B11 Tech Brief of November 2015
B11 Tech Brief of November 2015
The American Society of Safety Engineers is pleased to partner with the ANSI B11 Committee
to move machine guarding safety forward to better protect workers and reduce hazards and
exposures resulting from the use of this type of equipment.
B11 Standards Inc. also participates in a very large number of both national and international
standards development activities.
The Past
Standardization / standards provide a bridge between research, innovation and the market,
thereby strengthening competitiveness and boosting growth and jobs. Standards are a valuable
tool for market dissemination of research and development results and can therefore contribute to
the objectives of overall market innovation and competitiveness.
The original project on Safety Standard for Power Presses, B11, was initiated under the
procedures of the American Engineering Standards Committee (which later became the
American Standards Association, the United States of America Standards Institute, and in 1969
the American National Standards Institute - ANSI), with the National Safety Council as sponsor.
The first standard, bearing the title Safety Code for Power Presses and Foot and Hand Presses,
was developed by Sectional Committee B11 and was approved on November 13, 1922. Only two
purposes of that "code" were listed. The first and primary use was for state industrial
commissions in developing their workplace codes. The second use was as an operating guide for
users operating press production systems.
1
Revisions of the first B11 standard were issued in 1926, 1937, 1948, 1960, 1971, 1982, 1988,
2001 and 2009. The Association For Manufacturing Technology (AMT) assumed this activity
from the National Safety Council in 1970 and administered the activity until 2010, when they
transferred it to B11 Standards, Inc., which is now the ANSI-Accredited Standards Developing
Organization (SDO) for the B11 series of safety standards for machines and is the Secretariat for
the B11 Accredited Standards Committee (ASC).
The Present
The B11 ASC is comprised of organizations representing different stakeholder groups having a
substantial interest and competence in the overall scope of B11 standards. It is recognized by
ANSI as the body that evaluates and votes on final draft standards (or technical reports)
developed by B11 writing subcommittees for approval as American National Standards and
ANSI Technical Reports by the ANSI Board of Standards Review. Each of the standards and
technical reports within the B11 series has its own writing subcommittee. These subcommittees
function somewhat autonomously from the B11 ASC, with their own Chair (and possibly Vice-
Chair), however, they are ultimately responsible and answerable to the B11 ASC. Once they
complete work on their document, it is turned over to the Secretariat for procedural commenting
and balloting by the public and the interested Voting Group of B11 ASC Member organizations,
which forms the "consensus body." Once this process has been completed, the candidate
standard is submitted to the ANSI Board of Standards Review for approval as a new or revised
or reaffirmed American National Standard.
2
Informative Note 2: A machine system is a systematic array of one or more industrial machines
that is not portable by hand while working and includes any associated material handling,
manipulating, gauging, measuring, or inspecting equipment.
Informative Note 3: See ANSI B11.20 for additional information on integrated manufacturing
systems.
This standard specifies basic terminology, principles and a methodology for achieving safety in
the design and the use of machinery. It specifies principles of risk assessment and risk reduction
to help designers, integrators and users of machinery in achieving this objective. These
principles are based on knowledge and experience of the design, use, incidents, accidents and
risks associated with machinery. Procedures are described for identifying hazards and estimating
and evaluating risks during relevant phases of the machine life cycle, and for the elimination of
hazards or the provision of sufficient risk reduction. Guidance is given regarding the
documentation and verification of the risk assessment and risk reduction process.
Other industry sectors may benefit from applying this standard. A risk assessment may be
required to determine if a machine specific (Type-C) standard covers the hazards associated with
the application of the machine covered by the Type-C standard.
3
ANSI B11.2-2013: Safety Requirements for Hydraulic and
Pneumatic Power Presses
Excluded from the requirements of this standard are: Manually powered presses; mechanical
power presses; air powered presses; powdered metal presses; horizontal hydraulic extrusion
presses; high energy rate presses; manually positioned "C" frame punching and riveting presses;
meat-processing presses; forging presses and hammers; powered press brakes; metal shears; iron
workers; cold headers; die-casting machines; plastic injection molding machines; stretch forming
machines; roll-bending machines; welding machines; welding presses; radial expanding and
compression equipment; packaging machines; balers; laboratory machines or equipment used to
determine properties of materials; and guillotine paper cutters.
Excluded from the requirements of this standard are mechanical power presses; hydraulic power
presses, hand brakes; tangent benders; apron brakes; and other similar types of metal bending
machines.
4
ANSI B11.4-2003 (R2013): Safety Requirements for Shears
Scope: This standard applies to those mechanically, hydraulically, hydra-
mechanically, or pneumatically powered shears used to cut material by
shearing and which utilize a fixed blade(s) and non-rotary moving blade(s).
