Papua New Guinea Port Moresby Urban Profile
Papua New Guinea Port Moresby Urban Profile
Papua New Guinea Port Moresby Urban Profile
1
Port Moresby Urban Profile
E-mail: [email protected]
Website: http://www.unhabitat.org
This report was prepared by Angela Mageto, Kenneth Asatoa, Amanda Binoka, Kemo Pepena, Jacklyn Taranu, Daisy Baur,
Wesley Yanum, and Benjiman Vagi with information collected through interviews with key urban actors in Port Moresby.
This project and report was managed by Max Kep and supported by Wesley J. Aruga, with critical inputs provided by Chris
Radford, staff in UN HABITATS Regional Office for Asia and Pacific and UN-HABITAT Urban Profiling team in Nairobi,
Kenya.
HS Number: HS/1259/09E
Disclaimer
The designation employed and the presentation of the material in this publication do not imply the expression of any
opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory,
city or area, or of its authorities, or concerning delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries, or regarding its economic system
or degree of development. The analysis, conclusions and recommendations of the report do not necessarily reflect the views
of the United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UN-HABITAT), the Governing Council of UN-HABITAT or its
Member States. Excerpts from this publication may be reproduced without authorisation, on condition that the source is
indicated.
Acknowledgements
2
PAPUA NEW GUINEA:
PORT MORESBY
Urban PROFILE
Table of contents
Forewords 5
Executive summary 8
Background 10
GOVERNANCE 16
Slums 22
GENDER AND HIV/AIDS 28
ENVIRONMENT 34
LAW AND ORDER 38
LAND 42
Project proposals
GOVERNANCE 19
Slums 25
Gender and HIV/aids 31
Environment 36
LAW AND ORDER 40
LAND 45
3
44
Forewords
5 5
As more and study uses a well structured approach where priority
more countries intervention projects are agreed through consultative
in the Pacific are processes.
urbanizing, the cities
and town authorities The Urban Profiling methodology consists of three
are confronted with phases: the first phase is an assessment of key urban
the task of meeting issues at the local levels, focusing on Governance, Basic
the demands of Urban Services, Informal Settlements, Gender and
the growing urban HIV/AIDS, and Land.
population. The second phase involves feasibility studies on priority
These urbanization projects identified in the study and policy development
challenges require as well as training on settlement upgrading and urban
comprehensive and sustainable Urban Governance and service improvements, local leadership training, and
Management Systems and Strategies. Both national management. The third phase of the project involves
and local urban authorities are unable to cope with the implementation of these priority projects.
increasing pressures on urban services. The Urban Profiles will provide a framework for
The local urban governments lack financial and National, Local and Urban Actors, as well as Donors
management capacities to respond to the proliferation and External Support Agencies.
of sub-standard developments and the rising levels of
urban poverty among the poor urban communities.
The UNDP has supported UN-HABITAT in this project
because it contributes to the Millennium Development
Goals (MDG), Target 11 to reduce urban poverty
through effective urban governance. The objective of
this Urban Profiling study is to develop urban poverty
reduction policies at local levels. Dr. Jacquie Badcock
UN Resident Coordinator
The study is based on analysis of existing data and a United Nations - PNG
series of interviews with all relevant urban stakeholders,
including local communities and institutions, civil
society, the private sector, development partners,
academics, and others.
The Urban Profiling is an assessment of needs and
capacity building gaps at the local and national levels.
This project is currently being implemented in over 20
countries globally.
In the Pacific region, this project has been piloted in
PNG and Port Moresby, Goroka and Kokopo cities
have been selected for this study. The Urban Profiling
ForewordS
66
Though Papua The Urban Profiling Study has already high-lighted the
New Guinea is citys institutional capacity gaps which I hope donor
one of the least partners can support.
urbanized countries
in the world, there The National Capital District Commission has already
is a growing and embarked on developing its urban development strategies
irreversible trend of in an attempt to address the current urbanization
urban migration. challenges; I would welcome a further intervention
from UNDP and UN-HABITAT to support our
According to endeavours.
the 1990 census
only 15% of the
population was
resident in urban areas. Nevertheless, at 4.3% annual Honorable Powes Pakop. MP
growth, the urban population is increasing at almost Governor
double the national average. At this rate, by the year
National Capital District Commission
2020, 27% of the countrys population will be living in
cities and towns.
This urbanization trend is not seen as a potential
stimulator of growth, but as the cause of problems
such as expansion of spontaneous informal settlements,
incidents of high unemployment rates, alienated
and delinquent youth, violent crimes and drugs, and
alcohol abuse. This unfortunate trend is the result of
uncontrolled rural-urban migration caused by weak
governance. National policies regarding balanced rural
and urban development, urbanization, local economic
investments and development, social development,
poverty reduction, basic services, and social amenities
or crime prevention have not been fully implemented.
Port Moresby is the national capital and the seat of
the government. Like many other cities and towns in
Papua New Guinea, Port Moresby is confronted with
issues directly related with rapid urbanization and the
National Capital District Commission lacks resources
to manage this increasing urban growth and the
problems associated with it. The intervention by the
United Nations, for which I commend the UNDP and
UN-HABITAT, is timely as the local governments are
beginning to assume more responsibilities.
