universefirst cosmic, then scientific as well as spiritual truths, of cosmic order
organicat various levels of evolution. However, and universal ethical principles (ta and satya), of
he was not satisfied with all these animals, serpents, beauty as a reflection of the reality underlying and
fishes, trees, etc. Why? Because he thought that if interpenetrating the universe, and of the possibility
he were to enter into these bodies, he would not be of attaining unalloyed and indestructible bliss have
able to rediscover himself. Therefore, he projected
all followed from the quest for these values.
the human form. Having projected the human form,
puruam vidhya, he was very happy, mudampa The Reality about Morals
deva, because he thought, in that form he could
rediscover himself. That is the uniqueness of the Interestingly, empirical studies of moral under-
human form. Bhagavata, 11.9.28 standing and moral judgment of men and women
of various ages have shown that very few people
The Moral Ideal ever attain to the highest level of moral under-
A
nimals are known to show goal-oriented standingtermed the post-conventional stage
behaviour. But these goals are essentially bio- by the psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg, the
logicalself preservation and species prop- most well-known of researchers on this issue. This
agationcharacterized by hra, feeding; nidr, highest stage in Kohlbergs classification involves
sleep; bhaya, fear; and maithuna, copulation. Hu- understanding right action as being guided by self-
mans share these goals with other animals, but they chosen ethical principles of conscience [universal
are set apart by their unique capability for abstract ethical principles] that are valid for all humanity,
thinking and self-reflection. This allows them to rec- regardless of law and social authority. Even the next
ognize themselves as distinct from their bodies and (lower) stage of moral understandingcharacter-
minds, which they can control and direct, as well ized by a social contract orientation, whereby indi-
as to conceive of abstract ideals and realize them in viduals regard laws and rules as flexible instruments
their lives. In the words of the Aitareya Aranyaka: for furthering human purpose and obey laws be-
Among living beings, it is man alone that says what cause they are consistent with individual rights and
he has known, that sees what he has known. He the interests of the majorityis reached by only a
knows the future, he knows this world and the next; small proportion of the general population.
and he desires to attain the immortal through the Most adults function at a level that Kohlberg
mortal. Thus is he endowed, while other creatures terms conventional morality, characterized by the
are aware of only hunger and thirst. social-order-maintaining orientation or the good
It is this capacity for abstraction that has al- boygood girl orientation. The latter is also termed
lowed humans to look upon truth, goodness, and morality of interpersonal orientation, wherein peo-
beautysatya, iva, and sundaraas intrinsic val- ple try to be trustworthy, loyal, respectful, helpful,
ues worthy of pursuit for their own sake. It is this and nice so as to gain social approval and main-
PB April 2008 233
12 Prabuddha Bharata
tain warm interpersonal relationships. This also all possible ethical issues that a complex real-life situ-
involves practising the Golden Rule: Do to oth- ation may throw up. Introducing children and youth
ers what you would have them do to you. The so- to a wide range of ideas and opinions through peer
cial-order-maintaining orientation is a stage higher discussion on ethically challenging issuesas done
wherein interpersonal relations are not allowed by the Pune groupis a potent method of assisting
to influence moral choiceslaws are considered moral maturity and encouraging ethically sound be-
universally applicable for the sake of maintaining haviour. Such discussions open up the mind to wider
social order. perspectives, help one discover innovative solutions,
In contrast to adults, the moral understand- and foster the realization that cooperation based
ing of children and adolescents is largely pre- on empathy, mutuality, negotiation, and personal
conventional. In their pre-teen years children have warmth can help resolve most conflicts. The picture-
only a limited capacity to imagine or comprehend narrative approach (pp. 23843) is another powerful
viewpoints other than their own. They think of method of invoking ethical awareness and fostering
rules as inbuilt features of reality handed down maturity of moral thought among children.
from authority figures, and therefore inviolate. It is worth noting that both the above-mentioned
The moral status of actions is judged from conse- methods are non-judgmental and student- or par-
quences rather than intentionsan action is bad ticipant-centred. This is in consonance with the
if it meets with disapproval from authorities or en- vision of education as manifestation of inherent
genders punishment. human perfection and the role of the teacher as
As children grow into their teens, adults are no facilitator in the process of learning, as revealed by
longer seen as unimpeachable authorities. Cogni- Swami Vivekananda.
tive development coupled with interaction with Does maturity of moral understanding auto-
peers from diverse backgrounds helps them realize matically translate into moral behaviour? Research
that moral perspectives can vary among individuals has shown that it does only to a limited extent. Un-
and that the intention behind any action is a better derstanding is a cognitive trait, while ethical be-
indicator of its moral status than the consequences haviour is dependent on control of ones instincts
that may ensue. and emotions through the mastery of will. This
requires practice of ethical disciplineyama and
Working for Moral Maturity niyama. The Vidymandira experience recorded in
The transition to the abstract understanding of in- this number briefly highlights its efficacy.
tentions and then to the conventional adult moral Children and youth hate being disciplined. But
understanding characterized by the ideal reciproc- the Vedantic concept of discipline is self-actuated,
ity of the Golden Rule is what the average school- based on a deeper understanding of ones nature,
teacher is called upon to aid in his or her students. and productive of powerful results. Interviews with
All courses on value education for schoolchildren moral exemplars have revealed that their most dis-
must needs address this core issue. tinguished characteristic is seamless integration
Externally enforced moral regulations are clearly of moral vision with personal identity. This squares
detrimental to the development of moral maturity, well with Swami Vivekanandas exhortation: Teach
as are teachers and role models who see morality in yourselves, teach every one his real nature, call upon
clear-cut black and white terms. The discussion on the sleeping soul and see how it awakes. Power will
ethical dilemmas faced by Pune youth (see pp. 251 come, glory will come, goodness will come, pu-
6) clearly highlights the fact that there can hardly be rity will come, and everything that is excellent will
one view on or a single solution to complex ethical is- come when this sleeping soul is roused to self-con-
sues. Nor can any one person ever hope to apprehend scious activity. P
234 PB April 2008
Is This Moral?
Swami Ishatmananda
T
oday a very important topic, Business the necessity of a code of conduct. That would
Ethics, will be discussed by Swamiji. The have slowly developed into the concept of moral-
principal of a management college was in- ity. Many of the moral codes followed by different
troducing me to the final-year MBA students. He human societies in different places are found to be
concluded with the remark, Morality has eroded in similar. Does this reflect the essential sameness of
every sphere of life. Business, commerce, and trade human nature?
are also affected. Hence, we have invited Swamiji
to enlighten us all on business ethics. Jarawa Values
I was about to recite, as is my wont, a Vedic I have observed wonderful values among the ab-
mantra before the talk, when a student stood up original peoples of the Andaman Islands. At the
and said, Swamiji, please tell us specifically about time when I was in Andaman, the Jarawaone
morality. Something is immoral for somebody but of the aboriginal tribes who for many centuries
perfectly moral for many others. What is morality? fiercely resisted interference from so-called mod-
Is it a list of dos and donts? ern peoplehad started showing some signs of
I shall answer your question by asking you two friendship. Once or twice, while passing through
questions in turn, I said. A man killed another per- Jarawa-inhabited areas, I saw a few of them from
son and robbed him of his moneyis this moral? distance. The innocent faces of the childrenwith
All the two hundred or so students shouted, No, bright, intelligent eyesimpelled me to do some-
immoral. I asked again, A soldier on a battlefield thing for them. I talked with the then Lt Governor
killed ten enemy soldiersis this moral? Again a of Andaman and Nicobar Islands, Sri I P Gupta, a
thundering reply, Yes, moral. The students were all broad-minded administrator, and he appreciated
happy, as though they had successfully answered my plan of starting a Jungle School for Jarawa chil-
questions in a quiz contest. Then I asked again: dren. Before approaching our headquarters at Belur
Both of them killed: one man robbed and killed Math for formal approval, I wanted to gather some
only one person, and the other killed ten persons. information and experience. Sri I P Gupta arranged
Both were acts of cruelty. Why, then, did you say my visit to the Jarawa jungle with the Bush Police.
killing one person is immoral while killing ten is They chose to take me during the time when the
moral? There was perfect silence. It was a conun- men would be out hunting and collecting food.
drum for them, and I was enjoying their predica- There were old women, one or two very old men,
ment. Then a young woman stood up and said, The and childrenfrom toddlers to young teens. At
first person killed to rob, which is immoral; but the first, they were sceptical about us and hid them-
second killed to protect his country and to perform selves behind some bushes. We took some very at-
his duty, which is moral. tractive gifts for themcoconuts, ripe bananas, red
It seems that a sense of morality has been extant cloths, and mirrors. The moment they saw the gifts,
in human society from its very beginnings. When they came running to me.
human beings started living together, forming A little girl of five or six seemed to take a special
groups and societies, they must have understood fancy for me. Her nameas it sounded to my ear
PB April 2008 235
was Moo, and I called her Black Moon. She first Swami Ranganathananda, thirteenth president
smelled my hand and then took it in her two little of the Ramakrishna Order, was once asked whether
hands, rubbing her chubby cheeks with it. An eld- sadhus tell lies. To the surprise of all, he answered,
erly police constable explained that she was trying to in his characteristically reserved way, Yes. There
tell me that she liked me and wanted to be my friend. was commotion in the auditorium! Revered Maha-
She started using my hand as a swing and was having raj raised his right hand to calm the audience down,
great fun. In the meantime, the policemen started and then told the following story: There was a sadhu
distributing the gifts, and all the children thronged who was known for his truthfulness. One evening,
near the jeep. I signed to Black Moon to go and col- he was sitting alone by the side of a road when a
lect her share. She looked at me intently, as if trying man came running to him, gasping and panting for
to read my lips. Then, suddenly, she ran towards the air. Swamiji, some cruel men are chasing me! he
jeep, touched a few coconuts, bananas, and so on, cried. They want to kill me for my money! The
and came back again to swing. I tried to convince sadhu looked at him but did not break his silence.
her that if she left her things like that, others might The man ran off to the left. After a few moments a
take them away, but she paid no heed to me. group of ferocious-looking men, daggers in hand,
Afterwards I noticed a wonderful thing: any ran up to the same sadhu and demanded, Did you
item that a Jarawa child touched would belong to see a man running along this road? The sadhu nod-
that child. Those who did not get a certain item did ded his head in affirmation. Which way did he go?
not quarrel or try to take away others goods. Were they roared. The holy man pointed to the right, and
they not moral? the dacoits ran off in that direction. Swami Ranga-
nathananda then asked the audience, In that situ-
Same Act, Different Circumstances ation, did the sadhu practise dharma by telling an
An act which is generally considered immoral and untruth? The audience burst into applause.
unethical may become moral in certain situations, Though so much has been written on morality
particularly if it is done for the benefit of others. thousands of words have been used to explain it
Telling lies is considered immoral. But on the bat- still, people find the concept difficult to understand
tlefield of Kurukshetra, when Acharya Drona was and to put into practice.
killing the supporters of the Pandavas by the hun-
dreds, it was Bhagavan Sri Krishna himself who A Tale of Woe
urged the truthful Yudhishthira to tell a lie to stop Once a young woman approached me with a request
Dronas fury and save many lives. to admit her son, a boy of hardly six years, in our
A unique incident from the life of Sri Rama- home for destitute boys. When I enquired about the
krishna may be mentioned here. Sri Ramakrishna boys father, she said that he had left the island. In
had been ill, and Kaviraj Gangaprasad Sen of Ku- Andaman, there are many sad cases of family deser-
martuli, Kolkata, was consulted. He prescribed tion by men who go to other places to try their luck.
medicine and asked Sri Ramakrishna to give up I admitted the boy in our home, and she left with a
water altogether. Sri Sarada Devi, the Holy Mother, promise to visit her son at least once a month.
would give him plenty of milk daily, and gradually She kept her promise and visited our home fre-
increased the quantity without his being aware of quently. After a few months she came along with a
it. Sri Ramakrishna would ask, How much milk is man of South Indian origin. She asked me to note
this? Holy Mother would artfully dodge the ques- the name of the man as the father of her son. After
tion, giving hazy answers. Afterwards she explained, a year or so she came with another man, of local
There is no harm in telling a lie for feeding some- origin, and wanted to put his name as the father of
one. In this way I coax him to eat. her son instead of the previous one. I did not say
236 PB April 2008
Is This Moral? 15
anything, but from my face perhaps she could un- few months, when she found another labourer for
derstand that I did not like her behaviour. her cultivation. I had to obey her order. This man
One afternoon she came alone and wanted to continued for eight years and became the father of
touch my feet. I did not allow her to do so and, my son. Then one morning I learned that he had
perhaps a bit roughly, told her to sit on the veranda. left. By this time I was mature enough to under-
She left my office, sat on the floor of the veranda, stand that my stepmother was using me as bait to
and burst into tears. I do not know why, but I did get a labourer for her land.
not feel any sympathy for her. When for a third time she found a man to work
I know why you hate me, she sobbed. I know a her land, I secretly left homewithout knowing
holy man like you can not tolerate a characterless where to go. I got on a boat. On board, I met a
woman. But please allow me to tell you a few words lady who told me about you and your ashrama. She
about my life. She then related her tale of woe: advised me to leave my son with you and to join a
My mother died just after I was born, and I grew stone factory as a daily labourer. Swamiji, you are
up under the care of my stepmother. My father died a holy man; you know many thingsbut you do
when I was ten or eleven years old. We had land to not know the suffering of a woman without moor-
cultivate, but no men to do that. One day when ings. Just for survival I had to marry the first per-
I returned from school, my stepmother told me, son I could findhe was a driver. And now for the
Get ready for marriage. I saw a Hindi-speaking same reason I have taken shelter with this man. But
labourer, three times my age, sitting in the corner of Swamiji, I promise that I will bring an end to my
our room. I was forced to marry him. That man was life when my son turns eighteen and is able to look
not bad and never misbehaved with me, but my go- after himself. Believe me, Swamiji.
ing to school was stopped. After a year or so, he had Through her sobbing, she asked me a question:
a fight with my stepmother over the share of grain Swamiji, am I immoral?
and left our house. My stepmother allowed me to I could not answer her question. Can you,
go to school again; but that again stopped after a readers? P
The Alternate Viewpoint
A nimesh Debnath (class eight) raised his hand and

asked us to show the scene once again. The film
was Pather Panchali, directed by Satyajit Ray, and the
scene had Durga peeping into an earthen jar to look at
the kitten she had kept there. Ray wanted to show us
how Durga appeared to the kitten, and the scene does
give the impression of us being in the place of the kitten,
looking at Durgas face through the mouth of the pot.
Animesh reviewed the scene several times over, and af-
ter being lost in thought for hours reproduced the scene
in pencil and water colour. When asked the reason for
his interest in this particular episode, he was reluctant In discussing values, it is voices such as Animesh
to explain. On being pressed, he said, I have drawn the Debnaths that we need to listen to. Many such voices
picture, there it ends, as if to tell us that every painting will be speaking to us in the following pages. If we are to
has its own language of expression, which need not be benefit from them, we will have to give them a percep-
translated into words. tive ear. Swami Sanmatrananda
PB April 2008 237