The shears that are excluded from the requirements of this standard are
slitting-rotary, nibblers; coil slitters; portable hand tools; rotary-blade
slitters and shears; iron workers; alligator; angle, bar, bean, channel, and
notching machines.
Excluded from the requirements of this standard are NC Turning Machines where manual
control is used only to set the machine for automatic production.
5
extruding, trimming, forming, cold working, or warm forming material by means of tools and
dies. This type of equipment generally has the ram in a horizontal position. Included are pointers
and roll formers when they are mechanically an integral part of the basic machine.
Excluded from the requirements of the standard are: mechanical, hydraulic, and pneumatic
power presses; hot forgers; hot upsetters (including cold work); hot farmers; hot headers; vertical
cold forgers; four slide machines; swaggers; wine drawers; slotters; shavers, and high-energy
machines. Also excluded are pointers and roll formers, unless they are an integral part of the
basic machine.
Excluded from the requirements of this standard are NC milling, drilling, and boring machines
where manual control is used only to set the machine for automatic production.
Excluded from the requirements of this standard are: portable hand-held grinding machines,
machines using loose abrasives, machines used in wood-working applications, or machines used
for concrete cutting in road construction. Also, this standard does not apply to honing machines,
lapping machines, polishing machines or belt grinding machines.
6
machine tools that use a saw blade (tool) to cut off or change the shape of the workpiece. This
standard also applies to ancillary devices integrated into the machine (e.g., part handling
mechanisms, chip handling systems).
Excluded from the requirements for this standard are: Bench presses; hydro forming; forging
presses; four-slide machines; hydraulic presses; mechanical presses; power press brakes; roll
benders; roll formers; and assembly machines.
7
powder metal forging presses, metal powder sizing presses or metal powder coining presses. For
the purpose of this standard, they shall be referred to as "PM presses." PM press axes can be of a
direct driven type.
Excluded from this standard are: mechanical and hydraulic power press brakes; mechanical and
hydraulic power presses; bulldozers; conventional hot bending and hot metal presses;
conventional forging presses; hammers; riveting machines and similar types of fastener
applications; isostatic and hydrostatic presses; high energy rate presses.
Excluded from the requirements for this standard are: hydrostatic extrusion presses; vertical
extrusion presses; laboratory presses used to develop extrusion techniques for new materials and
products; and extruding machines of unconventional design.
Specifically excluded from this standard are machinery and devices for the sole purpose of
performing thermal, coating, chemical, and electrolytic processes and any emissions therefrom
are commonly associated with metal processing systems. This standard does not provide safety
requirements for these specific processes or devices.
8
ANSI B11.19-2010: Performance Requirements for Safeguarding
a) Guards;
b) Safeguarding devices;
c) Awareness devices;
d) Safeguarding methods.
This standard also provides performance requirements for complementary equipment and
measures, safe work procedures, and safety functions.
This standard does not provide the requirements for the selection of the safeguarding for a
particular application.
Scope: This standard specifies the safety requirements for the design,
construction, set-up, operation and maintenance (including installation,
dismantling and transport) of integrated manufacturing systems.
This standard does not cover: safety aspects of individual machines and equipment that may be
covered by standards specific to those machines and equipment (B11_ base_ standard), transfer
machines or transfer lines, or continuous flow processes.
Scope: This standard applies to machine tools using a laser for processing
materials, and its associated equipment. It describes the hazards generated
by such machines and states the protective measures to be incorporated into
such machines. The standard also contains requirements for the information
provided with such machines.
Excluded from the requirements of this document are: photolithography; holography; equipment
used in medical applications; data storage; laser printers; and copiers.
9
ANSI B11.22-2002 (R2012): Safety Requirements for Turning Centers
& Automatic Numerically Controlled Turning Machines
Scope: This standard specifies the safety requirements for the design,
construction, operation and maintenance (including installation, dismantling
and transport) of turning centers and automatic numerically controlled
turning machines.
This standard does not cover safety requirements of manufacturing systems/cells (integrated
manufacturing systems, B11.20).
Scope: This standard specifies the safety requirements for the design,
construction, operation and maintenance (including installation,
dismantling, and transport) of machining centers and automatic numerically
controlled milling, drilling and boring machines.
This standard is applicable to machines where the axes of travel is not greater than 1x1x1 m
(39x39x39 in).
Scope: This standard specifies the safety requirements for the design,
construction, operation and maintenance (including installation,
dismantling, and transport) of machining centers and automatic numerically
controlled milling, drilling and boring machines.