The Urban Profiling study will no doubt improve
Port Moresby current performances and its efforts in
responding to urban poverty through improved service
provision, particularly improved water supply, sanitation
ForewordS
7 7
Executive summary
Introduction Background
The Urban Profiling is an accelerated and action-oriented Port Moresby is the capital city of PNG and is the
urban assessment of needs and capacity-building at the main administrative, commercial and education centre
city level. It is currently being implemented in over 20 of the country. It has a population of a little over
countries in Africa and the Arab States. Urban Profiling 400,000 with an average density of 16 persons per
uses a structured approach where priority interventions hectare. It developed based on its historical and strategic
are agreed upon through consultative processes. The considerations. The main economic activities in Port
Urban Profiling methodology consists of three phases: Moresby are in the service industry. The unemployment
(1) a rapid participatory urban profiling, at national rate in Port Moresby is high with more than 50% of the
and local levels, focusing on governance, slums, unemployed in settlements and urban villages. Most of
gender and HIV/AIDS, environment, and proposed these people participate in some form of informal sector
interventions; (2) detailed priority proposals; and (3) activities.
executive summary
88
illegal means to access basic services. Public transport to hinder womens participation in development.
needs improvement and the existing road network is Cultural biases and commercial sex increases the
poorly maintained particularly in the suburban and vulnerability to STIs and the risk of HIV/AIDS. There
settlement areas. Health care and education facilities is an urgent need to develop and implement policies that
although available are sometimes run-down and poorly advocate changes in attitude, promote gender equality
resourced. and reduce the prevalence of HIV/AIDS.
Port Moresby is set to expand due to its strategic location
and strong trade agreements with its neighboring ENVIRONMENT
countries in the Asia Pacific region.
Port Moresby is experiencing rapid population growth
coupled with weak frameworks for environmental
regulation and implementation. Environmental
GOVERNANCE deterioration of marine and terrestrial assets is a serious
The governance system in Port Moresby comprises an problem affecting the city. Strategic environmental
appointed body (the NCDC) as the city authority. It planning and management is urgently needed, along
is responsible to the Ministry of Inter-Government with greater coordination and enforcement of existing
Relations. The Motu Koita Assembly administers environmental policies and standards.
and controls the Motu Koitabu areas of the city. The
Governor who is the elected Regional member is
also the Chairman of the NCDC. For the most part, LAND
the Commissioners are not accountable to the citys
The fact that most developable land in Port Moresby
population. This leadership does not generally promote
is under customary ownership tends to be the main
civil participation or create accountability frameworks
constraint to the mobilisation of vacant land for
for overall management. The NCDC must modernize
urban development. The lack of cooperation between
in favour of a more effective service provision for
the NCDC and Department of Lands and Physical
the city residents and provide a way for community
Planning (DLPP) results in conflicting planning
participation in urban decision making. Such efforts
and land decisions. One way to improve the current
would involve the city residents in a meaningful way
situation is to transfer land powers from the national
and convey a vision that is clear enough to win the
level to the city authority. There is an urgent need to
peoples confidence and ensure their participation in the
launch a customary landowners awareness campaign.
development of an attractive city for all.
A tracking or retrieval system with the DLPP would
make it more accountable to its clients and the general
public.
SHELTER AND SETTLEMENTS
About 45% of Port Moresby total population lives in
settlements. There are 20 planned settlements and 79 Law and order
unplanned settlements. 44 unplanned settlements are on
Law and Order problems have a constraining effect on
state land and 37 are on customary land. The growth of
Port Moresby and are a result of disparities between
these settlements is the result of uncontrolled migration
income groups. The movement of residents is restricted
and population growth and the governments failure
and there are no go zones which can only be accessed
to provide affordable housing and developable land
with heavy security protection. The Royal Papua
executive summary
99
Background
at national and local levels. The capital city, a medium develop options for formal inter-agency collaboration
size city and a small town are selected and studied to in order to create a coordination body integrating a
provide a representative sample in each country. In the wide range of urban stakeholders in a single response
case of PNG, the capital city and two small cities have mechanism.
been selected. For Port Moresby the analysis focuses on
six themes: governance, shelter and settlements, gender
and HIV/AIDS, the environment, land, and law and Report structure
order. Information is collected through standard This report consists of:
interviews and discussions with institutions and key
informants, in order to assess the strengths, weaknesses, a general background of the urban sector in
opportunities and threats (SWOT) of the national Port Moresby, based on the findings of the Port
and local urban set-ups. The findings are presented Moresby assessment report, a desk study, interviews,
and refined during city and national consultation and on-going NCD Urban Development Plan
workshops and consensus is reached regarding priority consultations that were held in Port Moresby in the
interventions. National and city reports synthesise the course of the year 2007. The background includes
information collected and outline ways forward to data on administration, urban planning, economy,
reduce urban poverty through holistic approaches. the informal and private sectors, urban poverty,
infrastructure, water, sanitation, public transport,
energy, health and education;
10
10
a synthetic assessment of six main areas governance, a SWOT analysis and an outline of priority project
shelter and slums, gender and HIV/AIDS, proposals for each theme. The proposals include
environment, land, and law and order in terms beneficiaries, partners, estimated costs, objectives
of the institutional set-up, regulatory framework, and activities.
resource mobilisation, and performance. This second
section also highlights agreed priorities and includes
a list of identified projects; and
1111
DEVELOPMENT OF PORT MORESBY Urban planning
Port Moresby is the capital city of Papua New Guinea. The Physical Planning Act of 1989 places planning
It is the major urbanized centre in the country thus a responsibilities on physical planning boards. There is an
main attraction for migration. Being the administrative independent NCD Physical Planning Board (NCDPPB)
centre for the country, Port Moresby benefits from for Port Moresby. The support unit for the NCDPPB is
substantial investment in infrastructure and physical part of the NCDC staff structure and the Commission
development. There are seven urban villages generally is represented on the Board. The NCDC is responsible
located along the coastal strip. As the built-up area of the to the Board for the preparation of development plans
city expands to accommodate the increase in population and assessment of development proposals.
and economic growth, there is a threat to the traditional
way of life of the local villagers. The demand for land for There is a zoning plan but this only relates to the formal
expansion is mounting. Because of its strategic location built up part of the city and excludes extensive peripheral
Port Moresby is set to expand and at a much higher rate areas. Settlements development is taking place ad hoc
with the onset of a favorable global economic climate and is largely uncontrolled.
and the National Governments strengthening of trade The NCDC has recently established a strategic planning
agreements with its neighboring countries in the Asia- section. A draft NCD Urban Development Plan has
Pacific Region. recently been completed and is waiting final approval.