The Patachitra Tradition: An Effective Means
for Value-based Education
Swami Sanmatrananda
T
he present approaches to value and moral therein, and (iii) ask them to explain their paint-
education in Indian schools are largely de- ings in their own language to an audiencetheir
pendent on textbooks and certain stereo- classmates, or visitors to a painting exhibition. The
typed tests administered to students on a monthly children could explain their paintings through nar-
or annual basis. This method fails to inspire stu- rative, action, or song.
dents, who look upon the subject as an added bur- This is what we tried to do at the annual painting
den in their already overloaded curricula. Moreover, exhibition of the Ramakrishna Mission Vidyalaya
in this approach, it is often difficult for students to at Viveknagar.
relate their classroom lessons to the life they actu- We chose Bhibhutibhusan Bandyopadhyays cel-
ally live. It is, therefore, important that we explore ebrated novel Pather Panchali (The Ballad of the
fresh and interesting methods of value education to Road) for this project. There were several reasons
supplement the existing courses. With this purpose for this choice. First, this novel tells how a village
in mind, we have tried to introducein a modern boy, Apu, grows into manhood, overcoming many
waythe ancient Patachitra art tradition of rural emotional hurdlesa simple yet subtle story of the
Bengal in our school at Viveknagar, Tripura. This transformation of an imaginative rural child into a
article presents an overview of the method. sensitive youth living in the bewildering complexi-
Even in recent times, the wandering minstrel ties of an urban metropolis. It has been found that
with a roll of canvas pieces tucked under his arm adolescent students are deeply attracted to this nar-
was a common sight in the afternoons in the sleepy rative because similar transformations are taking
hamlets of Bengal. These minstrels are called pat place in their own psyche. Second, the author of
uas or painters, and their canvas paintings pata this novel has successfully captured the untram-
chitra or simply pat. The paintings usually depict melled beauty of Mother Naturethe richness of
stories from the great epicsRamayana and Maha flora and fauna, green pastures, murmuring rivu-
bharataor Puranic legends and popular folk tales. lets, rural hutments humming with activity, open
The patua acts out the legend he has drawn even as skies, and fluid moonlight. These descriptions eas-
he recites and sings the narrative composed in en- ily capture the hearts of the students and transport
gaging verse and song. Traditional culture, house- them into the world of creative imagination. Third,
hold values, and contemporary social idealsall the narrative is suggestive of a lofty ideal underpin-
enter spontaneously into the hearts of village chil- ning mundane life. Life is a never-ending path; it
dren gathered round the patua displaying his paint- is a continuous movement, through happiness and
ings and dramatic solo performance. suffering, through trials and tribulations. A sense of
Can we not produce the same effect on the unity, however, survives this sea of changea sense
minds of the young students in our schools? We of connectivity, of oneness of all lives. This unify-
could (i) tell them some story from a noble literary ing thread is closely associated with the perennial
piece, (ii) inspire them to sketch or paint different flow of noble human aspirations. On reading this
scenes from the narrative or image the characters story, young readers spontaneously receive an edu-
238 PB April 2008
cation in value-oriented
living and, unbeknown
to themselves, enter into
the current of these no-
ble ideas, becoming srot
apanna, stream entrants,
as it wereto use a Bud-
Nishchindipur, Rituraj Bhoumick, Class 6
dhist phrase.
ate stagnation; cutting across barriers of time and
Pather Panchali space, it moves on relentlessly. Life changes, but
Let us recall the storyline of the novel in brief. Apu within this dark sea of change, the connectivity of
is a village boy and Durga is his elder sister. They all existence remains aglow.
live with their parents, Harihar and Sarvajaya, in As we narrated the story to the students of our
Nishchindipur, a village on the Ichhamati River. high school, read out selected passages to them
An old aunt, Indir Thakrun, is also part of the fam- (the book has been translated into English by Tara-
ily. Harihar is more a man of poetry than of prosaic pada Chatterjee) and showed them the film based
practical life. But he has to function as a priest to on this story made by the famous director Satya-
maintain his family. He also travels from village to jit Rayfor which he was honoured at the 1956
village explaining the scriptures in the local dialect. Cannes Film Festivalwe could see their facial
Theirs is a poor but simple family. expressions change with Apus changing fortunes;
The bounties of naturethe green fields, clear they were living in the dream world of Apu. We
skies, open paths, and the free-flowing rivertouch encouraged them to translate their inner feelings
Apus sensitive heart and open his eyes to a delight- into drawings, and they responded enthusiastically
ful world. He bonds very well with his sister Durga, by reproducing the various episodes of the novel
and together they run through the meadows to see in different media: water colour, pastel, and pen-
a train for the first time, to enjoy the first raindrops, cil sketches. An exhibition of this pictorial Pather
to gather mangoes in stormy afternoons, and to ex- Panchali was organized, and soon the budding art-
ecute many such innocent expeditions. ists were busy explaining the story to visitors in
Harihar has to stay away from the family over animated tones.
long periods, and the family suffers dire poverty. To
add to their sorrow, Durga falls ill and dies almost What They Felt
untreated on a stormy night. Harihar returns to At this point we decided to explore whether the
Nishchindipur, only to receive this heart-breaking values underlying the narrative had been assimi-
news. The family now leaves their village home and lated by the students. This we did by interviewing
moves to Varanasi. Here too their condition doesnt the artists without disclosing the purpose of these
improve. Eventually, Harihar also dies and Sarva- interviews. Given below is a report of some of these
jaya has to work as a cook in the house of a rich interactions.
man to support Apu and herself. The realization Rituraj Bhoumick, a student of class six, has
of their helplessness slowly dawns on Apu. City painted a village scene from Nishchindipur. His
life suffocates his imaginative spirit, and he plans to depiction follows the description in the novel, with
return to the open air of Nishchindipur. But deep only a slight variation. Rituraj prefers landscapes.
within his being, he hears a voice. That voicethe We asked him: Why did you choose to draw a land-
presiding deity of lifeexhorts Apu to go forward. scape instead of narrating the story of the novel?
The journey of life knows no end, it does not toler- Rituraj: To depict the story through painting,
PB April 2008 239
Id have to bring onto my canvas human beings in-
teracting with each other in closed rooms. I dont
like closed rooms. I like open space.
Q: Why? Why do you like open space?
Rituraj: If someone forces me to stay in a closed
room, I feel suffocated. But in open space, Im
free!
Q: So, you like freedom! Wonderful! One point
that strikes us is that you have drawn a dead tree by
the side of a path stretching to the horizon. Why
did you put a dead tree at the centre of a village
that is so green?
Rituraj: In Pather Panchali there are so many
deaths. Indir Thakrun, Durga, Harihar one af-
ter another, they passed away. Apus story is full of The Old Aunt,
suffering. Yet, he never loses heart. The dead tree Koustuv
in my painting can be compared with these suffer- Roychoudhury,
Class 6
ings. In spite of that, the other trees remain full of
leaves. The path also cares not for this dead tree. It journey through time and space, in the face of many
goes forward. This path itself is like Apu full of odds, have clearly inspired this budding artist.
life I mean Apu has travelled a lot. From his Unlike Rituraj, Koustuv Roychoudhury of class
childhood to boyhood, from boyhood to a more six likes to draw human figures. He is particularly
grown-up stage from Nishchindipur to Varanasi. interested in the character of Indir Thakrun, the
I imagine that this path has gone with him to all old aunt who took shelter with Harihars family.
these places. Q: Why have you chosen the old aunt as the
A great sense of freedom and the image of lifes subject of your painting?
Durga Passes Away, Devajyoti Sengupta, Class 7
Koustuv: For her helplessness,
Indir Thakrun draws my sympa-
thy. She has no one of her own. She
has nowhere to stay. She finds the
shadow of her deceased daughter in
Durga. Sarvajaya quarrels with her.
Shes a burden to Harihars fam-
ily. She gets angry and temporarily
leaves the house. But she forgets
her anger when she meets Durga.
In almost all families there are
some members who are like Indir,
the old aunt. They are helpless. Yet,
they fill many gaps in our daily
drama. Im especially attracted to
such old men and women. This is
why Ive chosen the old aunt as the
subject of my painting.
240 PB April 2008
The Patachitra Tradition: An Effective Means for Value-based Education 19
It is evident that through this character the nov-

elist has touched a very deep chord in Koustuvs
heart.
A painting on Durgas death, done by Devajyoti
Sengupta of class seven, attracted our attention
next. The painting is clearly influenced by Rays
film. We asked him about the inspiration behind
this work.
Q: Why did this particular episode especially
attract you?
Devajyoti: When I heard this incident for the
first time and then saw the scene in the film, I mean
Durgas death, I was deeply touched. It reminded
me of the loss of my own sister a year ago. Ive
tried to present my departed sister in this painting.
I found relief when I could express my feelings in
this way.
Q: Is there any other reason for your choosing
this incident?
Devajyoti: Another reason is the fact that I find Harihar, Kaustav Das, Class 9
the very existence of death to be mysterious. Is there after all, is a second infancy in many waysand
anything after death? Where did Durga go? Where Kaustav apparently is more fascinated by the world
did my little sister go? We dont know. But these of elders. We asked him why he chose to paint the
questions often come to my mind. Thats another senior members of the family and why he presented
reason why I chose this topic. Harihar as a man much older than what his age ac-
Q: We see Sarvajaya, Durgas mother, sitting mo- tually is in the novel.
tionless in your painting, as we did in Rays film Kaustav: I find that the childrenApu and
Devajyoti: Yes, she appears lifeless as if frozen Durgaare at the focus of this novel. I feel that
by this terrible shock. the novelist has had less scope to concentrate on
Q: But how can a person come out of this fro- the elderly characters in his novel. For this rea-
zen state and start living once again? son, I sympathize with the senior members of the
Devajyoti: For me, I can only say (after some familywith Harihar and Sarvajaya in particular.
thought) I believe in God. Even though there are Moreover, I didnt like to depend much on the nov-
such terrible losses in life, we shouldnt forget that elists portrayals; I wanted to be independent.
He is looking after everything. Q: And why does Harihar appear so old in your
An earnest endeavour to solve the riddle of death painting?
and deep faith in God amidst all sufferings of life Kaustav: It is true that in the novel Harihar died
were glowing in the eyes of this Nachiketa. in middle age. But Ive tried to imagine how he
Kaustav Das of class nine has drawn the por- would look if he had lived into old age.
traits of Harihar and Sarvajayathe elderly mem- Q: But then you could have drawn the image
bers of the family. He seems to be less interested of any old man
in Apu and Durga; he is even reluctant to portray Kaustav: That doesnt really matter. I drew my
the old aunt Indir Thakrun. Possibly, the old aunts inspiration from Harihar of the novel, but I actu-
behaviour is much like that of a childold age, ally wanted to draw the pathos of any old person.
PB April 2008 241
Prabuddha Bharata
of class eight. It was Durga who actually taught
Apu to look into the beauties of nature. Durga is
the very symbol of nature. So, when Durga passed
away, I couldnt control my tears. Then Apu left his
village. We are reading this novel through Apus
eyes. This little village was Apus entire world. Thus,
when he left the village, it was like his passing away
from this world. However, at that time, Apu didnt
understand that this passing away was equivalent
to entering into a broader world.
Prasenjit Datta says, Apu experienced the ir-
reparable loss of his father, and the transformation
that came upon his psyche after that has been well
documented towards the end of the exhibition.
Indir, Amlan Durgas premature death after a lot of suffering was
Mallick, Class 8 quite unbearable for me, remarks Sayak Debbarma.
Sourav Roy points out, Following in the footsteps
arihar of my painting isnt just Harihar of the
H of the film-maker, Amlan Mallick has drawn a pic-
novel; he stands for all aged persons of all time. ture where the old aunt is found unable to pass a
We appreciated the spirit of independent think- thread through the eye of a needle due to her poor
ing that Kaustav has shown. eyesight. The helplessness of the old woman has
Thus we see that the students who worked to left an indelible mark on my mind. Chirantan Das
set up this exhibition have been significantly in- remarks thoughtfully, We find eternal mother-
fluenced by the ideas and values portrayed in this hood expressed in the character of Sarvajaya, as
masterpiece. An indomitable spirit of freedom, the portrayed in this exhibition as well as in the novel.
sense of mystery in the face of death, dependence Sagnik Bhattacharya says, Above all, Harihars po-
on God, an apprehension of the evanescence of hu- etic simplicity attracts me the most. All of them are
man life, insight into humanitys endless journey, students of class seven.
love and respect for elders, a deep feeling for the One thing is certain, observes Sri Gopikananda
helpless men and women wending
their way through the troubled wa- Apu Leaves His Village, Anubhav Chakravarty, Class 6
ters of the world in the afternoon
of their livesthe seeds of all these
ideas have found a fertile soil in
these young hearts.
What about those who did not
contribute paintings but attended
the exhibition as spectators? We
have talked to them too and have
obtained similar reactions.
Ive been deeply touched by
two of the paintings: Durga Passes
Away and Apu Leaves His Vil-
lage, says Rajarshi Bhattacharya
242 PB April 2008
The Patachitra Tradition: An Effective Means for Value-based Education 21
Chattopadhyay, the students art teacher, The no- justification to believe that this picture-narrative
ble values which enter into the hearts of these chil- method is remarkably effective in helping students
dren through this method will become permanent imbibe important values on their own. It may,
assets in their lives. They will never forget this therefore, be used in conjunction with existing
experience. textbook-based approaches to impart value-based
In the light of our findings, there is sufficient education more effectively to school students. P
The purpose of religion has always baffled young- animate; perhaps, in the way we see atoms in every
sters. Since time immemorial children have always particle of matter. But how to achieve this seemingly
been taught to worship only in temples, churches, and impossible goal is a matter of perseverant practice and
mosques. As we grew older our minds started popping self-introspection, to purify the mind and go through
up questions like: all obstacles. The question then arises as to how to re-
What is the purpose of worship in temples, churches, ally experience this truth. Is it by divine grace or self-
and mosques? effort alone, or by both? This riddle must be resolved
Why should religion confine us to worshipping in and right knowledge and guidance must be invoked
places of worship? by all religions of the world. Seeing God everywhere
The purpose of religion is to experience God within must be the real purpose of all religions. No religion
us. The great sages and rishis who have experienced must force ignorance, though it is difficult to experi-
this truth within themselves are said to have preached ence and visualize the subtle unseen truth about God
that the Lord is omnipresent and omnipotent. We must by us youngsters.
hence go beyond temples, churches, and mosques Art by Manjunath M; Script by Gaurang R Makam
and find and see God in every object, animate or in- Class Ten, Sri Ramakrishna Vidyalaya, Mysore
PB April 2008 243

Vidyamandira Values: Some Reflections
Swami Shastrajnananda
Ramakrishna Mission Vidyamandira, Belur Math
F
ounded in 1941, the Ramakrishna Mission ten responses to these, and then held informal dis-
Vidyamandira was started as an initial step in cussions with them to clarify our understanding of
the march towards the fulfilment of Swami their thoughts. We present here the responses of
Vivekanandas dream that a university should grow some of these alumni. The sample is small and the
at the Belur Math, having religion as its pivot and responses cannot be taken as representative of the
combining oriental with occidental learning. The entire body of Vidyamandira alumni. But they do
Vidyamandira is a fully residential degree college offer interesting insights into the value system of
for boys affiliated to the University of Calcutta this institution and its impact on its students.
and is modelled on the ancient gurukula system. Five of our respondents are pursuing medi-
Reputed as a premiere institute of higher learn- cal courses and two engineering. We also have
ingit has been accredited with an A+ grade by responses from a software professional and an
the National Accreditation and Assessment Coun- English-language lecturer.
cilit presently offers eleven undergraduate and 1. What are the values that you imbibed at Vidya
two postgraduate courses. mandira?
The Vidyamandira is located close to the head- Abhijit: Besides emphasizing such values as
quarters of the Ramakrishna Math and Ramakri- punctuality, hard work, and self-realization, the
shna Mission at Belur, amid peaceful and elevating most pertinent stress was on ones becoming a good
surroundings, free from the din and bustle of busy human being. All of these have slowly helped me
city life. In this residential college, students inter- develop my humanity. In todays fast-paced society,
act closely with their teachers, who try to impart it is often difficult to distinguish the good from the
all-round training in an atmosphere of serene peace, bad, though security and development are impor-
discipline, and moral purity. The aim is to help stu- tant indicators of social health. The ethical dilem-
dents develop into worthy citizens of the country mas that we often face in society cause me much
with a sense of genuine pride in its hoary cultural pain; but I also know that this pain is a sure indica-
traditions. tor that I am on the right track. This awareness is a
Recently we explored the thoughts of some of our gift from Vidyamandira.
alumni about the values they imbibed at Vidyaman- Kamakhya: Vidyamandira has taught me the
dira and their experiences in post-Vidyamandira virtues of an ideal student, especially the need for
life vis--vis their value systems. We put them seven honesty. I have gained immense mental power as a
questions (see box on p. 245), obtained their writ- result of my stay at Vidyamandira; this has enabled
244 PB April 2008
Vidyamandira Values: Some Reflections 23
me to face all odds. Kaushik: When I first came to Vidyamandira,

