The Legal Environment of E-Commerce
The Legal Environment of E-Commerce
The Legal Environment of E-Commerce
In 1999, Dell Computer and Micron Electronics (now doing business as MPC Computers), two companies that sell
personal computers through their Web sites, agreed to settle U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) charges that they had
disseminated misleading advertising to their existing and potential customers. The advertising in question was for computer leasing
plans that both companies had offered on their Web sites. The ads stated the price of the computer along with a monthly payment.
Unfortunately for Dell and Micron, stating the monthly payment without disclosing full details of the lease plan is a violation of the
Consumer Leasing Act of 1976. This law is implemented through a federal regulation that was written and is updated periodically by
the Federal Reserve Board. This regulation, called Regulation M, was designed to require banks and other lenders to fully disclose
the terms of leases so that consumers would have enough information to make informed financing choices when leasing cars, boats,
furniture, and other goods.
Both Dell and Micron had included the required information on their Web pages, but FTC investigators noted that important
details of the leasing plans, such as the number of payments and the fees due at the signing of the lease, were placed in a small
typeface at the bottom of a long Web page. A consumer who wanted to determine the full cost of leasing a computer would need to
scroll through a number of densely filled screens to obtain enough information to make the necessary calculations.
In the settlement, both companies agreed to provide consumers with clear, readable, and understandable information in their lease
advertising. The companies also agreed to record-keeping and federal monitoring activities designed to ensure their compliance with
the terms of the settlement.
Dell and Micron are computer manufacturers. It apparently did not occur to them that they needed to become experts in
Regulation M, generally considered to be a banking regulation. Companies that do business on the Web expose themselves, often
unwittingly, to liabilities that arise from today’s business environment. That environment includes laws and ethical considerations that
may be different from those with which the business is familiar. In the case of Dell and Micron, they were unfamiliar with the laws and
ethics of the banking industry. The banking industry has a different culture than that of the computer industry—it is unlikely that a
bank advertising manager would have made such a mistake.0
As you will learn in this chapter, Dell and Micron are by no means the only Web businesses that have run afoul of laws and
regulations. As new and existing companies open online operations, they become subject to unfamiliar laws and different ethical
frameworks much more rapidly than in the physical world.