The Plan contains a vision as well as broad policies
and proposals for the entire city. It identifies 14 local
Administration planning areas for more detailed planning. Only one
Political interference affects Port Moresby and its Local Development Plan has so far been completed.
capacity to respond to the needs of its residents and
The NCDC faces real challenges. There is a shortage
the private sector. There have been changes made to
of planning professionals and a backlog of Local Plans
the system of governance from the national level and
to prepare. Increasing pressure from the rising informal
administrative performance has been compromised
sector poses a further challenge, as does the exclusion of
because of political influence in administrative matters.
settlement dwellers from planning processes. Corporate
There is weak capacity in various areas of the NCDC
and urban planning is not integrated and urban
due to cronyism and nepotism, limiting the councils
planning does not get the recognition or resources it
ability to effectively provide essential services. Capacity
needs to address these challenges.
building and staff development has traditionally been
port moresby URBAN profile - background
given low priority and there is no training policy. Members of the NCDPPB do not always follow
Liaison and coordination is poor within the NCDC professional advice and approved policies in their
organization and its relationship with all stakeholders decision making, even though good guidelines for
needs considerable improvement. Executive managers decision making have been provided in the form of a
in particular have fallen victim to political interference, comprehensive handbook.
leading to high turnover which has, in turn, led to a
lack of continuity, loss of direction and a lowering of Frequently, there is political influence at the national
staff morale. level in planning decisions, which undermines efforts
to attain balanced and sustainable development.
Insufficient emphasis is given to forward planning in Environmental planning must play a crucial role in
the NCDC. Corporate planning is weak as funding the sustainability of the city and the surrounding
priorities are often determined by political agendas and environment.
strategic urban planning is marginalized. Emphasis has
been on funding major engineering projects unrelated The complexities surrounding the mobilization of
to urban development plans, while community level customary land poses additional challenges to attaining
needs have been largely neglected. balanced development and this is discussed in more
detail later in this document.
There is a need for stronger corporate planning in the
NCDC, linked to strategic physical planning and social
policies and programmes. Capacity building and staff
development should be given higher priority.
12
12
Economic situation URBAN POVERTY
The economy in Port Moresby is dominated by the PNG does not have an official basis for measuring the
tertiary sector. This reflects the role of Port Moresby as level of urban poverty. Poverty is measured either by
the main administrative centre and the main point for the level of consumption, the level of income or both.
import of manufactured products. Besides the activities Port Moresby is far better than other urban areas of the
defined in the Public Services Act, wholesale and retail country in terms of poverty severity. Settlement residents
activities together with restaurants and hotels make up are able to meet their basic needs and most informal
the main service activities in Port Moresby. settlement dwellers carry out subsistence farming to
supplement their household food supply.
There is very little large scale manufacturing in Port
Moresby. The main industries range from building
and construction to brewery, clothing and printing Urban infrastructure and
presses. The recent establishment of an oil refinery and
a dry-dock should result in some increase in direct and basic services
indirect employment through spin-off businesses. The There are obvious disparities in the distribution of urban
unemployment rate in Port Moresby is considerably infrastructure and basic services between the formal areas
higher than in other urban centres of PNG. A high and the settlements. While formal areas are serviced, the
percentage of the unemployed are those with no formal settlements, because of their unplanned status, often do
education or education up to primary school level. not have access to many basic services. Some people who
More than 50% of unemployed persons are found in live in settlements access services illegally; the burden of
settlements and urban villages. However, this is not to payment is borne by rate-payers in the formal areas. The
say that they are not involved in other income generating existing road network is poorly maintained and while
activities as most of these people participate in informal access to health care and education is available, the
sector activities. facilities are often run-down and poorly resourced.
1313
Sanitation and refuse the harbour, two ferries travel between the main wharf
and the refinery at 10 minute intervals. There are no
collection
proper docking facilities for passenger vessels coming
All formal areas are connected to the sewerage network from other provinces.
administered by Eda Ranu Water and Sewerage
Company. Informal settlements do not have linkages to
the sewerage network and therefore they use alternative Street lighting
outlets such as pit latrines and direct disposal into the
Provision of street lighting throughout the city varies
sea, bushes, drains or waterways which leads to pollution
considerably, from non-existent on some residential
of the environment.
streets to well-lit on arterial roads. There is no street
The collection of refuse within the city is the responsibility lighting in the settlements. Most streetlights are in
of the NCDC. There is a set schedule for refuse collection working order. Some residential streets in the formal
in the city, however, the actual collection is not reliable housing areas lacking street lights are lit by security
and consistent. Although NCDC undertakes to service lights on individual properties.
all parts of the city, a lack of common collection points
and safety problems in the informal settlements has
disadvantaged these areas. Therefore, the collection Sources of energy
of refuse is limited to the formal areas, urban villages PNG Power which administers the national grid
and safer settlements. In areas where there are no provides electricity to the city primarily through its
refuse collection services, residents dispose their refuse hydro complex outside the city boundary supplemented
haphazardly causing degradation of the environment. by thermal and diesel sub-stations 24 hours a day.