Krishnendu: When I joined Vidyamandira, I I was a fearful village boy, unfamiliar with the
hardly knew how to communicate with people worldboth sweet and violentthat lay beyond
around me. This was partly due to the conserva- our green and cool village environs. At Vidyaman-
tive environment at home and partly because of dira, I got introduced to a larger world. I learnt that
my own self-centred attitude. So, the attitudinal there are some wonderful similarities between the
changes I underwent in my years at Vidyamandira various branches of science and spirituality; that
can all be credited to the institution. The central all research is a quest for a deeper understanding
value, in my view, is captured in Swami Viveka- of creation, and through this, a discovery of the
nandas exhortation: Be good and do good. All Creator; and that in serving humans we serve God.
other valuesself-help, truthfulness, purity, pa- These ideas fascinated me. The Vidyamandira disci-
tience, obedience, discipline, and the likeare but pline and routine initially appeared to be too chal-
echoes of this cardinal note. lenging; I even thought of dropping out, but soon
Partha: Vidyamandira has helped me inculcate realized that this was not very different from the
such qualities as a disciplined life, concentration, routine and discipline one has at home.
honesty, and the ability to take right decisions at Asis: The most important thing that Vidyaman-
the right moment. dira did was to teach me the need for having proper
Pratik: I believe that most of the values I hold values and the importance of sticking to them. We
have been shaped by the thoughts and views of my learnt that our lives depend on choices, and that we
parents. But Vidyamandira has acted as an impor- must make the right ones with a clean conscience.
tant catalyst in this shaping process. It has especially Also, it is here that we became social animals in the
helped me with self-actualization, self-control, cop- real sense of the term, having stayed with a whole
ing with anxiety and stress, and developing self- lot of fellow students in the hostels. This challenge
esteem and perseverance. would become unbearable at times, but we kept
Sourav: My stay at Vidyamandira is an impor- learning.
tant milestone in my life, as that was the first time I
was away from home and on my own. It is here that
I learnt that if one remains good and does good The Values Questionnaire
things, the result will always be good. It also taught 1. What are the values that you imbibed at Vidya-
me the necessity of a routine-bound life. mandira?
Abhisek: The thousand things that Vidyaman- 2. To what extent have you been able to practise
dira put forth before us, either as instructions or these values in your post-Vidyamandira life?
as lifestyle requirements, could all be termed val- 3. Please describe some incidents in which you were
ues. But for an instruction or thought to become a able to act in accordance with these values.
value it must be consciously put to the test of prac- 4. Do you think you have a distinctive identity at
tice. The values that I have learnt to consciously fol- your workplace?
low include (i) never compromising with whatever 5. Please describe some incidents in which you
one feels to be wrong; (ii) being strong but flex- were not able to act in accordance with your
ible, whatever be the situation; (iii) being fearless; values.
(iv) being always hungry to learn more; (v) making 6. Have you had any problems adjusting to post-
sure life makes personal sense; (vi) knowing that a Vidyamandira life?
well-regulated life brings one happiness beyond 7. What influence has Vidyamandira exerted on
ones imagination; (vii) getting to love trouble, as your functioning as an ideal citizen of India?
it never leaves you.
PB April 2008 245
2. To what extent have you been able to practise ing casually with ones neighbour during exams is as
these values in your post-Vidyamandira life? good as cheating. So, even when I am ill-prepared,
Partha: There is, no doubt, a huge difference and even when there is ample opportunity to copy,
between life in Vidyamandira and in the world I have been unable to use devious means to get a
outside. But I have been sincerely trying to apply better score. I have been ridiculed, but I have the
the values picked up at Vidyamandira to tackle the mental satisfaction of remaining true and just.
problems I face, and I believe that, to some extent, Kamakhya: I do not like smoking. But most stu-
I have been successful in doing so. dents in my hostel are smokers. Some of them have
Abhijit: I have learnt from Vidyamandira that tried to coerce me into smoking on several occa-
society has helped me become what I am and so sions, but I have always been able to resist such at-
I must try to repay this debt in equal measure tempts successfully. This moral courage, I believe, I
through selfless service. have gained from Vidyamandira. From Vidyaman-
Kamakhya: I have joined a study circle based dira I have also learnt to render service to the needy.
on Swami Vivekanandas ideals at my institute. The Our study circle provides me with such an oppor-
spiritual training at Vidyamandira helps me refrain tunity. The poor boys of the neighbourhood often
from dishonest ways. come to our study circle, and I teach them.
Krishnendu: It is very difficult, no doubt, to Krishnendu: Let me cite two examples: (i) In
practise these values in the college environment our medical college hostel a picnic is organized
that I am presently in. There are obvious failures. every year by the second-year students. A major-
But, I believe these failures are evidence that there ity of the students in our hostel are smokers. They
is something called success. All I have to do is to found it difficult to restrain themselves from smok-
try harder, and I am determined to do so. This self- ing in the bus on the way to the picnic spot. Non-
determination is one of the values I imbibed at smokers, including myself, who happened to be
Vidyamandira. in the minority, clearly had a hard time. The next
Pratik: At least to a small extent. year, I was elected to the organizing committee;
Sourav: It is not easy to stick to ones values. I and I arranged for a separate bus for non-smokers,
have tried to do so despite lapses. even though they were small in number. (ii) One
Abhisek: I dont know to what extent I have Saraswati Puja night, a friend of mine came to me
been able to put them into practice, but I do re- shivering and sweating. He had been out partying
main aware about the need for values in different with friends and had taken an intoxicant, siddhi,
situations and try to practise themnot to remain though he was not used to it. He had reacted badly
a good boy at the end of the day, but to make sure to the drug, but his friends were too intoxicated to
that I find myself clean. take notice of him. I put him to bed and, at his re-
Asis: To every possible extent, in public as well quest, stayed with him the whole night, monitoring
as private life. It has been three years since I parted his condition till he recovered.
from my Alma Mater, but the things I learnt there Sourav: Taking help from your neighbour dur-
in both easy and hard wayswill remain with me ing exams is something we never did at Vidyaman-
for life. dira. I have been able to hold on to this habit even
3. Please describe some incidents in which you in situations where many others are doing so, and
were able to act in accordance with these values. despite great temptation to do so.
Abhijit: At my university, the practice of copy- Partha: Once I took a mathematics book from
ing answers from papers during tests is rampant; my teacher and, while going through it, found the
scoring high marks seems to be the sole aim for stu- question paper of the ensuing class test kept in it.
dents. But at Vidyamandira I learnt that even talk- Although I could have looked at the questions, I
246 PB April 2008
did not do so and left the paper where it was. be punished for the wrong reasons. This was not
Abhisek: I have seen people quarrel over trivial an infrequent occurrence, due to some reason or
things; this is common in our trains and buses. One the other. But we were expected to bear with it,
is apt to avoid such quarrels and pass by. But if one and we slowly learnt to do so. Now, whenever my
stops for a second, one might find a poor fellow father says something that does not make any sense
being bullied by a large crowd for some minor mis- to me, I just think over what I would have done in
take. If one can stand by him at that moment and a similar situation at Vidyamandira. And there is
save him from a beating, one feels good. This has never any bitterness in the relationship. Sometimes
happened with meand I feel it requires much one feels very bad, and even stupid, to take every-
courage to stand up to a crowd. Such courage can thing head-down, but the biggest consideration at
only be derived from the values one holds dear. such times is that the person speaking to me is my
Pratik: These values help me regularly cope with father. Maybe he is wrong in saying one thing, but
the day-to-day stresses of life. he is right in all others
Asis: After completing my BA from Vidyaman- 4. Do you think you have a distinctive identity
dira in 2005, I joined Jadavpur University. Some- at your workplace?
where, deep inside, I firmly believe that those two Pratik: Yes, I do. The reasons for this are my per-
years at Jadavpur would not have been so bliss- severance and self-control.
ful had I not had some very strong values, ethics, Abhijit: After passing from Vidyamandira, I got
and practical experiencesall gathered during my admitted to a reputed university. But the lifestyle
three years stay at Vidyamandirato guide me all of students here is very different from that at Vidya
the way through. Jadavpur University taught me mandira. The one aim of students here seems to
to be myself, and Vidyamandira reminded me how be to project a polished image; everythingfrom
I must be. The rest of the journey was a cakewalk. dress to interpersonal dealingsseems to have that
Since I am to cite some incidents, let me begin with one aim. The temptation for luxury and elitism is
the one that comes to mind immediately. On the strong. But the inner strength that I gained while
second day at the Jadavpur campus, a girl from my staying at Vidyamandira seems to act like a strong
batch asked me for a lighter, for obvious reasons. I shield and prevents me from falling in line with the
will never forget the expression on her face when general trend. I clearly feel that this distinguishes
I said, I dont have one because I dont smoke. It me from others.
was funny, deeply disturbing, and insulting. I felt Kamakhya: All my friends love and respect me.
challenged and belittled. For a moment I thought I feel this is due to my moral strength and boldness
I would take up smoking. The atmosphere in the of character.
corridors encouraged and affirmed such behaviour. Krishnendu: Certainly, I believe that I have a
But then I came back to my senses within seconds. distinctive identity in my hostel and at college. I am
Just because someone else was doing it didnt mean never swayed by external provocations and try to
that I would have to do it too! I would do it only if keep my own counsel. But if anyone seeks any help
I felt like doing so. from mebe he or she a senior or juniorand if I
More often than not, we take our parents for feel that it is within my ability, I try to do my best
granted. I remember with shame a time when a gulf to help. I have felt that I am appreciated for this.
existed between my father and me. Everything he Sourav: I dont know if I have a distinct iden-
said or advised seemed inappropriate to me. This tity, but I try to do all work with care and full
caused both of us a lot of worry. Here again, Vidya attention.
mandira helped me counsel myself. At college or Asis: I have a very distinctive identity at the
in the hostel we would often receive scoldings or places where I work. I am a teacher and have learnt a
PB April 2008 247
lot from my teachers, both at the Ramakrishna Mis- any remuneration from him. But even then he was
sion and at Jadavpur University. Every day, when I irregular as he had to help his father earn a living
teach, I think about the approaches that a few of my for the family. Although I came to know about
teachers might have taken for a particular chapter or his problems, I did not bother to help him in any
exercise. And I really love my students. That is most other way. I could not have personally given him
important. I sincerely believe that just like doctors, financial help, but I could definitely have provided
teachers too give people life, though in a more com- him moral and mental support. Even some way for
plicated sense and form. My students are my friends; financial assistance could have been worked out if I
I am what they will surely be tomorrow. I keep re- had applied myself to it. But I remained aloof, and
minding myself that every day I deal with potential I regret having done so.
leaders, littrateurs, historians, professors, and so on. Kamakhya: Once in our hostel there was a big
So I feel all the more responsible, and sometimes political agitation which resulted in a bitter clash
nervous. And there is something that I find lacking between two rival groups. One group forced us to
in teachers of the present day. They only teach; its support them. Many apolitical students like me had
really unfortunate. I feel that a teacher must under- no other way but to follow their order.
stand that a students personal problems hamper his Partha: Once, owing to lack of time due to ill-
or her progress in the academic field. And if teachers ness, I filed my laboratory report by simply copy-
are not friendly with their students, they will never ing from the report of a previous-years student. I
get to the root of the students problems, and hence think this is the sole instance in which I deviated
their ultimate purpose will be defeated. When I from truth.
accept the responsibility of a student or a batch, I Abhisek: I felt bad the day I was ragged by my
dont think about just their mark-sheets. If they do seniors at college. I was made to sing and dance and
something wrong, I feel ashamed and responsible. read out from a list against my wish. But then I did
So I try to instil values and ethics in them; and this not feel a strong urge to protest and thought that it
is impossible unless they accept me as a friend. And is better to be reasonable than to be too rigid with
to be a friend, I have to stop being just a teacher. ones principles.
Abhisek: I think I do have a distinct identity Asis: I believe there is always a second or third
among those who understand my background approach to dealing with any problem. And those
and my work. But this doesnt matter much to me. other approaches are also a part of what we learn
What does matter is that my senior manager trusts at college. Everything is, so to say, in the syllabus
my analysis and my method of argument to such an here.
extent that he grants me full freedom to handle my 6. Have you had any problems adjusting to post-
work the way I wish to. Vidyamandira life?
Partha: Vidyamandira has taught me to aspire Pratik: Yes, I have. These included (i) an initial
for higher personal standards. So, even though I am uneasiness in getting along with girls in class; (ii)
presently studying in a good engineering college, I feeling slightly overwhelmed by unrestricted ex-
have also been working hard to secure admission to posure to a larger world; and (iii) facing a dilemma
more reputed institutions. I think this sets me apart about how to respond diplomatically to the de-
from my fellow students. mands of a politically oriented society.
5. Please describe some incidents in which you Partha: Ragging posed a real problem in my
were not able to act in accordance with your values. post-Vidyamandira life. But I managed to handle
Abhijit: While I was studying at the university, it. The routine of regular prayersmorning and
two students used to come to me for private tui- eveningat Vidyamandira, which I found particu
tion. One of them was very poor. I did not take larly tough, helped me at this time. It helped me
248 PB April 2008
become more patient and tolerant. to be leading rather mechanical, self-centred lives.
Abhijit: Life at Vidyamandira was well-balanced There was plenty of show but little discipline. Life
and well-regulated. Activity was balanced by seren- in a metropolis like Kolkata can be attractive, but
ity, strictness and punctuality were moderated with the city can also be hard on those who fail to keep
love and affection. But on leaving Vidyamandira I pace with it or who happen to fall. This I find par-
was faced with a world full of greed and selfishness, ticularly difficult to digest.
marked by unimaginable wastage of lifes energies Asis: Yes, there were initially some glitches in
and resources. I would often feel angry, but soon I the post-Vidyamandira phase of my life. They arent
realized that these are the very circumstances that serious enough to be dealt with or analysed here.
one has to face and overcome; one cannot turn For example, since the Vidyamandira rules prohibit
away from them, even as one cannot become a students from going off-campus frequently, it be-
party to this state of affairs. came a little difficult initially to adjust to the ways
Kamakhya: The atmosphere in the institution of the world in the post-Vidyamandira phase. Also,
where I presently study can hardly be compared students from the outside world have a peculiarly
to that at Vidyamandira. Students here are more distorted view of and opinion about students from
prone to moral corruption, and the teacher-student the Ramakrishna Mission. That makes it difficult
relationship is far from healthy. This causes me to get accepted by and introduced to the groups
much difficulty and I also feel sorry for this state that form among students in the first month of the
of affairs. term at every college and university. I have no idea
Krishnendu: There are several issues that I find why, but they seem to think that students from the
problematic: (i) the fast-paced life that hampers Ramakrishna Mission are (i) definitely the nerdy,
thoughtfulness, allowing only the satisfaction of studious type who dont know anything about the
momentary pleasures; (ii) the never-ending appe- outer world, and (ii) perhaps, homosexual. This I
tite for recreation and luxury among my friends; found utterly ridiculous. Besides, due to limited
(iii) students political movements in which prin- exposure to the outer world, I found myself lacking
ciples and honesty are sacrificed to fulfil personal in the latest information about films, theatre, music,
desires and seek personal revenge. and so on. It was very difficult to contribute to in-
Sourav: Yes, I had problems trying to adapt my- telligent discussions, and sitting like a fool doesnt
self to the totally different lifestyle in the medical do ones self-confidence and ego a world of good.
college hostel where I stayed. Absence of a com- 7. What influence has Vidyamandira exerted on
mon routine and prayers, and the lack of supervi- your functioning as an ideal citizen of India?
sion caused real problems. But Vidyamandira has Partha: I believe that the values imparted at
also taught me to adapt myself to whatever situa- Vidyamandira are eminently suited to making
tion I might find myself in. This helped me. good citizens of its students. But individuals have
Abhisek: I have never had to go through any to put these into practice, and it is the social en-
situation where I had to make compromises or to vironment that puts these values to the test. The
feel that my conscience was being damaged. But post-Vidyamandira life has given me the chance to
one does have to make numerous adjustments test my ability to apply these teachings in difficult
that can be considered trifling in terms of moral practical situations. But only time will tell if I have
consequences. been able to truly fulfil Vidyamandiras mandate.
Kaushik: The atmosphere at the medical college Abhijit: Vidyamandira has taught me the great
hostel that I joined after passing out of Vidyaman- message given by Swami Vivekananda: This life is
dira was an eye-opener for me. The whole atmos- short, the vanities of the world are transient, but
phere was professionalstudents here seemed they alone live who live for others, the rest are more
PB April 2008 249
dead than alive. If I am able to function as an ideal a few things. And today, whenever I eat a piece of
citizen of my country, it would be an indication candy or something like that, I carry the plastic
that Vidyamandira is a living entity, continuously packet or wrapper home with me, to put in the
inspiring its students in their walk through the dustbin. I never throw the wrappers on the ground,
complex avenues of life. as many people still do. And every time I do this, I
Kamakhya: Vidyamandira has taught me how feel the success of the teacher who had turned his
to remain steady amidst all ups and downs. It has old voice up to full volume in one of his classes to
given me an education based on spirituality and insert this idea into our minds. Weve all learnt our
taught me to sacrifice self-interest and engage in lessons. Of course, this is not to say weve become
social welfare. ideal citizens, but to say that were among the few
Krishnendu: As my friends regard me as a good who are close to being that. Things of this kind
friend, my juniors see me as a good senior, and sen- inspire me to become a better teacher, and tell me
iors find in me a good junior, I think I will be able that a good teacher never loses or is lost; his teach-
to prove myself a fair, if not good, citizen in the fu- ings never completely miss their mark. And for a
ture. The credit for imparting noble values to me student of Vidyamandira, such incidents are avail-
goes to Vidyamandira. able in plenty.
Pratik: By helping me develop responsibility,
honesty, punctuality, and discipline, Vidyaman- In Conclusion
dira has influenced my functioning as an ideal In- Swami Vivekananda wanted to rehabilitate the past
dian citizen. glories of India through an education which would
Sourav: Vidyamandira has encouraged me to be not merely combine in it the best elements of East-
a good citizen. Thats why I work hard and dream ern and Western cultures but would at the same
of being a good doctor, a good human being, and time hold aloft the Indian ideals of devotion, wis-
an ideal citizen. dom, and morality. Real education, he said, enables
Kaushik: There are numerous good people in people to stand on their own feet and helps them to
society who are working hard to keep things in manifest their inherent perfection through a har-
order and to provide necessary services to fellow monious development of head, hand, and heart. In
citizens. Though I have not been able to do much his opinion, a balanced combination of secular and
as yet in this respect, I certainly hope that I too spiritual training constitutes true education.
shall succeed in being a useful citizen by offering The process of education outlined by Swamiji is
my services to society. not easy, and the value systems that he stresses are
Asis: This question gives me scope to say some- difficult to uphold under present-day social con-
thing that Ive been meaning to say for a long time ditions. This is evident from the responses of the
now. I know for a fact that the environmental sci- alumni. But the heartening fact is that they have
ence paper is not taught properly in most of the all tried to practise the values they have learnt to
colleges under Calcutta University, although its cherish, despite the odds, and in so doing they have
mandatory to do so according to the rules of the been making their mark as valuable citizens of the
University. In Vidyamandira we had all the classes, world. P
and some very high-profile professors came to de-
liver lectures; this still amazes me. To be honest, we The food that feeds the needythat alone true charity is,
took those classes very lightly because the paper we True men they who that simple truth do find;
had to write was very easy indeed. There used to But they who hoard, like water in pools past access,
be so much noise in the classroom that the teach- To eat and gorgeto charitys ways are they blind.
ers were hardly audible at times. But we did learn Tirumular
250 PB April 2008

