Capstone AMRP Report - Q3 2015
Capstone AMRP Report - Q3 2015
Capstone AMRP Report - Q3 2015
$25,000
$20,000
$15,000
BOSTON
CHICAGO $10,000
LONDON
LOS ANGELES $5,000
PHILADELPHIA
SAN DIEGO $0
SILICON VALLEY 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 E 2017 E 2018 E 2019 E 2020 E
TAMPA
Source: IBIS World
OD4581 3D Printing and Rapid Prototyping Services
Additive Manufacturing & Rapid Prototyping
Q3 2015
sectors can support a $40 Industry growth is being fueled by improved technologies, ever expanding applications,
increasingly shorter product development cycles and accelerated product launch requirements.
billion market over the Due to the significant advantages offered by AMRP, many industries are weaving rapid
next 15 to 20 years with solutions into their product development processes. According to Wholers, consumer
products/electronics lead the way with 20.3% of the global AMRP market share, followed by
upside potential from motor vehicles (19.5%), medical/dental (15.1%) and aerospace (12.0%).
technological advances. AMRP technology is of particular interest within the aerospace, healthcare, automotive and
industrial sectors where product development, innovation and time-to-market are critical to
success. With advancements in materials and processes, AMRP has afforded players in these
sectors the ability to further expand their capacity to develop and manufacture complex
products that are extremely light, stable and durable. Goldman Sachs suggests AMRP
applications in these sectors could support a $40 billion market over the next 15 to 20 years
with upside potential from technological advances.
Engineers can now With the introduction of interactive cloud-based interfaces and software automation processes,
designs can now be submitted, analyzed, modified, quoted and approved for manufacturing
produce multiple product concurrently on the web. As a result, designs can be approved and quoted within minutes and
iterations in the same with same day product shipping. Moreover, as material qualities and dimensional accuracies
improve, companies are using AMRP technology in a range of applications including direct part
time it would have production (19.2%), functional modeling (18.4%), patterns for prototype tooling (12.2%) and fit
historically taken to & assembly (12.1%), as illustrated below.
8.9%
10.1% 18.4%
12.2%
12.1%
Despite improvements in technology, AMRP capabilities do not entirely meet the product
developers and engineers requirements for dimensional accuracy, material properties and
cosmetics. As a result, several larger competitors in the sector offer quick-turn manufacturing
solutions utilizing CNC machining, injection molding and stamping capabilities. Examples of
companies embracing this holistic solution include Proto Labs, Arc Group Worldwide and
Stratasys.
There are some This dynamic has already started to change as more companies enter the marketplace. New
entrants tend to cater to niche industry segments with differentiated specialization. This trend
companies that have has taken root in areas such as the automotive and aerospace end markets. Gaining footholds
been able to generate in niche markets allows companies to secure demand and command premium pricing as many
of their clients represent the early adopters.
above-market
profitability by offering BARRIERS TO ENTRY
superior service. On the surface, there are moderate barriers to entry in the industry with capital equipment
accounting for the vast majority of initial startup costs, namely 3D printers and CNC injection
machines. Many smaller firms are forced to source their printing equipment from external
manufacturers. Beyond capital equipment, raw materials represent the next significant
component of a firms cost structure but are not very much of a factor. Because there are a
small number of refined material suppliers, players in the industry experience the same price
fluctuations for raw materials, such as thermoplastics or nylon. However, the competitive
barriers lie much more in advanced capabilities. Sophisticated and integrated solutions, such as
automated quotation, engineering systems and front-end web client interfaces separate the
market leaders from the remaining fragmented pack.
The capital markets have Summary M&A Activity (2013 to YTD 2015)
been open across the
2013 2014 2015* TOTAL
board with robust Party/Group
# % # % # % # %
strategic M&A activity,
active PE investments and 3D Systems 8 33% 4 8% 3 12% 15 14%
successful IPOs.
Stratasys 2 8% 4 8% 2 8% 8 8%
As illustrated above, the industry is attracting increased levels of institutional investment from
the private equity community. In 2013, only four notable deals occurred, representing 17% of
the M&A market. That volume jumped quickly to 13 deals (a 27% market share) in 2014.