PNG Power has prioritized to further increase hydro
resources and eventually replace fossil fuels. PNG
Public transport Power is investigating two new sources just outside Port
Buses or Public Motor Vehicles (PMV) are the main Moresby. Fossil fuel, in the form of diesel and petrol, are
form of motorized public transport and there is a strong being consumed at a large scale in the transport sector.
dependence on them. PMV routes generally follow the In settlements, wood is the widely used source of fuel for
major road pattern. PMVs are privately owned and are cooking and lighting followed by kerosene, Liquefied
managed by a national regulatory authority, the Land Petroleum Gas and electricity. Candles are also widely
Transport Management Board, which sets the fares. The used for lighting. The harvesting of firewood has led to
port moresby URBAN profile - background
buses do not operate after sunset. depletion of trees in some areas in Port Moresby.
Privately owned taxis are an alternative form of transport PNG Power indiscriminately supplies electricity within
and are becoming increasingly popular. the city based on a user-pay system. However, there are
cases of people with electricity connection in informal
PMVs are badly managed and controlled and are a settlements on the fringes of residential areas entering
disruption to traffic. PMV drivers are undisciplined, the into agreements with other settlers to extend connection
condition of vehicles is substandard, passenger comfort to them at some fee.
is ignored, the standards of dressing of the transport crew
is poor, and often designated routes are not followed.
There are similar problems with taxis in relation to
vehicle condition, passenger comfort, conduct of the
drivers, and standards of dressing.
There is a clear need for more effective management and
control over PMVs and taxis. Port Moresby has a limited
level of maritime public transport and local villagers
who come to sell their catch at the local markets daily
have only two locations to moor their banana boats.
With the Napa Napa oil refinery on the other side of
14
14
Health on new or upgraded arterial roads. This has led to the
neglect of distributor and local access roads, resulting
The most common diseases in Port Moresby are malaria, in their deterioration. There is little strategic planning
tuberculosis and sexually transmitted infections (STIs). for road upgrading and maintenance. At present there
HIV/AIDS poses the largest threat. Public and private is no process in place to undertake assessment of road
health-care services are available for the residents of the projects, either in the strategic framework or in cost/
city and, in addition, there are traditional medicine benefit analysis. As a result there is no means to prioritize
practitioners. These systems may sometimes overlap. The proposals, or justify budget requirements.
middle and high-income groups rely on the citys private
hospitals and clinics, whereas the poorer groups rely on Maintenance decisions are responsive and not
the government run hospitals and clinics. Residents can programmed. Funds are expended on an as-required
also access health care services from institutional clinics. basis, responding to immediate maintenance needs.
Based on the Department of Healths standards there is Footpaths and pedestrian routes are non-existent or are
a shortage of government-run clinics. At times, some not clearly marked.
clinics have to close due to theft and vandalism. As
the city expands further urban clinics will be required
in suitable locations and there will also be need for a AIRPORT
second public hospital. Port Moresby is the main gateway to the rest of the
country. The city hosts the main international airport
in the country. Air transport is the main mode of inter-
Education provincial travel in PNG. Air Niugini, the national flag
There is a high student to teacher ratio in schools in carrier alone, operates 47 international flights to Narita,
Port Moresby. Classrooms are overcrowded and the Singapore, Brisbane, Cairns, and Honiara, and 256
limited land area for schools makes it difficult for domestic flights weekly. Other third level airlines and
further extensions. Some schools lack adequate facilities cargo airlines also operate from Port Moresby to other
such as libraries, laboratories and playing fields. School destinations within the country.
fees is partly subsidized by the National Government.
However, the school fees is still unaffordable for the poor
majority. These factors, in addition to the overcrowding Port
in schools, are the reasons why most school age children Port Moresby has the second largest seaport in Papua
in informal settlements do not attend school. Although
1515
Governance
Over recent years, Port Moresby has suffered from have had adverse impacts on overall stability of the
continuous political volatility and uncertainty over its organization, especially in the executive management.
system of governance. One of the main challenges it is
facing is the current system of appointing members to The Commission is not able to involve all its diverse
the National Capital District Commission which denies citizenry in the citys affairs, although positive
developments are taking place. There are NGOs that
port moresby URBAN profile - governance
16
16
The Motu Koitabu Assembly is an elected body three elected members, are appointed and are not
having powers to manage, control and administer accountable to the citizens.
the Motu Koitabu areas of Port Moresby and other
powers delegated by the NCDC. Monitoring and evaluation of the Commissions
activities is weak and there is no system for measuring
Decision making in the Motu Koitabu is performance against the existing service standards
characterized by political interference and weak and submitted work plans.
administrative capacity which constrains service
delivery and physical planning. There has been community consultation in the
preparation of physical development plans and
The potential for public-private partnerships in policies, but this needs to be continuous and
service delivery has not been fully explored. systematic.
NGOs are numerous and they are involved in The Motu Koitabu Assembly lacks the necessary
urban affairs to differing degrees, but there is no funding under the current legislative framework to
formal institutionalized involvement mechanism, effectively carry out its functions and responsibilities
such as an urban forum, to collectively engage all within its jurisdiction.
stakeholders in civic affairs.
There is no communication strategy between the
NCDC and city residents, no Citizens Charter and
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK no formal complaints procedure. The Governor or
Executive Management addresses complaints on an
The NCDC is under the supervision of the Ministry ad hoc basis.
of Inter-Government Relations.