Facing Ethical Dilemmas
Dilip Dhopavkar and Prashant Puppal
S
wami Vivekananda started the Ramakri- Hit and Run?
shna Mission on 1 May 1897. One important While driving, you knock someone down in a not-
aim of the organization was to awaken India very-busy area. What do you do? Do you stop and
from the deep slumber into which it had fallen. see how badly the person is injured, or flee as fast as
Swami Vivekananda had tremendous faith in the possible?
Indian youth and believed they would find success Abhijit: I faced such a situation around six
in a value-based life. months back. It occurred at Dattawadi, just five
Social currents and trends are like the changing minutes from the Ramakrishna Math, Pune. I was
fashions of our times. They come and go. Values driving at 25 kph, when a dabbawalla (carrying milk
are eternal and unchanging. But over time, these for sale on a motorbike) came across and struck my
passing trends leave residual impressions and often vehicle. I stopped my vehicle in the middle of the
obliterate the original values. From time to time road and picked him up. Soon people gathered
one needs to retrieve the true values and separate around, but instead of understanding the situation,
them from the distortion created by passing trends. they started hitting me. Thank God, my friends
This is the true role of the Ramakrishna Math and were around and tackled the situation, and I was
Ramakrishna Mission in society, as envisioned by saved. After this experience I started thinking that
Swami Vivekananda. if this happened again, I would run away from the
India is fast re-emerging as a world economic place. But I regularly visit the Math, and Swamiji
power. On the brink of such growth it is worth has told us not to approach people and situations
examining our values to ensure that there is no with preconceived notions but to check any given
lag between inner and outer progress. It would situation and react accordingly.
necessarily be superficial progress if it were only Prashant Puppal: You said that your friends
an external one. With this idea in mind, the Ra- came and tackled the situation. What exactly did
makrishna Math, Pune, organized a seminar in they do ?
which members of its youth forum shared their Abhijit: They pacified the mob. The person in-
personal experiences on real-life ethical dilem- volved in the accident started asking for money,
mas and articulated their feelings and responses as his vehicle had had some damage. But my ve-
to such situations. Forty youthsixteen women hicle had also been damaged, though his damage
and twenty-four men aged seventeen to twenty- was slightly greater. The beating was entirely unex-
sevenparticipated in the seminar. The group pected and my tooth was broken.
included sixteen students; the rest were employed Madhura: I had a morning lecture at my col-
youth, largely IT professionals. We present here lege and was travelling from home. I had to take
some of the thoughts that were shared during this a left turn and was indicating so. There was a rick-
process. The aim of the discussion was to gener- shaw coming and I thought the driver had seen
ate data about youth responses rather than pass my signal; but, apparently, he hadnt. Our vehi-
judgment or seek definitive answers to complex cles collided; my car got scratched and his indica-
problems. tors broke. He seemed very poorthats probably
PB April 2008 251
why he was driving a rickshaw. I thought it was my of the crowd that gathered, he ran away. From that
mistake; maybe he didnt see me, or maybe I took day I decided in my mind that if I came upon any
the turn too fast. He started saying, Madam you such accident, I would try my best to help.
dont watch while driving! I said, I am sorry. I just Recently, a similar incident took place near our
handled the matter very peacefully without shout- school. Our class had just finished, and coming out-
ing at him, because I knew I was at fault and that side, we saw a girl on a scooter being struck by a ve-
he would need money. He was angry and wanted hicle. She was thrown from her bike and fell to the
me to go with him to a mechanic. I said I couldnt ground. Since class had just finished, all the students
come with him on account of the lecture. So I gave were nearby; they all gathered around the scene, but
him a hundred rupees to cover the damage to his merely stood and watched. I ran to the girl, picked
rickshaw. Thats how I solved the problem. her up, picked up her scooter, made her sit comfort-
Dilip Dhopavakar: One important point here is ably, and gave her water. After all this had happened,
that you admitted that it was your mistake. Perhaps my classmates started asking whether that girl was
that reduced his temper. my friend. I said, No, I dont even know her. All
Madhura: I think so. were observing me while I was helping the girl, but
Dilip Dhopavakar: So do I. What is the opinion nobody came forward to help. I thought, Should
of others? If you admit your mistake immediately, we help someone only if we know them? Every-
it has a dramatic effect; it soothes the other persons body was observing me, thinking that I was helping
ego so that he is not in a reactive mood anymore. the girl because she was a close relative.
Kailash: The reverse incident happened to me: Kiran: I have faced such a situation once: I was
somebody knocked me down. I was riding a brand- stopped in my own vehicle at a red light. A person
new motorcycle, with my sister seated behind me. in a Fiat came from behind and rammed into my
A Zen car, coming from the right, hit us. It was his car. Fortunately nothing happened to anyone sit-
mistake, because my indicator was on. My sister ting in the car. But what I found was that by being
was injured. In our society, the person who is rid- very calm and very quiet and not making much fuss,
ing or driving the bigger vehicle is normally con- I ended up on the receiving end. The other person
sidered the culprit. People gathered around, but was not even apologetic; on the contrary, he began
I asked them to calm down and let us handle the charging me! Fortunately the crowd had seen that
situationI just dispersed the crowd. Then I talked the other man was at fault. Sometimes it seems that
with the other driver and found that he also was a if you are polite, that is taken as a weakness. Finally,
good person; he realized that it was his mistake. nothing much happened. I called the police, but as
Then we took my sister to the hospital. It was kind usual they did not come for quite some time. And I
of him to admit that the accident was his fault, had to slowly convince that man that it was his fault.
and he covered the repairs for my bike; he had, of I took a lot of photographs and made it clear that he
course, his insurance. would be in trouble. He finally became apologetic.
Amrita: Three or four years ago, I was cycling But I was left a little confused as to how to handle
home from school one Saturday. I had not eaten such situations. If you are polite and calm, the other
lunch that day, and I fainted and fell down right in person says that it was your mistake! Its a dilemma.
the middle of Swargate square. At that same mo- Umesh: Once I had gone with some friends to
ment, the traffic signal in front of me turned green, a restaurant for dinner. From the restaurant we saw
and a Hero Honda motorcycle passed over my hand. an accident involving three or four bikes. We saw
No sooner did the motorbike rider try to pick me up, a woman falling down on the road. Just after this
than the police arrived on the scene, and the rider an Indica car ran into a Zen car. The Indica was
fled. I thought he was going to help me, but because a call-centre car; after the collision it fled. In the
252 PB April 2008
Facing Ethical Dilemmas 31
Zen car there was a lady driver along with her old him. Then the other driver took him to the hospital.
parents. After the accident, nobody came forward So I realized a good thing: that people do stop and
to help the lady. There had been a loud crash, and I help. I also realized that I was doing the same.
felt that there were surely injuries, and that I should There was a second incident which took place at
see if I could render any assistance. There were five nearly the same spot. An elderly man on his scooter
or six spectators watching the scene. A man came came out of a residential complex. I passed him,
forward and opened the door of the car. I went and he was close to the back door of my car. There
and saw what had happened to the lady. I asked an- was a cyclist riding in front of me. Now the scooter
other person to call a rickshaw and arranged for the rider wanted to overtake the cyclist, and taking
lady to be taken to the hospital. I also noted down a sudden right turn, hit my car. At that pointI
her phone number and she noted down mine. The dont know what happened to mebut I really lost
next day I received a call from her. She thanked me control, not control of the car but control of my
and said that I had helped her a lot, that thanks to mind. I really got annoyed. Luckily I was not driv-
me they could reach the hospital. I reported the ing fast, and he was also going slowly. But I spon-
incident to the newspaper and police by calling taneously lost complete control of my mind and
100, and the call-centre vehicle was tracked down. shouted at the man. He was an elderly man. I dont
The expenses incurred by the lady were reimbursed know why, I just felt I had to talk to him in a very
by the insurance company as well as by the Indica bad way. No bad language, but in a very loud voice.
owner. Because of all this, the call-centre driver He was visibly disturbed too and tried to put the
learnt a lesson. But by the grace of God, there were blame on me, which added to my annoyance. So in
no serious injuries, and the lady also got treatment one situation I tried to help, and in another, I was
at the hospital. In Pune, people usually ignore acci- shouting at somebody.
dents and drive away; it is such a regular occurrence Ravindra: I am from rural parts. I dont have
that people think it doesnt need any attention. But experience with city accidents, but in my village
I feel that in such situations we must offer some I had some experiences that I would like to share.
help; so that is what I did. I have observed that usually in an accident which
Satya: My wife and I were driving to the office involves a motorcycle and a pedestrian, even if the
one morning, passing through an area where many pedestrian is at fault, people beat the motorcyclist.
elderly people go for a stroll. We passed an elderly In short, the driver of the bigger vehicle is held re-
gentleman taking his walk, and made a turn at a sponsible in any accident, irrespective of whose mis-
blind corner; there was a car coming from the other take it is. If a truck hits a pedestrian, even if it is the
side too and we passed each other at the turn. At pedestrians mistake, villagers will break the trucks
that moment, I heard a loud thud and realizedI window. This has happened many a time, at least in
dont know if it was intuition or whatthat some- villages. Moreover, accidents that happen near the
body had been hit. I immediately stopped the car highways are mostly killer accidents, and when the
and ran over to see if it was the old man who was injured are taken to the hospital they are first asked
walking. Yes, he had fallen down and was breathing for money, a deposit, only then are they admitted.
very hard; I didnt know what to do. But I was glad
that the other car had also stopped and that the Software Pirate, You?
driver came to see what happened. I told him, This Do you feel a prick of conscience while clicking the I
guy looks like hes not doing well; we need to take Agree button on the license agreement when install
him to the hospital. Fortunately there was another ing pirated software?
man, I dont know who he was, who came up and Pranav: I just installed Windows Vista on
also helped us put him in the car, the car that hit my computer and really did not feel a prick of
PB April 2008 253
conscience while clicking on I Agree, because, Vaibhav: I am an engineering student. We of-
for one, Windows Vista is outrageously priced. ten need to install very costly software on our own
It is priced at twelve or thirteen thousand rupees, computers, which we simply cant afford. These
which, as a student, I simply cant afford for an op- software companies dont have any concern for stu-
erating system. And I believe Microsoft is making dents. Thats why even our professors teach us how
enough money. to crack software and how to install them on our
Nitin: I disagree with Pranav. I work for a soft- systems. So I dont feel anything while clicking the
ware company. I feel that when somebody uses pi- I Agree button.
rated software, my salary is affected. Everybody Dilip Dhopavakar: You dont feel any prick of
should think about that. Microsoft engineers are conscience at all.
putting their brains into Windows and are work- Vaibhav: No.
ing hard for it. Microsoft and Bill Gates deserve that Prashant Puppal: Are there other software en-
money. If you think that Microsoft is making enough gineers here?
money, you should use Linux instead. That is another Sagar: I just completed my BE Mechanical and
competitive operating system and is free of charge. joined the local MIT college to learn how to use
So I feel that we should think deeply before installing some specialized engineering software. I asked the
pirated software. The case is the same with movies professor for a copy of the software, but he told me
and other copyrighted items. This is my opinion. that he would not be able to give me the institutes
Dilip Dhopavakar: But before you joined your copy. Instead, he gave me a phone number and told
company, you were on the other side, werent you? me that some people would install that software
You were in his group then. So we need to think on a home PC for two or three hundred rupees.
how and why this change in attitude takes place. Though I think that to use pirated software is im-
Nitin:Yes. proper, I have to go through this route as I dont
Satya: When I was a computer-engineering stu- have enough money to purchase a licensed copy of
dent, I never knew what pirated software was. I the software.
used to install pirated software on my machine and Kiran: We have in fact used a lot of software for
use it, using cracks or known keys. I didnt under- making our presentation at the Math. While do-
stand what piracy wasat that time, in the nineties, ing so I never had any prick of conscience because
no one knew. No one cared much about that. But I was doing it to help with the service activities of
when I went to the Indian Institute of Technology, the Math.*
and then for my masters and my job, I started to Atreyi: I am afraid I am merely a consumer. I
realize what piracy is. But still we had two thoughts dont know anything about the technicalities. No,
about it. First, is the software good enough to spend I dont feel any prick of conscience. Some of you
money on? Second, can I get it free? So now, if I might know about the free software movement:
click the I Agree button, I feel bad that again I am there is a whole lobby trying to free computer users
using pirated software. Nowadays I try not to use from the tyranny of Microsoft taking over the whole
pirated software; I try to buy. For example, I used market. People probably feel that Microsoft has so
to have a pirated copy of Windows XP, but now I much money, is such a huge empire, that it cant lose
have bought a licensed copy, and all other software from a little taking, that is, using some pirated soft-
which I use I try to buy. If I dont, thenas the ware. Its easy to take from a place that has so much.
gentleman there mentionedI work with Linux. Dilip Dhopavakar: So whats the end result: do
So it was a slow change: earlier I never knew about * This is the speakers personal opinion. It is the official
it, later I knew but still was using it, and now I am policy of the Ramakrishna Math and Ramakrishna
trying not to use pirated software. Mission to use licensed software at its centres.
254 PB April 2008

Facing Ethical Dilemmas 33
you feel a prick of conscience or not? Windows and other software that I need. So it de-
Atreyi: No! [Loud laughter] pends on the condition.
Dilip Dhopavakar: No, you dont. See, one can Dilip Dhopavakar: So, your conscience is
justify with tremendous force any kind of act. But, conditional!
while doing thatwhile justifyingstill inside, in Seema: We have had a computer at our home
your inner mind, is there a prick of conscience? for many years now. It has had pirated software all
Atreyi: That gentleman therewhen he said, I along; in fact, we did not know that there is such
have used it for the Mathhis intention super- a thing called original software! We are using the
sedes the doubts he has about using it. I am not software that came pre-installed with the system.
using pirated software for anything wrong and I Whenever I have software-related problems with
know very well that I am not going to use it for my PC, I call a person who can fix it. Every time
something wrong. he repairs the software he charges around three
Dilip Dhopavakar: No, no; if you observed hundred rupees. The repaired software works with-
his statement very closelyhe felt a prick of con- out trouble for a month; then I have to call him
science, but he justified his act by saying that it was again, and pay again. I have been working like this
done for the Math. The whole question is whether all along. Though I now understand that there is
our values bring up that conscience or not. So we original software available on the market, I cant
just want to know whether you feel that prick of afford to purchase it. But neither do I like to pay
conscience or not. three hundred rupees every month to keep my
Abhijit: We supply computers to a number of computer running.
institutes. It is our daily routine to install software Prashant Puppal: Though you dont like to pay up
on many machines. I dont feel any prick of con- every month, you cant break the habit now, right?
science because, indirectly, I am marketing a Micro Seema: Yes.
soft product. I feel that way. Dilip Dhopavakar: The issue has many facets.
Dilip Dhopavakar: So your justification is so Ameya: I also use pirated software. When I click
strong that it overpowers the conscience! I Agree, I feel it is not good to do itbut at the
Sanyogita: After listening to the views of all of same time I feel that it is alright, because I cant
these people, I too feel like talking, though my con- afford such software. Secondly, though I feel bad
tact with computers is restricted to dealing with when installing pirated software, still, by doing so
just two or three programmes. I have always used I am supporting a big, flourishing industry. When
pirated software or software given to me by some- you pay a software guy, you are actually supporting
body. I have never purchased software as I could a big industry and are helping to employ a lot of
never afford the cost. I have to always update the people. It may be wrongyet people are getting
software to the latest version and I cant possibly employed because of this, and there are many un-
pay up every time I update. But I do have in mind employed people in India. So you are helping India
that, though currently I use pirated software, some- to grow in this manner!
day I will be able to purchase licensed copies. Prashant Puppal: [laughs] Thats a good one! So
Vishal: I sometimes do, and sometimes dont we shouldnt really regret an act which has a posi-
feel that prick of conscience, depending on the tive side to it!
conditions. For instance, if I am installing Norton
Anti-Virus on the computer and I feel that a pirated How Badly Do You Need a Job?
version would harm my computer, then I would go Your family is not doing well, and you need to get a job.
for a licensed version. So the outside protection is To get a job with the police, you need to pay Rs 50,000,
original and inside I put everything pirated, like which you can somehow gather. Will you say no?
PB April 2008 255
Hari*: I will not do such a thing. I can invest the I rejected the job my family would suffer, which
Rs 50,000 somewhere and do something else. So I would be a greater loss. So I would compromise
wouldnt take such a job. with my conscience. The fact that I am protecting
Satya: In such situations there is something my family would give me more satisfaction than as-
called practical conscience. You have a family, or suaging my conscience.
you have your parents, brothers, and sisters to sup- Prashant Puppal: And how about your family?
portand you are getting a job. You need to do Will they be happy?
that. I think ninety-nine per cent of people would Sita: Yes, because the need of the hour was
take the job if they could. This is something of a money. If they needed money I would take the
practical situation. My thought, practically speak- job.
ing, would be to take the job. Puja: As others have said, this is a practical situ-
Prashant Puppal: You will compromise with ation. If I have to pay Rs 50,000 for a job, and if my
ethics? salary would be some two, three, or five thousand,
Satya: As I just said, it could be a practical situ- I dont think its logical. But if my salary was forty
ation, and yes, I would compromise. or fifty thousand [laughter]
Sita*: I would certainly take the job by paying Prashant Puppal: The price of that job would be
Rs 50,000, because that would save the family. If quite high in that case!
Puja: It is a practical situation.
* Names marked with an asterisk are not the partici- (To be concluded)
pants real names.
Mother Earth
Help, help! shouts Mother Earth. But no one listens her own children, who were the children of God.
to her, and she is forced to do the unpredictable, the Today humans are exploiting Mother Nature and
unthinkableshe is forced to bring about DOOMSDAY , stripping her of all her riches and energy. Human have
killing and destroying everything she had ever created become more and more greedy and what Gandhiji once
out of remorse. Never had she done this before, never said, Nature has everything for mans need but not for
had she even thought of it, never had she wanted to kill his greed, is very much applicable today.
It is high time we awaken