Moreover, there have been 12 deals YTD in 2015 already, representing a 48% market share.
Globally, PE firms of particular interest have included The Riverside Company (US), Cornerstone
Capital (US), CorpAcq (UK) and SkyLake (Korea), among others.
David Reis, Statasys CEO, said, These transactions are consistent with our core strategic
imperatives and M&A strategy, which is focused on acquiring leading companies to support our
goal of continued leadership in the segments in which we operate, as well as reaching new
niche verticals. We will apply our integration expertise to combine Solid Concepts and Harvest
Technologies with our existing RedEye digital manufacturing service business to form a single
business unit focused on additive manufacturing services
The acquisition provides Laird a South Korean platform to service leading customers in the
electronics industry and other international OEMs. It also allowed access to a broad customer
base in different market segments and complements the organic investment of capacity
expansion in Vietnam announced earlier in the year. David Lockwood, Laird CEO remarked,
This acquisition shows our strategy at work. It allows us to further penetrate the important
strategic market that is Korea, demonstrating a broader offering to customers who value the
importance of innovative design and speed of delivery.
Alphas Selected Provides selective laser sintering, direct metal laser sintering and
10/02/15 Proto Labs - - -
Assets stereolithography capabilities services in Europe.
RTI International Offers a portfolio of titanium mill products, extruded shapes, formed and
07/23/15 Alcoa $1,490.6 1.9x 12.9x
Metals 3D-printed parts, as well as high speed machined components.
RTC Rapid Provides rapid prototyping technologies for design, engineering and
07/02/15 Stratasys - - -
Technologies manufacturing predominantly in the German-speaking regions.
Mechtronic Cornerstone Capital Offers engineering, prototyping, manufacturing and product life-cycle
04/30/15 - - -
Solutions Holdings support services to a variety of industries.
Easyway Design Designs, develops, manufactures and markets 3D printers and related
04/02/15 3D Systems - - -
and Manufacture products, print materials and services in China.
INITIAL and
03/26/15 Groupe Gorg Manufactures 3D printed parts, components and 3D printers in Europe. - - -
NORGE Systems
Intelligent
02/10/15 Stratasys Provides 3D printing services in China. - - -
CAD/CAM
11/25/14 Robtec 3D Systems Develops rapid prototyping technologies in Brazil and Latin America. $21.9 - -
Vector D3 Technical Distributes 2D and 3D computer aided and drafting design Autodesk
10/13/14 - - -
Graphics Services solution.
Tatra Plastics Designs, manufactures and prototypes round, oval and square plastic
07/10/14 Coral Products $4.2 0.8x -
Manufacturing tube and profile extrusions, co-extrusions and injection moldings.
Model Laird and Engages in prototype model making and quick-turn tooling and
04/22/14 $67.6 2.2x -
Solutions SkyLake production of injection molded parts in South Korea.
Sysopt
01/23/14 Stratasys Provides 3D printing applications and solutions in South Korea. - - -
Engineering
Realtime Dassault
01/13/14 Provides 3D visualization software, consulting and creative services. $232.5 2.3x 18.3x
Technology Systemes
01/02/14 Xerox 3D Systems Operates in product design, engineering and chemistry group. $32.5 - -
PROTO LABS
Based in Maple Plain, Minnesota and founded in 1999, Proto Labs (PRLB) manufactures CNC
machined, injection molded and 3D printed custom parts for prototyping and short-run
production in various markets including medical, aerospace, electronic, consumer products and
Proto Labs is pushing the industrial machinery. Proto Labs is the worlds largest provider of part-making services to
technology envelope to product developers. The company works with innovative product designers and engineers to
help bring their ideas from concept to market quickly.
produce bigger and more
complex parts, The business first introduced the Firstcut CNC machining service and opened up manufacturing
facilities in Europe and Asia. In 2009, the company combined its Protomold and Firstcut
introducing the Firstcut
services under one corporate name, Proto Labs, to reflect its growing capabilities.
CNC Machining service
Proto Labs plans to expand its manufacturing processes through acquisitions in an attempt to
and opening up expand its customer base and broaden its parts envelope. The company looks to establish
manufacturing facilities in more advanced technologies to increase the size and complexity of its modeling capabilities.