NGOs are active but they lack the coordination
The Physical Planning Act gives the NCDC required to be more effective.
planning responsibility but the Commission does
not place enough importance on physical planning. The traditional residents of the city feel that their
It lacks, therefore, the capacity to plan for some culture and way of life is under threat from expanded
parts of the city, particularly the areas of traditional urban development. They also feel excluded from
land and settlements. urban decision making despite being represented by
the Motu Koitabu Assembly.
The city has a draft NCD Urban Development
1717
AGREED PRIORITIES
Improve corporate planning and management
practices in order to achieve more accountability
and transparency within the NCDC.
18
18
GOVERNANCE
1919
Project proposal ACTIVITIES: (1) Assess the activities, priority needs
and future plans of community-based organizations,
GOVERNANCE faith-based organizations, NGOs, neighbourhood
N1 Support for the broad based
stakeholder forum for action organizations and individuals active in Port Moresby.
(2) Organise an awareness campaign on the Citizens
Forum in order to ensure broad-based participation. (3)
Organise a consultative meeting in order to formulate
the concept of a Citizens Forum involving stakeholders
LOCATION: National Capital District Commission. and taking into consideration the realities in Port
Moresby. (4) Prepare an annual action plan on the
DURATION: 12 months.
priority issues, including budgets and also containing
BENEFICIARIES: National Capital District and Port future fund-raising activities. (5) Employ two local full-
Moresby civil society. time community focal points who will take the lead
in the organization and management of the Citizens
IMPLEMENTING PARTNERS: Civil society Forum. (6) Organize awareness campaigns, workshops,
organizations, National Capital District Commission meetings, or trainings based on the priorities identified
and UN-HABITAT. by stakeholders in the initial consultation. (7) Put
ESTIMATED COST: US$80,000 in place monitoring and evaluation mechanisms to
monitor the operations of the Citizens Forum and
BACKGROUND: There are several community- document the experiences.
based organizations, faith-based organizations, NGOs,
neighbourhood organizations and individuals active in OUTPUTS: Creation of a Citizens Forum that brings
Port Moresby. There are also many individuals who are together the various community groups and individuals
not part of any group but who would like to participate who would like to participate in urban decision-making.
in urban decision-making. Several constraints prevent The Citizens Forum will meet on a regular basis to
the community sector from fully participating in the discuss relevant issues in the spirit of cooperation and
citys affairs. Many are not aware of their rights and understanding. It will coordinate the various activities
responsibilities; there is no Citizens Charter to guide of different community-based organizations, NGOs
the residents in their communication with the city and faith-based organizations operating in Port Moresby
authority. The community-based organizations, faith- and will work towards the creation of joint responses
based organizations and NGOs are not coordinated and actions to the city authority. It will also organize
so they rarely cooperate although there is enormous regular workshops and training on important issues
potential for collaboration. For the community sector as identified by the participants. The Citizens Forum
to be fully able to participate in urban decision-making, will have two local full-time employees and various
the above issues need to be rectified. volunteers who will be responsible for the smooth
running of the Forum.
project proposals - governance
20
20
Project proposal Project proposal
GOVERNANCE Formulation of training policy GOVERNANCE
N3 Performance Audit for the National
N2 for the National Capital District
Capital District Commission
Commission
LOCATION: National Capital District Commission. LOCATION: National Capital District Commission.
BENEFICIARIES: National Capital District BENEFICIARIES: NCDC staff and residents of Port
Commission officers and eventually residents of Port Moresby City through improved performances in
Moresby, through improved performance and service service delivery.
delivery. IMPLEMENTING PARTNERS: NCDC.
IMPLEMENTING PARTNERS: National Capital BACKGROUND: The NCDC commits US$10,000
District Commission, UN-HABITAT, and a training on different projects and activities. However, there is no
organization. systematic method of evaluating quality, quantity, actual
ESTIMATED COST: US$100,000 expenditure, and whether or not the objectives of the
project have been successfully met.
BACKGROUND: Although training of some NCDC
staff members does proceed, it is ad hoc without a OBJECTIVES: Comprehensive audit of all projects
logical basis. Some sections, where training needs are and activities planned and budgeted by NCDC.
evident, are neglected. ACTIVITIES: Evaluate all projects and incorporate
OBJECTIVES: Comprehensive development of them into business practice.
NCDC skills. OUTPUTS: NCDC projects and activities reports.
ACTIVITIES: (1) Assessment of training needs for STAFF REQUIRED: An international consultant with
governance and job orientation at all levels of the experience in institutional management and training.
NCDC structure. (2) Assess and evaluate all current
training activities. (3) Develop an NCDC Training
Policy document. (4) Hold consultations with the
NCDC Board and executive management. (5) Finalise
the NCDC Training Policy. project proposals - governance
OUTPUTS: A National Capital District Commission
Training Policy.
STAFF REQUIRED: An international consultant with
expertise in institutional administration, management
and training.
2121
Slums
developable land supply to match this increase. The existing settlement situation in the NCD and to set the
high cost of living has resulted in overcrowded living agenda for addressing the informal settlements issues.
conditions. It needs the financial and human resource capacity
Settlements are located throughout the city, within the and the political support to adequately implement the
existing fabric and on the urban fringes. They are found on action plan.
both state land and customary land and are characterized
by a lack of planning and poor infrastructure especially
water, sanitation and electricity. INSTITUTIONAL SET-UP
AND EMPOWERMENT
Most of the citys low income work force lives in
settlements, however, the trend is changing with middle No particular ministry is responsible for dealing
and high income earners moving into settlements with settlement issues after a housing policy change
because of the limited access to formal housing. There are in 1986 that left housing development to market
20 planned settlements and 79 unplanned settlements forces.
of which 42 are on state land and 37 on customary
land. The condition of houses and infrastructure in the
22
22
Initiatives by individual ministries and statutory Tete Settlement and the Two Mile Settlement to
organizations are small scale and do not address the make way for formal development. This move is
low income sector. yet to be made formal as further deliberation with
the Department of Lands and Physical Planning
The city authoritys inability to plan and cater for regarding possible relocation sites is required.
the settlement areas has resulted in NGOs and
community based organizations getting involved, There are no up-to-date guidelines for subdivision,
but they lack coordination. In future, the design and utility service provision in settlement
Urbanization Unit of the NCDC will coordinate all upgrading.
settlement activities including those highlighted in
the Settlements Strategic Plan. There are no pro-poor policies in place to deal with
settlement problems.