from our slumber of igno-
rance and greed and learn
to respect the life-giving
Mother Earth for the be-
nevolent gifts that she has
showered upon us since
the beginning of time.
We need to preserve the
nurturer of all creatures,
the forever-green and all-
generous Mother Earth.
Artwork by Manjunath M
Script by Sagar G Nahar
Class Ten, Sri Ramakrishna
Vidyalaya, Mysore
256
Buddha in Swami Vivekanandas Eyes
Swami Sandarshanananda
(Continued from the previous issue)
T
hree personalities profoundly moved Swami it as being opposed to the tmavda of the Upani-
Vivekananda in his youth: Buddha, Sri Ra- shads. But Swamiji is not perplexed by this seem-
makrishna, and Pavhari Baba of Ghazipur. ing dichotomy. He was able to see that, by tm
Buddha he had studied deeply, and his brief asso- or self, Buddha never meant the absolute Self or
ciation with Pavhari Baba was sufficient for him to paramtm. Swamiji equates Buddhas tm with
confirm his exalted spiritual state. But it was only the mind, which is in a state of flux and has no
in Sri Ramakrishna, whom Swamiji examined day permanent existence. He learnt from Sri Rama-
in and day out, that he found Buddha. About his krishna that a man attains Brahmajnana as soon as
master he says: His life is a searchlight of infinite his mind is annihilated (776). When the mind and
power thrown upon the whole mass of Indian re- ego die, the Selfthe only changeless Substance,
ligious thought. He was the living commentary to which is again the material as well as efficient cause
the Vedas and to their aim. He had lived in one of the universeis directly perceived. By nirvana
life the whole cycle of the national religious exist- Buddha would have meant annihilation of mind or
ence in India.14 Seeing Sri Ramakrishnas samadhi destruction of the small self, the ego, which is the
and hearing from him about his experience in that seat of all ignorance and the root of all suffering.
state must have given Swamiji insights into Bud- Swamiji had a vigorous discussion about Bud-
dhas nirvana. With his sharp intellect and monistic dha with his guru on 9 April 1886. He said that
training, he would have quickly understood that Buddha could not express in words what he had
the nirvana of Buddhism and samadhi are identi- realized by his tapasy. So people say he was an
cal, both being realizations of the ultimate Reality. atheist. The conversation continued:
He was aware that academic deliberation alone can- Master: Why atheist? He was not an atheist.
not remove confusion but rather creates it. So Sri He simply could not express his inner experiences
Ramakrishnas remarks on Buddha, illumined as in words. Do you know what Buddha means? It
they were by the Masters realization, would have is to become one with Bodha, Pure Intelligence,
immediately struck Swamiji as being authentic. Sri by meditating on That which is of the nature of
Ramakrishna declares: I have heard a great deal Pure Intelligence; it is to become Pure Intelligence
Itself.
about Buddha. He is one of the ten Incarnations of Narendra: Yes, sir. There are three classes of
God. Brahman is immoveable, immutable, inactive, Buddhas: Buddha, Arhat, and Bodhisattva.
and of the nature of Consciousness. When a man Master: This too is a sport of God Himself,
merges his buddhi, his intelligence, in Bodha, Con- a new ll of God.
sciousness, then he attains the Knowledge of Brah- Why should Buddha be called an atheist?
man; he becomes buddha, enlightened.15 Needless When one realizes Svarupa, the true nature of
to say, Vivekanandas conviction that nirvana and ones Self, one attains a state that is something be-
tween asti, is, and nsti, is-not.
brahma-jnna or knowledge of Brahman are iden-
Narendra (to M.): It is a state in which con-
tical was surely reinforced when he himself experi- tradictions meet.
enced samadhi by the blessings of his guru. In that state both activity and non-activity are
Buddhas antmavda or doctrine of no-self is possible; that is to say, one then performs unself-
an oft-misunderstood principle; scholars often take ish action.
PB April 2008 257
Worldly people, who are engrossed in sense- him to close the divide between faith and reason.
objects, say that everything existsasti. But the In order to do this, he had, as Radhakrishnan puts
myvdis, the illusionists, say that nothing ex- it, only to rid the Upanishads of their inconsistent
istsnsti. The experience of a Buddha is beyond compromises with Vedic polytheism and religion,
both existence and non-existence.
set aside the transcendental aspect as being inde-
Master: This existence and non-existence
are attributes of Prakriti. The Reality is beyond monstrable to thought and unnecessary to mor-
both. als, and emphasise the ethical universalism of the
What did Buddha preach? Upaniads.18 Buddha accepts the law of karma
Narendra: He did not discuss the existence like all the orthodox systems of philosophyand
or non-existence of God. But he showed compas- his view of suffering as an unavoidable fact of life
sion for others all his life (9478). is shared by nearly all schools of Indian thought.
Sri Ramakrishna didnt say anything more. This Hence, his doctrine cannot be considered an aber-
clearly indicates his satisfaction with Narendra ration of Indian thought; rather, as Radhakrishnan
Swamijifor understanding that Buddhas experi- says, Buddhism, in its origin at least, is an offshoot
ence was nothing but the non-dualistic experience of Hinduism, thus justifying the epithet rebel child
taught in the Upanishads, an experience in which of Hinduism applied by Swamiji (361).
he himself was adept. He must have been specially Swamiji describes how Buddha strove for illumi-
happy that Swamiji so admired Buddhas compas- nation, until he reached that supersensuous state of
sion, for he knew that Swamiji too was born to al- mind. All his teachings came through this, and not
leviate the misery of the world. through intellectual cogitations.19 In that state he
The crude materialism that Buddha had to en- discovered the law of dependent origination, an
counter taught: Eat, drink, and be merry; there eternal law governing the phenomenal world. The
is no God, soul, or heaven; religion is a concoc- goal is permanent liberation from its control. So
tion of wicked priests.16 It preached the morality he does not care for dualist gods but only for a
that so long as one lives one must try to enjoy, even supersensuous state of existence, where the law of
borrowing money from others and not thinking dependent origination does not hold.
of returning the debt. It was a popular philosophy
that easily captured the imagination of the people. Dependent Origination
To save people from this menace Buddha brought In Buddhas view, everything is an aggregate of qual-
the teachings of Vedanta to all without restriction. ities, hence inevitably a compound. And that which
Swamiji says: This Advaita was never allowed to is compounded is ever-changing and has no perma-
come to the people. At first some monks got hold nent existence. Therefore, the world, being a con-
of it and took it to the forests By the mercy of glomerate of combinations, is in a state of constant
the Lord, the Buddha came and preached it to the flux, having no permanent substratum to bear the
masses (2.138). Thus he rescued India from hide- ceaseless flow of change. It is neither real nor un-
ous practices. real but something in between. Similarly, body and
mind are two separate entities constantly chang-
He Preached the Highest Philosophy ing in form, two streams, of matter and thought
Sister Nivedita remembers that chief of intellec- respectively. The close succession of changes ap-
tual passions with the Swami, was his reverence for pears as a unityan illusion of continuity, like the
Buddha.17 Buddhas philosophical insight, Swamiji circle of fire produced by a whirling torch. There
believed, was directly inspired by Upanishadic is no immutable substance within them sustaining
thought. He deemed Buddhas view as one of the their flux; they are self-sufficient. To be caught in
most original in its scientific spirit, which enabled this flux and momentariness is to lose freedom and
258 PB April 2008
suffer through endless births. The only remedy is telligence operating within time and space.
emancipation from the vicious circle of causation, Buddha says, to withdraw from flux is to attain
the cycle of dependent origination. nirvana. In deep contemplation, the mind and body
Buddha, before his awakening, lamented, In are found to be substance-less and therefore illu-
what miserable condition are the people! They are sory. But according to Yoga-Vedanta, with further
born, they decay, they die, pass away and are born progress it becomes clear that there is an unchange-
again; and they do not know the path of escape able substratum on which the changing mind and
from this path of decay, death and misery.20 At en- body are projected, a fact many Mahayana schools
lightenment, he discovered that this cycle of sam- seem to implicitly accept. When this substratum is
sara is powered by a chain of twelve links. In fact, he perceived, one can no longer be deluded by them,
found that all of relative existence is bound in a web for one sees that they have no independent exist-
of cause and effect; nothing has an independent ence. Hence, in that state there is nothing to be
existence of its own. He then formulated the law observed. But there still persists that which real-
of dependent origination, with each of the twelve izesthough there is no differentiation between
links or nidnas, giving rise to the next. At the root subject and object. There is yet one more step: with
lies avidy or ignorance, which leads to saskra the ripening of non-dual realization, everything
or mental constructs, which results in vijna or that was denied earlier is cognized as real. The ex-
relative consciousness, which has nma-rpa or perience of unity of the phenomenal world and its
name-and-form as its object; this is accomplished observer is the most blessed condition, which Bud-
by the ayatana or six sense organs (including dha describes as nirvana or nya. nya, accord-
the mind), through spara or sense-contact, which ingly, is not negative but something most positive
leads to vedan or feeling, which produces t that destroys the last trace of ignorance sprouting
or desire, and updna or clinging, which leads from the notion of duality.
to bhava or becoming, to jti or birth, and to jar- Buddhas followers gave a different interpreta-
maraa or old age and death. tion, since they wanted to assert the independence
These twelve links turn the wheel of samsara. of Buddhas philosophical framework from the
With the extinction of ignorance, which is the root ideas of the Upanishads. Swamiji points out their
cause, all the other causes involved in the cycle also defects with unfettered voice:
cease, putting an end to rebirth and suffering. Bud-
So far as the Buddhists say that the whole universe
dha observed that in nirvana alone is ignorance is a mass of change, they are perfectly right; so
annihilated and are beings released from the shack- long as I am separate from the universe, so long as
les of dependent origination. But he uses no word I stand back and look at something before me, so
other than nya or void to describe nirvana. This long as there are two thingsthe looker-on and
mute stance eloquently conveys his profound feel- the thing looked uponit will appear always that
ings, which resonate with the non-dualistic teach- the universe is one of change, continuously chang-
ings of the Upanishads. Swamiji praises the way ing all the time. But the reality is that there is both
these thoughts are knit, and says: We see how won- change and changelessness in this universe. It is
derful some of these arguments are, and they appeal not that the soul and the mind and the body are
three separate existences, for this organism made
easily to the ordinary experience of humanityin
of these three is really one. It is the same thing
fact, not one in a million can think of anything which appears as the body, as the mind, and as the
other than phenomena (2.273). Buddha points the thing beyond mind and body, but it is not at the
way to freedom; he knows that the ultimate truth is same time all these. He who sees the body does
beyond reason, beyond mind and speecha mat- not see the mind even, he who sees the mind does
ter of Pure Intelligence, far beyond the limited in- not see that which he calls the soul, and he who
PB April 2008 259
sees the soulfor him the body and mind have if I had only one drop of that strength! The sanest
vanished. He who sees only motion never sees ab- philosopher the world ever saw (3.5289).
solute calm, and he who sees absolute calmfor
him motion has vanished.21 Conclusion
Swamiji sees their view of the denial of existence Swami Vivekananda does hold Buddha responsi-
of self, or substance, and acceptance of qualities as a ble for the degeneration of Buddhism. But, never
miscalculation, for qualities are seen by an ordinary theless, he praises him for the missionary zeal he
man and substance by a realized person; they are infused in his followers, a zeal that eventually called
not at the same level of perception, differing in their forth the first historical outburst of a world re-
spiritual attainments. Buddha had the same concept ligion. On the other hand, he also holds that by
in mind. He separated sense experience from expe- popularizing monasticism, Buddha brought about
rience of the superconscious state. He said: There societys downfall. He argues:
is an unborn, an unoriginated, an unmade, an un- Monasticism is all very good for a few; but when
compounded; were there not, O mendicants, there you preach it in such a fashion that every man
would be no escape from the world of the born, the or woman who has a mind immediately gives up
originated, the made, and the compounded.22 social life, when you find over the whole of India
Buddha was an avowed proponent of renun- monasteries, some containing a hundred thousand
ciation. He inducted so many men and women monks, sometimes twenty thousand monks in one
into the order of monks and nuns because he be- building who were left to procreate progeny, to
lieved in annihilation of all imperfection through continue the race? Only the weaklings. All the
the sacrifice of material enjoyments, considering strong and vigorous minds went out. And then
came national decay by the sheer loss of vigour
that as a compulsory precondition for realizing
(3.5334).
the perfect supersensuous state of abiding peace
and happiness. The folly of making monasticism commonplace
This Vedantic attitude of Buddha was always at- exacted an enormous price. Buddhas principles
tractive to Swamiji. He said, I always cling to the of poverty and purity were supplanted by plenty
idea set forth with one voice by Christ, Buddha, and and pretension. Admission to the order was freely
the Vedanta, that we must all come to the perfection given; that the life of renunciation is not suitable
in time, but only by giving up this imperfection.23 for all, that it requires great inner preparation, was
By imperfection he means jvatva, or the apparent seemingly overlooked. Consequently, in time the
man, which in Buddhas language is the one who is order was unable to provide moral sustenance to
born, originated, made, and compounded. Christ, society, which began to slide downwards. Swamiji
Buddha, and Vedantafinding them rooted in the calls the result a mass of corruption. He says: I
same spiritual values, Swamiji names them in the have every respect and veneration for Lord Bud-
same breath with equal reverence. The teachings dha, but mark my words, the spread of Buddhism
of Buddha and the Upanishads, however, differ in was less owing to the doctrines and personality of
their points of emphasis: the former emphasizes the the great preacher, than to the temples that were
impermanence of sense experience, and the latter built, the idols that were erected, and the gorgeous
the permanent and immutable reality behind it, but ceremonials that were put before the nation (3.217).
in the end they say the same thing. Swamiji gives his Swamiji felt ashamed even to mention the vulgar
final reading on Buddha: Stern, sane, every brain- depths to which Buddhism fell.
cell perfect and complete, even at the moment of But there is a perennial dynamic in India that
death. No delusion. I do not agree with many of naturally absorbs such cyclical shocks to the field
his doctrines. You may not. But in my opinionoh, of dharma. When the time was ripe, the old reli-
260 PB April 2008
gion drew it in, exalting Buddha as an incarnation That Shiva-worship, in various forms, ante-
of God; Buddhism thus lost its status as a separate dated the Buddhists, that the Buddhists tried to
religion in India. As Swamiji says, This gigantic get hold of the sacred places of the Shaivas but,
child was absorbed, in the long run, by the mother failing in that, made new places in the precincts
that gave it birth (3.512). By and by, a new era of the just as you find now at Bodh-Gaya and Sarnath
(Varanasi).
Sanatana Dharma, the Religion Eternal, emerged
Gaya was a place of ancestor-worship already,
with the appearance of Shankaracharya and oth- and the footprint-worship the Buddhists copied
ers following him; they dexterously purged it of from the Hindus.
the accumulated dross and restored Hinduism to Many are the new facts I have gathered in Bodh-
its true form. Gaya and from Buddhist literature.
Buddha allowed all to join the order; and ma- A total revolution has occurred in my mind
terialism later stifled it. His mission can be seen about the relation of Buddhism and Neo-Hindu-
as contributing to the later collapse of India by ism. I may not live to work out the glimpses, but I
rendering the Indian race intrinsically powerless, shall leave the lines of work indicated, and you and
through the practice of non-injury and detachment your brethren will have to work it out (5.1723).
from temporal affairs. These are, broadly, reasons Swamiji has given us enough food for thought.
for which Swamiji sometimes criticizes Buddha; He points out that there are many things in Bud-
and he freely speaks his mind: I love the Masters dhism which are untenable and demand fresh as
ideal. Great! But, for me, I do not think that the well as unprejudiced research. But he does not deny
working was very practical; and that was one of the that Buddha contributed immensely to the devel-
great causes that led to the downfall of the Indian opment of India. He is full of praise for monasteries,
nation, in the long run (3.535). However, he never schools, colleges, hospitals, veterinary refuges, rich
commingles Buddhas work with his character; for architecture, art, and sculpture left by Buddhism.
that draws his inspired admiration to the last. Bud- His view in this regard is unequivocal: What was
dha was born at a crucial juncture in Indian history. there in this country before Buddhas advent? Only a
The prevailing circumstances warranted his advent. number of religious principles recorded on bundles
He led an exemplary life to be emulated for all time. of palm leavesand those too known only to a few.
In Swami Vivekanandas eyes, Buddha was the fin- It was Lord Buddha who brought them down to the
est fruit of humanity. practical field and showed how to apply them in the
It will not be inappropriate to present here ex- everyday life of the people. In a sense, he was the liv-
cerpts from Swamijis letter of 9 February 1902 to ing embodiment of true Vedanta (7.1189). P
his disciple Swami Swarupananda. Written a few
References
months before his passing away, the letter dem- 14. Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 7.483.
onstrates how Swamiji was engrossed in Buddha 15. M, The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna, trans. Swami
and Buddhism, even through the last months of Nikhilananda (Chennai: Ramakrishna Math,
his life: 2002), 430.
There are references in Buddhistic literature, to 16. Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 2.139.
Vedanta, and the Mahayana school of Buddhism 17. Complete Works of Sister Nivedita, 171.
18. Indian Philosophy, 36061.
is even Advaitistic. Why does Amara Singha, a
19. Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 2.61.
Buddhist, give as one of the names of Buddha 20. Samyutta Nikaya, 11.5.
Advayavdi? 21. Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 2.274.
I hold the Mahayana to be the older of the two 22. Udana, 8.3, quoted in Swami Prabhavananda, The
schools of Buddhism. Spiritual Heritage Of India (London: George Allen
I have had much light of late about Buddhism, & Unwin, 1962), 181.
and I am ready to prove: 23. Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 2.174.
PB April 2008 261