This standard is applicable to machines where the axes of travel is not greater than 1x1x1 m
(39x39x39 in).
The requirements in this standard apply to all large machines, unless they are specifically
covered in or by another standard. This document is intended to be used with both ANSI B11.0
10
and ANSI B11.19 to execute the risk assessment process and the safeguarding of machinery
respectively.
The requirements of this standard do not apply to turning machines and turning centers designed
to accept work holding devices less than 500 mm (20 inches) outside diameter and with a
distance between centers less than 2 meters (80 inches).
Scope: The purpose of this Technical Report is to provide guidance for the
design or selection, integration, and validation of PESs for the safety related
functions of a machine production system. The terminology used in this
document may not be used consistently throughout the industry, but this
11
document does represent the concepts which are important when using and designing safety-
related control systems.
NOTE 1: The terminology used in this document may not be used consistently throughout the
industry, but this document does represent concepts which are important when using and
designing safety-related control systems.
NOTE 2: Usage of [machine] in the following text means any of the specific machine tools
covered by the ANSI B11 base' series of safety standards.
12
Links and information related to the ANSI B11 American National Standard
The links below will give information addressing how voluntary national consensus
standards are used in regulatory settings:
www.asse.org/assets/1/7/Dembystandardsarticle3-21-2006.doc
http://www.ansi.org/news_publications/other_documents/safeguarding.aspx?menuid=7
There is an official memorandum of understanding between OSHA and ANSI. The link
to the read the memorandum is at:
http://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=MOU&p_id=323
There are dozens of examples of how the B11 Standards are recognized by OSHA. Below are
two examples:
http://www.osha.gov/pls/oshaweb/owadisp.show_document?p_table=INTERPRETATIONS&p_
id=19422
https://www.osha.gov/SLTC/etools/machineguarding/bibliography.html
http://www.oshrc.gov/decisions/html_1976/8597.html
http://www.dir.ca.gov/oshsb/GP_Die_ISOR.pdf
From CDC/NIOSH:
http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/nioshtic-2/20031240.html
http://www.osha.oregon.gov/pdf/pds/pd-217.pdf
13
In regards to 5A1 citations, B11 Standards are used extensively. Below is an example from the
B11.3 Standard. The most recent inquiry indicates that B11.3 alone has been referenced 160
times at the level of Federal OSHA. Some examples are below:
By Date
Inspection Citation Issuance Report ID Category SIC Establishment Name
1 315739847 01001 03/20/2012 0418100 Falling 3511 D & D Manufacturing Company, Inc.
2 316226703 01001 01/26/2012 0213600 Guarding 3499 Truform Manufacturing Corp.
3 315977652 01001 01/18/2012 0213900 Guarding 3443 Kiker Sheet Metal Inc.
4 113740690 01001 11/18/2011 0316700 Crushing 2541 Fleetwood Industries, Incorporated
5 315552109 01001A 10/04/2011 0522300 Crushing 3496 Advance Wire Forming
6 315568428 01001 10/03/2011 0213900 Unclass 3499 Crest Ultrasonics Corp.
7 315717173 01001 09/30/2011 0213900 Cuts 3412 Sp Sheet Metal Company
8 315717173 01007A 09/30/2011 0213900 Cuts 3412 Sp Sheet Metal Company
9 314723966 01001 09/21/2011 0317900 Guarding 3599 Stanley Vidmar
10 314723966 01002 09/21/2011 0317900 Guarding 3599 Stanley Vidmar
11 314890450 02001 06/30/2011 0953220 Falling 3442 Arcadia, Inc.
12 315361717 01001 06/28/2011 0420600 Electric 3442 Quality Engineered Products Corp.
13 315487264 01001 06/27/2011 0213900 Guarding 3499 Compass Wire Cloth Corporation
14 314378795 01001 06/10/2011 0453710 Crushing 3568 Fenner,Inc., Dba Fenner Drives
15 314371691 01001 06/09/2011 0453710 Crushing 2011 The Smithfield Packing Company, Incorporated
16 315523084 01001 05/10/2011 0111100 Falling 3499 Saunders Mfg. Co. Inc.
17 315156919 01001 05/02/2011 0521700 Falling 3446 David Architectural Metals, Inc.
18 314205840 01001 04/19/2011 0418100 Crushing 3444 Don Park (Usa) Limited Partnership
19 314205840 01002 04/19/2011 0418100 Lifting 3444 Don Park (Usa) Limited Partnership
20 314205840 01003 04/19/2011 0418100 Falling 3444 Don Park (Usa) Limited Partnership
14