The city administration needs to appreciate its
full responsibility towards providing services to
settlements and provide resources for intervention in RESOURCE MOBILISATION
the same.
There is no service infrastructure development in
Proposals have been made under the revised settlements but there is hope for improvement
structure of the city administration to strengthen its through the National Urbanization Policy and the
coordination but this needs further improvement. NCD Settlements Strategic Plan.
The new NCDC Chairman has made favorable The city authority lacks the financial capacity to fully
remarks on his desire to provide basic services like address problems in all settlements especially with
water and sewerage to settlements in the cities. regard to settlement upgrading and development.
There are several small-scale NGO funded initiatives
aimed at settlements improvement. However most
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK of these programs are undertaken in isolation and
The present regulatory framework including the are poorly coordinated. One example would be the
Land Act, the NCDC Act, Physical Planning Act, initiative undertaken by Digicel (PNG) to provide
Building Act, Informal Sector Act, Public Health educational services (pre-school and skills training for
Act, Environment Act, and NCDC By-laws provide womenfolk) through the set up of mobile centres.
for settlement improvement in Port Moresby.
Financial assistance to informal settlement dwellers
The capacity of the NCDC is constrained since is not sufficiently developed.
important decision making powers like land
Although there is an Informal Sector law, it only
port moresby URBAN profile - slums
allocation are held by the central government agencies.
Nevertheless the current Governor has suggested his governs the informal sector activities and does not
plans for the removal of some settlements such as provide an avenue for vendors to improve their
activities.
Pilot projects
June Valley (Uguha Dubu) Pilot Settlement Upgrading Project
Introduction of the direct dealing (leasing) concept between settlers and customary landowners in Port Moresby which
enables land owners to formally lease land directly to settlers in order to enable their participation in urban development
without alienation of title to land.
Upgrading and alignment of existing unplanned squatter settlement with a view to providing affordable homes for low
income families on State land.
23
23
Pilot projects
To secure political backing for the implementation
of the NCD Settlement Strategic Plan.
24
24
Slums
RESOURCE MOBILISATION
The Informal Lack of funding The wantok system of Deterioration of living Introduce a micro
Sector creates support or credit support livelihood and conditions of people finance scheme for
income generating scheme to settlers to security. living in settlements the urban poor.
opportunities. improve their living and lawlessness.
Employees to provide
conditions.
affordable housing to
workers.
2525
Project proposal Project proposal
SLUMS SLUMS
N1
Awareness on rights N2 Comprehensive Data Base on Existing
and responsibilities Shelter and Settlements
26
26
Project proposal Project proposal
SLUMS SLUMS
N3 Small loans scheme N4 Manual for Settlement Improvement
2727
GENDER AND HIV/AIDS
people living with HIV/AIDS is a growing concern for is intended to monitor program activities for
the authorities. There is need to incorporate HIV/AIDS both gender and HIV/AIDS, promote leadership
education in the school curriculum so that children are of women through multi-sectoral partnerships
made aware of these issue at an early age. and mainstreaming gender into all HIV/AIDS
Despite the socio-economic and cultural challenges faced activities.
by women, there is an emerging trend where women Various Civil Society Organizations (CSOs)
are going into careers that were formerly dominated by supported by donor agencies are actively involved in
men such as engineering and other technical careers. addressing gender and HIV/AIDS related issues, but
However, womens participation in governance and their efforts are ad hoc and require coordination and
development and in the decision making process comprehensive support from all sectors.
remains low and this is a challenge for the government.
Women need to be empowered in these ares in order Meri Seif Projek (Women Safety Project) under the
to improve their economic livelihood and improve the YLM Projek (Yumi Lukautim Moresby Project) is a
standards of living of the citizens of PNG. womens project supported by AusAid, an Australian
aid agency.
2828
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION Condom use is being promoted as they prevent
unwanted pregnancies and the spread of HIV/AIDS
Donor funding is available but there is lack of Business Coalition against HIV/AIDS is an initiative
transparency and accountability. of the private sector to work in collaboration with
Port Moresbys Provincial AIDS Council (PAC) in
the fight against HIV/AIDS.
2929
A work place policy on HIV/AIDS had been
introduced. Currently there are 100 organizations AGREED PRIORITIES
that have a HIV/AIDS work place policy. Business
Strengthen the existing partnerships.
Coalition Against HIV/AIDS (BAHA) and Port
Moresbys PAC also provide information on Gender Carry out awareness on Gender Based Violence
and HIV/AIDS. centres in the media.
Individual Community Rights Advocacy Forum There is need to legislate and impose tougher laws
(ICRAF) is an NGO that deals in human, on gender based violence.
environmental and land right issues in PNG. It has a There is need for better coordination mechanisms
desk officer dedicated to womens issues. It monitors among gender and HIV/AIDS focused
the abuse of womens rights and provides counselling organizations.
and legal aid for abused women.