Sri Ramakrishna:
Patron Saint of the Bengali Stage
Swami Chetanananda Star Theatre
Beadon Street, Calcutta (188388)
G
irishchandra Ghosh, the noted and prudish Bengalis considered Ramakrishnas
Bengali playwright and prominent disciple action, and his subsequent visits to the theatre, to
of Sri Ramakrishna, brought his master to be unpardonable.
see many of his plays. And by doing so, Girish made The first repercussions came from the Brahmos.
him the patron saint of the Bengali stage. Through Hemendranath Dasgupta wrote:
his plays, Girish carried Ramakrishnas message to Many people of the Brahmo Samaj stopped visit-
the red-light districts of Calcutta. ing Ramakrishna. After Keshab Sen passed away
Christopher Isherwood notes: In those days, on 8 January 1884, Vijaykrishna Goswami became
actresses in the Bengali theatre were regarded as devoted to the Master. Shivanath Shastri, however,
no better than prostitutesa prejudice which also stopped coming to him. Some people asked Shiva
persisted in England until at least the beginning of nath: Previously you were devoted to the Master.
the nineteenth century.1 About Girishs disciple- Why do you not visit him anymore? Shivanath
ship to Ramakrishna, he observes: One curious replied: How can I go to see him? He is now con-
result of their association is that, today, Rama nected with the immoral people of the theatre. I
krishnas picture is to be found hanging backstage cant go to Dakshineswar anymore.2
in nearly every theatre in Calcutta. The actors bow One day Ramakrishna discussed Girish with
to it before they make their entrances. By giving Ashwini Datta, a devout Hindu philanthropist.
his approval to Girishs art and encouraging him Do you know Girish Ghosh? Ramakrishna
to continue practising it, Ramakrishna became, as asked.
it were, the patron saint of the drama in Bengal Which Girish Ghosh? The one who is in the
(254). theatre?
Nowadays it is no disgrace to go to the theatre, Yes.
opera, or cinema. On the contrary, one is consid- I have never seen him. But I know him by
ered to be uncultured, uneducated, and unsophis- reputation.
ticated if one does not attend such cultural events. A good man.
But in Ramakrishnas time, conservative Hindu so- They say he drinks.
ciety in Bengal, the progressive Brahmo Samaj, and Let him! Let him! How long will he continue
other groups abhorred the stage because they con- that?3
sidered the performers to be immoral drunkards, Ramchandra Datta, a Vaishnava and a staunch
debauchees, and prostitutes. Theatres were there- devotee of Ramakrishna, did not approve of the
fore considered to be sinful places. Under these Masters visits to the theatre either. Girish wrote:
circumstances, it was shocking when Sri Rama Wherever the Master went, Ramchandra invari-
krishna Paramahamsa, who was regarded as an il- ably accompanied him. But when the Master came
lumined soul and even as an avatara, went to see to the theatre, Ram did not comebut he did have
Girishs Chaitanya Lila on 24 September 1884 at food sent to him [Ramakrishna]. Ram considered
the Star Theatre in Calcutta. Some conservative the theatre to be a sinful place.4
262 PB April 2008
Sri Ramakrishna: Patron Saint of the Bengali Stage 41
M recorded in the Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna: eshub and Ramakrishna. If, as we are told, he
K
Sri Ramakrishna was planning to go to a per- did not show sufficient moral abhorrence of pros-
formance of the Chaitanyall at the Star Theatre. titutes, he does not stand quite alone in this among
Mahendra Mukherji was to take him to Calcutta the founders of religion. If he did not honour the
in his carriage. They were talking about choosing principle of teetotalism according to Western no-
good seats. Some suggested that one could see the tions, no one, as far as I know, has ever accused
performance well from the one-rupee gallery. Ram him of any excess in drinking. Such bickerings
said, Oh, no! I shall engage a box for him. The and cavillings would have been most distasteful
Master laughed. Some of the devotees said that both to Keshub Chunder Sen and to Ramakrishna.
public women took part in the play. They took the Both had no words but words of praise and love for
parts of Nimi, Niti, and others. each other, and it was a great pity that their mutual
Master (to the devotees): I shall look upon relation should have been treated in a jealous spirit,
them as the Blissful Mother Herself. What if one and thereby totally misrepresented.6
of them acts the part of Chaitanya? An imitation The Brahmos charged that Ramakrishna did
custard-apple reminds one of the real fruit.5 not show sufficient moral abhorrence of prosti-
Modern readers may not be bothered by the tutes. In his review of the book, Swami Viveka-
idea of Ramakrishnas visiting theatres, mixing with nanda wrote:
drunken actors, and addressing immoral actresses Again another charge put forward is that he did
as Blissful Mother. But for many years he and his not show sufficient moral abhorrence of prosti-
disciples had to face opposition and criticism from tutes. To this the Professors rejoinder is very very
prominent citizens and from society in general. sweet indeed; he says that in this charge Rama-
People spoke out against the Master even after he krishna does not stand quite alone among the
founders of religion! Ah! How sweet are these
passed away in 1886.
wordsthey remind one of the prostitute Amba
For example, in August 1896, Max Mller wrote pali, the object of Lord Buddhas divine grace, and
an article on Ramakrishna entitled A Real Mahat- of the Samaritan woman who won the grace of the
man. A relative of Keshab Chandra Sen, the fa- Lord Jesus Christ.
mous Brahmo leader, became very jealous. When Yet again, another charge is that he did not
Max Mller planned to write a biography of Rama- hate those who were intemperate in their hab-
krishna, this man wrote to him in an attempt to its. Heaven save the mark! One must not tread
change his views. I could not locate the contents even on the shadow of a man, because he took a
sip or two of drinkis not that the meaning? A
of that letter, but Max Mller commented on it in
formidable accusation indeed! Why did not the
Ramakrishna: His Life and Sayings: Mahapurusha kick away and drive off in disgust
A relative of Keshub Chunder Sen, however, who the drunkards, the prostitutes, the thieves, and all
evidently completely misapprehended what was the sinners of the world! And why did he not, with
implied by the influence which I said that Rama- eyes closed, talk in a set drawl after the never-to-
krishna had exercised on Keshub Chunder Sen, be-varied tone of the Indian flute-player, or talk in
[Pratap] Mozoomdar, and others as his disciples, conventional language concealing his thoughts!7
is very anxious to establish the priority of Keshub
Chunder Sen, as if there could be priority in philo- With their redeeming power, avataras transform
sophical or religious truth. It was Keshub Chun- peoples characters and make sinners into saints.
der, he tells us, who brought Ramakrishna out of
One morning Jesus went to the temple. People
obscurity. That may be so, but how often have dis-
ciples been instrumental in bringing out their mas- gathered around him. While he was teaching
ter? He then continues to bring charges against them, a group that included teachers of Jewish law
Ramakrishna, which may be true or not, but have and Pharisees brought in a woman who had been
nothing to do with the true relation between caught committing adultery. They said to Jesus:
PB April 2008 263
Teacher, this woman was caught in the very act to Ambapalis house. After they had eaten, Amba
of committing adultery. In our Law, Moses com- pali sat at Buddhas feet and offered her mansion
manded that such a woman must be stoned to and mango grove to his order, which he accepted.
death. Now, what do you say? They said this to Her whole life was transformed and she became a
trap Jesus. Jesus kept quiet at first, but when they follower of the Blessed One.
repeated the question, he replied, Whichever one There is a saying: A church is not a museum for
of you who has committed no sin may throw the saints. It is a hospital for sinners. It is amazing how
first stone at her. When they heard this, they all left, love, compassion, and forgiveness are misunder-
one by one. Only Jesus remained with the woman. stood by so-called civilized people. When Rama-
He then asked her: Where are they? Is there no krishna was criticized for his visits to the theatre,
one left to condemn you? his compassion for the actors and actresses, and his
No one, sir, she answered. appreciation for their art, his devotees and disciples
Well, then, Jesus said, I do not condemn you came forward to defend their guru.
either. Go, but do not sin again.8 In the beginning, Ramchandra Datta did not
Hatred cannot be conquered by hatred; it can approve of the Masters patronage of the theatre.
be conquered only by love, said Buddha. Towards Later, however, he realized that every one of the
the end of his life, Buddha travelled to Kushinagara Masters actions had deep meaning and significance,
from Rajagriha and took shelter in the mango grove and that he had used his redeeming power to save
of the courtesan Ambapali. When she heard of this, those wayward souls of the stage. In the 1890s Ram
she went to visit the Blessed One. As a prudent began to lecture now and then at the Star, City, and
woman goes forth to perform her religious duties, Minerva theatres on Ramakrishna and his teach-
so she appeared in a simple dress without any orna- ings. Ram published an article entitled Society and
ments, yet was beautiful to look upon. MoralityActing in the first issue of his magazine,
Buddha thought to himself: This woman Tattwamanjari. The writer of the article supported
moves in worldly circles and is a favourite of kings the theatre as a wonderful medium for carrying
and princes; yet is her heart calm and composed. education to the masses. He wrote: People are be-
Young in years, rich, surrounded by pleasures, she is ing improved by watching dramas in which the
thoughtful and steadfast. This, indeed, is rare in the actors and actresses unveil the mystery of spirit-
world. She, although living in luxury, has acquired ual truths. Those who have seen Girish Chandra
the wisdom of a master, taking delight in piety and Ghoshs Chaitanya Lila, Prabhas Yajna, and Bud
able to receive the truth in its completeness. dhadev Charit at the Star Theatre are truly uplifted
As Buddha presented his teachings, Ambapalis and inspired.10
face brightened with delight. She then arose and The writer defended employing courtesans by
humbly asked: Will the Blessed One do me the pointing out two facts: first, using male actors in
honour of taking his meal, together with the breth- female roles was not natural; second, at that time,
ren, at my house tomorrow? The Blessed One si- most women in mainstream society were not will-
lently gave his consent. ing or able to perform onstage. Therefore, society
Later, the wealthy people of the area came and in- should not despise actresses, but rather appreciate
vited Buddha to eat with them the next day. Buddha their talents and their efforts to lead an honest life.
declined, explaining, I have already promised to For many of the women, the rigid rules of society
dine tomorrow with Ambapali, the courtesan. They had forced them to become courtesans; in addition,
departed, saying, A worldly woman has outdone many of them were murdered every year. Regard-
us; we have been left behind by a frivolous girl.9 less, many actresses were not prostitutes as such,
The next morning Buddha and his disciples went but were poor women who became mistresses of
264 PB April 2008
wealthy menwhich was their only means of bet- those who have sinned and those who have not,
tering their condition. the saintly and the vicious, men and women and
In response to the concern that the characters children irrespective of age, all have equal right.
of young people would be damaged by watching That for one day at least in the year thousands of
these women act onstage, the writer concluded that men and women get rid of the sense of sin and
ideas of distinction and sing and hear the name of
youth who have wayward tendencies do not listen
the Lord, is in itself a supreme good.
to the advice of their parents and school teachers. 4. If even in a place of pilgrimage peoples ten-
He stated: Of course, it is true that evil company dency to evil be not curbed for one day, the fault
encourages evil tendencies. It is better for society if lies with you, not them. Create such a huge tidal
those who have wicked tendencies go to houses of wave of spirituality that whatever people come
ill fame rather than spread immorality among their near will be swept away.
own relatives or neighbours. 5. Those who, even in a chapel, would think
The actress controversy continued for a long this is a public woman, that man is of a low caste,
time. Swami Vivekananda had been an uncompro- a third is poor, and yet another belongs to the
massesthe less be the number of such people
mising puritan before he met Ramakrishna. On
(that is, whom you call gentlemen) the better. Will
6 July 1896 he wrote to Francis Leggett about his
they who look to the caste, sex, or profession of
transformation: At twenty years of age I was the Bhaktas appreciate our Lord? I pray to the Lord
most unsympathetic, uncompromising fanatic; I that hundreds of public women may come and
would not walk on the footpath on the theatre side bow their heads at His feet; it does not matter if
of the streets in Calcutta. At thirty-three, I can live not one gentleman comes. Come public women,
in the same house with prostitutes and never would come drunkards, come thieves and allHis Gate
think of saying a word of reproach to them. Is it de- is open to all. It is easier for a camel to pass through
generate? Or is it that I am broadening out into the the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the
Universal Love which is the Lord Himself ?11 Kingdom of God. Never let such cruel, demonia-
cal ideas have a place in your mind (6.36970).
Vivekananda wrote to Swami Ramakrishna
nanda from Switzerland on 23 August 1896: Intolerance, however, was not confined to
Bengali society; many Westerners also believed
Today I received a letter from Ramdayal Babu,
in which he writes that many public women at- the theatre to be sinful. During Swami Vivekanan-
tend the Ramakrishna anniversary festival at das visit to Paris in 1900, he wanted to hear the
Dakshineswar, which makes many less inclined to famous opera singer Emma Calv sing Carmen;
go there. Moreover, in his opinion, one day should he had known Madame Calv in America, where
be appointed for men and another for women. My she had attended many of his lectures. His Irish dis
decision on the point is this: ciple Sister Nivedita vehemently objected, as Liz-
1. If public women are not allowed to go to elle Reymond tells it in The Dedicated:
such a great place of pilgrimage as Dakshineswar,
I should like to see you in your favourite role,
where else shall they go to? It is for the sinful that
he [Swamiji] said to her. What is it?
the Lord manifests Himself specially, not so much Calv blushed as she answered, Its Carmen.
for the virtuous. Swamiji, you must pardon me, but every evening,
2. Let distinctions of sex, caste, wealth, learn- in spite of myself, I become that woman when I
ing, and the whole host of them, which are so sing and dance and play my castanets.
many gateways to hell, be confined to the world I shall come and hear you, said the Swami.
alone. If such distinctions persist in holy places of At this point Nivedita broke into the con
pilgrimage, where then lies the difference between versation.
them and hell itself ? But thats impossible, she said. Swamiji, you
3. Ours is a gigantic City of Jagannatha, where cant go to the Opra Comique; you will be
PB April 2008 265
severely criticized. fluenced not only Girish but also his actors and
The Swami looked at her in astonishment. His actresses. Binodini, who performed in the title
only reply was a tender smile. role in Chaitanya Lila as well as in many other of
And, two evenings later, accompanied by Girishs plays, wrote in her autobiography: I dont
Mr. Leggett, he not only went to hear the opera
care if the whole world looks down upon me, be-
but was taken to the stars dressing-room during
the intermission. Calv received him with some cause I know that the pure and venerable Rama-
embarrassment. krishna Paramahamsa blessed me. His hopeful and
I wanted to see your Carmen, Emma, he said. nectar-like message Hari guru, guru HariHari
Dont think shes a bad woman. She is just true. She is the guru and the guru is Haristill reassures me.
does not lie. And in her violence she expresses When I am oppressed by unbearable pain and ag-
her soul. She is of that superb race of women who ony, his forgiving and gracious form appears in my
say to the Divine Mother, after they have prayed heart and I hear his voice: SayHari guru, guru
to Her, Dont listen to my prayers, O Mother of
Hari. I dont remember how many times he came
God, for I want to die of my desire.12
to the theatre after Chaitanya Lila, but I saw his
Pravasi and other puritanical magazines in Cal- joyful face many times when he was seated in a box
cutta continued to criticize the practice of allow- seat of the theatre.14
ing courtesans to perform onstage, but Rangalaya, The actor Amritalal Basu wrote: When the
Rangamancha, Rangadarshan, Majlish, and other humble actress [Binodini] acted in the role of
publications supported the custom. The editor of Chaitanya, the incarnation of God of Nadia, on
Rangadarshan pointed out to Pravasi (a very popu- the stage, Sri Ramakrishna of Dakshineswar, an-
lar and powerful magazine) that the actresses raised other incarnation of God, watched that play and
money to support various philanthropic activities made the wretched stage like Vaikuntha [heaven].
benefiting society. For example, in the August 1901 We were blessed! The audience was blessed and so
issue, the editor of Rangalaya announced: There was the Mother Earth! The stage of the theatre be-
will be a Ramakrishna Festival in Kankurgachhi came a holy place when Sri Ramakrishna watched
Yogodyana for five days. To support this function, through his divine eyes the Chaitanya Lila, which
there will be a play in the Classic Theatre on Sun- was enacted on it. To watch Chaitanya Lila is no
day evening. The owner will donate all the proceeds longer considered to be enjoying an amusement, or
to that cause.13 A letter was published in the Au- being educated, or hearing kirtan; it is now consid-
gust 1911 issue of Rangamancha that read in part: ered to be witnessing a divine lila!15
The Minerva Theatre gave two benefit perform- The actor Aparesh Mukhopadhyay wrote:
ancesone for Ramakrishna Mission Sevashrama, When the theatre was first started, most people
Varanasi, and the other for the poor and sick fa- believed that those who act on stage are pariahs,
mous poet Rajanikanta Sen. The superstar Tinkari or outcastes. Girish once wrote in a drama, Who
and other actors and actresses did not receive any pays respect to a fallen courtesan? But there was
money for their performances (73). Miss Josephine someone who paid respect, and he was none other
MacLeod wrote in a letter on 19 February 1923: than a monk who had completely renounced lust
Going in the evening to a benefit performance at and gold! He put his palm on the head of a fallen
the Star Theatre, for Ramakrishna Mission of Bhu- actress and blessed her, saying, May you be illu-
baneswar, near Puri. The great Indian actress Tara mined (745).
coming out of retirement for it (ibid.). Amar Datta, the editor of Natya Mandir, used
Ramakrishnas picture on the cover of one of the
It is amazing to see the extent of Ramakrishnas magazines issues. Within, he commented: We
influence in the Calcutta theatre worldhe in- have printed the picture of Bhagavan Sri Rama-
266 PB April 2008
krishna on the cover page of the current issue of krishna, however, approved of it. Basanta Kumar
Natya Mandir. Someone may ask why I have used Ghosh wrote an article entitled Bengali Women
the picture of the avatara Ramakrishna in a maga- and the Theatre in Natya Mandir: Being im-
zine that is full of pictures of actors and actresses. pressed with their artistic skill and performances,
Here is my answer: According to the Natya Mandir Bhagavan Ramakrishna blessed the courtesan ac-
this whole world is a theatre. All human beings act tresses. It was a great achievement of an actress
as actors and actresses on its stage every day. When [Binodini], who brought a great soul to the thea-
the fallen ones forget to act in their proper roles tre and sanctified it (756).
according to the will of the Creator, the univer- Those days are gone. Nowadays, upper-class men
sal Director descends on the world stage. Thus a and women do not hesitate to become actors and
masterly Director was once born in a remote place actresses, and their family members are proud of
of Bengal. He lived in the holy temple compound them.
of Dakshineswar near Calcutta and attracted the In the Hindu tradition, Shiva is sometimes
learned and the illiterate, the rich and the poor. known as Nataraja, the king of actors. Actors and
He imprinted in the hearts of seekers: This world actresses worship Nataraja by their performances,
is apparent and not absolutely real, and the goal of so their profession cannot be considered sinful. If
human life is to realize God. No one was deprived Binodini had appealed to the prominent members
of his teachingbe that person a sadhu or a yogi, of Calcutta society thusI was born poor, in a
a sinner or a fallen woman. Incognito, he appeared red-light district. My mother was a courtesan, so I
as a poor and humble human being and mixed with followed in her footsteps. I know that society hates
all equally, out of pure love and compassion. The our profession. God has endowed me with a talent
holy feet of this divine beingthe saviour of the for acting. Is it wrong if I want to change my pro-
fallentouched the national theatre of Bengal. Or- fession and become an actress? Is it sinful to act in
dinary people despised the theatre, considering it the role of Chaitanya and bring the audience to a
to be an abode of immoral men and women, but spiritual realm?we dont know what they would
heaven and hell were equal in the eyes of that great have answered. We leave Binodinis question to the
deliverer of sinners. So Ramakrishnathe teacher reader to answer. In this world there are thousands
of humankind, the man-god, the compassionate of Binodinis who are used and abused, neglected
onecame to the theatre. The touch of his holy and persecuted, ill-treated and hated, and who are
feet sanctified the stage by wiping out all impuri- waiting for the right answer.
ties, enhanced its dignity and beauty, and made it
an attractive and wonderful place (75). Girish remarked: Chaitanya Lila was my all in
At that time, the magazines and papers con- all. I received the grace of my guru through that
nected with the Bengali stage gave tremendous play (77). Through that play the Bengali stage ac-
importance to Ramakrishnas visits to the theatre. quired its patron saint. Undoubtedly it was Girish
Until Ramakrishna sanctified the theatre with his who made Ramakrishna the presiding deity of the
presence, most Bengalis considered houses of ill Bengali theatre. At that time, Girish was carried
repute and theatres to be more or less the same. away by a great current of devotion. People in the
Ramakrishnas patronage lifted the taboo. Going theatre were overwhelmed by his gigantic personal-
to see plays became socially acceptable. ity and followed him spontaneously. Girish whole-
The great reformer Ishwar Chandra Vidyasagar heartedly believed that on the pretext of seeing a
fought all his life for womens liberation, but he play, the avatara Ramakrishna had come to the thea-
dissociated himself from the theatre because he tre to deliver his message to actors and actresses. As
disapproved of women performing onstage. Rama- manager and director of the theatre, Girish would
PB April 2008 267
personally introduce to the Master those perform- all the odd and wicked ones, the drunkards and
ers who had some devotion for him. prostitutes.
When a famous person comes to see a play, it is Manomohan: That is the reason the Master at-
natural for the cast members to become inspired tracted you. If you can captivate and change the
and act more enthusiastically than they normally most nefarious sinner, then others will be capti-
would. But the actors in Girishs plays were even vated easily.
more thrilled when Ramakrishna attended a per- Girish: Even the courtesans are flocking to me.
formance. Previously they had been treated as un- Before they appear onstage, they bow down to the
touchables, but Ramakrishna gave their morale a Masters picture and then take the dust of my feet.
tremendous boost and helped them achieve recog- If I do not allow them to touch my feet, they get
nition and respect in society. The performers would offended and cannot act wholeheartedly. I am now
talk about Ramakrishna while dressing and putting in trouble! (789).
on their make-up in the green room. After the play, The tradition of bowing down to Ramakrishna
they would assemble in Girishs room. One night, before going onstage still continues in Calcutta.
at a gathering at the Kohinoor Theatre, the actress The Masters picture is decorated with a garland
Tarasundari said: With the type of life we have led, every night before a performance, and someone
there is no deliverance for us. waves lights and incense. It is astonishing that even
Girish: Dont say that, Tara. Dont you re- now there are pictures of Ramakrishna in Calcutta
member your aunt Bini [Binodini]? The Master theatres, in the green room, in the parlour, and in
was moved by her acting in the role of Chaitanya some actors private dressing rooms. Even the tech-
and blessed her, saying, Mother, may you attain nical workers of the theatre do not start their work
illumination. before saluting Ramakrishna. Girish, a man who
Abinash: Binodini is now a devotee and wor- once called himself an atheist, is responsible for in-
ships Gopala. troducing this tradition.
Amritalal Basu also had a role in Chaitanya Lila, The following story illustrates how deeply Rama
but he avoided Ramakrishna because he thought krishnas teachings permeated the red-light districts
himself a sinner. Later Girish took him to the Mas- of Calcutta: A courtesan died in a nursing home a
ter and changed his whole life, as is described in his few years ago. Some young people went to a monk
memoirs (778). of the Ramakrishna Order in Calcutta and in-
After Ramakrishnas passing away, Girish be- formed him that they needed 26,000 rupees to
came the Masters representative to the people of cremate that woman. The swami learned from them
the theatre, as well as their guide. One day Ram- who she was and found information about her will
chandra Datta and Manomohan Mitra, staunch and the executor of her estate. He then talked to
devotees of the Master, went to visit Girish at his the executor, a prominent political leader in that
home. While smoking a hubble-bubble, Girish area, and was informed that the woman had left
said: Brother Ram, the Master has possessed me. everything to a hospital of the Ramakrishna Mis-
He is bringing all sorts of people to me. This way- sion. The swami gave the money to those young
ward Raju, a nephew of Akshay Sen, is pestering people for her cremation and later went to her
me to take him to the Holy Mother and to the home with the police. From her house he recov-
monastery. ered half a million rupees in cash, half a million ru-
Ram: You are ordained to do that. But what pees worth of jewellery, and a certificate of deposit
good will it do if you take him? Dont you see his worth one million rupees. The swami also found in
character? her home some books about Ramakrishna as well
Girish: Yes, you are right. The Master left me as his picture.16
268 PB April 2008
That unknown courtesan must have been a great 7. The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda, 9 vols
soul! She left everything she had to Ramakrishna. (Calcutta: Advaita Ashrama, 18, 1989; 9, 1997),
4.41819.
Although her profession kept her body in the world,
8. John, 8.211.
her devotion connected her mind with Ramakri- 9. Adapted from Paul Carus, The Gospel of Buddha
shnathe man-Godthe Saviour of the soul.P (New Delhi: Publications Division of Government
of India, 1961), 1837.
References 10. Nalini Ranjan Chattopadhyay, Sri Ramakrishna
1. Christopher Isherwood, Ramakrishna and His Dis- O Banga Rangamancha (Calcutta: Mandal Book
ciples (Calcutta: Advaita Ashrama, 1974), 292. House, 1978), 678.
2. Hemendranath Dasgupta, Sri Sri Ramakrishnadev 11. Complete Works, 6.366.
O Bhakta-Bhairav Girishchandra (Calcutta, 1953), 32. 12. Lizelle Reymond, The Dedicated (New York: John
3. M, The Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna, trans. Swami Day, 1953), 222.
Nikhilananda (Chennai: Ramakrishna Math, 13. Banga Rangamancha, 723.
2002), 1026. 14. Binodini Dasi, Amar Katha O Anyanya Rachana
4. Girish Rachanavali, ed. Devipada Bhattacharya (Calcutta: Subarnarekha, 1987), 47; Banga Ranga-
(Calcutta: Sahitya Samsad, 2002), 5.291. mancha, 74.
5. Gospel, 546. 15. Banga Rangamancha, 74.
6. Max Mller, Ramakrishna: His Life and Sayings 16. Told by a swami (who prefers to remain anony-
(Advaita Ashrama: Calcutta, 1988), 667. mous) to the author in 2004.
Impact of Knowledge and Ignorance
Lost in the dark ignorance of the world,