Europe and Asia. Additionally, with a marketing staff of approximately 30+ and a global support staff of 200+,
Proto Labs has been able to establish itself as an industry cornerstone that looks to keep
growing.
In April of 2014, Proto Labs established its 3-D printing branch in an acquisition of Fine Line
Prototyping. Prior to the move, Proto Labs had no services in 3-D printing, something 70% of
the companys customers utilized. Now the Fine Line branch of the business does all of the
additive manufacturing services through embracing stereolithography and laser sintering. This
was a large strategic move for one of the pioneers of the industry, with immediate market
impact. Fine Line accounted for $9 million in revenues in 2014.
Currently, Proto Labs has over 1,000 employees and just recently surpassed $200 million in
sales in 2014. This illustrates a considerable growth pattern, as 2010 revenues were $65 million
with $16 million income from operations, opposed to almost $61 million in 2014.
Capstone has been impressed with Proto Labs industry foresight and recognizes it as one of the
first companies to combine CNC machining, injection molding and 3D printing. The businesss
speed and versatility allows customers to take parts from very early stages of prototyping all
the way up to the final short-run production of over 10,000 parts, all with one technology-
driven process.
The quick-turn manufacturer has shaped its strategy around being a one-stop shop for its
customer base by providing holistic solutions for metal and plastic fabrication. Additionally,
ARC offers its services cradle to grave in an attempt to avoid lengthy bottlenecks which bog
down the current manufacturing supply chain.
True to its strategy, in June of 2014, ARC acquired Kecy Corporation, a leading precision metal
stamping company utilizing automated manufacturing. Kecys utilization of advantage
technologies provided an opportunity for ARC to accelerate technological adoption and grow
the overall function of the business.
ARC has over 700 employees and sales of nearly $83 million worldwide. The company has
posted a 65% CAGR over the last three years.
Capstone Partners tracks ARCs market activity as we have been impressed by the leading role
the company has taken in developing the next phase of manufacturing and production
standards and we expect that their input will be influential. Look for ARC to be one of the first
initial public companies in an ever-expansive marketplace that is starting to shape the face of
industrial production.
Xcentric is a privately owned business and specific information is not publicly available.
However, in Capstones industry coverage activities, we were given the opportunity to meet
With a growing with the companys founding entrepreneurs, Damon Weaver and Brendan Weaver. What we
proprietary technology learned in the meeting was exciting enough for us to highlight Xcentric as a company on the
move and to expect it to out-perform the market.
platform, Xcentric is
recognized as one of the For background purposes, Xcentric was founded in 1996 in Michigan. The company specializes
in offering injection molding, CNC machining and rapid prototyping services for all industries,
top injection molders and
including defense, medical, aerospace, automotive and consumer products markets. What
rapid custom parts impressed us about the companys capabilities is its highly streamlined and proprietary
suppliers in North technologically advanced quotation, engineering and manufacturing process system, enabling it
to produce intricate custom plastic and metal parts with what we believe may be among the
America. industrys fastest lead times for more complex prototypes and production parts. Xcentric
boasts design-to-delivery capabilities in two weeks or less.
Xcentric has the unique ability to produce high quality sophisticated custom parts, something
largely missing from the market. Their advanced molding system is best-of-breed, allowing for
custom colors and designs requiring tight tolerances, intricate geometric complexity and multi-
component assemblies. Their unique interface and technology platform expands the typical
customer reach amongst rapid manufacturers. The company benefits from a diversified
customer base and end markets, while some of Xcentrics rapid manufacturing services may
very well play a role in shaping the future of the industry.
While we cannot disclose specific financial information on the business, Xcentric has posted
top-quartile results in terms of revenue growth rate. In addition, the company has reached
critical scale. While we expect the current meteoric growth rate to ease slightly, we also
anticipate continued efficiencies and impressive profit margins.
In summary, our preliminary thesis on the attributes of this business are as follows:
Based on our research, together with other insights from our meeting with the companys
shareholders, Capstone believes Xcentric is deserving of recognition among the industry
leaders. As the industry continues to grow and evolve, we expect Xcentric to be at the
forefront (or at very least in the lead pack).
World Class Wall Street Expertise. Built for the Middle Market.