Review NCDC Strategic Plan on HIV/AIDS 2006
Meri Seif Ples or Famili Seif Ples is an initiative 2010.
under the Yumi Lukautim Moresby Project that
Centralise all data on HIV/AIDS.
helps distressed women by providing transport to a
safe place or hospital. It has four stand-by female There is need to coordinate and develop data on
personnel at Protect Security who respond to gender based violence from all stakeholders.
emergency calls 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
Validate all data available on HIV/AIDS and
Boroko Police Station has a Sexual Offence Squad Gender.
manned by two police women who assist women Establish community learning centres to empower
to report violence and sexual crime and prosecute communities in dealing with Gender and HIV/
offenders. AIDS.
The media is involved in educating citizens about Conduct awareness campaigns on Equal Gender
Gender and HIV/AIDS related issues. Participation.
port moresby URBAN profile - gender and hiv/aids
GENDER Project proposal Page 32 Carry out Life Skills training programs.
HIV/AIDS
Awareness on Gender Equality Establish community learning development
N1
centers.
GENDER Project proposal Page 32 Review the NCD Strategic Plan on HIV/AIDS
HIV/AIDS Create database for Gender and HIV/ 2006 2010.
N2 AIDS information
Create Proper database in consultation with the
Project proposal Page 33 existing organizations that deal with Gender and
GENDER HIV/AIDS.
Review - National Policy and Strategic
HIV/AIDS
Plan on Gender and HIV/AIDS 2000-
N3
2010
3030
GENDER AND HIV/AIDS
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION
3131
Project proposal Project proposal
GENDER GENDER
N2
Training in gender disaggregated
N1 Awareness on Gender Equality
data collection
BENEFICIARIES: Men, women and their families. BENEFICIARIES: Port Moresby residents, decision
makers, organizations that deal with HIV/AIDS and
IMPLEMENTING PARTNERS: Department for Gender issues.
Community Development and National Capital
District Commission. IMPLEMENTING PARTNERS: National AIDS
Council, Provincial AIDS Council, BAHA, and
ESTIMATED COST: To be determined. Anglicare Stop AIDS.
32
32
Project proposal
GENDER Review - National Policy and
N3 Strategic Plan on Gender and HIV/
AIDS 2000-2010
3333
ENVIRONMENT
As the capital city of PNG, the population of Port The informal settlements totally lack environmental
Moresby has steadily increased thus giving rise to and health standards due to lack of provision of basic
various environmental pressures. The need for land and services such as the reticulated sewer and water as well
shelter had resulted in the spontaneous development as the garbage collections services.
of settlements on ridge tops and hillsides and other
unsuitable areas. The indiscriminate felling and lopping The city lacks proper solid waste management facilities.
of trees for firewood impacts on the environment of Open burning of domestic and industrial wastes is
the city. Clearing of grasslands, unsustainable use of common. An increase in the number of privately owned
wetlands, over-harvesting of mangrove forests, and over- vehicles has contributed to the high traffic congestion
fishing all contribute to the depletion of Port Moresbys and pollution in the city. In addition, many vehicles are
marine resources and environment. not roadworthy.
Irresponsible disposal of litter and lack of cleanliness in As a consequence of development pressures, a lot of
the city has been a challenge for the city authorities. open public spaces and potential recreational areas
The public spaces, waterways and public beaches are are under threat of being taken over for commercial
polluted with rubbish due to indiscriminate littering. development. Acquiring of land for port expansion
However, this is gradually being addressed through the and commercial developments along the shores of the
beautification and cleaning program initiated by the harbour has resulted in the discharge of raw sewage into
NCDC through a partnership with a private company the sea which is detrimental to marine life.
- PNG Gardener. In some parts of the city, seasonal
gardening on the hillsides has become a common
practice resulting in the destruction of vegetation and
severe soil erosion and water run-off during periods of
heavy rainfall.
PORT MORESBY URBAN profile - environment
3434
INSTITUTIONAL SET-UP EMPOWERMENT AND
The Department of Environment and Conservation ACCOUNTABILITY
(DEC) is mandated under the Environment and Environmental awareness among the city residents is
Conservation Act to formulate policies and regulate generally weak. However, the city provides funding
environmental standards and conservation. support to significant global events.
DEC as the national regulatory agency is mandated There is no environmental awareness strategy in
with the responsibility of ensuring that development place to raise awareness on environmental issues.
activities conform to environmental standards
There is a lack of coordination and enforcement of
and guidelines. The environmental monitoring
existing environmental policies and standards.
involves impact assessment, issues of development
permits and monitoring to ensure compliance with
environment standards.
The NCDC regulates environment standards
through the Public Health Act and Physical Planning AGREED PRIORITIES
Act.
Establish a properly resourced Environment Unit
NCDC does not have an environmental planning within the NCDC.
and monitoring unit to enforce its environmental
policies or promote environmental awareness. Develop an environmental checklist specific to Port
Moresby to provide guidelines for the assessment
of development projects.
REGULATORY FRAMEWORK Develop a database on marine and terrestrial assets
The Environment Planning Act 2000 is the principal and relevant environmental information for Port
legal and institutional framework for environmental Moresby to aid informed decision-making.
planning and protection.
Conduct public education and awareness
The Act requires developers to submit environmental campaigns on environmental issues.
impact studies for development activities. It allows
for Public Consultation on environment issues Build and strengthen local capacity in
environmental planning, management,
on large development projects with significant
monitoring, and governance.
environmental impacts.
3535
ENVIRONMENT
36
36
Project proposal STAFF REQUIRED: Project team manager and research
ENVIRONMENT team.