We, The children of God,
Cut trees fit, Arise, awake Only Knowledge will lead you
For our own benefit; Said the Lords, To the better half of man;
Kill, Harm and Destroy, For your own sake With education true
The creatures of joy. Or face the odds. You will truly become a better man.
Art by Manunath M; Script by Sagar G Nahar; Class Ten, Sri Ramakrishna Vidyalaya, Mysore
PB April 2008 269

American Indians
and Indians:
Echoes across
Time
Rajaram Suryanarayanan
C
Library of Congress, Washington DC
olumbus discovered America is a air. Soon conflicts started breaking out be-
schoolhouse truth drummed into the tween them. There were enough reasons for
brains of schoolchildrenbut what this.
about the Americans that were living in Amer- What, one may ask, is so interesting about
ica already, who were discovered by him? Co- these peoples or tribes who are now commonly
lumbus believed that he had actually landed called the American Indians? One answerthe
in India and took the people he saw there to one I have foundis wisdom. Yes, these peoples
be Indians. Thus came the terms American In- were real kings of wisdom, and I was amazed
dian and Red Indian, by which the native in- to find many striking similarities between their
habitants of the American continent came to wisdom and the wisdom of the Indian Indi-
be known. ansthat is, the ancient Hindus.
It is believed that the Native Americans I was much surprised to see that the es-
have been living in the continents of North sence of their wisdom was very much akin to
and South America from at least as early as that which is found in the Upanishads and Ve-
30,000 years ago. Only in the sixteenth cen- das, and which has been nurtured by Hinduism
tury did white Europeans start to migrate to through the ages.
the newly discovered land, bringing with them In this article I have tried to share some of
lots of desires and expectations. When they set my findings of correlations between the insights
their foot on American soil, they were met by of the American Indians and the timeless truths
the Native Americans, and both sides looked expressed in the Vedas and Upanishads and of-
upon the other with a puzzled and suspicious ten reiterated by Swami Vivekananda.
270 PB April 2008
Prayers for Well-being, Peace, and Strength
Shanti mantras or prayers for peace form an
integral part of Hindu religious activity. Ve-
dic chanting includes these prayers, which
seek divine guidance and peace for all beings,
starting from ones own self. This well-known
shanti mantra from the Taittiriya Aranyaka be-
gins with the words Om yachandasabho
vivarpa. The Native American prayer, trans-
lated by Lakota Sioux Chief Yellow Lark, ex-
presses many of the same ideas.
Om. May He, the Lord of all, pre-eminent among O Great Spirit, Whose voice I hear in the winds,
the Vedas and superior to the nectar contained in and whose breath gives life to all the world, hear
them, bless me with wisdom. May I be adorned meI am small and weak, I need your strength
with the knowledge of Brahman that leads to im- and wisdom.
mortality. May my body become strong and vig- Let me walk in beauty and make my eyes ever
orous (to practise meditation). May my tongue behold the red and purple sunset.
always utter delightful words. May I hear much Make my hands respect the things you have
with my ears. You are the scabbard of Brahman made and my ears sharp to hear your voice.
covered by worldly wisdom. May I never forget all Make me wise so that I may understand the
that I have learnt. things you have taught my people.
Om, peace, peace, peace! Let me learn the lessons you have hidden in
every leaf and rock.
Idea of Universal Happiness and Harmony
Here is another instance of the striking similarity seen between Indians and American In-
dians in their idea of universal happiness, health, harmony, and well-being. Both peoples
understand well that individual happiness depends solely on the collective happiness of
all living beings.
Om. Auspiciousness (svasti) be unto all; peace be May the Warm Winds of Heaven blow softly upon
unto all; fullness be unto all; prosperity be unto your house. May the Great Spirit bless all who en-
all. ter there. May your moccasins make happy tracks
May all be happy, may all be free from disease, in many snows, and may the rainbow always touch
may all see what is good, may none suffer from your shoulder.
sorrow. Cherokee Prayer Blessing
May the stars carry your sadness away,

Chief Dan George (18991981) May the flowers fill your heart with beauty,
was a modern Native American, May hope forever wipe away your tears,
a gifted actor and chief of the
Tsleil-waututh Nation in Burrard
And, above all, may silence make you strong.
Inlet, British Columbia. He is well- Chief Dan George
known for his words of courage
and wisdom.
271
Secret of Work
If you set to work in right earnest, then you are Friend do it this waythat is, whatever you do in
sure to be successful. Whoever works at a thing life, do the very best you can with both your heart
heart and soul not only achieves success in it, but and mind. And if you do it that way, the Power of
through his absorption in that he also realizes the the Universe will come to your assistance, if your
supreme TruthBrahman. heart and mind are in Unity.
Swami Vivekananda Lakota Instructions for Living
Die Like a Hero

Fear, particularly of death, has to be conquered. See how American Indians
tried to live a detached life, welcoming death like true heroes:
How few have dared to worship Death or Kali! Let When it comes your time to die, be not like those
us worship Death! Let us embrace the Terrible, whose hearts are filled with the fear of death, so
because it is terrible, not asking that it be toned that when their time comes they weep and pray for a
down. Let us take misery for miserys own sake! little more time to live their lives over again in a dif-
Swami Vivekananda ferent way. Sing your death song and die like a hero
going home. Chief Tecumseh (Crouching Tiger)
ings Move in a Circ

All Th le
Nature recycles; Not only in the
physical sense, but also in the spiritual
sense. Every soul journeys between birth and death.
You have noticed that every-

thing an Indian does is in a circle,
Everything moves in a circle; a and that is because the Power of the
straight line, infinitely produced, be- World always works in circles, and
comes a circle. If that is the case, there everything tries to be round. The life
cannot be eternal degeneration for any of a man is a circle from childhood to
soul. It cannot be. Everything must com- childhood, and so it is in everything where
plete the circle, and come back to its power moves. Our teepees were round like
source. the nests of birds, and these were always
Swami Vivekananda set in a circle, the nations hoop, a nest of
many nests, where the Great Spirit meant
for us to hatch our children.
Black Elk
Black Elk (18631950) was a famous Wichasha Wakan (Medicine Man or Holy
Man) of the Oglala Lakota (Sioux). He served as a spiritual leader among
his people, seeing no contradiction in embracing what he found
valid in both his tribal traditions and those of Christianity.
272 PB April 2008

Nature Worship
The ancient Hindus cared for their environment. Whatever was around themplants,
animals, the five elements of nature, and so on were just extensions of their own self.
It was likewise for the American Indians. They honoured them and lived in balance and
harmony along with them.
Om. May there be peace in heaven; may there be Honour the sacred.
peace in the sky; may there be peace on earth; Honour the Earth, our Mother.
may there be peace in the waters. May the trees Honour the Elders.
and plants be full of peace. May the gods be peace- Honour all with whom we share the Earth
ful. May there be peace in Brahman; may there be Four-leggeds, two-leggeds, winged ones,
peace in all. May the peace be peaceful. May that Swimmers, crawlers, plant and rock
peace enter into our deepest being. People
Om, Peace, Peace, Peace! Walk in balance and beauty.
Native American Elder
Sacred Land of Our People

Whosoever stands on this sacred land, whether Every part of this soil is sacred in the estimation of
alien or a child of the soil, feels himself surround- my people. Every hillside, every valley, every plain
edunless his soul is degraded to the level of brute and grove, has been hallowed by some sad or happy
animalsby the living thoughts of the earths best event in days long vanished. Even the rocks, which
and purest sons, who have been working to raise seem to be dumb and dead as they swelter in the
the animal to the divine through centuries, whose sun along the silent shore, thrill with memories of
beginning history fails to trace. The very air is full stirring events connected with the lives of my peo-
of the pulsations of spirituality. This land is sa- ple, and the very dust upon which you now stand
cred to philosophy, to ethics and spirituality, to all responds more lovingly to their footsteps than
that tends to give a respite to man in his incessant yours, because it is rich with the blood of our an-
struggle for the preservation of the animal, to all cestors, and our bare feet are conscious of the sym-
training that makes man throw off the garment of pathetic touch. Our departed braves, fond moth-
brutality and stand revealed as the spirit immor- ers, glad, happy hearted maidens, and even the
tal, the birthless, the deathless, the ever-blessed. little children who lived here and rejoiced here for
Swami Vivekananda a brief season will love these somber solitudes, and
at eventide they greet shadowy returning spirits.
Chief Seattle
Chief Seattle (also Sealth, Seathl or See-ahth, c. 1786