N1
Developing an
environmental checklist LOCATION: The National Capital District Commission
(NCDC) of Port Moresby.
DURATION: 24 months.
37
37
Law and order
Law and Order problems have had a negative effect on past, it is perceived as undisciplined, corrupt and largely
Port Moresby over the years. Peace and order is a concern ineffective. There are many cases of excessive use of
in all levels of the community. Increase in crime has led force and police brutality. The poor police performance
to a lot of insecurity among resident of Port Moresby. has been attributed to poor working conditions and
poor salaries and compensation for the members of the
There are several reasons for this situation including police force.
high youth unemployment rates, the erosion of cultural
values and the huge gap between the rich and the Due to the lack of confidence in the police force, private
poor. As the city expands, so does the crime rates. The security companies are commonly used to provide
settlements are perceived as safe havens for criminals, security to those who can afford to hire their services.
although criminals come from the formal housing areas
too. The judicial system is also flawed. The state prosecution
services are largely ineffective and unprofessional. Non-
Common crimes are pick-pocketing, armed robbery, appearance in court, loss of files and loss of evidence
vehicle theft, carjackings, and aggravated assault. Gang are common. The performance of the CIS which is
rapes and homicides are also increasing in number. responsible for prisoners is also poor and cases of prisoners
Movement of residents is restricted after dark due escaping from the Bomana prison are common.
to the high crime rates and there are certain no-go
areas which can only be accessed under heavy security The existing law and order situation receives unfavourable
protection. publicity overseas and this is a deterrent to foreign
investors and potential tourists. The law enforcement
The RPNGC, is responsible for law-enforcement. While and judicial system in Port Moresby needs considerable
this force has performed well in crisis situations in the strengthening and improvement.
PORT MORESBY URBAN profile - LAW AND ORDER
38
38
INSTITUTIONAL SET-UP
AGREED PRIORITIES
The RPNGC which is under The Internal Security
Ministry oversees all law related matters through the Strengthen coordination among the law enforcement
agencies and the communities.
existing police stations. However, five of the existing
police stations are run down and require upgrading Promote and maintain a high level of professionalism
to provide effective police service. and ethics in the disciplinary forces.
The CIS provides prison rehabilitation programs, Strengthen the RPNGC and the CIS with
however, this rehabilitation programs have not been introduction of more professional training
very effective. programmes.
Under the Safer Cities Initiative, the NCDC has Empower the youth through capacity building
programmes to engage in legitimate income
coordinated the Yumi Lukautim Mosbi project.
earning activities.
3939
Law and order
40
40
Project proposal
LAW AND ORDER Capacity Building Programs
N1 linked to income earning
ventures to empower youths
41
41
Land
42
42
REGULATORY FRAME-WORK Performance and
The Land Act of 1996 allows the government to accountability
control and manage land through the establishment Poor administration of the state leasehold, state
of a Land Board and through the authority of the freehold and private freehold land.
Minister for Lands and Physical Planning.
There have been widespread allegations of corruption
Powers and responsibilities are shared between the and irregular practices within the DLPP.
Minister, the Land Board and the Departmental
Head. As a general rule the Land Board considers Only a limited amount of State land has been
applications for leases and makes recommendations advertised for tenders over recent years depriving
to the Minister. the general public of the opportunity to apply. Land
is often exempted from advertisements on dubious
Under the Act, the government, through the minister, grounds.
can acquire land through agreement from the land
owners or by compulsory means. The Act also makes Poor liaison between DLPP and the NCDC
provisions for the right to compensation of land for resulting in land decisions taken without physical
the land owners. planning inputs, leases issued contrary to zoning,
leases issued over reserved land, land parcels created
The Land (Tenure Conversion) Act 1963, the Land without physical planning input or approval,
Groups Incorporated Act 1974, the Land Disputes double allocations of land, lack of forfeiture action,
Settlement Act 1975, and the Land Registration Act and questionable decisions concerning Urban
1981 have provisions for dealing with customary Development Leases.
land.
Inefficient land dispute settlement system resulting
The DLPP office of the Registrar of Incorporated in many outstanding land dispute cases.
Land Groups administers the Land Groups
Incorporated Act. There is no tracking or retrieval system within the
DLPP to enable departmental staff to determine
It has been recognized that the legislation relating to where clients applications are in the process. If such
the registration and mobilization of customary land a system was in place, this would make the DLPP
needs revision. more accountable to its clients.
The NCD Urban Development Plan contains broad Substantial proportions of prime developable land
land use proposals for the entire city. are being held back from development as they are
43
43
AGREED PRIORITIES
Improve the land administration systems in DLPP
to be more transparent and accountable.
44
44
Land
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION
Availability of vacant Land disputes constrain Mobilization of Land disputes. Funding and training for
customary land. customary land release. customary land. mediation.
Non-release of
customary land. Encourage traditional
landowners to register
Lack of funding for
land identified for
mediation.
development in the NCD
Urban Development
Plan.
Launch a customary
land owners awareness
campaign on voluntary
registration.
45
45
Project proposal ACTIVITIES: (1) Identify training programs. (2) Make
LAND funding available to implement training programs. (3)
N1
Improving the village and land City Authority to educate the village court chairmen,
courts mediation systems magistrates and land mediators on its approved city
plans. (4) Construction of multi-purpose community
halls that could facilitate the court sessions. (5) City
LOCATION: Port Moresby. Authority to budget for mediators allowances.
46
46
ACRONYMS
47
CONTACTS:
Alioune Badiane, Director, Regional Office for Africa and the Arab States
e-mail: [email protected]
e-mail: [email protected]
48