1866) was a leader of the Suquamish and Duwamish
Native American tribes in what is now the state of
Washington. A prominent figure among his people, he
became a convert to Roman Catholicism and pursued
a path of accommodation to European settlers.
We have examined just a few samples of the eternal wisdom that permeated
the lives of Native Americans. We shall surely find more marvels as we continue
digging. Let us welcome noble thoughts that come to us from every side. P
PB April 2008 273
REVIEWS
For review in Prabuddha B harata ,
publishers need to send two copies of their latest publications.
Search after Happiness and Maya, The Necessity of Religion, and Is a Be-
Swami Ramakrishnananda lief in Transmigration Consistent with Reasoning,
and appropriately concludes with a focus on the di-
Ramakrishna Math, Mylapore, Chennai
600 004. E-mail: [email protected]. vine life of Sri Ramakrishna and the universal doc-
2006. iv + 195 pp. Rs 32. trine he unfolded. Despite an orthodox upbringing,
Sri Ramakrishna was not a religious aristocrat. He
T he book under review is a revised

edition of two notable publica-
tions of Sri Ramakrishna Math, The Message of Eter-
demonstrated how orthodoxy must blend with lib-
eralism and how Truth is not the monopoly of any
person or nation.
nal Wisdom and The Ancient Quest, bringing together The search for happiness is not an endless journey
the plenary wisdom of Swami Ramakrishnananda, if the path unveiled by the Great Master and pre-
one of the foremost disciples of Sri Ramakrishna. sented by Swami Ramakrishnananda is adopted. This
It contains fourteen lectures of the eminent swami moderately priced book will be valuable to young
delivered between 1893 and 1911, one of which lends and old.
its title to the book. P S Sundaram
The search for happiness begins from birth. Mumbai
Strangely, a higher standard of living is accompanied
by a steady erosion of peace and happiness. This is a Philosophy and Science of
global phenomenon. Value Education in the
The search for happiness should begin with the Context of Modern India
basics: What constitutes life, existence, death, body,
Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Cul-
mind and soul, maya, consciousness, and reality? ture, Gol Park, Kolkata 700 029. E-mail:
Without this foundational understanding, a search [email protected]. 2006. x + 332 pp. Rs 50.
for happiness in the psychophysical plane becomes a
futile exercise. Swami Ramakrishnananda addresses
all these issues; his convincing presentation of these
concepts will infuse confidence in the distressed. He
I f by education is meant character-
building and man-making, then
value education is the crying need of the hour. Value
explains: education is needed not only for students in vari-
Our present life is only a tiny chapter in a big ous educational institutions but also for all human
volume whose beginning as well as end is the one beings in all stages and walks of life. How to do it
eternal God. We are only dwellers in the body and constitutes the theme of this book, which contains
should quit it when it becomes uninhabitable. Wants thoughtful addresses delivered by twenty dignitaries,
number in the millions; one cannot satisfy all of including educationists, scientists, media persons,
them. The flame of desire increases with enjoy- monks, and philosophers, at a national seminar held
ment. If we have many wants, we are never happy. at the Institute of Culture.
We need to realize that we are masters of and not The seminar comprised six academic sessions with
slaves to desire. The self is not the body but exists fourteen papers presented, discussions on twelve of
everywhere in the body; it is also distinct from the those papers, two panel discussions, and inaugural
emotions that bathe the body and mind. The real and valedictory sessions, held over the course of two
man is infinite, without hunger, thirst, or desires. days in January 2005. In his address of benediction,
Religion is necessary for the foolish as well as the Swami Ranganathananda, fourteenth president of
wise. Also, multiple religious faiths are necessary the Ramakrishna Order, says: The problem for India
and inevitable. in the modern age is the assimilation of the forces re-
The book covers topics like Who am I, Mind leased by science, technology, and democracy, which
274 PB April 2008

Reviews 53
are being grafted on to her traditional tree. The suc- sensuous presence itself. He was the ambrosia of
cess of this experiment depends upon two factors: spiritual consciousness personified in human form,
one, the vitality of the spiritual sap running in the a glimpse of which would be caught by every single
tree, and two, its hospitality to the new forces con- visitor who was fortunate to approach him. As such,
tained in the grafts (8). to be face to face with Sri Ramana Maharshi, as one
In his inaugural speech Prof. Kireet Joshi points visitor remarked, was to be face to face with Gods
out that yoga is a valid means for realization of val- gracious power working in his person.
ues. Dr Saibal Gupta draws our attention to the daivi A significant feature of this book is that the Ma-
sampad, a detailed catalogue of universal values that harshi is presented not as a bygone entity but as a
appears in the Bhagavadgita. He also narrates how living source of divine bliss. Each of the one hundred
Niels Bohr, the famous physicist, had deep interest sixty accounts presented here bears testimony to this
in some ideas of the Upanishads, an interest that fact. What his admirers see in him are the wonderful
was shared by Erwin Schrdinger. The Indian value traits of a true sthitaprajna and jivanmukta, as de-
system is based on the experience of the unity of scribed in the Hindu scriptures. Though his easy ac-
existence. The doctrines of innate human divinity cessibility, utterly normal behaviour, perfect sense of
and oneness of existence, according to Swami Atma equality, overflowing compassion, and undisturbed
priyananada, have the potential for ushering in a silence are captivating, it is his loving but penetrating
new world order. According to Prof. J S Rajput, the look that shakes the depths of ones heart and reveals
term value education implies valuable education, answers to countless troubling questions. Realization
education through which humans are enlightened. is no longer a distant dream, but an immediate real-
An education based on the Upanishads, Gita, and ity, the flow of which can be felt in the person of Sri
yoga is valuable because it enlightens. Ramana Maharshi.
The topics covered in the volume range from the The intimate accounts given in this book are in-
plight of family values in modern times, to scientific, valuable, for they depict Ramana as a complete man,
genetic, and political aspects of value education, to in all dimensions and forms. While some focus on
value-based leadership and the role of the media. his spiritual achievements, many have recounted the
Unfortunately, a number of careless typographical er- deep impressions his human personality left on them.
rors litter the pages of the book; more careful proof- These recollections form a beautiful blending of Ra-
reading would improve a second edition. manas life, teachings, and influence on people from
Every participant has contributed to the literary diverse strata of society. While his close devotees
and knowledge content of the book. It is recom- look upon Ramana as an incarnation of God, oth-
mended especially to our political leaders as a wide- erslike his many non-Indian admirerssee in him
ranging treatment of a vitally important subject. the embodiment of the spiritual treasure of India. It
Dr S C Goswami is an enchanting as well as uplifting experience to
Former Reader in Chemistry meditate on the Bhagavan as he has been envisioned
Dayal Singh College, New Delhi by disciples and devotees.
These accounts belong to a vast span of time
Face to Face with (18791950); hence we can trace the gradual mani-
Sri Ramana Maharshi festation of Ramanas inner spiritual potential. But
Comp. and ed. all the writers agree, based on their own experiences,
Prof. Laxmi Narain that an intense power to transform others was latent
in him. Every one of them, in his presence, found an
Sri Ramana Kendram, 2-2-1109, Bat inexpressible change taking place in their minds and
kammakunta Sivam Road, Hyderabad
500 013. Distributed by Motilal Banarsi personalities. In Bhagavans presence, again, many
dass, 41 UA Bungalow Road, Jawahar would find a kind of overwhelming power engulf-
Nagar, Delhi 110 062. E-mail: mlbd@ ing their limited being. But there was no cause for
vsnl.com. 2005. xviii + 401 pp. Rs 200. fear or anxiety, as Ramana would radiate nothing
S ri Ramana Maharshi would ask his followers to

ask themselves the question, Who am I? Thus
would begin an exalted spiritual endeavour, the ful-
but silent waves of peace, quietude, and fearlessness
around him.
Our thanks go to Prof. Laxmi Narain of Ramana
filment of which could be found in Ramanas supra- Kendram for compiling this large collection of remi-
PB April 2008 275

niscences culled from numerous sources. It is like ple of Indian Origin) in all that it has achieved thus
a bouquet of beautiful flowers offered at Ramanas far, is one means of access to Bharata.
feet. A brief life-sketch of the sage, beautiful photos, Historically, PIOs and NRIs have been both vic-
a detailed bibliography, a brief description of all con- tims and victors politically, socially, economically,
tributors, a list of accolades showered on Ramana, and culturally. With minimal to no support from
and an extensive indexall these have added to the or connections to Mother India, their spiritual and
usefulness of this book. cultural values served as their mainstay.
Swami Vireshananda Unfortunately, Voices of the Indian Diaspora con-
Editor, Viveka Prabha tains occasional typographical errors throughout. A
Ramakrishna Ashrama, Mysore number of paragraph-length quotations are given
in French without any English translation, proving
Voices of the Indian Diaspora meaningless to readers who do not know French.
Anand Mulloo The actual voices of the Indian Diaspora span
Motilal Banarsidass. 2007. 393 pp. most continents and convey an initial foundation of
Rs 395. knowledge. However, Mauritius is given the greatest
prominence in the ensuing analysis and reflections.
I felt privileged and inspired to read

Voices of The Indian Diaspora; as a
person of Indian origin myself, I
The cover illustration is given a fleeting mention in
the course of narration, but an explanation and ac-
knowledgement provided at the beginning would en-
found it personally relevant. More importantly, it hance the readers appreciation and understanding.
reminds us of the toils and struggles of our forebears, The author has researched his subject extensively.
and that in those times of trial, never was jyotithe I found myself fully identifying with the cross-
spiritual lightsacrificed. Herein lies the books em- cultural life experiences of PIOs and NRIs through
powering message. The book also made me aware of the course of history, as encapsulated in the book,
my own ignorance about the status and struggles of and grappling with a myriad of feelings on read-
PIOs and NRIspersons of Indian origin and non- ing the explicit descriptions of the lives of our fore-
resident Indiansacross the globe. bears who left the motherland, either voluntarily or
V S Naipauls novel A House for Mr Biswas was my through compulsion.
first contact with Indian literature. The two themes Rita Ramsaran
that stood out for me, as a class nine student, were Bialik College, Melbourne
Mr Biswass love of tea and his ambition to own a
house, yet having neither the outer nor inner means BookS Received
to acquire one. The context is different, but the is-
sues that assailed Mr Biswas are common to Indians Holy Vrindaban
everywhere. Anand Mulloo attributes some of these Ramakrishna Mission Sevashrama,
issues to deficits in Indian political leadership, and Vrindaban, Dist. Mathura, UP 281 121;
E-mail: [email protected]. 2008.
identifies the challenge of maintaining unity in the 47 pp. Rs 25.
face of diversity and forces of disunity through ef-
A commemorative booklet to mark
fective leadership.
one hundred years of medical, socio-
Voices of The Indian Diaspora is a spiritual journey,
economic, and spiritual service of
retracing the roots of our forbears. It affirms and re-
the Ramakrishna Mission Sevashrama, Vrindaban.
affirms our sense of identity and belonginga sense
often lost by PIOs.
Mulloo uses the terms Old India and New India, Fifty One Saints of India
which brings to mind an image of the unfurling and Bimal Kumar Banerjee
furling of the tentacles of the octopus that is Bharata. AK-7, Sector II, Salt Lake, Kolkata
For decades they remained furled, and Bharata im- 700 091. 2007. x + 192 pp. Rs 150.
mune to the plight of its children living away from Brief pen-portraits of such diverse
her; she is only just beginning to unfurl her tentacles Indian saints as Buddha, Mahavira,
toI hopereach out and embrace her children to the Nayanmars, Gorakhnath, Rama-
her bosom. The GOPIO (Global Organization of Peo- krishna, and Dhananjaydas Babaji.
276 PB April 2008

Reports
News from Branch Centres

The new Vivekananda Vidya Vihar or Centre for
Excellence through Education at Ramakrishna
Mission, Sitanagaram (Vijayawada), was inaugu-
rated on 14 February 2008 by Srimat Swami Sma-
rananandaji Maharaj, Vice President, Ramakrishna
Math and Ramakrishna Mission. Besides housing
both a Telugu-medium high school and an English-
medium school, the centre will also serve as a hub
for various service activities benefiting rural poor
and youth. As part of the inauguration, several Fruit tree saplings for farmers in rural areas of
cultural programmes and a parents convention Inanda and Nonoti, KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa
were conducted.
As part of its ongoing agricultural activities,
the Ramakrishna Centre of South Africa, Dur
ban, donated over one thousand fruit tree saplings
(mango, litchi, orange, lemon, avocado, pear, and
banana) to community and individual farmers in
the rural areas of Inanda and Nonoti, KwaZulu-
Natal over the last three months of 2007.
Achievements
Soumya Subra Bhadury, Sandipan Chakraborty
Newly constructed Vivekananda Vidya Vihar or Centre for
Excellence through Education at Sitanagar (Vijaywada)
and Upamanyu Sengupta, students of the college
at Ramakrishna Mission Ashrama, Narendrapur,
Ramakrishna Math and Ramakrishna Mis won the first, fourth, and fifth prizes respectively
sion Sevashrama, Allahabad, organized a medical in the All-India Elocution Competition on Swami
camp, discourses, and an exhibition on Sri Rama- Vivekananda, held at the Ramakrishna Mission
krishna and Swami Vivekananda at Triveni Sangam Institute of Culture, Gol Park, in December 2007.
on the occasion of Magh Mela, from 20 January Rudra Sekhar Basu, a 2nd-year BA student of
to 21February. About 16,000people were treated Ramakrishna Mission Vidyamandira, Sarada
at the medical camp, and nearly 80,000 people at- pitha, Belur, secured the second position in the
tended the exhibition. undergraduate group.
Sri Ashwini Kumar Chaubey, Minister for Ur- Arnab Rudra, a 1st-year BSc Physics (Honours)
ban Development, Bihar, inaugurated an addi- student of Vidyamandira, Belur, was awarded the
tional operation theatre at the Sarada Netralaya Jagadish Bose National Science Talent Scholarship,
of Ramakrishna Mission Ashrama, Patna, on 16 2007, and Kishore Vaigyanik Protsahan Yojana Na-
February. tional Science Fellowship, 2007.
PB April 2008 277
Nyato Doji, Tania Uli, Nanjal Dulom, Kembi nipur: 300; Puri Math: 1,000; Purulia: 1,500; Ra-
Basar, and Baanu Loya, students of Ramakrishna hara: 106; Rajkot: 47; Ranchi Sanatorium: 529;
Mission School, Aalo, were each awarded a gold Sikra Kulingram: 600; Taki: 673; Tamluk: 1,000;
medal for their case studies on a biodiversity project Varanasi Home of Service: 451. Distribution of win-
presented in the 15th National Science Congress ter garments: Baranagar Mission: 125 chadars and
held at Bharatiya Vidya Pratishthan, Pune, from 27 415 sweaters; Rajkot: 63sweaters; Ranchi Sanato-
to 31 December. rium: 25woollen chadars.
Sarjick Bakshi, Satrajit Das, Laksabir Deb- Flood Relief Belgharia centre distributed
nath, Saptarshi Saha, and Annek Roy Choudhury, 1,900 biscuit packets, 520 dhotis, 233shirts, and
class-11 students of Ramakrishna Mission School, 532frocks to 765 flood-affected persons in East
Viveknagar, were awarded the Jagadish Bose Na- Medinipur district.
tional Science Talent Search Junior Scholarship, Distress Relief The following centres dis-
2007. Chitradeep Gupta, a class-10 student of the tributed various items to persons of nearby areas:
same school, was the only student from the entire Baranagar Mission: 298 saris, 211 dhotis, 15churi-
north-eastern region of India to be selected for the dars, 87pants and shirts, and 36 bags; Dinajpur
2008 International Mathematical Olympiad Train- (Bangladesh): 498 saris, 475 dhotis, and 80 other
ing Camp, which prepares students for the Interna- garments; Garbeta: 70 dhotis; Jayrambati: 1,520sa-
tional Mathematical Olympiad. ris; Katihar: food packets to 340 families, 30 cycles,
and 400books and stationery to students; Medi-
National Youth Day Celebrations nipur: 50 saris and 20dhotis; Rahara: 174 saris,
The following centres celebrated National Youth 51dhotis, 120 mosquito nets, 76wrappers, 26 litres
Day on 12 January: Baghbazar: speeches, question- of coconut oil, and 309food packets; Taki: 275sa-
answer session, cultural competitions, and music; ris and 25 dhotis. Also, 30 tube wells were sunk by
Delhi: cultural competitions, music, and public Katihar centre in nearby villages.
meeting addressed by Sri Jairam Ramesh, Union Economic Rehabilitation The following two
Minister of State for Commerce; Jayrambati: pro- centres distributed various items to people under
cession and cultural competitions; Porbandar: a self-employment programme: Katihar: 4 sewing
cultural competitions; Shyamla Tal: speeches and machines and 15rickshaws; Tamluk: 16 sewing ma-
cultural competitions. chines, 16fishing nets, and 7rickshaws. P
Relief
Centres of the Ramakrishna Math and Ramakri-
shna Mission conducted relief in the month of Feb-
ruary as follows:
Winter Relief A total number of 19,284
blankets were distributed to people affected by
the severity of winter through the following cen-
tres: Almora: 302; Asansol: 500; Baghbazar: 210;
Bankura: 987; Baranagar Mission: 800; Barasat:
500; Belgharia: 520; Chapra: 370; Cooch Behar:
336; Deoghar: 2,000; Dinajpur (Bangladesh): 257;
Garbeta: 50; Guwahati: 250; Jayrambati: 1,057;
Kamarpukur: 1,300; Kanpur: 231; Katihar: 400; Helping combat a bitter winter; blanket distribution,
Koalpara ( Jayrambati): 2,748; Limbdi: 260; Medi- Home of Service, Varanasi
78
PB April 2008

PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

PDF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

PDF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Rs 8.

H uman society is a graded organization. We

Vol. 113, No. 4 Contents

Dharma April 2008

m liJ gCJ;T ;A[ugtuvbgm]s; tbobT ;=u;;T Gtg Gtk gbo&

The Alternate Viewpoint

A nimesh Debnath (class eight) raised his hand and

PB April 2008 237

It is evident that through this character the nov-

PB April 2008 243

Ramakrishna Mission Vidyamandira, Belur Math

me to face all odds. Kaushik: When I first came to Vidyamandira,

250 PB April 2008

254 PB April 2008

It is high time we awaken

PB April 2008 261

Impact of Knowledge and Ignorance

Lost in the dark ignorance of the world,

PB April 2008 269

May the stars carry your sadness away,

Die Like a Hero

ings Move in a Circ

You have noticed that every-

272 PB April 2008

Sacred Land of Our People

Chief Seattle (also Sealth, Seathl or See-ahth, c. 1786

T he book under review is a revised

274 PB April 2008

S ri Ramana Maharshi would ask his followers to

PB April 2008 275

I felt privileged and inspired to read

276 PB April 2008

News from Branch Centres

You might also like